• Aucun résultat trouvé

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut"

Copied!
14
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

!#"$% & '()+*,- ./0)1 "%&

24365768:9<;>=?768@A=?768

BDCFE:GIHKJKLMCFNJPORQTSUOL#E:VWJKCFHDXWY[Z\C]N:Y]C

^_N`Z\aRCFHcbKZdJfegORQ6h4C]ZiY[CjbfJcC]H

^DN`ZkaC]HlbmZkJfeonPOGRprq`h4C]ZiY[CFbmJKCFH_h4sDt1uIn_v1q`^w

sTLgGRZkx>yzb]{eGRN`|}LgY]bF{xkC{GYI{V`~

€(‚lƒl„[…†jƒ

‡‰ˆ‹ŠŒFŽ‘j’“1”W•l•c’M–f•l—lj“F’˜‘™l•›šMˆfŠŒ]ˆUœžˆmŒ[ˆf˜‘j’M˜‘ŸŒ ¡•K¢#˜‘’“]–f•›š˜‘•l’£ˆU˜‘’g“j•l’•cˆf˜‘—

Œ]Ž‘“jF–f˜¤ˆfŠœg¥‰¦Ÿ§Um¨ŒF’šˆfŠ•M—KŠj˜‘—l•M]©Pª˜¤ˆmŒ]”Ž‘•gœžRˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘j’«–fF”ŒF”˜‘Žd˜¤ˆ¬¢­T˜‘Ž‘Ž

ŠŒ›®¡•#Œoª˜‘“j’˜‘¯—›ŒF’£ˆ•K°`•l—cˆF’ˆfŠ•#«W•c–ª©\F–fœ1ŒF’—l•F©Ÿ“F•l’•Kˆf˜d—Aª•›Œ]–f—mŠ²±‡¬’³ˆfŠ˜‘

«ŒF«W•c–›´‹Œ,µˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘µˆf˜‘—lµ¶‰”Œ]ª•›šŒjšŒ]«ˆf˜‘®¡• ’F’¶‰’˜‘©\F–fœ·œžRˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘j’¸¥‰¹R§UºU»P¼g¨ž˜‘

«R–f•lª•l’£ˆf•›š³­T˜‘ˆfŠ˜‘’$­TŠ˜‘—mŠ$ˆfŠ•g«R–fj”Œ]”˜‘Ž‘˜¤ˆ>¢ˆfŠŒ]ˆ1•lŒF—mŠ“j•l’•M­T˜‘ŽdŽ‹ª”I½µ•l—cˆ1ˆf

œˆmŒ[ˆf˜dF’˜‘6Ž‘•›Œ]–f’£ˆzŒFšŒ]«ˆf˜‘®¡•lŽ¤¢[®¡•c–¾ˆf˜‘œ•UŒ]’š[®¡•c–¾ˆfŠ•Žd£—c˜¿±¾§6ŒPª•›Œ]–f—mŠAŒFŽ¤¶

“FF–f˜¤ˆfŠœÀ”Œ]ª•›šF’Aœ•c—KŠŒF’˜‘ªœ¾ŒF”µˆª–mŒF—cˆf•›š©\–fFœ«Wj«ŽdŒ]ˆf˜‘F’A“F•l’•cˆf˜‘—ll´¦Ÿ§

˜‘œ«Žd˜‘—l˜¤ˆfŽ¤¢_œ1ŒF˜‘’£ˆmŒF˜‘’DˆfŠ•<µˆmŒ[ˆf˜‘µˆf˜d—c¾Œ]”WjRˆrˆfŠ•<ª•lŒ]–f—mŠª«Œ]—l•<ˆfŠ–fF“FŠDˆfŠ•6«Wj«R¶

ŽdŒ]ˆf˜‘j’:±¾¹§UºU»P¼%•cÁR«Ž‘˜‘—l˜¤ˆfŽ¤¢œ1ŒF ¡•c¾ª•U]©²ˆfŠ•UµˆmŒ[ˆf˜dµˆf˜‘—l<˜d’R©i]–fœ1Œ]ˆf˜‘j’F©`ˆfŠ•

Œ]Ž‘Žd•cŽd•1šR˜‘µˆª–f˜d”ˆf˜‘j’˜‘’•›Œ]—KŠÂ“j•l’•Ž‘£—lPˆf#ŒjšŒ]«ˆf˜‘®¡•lŽ¤¢ ŒFš]½µµˆPˆfŠ•œžˆmŒ[ˆf˜‘j’

«R–fj”ŒF”˜‘Ž‘˜¤ˆ>¢1]©?ˆfŠŒ[ˆzŽ‘£—ll±¾Ã?_ˆf•lµˆ6ˆfŠ•‹«W•c–ª©\F–fœ1Œ]’—l•UF©Ä¹R§UºU»P¼Â´£˜¤ˆz˜‘z—lFœ¶

«Œ]–f•›š1ˆfžˆª–mŒjšR˜¤ˆf˜dF’Œ]Ž?”˜¤ˆTœˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘F’#j«W•K–mŒ]ˆfF–­T˜¤ˆfŠMŒž’Iœž”W•c–z]©PÅ>µˆmŒ]’šŒ]–mšÆ

¯ÁR•›š#œžRˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘j’A«–fF”ŒF”˜‘Žd˜¤ˆf˜‘•lŸª“j“F•lµˆf•›šM”£¢#]ˆfŠ•c––f•lª•›Œ[–f—KŠ•c–f‹[®¡•K–‹Œž–mŒ]’“F•

]©Wˆ>¢R«˜‘—›Œ]ŽRˆf•cµˆ¾«R–fj”Žd•cœl±rÃ6Š•6–f•cªŽ¤ˆf<šR•lœj’µˆª–mŒ]ˆf•<ˆfŠŒ]ˆ<¹§º‹»Ÿ¼«W•c–ª©i]–fœ

«W•K–fª˜dµˆf•c’IˆfŽ¤¢D­6•lŽ‘Ž]®j•c–ĈfŠ•6–mŒF’“j•z]©Wˆf•lµˆ4«–fj”Ž‘•lœr­TŠ˜‘Ž‘•6ˆfŠ•z«W•c–ª©\F–fœ1ŒF’—l•zF©

ˆª–mŒFš˜¤ˆf˜‘j’ŒFŽ(œˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘F’Mj«W•c–mŒ[ˆfF–f‹­T˜¤ˆfŠM¯Á•lš#œžRˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘j’M«R–fj”ŒF”˜‘Ž‘˜¤ˆf˜‘•l‹“]–f•›Œ]ˆfŽ¤¢

šR•l«W•l’šŸF’ ˆfŠ•ž«–fF”Ž‘•lœÇ’šR•c–P—lF’ª˜dš•K–mŒ]ˆf˜‘j’:±1¹§º‹»Ÿ¼È–f•l«R–f•lª•l’£ˆfPŒ–f]¶

”µˆžŒjšŒF«ˆf˜‘®¡•œžRˆmŒ]ˆf˜‘j’!F«W•c–mŒ]ˆf]–ˆfŠŒ[ˆž’•l•›šRž’o«R–f˜d]– I’›­TŽ‘•›šR“j•MŒ]”WjRˆ

ˆfŠ•‹¯ˆf’•lªTŽdŒF’šRª—›ŒF«W•P]©rˆfŠ•Ÿ«R–fj”Žd•cœ%”W•l˜‘’“ªFŽd®j•›š:±

É ÊÄËMÌ<ÍzÎoϳÐ,ыÌzÒ[ÎAË

ӟÔ`CŸ|RCFN`C[JcZ\Y‹GIx\|ROHKZkJKÔ:LÈÕ¬Ö×Ø[qRGRb<ON`CU~Z\N:pAOIQ:|C]N`CFHcGIJKZ\ORNWÙµÚ:GRbKCFp1C]aROxkV`JKZ\ORN:GRHKeGIx\|RORÙ

HcZdJcÔ`L,qLgGIZ\NJcGRZkN:bGE?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORNgORQ(YFGIN:pWZip`GIJKC_bKORx\VWJKZ\ORN:b<JcOG|RZ\aRCFNAE:HKOÚ`xkCFL,qRÛPÔ`ZiYlÔ

GIHcC1CFa¡GRxkV²G£JKCjp³GRYFY[OHcpWZ\N`|gJcOÂGgE:HKOÚ`xkCFL#ÙµbKE²CjY[ZkܲYÜ:JKN`CjbKbDQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN³JcÔ:G£JpWC[ܲN`CFbDJKÔ`C

C]NaZ\HKON`LMC]NJQ¿ORHJKÔ:CgC]aROxkV`JKZ\ORNÄ{gÝ_CFÛÇE?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORN:bGRHKCgY]HKCjG£JKCjpÚebKC]x\CFY[JKZ\N`|,HKCFxdÙ

G£JcZkaC]x\e$Ü`JmJcC]HMLMC]LÚ?C]Hlb#OIQPJcÔ`CÂE:HKCjbmCFNJME?ORE`V`xiG£JcZkONGIN²p0C]aORx\aZkN`|³JKÔ`CFLÞJKÔ`HcORV`|Ô

HcCFY[OLÚ`Z\N:GIJKZ\ORNßGRN:p0LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNàORE?C]HlG£JcZkON:bÂáktjâ¡ã>{àӟÔ`C,E²CFHmQ¿OHKLgGIN²Y[C-OIQGäÖ×åpWC[Ù

E?C]N:p`bMONLgGINeQ‰GY›JKOHcbFqbKV:YlÔßGb1JcÔ`C,C]N:Y]OWpWZkN:|$bcYlÔ`C]LMCqzJKÔ`C!bKC]x\CFY[JKZ\ORNLMC]JKÔ`OWprq

JKÔ:CE²OE`V`xiG£JKZ\ORN,bKZkæFCRqJKÔ:CY]HKObKbKO£aRCFHUGRN:p LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNÂORE?C]HlG£JKOHcbF{6ӟÔ`Z\bŸLgGR~RCFb‹ZkJDpWZkç#Ù

Y[V:xdJjqZkQrN`OIJZ\LME²ObKbKZ\Ú`xkCqIJcOYlÔ`OObKCŸORE?C]HlG£JKOHcbzGRN:p#HKCFxkCFa£GINJTE:GIHlGILMC]JKC]Hlb<Q¿ORHOREWJcZkLgGIx

E?C]HKQ¿ORHcLMGRN:Y[C{6èªNÂJcÔ`ZibPE:GIE?C]HPۋCžQ¿OWY[V:bPON JcÔ`CLV`JcG£JcZkON,ORE?C]HlG£JKOHF{

v_OxkxiGIN²páktjéjãrZ\NJcHKOWpWV²Y[CFpoJKÔ`CLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN OE²CFHcGIJKOHUGRbŸGêmÚ:GYl~|HKOV`N:pMOE²CFHcGIJKORHlë

JKÔ²G£JUYlÔ:GRN`|RCjbzÚ`ZkJcbOIQ(ZkN:p`ZkaZipWV:GIxibTON`x\eOWY]YFGRbKZkON:GIx\xkeqIÛPZkJKÔoGHlG£JcÔ`C]HTbKLgGIx\x:LV`JcG£JcZkON

E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfe,ì²íïîðáñ`ò]t]ã‹E?C]H#Ú`ZkJF{äó!VWJlG£JcZkON0Z\b#V:bKCFpäJKOCFN:bKV`HKC JKÔ:GIJMGRxkx‹E?ObcbmZ\Ú`x\C

GIx\x\C]x\CFb6Y]GRNACFNJcC]H<JKÔ:C‹E?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORNMGIN:pE`HcO£aZipWC‹a£GIHcZ\GIJKZ\ORN1Z\N#GÖ×àE?ORE`V`xiG£JcZkONÄ{6ӟÔ`Z\b

(2)

HcC]E`HcCFbKC]NJlG£JKZ\ORN4qjLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN#ORNMGDE²GIHcC]NJ¾JcOE`HKOWpWV²Y[CŸGžYlÔ:ZkxipZibzpWON`CUÚe²ZkE`E:ZkN`|CjGRYlÔ

Ú`ZkJHlGIN²pWORLMx\e-GY]Y[OHcp`ZkN`|oJKOÂGoLVWJlG£JKZ\ORNE`HKOÚ:GIÚ:Zkx\ZdJfe{ŸGRbKCFp!ON³v_OxkxiGIN:p bžbmZ\LME`x\C

Öׁq`JKÔ:C]HcCÔ:GRbPÚ?C]CFN!LV:YlÔ!ۋORHc~(qWÚ²ORJKÔ!E`HlGRY[JKZiY]GRxkx\eáâIñ¡ã6GIN:pÂJcÔ`C]OHKC]JKZiY]GIx\x\eáâ¡ã4ON

JcÔ`C1HcC]xiG£JKZ\aRCLMCFHKZkJcbDOIQzLVWJlG£JcZkON,GbDGgbKCFGRHcYlÔ,LMCFYlÔ:GRN`ZibmL,{Ÿó!V:YlÔ!OIQ6JcÔ`C1ۋORHc~ Ô:Gb

Ú?C]CFN,Y]ORN:Y]C]HcN`CFp ÛPZdJcÔ-Ü:N:pWZ\N`|g|Rx\ORÚ²GIx\xkeäêKOREWJcZkLgGIxiëALVWJlG£JKZ\ORN,E`HcORÚ²GIÚ`Z\xkZkJfeMQ¿ORHDÖ×b]{

SUOL#LMON$bKC[JKJKZ\N`|bORQ‹bmJcG£JcZ\YMLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN$E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfe!HKCjY[ORLMLMC]N²pWCFpÚe³HKCjbmCjGIHlYlÔ`C]Hlb

GRHKCžGRbUQ¿ORx\xkO£Û_bFy?ì í ññRñ:t_ÚeoBDCORN`|-áu¡ã>q£ì í ññ:tÚe ֞HcC[Q¿C]N²bfJcC[JmJcC#áktRt]ã>qWGRN:p

ì í îàáñññé`òKññRñ:t[ãrÚe,X`YlÔ:G(C]H4áâRñ¡ãµ{ŸGRbKCFp,ON,JKÔ`CAHKCjbmV`xkJDORQUXWYlÔ:G(C]H

áâIñ¡ãµqGYl~á¡ã¾E`HcORE?ObKCFp,GRN!CWE`HcCFbcbmZ\ORN-OIQrì í t ‘uIé"!WÕ$#&%('()+*-,j؟ÛPÔ`C]HcC.#ÞZibPJKÔ:C

E?ORE`V:x\GIJKZ\ORN,bmZ\æ]CGIN²p/'pWCFN`OIJcCFb‹JcÔ`C1bfJcHKZ\N`|Mx\C]N`|RJKÔÄ{Tó0V:Ô`xkCFNÚ²CFZkNäákt21¡ã¾p`C]HcZkaCFp JKÔ:GIJ

ì?í

t3!' bKÔ`ORV:x\pÚ²CM|RCFN`C]HlGIx\x\e54ORE`JKZ\LMGRx$\qÄÛPÔ`ZiYlÔ۟GRbQ¿V`HKJKÔ:C]HaRCFHKZkÜ:CFpÚeXLMZdJcÔ

GRN:p6:OR|GIHKJfe³áââjã>{UӟÔ`CFbKCbmC]JmJKZ\N`|bŸÛUCFHKCORÚ`JcGIZ\N`Cjp Úe CWE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJcGRxrZkNaRCjbfJcZk|G£JcZkON:b

GRN:pÂGRHKCY]ORN:bKZ\bmJKCFNJŸÛPZkJKÔ³vDORx\x\GRN:p7bŸE`HcORE?ObcGIx(OIQ6V:bKZkN`|MLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN!GRbPG#Ú:GYl~|HKOV`N:p

OE²CFHcGIJKORHj{ v_O£Û‹C]aC]Hjq‹JKÔ`CFHKCZ\b-GIN Z\N:Y]HKCjGRbKZkN`|äÚ?OWpWeOIQ1Ú?OIJcÔ C]LME`Z\HcZ\YFGIxAáktFñ£ãGRN:p

JcÔ`C]OHKC]JKZiY]GIx<áIã?CFaZ\pWCFN:Y[CžbmÔ:O£ÛPZkN`|1JKÔ:GIJUJcÔ`CDOEWJKZ\LgGIx?LVWJlG£JKZ\ORNÂE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfeAÛPZ\xkx?N`ORJ

ON`xkepWCFE²CFN:päORNJcÔ`CoE`HcORÚ:xkCFL Ú?C]Z\N`|bKORx\aRCjp$Ú`VWJ#GRx\bKO!a£GIHceÛPZkJKÔ0JKÔ`CoE:HKO|RHcCFbcbOIQ

CFaRORx\VWJcZkON:GIHcegbmCjGIHlYlÔ`ZkN:|:{

èªNJKÔ:Z\b4E:GIE?C]HjqjGPbmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFbfÙµÚ:GbmCjpžGp`GIE`JKZ\aRC6N`ORN`Ù>V`N:ZdQ¿OHKLLVWJlG£JcZkONMÕ>XW×DÝ^DóØÄZ\b

E`HcORE?ObKCFpQ¿ORHTÖ×DbF{<×b6GbKCFGRHcYlԁGRxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`LÚ:GRbKCFpORNAL#CjYlÔ:GIN:Z\bKLgb¾GRÚ:bfJcHcGY›JcCFpQ¿HcORL

E?ORE`V:x\GIJKZ\ORN|C]N`C]JKZiY]bFqUÖ×DbMZ\LME`x\Z\Y]ZdJcxke0LgGRZkNJcGRZkNJKÔ`C!bmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFb#GRÚ²OVWJMJKÔ`C!bKCFGRHcYlÔ

bKE:GRY]CJKÔ:HKOV`|RÔ!JcÔ`CE?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORNÄ{Ö×DbžV:bKC1JcÔ`CAbKC]x\CFY[JKZ\ORNÄqrY[HcObcbKO£aRC]HPGRN:p!LV`JcG£JcZkON

OE²CFHcGIJKZ\ORN:bžJcO!CJKHlGRY[JžJcÔ`CoZ\LME`xkZiY[ZkJAbmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFbQ¿HKOL·JcÔ`CoE?ORE`V`xiG£JcZkON$JKO!HcCFGRYlÔJKÔ:C

N`CJÂbmC]JoOIQE?ORZ\NJlbgZ\NJKÔ`CbKCFGRHcYlÔbKE:GRY]CR{ÀӟÔ:Z\bgZ\LME`x\Z\Y]ZdJ,bfJlG£JKZibmJKZiY]boYFGINÚ²CV:bmCjp

CE:xkZiY[ZkJKx\e,JKO-C]N`Ô²GIN:Y]CMÖ×8bžE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLMGRN:Y[C{1XW×DÝ^Dó CWE`x\Z\Y]ZdJcxke!LgGR~RCFbV:bKCAORQTJKÔ:C

bmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFb Z\NWQ¿ORHcLgG£JcZkON OIQJcÔ`C$p`Z\bmJKHcZkÚ:VWJKZ\ORN ORQAGIx\x\C]x\CFboZ\NÀG|RCFN`Cx\OWY[V:bÂO£aRCFHoJKÔ:C

E?ORE`V:x\GIJKZ\ORN$JKOGp39fV:bmJ1JKÔ:CoLVWJlG£JcZkONäE`HKOÚ:GIÚ:Zkx\ZdJfe³Q¿ORH1JcÔ:G£JAxkOWY[V²b1GRp`GREWJKZ\aRCFxkeÛPZdJcÔ

JcÔ`CE`HcOR|RHcCFbcbUOIQ<JKÔ`CÖׁ{

èªNJKÔ:C³HKCjbfJgORQžJcÔ`ZibgE:GIE?C]HjqŸÛUC,ܲHcbmJoÚ`HcZkC:eHcC]aZ\C]Û HKCFxkCFa¡GRNJMۋORHc~(qUN:CJ pWC[Ù

bcY[HcZkÚ?C_XW×DÝ^DóåZ\NgpWC[JlGIZ\x¬qGIN:pAJKÔ:C]NME`HcCFbKC]NJTORV`HzCWE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJbfJcV:pWeJKÔ:GIJY[ORLME:GRHKCjb

XW×ÝD^óÞO£aRC]H‹JcHcGpWZdJcZkON:GIxrÚ:ZdJ_LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN,Ú:GRbKCFpÂORN,G#JfeE`ZiY]GIxÄbKC[J_ORQ¾JcCFbmJ_E`HcORÚ`x\C]LgbFq

Ü:N²GIx\xkeÂ|RZ\aRCORVWJ_OV`H_Y[ON:Y[x\V:bKZkON:bPGRbŸÛ‹C]x\x4GbPpWZ\bcY[V²bKbKZkON:bŸORN,E?OIJcC]NJKZiGIxrQ¿V`JKV`HcC1ۋORHc~

HcC]x\C]a£GINJŸJKOoXW×ÝD^óä{

: ;·Ï=<.>ÂÌ6ÒFË@? ÌBA@CED ÐÂÌB<žÌ6Ò]ÎAË Ò]ËGFH;JI

ӟÔ`CÂGRp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORNäOIQP|C]N`C]JKZiYgORE?C]HlG£JcORHlb1GIN:pHcC]x\C]a£GRNJAE:GIHlGILMC[JcC]Hlb۟GRbÜ:HlbmJZkNJcHKORÙ

pWV²Y[CFp³ZkNJKOÂsTaROxkV`JKZ\ORN:GRHKeÂXJKHlG£JKCF|RZ\CFbAՉsUX`bc؟ÛPÔ:C]HcC1JKÔ:CLV`JcG£JcZkON³bfJcC]EbKZ\æ]C1ZibbKV:Y[Ù

Y]CFbcbfQ¿V`x\x\eY[ONJcHKOxkx\CFp³ÚebmCFxdQÙªGRp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORNÄqrC{|²{kq¾bmCFCgX`YlÔۋC[Q¿CFxPáâ`t›ã>{#èªNHKCjY[CFNJeRCjGIHlb

ÛPZkJKÔ-JKÔ:CZkNJKCFHcGY›JcZkONÂÚ?C[JfۋC]CFNÂJcÔ`CÖ×%GIN²p JcÔ`C1sUXÂY[OLMLV`N`ZkJKZ\CFbFqWJcÔ`C]HcCÔ:GRbŸÚ?C]CFN

GRNäZkN:Y]HKCjGRbKZkN:|!ZkNJKCFHKCjbfJ1Z\NäJcÔ`C V:bKCoORQPGp`GIE`JKZ\aRCoOE²CFHcGIJKORHlbÛPZkJKÔ`Z\NäJKÔ:CÂÖ× JcO³C]NWÙ

Ô:GRN:Y[C‹Ö×.bÄE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLMGRN:Y[C_á1£ãµ{KŸGbmCjpONÔ`O£ÛJKÔ`C‹bfJcHcGIJKC]|eDE:GRHcGRLMC[JKCFHcbrGRHKCTYlÔ²GIN`|CFp

Gp`GIEWJlG£JcZkON-Z\NÖ×DbY]GRN-Ú?CY]x\GbKbKZdܲCFp-ZkNJcOgJKÔ`HcC]C1YFG£JcC]|ROHKZ\CFbFyL MNPORQTSQVUPWQYXROZXZ[]\

SQVUPOåÛPÔ`C]HcC JcÔ`C-a¡GRxkV:CÂORQDGbmJKHlG£JcC]|Re$E:GRHcGRL#C]JKCFHAZibMGIxkJKC]HcCFpGRY]Y]ORHlpWZ\N`|!JKObKORLMC

(3)

C]|eE²GIHlGILMC[JcC]HjqFGIN²pRUZ\+_L -`a$QTbOZXZ[SQVUPOßÛPÔ`CFHKCTJKÔ`CUE:GIHlGILMC[JcC]H(JcO_Ú²C‹GRp`GREWJKCjp

ZibzC]N:Y]OWpWCFp#Z\NJcOJKÔ`CYlÔ`HKOLMObKORLMCFb<GIN:p#V`N²pWC]Hc|ROCFb6|C]N`C]JKZiYŸORE?C]HlG£JcZkON:bŸÕ¿Ô`CFN:Y[CqGRx\bKO

Y]GRxkx\CFp X\+b WQS؛{

ӟÔ`CFHKCTÔ²GRbrÚ?C]CFN1LV:YlÔۋORHc~DON1GRp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORNZ\N1LVWJlG£JcZkONQ¿ORH¾Ö×bUá£ãµ{6֞CFN`C]HlGIx\xke

bKE²CjGI~ZkN:|:q²Gp`GIE`JcG£JcZkON!ZkN!LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN!Ô:GRE`E?C]N:bžG£J_JfۋOgx\C]aRCFx\bF{_׋J_JcÔ`C1JcORE!x\C]aRCFx¬q:JKÔ`C

HlG£JKZ\OÚ²C]JfÛUCFC]NgLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNgGIN:pMY]HKObKbKO£aRCFH4ZibGRp:GIEWJcCFp#pWV`HcZkN`|JcÔ`C_HcV`NMOIQrG1Ö×1{RBžG¡aZ\b

á£ãE`HcORE?ObKCFpJKÔ²G£J1JcÔ`C Ö×ÈY]GRNäbmCFxkCjY›JQ¿HcORL G!bKC[J1ORQ‹OE²CFHcGIJKOHcbJKO!E?C]HKQ¿ORHcL ONäG

YlÔ`ObmCFN E:GRHKCFNJjqWCFGYlÔ ÛPZkJKÔ!GAÜWCFpÂE`HKOÚ:GIÚ:Zkx\ZdJfe{ V`xibfJcHKOL ákt ¡ã4Gp`GIEWJcZkaC]x\eoGRp`GREWJKCjp

JKÔ:CAHlG£JcZkOÂÚ²C]JfÛUCFC]N³LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNGRN:pY]HKObKbKO£aRCFHPÚ:GRbKCFp!ON!JKÔ:C]Z\HE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLgGIN:Y]CR{1SUORHcN`C

éjã(pWC]aZibmCjpJcÔ`CžSžbmJ ŸGRbKCFpAORE?C]HlG£JKOHTn_G£JcC_×Dp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORN!Õ>S Ÿn_מØ6LMC[JcÔ`OWp

ÛPÔ`CFHKCzJcÔ`C‹Ö×E²CFHKZ\OWpWZiY]GIx\x\ežbKۋGRE:bÄ|ZkaC]NÜWCjpE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJKZ\CFbÄÚ?C[JfۋC]CFNORE?C]HlG£JcORHlb

ÚeÂ|ZkaZ\N`|MJKÔ:C1Ô`Z\|RÔ`CjbfJDE:HKOÚ:GIÚ`Z\x\ZdJfegJcOgJKÔ:C1ORE?C]HlG£JcORHŸJKÔ²G£JÔ²GRbPÚ?C]CFN!E`HKOWpWV²Y[Z\N`|MJKÔ`C

LMObmJ-|GIZ\N:bÂZkN Ü`JKN`CjbKbF{ÈÓ¾V:bmONÀGRN:p nPObKb$áâ£ãCJcC]N:pWCjp¸JcÔ`CäS Ÿn_× LMC[JcÔ`OWp

ÚeäY[OIÙµC]aORx\aZkN`|-JcÔ`CÂLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN0GRN:p0Y[HcObcbKO£aRC]HE`HcORÚ²GIÚ`Z\xkZkJKZ\CFbÂÕ¿ON`C[ÙµN`ORHcLgGIx\ZkæFCFpHcCFGRx

NV`LÚ?C]Hlbl؋ÛPZdJcÔ-CjGRYlÔ-ZkN²pWZkaZipWV:GRx¬{

׋JŸJKÔ`CÚ?OIJKJKOLÈxkCFaRCFx¬qJcÔ`CE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfegOIQ¾LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN-Z\bPGp`GIE`JKCFp-pWV`HcZ\N`|JcÔ`CHcV`N

OIQPG³Ö×1q4V`N`ZkQ¿ORHcL#x\eOHN`ORN`Ù>V`N:ZdQ¿OHKLMx\e³O£aRCFHJcÔ`Cgx\OY]Z¬{6 GYl~á£ãE`HcORE?ObKCFpG!bmCFxdQÙ

GRp:GIEWJlG£JKZ\ORNäbcYlÔ`C]LMCoÚe$GRp`pWZ\N`|³G!E:HKOÚ:GIÚ`Z\x\ZdJfeaRCFY[JKOHì ì )

ò22[ò‰ìÕZibJKÔ`C

NV`LÚ?C]H OIQORÚ 9fCjY›Jga£GIHcZ\GRÚ`xkCjbc؁Q¿OHgCFGRYlÔàZ\N:pWZ\aZipWV:GRx¬{ÀӟÔ`C!LVWJlG£JcZkONbcYlÔ`CFL#C-Ü:HlbmJ

LV`JcG£JcCFbDJKÔ`C#LV`JcG£JcZkON³E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfeAìTÛPZkJKÔÂìTZkJcbKC]xkQUGRN:p,JKÔ:C]N³V:bKCFbDJKÔ:CHcCFbKV`xdJcZkN:|

ì¾JcOLV`JcG£JcCDJcÔ`C>JKÔ OÚ 9fCFY[JUa£GIHcZiGIÚ`x\CR{zv_CjbKbKC]HŸGIN²poó GIN:N`C]Hádt IãÄpWCFHKZ\aRCjpoG1|C]N`CFHcGRx

CWE`HcCFbcbKZkONoJKÔ²G£JDpWC]JKC]HcLMZkN:Z\bmJKZiY]GRxkx\e a£GIHcZ\CFbUJKÔ`CLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN,E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfegÛPZdJcÔ-JKZ\L#CÚe

ì í ÕmØ

ÕB! ¾Ø ) *-,"!$#&% ì¾Õ('*)+!IâØ !`ÕY# ! ' )+*-, Ø

ÛPÔ`CFHKC,q- Tq.)0GIHcCMY[ORN²bfJlGINJcbFq # ZibžJKÔ`CME?ORE`V:x\GIJKZ\ORNbKZ\æ]CRqK' ZibžJKÔ`CgbmJKHcZkN:|Âx\C]N`|RJKÔÄq

GIN²p/4Zib¾JKÔ`CUJKZ\LMCÕ¿|RCFN`C]HlG£JcZkONY[OV`NJKCFHlØ[{K`O|GRHmJfeMádtjñ£ãWV:bKCFpAGpWC]JKCFHKLMZ\N`Z\bmJKZiY‹bKYlÔ`CFLMC

JKÔ²G£Jžp`CFY[HcCFGbmCjbTì?í O£aRCFH_JcZkLMCCWE²ON`C]NJKZiGIx\x\eRq(bmV:YlÔ,JcÔ:G£J"021$34/576¾í#ÕmØ

ñ`{:OR|RÙ

GIHKJfe0áktFñ¡ãGRx\bKOÂV²bmCjpG,bcYlÔ`C]LMCAJKÔ:GIJpWCFY]HKCjGRbKCFbDJKÔ`CMLV`JcG£JcZkONE:HKOÚ:GIÚ`Z\x\ZdJfe!O£aC]HžÚ`ZdJ

HcC]E`HcCFbKC]NJcGIJKZ\ORN#GIN:p|RZ\aRCFb<Ú`ZkJcbTOIQ?p`Z(C]HcC]NJTbmZ\|RN:ZdܲYFGIN:Y]C‹p`Z(C]HcC]NJTbKYlÔ:CFpWV`x\CFbF{4èªNAJKÔ:Z\b

E:GRE²CFHŸGN`C]Û L#CjYlÔ:GIN:Z\bKL Z\bUE`HcORE?ObKCFpMJcÔ:G£JPGRp`GREWJcbJKÔ:CLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN E:HKOÚ:GIÚ`Z\x\ZdJfeMO£aRCFH

JKÔ:Cx\OWY[Z?Ú`VWJŸN`C]Cjp`b‹N`O~N`O£ÛPx\CFpW|C_Z\NÂGRp`a¡GRN:Y[CGIÚ?ORVWJ‹JKÔ`CÚ`ZkJ‹HcC]E`HcCFbKC]NJlG£JKZ\ORNgORQrJKÔ`C

E`HcORÚ`x\C]L,q`bKV:YlÔ!GRb‹JcÔ`C1bmZ\|RN:ZdܲYFGIN:Y]CORQ6G#Ú`ZkJ_E?ObKZdJcZkON,Gb‹ZkN=`O|GRHmJfeab‹bcYlÔ`CFL#CgáktFñ¡ãµ{

8 9gÌB<žÌ6ÒIÄÌzÒ[Ñ I;:<@<IKC_Ï ;·Ï=<.>ÂÌzÒ>= C@? ÎAËA:BÞË!ÒDCIÎAÍFE

D ÐÂÌ <žÌzÒ[Î#Ë

`OHžJKÔ`CMY[ONaC]N`Z\C]N²Y[CORQUpWCjbKY]HKZ\EWJKZ\ORNGIN:pGIN:GRxkeWbKZ\bFq(ÛUCAZkNJKHcOWpWV:Y]CJcÔ`C#Y]ORN:Y]C]EWJlbžOIQ

Z\NJcHKZ\N:bKZ\YG£JmJcHKZ\Ú`VWJcCGIN²p,CJKHcZkN²bmZiYžJKCFN:pWC]N²Y[e-OIQTGIx\xkCFxkCa¡GRxkV:ZkN`|MQ¿OHGM|C]N`C1x\OWY[V:bF{ŸèªN

JKÔ:CUÚ`Z\N:GRHKeÙµC]N:Y]Op`CFpORE`JKZ\LMGRxbKORx\VWJcZkON4ՉblØrORQ:G_|RZ\aRCFNE`HcORÚ`x\C]L,qIGP|C]N`CUxkOWY[V²b4Zib¾YFGIx\xkCjp

G \MQTS$NPQTSUPQYXZkQ4ZkJcbŸGIx\x\C]x\C_Z\bžtq+H\MQTSWNPQTSUPQYXUZdQ4ZkJcb‹GIx\x\C]x\CDZibUñ:qOHSaD WN RZdQ4ZkJcb‹GIx\x\C]x\CY]GRN

Ú?C1C]ZkJKÔ`CFH_ñMORHt{JI¸Ô`C[JcÔ`C]HDG#x\OWY[V:bPZibt[ÙµZ\NJcHKZ\N:bKZ\YRq`ñ£ÙµZkNJcHKZ\N:bKZ\YRqWORHPN`CFVWJKHlGIxÄpWCFE²CFN:p`b

ORN#JcÔ`CPE`HcORÚ`x\C]L V:N:pWC]HTY]ORN:bKZipWC]HlG£JcZkONAGIN²pCFN:Y[OWpWZ\N`|1bcYlÔ`C]LMCRqRCR{|:{\qIÛPÔ`C[JcÔ`C]HZkNJKHcORN²b

GIHcCžZkN:bKC]HKJKCjpákt¡uFãµ{zBDV:HKZ\N`|#JKÔ`CžHcV`N`N`Z\N`|#OIQ<GMÖ×1qWGA|RCFN`Cx\OWY[V:b‹ZibŸY]GIx\x\CFp

G

\MQTS XQTS ZL

(4)

pWCjY[HcCFGbmCPÕJcO_JcÔ`CTx\ZkLMZkJ¾OIQ`ñ:{ñ؛qjORH S+S\MQTSaXQTS ZLzZkQWJKÔ`CFHKCZ\b4N`OŸJKCFN:pWC]N²Y[eOIQWZ\N:Y[HcCFGbmZ\N`|

OH4pWCFY]HKCjGRbKZkN:|:{;I¸Ô`C]JKÔ`CFH<G_xkOWY[V²bÄZibt]Ù>Z\N:Y[x\Z\N`CFprq£ñIÙ>Z\N:Y[x\Z\N`CFprq¡OHÄN`ORN`Ù>Z\N:Y[x\Z\N`CFp1p`C]E?C]N:p`b

ONJcÔ`CgE`HcORÚ`x\C]L V`N:pWCFHY[ON:bKZ\pWCFHcGIJKZ\ORNÄq4C]N:Y]Op`ZkN`|³bcYlÔ`CFL#Cq4|C]N`C]JKZiYMORE?C]HlG£JKOHcbGRN:p

Z\N`ZkJKZiGIx4Y]ORN:pWZkJKZ\ORN²b]{

^DbKV:GRxkx\eäÛPZdJcÔ0JcÔ`C,E`HKO|RHcCFbcbOIQDJKÔ`C³Ö×1q<JcÔ`ObKCÂ|C]N`CÂxkOWY]ZUJcÔ:G£JgGIHcCt]Ù>Z\NJKHcZkN²bmZiY

ՉORHñ£ÙµZkNJKHcZ\N:bmZiYFØDÛPZ\xkxzGIE:E²CjGIHžJKO-Ú²C,t]Ù>Z\N:Y[x\Z\N`CFpßÕ¿ORHñ£ÙµZ\N:Y[x\ZkN:CFp:Ø[qÄZ¬{CR{\q(JKÔ:CAQ¿HcC KV`CFN:Y[e

ORQDtFbZkNJKÔ`CMGIx\x\C]x\CFbžOIQzJcÔ`CFbKCAx\OWY[Z6ÛPZ\xkx6C]aC]NJKV²GIx\xke!Y[ONaRC]Hc|RC1JKO$tÂÕ¿OHžñ؛{XW×ÝD^ó

LgGI~CFbV:bKCAORQTJKÔ`ZibY[ONaRC]Hc|RCFN:Y[CZkNWQ¿OHKLgGIJKZ\ORNGbDQ¿CFCFpWÚ²GRYl~!Z\NWQ¿ORHcLgG£JKZ\ORN³JKO!Y[ONJcHKOx

JcÔ`CLVWJlG£JcZkONÂÚeÂGp39fV:bmJKZ\N`|#JKÔ`CLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN-E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfegQ¿ORHPCjGRYlÔ-xkOWY[V²b]{

I$C!V:bmC,JcÔ`C,Q¿HcC KV`C]N²Y[e0ORQ#tjbMZkNàJKÔ:C³GIx\xkCFxkCjbMZkN¸G$xkOWY]V:bMO£aRCFHAJcÔ`C!E?ORE`V`xiG£JcZkON

ՉC KV`Z\a¡GRxkCFNJKx\eßۋCYFGIN¸V:bKC!JKÔ:C³Q¿HcC KV`C]N²Y[eàOIQñRbÂGRboJKÔ`C$GIHc|RV`LMC]NJ›ØAJKOßYFGIxiY[V`xiG£JcC

Y]ORHcHKCjbmE?ORN:p`ZkN`|LVWJlG£JcZkONßE`HcORÚ²GIÚ`Z\xkZkJfeäOIQJKÔ:GIJoxkOWY]V:b]{ӟÔ`C,Q¿HcC KV`CFN:Y[eäORQ#tjbAZ\N¸G

x\OWY[V:b2b‹GIx\x\C]x\CFbŸY]GRN Ú?Cx\OOR~RCjpoGRbUJcÔ`Cžp`C]|RHcC]COIQ¾Y]ORNaRCFHK|C]N:Y]CPJKO$ê]tjëQ¿ORH‹JcÔ:G£JŸxkOWY]V:b]{

h4C[J

)

ÕlòmØoÕ tò2[ò-'UØpWCFN`OIJcCgJKÔ:CgQ¿HKC&KV`C]N:Y]eORQtFb1Z\NJKÔ:CÂGIx\x\C]x\CFbZ\N0x\OY]V:b/

O£aC]HÄJcÔ`CŸE²OE`V`xiG£JcZkONAG£J<JKZ\LMCÕ¿|RCFN`C]HlG£JcZkON²Ø 4GIN:pDì²í#Õlò mØ‹Õ tò2[ò-'UØ<pWC]N:OIJKCUJKÔ:C

LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN,E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfeoOIQ<xkOWY[V²bUGIJPJKZ\L#C"›{UӟÔ`C]NÄq²GRb_bKÔ`O£ÛPN-ZkN=<Zk|V`HcCgtRq£ì²í#Õlò

YFGIN-Ú²C1YFGIxiY[V`xiG£JcCFp Q¿HKOL

)

Õlò m؟GRb‹Q¿Oxkx\O£Û_bFy

ì²í#Õlò 6¾í'äâ%

)

Õcò 'ñ¤é %žÕ6<í"' 6¾í Õft¡Ø

ÛPÔ`CFHKC

%

4pWC]N`ORJKCjbžJKÔ`C GRÚ:bKORx\VWJKCMa£GIx\V`CgOIQ

% q 6 í GRN:p 6 í GIHcCAJcÔ`CgLgGWZ\LV`L

GRN:pLMZ\N`Z\LV`L GIx\xkO£ÛŸGIÚ`x\C-LVWJlG£JKZ\ORNàE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJKZ\CFbAQ¿ORHoG$x\OWY[V:bMHcCFbKE²CjY›JcZkaC]x\eRq‹CR{|:{\q

6 í8 t!'àGIN:p$6 í tjñI{

1.0 0.5 1−Inclined

0−Inclined 0.0

P

Mutation Probability

P

Frequency of 1’s in the Alleles in a Locus min

max

<Z\|RV`HcCty<Ó¾HKZiGIN:|RV`xiGIHQ¿V`N:Y›JcZkON V:bKCFpoQ¿ORHŸY]GRx\Y]V`x\GIJKZ\N`|1JcÔ`CžLVWJlG£JKZ\ORN E`HKOÚ:GIÚ:Zkx\ZdJfe#Q¿OH

G#|RCFN`CxkOWY]V:b]{

Ý_O£Û pWV`HcZkN`|JKÔ:C-CFaROxkVWJcZkONORQDJKÔ:C!ÖׁqTG£QJcC]HgGN:C]Û E?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORN Ô:GbAÚ?C]CFN

|C]N`CFHcGIJKCFpÄqWÛUCÜ:HlbmJDY]GIxiY[V:x\GIJKCJKÔ:CpWZibfJcHKZ\Ú`VWJcZkON-ORQ‹tjb

)

Õlò m؋Q¿OHPCFGYlÔ-x\OWY[V:b O£aRCFH

JcÔ`CE²OE`V`xiG£JKZ\ORN,GIN²poQ¿HcORL JcÔ`ZibŸORÚWJlGIZ\N JcÔ`CLVWJlG£JcZkONÂE`HcORÚ²GIÚ`Z\xkZkJfeì²í#ÕlòmØTQ¿OHP|RCFN`C

x\OWY[V:b l{ӟÔ:C]NۋCAYFGINE²CFHmQ¿OHKL·XW×ÝD^Dó ORE?C]HlG£JcZkON:bDbKZ\L#Z\xiGIHcxke!GRbDJKHlGRp`ZdJcZkON:GIx<Ú`ZkJ

LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN C`Y[C]E`J‹JcÔ:G£JDXW×ÝD^ó V²bmCjb¾ì?íAÕlò m؏Q¿ORHŸCFGYlÔ x\OWY[V:b TZ\N:bmJKCFGpoORQ<GA|Rx\ORÚ:GRx

(5)

JKÔ:C|ROGIxÄORQTGRp`GREWJKZ\aRCLMCFYlÔ²GIN`ZibmL ZibPJKO V:bmC1JKÔ`C1~N`O£ÛPx\CFp`|RC1pWeN:GRL#ZiY]GRxkx\e,GRY KV`Z\HcCFp

GIÚ?ORV`JAJcÔ`CÂbKCFGRHcYlÔ0bKE:GRY]CoJcOGRp9fV:bfJAJKÔ`C!Ö× bmV`ZkJcGRÚ`x\eJcO³JcÔ`CÂE:HKOÚ`xkCFL,{XW×ÝD^ó

Ú?C]x\ORN`|bŸJKOgJcÔ`CY]x\GbKbPORQTGRp`GREWJKZ\aRCLMCFYlÔ²GIN`ZibmL JKÔ:GIJDOWY]Y]V`HcbDG£JPJKÔ:CÚ?OIJmJcORL#ÙµxkCFaRC]x4OIQ

LV`JcG£JcZkONÄ{6èµJUV:bKCFbTJKÔ`CžbfJlG£JcZ\bmJKZiY]bUOIQÄGIx\x\C]x\CDpWZibfJcHKZ\Ú`VWJcZkON GRbTQ¿C]CFp`Ú:GRYl~#ZkN`Q¿ORHcLMGIJKZ\ORNMJcO

GRp:GIEWJcZkaC]x\e-Gp39fV:bmJDJKÔ:C1LVWJlG£JcZkON³E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfe N`ONWÙ>V:N`ZdQ¿OHKLMx\eÂO£aC]HPJcÔ`Cx\OWY[Z>q²Ô:C]N:Y]C

JKÔ:CN:GILMCXJlG£JKZibmJKZiY]bmÙ>Ú:GbmCjp ×p`GIEWJcZkaC1Ý_ONWÙµ^DN`ZkQ¿ORHcL ó!VWJlG£JKZ\ORNäÕ>XW×DÝ^DóØ[{

XW×ÝD^Dó·Z\b‹bmZ\LME`x\C]HTJcÔ:GINoJKÔ`ObmC_LMCjYlÔ:GIN`ZibKLMbTJKÔ:GIJUGRp:pgORN`CDCJKHlGa£GIx\V`CDE?C]HUÚ`ZdJ

GIN²p Y[ORÙ>CFaROxkaCPJKÔ`CjbmCža£GIx\V`CFb‹ÛPZkJKÔÂCFGRYlÔ ZkN:p`ZkaZipWV:GIx>q`bKV:YlÔÂGb GRYl~abUbKC]xkQÙªGRp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORN

bcYlÔ`C]LMC_á£ãµ{ I¸ZkJKԁXW×ÝD^Dó0qFÛPÔ:GIJ4ۋCTGRp`pJKO_JKHlGRpWZkJKZ\ORN:GRx£Ú`ZkJ4LVWJlG£JcZkON1GIHcC6bKE:GIJKZiGIx\xke

ORN:xkeMORN:CDHcCFGIx?aRCjY›JcORHORQ'zÙªpWZ\L#CFN:bKZkONgJKÔ:GIJUHcCFY]ORHlp`bzJcÔ`CDQ¿HcC KV`CFN:Y[eMORQÄORN`CjbTQ¿OHUCjGRYlÔ

x\OY]V:bFq6GRN:p0Y]ORLME`VWJlG£JKZ\ORN²GIx\xke$ORN`x\e$ORN`C bmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFb1E?C]H#|RCFN`C]HlG£JcZkONJcÔ:G£JMY]GRx\Y]V`x\GIJKCjb

JKÔ:CQ¿HcC KV`CFN:Y[eMORQ4ORN`Cjb‹O£aRC]HJKÔ`CžE?ORE`V`xiG£JcZkONՉÔ`C]N:Y]CžJKÔ`CžLVWJlG£JcZkON E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfe`Ø6Q¿ORH

CFGYlÔÂx\OWY[V:bF{TӟÔ`ZibPbmZ\LME`x\C1bfJlG£JKZibmJKZiY]bPGRp:pWCFp-ZibŸÛUCFxkxÄHcC]۟GIHlpWCjp GRbŸpWZibcY[V:bcbmCjp-Ú²CFxkO£Û{

ӟÔ`CgLMOIJcZka£GIJKZ\ORNÚ²CFÔ`Z\N:p0XW×DÝ^Dó x\ZkCjbZ\NJcÔ`CgQ‰GY›JJKÔ²G£J1ÛPZkJKÔJKÔ:CgE`HKO|RHcCFbcbžOIQ

|RCFN`C[JcZ\YbmCjGIHlYlÔ XW×DÝ^Dó Ô`C]x\E:bUE`HKORJKCjY›JKZ\N`|1Ú:V`ZkxipWZ\N`|#Ú`xkOWYl~WbzQ¿OV`N:pobKO1Q‰GRHÛPÔ`Z\x\CbmJKZ\xkx

CWE`x\ORZkJKZ\N`|#N`C]ÛÀÚ`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|#Ú`x\OWYl~bF{zÓ4OAQ¿ORHcLgGIx\xkegGRN:GIx\eæ]C_JcÔ`CÚ²CFÔ:G¡aZkOHUORQ<Ö×DbFq`v_OxdÙ

xiGIN:páktjéjãÄܲHcbmJ_ZkNJcHKOWpWV:Y]CFpÂJKÔ:C1Y[ORN²Y[C]E`J_OIQ^UXZ[O žJKOopWCjbKY]HKZ\Ú?CGgbKV`Ú:bKC[J_ORQ¾Ú`Z\N:GRHKe

bmJKHcZkN`|bŸOIQ<ÜWCFpÂxkCFN`|IJcÔ-JKÔ:GIJ_Ô:G¡aRCbmZ\LMZkxiGIHcZkJKZ\CFbPG£JDY]C]HKJcGRZkN-E²ObmZkJKZ\ORN²b]{ `OHPC`GILME`x\CRq

JKÔ:CžbcYlÔ`C]LgG t % % % %£ñÕ‰ÛPÔ`C]HcC ê£ë1p`C]N`ORJKCFb‹G!êcpWORN J‹YFGIHcCFëÚ:ZdJ›ØTHcC]E`HcCFbKC]NJlb6JKÔ`C

bKC[J1OIQŸGIx\xF£ÙµÚ`ZkJbmJKHcZ\N`|bJKÔ²G£J1Ú?C]|RZ\N$ÛPZdJcÔàtgGRN:pCFN:p$ÛPZdJcÔäñ`{g֞ZkaC]NäGÂbcYlÔ`CFLMGŸq

ZkJcbN L NWÕT؋ZibŸJKÔ`CNV`LAÚ²CFHPOIQ¾ÜWCFp-E²ObmZkJKZ\ORN²bŸÛPZdJcÔ`ZkNßGIN:p-ZkJcb.L_ SQTS S T[

0mÕTØAZ\bAJcÔ`C!pWZ\bmJcGRN:Y[C,Ú?C[JfۋC]CFN0JKÔ:C-OVWJKCFHKLMObfJ#ÜWCFpßÚ`ZkJcbMOIQŸ{ ‹V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|$Ú`x\OWYl~b

GIHcCAbKÔ`OHmJjqrxkO£ÛŸÙµORHlpWC]Hjq:Ú?C[JKJKCFHJcÔ:GING¡aRCFHcGR|RC1bcYlÔ`C]LgGb]{v_OxkxiGIN²p7b8UX-[O @[N-O

bmJcG£JcCFbJKÔ:GIJ‹Ú:V`ZkxipWZ\N`|#Ú`xkOWYl~WbUHKCjY[C]Z\aRCGINoCE?ORN:C]NJKZiGIx\xkeMZ\N:Y[HcCFGbmZ\N`|1NV`LAÚ²CFHUORQrJKHcZ\GRx\b

Z\NÂJcÔ`C1bKV`Ú:bKC KV`C]NJP|RCFN`C]HlG£JcZkON:bF{

èªNoQ‰GY›JPÚ`V`Z\xipWZkN:|#Ú:xkOWYl~WbUYFGINÂÚ²Cx\OO~RCjpoGRbUJKÔ:CY]ORLAÚ`ZkN²G£JKZ\ORN OIQ¾N:ORNWÙµN`C]V`JKHlGIx6Õft[Ù

Z\NJcHKZ\N:bKZ\YŸOHñ£ÙµZ\NJcHKZ\N:bKZ\Yjؾ|RC]N:CFbF{-I¸Ô`CFNMJKÔ`CPE?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORNMZibTHlGIN:pWOLMxke1Z\N`ZkJKZiGIx\ZkæFCFprqRJKÔ`C

Q¿HcC KV`C]N²Y[e-OIQPtFbDZkN,JcÔ`CAGRxkx\C]x\CFbPZ\N³CjGRYlÔ,xkOWY]V:b_ZibDbmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFGIx\xke,GIÚ?ORVWJžñ`{¤égGIN:p,Ô:C]N:Y]C

ì í Õlò 6 í Q¿OHžGRxkx<JcÔ`CAx\OWY[Z>{v_O£Û‹C]aRCFHFq?ÛPZkJKÔ³JcÔ`C#E`HKO|RHcCFbcbPOIQJKÔ`CgÖ×1qrÛPÔ`CFN

Ú`V`Z\xipWZkN:|Ú`x\OWYl~bÂGIHcC³E:GRHmJcZ\GRxkx\e0Q¿OV`N:prqPJcÔ:G£J-Z\bFqDbKORLMC0t]Ù>Z\NJKHcZkN:bKZiY!GIN:p ñIÙ>Z\NJKHcZkN²bmZiY

x\OY]ZÄJcC]N:p-JcO Y[ONaC]Hc|RCJKO³t1GRN:p!ñMHcCFbKE²CjY›JKZ\aRCFxkeq?XW×ÝD^ó pWCFY]HKCjGRbKCFb‹JcÔ`C1LV`JcG£JcZkON

E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJKZ\CFbgORQJcÔ`CFbKC³x\OWY[ZDGY]Y[OHcp`ZkN`|JKOßs KV:G£JcZkONÕmtjØ[{ èªNJKÔ:Z\b ۋG¡eqŸXW×ÝD^ó

Y]GRN!E`HcOIJKCjY›JDÚ:V`ZkxipWZ\N`|oÚ`x\OWYl~WbPQ¿ORV:N:p!bmOoQ‰GIH_JcÔ:G£JžGIHcCxkOWY]GIJKCjp,ORN,JKÔ:CFbKC1E:GIHKJKZiGIx\x\eÂOH

JKORJcGRxkx\eäY[ORNaC]Hc|RCFpx\OWY[Z>{ I¸Ô:Zkx\CÂON0JcÔ`CÂORJKÔ`CFHAÔ²GIN:prq6Q¿OHJcÔ`ObKC V:N:Y[ONaC]Hc|RCjpxkOWY[Z

JKÔ:C!LVWJlG£JKZ\ORNßE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJKZ\CFbMGIHcCÂHcC]LgGRZkN`Cjp0JcOÚ?C!Ô`Z\|RÔßÛPZdJcÔ`ZkN XW×ÝD^óä{ÓŸÔ`ZibMZ\b

V:bKC[Q¿V`x‹Ú?CFY]GRV:bKCMJKÔ`CFHKCoLgG¡e$Ú²C Ú`V`Z\x\pWZ\N`|Ú`xkOWYl~WbN`ORJCWE`HcCFbcbKCFp$ORNJcÔ`CFbKCox\OY]ZeC[JF{

`HcORL JKÔ:CFbKCpWZibKY]V:bKbKZ\ORN:bFqPZdJ-Y]GIN¸Ú?CbKC]CFNJKÔ:GIJ-XW×ÝD^Dó bfJcHKZ\~RCjbMJKOÚ:GIxiGIN:Y]C,JKÔ`C

Y[ON:bmJKHcV:Y›JcZkONOIQžN`C]Û Ú`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|$Ú`x\OWYl~bMGRN:pE:HKORJKCFY[JKZ\ORNßOIQDQ¿OV`N:pßÚ`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|$Ú`x\OWYl~b

O£aRCFH‹JKÔ`Cx\OWY[ZÄÛPZkJKÔ-JKZ\LMC1GRp`GREWJKZ\aRCFxke{

Ó¾HcGpWZdJcZkON:GIx²Ú`ZkJŸLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNo~C]CFE:bUGAY[ON:bfJlGINJULAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNÂE`HKOÚ:GIÚ:Zkx\ZdJfe#O£aRCFHUGRxkx²JKÔ`C

x\OY]Z¬{Ÿ×Db_JKÔ`CE²OE`V`xiG£JKZ\ORN³Y]ORNaRCFHK|CFbFqÛPZdJcÔ,JKHlGRpWZkJKZ\ORN:GRxÄÚ`ZkJLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNÄq`Z\N,Q‰GRY[J_Q¿C]ۋC]H

GIN²pMQ¿C]ۋC]HUOrbmE`HcZ\N`|b|RC]N:C]HlG£JKCjpMÚeALAVWJcGIJKZ\N`|1JcÔ`ObKCDY[ONaRC]Hc|RCjp#xkOWY[Z?ÛPZ\xkx(bmV:HKaZ\aRCPZ\N

JKÔ:C#N:CJ|RC]N:C]HlG£JKZ\ORN4{1ӟÔ:G£JZ\bFqrLgGINe!LV`JcG£JcZkONOE²CFHcGIJKZ\ORN:bžGIHcCÛŸGRbmJKCjp³ON³JKÔ:ObKC

Y[ONaRC]Hc|RCjpx\OWY[Z>{-ó³ObmJOIQ‹JKÔ`CjbmC ۋGbfJcCFp$LVWJlG£JcZkONäORE?C]HlG£JKZ\ORN²bGIN:pÔ`CFN:Y[Cg۟GRbmJKCjp

(6)

A@C

CI4ÌÇÍzÎ <C E I

èªNAORHlpWC]H¾JKOY[OL#E²GIHcCTJKÔ:CUE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLgGIN:Y]COIQ(XW×DÝ^DóäqRGDÛPZ\p`C‹HlGIN:|RCORQ`JfeE`ZiY]GIxÚ?C]N:YlÔWÙ

LgGIHc~!E`HcORÚ`x\C]LgbZ\bbKC]x\CFY[JKCjpGRbJcÔ`C#JKCFbmJ1bmC]JF{#ӟÔ`CFbKCME`HKOÚ`x\C]LgbžHKCFE`HKCjbmCFNJžpWZ?CFHKCFNJ

pWZkçoY[V`xkJfe x\C]aC]xib‹Q¿ORHDÖ×b]{TӟÔ`CFe GIHcCpWCFbcY[HcZ\Ú²CjpÂGb‹Q¿ORx\xkO£Û_bF{

! #"$&%

ӟÔ`CN`C]ÙµóG E`HcORÚ:xkCFL ádt]ã4bmZ\LME`x\eÂY[OV`NJcb‹JcÔ`CORN`CjbPY[ONJlGIZ\N`CFpÂZ\N,G#Ú`Z\N:GRHKe bmJKHcZ\N`|

GbŸJKÔ`C1Ü`JKN`CjbKb_OIQ6JKÔ:GIJbmJKHcZkN`|²{UӟÔ`CAGIZ\L ZibPJKOgOÚWJcGRZkN³GgbmJKHcZ\N`|oY[ONJlGIZ\N`Z\N`|gGIx\x4ORN:CFbFq

JcÔ:G£JDZibFq`JKO LMGWZkLMZ\æ]C1ON`CFbPZ\N³GobmJKHcZkN:|:{Ÿ× bfJcHKZ\N`|gx\C]N`|RJKÔ!ORQŸtjñRñMÚ`ZkJcbDۋGbPV:bKCFp-Q¿OH

OV`H_bfJcV:pWe{

(' *)+&,-."/)+!1032457698:$;7<

ӟÔ`CÂnPO£eGRxTnPOGp$Q¿V`N:Y›JcZkON:b>=

)

GRN:p?=

,

ÛUCFHKCopWCFaZ\bKCFpÚeó!ZdJlYlÔ`C]x\x>qB:ORHcHKCjbfJ1GRN:p

vDORx\x\GRN:päádtA@¡ã4JcOoZ\NaCFbmJKZ\|GIJKCÖ×.bE²CFHmQ¿OHKLgGIN²Y[CÛPZkJKÔ³HcCFbKE²CjY›J_JcO bcYlÔ`C]LgGgE`HcOWY[CjbKbmÙ

Z\N`|GRN:pHKCjY[OLÚ`Z\N:G£JcZkONZkN GRN¸Z\pWCjGIx\ZkæFCFpàQ¿OHKL,{ nPO£eGIxDnPOGRpßQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:b-Y[ONJcGIZ\N

JlGIZ\xkOHmÙµLgGRpWCŸÚ`V`Z\xipWZkN:|1Ú`x\OYl~WbPÕ¬bKYlÔ`CFLgGRblØ<Ú:GRbKCFp#ORN IÙµÚ`ZkJ6Ú:ZkN:GRHKe#bfJcHKZ\N`|b]{6ӟÔ`C]e#GIHcC

pWC]Ü:N`CjpMV:bmZ\N`|Gx\ZibfJ‹OIQÄbKYlÔ:C]LgGRbF{¾sUGRYlÔgbKYlÔ:C]LgGCB ZibT|RZ\aRCFNgG1Y[OC[çoY]ZkCFNJED ÛPÔ`ZiYlÔgZ\b

C&KV²GIxJKOZkJcb6ORHlpWCFH WÕ(B

؟ՉGžbcYlÔ`C]LgGb<ORHlpWC]H6Zib<JKÔ`CŸNV`LAÚ²CFH<ORQ:ÜWCjpE?ObKZdJcZkON:b6ÛPZkJKÔ`Z\N

JcÔ:G£JbKYlÔ:C]LgGØ[{#=

)

Y[ORN²bmZibfJlb_ORQ-@ pWZibY9fV`N:Y›JcZkaCAOHcp`C]HKÙF@obcYlÔ`CFLMGbDORQTÛPÔ`ZiYlÔCFGYlÔ³Ô:Gb

@-GRp39mGY[CFNJON`CFbF{G=

,

Y[ON:bmZibmJcbOIQUQ¿ORV`Hx\C]aC]xibOIQ‹bcYlÔ`CFLMGb]yxkCFaRCFxTñ$ՉڲORJmJcORL·x\C]aC]xØ

ZibPJcÔ`CbcGILMC1GRb7=

)

q:x\C]aRCFxtÔ:Gb gOHcpWCFHmÙlt MbcYlÔ`C]LgGbPOIQzÛPÔ`ZiYlÔ!CFGYlÔ,Y]ORLAÚ`ZkN:CFbŸJfۋO

Gp39mGRY]C]NJTbKYlÔ`CFLgGRb6Z\NgxkCFaRC]x`ñ:qRx\C]aC]x²âžY[ONJcGIZ\N:bTâžOHcpWCFHmÙMâbcYlÔ`C]LgGRb6CjGRYlÔMY[OLÚ`Z\N`Z\N`|

JfۋOgGRp39mGY[C]NJ_bcYlÔ`C]LgGRbŸZ\N,xkCFaRCFxTtRq`GRN:pÂÜ:N:GIx\x\eoxkCFaRCFx,ÕJKÔ:C1OREWJcZkLgGRx4bKYlÔ:C]LgG؋Y[OL#Ù

Ú`Z\N`Cjb6JKÔ`CâbKYlÔ:C]LgGRb6Z\NgxkCFaRCFx²âW{zӟÔ`CŸÜ`JcN`CFbcbTORQÄGÚ`ZdJ‹bfJcHKZ\N`| % Q¿OH;=

) Õ% ØzGIN²pH=

, Õ% Ø

ZibPY[OL#E:VWJKCjpÂÚe bKV`LMLMZkN:|MJKÔ`C1Y]OC]çoY[Z\C]NJcbIDDzY]ORHcHKCjbmE?ORN²pWZkN:|JcO#CjGRYlÔ-OIQ¾JKÔ`C|ZkaC]N

bcYlÔ`C]LgGJB OIQTÛPÔ`ZiYlÔ

%

Z\bžGIN!Z\N:bmJcGIN²Y[CR{žÓŸÔ:G£JžZ\bFq=

) Õ% ؞GRN:p=

, Õ%

ØDGRHKCApWC[Ü:N:CFp³Gb

Q¿Oxkx\O£Û_b]y

= ) Õ% Ø LKNM

O

LK

)

DD(P

%

؟GIN:pQ=

, Õ% Ø LK

)

O

LK

) D RP mÕ

% Ø

ÛPÔ`CFHKCSP Õ% Ø tòmZkQ % îB UT ñ`òmORJKÔ`CFHKÛPZibKC {TӟÔ`COEWJKZ\LgGIx4bKORx\VWJKZ\ORN²b‹Q¿ORH=

)

GIN:pQ=

,

GRHKCž|RZ\aRCFN-Gb]y1=

)

ÕmtRtRt_\tjØ MGRN:pV=

,

ÕfttRt kt¡Ø t21âW{

(W YXZ\[^]_`! #"$&% ab&&8c;

ӟÔ`CžHlGIN:pWOLÈhrÙfXW×zÓ¸E`HcORÚ:xkCFL |RC]N:C]HlG£JKOHUpWCFaZ\bKCFp ÚeoBCRON`|:qed6ORJmJKCFH‹GRN:pÂXWE²CjGIHlb

á@¡ãUZib1G,Ú?OORx\CFGINbcG£JKZibmܲGIÚ`Z\x\ZdJfeE`HKOÚ`x\C]L·|C]N`CFHcGIJKORH1p`C]aZ\bKCFpJcO!ZkNaRCjbfJcZk|G£JcCAJcÔ`CgC[QÙ

Q¿CjY›JcboOIQC]E`ZibfJlGRbKZ\bMONàJKÔ`C!E?C]HKQ¿ORHcLgGIN:Y]C-ORQÖ×b]{ èµJo|RC]N:C]HlG£JKCjbMHcGRN:pWOL Ú²OOxkCjGIN

CE:HKCjbKbKZkON:bgZ\N Y[ON9fV`N:Y[JKZ\aRC³N:ORHcLMGRx_Q¿OHKL OIQY]x\GRV:bmCjb bKV`Ú 9fCjY›J JcOäJKÔ:HKCFCE:GRHcGRL#C]Ù

JcC]Hlb7fäՉNV:LÚ?C]HOIQUÚ²OORx\CFGRNa£GIHcZiGIÚ`x\CFbl؛qNDÂÕ¿NV`LÚ?C]HORQUpWZib9fV:N:Y›JcZkaC#OHžY]ORN9fV:N:Y›JcZkaC

(7)

ñ`{¤éW{B`OHCjGRYlÔg|RCFN`C]HlG£JcCFp#Ú?OOxkCjGINgCE:HKCjbKbKZkONÄqIJcÔ`CDGRZkL ZibzJKO1Ü:N:poGRNoGRbcbmZ\|RN`LMCFNJUOIQ

JKHcVWJcÔ a£GIx\V`CFbJKOJKÔ`C7fMa¡GRHKZiGIÚ:xkCjbzJKÔ²G£JULgGR~RCFbTJKÔ`CžC]NJcZkHcC_CWE`HcCFbcbKZkONMJKHcV`CR{TXZ\N:Y[CDJKÔ`C

Ú?OOxkCjGIN³CWE`HKCjbKbKZ\ORN,Z\bHlGIN:pWOLMxke-|RCFN`C]HlG£JcCFprq²JKÔ`CFHKCZ\bN`O |V:GIHlGINJcC]CJKÔ²G£JžbKV:YlÔGRN

GRbcbKZk|N`LMC]NJzCWZ\bmJcbF{6ӟÔ`C_pWZkçgY]V`xkJfeAGIN²p#Y]ORLME`x\CWZkJfe1OIQ?JKÔ`CDE`HKOÚ`x\C]L a£GIHcZ\CFb6ÛPZkJKÔ#JKÔ`C

E:GRHcGRL#C]JKCFHcb-f²qeDGIN:p 0f{ `OHUCWGRLME`xkCqZkN:Y]HKCjGRbKZkN:|JKÔ`CNV`LAÚ²CFHUORQ¾Y[xiGIV:bKCFbUZ\N:Y[HcCFGbmCjb

JKÔ:CC]E`ZibfJlGRbKZ\bF{zӟÔ`CÜ`JcN`CFbcbŸQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN-Q¿ORHŸJcÔ`C1hrÙfXW×zÓÀE`HcORÚ`x\C]LÈZibPGRb‹Q¿Oxkx\O£Û_bFy

D

1,Ø t

D

OK )

DD0B

#

‰Ø

I¸Ô`CFHKCD 1 Y[ON:bmZibmJcboORQ>D!Y[xiGIV:bKCFbÂGIN:p¸JKÔ`CÜ`JKN`CjbKbÂY[ONJcHKZ\Ú`VWJcZkON¸OIQY]x\GRV:bmC cq

D 0B # ‰Ø[q`Z\b1tžZkQ<JKÔ`C1Y]x\GRV:bmCZibPbKGIJKZibfܲCFpÂORH_ñ#OIJcÔ`C]HcÛPZ\bKCR{

èªN-ORV`HŸCWE?C]HcZkLMCFNJlb‹ÛUCÛPZ\xkxrV:bKCžJKÔ`CbcGILMCžE:GIHlGILMC[JcC]HlbUGbŸZkNá@¡ã>{JI$CžÜWCFp JKÔ`C

NV`LÚ?C]HDOIQ¾a£GRHKZiGIÚ`x\CFbEfgJcO,tFñRñ#GIN²p JcÔ`CxkCFN`|IJcÔ,OIQ4JcÔ`C1Y[xiGIV²bmCjb04JcO `{zӟÔ`CNV`LÚ?C]H

OIQY]x\GRV:bKCFbD۟GRb_a¡GRHKZ\CFp-Q¿HcORL âIññ!Õ¿x\O£ÛC]E`ZibfJlGRbKZ\bl؋JcOtjâRñRñ,Õ¿LMCjpWZkV:L C]E`ZibfJlGRbKZ\bl؋JcO

âñRñ-Õ¿Ô`Z\|RÔ,CFE`Z\bmJcGbmZibl؛{

b 68:- 2475698:$;7<

BCFY[CFEWJKZ\aRCDQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bŸGIHcCPJcÔ`ObKCPQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bUÛPÔ`CFHKCDJKÔ`CxkO£ÛŸÙµORHlpWC]HÚ`V`Z\x\pWZ\N`|AÚ`xkOWYl~Wbp`O

N`ORJžY[OLÚ`Z\N`CJKOoQ¿OHKL Ô`Z\|RÔ`CFHmÙµORHlpWCFH_Ú`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|ÂÚ`x\OYl~WbFyŸZkN:bmJKCjGRp,JcÔ`C]e-Q¿OHKL Ú`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|

Ú`x\OWYl~b<HcCFbKV`xkJKZ\N`|DZ\NAGžbmV:ÚWÙ>OEWJKZ\LgGIxbmOxkV`JKZ\ORNÄ{<BDCjY[C]E`JKZ\aRC‹Q¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:b6GIHcCUp`C]aRCFxkOE²Cjp1GRb

pWZkçoY[V`xkJDJcCFbmJ_Q¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bŸQ¿OHDY[OLME:GIHcZkN:|opWZ(C]HcC]NJ_Z\LME`xkCFLMC]NJcGIJKZ\ORN:bDOIQTÖ×DbF{ŸÖžOx\pÙ

Ú?C]Hc|:qDwOHKÚ GRN:p BC]ÚÇákt2£ãžÔ:G¡aCpWCFaZibKCFp GRN ORHlpWC]HKÙMLMZ\N`Z\LV`L Q¿V`x\x\e pWCFY]C]EWJcZkaC

E`HcORÚ`x\C]L GRb‹Q¿ORx\x\O£Û_b]y

!" #$

$$%'& $$ ! ($ $ )

ÛPÔ`CFHKCGIx\x:JcÔ`CORHlpWC]HKÙlt_GIN:p ORHlpWC]HKÙªâÚ`V`Z\x\pWZ\N`|#Ú`x\OYl~WbžÕ¿C{|²{kq6êKñ Ië1GIN:pê IñRñRëÛPÔ:C]HcC

JKÔ:C1ÛPZkxip`YFGIHlpê£ë#LgG£JcYlÔ:CFbPÚ?OIJcÔ,ñgGRN:p$tj؋Z\N-JKÔ`CbKCFGRHcYlÔ-bmE²GRY[C1GRHKCpWCjY[CFEWJKZ\aRC1GRN:p

ÛPZ\xkxzx\CFGp,JKÔ`CM|C]N`C]JKZiYbKCFGIHlYlÔG¡ÛŸG¡e Q¿HcORL JcÔ`CM|Rx\ORÚ:GRx¾OEWJKZ\LV`L êFtRttFëoGRN:p,JKO£ÛŸGIHlp

JKÔ:C1pWCFY]C]EWJcZkaCxkOWY]GRxrOREWJcZkLAV`L êcñRññRë1Z\N:bmJKCjGRpr{

ŸGRbKCFpON0GINGRxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`L ORQDY[ORN²bfJcHKV:Y[JKZ\N`|!Q¿V`x\x\e0pWCFY]C]EWJcZkaCgQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bFqJI¸Ô`ZkJKx\C]e

áâRéjã4Ô²GRbPGIxibKOMp`C]aRCFxkOE²CjpÂGRNÂOHcp`C]HKÙAQ¿V`x\xke-pWCFY]C]EWJcZkaCžE:HKOÚ`xkCFL GRb‹Q¿Oxkx\O£Û_bFy

! !" *$! & +,(

(! ( -$" $-.& +/

$$! $$ -$ $$*$-$ $$ +/

$(! $( 0& $$!" $ +/)

èªN,JKÔ:Z\bE:GIE?C]Hjq:ۋCY]ORN:bmJKHcV:Y›JcCFp-JfۋOARñMÚ:ZdJpWCFY]C]EWJcZkaCQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bFyŸORN`CY]ORNJcGRZkN²b

âIñY]ORE`Z\CFbTOIQ4֞ORxipWÚ?C]Hc|:qwOHKÚMGIN²p#BC]Úb^£ÙµÚ`ZkJzQ¿V`xkx\eMpWCFY]C]EWJcZkaCDbmV:ÚWQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN³Õ‰YFGIx\xkCjp

BCFY[CFEWJKZ\aRC^`V`N²Y›JKZ\ORN2143

)

ØÄGRN:p1GRN`OIJcÔ`C]H4Y]ORNJcGRZkN²bTtjé_Y[ORE:ZkCjbÄOIQ I¸Ô:ZdJcxkCFe b-IÙµÚ`ZdJ4Q¿V`xkx\e

pWCjY[C]E`JKZ\aRCbKV`ÚWQ¿V:N:Y›JcZkONՉYFGIx\xkCjpoBDCjY[CFEWJKZ\aRC `V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN5143

,

؛{TӟÔ`COREWJcZkLgGRx²bKORx\VWJKZ\ORN:b

Q¿ORH6173 GRN:p5143 Ô²G¡aRCGAÜ`JKN`CjbKb_OIQ ñRñ#GIN:p$éIñAHKCjbmE?CFY[JKZ\aRC]x\eR{

(8)

^ b < :; V SN :% &-8

èªNORHlpWC]HJKO JKCFbmJXW×DÝ^DóäqrZ\N³JcÔ`ZibCWE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJcGRx6bmJKV²pWe!ZdJZibžY]ORLME:GRHKCjp!ÛPZdJcÔ³JcHcGIÙ

pWZkJKZ\ORN²GIx‹Ú`ZdJgLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN0ÛPZkJKÔàGbKC]HcZkCjb1ORQDHKCjY[OL#LMCFN:pWCFp êKbmJcGIN²p`GIHlp`ë,ÜWCjp0E`HcORÚ:GIÙ

Ú`Z\x\ZdJcZkCjb]y$t3!'ðÚe0ó0V`Ô:xkCFNÚ?C]Z\N%ádt 1¡ãµqUññ`t-Úe֞HKC]Q¿C]N:bmJKC]JmJcC0ádtt›ã>qt ‘uIé"!WÕY#J%'()+*-,jØ

Úe GRYl~¸áIã>qUGIN:pßññRñ`t Úe0BC@RON`|ßá¤ujãµ{0Ý_ORJKCÂJKÔ:GIJAQ¿OHMhÄÙªX`×zÓÈGIN:p N`C[Ùªó³G

E`HcORÚ:xkCFLMbFq(t3!'

ññ`t{ :ORH_XW×DÝ^DóäqJcÔ`CLVWJlG£JcZkON E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfeì

í

Õlò mØTQ¿ORHŸCjGRYlÔ

x\OWY[V:b#Õ tRò22[ò '‹Øa£GIHcZkCjpGRp`GREWJKZ\aRCFxke$ÛPZdJcÔäJKZ\LMCՉ|RC]N:C]HlG£JKZ\ORNäY]ORV`NJKCFH/mØÚ?C[Ù

JfۋC]CFN 6<í t3!' GIN:p 6<í tFñ !GRYFY[ORHlpWZ\N`|$JKO0C&KV:G£JcZkONÕmtjØ[{ :ORHoCjGRYlÔ

CE?C]HcZ\L#CFNJŸORQ<Y]ORLÚ:ZkN`Z\N`|MpWZ?CFHKCFNJPLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNÕJKHlGRp`ZdJcZkON:GIxrÚ`ZkJ(:Z\E-LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN-ÛPZdJcÔ

pWZ(C]HcC]NJLV`JcG£JcZkONHcGIJKCgORH#XW×DÝ^Dó؁GIN:p$JcCFbmJE`HcORÚ`x\C]L,q‹tFñRñ-Z\N:pWCFE²CFN:pWC]NJ#HKV`N²b

ۋC]HcCCWCFY]VWJKCjpr{zèªN!GIx\xrJKÔ`CCWE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJcbFqJKÔ`CÜ:JKN`CjbKbPE:HKOE²OHmJcZkON:G£JcCžbKC]x\CFY[JKZ\ORN,ÛPZdJcÔ

JcÔ`C-bmJKOWYlÔ:GbfJcZ\YoV`N`Z\aRC]HlbcGIxUbcGILME`x\Z\N`|ßáâjãµqUâ¡ÙµE²OZkNJMY[HcObcbmO£aC]Hjq¾GIN²päC]x\ZdJcZ\bmJML#OWpWCFxžá¤ujã

ۋC]HcC1V:bKCFp,Z\N!JKÔ:C#Ö×1{(ӟÔ`C#Y[HcObcbmO£aC]HŸE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfeÂ۟GRb_ÜWCFp-JKO JKÔ`CJfeE`Z\YFGIx¾a¡GRxkV:C

ORQ6ñ:q:GIN:pÂJcÔ`CE²OE`V`xiG£JcZkON,bKZ\æ]C۟GRbPbKC[J_JcO!tFñRñAQ¿OHPCFGRYlÔ,HcV`NÄ{TèªN!OHcp`C]H‹JKOoÔ²G¡aRCG

bmJKHcZ\Y[J1Y[ORLME:GRHKZibKORN!JcÔ`CgbKGRL#C-tFññÂp`Z(C]HcC]NJHcGRN:pWOL·bmCFCFp`bžÛ‹C]HcCAV:bKCFpJKO-|RCFN`C]HlG£JcC

Z\N`ZkJKZiGIxWE?ORE`V`xiG£JcZkON:b¾Q¿ORH6JcÔ`CtFñRñDHKV:N:b6OIQ?CFGRYlÔACWE?C]HcZkLMC]NJj{ :ORH6CFGYlԁHcV`NÄq£JcÔ`CŸZkN`ZkJKZiGIx

E?ORE`V:x\GIJKZ\ORN-Z\b‹HlGIN:pWOLMxkeoY]HKCjG£JKCjp V²bmZ\N`|MGJcCFYlÔ`N:ZKV`CžJKÔ²G£JP|RCFN`C]HlG£JcCFbUC`GRY[JKx\eoC KV:GRx

NV`LAÚ²CFH#ORQžñbAGRN:p tjbAQ¿ORHMCFGYlÔ0xkOWY]V:bZ)£qTJcÔ:G£JgZib]q

)

ÕcòcñØ ñ¤é!Q¿OH#CjGRYlÔ0x\OWY[V:b,

Õ tò2]ò-'U؋Z\N,JKÔ`C1Z\N`ZkJKZiGIx¾E²OE`V`xiG£JKZ\ORN4{‹èªN,JcÔ`Zib_۟G¡egJKÔ`CAHcGRN:pWOL bKGRLME`xkZ\N`|oÚ:Z\Gb

Z\N$JKÔ`CgZ\N`ZkJKZiGIxTE?ORE`V:x\GIJKZ\ORN¸ÕQ¿OH1C`GILME`x\C#Q¿ORHbKORLMCMx\OY]V:b²q

)

ÕòcñØ

ñ@-ORH1ñâØ

JcÔ:G£J_LgG¡eoLMZibmx\CFGp-XW×ÝD^óÞZ\bPYFGIN:Y]C]x\xkCjpr{

`OHgCFGYlÔßHcV`NÄqUJKÔ`CÚ²CjbfJKÙµbKOIÙ>Q‰GIH#Ü`JcN`CFbcbMۋGbMHKCjY[OHcpWCjp0CFaRC]Hce tjñRñC]a£GIx\V:G£JcZkON:bF{

vDC]HcCRq(ORN`x\e-JKÔ`ObmCMYlÔ`HcORLMObKORLMCjb_YlÔ:GIN:|RCFp³Úe!Y]HKObKbKO£aRCFH_GIN:pLVWJlG£JKZ\ORNORE?C]HlG£JcZkON:b

ۋC]HcCC]a£GIx\V:G£JcCFp-GIN:p,Y]ORV`NJKCjp-ZkNJKOMJcÔ`CNV`LÚ?C]HDOIQ¾CFa£GIx\V:G£JcZkON:b]{ :ORH_CjGRYlÔ-HKV:NÄqWJKÔ:C

LgGWZ\LV`L GIx\xkO£ÛŸGIÚ`x\CDNV`LAÚ²CFHPOIQ<C]a£GIx\V:G£JcZkON:bŸa£GIHcZkCjb‹ÛPZdJcÔÂJcÔ`CžJKCjbfJ_E`HcORÚ:xkCFLÈGIN:pÂZ\b

bKV`ZkJcGIÚ:xke,bmC]J_JKO xkC]JžGIx\xÄJcÔ`CLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN!OE²CFHcGIJKORHlbŸÔ:G¡aCJKÔ`CAYlÔ:GIN:Y]CJKO CWE`HcCFbcbŸJKÔ`CFZkH

E?O£ÛUCFHF{6sGYlÔÂCWE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJPHKCjbmV`xkJ_۟GRbŸG¡aRCFHcGR|RCFpoO£aRC]HtjñRñAZkN:p`C]E?C]N:pWCFNJDHKV:N:b]{

^(' V SN :% ;8e1"C)+&<c47"8<

ӟÔ`CMCE?C]HcZ\L#CFNJcGIxzHcCFbKV`xkJcbžORNpWZ?CFHKCFNJJKCFbmJE`HcORÚ`x\C]LgbGIHcCMbmÔ`O£ÛPNZkN <Z\|RV`HcCoâgJcO

<Z\|RV`HcC,éHcCFbKE²CjY›JKZ\aRCFxke{ `HcORLÞJcÔ`CFbKC ܲ|RV`HcCFbFqzJKÔ:CÂQ¿Oxkx\O£ÛPZ\N`|OÚ:bmCFHKa£GIJKZ\ORN:b#Y]GRNÚ?C

bKC]CFNÄ{

<ZkHlbmJFqPXW×DÝ^Dó E?C]HKQ¿ORHcLMb#E?C]HlbmZibmJKC]NJcxke0ۋC]x\xPORNßJKÔ:C,JKCFbmJoE`HcORÚ`x\C]LgbF{ßèªNàQ‰GY›JFq

XW×ÝD^ó E²CFHmQ¿OHKLgbgÚ?C[JKJKCFHoJKÔ²GINJKHlGRp`ZdJcZkON:GIx_LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN¸OE²CFHcGIJKORHlbMÛPZkJKÔ pWZ?CFHKCFNJ

êcbfJlGIN:p`GRHcp:ëÜCjp,HcGIJKCjbPORN³GRxkx4JKÔ`CJcCFbmJDE`HcORÚ`x\C]LgbDC`Y[CFEWJ_JKÔ:CpWCFY]C]EWJcZkaCQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:b

143

)

GIN:p 143

, { N³JKÔ:CMp`CFY[CFEWJKZ\aRCAQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bFq¾XW×ÝD^ó ZibžÚ²CjG£JcC]N$Úe,JcHcGpWZkJKZ\ORN:GRx

LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNàORE?C]HlG£JKOHcbAÛPZkJKÔì í ññRñ`t-GIN:p$ì í t ‘uIé"!WÕY#J%.'^)* ,F؛{ v_O£Û‹C]aC]Hjq

ZkJAGIxibKO³E²CFHmQ¿OHKLgbÚ?C[JKJKCFHJcÔ:GINäÚ`ZkJALAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNäÛPZkJKÔ³ì í t3!'GIN:päGb1ۋC]x\xUGRbÚ`ZkJ

LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN-ÛPZdJcÔ#ì?í

ññ`tR{

XCjY[ORN²prq¡ì í ññRñ:tDbmV:|R|RCjbfJcCFpMÚeoBC ORN`|-áujãrbKC]CFLgbJcOÚ?CžGA|ROOWpoYlÔ`OZ\Y]C_Q¿OH

Ú`ZkJPLVWJlG£JcZkONÄ{èµJPE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLMbŸÚ?C[JKJKCFHŸJKÔ:GRNÂORJKÔ`CFHŸÜWCFpÂE`HKOÚ:GIÚ:Zkx\ZdJcZkCjb‹ORN-L#ObfJPORQ4JKÔ:C

(9)

60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100

0 50 100 150 200

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

<Zk|V`HcCÂâWy#s WE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJ1HcCFbKV`xdJlbÛPZkJKÔ0HcCFbKE²CjY›J1JcO!Ú²CjbfJKÙµbKOIÙ>Q‰GIH1Ü`JKN`CjbKbAGI|GIZ\N:bfJCFa¡GRxdÙ

V:GIJKZ\ORN:bžOIQPÖ×DbžÛPZkJKÔpWZ(C]HcC]NJLV`JcG£JcZkONOE²CFHcGIJKORHlb_ON N:C[Ùªó³G!E`HcORÚ`x\C]L,{ÓŸÔ:C

p`GIJcG#ÛUCFHKCG¡aC]HlGI|RCjpgO£aRCFHtFñRñAHcV`N:bF{

JKCjbfJ1E:HKOÚ`xkCFLgb]{ovDO£ÛUCFaRC]HjqrZkJcbE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLMGRN:Y[CMZibbmCFHKZ\ORV²bmx\e!JKÔ:CgÛUOHcbmJžONHcO£eGRx6HKOGRp

Q¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bG=

)

GIN:p?=

,

{³ÓŸÔ:Z\bÔ:GIE`E?C]N²b1Ú?CFY]GRV:bKCoOIQPZkJcb1ۋORHlbmJY[ORN²bfJcHKV:Y[JKZ\ORNE?O£ÛUCFH

Q¿ORHAÚ`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|Ú`xkOWYl~WbF{-ӟÔ`Zib1C`GILME`x\CobmÔ`O£Û_bJKÔ:GIJJKÔ:CoE²CFHmQ¿OHKLgGRN:Y[CgORQ‹JcHcGpWZkJKZ\ORN:GRx

Ú`ZkJžLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN!ÛPZkJKÔÜWCFp!LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN!E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfeÂÔ:CFG¡aZkx\e,pWC]E?C]N:p:bDON!JKÔ`CAE`HcORÚ`x\C]L

Ü`JcN`CFbcbPxiGIN:p`bcY]GRE²C{

ӟÔ`Z\HcpÄq²XW×DÝ^DóÞE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLgbŸLV:YlÔ,Ú?C[JmJcC]HPJcÔ:GIN-JcHcGpWZdJcZkON:GIxrLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN,ORE?C]HlG£JcORHlb

ORNHcO£eGRx<HcOGp!Q¿V`N²Y›JKZ\ORN²b>=

)

GIN:p = ,

ՉbKC]C <Zk|V`HcC؛{ ӟÔ:Z\bZib1pWV:CMJKO,JKÔ:CobfJcHKON`|

Ú`V`Z\xipWZkN:|äÚ`xkOWYl~Wb#Ú`V`Z\xdJoZ\NßJKÔ`C!HcO£eGRxUHcOGpäQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bF{BDV`HcZ\N`|$JKÔ`C!CjGIHcxke0bmJcGR|RC-OIQ

bKCFGIHlYlÔ`Z\N`|#Ö×bŸÛPZdJcÔ JcHcGpWZkJKZ\ORN:GRx²Ú`ZkJPLVWJlG£JcZkONÂE?C]HKQ¿ORHcL Ú²C]JmJcC]HŸJKÔ²GINoJcÔ`C1Ö×ÛPZdJcÔ

XW×ÝD^Dó0{`v_O£Û‹C]aRCFHFqG£QJcC]HPY[CFHmJlGIZ\NoC]a£GIx\V:GIJKZ\ORN:bFqÛPÔ:C]NÂbKORLMCV:bmC]Q¿V`x(Ú`V`Z\x\p`ZkN`|#Ú`x\OWYl~b

Ô:GbÚ?C]CFNÚ`V`Z\xkJMV:E0JKÔ:C,Ö× ÛPZdJcÔàXW×ÝD^ó |HKCjG£JKx\e$ORVWJcE²CFHmQ¿OHKLgbMÖ×Db#ÛPZdJcÔ0JcHcGIÙ

pWZkJKZ\ORN:GRxÚ`ZkJ1LV`JcG£JcZkONäÚ²CjY]GRV:bmC X`×DÝD^ó C[çoY[Z\C]NJcxkeG¡aROZ\p`bžLAVWJcGIJKZ\N`|,JKÔ`ObmCoY]ORNWÙ

aRCFHK|CFpxkOWY[ZzÛPÔ:C]HcC#Ú:V`ZkxipWZ\N`|!Ú`x\OWYl~bGRxkHcCFGpWe,Q¿ORV`N²p$bKOÂQ‰GIHHcCFbKZ\pWC{MXWZkLMZ\x\GRHHKCjbmV`xkJcb

Y]GRN Ú?COÚ:bmCFHKaCFpONÀhrÙfXW×zÓåE`HcORÚ:xkCFLMb$ՉbKC]C <Zk|V`HKC ØÂGRbÂORN HcO£eGRx_HcOGRpàQ¿V:N:Y›Ù

JKZ\ORN²b]{ӟÔ`C#Ö×ÇÛPZkJKÔ$X`×DÝD^ó ZibDÚ?CFGIJKCFNÚe³Ö×DbÛPZdJcÔ³JKHlGRp`ZdJcZkON:GIx¾Ú`ZdJLV`JcG£JcZkON

ÛPZkJKԁì í ñññ`tDGRN:pì í t_¤uRé_!WÕ$# % '()+*-,jØTpWV`HcZ\N`|1JcÔ`CDCjGIHcxkeMbfJlGI|C_OIQ¾bKCFGRHcYlÔ:ZkN`|²{

v_O£Û‹C]aC]Hjq£G£QJKCFHzY[C]HKJcGRZkNC]a£GIx\V:G£JcZkON:b4JKÔ`C_Ö×àÛPZdJcÔ#XW×ÝD^ó OVWJKE?C]HKQ¿ORHcLgb<Ö×b<ÛPZdJcÔ

JKHlGRp`ZdJcZkON:GIxrÚ`ZkJ_LV`JcG£JcZkONÄ{

<ZkN²GIx\xkeqRGRb6HcCFY]OR|RN:ZkæFCFpÚe1ORJKÔ`CFHzHKCjbmCjGIHlYlÔ`C]Hlb]qFJKÔ:CŸYlÔ:ORZiY[CŸOIQ?LVWJlG£JKZ\ORN#ORE?C]HlG£JcORHlb

GIN²pÂE:HKOE²CFH‹E:HKOÚ:GIÚ`Z\x\ZdJcZkCjbŸZkN,|RCFN`C[JcZ\YGRxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`LgbUHcCFGRxkx\eoÔ:GbPGMbmZ\|RN`ZkܲYFGINJPC(CFY›J_ON

(10)

10 20 30 40 50 60 64

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 0.01 Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 192

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 0.01 Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

ՉGØ Õ¿Ú²Ø

<Z\|RV`HcC :y(s WE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJHcCFbKV`xkJcbÛPZdJcÔHcCFbKE²CjY›JJKO-Ú²CjbfJKÙµbKOIÙ>Q‰GIHDÜ`JKN`CjbKbGR|GIZ\N:bmJCFa¡GRxkV`Ù

GIJKZ\ORN:bPORQÖ×DbÛPZdJcÔ³pWZ(C]HcC]NJžLVWJlG£JKZ\ORN!OE²CFHcGIJKOHcbŸON³nPO£eGRxÄnPOGp=`V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:bAՉGØ

= )

GIN:p$Õ¿Ú?ØI=

,

{TӟÔ`Cp`G£JlGMÛUCFHKCG¡aRCFHcGR|RCjpgO£aRCFHžtjñRñAHKV:N:b]{

460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600

0 50 100 150 200

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 0.01 Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

320 340 360 380 400 420 440

0 50 100 150 200

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 0.01 Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

ՉGØ Õ¿Ú²Ø

<Z\|RV`HcCA²y<s E?C]HcZ\L#CFNJAHcCFbKV`xdJlbÛPZkJKÔßHKCjbmE?CFY[JJcOÚ?CFbmJmÙªbmORÙ¬Q‰GRH1Ü`JcN`CFbcbAGR|GRZkN:bmJACFa£GIxkÙ

V:GIJKZ\ORN:bžORQŸÖ×DbÛPZkJKÔpWZ?CFHKCFNJLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNORE?C]HlG£JKOHcbORN$BDCjY[CFEWJKZ\aRC `V:N:Y›JcZkON:bgՉGØ

143 GIN²p$Õ‰Ú²Ø 143 {TӟÔ:Cp:G£JcG#ۋC]HcCG¡aRC]HlGI|CFpgO£aC]HtFññHcV`N:bF{

(11)

0.95 0.96 0.97 0.98 0.99 1

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

0.9 0.91 0.92 0.93 0.94 0.95 0.96

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

ՉGØ Õ¿Ú²Ø

0.9 0.905 0.91 0.915 0.92 0.925 0.93 0.935

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800

Best-So-Far Fitness

Evaluations ( x 100 ) SANUM 1/L Bit Mut 1.75/(N*L^(1/2)) Bit Mut 0.001 Bit Mut

Õ¬YFØ

<Zk|V`HcC-éWy6s WE?C]HcZkLMCFNJ#HKCjbmV:xdJlbÛPZkJKÔßHKCjbmE?CFY[JJKO$Ú?CFbmJmÙªbmORÙ¬Q‰GRH1Ü`JcN`CFbcbAGR|GRZkN:bmJCFa¡GRxdÙ

V:GIJKZ\ORN:bÂOIQÖ×Db-ÛPZkJKÔ p`Z(C]HcC]NJÂLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN OE²CFHcGIJKOHcbgON hrÙfXW×zÓåE`HcORÚ`x\C]Lgb ÛPZdJcÔ

f tjñRñ`q.0

-GIN:pßՉGØx\O£Û%C]E`ZibmJcGRbKZib#D

âRñRñ`q6Õ¿Ú?ØDLMCjpWZkV:L·C]E`ZibmJcGRbKZib#D

t¡âIñRñ:q

GIN²p$Õ¬YF؋Ô`Z\|RÔ-C]E:Z\bmJcGbmZibID â ñRñ:{<ӟÔ:C1p`G£JlGAۋC]HcCG¡aRC]HlGI|CFpgO£aC]HtFññHcV`N:bF{

Y]GRN³GRp39fV²bfJ_JcÔ`C1LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORN!E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfeÂGp`GIEWJcZkaC]x\eoÛPZkJKÔ!JcÔ`C1E`HcORÚ`x\C]L Ü`JKN:CFbcb_xiGIN:pÙ

bcY]GIE?CUGRN:pÛPZkJKԁJKÔ`CUE`HKO|RHcCFbcbrOIQ`|C]N`C]JKZiYbKCFGRHcYlÔ`Z\N`|_Zib¾HKCjGIx\xkežLMCFGIN:ZkN`|RQ¿V`xQ¿ORH<ZkLME`HcO£aÙ

(12)

èªNßJKÔ`ZibME:GRE²CFHoGbmJcGIJKZibfJcZ\YFbfÙµÚ:GRbKCFpßGRp`GREWJKZ\aRC-N`ONWÙ>V:N`ZdQ¿OHKL LVWJlG£JKZ\ORN4q‹XW×ÝD^Dó0qTZ\b

E`HcORE?ObKCFpßQ¿OH |RCFN`C[JcZ\YGIx\|RORHcZkJKÔ`LgboӟÔ`CL#ORJKZ\a£G£JKZ\ORN OIQXW×DÝ^Dó Zib JKO0LgGI~C!V:bKC

ORQPJKÔ`C-bfJlG£JKZibmJKZiY]bAZkNWQ¿OHKLgGIJKZ\ORN0Z\LME`xkZiY[ZkJKx\e0Y[ONJcGIZ\N`CjpZkNJKÔ`CÂE²OE`V`xiG£JKZ\ORNCWE`x\Z\Y]ZdJcxke

JcO$|V`ZipWC,JKÔ`C!LAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNORE?C]HlG£JcZkONÄ{ XW×DÝ^Dó GYlÔ`ZkCFaRCjbJcÔ`ZiboÚe0V:bKZkN:|JcÔ`CGRxkx\C]x\C

pWZibmJKHcZkÚ`V`JKZ\ORNäZ\NJKÔ`C Y]V`HcHKCFNJ1E?ORE:V`x\GIJKZ\ORNJcOGRp39fV²bfJ1JcÔ`CoLAVWJcGIJKZ\ORNäE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJfe³Q¿OH

CjGRYlÔo|C]N`CžxkOWY]V:bPGRp`GREWJKZ\aRCFxkegpWV:HKZ\N`|AJKÔ`CE`HcOR|HKCjbKbOIQ4JcÔ`CÖ×1{`ӟÔ`HcORV`|ÔÂpWCjY[HcCFGbmZ\N`|

JcÔ`CLVWJlG£JKZ\ORN-E`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Z\xkZkJKZ\CFb‹ORNÂJKÔ:ObKCY]ORNaRCFHK|CFpMx\OWY[Z4XW×ÝD^DóÞYFGIN,bKG¡aCDLV`JcG£JcZkON

OE²CFHcGIJKZ\ORN:b‹ÛŸGRbmJKCFpÂORNÂJKÔ:C]L,{

ӟÔ`CTCWE²CFHKZ\LMC]NJcGRxIHKCjbmV:xdJlb(OIQJKÔ`ZibÄbmJKV:p`ežpWCFLMORN:bmJKHlG£JcC¾JcÔ:G£J4JKÔ`CUÖ×0ÛPZdJcԁXW×DÝ^Dó

E?C]HKQ¿ORHcLgbUE?C]HlbKZ\bmJKCFNJcxke ÛUCFxkxrO£aC]HŸGAÛPZipWCHlGIN`|CORQ4JKCjbfJPE`HcORÚ:xkCFLMb‹ÛPÔ`Z\x\CJKÔ`CE?C]HKQ¿ORHKÙ

LgGIN²Y[CŸOIQrÖ×DbzÛPZkJKÔ#JKHlGRp`ZdJcZkON:GIxWÚ`ZkJTLV`JcG£JcZkONAÛPZkJKÔgpWZ(C]HcC]NJ6ÜWCFp#LVWJlG£JcZkONAE`HcORÚ`Ù

GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJKZ\CFbŸ|RHcCFGIJKx\eopWC]E?C]N²p`bPORNÂJKÔ:CE`HKOÚ`x\C]L V`N:p`C]HDY]ORN:bKZ\p`C]HlG£JKZ\ORN4{<ӟÔ`CCE?C]HcZ\L#CFNJ

HcCFbKV`xkJcbZkN:p`Z\YFG£JKCJKÔ:GIJX`×DÝD^ó HcC]E`HcCFbKC]NJlbDGoHcORÚ:V:bfJžGRp`GREWJKZ\aRCALVWJlG£JKZ\ORNORE?C]HlG£JKOH

JcÔ:G£JŸN`C]Cjp`bUN`OAE:HKZ\ORHU~N:O£ÛPxkCjpW|RCžGIÚ?ORVWJUJKÔ`CžE`HcORÚ`x\C]L Ü`JcN`CFbcbUx\GRN:p`bcY]GIE?CGRN:pgJcÔ:G£JŸZkJ

ZibPG#|ROOWpÂYFGIN:pWZip`GIJKCLV`JcG£JcZkONÂOE²CFHcGIJKOHUQ¿OHDÖ×DbF{

XZ\N:Y[CXW×ÝD^Dó ÛUOHK~WbUG£JJcÔ`CDÚ?OIJKJKOLAÙµx\C]aRCFx²ORQÄLVWJlG£JcZkONÄqZkJPY]GIN Ú²CCFGRbKZ\xkegY[OL#Ù

Ú`Z\N`Cjp!ÛPZdJcÔ³OIJcÔ`C]HžGRp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORN-JKCjYlÔ`N`ZKV`CFbDQ¿ORHLVWJlG£JKZ\ORN³GRN:p³YFGIN³GRY[JGRb_JKÔ`CAÚ:GRbKZib

Q¿OH#GRN:GIx\eæ]Z\N`|GRN:ppWCjbmZ\|RN:ZkN`|N`C]Û HKCFx\GIJKCjp0GIx\|ROHKZkJKÔ`LgbF{èªN0JKÔ:Z\bgbmJKV:p`eRqG$bmZ\LME`x\C

JcHKZiGIN`|V`xiGIHQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN0ZibAV:bmCjp$JKOYFGIxiY[V`xiG£JcCgJKÔ:C LV`JcG£JcZkONäE`HcORÚ:GRÚ`Zkx\ZkJfe³Q¿ORHACFGYlÔäxkORÙ

Y]V:b]{JDJKÔ`CFH<Q¿V`N:Y›JcZkON:b6bmV²YlÔAGRb¾CWE?ORN`CFNJKZiGIxQ¿V`N:Y[JKZ\ORN:b<Z\N:bfJcCFGp1LgG¡eQ¿V`HKJKÔ`CFH<Z\LME`HcO£aRC

Ö×8bE²CFHmQ¿OHKLgGIN²Y[CRq¾ÛPÔ`ZiYlÔäZ\bORN`CgQ¿V`JKV`HcCoۋORHc~GIÚ?ORVWJMXW×DÝ^Dóä{TSUORLME:GRHKZ\N`|!ORÚ`Ù

JlGIZ\N`CFpX`×DÝD^óÈÛPZkJKÔAOIJKÔ:C]H¾Gp`GIE`JcG£JcZkONJKCjYlÔ`N`ZKV:CFb4Q¿ORH<LVWJlG£JKZ\ORNZ\b<GIN`ORJKÔ`CFHÄQ¿VWJcV`HcC

ۋORHc~oGIÚ?ORVWJDXW×ÝD^óä{

C C C_Í CDË,Ñ CI

ákt[ã1BA{4v1{r×Yl~x\C]eßÕft21\@uR؛{JSSa-XWQSQVUP _X-[ QTS DN SaWQYX.QTTXQTOQTSR{

‹ObmJKONÄq`ó³×y:wxkVۋC]HP×DYFGRpWCFLMZ\YSdV`Ú`x\Z\bKÔ`C]HlbF{

áâ¡ã.²{¾sD{KŸGI~C]HoÕft 1 @uI؛{¾nPCFpWV²Y[Z\N`|³Ú`ZiGRbAGIN:p$Z\N`C[çoY[Z\C]N²Y[eZkNJcÔ`C bKC]x\CFY[JKZ\ORN0GIx\|RORÙ

HcZdJcÔ`Lgb]{?èªN ²{ ²{?֞HcC[Q¿CFN:bmJKC]x\x\CÂÕ¿Cjpr{¤Ø›q^N X SaLPS FS D S SaWQYX \

NPQT[]O U›qÄt RÙªâ`tR{Wh4G¡ÛPHcC]N:Y]CžsHKx\Ú:GRV`L ×DbcbKOY]Z\GIJKCjb]{

á£ã1Ó{ GRYl~¸Õft 1 1âR؛{6XC]xkQÙª×Dp`GREWJcGIJKZ\ORNZ\Nà֞CFN`C[JcZ\Y-×_x\|ROHKZkJKÔ:LMbF{<èªN ‹{ :{TGIHcC]xiG

GRN:pJd6{ ‹ORV`Hc|RZ\N`C#Õ¿CFp:b]{¤Ø›q^N 2X& ( T[ G UP* N -`ZSFS&DJSNPWQ XQY Q[q

â £ÙfâuWtR{ó!èfÓ dTHcCFbcb]{

áIã1Ó{ GRYl~Õft 1 1uR؛{6ó!VWJlG£JKZ\ORN dzGIHlGILMC[JcC]Hlb]{ÄèªNàÓ{ GYl~?qTBA{ ž{ :OR|RCFx¬qTGRN:p<{

ó!ZiYlÔ:GRxkCFÛPZ\Y]æÕ¿Cjp`bF{Ø[q SaL! #"/ $^b $QS N&%'FO`+ $QS:qIs_t{â`{kt]ÙµsDtR{¤âW{‘u{

Q¿ORHlp-^_N`Z\aRCFHcbKZdJfe dTHcCFbcb]{

áé¡ã1BA{SUOHKN`Cq d6{RnPObKbzGRN:pMv1{Ùµh{ :GRN`|oÕft 1 1 ؛{RÖ׸n_CFbKCFGIHlYlÔMÝ_OIJcCuy :GRbmJ;dTHlGRY[Ù

JcZ\YFGIx`sTaORx\VWJKZ\ORN²GIHcežÓŸZ\LMC[JcGRÚ`x\ZkN`|²{)(ZXZ[]SQYX-+*M` NP>qRBDCFE:GIHKJKLMCFNJzORQ²×_HKJKZkܲY[ZiGIx

(13)

BA{XWYlÔ:G?CFHPÕ¿CFpÄ{Ø[q ^N X&;( [

N-LPS2)FS&D S SaWQYX NPQTT[ O8U›q Rñ£Ù 1:{

XWGRN-óG£JKCFO S‹×1y:ó!OHK|GIN-wGIVWQ¿LgGIN:NVdV`Ú`x\Z\bKÔ`C]HlbF{

á¤ujã1wM{:ׁ{:BC8RON`|!Õft 1uIé؛{S S %3UZQVU.[Z[b2QN, 8 BUZU (' S $QYX

L Z` WQTb3 %3UP O8U›{9dTÔ:B ӟÔ`CFbKZib]q(BDCFE:GIHKJKLMCFNJžOIQ‹SUOL#E:VWJKCFHGIN²pSUORLMLV:N`ZdÙ

YFG£JKZ\ORN!XWY]ZkCFN:Y[Cjb]q`^DN`ZkaC]HlbmZkJfeoORQ6ó!ZiYlÔ`Z\|GRNÄqW×_N`N³×DÚ²OHF{

á@£ã1wM{<×1{6BDC/RON`|:q6óä{6×1{.d6OIJmJcC]HGRN:p I%{6óä{zXE²CjGIHlb Õmt21 1uIØ[{4^DbKZkN:|³E`HcORÚ`x\C]L

|C]N`CFHcGIJKORHlb6JcOCWE`x\ORHcCPJcÔ`CDC?CjY›JcbUOIQ¾C]E`ZibfJlGRbKZ\bF{RèªNÂÓ{"GRYl~,Õ¿Cjpr{¤Ø›q^N X&- [

T[ S JS DS SaWQYX NPQT[]O U›qK_ @£ÙM éW{(XWGINó³G£JcC]O²q¾S‹×1yÄó!OHK|GIN

wGRVWQ¿LgGIN`NQdTV`Ú:xkZibmÔ:C]Hlb]{

á1£ã1ׁ{`s_{`sTZ\Ú?C]NÄq`n{`vDZkNJcC]HlpWZkN:|MGRN:p 6{`ó!Z\YlÔ²GIx\C]ÛPZiY[æMÕft21_1 1؛{edzGIHlGILMC[JcC]H‹Y[ORNJcHKOx

Z\N CFaRORx\VWJcZkON:GIHceàGRxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`Lgb]{ (N SU S ^b $QS N&% FO` MWQS

Õ¬â؛y\tjâRÙct :t{

áktFñ£ã1Ó{²S{:OR|GRHmJfe!Õmt21 @_1Ø[{ TGRHKeZ\N`|AJKÔ`CSdTHcORÚ²GIÚ`Z\xkZkJfeMOIQ6ó!VWJcGIJKZ\ORN-ZkNÂJKÔ:C֞CFN`C[JcZ\Y

×Dxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`L,{`èªN :{²B{(XWYlÔ:G(C]HAÕ¿CFpÄ{Ø[q ^N2X&F(8T[ N L PS2 FS&D S S $QYX

NPQT[]O U›qÄtFñ IÙltFñ_1`{WXWGIN,ó³G£JcC]O²q²S‹×1y:ó!OHK|GIN-wGIVWQ¿LgGIN:NQdV`Ú`x\Z\bKÔ`CFHcbF{

áktRt[ã.²{"²{W֞HKC]Q¿C]N:bmJKC]JmJKCMÕft 1 @ ؛{ EWJKZ\LMZkæjG£JcZkONoOIQ6SUONJKHcORx dzGRHcGRLMC[JKCFHcb<Q¿OHŸÖžCFN`C[JcZ\Y

×Dxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`Lgb]{ (N SU S %3UZMO8U S S L $%!ZNPSaWQYXUlq4ÕmtjØ[yžt¡âRâ£Ù

t¡â @`{

áktjâ¡ã1BA{rs_{?֞Ox\p`Ú²CFHK|$Õft21\@ 1؛{ S $QYX NPQTT[ O8URQTS7ZN XZ[ K` WQTO Q WQS S L

XZ[]QTSa ZNPSQTSR{:nPCjGRpWZ\N`|:q²ó³×1y:×p`pWZibmONWÙ2ICjbmx\C]e{

ákt2£ã1BA{?sD{(֞Ox\p`Ú²CFHK|²qž{?wOHKÚ³GRN:p!wM{(BDCFÚÕft 1 @ 1؛{?ó!CFbcbme!֞C]N:C[JKZiY×Dxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`Lgb]y

ó!ORJKZ\a£G£JKZ\ORN4q`×_N:GRxkeWbKZ\bFq`GIN:p@<Z\HcbmJ_nPCFbKV`xkJcbF{ FO` %3UPMO U›q4yJ²tjé¡Ù2 :{

ákt Iã.²{vDCFbcbmCFHUGRN:pon{ó GIN:N`C]HžÕft21_1`t¡Ø›{Ó¾O£ÛŸGIHlp`bTGIN EWJKZ\LgGIx²ó³VWJcGIJKZ\ORN dHKOÚ:GIÚ:ZkxkÙ

ZkJfe³Z\Nä֞CFN`C[JcZ\Yg×Dxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`Lgb]{rèªNv1{Ùd6{¾XWYlÔÛUC]Q¿C]x>q4n{4ó GIN`N`CFHgÕ¿CFp:b]{¤Ø›q ^N X

[

G

UP JS DFS N T^N !O+b2QTS ZN O8 N ]q:âIÙâW{

áktjé¡ã.²{rv1{Äv_OxkxiGIN²p0Õft 1uIé؛{L_-`a$QS QTS8 N S LNP$Q ^XQY %3UP O8U›{r×_N:N

×DHKÚ?ORHjq`^_N`Z\aRCFHcbKZkJfeoOIQ6ó!Z\YlÔ:Zk|GINQdTHcCFbcb]{

ákt £ã.ž{]RV`xibmJKHcORLåÕft21_1é؛{ I¸Ô:GIJUÔ:G¡aC_eROVopWORN:CPQ¿ORH‹LMCDxiG£JKCFxkeGRp`GREWJKZ\N`|1OE²CFHcGIJKOH

E`HcORÚ²GIÚ`Z\xkZkJKZ\CFbŸZ\N³GgbmJKCFGpWeÙµbmJcGIJKC|RCFN`C[JcZ\YGRxk|ORHcZdJcÔ`L,{WèªN!hT{²{:sbKÔ`CFxkLgGINäՉCFpr{¤Ø›q

^N 2X& ( T[! 3['S FS&DJS SaWQYX NPQT[]O U›q @`t]ÙF@u{X`GINÂóG£JKCFO:q`S‹×1y

ó!OHK|GIN-wGIVWQ¿LgGIN:NVdV`Ú`x\Z\bKÔ`C]HlbF{

ákt¡ujã.²{?h4C]aC]N`ZiYl~$Õmt21_1éRØ[{²ó!C]JcGRÚ`ZdJlb]yD֞CFN`C[JcZ\Y#sTN²pWOR|C]N`OV:bžSUHcObcbmO£aC]HDSUORNJcHKOx¬{?èªN

h{a²{rsbKÔ`C]x\LgGINՉCFpr{¤Ø›q$^N X *(R[" T[S FS D*S S $QYX NPQTT[ O8U›q

@\@£ÙM1éW{WXWGRN,óG£JKCFO:q²S‹×y:ó!ORHc|GRNÂwGRVWQ¿LgGIN`NQdTV`Ú:xkZibmÔ:C]Hlb]{

ákt @£ã1óä{‹ó!ZkJcYlÔ`CFxkx>q_X({ :ORHcHKCjbfJoGIN²p0²{Uv{UvDORx\x\GRN:pÕft21_1â؛{TӟÔ`Cn_O£eGIxPnPOGRpßQ¿ORH

֞CFN`C[JcZ\Y-×_x\|ROHKZkJKÔ`LgbFy ¾ZkJKN:CFbcbAh¾GIN:p`bcY]GRE²CjbGRN:pÖ×d6C]HKQ¿ORHcLMGRN:Y[C{ÄèªN ‹{ :{

TGRHKCFx\G!GRN:p?d6{‹ORV`Hc|RZ\N`C³Õ‰CFp`bF{Ø[q^N X [

G

UP N Z`ZS FS&NS XZ S

Références

Documents relatifs

[r]

On souhaite projeter une mire, succession d’un grand nombre de bandes opaques et transparentes de même largeur a = 0, 25 mm grâce à une lentille de vergence V = 10 Dioptrie..

Un calculette programmable ou un tableur font apparaître une stabilité autour de 5 pour les 100 premiers termes, puis vers 7 ensuite, ce qui laisserait entendre que la

A la grande table se trouvent les adultes et les adolescents dont les âges sont égaux à tous les produits des âges des plus jeunes pris deux à deux.. Déterminer les âges de tous

En effet, on peut facilement montrer que l'espérance du nombre de parties jouées est donnée pour un triplet (a,b,c)

D´ evelopper cette fonction en s´ erie de

[r]

En particulier comme y-qx = r &lt; x, nous nous ramenons au même problème, mais avec un triplet réordonné (x',y',z') tel que x'&lt;x. Le minimum des trois ne pouvant