HAL Id: hal-01823459
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01823459
Submitted on 26 Jun 2018
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
Experimental modal analysis and finite element model updating for structural health monitoring of reinforced
concrete radioactive waste packages
Jesús Eiras, Cedric Payan, Sandrine Rakotonarivo, Vincent Garnier
To cite this version:
Jesús Eiras, Cedric Payan, Sandrine Rakotonarivo, Vincent Garnier. Experimental modal analy- sis and finite element model updating for structural health monitoring of reinforced concrete ra- dioactive waste packages. Construction and Building Materials, Elsevier, 2018, 180, pp.531-543.
�10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2018.06.004�. �hal-01823459�
1
g
2
package
3 4 J
. 5
6 7 8 9 10 11
. 12
13
. 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 , 31 . 32
*Revised Manuscript
Click here to view linked References
1 33 34
g — : “ ”—
35 36
. 37
38
. 39
40
, 41
42
, 43
44 . 45 46 47 48
1.
n .
49
50 51 52
100 65
53
. ,
54 55
– . 56
57 58 59
. Previous 60
, 61
9 62
63
. 64
65 66
0 67
. 68
69 70 71
, 72
73 74 75
1 2 .
76 77 78 79 80
3 81
82 . 83
4 84
85
15– 7 . 86
87 . 88
n 89
, is used ,
90 91 8 . 92
, 93
18 . 94
95 96 97
u ng . n
98 99
, 100
19 0 . 101
102 103 104 105
1 2 , 3 , 24 ,
106
25 , 25 27 1 , 8 29 29 , 0 .
107
, 108
109 .
. 110
. 112
113
. 114
115
19 1 , 32
116
7 6 28 3 4 5
117 118
. ,
119 120
on 121
122 .
. 123
124 125 126 127 128
, ’
129 130 131 132 133 134
. 135
136 137 138
3 139
140 n 4 141 142
143 144 145
2 146 147 2.1 148 149
. , ,
150
2b 151
2b 152
153 1.5
1 154
2.
1. d
155
. 156
360 kg 662 kg
package 3831 kg
8417 kg
157 158 .
. 159
. 160
161 162 163 3 164 165 166 167 2
. 168
3.
169 170 on
. 171
dynamic modulus and Poisson’
172
14 36 . d
173
longitudinal frequency mode, and Poisson’s 174
c
, 14.
175 176
, 177
178
2 179
d .
180
2.
181
, Poisson’s ratio,ν ρ(kg/m3
39 0.18 2320
182 183 2.2 184 185
. 186
187 188 189 on
. 190
191 192 2
. 4
193 194 d
. 195
196 7 .
p p(ω)
197
, 1
198
p(ω) p(ω) 199
200 .
p, 201
1ω , 2 ω , …, 80 ω , , ω , o
202
o .
203
37 38 1
204 205 38 206 207
1 208
37 39 . 209
1000 210
211
4.
. 3
212
5 213
214
215 216 20
5 217
218 219
5 6
220 221 20 222 223 224 225 226 227
5.
20 and
228
6
. *
4 229
7 7b
230
, 7
231
7 . spring ,
232 233
. 234
235 ,
. 236
spring ,
237 238 239 240
ρ 2320 3 . 241
242
. 243
7 244
245 2
246
, 247
248 249 250 251
0 1
252 253
2 . 1 2
254
— 255
3 2 —
256 257 258 .
3831 kg 2
259
, 260
261
, 262
263
265 266
267 n
ϕn 7
268 269
2, 270
271
. 272
, 26, 27 273
274 . 275
, 276
, 2
277
ϕ ϕn
278
n 279
n v
280
. 8 20
281
shown in Figure 6 282
shown in Figure 283
284 285
. ,
286
, 16
287
8 288
289 290 291
. 292
7.
c
8.
,
293 5 294 295 296 297 , 298
, the Poisson’s ratio 299
ν, ,
300
, 301
302
, 3
303
304 305
n 306
307 4
308 , 309 310
on 311
. 312
313 314
7 315
316 7 . ob 317 318
4 . 319
320 5 321
. 322
323
, 5
324
, , , 325
. 326
1 5
327
1 6
328
indicative values obtained for the elastic modulus and Poisson’s ratio of the concrete (those 329
, , 330
331
332 333
4 334
5 335
336 337 338
genetic algorithms mimic “natural selection” to 339
340 341 342
on 343
by on
344 345 346 347 348 . 349 350 351 352 6 .
1.
353 354
104 355
356 357 358
3 1 9
359 360 361
3.
362
1 40 35 30
2 Poisson’s ratio 0.300 0.225 0.150
3 2 10.00 5.05 0.10
4 2 10.00 5.05 0.10
5 1000 500 0
6 2 10.00 5.05 0.10
363
9. .
364 365
10 0
366
, ,
367
. 368
10 369
0 0 .
370
ions of Poisson’s ratio 0 , 371
0 0
372 373
. 375
376 .
f’
377
10. 3
r loaded and unloaded FEM. a) Elastic modulus, b) Poisson’s ratio, c) , , , .
4 .
378 379 380
ν 381
c
382 383 384 385 386
. 1
387 388 1b
. 389
390 391 392
0 . 393
394 395 396 397 398
Figures 11 1d 399
400 401
both cases, while Poisson’s ratio, the added mass, and the boundary conditions variations 402
403
4.
404
ν
2 2 2
f ’4 4
k 7a 35.00 0.15 5.05 0.10 500.0 3.16
38.74 0.18 0.10 0.45 967.0 1.82 2.04
35.85 0.17 5.26 0.77 576.8 1.77
k 7 35.00 0.30 10.00 0.10 0 5.005 5.89
38.24 0.29 10.00 1.27 1000 10.00 12.63 3.57
5.
405
k
1 230.7 220.9 0.98 228.4 0.98 231.1 0.98
2 474.0 470.9 0.99 479.5 0.99 475.3 0.99
3 491.7 486.0 0.99 493.9 0.99 489.7 0.99
4 530.3 521.4 0.98 518.7 0.98 523.1 0.98
5 558.3 540.9 0.89 548.2 0.90 544.6 0.90
6 606.9 605.8 0.82 616.5 0.80 612.1 0.81
7 660.2 659.4 0.92 675.2 0.92 667.9 0.92
8 742.8 749.2 0.81 740.4 0.82 751.6 0.82
9 758.0 757.6 0.81 769.6 0.79 763.3 0.80
10 774.0 761.3 0.90 775.8 0.90 767.1 0.90
11 813.1 802.5 0.76 818.5 0.77 807.8 0.75
12 837.1 842.0 0.74 852.2 0.70 846.3 0.74
13 901.9 928.2 0.83
1 239.5 232.3 0.99 241.03 0.99 237.7 0.99
2 476.8 485.0 0.99 480.16 0.99 479.4 0.99
3 493.2 490.8 0.99 486.20 0.99 491.4 0.99
4 534.0 524.3 0.98 524.19 0.98 534.3 0.98
5 562.8 553.0 0.75 550.09 0.75 553.6 0.75
6 612.3 622.5 0.73 620.08 0.82 617.2 0.74
7 660.0 686.1 0.95 675.48 0.94 670.6 0.94
8 747.7 764.8 0.67 752.84 0.67 760.9 0.65
9 759.1 786.7 0.81 772.25 0.81 766.1 0.80
10 775.5 790.0 0.89 775.50 0.88 769.4 0.88
11 824.7
12 839.7 839.83 0.83 848.6 0.70
13 902.8 944.00 0.89 933.0 0.85
406 407 408 409
11.
a
410 6 411 412 p
. d two
413
, .
414
. 415
c
d 417
418 . 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428
. 429
430 431 432
27 4 . 433
434 435 436
, 437
b 438
439 440 441 442
65 . 47
443 444 445 446
48 49 . 447
448 449 450
0 . 451
, 452
453 . 454 455 456 457 458 459 460
1 1 2
461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468
3 . 469
470
support g
471
Investissements d’avenir, 472
, o .
473
on 474
475 476
477 478 479 480 481
. 482
483
, , 1006984, 2016.
484
olar, “Concrete and cement 485
composites used for radioactive waste deposition,” –
486
179, pp. 147–155, 2017.
487
K. E. Kurtis, Y. Xi, M. A. Glinicki, J. Provis, E. R. Giannini, and T. Fu, “Can We 488
Environments?,”
489
53–59, 2017.
490
B. Pomaro, “A Review on Radiation Damage in Concrete for Nuclear Facilities:
491
From Experiments to Modeling,” –10, 2016.
492
llote, and P. Zuloaga, “Some principles of service 493
494
radioactive waste containers of El Cabril disposal (Spain),”
495
no. 2–3, pp. 82–95, 2006.
496
. S. Duffó, E. A. Arva, F. M. Schulz, and D. R. Vazquez, “Durability of a 497
498
waste disposal facility,” –3, pp. 382–387, 2012.
499
a, H. Sasano, Y. Nishioka, and G. Igarashi, “Strength and Young’s 500
term drying and heating up to 90°C,”
501
– 502
N. Trivedi and R. K. Singh, “Assessment of in 503
specimen and prototype nuclear containment structure,”
504
71, pp. 16–
505 9 506
L. Areias, “Detection and evaluation of cra 507
Nuclear Waste container using combined NDT techniques,” , 508
–378, 2015.
509
0 A. G. Davis, J. G. Evans, and B. H. Hertlein, “Nondestructive Evaluation of 510
Tanks,”
511
–167, 1997.
512 513 1 514
“Trul 515
516
and concrete structure strain monitoring,”
517
2 . Bethmont, M. Landolt, and S. Lesoille, “Optical fiber for 3D 518
imaging of deformations in concrete containers stacked,” in 519
, 2017.
520
3 G. Hearn and R. Testa, “Modal Analysis for Damage Detection in Structures,”
521
–3063, 1991.
522
4 “ of civil engineering structures,”
523 524
, 1993.
525
5 , C. Farrar, and M. Prime, “A summary review of vibration 526
damage identification methods,” , –105, 1998.
527
6 . Fan and P. Qiao, “Vibration 528
2011.
530
7 S. Das, P. Saha, and S. K. Patro, “Vibration 531
for health monitoring of structures: a review,”
532
3, pp. 477–507, 2016.
533
8 X. Kong, C. Cai, and J. Hu, “The State 534
Structural Damage Identification for Decision Making,” p.
535
497, 2017.
536 19 537
. 538
1995.
539
0 J. E. Mottershead and M. I. Friswell, “Model Updating In Structural Dynamics: A 540
Survey,” –375, 1993.
541
1 E. Caetano, “Experimental Modal Analysis of Civil Engineering 542
Structures,” –20, 2006.
543 2 544
Aguilera, “Integrating geomatic approaches, Operational Modal Analysis, 545
546
of the historical Bôco Bridge,” –984, 2018.
547
3 . Brehm, V. Zabel, and C. Bucher, “An automatic mode pairing strategy using an 548
enhanced modal assurance criterion based on modal strain energies,” , 549
–5392, 2010.
550
4 G. Osmancikli, A. Bayraktar, T. Türker, Ş. Uçak, and A. Mosallam, “Finite element 551
model calibration of precast structures using ambient vibrations,”
552
–21, 2015.
553
5 D. P. Thambiratnam, “Model
554
updating of real structures with ambient vibration data,” , 555
–341, 2016.
556
26 . , M.A. Diaferio, “Preliminary approach of dynamic 557
nder buildings by neural networks,”
558
80, pp. 183 189, 2016.
559
7 P. G. Bakir, E. Reynders, and G. De Roeck, “Sensitivity 560
updating using constrained optimization with a trust region algorithm,”
561
–225, 2007.
562
8 S. Ivorra, F. J. Pallares, and J. M. Adam, “Dynamic b 563
A case study,” –1092, 2009.
564
29 A. Cabboi, C. Gentile, and A. Saisi, “From continuous vibration mo 565
masonry tower,”
566
–265, 2017.
567
0 Mayorga, and A. Sáez, “Control of structural
568 569
destructive techniques,” –583, 2015.
570 571 1
. , , , ,
572
32 J. L. Zapico, M. P. González, M. I. Friswell, C. A. Taylor, and A. J. Crewe, “Finite 573
element model updating of a small scale bridge,”
574
993–1012, 2003.
575
33 . , , , “
576
,” . 138, pp.
577
183 194, 2014.
578
4 “
579
” , 50, no. 3, 580
pp. 875 886, 2015.
581
35 , . , “
582
,” . 481–495, 2013.
583
6 14,
584
, ,
585
, 2014.
586
37 .
587
, , 1995.
588
38 R. J. Allemang and D. L. Brown, “A complete review of the complex mode indicator 589
function (CMIF) with applications,” in . . . . . ,
590
2006, pp. 3209–3246.
591
39 ng, “Structural Testing. Part 2 : Modal Analysis and Simulation.” Brüel &
592
, , 1988.
593
0 H. Takabatake, “Effect of Dead Loads on Natural Frequencies of Beams,”
594
–1052, 1991.
595
1 and X. Zhu, “Analysis of effect of dead loads on natural frequencies of 596
element techniques,” –516,
597
1996.
598
2 P. Lundqvist and N. Rydén, “Acoustoelastic effects on the resonance frequencies of 599
term measurements,” –
600
41, 2012.
601
3 C. Payan, V. Garnier, J. Moysan, and P. A. Johnson, “Determination of third order 602
elastic constants in a complex solid applying coda wave interferometry,”
603 604
R. J. Allemang and D. L. Brown, “A correlation coefficient for modal vector 605
analysis,” , pp. 110–116, 1982.
606
5 Response surface methodology :
607 608
6 L. P. Khoo and C. H. Chen, “Integration of Response Surface Methodology with 609
Genetic Algorithms,” –489, 2001.
610
47 as, J. S. Popovics, M. V. Borrachero, J. Monzó, and J. Payá, “The effects of 611
612
NDT methods,” pp. 565 571, 2015.
613
48 D. G. Lam, and C. S. Apstein, “Exponential
614
Temperature Dependance of Young’s Modulus for Several Oxides,”
615
122, no. 6, pp. 1754 1759, 1961.
616
49 S. N. Shoukry, G. W. William, M. Y. Riad, and B. Downie, “Effect of moisture and 617
n the mechanical properties of concrete,”
618
25, no. 2, pp. 688–696, 2011.
619
50 H. Sohn, “Effects of environmental and operational variability on structural health 620
monitoring,” Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci., vol. 365, no. 1851, pp.
621
539–560, 2007.
622
1 C. Boutin, S. Hans, E. Ibraim, and P. Roussillon, “In situ experiments and seismic 623
analysis of existing buildings. Part I: Experimental investigations,”
624
–1546, 2005.
625
2 A. De la Foye, “Development of a mechanical device meant to excite buildings 626
slated for demolition,” in ,
627
2017.
628
630 631 632 633 634
