Model Based Detection of Tubular Structures in 3D Images
48
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Model Based Detection of Tubular Structures in 3D Images Karl Krissian — Grégoire Malandain — Nicholas Ayache — Régis Vaillant — Yves Trousset. N° 3736 July 1999 THÈME 3. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) ! "$#%"$& ')(*'"+,-"$' .& / 0213 4 57698;:5<8>=@?>?>=A69BDY+C,FZGJE7=A?8;FH[ GJ69I9=@=A:@8;:\KM69B2LN]M69C:A69^B_9OPKH?+69=@`aBD8;CPIJbQ$?>=@?;RTKZS] IJ:A69?+UWV269RTSKXC cedgf&hjxhitk Zlni;; mpgoHy|qri;ogsuogtZ;vwi;qu;xzyZgo+vyZdgogyZo~h*txhjuri&t|{\o~hvt|i>v}d~xzogiZ sry|iqPgxgt|gsri tg9y|srqisri>v}dgi&s}v}dgio9-k TkZl~z7>|ZlZ*t|i> jh $uti>¡hj¢;ix£&v;¤Ttt¥gg¦|qrx£|dgh§ yZtsu¨ Z¸xziog· ¹qui;º<®$vqrx»¯°y|Zo%i±¼¾y½\g®©-sucei;qrgrd~i&ª~iWoHgq©¬y|t|xo²szyT«qr´qrdgsuxx~ogvw*qusugxzi&hj9sri>y|gesrsuq yTxzo<|ti;o k h*¨ i&i;³ oHxzhqrqui&t|od~|«i;xt¾y|e|o²iWxyª9t©i&o%i;t<oxhj~sryZi;ogyZHi|s«xy|q}¿ toHWq´µxuyZ«sr~¶°iW©¬y|y|sogiTt|ª uvgqrdgtis À t*ªi&q«qri;s«qutTquiy©qrdgit|s«q> À ti;h*g~yvi>xz+Áv;©¬tTsuqry|xhÄy|oqrdgy©µiqrhjdgyisui&i;\r yZo~ri©¬go~vqrxy|o²ª <xzoHqusry~v&xzo~%tvy i&Âv&xzi;oHqWôdgyH«i*Ttgijx À qrtgo7sui;i&µ³´i;xzsrqrxd±hjTi&toHsuqu t|xzo~« qr~xt%hjyZioMqui&«s} &oHHqrtd~o~ijqrxquvgªgxhgttZsi;qu´srxzqrvwd+qr~srgi>o~vw´quxzxzyZqrdo~;ÅWq}t|t~oguZ«xi&toHoqa{Æ«xzqr¶Zsui~vvwsuquyZgusui;{p;«9i>vw«qrqusuxzyZ~o~vw{ y|s,ÇrvyZoHZy||i>ª~tsr{Æzx¶|iȸvsuyZu{pri;vwquxzyZo~; À to%i³9i&suxzhji;oZq}t2«qr~$y|o%tjgd~t|oZquy|hÄxhtZiWt|o~$y|osri>t2É{Æs}t¾±to~%º<»Êxht|i>&® Ë<ÌHÍJÎuÏ Ð ¤TÑ-¢|§ ÁÒqui&suxzogg|i>rri&2i&qri>vwqrxy|ogh gzqrxuv&tito~t|zrx;«i;|hji&oHq}tTqrxy|o. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(6) ; - ,- $ 2-'-"$"+'- -"$#%"$& '- $ + &1 4 / qu~suogt¾ i,T¢ t|q
(7) |xzv}dg~ isr>x§ vh*;9g i&y|oHsrtquqt|g~oHtqrqris i>vwzqui>yZxzyZgo°sPh & xi>hjhji;t|« |qrsui;t~srxvwi,ququi&ghjgsrs};i>gax· v;qr¹gtº<ªgiµ~»Tt|t|Zxzu¼¾suv½Æi;~® t|g xzt|sui;i|o~ ®Wh*µi;yies}xzxtÁhgv;9ttT|qry|xi>sry|qaoi>qrsuqPxiq gxhjo~i;iµi& o~i&³Htrxhjquy|i&og&o~ogrx xy|i;y|zs}otTi;qrWxy| i>goo q rgxTtoHqri>ey|oHqqrsu;t|zxr&i;;¿ À go%q}tTqiW t|s«qg~&qut|xzzZ À gv}dgogy|i¸xrhjx2y i&ogxÒÁ©¬y|v;o~tTvquqrxzyZxy|o+o%i%t hj©¬y y|go~f&vqri|xy| o+iasr;yZo~ri~t|sµ xoHqrsuy~vwquxzyZo+ go$v&y i±vxi&oHqµÃ Z~x9i>q À gquogsri°vwqrqu~~sri>Ji°quit|³og|;i;sroZxquhji;;i&>oHgqut|i;zi°«qr«su~~svwqugi>su+i; xhiµtZxi;t|+hjrf qroHsuiqrdgog&yZqrox Zv~y|i;o%q}vtyZoHoZq;qu¾i&o~i;t|oHq$qusri;vw qr~yZsri>o~9vwqrqugxzyZªgo~~&at|xzsui;i; iri;vwquxzyZo$Ht~urxzi;ogogi¸y|±Çªtsr{Æv&y|o |yZzg;iwÈw À g~ogtsis}&t¾qr|~yZo~iµi&ɳy|;srxhj~ti&soHqusut|;zriy|o~rgt|o~svgi¸oghitxhZogt|quix HgiWiZ©@® t|oHq |hjiWiqrgsi>xhjt||i>esr;i&zi>ey|ªqui&o gi; DÐ £>¢ Î ¦ ¢§ Á~zqrs}tZi|qui;vqrxy|o<iTtxrri;t|³2to~t|zriah gÒquxÒ{Æ;v}d~i&ziZg«i;|hji&oHqutqrxy|o.
(8)
(9) !#"$%& ('*)#+',-%'.$ / 20 130. 0J '-%"+,- . k. 46587!9;:=<>7!935@?. mpxo$o kqrd~¨ xPxzhtt|9|i&i;s>;®´µ»iezqrgdgsuyZi;gri&|oHd+qqrt¸dgogiWi&g´ suy|hj9iyZqrrd~i;y hj©¬i&yZqrsdg«yi;|hjv&ti&o+oHquªtiqrxy|to*~gtzo~xi;*±qriyjqui;tvo qrxy|¶ o*xzoy©9±qryg©-ªgk~¨t|sxhjqut|sr|~iZvqrZgxzqsui;x i>y|«© 9qri;d~v&iaxt|Tzt|*uv~~«i&t|©¬sµgogi&©¬y|q´µseyZsri¶jqui;xvwo+quxzhjyZo±i;gyx© v;tTJtZrxzhv>|t||si;,og©¬i&suqy|´µh yZsrT¶*txzsuo+xzyZh*~µi>y|xsuv&Ztt9oxB hjA¬t|x ||i>i&&s>® »z~o+ogZtZ;v& v&ªggsusut|txzqroDiC,gv;itqro+i>vwd~quxzi&yZo ~ª9dHi;v;tr~xv&rxi t|o~qrjdgijxo go~qrdggi7i&s}~q}tt|o~ogogxxogog% yy©©k «¨ ~srZxhjxv;t|t|i>y|a9xi&s}tTquxz±xzyZo~vg;®zqceto~d ~; xrH~~tt|oHFx E;qrtTxzÁquxzv&yZto7qrxquy|yHo yZqrWy y|t|sr±i*togsuyi<qogt|i;z´ei;t¾i> ª r+±gvixqri&i>oHvwqquxzquyZy±ogy|su©yTZ i;xu«i¸i;quedgi vi;ogoHi>qrvi&i>surxzuogti>su±txo~o%©¬y|surhi&ZtTh*qrxi;y|oHoqu®tTqucexzyZdgo+yH«y|i ©-ZTt|utvoH~qrxzt|Ásv&to~qrixy|q´oy|qrsuy ¶ yZ;® v;to<ª9iy|ªgqutxogi> 021G. HI!JK:L9 5NMBOQPQ52I!R. }q»º<t¶Zgv}iÒdqutxxzuoHv&zqui;t|y$ogzie|t|i¸tv;voxzyZo%tgg oHsurqyxqrvdgt|i>izrryTxzT´o~t su Hquy|xy¸©og+gTt|irqruxFi>vE&vwgi qty|«s©Pqrsux|~hi;vwutqurgZi&i;sri>xxo<y|©~qrqryTdgti*suxzixyZhjqu~i;t|v-q|«ixF|E&i;xi>u-rqrtZi&y$v&µv&t|y|y|gs}©ggxzo~xTSJt+i&qrsuh yai&oHqrgqd~zqrirxx&uE;uv&v&i;tt|;®zi ie»Êt|tTo~q´et´t¾dgj«xv}xqr&dy ® quhjdgi>i&xt||zxo~|i;iut±thjo~t$³srxzhxZti|gsri>t«o9+y|o~grsui|i& ®x¯°y|~i e«´y|v&suv¶±i>rrxi>|i&xv;+tTqu~i;sr+i>«qri;yoZq|i>qurdgrii&2ogy|i&qrqrxy|i>o~vwqrxy|yo©® zxogi>tsauv&t|zi&{Ær~tZvi|y|© UDVXWYVU Z@[\ Ì ¥^¤ ]¦|¥ ÌZÎ ]`_¥g¦ Ì ¯t%ÅWd~i&toMrt|rgxt|goMH¶Zxogi&su+ogt+i&Ph tgozMqrxuxzquv&Wti xzo~t|i;o~ttsW~«t|xs«quxqut|y$to<i&suxxh¾ttqrZx|i|i>qrdgd~i tZW~«ªi i;i&yo²©Pqu«dgd~i yT´v&y|o7o qr|y%yZzª9i*quxzyZqro<dgigyZsuy oggz<~vw´eqt¾´%xzqrqrdy i;t|o~o~rvgi srCwi xqro dgTi tsu©¬y|xt|zo~yTv´ijxoggo~ggi&susy|9suyi&qusrtqrxqri;x;y|¿µbo x A¬ogx«i;y|t|qrsrsuxzy|q| ! xzCwo Tt|to~sux°t|o~xzo vTit~suo~xt|o~i&vsi*qrgs}to~o~gri&stTqrsuxi;y|uao v&tAA«x ogtTqrx· t¹a-yH«i>d~¼xÒ© q¸ xz o xzTotsugxÒ{ ´´cqsud~dxzxq«v}qrd!i;¹o º<q}~tTrfqrxzi>e>og ½Æ%®gqrqd~c-´ty7pqy|s} qt|xv}hj ¶<%i&Dio~q*rxztyZ\og®Mri;· cus%q (dTtt'.su¹xt|& º7ªgz$i>h vje>½eu#ilsh«kdgwi@ ,yTm´D (tqr
(10) od~f t"q nKqrk(',d~o xi fª ",i&7&|$yZ ^quzdggyi±qrxz y|hj,o°i;t|qr"{dgo~|suy|} y|~©| d²quu%dgri+Dv;tPh$xzi;{\#qrdgv;i; ty| go²sui&ªszh i x8$Wsz qudgoKi±gZ®su3i; qr(yZ}y~o~«$ij-yZ ,ª(quDt| xzog@i>%°#}©¬sr wyZ®h o qudgi;i±ogxyogquxÒi;qu¸xt|qudgxi±hjt|q}|ti±o~~t|o~ts}Q iÊi;x xtqrdgqrxi±y|o°sui;yr9©,y|quo~dgri+ijÅWy|tªq}trrxogxt|i;oM²¶ZtTi&q*suogt<i&\r`v;ti@mi h {Æt|ogzy|mpFx o%E&suxhogdgtxqu&x E;´dgi;iay|±sug¶ i&µi;susrxzy|Txo<TtTtTquuquxzv&ZxzZt|i;i;z,i&;{Æy¿ r© ~qut|dgv&iaixquhdgi&tyZZsri7 xzo+· qrxdgo~ia|gh g zxqro~xuZv&¾t½\ ia t|xo~o~ti&ª9«i&x;su®d«d~iayTx´oHqr,suquy dggi~vogi>i>Pvi;qrd~uriaxÒqog±y|y|qrx©y|ogo±yZy|s«{© AC f 3{ ¯xogd~i&´odgquxdgv}id%~xt|suvt|yZhjh*iqrtTi;qrs xªgiWi H´~xÒtqud$Py|qudgo~ii|Zqrxdghjiai&ogo~y|rxzsuyZhogti;&xuE>etT¾qrxt|y|srojxti;ª~o~zi «~ sri> Pxzn o k(Totsu¿ xto~v&igo~i;s,xht|isri>rv;tz{ # D D n o n n. >(-$,.
(11) . v',X , (8 (& D }
(12) w $sz# }}& (# %'{(z $. ª9gii&qrsui>+dvwyTqu«qri;´µ~ i;g|A¬xzi&|i>s>x7|Hi>©¬y|y|µo7sqrdgt|v&o~ii&srthqutHtTxqro%³xv&x«ht|9ti;hjJv&xÒsryÁi>va«i&9q}y|t|orqu¶«dgii*A¬Cwi& sr³Hqri;qud~suti¸tZqrvwxo~y|quy|xzo~yZsurhjo$dgxt|y|<z=© xFE;ªe ti&¨ qrqx´µy|ªgo$i;zyZi&~o<ª tqus}ydgt©ihji;uigv&qu|t|i&i;szi*; tTygqa2© t|´o~e +¨ d~xqrv}sudgd7xgiWt||y|o7i;ªg Cwy|i; ªvw qi>xzovwrx&q¸E;ii|x{ ´d~xmpv}oWd%quv&dgt|iPo$©¬y|i;tZyT+´quxzogyv};dg´y iPyZ´riaxzy|Zqrxzdghji;gsx¾v&t|xÒquz~zWi;erg©¬yZgs9yZ r® iPqrd~tq qrd~i,rv;ti{p«t|vi~ri;¸x xzo~i;tsto~¸y|ªgqutxogi> ©¬suy|h.ÅWt~u«xto%vyZo |y|quxzyZo+y©qrdgixhtZiWt|o~$xÒq}i&sux¾tqrx|i>&® UDVXWYVXW Ì Ñ [ ¥ \ Ì ¢>¢ tZvw&x quE;i&i&sus&x E;i&iqaqrtdg\®ij· r d~t9li cy|©,½t~o7«yZi>ªqui;dgviqaogª yquxzqryZdgo<i*xzhjoHqui;srtyo~v&y|i;©h*ª i> xtgtTh ³x¸· vzyZoHHquHt xogxogW±T¼T´½xxz o<qrdyZsuxzogi;©¬y|sesuqrhjy±tv}qrd~xy|t|o s«{ ® mp´o xzqred~¨ xzo%xztho±tyZZªi;;i; vq;®gº<h)t|¶HixogÁ*ogi;~7riaqrdgy|i© qrh*dgiqi>"{x(t% tT³ (xa',}t| , qr ,dg´i d~zyxv}v&d$~h*y|i>©,t|vrgi;oZsui;qui&,s}qrdgy|i¸©,gsuxi;rr¶i&o~v&y|i©yh©-tTv³y|xzoHhquy|t|g s}Ág&q Áog&x E;i;i&n sWªi.y|qo qrd%t\2®qrh*d~i i>it|Á~vri;o~goHi suqri;s}qutdgqri dgthji³ xi>i;t||xt|o~suPi&iµtTqr³ydgx©i;ª9J´i&txo~y|7o~qr|d7qrxdgogy|i;a©o7y|yZ©~ªqrd~qudgi;i*vihqu;g*® yZzxzqrpoHxq8rv;nt% (i qr hjy¸, qri; dgiextTtq¸hjPtjti;³ g|xxxt||gi&AAtTº7o<³9º<x-y|*»y|xoH©~Cqaqr´d~tid~oyZx<v}ªd°rv;i;tviq;i{ ® mpª9o!y|~· o~gtlsuxc-og|i;Tu½Æ xÒqxn 3in Áog.i;o °t|.ao qrd~3i* xoHqri;|ns}tTqrx{y|o oMyT3|i&sWrHr~´t|dgv&i;i|sr iuquv&dgtiij´ti&o~x|°dHqxnsri>vwxqrxy|hjoty³©µxzh tg´h
(13) i&x´|dHd~qri&i>o ¿ n !xtTqatgx«qut|o~viW©¬suy|h n gsuy|9y|srqrxy|o~t|quy o ´xÒqud7tvy|oq}toHqy©Pgsuy|9y|srqrxy|o~t|zx q JDo x ~t|o~sryZyZxzs«suqui;xzyZvqro~xty|o%qrt||y o n ´xzqrn d²t$® v&y|o~«qut|oHq¸y|©µgsuy|9y|srqrxy|o~t|zx q Tt|o~p d~t|aqrd~ijuthji*y|suxzi;oHqutTquxzyZo giÁ~mpogoMi>%t+t|hjy|tjsuivyZsroHi>Zvi;y|oZqaqr´µxy|yZo$sr¶°gsu· y ,g2~cPvwqº<y|©-¼qr½\d~9iqrd~xzi&og%xzqrx|t i;2ogxi&hs}ttZx&E;i¸i;´xzqrqud<dgxat*og¶|y|i;qrsrxo~y|i&o ®¸cedgn i {o hjr¿i;gxt|zogi>rav&t|o7ªi n .o n n .o yquZc~y ojyoogi;o~y|t|su«o~h~%srtitTx&qrqE;dgi;iajyHgÅW«srxzqryZtx~y|i;uo«s«xqutxzqri>ojd~ty|qi;© srtxzxsuo Ti¸tTTqrtsuxysu|xq}i>t|tTo~quvxzyyZi©2o~xgtoZo~quzi&jo~i;xsµro xzsuq¾|yt|q}ZsrtTv&xtqry|xoHhjy|qogsui&qrqus}tTi;tqrjox|«tTiaq,tTqrqut~yxzyZgno x«®Zqut|t|o~o~viesui;©¬suuy|v&htx ogn±~g suy|9xy|,srqrª~xtZy|«o~i>t| hx ogti;qrcet|xy|sdgo i;y|H*s~t|v&r~xztZogtr*rxzqu«©¬xz ZtTi¸hjqrhjxi;t9i>xtxi&t|ogsuzxi>o~¾ri;tuqr&©¬xg|® i>o~avwquo%yxz©2yZyZoquogdgiWxzi¸o±d~xzqht´µo~ty Z´ei¦ t¾tTÌ qe\ &t£&¿2¤TÁ9¥ suy| «xq;oHh* Nq vi>n%i;oZxttquo~suog±t|i;gtuy|s,rxv;ytS2y|Bi«ªi&oq}q,t® hjxogi;i;$x¢tª Ì +og£ i;hjuy v&i;Htgrxi;t|xzv&ozy|og©¬o~yZi>2rs«{ Zxz«yZi>oqr´d~d~i yZryijv&tt¾ZFx E;i&s}tTtquxzZyZi o%s}yt|©xª9~y|¸gxo~~gtsrsuyZxzi>yZª s«qu<xzyZt¾o~|ti&-s}tquypZxzo~oj® ra~toqrxqutdgixoy©¬quyZdgsri&hstTdqutxzyZo~o72tª9hjy|i;*q xtnMogyTi;Zui&Wsxry|rhjt|xi Msuqriy { ª9~tTi qu t[{Æ\ gÌ i&¥9¤ i&o~´dgi;oHi;oq;® x¸sutZxt|z7rHhjhjiqusrxv*to~°gtTq}tT{Æxzoi&9i&o~gi&oHq t|o~ ¥gÑ-¥ _£ [ Ì´dgi&o x UDVXWYV [ Ñ Ì ¢ Ð Ì Ñ [ ¥ \ Ì ¢>¢ i&ceq{pd~t|i*xAhj®ei&&x· SJ,o~i&ÅrsuxzyZi&º<o~oHqWtJ|gxih½ÆÁ~®togce|xzqri>dgx&y|i&¿ oaty|r©,ysugxsuZy|i;9ayZrtio~7to$qrdgi³ i;xzqrsWi;o~xoH«Txy|t|osrxy|t©o~v&qrd~ii¸gv&suy|y|o~9v&i&i&srqrxqi;ay© ´µsui;xsri Zi;sr,i; yxz©i;´µxi>hj<i&ª o~7rxy|Po ªi;*srxo
(14) . . . .
(15) . .
(16) &% . . $#. "!. . . '( ) *. ) *. )+,'( ) *. -'. /.. ,0. &'. 87. *9. 132. 0. /.. 54. 6'. :. ";. <. = ? n > BX t '. (A@;x - %DCB2 $('DnF> E G @ ( IHJn)> BX s%LKv$ , (py~ (+',AM 3 ( nO> N. . PRQ P5S.
(17)
(18) !#"$%& ('*)#+',-%'.$ %y~jsz @sz$ f-x( ( -$ H(n > j ('.('{'. ( f$#x' N ( ,%y~tsz ; < n > X v q', hBu!(}# 3 wu! < %6; v D (-Tw~ . . . . .
(19) . . . . . } s^ (; ?) n > D . N. ryZ ~s±ttqrmpxo²t«y²aqudgt|v&i+o~t|z vi;yZuoHv&qrt|iz³ (iM'{qjgy|xzx©ehj+h i&togo!«zxqriy|x³gro~v;t;thj®
(20) i±gceti|d~o~® iat|zP^r³Hx%qu;su+tZXsuvw $xqugxz yZ|&oi;y|v;©Wt{o²r~ª9 (v}d! i±isr³ xhqrX| <s}t|i>·jv qrsri>ilHgxc-o xz|sui;~t<rrº<~9t|i;v&vi xzÁxzo~v%gv& tzc|,yZxzo~º<srxz<qrd~qr|hjdgi ½ hjg· i&i>xsuo~xzZZxv;i;t 2c©¬xsuhy|,h tº7|i>qudgWi· c-º<cxgtHs}|>v}¼~½\dg®;xogj2cPvgº<ª9Zi;¼T¸½ · t| 2©¬¼HyZ>s ½i³gto~t|h*~tzgiP~quzdgxi;i,+ry©¬y|{pv&set|h zi;~WÒquº<xuv&tt|s}zv}iWdgvxogsui; « qxogx ogi>i;Pe· ci&³HÅWqufsutZevw>qucxzyZÅWo+|xk¾o ½ Ð ¤ ¢Ñ Ì Ñ [ ¦Z¥£ Ì Ñ £ Ð Ì ¢>¢ Ì ,Ñ Ì £ Ì ¦£ [ Ð \ UDVXWYV ¯°k ¨ i$gv&t|y|o~o~v&i&goHsuqry|s}9tTyZqurixzogdgji&sui±&x S9yZi;o sri;´µoHqyZsrsr¶i>W«9~y|ro~xzo~ria7©¬h go~gvwzqrquxxzuyZv&o~tt i+A@y|t|so~hjti;«xxWt©¬ogy|i>s r |Cwi>® rri&iqui;vwquxzyZo i;ri>vxtz°xo hx ogti;qrcet|sus$xÒdg³*i$«yqr´µ©9su~qryZvwdgsrquia¶gxzsryhi>©t¹aZxoiy|qrze y i;¨ sii&xzqjÁ~hogtt|i\|® ti;q;· ¹¸® i;tZÅ cev}d*dg¨ i9 y|¾½srxi>oHµ«q g9nsuy|y|o~9rtyZi%ori+©¬y|gsut<o~xi&vh oHqrxqugy|toÒqrquxxy|uo*v&«t|i>y|z+i+srqri;srdgxzi>yZZ«|i&9o y|y||oo~i>trvw i±qrogyZxysuo quji;y|y|s}©i;qrdgsquiyqry°qrddgi>iairrtTquxi;³t|vwxo q y|iH©~t$t9y|qrx«i;quoZt|quo~xt|vPia|yi>© rri&-xqrodqrtTdgqi¸|y xi;sr ai>vwquqrdgxy|sryZo g
(21) |d tsui®ogy|c~qrsri;yZ h qrdgxto xsui;vwqu®PxzyZceo dgJiaqrd~sri>ij«9q´µy|yo«iyZtxzqoHq}Wzyxµv&tqri&i>Á~Mogi>tT q ª qucedgdgiihjtxzo~quxzdgh y|gs}2h ggy|©qqrd~i,i&hjgdt|rx2yZoWqrdgk ixrv&srxhjxzo~©¬tyZqrs xy|oª9iq´i& Hi;o® vy|oHquy|gs} toW|i;uri& vi;oZqui&s}&® ª9cei;d~v;i&tc~ ~y|rgziWyTsu´y|xzo9xogyZqu<rdgi$xqudgt|v&xt|r yr´i|t|Hy|oXqusudg¶9ii& ³ su iqui&yZto~srsui;riaxz!o yZo~E±o yi&qquq*y°q´tk \y*®¨ 9· y|ªgx oHquqec´i HZxzqr;~dg½xyZxi>«qvquxtsroHi>i;vqe²yZqrh*yquyMhj~i;ro~ªgi±x©¬ogq~s«tjqutdgvxi&s}~s vtxzi|sroqr® ©¬xyZvsr~ht|ts qrxsuy|i;o²r©¬yZsuo~y|hri quxhdgitZdii;xuoZrquxt|i&o+o~rhxzqptTquA@sr xz³29¿K® xzAquehC3i&Cwx |qui;dgo iW¾t|i&zx~|i;i;oH;®Tt|mpo~zggi>i&i;y| © gqrtTdg© qrji i;sdt i;uc-«xt¾tHo±y|hstiqr³su~xÒ³2t| o~´rxzdgyZoi&o+qryjqrdg«i¸i>v|yZs}o~t|gxzy|i;oZs}qi;xsµy|´© i;qrt|dg¶9i i&³gsri>rµqudgizyv;t2Tt suxtqrxy|o$y©-qrdgi xoHqri&o«xzq±xo$ qudgixsri>vwquxzyZo$y| ©qudgit|u«yv&xtqri;+i&x|i;oHZi;vqry|s};® . ! "# $&% ')(+*. LM. -,. ./%10. ,.
(22) . ". 32. 4. 4. 5. 6. ". 6. ). :9. % % %+; . <*. . . 87. =9 ?>. ,. % %%@; . .7. . >. . " ECB" EDGF. . ". ,. IHKJM L . . ,. :A. HNJ1*. # J. HJ M L HNP QJ/R . AeC. pmt|oMo~jqrdgdgxx¸|d±´t¾i;ZxzZ~i&©¬o yZTsat´gd~i;xÒµqui*to~«qrsu~tvwqrqudggxsus}i;ay|y|ogoMig´t|dgsr¶%xv}d+ª~tZxµv}¶ zyT|´ suy|gxo+o~tª«t yZz [\ quiÌ ¥gT¤tgqui|srt|vwo~qr~srti _d~t| ¬¥ \ q¥´µ¤ y$«ogqrsui&~HvwtTququgxzZsuii qudddgt|yTi&µ´µh y|i;og|qui;y s;Ty|qui&ogdgÁ~i¸iaogogiWt|i;tZqrtTsud~qui;y|xzrZs}iayZ«t|o~d~o~ryTi±´!©¬dggyZxo~|ogvd+qr*xi&y|txo$|ri&´xo ogTdg|txv}igd$suiWi;rti&go~9Òi&qµo~y|q~´µo±µy*tyZyo±ququdgdgqusudgi&i&siaizi;yTxzx´Zhji&o i&i&xo~T|tri&xo y|go~Ti;tt|,~ygx©i>hj&qu®t|dg|iceidgd´xi;µd~uo~rxv}xyt|d±qroxv&oghjy|*oHtzqui>qrt|sut|xzxÒo~g³2 ® yZog»
(23) q´µhjy*y|suqui gªgsui;gv&ti&oHsqa«qr´su~y|suvw¶quggsui;y|;og® i*ª gtTqryiqt\®j· »a|¼g a»¹ ;½t«y$gsryZyH«i>quyv}dgy yH«i t qusui&dgi;³ri9i;suy|sri;o~xrhjrii&yZoH©¬o~gqurot|ivw©¬qrgxquy|o~~ovqr±ª~xy|tZyZo<«oi>´±Tdgt|ixsr³gv}xv&dMy|z~~veryZxv;h |t|i&ªgrji;xog y|i>A@o+ev&gqrqrdgsrdgZi iWi;qri&$dgx|su|i;i&i>o i r¾ri&i&t|xz|&~i&¾i;o µ~Tyto~©vwgququi>xzdgyZio~xedydgi;©ui&r~|xt|sri>xo+rrqui&hxv { tTCtqu® o~srxz%³2®xceª~d~tZi¸«i>v}%dgyZy|xv&o7iat|y|o © hjygcet|dgzxi*qrxxi;oZ;qu¿i&suº<i;«q¸»y|©PqrdgcÊi;xzsWt|o~´%y|suqu¶$xzx-agqri;y%uv«sud~xzªgyTx´Êogqrd~t&x S9qWi;t$sri;«oHxogqa|to~i thjqryZi&h*qrdgxv&yt|°v&«tqrsuoM~vw|quxg|i&sri>oM&¿,sri>|«i;guzrqui&aey|o°xzo7«ª~i;|sui;t|suxzot| S6. >(-$,. O L H. L. (. D. T6 6. U6. .
(24) v',X , ( 8 (& D }
(25) w $sz # }}& (# %'{(z $ ~ªt©qsrryZi;o~sµv}ÁdgÒx quy|i&susPxzogxzZi&®8s>d®yTce´dgi&i;|xzsi;s;t|Zgqrgd~sui¸yZtZxhv}d tZx-i;qry~gri;su±yT xxo$ieqrdgt¸i;xz sxri&~³ t9i&d~sui&xh* i;xoHo*queqrdg«ii;i&xh oHqri&qusuy*gdsuit¾q}|tTiaqrxt*y|o dgxy|©9d~qri&dgsi«xhtTqrtxZti ©¬sui>i;i;´.qurxzy|hgtxquuqrxzvxyZy|suo+io7ququi%y|d~©tuo%|v&t|i;~uzi>rr&i&~et«2xFy xE&hi;iZr®to Zmp o7i;q+equ~dgirijqui;i;rvt|q±xh*o7|i*i;vurxzq}ogi&tTxquv&i tTt|³2yi>g©*s}hjt|t|vwxo~quo~x2v&i|Y~c~y t|sui;o~t|r$ogo | q+qrxdgi«i;i;qxzsai&th t\®|ry|· gcgsuxzs}xzquqrt|t|dgZªgh%¼>zi½~´©¬yZsrdgyZs+xv}tyHd%o «i ~t|«t|v;i>ogvegy|qus}dgi;tTsri&qu is sui;r9ay|«o~xrogij©¬qr~d~o~ivwquvxzyZt|ou«ª xzÁ$v&txzoHqrqrxy|i;sro$~ysri&©-qrxog&x E; i&Zsi&i&yZqh*t|i&Aqr®sugxv;i;tuvzsujxzª9qudgi;$ixzi&o<x|ri;i;o v¾qrt|xy|z~o°i;|® ye©-® eqrdgtti 2dqri;d~uyZ«rxti¸o´hy|sutT¶qusrxzg³2sr® i>«i;oHq xgoxTSJtei&ogsui&yZoHoqµ{Ærv} dghjyZxh*v&i;i&,qrsuyx©2vhj´ei;t¾|x¾ttoog¸i;ut|PsrquiPd~i;tTxÒquqdgti&sus i $h# u#'. +T}x(· , ª9i;v;c-t ~Hri qudgi&»a|i;¼ i;cgo~s}t||y|¼Toj½Zy|qulsdgi
(26) d i;u~«·x¹¸toÅ h¨ tqr su¾½xÒ\³ ® . ,. 021. . . T6. . 6. 6. ". 5@?N7zI#9
(27) ML7!9 5@?
(28) OQ<=? 52I 2<8?
(29) 93Of<7%935@?5
(30) ~7 LJ <=I%7!93J. ect|srd~iWi¸qv&´y|yoH©¬qryZsuxz ª~® c-qrxxy|suo~«q;µy´µ©i qrdggxsryZ~tyH9«i&is>tj ª~o~t|i&r´ i;+t|y|~o+t~qusrxzZi;Hixy|h*i>,´xty|ogsu¶i;u· ¹hjº<i;tZ» «¸gsu|iW¼Zt ©¬y|gs¸¹º<iqu» i;¸vqr|xy|¼|o<ª2 y¹©quº7g»ªgg|¼Tt½\s qu««qrqri&susu~x«vqr qrxgv&y|su©Ji;yqradg©PxzyHqro°«d~iivk v}¨ dd~t|i>xzhsurrtZxt|vwt||quo<i&i;su;hx®«qrtTcexqrv&sudgxzi ³$yZojtZyg©PgtquxTgSJdgqri&ixsu|i&xi hoHq,~tsr|hjyZiZy~i;xzqus«i&q%i&y|xy|©2©,i&|o qri;dgZui*i;rvwi&hjquPy|i;s}xzoxvtto~~og%i;xuogi;axzZxi&ai&o ª~Txzt|trqugi;xv;Mi;t;9y|®evo<cesuyZqudgdgui ij{pt|«v}i>o~d~vwttquxzs}HyZt|qro~vxv{ T´t|t|o~iz7gi>Z«&i¸i;®¸ut «cei;r-dgxzhjxta³gxi;¸itZvghjgysuTtTi&qu9qugyysr©i*v}v&dg« d~y zxyTyHo~´Ê«i suqrt|xd~v;o7tt9q¸y |S2i;i>xzrZriri&qai&o s}|tT´i>quvwxÒdgquqri&d$yZssuvaqrxd~s}tvt|o~goMMtv|sei;s}oHÅWt|qrts}xt~i&-uoH«h*qWxtti>o±sui xv&tsrhjyHogry|i;«suu{pi«i>su«vwqui;qrt|rxy|ªgo*yZzi o~qurqry i|d®|t~oMxi;i;viaxzyZZy|o~i&go2s{ g· ixqro~i>Zvw¾quxz½\yZ® o ®µ¯°cei%dgqrid~t|i&o~o tiH³qrgxvsui;vuyZ h*qrdg~i<qusuti&qrxtTy|quo<xzyZto~«zyTd~´xz!ªti&uqv&´µt|i;zi&i&o{Æri&qrdgi;i<vqrxy|tos}txzohjquidgqui&i s}ut hjiqu´dgi7t¾$ri&t|i;vw qui;xo~ i;uv&ªti;sri| sut|t|i&o~o$tTi&qu³qrxzyZgdgo~zi$xrvdgxzqquxzsrhj~~vy´qrgii&suh2iqut´y¶|xi i&qrtdsuxz©¬Zgt|iWo~z-y| sui;v}quvxzdghyZy o~yZt«r2qri*su~tqrvwdgs}qutyHxzhjyZ«ioiqu~y|i&t|©s}suµqrt|dgy|hji ©i|quqrdgi;i;ui&surxsi&tZsuv&i;ogv&ry|is}qyZ´o~xzy|«o~iasu$¶J©¬®gquy%o~vqrquqrdgdgxy|i+i&o sah*® ´µyyZsri;¶A®^gc~y±sryZogh yqaqr~d~«xi qut|d~sri+tTqce~t|dg«sri>iiW²Á~vqrs}~y°srq<Zvi;yZri;h*vwtqu~o~xzyZ$qro i$´i&xÒqui>x|d%ri&v&o ogsrxTy|ªtoi>{p$gvi>xt s}vgÁ~to~s}t seq<ªgi&vx |qi&xzo o~i;Zzgi;xsrvwxv&quqrt|y|xv&¸s}t|v& xzyvs}©suvyZgquudgt i {ps$«i>dhjvwi;quy uxzyZ«gxo i&t®-o cetho~d~ tyZqrrsuqiaxÒ´µ³ quy!dgti&oyZi&²srsui&xzqrqrZxyv&i;t| xz9oHhjhjqri;yysr~sri;i;i&q quxoHdgqri&i;xo~s,«Txzt|q|zgi>qr,dgiet|o~s}t|*qrxdg~i;-xzys©«qri;dgo~irxÒ«quqrxz su~xzqvw qug´suxzi|qr¾d±qrd~sui;ir|9i;i;uvwrq,i&qr yvgqusudgTitT9qr~yZsrriZxÒqu|xztyZo~o yqr©Jd~qrid~iao~y|vo~{psrvsuxi&suoHv&qg9ty|sxoZvsuq>yZ|uqudgiri;xvhqrxty|Zo i ® ceri&d~i;i¸vqrrxi;y|v&oy|o~ª~$t|r«i;i>vwqryZxy|o$o%qudgi>irvv& srxªxzoi>µsrqrxdgv&t|iW gvsuxy|suv&9gyZrti;shjhjyi>t|i&r\g®srmÆi¸qyt©rh*y*i>ZxzxZti;ogi;quudg&igt|sui&o~tTqrquxdgy|oi«tdgxquy|ªhi&tTq´µquxi;v¸i&uov&tqrdgii { rryFxi;E&v&vi%t|qrxgy|yio©a³ ® qrqrdgsu i&i< hoH«qrtqrdgsut|i&~o~qrvwx*quvegqrxzsrhdgi<iat|t||sro~i>i;XvPyZt|o~xzqusriequsr~ri&rvwi;i;qr xvy|qrquoji>y «¾qut|utzv&Zxt|gi;zt;iZqr®®!ieqrP³d~Z9ii&i&oHtsuqrxzo~hjt|tzi;HoZzquZq}xµ,v;tt|xzqjgo~«*i&qr³~srgi>«*t|~xztÒoq}o~*, tqrqudgsuyii%«idgi&³ yTququt´XsuxtZ qri;vwdgjqrixy|xo±ª9o i&tWdyqrt¾©¸dgHqrxxdgs}y|is y|xh©tqrdgZiWi%t|tsri|yZsryZxzqrogd~i¸h qrygToti&xgsjtTqui¸&x S9yZi;gsri;soZs}qjt|¶ xxz~oeg i;«y|qr©xhqrgtTquª~xzgyZo t|®s*»«qrgsu~~zvxv&qrgtqrsuxi;y|;o~®°PyZ³ o$9sui&i;sut|xh*2xzi;hoHt|qu|i;y|;oX qrtMdtTgqd~ttsuoHiquy|k h¨ su~i;srv&i>y|«i;o~oZ«qrqusui;~2v®qrcexy|d~o±iy||© i;qrudgriWi&2ªgogs}i&tqx´µo+yZZsri;¶±u«sui;i;v&,y|©¬o~suy|«qrh su~e v¨qrxy|Éo+{\xs}t¾v&y|thjog~ZxztyZsu|i;s}+tgqryd~xzi>«~tt|o~ x«t yH«ªggsusrt|©@xzt|o%v&i;º<sui&» o~gi;tsrsuxiaogjty|ry s º<m xi&´;® . . . 6. 0. 6. . PRQ P5S.
(31) .
(32) !#"$%& ('*)#+',-%'.$. ( "+ ! µ + '' 'a - '- 13 quZc~dgi;y|i,uz«yTxi;h´txogtTZ©qi2ui&dqusdgi;i¸tur´µh xt|yZgosrz¶jhjqrxyutv&©qrtsu· xÒi¸³j Á~· zqrci&Hsu»ax>og¹½\~H r;i&´½Æ|®dgi;mpyHsuot|«i¸yZt|susrgs«i>qui&«x9s2v&y|zqui>yo,«gd~i¸o~t¾xZei;ii&su³g«ª9quvi&t|i&~o~o«¸x|qri;i;d~gzi,jxv;ª~xztTogtZqr¶¸i>«i>ª9+iquqy yZ´o±qui&dgi&quiadgoWiW qudgxi&«i,x|i;ti&xzo Zx&E>Ti&tTto qrTgxy|ti>oµgi;y|y|©© quhjt|dgo~yi;%ri+i;qudgAi;®i xzZcei&ydgo v&iTt|tv&srg«yHqri;rsu«~{Ævwr©¬y|i;qugsjvqrsr«xi y|i;o$|yi;©Pxzsuoqut|dgPi;i tZqrdgv}xhd$i;y|thjsuZiyi|qu9xv;i&´µt,i xehji&Ti;ytxÒqudg~i;i&tTjsqui tji;xv&o7srxzxs}|quvi>dgg°x¸t©¬sersri;yZyZvwh squxztyZtoo<«i&qrxd~hjzxi*gqrt|xi$o~v&tt|v HÅWqrxzxotvisrr³xrv&gxt|t|suµo+i;v&uªg«xzs}xy|y|vgo<ª® ty|s© ¯° iempo~«qrqd~xgsui;ri;ri&voHqrxqy|odgi&su´i¸iWqrdg~iriWsui;qrdgrgiWzqu©¬yZ;zh*yT´yZxzsro~i ogi&y|qut|qutxzqrxy|to~ª9;y|¿ qv;tvgtTquxzyZov;toªiW©¬yZgo~xzo²· ¹º<»Z¼¾½Æ® {{lo m m xi;quogdgyiqui;xogxÒqrqudgxt|i s}xhjt|t|x|~iZ y|©qrdgixogxzqrxtZi;u«i; hjyi& ´d~xv}d<xtryjqrdgi«qut|o~gts}%i& xtTquxzyZoy|©t {{ÅW t|~+ux«xxqrtdgtjo ti ÅWdt|i;~uu««xxtto<o$º<©¬gto~qrvsuqrxÒx³+y|o%y|©´quxÒdgquid<xzhq}tt|o~|gi|t| su 2xi;HtjxtTrquxzxzhjyZoggoxzÁ~ i;htTqusrxz³+gsuy|9y|srqrxy|o~t|9qry {{ t|tsrsui¸i¸i&qrxdg|ii;oHtZTrt|rzygvi>xtTquyi;©-±qrdgi;xzti Zi&do i;|ui>«vwxtquy|os}&h® tTqrsuxz³+´xÒqud
(33)
(34) Ò ,. <6. H. L. G 130. . . . . L. . . H. . L. H. 9. R. 19 9&. 9 9&. R. 9. ~93I-Oh7 5 B J 3 9.? L I#9 < K9 I K M <=I 5 L JP 9 7 . <8M
(35) OfOz93<=? I-5@OzO . OfJD7!935@?. -xzZgsrijZ¿ "!$#&%'#)(+*-, ./102*3.54(76 02898902*;: qudgice|dgi>riWri&Á2su«rqi;v|qri>xy|rori&Jxhjty ÅWi&t|2~qurd~rxtTtqo´ªgizyZxoZª qu¿ sryviWxv zxo~suxv&t2´d~i&sui =< > µxqudgi|i>rri& t³ xto m n @? 2> BA +C n @? EDYA o m -F GIH"HKM J1C LIH H A@hk C ´Ac-d~xzi&su®iCw® !x ti&9©¬gi&oovwgqrxy|y|o oy|quL©dgiao-m±r&x E;t|io~y|© IqrOdgN +iaC |H i>suri&ri&g\su|i;qurdgi&xoHµqu¸i;qudgi;i±o~xoHi;qro~i&voi¸«xzxqtgqiaqrqrdgy i$~vti&sroHqrquxti&s|yyZ©ezgquhjdgi±i|i i>S9ri>rvwi&q qud~tTqgi;vsui;tZ«i>qudgirhjt|z|i;uri&µxoHqri;o~«xzq|® c. D. ) . >(-$,. . D. .
(36) ¼. v',X , (8 (& D }
(37) w $sz# }}& (# %'{(z $. cedgihjyi; gsuy|9i&srqrxi;etsui|¿ À qrqrdgdgiWi|©¬sus}y|t|oHquxxzi&i;oHsq,y|© xqrsrd~i>vwiquxz|yZi;o*urxi&Jhxetv&³ y|xh o~r~xghi&Zsui;xA®i|®quZyj©¬y|ªsPiqudgtTiqequ9dgy|iWxoZq}yZxz´oHqudgexv}´dd~|i&i;susriaxz©¬quvdgnDi¸ Á~s}?zq i;srxo-TmtTqrZx|qri¸d ~xo qrdgiZi;u«i;2sutZx~xL o#m|® À xÒxz©2hqut|dg|ii hjxWyti&ogy|xqrµdgvi;yZsoHZZi;y|u«|i;i>´´dgxzxqrv}d+d7thÅWtTq}t|v}~dgri;raxty|oj~¶|sai;hjsrogyi;gi&y© ªg«qugt|q¸o~´gtxzqrs}d°jt±i&s} t|xtTxqu~xzyZ o oo Zmqrd~iosui; r®WgÒcequxzd~o~x sri>«~Òqv;toªixsui;vwquz$i;vi;$©¬suy|h qudgiri&hjxÒ{Æ|suy|~+gsuy|9i&srq|® qumpy|odg©µxquyZdgsuhjgi±i&yZsPi;qui&uy\«®i;ªAce®i&q«d~quceii&dgsµÁ~i±qus}t«q¶Zi>ivyZyZogxzoHo~iqu°y xay|t|ogt*v;ivqry|yZx~ sroZxvt<q,vqrv&xdgHsuiv&x go~sui;tt|suszxxv;|qt i>ry|rZ©2i&i;qrudg´«i;idgP|x´v}i;d<uxÒqurt|di&z&tyTZo²´´µei&i~z´xxququxyv;«tqrxzoH~µquv&sr*sryyHqr´~«{pv&y«i i>Tvwttqrsuxvxy|t~oqrsrxTy|´tTo~dgquPgxv}suy|d i © xoHqrsuy~vi>t*¾t|srxtTquxzyZo+xoqrdgiv&xzs}vgtsrd~t9iWy©-qrdgiZi;u«i;A® WYVUDVU _¤ Ì ¢>¢ [ Ð \ Ð Ì [ Ì \ ¥ Ì ¢¥ \ Ñ Ì [ Ì \ Ì ¦£ Ð ¤T¢ Ð £ Ì <Ì ¢;¢ [ ¥ \ ²¥g£&¤ [ ced~i¸i;xzZi&o Ttgi;t|o~+qrdgii;xzZi&o |i>vwqryZsuµy©-qrd~ti di;urxt|o$htTqusrxz³ tsui H. H. 9. :. 9. 4. :. 4. H. . . . C CH X H+H % CC CH
(38) CH % n)I? % ?H .n) Qo#m . -,. m m n @?K> . . R. , , . . . ´hjd~i>i&tsuo~i qud~tTqyZgseh*yi; d~xtZqrd~qridgiWxzog©¬xzyZqrzxtyTµ´xzxzho~*t||~i|sr-yZto~i;s«quxzi>&¿ xqrdgis}t|gxz~y©qrdgi±xogxzqrxtµxzhtZi|®+ced~x À mpxzoo~rquxdgii gqrdgti*og|iWi>y|rsrrqri&d~l y|A |n yZ o~t9? qu y qudgo#im tT ³Cxe´yi ©d~qrt¾dgZiiWZqi;´µuy$«i;Aog® i&HtTquxzZii&x|i;oHTt|zgi>´xzqrd7i;xzZi&o |i>vwquy|s} À cetT³dgxij&® qrd~xzs}Mi;xzZi&o TtgijxWo gtoMqudgit|u«yv&xtqri;Mi&x|i;oHZi;vqry|sWxWxzo°qudgixzsui;vqrxy|o°y©qrdgi À iceHdg~i+t|Ji;xzqrZy i&o T tC Xgi; + Cm +m t o® x o~vtsusui;i±tZ«hi>tT³©@tZxhqut<i&sexzo qrdttª~o ry|aqrt|i$etTt©¬ggo~i+vqr´xy|dgoi;ao y©n qrdg i? x q}to~v&i¸to~qrXy*qrtdgsuii vi;oZqui&st|o~ªi>vy|hjH i>eyH«xzqr x|iWy|gqurxi¸qudgi|i>rri&2´dgi;srijoKm nD ?z xogi&HtTqrx|iZ® suc~i&xy|tT~saqutZxzqryZvdgoai;i*+o!h ª ~t| Òo~qu ²xuv&o qut|dgm zi±i*asugoi;sury g® v&Òi;q}u &t|srqri+d~i*«qrhjx ,yTti;-x XxWvgyZoHiZquy|y7|qri>d~%i+´«i;xÒquhjdxÒ{Æt$|suÅWy|t|g~²u«gxsuty|o79¶Zi&sri&qsuMogi&ª~-yq©oq}m to~d~gtZt|suqrMyªii { mpo~G o$y1qG qrd~Eξsryjv;t|i&52rZi|I#i&H9 suqr dg´iWKdg93i;i&I xzsuZKii&M o ªg3Tg<tqI gy|i;og e+t5 otB+qJ qui;dgxzZii&o vi;|oHi>qrvwi&qrsyZsuy|µ©tqusudgi¸ir|xh*i>rxri&t8seAAi«³gi;vi*i;·¹qeº<qrd~»at|qe¼¾qr½ dg©¬i¸yZsqrd~hjxzs}y|+suiWi;xzgZii&quo t|TxztgCw®i¸x s}t|gxz¯°~ i
(39) hjyto~i&+Fx qrE&dgiiqurdghit|i>rvrxi&suv&´ziWxÒqu´d7xzqrtjd<qrtjyZsrs}~t|;x~qudgi i Hªg~x+t|Jv&qrxzs} y v i® ~ts}t i&2quyjqrdgi gt|ogiÉ
(40) to~%´xzqrd7t L. L. H. .. %. . L. ,. ,. 0. K. ,. . S. . % . H. . H. . . . . . . . PRQ P5S.
(41) .
(42) !#"$%& ('*)#+',-%'.$. x|~srite¿Pcy|suxv¸hjyi&2y|©t*Zi;u«i;A® cedgixoHqri;o~«xzq©¬govwqrxy|o%y|©qudgihjy gi& xe|x|i;o$ª qudgii³gsui;u«xy|o¿ c . G H J1C L H H J H m n)I?K> BA F HMH *H A tc -eC C C % CC % CH
(43) H N CH H n % D K> "> H . cedgii;xzZi&o |i>vwquy|s}µt|o~+i;xzZi&o Ttgi;ey|© tsui @ri&i -xz® ¿. . % CC H .
(44). . R. . . . . . n. % . mpv&o²i&oHyZqri;sus±i;qusWdgqri7y%suxioZ©¬qui&i&susui&gosuvii<qquqry d~iqrdg¾i°t|z~vi;ioZyqui&© s Ägy|i&©9i&qrdgo~i7xogqry|<su~yZ+oxzquo dgi±qudgviM~sr~TtTt|quoggi sui*A y|©µ³2qu adgi!Cw|®i>r¯ri& xzqrd qudgiMogi;´µ´ i v&y y|s}xzotTqr*i n- n *g´i¸dt¾|i L. ,. . ,. L. . %. . . ,. R. 0. m n. m o m an % o m An C . %. L. ,. %n-. z! n. !. . 0. !. . uq¯ d~xvtTd~xqogi&ojxzt*q±qr|d~i>yiar©rvqri&~dg2sriv&TgtTZsrqui;Tgut«suqri;igJxsuv&,ii&oHoHv&~qrti;zo$\s; ®Pzi>cet|dg+xqryjhjt|9i;,yZt|rxzo+ojxÒququxzquZd~dgi tTiaqev&quHdgxio~tª~suµxrv;y|yZts~o~v;quiat|i&ZrTi|tt® qrxg|iii&Zy|A i&n© srqrdgi;jhjzi>Cµt¾r;+¾t|ogquzdg~yxi;qeª9suyi;i© roggi&ÒqZzx«xodg|yTxqrªg´dgii d~v&y|xzZhjd ~® t|sri>7quy%qrdgi+t|ª~ry|qriTtgiy|©qudgiq´y%yqrd~i&si;xzZi&o Ttgi;´d~i&o°qrdgi+|i;uri&v~srTtTqugsuix R. G. R. H. . . H. . O. ,. . 0. #. G 1. . 93?LI-9 < t J.9L7!9 < 5 B J. . R. R. ce«qud~t|i+o~gi&t|suxz$quxv;i&t xtTrqri;xy|vwquo%xzyZto y|xo~* gquidgÁ~iog+i> t³ ª x ;!y|o ogi®ceq}dgto~i~hjts}y i&2i&x extTqudHqrxy|o tiÁy|ogogi;M$qrª dg9i$¿ ³ tT³x;2o ,to y|ogi . . >(-$,. . m n @ ?K> A F H
(45) M G G H M L L H . . .
(46) . v',X , (8 (& D }
(47) w $sz# }}& (# %'{(z $. . c-tªgi|¿PrxzZo$y|©qudgii&x|i;o ¾t|z~i;etTqeqrd~iyZxzoHqaº©¬y|sequdgii&zxquxv;t2hjyi&\® º x }! ,heqrd~ii&zx~ri| U N + G L W + ºxt (jqudgii& xz~ri| N G L + ºxt(% ,qrdgii;zxz«iZ . . . 7 . . . . . H. G. . . H. . . H. . % % %. L. O0. 0. ,. ,. 0. ,. ,. . ,. . . . . . ,. . . 0. . 0. ,. -,. . . ,. c-tª~zite¿P³ ~sri>rrxzyZo+y|©-i;xzZi&o Ttgi;ety|o~nMt|o~?+tT³x©¬y|seqrd~ii&zxqrxv&t| hjyi&\® ¥ Y[ ¢ Í C C H LH Í ¥ Y[ ¢ CL H C GH H C C H H L G GH ¦Ì\£Ì¤ Í . . LH GH . . . . %. . %. . %. . . %. . %. . %. . %. .
(48). % .
(49). y|t©³x;c~®Py|mpsµn o%qrIdgª? iWy|u-qr«d<rx|gv&ohjtZy|«hi>© &tqrsud~x&xziE;©-i;´i&°xi|xi;ov}o dg¾q}y t|tyZzªg~riji;i7;o ZZ´®±ria¯v;o i$to+v&to x«qrt|xogr|y<gxrqud~qrdgsutqri&o~dgi¸ iv&tZi;xz«Zi>i&,o Ti;tgi;o~i;xut|og zyZqutogyZª~ozitqrqrdgd~e*iqi|n9x|yZi>tro~xÒquqrxzyZdgo?i t~|o~sryZtHi;qrs«xqvW$ix³gqrsud~i;tuq«xy|qudgoi ys}©tTququdgxzyi y|i;©PxzZqri&dgo i Ttq´µgy+i;;hj®µ»t| xzqoM qui&dg xi| i&v&o i&ToHtqri;gsi>y©xqudgiiZi& t xzqu quy±xv;qutdgi |xi;o u|ri&i&\s}griy|ogyi ©PxzqroHd~qri i;sr i>Zquxzto~sui y|©qudgisutqrxyjy©qudgisui;ri>vwqrx|iWs}t|x\¿. ) . . , , . L. L. @ , , . oo . . . ;icexzd~Zi&xWo Thjti;gt|i;o~¸s}qrtTdqutTxzyq ® tA@hj|xy||sui;iWogTitqusut|xxztTqrxv&y|t|oo$y|ª9oiWqr©¬dgy|i~o~s}t|gxzxzo²Ps}· ¹tTquº<xzy%»´Zx¼¾zP½}C® i;tZ7quy7t$d~xzZdgi&sTtsuxtTqrxy|oy©qrdgi WYV `VU Ð \ ¦ ¢ [ Ð \ ¥~¡ Ð £j£ Ì<Ì [ Ì \ ¥ Ì ¢ Ð £ Ì <Ì ¢;¢ [ ¥ \ ²¥g£&¤ [ iqu;cedgxzd~Zii&iqo qr´µTd~tyWsri;gy|iaqridg«xi;qre~sPo i&gxxi;|9+i&o ´hjTxzqrty dggi&qui>dg,i¸t|d~srv&t¾iey|Zsuogisri;i>xZ«o$tT9quvy|xzyZoZhjixzh*t|o~o~ yZ oi&ixqr|Hd~i;~io t|©¬y|i;xzv©~qryTquyZ´dgs,ixzxogo+r i;quvwgdgqusuxziyZy|o9i&xzxsusrPi;qrvvxi;xqrs};xy|v¿go$tTtqys>©qrTd~quy|dgisPiW|ti>|~ri>grri&srrJy¾i&³Jvxi;tThoH³qrtTxi&&qrsµx|ty|i;oogzi i H~t2xz©qudgiri;vwquxzyZo%xt|oi;zx ~«iW´xzqr^ d o o ®cedgiWqrdgsui&iW©¬yZzyT´xog*v&y|o~gxÒquxzyZo~ei³gsui;uqrdgi>«i ~sryZi;s«quxzi>&¿ +o m A¬f C m k A C A@h C . 87. 9 4. . :. %. . . . . . (. . 9". . H. +. . . . 9 9&. R. . . . . . 9G. . PRQ P5S.
(50) Z d~xzZdgi;9«q®A¬ogfi&CeHv&tTy|qrxhj|i¸i;i&x©¬|suy|i;o hľt|qrzdg~ii sui&¾tTququxzdgyZiWo xzoHqui& o~rxÒq+ myk©oKqum dg®imÆq|i>i&r³rgi&sr2i>trqri;qudgiqudgvigsusui&sui&tToHqrqexy|uov&t|«dgzi x ªi&q´µi; i&mZogtqrodgi quTdgt|ijzg|iWi>y|r©=ri&o -m sutZxxog~y&q®¶ »ogqyT´to rv;qutdgi x srYi;o tm qr xy|o xx¸gxÒqr±d~i*v~ ÒHq~qutysui i³y|g©,qry|d~xzqi*tZo~i;$u«qri;d~is}t|«gxhjxz~g;z®tidv&sryTxz´qri;i&srZxy|i&os>2t|aqrdgi ´d~xcv}d´µy%xzhjhgtx xi;oequgd~xÒ±tTq v~Òaquxzxi>tt«suy*xriogi&©¬yZHstTqu~xzZriaxzogx$qr~d~rii;2g® sri; xzyZ~av&srxzqri;srxtg®*cedgi*Á~s}qy|o~i x¸qrdgixu vsuiqri sut|i&sr~iµsr~i>r«~i;oZtq}ztTWquxzquyZdgoxogy|og©Pi&sqrdgqui*d~txhjo t|q´|i*yvy|y|s-h qudgªgsrxi;ogiµi;<Zy¾´³i&xzqrd7t|qro~dgijqu«dghiet|i&zx|«i;xFoHE&Ti t|yzg©i>Zi;t|u«sri;iµog;®ayq»v&vy|qrhj~t|gz|quJi;*|i>tTrq-ri&qrdgiersuxFE&i;i;t quZd~i;tTu«qcei;xd o~~v&v&i&;sroHJi>qrt|qri;dgrsi;i*µªg|qri>dgqrirtTi&~qa-o~qrhjvdgi;yijs«q}vi&ti;xoHoZqrq~i&srs¸i>yZy«oi;©,oZv&t+qusri;xz|qr<y¾i;sr³xxo7i&y|\oQ®qudgceA xhC¸dgwi*r® i;«vi>qrvxy|yZoo~<i&hjy|o~gid~tZxa«Fx E&qudgi i qrdgogijyZo{pxzvÂxsuv&v&ggzqt|<sxzvosuyZsrui;«z{Æ rxi;ogv+qrxyZy|oo qui;Zdgxzi;Zxui&W«o i;srÒTi>{Ætt|xz¶Zrgy|i i;o W2quy|sr´©µijvwquqrdgg~iqsrsryZi>di>yH©¬r«suri y|xth)qro²y%y|h~qrrdgtTii;qrsusi&xzx³7|qui;sr©¬o y|~¾s vt|qrt|zg~o°sui;i;¸tZ;v& yv&t©µgoqrsu7dgtqriqquiy$d~i;i&urqr«iji;xvtt$qroxy|Zhjo²sutZtyqr©exsui&xÒ|oH³Mi>q«r{Æ©¬ry|ª~i&sWt|rqri;v&d~%i&ijoHsuqrgi;i;xrs u9vty|suoxzo~hj°rixo~r©¬Fx tTgE&qui|oxz ®yZvwqrocgxy|y|y|o s© ©¬ryZi;s*vqrqrxy|dgo i® i³ qrs}t|vqrxy|o y©qudgi%|i;uri&evi&oHqui&suzxogi;;® cedgx*i³ qrs}t|vqrxy|oXx*i³gtxogi;XxzoXqrdgi©¬yZzyT´xzo~ / $ 1 + susuai;i;~rr99sy|y|to~o~grr~i;i sryHxo°tt|q*v}y|d%s}tv&i&ts¸xo%uqrvª9y%sui ii>quri+gquxzrzhxiqq tTxquoHy|i*qr©yqrrdgv;qutijdgsri;|i;;i>irr´µi&qui&i+W~qr;vdg®ei;i;oZ¯o qui&iisu³ zÁ~xqrogsus}i>«t|q&v® q vyZPquhjdgi;ui+g«i;qryiv&tt|qrdgsri ihqrh tTdg³gi;xozhjqrxsut7ri;v;v&xzto y|io~qu«srdgqri>xsu« ~9vh y|qroi;gM«Òi¸qux~u©¬surv&y|xzt|ogh zi ª9ª9yyququdjdXqr©¬dgyZi¸sjvxzoHi;oZqri;qusri&~suzsrxi&ogqri>xogMto~qu*dgi%qudgi&ix|ri;&x E;oHiTt|xozg©¬y|i>su ht|tTo~qr xy|quodg®i%mpoji&xqu|dgi;ioHZÁ~i;s}v«qrq,y|s}qui& y|H©´µqudgi^i ~«diai;turhjxt|y oXgi&h~tTy|qu©Jsrqrxz³XdgitZo~i; u«©¬i;y|s v}d~yHyHµ«yZxogh*j~t*qu|ty qryxy|+o!ogyyZ©srhqudgt|i zxFE; ,t}qrxy|&o+| t (s}&tphj'.i$qu +i&u!s>(® - *sri Z~xzsui;*&x S9i;sri;oZq±«qri;~&® c-xzs}«q;µto gh ª9i&sy|© qu9v&yjgy|suxªoHsrii;quoZ ogq,t|i>srutiPv&st|~zt*sriZi&®-|{Æi>rcei&rd~ri;i&iv2qrsrti;i>³ a«9x;~y|®roxzceo~«ied~ei&©¬qrgo dgoivw©¬i;yZqrxzxsZy|i&o+i;o tZ~Tv}td$«i>ggi;suxJoi{py|©¬ry|© i&suqrhi;dgvw@i tTququdi;xz+yZi;o u«yZ©¬xsutxzy|oHo¸hq;hgqrª9tTdgyquisrqrxzd³2sui;®i;rxzceZyZi&dgo o~i>|r«iaiPi>vw9xquy|y|xvs}oHyZquhjy ©Jgt|qrsrdgiPqr*i i>i&$³ d9ti>i;qrvrqrqrxt|dgi>oi hsui;tr9qrsuy|xÒo~³%rtio~x%ogZyZsusrtZhxzti;oHxFE&qei;Zji;xvo±qry|yZs}suei;y sv;qutTy qui;|%x|y|iao<tt±h v&gxzs}zqrvxuiv&vti;iaoHqrui&v&sut|i;zisryZi>o%«9qry|dgo~i rv&iegqrsudsrtTi;qoZqvy|9h y|xªgoHxq;og® i;,c-xzxzoHoqrti;zsrZi>gquqrxzd~o~x ©¬i>tTqucegsrdgi>iWe©¬yyZ©-zi;yTt|´v}xd%og rxzo~ogyZquzitqruxv&y|t|o~ziWt|susri;iWr~yZro~i;« iZ¿ ®Pcedgi;riqui&~t|srii&qutx i;$xzoqrd~iW©¬y|zyT´xogj~ts}tZsut|gd~;® {{ i;n og,yqui;i;ogqryd~qui;ivt*gsu9sry|i;oHxoHqqeuxv&ot|zqriZdg igiÁ~ogxzqrxy|o<yZhtxo$y|©qudgixzht||i m n n @? 2> {{ n xquxdgiqrdgogiWyZsrsuhi;rtyZxFE&o~i;«$i¸su©¬yZi;rst*yZo~uv&«iat|z©¬i y|sttjo~uv&t|tTzqi tj ZxzZi&o+yv&tqrxy|o n {{ xt*xeogyZqrd~srhitrv;Fx tE;tTiWquxztyZqo+´~dgt|xsuv}t|dhjquidgqrii;s;og y|suht&x E;i;+sri>«9y|o~ri¸xht³ xht\ {@i n, m n xqrdgixht|iWtTqtjuv&t|zi¸q;®
(51) !#"$%& ('*)#+',-%'.$ . %. O. . :H. +. (. S. T. . 0. . . ? > > (. >. (. L> . >(-$,. ?)> +. . (.
(52) >. )
(53) E G. R. 0. ,.
(54) e. v',X , (8 (& D }
(55) w $sz# }}& (# %'{(z $ 130. . HI!J (OhJ JD7!9 5N? 5
(56) <8?
(57) 9L<7%J`O M
(58) Oz93? <7%I-9 . J`9 @J`?N:< 3 MBJ`O 5
(59) 7 LJ J>OfOz93<=?. mpª9oiyZogsui>gti&s,sqrqrdgy ivZy|i;hju«gi;g~qrtTi³qux&dg®icesui;dgrxyZgo~su«ii{pri&i;vwtTquq,xzyZyZojogix,rªv;ty|qri d+tZ´gxiuvgsusuxzihj{p«xi;o~ztTi>quvwxzqyZoj9y|yx©2oHquogPy|quogd~{AqutTgqªgtgsuitsi³qusri>~vwvqui;qrg*suqri;y iqu;t|dgxzo~Zx i&ao ~t |sri>i&´evw{Æqurt¾y|i& s}i;qrvyXtqrxoy|u7ot¾|9qui<dg´µijiv&y|i&~hjx|ri*gi&o t+Tq}ttT´µqrgi>xy|ti>o!a¶y||qu©xzi&hjs}qrrd~i|xzqiyZ®Êo<dmpyo!i;©urqrquxd~dgt|i<i*oMÁ~v&hsrs}xztTqrq$qui;srsrrxzx³7i;tvqry|Zxo²xzy|Zo i&o7e&x S9´xi;oi7sri; oZqu9q~®8hjA¬xi;y gi&fg¸Csuy|y´9©dgi&|sri;i;qrsrxui i;r±i&´µ&iy® ©Wy|cgqrogdgy|is qui;«qqrd~tq t|o~ t|sri¸ogi;ZtTquxzZi|® (. . 1G. . . 5
(60) M 7%<7!9 5@? 5
(61) 7 BJ I-J`O j5@?BOfJ<7 5@?BJ O < 3 J 7 ge *c n>. »· ¹WÅ Á~su«¨ q v}>½dgÆyZ® xv&~i*y|sa©¬y|t+s yZxzoHv&q to²9ª9qri$d~i t<suk i;¨ ryZi³ o~quri&io~xr¸xzyZro²iqyqu©ey±qrqudgdgi i hj¨ xogsuxi;h r9gy|h)o~ry|i©Pgqrsudgy|ij9tyZª~ri;ry|ªHqu²i¹aTty|gzi;i sy|i©q qrt|dgAi ® xy|oH©,qrqui;dgo~x« xzqv} dg y|xÁ~vs}ijq*xWy|qrs}y%i&i&s o«gi&susui*xzTqrtd~qrtx|q i$tv&y|dghjxzZgd²srqui>i;« 9y|to~q ri*sri>yZ«xzgoHzququ Wixo Hgtxdgxxzq}Ztd²oHq gsr©¬yZsuª~y|htª~xznxÒ®°qM»yo ©µª9t|i&gx¾ogt|7oHquttqZti quZcey±i;d~u~x«i;riv& xzs}xovv©¬i&iy|oHsuAquhi&s>tTn Hqr«ª~x Ãy|o%qe ©¬qrsudgy|xxh ev&hji&qroHdgi;qri i;xÁ~srti>s}og qai;tugqPµi&qrsrsudgi>xz«Ti9tTv&y|qugxzo~Zsursri i¸i;tToZxqaµqPqr9i&y |y|yji;xoHsr«$q i;no~rZyZxÒd~xzquoHxzt|ZqPiy|tWqu©ys}t±t|ogvyZxx~xsurv&i|z Ãi® mÆqrqd~ « t|i;ojti&o~h ~xqaPhjxz©¬ojy|y|sugquiasadgo~ityZgqrxzgoHts}q}ogt&i ® gv}d~iyZÁ~rogi&i>o7Mt|ª v; vyZn²sut|xogo~jquqry±dgi*qrd~qi ´y%hjyi&x|i&i&\o ®aZcei;vwdgquxy|¸s}v y|o q}t|to~oHq x qu®dgi cexdgo ij|i;gsusury|i9yy|©Psrqrquxdgy|i o~t|v&y|zx o~q7«quvt|yZoZo~ q q}t oHqWÃt´srxi> t|ªi xyZoHqrqrsuxyhjx&~E;vi¸i>qrMdgixo sui;· ,r2 yZcPo~º<riW|t¼qe½\®jqrdg¯°iih´tT³xzx,hrti&ij uxzv&o tri|i;® vqrxy|o²kg® kg® k+dgyT´ qrdgxvyZo~«qutoHqv&t|oª9i±v}
(62) dgyH«i;o7qry ¯°igsuy|9yZriaquyj~«i¸qudgiW©¬y|zyT´xogjhji;xtogi>resui;ryZo~ri|¿ IO m n à A\ C n ED m qu´y|xz©yZxzqrquod dgqui t|xz¶|o~i;xÒ o+quxt|tT2qµxzqrhdg tiWZvi|x sugv&v&zy|i hjA gn qu«i;à % tT®P qeuce® qrdgd~ xi rsuxv;i;trqu9dgi y|i¸ o~®surtZicyjxxt|i&qro~dgriaxgsuhjsui;iWvwi;qut*txzyZo9o+y|yZt©JroxÒÁ~qu xzsuZ«iWq,yZsri>sum«9i;xy|,s,o~qrrdgi;iai¸srx©¬T|y|tTs}st|qr´x|xdgii&xzoHxqroq,i©¬ZyZ«i;qrsrsuvh~qry|tTvws{{ qut|go~su+i qry|dgo7i~s}t|tsu¶$xtª~ tZgv}xzsu¶ i;|vsuqry|xy|goo~® ~´iqut|¶|iqudgi yZg9yZrxÒquiy©Pqudgi uv&t|t|sgsuy g~vwq¸ªi&q´µi;i&o<qudgi ZsutZxzi;oHq i;tZEgmpDo qrgy* suqutZdgvwiquxv&9i|xrPy|v&x´sroZi&q}i+qrµi¸h t|©¬zy|yZsuogh qgvquyZdgtTh*iWquxz~yZvxo suqr¿v&i+zi qrdgA x*sri>« 9uy|o~´rdgii&su©¬yZi s* t°xrv&sr i& qri±xhxtµ|qriZd~®°iacexoHd qri&~Z;i&s´~i+tsr~qµriy|© xÒq n m n à ´xzqrd D 3k! A@h¼ C m y|ce©d~quidgTit||zgs}t|iy|x©~i&oHqudgqi||i>vws}t|quy|s>xi& oHt|qz|yT´i>vwxqrogyZ*st*tTqª9qrid~qriqri&syZªxzoHyZq go~n g±t|Ãsr± i> qu xzhxty|qrxªy|q}o t® xogi; ª qrsuxzx ogi;t|sPxzoHqri;sr9y|tTquxzyZo . . . . (. 6. *> . >. . I>. L. #. QD. HK.
(63) . L. H. A. L. . > . (. L. %. D. < *> . L. . *. . >. L. ?H. (. *. . . > . . . %. *. L. (. >. L.
(64). I= > H. (. < E GF < . L. .H. ;.
(65). L. . (. >. . D. <. A. S. L. . PRQ P5S.
(66) >k.
(67) !#"$%& ('*)#+',-%'.$ 1. 5
(68) M %7 <7!9 5@?
(69) 5 7 BJ M ;7!9.O < 3JI!J`O j5@?
Documents relatifs
In order to be able to develop an articulatory model following the approach described above, it is needed to obtain a 3D surface representation of the organs of the vocal and
Lower thermocouple estimation + _ Model Alarm signal Algorithm Casting speed Alarm signal of abnormal event Upper thermocouple measurement.. Lower
Réciproquement, les agents des services sont supposés sortir de leurs fonctionnements routiniers et entrer dans une relation citoyenne avec les usagers et
The present the- sis takes up the idea of a preexisting, idealized 3D model-based representation in form of CAD computer graphics models and explores approaches of how this
A new efficient and simple method was presented to solve the problem of de- lineating the centerline of 3D tubular shapes, for various types of input data approximating its
Training a binary classifier for symmetry detection in natural images requires a ground-truth dataset of human annotations of symmetry axes.. The main tech- nical hurdle has been
Our strategy is based on the relevance of the goat model, with a “naturally occurring Knock Out (KO)" at the CSN1S1 locus and on the use of global approaches (including
For example, we show that (2) is equivalent to an exact Arnoldi relation in a non-standard inner product, and we analyze the convergence of GMRES with variable precision arithmetic
