HAL Id: jpa-00246767
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00246767
Submitted on 1 Jan 1993
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Diffuse scattering in K1-x(ND4)x I mixed crystals
Jean-François Berret, S. Ravy, B. Hennion
To cite this version:
Jean-François Berret, S. Ravy, B. Hennion. Diffuse scattering in K1-x(ND4)x I mixed crystals. Journal
de Physique I, EDP Sciences, 1993, 3 (4), pp.1031-1041. �10.1051/jp1:1993181�. �jpa-00246767�
J. Phys. I France 3 (1993) 1031-1041 APRIL 1993, PAGE 1031
Classification
Physics
Abstracts64.70P 61.12 61.10
Diffuse scattering in Ki _~(ND~)~I mixed crystals
J,-F. Berret
(~),
S.Ravy (2)
and B, Hennion(3)
(~)
Groupe
deDynarnique
des Phases Condens6es (*) (2) Laboratoire dePhysique
des Solides(**)
(3) Laboratoire Ldon Brillouin, F-91190 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
(Received lo
September
J992,accepted
infinal form
J5December J992)Abstract. We have used thermal neutron
scattering
and x-ray diffraction toinvestigate
the short range order correlations in the orientationalglassy phase
ofKi_~(ND4)fl. Single crystals
withammonium concentrations x
=
0.42 and x
= 0.62 have been studied between ambient temperature and lo K. Both
experiments
exhibit diffusescattering
pattems characteristic of the low-temperature
phase
ofKi ~(ND~ )J.
The diffusesignal peaks
at the Brillouinzone-boundary
and isstrongly anisotropic.
Itsintensity
does notdiverge
as T- OK,
indicating
thatonly
on a local state, the f. c-c- symmetry is brokenthrough
the short-range antiferroelectric correlations. As a result of thecomparison
between the different cross-sections obtained by x-ray and neutron scattering, it is concluded that staticdisplacements
of one or several atoms away from the lattice sites (mostprobably
the iodide ions) are involved in thedipolar
freezing. Thedependences
of the diffusesignal
as functions of wave-vector, temperature and concentration arefinally
discussed.1. Introduction.
In an orientational
glass (OG), multipolar
moments(dipoles, quadrupoles, etc.)
occupyrandomly
some of the sites of aregular
lattice. These moments interact eitherdirectly
viaelectric
interactions,
orindirectly
via acoupling
of the reorientations with the lattice modes(these
are elasticiteractions).
Thecompetition
between interactions which act in favor oforientational
ordering
and the substitutional disorder results in afreezing
of the orientationaldegrees
of freedom. An orientationalglass
is asystem
where the molecular orientations are frozen-in and disordered in thelow-temperature phase.
Two conditions aregenerally
added : The translational order ispreserved
at alltemperatures
and the transition towards theglassy
state is a collective process. OG'S have attracted much attention these last years because the
freezing
of the orientationaldegrees
of freedom shows strong similarities with theliquid-glass
and the
spin glass
transition(for
a review, see[1]).
(*) U-A. 233, Universitd de
Montpellier
II, F-34095Montpellier,
France.(**) Universit£ de Paris-Sud, F-91405
Orsay,
France.Recently,
it has beensuggested
that the mixedpotassium
ammonium iodidecrystals, Ki _~(NH~)J,
exhibit adipolar glass
state for intermediatecompositions (x
~
0.50)
and low temperatures(T
< 50 K) [2-4].
This conclusion resulted from two main observations : First a Curie-Weiss behavior of the dielectricsusceptibility
followed at lowertemperatures by
acusp
[3] second,
thegrowth
of diffusescattering
pattems in the elastic neutron response in thesame
T-range [4].
The first feature wasinterpreted
in terms of afreezing transition,
inanalogy
to that encountered in other OG'S or in
spin glasses.
The second result indicated the existence of antiferroelectric(Am) spatial
correlations at lowtemperatures.
In theoriginal reports
onthis
compounds [3, 4],
the orientationaldegrees
of freedom have been identified as electricdipole
moments associated with the ammonium molecules. Onlowering T,
thesedipoles
wereassumed to freeze
collectively
toward a state devoid oflong
range order.Compared
to other orientationalglasses
withdipolar degrees
of freedomill, Ki _~(NH~)~I
presents many
advantages. I)
thecrystallographic
structure of the mixedcompounds showing
disorder remain cubic face-centered
(Fm3m)
at alltemperatures [4]
;it)
The orientationaldisorder is observed on a wide
composition
range,typically
for x<x~m 0.75. Abovex~ the
freezing
isreplaced by
structural transitionsanalogous
to those ofNH4I [5].
However, conceming
thissystem,
seriousquestions
are still not elucidated such as theorigin
of the electric
dipole
moment or themicroscopic description
of the frozen disorderedphase.
It is indeed unclear whether thedipole
of 1.4Debye
determined from dielectricspectroscopy [3]
results from the distortions of the H-N-H
angles [2, 6]
or from the off-centreposition
of the ammonium ions[3, 7, 8].
In the
present
paper, we report x-ray diffraction and coherent neutronscattering
measure-ments on deuterated
homologs, Ki _~(ND~ )J
with concentration x=
0.42 and x
= 0.62. Both systems fall in the x-range where the transition between the
plastic
and frozenphase
is acollective process. We
give
here acomprehensive
account of the coherent neutron studies undertaken onKi _~(ND~)J,
andpartially published
elsewhere[4].
Inaddition,
the neutron data arecompared
to new x-ray diffraction pattems obtained on the samecrystals. Qualitative
comparisons
between the diffuse intensities received from the twoexperiments
enable us to establish that theglassy phase
ofKj _~(ND~)J
does notcorrespond
to the naivepicture
of frozenND(
tetrahedtaslightly
distorted andrandomly
distributed on a f.c.c. sub-lattice. The short range ordbr which establishes onlowering temperature
also reflects correlations in atomicdisplacements.
2.
Experimental
details and results.Deuterated
single crystals
arerequired
for coherent neutronscattering experiments.
Twosamples (~
0.5cm~ )
have beeninvestigated
at x = 0.42 and x= 0.62.
They
were grown from aqueous solutionsby
Haussfihl at the Universitdt zu K61n with nominal concentrationsx = 0.5 and 0.75. The true ammonium contents were determined afterwards
by estimating
themass fraction of
nitrogen
atoms from smallpieces (see
Ref.[9]).
X-RAY DIFFRACTION.
X-ray investigations
wereperformed
with the MoK~ (A
= 0.7 II
A )
radiation after a
(002)
reflection on asimply
bendgraphite
monochromator. Twocrystals
of size(3.2
x 1.3 x 0.7mm~)
and(2
x 2 x 0.3mm~)
werestudied,
the latterbeing
thinnedby
ethanol. The
crystals
were attached on the cold tail of adisplex cryocooler
and were cooled down to about 20 K.Figure
Idisplays
the x-ray pattems taken at 300K,
70 K and 20 K from the secondsample
with the normal to theplatelet ([001] direction) parallel
to the x-ray beam.As shown in
figure
lc,strong
diffusescatterings
at the f,c.c. forbidden(h, k, f ) positions
(X-point
of the zoneboundary)
areclearly
visible at low temperatures. Moreprecisely,
threetypes
ofscattering
arepresent
atpositions QB+qz~,
where qz~ is2arla(1,0,0),
N° 4 DIFFUSE SCATTERING IN
Ki _~(ND~)J
MIXED CRYSTALS 1033:' ,,
L
j
-~
a)
>~
b)
'
., j
)
.d
lWT
~,
(4*
, ?.' ,~,
~. .-*~~+~ ~.=~
C)
Fig. I.
X-ray
pattems taken at 300 K (a), 70 K (b) and 20 K (c). The c axis isalong
the x~ray beam, and the b axis is vertical. On thelow-temperature photographs
the thin arrowspoint
toward the (7, 3,4)
=
(1,
3, 3) + (0, 0, 1)scattenngs,
medium mows toward the. (4,3,
1)= (3,
3,
1) +(1, 0, 0) and the (5,
4,
2)= (4,
4, 2)
+ (1, 0,0)
ones, and the small arrows toward the (1, 4, 1)=
(1,
3,
1)+ (0, 1,
0) scattenngs.
2
aria(0, 1,
0 or 2 aria(0, 0, ), QB
theposition
of theBragg
spot and a the latticeparameter (a
-7.IA).
Infigure
I thearrows
point
toward diffusepeaks
of each ty1Je. The diffusescattering
decreasesrapidly
below 50K,
but it is still observable athigher
temperatures, down to loo K(although superimposed
to the diffuse thermalscattering),
As shown infigure
I, thediffuse pattems are thinner in one
direction,
but the confirmation of stronganisotropy
observedby
neutrons(see below)
would demand a morethorough
x-raystudy.
COHERENT ELASTIC NEUTRON SCATTERING. The
hleasurements
wereperformed
at the Laboratoire L£on Brillouin on atriple
axisspectrometer
installed on the thermal source of theOrph£e
reactor. The(graphite~filtered)
wave-vector of 2.66A-~
was selected for the incident neutrons. In its standard
configuration,
the neutron spectrometer is mounted with a double(PG002) monochromator,
a PG002analyser
and with horizontal collimations fixed at-/-/-/60/60, equivalent
to asimple
monochromator with-/23/60/60.
In order to observe diffusescattering,
thespectrometer
was utilized at zero energy transfer with an energy resolution AE=
280 GHz. This last
quantity
isimportant
since collective excitations characterizedby
correlation timeslonger
thanhlar
AE~ l ps will appear as frozen. The measured elastic
scattering intensity I(Q,
w=0)
is then thefolding
of thedynamical
structure factorS(Q,
w= 0
integrated
over the energy AE with the resolution function.In the
chronology
of this work, neutronscattering
were carried outprior
x-ray diffraction.This is the converse to what is
usually
done in the search forspatial
correlations. This can beexplained easily
: At theorigin
of thiswork,
the idea was to search for anomalies in thedispersion
curves ofKi _~(ND~)J
mixedcrystals,
andactually
anomalies in thedynamics
were evidenced. The transverse acoustic
phonon
exhibits a relaxation behavior due to itscoupling
with the rotational modbs of the ammonium ions. Howeverscanning
in energy at the Brillouinzone-boundary
also revealed aquasi-elastic
centralpeak strongly
temperaturedependent.
It was hencelogicial
to check that thisdynamical
centralpeak
condenses at lowtemperatures, resulting
in diffusescattering.
Acomplete
discussion of thedynamical aspect
of the reorientations inKi _~(ND~)J
has beengiven recently [10].
Wave-vector
dependence.
-Elasticscattering
measurements in thereciprocal (h, k, 0)- plane
have evidenced diffusepattems
in theneighborhood
of antiferroelectricpoints
with h + k odd[4]. They correspond
to theX-boundary points,
that is for reduced wave-vectorq*
=
aqz~/2
ar = I. The location and contour of the diffusepeaks
which have been indeed measuredby
neutron areschematically
drawn infigure
2. Thesepeaks
were obtained at differentqza-values
of the(h, k,
0)-plane
for T ~ lo K and x= 0.42. Their
elongated shapes
are discussed below.
Figures
3 and 4 show the diffusepeaks
more in detail aroundQ= (2,I,0)
forx = 0.42 and x
= 0.62,
respectively.
The «A/2»-contaminationarising
from theQ
"
(4, 2,
0)-
Bragg peak
has beencarefully
checked and avoidedusing graphite
filters on incident and scattered beams. Bothfigures
are constructed in a similar way : in the upper part maps of I(Q
areplotted
in the f=
O-plane
whereas in the lower part, the contours ofequi-intensity
aredrawn in the
vicinity
of the AFE wave-vector. In order todistinguish clearly
the coherent diffusesignal
in the x=
0.42-sample,
room-temperature I(Q)
has been subtracted. Such a calculation was not necessary for x=
0.62,
the diffusesignal being
enhanced of more than one decade(indeed,
due toexperimental
reasons, an absolutecomparison
betweenpeaks
ofFigs.
3 and 4 cannot be achievedprecisely).
For both
compositions however,
the diffuseintensity
looks similar : it is characterizedby
acigar-shaped pattem elongated
in the h-direction. In theperpendicular direction,
nobroadening
could be detected
compared
to the wave-vector resolution(Aq~~
=0.035
d~
~,
FWHM).
Temperature
evolution. Infigure
5 for Ko_~~(ND~IO_~~I aredisplayed
the elasticspectra performed
in the k-direction aroundQ
=
(1, 2, 0)
at severaltemperatures
between 9 K and 68 K. Subtraction of theroom-temperature
incoherentscattering explains
theQ-independent
background
of each spectrum. As illustrated infigure 5,
the diffuse contribution mergestypically
below~ 60 K.
An other way to show the strong increase of the diffuse
scattering
withlowering
T consists inmeasuring
the neutron counts at agiven
AFEpoint
and to scan the temperature. The results areN° 4 DIFFUSE SCATTERING IN
Ki _~(ND~)J
MIXED CRYSTALS io35k
040 240 440
020 220 420
000 200
020 220 420
1(Q,T.9K)- 1(Q,T.298K)
Q =
(h,k,0)
X
(D)=
0.42~
h
3°°
'2.6
-~
_i _2/ -i~
i / -1~$
_8/
-.6' k
a)
k 12oo
a)
i
1.6 1.8 2.0 2.2
~ 2A
b)
Fig.
3. a)Map
of theelastically
scattered neutronintensity
around Q=
(2,
I,
0) in Ko,~~(ND~)o~~I taken at lo K, b)Equi-intensity
contour related to the diffusepeak
shown in a). The wave-vectorresolution is
given by
the cross. Bothfigures
exhibit the stronganisotropy
in the directionperpendicular
to the AFE wave-vector qz~.
expression
of the form[13]
:f
/f2
S(q)
=
~~
~ ~
(l) (q
qzB)
+I/f
was considered, where
(q
qm)
denotes the distance from the next Xpoints
in the direction ofanisotropy
andf
the correlationlength. According
to the OZassumption,
the maximumintensity In
inequation (I)
isexpected
to varyquadratically
withf.
The dataanalysis
consisted in
calculating
the scatteredintensity by folding
the four-dimensional resolutionN° 4 DIFFUSE SCATTERING IN
Ki _~(ND~)J
MIXED CRYSTALS 1037J(Q,w=O) Q(h,k,o) x(D)zO.62
~
h
ia
~'
@
@
~
i~
-I
jf~
5 3 ~
X
ID)
=O.62
1.7 la 19 2 2.1 22 h
Fig.
4. As infigure
3, but for the Ko_~~~ND~)o~~Isingle crystal,
function of the spectrometer with S
(q
inequation (I ). Treating IzB
and f asfitting
parameters, the results of the convolution accounts well for the AFE diffusepeaks,
as thosedisplayed
infigure
5 forQ
=
(1, 2, 0).
The inverse width received from best fit calculations is shown as function of temperature infigure
7,f
increases oncooling
but saturates at a value of about lo lattices parametersf(T
= lo K
)
= 62A,
This value is muchlarger
that the correlationlength
found in the x= 0.42
crystal [4],
which does not exceed 2 lattice cells atcomparable
temperatures, It should beemphasized
that in theperpendicular direction,
the AFE correlationsare at much
longer
range(say,
more than~
200
A)
but cannot be resolved within the presentexperiments,
As mentioned
above,
aIza
ocf~-variation
isexpected
from the OZapproximation,
This behavior has been testedby eliminating
thetemperature
from theIza (T)
andf (T) dependences (Figs.
6 and7).
The result shown infigure
8 indicates well an increase ofIza
withincreasing f, However,
a closerinspection
reveals two differentregimes
; belowf
w 30A,
this increaseis
nearly linear,
and above it goestypically
asf~ (shown by
solidline),
The observation of power laws in theIza(f)
variation can -beinterpreted
in terms of nucleation processcharacterized
by f(T)
asunique scaling length,
The cubicdependence
observed forf
m 30A
infigure
8 istypical
for coalescencephenomena [14], Although
these results arequalitative, they
could indicate differentphysical
processes in thegrowth
ofcorrelations,
one1400
Q
=11,2+q*
1200
fi
~~
~
~ 800
I
~
)
~~~~
200
~-0,3
-0,2 -0,1 0 O-1 0,2 0,3
Reduced Wave-vector q*
Fig.
5. Elastic neutron spectra at x = 0.62 andperformed
in the k-direction around Q= (1, 2, 0) at
several temperatures between 9K and 68 K, The room-temperature incoherent
scattering
has been subtracted in order to get aq*-independent background.
The diffuse contribution merges below T~ = 58 K.~
*
~l~x~4~x~
i~
~s~~
: o
x = 0,42 ;
Q
=
(4,1,0)
~ . x = 0.62 ;
Q
"(2,1,0)
c .
I
*~ 10
I
.I
..
i~
5°o
lo 2o 3o 4o 5o 6o 7o 8oTemperame~K)
Fig. 6. Temperature
dependences
of the diffuse intensitiesIz~
at wave-vector Q= (4, 1, 0) and Q
=
(2,
1, 0) for x= 0.42 and x
= 0.62,
respectively.
Note that the increase of the diffusescanering
occurs
continuously
and withouthysteresis
effect.N° 4 DIFFUSE SCATTERING IN
Ki _~(ND4)fl
MIXED CRYSTALS 1039/ 4rW ~~'~~~~~~'~~~
~
~~tf~#~c
d
_~~~p
.( fl-
f
2o _~
10
+
0
0 10 20 30 40 30 60 70
Temperawre @l)
Fig.
7. Correlationlengths
as a function of tempemture in Ko_~~(ND~j~~~I. The f-values are results of best fit calculationsusing
an Omstein-Zemickeassumption (Eq.
(1)) which accounts well for the diffuseprofiles.
f saturates as T- 0 K at a value of about 10 lattice parameters, f 62
A.
~i
~ ~0.38~4~0.62~
_©
Q
( 1
fl
~#
~
W
0 10 20 30 40 30 60 70
Conelafion Length (A)
Fig.
8. Variation of the zone-boundary diffuseintensity Iz~
(seeEq.
(1)) for x=
0.62 as a function of the correlation
length
f. The observation of a power lawsIz~
oz £~ above30A
could indicatea
coalescence
phenomenon
in the correlationgrowth
processes [14].occuring
near thefreezing,
the second at much lower T. Moreexperimental
informations areobviously
needed toverify
thisassumption.
Comparison
benveen x-ray and neutronscattering.
The x-ray and neutron data on theKo~~(ND~)o_~~I crystal
are consistent with each other. Bothexperiments
establish theoccurence at low
temperatures
ofstrong
diffusescattering
at theX-point
of the Brillouin zone.Nevertheless,
as the x-rayscattering
isroughly proportional
to the square of the atomic number of theconstituents,
the contribution of thelight
elements such as deuterium ornitrogen
andthus that of the
ND( dipoles,
is almostnegligible.
This remark rules out thepossibility
of a pureordering
of theND( species
withoutdisplacements
of one(or several) atom(s)
away from its face-centeredposition.
Such a conclusion could not be derived from the neutron resultsonly,
the coherentscattering length
of the four elements involvedbeing comparable (from
0.37 for K+ to 0.94 for D+). Moreover,
since the iodide ions are thestrongest
x-ray scatterers, wesuggest
thatdisplacement
modes of the I~species
are mostlikely
involved in thefreezing.
Thepossibility
of off-centerdisplacements
in theplastic phase
ofNH~I
wasalready speculated by Seymour
andPryor [7].
Finally,
it cannot be decided from the x-ray measurements whether the modulated pattemsare static or
dynamic.
This is because all thedynamical
modes with wave-vectorqza contributes to the cross-section. This could
explain
thepersistence
of the diffusesignal
above
T~,
as revealed on the x-rayphotograph
at 70 K(Fig. lb).
It corroboratesindirectly
thedynamical
nature of thefreezing
in Ko_~~(ND~~O_~~I.Comparison
with dielectric data. It is also ofimportance
to test that the onset of short- rangeordering
coincides with thedipolar freezing probed by
dielectric spectroscopy[3].
From dielectric loss measurements onKo_5~(NH~)o_~~I,
it was concluded that the temperatures of maximalabsorption
relate to thefrequency
of measurementsthrough
the usual Arrhenius law,v =
voexp(E~/k~T),
with anattempt frequency
vo=10~~
Hz andan activation energy
E~
= 460 K. Anextrapolation
of the aboveexpression
at v =280 GHz
yields T~
~ 14K,
in clear contradiction with the results offigure
6. For the deuteratedcrystal
atcomparable
x, the onset of
freezing
is estimated atT~
= 34 K and the sameT~-value
was derived for anx = 0.43
protonated sample
studiedby
Ramanscattering [9].
Thisdiscrepancy
could have twoexplanations
:first,
in reference[3],
the Arrhenius law is determined on atemperature
range which does not exceed I KSecond,
and this issurely
morefundamental,
the dielectricexperiment
measures amacroscopic susceptibility averaged
on the wholecrystal,
that is at wave-vector q « 2 aria.Contrary
tothat,
theanomaly
revealed in theKi
~
(ND~)J system
is alocal
ordering
process at the Brillouin zoneboundary,
at q = 2arla.4.
Concluding
remarks.Diffuse
scattering
pattems obtainedusing
x-ray and neutron measurements have been shown to characterize thelow-temperature phase
ofKi _~(ND~)J
with x < x~. The essential features of the diffusesignal
are thefollowings
:I)
Itpeaks
belowT~
at thezone-boundary X-point (I.e.
atQ~
+qzB)
and formscigar-shaped
contours
elongated
in the directionorthogonal
to qm.ii)
The diffuseintensity
does notdiverge
as T- 0K. This means that nomacroscopic
change
in thecrystal symmetry
occurs down to the lowest Tinvestigated.
However, on a localscale,
the fcc symmetry is brokenthrough
theshort-range
correlations. Note that the absence ofsaturation in the diffuse
scattering suggests
that at such low temperature as lo K theND( dynamics
is notcompletly
frozen in.iii)
It isplausible
that staticdisplacements
of one or several atoms away from the lattice sites(most probably
the iodideions)
are involved in thefreezing.
This is a crucial result for the KIND~I dipolar glass.
It appears as a direct consequence of the different x-ray and neutronscattering iross-sections.
Thesefindings
ruleout the
assumption
of an electricdipole
moment inKi _~(ND~)J solely
due to the distortions of the H-N-Hangles,
asoriginally
believed[2],
Accordingly,
static disordermight
also increase the value of the baredipole
of theND(
groups,iv)
Thefreezing
of thedipolar degrees
of freedom is adynamical
process,Measurements of the diffuse structure factor as function of
Q
in the wholereciprocal
spaceN° 4 DIFFUSE SCATTERING IN
Ki _~(ND~)~I
MIXED CRYSTALS 1041are
underway
in order tofully
characterize the structural aspects of thefreezing
and of thedipolar glass
state.Acknowledgments.
It is a
pleasure
toacknowledge
K. H.Michel,
C. Bostoen and M.Descamps
for fruitful discussions. We also wish to thank Jean-Pierre Fluxench for thedrawings.
References
[ii HnCHLI U., LOIDL A. and KNORR K., Adv. Phys. 39 (1990) 405.
[2] BOSTOEN C., CODDENS G. and WEGENER W., J. Chem. Phys. 91(1989) 6337.
C. Bostoen, Ph. D. Thesis,
Univerity
ofAntwerpen
(1991),unpublished.
[3] FEHST I., BnHMER R., OTT W., LOIDL A., HAUSSUHL S. and BOSTOEN C.,
Phys.
Rev. Lett. 64 (1990) 3139.[4] BERRET J.-F., BOSTOEN C., SAUVAJOL J.-L., HENNION B. and HAUSSUHL S.,
Europhys.
Lett. 16 (1991) 91.[5] PARSONAGE N. G. and STAVELEY L. A. K., Disorder in Crystals (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1978).
[6] BERRET J.-F., BRUCHHAUSER F., FEILE R., BOSTOEN C. and HAUSSUHL S., Solid State Commun. 74 (1990) 1041.
[7] SEYMOUR R. S, and PRYOR A. W., Acta
Cryst.
B 26 (1970) 1487.[8] TOMKINSON J,, DASANNACHARYA B. A., GOYAL P. S. and CHAKRAVARTHY R., J. Chem. Sac.
Faraday Trans. 87 (1991) xxx.
[9] BERRET J.-F., SAUVAJOL J. L, and HAUSSUHL S., J. Chem.
Phys.
92 (1992) 4896.[10] BERRET J.-F., SAUVAJOL J.-L. and HENNION B., J.
Phys.
Cond, matter 4 (1992) 9235.[I I] For a review, see : GRIMM H.,
ILL-Workshop
onDynamics
of disorderd Materials(Springer- Verlag,
1988) p. 274.[12] COWLEY R. A., RYAN T, and COURTENS E., J. Phys. C IS (1985) 2793.
GRIMM H. and MARTINEZ J., Z. Phys. B 13 (1986) 64.
[13] STANLEY H. E., Introduction to Phase Transitions and Critical
phenomena
(OxfordUniversity
Press,1971).
[14] DESCAMPS M. and CAUCHETEUX C., J. Phys. C 20 (1985) 5073.
JOtJRNAL DE PHYSIQUE i -T 3, N'4, APRIL 199~