Packet Reordering in Networks with Heavy-Tailed Delays

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00070238

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070238

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Packet Reordering in Networks with Heavy-Tailed Delays

Marc Lelarge

To cite this version:

Marc Lelarge. Packet Reordering in Networks with Heavy-Tailed Delays. [Research Report] RR-5783, INRIA. 2005, pp.31. �inria-00070238�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--5783--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Packet Reordering in Networks with Heavy-Tailed Delays

Marc Lelarge

N° 5783

December 2005

(3)

(4)

5768:9<;4=?>@68:AB=

∗

CEDGFIHKJKLNMPO,QSRJUTWVBX/JIY,R[ZBR[YFIHKJSR

\]^W_#JIYNCO,`ba

ONTWcdce^f][YgdJ!]JShDGJI]hDGJji%klnmfoqprMts*JShSJIHvueJI]NwqxqxqlMypBL*czTW{nJSR

|~}SUWdqq< iHc^f][YTWi.Y*hDzTW]TfhIYJI][R[Y[h^WbTWiZC,a\hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiRNY[DGJRJSVGJIiGhIid{/^W(czTfhnJIYR

Y[DdiY[DzTWY<hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiNVdY#^W!RJSVGJIiGhSJ/czTfhnJIYRKiGgBhUTWYJY[DzTWYY[DGJhS^fidiGJShIY[^fiR[VBeJI]R@]^fH

^qRRU.gBVdc hUTWY[^fi~^f]b]JS^f]gdJI][id{G Y4R(Y[DVGRb^Wei.YJI]JSR[Y(Y^vR[Y[VGgBZ¡Y[DGJH<TW{qidY[VGgdJ,^W^fVdY#^WRJS.VGJIiGhSJ

czTfhnJIYR

Y[Ddi ¢iYJI][iGJIY,C,a\hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiTWiGgY^KgdJIiY[£@Z¤Y[DGJI]NhUTWVGRJSRU

¥^f]J¦{nJIiGJI]T Zn,iH<TWi.ZgBR[Y[][udVdYJSgTWcdc hUTWY[^fiGR¨§@Jq{G]JIHK^fYJ©hS^fHcdVdYTWY[^fiGRUNgGTWYTWuzTfRJ

H<TWidcdV TWY[^fiGRUG^f]gGTWYTY[]TWiGR[HRR^fi/^«ªnJI],TvhS^fHcdVdYJI]iGJIY

^f][G¬diB®^f][H<TWY[^fiiYJI{q][YZ/]JS.Vd]JSR

Y[DzTWYKgGTWYT¯JXdhDzTWid{nJSRueJIY

JSJIigB£°JI]JIiYKiG^gdJSR^W±TRZR[YJIH²ueJ¤cJI]#®^f][HKJSg³iT©R[ceJShI£´zh^f]gdJI]U

µ¶^

JIªnJI]UgBVGJ!Y^]TWiGgd^fH·gdJ TSZBR,^«ªnJI]NgB£°JI]JIiY,czTWY[DGRNiT¡R[ZBR[YJIHrdY[DGJ±czTfhnJIYR¶^f]VdcgGTWYJSR,H<TSZ

TW][][ªnJTWY¡Y[DGJ~]JShSJIªnJI]iTgB£eJI]JIi.YK^f]gdJI]¡Y[DzTWiY[DGJI]¡hDd]^fiG^ ^f{qhUT ^f]gdJI]U¨ ¢i7RVGhDThUTfRJq(T

]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{KudVB°JI]NTWYY[DGJ*]JShSJIªnJI],DzTfRY^R[Y^f]J±gBR^f]gdJI]JSgczTfhnJIYR,YJIHce^f]TW][

Zn

¸¨JTWizT Z¹UJu^fY[DY[DGJ

TWY[id{vY[HKJ^WeTNczTfhnJIY4i¡Y[DGJE]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{!udVB°JI](TWiGgY[DGJR¹UJ^WY[DdR

]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{!VGJIVGJq¸¨J(gdJI][ªnJY[DGJJXdTfhIYTfR[Z.HcdY^fY[hSR®^f]Y[DGJ TW][{nJEgdJIª.ºTWY[^fi¡^WGY[DGJSRJVzTWi.Y[Y[JSR

VdiGgdJI]»DGJUTUª.Z.¼YTWJSgTfRR[VdHcdY[^fiGRU i±hS^fi.Y[]TfR[Y

Y[D]JSR[V YR»^fudYTWiGJSg±@^f] {qD.Y#¼YTWJSggBRY[][udVdY[^fiGRU

JR[DG^

Y[DzTWY¶Y[DGJI]JJXR[YR¶RJIªnJI]T »½ YZcdhUT czTWY[DGR#¾±Y[DzTWY JUTfg¦Y^~Y[DGJ TW][{nJ¡gdJIªºTWY[^fi,¸¨JgdJI][ªnJ

JXBc hIY Z¤Y[DGJSRJ!gB£eJI]JIi.Y ½ YZcdhUT czTWY[DGR#¾vTWiGg/{qªnJ!DGJIVd][RY[h!][V JSR®^f],TWi¦^fcdY[H<T uzT TWiGhIid{G

¿ÀÁeÂÃÄ WÅ qÆ RZ.HcdY^fY[hSRUBczTW]T J VGJIVGJSRUG]JSRJSVGJIiGhIid{GGDGJUTSªZ¤YTW

∗ÇÉÈ Ê»Ç@Ë»ÌÉÍGÈÎqÏUÍzÈÎnÏ«ÐSÑbÒ¼Ó?ÔÕÖ×ØÚÙ*ÏWÛ:Ñ:ÜÜÑEÝdÞÒ¼ßáà#Ïqâ«ÒÞ:ãWäåÔÏqæ*ÞÒ¼äçè.Ô#ØÚÞÒ¼éÔê Ô#ã?à#çëìÒ

(5)

0ve

iGJrhUTW]TfhIYQI][R[Y[.VGJ¦Hce^f][YTWiYJgVdiGJ¦hS^fidiGJShIY[^fi C,a\ JSR[Y ^f]gB]JgdJSR<czTf.VGJIYR

TWVRJIigdJhSJIY[YJ¦hS^fidiGJShIY[^fis*JSRczTf.VGJIYR<gdQSh TfRRQSRKiGgBVGJIi.Y~.VGJ T©hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiR^fVBe]JrgdJ

ceJI][YJSRU°gBVdc hUTWY[^fiGR±^fV©]JSh TfRRJIHKJIi.YRU± JSRY¶gd^fiGh¡i.YQI]JSRRTWiY±gQIY[VGgBJI] áTWHc JIVd]±gBV©iG^fHud]J

gdJ!czTf.VGJIYRgdQSh TfRRQSRNTWV¦RJIirgVdiGJ±hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiC,a\JIY,ggdJIi.Y[£´zJI]NRJSRhUTWVGRJSRU

\ VGR*{nQIiGQI]T JIHKJIi.YUgGTWiGR!gdJiG^fHud]JIVGRJSRvTWcdc hUTWY[^fiGR±gBR[Y[][udVGQSJSRK§H<TWidcdV TWY[^fiGRgdJuzTfRJSR

gdJ¡gd^fidiGQSJSR!^fV¯hS^fHHvVdidhUTWY[^fi RVd]NVdi©]QSRJUTWV©iB®^f][H<TWY[VGJ«¬ i.YQI{q][YQKgdJ iB@^f][H<TWY[^fiJXB{nJ

.VGJ QShDzTWid{nJ¶gdJ,gd^fidiGQSJSRbJIiY[]J JSR(gB£°QI]JIiYRbi*VGgdRbR^fY4®TWYJgGTWiGR(Vdi~^f]gB]J,cd]QShIRU4aJIcJIiGgGTWi.Y

hUTWVGRJrgdJSR~gdQ TWR<T QUTWY^f]JSR¤R[Vd] JSRKgB£°QI]JIiYR¤hDGJIHiGR<gBVR[ZRYFIHKJq JSRczTf.VGJIYR<^fVHRJSR

_[^fVd]cJIVdªnJIi.Y¶TW][][ªnJI]NTWVr]JShSJIcdYJIVd]¶gGTWiGRVdi¦^f]gB]J±gB£°QI]JIiY¶gdJ JIVd],^f]gB]J±hDd][iG^fiG^ ^f{qVGJqs!TWiGR

hSJ<hUTfR«»Vdi YTWHc^fi³gdJK]JSh TfRRJIHKJIiY¡gd^fYv{TW]gdJI]YJIHc^f]TW]JIHKJIi.YU(TWVidªnJUTWV³gBV]JShSJIcdYJIVd] JSR

czTf.VGJIYRgdQShUT

RRQSRU

¶^fVGRvTWizT ZBR^fiGR J¡YJIHcGR±gáTWY[YJIi.YJ<gGTWiGR J¡YTWHce^fi¨gdJ]JSh TfRRJIHKJIi.YTWiGR[4.VGJ T¤YTWJKgdJ

T´ J±gGTWiGRNhSJ!YTWHce^fi ¶^fVGR^fudYJIiG^fiGR JSR¶TfR[ZHcdY^fY[VGJSRNJXdTfhIYJSRce^fVd] JSR,{q]TWiGgdJSR,gdQIªºTWY[^fiGR

gdJ¤hSJSR.VzTWiY[YQSR¡R^fVGRgdJSRvD.Z.ce^fY[DGFSRJSR¡gdJ¤gBR[Y[][udVdY[^fiGR .VGJIVGJ

^fVd]gdJq!N^fVGRHK^fiY[]^fiGR.V"

JXBR[YJ(gB£°QI]JIiYR#IhDGJIHiY¢Z.cd.VGJSR#4HKJIizTWiY hSJSR{q]TWiGgdJSRgdQIª.ºTWY[^fiGRJIY JSRgdQShI][ªn^fiGRgdJbH<TWidFI]J

JXBc hIYJq4`iB´Gi¦iG^fVGR,gd^fidiG^fiGR,gdJSR]FI{ JSR,DGJIVd][R[Y[VGJSR,c^fVd]VdiQSVdud]TW{nJ±^fcdY[H<T

$ Ä U Â &% ~ R[Z.HcdY^fY[.VGJSRU´ JSREJIi¤czTW]T F JqB]JSRQSVGJIiGhSJIHKJIi.YUdgBR[Y[][udVdY[^fiGR

VGJIVGJ ^fVd]gdJ

(6)

- . %['b%

O,JS^f]gdJI][id{©Y[DGJ¤^fVdY#^WÉ^f]gdJI]KTW][][ªqT

czTfhnJIYRKTWYY[DGJ¤gdJSR[Y[izTWY[^fi³R¡T¦hS^fHHK^fi³cdDGJIiG^fHKJIiG^fii

Y[DGJ/ i.YJI][iGJIY0/2143/áwql,3¨CEDGJ¤H<T?_[^f]hUTWVGRJ/^W,]JS^f]gdJI][id{¨DzTfRuJSJIi7®^fVdiGg7Y^ueJ~Y[DGJ/czTW]T J R[H

i¦ ¢iYJI][iGJIY,hS^fHce^fiGJIiYR¡§@R

YhDGJSR:¬TWiGg idBR5/21434ONJS^f]gdJI][id{<{q]JUTWY Z/HczTfhIYRY[DGJ±cJI]#®^f][H<TWiGhSJ

^WbTWcdc

hUTWY[^fiGR¶i¦Y[DGJ i.YJI][iGJIYU, ¢iTKC,a\ hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiY[DGJ±]JS^f]gdJI][id{^WY[Dd]JSJ^f]NHK^f]J±czTfhnJIY

ce^qR[Y[^fiGR

Y[DdiT6z^

H<TSZvhUTWVGRJ4®TfRY»]JIY[]TWiGR[HRR^fi¡TWiGgv®TfRY»]JShS^UªnJI][ZvHvV Y[c JY[HKJSR ]JSR[V Y[id{

iTr]JSgBVGhSJSg³C,a\

iGgd^

TWiGg7hS^fiGRJS.VGJIiY ZiTrgB]^fc³i id¯VdY[¹«TWY[^fiTWiGgDGJIiGhSJ~i JSRR

Y[Dd]^fVd{qDdcdVdY±®^f]±TWcdc

hUTWY[^fi7/áw,83:9G^f]vgdJ

TUZ¼uzTfRJSg¯]JUT

¼Y[HKJKRJI][ªhSJ¡i

s*\3§@R[VGhD TfR<;4^q å\ ^f]

ªgdJS^<hS^fiB®JI]JIiGhSJ«¬eY[DGJTWudYZ¦Y^<]JSR[Y^f]J^f]gdJI]*TWY¶Y[DGJvgdJSRY[izTWY[^fi

nJ ZDzTSªnJv´GidYJ HYRU

CEDGJKgdJIc ^«Z.HKJIi.Y^WT¤]JUT ¼Y[HKJ<RJI][ªhSJ¡iGJShSJSRR[YTWYJSRhSJI][YTWi¨]JS^f]gdJI][id{hS^fiGR[Y[]TWi.YR±Y^/ueJ¡HKJIYU

C»^rªnJI][£Z

DGJIY[DGJI]vY[DGJSRJ=¶^>]JSVd]JIHKJIi.YR¡hUTWi¨uJR:TWY[R#´zJSg°iG^

JSgB{nJ¤TWu^fVdY±Y[DGJK]JS^f]gdJI][id{

ueJIDzTSª^f]NiY[DGJv ¢iYJI][iGJIY*RJSJIHKRNgdJSR]TWu Jq iY[DdR,czTWceJI]U

J¡TWizT Z.¹UJvY[DGJJ°JShIYN^WDGJUTSªZ.¼YTWJSg

gdJ TSZBR,^fiY[DGJ±]JSRJSVGJIiGhIid{~gdJ TSZrTWiGgr^firY[DGJ*i.VdHvueJI]N^W^fVdY#^WÉ^f]gdJI]*TW][][ªfT czTfhnJIYRU

congestion

1.5 G 0.75 G 1.5 G 1 G 2 G

1.5 G 0.75 G

2 G

1 G

1.5 G

9 {qVd]JKL@?¸ Y[DG^fVdY,C»][Vdid.id{

a^fiGR[gdJI]<Y[DGJ<®^ ^

id{ R[Y[VzTWY[^fi

DGJI]J/Y[DGJI]JrTW]J¤®^fVd]cdDZBR[hUT hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiGRKueJIY

JSJIiY[DGJ

RTWHKJEczTW]^WgdJIªhSJSRU`(TfhD idvDzTfR4T*hUTWczTfhIY¢Z^W°w5A¶udYCBWRJShq RR[VdHKJiG^

Y[DzTWYY[DdRR[ZBR[YJIH DzTfR

Y^±cd]^hSJSRRY[DGJ@^ ^

id{Y[]T4D<h Rbcd]^W´ J§iEA¶udYCBWRJSh«¬?wBzLqálBBxBÚmflBLqál±TWiGg~w¶@]^fH3´GªnJNgB£eJI]JIi.Y

6z^

R« Y[DGJ~RZR[YJIH²T ^hUTWYJSRY^JUTfhD³cdD.ZR[hUT hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiT¦RJIY^W6z^

RUYhUTWidiG^fY¡cd]^hSJSJSg

Y[DGJ

DG^

J!Y[]T4D<hTWiGg¦TWY

JUTfR[Y,^fiGJ±cdDZBR[hUT

id/RhS^fid{nJSR[YJSg

DGJI]JUTfR,^fY[DGJI]RNTW]J±VdiGgdJI][VdY[

¹UJSg°

¢iY[DGJhUTfRJ^W<9 {qVd]J¯LqbY[DGJJeJShIY[ªnJrY[Dd]^fVd{qDdcdVdY<RKlBÚmflFA¶udYRBWRJShq

DGJI]JUTfR<Y[DGJ/H<T?XHVdH

Y[Dd]^fVd{qDdcdVdY®^f]Y[DGJ±JIi.Y[]J±{q]^fVdc¦^W idRR,oGA¶udYRCBWRJShq

NiGJ

TUZY^*R^

ªnJY[DdRcd]^fu

JIH R Y^!TW{q{q]JI{TWYJEY[DGJb@^fVd]

idBRiY^!T¶R[id{

J

^f{qhUT

o<A*udYRCBWRJSh

Y[][Vdid{q]^fVdcCEDdR±Y[][Vdid{q]^fVdchS^fHudiGJSR±Y[DGJ¡uzTWiGg

gBY[D^WT idR±Y^^fcdY[H¹UJKgGTWYT¤Y[]T4D<h

^nTfgR[DzTW][id{©§@RJSJH9 {qVd]Jvwn¬

IGIGIGIGIGIGIGI IGIGIGIGIGIGIGI IGIGIGIGIGIGIGI

JGJGJGJGJGJGJGJ JGJGJGJGJGJGJGJ JGJGJGJGJGJGJGJ

2 G 1.5 G 0.75 G 1.5 G 2 G

1.5 G 0.75 G 1.5 G 2 G 2 G

9 {qVd]JvwK?4¸Y[DrC»][Vdid.id{

CEDGJI]JJXR[YR,RJIªnJI]T

TSZBRY^

^nTfg¦uzT

TWiGhSJ±Y[DGJ!Y[]T4D<hSR*TfhI]^qRRczTW]T

J

idR¶TWiGg

J

iG^fY

gBRhIVGRRY[DdRRR[VGJ*DGJI]Jq(¸¨J

^fi Z/{qªnJ±R^fHKJ!JXGTWHc JSR

DGJI]J!Y[DGJ±RY[VzTWY[^fi¦gdJSRhI][ueJSg¦TWu^«ªnJ

DzTWcdceJIiGRU

>.Y^f]TW{nJTW]JUTiGJIY

^f][R¡§L> NR:¬bcd]^«ª.gdJY[DGJ±gGTWYThS^fHHVdidhUTWY[^fi©iB]TfR[Y[][VGhIY[Vd]J±@^f]NR[Y^f]TW{nJ

R[ZBR[YJIHKR±hS^fiGR[RY[id{^WR

YhDGJSR«RJI][ªnJI]RTWiGgR[Y^f]TW{nJ~R[ZBR[YJIHKRU< ¢i¨Y[DdRhS^fiYJXBYU]JSgBVdiGgGTWiGhIZ¨^W

cdDZBR[hUT hS^fidiGJShIY[^fi¯R!T~cd]^fYJShIY[^fi TW{TWiGR[Y¶¼TWVd]Jq ¼TWVd]J¡gd^.JSR¶iG^fY!hS^fHc JIYJ Z ½ud]JUTWY[DGJ

cdceJ¾NudVdYR[Hc Z~H<TWnJSREY[DGJ*cdcJ¶Y[DdidiGJI]U4 ¢i/Y[DGJ!hUTfRJ*^W> NRUY[DGJI]J*JXBR[YRR^W@Y

TW]J!R^ VdY[^fiGR

ir^f]gdJI]Y^iGhI]JUTfRJ*cJI]#®^f][H<TWiGhSJ

Y[D¦ ¢iYJI]#M>

YhDON°id¯§@ >PN¬EC][Vdidid{<RJSJ¶®^f]JXGTWHc JG/L«m43

(7)

¢YET ^

REVdc~Y^®^fVd] >PNRuJIY

JSJIiY

^KwA¶udYCBWRJSh*R

YhDGJSREY^vueJ ^f{qhUT Z~hS^fHvudiGJSg/i^f]gdJI]EY^

uzT TWiGhSJgGTWYT*Y[]T4D<h§®TfR4gdJSRhI][ueJSg¡i<^fVd](JXGTWHc J,TWue^UªnJ«¬CEDGJI]J,TW]JRJIªnJI]T TfgBªfTWi.YTW{nJSR4®^f]Y[DdR

YJShDdiG^ ^f{qZ ?YEgBR[Y[][udVdYJSRDGJUTSªZ> ]TWHKJNY[]T4D<h!TfhI]^qRRET Y[DGJ* >PNR(iTvY[][VdidYEJ HizTWYJSR

Y[DGJiGJSJSg³®^f]<gGTWYT©]JI]^fVdY[id{ £*^fiGJ id³^W*Y[DGJY[][Vdid7¼TWR<TWiGgYKR[Hc £´zJSR<H<TWizTW{nJIHKJIiY/uZ

]JSgBVGhIid{<Y[DGJ*i.VdHvueJI]N^W >PN»R]JSVd]JSg°

¢i¦Y[DGJhS^fiYJXBY!^W(hS^fHHvVdidhUTWY[^fi¨iGJIY

^f][BRUHvV Y[c J idR!TW]JVdYJ± ]JS.VGJIiY Z¦c TfhSJSgueJ

Y

JSJIi¤T¶czTW](^W°gdJIªhSJSRiK^f]gdJI]4Y^*iGhI]JUTfRJceJI]#®^f][H<TWiGhSJuZ ½

gdJIidid{±Y[DGJcdceJ¾±§

Y[DG^fVdY4{n^fid{

Y^~TiGJ

JI]UHK^f]JvJXBcJIiGRªnJ±YJShDdiG^ ^f{qZG¬ ¢irY[DdR¶R[Y[VzTWY[^fi%JSRYTWu R[Ddid{~\ ^fiY#¼Y^W\ ^fiY\]^fY^W

hS^

§@\4\4\b¬^«ªnJI]JUTfhDrhS^fidiGJShIY[^fiiGgdJIceJIiGgdJIiY

Z¤R(¼TW]]^fH TWi/gdJUT

R^

VdY[^fiBuJShUTWVGRJNYRY[DGJIi

iGJShSJSRRTW][ZY^H<TWiVzT Z~gBR[Y[][udVdYJ¶Y[DGJY[]T4D<h¶^UªnJI]EY[DGJY

^§@^f](HK^f]J«¬bhDzTWidiGJ RE^f] idR« ueJIY[YJI]

R^ VdY[^fi

^fV ghS^fHvudiGJ¦HvV Y[c J idBR<TWiGg³VGRJ/Y[DGJIH TfR¡£¶Y[DGJIZ

JI]Jr^fiGJ/Dd{qDB¼ceJI]#®^f][H<TWiGhSJ

ideO>^fHKJ¤DzTW]g

TW]J/gdJIªhSJSR¡TfhIY[VzT Z7T ^

Y[DdRY^rueJ~gd^fiGJ/TWYY[DGJ~DzTW]g

TW]J JIªnJ YRJ i

¢iYJI{q]TWYJSg>JI][ªhSJSR4s¶{qYT ¶JIY

^f][¦§@ >s!¬Y[DdRYJShDdiG^ ^f{qZRR^fHKJIY[HKJSRbhUT JSgue^fiGgBid{

DGJIi

gd^fiGJ¡TWY TUZnJI]*^fiGJq 9G^f]¶Y[DG^qRJDzTW]g

TW]JVdidYR¶Y[DzTWY¶gd^~iG^fYNcd]^«ª.gdJY[DdR¶hUTWczTWudYZn\(\4\ H<TWnJSR

YTSªqTWTWu J*i/Y[DGJ¶@^f][H ^W»Y[DGJ!\4\(\¥¦V Y[id¤\]^fY^hS^ §@¥\b¬dCEDdREcd]^fY^hS^

TfR^f][{qizT Z¤gdJ

RhI][ueJSg¤i¤O 9aL«mL«mBTWiGg

TfREVdcgGTWYJSg¤iO 9aL qx/L43¥\T ^

R\4\4\Y^udVdiGg J¶HV Y[c J

cdDZBR[hUT 4idBRTWiGg¨VGRJY[DGJIH nJ<TrR[id{ JqDd{qDBhUTWczTfhIY¢Z id/NiGhSJK^fceJI]TWY[^fizT Y

^f][BR±uZ

@]TW{qHKJIiY[id{

DG^

JK\(\4\@]TWHKJSR±TWiGg¯RJIiGgBid{Y[DGJ@]TW{qHKJIiYRv^«ªnJI]±gB£eJI]JIi.Y±cdDZBR[hUT

idBRU 9G^f]

Y[DGJ±Y[]TWiGRHRR[^fi¥\´G]R[Y,JIiGhUTWcGR[V TWYJSR¶Y[DGJgGTWYTW{q]TWHKRNi.Y^¤TKHK^.gB£´zJSg¦ªnJI]R[^fi^W4Y[DGJv]JI{qV TW]

\4\4\@]TWHKJq ¢YY[DGJIiYTWnJSR4Y[DzTWY4]TWHKJTWiGgKgdJShIgdJSR(DG^

Y^±Y[]TWiGR[HY4Y4^UªnJI](Y[DGJHvV Y[c J,cdDZBR[hUT

idBRUC4ZcdhUT

ZnGY[DdRR,gd^fiGJ!uZ/gBª.gBid{<Y[DGJ*]TWHKJ*i.Y^@]TW{qHKJIiYR,Y[DzTWYNTW]J!JIªnJIi

ZR[cd]JUTfg^fVdY

^UªnJI]Y[DGJKRJIYv^W idBRU<CEDGJSRJ~TW]JY[DGJIi JIiGhUTWcGR[V TWYJSg7TWiGgRJIi.Yv^UªnJI]Y[DGJcdDZBR[hUT bidRU Y±Y[DGJ

]JShSJIcdY[^fiG¥\³YTWnJSRY[DGJ¶@]TW{qHKJIiYR]JShSJIªnJSg¤@]^fH T cdDZBR[hUT °idRTWiGg/]JUTfRRJIHvu JSRY[DGJIH i.Y^

Y[DGJv^f][{qizT

\4\4\ @]TWHKJqCEDzTWYN]TWHKJvR,Y[DGJIicd]^.hSJSRRJSg

nJTWi.Z¦\4\4\@]TWHKJqzu.Z

^.^fid{¤TWYNYR

\]^fY^hS^ ´zJ g¨TWiGg©czTfRR[id{Y*Y^/Y[DGJKTWcdcd]^fcd][ºTWYJiGJIY

^f][ TUZnJI]±cd]^fY^.hS^ ¡CEDGJ@]TW{qHKJIiY[id{¦^W

gGTWYT!i¤¥\iY[]^gBVGhSJSRT*iVdHuJI]E^WhS^fHc JXY[JSRY[DzTWY(Y[DGJ,cd]^fY^.hS^ HvVGR[YbDzTWiGg Jq i<czTW][Y[hIV TW]U

R[iGhSJE@]TW{qHKJIiYRTW]JueJIid{RJIiY(]^fVd{qD ZKhS^fiGhIVd][]JIi.Y Zn

JiGJSJSg<Y^±gdJIi.Y[£ Z¡Y[DGJIH

Y[D/T!RJS.VGJIiGhSJ

iVdHuJI]NY^KT ^

]JUTfRRJIHvu Zn

¶^fYJ(Y[DzTWYYRT R^,c^qRRu J4Y^ ^nTfg±uzT TWiGhSJY[DGJ(Y[]T4D<hETWY»Y[DGJ TSZnJI]p§@ i.YJI][iGJIY:¬ 9z^f] JXGTWHc J

YhUTWi7ueJKJIizTWu

J~^fiabRhS^`Xcd]JSRR*9G^f]

TW]gBid{©Y[DzTWidRY^rY[DGJ¤hS^fHH<TWiGgc

^nTfgR[DzTW][id{§@RJSJ

/LUo,3¬? ½ \ JI]#¼czTfhnJIY ^nTfg~uzT TWiGhIid{T ^

RY[DGJ,]^fVdYJI]EY^vRJIiGg~gGTWYTvczTfhnJIYRE^UªnJI]R[VGhShSJSRR[ªnJ,JS.VzT

hS^qR[YczTWY[DGR

Y[DG^fVdY,]JI{TW]gY^KiGgBª.gBVzT gdJSR[Y[izTWY[^fi¦DG^qR[YRN^f]VGRJI],RJSRR[^fiGRU4\TWY[D¦VdY[¹«TWY[^fiR

{n^^.g°dudVdYNczTfhnJIYR¶gdJSR[Y[iGJSg®^f]NT¡{qªnJIigdJSR[Y[izTWY[^fi¦DG^qRYH{qDY¶YTWnJ±gB£°JI]JIiY¶czTWY[DGRNTWiGgrH{qD.Y

TW][][ªnJ±^fVdY,^W^f]gdJI]U¾

¢iGgdJSJSg°i7T Y[DGJ~JXGTWHc JSR¡hIYJSg7TWue^UªnJqgBVGJ~Y^r]TWiGgd^fH²gdJ TUZR¡^UªnJI]¡gB£°JI]JIiY¡czTWY[DGRU Y[DGJ

HKJIY[DG^g~^WceJI]#¼czTfhnJIY ^nTfg~uzT TWiGhIid{¡hUTWi~HKJUTWi~Y[DzTWYczTfhnJIYREi/T!czTW][Y[hIV TW]hS^fidiGJShIY[^fi^f] 6z^

TW][][ªnJNTWY(Y[DGJI]bgdJSR[Y[izTWY[^fi/^fVdY(^WRJS.VGJIiGhSJq ¢Y(hUTWi¤hUTWVGRJcd]^fu JIHKRUJSR[ceJShIºT Z®^f]4Y[DGJNR[Y[]JUTWHid{

HKJSgBºTB nJKª.gdJS^¦TWiGg¨TWVGgB^d~ i©Y[DGJKhUTfRJ^W]J ºTWu J<cd]^fY^.hS^ R±RVGhD TfR±C,a\ czTfhnJIYR±DzTUªnJKY^

ueJgdJ ªnJI]JSgY^¤Y[DGJv]JShSJIªid{rTWcdc hUTWY[^fi¯iY[DGJ¡^f]gdJI]*Y[DGJIZTW]JY[]TWiGR[HY[YJSg¨TWY¶Y[DGJRJIiGgdJI]U¶ ¢i

^f]gdJI]Y^*gdJ

ªnJI]4Y[DGJTW][][ªnJSgczTfhnJIYY^*Y[DGJTWcdc

hUTWY[^fi<i¡RJSVGJIiGhSJqqY[DGJE]JShSJIªnJI] R4Y[]TWiGR[c^f][Y

TUZnJI]

iGJSJSgdREY^¡YJIHce^f]TW][Z<udVB°JI]^fVdY#^W ^f]gdJI]czTfhnJIYRNTWiGg/]JSRJSVGJIiGhSJ¶Y[DGJIH TfREHK^f]J*czTfhnJIYR,TW][][ªnJq

¢iY[DdRKczTWceJI]U

JTWizT Z.¹UJ¦T¯HK^.gdJ

DGJI]JrHR#^f]gdJI][id{ R<hUTWVGRJSgu.ZHvV Y[czTWY[D ]^fVdY[id{G

\TfhnJIYR¦TW]J{nJIiGJI]TWYJSgTfhShS^f]gBid{Y^T¨]JIiGJ

T cd]^.hSJSRR« CEDGJIi Y[DGJIZ TW][][ªnJ¯TWYT7gBR^f]gdJI][id{

®JSJSg®@^f]

TW]giGJIY

^f][e ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{udVB°JI]K®^ ^

R~Y[DGJrgBR^f]gdJI][id{7iGJIY

^f][ ¸¨JTfRR[VdHKJ

Y[DzTWY!Y[DGJKgdJ TUZR<§

DdhD

ueJ¡H<TfgdJ¡cd]JShIRJi

DzTWY*®^ ^

R:¬±TWY!Y[DGJgB£eJI]JIi.YR[YTWY[^fiGR±^WY[DGJ

gBR^f]gdJI][id{iGJIY

^f][7TW]JDGJUTSªZ¼YTWJSg°~¸¨J

RJSJY[DzTWY±Y[DdRR[Y^.hDzTfR[Y[h<TfRRVdHcdY[^fi7T ^ RY^

HK^gdJ Y[]TWiGR#®JI]N^WªnJI][Z TW][{nJ!´ JSRN^f]¼TWVd]Jv^W(gdJIªhSJSR,^f] idR§ Y[DzTWY¶TW]J±Y¢Z.cdhUT Z¦ªnJI][Z ^fid{<i

(8)

hS^fHczTW][R^fi©Y^~czTfhnJIY*RJI][ª.hSJY[HKJSR:¬¶ i©TWi ¢iYJI][iGJIY*hS^fiYJXBYUeY[DGJI]J¡TW]JR[YTWY[RY[hUT JIªgdJIiGhSJ^W

Y[DGJcd]JSRJIiGhSJ,^WDGJUTSªZ.¼YTWJSgK´ JNR[¹UJ,^f]4Y[]TWiGR[@JI]bY[HKJ§@RJSJ*/áwnm43 /LUx,3eTWiGgKY[DGJ]J®JI]JIiGhSJSRbY[DGJI]JIi%¬

¸¨JR[DG^fV gR[Y[]JSRR¡Y[DzTWYcd]JSRJIiGhSJ^WNDGJUTUª.Z.¼YTWJSggBR[Y[][udVdY[^fiR~TRY[]^fid{¯HK^fY[ªfTWY[^fi®^f] ^nTfg

uzT TWiGhIid{G( ¢i/czTW][Y[hIV TW]UGY,T ^

RirhSJI][YTWi¦hS^fiGgBY[^fiGR,Y^¡{qVzTW]TWiYJSJTHidH<T uzTWiGg

gBY[D¦Y^

JUTfhDh TfRR^W 6z^

R5/LqL3 /43¥^f]JS^UªnJI]UzY[DGJ!R[Y[][VGhIY[Vd]T HK^gdJ cd]^fc^qRJSg/i /áw@13cd]^UªgdJSR,T¡gB]JShIY

id<ueJIY

JSJIi¦Y[DGJ*^fuGRJI][ªnJSgrRJ ÉR[HTW][Y¢Z¤hDzTW]TfhIYJI][R[Y[h±^W HKJUTfR[Vd]JSg¦TW{q{q]JI{TWYJ!iGJIY

^f][/Y[]T4D<hq

TWiGg~Y[DGJNR[Y[]^fid{JIHcd][hUT JIªgdJIiGhSJNi~¼TSªn^f]E^W»DGJUTSªZ¼YTWJSg°iB´GidYJ¶ªqTW][ºTWiGhSJNcdDGJIiG^fHKJIizT¡TWYY[DGJ

JIªnJ ^W°iGgBªgBVzT iGJIY

^f][<hS^fidiGJShIY[^fiGRU( i<^fVd](HK^.gdJ

J¶TW]J,TWu JY^gdJI][ªnJ,JXGTfhIYbTfR[ZHcdY^fY[hSR

^WY[DGJ~czTfhnJIY¡]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{gdJ

TUZ TWiGg ^WY[DGJ¤R[¹UJ~^WY[DGJ<]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{¯VGJIVGJq i ª.J

^WY[DGJ

]JShSJIiY4JXBceJI][HKJIiY]JSR[V YR^fudYTWiGJSg¡iE/ápqx,3q^fVd]H<TWi]JSR[V YR4TW]JY[DGJb´G]R[YiGJIY

^f][.id{±HK^gdJ Y[DzTWY

hS^fV gJXBc TWiY[DGJ*c^

JI] T

^fuGRJI][ªnJSg/®^f]Y[DGJ*]JS^f]gdJI]JSgrczTfhnJIY JIid{qY[DTWiGg/Y[DGJ ^fid{YTWiGJSRR^W

czTfhnJIY TW{§@RJSJ/áw 43@^f]¶TR[Hc £´zJSgrHK^gdJ ¬C»^Y[DGJvuJSR[Y^W4^fVd]iG^

JSgB{nJq%Y[DGJI]JTW]J±ªnJI][Z~®J

]JSR[V YR^fi¡Y[DdR cd]^fu JIH VdiGgdJI]DGJUTUª.Z.¼YTWJSgKTfRR[VdHcdY[^fiGRU R[HTW] @]TWHKJ

^f][DzTfRueJSJIi¡R[Y[VGgBJSg

uZnJUTWiB¥©TW][J<TWiGgFAdi /áwqw,3

DGJI]JKY[DGJgBR^f]gdJI][id{riGJIY

^f][¯hS^fiGR[R[YR±^W

K ^czTW]T ^J M/GI/1

.VGJIVGJSRvTWiGg©Y[DGJhS^f][]JSR[ce^fiGgBid{¦gBR[Y[][udVdY[^fi^WY[DGJ¡]JSRJSVGJIiGhIid{gdJ TSZR±gdJI][ªnJSg° R[Vd][ªnJIZR

{qªnJIi³i /ál43¨¥^f]J~]JShSJIiY Zn¶ºTTWiGg³C»RJO/áwqo3EhS^fiGR[gdJI]<T

2−M/M/1 .VGJIVGJIid{©RZR[YJIH²TWiGg gdJI][ªnJ TW][{nJgdJIªºTWY[^fi]JSRV YR®^f],Y[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{¤.VGJIVGJR¹UJqCEDGJvH<TWi]JSR[V YR¶^W(^fVd]NczTWceJI]

T

^

Y^*{nJIY4Y[DGJJXdTfhIYTfR[Z.HcdY^fY[hSRN§

DdhD<RHVGhD~HK^f]Jcd]JShIRJEY[DzTWiKiY[DGJ

log^RhUT JTfRVGR[VzT

Z

gd^fiGJiKY[DGJ TW][{nJgdJIª.ºTWY[^fi YJI]TWY[Vd]J«¬^WeY[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{gdJ TSZKTWiGgK^WeY[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{.VGJIVGJ

R[¹UJ¶®^f]Y[DdR,gBR^f]gdJI][id{<iGJIY

^f][VdiGgdJI],DGJUTSªZ¼YTW TfRR[VdHcdY[^fiGRU

¢ivY[DGJ(iGJXY RJShIY[^fi

JgdJSRhI][ueJ(^fVd]»H<TWY[DGJIH<TWY[hUT

HK^gdJ

TWiGgv{qªnJT,R[VdHH<TW][Zv^WG^fVd] ]JSR[V

YRU

¢i >JShIY[^fip

J~{qªnJ~Y[DGJ¤JXdTfhIY¡TfR[Z.HcdY^fY[hSRY[DzTWY

JTW]J~TWu J~Y^gdJI][ªnJ<®^f]vY[DGJ~]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{

gdJ TSZTWiGgY[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{.VGJIVGJKR[¹UJq~¸¨JK{qªnJ~R^fHKJDGJIVd][R[Y[h<][V JSR±®^f]v^fcdY[H<T uzT TWiGhIid{G

a^fiGhSJI][idid{Y[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{³gdJ

TUZn,Y[DGJ]JSR[V

YRrTW]JgdJI][ªnJSg @]^fH /LUw,3 CEDGJhUTfRJSR/Y[DzTWYTW]J

iG^fYvhS^«ªnJI]JSgi¯Y[DdRv]J@JI]JIiGhSJ¤TW]Jcd]^UªnJSgi >JShIY[^fi7oB)9G^f]±Y[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{.VGJIVGJKR[¹UJq»iGJ

TW][{qVdHKJIiYR¶DzTUªnJvY^ueJ±gdJI][ªnJSg°CEDGJIZ¦TW]Jv{qªnJIi¦i >JShIY[^fi 8¤TWiGgY[DGJIi©gdJIªnJ ^fceJSgri >JShIY[^fiGR*l

TWiGg 1B9 izT ZnGhS^fiGh VGgBid{~]JIH<TW][R¶TW]J±gBRhIVGRRJSg/i >JShIY[^fi¯m

.

%$

% 0

.

!0

a^fiGR[gdJI]~Y[DGJrR[Y[VzTWY[^figdJSRhI][ueJSgiY[DGJiY[]^gBVGhIY[^fi

Y[DY

^ idR¤TWiGg

Y[DhI]^qRR<Y[]T4D<hq

VGR[Y[]TWYJSgi09 {qVd]J±pB RTWiVGRJI]^WY[DGJ*iGJIY

^f][e

JvTW]J*iYJI]JSR[YJSgruZ¤Y[DGJ!gdJ TSZBR^W^fVd]^

i

czTfhnJIYR«N ¢i^fVd]¶HK^.gdJ %Y[DGJYTW{q{nJSg06z^

hS^f][]JSR[ce^fiGgY^<Y[DGJSRJR[cJShI£´zhvczTfhnJIYRUN¸¨J¡TfRR[VdHKJ

node 2 cross traffic

node 1

node 4

node 3

ζ_n⁽⁴⁾ n

n−1

n+ 2

n+ 1 n+ 3 n+ 4

n+ 5

9 {qVd]JvpK?CEDGJ±hUTfRJ!^WY

^ idBRU

Y[DzTWY*Y[DGJ¡RJI][ª.hSJY[HKJSR!^W(czTfhnJIYR±^W(Y[DGJYTW{q{nJSg 6z^

TW]JiGJI{ {qu JhS^fHczTW]JSgY^~Y[DGJ¡.VGJIVGJIid{

gdJ TSZBRU©¸¨J¤RJSJ¤Y[DzTWYY[DGJ¤Y[HKJ/R[ceJIiYiT¦RJI][ªnJI]¡RH<TWi Z gBVGJ~Y^Y[DGJ~hI]^qRRY[]T4D<hqCEDVGR¡i

^f]gdJI]¶Y^~TWizT

Z¹UJvY[DGJgdJ

TSZ¦^WY[DGJYTW{q{nJSg¦czTfhnJIYRU

JgdJ´GiGJY[DGJ±ª][Y[VzT

RJI][ª.hSJvY[HKJSR®^f]NJUTfhD

(9)

YTW{q{nJSgczTfhnJIY,Y^ueJ*Y[DGJvTWHK^fVdiY¶^W4hI]^qRRY[]T4D<hvTW][][ªnJSg¦uJIY

JSJIi¦Y

^~R[VGhShSJSRR[ªnJvTW][][ªqT R^WY[DGJ

YTW{q{nJSghIVGR[Y^fHKJI]RUCEDdR¡§ª.][Y[VzT ¬,RJI][ªhSJ±Y[HKJ±RNgdJIiG^fYJSgTfR

ζ_n⁽ⁱ⁾ ^{§É®^f]} ^id i¬CEDGJSRJRJS.VGJIiGhSJSR

ueJ*TfRR[VdHKJSg¤Y^¡uJ*R[Y^hDzTfR[Y[hUT

Z¤iGgdJIceJIiGgdJIiYNTWiGg/Y^DzTSªnJ*DGJUTUª.Z.¼YTW

JSgrgBR[Y[][udVdY[^fiGR«4CEDGJ

Y[D³R[VGhD ª.][Y[VzT RJI][ªhSJKY[HKJSR:¬!RT¦R[id{ J<h TfRR*9 M9 .VGJIVGJIid{

iGJIY

^f][

9d]^fHiG^

^fi°czTfhnJIYR

Lq ¢i¦^fVd]NJXGTWHc Jq

J

TWiY¶Y^KHK^gdJ T<R[Y[VzTWY[^fi

DGJI]JTczTfhnJIYNY[DzTWY JUTSªnJSRNY[DGJ!´G]R[YNiG^.gdJvR

Y[D

iVdHuJI]R

n^TWiGg n+ 2 ^TW]J TWY[id{Ki¤Y[DGJ¶]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{udVBeJI]®^f]bY[DGJ¶czTfhnJIYi.VdHvueJI]

n−1 ^§®TWiGg

Y[DGJIi

n+ 1¬ N^fYJ¶Y[DzTWYEi/Y[DdRhUTfRJqczTfhnJIYR

n ^TWiGg n+ 2DzTUªnJ*iGJShSJSRRTW][Z<ueJSJIi/]^fVdYJSg/Y^iG^.gdJ w

DGJIirY[DGJIZ

JY,iG^.gdJLq ¢iGgdJSJSgY[DGJ*®^

^

id{K]JIH<TW][

ueJ!^WHce^f][YTWiGhSJ±i

DzTWY@^

^ R"?

¤À ¨d + 7 0C+" % @& !,+ :C KE+G0%" @%

P K O K @ K5 "

¸ DGJIi

J hS^fiGR[gdJI]*Y[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{/.VGJIVGJ¡R[¹UJq

JTW]JhS^fVdiY[id{Y[DGJiVdHuJI]!^W¶§ª][Y[VzT ¬

JKDzTSªnJY^YTWnJKiY^¦TfhShS^fVdi.YT

HvV Y[c hUTWY[ªnJv¼TfhIY^f]Y[DzTWY,gdJIceJIiGgdR^firY[DGJ!R[YTWY[R[Y[hv^W Y[DGJ±hI]^qRRY[]T4D<hq

¸¨J!iG^

ud][J6GZ/{qªnJvT*6%TSªn^f]¶^W^fVd]]JSRV YRiY[DGJ±hUTfRJ!gdJIcdhIYJSg^fi09 {qVd]JvpK?

¤À %É +C+ K@ K " L@ +" "C *H%"

i +<K "!# L&

P(ζ_n⁽ⁱ⁾> x)∼`ix^−αⁱ, ^,+ x→ ∞,

K

α_i >1 `_i ≥0^: ⁺ ^{+: P@} ^@ p ^{* KK} ⁺ ^*+" ^L ^%" 2 ^% ^K

G "

(1−p) ^+<+ ^L%" 3

$ K ,+! L@ +55 KHC+" % &@!

R ^! ^K*^H+" ^% ^"#$ ⁺ ^,&%!

P(R > x)∼C_R(p)x⁻^maxⁱ^(αⁱ⁾⁻¹, ^,+ x→ ∞,

K

C_R(p) ^+<' ^@ < K<K % (%%& !

p ^K@ ^{+ ,} ^*)%&⁺ ⁰ ^P

&&' +

$ K ,+! L@ +*5 K*C+ , P- *+C/.

Q_r ^! ^< ^*+(% ^{0K +} ^O%"#$

+@ ,1%!

P(Q_r> n)∼C_Q(p)n⁻^maxⁱ^(αⁱ⁾⁻¹, ⁺ n→ ∞,

K K2 %"

C_Q(p) ⁺³ ^{% 4} C_R(p)

¸¨J

^fcdY[H¹UJ/gdJ TUZ TWiGg .VGJIVGJ¤R[¹UJ¤TfRZ.HcdY^fY[hSRUu.Z¨gdJIYJI][Hidid{¨^fcdY[H<T ªfT VGJSR^W

p

Y[DzTWY<HidH¹UJ

CR(p) ^{^f]} CQ(p) ^TWiGg ^J RJSJigdJIYTW

R~Y[DGJHc

hUTWY[^fiGR/gBVGJrY^¨Y[DGJ¼TfhIY

Y[DzTWY

C_R(p) 6= C_Q(p) CEDdR<^fcdY[H¹«TWY[^fi RKHce^f][YTWiY¤ueJShUTWVGRJYKR

J iG^

iY[DzTWY~C,a\

ceJI]#@^f][HKR*ce^.^f] Z¦VdiGgdJI]±R[{qid£´zhUTWiY!czTfhnJIY±]JS^f]gdJI][id{Y[DzTWY!R¶iG^fY!iGJShSJSRRTW][ZhUTWVGRJSgu.Z¦czTfhnJIY

^qRRJSR /áo,3 NVd]~]JSR[V

YR<hUTWiJXBc

TWiY[DGJrc^

JI]

T

R~^fuGRJI][ªnJSgJIHcd][hUT

ZuZ65%DG^fV TWiGg ;(TWi

¥JI{qDGJIH·i /ápqx,3 @^f]¶Y[DGJ]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{/^W s*\ czTfhnJIYRU*¸¨J¡R[DG^fV gR[Y[]JSRR¶Y[DzTWY*]JS^f]gdJI][id{hUTWi

ueJShS^fHKJ,T!R[{qid£´zhUTWi.Y4¼TfhIY^f]4iY[DGJE@VdY[Vd]J i.YJI][iGJIYTfR]JSRV Y(^WiGhI]JUTfRJSgczTW]T J R[Hr(NVd]4HK^gdJ

R±TfhShIVd]TWYJ®^f]*Y[DGJKR[Y[VGgBZ^WE^fY[DGJI]!iGJIY

^f][BR

Y[D¯]TfgBhUT Z¯gB£°JI]JIiYvhDzTW]TfhIYJI][R[Y[hSRvY^^d¡CEDdR

RY[DGJvhUTfRJ±^W

]J JSRRiGJIY

^f][BRUzi¦czTW][Y[hIV TW]NHV Y[£¼DG^fc¦HK^fudJTfg¼DG^h±iGJIY

^f][BRU irY[DdRNhUTfRJ

(10)

node 1 p

1−p

node 2

node 3

node 4

9 {qVd]JH8 ?ONJSRJSVGJIiGhIid{<cd]^fu JIHr

]^fVdY[id{rcd]^fY^hS^

DdhD¨H<TSZ

JUTfg¯Y^/czTfhnJIYv]JS^f]gdJI][id{ §@gBVGJ

Y^¡Y[DGJ!HV Y[c J±czTWY[DGRNTfRir^fVd],JXdTWHc J«¬

¢iY[DGJ~RJSVGJ

J~R[DzT Y[DVGR¡hS^fiGR[gdJI]Y[DGJKHK^gdJ gdJSRhI][ueJSg i 9 {qVd]J8Gr¸¨J~TfRR[VdHKJ<Y[DzTWY

T cd]^.hSJSRR

{T_n}^¸¨J ^{HK^.gdJ} ^Y[DGJ

]^fVdY[id{¯TWY±iG^.gdJLKu.ZTEJI][iG^fV b]^fVdY[id{G¦NiGhSJ~czTfhnJIY

k ]JUTfhDGJSRY[DGJK]JShSJIªnJI]U Y JUTSªnJSRY[DGJ R[ZBR[YJIH £¶T czTfhnJIYR

j ^Y[D j < k ^DzTUªnJrT ^]JUTfgBZ J@YY[DGJ/R[ZBR[YJIHr¨NY[DGJI]

RJ¤YR[YTSZBRi Y[DGJ

]JSRJS.VGJIiGhIid{KudVB°JI]U

DGJI]J!Y

TWYR®^f]Y[DGJ!czTfhnJIYR

Y[DriVdHuJI] JSRRY[DzTWi

k

NiGJ^Wv^fVd]<H<TWiY^^ i ^fVd]¤TWizT ZBR[R

uJ¦Y[DGJ

^f][^WTfhShSJ !TWiGg 9G^qRR<i /áp3¶TWiGg

Y[DGJ±R[VduGRJSVGJIi.Y

^f][BR,gd^fiGJvi /8@3TWiGg /LUw,3¸¨J±ud][J6GZ/gdJSRhI][uJ!DG^

J±hUTWirHK^gdJ Y[DGJ±R[ZBR[YJIH

gdJSRhI][ueJSgTWue^UªnJ(Y[DzTWidRY^Y[DGJ,§H<T?X°c VGR:¬T {nJIud]Tv§@^f] \JIY[][iGJIY:¬CEDdR»®^f][H<T R[H R»iG^fYJSRRJIi.Y[ºT

i^fVd]~czTWcJI]/TWiGg

J¦]J®JI]<Y^7/áw43,®^f]KHK^f]J¦]J®JI]JIiGhSJSRUµ¶^

JIªnJI]U

JR[Y[]JSRR<Y[DzTWY§H<T?X°c VGR:¬

®^f][H<T R[H R,hI][VGhIºT @^f],Y[DGJ!cd]^.^W4^WCEDGJS^f]JIH L±uJ ^ §Y[DzTWYNhUTWirueJ*®^fVdiGgiF/LUw,3¬b i¦ª.J

^W

Y[DGJnJIZ©]^

J<^WEY[DdR±Y[DGJS^f]JIH @^f]^fVd]TWizT

ZRRU

JKhDG^qRJKY^rR[DG^

Y[DGJKhS^fidiGJShIY[^fi7ueJIY

JSJIi7^fVd]

HK^gdJ TWiGg¨§H<T?Xec VGR¬T {nJIud]TB(¥^f]JS^UªnJI]UzY,T ^

R®^f]NT][{n^f]^fVGR,cd]JSRJIiYTWY[^fi^W^fVd]HK^gdJ

a^fiGR[gdJI]/Y[DGJR[YTWiGgGTW]g@^f][TWiGg_#^fi R[ZBR[YJIH TfR¤gdJIcdhIYJSg §

Y[D \ JIY[][*iGJIY<®^f][H<T R[H~¬<i

9 {qVd]J±lB i¤Y[DdRTWVBXB

ºTW]

Z<HK^gdJ

GTgB£°JI]JIiYiGg/^W»]^fVdY[id{REirTfhIY[^fi4`(TfhDY[HKJ*TczTfhnJIY

§@RTUZ

k¬´GidRDGJSR(YRbRJI][ª.hSJ

ζ_k⁽¹⁾ ^{iKiG^gdJ} 1nY[DGJI]J,R(^fiGJ,czTfhnJIYbRJIiY(Vdc¤TWiGg<^fiGJczTfhnJIYRJIi.Ybgd^

i

R[HV YTWiGJS^fVGR ZnCEDGJVdc"¼czTfhnJIY~§ágd^

i"¼czTfhnJIY:¬*R*Y[DGJIi¨T R^¤Y[DGJ

iG^gdJp~]JSR[ceJShIY[ªnJ Zd¬*CEDGJ

k¼Y[D©czTfhnJIYE_[^fiGR,Y[DGJ¡.VGJIVGJ^W4iG^gdJ 8¤^fiGhSJue^fY[DczTfhnJIYR!DzTSªnJ J@Y iG^gdJ±wKTWiGg¦p]JSR[ceJShIY[ªnJ Zn4`(TfhD¦iG^gdJ*R,TR[YTWiGgGTW]g

·/G/1/∞ .VGJIVGJq

ζ⁽¹⁾

ζ⁽²⁾

ζ⁽³⁾ ζ⁽⁴⁾

9 {qVd]JvlK?9z^f][/TWiGg¡_[^fiHK^gdJ

CEDGJ¶§H<T?XeWc VGR:¬eRJIH£¼][id{

Rmax

RY[DGJ(RJIY

R∪{−∞}fJSVdcdceJSg

Y[D

max ][Y[YJIi¡TfgdgBY[ªnJ Z

§¼Jq

a⊕b= max(a, b)¬TWiGgvY[DGJbVGR[VzT RVdHr

][Y[YJIiHvV Y[c hUTWY[ªnJ Z§¼Jq

a⊗b=a+b^¬ ^NJIY Xn⁽ⁱ⁾