HAL Id: jpa-00248083
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00248083
Submitted on 1 Jan 1994
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Surface ordering and destruction of the first order phase transition smectic A-smectic C* in free standing smectic
films
E. Demikhov, U. Hoffmann, H. Stegemeyer
To cite this version:
E. Demikhov, U. Hoffmann, H. Stegemeyer. Surface ordering and destruction of the first order phase
transition smectic A-smectic C* in free standing smectic films. Journal de Physique II, EDP Sciences,
1994, 4 (10), pp.1865-1874. �10.1051/jp2:1994237�. �jpa-00248083�
J. Phv.v. II Fiance 4 (1994) 1865-1874 OCTOBER 1994, PAGE 1865
Cla,,iiication Ph i'ii (I Ah-Iii a( ii
64.711M 68.15
Surface ordering and destruction of the first order phase
transition smectic A-smectic C* in free standing smectic films
E. Demikhov. U. Hoffmann and H.
Stegemeyer
Univer,ity ol Paderborn, ln,iiiuie oi Phy,real Cheiii,try, 33115 P;tderborn, Germany
(R£>( (»led II M(fi£h 1~94. £i(££>/»e(I m tin£d trim Iii./iii£> /994)
Abstract. The therniodynaniic behitviour ot the fir,t order phJ,e iritn,ition ,meciic A-,meciic C in l'ree ,landing film, i, ,tudied numeric,tlly. Profile, of the tilt angle acro,, the film, the tree
energy ~inii ave<~tge ,iructural p;tr;ii1Jeier, ((M)) ;tad
(co,
(M)) tire calculated. By dimini,hing the number of ,niectic layer, the phJ,e iritn,iiion di,Jppeitr, ii it criticitl lilm ihicLne,, ((, which i,~tpproxiniiitely one order of'mitgnitude litrgcr ih~tn the peneir;ttion length of the ,urlace induced oriier.
Cunipuier,imulatitJn
re,uli, lie,cribe well recente,perinientitl
ii;iiJ.Introductit~n.
Free
,t~inding
,mectic film, are ,tact, of,mecticlayer,
with two free boundarie;. Without anycomplication,
one canproduce
film, of ?-I ()I)()layer,,
which make them J convenientob_ject
forinve,tigation,
ot'low dimen,ion eiiect,(1-3
(, Pha,e tran,ition, andprecritical phenomena
in the iree
,tanding
,niectic iilm, are iniluencedby
a combinatiun oi the ,uriaceorderiig
and finite-,ile effect, (,ee al,ogeneral
review, (4, 5ii,In many ca,e, the
houndary layer,
oi,mectic iiieiihrane, are niore ordered than thelayer,
inthe iiiidiile. Tfie,tructure of'tfie
hour<tory layer, u,uall»
reilect, ordertypical
nor the lower temperaturepha,e,
c)I agiven
material. Fore~ample
the ob,ervation oi,mecticlayer,
in a,mectic C iiliii ha, been
reported
in (7(. A ,iiectic A-,mectic Bpha,e
tran,ition inboundary
layer,
ha, been iound inhigh preci,ion calorimetry
mea,urement, (8(.In the pre,ent article we ,hall con,ider,uriace
ordering
eiiect, in thevicinity
oi the iir,torder
pha;e
trJn,ition ,mectic A-,mectic C '..Meyer
<,t <II(~(
have ,hown that in the ;meciic Apha,e
oi DOBAMBC the ,iiectic C' appear, inboundary layer,
tar above thepha,e
tran,ition temperature. The ieniperaturedependence
ot'the order parameter and the tran,ition tempera-ture; are t'ound to be iunction, oi the iilm thickne,,. An other
intere,ting example
oi theinfluence of confined diiiien,ion on the char;tcter of the
pha,e
tran,ition, I; therecently
ob,erved eiiect ui the
di,appearance
oi the iir,t orderpha,e
tram,ition SmA-Sm C~by
dimini,hing
the number oi ,iiiecticlayer,
(10,11(.
By
iinite-,ize eiiect, the variation otthermodyn;tmical
parameter, ondimini,hing
,y,tem;ile I, under,toad (,ee ion a review
II ?]).
The mo,timportant
iinite-,ize eiiect, are therounding
iii thepretran,itional
characteri,tic, and,hiiting
iii tfie tram,ition teiiiperature,.Experimentally
it I, <iiificult todi,tingui,h
the finite-,ile effect, iroiii the ,unfreeordering,
becau,e
u,ually integral propertie,
oi the iilm, are urea,ureaII II-
In thi, wc)rL we have carried out nuiiierical calculation, oi the ,uriace
ordering
eiiect, in iree,tanding
it Ini, in thevicinity
iii the iir,t orcierpha,e
tran,ition ,niectic A-,niectic C in the ca;e oi a ;tronganchoring
iii'the tiltangle
at thehoundary.
It wa, iound that at ,ante critical thicLne,, (£l~ thepha,e
tran;ition<it,appear,. Average
,truciural paraiiieter, oi the ,y,tent, varycontinuously
from the smectic A state with surface orderedboundary layers
to the smecticC*, which correlates with recent
experiments
lo, II,13].
Thepenetration length
of thesurface order is found to be one order of
magnitude
smaller than the critical thickness. Asurface induced
phase
transformation in a thinboundary region
was found close above thephase
transition temperature in thick films. In our work we show that the observedexperimental
results[10,
II can beexplained by taking
surfaceordering phenomena
into account.Theoretical model.
In our work we u,eii ;i contiiuuiii nie;in iield
lie,cription
iii'tfie t'ir,t orderph;t,e
tr;tn,ition ,niectic A-;niectic C.inalogou;
to tfiJtof']13].
Tfie ,t;tte oi tfie iiIni wa, cfi;ir~icteriledhy
a<iependence
of'tfie tiltmigle
((M)) on tfie coordinate (=perpendicular
to tfie ,iiiecticplane, Fig,
). Theorigii
oi coordinate, ha, heen taken at one oi the houndarie,. To rind ifieproiile,
oi the tilt
angle
we fiavenuiiiericall»
iiiiniiiiiled (he li.ee energy oi the l'ilni taken in ;i iorniconiiiionly
u,ed li>r tfiede;cription
iii thepfia,e
ir;in,ition ,iiiectic A-,iiieciic C ~. ]14]1/
~
=
~
~
L)Z
>
where (I I, tfie thickne,, ot tfie iiIni and
F~
I, tfie part oi tfie li.ee energyden,iiy
per unit area iii the iiliii, wfiicfi I,coupled
witfi the tilt oi the directt>r. The tiltangle
~,;i, u,eci a, an artierparJiiieter ior the
lie,cription
oi tfiepfia,e
tram,ition. The iiee energylien,ity
F'~ i,given hy
theiollowing e~pre,,ion
>~ i
(.~2+ (">~ +
i
("~< +i
j~">~
i~
where <,
= t~
~ ~
<y i, ;i teiiiperature
independent
con,t;int and J'i I, the t~niperatur~ of theT
ab,olute
in,lability
iii the,niectic Apha,e
with re,peat to the,niectic C 'ph;i,e.
Mininii/Jtion oi the iree energy with re;peat tLJ (M) re,ult, in theiollowing
Lliiierenti;iIe~u;itier
ion theiunction (M)j=
q
~
+ <, (M) + Ii ("I'+ (Ml'
=
I) 1~)
~=~
There are two adLfitional
bounLf;iry
conLlition,, which are ,utl'icient to,rive e~uation (3)h)ji)
=
M)j~ at the ,url'ace iii the l'i[iii iii
lLl(.)
= I) in the niiLlLfle iii the l'i [iii j~)Lf= ~i1
The iir,t
bounLfary
conLlition nioLlel, the ,trongmichoring.
N° II) SURFACE ORDERING IN FREE STANDING FILMS 1867
x
y
,
8
, ~i
, ZmL
i
to
t~
z.o
Fig, I. Schematic
dr~iwiig
iii the,iruciuie i~ ~i lice,mn<fi~g,meciic A Ii Iii m ~icciird~mce with re,uli, iii IL)(To finLf red,enable nuniericJl ,olution,
by
a,iiiiul;iurnproceLfure
we u,eLf the coel'iicieni,<y. />, iinLf g which were calculated from the
typical
value, of'thefollowing
parameter,. jT~ T ), where T~ I, the l'ir,t orLfer
pha,e
tram,itiiin teiiiperature. the tilt
angle
F)~ ,ii the iron,turn teiiiperature ,niectic A-,iiiectic C. the pen~tratiiin
length
iii of the ,unlace inLfuceLl orLfer ;inLf the tran,itionenthalpy
~l-I.
The ,hilt of the fir,i orLler
pha,e
tram,ition tempermur~(l~
with re,peat to the ab,olutein,tability
teiiipermure al'the ,niectic Apha,e
II ' cmi bee~pre,,eLf by
3]/>]~(
~T T~ T 16)
the tilt
angle
at the tran;ition temperature (M), can be written ;i,<m)2
)
j7)~ 4 <.
In a iir;t
approximation
the variation oi the tiffangle
in theboundary region
can be de,cribedby
anexponential
iunctiLJn oi =(M)j= = M)j~ + (M)jj (M)~ exp(
=lij~
). (8)where
(M)~ i, the value of the tilt iar away irom the
bounLiary.
ij~ I,given by
ii)
=
~)(
(~)A
typical
value iii thepenetration length
I~J, been e,timated in(13(,
Value, iii the tr;in,itionenthalpy
have been taken irLJm(15,
l~(. Nuiiierical par;iureter, u,eLf in the ,iniulationprocedure
are ;ummJrized a, fLJllow,t~ = 6, x 11)~ Jni ~ />
=
(),75 x
lo"
Jiii ~,<. = 4,4 x lll'~ Jiii ~, g
=
6 x lo '~ Jm
(M)jj = 41i°, T1
=
300 K,
T,
=
301.17 K.
(M), = ?0°. (ii = 8 nni, ~Hl bulk1= 4 x 11)~ Jm ~.
The iiith parameter iii the numerical
procedure
wa, theboundary
contrition ior(M), In [hi, paper we report J
,impler
ca,e oi the temperatureinLfepenLient boundary
cLJnLfition,.thereiore we ha~e taken the tilt
angle
LJn theboundary
to be a con,t;int (")j, m (M)~, Numericalprocedure
with teiiiper;iluredependent boundary
I; now in prLJgre,,. Differentiale~u;ition
3was ,olved
according
to J nuniericalprocedure
de,cribeLl inii 7(.
Results and discussion.
PROFILES OF THE TILT ANGLE. Prairie, oi the tilt
angle
calculated iur une half of the,ample
for three film thicknesses
(400nm~
160nm~ 70nm) are shown infigures
2-4. Allplots
correspond
to the minimum of the free energy(E~,
)) (the ,table ;olution;). In the ,imulationprocedure
theboundary
condition, for the tiltangle
werekept
con,t;int for all temperature, and thicLne,,e,,m.67
3ot.28
o.4
z
/ 100
nmFig. ~. Till migle prattle, in ~i 4()() nn> t'ilni ~ldili'erenlleniper~ilure,. The iii,i order ph~,e irmi,ition Sni A/Siii C' i>ccLir, al T~ = I()I ? K.
N° II) SURFACE ORDERING IN FREE STANDING FILMS 1869
Although
weapplied
a continuou, model ;ometime; we ,hall u;e«
layer;
» 3,5 nm inthickne;, I,ee () to illu;trate the relevance of the computer ;imulation result, to known
experiments.
The ;imulation re;ult; for a 400 nm film are shown in
figure
~. In the ,mectic Apha;e
the tiltangle
decrea;e,abruptly
in 3-4layer;
,tarting from a value of 6)j, to (M) = 0 in the middle of thefilm, The
penetration length fjj
isindependent
of the film thicLne,, and temperature far fromthe tran,ition. The
=-dependence
of the tiltangle
ha, nopeculiar point, (Fig,
?, T=
31~.34 and
~0?,84 K).
At temperature; where the ,mectic C~
pha,e
I, ,table the tiltangle
varie, from6)j, to a nonzero temperature
dependent a;ymptotic
bulk value(Fig.
~, T=
301? K and
?tl6.67 K). In thi, ca,e the
pha,e
tran,ition I,abrupt
and theprofile change;
from the ;mecticA to the ,mectic C" within several tenth, of
degree.
Thepha;e
tran;ition temperature I, afunction of the number of
layers
and I; ,hiftedby approximately
1.6 K to thehigher
temperature, in the 70
layer
film with re;pect to the bulk.An
intere;ting
feature of the 40(J nm film in thevicinity
of the transition temperature I; a«,urface
pha,e
turn,ition» in the ,mectic A
boundary
regionof'approximately
8layer,
inthicLne,, IT
=
3~Jl ?8 K curve in
Fig.
?). Thedependence
oi the iiltangle
on =-coordinate inthi; ca,e ha, two inflexion
point,,
which I,Ljualitatively
diiierent irom the re,ult; at all other temperature;. Thechange
of the 6)profile,
with temperature indicate; that thepha;e
tram,ition;mectic A-,mectic C~ I, J di;continuou, one.
By
definition the fir,t orderphase
tran;itiontake,
place
at the temperature where the tiltangle prof'ile
with two inilection points tran;iorm;into a monotonou, ;mectic C~
prairie.
The ,imulation re;ult, for a 160 nm iilm and a 70 nm iilm in
figure,
3 and 4 ;how that thetran,ition temperature increa,e; and the temperature interval where the
profile
varies from the,mectic A to the ;mectic C." become, broader
by decrea;ing
the number oflayer,.
In thevicinity
of'the critical thicLne,, the tiltangle profile e,,entially depend,
on the iilm thicLne;;.The
« boundJrie,
» oi the,mectic C ",urface
region
at T=
31)1.46 K in
iigure
3 arepractically
not ob,ervable, but the main ieature of'thi, ,late (two inflexion
point,)
remain,unchanged.
Ina 7() nm f'ilm
(Fig.
4) the tiltangle prairie,
with two inilectionpoint,
were not iound and thepha,e
tran,itionLii,appear,.
The ,late of'[hi, f'ilm I,continuou,ly changed
irom ;mectic A-like296.67
xi-w
0.2 0.6 0.8
z
/
nmFig. 3, Tilt angle prol'ile, i~,1 161J nm film I'
= 31)1.4 K,
296.67
3oi.92
31~34 302.84 302.09
0.21 0.28 0.35
z
/ 100
nmFig. 4. Tilt angle profile, in a 71J nm film. The ph~i,e iron,ition ,iiectic A-,mectic C di,~ippear, in ihi, film.
tLJ ,iiiectic C' -liLe
by Lfecre;i,ing
the teiiiperature. For iiliii, thinner than 71) nm noLju;ilitative change,
of the teniper;iluredepenLfenc~
iii the tiltangle profile,
were <>b,erved. It I, iiiiportantto
enipha,ile
that the critical I'[[iii thicLne,, where (hi, behaviour occur, l'ir,t I, about one artier titiiizgni(uLle larger.
thmi thepene1rMiiin length
ij~. ThJ, i, a nontrivial re,ult, hecau,e triiiii anaive
point
of view one coulLl expect that the thicLne,, where the fir,t orderpha,e
tran,iiion ,mectic A-,iiiectic ClLfi,appear,
,houlLf beappriixiiiiJtely
eLju;iI to ~iii.
Our ,iniulation de,cribe, JLjualit;itively
diiferent behaviour anLf deiiion,tr;ite, theiniportance
iii the tail, oi the (M)j=)prairie,
I;ir iroiii theboundary.
Let u, compare our,iiiiulation re,ult, i&.ith the
experinient, reported
in II), (. The author, iii lo have urea,ureLl the average tiltangle
in iree,tanding
iiliii, ;i, ;i iunction iii teiiiperature and nuniber LJilayer,.
In theoptical
thicLne,, oi iiliii, ha, been LfeterniineLf which give, anaverage value of co, (")i=), ii one
neglect,
the teiiiper;itunedepenLlence
oi the reiractive inLfex.llji ~°°o~
~~
~j
+ o~
iA++
o~§~j ~
+ o°o
+ °o
o~
°o~
+~ °o
~ +
x~
++~
~~
~
+++~
A
o~x~~ ++++
~
6~ °°o(([[jjxx~
~6666666666666
°°~DaDDaDaDaDDDDDa°
305 T
/
°CFig. 5, Temperature dependence tit the JveiJge tilt angle
((9)
[or film thicLne,,e, 41)li nni (U), fill nm (Zii, ~0 nm lo). 711 nm (x). 5(1nm (+) an~l 30 nni lo).N° I() SURFACE ORDERING IN FREE STANDING FILMS 1871
f~~iiiiiiiiiiiiii
A
~jf~~~~~~~~~~~~~
/
# ~+~~~ooo
/f
+~o°
+ ~o
V
j ~i(R++ j++
~o~o°
))'++(o°°°
~~o°
oo
300 305 310
T
/
°CFig, 6. Teniperiiture dependence al (he average
(co,
(")) for l'ilii 1hicLne,,e, 41)() wt, 161) nni, X() nni. 7() nni, 5() nni >id 3() nni. The ,~inie nol~ilion, ;~, in I'[pure 5.The critical thicLne,, in I()( i&a,
approxiiiiately
5~ nm and in Ii 315 nni.Figure;
5 and 6,how the calculateLf teiiiperature
LfepenLience,
of(("))
anLf(co,
(M)) l'or Lfiiierent iilm
thicLne,,e,. In the thick iiIni, both value, reveal Lfi,continuitie, at the
pha,e
trJn,itionteniperature,. In ;i 7() nni iiliii the
<fi,continuity, Lfi,appear,.
Our calculation, give a critical thicLne,,, whichL~ualitatively carte,ponLf,
to the ie,ult, of II)(. An morel,e of'thepenetration length
in the nuniericalproceLfure
leLf iii an i~cieJ,e al'the critical thicLne,,, Thu,, the differentcritical thicLne,,e, f'ounLl in I()( anti can be
explmneLl by
Llif'f'erentpenetration length,
oi the ,urface orLfer at thebounLiary
liLjuiLfcry<,tat-;iir,
Ii I,inteie,ting
to point out that the criticalthicLne,, liiund in the calculation,
of'([pure,
5 anLf 6 coincide, with that oifigure,
~-4,although
the <fef'inition LJi the tram,ition teiiiperature, i, diif'erent, To obtain aLjuantitative de,cription
iii the experiiiient,of'(
II), the value, of the LanLf;iuexp;in,ion
coeiiicient, iiiu,tbe known,
FREE E~ERI;' DENSITY. A
,tuLfy
of'tlie temperaturedepenLfence
of'tlie free energyden,ity
give,
aniiiiport;int
i~f'ormJtion about thechange
of'the chin.deter oi theph;i,e
tr;in,ition cau,eLfby
~i Lfecrea,e of the l'ilm thicLne,, Fruit thegeneral theory
of'the iir,t orLfer tran,ition IX it I,well-known that the iree energy can be Lle,cribe<f
by
a double well f'unction oi the orderpm.Jiiieter in the
viciiity
iii thepha,e
tr;in,ition temperature. The local miiimJcorre,pond
to theph;i,e, coexi,ting
in the cour,e al thepha,e
trill,ition (ii our c;i,e the ,niectic A and C.' ).At certmn teiiiperature, T ' above the
pha,e
tran,ition the Sin C 'mini~ium
di,;ippear,,
Thelower
bounLlm.y
iii the teiiiperature interval where the free energy exhibit; two local minima I, noteLfby
7 ~. At [hi, teniperature the SW A ~ii~iniuniLfi,appear,.
The iree energy oi the ,y,ternvarie,
continuou,ly
at the tran,ition poi~t IX(, thereiore the condition ior thepha,e
tr;Ln,itit~nteiiiperature i, given
by
F, =Fj
II())Figure,
7a-dLfi,plJy
the teiiiperatureLfepenLfence
of'the ~ib,olute iree energy minimum(F ior iour f~Ini thicLne,,e, 4()(), 161). 7() anLf 50 nni. In the ca,e iii the fir,t order
pha;e
tran,ition ,mectic A-,iiiectic C' m the thick iiIni, (4()0 anLf 16(1nit) the fir,t derivative
~z
i, di,continuou,, iihich i, ,hewn in
figure,
7;i anLf 7b. The location iii the Linkpoint
d
« «
b b
~
~
hi
~
4
, ,
v- v-
301.25 100
a) b)
« «
b b
I I
4 4
,
~
,
v- v-
305 T/
ci d)
Fig 7, Temperature dependence ot'the free energy niinmiuni for the following l'ilm ihicLne,,e, 4()() nni (al. 160 nm (b). 70 nm (c) and 5() am (di,
F/(orb. units)
40
_j .' ",, 1' ._ 30
1 ~ ~
~ ~~~
~~~ 5 6 ~
~
~~~l~~
/
7Fig. X, Free energy J, a junction oi t'ilm thicLne,, and the average tilt
angle ((")).
N° lo SURFACE ORDERING IN FREE STANDING FILMS 1873
corre,pond;
to the turn,ition temperature. The iir,t and the ;econd derivative, oi the iree energy become continuou, at thicLne,;e, lower than </, = 70 nm(Fig,,
7c and 7d),indicating
that the
phase
tran;itiondi,appear,
at thi; thicLne,;. Thi, i; anexpected
re,ult becau,e the ,ymmetry of the whole film i,already
broken in the ;mectic Apha;e
due to the tiltedboundary layer,
and the thicLne,, of the tiltedboundary region
become,comparable
with the filmthickne,;
(Fig~.
?-4).The
di,appeamnce
of thepha,e
tran;ition I,qualitatively
illu,trated infigure
8 where the free energyden;ity
I; ,hown J, a function of the average tiltangle
and the film thickne;s at thetran,ition temperature determined for each thickne;s in an
analogy
tofigure,
7J and 7b. The,mectic A and ,mectic C'. ,tates are
,eparated by
an energy barrier. The energy barrierdecrea,es and both minima
approach
each otherby
a decrea;e of the number oflayer;.
At thecritical thicLne;s any difference between above mentioned ,tates
di;appear;,
Conclusions.
Surface
ordering
effect; in free;tanding
film; are de,cribedu;ing
a computer ;imulatiLJn ba;edon the Landau
theory
with ,trongboundary
condition;.By
the decrea,e of the nuniber oilayer;
the
pha,e
tran,ition ,mear; out, the tran;ition temperature I; ,hifted tohigher
temperature, and the di,continuitie, of theintegral
,tructural parameters( 6))
and(co, 6))
a, well J; the energybarrier between ;mectic A and ,mectic C '.
pha,e;
become ,mailer.The fir,t order
pha,e
tran;ition ,mectic A-,mectic C 'di,appear;
at ,ome critical thickne;,which
depend,
on the coeiiicient; of the Landauexpan,ion, e;pecially
on the value oi theparanieter g, A nontrivial re,ult oi [hi, paper I, that the critical thickne;, I,
approximately
oneorder oi
magnitude larger
than thepenetration length iii
oi the ,uriace ordercharacterizing
the variation oi the tiltangle
irom it, value at theboundary
6)jj to the bulk(M)~). In iilm, thinner than the critical thicLne,, all a~er;ige ,tructural parameter, and the iir,t derivative oi the iree
energy become continuou, iunctiLJn, LJi temperature, the energy barrier between the ,mectic A
anti ,mectic C
pha,e,
and the ,uri;iceph;i,e
tran,itiondi,appear,
l'hecomputer,imul;ition
re,ult, de,cribe
~ualitatively
cLJrrect recentexperiniental
re,ult,ill),
II (.Acknow~ledgement~.
The aufhor, are
grateiul
to Prof. P. Pieran,Li(Or,ay)
and Dr. M.O,ipov (Southampton)
furmany
,tiniulating
di,cu,,ion,. Thi, work ha, been,upported by
the Deut;cheFor;chung,geiiiein,chait
and the Fond; der Chenii,chen Indu,trie.Reierences
Pier;~n,Li P.. PI <,/ P/,i S,< <, A 194 119~3 364.
]~] Huang C. C, and Siiebe T. A<fi. Pfivs 4211993j 343
(3 Gee' R.. Sioebe T. ~m(I Huaiig C C., PfiSS Rei E 48 l~~3j 40X.
(4( Bmder K.. Pha,e Tr~in,ition, wit) Critical Phenomena. C. Dr~mb and J. L. Lebr~wiiz ELI,.. Vol.
(Academic Pre,,. London, l~X~) p. 2.
(5] Forgac, G.. Lipow,Ly R anti Nieuwenhuizen Th. M.. Pha,e Tran,ition, mid Critical Pheiiomeiia.
C. Donib ~nd J. L. LebtJwitz Ed,., Vol, 14 (Academic Pre,,. LonLlon, l~~ Ii p. 136.
(6( O,LtJ B. M.. BrJ,l~iu A.. Per,han P. S., Al,-Niel,en J. anti Deui,ch M.. P/JVS Ret L<,11 57 lL)X61
~4.
(7( Siroia E. B.. Per,han P. S., AniadtJr S and Soren,en L. B., Plivs Rei A 35 l~X7j 22X3,
(~( Stoebe T.. Geer R.. Huang C. CT,ind Goodby J. W.. P/Jv.S. R<>I L<>11 69 l~~2j 2(N0.
(~( HeineLamp S., PelLovit, R.. Fonte, E.. Yi Chen E.. PindaL R, and Meyer R., Fiji Rci Leii 52 (t9X4j 1017.
(lo( Bahr Ch. ~md Fliegner D.. P/JVS R<.i A 46 (l~~~) 7657.
II Kr;iu, I., Pier;in,Li P.. DeniiLhov E.. Stegemeyer H.. P/JVS Rci E 48 (lL)~3) l~16.
? Barher M. N.. PhJ,e Tran,turn, and Critical Phenomena, C. Domb and J. L. Lebowitz Ed,.. Vol.
(Academic Pre,,. London, t~X9) p. 146.
ii3( DemiLhov E.. Krau, I.. Piemn,Li P..
Stegemeyer
H..Goodby
J.. Sl;iney A. ,ind O,ipov M.. B<>J.BJIJJ,ciJqe, Fiji., C/J<>fir 97(19L)3)1376.
(14( PILI~ S. A. ind
O,ipov
M. A.. Ferroelecinc Lit~uidCry,tal,
lGorLion and Breach.Philadelphia.
lL)L)I p. ~49,
(15( Bahr Ch.. HeppLe G. and SabJ,chu, B.. LJ<j CJ.i,J<,/ II 1199~) 41.
[16] Demikhov E,. Kraus I, and Pieran~ki P., ,I. Phi-I- (Condensed Matter) 6 (1994) A415,
(17( Pre,, W. H.. Fl~mnery B, P., TeuLol,Ly S. A. ~ind Vetterli~g W. T., Numerical Recipe,
lc~imhridge Univer,iiy Pre,,. C~imhridge, 19L)~) p. 645.
Xl Binder K., R<>p. Pi <>qi Pfiv, 51) II 9X71 7X3.