HAL Id: jpa-00246603
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00246603
Submitted on 1 Jan 1992
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
The implication of the lattice in the non-equilibrium behaviour of a glassy crystal
Michel Descamps, Jean-François Willart, G. Odou, K. Eichhorn
To cite this version:
Michel Descamps, Jean-François Willart, G. Odou, K. Eichhorn. The implication of the lattice in
the non-equilibrium behaviour of a glassy crystal. Journal de Physique I, EDP Sciences, 1992, 2 (6),
pp.813-827. �10.1051/jp1:1992181�. �jpa-00246603�
Classification
Physics
Abstracts61.50 64.70P 61.40D
The implication of the lattice in the non-equilibrium behaviour of
aglassy crystal
M.
Descarr~ps (I),
J. F. Willa~(I),
G. Odou(I)
and K. Eichhom(2)
(~) Laboratoire de
Dynarnique
et Structure des Matdriaux Mo16culaires (*), Universitd de Lille I, Bit P5, F59655 Villeneuved'Ascq,
France(~) DESY F 41,
Hasylab,
Notkestr. 85, D 2000Hamburg
52,Germany
(Received 5 February J992,
accepted
infinal form
J7 March J992)Abstract. Time resolved
X-ray
measurements onsingle crystals
of the mixed system(cyanoadarnantane)
j_~ (chloroadamantane)
~,
for xm 0.25, have been made.
Special
attentionhas been
paid
to theunderlying
lattice in theglassy
state. The rotationalglass
transition issignalled by
ajump
of theexpansivity
at T~ as irt conventionalglasses.
There is no signature of thefreezing
on thepeak profiles
after a deepquench
below T~. In theneighbourhood
ofT~
there is evidence of a slow correlatedamplification
of antiferroelectric and ferroelastic fluctuationsrespectively
observed at the X and rpoints
of the Brillouirt zone. In thisquasi
staticordering
process the averageunderlying
lattice ispreserved
but the mean squaredisplacements
are
considerably
increased.1. Introduction.
The
study
ofglasses
and of theglass
transition iscurrently
very active for two main reasons In the domain of conventionalglasses
this ismainly
due to the recentdevelopment
of a modecoupling theory [Il.
The latter has reactivated the discussion between apurely dynamic interpretation
of theglass
transition and the research of a maskedthermodynamic singularity occurring
at atemperature
somewhere below that of the calorimetricglass
transition(T~) [2-4].
In these systems, the translationaldegrees
of freedom aremainly
involved. Inexperiments
this can be seen as a source ofdifficulty
in so far as the structural informationonly
appearthrough
a structure factorS([Q( )
which isspatially averaged.
During
the past few years the domain ofstudy
has been extended to alarger
class of disordered systems. These are inparticular crystalline phases
with an orientational disorder of ce~ain entities which areexpected
to be theonly
ones involved in thefreezing
process. Forthis reason
they
have been seen as suitable models of conventionalglasses.
In fact thisfamily
includes very miscellaneous situations which may be related
only indirectly
to the conventionalglass
state.The most
formerly
studied of theseglassy crystalline
systems are themagnetic spin glasses [5].
Aprerequisite
to their formation is a «positional
» disorder obtainedby
dilution which(*) UA CNRS 801.
leads to a distribution of the
exchange
interactions.Contrary
to conventionalglasses,
frustration and
freezing
as well is inducedby
this dilution.The second category is that of « orientational
glasses
» a review of which waspresented recently [6].
These are mixed molecularcrystals showing
aparaelectric
orparaelastic phase
athigh
temperatures. Thenecessity
of dilution is the aspectthey
share with themagnetic glasses.
Here too, this dilution can induce a frustration effect
[7]. However,
their proper characterseems to be
mainly
associated with thecoupling
between the orientationaldegrees
of freedomand the lattice
displacements.
This mediation of the lattice in thefreezing
mechanism observed at low temperatures appears in every class of orientationalglasses.
It is the case with mixedcrystals
of NaCN : KCN[8]
where the dilution does not involve the rotors(CN)
the cations of different sizes induce static random strains. It is also the case insystems
like KBr KCN[9]
where thedilution directly
acts at the rotor level.Some connections with the
dynamical description
of conventionalglasses
have beenestablished
by
Michel[10]
in atheory
which does not consider the frustationphenomena
asessential.
Through
aparticular
modecoupling formalism,
he was able to describefreezing
as acollective mechanism
leading
to anon-ergodic instability.
The foundation of thetheory
ishowever the
coupling
of orientations with the random strain fieldsgenerated by
thesubstitutional disorder. The
glass
transition canhappen
if thiscoupling
is not toostrong
withregard
to thecoupling
of orientations to lattice vibrations. As a result, the orientational and translational modes are frozentogether.
In diffractionexperiments
thesignature
of thiscoupling
below theglass
transition is an apparentbroadening
of theBragg peaks (B.P.)
of theunderlying
lattice[9].
In this
article,
we are interested in the third category which is that of «glassy crystals
» II].
They
are obtainedby
theundercooling
of theorientationally
disorderedphase
of molecularcrystals (platic phases). Contrary
to the systemspreviously described,
the dilution of animpurity
is not at all necessary to get the orientationalfreezing.
On the other hand there is asimilarity
with theglass-forming liquids,
both in the way theglassy
state is reached and in the manifestation of theglass
transition. This concems inparticular
thefollowing points
which are not found in the diluted orientationalglasses
The disordered
phase
must be undercooled below the first orderequilibrium phase
transition
(occurring
at T~)leading
to the orderedphase.
This transition is not removed as it isby
the dilution in the orientationalglasses
butbypassed
: the success of thequench depends
on a kineticcondition,
which is to crossrapidly
the temperature range ofrapid
transformation
(the
nose in a TTTdiagram [12]).
Theglass
transition occurs in a range oftemperatures
far below T~.The transition from an
ergodic
to anon-ergodic
situation appears in ajump
ofspecific
heat at
T~
withchange
oftemperature.
The
study
of this kind ofglasses
is very attractive since we canexpect
them to be the rotationalanalogue
of conventionalglasses,
and thus contributes to theunderstanding
of the latter. Theunderlying
latticeprovides
agood oppo~unity
offollowing
with accuracy the evolution of thespatial
correlationsthrough S(Q) (Q-Vector
rather than[Q()
in diffractionexperiments.
Of course on can use thisopportunity only
ifsingle crystals
of theplastic phase
can be
quenched.
To ourknowledge,
this could be achievedonly
in two cases :cyclohexanol [13]
andcyanoadamantane (CN-a) [14, 15].
From a technical
point
of view thedifficulty
is that one mustquench
asample
which iseffectively plastic
and often sublimatesquickly.
It is thus necessary toplace
thecrystal
in aglass capillary.
Understrong cooling
the contact of thecrystal
to theglass
wall may induce cracks in thesingle crystal.
Here we present some results of a
study
of CN-a and mixedcompounds
of the latter with the chloroadamantane(CN-a)~ _~(Cl-a)~,
for which the above difficulties does not occur. Atroom
temperature
thesecompounds
haveisomorphous
f-c-c-orientationally
disordered structures[16].
For x«0.5, they
show the sametendency
to form aglassy crystal
afterquenching [19].
However the mixedcompounds
with x m 0.25 are found to be betterglass
formers in the sense which is
usually given
forliquids.
As a consequence the metastable stateranging
between(T~
m 237K)
and(T~
m165K)
is moreeasily investigated
inparticular
indiffraction
experiments.
Infigure 4,
forinstance,
two measurements of latticeparameters
could beperformed
in the domain ofmetastability
fortemperatures higher
thanT~ (180
K and 190 Krespectively).
At thesetemperatures
the metastable state of the mixedcompound
has a life timelong enough
to allowinvestigations
of more than 30 min.Aging
effects have beenclearly
seen in anX-ray investigation
of CN-a[15]. They
appear in the slowgrowth
of superstructurepeaks
at the Brillouin zoneboundary (X point)
whichreflect an antiferroelectric
ordering
of the molecules. In the course of thespecific
investigation
of theordering kinetics,
some reference measurementsperformed
at the zone center(r point) pointed
out thataging
also induced an apparentbroadening
of theBragg peaks (B.P.).
This resultprompted
us toreinvestigate
these B.P, morespecifically
both in time and temperature afterquenchs
from thehigh
temperature disorderedphase.
We are inparticular
concemed with apossible implication
of the lattice in theglass
transition mechanism. From the results obtained with the orientationalglasses
it is a fundamentalpoint
which could
guide
any further theoreticalapproach.
The
technique
used is conventionalX-ray
diffractionsupplemented by
some information drawn from thehigh spatial
resolution of asynchrotron
source.The paper is
organized
as follows.The
experimental procedures
are described in section 2. In section 3, we consider thepossible
influence of theglass
transition on the latticeproperties.
Next(Sect. 4) aging
effectsare
investigated.
2.
Experimental
details.The
single crystals
of(CN-a)1_~(Cl-a)~
with xm 0.25 have been grown
by
slowevaporation
of a solution in methanol
(crystal
sizem 0.8 x 0.8 x 0.8 mm ~).
Experiments
wereperformed
with a conventional
X-ray
sourceequipped
with apyrolitic graphite
monochromator(A
Mo K&=
0.711
A).
Thesamples
were mounted on the Eulerian circle of an automaticdiffractometer
allowing rapid changes
of orientations to follow the simultaneous timeevolution of several reflections and
superstructure peaks.
Thesample
temperatureT could be controlled to within 0.5 K in the range l10K ~ T~ 300 K.
Quenching
wasachieved
by blowing
a stream of coolnitrogen
over thesample.
We estimate the time forquenching
from room temperature(R.T.)
to be less than 5 susing
this method. In theexperiment
thecrystal
was notprotected by
acapillary.
Theonly precaution
is not to stay toolong
at R-T- in order to avoid sublimation. Some testexperiments
wereperformed
on thesynchrotron
source DESY withsingle crystals
of the sameorigin (Diffractometer
D3 of theHasylab).
The results
presented
in this paper were obtained on the samesingle crystal
at several stages of a treatment whichimplies
thetemperature
and the time. An overallpicture
of thethermal
history imposed
to thesample
is shown infigure
I. Thepa~ition
of theexperiment
isas follows :
a) study
of the domain ofstability
of the disorderedphase
: measurements of the lattice parameters andpeak profiles
;b) study
of thepeak profiles
after adeep quench
below theglass
transitionT~
;c)
measurements of the lattice parameters belowT~
;d) aging experiment
at 160 K : time evolution of the B-P- and superstructurepeaks
e)
measurements of the latticeparameters
aboveT~
in the domain ofmetastability
of thedisordered
phase.
Thesample
wasrecycled
to R-T- after everyquench
in order to avoidparasitic
nucleation.The o-2 o scans
presented
in the paper(Figs. 3,
7,9)
are not corrected forK~~ spectral
line.This
leads,
atlarge Q,
tonon-significant asymmetry
andshifting
with respect to the ho= 0
setting
valid for theK~j
radiation.K~~
contribution is included in thefitting procedures.
@ @ @ @ @
(
~
PLASTIC PHASE
(P.P)
I
«---(
< w
~j
f
METASTABLEBP
#
~ ~
~ ~ ~
UJ
I-
~ GLASSY PP. AGING
16H 24H 6H 15H 2H
EXPE RI MENT TIME PARTITION
(HOURS)
Fig.
I. Thermalhistory
of theexperiment.
The five stagesappearing
on thediagram
are described in the text.3. The cubic lattice in
equilibrium
and undercooled conditions.A remarkable feature is the
perfection
of thecrystals
of the disorderedphase.
This was tested with thesynchrotron
source and is illustrated infigure
2. On severalcrystals,
w -scans as wellas o-2 o scans of the
(511)
B.P. gave widthsranging
between 0.004° and 0.007° HWHM ino. It is
typically
the width observed on this instrument for aperfect
siliconcrystal.
Themeasurements were useful in order to determine the instrumental resolution of the
conventional apparatus, used in the
following
; the same scan gave a width of 0.06° HWHM in o.The same
crystal
could be studied in the domain ofequilibrium
within theplastic phase (T
m 240 K and under undercooled conditions(Fig, I).
It was notquenched
totemperatures ranging
between 190 K andm 237 K where the transformation to the low temperature
phase
is the most
rapid.
At R-T- it was found to be cubic f-c-c- The lattice constants were obtained from the set ofequivalent (sll)
B-P-giving (a=9.833h±0.002;
a =90°±
0.02°).
Figure
3apresents
o-2 o scansthrough
variousreciprocal
latticepoints.
TheBragg intensity
decreases
considerably
athigher
hklbut,
contrary toother,
more disordered,plastic crystals,
several orders of reflection can beclearly
observed. When corrected for theK~~
contami-(cNa)
~~
(cia)
~~
5
0=sll
'295K
/~
u~
' u~
d
~o
3~
°
~/
~ 2
~
z
uJ .
~ z
o .
o o
,o o
Q -
nation and
plotted
on theQ scale,
it becomesapparent
that there is noQ dependent broadening.
As a consequence, thelarge
orientational disorder of the molecules acts as adistortion of the first kind
[17a]
and isfunctionally indistinguishable
from the effect of thermal vibrations.It will be shown in section 5 that
aging
thecrystal
at temperaturesneighbouring
T~
involves anapparent broadening
of the B.P. Our aim at present is to know if such abroadening
can be detected soon after aquench.
To suppressaging effects,
thecrystal
wasquenched
at a temperature well belowT~
where the kinetics of evolution areimperceptible.
Figure
3b shows scans which wereperformed
after aquench
at 116 K. Neithersplitting
norbroadening
of the lines can be detected. The widths of thepeaks
remain those of the instrumental resolution. The lattice is found to beagain
f-c-c- with the same accuracy on theparameters (at
116 K a=
9.652
A
± 0.002
A
; a = 90° ±
0.02°).
Weonly
notice a sizeable increase of thepeak intensity.
The evolution with temperature of the
cubic
latticeparameter
was obtained from the(511)
B.P,
during
the stages a, c, e of theexperiment
described infigure
I. The result isgiven
infigure
4. Theexperimental points
areclearly
divided into two data sets which can beindependently
fitted to twostraight
lines. Note that thepoint corresponding
to 160 Kdeparts slightly
from the fitted line. This can beexplained by
some unavoidableaging
effectsoccurring quite rapidly
at thistemperature (cf.
Sect.4).
Theparameters
measured in the metastable domain(180 K,
190K)
of theplastic phase
follow the line of thehigh
temperature data.The intersection of the lines at m 166 K
gives
rise to apronounced jump
of theexpansivity
ha m 10~ ~ K~
(Fig. 5).
Such anexpansivity change
is athermodynamic signature
of theglass
(CNa)_75 (C~a)_25
2
$400
~~~~~~~~
j
~~~~ ~O .~
~
~
~
~ ~
i *
z
.
~ .
o
«(
o
~
~~_ ~
8 ~
~
f~
.
*
O
~
O .
~ °
°
O
z .
O
.
~ . .
*
O . .
* *
~ O *
O
.
. .
~
. *
O
o
o
O *
uJ .
~ ° .
~ o
~ o
z o o
~ 5 $
Q ,
O ~
~
. o O
o o
-5 -25 O 25 -25 O 25 5
AH (DEGREES)
Fig.
3. 0-2 6 scans of differentBragg
peaks at R-T- a) and just after a quench b) into the glassy plasticphase at 116 K. In the limit of the instrumental resolution, no
broadening
of the lines was detected in this quenchexperiment
(K~~ contaminants are not removed).transition T~
[18].
Its occurrence at a temperature somewhat below that of the pure CN-a[19]
reflects theslightly
sho~er time scale for the moleculardynamics
in the mixed system.One can conclude
that,
while the manifestation of the conventionalglass
transition occurs atT~,
no noticeablechange
is observed belowT~
at the Brillouin zone center, which couldindicate a modification of the lattice strains. This is true after a
deep quench
and at the short times after a more shallowquench.
4.
Aging
effects at the Brillouin zone center.At low
temperatures, roughly
for T~140 K, no clear evolution of theX-ray
spectra arevisible at least
during
the first hoursfollowing
aquench.
Towardshigher
temperatures(140
K~ T<
T~) large
timedependent
effects have beensignalled
for the(x
=0)
purecompound [14,15].
In aprevious study
a slowgrowth
of diffusescattering
around the960 40
~s
~
i~
"< 940 7 ~~ ..
. . ~
uJ
~
30
g
920 /~
j
l~ I
25~
900
~
~~ 20
loo 150 200 250 300 loo 150 200 250 300
TEMPERATURE
(K)
TEMPERATURE(K)
Fig.
4.Fig.
5.Fig.
4.Temperature dependence
of the cell volume. The datacorresponding
to the stable and metastableplastic phase
and thosecorresponding
to theglassy plastic phase
areindependently
fitted to twostraight
lines.Fig.
5. Coefficient of thermalexpansion
: a =~~'
versus temperature.
V aT
forbidden reflections of the f-c-c- structure was observed.
Figure
7 shows that these Brillouinzone
boundary
effects(X points)
also appearduring
an isothermalaging
of the(x
=
0.25) compound.
At the sametemperature
theonly change
between x=
0 and x
=
0.25 is the
slightly higher
rate of evolution in the latter case ; thegeneral
outlook of thegrowth
curve(Fig. 8c)
ispreserved
I-e- immediate but slowgrowth
andgradual slowing
down whichgives
a weak timedependence
to the overall process.Fu~hermore some test measurements of the main B-P- of CN-a have shown
changes
occurring
at the Brillouin zone center(r points).
A summary of the results will begiven
before
describing
ourspecific investigation
of thisphenomenon
on the mixedcompound.
These results are
represented
infigures 6a, 6b,
taken from aprevious
paper[15].
The lattice parameter determination
repeatedly performed
on the(sll)
B-P- indicatesan apparent contraction of the cubic cell
resulting
from a slowshifting
of the top of thepeaks
toward
larger Q
values.Scans
through
various B.P. taken at certain momentsduring
anaging
run at 160 Kdisplay
abroadening
of the lines which can besignificant
after several tens of hoursespecially
at
large
values ofQ.
The
broadening AQ
seems to be verydependent
of theQ
value(AQ
ozQ~
withn m
2).
This couldpoint
out the occurrence ofcrystalline imperfections
of the second kindII 7a].
These would inducelarge
fluctuations of the intermolecular distances whichdestroy
theaverage
crystalline periodicity.
However the
points quoted
above do not matcheasily
with other observations :I)
the loss of translational invariance has been found to beperfectly
reversible uponreheating
;it)
whilebeing only signalled by
a limited number ofexperimental points,
thebroadening
seems to
obey
kinetics of evolution which have characters incomplete opposition
to those800 : Q scans at160K
2 h 64 h
1000
I
O
~
~
~
z x
O
~
~
~16h 73h
f
« z
UJ ~
~ O
~ ~
~ z
~
o 1 x10-~
° 40 h
~io-2
hours
I
dq
a) .
t 800
8
_x Ok
.
,
#
~
j
i
"«
~
j . .
5
..
O 2 A
b)
Fig.
6. - a)
Q fter ging for 64
-.25 O .25.50 -.25 O .25.50 -.25 O.25 .50
~
~~~~ fi
t=lHz ~
: ~
t=7.2H
m° .
I
4%
t=15,2H
o
.
..
.
:
Z S
8 ~
I(
I
~(
o.5
9
G
6 6~
. 160K
@
u~ .
~ .
f
4 .o .
u ~~ .
~~
[ lS T=160K .i
2iio
2aJ b
-
v 5
~i
O 5 lO 15
O ~"'~ ~~°~'~~
-
@
#
u .~ .
~ 4 . 4
z .
~ ~
o
u .
~
.m . 2
~ .
d
_ . .
O .
" .
@
°' .
Ul ~ . ~
~ .
Z .
~ O
O .
O i
Z~
o o
o
5io
15TIME
(HOURS)
Fig.
8. Kinetics of evolution observed at the r (511) and X (121)points during
a 15 hoursaging
at 160K. a)peak intensity
of the sll Bragg component (inset time evolution of the mean squaredisplacement),
b)peak intensity
of the sll diffuse component, c)peak intensity
of the 121 superstructurepeak.
The
Q dependence
is illustrated infigure 9,
which shows scans at the(400)
and(800) positions performed
at the start and at the end of theaging
run.Comparing
the differentscans, it is clear that the ratio of the diffuse over the
Bragg
component as well as its rate of evolution increase withincreasing Q.
This effect is soimpo~ant
at the(800) position
that theBragg
reflection becomesnearly
obscured: after 15 hours theintensity
of the D-C- ism 0.7 times that of the B-P- Fitted values of the
peak
parameters are listed in table I.The
large
decrease of theBragg intensity
iscoherently explained by
the decrease of an effectiveDebye
Waller factor. As shown infigure
8a the associated mean-squaredisplacement
Table I. Fitted value
of peak intensity
correctedjkom
theK~2
radiation.Peaks
I~c(t
m0) IBC(t m0) I~c(t
m15h) IBC(t
m15h)
121
(X)
13 28400
(l~
205 13 891 852 8 333sll
(l~
178 5 220 481 2 416800
(l~
43 802 165 15~~~
~~.~~~~~~~~~
20
$400 ~
~"°.~~'~~~
~l~~~~
5
* . 160K ~~~
u w
. li w
~
*
~
. .
~ . .
~ *
§
~ ~ ] $
o
~u *
o . .
-
~ *
--,,,....»,>
~
*
$
160K8
~
.
~ ~
~
*S
° .
° *
~ .
°
2
~ . ~
AH
-5Fig.
15 hours ging at
160
K. The hatched
reas orresponds
the Bragg
ncreases lmost in time. At the end of
aging it
is2.5 times that
observed
at
R-T-Onthe other
hand
the widths of the D-C- andtheir
l-offset rom the correspondingB-P-
areeemingly
independent
of Q.
Their rate of increasedependence.
The impo~ant point
revealed by igures 7, 8 is that the intensity of
the
D-C- growswith the
iffracted ntensity observed at the X point.The growth
curvescan
be
nearly
DiscussioN. Satellites
occurring
at the Xpoints
indicate atendency
to form a superstructure. The diffusivepeaks
have been found to be staticby
neutronscattering
measurements on CN-a
[20]
; thusthey
represent anordering
of the moleculardipoles.
Considering
the behaviour of theordering
kinetics under such adeep undercooling
and inparticular
the fact that the response is immediate and notdelayed,
it was concluded in[15]
that the mechanism is most
probably
a continuousordering
rather than adroplet
nucleation.ln real space this may be described as the spontaneous
development
of diffuseregions
ofincreasing
antiferroelectric orderthroughout
the disordered lattice. The situation isanalogous
to that of
spinodal decomposition
for ademixing
systembut,
in this case, it involves and order parameter which is not conserved[211. Accordingly
the mechanism is the rotational diffusion of the molecules rather than the volume diffusion which operates in the conserved case.The
non-randomly
distributedperturbations
of the parent cubic lattice are also the centers of elastic distortions which areprobed
at the rpoint
of the Brillouin zone. Thegrowth
at thispoint
of the D-C- in exact correlation with that observed at the Xpoint
can beinterpreted
asbeing
theamplification
of Fourier components of strain waves[17b].
The width of the D.C.gives
an estimate of the minimum value of the lattice modulationwavelength
which can grow.It appears to be about 2 times that of the minimum
wavelength
for the orientationalmodulations.
The asymmetry of the D-C- with
regard
to the average lattice nodepoints
out a correlation between the orientational andpositional
disorder[17c]. According
to the direction of this asymmetry one thus expects that the most diffusive latticeplanes
are also the lessspaced.
Molecules of adamantane derivatives are achieved
by
introduction of abulky
side group into the adamantane molecule and are much lessglobular
than adamantane itself. It has been shown[22]
that stericrepulsions
between the Van der Waalsenvelopes
of the moleculesplay
an
important
pa~ in the formation of thecrystalline
field and also in the formation of strong orientational correlations. One cansuspect
that the rotational translationalcoupling
isgenerated by
steric hindrance as shownschematically
infigure
IO.From
X-ray experiments
one cannot determine whether theordering
is static ordynamic,
but due to the correlations mentioned
above,
the D-C- seems to bequasistatic.
From the evolution of the B-P- it appears that thecrystal
remains cubic on an average. The timedependence
of theDebye-Waller
factors could beexplained by
theamplification
of thequasistatic
translational modes. This leads tolarge
anomalous mean-squaredisplacements
asituation which is close to that described
by
thetheory
of Michel and Rowe[26].
Anexperiment performed
on a muchlonger aging
time would be very suitable in order tocorrelate more
precisely
the timedependence
of the different data.5.
Summary
and conclusion.The most relevant results of this
X-ray investigation
of the Brillouin zone center of(CN-a)j _~(Cl-a),
are thefollowing
ones.Effect on the lattice of the
change-over
to theglassy-crystalline
state.Contrary
to whatwas observed in KBr: KCN orientational
glasses [8]
no effectivebroadening
of thefundamental lines of the
underlying
cubic lattice can beobserved,
at least within the limit of resolution of the conventional apparatus which was used. Thisnegative
result isimportant
since it couldgive
a strong indication that thecoupling
of orientations with both translations and randomstrains,
as introduced in the modecoupling theory
of the diluted orientationalglasses [10],
either would not be fundamental toexplain
the entrance of the present system into anon-ergodic situation,
or would have more subtle manifestations.Anyway,
the nature of the « defects » which could induce static strains is not clear in thepresent
system. Ina-~~
a
I+£
Fig. 10. Schematic illustration of a
possible
mechanism for translation-rotationcoupling
in CN-a.particular
one should not cite the dilution of Cl-a since the pure CN-a has anexactly
similarglass
behaviour. On the other hand theexpansivity
of the lattice shows apronounced change
at
T~.
This raises thequestion
of the connection between the process offalling
out ofequilibrium
of theassembly
of rotors and theapparent
decrease ofanharmonicity.
Effect on the lattice of an
aging
process belowT~.
Under isothermal
aging
at not too low atemperature,
an apparentbroadening
of the B.P.slowly
takesplace.
It is shown in this paper that, infact,
itcorresponds
to the correlatedgrowth
of a diffuse componentslightly
shifted from the rposition
and to thedrop
of the B.P.intensity
itself. Both effects are correlated to a slowdevelopment
ofsuperstructure peaks
situated at the zone
boundary (X point).
This is
interpreted
as a process ofordering
which occurs in a continuous rather than nucleated way. The mechanism is theslow,
butspontaneous amplification
ofstrongly coupled
orientational antiferroelectric and ferroelastic fluctuations. In this process the
crystal
remains cubic on average but shows an effective increase of the mean-squaredisplacements
associated with the strain field. Theamplification
ofhomophase
fluctuationsessentially proceeds
incoherency
with the parent lattice. This is inperfect
agreement with thecomplete reversibility
observed when
heating
upagain.
In
[15]
it has been shown that the kinetics of antiferroelectricordering
isextremely weakly
time
dependent.
Forexample,
the characteristic size Lprovided by
the radial width of the Xsuperlattice peaks
grows as L= At ~ where b m0.I. Here t is the time
elapsed
after thequench.
In a system with a non-conserved order parameter one expects b =1/2[23].
The steric hindrance betweenrotating
molecules has beenproposed
as a mechanism which couldexplain
this unusual value of b. The simulation of asimple [24]
modelincluding
steric constraints couldeffectively give, during
a transient, values of b somewhat lower than theexpected
one but not smallenough
toexplain
theexperimental
results. Because of thecoupling
which has been shown above it seems reasonable to assume that the anomalousslowing
down of the kinetics could also have itsorigin
in the need to accommodate elastic strains as the transformationproceeds.
Theoreticalpredictions
on the timedependence
would then have to introduceexplicitly
the translation rotationcoupling [25, 26].
Since the
ordering
kinetics are notdelayed
after adeep quench,
anextremely
limitedamount of
homophase
fluctuations mustcertainly spread
outduring
thequench
itself. Itcannot be discarded that these fluctuations influence the
freezing. They
couldplay
the role ofpre-existing
« defects »although they
arecertainly
notrandomly
distributed in the lattice.This would lead to very fine effects : the
quenched phase
is wo~hbeing
studied athigher
resolution the
quality
of thecrystals
would allow such anexperiment.
Acknowledgements.
This work was
suppo~ed by
the EEC Science contract SCI-0426-C(CD).
We thank Dr J. Naudts and Prof. K. H. Michel for useful discussions.
References
[I] GOTzE W.,
Aspects
of structuralglass
transition, inLiquids Freezing
and the Glass transition, J. P.Hansen, D.
Levesque
and J. Zinn Justin, Eds. (North Holland, 1990).[21 ANGELL C. A., J.
Phys.
Chem. Solids 49 (1988) 863.[3] SOULETIE J., J.
Phys.
France51(1990)
883.[4] SETHNA J., SHOVE J. D., HUANG M., Phys. Rev. B 44 (1991) 4943.
[5] BINDER K., YOUNG A. P., Rev. Mod.
Phys.
58(1986)
801.[6] HOCHLI U. T., KNORR K., LOIDL A., Adv. Phys. 39 (1990) 405-615.
[71 CARMESIN H. O., BINDER K., Z Phys. B 68 (1987) 375.
[8] LOIDL A., SCHRADER T., BOHMER R., KNORR K., KJEMS J. K., BORN R.,
Phys.
Rev. B 34 (1986) 1238.[9] LOIDL A., KNORR K., ROWE J. M., Mc INTYRE G. F., Phys. Rev. B 37 (1988) 389.
[10] MICHEL K. H., Z. Phys. B, Cond. Mat. 68 (1987) 259 BOSTOEN C., MICHEL K. H.,
Phys.
Rev. B 43(1991)
4415.[I II SUGA H., SEKI S., J. non
Cryst.
Sol. 16 (1974) 171.[12] EL ADIB M., DESCAMPS M., CHANH N. B., Phase transitions 14 (1989) 85.
[13] CECCALDI D., DENOYER F., LAMBERT M., SzwARc H., J.
Phys.
France 41(1980)
L365 ANDRt D., CECCALDI D., SzWARC H., J.Phys.
France 45 (1984) 731,[14] DESCAMPS M., CAUCHETEUX C., ODOU G., SAUVAJOL J. L., J. Phys. Lett. 45 (1984) L719.
[15] DESCAMPS M., CAUCHETEUX C., J. Phys. C 20 (1987) 5070.
[16] FOULON M., LEFEBVRE J., AMOUREUX J. P., MULLER M., MAGNIER D., J. Phys. France 46 (1985) 919
FOULON M., Thdse de Doctorat d'Etat, Lille (1987).
[17] GUINIER A., Thdorie et
technique
de laradiocristallographie
(Dunod, Paris, 1964) a) pp. 490-492 ; b) pp. 539-541 c) pp. 588-591.[18] ANGELL C. A. and SICHINA W., Ann. NY Ac Sc 279 (1976) 53-67.
[19] FOULON M., AMOUREUX J. P., SAUVAJOL J. L., LEFEBVRE J., DESCAMPS M., J.
Phys.
C : Solid StatePhys.
16 (1983) L265.[20] LEFEBVRE J., ROLLAND J. P., SAUVAJOL J. L., HENNION B., J.
Phys.
C Solid StatePhys.
18(1985)
241.[21] BJNDER K., Rep. Frog. Phys. 50 (1987) 783.
[22] DESCAMPS M., J.
Phys.
C : Solid StatePhys.
15 (1982) 7265.[23] ALLEN S. M., CAHN J. W., Acta Met. 27 (1979) 1085.
[24]
WILLART J. F., NAUDTS J., DESCAMPS M., Phase Transition 31 (1991) 261.[25] MICHEL K. H., NAUDTS J.,