HAL Id: tel-00010621
https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00010621
Submitted on 13 Oct 2005
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
un contexte d’intelligence économique
Najoua Bouaka
To cite this version:
Najoua Bouaka. Développement d’un modèle pour l’explicitation d’un problème décisionnel: un outil
d’aide à la décision dans un contexte d’intelligence économique. domain_stic.inge. Université Nancy
II, 2004. Français. �tel-00010621�
Ecole doctorale Langages, Temps, Soci´ ´ et´ es
D´ eveloppement d’un mod` ele pour l’explicitation d’un probl` eme d´ ecisionnel : un outil d’aide ` a la
d´ ecision dans un contexte d’intelligence
´ economique
TH` ESE
pr´esent´ee et soutenue publiquement le 13 d´ecembre 2004 pour l’obtention du
Doctorat de l’universit´ e Nancy 2
(sp´ ecialit´ e Sciences de l’information et de la communication) par
Najoua BOUAKA
Composition du jury Pr´ esident : Le pr´esident
Rapporteurs : Viviane COUZINET : Professeur `a l’Universit´e de Toulouse 3.
Philippe DUMAS : Professeur `a l’Universit´e de Toulon et du Var
Examinateurs : Amos DAVID : Professeur `a l’Universit´e de Nancy 2 (Directeur de th`ese).
Louis-Philippe LAPREVOTE : Professeur `a l’Universit´e de Nancy 2.
Odile THIERY : Professeur `a l’Universit´e de Nancy 2.
Laboratoire Lorrain de Recherche en Informatique et ses Applications — UMR 7503
! ! #" ! %$ '&(# !*)#,+ -.0/1
2
354 ! # 6"0 ! /17& *)
8 !9 ! .6"
! !# : <;% .= # # # <$ '&?> !*)%@+
AB C7& #*) 6 A D& 8) *4 /17&% E" !*)$ D&F) *
"
! ! G "! :H #JI # :H # #. !" !# :$ D&F 8)%K L
M N/1 #*)O *) # ! 2 8)@P" ! QSRT TLU 6!"
3# *# T6 ! "
V 2 #W #" ! ,X% ; 37Y Z#
6!O/1[\& T @7& ']\& 9 !#
#* " ! *) * @Q^# G `_a ! "
V @)V # .b 9/1 '&Q E" !*)@$P c) *N/`# #
!# d N # )G# 6"
@$ 8) < a "V ,e@,+f) JL #
g" !# 3#V "O 6U]&(#U 36 T6 !
!/1 # ! # V # # # *)% 6!"0h@7& !#
'&i_# # !j# !" 8#"
A$ ! ."k)V l '& m;%) # n #o #
# 0]& #*),]&() 3 < d/1 %9 @" !
! V i_# p) !G "
! !<)V m) 8 m@;@=qnnSrJn`+<s#rt=u# D&(> # !8)G@K L MSv !#I
Mww -s Mwwxzy A7& i_ N) 3 *)j : !UV CR! k
O){#< # #B7&." * "
V
2
: D&F)/1 n{r|+= # V */1:/1]j& f)@$
! "
*# gb !S\ V "m ! <\ ! !
} mn## Y/1\& T)c ! P f~ # V
VN @" T6 ! ! V ! # V $ N 3\7n 3
Gn8) 7& *U\& # # )<7&(# ! f 2 # "
(*$+'-,/.0'1
2435+(6
! #"$%&'(*)+,)+-/.10 2*2
i_ " """ "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
M 2 3) 3/1 zL 6 "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" CM
- n * 8 !,\O) ! " " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" 3
46587:9:;=<?>?@BAC9:589EDF<HGJI&587+9 >LK
MON
-QPR%S0T2UWVX%&0+.Y.&%1('0+!"Z0[)+"Z,'\T%&] !00^_.10a`80+bc'%&%&!de*f\g-Q%&'!!0+. 2+h
" r !{# "" "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" Mw
"M
;%)b# * " "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
Mw
"(- ; $ D& <) 3/1 "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
M -
"(-#" n`L!86V 7&." * S "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" M -
"?- " " ikjJlXm$lSnporq+orsXtvu$oJlSsSswo "" "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" M -
"?- " "M xylzB{Jj|oJn/}1~y}&/o~Oq+oru$oJlSsSswo " " "" """ "" """ " "" "" - w
"(-#"
M
n`L!86V 7&." * S. ! "" """ "" """ " "" "" - M
"(-#"(- r ) 3/1 " """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" - x
"(-#"
x ; fN) ! D& #%)# f/1 " " "" "" -^
"x r #) 3/1 # " "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" -Z
"3 r| #Q D&." T \O) ! P '& ,) I
3/1 " " """ "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" x1M
"3 " ;%)Vb# |L @ D&{" * " """ "" """ " "" "" x -
"3 " " x{1 n/lS}YlfnQ~ " "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" x -
"3 " "M xoq+fn/np{o~_sXt6fn/n't$lw~~ct$npo " """ "" """ " "" "" x -
"3 "
"(-
/fswm$loq+oyslSnfjt$}Ylfn
" "" """ "" """ " "" ""
x^
"3 " "x LsXtf~~Jl kt$}YlfnoJnfnpJ}Ylfnq+o~~f:j|o~
"" """ " "" ""
x
"3 " "3 LsXtf~~Jl kt$}Ylfn6~oJswfn sXt[q+oJt$n'q+o
" "" """""" "" ""
x
"3 " " LsXtf~~1 kt$}Ylfn6~oJswfn sXtF n't$slS} { "" "" """""" "" "" x
"3 "M H #G9 D&." * "" ""
3w
" #3# "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" 3w
MON - P#%10v"^" +b . VX%&!d'f\g-:%&' * %10+)| ,%&.&%Ybc-:0+ !
M " r !{. "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" 3#x
M "M *) !!3/1<]&( ! T%.) _ """""" "" "" 3#x
M "M " # TL I #Q)! "" """""" "" "" 3Z3
M "M " " cqJswox
" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
3$
M "M " "M Z}=oJnQ~JlfnQ~m$n/lS}&lSu$o~q$ _cqJswo|x
"""""" "" ""
3
M "M " "?- Z}=oJnQ~JlfnQ~[q+f lSn't$n/} o /~J^/fswm$lc/oq$_cqJswox w
M "M "M ;%)! _ "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" .
M "M "M " f'swoZlS}={rq+oyslSnfjt$}Ylfn """ "" """""" "" "" zM
M "M "M "M B~ /oJ}S~ fn/}oZ}Y/oJs~q+orsXtCq+{Jlw~Jlfn
"" """""" "" ""
zM
M "M "(- n`L 6 """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" x
M
"(- n`L 86 <7&." * ]&f$Q)! "" "" """""" "" ""
^3
M "(-#" n`L!*6 <7&." T "" "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" ^3
M
"(-#"
" x{1 n/lS}&lfnQ~
" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
^3
M "(-#" "M /fswm$lo~rq+o~B~J~J}J_o~Oq!lSnfjJt$}&lfn """"" "" ""
M
"(-#"
"?-
n/}!"~o
"" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" x
M "(-#"M n`L!*6 <7&39$ Q) " " "" """ "" """""" "" "" x
M
"(-#"
M " x{1 n/lS}&lfnQ~
" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" x
M "(-#"M "M /fswm$lorq+o~ ~J~J}#J_o~rq!t$l&q+o_sXtCq+{Jlw~Jlfn """ "" "" 3
M
"(-#"
M
"?-
n/}!"~o
"" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" w
M "x `) c '&(# # " """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" w
M "x "
`6 D&F# "" "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
M "x " " $Bo~flSnq!+n _cqJswoq+oys+}&lSslw~ct$}=oJ+j " """""" "" ""
M "x " "M t$}={m+fjlw~ct$}&lfnq+o~y_cqJswo~q+o s:}&lSslw~ct$}=oJ+j
""" "" ""
M "x " "?- cqJswoOq+ors+}&lSslw~ct$}=oJ+jq^t$nQ~rswo~ ~J~J}J_o~Oq+orjo/oJj|/o
q!lSnfjt$}Ylfn """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" M
M "x "M
X/1d\ {6@#'&( V """ "" """""" "" "" 3
M "x "M " B%c+lw~JlS}&lfna~J}et$}&lc*o " " "" """ "" """""" "" "" 3
M "x "M "M B%c+lw~JlS}&lfn q$ n't$ lc/o
" "" """ "" """""" "" ""
M x M B%c+lw~JlS}Ylfn lZ} o
M "3 3! "" "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
46587:9:;=<
@ 9+7 ; 9:;
MON -QPR%S0 rf*P8'b%S%1g VX !\g +.10CP8' ! .=V0PR.&%Y"^%S-Q%&' VX !EP!'`#. :\ 0
,):"^%&b%1'#,0+. h2
-#" r !{# "" "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" zM
-#"M 2
36 )!#l i_ ,]& @) 3/1 " "" -
-#"M " ! 2 f) f/`# " " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" -
-#"M "M X !~ `) @ D&F# ] T7&`I
@) 3/1 "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" x
-#"
M
"(- ;%)Vb# d7&F # 2 f6 )!# "" """ "" """ " "" ""
-#"
M "x r *) T4G Q {) c]&( ! 2 36V %) " " "" ""
ww
-#"(- `) 5E]) " 7&F # 2 f6 )!# " "" ""
wx
-#"(-#"
{.) 5.j)f """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
w^3
-#"?- " " }Yfswo m$n/lS}Yl "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" w
-#"?- " "M j t$lS}1~rq+o /oJj~fn/n't$slS} { "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" w
-#"?- " "(- /{JjloJnpo~ " "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" -
-#"?- " "x cq+oJn/}&lS}={ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" x
-#"?- " "3 n/}!"~o "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" x
-#"(-#"M {.) 5#'& # " " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
-#"(-#"(- {.) 5#'& # " "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
-#"
x X # 9 {6@ Q)b \]&( ! 2 36V .) "
CM{
-#"
x "
T)! \\ `6 " """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
CM{
-#"x " " x{1 n/lS}Ylfn q$ 'j| csJ_o "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" CM#x
-#"x " "M xy 'j| csJ_oq+{Jlw~Jlfn/npoJst$ 'j| csJ_oBlSnfjJt$}&lfn/npoJs " CM$
-#"x " "(- {JswoJ}Ylfnq+o~ lSnfjJt$}&lfnQ~k/oJj}&lSnpoJn/}=o~ " """ " "" "" CM
-#"3 3! "" "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" CM
MON -QPR%S0 R0P8) f%Y\g0+-Q%1!f)+b !.S-Qb0^_\T%Yb00+0+ 0 22
x " r !{# "" "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
- M
x "M
;%) _ p) f 5\ {6 j=q ; "" """ " "" ""
- M
x "M " H 8) ! Q/1 """ "" """""" "" ""
--
x "M "M H d {6 J" *O)\5" TQ """"" "" ""
--
x "M
"(- H T* d" *Q# " "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
- 3
x "M "?- " ,o~ t$jt+J} {Jjlw~J}Ylc/o~ylSn'q$lSul&q$/oJsSswo~rq$aq+{Jl&q+oJ:j " "" "" - 3
x "M "?- "M ,o~ Qt$jt$ J}&j|o~q+oysoJn/ulSj|fn/npoJ_oJn/} " """""" "" "" xzw
x "M "?- "?- ,o~ Qt$jt$ J}&j|o~q+oysfjYm^t$n/lw~ct$}&lfn "" """""" "" "" x
x "M "x = 35.\" TQ ! "" "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
x1M
x "M "3
n`L 6 """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
x
x "M "
=_#V # """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
x
x "(- r U= ;H |L O Z# '&! f/`#P 2 36V .)I
!# "" "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
3Z3
x
"(-#"
r ` " " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
3Z3
x "(-#"M ; ! ! #d 2 99.) "" """ "" """""" "" "" 3$
x "(-#"(- ; ! ! #dD& T" @9r U= ; """ "" """""" "" "" 3
x "x #3# "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" "" .
M
'!"^.Y !b%1'(*):,) -/.&00^vP80 fbcP80+"$%'0:b 2
%&`#.Y%1*(*f-QP N %&0 2 p2
- `#.&0a!0+bR(' ,f0+b 22
F< < >
[!,00 Wc'0 fd-/"Z0V0PR.&%&"^%1-:%&'HVX # P#*`R. +\g0E!)+"^%&b%1
,0+. 2
X " r !{. "" """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
Z
X "M K + f/1 "" " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
X "M " X ! * JI "" "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
X "M " " r ` """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
X "M " "M X ! * , sn V """ "" """""" "" "" w
X "M " "?- X ! * JI "" """ "" """""" "" "" zM
X "M "M _ 3/1 " """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
x
X "M "M "
% " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """""" "" ""
^3
M M M Z
X "M "M "?- X # " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" Z
X "M "M "x # \L`X: " """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
X "M "M "3 = TL{ % "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
X "(- K 7&F# """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
X "x K 7& "" " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
Mw
X "x " r ! c= TL{ % " """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
Mw
X "x "M ;%) 3 '& # "" "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" Mw
X "x "(- *) \# 2 99) "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" Mw
[!!00 [) L!%1%&'6!0,"^ #\ 0:'k
P80y0:.&- !(*- (*0r!0r`!-/.Y%&bc- (*0y00+!b%&`#.10
UrP8 ,[.10+b d'f\ !.&-/%10+b 'h
o " *) j# UH "" " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" Mw
o " " G+ UH UH " " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" Mw
o " " "
G+ UH " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
Mw
o " " "M
UH " " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
M{ w
o " "M
n`L _ B UH " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
M{ w
o " "M " H &3# Eb UH " "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" M{ w
o " "M "M H G)3)V UH "" "" " "" """ "" """ " "" "" M{ w
o "M
;%)bd;%+; """ " "" "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
M{CM
o "(- ;%)bd9. |L " "" """ "" " "" """ "" """ " "" ""
M{x
PYSY
H \ # U,) 2 ) D&# ##I
3/1 !* G%" V GQ c */1%/1 . d
#3 #3# @$Q#9) %) 3/1 ". _ {I
T) V 3 3 3 f %7&." T ]/1
CR! *]&1 '& # !
2
f6 G7& 2
3# # ." T # $ V
CR!#8) T) !G$ V #m$ ! * kO4 [7&# "
n :" ." * *) *) [" T 7&I
V :/1 G4 ! *) *) #5)3V f) T)O _ !0/1 # O
_ *) . %$ *) "{H ! T) 5 ." * !
" T 7&. V V#~4 ! T) *) # # ~q)V ! ]& [) 3/1
D&3 fb Q ! 2 f6 ~RT*/17&($'&() 2 B ! )! m$
T)3# "` #*)/1 D& ) f/`# * :#%" ! $ D& ! !!@
# *)#!Qb#: # # A L#[7&." T ,
9 "7 _ f/1 '& *) T4 8)B$ # #@/1 O Q$ # .
*): "
= '& ) 3/1 !q1G<) #</1 T q)
!**)m # 8# *# ! D& ." T I
#D _ #. D& ! !!"`H 2 # # q) 2 [ !
) )# m/`# ! # `! q/1 )8) m D&! "1r
! . A/1 [" V f)[ TV6 p) 8)m7&(# #
