Preference Heterogeneity in Monetary Policy Committees
21
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) Département de sciences économiques Université de Montréal Faculté des arts et des sciences C.P. 6128, succursale Centre-Ville Montréal (Québec) H3C 3J7 Canada http://www.sceco.umontreal.ca SCECO-information@UMontreal.CA Téléphone : (514) 343-6539 Télécopieur : (514) 343-7221. Ce cahier a également été publié par le Centre interuniversitaire de recherche en économie quantitative (CIREQ) sous le numéro 05-2007. This working paper was also published by the Center for Interuniversity Research in Quantitative Economics (CIREQ), under number 05-2007.. ISSN 0709-9231.
(3) ) ) & + )' & "+- "& '& +)- '$" - '%%"++ * A:HH6C9GD ->7DC>6C9 "G6C8>H8D & -J<: )JG8>6. )6N . ,89C C8?BD @1@5B 5=@<?IC 9>49F94E1< F?D9>7 B53?B4C ?6 D85 %?>5D1BI (?<93I ?= =9DD55 %( ?6 D85 1>; ?6 >7<1>4 D? CDE4I 85D5B?75>59DI 9> @?<93I @B565B5>35C 1=?>7 3?==9DD55 =5=25BC ,85 1>1<IC9C 9C 31BB954 ?ED EC9>7 1 C9=@<5 75>5B1<9J1D9?> ?6 D85 CD1>41B4 &5? #5I>5C91> 6B1=5G?B; D81D 1<<?GC =5=25BC D? 495B 9> D85 G5978D D85I 79F5 D? ?ED@ED 3?=@1B54 G9D8 9>1D9?> CD129<9J1D9?> 1>4 9> D859B F95GC B571B49>7 ?@D9=1< 9>1D9?> 1>4 >1DEB1< ?ED@ED *5CE<DC 9>4931D5 D81D
(4) AE1<9D1D9F5<I
(5) %( =5= 25BC 1B5 619B<I 8?=?75>5?EC 9> D859B @?<93I @B565B5>35C
(6) 2ED D81D D85B5 1B5 CICD5=1D93 AE1>D9D1D9F5 495B5>35C 9> D859B @?<93I B513D9?> 6E>3D9?>C D81D 1B5 B5<1D54 D? D85 >1DEB5 ?6 D859B =5=25BC89@ 1>4 31B55B 213;7B?E>4
(7)
(8)
(9) ?==9DD55C
(10) B513D9?> 6E>3D9?>C
(11) 1>; ?6 >7<1>4. . 5@1BD5=5>D 45 C395>35C 53?>?=9AE5C
(12) ->9F5BC9D5 45 %?>DB51< 5@1BD5=5>D 45 C395>35C 53?>?=9AE5C 1>4 !* )
(13) ->9F5BC9D5 45 %?>DB51<.
(14) . &+)' , +"'&. /=>H H=DGI E6E:G JH:H I=: >C9>K>9J6A KDI>C< G:8DG9H D; I=: )DC:I6GN ,DA>8N DBB>II:: ), . D; I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 ID HIJ9N I=: :MI:CI 6C9 C6IJG: D; EG:;:G:C8: =:I:GD<:C:>IN 6BDC< 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH 0C9:GHI6C9>C< 8DBB>II::H >H >BEDGI6CI 7:86JH: B6CN 8:CIG6A 76C@H JH: 6 8DBB>II:: HIGJ8IJG: ID ;DGBJA6I: EDA>8N /=>H >H I=: 86H:
(15) ;DG :M6BEA:
(16) >C DJI D; I=: 8:CIG6A 76C@H HIJ9>:9 7N "GN * " I I=: I=:DG:I>86A A:K:A
(17) L: JH: 6 H>BEA: <:C:G6A>O6I>DC D; I=: HI6C96G9 *:D ':NC:H>6C ;G6B:LDG@ I=6I 6AADLH B:B7:GH ID 9>:G >C I=: G:A6I>K: L:><=I I=:N 6II68= ID DJIEJI , ()+) >C6I>DC HI67>A>O6I>DC 6C9 >C I=:>G K>:LH G:<6G9>C< DEI>B6A >C6I>DC 6C9 C6IJG6A DJIEJI 0C9:G I=: 6HHJBEI>DC D; H>C8:G: KDI>C<
(18) I=: >C9>K>9J6A G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH 6G: 9:G>K:9 6C9 :HI>B6I:9 ;DG :68= B:B7:G 6C9 ;DG I=: 8DBB>II:: 6H 6 L=DA: /=: BD9:A >BEA>:H I=6I
(19) <>K:C I=: :8DCDBN E6G6B:I:GH 6C9 EG>K6I: H:8IDG :ME:8I6I>DCH
(20) 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH 6<G:: DC I=:>G G:68I>DC ID I=: :ME:8I:9 DJIEJI <6E 6C9 9:B6C9 H=D8@H 6C9 9>H6<G:: DC I=:>G G:68I>DC ID :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC 6C9 HJEEAN H=D8@H %C 699>I>DC
(21) B:B7:GH L>AA 9>:G HNHI:B6I>86AAN >C I=:>G EG:;:GG:9 >CI:G:HI G6I: :K:C >; I=:N H=6G: I=: H6B: >C6I>DC I6G<:I 6C9 :HI>B6I: D; I=: C6IJG6A DJIEJI G6I: GHI HC6EH=DI D; I=: ), KDI>C< G:8DG9H G:K:6AH I=6I 9>H6<G::B:CI >H ;G:FJ:CI 6I I=: EDA>8N B::I>C<H D; I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 %C 67DJI ILD I=>G9H D; B::I>C<H 7:IL::C &JC: 6C9 &JC: 9:8>H>DCH L:G: CDI JC6C>BDJH .JBB6GN HI6I>HI>8H A>@: I=DH: 8DBEJI:9
(22) ;DG :M6BEA:
(23) 7N #:GA68= 'G>HI:C 6C9 .E:C8:G 6G: HJ<<:HI>K: D; =:I:GD<:C:DJH EG:; :G:C8:H DK:G EDA>8N DI= HIJ9>:H 8DC8AJ9: I=6I :MI:GC6A B:B7:GH 6EE:6G ID =6K: 9>:G:CI KDI>C< E6II:GCH I=6C >CI:GC6A DC:H
(24) I:C9 ID 9>HH:CI BDG: ;G:FJ:CIAN 6C9
(25) L=:C I=:N 9>HH:CI
(26) 6G: BDG: A>@:AN ID KDI: ;DG 6 ADL:G >CI:G:HI G6I: /=:H: G:HJAIH B>GGDG I=: DC:H D7I6>C:9 7N I=: A>I:G6IJG: DC I=: ":9:G6A +E:C )6G@:I DBB>II:: "+)
(27) L=>8= JHJ6AAN C9H I=6I D6G9 B:B7:GH 6EE:6G ID EG:;:G BDG: :ME6CH>DC6GN EDA>8N I=6C I=: -:H:GK: 6C@ EG:H> 9:CIH H:: :A9:C
(28)
(29) #>A9:6
(30) $6KG>A:H@N 6C9 .8=L:>IO:G
(31)
(32) 6C9 $6KG>A:H@N 6C9 #>A9:6
(33) /=: 6;DG:B:CI>DC:9 A>I:G6IJG: JH:H 9>HH:CI>C< KDI:H DCAN 6C9 6C6ANH:H 9>:G :C8:H >C I=: KDI>C< 7:=6K>DG D; I=: ILD <GDJEH 7N 8DBE6G>C< 9>HH:CI>C< ;G:FJ:C8>:H /DDI:AA
(34)
(35) L=DH: 6EEGD68= >H ;DAADL:9 =:G:
(36) JH:H >CHI:69 6AA KDI:H 6C9 >CK:HI><6I:H =:I:GD <:C:>IN L>I=>C I=: "+) 7N 8DBE6G>C< 8D:8>:CIH D; >C9>K>9J6A EDA>8N G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH DCIG6GN ID I=: EG:K>DJH A>I:G6IJG:
(37) =: C9H CD :K>9:C8: D; 6 HNHI:B6I>8 9>:G:C8: D; KDI>C< E6II:GH 7:IL::C D6G9 B:B7:GH 6C9 6C@ EG:H>9:CIH %C9>K>9J6A G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH 6G: 6AHD :HI>B6I:9 7N =6EE:AA * " /=: A>I:G6IJG: =6H 6AHD 8DCH>9:G:9 DI=:G ;68IDGH I=6I B6N =6K: 6C ::8I DC "+) KDI>C< 7:=6K>DG
(38) HJ8= 6H 86G::G 768@<GDJC9H H::
(39) $6KG>A:H@N 6C9 .8=L:>IO:G
(40)
(41) 6C9 #>A9:6
(42) 6C9 G:<>DC6A 6A>6I>DCH "DG :M6BEA:
(43) ):69: 6C9 .=::IH C9 I=6I G:<>DC6A JC:BEADNB:CI G6I:H =6K: 6 HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>86CI ::8I DC 35.
(44) I=: KDI>C< E6II:GCH D; 6C@ EG:H>9:CIH 6C9 D6G9 B:B7:GH 6A>@: /=: B6>C :BE>G>86A G:HJAIH 6G: I=: ;DAADL>C< ">GHI
(45) 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH 7:=6K: >C 6<G:: B:CI L>I= :8DCDB>8 I=:DGN >C I=: H:CH: I=6I I=:N <:C:G6AAN ;6KDG =><=:G ADL:G >CI:G:HI G6I:H L=:C >C6I>DC JC:BEADNB:CI >H :ME:8I:9 ID >C8G:6H: 6C9 I=: DK:G>9:CI>86I>DC G:HIG>8I>DCH D; I=: BD9:A 6G: CDI G:?:8I:9 7N I=: 96I6. /=JH
(46) >C FJ6A>I6I>K: I:GBH
(47) ), . B:B7:GH 6G: ;6>GAN =DBD<:C:DJH >C I=:>G EDA>8N EG:;:G:C8:H .:8DC9
(48) I=: ?D>CI =NEDI=:H>H I=6I >C9>K>9J6A G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC 8D:8>:CIH 6G: ID :FJ6A I=DH: D; I=: 8DBB>II:: >H G:?:8I:9 7N I=: 96I6 $:C8:
(49) >C FJ6CI>I6I>K: I:GBH
(50) I=:G: >H HDB: =:I:GD<:C:>IN >C I=: EDA>8N G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH /=>G9
(51) I=>H =:I:GD<:C:>IN 6EE:6GH ID 7: HNHI:B6I>8 >C I=6I >C9>K>9J6AH L=D ;6KDG 6 HIGDC< G:HEDCH: ID :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC DG JC:BEADNB:CI 9D HD G:<6G9A:HH D; I=: ;DG:86HIH =DG>ODC. "DJGI=
(52) HNHI:B6I>8 =:I:GD<:C:>IN 6EE:6GH ID 7: G:A6I:9 L>I= I=: C6IJG: D; I=:. B:B7:GH=>E L=:I=:G :MI:GC6A DG >CI:GC6A 6C9 >C9>K>9J6A 768@<GDJC9 L=:I=:G 6869:B>6
(53) EG>K6I: H:8IDG DG 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 . %C E6GI>8JA6G
(54) I=: B:9>6C :MI:GC6A B:B7:G I:C9H ID. G:68I BDG: HIGDC<AN ID :ME:8I:9 JC:BEADNB:CI I=6C I=: B:9>6C >CI:GC6A B:B7:G
(55) 7JI 6H HIGDC<AN ID :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC /=: E6E:G >H DG<6C>O:9 6H ;DAADLH .:8I>DC 9:H8G>7:H I=: BD9:A I=6I BDI>K6I:H I=: :BE>G>86A HE:8>86I>DC
(56) .:8I>DC G:EDGIH :BE>G>86A G:HJAIH
(57) 6C9 .:8I>DC 8DC8AJ9:H. . ! ' $. DCH>9:G 6 BDC:I6GN EDA>8N 8DBB>II:: 8DBEDH:9 D; B:B7:GH HHJB: I=6I B:B7:GH =6K: =:I:GD<:C:DJH EDA>8N EG:;:G:C8:H >C I=: H:CH: I=6I I=:N B6N 6II68= 9>:G:CI G:A6I>K: L:><=IH ID DJIEJI , ()+) >C6I>DC HI67>A>O6I>DC 6C9 B6N =6K: 9>:G:CI K>:LH G:<6G9>C< I=: DEI>B6A >C6I>DC G6I: 6C9 I=: IGJ: C6IJG6A DJIEJI A:K:A /=: E6ND D; B:B7:G
(58)
(59)
(60) >C :68= E:G>D9 >H
(61) .
(62) . L=:G: >H I=: >C6I>DC G6I:
(63) >H 6C DJIEJI B:6HJG:
(64) 6C9 6G:
(65) G:HE:8I>K:AN
(66) I=:. DEI>B6A >C6I>DC G6I: 6C9 I=: C6IJG6A A:K:A D; 688DG9>C< ID B:B7:G
(67) 6C9 >H I=: G:A6I>K: L:><=I I=6I B:B7:G 6II68=:H ID DJIEJI HI67>A>O6I>DC *DGB6A>O>C< I=: >C6I>DC L:><=I ID DC: :CI6>AH CD ADHH D; <:C:G6A>IN /=: HE:8>6A 86H: L=:G: B:B7:GH 6<G:: DC 6 EDHH>7AN I>B: K6GN>C< >C6I>DC I6G<:I 8DGG:HEDC9H ID ;DG 6AA /=: 9>:G:C8: 7:IL::C B:B7:G H :HI>B6I: D; I=: C6IJG6A G6I: 6C9 >IH IGJ: K6AJ: >H 6HHJB:9 ID 7: L:AA 6EEGDM>B6I:9 7N
(68) . L=:G: >H 6C 6JID8DGG:A6I:9 9>HIJG76C8: L>I= O:GD B:6C 6C9 8DCHI6CI 8DC9>I>DC6A K6G>6C8: 35.
(69) /=>H ;DGBJA6I>DC 6AADLH I=: HE:8>6A 86H:H L=:G: 6AA B:B7:GH H=6G: I=: H6B: :HI>B6I: D; I=: C6IJG6A G6I: L=:C ;DG 6AA /=: 7:=6K>DG D; I=: EG>K6I: H:8IDG >H HJBB6G>O:9 7N
(70). .
(71). . L=:G: >H I=: CDB>C6A >CI:G:HI G6I:
(72)
(73)
(74) 6G: 8DCHI6CI E6G6B:I:GH
(75)
(76) 6G: >CI:<:G CJB7:GH
(77) 9:CDI:H I=: EJ7A>8H :ME:8I6I>DCH 8DC9>I>DC6A DC >C;DGB6I>DC 6K6>A67A: 6I I>B:
(78) 6C9 6C9 6G: :MD<:CDJH 6JID8DGG:A6I:9 9>HIJG76C8:H L>I= O:GD B:6C 6C9 8DCHI6CI 8DC9>I>DC6A K6G>6C8: !FJ6I>DC >H 6C %. 8JGK: 6C9 :FJ6I>DC >H I=: *:D ':NC:H>6C ,=>AA>EH 8JGK: /=: %. 8JGK: B6N 7: 9:G>K:9 ;GDB 6 A>C:6G>O:9 !JA:G :FJ6I>DC ;DG 8DCHJBEI>DC 6C9 I=: G:HDJG8: 8DCHIG6>CI H::
(79) )8 6AAJB 6C9 *:AHDC
(80) /=: *:D ':NC:H>6C ,=>AA>EH 8JGK: B6N 7: 9:G>K:9 ;GDB I=: A>C:6G>O:9 EG>8>C< 9:8>H>DC D; 6 EGDI B6M>B>O>C< BDCDEDA>HI>8 8DBE:I>IDG >C 6 HI>8@N EG>8: :CK>GDCB:CI DBB>II:: B:B7:GH 6G: 6HHJB:9 ID H>C8:G:AN 86HI I=:>G KDI: ;DG I=: >CI:G:HI G6I: I=6I B6M>B>O:H I=:>G E6ND >C I=: 8JGG:CI E:G>D9 HJ7?:8I ID 6C9 0C9:G 9>H8G:I>DC
(81) I=: DEI>B6A >CI:G:HI G6I: BJHI H6I>H;N I=: GHI DG9:G 8DC9>I>DC . . . 0H>C< 6C9 I=: 6<<G:<6I: G:A6I>DCH 6C9
(82) DC: 86C LG>I: . . . . . . . . . . .
(83). . . L=:G: >H B:B7:G H EG:;:GG:9 >CI:G:HI G6I: #>K:C I=: :8DCDBN E6G6B:I:GH 6C9 EG>K6I: H:8IDG :ME:8I6I>DCH
(84) I=G:: :BE>G>86A >BEA>86 I>DCH ;DAADL ;GDB !FJ6I>DC ">GHI
(85) 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH 6<G:: DC I=:>G EDA>8N G:68I>DC ID I=: :ME:8I:9 DJIEJI <6E 6C9 9:B6C9 H=D8@H /D H:: I=>H
(86) CDI: I=6I I=: 8D:8>:CIH D; 6C9 6G: 7DI= :FJ6A ID
(87) L=>8= >H I=: >CK:GH: D; I=: HADE: D; I=: %. 8JGK: .:8DC9
(88) 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH 9>H6<G:: >C I=:>G G:68I>DC ID :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC 6C9 HJEEAN H=D8@H. /=>H ;DAADLH ;GDB I=: D7H:GK6I>DC I=6I I=: 8D:8>:CIH D; 6C9 . . !D 9C 51CI D? 75>5B1<9J5 D85 =?45< D? D85 31C5 G85B5 =5=25B C 5CD9=1D5 ?6 D85 >1DEB1< B1D5 495BC CICD5=1D931<<I 6B?= 9DC DBE5 F1<E5 2I 9>DB?4E39>7 1 >?> J5B?
(89) =5=25B C@5393 9>D5B35@D 9> AE1D9?> ,89C 75>5B1<9J1D9?> 4?5C >?D 381>75 D85 B54E354 6?B= ?6 D85 B513D9?> 6E>3D9?> 5CD9=1D54 25<?G 2ED 9D 381>75C D85 CDBE3DEB1< 9>D5B@B5D1D9?> ?6 9DC 9>D5B35@D. 35.
(90) 9:E:C9 DC I=: >9>DHNC8G6I>8 EG:;:G:C8: E6G6B:I:G ">C6AAN
(91) :K:C >; B:B7:GH H=6G: I=: H6B: >C6I>DC I6G<:I 6C9 :HI>B6I: D; I=: C6IJG6A G6I: B:6C>C< I=6I 6C9 ;DG 6AA
(92) I=:N LDJA9 9>H6<G:: >C I=:>G EG:;:GG:9 >CI:G:HI G6I: 7:86JH: I=: 8D:8>:CIH D; 6C9 6AHD 9:E:C9 DC . /=: G:6HDC L=N B:B7:GH 6<G:: >C I=:>G G:HEDCH: ID 9:B6C9 H=D8@H 7JI 9>H6<G:: >C I=:>G G:HEDCH: ID HJEEAN H=D8@H >H I=: ;DAADL>C<. %C I=: *:D ':NC:H>6C BD9:A
(93) I=: ::8I D;. 9:B6C9 H=D8@H DC I=: DJIEJI <6E B6N 7: DH:I 9>G:8IAN 7N 8=6C<:H >C I=: CDB>C6A >CI:G:HI G6I: H:: !F . $DL:K:G
(94) DH:II>C< I=: ::8I D; HJEEAN H=D8@H DC >C6I>DC G:FJ>G:H 6 BDC:I6GN EDA>8N >C9J8:9 8=6C<: >C I=: DJIEJI <6E 6C9
(95) 8DCH:FJ:CIAN
(96) 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH ;68: 6 IG69: D 7:IL::C >C6I>DC 6C9 DJIEJI HI67>A>O6I>DC. %(")" $ &$-*"*. . +. /=: KDI>C< 96I6 8DCH>HIH D; I=: EG:;:GG:9 >CI:G:HI G6I:H HI6I:9 7N :68= B:B7:G D; I=: )DC :I6GN ,DA>8N DBB>II:: ), D; I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 >C 6AA I=: B::I>C<H =:A9 7:IL::C &JC: 6C9 &JC: /=: H6BEA: HI6GIH L>I= I=: GHI B::I>C< D; I=: ), 6C9 :C9H 6I I=: I>B: I=: 96I6 L6H 8DAA:8I:9 0C9:G I=: 6HHJBEI>DC I=6I B:B7:GH KDI: H>C8:G:AN
(97) L: 6G: 67A: ID 6HH><C ID :68= B:B7:G =>H=:G EG:;:GG:9 EDA>8N >C :68= B::I>C< /=>H >H EDHH>7A: 7:86JH: I=: )>CJI:H G:8DG9 I=: C6B:H D; B:B7:GH >C ;6KDG D; I=: #DK:GCDGH EGDEDH6A 6C9 I=: C6B:H 6C9 EG:;:GG:9 EDA>8N DEI>DCH D; 9>HH:CI>C< B:B7:GH /=: ), 8DCH>HIH D; C>C: B:B7:GH D; L=>8= K: 6G: >CI:GC6A
(98) I=6I >H
(99) 8=DH:C ;GDB L>I=>C I=: G6C@H D; 76C@ HI6 6C9 ;DJG 6G: :MI:GC6A 6EED>CI::H %CI:GC6A B:B7:GH 6G: CDB>C6I:9 7N I=: #DK:GCDG
(100) L=>A: :M I:GC6A B:B7:GH 6G: 6EED>CI:9 7N I=: =6C8:AADG )::I>C<H 6G: 8=6>G:9 7N I=: #DK:GCDG D; I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 6C9 I6@: EA68: BDCI=AN
(101) JHJ6AAN DC I=: 2:9C:H96N 6C9 /=JGH96N 6;I:G I=: GHI )DC96N D; :68= BDCI= :8>H>DCH 6G: B69: 7N H>BEA: B6?DG>IN 6C9 KDI:H 6G: DC 6 DC: E:GHDC
(102) DC: KDI: 76H>H H D; &JC:
(103) IL:CIN ;DJG >C9>K>9J6AH =6K: 7::C B:B7:GH D; I=: ), 7JI H>M D; I=:B =6K: KDI>C< G:8DG9H I=6I 6G: IDD H=DGI ID 6AADL B:6C>C<;JA :BE>G . $9;5 ,??D5<<
(104) G5 EC5 1<< F?D5C 5<45> 1>4 1FB9<5C;I 1>4 +38G59DJ5B EC5 ?><I 49CC5>D9>7 F?D5C 81@@5<<
(105) @ 1B7E5 D81D 1 49CC5>D 61F?B9>7 1 =?F5 D?
(106) C1I
(107) D978D5> 9C 02581F9?B1<<I 495B5>D 6B?= 1> 1CC5>D D81D 3?>3EBC G9D8 1 3?==9DD55 =?F5 D? D978D5> +9>35 9> D859B F95G 49CC5>D9>7 9>F?<F5C 1 H54 3?CD 9> ED9<9DI D5B=C
(108) =5=25BC 49CC5>D ?><I G85> D85 @B565BB54 9>D5B5CD B1D5 9C CE395>D<I 495B5>D 6B?= D85 ?>5 14?@D54 2I D85 3?==9DD55 !D 6?<<?GC D81D ?><I 49CC5>D5BC B5F51< D859B DBE5 @B565BB54 9>D5B5CD B1D5 <D5B>1D9F5 71=5 D85?B5D931< =?45<C ?6 49CC5>D C55
(109) +594=1>>
(110)
(111) 1>4 B?C53<?C5 1>4 %9<I?
(112)
(113) 1B7E5 D81D ?>5 31>>?D 9>65B D85 DBE5 @B565B5>35C 6B?= 49CC5>DC !> D89C @1@5B
(114) D85 1CCE=@D9?> ?6 C9>35B5 F?D9>7 C9=@<95C D85 1>1<IC9C 1>4 :ECD95C D85 EC5 ?6 1CC5>D9>7 1>4 49CC5>D9>7 F?D5C 1<9;5. 35.
(115) >86A 6C6ANH>H ;I:G :M8AJ9>C< I=:H: >C9>K>9J6AH
(116) I=: H6BEA: G:9J8:H ID KDI:H HI6I:9 7N :><=I::C ), B:B7:GH 9JG>C< B::I>C<H "DG I=: :HI>B6I>DC D; G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH
(117) L: 6AHD JH: D; I=: I>B: H:G>:H D; >C6I>DC
(118) JC :BEADNB:CI
(119) 6C9 BDC:N <GDLI= )DCI=AN D7H:GK6I>DCH D; I=: -:I6>A ,G>8: %C9:M -,%
(120) DCHJB:G ,G>8: %C9:M ,% 6C9 JC:BEADNB:CI G6I: L:G: I6@:C ;GDB I=: 2:7 H>I: D; I=: 0' *6I>DC6A .I6I>HI>8H ---)** )* ) %,+! /=: HID8@ D; BDC:N >H B:6HJG:9 7N I=: :C9 D; BDCI= K6AJ: D; DJIHI6C9>C< ) 6C9 L6H I6@:C ;GDB I=: 2:7 H>I: D; I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 ---$!% $ "$%+! . . '&'% +)" +)+ -. /=: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC D; B:B7:G B6N 7: LG>II:C >C G:9J8:9 ;DGB 6H
(121) L=:G:. . . . .
(122)
(123) .
(124). . . .>C8: I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 ;DAADLH 6C >C6I>DC I6G<:I>C< EDA>8N
(125) I=: 9:C>I>DC D; I=: >CI:G8:EI
(126)
(127) :MEA>8>IAN 6HHJB:H I=6I 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH H=6G: I=: H6B: >C6I>DC I6G<:I $DL:K:G
(128) CDI>8: I=6I 7:86JH: 6AHD 9:E:C9H DC I=: EG:;:G:C8: E6G6B:I:G
(129)
(130) I=: >CI:G8:EI >C I=: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC >H B:B7:G HE:8>8 "DG I=: H6B: G:6HDC
(131) I=: >C6I>DC 8D:8>:CI
(132)
(133) 6C9 I=: K6G>6C8: D; I=: 9>HIJG76C8: I:GB 6G: B:B7:G HE:8>8 6H L:AA %C EG>C8>EA:
(134) I=: DJIEJI . '6 D85C5 C9H
(135) 6?EB 1B5 F5BI B535>D =5=25BC ?6 D85 %( 1>4
(136) 1C ?6 "E>5
(137) D85I 814 @1BD939@1D54 9> ?><I DG5<F5 .1<D?>
(138) 5978D " 95F5
(139) 6?EB <1>38?G5B
(140) 1>4 ?>5 , 5C<5I =55D9>7C 1F95C G1C 1 =5=25B 9> D85 ?B979>1< %( 3?==9DD55 2ED @1BD939@1D54 ?><I 9> DG? =55D9>7C ?> "E>5 1>4 "E<I E44 G1C =5=25B 6B?= 535=25B D? %1I 2ED 89C F?D9>7 B53?B4 3?>C9CDC ?6 ?><I ?2C5BF1D9?>C (B9?B D? &?F5=25B
(141) =9>ED5C B5@?BD54 G85D85B 49CC5>D9>7 =5=25BC 61F?B54 D978D5B ?B <??C5B @?<93I
(142) 2ED >?D D85 9>D5B5CD B1D5C D85I F?D54 6?B ,89C =51>C D81D 1 D?D1< ?6 49CC5>D9>7 F?D5C 6B?= D85 @5B9?4 "E>5 D? '3D?25B 3?E<4 >?D 25 EC54 6?B D85 5CD9=1D9?> ?6 D85 9>49F94E1< B513D9?> 6E>3D9?>C ?6 F5 =5=25BC ,85I 1B5 % #9>7 F?D5C
(143) E44 F?D5C
(144) . E9D5B F?D5C
(145) ??481BD F?D5C
(146) 1>4 "E<9EC F?D5C H35@D 6?B . E9D5B
(147) D85 >E=25B ?6 =9CC9>7 ?2C5BF1D9?>C 9C B5<1D9F5<I C=1<< 3?=@1B54 G9D8 D85 D?D1< >E=25B ?6 9>49F94E1< ?2C5BF1D9?>C. 35.
(148) 8D:8>:CI
(149)
(150) H=DJA9 7: I=: H6B: ;DG 6AA B:B7:GH
(151) 7JI I=: 6EEGD68= I=6I L: L>AA ;DAADL =:G: >H ID :HI>B6I: 6C JCG:HIG>8I:9 K:GH>DC D; I=: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC I=6I 6AADLH ID K6GN 68GDHH B:B7:GH 6C9 I=:C HI6I>HI>86AAN I:HI L=:I=:G >H 8DCHI6CI DG CDI "DAADL>C< I=: A>I:G6IJG: ;DG :M6BEA:
(152) A6G>96 * "
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
(154) 6 K6AJ: ;DG 6C9
(155) I=: :BE>G>86A D7H:GK6I>DC I=6I BDC:I6GN EDA>8N 6:8IH DJIEJI 6C9 >C6I>DC L>I= 6 ADC< A6< BDI>K6I:H DJG JH: D; BDCI=H ;DG I=: 7:C8=B6G@ G:HJAIH $DL:K:G
(156) 6H L: L>AA H:: 7:ADL
(157) G:HJAIH JH>C< DI=:G =DG>ODCH 6G: FJ6A>I6I>K:AN H>B>A6G %CHIGJB:CIH 6G: 6 I>B: IG:C9
(158) I=: >C6I>DC I6G<:I
(159) 6C9 DC: A6< D; I=: >CI:G:HI G6I:
(160) -,% >C6I>DC
(161) ,% >C6I>DC
(162) I=: JC:BEADNB:CI G6I:
(163) 6C9 I=: G6I: D; BDC:N <GDLI=. . *,$+*. /67A: G:EDGIH 7:C8=B6G@ G:HJAIH 76H:9 DC 6 ;DG:86HI =DG>ODC D; IL:AK: BDCI=H /67A:H I=GDJ<= G:EDGI G:HJAIH JH>C< DI=:G ;DG:86HI =DG>ODCH
(164) C6B:AN /67A:
(165) 6C9 /67A:
(166) 6C9 6C9 /67A: /=:H: /67A:H H:GK: ID 6HH:HH I=: GD7JHIC:HH D; I=: G:HJAIH ID 9>:G:CI K6AJ:H D; 6C9 ,6C:A >C /67A: G:EDGIH :HI>B6I:H D; >C9>K>9J6A 6C9 8DBB>II:: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH /=:H: G:HJAIH >C9>86I: I=6I I=: KDI>C< 7:=6K>DG D; >C9>K>9J6A ), B:B7:GH >H <:C:G6AAN 8DCH>HI:CI L>I= I=: I=:DGN ">GHI
(167) ED>CI :HI>B6I:H D; I=: >C6I>DC JC:BEADNB:CI 8D:8>:CIH 6G: JHJ6AAN EDH>I>K: C:<6I>K: 6C9 HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>86CI B:6C>C< I=6I B:B7:GH I:C9 ID KDI: ID G6>H: ADL:G I=: -:ED G6I: L=:C >C6I>DC JC:BEADNB:CI IL:AK: BDCI=H 6=:69 >H :ME:8I:9 ID >C8G:6H: %C I=>H 6C9 DI=:G /67A:H
(168) I=:G: 6G: D886H>DC6A :M8:EI>DCH ID I=>H <:C:G6A . (B9?B D? 535=25B
(169) D85 9>1D9?> D1B75D 1@@<954 D? D85 DG5<F5 =?>D8 381>75 9> D85 *(!/ 9>45H. D81D 9C
(170) D85 *(! 5H3<E49>7 =?BD7175 9>D5B5CD @1I=5>DC ,85B516D5B
(171) 9D 1@@<95C D? D85 381>75 9> D85 (! *5CE<DC EC9>7 D85 *(!/ 6?B D85 C1=@<5 E>D9< 535=25B 1>4 D85 (! 16D5B D81D 1B5 C9=9<1B D? D85 ?>5C B5@?BD54 25<?G 1>4 CE@@?BD D85 C1=5 3?>3<EC9?>C ,85C5 B5CE<DC 1B5 >?D B5@?BD54 D? C1F5 C@135 2ED 1B5 1F19<12<5 6B?= D85 3?BB5C@?>49>7 1ED8?B E@?> B5AE5CD .5 1<C? 3?>C945B54 EC9>7 ?D85B ?ED@ED =51CEB5C 2ED 65G 1B5 1F19<12<5 1D D85 =?>D8<I 6B5AE5>3I ,85 &1D9?>1< !>CD9DED5 6?B 3?>?=93 1>4 +?391< *5C51B38 @B?4E35C 1 =?>D8<I ( 9>45H 41D9>7 213; D? @B9< 2ED D85 C5B95C @B5 1>4 @?CD @B9< 1B5 >?D 3?=@1B12<5 ,85 1>; ?6 >7<1>4 3?=@9<5C 1> 9>45H ?6 31@139DI ED9<9J1D9?> 21C54 ?> CEBF5I 41D1
(172) 2ED 9D 9C >?D 1F19<12<5 6?B D85 3?=@<5D5 C1=@<5. 35.
(173) D7H:GK6I>DC 7JI :M8:EI>DCH 6G: JHJ6AAN 8=6G68I:G>O:9 7N CJB:G>86AAN HB6AA 6C9 HI6I>HI>86AAN >CH><C>86CI 8D:8>:CIH .:8DC9
(174) I=: DK:G>9:CI>;N>C< G:HIG>8I>DCH D; I=: BD9:A 86CCDI 7: G:?:8I:9 ;DG 6CN 8DBB>II:: B:B7:G CDG ;DG I=: 8DBB>II:: 6H 6 L=DA: /D H:: I=>H
(175) CDI: I=6I I=: &K6AJ:H D; I:HIH G:EDGI:9 >C I=: A6HI 8DAJBC D; ,6C:A >C /67A: 6G: 6AA 67DK: HI6C96G9 H><C>86C8: A:K:AH. DBE6G>C< I=:H: G:HJAIH L>I= I=DH: >C ,6C:A >C /67A:H . I=GDJ<= >C9>86I:H I=6I I=:H: 8DC8AJH>DCH 6G: GD7JHI ID I=: ;DG:86HI =DG>ODC /=: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC 8D:8>:CIH 6G: 6AHD <G6E=>86AAN G:EDGI:9 >C "><JG: L=:G: 4EAJH:H 6G: 8D:8>:CIH D; >CI:GC6A B:B7:GH
(176) 48GDHH:H 6G: 8D:8>:CIH D; I=: :MI:GC6A B:B7:GH
(177) 6C9 K:GI>86A A>C:H 6G: I=: 8D:8>:CIH D; I=: 8DBB>II:: 6H 6 L=DA: +K:G6AA
(178) G:HJAIH >C ,6C:A 6C9 "><JG: HJ<<:HI I=6I
(179) >C FJ6A>I6I>K: I:GBH
(180) ), B:B7:GH =6K: ;6>GAN =DBD<:C:DJH EG:;:G:C8:H DK:G EDA>8N $DL:K:G
(181) I=:H: G:HJAIH 6AHD H=DL I=6I I=: B6<C>IJ9:H D; G:68I>DC 8D:8>:CIH K6GN <G:6IAN 68GDHH 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH %C DG9:G ID :M6B>C: L=:I=:G I=>H =:I:GD<:C:>IN >H HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>86CI
(182) L: E:G;DGB 26A9 I:HIH D; I=: ?D>CI CJAA =NEDI=:H>H I=6I I=: >C9>K>9J6A 8D:8>:CIH 6G: :FJ6A ID I=DH: D; I=: 8DBB>II:: 6C9 G:EDGI G:HJAIH >C ,6C:A D; /67A: "DG I=: 8DBEA:I: H6BEA:
(183) I=: =NEDI=:H>H 86C 7: G:?:8I:9 6I I=: E:G 8:CI H><C>86C8: A:K:A ;DG I=: >CI:G8:EI 6C9 >C6I>DC 8D:8>:CI 7JI CDI ;DG I=: JC:BEADNB:CI 8D:8>:CIH /=>H G:HJAI >H >C A>C: L>I= I=: >BEA>86I>DC D; I=: BD9:A I=6I B:B7:GH 6G: BDG: A>@:AN ID 9>H6<G:: DC I=:>G EDA>8N G:68I>DC ID :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC I=6C DC I=:>G G:68I>DC ID I=: :ME:8I:9 DJIEJI <6E -:86AA I=6I >C I=: BD9:A I=>H L6H 9J: ID I=: ;68I I=6I 8=6C<:H >C :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC G:FJ>G: 6 BDC:I6GN EDA>8N >C9J8:9 8=6C<: >C I=: DJIEJI <6E L=>8= A:69H ID 6 IG69: D 7:IL::C >C6I>DC 6C9 DJIEJI HI67>A>O6I>DC
(184) L=>A: 8=6C<:H >C I=: :ME:8I:9 DJIEJI <6E B6N 7: DH:I 9>G:8IAN 7N 69?JHI>C< I=: CDB>C6A >CI:G:HI G6I: "GDB ,6C:A >C /67A:H I=GDJ<=
(185) >I >H 8A:6G I=6I I=: G:?:8I>DC D; I=: CJAA =NEDI=:H>H ;DG I=: >C6I>DC 8D:8>:CIH >H GD7JHI ID I=: ;DG:86HI =DG>ODC
(186) 7JI G:HJAIH 8DC8:GC>C< I=: JC:BEADNB:CI 8D:8>:CI 6G: B>M:9 +K:G6AA
(187) I=:H: HI6I>HI>86A G:HJAIH HJ<<:HI I=6I >C9>K>9J6A EDA>8N G:HEDCH:H L>I=>C I=: ), 6G: =:I:GD<:C:DJH "><JG: I=6I EADIH I=: G:A6I>DC 7:IL::C I=: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC 8D:8>:CIH >C I=: 7:C8= B6G@ G:HJAIH K:GI>86A 6M>H 6C9 I=DH: D7I6>C:9 JH>C< DI=:G ;DG:86HI =DG>ODCH =DG>ODCI6A 6M>H %C 6AA 86H:H I=:G: >H 6 EDH>I>K: G:A6I>DC 68GDHH ;DG:86HI =DG>ODCH 6C9
(188) L>I= DCAN DC: :M8:EI>DC
(189) >I >H HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>86CI 9>:G:CI ;GDB O:GD /=>H B:6CH I=6I
(190) >C <:C:G6A
(191) >C9>K>9J6AH L=D ;6KDG 6 HIGDC< G:HEDCH: ID :ME:8I:9 >C6I>DC DG JC:BEADNB:CI 9D HD G:<6G9A:HH D; I=: ;DG:86HIH =DG>ODC /=JH
(192) I=: =:I:GD<:C:>IN >C >C9>K>9J6A EDA>8N G:HEDCH:H L>I=>C I=: ), 6EE:6GH ID 7: HNHI:B6I>8 /=:G: 6G: 6I A:6HI ILD 9>B:CH>DC 6ADC< L=>8= ), B:B7:GH HNHI:B6I>86AAN 9>:G ">GHI
(193) I=: C6IJG: D; I=:>G 6EED>CIB:CI L=:I=:G >CI:GC6A DG :MI:GC6A ID I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 6C9. 35.
(194) H:8DC9
(195) I=:>G 86G::G 768@<GDJC9 L=:I=:G 6869:B>8
(196) EG>K6I: H:8IDG DG 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 . /=JH
(197) L: 6AHD E:G;DGB I=: 26A9 I:HI 9:H8G>7:9 67DK: ;DG HJ7H6BEA:H D; 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH /=:H: G:HJAIH 6G: G:EDGI:9 >C ,6C:A D; /67A: 6C9 H=DL I=6I I=: =NEDI=:H>H I=6I >C9>K>9J6A 8D:8>:CIH 6G: :FJ6A ID I=DH: D; I=: 8DBB>II:: 86C 7: G:?:8I:9 ;DG :MI:GC6A 7JI CDI ;DG >CI:GC6A B:B7:GH
(198) 6C9 ;DG 6869:B>8
(199) 7JI CDI ;DG EG>K6I: H:8IDG DG 6C@ B:B7:GH *DI: I=6I I=:H: G:HJAIH 6G: CDI >C9:E:C9:CI 7:86JH: BDHI 6869:B>8 B:B7:GH >C I=: ), 6H 6AHD :MI:GC6A 6EED>CI::H /=>H G:HJAI >H <:C:G6AAN GD7JHI ID I=: ;DG:86HI =DG>ODC H:: ,6C:A >C /67A:H I=GDJ<= 7JI >C I=: 86H: D; I=: JC:BEADNB:CI 8D:8>:CIH G:HJAIH 6G: HDB:I>B:H B6G<>C6A /67A: H=DLH I=6I ;DG H=DGI =DG>ODCH D; I=: JC:BEADNB:CI ;DG:86HI H>M BDCI=H. I=: =NEDI=:H>H >H G:?:8I:9 ;DG EG>K6I: H:8IDG B:B7:GH
(200) 7JI CDI ;DG 6869:B>8H. .I>AA
(201) 6H 6. L=DA:
(202) I=:H: G:HJAIH HI6I>HI>86AAN 8DCGB I=: >9:6 I=6I DC: >BEDGI6CI HDJG8: D; =:I:GD<:C:>IN L>I=>C I=: ), >H I=: C6IJG: D; I=: >C9>K>9J6A B:B7:GH=>E
(203) ,6C:A >C /67A: G:EDGIH I=: G:HJAIH D; * I:HIH I=6I I=: 8DBB>II:: G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DC 8D:8>:CIH 6G: :FJ6A ID I=: B:9>6C D; I=: >C9>K>9J6A 8D:8>:CIH .>C8: I=: & K6AJ:H 6G: 67DK: HI6C96G9 H><C>86C8: A:K:AH
(204) I=: =NEDI=:H>H 86CCDI 7: G:?:8I:9 ;DG I=: >CI:G8:EI
(205) >C6I>DC
(206) DG JC:BEADNB:CI "GDB ,6C:A >C /67A:H I=GDJ<=
(207) >I 6EE:6GH I=6I I=>H G:HJAI >H GD7JHI ID I=: ;DG:86HI =DG>ODC
(208) I=DJ<= >C /67A: I=: =NEDI=:H>H LDJA9 7: G:?:8I:9 ;DG I=: >C6I>DC 8D:8>:CI 6I I=: 7JI CDI 6I I=: E:G 8:CI H><C>86C8: A:K:A .>C8: I=: 8DBB>II:: 6C9 B:9>6C 8D:8>:CIH 6G: HI6I>HI>86AAN I=: H6B: 7JI I=: 8D:8>:CIH D; 8DBB>II:: 6C9 :MI:GC6A B:B7:GH 6G: HI6I>HI>86AAN 9>:G:CI
(209) >I ;DAADLH I=6I I=: B:9>6C KDI:G >C I=: ), >H A>@:AN 7: 6C >CI:GC6A B:B7:G ,6C:A >C /67A: G:EDGIH I=: B:9>6C ;DG 6AA B:B7:GH 6C9 HJ7H6BEA:H /=:H: G:HJAIH >C9>86I: I=6I I=: B:9>6C :MI:GC6A B:B7:G G:68IH 6H HIGDC<AN ID >C6I>DC 6H I=: B:9>6C >CI:GC6A B:B7:G
(210) 7JI I=6I =:H=: I:C9H ID G:68I BDG: HIGDC<AN ID JC:BEADNB:CI HE:8>6AAN 6I ADC< ;DG:86HI =DG>ODCH -:HJAIH 6G: H>B>A6G ;DG I=: HJ7H6BEA:H D; 6869:B>8H 6C9 EG>K6I: H:8IDG B:B7:GH 8DBE6G:9 L>I= 6C@ B:B7:GH H CDI:9 67DK:
(211) I=:H: G:HJAIH 6G: >CI:GG:A6I:9 7:86JH: 6 HJ7HI6CI>6A CJB7:G D; I=: ;DGB:G B:B7:GH 6G: :MI:GC6A 6EED>CI::H. '& $,*"'&*. /=>H E6E:G :MEAD>IH I=: KDI>C< G:8DG9H D; I=: )DC:I6GN ,DA>8N DBB>II:: ), D; I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 ID HIJ9N EG:;:G:C8: =:I:GD<:C:>IN 6BDC< 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH /=: 6C6ANH>H >H BDI>K6I:9 7N I=: :BE>G>86A D7H:GK6I>DCH I=6I 9>H6<G::B:CI >H ;G:FJ:CI L>I=>C I=: ), 6C9. ?B D85 3<1CC931D9?> ?6 %( =5=25BC 9> D5B=C ?6 31B55B 213;7B?E>4
(212) G5 =?CD<I B5<I ?> D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 3?>D19>54 9> +@5>35B . ,89C B5CE<D 9C B?2ECD D? 5H3<E49>7 3819B=5> 6B?= D85 CE2C1=@<5. '> D89C @?9>D
(213) C55 1<C? 5B<138 #B9CD5> 1>4 +@5>35B . 35.
(214) 7N HJBB6GN HI6I>HI>8H G:EDGI:9 >C :6GA>:G A>I:G6IJG: L=>8= HJ<<:HI 9>:G:C8:H >C KDI>C< E6I I:GCH /=>H G:H:6G8= H=DLH I=6I
(215) >C FJ6A>I6I>K: I:GBH
(216) ), B:B7:GH 6G: ;6>GAN =DBD<:C:DJH >C I=:>G EDA>8N EG:;:G:C8:H /=6I >H
(217) >C9>K>9J6A B:B7:GH I:C9 ID KDI: ;DG 6C >CI:G:HI G6I: G6>H: 9:8G:6H: L=:C >C6I>DC JC:BEADNB:CI >H :ME:8I:9 ID >C8G:6H:
(218) 6H DC: LDJA9 :ME:8I $DL:K:G
(219) I=:G: 6G: HNHI:B6I>8 FJ6CI>I6I>K: 9>:G:C8:H >C I=:>G EDA>8N G:68I>DC ;JC8I>DCH I=6I 6EE:6G G:A6I:9 ID I=: C6IJG: D; I=: B:B7:GH=>E 6C9 EG:K>DJH 86G::G 768@<GDJC9 /=:H: HNHI:B6I>8 9>:G:C8:H B6N 7: >BEDGI6CI >C I=: 9:8>H>DC B6@>C< EGD8:HH D; I=: ), 6C9 6:8I I=: >CI:G:HI G6I: A:K:A H:A:8I:9 7N I=: 8DBB>II::. 35.
(220) ):B7:G #:DG<: '>C< (DB6M (6G<: /J8@:G :6C 6G@:G *>8@:AA AAHDEE :AA (6B7:GI J>I:G #DD9=6GI 1>8@:GH &JA>JH 269=L6C> ,A:C9:GA:>I= A:B:CI> DBB>II::. $ & !%)# *,$+* * %$ +$* %$ % $*) %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. $ , +" $ %## ** % $*) ( '+" %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI %## ** % $*) ( '+" *% * $ %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. %CI:G8:EI .
(221) $ % $*) %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI 35. I:HI .
(222) ):B7:G #:DG<: '>C< (DB6M (6G<: /J8@:G :6C 6G@:G *>8@:AA AAHDEE :AA (6B7:GI J>I:G #DD9=6GI 1>8@:GH &JA>JH 269=L6C> ,A:C9:GA:>I= A:B:CI> DBB>II::. $ ',*+& ** !
(223) #
(224) * %$ +$* %$ % $*) %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. $ , +" $ %## ** % $*) ( '+" %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI %## ** % $*) ( '+" *% * $ %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. %CI:G8:EI .
(225) $ % $*) %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI 35. I:HI .
(226) ):B7:G #:DG<: '>C< (DB6M (6G<: /J8@:G :6C 6G@:G *>8@:AA AAHDEE :AA (6B7:GI J>I:G #DD9=6GI 1>8@:GH &JA>JH 269=L6C> ,A:C9:GA:>I= A:B:CI> DBB>II::. $ ',*+& ** ! #
(227) * %$ +$* %$ % $*) %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. $ , +" $ %## ** % $*) ( '+" %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI %## ** % $*) ( '+" *% * $ %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. %CI:G8:EI .
(228) $ % $*) %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI 35. I:HI .
(229) ):B7:G #:DG<: '>C< (DB6M (6G<: /J8@:G :6C 6G@:G *>8@:AA AAHDEE :AA (6B7:GI J>I:G #DD9=6GI 1>8@:GH &JA>JH 269=L6C> ,A:C9:GA:>I= A:B:CI> DBB>II::. $ ',*+& ** ! # * %$ +$* %$ % $*) %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: !HI>B6I: H: . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. $ , +" $ %## ** % $*) ( '+" %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI %## ** % $*) ( '+" *% * $ %CI:G8:EI %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI . AA B:B7:GH !MI:GC6A %CI:GC6A 869:B>8 ,G>K6I: 6C@. %CI:G8:EI .
(230) $ % $*) %C6I>DC 0C:BEADNB:CI 35. I:HI .
(231) %* ) *% "" " ) %CI:GC6A B:B7:GH 6G: #:DG<:
(232) '>C<
(233) (DB6M
(234) (6G<:
(235) /J8@:G
(236) :6C
(237) 1>8@ :GH
(238) ,A:C9:GA:>I= 6C9 A:B:CI> /=: G:B6>C>C< B:B7:GH 6G: :MI:GC6A '>C<
(239) :6C
(240) *>8@:AA
(241) AAHDEE
(242) J>I:G 6C9 1>8@:GH =6K: 6869:B>8 768@<GDJC9 (6G<:
(243) 6G@:G
(244) :AA
(245) (6B7:GI
(246) &JA>JH 6C9 A:B:CI> 8DB: ;GDB I=: EG>K6I: H:8IDG /=: G:B6>C>C< B:B7:GH =6K: 7::C 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 HI6 DG <DK:GCB:CI D8>6AH. .:: .E:C8:G ;DG 699>I>DC6A 9:I6>AH. /=:. HJE:GH8G>EIH 6C9 9:CDI: I=: G:?:8I>DC D; I=: CJAA =NEDI=:H>H I=6I I=: IGJ: 8D:8>:CI >H O:GD 6I I=: 6C9 E:G 8:CI H><C>86C8: A:K:AH. 35.
(247) ) & * 35 :A9:C
(248) .JH6C
(249)
(250) 4,DA>8N ,G:;:G:C8:H D; "+) ):B7:GH 6H -:K:6A:9 7N >H:CI>C< 1DI:H
(251) %+($" % %$ / ( * $ $! $
(252) EE 35 =6EE:AA
(253) $:CGN 2
(254) -D7 -DN )8#G:<DG
(255) 6C9 /D99 1:GB>AN:6
(256)
(257) %## **
(258) ) %$) %$ %$ *(/ %" / 6B7G>9<: )%/ ,G:HH 35 A6G>96
(259) ->8=6G9
(260) &DG9> #6A> 6C9 )6G@ #:GIA:G
(261)
(262) 4)DC:I6GN ,DA>8N -JA:H 6C9 )68GD:8DCDB>8 .I67>A>IN !K>9:C8: 6C9 .DB: /=:DGN
(263) +(* ("/ %+($" % %$%# )
(264) EE 35 "GN
(265) )6ML:AA
(266) : CC: &JA>JH
(267) (6K6C )6=69:K6
(268) .6C9G6 -D<:G
(269) 6C9 #67G>:A .I:GC:
(270)
(271) 4':N %HHJ:H >C I=: =D>8: D; )DC:I6GN ,DA>8N "G6B:LDG@
(272) >C %$ *(/ (# -%(!) $ "%" %$* .*
(273) (6K6C )6=69:K6 6C9 #67G>:A .I:GC: :9H
(274) (DC9DC -DJI A:9<: 35 #:GA68= 'G>HI:C
(275) ,:IG6
(276)
(277) 4%CH>9:GH 6C9 +JIH>9:GH 6I I=: 6C@ D; !C<A6C9
(278) $ *(" $! $
(279) EE 35 #>A9:6
(280) &D=C
(281)
(282) 4!MEA6>C>C< "+) ):B7:GH 1DI:H
(283) >C %" * " %$%#/ % # ( $ %$ *(/ %" /
(284) /=DB6H )6N:G :9
(285) EE
(286) 6B7G>9<: 6B7G>9<: 0C>K:GH>IN ,G:HH 35 #GDH:8ADH:
(287) / 6C9 & )>AND
(288)
(289) 4 -6I>DC6A =D>8:
(290) "DGB6A /=:DG:I>8 G<JB:CI <6>CHI I=: !M>HI:C8: D; .DE=>HI>86I:9 1DI>C< >C (:<>HA6IJG:H
(291) 0 (
(292) )>B:D 35 $6KG>A:H@N
(293) /=DB6H ) 6C9 -D7:GI ( .8=L:>IO:G
(294)
(295) 4 /=:DGN D; "+) >HH:CI 1DI>C< L>I= !K>9:C8: ;GDB I=: />B: .:G>:H
(296) >C %" * " %$%#/ % # ( $ %$ *(/ %" /
(297) /=DB6H )6N:G :9
(298) EE
(299) 6B7G>9<: 6B7G>9<: 0C>K:GH>IN ,G:HH 35 $6KG>A:H@N
(300) /=DB6H ) 6C9 &D=C #>A9:6
(301)
(302) 4/=: ,DA>8N ,G:;:G:C8:H D; "+) ):B7:GH 6H -:K:6A:9 7N >HH:CI>C< 1DI:H DBB:CI
(303) %+($" % %$ / ( * $. $! $
(304) EE 35 )8 6AAJB
(305) :CC:II 6C9 !9L6G9 *:AHDC
(306)
(307) 4 C +EI>B>O>C< %. () .E:8>86I>DC ;DG )DC:I6GN ,DA>8N 6C9 JH>C:HH N8A: C6ANH>H
(308) %+($" % %$ / ( * $ $! $
(309) EE . 35.
(310) 35 ):69:
(311) !AA:C 6C9 *6I=6C .=::IH
(312) 4-:<>DC6A %CJ:C8:H DC "+) 1DI>C< ,6I I:GCH
(313) %+($" % %$ / ( * $ $! $
(314) EE 35 .:>9B6CC
(315) 6C>:A
(316)
(317) 4 /=:DGN D; 1DI>C< ,6II:GCH 6C9 ,:G;DGB6C8: >C ,G>K6I: 6C9 ,J7A>8 DBB>II::H
(318) *DII>C<=6B 0C>K:GH>IN
(319) )>B:D 35 .E:C8:G
(320) =G>HIDE=:G
(321)
(322) 4/=: >HH:CI 1DI>C< 6=6K>DJG D; 6C@ D; !C<A6C9 ), ):B7:GH
(323) 0C>K:GH>IN D; .JGG:N
(324) >H8JHH>DC ,6E:G 35 /DDI:AA
(325) #:DG:N )
(326)
(327) 42=DH: )DC:I6GN ,DA>8N %H %I CNL6N %+($" % %$ *(/ %$%# )
(328) EE 35 /DDI:AA
(329) #:DG:N )
(330)
(331) 4 G: >HIG>8I ,G:H>9:CIH )DG: DCH:GK6I>K: I=6C D6G9 #DK:GCDGH - $ "$ %$%# , - EE . 35.
(332) Figure 1: Reaction Function Coefficients.
(333) Figure 2: Relation with Benchmark Coefficients.
(334)
Figure
Documents relatifs
In experimenting with a number of alternative model specifications (unemployment as a fall- back for wage negotiation, a one-time hiring cost, allowing workers to switch jobs only
The signs of the coefficients appear appropriate for the expected dependence of the probability of default on the selected macroeconomic variables. Positive increases in the
We obtain a similar conclusion and emphasize that in economies with a frictional labor market, changes in the equilibrium unemployment rate provide an additional mechanism by
We start off by estimating the effect of the Basel III liquidity regulations on monetary policy transmission using historical individual bank data for a sample of banks covering
For example, since a 3 percentage point decrease in interest rate was given only to individuals with high behavior scores and low utilization rates (cell 9), we cannot generalize
The behavioural and time preference traits again show up as having an important impact on the incidence of financial distress, though the size of the coefficients on these variables
Overall, the higher participation in the mortgage market for all age and income categories in the US than in the euro area, albeit the gap being more significant for the higher
This paper uses three different household surveys which link wealth holdings to migration histories and analyses the relative wealth position of immigrant and native
