HAL Id: jpa-00208917
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00208917
Submitted on 1 Jan 1980
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Swelling equilibrium and light spectroscopy in swollen polymeric networks at theta conditions
S. Candau, J.P. Munch, G. Hild
To cite this version:
S. Candau, J.P. Munch, G. Hild. Swelling equilibrium and light spectroscopy in swollen polymeric networks at theta conditions. Journal de Physique, 1980, 41 (9), pp.1031-1038.
�10.1051/jphys:019800041090103100�. �jpa-00208917�
Swelling equilibrium and light spectroscopy in swollen polymeric
networks at theta conditions
S. Candau, J. P. Munch
Laboratoire d’Acoustique Moléculaire (*), Université Louis-Pasteur, 4, rue Blaise-Pascal, 67070 Strasbourg Cedex, France
and G. Hild
Centre de Recherches sur les Macromolécules, 6, rue Boussingault, Strasbourg, France
(Reçu le 13 novembre 1979, révisé le 29 février, accepté le 8 mai 1980)
Résumé. 2014 Les variations thermiques du temps de corrélation de la lumière diffusée quasi élastiquement et du
taux de gonflement à l’équilibre ont été mesurées pour des réticulats de polystyrène gonflés soit par du benzène soit par du cyclohexane.
Les résultats obtenus montrent qu’il se produit une séparation de phase interne à une température Tc inférieure à la
température « 03B8 » et qui dépend du degré de réticulation.
Un comportement critique des fluctuations de concentration est observé à Tc.
Abstract.
2014The temperature dependences of the correlation time of laser light scattered and of equilibrium swelling degree for polystyrene networks swollen in cyclohexane are reported.
The results provide evidence of an internal microphase separation at a temperature Tc below the « 03B8 » temperature which depends on the crosslink density.
The concentration fluctuations show critical behaviour at Tc.
Classification Phy.sics Abstracts
36.20
-61.40
-64.70
-78.35
Introduction.
-It has been recently established that the scaling theories developed for polymer solu-
tions [1-2] are also applicable to gels [3-5]. The analogy
between polymer solutions and swollen networks is based on the following assumption : a network,
swollen to equilibrium, is similar to a solution of free chains with the same number of statistical segments N
as the network-chains, at the crossover concentra- tion ({J*(N) between the dilute and semi-dilute
regimes [2]. As a consequence the network swollen in an excess of solvent adjusts its volume fraction to
the value o,, given by :
where RG is the radius of gyration of the free chain
containing N segments, in the same solvent. The above
relationship can be derived from the classical mean
field Flory theory [6] if one assumes that the change of swelling is affine in the dimensions of the chains of the network [2, 5]. Such an assumption is equivalent to
the following packing condition :
where R is the radius of gyration of the chains of the
gel at a monomer concentration C.
The validity of the previous approach has been
confirmed by the results of quasi-elastic and elastic light scattering experiments which demonstrate that networks swollen in a good solvent obey the same scaling laws as the semi-dilute polymer solutions [3, 7].
In the present paper we consider the influence of the quality of the diluent on the thermodynamic
and dynamic properties of gels. Such a problem raises
two fundamental questions :
-
Is it possible to extend Flory’s theory to the
networks swollen in a « theta » or poor solvent ?
-
How is the phase diagram of a gel compared to
that of a polymer solution ?
In this regard, a recent theory of Tanaka [8] based
on the extension of Flory’s formula for free energy of gel predicted essential differences between phase separation of gels and that of binary fluid mixtures.
The shape of the phase diagram depends critically
on the crosslinks density. As a matter of fact, two polyacrylamide networks of different crosslinks den-
sity swollen in an acetone-water fluid mixture exhibited volume curves of significantly different shapes. Ano-
ther interesting feature, related with the phase dia-
gram of gels, is the ability of a gel to undergo a spinodal
(*) E.R.A. au C.N.R.S.
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:019800041090103100
1032
decomposition under sudden cooling [9-12]. The resulting concentration fluctuations exhibit a critical behaviour which can be probed by light scattering experiments [9].
This paper presents some measurements of the temperature dependence of the equilibrium volume
fraction for series of polystyrene networks of various crosslinking degrees, swollen in a good solvent (ben- zene) and in a « theta » solvent (cyclohexane). The experimental results show that the validity of the analogy between polymer solutions and gels is res-
tricted to the good diluent systems. Measurements of the correlation time of laser light scattered by the
concentration fluctuations of polystyrene networks
swollen at equilibrium in cyclohexane are also report- ed. The experiments show that the spectrum of scattered light is dominated by slow modes associated with the critical process evidenced by Tanaka [9],
even when the systems are at the swelling equilibrium
state.
1. Experimental part.
-1.1 SAMPLES.
-The networks were obtained by radical copolymerization
of styrene and divinylbenzene in benzene solution
in the presence of azo-2-2’-isobutyronitrile as the initiator, at 60 OC over a period of 48 h. A series of networks of various crosslinking degrees has been prepared using different concentrations of styrene (CST) and of divinylbenzene (CDVB). The crosslinking degree can be qualitatively characterized by the equilibrium swelling degree qi of the network in a
good solvent of the polymeric chains. The values of the
equilibrium swelling degrees qiBZ and qio for the series
of polystyrene networks swollen in benzene at room
temperature (21 OC ± 1 °C) and in cyclohexane at
34.5 OC, respectively, are listed in table I.
Table I.
-Parameters of styrene-divinylbenzene net-
works prepared by radical copolymerization.
CST % and CDVB % are the weight concentrations of styrene and divinylbenzene, respectively.
qiBZ is the equilibrium swelling degree of the gels in benzene
at 21° + 1 °C.
qio is the equilibrium swelling degree of the gels in cyclohexane at 0
=34.5 °C.
1. 2 TECHNIQUES. - 1.2.1 Swelling equilibrium
measurements.
-The equilibrium swelling degree qi of the polymer in the swollen networks was determined
with an accuracy of approximately 5 jo by a weighing technique described elsewhere [13].
1.2.2 Light scattering spectroscopy.
-A Spectra- Physics argon-ion laser (Â
=4 880 À) was used in
conjunction with a 48 channel clipped digital auto-
correlator (Precision Devices and Systems LTD Malvern, type K 7023) for measuring the autocorre-
lation function of the scattered light intensity. The scattering angle was varied from 200 to 1200. The temperature was held constant to within ± 0.1 °C.
The experimental data were routinely processed using
the method of cumulants [14-16] to provide the average
decay rate T and the variance V. The latter parameter is a measure of the width of the distribution of decay
rates and is given by :
where f2 is the second moment of the distribution.
In previous papers [3, 4, 7], it was shown that the intensity scattered from elastic deformations of swollen networks is heterodyned to some extent by the static component due to microscopic heterogeneities. The heterodyne ratio can be checked by measuring the
autocorrelation function obtained by mixing the
scattered signal with an extemal oscillator using a
Michelson type interferometer.
2. Swelling equilibrium and phase diagram of polystyrene gels.
-2.1 1 THEORETICAL PREDICTIONS.
-The equilibrium volume fraction (p,, of a gel immersed
in a fluid is given by the condition of zero osmotic pressure. This condition can be derived from Flory’s
mean field theory together with the packing condi-
tion (2) and is given by [2] :
where cr is the radius of the statistical 5egment and V, is
the molar volume of the solvent. In the vicinity of the
« theta » temperature the Flory-Huggins interaction parameter x can be expanded as a function of the
T - 03B8
reduced temperature ! = T e 8 ’ according to the
following relationship :
1/2 - x = t/J! (4)
where § is an entropy parameter [6].
Eq. (3) reduces to simpler forms in the two following limiting cases :
i) Networks swollen by a good solvent of the poly-
meric chains (9, « 1)
ii) At the « 0 » temperature (X
=1/2)
Eqs. (5) and (6) predict that for both good solvent
and « 0 » regimes, ({Je(N) ’" (p*(N), where ({J*(N) is
the crossover volume fraction between dilute and semi-dilute regimes for a solution of macromolecules
having N statistical units. From eqs. (5) and (6) one
obtains the following relationship between o,, and 9eF ’
As a matter of fact the phase diagram of polymer
solutions as derived from Flory’s theory differs from that obtained from the scaling law approach, as
illustrated in figure 1. The scaling law approach [17]
predicts a crossover between a good solvent and a « 0 » behaviour at a reduced temperature i - N - 1/2
.Fig. 1.
-Phase diagram of a swollen network. The equilibrium
curve q>e(r) and the spinodal curve q>(rs) have been calculated from eqs. (3) and (14) respectively. The dashed lines represent the phase diagram of a polymer solution as given by the tricritical theory [17].
ln the« () » domain, defined by - N-1/2 i N-1/2, ({J* must be constant and equal to ({J:. For
-r > N - 1/2
ç* varies as -r- 3/5 which is in good agreement with eq. (5).
Neutron scattering experiments have provided évidence of the behaviour predicted by the scaling
law approach. However, the actual ! dependence in
the crossover vicinity is not established, and the curve ((r) as derived from eq. (3) can be considered as a
good approximation for the behaviour of swollen networks in the « () » domain.
It is also interesting to consider what happens when
T - N-l/2. For polymer solutions at the concen-
tration cp: one should expect a critical phase separa- tion. On the other hand a gel at swelling equilibrium
cannot break up into two phases. Therefore a further cooling of the gel should lead to an increase of rpe
represented by the straight line asymptotic to the
coexistence curves of polymer solutions. Figure 1
shows that again the curve ({Je(-r) as derived from eq. (3) gives a good approximation of the behaviour
of the swollen gels in this range of temperatures.
2.2 EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION.
-Let us consider first the behaviour of networks swollen in a good diluent. In table II, we have reported the température dependence of the equilibrium volume
fraction of a polystyrène network prepared by anionic
method and swollen in benzène. The rate of increase of the swelling degree with température is very small
as expected from eq. (5) since the value of 6 for poly- styrene-benzene systems is far below the temperature encountered hère [18].
Table II.
-Temperature dependence of the swelling degree for a polystyrene network swollen by benzene.
The sample has been prepared by anionic block copo-
lymerization using a precursor polystyrene of molecular weight McRc
=43 500 and 3 molecules of divinyl-
benzene per living end.
We now turn our attention to the case of a network swollen in a poor diluent. In order to draw the dia- gram r«p,) it is necessary to know the « 0 » tempera-
ture of the investigated systems. For the polystyrene- cyclohexane systems, it is well known that 0
=34.5 °C.
.
Figure 2 shows the (p,,(,r) diagrams for two polysty-
rene networks prepared by radical copolymerization
and swollen in cyclohexane. The full lines represent the curves calculated from eqs. (3) and (4), adjusted
at the theta temperature. The values of ({JeO required
for this adjustment have been obtained from eq. (7)
where we have used the rpeF values experimentally
determined for networks swollen in benzene and x
=0.43 [19]. These experimental values have been reported on the calculated curves -r«({Je). The corres- ponding value of i leads to 0 = - 90 °C. This value
can only be considered as indicative, since it has been obtained by assuming the validity of eq. (4),
which is restricted to small values of i.
It can be seen on figure 2 that the experimental
volume fractions of polystyrene-cyclohexane gels
exceed largely the theoretical ones. This result can be
explained either by a lack of validity of the packing
condition (2) in the « 0 » domain or by a collapse
1034
U. U.2 U.3
Fig. 2.
-Temperature-volume fraction curves for polystyrene
networks swollen at equilibrium by benzene and cyclohexane. The full curves have been calculated from eq. (3) : te. R 43, à R 37.
The dashed lines drawn through the experimental points have been arbitrarily extrapolated to the calculated curves.
of the elastic chains of the network. The latter possi- bility can be excluded, since neutron scattering experiments have demonstrated that the elastic chains of polystyrene networks swollen by cyclohexane are unperturbed gaussians and that the deswelling of the
networks with decreasing solvent quality is not
affine in the mesh size of the network [20]. Therefore,
the variation of pe in the « 0 » domain results pri- marily from a mutual interspersion of the chains.
There is no available interpretation of this phenome-
non which has been discussed in more detail recent-
ly [5].
The interspersion degree of a network swollen in
cyclohexane can be estimated from a comparison of
the equilibrium volume fraction measured at the 0
temperature and that calculated under the packing
condition assumption.
Figure 3 shows in a log-log scale the variation of 9,,, for a series of networks as a function of the corres-
ponding equilibrium volume fractions in benzene
at 21 °C. On the same figure we have plotted the curve
calculated from eq. (7). Inspection of this figure reveals
that the degree of interspersion does not vary consi-
derably from one gel to another, although the para- meters of the crosslinking reaction are quite different (cf. Table I).
The degree of interspersion which can be charac-
terized by the ratio between experimental and calcu-
lated values of (Pel is found equal to 2.8 + 0.5..
Fig. 3.
-Equilibrium volume fraction in cyclohexane at 34.5 °C
versus the equilibrium volume fraction in benzene at 21 °C for a
series of networks prepared by radical process. The full line has been calculated from eq. (7). The dashed line drawn through the experimental points has the same slope.
3. Light spectroscopy.
-3.1 THEORY.
-It has been shown both theoretically and experimentally
that the correlation function of light scattered from
thermally excited longitudinal fluctuations of swollen networks has the form of an exponential decay. The decay rate for fluctuations of wavevector K is given by :
where Dc is the cooperative diffusion constant equal
to the ratio of the longitudinal osmotic elastic modulus
El to the frictional coefficient 0 of the network in the fluid medium
Two experimental situations have been considered up to now :
-