Verification of Embedded Reactive Fiffo Systems
16
0
0
Texte intégral
(2)
(3) "!# $ %&'( *),+.-/ 01243658745936:<;=0>83@?A3@>9B@>8CED F 243GCIHJ;GK L
(4) CEM6MN>8O FAPRQ CE:SHT2:<H4KE> Q FJUVQ :<WX:S>830Y ZED\[ EC HA7T]^3@58_EZ`:S36>a\D\B@36> bdc$efeg`hj8ikeh
(5) 9 c
(6) ldmInoc'88pr/q8 srtrru@vx9w8Ev`8y{8z` |0k¡E}`¢|£~¤I^¥r¦Ih9I|rv 98§8rdIIwRI¨6hE9II{©|6IfªG¬|«r}` |@oIv\`yN9 G| ª8®c$bikeh
(7) c
(8) l9mnor·c8Eq9¯rª°8°k¸u@v4r8r¹IqIwr8v ©Gr9zE£ºy{$ }`»r|~r±¼¢J9²´³\µ6/yN¬½{£I²´r©Jv ¥rr¦9r9°r¹qE¶ªª8d«~´|G 6|Re|}`|64v `yN9 G| xlI¾jikehclm noc¿¯rp8ru@vXpEwr«EvXrÀE|GIz r¦| }E9z, ¬Á/9y{`µGI¨8²}`8|GIGÈEÃE9ÄÅd²´«r~´Â rJvXs88q±eÆ9@Ç 8,6|}`|64v `yN8`G| É cºv rq9e8yÂgËÊ9~~Ìv m
(9) ²´À|@y{²´dg8ÍeÆ9~²ÎÍ<8y{ ²Iv4®|6y{Ï|6~|@gv\eÆÐs9t88°Ev m lEÐ 1,2. 1. 3. 1. 2,4. 1. 2. 3. 4. ÑÓÒxÔGÕGÖ×XØ8ÕrÙ c$|96{²´À|fx²ÎÚ4lgEÛ{|GܱiÌc l uA9y{|Æz`Â|}0{ܱI}`|G~8y{|86{²´À|Ûg`ÛÝ {|Gܱ ÞßÇ`²NÇà9y{|Ë8³`~´|{.ܱ|6ܱ8y{²´áG|±{Ç |±|GÀr|G{0{Ç 9V8` 9^³\|â`y{6|GÂÂ|} ÞßÇ`|G.{Ç |6goGGz`yÃ4bd,{Ç ²´
(10) â 8â\|6yÞÆ|V²IÀ|6Û{²ãr9{|0{Ç |V}`|G6²S}`8³`²~´²Î¬g,8ÍÀ|6y{²Îä Ý {²´roâEy{r³`~|6ܱÍå9y É ÜV³\|} }E|}c l±ÞßÇ`²NÇË9y{|
(11) c l^y{z ` ²´ ãRz }`|6yÂrܱ| |GIÀI²Îy{r`ܱ|GN8~G8 ÛÂyN8²´{GÃ9Ä |ÂÇ`Þæ{Ç 9 9~´Ü±rÛº8~´~I{Ç |z ÂzX9~IÀ|6y{²ÎäX{²´r âEy{r³ ~´|GܱV9y{|Óz }`|G6²S}`8³`~|±Í<8y{Ç`|Ó6~S9Â^9ÍÁx|6y{²´I}E²G8~´~Îg É ÜV³\|} }E|} c l Þß²Î{Çà¬ÞÆ Ü±|Gܱ8y{²´áG²´`ãç|6À|G{GvxÞßÇ |@y{|8{Ç`|6gT³\|GG8ܱ|o}E|GG²} 9³ ~´|ËÍ<8yc$|Gã8Ý z`~Sy{~Îg É ÜV³\|} }E|} c lçÞß²Î{Çæ,²´ ãr~´|Óܱ|Gܱ8y{²´áG²´`ã.|GÀ|GÃAÄ |±{Ç |G Í<Gz 8 É Ü^³\|}`}`|}oJrÂÛgèc l.8 }.Þ|^ÂÇ`Þ²èâ 9yÂ{²´Gz ~y{ÇX
(12) Íå9y c$|Gãrz`~Sy{~Îg É Ü^³\|}`}`|}VJ8ÂÛg^c lR{Ç |Â|69Í4â`y{|}E|GG|GÂÂ9y{féê{ëÂì ²´z`âIÞÆ9yN}^6~8Â|}±8 } |6Ú4|66{²´À|G~Îgo6rܱâ zEN8³`~|8à íTî`ï/ðËñAòóôEõ Y >8C`;B6:SW`>ç2:öxZ÷a\øXMNB@>8ù.M Fú ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87aXø\M{B6>9ù.M Fû >83@:SüJ;9CIB@:<ZEH F Y >rC SQ ý þ:Sù,>ÓaXø\MNB@>9ù.M F\ÿ H\üAH4:SB@> ý aXB6CB6>ÓaXø\M{B6>9ù.M F >r;:å74CI?A: Q :B{ø ∗. .
(13)
(14) . ñ 8î àZX74> !; 4>r;GKX:SH4"_ AC`MÆ?J>r;ZEù,>0C^WE>83@$ø #JZ#4D CI3fWE>83@:SüJ;8CB@:<ZEHËù,>B%AZX7 MN:<HA;9> :B :åM'& D QSQ øçCED\B@Z`ù,CIQSýB@:å;(& Z`3
(15) üAH4:SB@>±M{BGCB6>M@ø\M{B6>9ù.MCIHA7 :SB JCQ EM
(16) ?J>8>9H C)# # Q :<>87 MNDJ;9;>rM@F M*& D Q<Q ø :S+H #ACI3@B@:å;D Q CE,3 & Z`3 û - a ÿ ;:<3G;D4:SB6"M .0/2134=05Z 4
(17) >9WE>83 F M@:SHA;9>Vù,Z M{B0M@øXMNB@>8ù.M
(18) CE3@>^:<H`B63@:<HAM@:<;8C Q<Q ø :SH\üJH4:B6>ËMNB6CIB@> F %B 4>83@>:åMRC,HA>9>87TB@Zè7\>rMN:<_EHàCEH 7> 6è;:<>9H BRWE>83@:SüJ;8CB@:<ZEH ù,>B84Z\7\Z Q ZE_`ø9& Z`3 :SH\üJH4:B6>M{BGCB6>MNø\MNB@>9ù.:M ; , > & Z\;DAM:SHÓ%B 4:å<M #A)C #ª>93ZE>H ='?>@!A!BCBA!BDA!EFHGJILKMA,NOI PQ"RTSMUVGWAH?XUYZ='?[@!A8BBCA!BDN\R] C ù,ZX74> Q & ZE3º>8ùÓ?ª>87474>897 ^dCEM@ø HJ!; 43@Z`H4ZEDJ8M _J36>8CE;B@:<WE>ßM@ø\M{B6>9ù.`M 4 :S%B >8WE>8H`Bùo>8ù,ZE36:SOrCB@:<ZEH FF ; Q Z`M@>B@ZTa "- . a)1J P HXø ú ùË?J>r747\>87 Y02faæ:<MCE;B@DAC QSQ øTbC F7cdQ5UHA!B+UVSMUVGWAH? F ZE?\BGCI:<H4>87T?Xø MNøXHA!; 436ZEHA:SOrCB@:<ZEHTCZ &CIH >9HXWX:S36ZEHAùo>8H B7\>9üAH4:<H4_ %B 4>,MN2> e D4>9HA;9>8M^)Z &:S H #AD\B±>9WE>8H B6"M 4 :8B C DA!ECF7GfILK5A"N I PQ9RTSMUVGWAH? ù,Z\7\> Q :<H4_o%B 4>±36>8C`;B6:SZ`HAMB@Z,%B A>8M@>^>8WE>8H`BG7M > DA!ECF7GfILK5A9N I PQgRTSMUVGWAH?XUhYiDNORC]j4>83@>ç:SH B@36Z\7\DA;9>87Å:<k H . l !F mCm 1n^kCEHA7 ;8C Q<Q >ro7 DA!ECF7p GfILK5A(N I PQrqs G3Q)?>E)G3E%B 4>83@M> _ÆB@ZÓùoZ\7\> Q ^dCEM@øXHA!; 436ZEH4Z`DA8M _36>8C`;B@:<WE>VMNø\MNB@>9ù. M 4 :8B è>9W`>9H B ùo>8ù,ZE36:SOrCB@:<ZEHJM%B ACIBËCI36>è%M #J>r;:SüA>87÷:<H÷%B 4>btu v:wHxVyzv{. l51
(19) 3@>rCE;B6:SW`> Q CEH4_EDJCI_E> P ù.5C |{Z`3.
(20) . Ã Ê
(21) |6y{³Ey{|6{|9zXì & >8CB6D436>èZ)&B%A:<M Q CEH4_EDACE_E>.:åM±B8ACBÓ:SBË:åMr#ªZ`M6M@:S? Q >.B6ZæM{B6ZE36>.Z\;9;DA3@36>9HA;9>8MZC&>8WE>8H`BGM:<H ZE3G7\>93$B@$Z #A3@Z\;>rM@Mß%B 4>8ù Q CIB@>923 X þ 4>4CøÓ8B 4>R>8WE>8H`BGMCE3@>#43@Z\;9>8M6MN>r7,:<M
(22) ;9C QSQ >87oB84> N I PQ ZE3G7\>93 & ZEO3 N I !U!G
(23) XN I !UVGN I %A!EC@7cdA s G/f: C> 54
(24) >ßBGCIKE>:SH B6Z^C`;9;Z`D4H BºB84>
(25) MNB@Z`3@>r7>8WE>9H BGMC`M MNZXZEHèC`OM #ªZ`M6MN:<? Q >RCIHJ7,:SHç;8CEM@> )Z &º;9ZEH A:å;B$%B 4>VZ Q 7\>8MNBMNB@ZE36>87,Z\;8;D4363@>8HA;> :åOM #A3@Z\;>rM@M@>8`7 þ 4>0HXD4ùÓ?ª>93)Z & MNB@ZE36>87oZ\;9;9D4363@>8HA;>rMf:SH,8B 4>R2:SöªZ e`DA>9D4>0:åMf8B 4>9Z`3@>9B@:å;9C QSQ øÓD4HX?ªZED4HJ7\>8 7 LZEHAM@>:e D4>8H`B øàB%4>è?ª>7JCW :<ZE3GC ù,Z\7\> Z)& CIH tu v:wHxVyzv>#436ZE_`36CEù :<MCTYR2Æab4A:<;! AC`M CIH :SH\üJH4:B6>HXQ D4ùÓ?ª>93 CZ &MNB6CIB@>8nM Q . mCm 1J Q çî rîXó ðÓñJò \ ÿ HjC #43@>8WX:SZ`DA[M 4
(26) ZE36k K . mCm 1 F 4
(27) >æCIHJC Q ø O8>87Y02fa \ILG kE kIL? c0IZF7ILG A! TK:I %Q ?[A! TGZ)&B%4> & Z`3@ù % B AC I 0 B < : V M CIH >9HXWX:S36ZEHAùo>8H B_`>9H4>836CIB@:<H4_,>9W`>936øçMN>2e D4>9HA;9> Σ F )Z &±>9W`>9H B6:M O; > #436ZWE>r7 8B 4>h & Z QSQ 5Z 4 :SHA_Å3@>rMND Q B6[ M & ZE3 YR2Æ#a "^%$M_,8B 4>æM@>B &Q5UVG )Z &%B A> 3@>rCE;!ACE? Q > M{BGCB6>8M,Z)&C÷Y02fa :åM,3@>r;Z`_EH4:<O8CE? Q > CIHA7¿>öx>8;B@:<WE> Q ø ;9ZEù>#4D\BGCI? Q >('^ m _ËB%A> Q :<H4>8þ CE34>B@8>8M@ù>Ó36#ª>8ZEM@3GD C Q/B6MQ ZE4_`:<>8; 3@>o- þ MND4- 38#44 36:<:S%BM@4Z:<H4`_çD\B M@:S%BHA4>;9±>ËHAY0>2f[XaæB0CZ CI#ª36>Ë>93G;CB6Z`ZEM@3
(28) >:<B6M0Z*74>8)O;Q5:å74? CE? ? Q s"> & IZZ`F!30E5GJY0I ,2f+ a N I TILG3A Q RTGWE5GWA.- ECF/ I AHU[Y/)`NOR0-+U3]ZE( 3 N I 1HQXqs GWQ5?[E5GWE F CIHA7è:Q B :å,M 4
(29) > Q<Q K HA5Z 4 Hè%B JCB
(30) %B 4:åM; Q CEM6M ACEMºB%4>'#ªZ54>83ZC&JþºDA3@:<H4_ æCE;!4:<H4>8M,. 2 $35138þ 4:åMÆ7\:Söª>83@>8HA;>
(31) :<Mù.CI:<H ø7\D4>B@ZVB%4>,&kCE;B B%ACIBY02f{a ^i4 :S%B CIH,:S>ù # Q :å;:SB>9HXWX:<3@Z`H4ù,F >9H !B _ÆCE3@> Z #J>8HèMNø\MNB@>9ù.M ^i44>8Q 3@>rCEML
(32) 2f a àMCI36> ; Q Z`M@>87_ ZEH±B84>Z`H4>OACEHA7 F CIHJ7n& 3@Z`ù B%4> Q ZXZC#A:SH4_& ZE36ùZ)&\B%A>ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9:<H4_ B636CEHAMN:SB@:<ZEHJM ^i44:å!; à;9CEH 8B XDAM0?ª>Ó>9[X>r;D\B6>87 CIHXø H DAùÓ?ª>93RCZ &ÆB@:<ùo>r8M _44:<!; T>8H B6CI: M%B ACIB0%B A>ÓM{BGCB6> M*#AC`;>Z)&ÆY02fa CI36>74Z54 H4CI3G7è; Q Z MN>r7 CEHA7 B%XDAM36>8;Z`_EH4:<O8CE? Q >C Q 465 ò Tñ 8ò 78 5 7dTñ , þ 4>b#4D483 #JZ MN> )Z &8B 4:åM #J)C #ª>93 :<MçB@ZCIHJC Q ø O8> Y02f9 a \ILG E A;:! c IZFHILG A! TK:I %Q ?[A! TG F B%4>
(33) MNZ ý ;8C Q<Q >r7$='?[@8A!BBCA!BDNOR F 44:å;!CI36>$Y02faB8ACB3@D4H±DAHA7\>93 MNZ`ùo> A< K2I %Q= T?>A< GWE5cF!Q= UVG> %E)I GfUV ÿ HJ7\>9>r7 F 4 :8B 4ZED4BfCEHË>9 [ # Q :å;:SBÆ>9HXWX:S36ZEH4ù,>8H`B F 4>CI36> CI? Q >^B@Zè;Z`ù>#4D\B@>^B84>MN>9B0Z)&3@>rCE;!ACE? Q >MNB6CB6>8M &Q5UVG . mCm 1 F ?AD\B0ù.CIHXøèZ)&B%4>rMN>MNB6CIB@>rM 4Z`D Q 7 H4ZIB.?ª> 3@>rCE!; ACE? Q > :SH C ?{36>8C Q :åM{B6:<; @ç>9HXWX:S36ZEHAùo>8H BÓ%B JC[B 4Z`D Q 7 ;Z`HAMNB@3GCI:<H %B A> MNø\MNB@>9ùj ùÓ?ª>87474>87çYR2Æa CI36>RHJCB@DA36C ø.7\>üAHA>87çC`Mß8B 4>MNøXHA!; 436ZEHA:SOrCB@:<ZEH.?ª>B 4
(34) >9>8H CoY02fa CIHA7 ú CIH >9HXWX:<3@Z`H4ù,>9H B _E:<WE>9H CEMRC QSQ Q CI?ª> Q >87 B636CEHAMN:SB@:<ZEH M@øXMNB@>8ùj ; >±:<Hj#ACI3@B@:å;D Q CE30;ZEH ý MN:å7\>9A3 %AB+)s czE= CIHA7 A! VIZQ2B5IZF^>8HXW :<36ZEH4ù,>9H BGM F 4A>936> %B 4> Q CEH4_EDACE_E>rMf)Z &/>9W`>9H BM@:> e D4>8HA;>rM CI36>Ó36>9_ED Q CE3VZ`3"#ª>936:<ZX74:<;Ë3@>rM*#ª>8;B@:<WE> Q øxþ A>8M@>o; Q C`M@M@>8MVZ)&$>8HXW :<36ZEH4ù,>9H BGMVCE3@> #ACI3@B@:å;D ý QCICE363 >RQ øËM{B6363@> Z`Q H4>9W_ CEø H`B#J:S>8H.3@:<8BZ\4>7\:<;XCI36^ >>8C_T)Z & U7F/36 >8A!C B5Qý s B@c0:<I ù, + >R_M@øXZE3
(35) MNB@ù,>8ù.CE:SM$H CEø. M &;ZEZ`3ù>:SHJ#JM{Z BGMNCI>rHA7.;9Z)> &CF ù, %AB+CCEs HXøocdE= ±CC # ;9# øXQ ; :<;8:åC;(B@#A:<ZE3@HJZ M Q ý ;>8M6M@>8M ^k;9ZEH Q B@36Z Q CZ &HXDA; Q >rCI 3 # Q CIH B6M F CWX:SZ`H4:<;M@ø\M{B6>9ù.Q M F :7!_V þ 4>ù,CE:SH 36>8M@D Q B6MZ)&B%4> #JC)#ª>930CI36>^B4Z & Z Q 7#' 4
(36) >üA3GM{B0M%4Z54 B8ACB" ^D$2_FEÆ>936:SZ\7\:å;9C QSQ ø ú ùË?J>r747\>87 Y02fa ACW`>R8B 4>n#J5Z 4
(37) >93 CZ &þD43@:<H4_,ù.CE!; 4:<H4>r<M "Xù,Z`MNB WE>936: ý üJ;9CIB@:<ZEH+#436ZE? Q >9ù.M CI36>D4HA7\>r;:å74CI? Q >"& ZE3B84:åM0; Q CEM6M7 aX:SHJ;> ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87Y02fa¿CI36>çB6Z bZ #ª5Z 4>8*3 & D >9W`>9H :<H¿%B 4>F?@MN:<>ù # > @ ;8CEM@>ç)Z &"#J>83@:<Z\7\:å; >9HXWX:S36ZEH4ú ù,>8H`BGM F 4
(38) >,%B 4>8H B@36øTB@Z Q 5Z 4>83^%B 4>8Q¬:SF 3±>9[ #A3@>rM@M@:SW`>9H4>rM@MV:<H Q Z`3674>93^B@ZTZ`?\B6CE:SH÷7\> ý ;:å74CI?4: Q :B{øè36>8M@D Q B6:M ; >%M 4Z54%B ACIB " ^ m _ ; 4>9H,8B 4>936>0:åMßCBùoZ M{BßZ`H4>0ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9:<H4_>9W`>9H B F ùoZ M{BßW`>936:üª;9CB6:SZ`X H #A3@Z`? Q >8ù.MßCI36> 7\>8;9:<7ACI? Q "> & ZE3RY >8_ED Q CI3 Q ø ú ùÓ?ª>87474>87 Y02fa ^>3_ ú ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87 - Z M@M@ø YR2ÆaæCI36r > 4
(39) > M{B63@DJ;B@DA3@>r7 B@3GCIHAM@:B6:SZ`HæM@øXMNB@>8ù.XM ^Z;a\þ0 a _4 :8B >öx>8;B@:<WE> #43@>r7 ý ?ACEM@:<$M ^kCEM7\>9üAH4>r7TQ<Qý :SH .G$H)1i_ F #436ZW :å7\>r7 %B ACIBV8B 4>Ë>8HXW :<36ZEH4ù,>9H BR:åM^C ∗. ∗. ∗.
(40) ¾ |6y{²Îä 9{²´ro8Í É Ü^³\|}`}`|}c$|86{²´À|0x²ÎÚ4lgEÛ{|Gܱ ;a\þ0a+4 :SB%à>9öª>r;B@:<WE> #A3@>r7 ý ?JCEM@:<M:SB6M@> Q &J=R>9HA;9>±B%4>Ë;ZWE>83@:<H4_>#436ZE? Q >9ù :<MR7\>8;9:<7 ý CI? Q > F CEHA7+4>±;8CIH ùoZ\7\> Qý !; 4>r;GKçM@)C & >B{[ø #436CZ #ª>93@B@:<>8MZ`Hç8B 4>8M@>M@øXMNB@>8ù.7M ^H_ TZE36>9ZW`>93 F 4
(41) > M%4Z54 B%ACI6 B & %A!B F %B A> M@>Bo)Z ƴ>874>8;>rM@M@ZE3GM F :<MË>öx>8;B@:<WE> Q øÅ;Z`ù ý #4D\BGCI? Q >r& Z`3VY >8_ED Q CI3 Q ø ú ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87 - Z`M6M@ø Y02fa LZEHJMN>2e`DA>9H B Q ø ù,Z\7\> Qý ;!4>8;GKX:<H4_ B%4>±>9[\:<MNB@>8H`B6:<C Q & 36CE_Eù,>9H B )Z &ßL
(42) þ - :<M 74>8;:å74CE? Q n> & Z`3%B 4:åM ; Q CEM6:M M
(43) >9ù># AC`MN:<O9>r7è:<Hç8B 4>±;Z`HA; DAM@:SZ`H.%B 4>rMN>^36>8M@D Q BGM
(44) _E:<WE>V$C & ZEDAHA74CB6:SZ`9H & Z`38B 4>WE>83@:SüJ;9C ý B@P :<ZEH Z)& ú ùÓ?ª>87474>87TY02fa Q 465 7fî'ñ î $î ò þ 4> H4>[XB,MN>r;B@:<ZEH 3@>r;9C Q<Q MMNZ`ù,>è?ACEM@:å;9MÓCEHA7Å:<H B@36ZX74DA;>rM %B 4> ù,Z\7\> Q CZ & ='?[@!A!BCBCA!BhDN\R ÿ Ha\>8;B6:SZ`H 3b4
(45) > #A3@ZW`> Z`H4> CZ &VZ`D43.ù.CI:<H¿36>8M@D Q B6M " E>83@:<Z\7\:å;9C Q<Q ø ú ùÓ?ª>8747\>r7ËYR2Æ$a ACW`>ß%B A>,#ª5Z 4>83CZ &JþD43@:<H4_^ù.CE!; 4:<H4>8:M ÿ H,aX>r;B6:SZ`H H F 4
(46) > & ZX;9DAMßZ`H.C>cdQMU!UVSÓW`>93GMN:<ZEHoZ)&/Y02fa,CIHA7>4
(47) >#436ZWE>ZEDA3ßMN>r;ZEHJ7Ëù.CE:SH.36>8M@D Q B" ú ùË?J>r747\>r7 > 4
(48) > MNB@36DA;B6D436>87çB@3GCIHAM@:B6:SZ`HTMNø\MNB@>9ù.:M 42:SHAC øç:<HàaX>8;B@:<ZEH 4
(49) >7436MC 4 - Z`M6M@øçY02fa CI36" MNZ`ùo>±;9ZEHA; Q DAM@:<ZEHAMCIQ<Q HJ7 _`:SW`>^M@ZEù,>n4:<H B6M & Z`3 & D\B@D436> 4
(50) ZE36K QSQ ∗.
(51) . \ [ r
(52) ! ". òî7('*7Z \ò=7kîXô 8BCA< VI ,++E= B*)7sEMUVILp*Q= %BA! VI +,+^2AZE30C,_E:<WE>8H M@>B F Co?4:SHJCI36øè3@> Q CIB@:<ZEH ≤ :åM0C)7sEMUVILp Q= %BA! VI +.:d&
(53) :SBÓ:åM^B@3GCIHAM@:B6:SW`>.CIHA7 36>!A>9[X:<WE> þ 4>{X s E %B5p*F7cdQ5U!s 8AZ)& :åM ↑Y = Y ⊆X P üAH4:SB@>oMN>9B å : V M C . -C ILGWA>@!EMUVI U& ZE3CIHTD # 4CI3G7 ý ; Q Z`M@>87 {x ∈ X | ∃x ∈ Y, x ≤ x } MN>9B X : & ↑X= X P A7cLc)HsE5U!ILp*Q %BCA< VI ,+hXYB/):QV] (X, ≤) :<M
(54) rC e DACEM@: ý Z`367\>83@:<H4_ ≤ MNDJ;! B%ACIB$:SH.>8WE>83@øË:SH\üJH4:B6>RM@>:e D4>9HJ;>(" x , x , . . . , x , . . . ZC&x> Q >8ù,>9H B6MO& 3@Z`ù X F B%4>83@> >9[X:åMNB B 4Z.:<H B@>9_`>93GM M@DA!; B%JCB x ú WE>83@ø #ACI:<3 (X, ≤) M@DA!; B%ACIB X :åM üAH4:SB@>Ó:<M BCAA1HECF7G3Q,C+4(e i Z< 2AjD43NB84>936ù,ZE36> xF ?X≤ øæ7\>9üAH4:SB@:<ZEH C+4
(55) > e DACEM@: ZE3G7\>83@:<H4_ (X, ≤) AC`M^C üAH4:SB@>±HXD4ùÓ?ª>93 CZ &ù,:<H4:<ù,C Q > Q >9ù,>8H`BGM ^ :SB0:<(M 4> QSF QSý & Z`D4HAQ<7\Q >r7 _V ý LZEHAM@:<74>936:SH4_,CËüAH4:SB@>ÓC Q #ACI?ª>B Σ = {a , . . . , a } F CoüAH4:SB@>9^k3@>rM*# \:SH\üJH4:B6>2_ 4
(56) ZE3G7 :åMCüAH4:SB@[> ^ 36>8%M #` :SH4üAH4:SB@2> _
(57) M@:> e D4>8HA;>V)Z &ºM@ø ùË?JZ M & 36ZEù ' 7\>9HAZIB@>rMß8B 4> u∈Σ >Q 9BNB@>83ßZ)& u CEHA7 ε :åMÆB%4> >8ù>#\B{ø$4
(58) ZE3G7 Iþ 4>nU; s10 AßZ)&ªB4Q Z^üAH4:SB@>Σ4Z`u3674M u CEHA7 v :åMÆB%i4> MN>9BR7\>üAHA>87 ?X
(59) ø " u tt v = {u v . . . u v | u , . . . , v ∈ Σ CEHA7 u = u . . . u , v = X þ 4>XUVs@Hp Q %B>Q= %BA! VI + 4 :åM
(60) 7\>üAHA>87.?X
(61) ø " ∀u, v ∈ Σ , u 4 v :ö u ;9CEHè?J> vZE?\BG. CI. :<.H4v>87 } & 3@Z`ù ?Xøà3@>8ù,ZW :<H4_ MNZ`ùo> >BNB6>93G7M þ A>6&E VI32 ?[E ( I ,+j. $71 7\>üJH4>8M B%4>WE>r;B6ZE3 Ψ (u)v= (k . . . k ) 44>Q 83@> k :åMB%4>HXD4ùË?J>83
(62) ZC&ºZ\;9;9D43@36>9m HJ;>8ΨMZ)& a :<H %B 4>üAHA:B6> 4Z`367 u 4 E@8A7cdA!B65 8E= UVILGJIZQ= RTSMUVGWAH?XU7+ P cdEC@!A7cdA!BG %E UVILGfIZQ $UVSMUVGWAH?¿:<M C H ý B6 D # Q > S = (Q, q , L, 44>83@> å :
(63) M %A>MN>9BZC&MNB6CIB@>8M F B < :
(64) M 84>±:<H4:B6:<C Q M{BGCB6> F :<M
(65) B84> B M@>B Z)& CE?J> M →) CIHA7 →⊆ QQ× L × Q :<Mß%B 4>RB@3GCIHAM@:B6:SqZ`H.∈3@> QQ CIB@:<ZE`H P Vs çCZ & S :<MCLüAH4:SB@>VZE3$:<H\üAHA:Q B6>VM@> Q ý e`DA>9HA;9>
(66) CZ &AB636CEHAMN:SB@:<ZEHJM 5; >07\>9HAZIB@> %B A>
(67) 36!> J>[\:SW`> CIHA7,B636CEHAM@:B6:SW`>R; Q Z`M@D436>0q)Z & −−→→ qP −MN−B6→CB6> · ·q· ∈−−→Q q:åM %A!E·F · ·EC@7cdA:<H S & 36ZEù →M{BGCB6> q ∈ Q :Sö #&Q5UVG :<MRB%A>oM@>B^Z)&ß36>8CE;!JCI? Q >ÓMNB6CB6>8MR:SH S & 3@Z`ù q ª2AZE3Cè_E:<WE>8HàM{BGCB6> (S) q→ q CIHJ7ÅC _E:<WE>9H Q CI?ª> Q :åM±8B 4> M@>BÓCZ &%B 4> F & 8A8B |q − q} q ∈ Q #43@>r7\>8;9>8M6MNZ`36MCZ & ? ø - >B l ∈ L ^k3@>r*M #` (q) = _ß{q7\>9H4∈ZEB@Q r > M %B 4>0→ @ M > G B f M )Z & I F!Q5? I ,+XcdE@!AHc U ^ 36>8%M #`,Q5s G +Q5I ,+ qcdE@8A7c lU*_"& 36ZEù in(q) 2:<out(q) HAC ø 8B 4>çM@>BGM±)Z &
(68) %B 4>
(69) %A!BCA!F!AVU!U7Q= !U)Z & :<M & %A!B = S & %A!B (q) CIHJ 7 q& ∈ 8A8B Q 7\>8H4ZIB6QS>8Q MF :SB6MB636CEHAM@:B6:SW`>CEHA7 3@<> A>[\:<WE>; Q Z`M@D43@q> # % $. &. 0. 0. 0. 0. 1. 2. i. i. j. 1. ∗. th. i. 1 1. 1. n. 1. n n. n. ∗. 1. n. 1. ∗. n. i. n. i. 0. 0. ∗. 0. ln. l1. l0. 0. 1. ∗. n+1. 0. ∗. 0. l. l∈in(q). l. ∗. 0. 0. l.
(70) . Ã Ê
(71) |6y{³Ey{|6{|9zXì & %QC@7cdA7?$U{Q%1 I GWA! %AHUVG +ç24Z`3oCæ_E:<WE>9H CI?ª> >87ÅB@3GCIHAM@:B6:SZ`H M@øXMNB@>8ù CIHA7 C>4(e Z (Q, ≤) F 4>±;9CEH 74>üAH4>B84>Qn& Z Q<Q Q Z54 :SH4_ #436ZE? Q >9ù.M " S = (Q, q , L, →) þ 4> @!Q5s BCA!B= AVU!U %Q@HczAH? " ÿ AM &Q5UVG (S) üAHA:B6> CEHA7 q ∈ Q F :åM B84>936>CIHXø þ 4> F!Q5K5M@A<DA V!; I , B+ %AC I %QB @HczAH? "ª2AZE30CIHACE7 H ø M{BG:<CM0B6>83@>rM CEq!; AC∈E? &QM> UV& G 3@Z`(S) ù Q üAHA:B6> q q ∈Q q ≤q q þ 4> [ W G ! A V. ?. I . ) E f G Z I Q 6. 8. C Q 7 @ d c H A ? " M 8 > E W 8 > @ 3 . ø 6 3 4 D. H Z ) & ÿ YB %AHU +AZPA!F7GfILK5A] %A!F!Q;+( I2EC@7ILc0ILGJS
(72) %QC@7cdA7S?" ÿ MÓB%4>83@> Co^ 36>8M%#`;ZEù>#4D4B6CI? Q >M_ üAþ H44>:So B@>±367> #436>8M@>9H BGCB@:<ZEH & ZEA3 &Q5UVG (S) þ 4> s %A< GOcdQ2F!E5c0ILGJS
(73) %QC@7cdA7?" ÿ M8B 4>936>C,3@DAH CZ & 8B ACBRWX:åMN:SB6MRC,_E:<WE>9H :SH4üAH4:S %B@A!> F7øç S q∈Q CZ &ÌB@>8 H Q þ ^ 364>>8%M#`4 JL
(74) 5 4 þ YB %AHU ] +)\25 4 _'(& Z`= 3@ùË
(75) D =OC N`] ?[7\ZXQ:B>8AHMc0p*>9F/W` >9A!36F ø.25I 3@ DA+ H
(76) CZ %& QC@7cdA7M6?CB@"f:å*M 24& ø Z`3oCæ _E:<WE>8H - þ -ßFAú F4ú Q φF S φ çî C7J î 7$ñ 5 8ñ ' # # Y >8C`;B@:<WE> M@ø\M{B6>9ù.MfCI36>DJMNDAC øÓ;9ZE>ù #JZ MN>r7ÓCZ &xCM@>Bf)Z &ªB6C`MNK\<M 44:å!; .CI36>
(77) C`;B@:<WCB6>87 #A3@> >9ù>#\B@>r7æZ`3>9HA7\>r7 4A>9H÷MNZ`QSùoQ >,>8WE>9H BGMVZ\;8;D432/Y >8C`;B@:<WE>,2:öxZ P D\B6ZEù.CBGC ^kY02 P F _$. l5ý1 CI:<ù CBVù,Z\7\> Q :<H4_ MNDA!; EMUVS= F/ 8Q= Q)s URMNø\MNB@>8ù,M F %B XDAMV%B A>9jø & Z Q<Q 5Z 4B 4Z ù,CE:SH _ED4:å7\> ý QMN:<D4H4>ù >8M#\"B6:S?[Z`H÷AH?[:S>ù Q= V# I2:SE5>rGJM^IZQ=%B ACICEB±HA%B7 4>,I BGUVCEG3M@E K\ nM GWE=AC A!WEQ)>,s U C %H4A!ZEECH F7GJIZHXQ=D ÿ 7\HJD47\3G>9C>rB@7 :<ZEF H B%4>%B TXDAC`M^MNøX%B HAA>;!943øæ6ZEù.HACZEhøDAMË#ACE3@>M ý WE>9H BB%4>'#436ZX;9>8QM6MN:<H4_ ZC&A>9W`>9H B6M F 44:å;!Óù.CøVB%XDAMH4>8>8QSQ7B6ZR?ª>ù,>9Fù,Z`3@:<O9>r7 r2AZE33@>rCE;B6:SW`> ý MNø\MNB@>9ù.M F 4
(78) "> JCWE>±!; 4Z`M@>9H B@Z.?JCB6!; j#436Z\;>rM@Mù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9>r7 >8WE>8H`BGrM EMUnU7Q:Q E5U Q5U8UVIZ@7cdA CIHA7 :<Hæ;9C`MN>B4Z.ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9>r7 >9WE>8H B6MR;8CIHT?ª>$#436Z\;>rM@M@>87 B@Zç_`:SW`>B%4>X#436:SZ`3@:SB{øèB6ZèB%A> Z Q 7\>93ZEH4> r þ A:<M_EDJCI3GCIH B@>8>8M &kCE:S36H4>8M6MCIù,ZEH4_R%B 4>
(79) ù,>9ù,ZE36F:<O9>87ZX;8;D43636>9HA;9>8:M : TZ`3@>8ZWE>93 F ?ACBG;! #43@Z\;9>8M6MN:<H4_jACEM$#436:SZ`3@:SB{øæCI_ CI:<HAMNBr#43@Z\;9>8M6MN:<H4_ Z)& H4>:4 :<HA;9ZEù,:SHA_àZ\;9;DA3@36>9HA;9>8M: þ 4:<MoB{ø #ª> CZ ƴZ\;>rM@M@:SHA_æ:åM.;9C >87 N I PQCß=R>9HA;9> Y02 ;8CIH¿M@>936WE> CEM,C÷MN>8ù.CIH B@:å; ùoZ\7\> Q & ZE3 tu v:wHxVyzv"#436ZE_`36CEù,M. l51 Q<F Q C`M'4> QSQ C`M & Z`30a -F . a51ºP M%#J>r;:SüJ;9CIB@:<ZEHAM F CIHA7 & ZE3 CEH ø & ZE36ù,C Q :åM@ù & ZE3 36>8C`;B@:<WE>M@øXMNB@>8ù. M 4 :8B ù,>8ùoZ`3@:<O8CIB@:<ZE`H 2:<_EDA3@> $^kC_$7\>:#4:å;B6M
(80) CÓYR2 P ù,Z\7\> Q :<H4_oCÓ3@>rCE7\>836MM4 36:SB@>93GMÆùÓD4B@DAC Q >9[\; Q DJMN:<ZEH9#A3@Z ý B@Z\;Z Q 4 :S%B ËB4ZR3@>rCE7\>836M R CIHA7 R CIHJ7ZEHA > 4 36:B6>93 W ÿ HÓ>8CE!; Q Z\;9CIB@:<ZEH±8B 4>
(81) 3@D4HAH4:SHA_ B6CEM@K\MCI36>R_E:<WE>8Hg^ ∅ ù,>8CIHJMHAZÓBGCEM@K.:<M36D4H4H4:<H4_ F R B%ACIB 3@>rCE7\>83 1 :<M
(82) 36>8C`7\:SHA_ËCIHJ7 M@Z ZE`H _ß þ 4>V>9W`>9H B6M ;ZE3636>8%M #JZ`HA7ËB@Z8B 4>R>8HA7.CZ &ºC 4 3@:SB@:<H4_ËZE3$36>8C`7\:<H4_B6C`MNK B@3GCIHAM@:B6:SZ`HZ)&AB%4>'W& ZE36,ù R ∅, R−−→ R ù,>8CIHJMºB8ACBÆ>9W`>9H B r ;9CIHË?J> #436Z\;>rM@M@>87:<H Q Z\;9CIB@:<ZEP H CIHA7 Q >rCE74MVB6Z C M{BGCB6X> 44>83@> R :åM^3@DAH4H4:<H4_ ' ∅ −−−→ R ù,>8CEHAMV%B ACIB #43@Z\;9>8M6MN:<H4_ ∅ C ùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8>87 Z\;9;DA3@36>9HA;9>,)Z &>9WE>8H B r Q >8C`74MB@Z R CEHA7 üAHAC QSQ ø R −−→ R ù,>8CIHJM %B ACIBËd: & ZX;8;D43GrM 4A>9H÷%B A> M@øXMNB@>8ù :åM:<H Q ZX;8CB6:SZ`H :$B JCEM±B6Zà?ª> MNB@ZE36>87 :<HÅ%B A> e`DA>9D4> w ^ RZIB6:<;9>±B%ACIBRB4
(83) ZèM{BGCB6>8M0;9ZE363@>rM*#ªZEHA7 B6Z.B6C`MNK R 3@D4HAH4:SHA_.?4D\BRB84>9ø CI36>±H4ZEB R ?4:<M@:<ùo: Q CI23 _ î 7Z7kñ $!%çî C7J" î 7$#ñ 5 8ñ ' rTñ $%%&(''5 $q#Y >8C`;B@:<WE> 2:öxZ D B@ZEù.CIB@ZEH ^dY02 P _XI UXE*) pWGJs czA R = (Q , q , A , → ) A< %A,+ Q I U E - ILGWA U7A7P GQD1ý - c|68~´~4{ÇX9f{Ç`| É ÷iåy{|GÂâJà /É . uÆÍSyN8ã8ܱ|Gß8ͺeƶf z`Â|Gfâ`y{|G}`²´9{|6Gv ³\8~|G8,8â\|6yN9{9y{Gv 0 {xÇ ²Îy{|Û8 bd|6,ÝkÛx{|G²Îy{âoÛ x|6I²Îy{ß|89³`X~}Ë2| {1
(84) Ç`zE| É Ã Åiåy{|GÂâAÃ /É . uÆrâ\|6yN{8y{GÃ 0. ∗. ∗. 00. 0. 00. 0. 00. ∗. 1. 2. 1. 1. 2 r1. 1. 1 ?r1. 1. 1. !w. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. R. 0 R. R. R. R. 1.
(85) ¾|6y{²Îä 9{²´ro8Í É Ü^³\|}`}`|}c$|86{²´À|0x²ÎÚ4lgEÛ{|Gܱ !w, !r1 , !r2. W ?w, w. !w, !r1. !w, !r2. W. ?r1 , r1. w. R1 !w, !r1 , !r2. R2. R1. ?r2 , r2. •. •. • W. i̳\u,Ð$z`{rÜ{r Íå8yç{Ç | â\|6y{²´I}`²´Æ|GIÀI²Îy{r`ܱ|G E Ã. R2 !w, !r1 , !r2. R1 •. ?r1 , r1. R1 ||R2. w. r2. R1. R2. R2. •. R2 •. R2 R1. r1. •. ?r2 , r2. R1. •. q. w. •. r2 . . .. iÌu É IÀI²Îy{r`ܱ|G E à i ufпcIÐ Í<8y±Ry{|8}`|6y{ w0Þfy{²´{|@yâEy{r³`~|6Ü,à ٠٠lErܱ|
(86) |6`8ܱâ ~´|Gf9Í/cEÐ'8X}Ó|GIÀI²´y{8 ܱ|G{Gà QG Z\ ;9A CI- B@:< ZEILHAGWM A[\U7A7ILG Gn bQD1¿G A9C`;B)B@I:<UVZEGfHJI M +)Y3s cdIEU;@8 A7A!c U3B ] :<H4 :S B@A<:åC %QÆA Q Z\;8CI B@U9:<ZEG H A q- ILAGWA>U7=AHG ΣQ%1'∪>8WE({!,>9H BG?}M × Σ ) I U Σ I U>G A -C TILG3A U7A7G"QD1 ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9>r7æ>8WE>9H BGM E= B I U G A9U7AHGnQ%1 Σ J>9>⊆B6:SHAΣ_ Σ = Σ \ Σ >9WE>8H B6$M E B- E)cLc0S → ⊆ Q × A × Q I UnG AXBAHGWA! V? I I UVGJIZFrG %E UVILGfIZQ %A7cdE5GJIZQ= !w, !r1 , !r2. 0. . . 0 R. R. M. M. U!sF/ jG E)G. A<. +XAHILG. =. +XQ. R. R. ∀q ∈ QR , ∀e ∈ ΣM. . !e. +. F. R. / . M. R. =. q −−→R q UVsF jG E)G E B + e ?e ∃q 0 ∈ QR q −→R q 0 q −−→R q 0. þ 4>ùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8:SH4_ËB@3GCIHJMN:SB@:<ZEHAM CE3@> Z Z#AM"XB%4> #436Z\;>rM@M@:SHA_ËZC&ºB%A>±>9WE>8H B:åM 7\> Cø`>87 CIHA7÷B84> MNø\MNB@>9ù7\ZX>rMÓH4ZEBoC QSQ Z54 CIHXøÅQ M{BGCB@> ;!ACIHA_E>C 0ZEB@:å;>èB8ACBËB%4> ù,>9ù,ZE36Q :<O9:<H4_ ;9C)#JCI?4: :SB{ø,7\ZX>8MßHAZIB
(87) CC# # øoB@ZÓC B%4>V>9W`>9H B6M$Z)&/B%A>VY02 HA74>9>87 B84>V>8WE>8H`BGM MN>9B :<M7\:<WX:<7\Q >r7à:<HæB 4
(88) Z #JCI3@B6M "AQ 8B 4>,ùoQSQ>8ù,ZE36:SO8>87T>8WE>9H BGM Σ PCEHA7Tÿ 8B 4> AF >9>9B@:<H4_ >8WE>8H`BGM Σ ΣF 4 :8B H4>±;ZED 7 C M@Z,;9ZEHAM@:å7\>930MNB6CIB@:ån ; #43@:<ZE36:SB{ø.?J>9B 4>8>9H >9W`>9H B6M :<KE> ?{:d& e Σ:<M^:<Hæ∩B8Σ4>.2=:öx∅Z UQ :åM{B F ?ACBG;!Q g#AQ 3@Z\;>rM@M e >9WE>8Hæ:d&
(89) M@ZEù,>oZIB%A>93 e :åM?ª>H& ZE36> eF\Q :<H %B 4> Q :åM{BRCEHA7 ;9CIH ?ªr > #436Z\;>8M6M@>8 7 @ þ 4:åM0;8CIHTC Q 3@>rCE7\øç?J>Ó%M #ª>8;:SüA>r7 ?Xø Y02 PF CIHA7 %B XDAM ZED434
(90) ZE36K.:SHJ; Q DA7\>8M B%4:åM ;9C`MN> 24Z 5Z 4 :SH4$_ #JZ`:SH B6"M ^%$M_ßCEHAh7 ^ _f8B 4>VYR2 H4>8WE>83 cdQ2QMU7AHU^Cù,>8ùoZ`3@:<O9>r7,>9W`>9H BZ\;9;9D43 3@>8HA;> F Q<Q CEHA7æC`MR>8H B6CI: Q >87à?Xø ^ m _ F m B84>>#43@Z\;9P>8M6MN:<H4_ ^ e_^CEHA7TB84>Ë?JCB6;!g#436ZX;9>8M6MN:<H4_b^ ?e_ý )Z &fCIH >9WE>8H B JCWE>V%B 4>M6CIù,>>öx>8;(B 4 23 2B \B@Zo8B 4>M{BGCB6> M !; ACIH4_`>^%B 4>8øè?436:SH4_.CE?JZ`D\:B î 7Z7kñ # %çî C7Jî 7 ñ ï 7ô rî ' % ''5 {qY >8C`;B@:<WE>¿2:SöxZjaXø\M{B6>9ù ^kY02f a _A+)ILK2I ,+oG AjU7A7?>E GJIZFVUhQ%1jG A DN q nI U{G A YJI -Op R = (Q , q , A , → ). .
(91). M. M. F. F. 1. 1. 2. 1.
(92). . . ILGWAW]rcdE@!AHcdA!BXG %E= U!ILGJIZQ= UVSMUVG3A7? S = (Q , q , A , → ) BA(- A!BX@7S + Q = Q × Σ I U,G A'U7A7G Q% 1 U!GWE5GWAHU A< %AQ AB)I U!GJI ,+Cs I U; AHU'G AI ILGJIZE5cUVG3E)G3A A =A I U"G A - ILGWA"U7AHG QD1 ECF7GfIZQ U>YJczEC@!AHc0UJ]9E= B>G AnG %E= UVILGfIZQ %AHczE5GJqIZQ= = (q I ,Unε)G A" UV?>E)cLcdAVUVG → U!s@HU7AHG Q%1 UVsF/j G E)G + Q ×A ×Q R. S. 0 S. S. 0 R. R. R. S. S 0 R. 0 S. S. S. S. S. R. ∗ M. S. R.
(93) p. Ã Ê
(94) |6y{³Ey{|6{|9zXì 1. =. +. ,+. ∗ JY ?[A7?>Q VI HI V] I E B !e !e (q, w) −−→S (q, w.e) q −−→R q w ∈ Σq! ∗ Y %Q2F!AVU!UVI H] + I E B e e (q, w) −→S (q 0 , w) q −→R q 0 w ∈ Σq! ∗ Y@8)E G3F + I E B ?e ?e (q, w1 .e.w2 ) −−→S (q 0 , w1 .w2 ) q −−→R q 0 w1 ∈ Σq! +. ). 1. +. 1. =. =. I1. e. G . E B. (q, w) −→S (q, w) e 6∈ (out(q) ∪ ΣM ) n o+ \ILG !e Σq! = e ∈ ΣM | q −−→R q. w ∈ Σq!. . / %Q2F!AVU!UVI ,+H]. ∗ . ZEB%4>83%4 :åM@>è:BË:<M s UVGWEC@7cdA9^k:SHÅB84> CB@B@>93 M{BGCB6> :å[M UVGWEC@7cdAd: & 9; CEM@> P CIHo>9W`>9H (q,Bf:<Mw)B6Z±?J> ?ACIB6;! #436wZX;9>8∈M6MN>rΣ7_V=E$3@:<ZE36:B{ø±:åMf_`:SW`>9HB6ZB%4> ?JCB6;! #436Z\;>8M6Q M@:SH4_ M MN:<HA;>VB%A>VZEB%4>83$B636CEHAMN:SB@:<ZEHJM$CI36>RZ`H Q øo>8HACI? Q >r7è:<H MNB6CI? Q >^M{BGCB@>rM7 TZ`3@>8ZWE>93ßB%4>^?ACBG;! Z)&n^3_ #43@Z\;9>8M6MN>r7àZ\;9;9D43@36>9HJ;>j^ :d&CEH ø _V:åM^B%4>.Z Q 7\>rM{BZEHA>,C`M±;Z`HA7\:SB@:<ZEH CI?ªZWE>$:<>ù # Q :S>r7M 2:SHJC Q<Q ø F ? nø #ªZE:<H B ^H_ F 8B 4> Y02fa:åMÆ;Z`ù # Q >9B@>CIHA7B%wXDAM∈3@>rCEΣ;B6MºB@Z^>9WE>83@ø >9WE>8H B ^Z44>936>8C`M
(95) %B 4>YR2 P ù,Cø.HAZIB0?ª>;ZE>ù # Q >B6>n4 32 B J>9>B6:SHA_o>8WE>8H`BGM8_H = : E5? cdA +R þ 4>TMN2> e D4>9HA;9> ?ª> Q 5Z 4 7\:> #4:å;B6M.bC #ªZ`M6MN:<? Q > 36D4H')Z &08B 4> 3@>rCE7\>836M M4 36:SB@>93GM Y02 P :SHT2:<_ED436> $^kC _V ! ∗ q. ! ∗ q. 1. !r1. w. !r. !w. W. 2 −→S ( , ε) −−→S (W, ε) −−→S (W, r1 ) −−→S (W, r1 w) −−→ S (W, r1 wr2 ) −. ?r. ?r. R. R. 1 2 1 2 ( , r1 wr2 ) −−−→ −−→ S (R1 , wr2 ) − S (R1 ||R2 , w) −−→S (R2 , w) −−→S ( , w) . . .. þ 4> B@3GCIHAM@:B6:SZ`H ; >rCI3 ø÷7\>:#4:<;B6MËB%A> 2:SöªZ ^k2:<36MNB H 2 :<3GM{BR2:<3@>rCI? Q > U D\(RB!_#J, wr Z Q :å;ø) −−ÿ HA−→7\>8>87 (RF r ||R:åM ?A, w)CIB6;!j#Q 436ZXQ ;9>8M6MN>r7ç?ª>8;8CIDAM@>9^ :L_
(96) B84>Ó;Z`H\üAÿ _ ý D436CIB@:<ZEH (R , wr ) :åMD4HAMNB6CE? Q > F CIHA7g^ :<: _$B84>>9WE>8H B6MCI36>R?ACIB6;! #43@Z\;9>8M6MN>r7èCEMM@Z Z`H C`M #JZ M@M@:S? Q >±CIHJ7 4 :SB%j#436:<ZE36:B{ø,B6ZËB84>±Z Q 7\>rM{B ZEHA>C ' 8$îXóóîXó ç î C7 ªî 7 ñ ï ô:8î ' ô # :<MËC P CEH?J> A<>r 7.K2I B@ %3GQ=CI THJ?>MN:SA<B@ :<ZEG HçEM@ø\=M{B6>9(Qù 4 , q:8B , A , → ) 7\& ZE>üA3ËHACà:SH4Y0_Ë2f%B aA>VS:< H =#4D\(Q ,q ,A ,→ ) B
(97) 4 E Z G 3 4 7 ß M Z C & B % A> ^ @ M \ ø { M 6 B >9ù Q ^ J: > xQ M@:> e D4>8HA;>rMRCZ &ß>9W`>9H B6MV:SF H _HAx þ A>=[Σ='?[F @!A!BCBCA!B[DA8EFHGJILK5A$N I PQ RTSMUVGWAH? :<M SkE ZE?\BGCI:<H4>87 ?Xø M@ø HJ!; 43@Z`H4:<O8CB6:SZ`HèΣ)Z & S CIHA7 E " î 7Z7kñ ' 8$îXóóîX ó çî C7Jî 7 $ñ ï 7ô rî ' ô '5 qA ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87ÅY >rCE; B@:<WE>Ó2:SöªZ aXø\M{B6>9ù ^ ú ùË?J>r747\>87 Y02f a _XI UXEgYJI -C TILG3A]9cdEC@!A7cdA!B G> %E UVú ILGJIZQ= bUVSMU!GWA7? S ký ?r2. 1. 2. 1. S. 2. 2. 1. . 2. . . E. 0 E. E. E. 0 S. S. S. S. E. ∗. . . . BA(- A!BX@7S. %1 = + = = D1 = C %1. +. I UG AU7AHG. ∗. . . + = . 0 E = (QSkE , qSkE ,A ,→ ) Q = QR × (ΣM ) × QE Q $F!Q - Cs %E5GJIZQ U$E SkE B 0 SkE 0 I UrG SkE A$I ILGJIZE5c<F!Q - Cs %E)GfIZQ 0 qSkE = hqR , ε, qE i SkE I U+G A{UHA7GXQ hECF7GfIZQ U XE B6- E5cLc0S G AjG %E UVILGfIZQ %A7cdE5GJIZQ I U+G A A{ UV?>= E)cLcdAAVUVSG → SkE U!s@HU7AHG Q UVsF {G E5G QSkE × ASkE × QSkE. . . + I1 E= B . + hq , w, q i −−→ hq , we, q i (q , w) −−→ (q , we) q −→ q I1 E= B + hq , w, q i −→ hq , w, q i (q , w) −→ (q , w) q −→ q + I1 + hq , w ew , q i −−→ hq , w w , q i (q , w ew ) −−→ (q , w w ) $Q5GJIZF!ArG E)G @7S BCA%-C TILGfIZQ V s cdA E5U V IZQ=V ILGJS Q)KMA< V s cdAHU E= B + !e. R. E. SkE. e. R R. . E. 1. SkE ?e. 2. E. R 0 R. SkE. !e. 0 E. R. 0 E. 0 R. R. e. S. e. S. R. E e. 0 R. E. ?e. 1. 2. E. R. 1. 2. S. E. 0 R. 0 E. E 0 E. 1. 2. .
(98) ¾ |6y{²Îä 9{²´ro8Í É Ü^³\|}`}`|}c$|86{²´À|0x²ÎÚ4lgEÛ{|Gܱ t þ 4>036D4HAMßZC& CE3@>R;8C >r7oB%4>>F!Q= UVG %E5I A!B Vs UZC&xB%4>^MNø\MNB@>9ùj þ 4>RH4ZEB@:<ZEHAM Z)&
(99) MNB6CE?4: Q :SB{øàCIHA7 SD4HAkMNEB6CE?4: Q :SB{øTHAQ<Q CB6D43GC Q<Q øT>9[ B6>9HA7æB@Z ú ùË?J>r747\>87÷Y02fa ÿ H %B A>,M@:> e D4> QdF ú ^ ùÓ?ª>87474>87o_VY0 2fa ^ n_7\>9HAZIB@>rM 8B 4>; Q CEM6MºCZ & ú ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87ËY02fa 4 :S%B n ùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8>87±>8WE>9H BGM |Σ | = n LZEHAM@:<74>936:SH4_,B84>o>9HXWX:S36ZEH4ù,>8H`B :<Hæ2:S_`D43@> $^kT? _ %B 4>o>[\>r;D\B6:SZ`Hà)Z & [4CEù # > $ :<MB84> #436>ü4[ Z)&fCo;9ZEHAMNB@3GCI:<H4>r7è36D4H EZ)&B%4>Y02 P :<HT2:SF_`D43@> $^kC_H
(100) D\B B%4:åM ú >9[X>r;D\B6Q :SZ`H :<M 7\:åM@;8CI3G7\>87?Xø E :<Hj2:<_ED436*> $^k:; _çMN:<HA;9>æ8B 4>æB636CEHAM@:B6:SZ`H (W, ε) −−→ (W, r ) :<M 7\:<M6CI? Q >r7ç?Xø r :SH E ?AMN>83@W`> %B ACIB #436ZW :å7\>r7 8B 4> M@>B )Z &>8WE>9H BGM :<MçH4ZEH>9>ù #\B{ø C Y02fa AC`MèH4Z 7\>8C`7U Q Z\;GK M{BGCB@> F M@F:SHJ;>è:<H >9W`>936ø MNB6CIB@>è:SBË:åMÓCE? Q >èΣB@Zà36>8C`;B±B@Z CIHÅ>8WEF >9H BZ\;9;9D4363@>8HA;> F >9:S%B 4>83±? øæùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8:SH4_ :SB ?Xø Z`M@:SH4_ :S9B ^ d: &8B 4:<M>8WE>8H`B±:å.M A>9>9B@:<H4_ ?Xoø ^H_V:<H >üJH4: B@:<ZEH m _ F Z`30?Xø #436Z\;>8M6M@:SH4_.F :SB:ª=0Q >8HA;>ÓCEHXø ú ùË?J>r747\>87æY02fa+4 :B8æC,F H4ZEH ý B6>936ùo:<HACIB@:<H4_ ý >9HXWX:S36ZEH4ù,>8H`BR74Z >rM0H4ZEB0B@>83@ù,:<HACB6C> HT%B 4>Ë3@>rM{B0CZ &f%B 4>$#A)C #ª>93 4
(101) r> 4
(102) ZEH BV7\:åM@;9DAM6M %B A> B@>936ù,:SHJCB@:<ZEHo#43@Z`? Q >9ùCIHXøXù,ZE36> F CEHAÿ 7 ?Xø ?#A3@Z`? Q >8ù.MZ)&0:<H B@>83@F >rM{BD@ 4>èù,>rCIH¿C QSQ B%A> #43@Z`? Q >9ù.M 7\>üJH4>87 :<HTa\>8;B6:SZ`H m G$>9[\;97> #\B8B 4>B@>83@ù,:<HACB6:SZ`H #436ZE? Q >8+ ù M. !r1. 0. S. 0. 2. 1.
(103). j
(104) `
(105) .
(106) . . . ÿCjH #JB%>84:3@å:<M0Z\7\M@>8:<;,;B6>8:SZ`HXH W F:<364
(107) ZEH4>ù,üA3G>9M{H BB#ACI3@36Z>.W`>R7\>B8B6AC>936BVù,YR:SH42Æ:åMNa+B@:åJC;.;W ZE:<DAH4H`_oB6B>94
(108) 3Z.CED\ùoB@Z`>8ù,ù,ZECI36B6:SCO8 >87 Br>9& W`Z >9H Z5B640M M^CEHAB8AC7j4 BÓ:C B8 B%4>X#43@Z`? Q >9ù.M0CZ &ß:SH B@>83@>rM{B^CI36>±D4HA7\>r;:å74CI? Q C> x þ 4>8H F 4
(109) > & Z\;DJMRZ`HàY0ÿ 2f{a Q<4 Q :S%B æCIBRù,Z`MNQSB Q ZEH4>±ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9>r7ç>8WE>9H B0;Z`HAMNB@3GCI:<H4>87 ?Xøç36>9_ED Q CE3
(110) >8HXW :<36ZEH4ù,>9H BGM CIHA+7 #436ZWE>V%B ACIB %B 4>8:S3 3@>rCE!; ACE?4: Q :SB{øèMN>9B:åM >9öª>r;B@:<WE> Q øç3@>r;ZE_`H4:<O8CI? Q > ` %$
(111) +óî (7kó 8 7>7iGï¿ñ &Rî =ò 7kñºó 7 ( > ï ' 8î óóî ó # ' &(A! VIZQ2B5IZF!E5cLc S+='?[@8A!BBCA!B DNOR :<MCEH ùË?J>r747\>87÷Y02faà%B 4>o>9HXWX:<3@Z`H4ù,>9H B^CZ & 44:å!; 3@P >r;ZE_`H4:<O9>8MC #ª>936:SZ\7\:å;MN2> e`DA>9HA;9>^CZ &>8WE>8H`ú BGM u 4A>936> u :åM0CËüAH4:SB@> 4
(112) ZE3G 7 î 7Z7kñ n `ñ 5 8î ò 5 rñ ' # '5 'q ný ;ZEDAH`B6>93CID\B6ZEù.CB6ZEH C I U9BCA7p A! 8A + I U>E - ILGWAXUHA7GQD1rUVGWE5GWAVU -C A!Bj@7S+G A GJs czA , . . . , c }, → ) \ILG I ILGJIZE5cUVGWE5GWA q (Q {c, q, . ,. {c I U"E - ILGWAUHA7GOQ%1T;9ZED4QH B@>836. M \ILG KME)c0sAVUI N E B .,c } . . . ∗. 0 C. C. 0 C. 1. 1. n. C. C. n. < ! ,+ D1 ! <. + ! < / < + AHILG A< XE hI F< %A!EMUVI ,+ G %E= UVILGfIZQ + Q=X E+BCA!F<% A!EMUVI ,j + E B+E*2A< %Q[GWAVUVGJI ,q+ −−G>− 8E=−→ UVILGJIZqQ= E B q −−−−→ q + q −−−−→ q. I U[G A[G % E UVILGfIZQ * %A7cdE)GfIZQ * A< %A < ,+ =E B ck =0? %A %A7p = C
(113) %Q5K2IZBCA!B. →C ⊆BCQ 1 , . . . , cn } × {++, −−, =0?}) × QC A CQ5GW× AHU"({c G An I F 8A8E5UVI 9Q A 8A8E5U I U"ILGZU CB A!F %A!EMUVI ck ++ k −− UHA GfU G A 2A %QG3AHUVGfI Q A %E)GfIZQ + ckq p*F!Q5s GWA c, E5s GWQ5?[E5GWQ >I U n HQ XA!ECF +UVGWE5GWA G A %A$I U q. < 1 = . ck ++. C. ck −−. ck =0?. 00. 0. 07\>B6>936ù,:SH4:åMNB@:å;. BCA!E5c0I + \ ILG hG ArUHE)?>A>F!Q5s TG3A< +. 0. . þ 4>^M@>9ù.CEH`B6:<;8MßZC&C ný ;Z`D4H B@>93
(114) CID\B6ZEù.CB6ZEH C :<M$B%4> Q CI?ª> Q >87.B636CEHAM@:B6:SZ`HèMNø\MNB@>9ù S = 44>83@> :åMfB%A>VM@ù,C QSQ >8MNBM@D4?AM@>B$ZC& (Q × N ) × (Q × N ) (Q × N , hq , 0, . . . , 0i, →) _E:<WE>9H ?Xø ^ m , . . . , m ∈ N_!" → $C hq, m , . . . , m i → hq , m + 1, . . . , m i d: & q −−−−→ q F C. 2. C. 2. 0. 1. 1. n. n. 0. c1 ++. 1. n. C. 0. 2.
(115) ¯. Ã Ê
(116) |6y{³Ey{|6{|9zXì. :. F HA7 : E C hq, m , . . . , m i → hq , m − 1, . . . , m i q −−−−→ q m >0 CIHA7,B84>MNøXù,ù,>B@36:å;B@3GCIHAM@:SB@:<ZEHAM & ZE3 c , . . . , c P Vs ZC&ºC ný ;ZEDAH`B6>93$CED\B@Z`ù.CB@Z`H C :<M0Co36D4H :SH S ÿ ö H,&B%4>Q5RU!G M@>:e D4> Q 4
(117) >0M@C&øÓQMB%UVACG IBCB6364 CEHA:8B MN:SB@:<ZEH.C M@ø\M@:SM{>ù B6>9# ù >èSù.UV)C IL#? #4s :SHAcdE5_ GWAH^kUfC> C^ _ B6`36#ACE3@HACZ M@|{:B6>8:S;Z`B6H,:SZ`M@H÷ø\M{ZEB6H÷>9ù C S : S MND4?JMN>9BVZ)&$B%4>(S,MN)>9BV=ZC&fM{BGCB6>8M0:<(S) H Q M@Zè8B ACfB &Q5U!G (SQ ) ;9CIHæ?J>,;Z`ù #AD\B@>r7à>8C`MN: Q ø & 36ZEù &QMUVG (S)_V XG A< %A I U E BCA7G3A< V? I I UVGfIZF 2 p îXñJòî ' $ # 'M 9N Q= E= S 5 s VI ,+ ?[ECF/ I A T c1 =0? m hq, 0, m2 , . . . , mn i → hq 0 , 0, m2 , . . . , mn i d& q −− −−→C q 0 3 d & c −− 1 0 0 1. 2. 1. 2. 2. ∗. 0. 1. C. n. ∗. 0. ∗. 0. ∗. F8Q)s GWA! rE)s G3Q)?>E)G3Q G E5G UVIL?Xs cdE)G3AHU. T. +. . > H4Z54 #436ZWE>[4Z54 B6Z M@:SùËD Q CIB@> C >B@>83@ù,:<H4:åM{B6:<; mý ;Z`D4H B@>93ËCID\B6ZEù.CB6ZEHÅ?XøÅC ùË?J>r747\>r7çY02fa ^ _V M@M@D4ù,> :åM
(118) CÓ7\>9B@>936ù,:SHA:<MNB@:å; ;Z`D4H B@>83$CID\B6ZEù.C B@ZEH 4 :B8ç;Z`D4úH B@>93GM c CIHA7 c - m >B SP k E ?ª>0CB84> EÆ>936:<ZX74:<;8C Q<Q ø ú ùÓ2?ªý >87A7\>87èYR2Æa.?4D4: Q B ý :SHç%B 4>"& Z 5Z 4 :SH4X_ 4
(119) Cø þ A>RB4
(120) ZË;9ZED4H B@>836M CIHA7 CI36>R36>8M%#J>r;B@:<WE> øè74>üAH4>r7è?Xø,B%A> B4Zèù,>8ùoQ<Q Z`3@:<O9>r7 >9W`>9H B6M e CIHA7 e MNZ.B8ACcBVB%4>ËHXcD4ùÓ?ª>93VZ)&ßù,>9ù,ZE36Q :<O9>87 Z\;8;D4363@>8HA;>rM )Z & ^k3@>r*M #` _
(121) :<M8B 4>±WC D4>)Z & ^ 36>8%M #` _V e Wú E>83@ø.B636eCEHAM@:B6:SZ`H :<H CQ :<MB636CEcHAM Q CIB@>87 :<cHàCoYR2 P M{B63@DJ;B@DA3@9> ^d>C 4 :<7\_`>VB _V U D43V;ZEH ý M{B63@DA;B@:<ZEH 3@D4HJM^C`M& Z Q<Q Z540M"ªB@Z MN:<ùÓD Q CB6>ËZ`H4>,M{B6>7# Z)&ßB84> 2ý ;ZEDAH`B6>93CID\B6ZEù.CB6ZEH F 4
(122) > ;ZEHJM{B636CE:SHæ%B 4>çYR2 P 4 :<7\_`>BGnM 4 :8B ÷C+4
(123) ZE3G7 u þ 4:åM 4Cø F ?Xø #436Z\;>8M6M@:SH4_ u 4>.;9CEH MN:<ùÓD Q CB6>.CIH÷>[\>8;9D\B@:<ZEH Z)&
(124) B%A>è;ZEDAH`B6>93±ù.CE;!A:SH4> þ 4>.KE>8øh#ªZE:<H`BrA>936>o:åMB6Z üJHA7÷C 4Z`367 B@Z ?J>> #436Z\;>rM@M@>87æ? ø C Y02 4 :å7\_`>B±:SH ZE3G7\>83VB6ZTMN:<ùÓD CB6>oC MNB@:> #` þ 4>,>9H W :<36ZEH4ù,u>9H B4
(125) >±BGCIKE> A>936>3@>r;Z`_EH4:<O9>rP M (τ e e τ ) 44>936> τ :åMVC6AQ >9>9B@:<H4_è>9W`>9H BVCEHA7 e ý CIHA7 e CI36>^ù,>8ùoZ`3@:<O9>r7è>8WE>9H BG7M ;. E>83@:<Z\7\:å;9C Q<Q ø. 1. 2. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 1. 2. ∗. 1 2. ∗. 1. 2. τ. 0 qE. e1. 1 qE. e2. 2 qE. 3 qE. þ 4>{4 :<74_E>BGM>& ZE3èB%4> B4
(126) Z÷B{ø #J>rM.Z)&^B@3GCIHAτM@:SB@:<ZEHAM,DAM@:<H4_ ;Z`D4H B@>93 CID\B6ZEù.CB6ZEH CI36>V_`:SW`>9H ? ø (" $C 4 :<74_E>B & Z`3 q −−−−→ q " c1 ++. C. 0. !e1 , !e2. :<74_E>B& Z`3. m 4. q c. =0?. τ. CEHA7. ?e2 , e2. q1 c. q −−1−−→C q 00 −−. τ. q2. τ. ". q0. q00 !e2. q. . !e1 , !e2. !e1. q −−1−−→C q 0 ?e1 , e1. :SH C 2ý ;9ZED4H B@>83. c1. !e1 ?e1 , e1. !e2 ?e2 , e2. !e1 τ. Ð~´~{Ç |f}E8Â{|}R~´râ ºy{|Æ |G6|GÂ{9yÂgR{
(127) Ü{@Ç|6ä ²Î{²´rËwâ\r²´ßiÛwu@v8³ zEx{Ç |6gRy{|f |GÀr|6y |6E|GGzE{|}o}Ez`y{²´ ãR{Ç |²´Ü^z`~9{²´r,9Í C à q1. q2. q3. q0.
(128) ¾|6y{²Îä 9{²´ro8Í É Ü^³\|}`}`|}c$|86{²´À|0x²ÎÚ4lgEÛ{|Gܱ s þ 4> A>9>9B@:<H4_.>9W`>9H B τ :<M :<H B@36Z\7\DA;>r7 B@ZèC Q<Q 5Z 4O9>83@ZoB6>8MNB@:<H4_ ^kM@>9> 4 :å7\_`>$B ^ m _*_CEHA7 B%4>B4
(129) Z τ B@3GCIHJMN:SB@:<ZEHAM" q −→ q ^kZEH+4 :<7\_`>Br^%$M_*_CEHA7 q −→ q ^ Z`H+4 :å7\_`>B ^ m _%_CI36> H4>9>r7\>87 B@Z>#4D4B B@ZE_`>B84>93B84> 4 :<74_E>BGM
(130) B@3GCIHAM Q CB@:<H4_Ë%B 4>B636CEHAM@:B6:SZ`HAM)Z & C aX:SHJ;>0:<HA;36>8C`MN:<H4_ :<Mù,ZX74> >87,?Xø,ùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8:SH4_ %B A>R>9HXWX:<3@Z`H4ù,>9H BßùÓDAMN,B #A3@Z 7\DA;> e CIHJ7 e M@>:e D4c>9H B6:<C QSQ ø M@:<HAQ ;+> ^ L: _0:SBV:åM #ª>936:<ZX74:<; eF CEF HA7 ^ :<L: _(4 :å7\_E>9B ^D$2_ HA>9>87AM0B6Z ý C)# # Q ø.B6Z.?JZE%B T;Z`D4H B@>93G:M þ DJM ZEH 4 :å7\_E>9B ^D$2_ & 3@Z`ù >9:S%B 4>83Æ%B 4>83@>:åMÆZEH4>ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9>r7 "IZ`H4>
(131) )Z &A8B 4>9ù :<M ?ACBG!; X#436Z\F ;>rM@M@>87 ^ Q >8CE74:SH4F"_ & 36ZEù qq F B@Z q _ÆCIHA7 e 8B 4>9H e CI36>ù,>8ùoZ`e3@:<O9>r7Ó:<H q F ZE3 e :<M
(132) ù,>9ù,ZE36:<O9>87è:SH q CIHA7 e :å,M #A3@Z\;>rM@M@>87 F`Q >8C`7\:SHA_B@Z q ÿ Hç?ªZI%B ;9C`MN>rM F %B 4>^HXD4ùÓ?ª>93 )Z &Æùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8>87 JCEM ?ª>9>8H :<HA;93@>rCEM@>87 ? ø ZEH4> 44>936>8C`M
(133) %B 4>±HXD4ùË?J>830)Z &fMNB@ZE36>87 :<M :SHXWCI36:<CEH B & 3@Z`ù eq B@Z q ÿ {H 4 :<7\_`>$B ^ m _ F e :<MR:SF ù,ù,>874:<CIB@> Q +ø #43@Z\;9>8M6MN>r7 & 36ZEù q B@eZ q MN:<HA;> :åM3@>rCE;!ACE? >:öÅB84>936>,:<M^H4Z ù,>9ù,ZE36:<O9>87 e /þ 4>9H F & 3@Z`ù q F e :åM^CC# # Q :S>r7 B%4>M6CIqù,>^B@36>8CIB@ù,>9H B0Q CEM:<jH 4 :<7\_`>rB ^%$M_V ÿ 9B & Z Q<Q 5Z 40Mè%B AC:SI{ö Bè4 %B A>:<74_E>2nB ý ;^%Z`$MD4_ßH ;9B@CE>8H.3çù,CID\ZB6WEZE> ù.& 36CZEB6ù ZEH C ;9CEH ùoZ4 W`:Sj>%B & 3@Z`ù hq, m , m i B6Z hq , m + 1, m i >9[4CE;=B Q ø (mB84>X4
(134) mZE3G)7 F B@Z hq , w , q i F 4 :SB% Ψ (w ) = (m + 1 m ) :Jhq, >Cxw,?Xø{q#43@iZ\F ;9>8M6MN:<H4Ψ_ç(w) ª þ 4>M@CEù,>^36>9ù.CE3@KçCC # # Q :S>r M & ZE30%B 4>±ZE%B 4>8(3 4 :<74_E>BRCEHA7 %B 4>74>8;36>8C`MN:<H4_oB@3GCIH ý τe e τ MN:SB@:<ZEH` îXñJòî ' # rN Q nA7K5A! VS9BCA7GWA! V? I I UVGJIZF p*F!Q)s GWA! E)s G3Q)?>E)G3Q \G A< %ArA :CI UVGfU"E &A< VILp 2 τ. 2. τ. 0. 3. k. 1. k. 2. 1. 2. 1. 1. 1. 2. 1. 0. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 0. 1. 1. 1. 0. 0 E. 2. 1. 2. 1. 0. 0. 2. 1. 0 E. 0. 1. 2. 2. 2. 1. 2. 2. 1 2. Q:B)IZF8E)cLc0S>= ?>@!A!BCBA8B DNOR Y ] G E)G UVIL? s cdE5GWAVU. C. +. . M$C±;9ZEHAM@>:e D4>8HA;> C B84>#A3@Z`? >8ù.MfZ)&/:<H`B6>936>8MNB$CI36>0D4HA74>8;:å74CE? >(& ZE3 ùË?J>r747\>r7 Y02fa P 4 :SB%TCIB Q >rCEMNB
(135) B4
(136) F Z,ù,Q<Q >9ù,ZE36:SO8:SHA_ËQ >8WE>9H BGM CIHA7 C #J>83@:<Z\7\:<;>8HXW :<36ZEQ H4ù,>9H B2ú ` # çî 5 >\ò= ï ' 8$îXóóîXó % 1$ '\òî 2$î)7 Jîkï*çîEñ 7(8 kî ÿ;Hç:å748BCI4>? >\#A& 3@Z`>83 W EÆ:<ZE>9DJ36M:SZ\M@7\>8:å;;9B@C :<ZEøH F 4
(137) ùÓ> ?ªAC>874W`7\>^>r7ÓM@>9Y0>8Hè2fa 8B AC^ _HB rC þ Q<Q 4:%BåMº4>n; C`#4M@36M ZE?Z)&Q >9ù.ùËM
(138) ?J)Z >r&74:S7\H >8B@>87Ó3@Y0>rM{2fB aCI36:SHJ>R; DADAHA7\7\>8> Mý B%4> XD4Q _E>ù.)C |{ZE36:B{ø )Z &OQSQ #43Gú CE;B@:å;9C Q M@øXMNB@>8ù.7M m ; >ËH45Z 4 Q & Z\;DAMVZEú H ú ùÓ?ª>87474>87æYR2Æha Q 4 :8B ZEH Q ø Z`H4>ù,>9ù,Z`3@:<O9:<H4_è>8WE>9H B e :SHàZ`3674>93 B6Z ;Z`ù># Q >9B@>Z`D43VMNB@DJ7\øC EfCI3@B@:å;D Q CI3 Q ø F 4
(139) > *M 4Z548B ACB
(140) %B A:<M3@>rM{B63@:å;B6:SZ`9 H 4>rCW : ø,74>8;36>8C`MN>rMÆ%B A>#ª5Z 4>83CZ & ùÓ?ª>87A7\>87 Y02faèC`Mß8B 4:<M :<MRB%4>o;9C`MN> & Z`3V2:d& Z CID4B@ZEù.CIB6C ÿ Q HA7\>8>87 F H4ZIB6>B8ACB"44>9HTB84>ú 936>:åMVCçD4H4: e D4>Óù,>9ù,Z ý 3@:<O9:<H4_,>9W`>9H B 8B 4>2:öx9Z e D4>9DA>±)Z &fC.Y02fa C`;B6DAC ø ?J:> ACWE>rM CEM C.;9ZED4H B@>83 M@:<HA;>ZEH ø B%4>±HXD4ùË?J>83 F )Z &Æ>9WE>8H B6M
(141) :SH 8B 4>re D4>9D4>:åM 36> Q >9WCIH Q<:B Q à>9ù,ZE36:SOrCB6:SZ`gH ^ ?JCB6!; +#4F 36Z\;>8M6M@:SH4_ Q _ )Z &ºCIHçZX;8;D43636>9HA;9>0)Z & %B XDAM
(142) ;ZE3636>8%M #JZ`HA74MÆB6ZËC:<HA;93@>8ùo>8H " B ^ 36>8%M #`X7\>8;93@>8ù,>9H !B _ß)Z &/%B A> ;ZEDAH`B6>923 ` þ 4>#43@Z\;9>8M6eMN:<H4_CZ &/C A>9>9B@:<H4_Ó>8WE>9H B$:<HçC Q Z\;9C Q :SB{Xø 4A>936> e ;8CIH.?ªX> ^ ?JCB6!; _ #43@Z\;9>8M6MN>r7 :år M #ªZ`M6M@:S? Q >è:Sö¿8B 4> e D4>8D4>è:åMÓ>8>ù #\B{ø F %B ACIBË:åM:Sö¿8B 4> ;9ZED4H B@>83:åM:> e DAC Q B6Z O9>936Z 24Z 5Z 4 :SH4_ 8B 4>h#436>9WX:<ZEDAM,:<H B@D4:SB@:<WE>T:å7\>8C`M CIHXø¿Y02f a ^D$2_.;8CIH?ª>æMN>8>9H CEMçC÷ZEH4> ;ZEDAH`B6>9Q<Q3 CID4B@ZEù.CIB@ZEH 4Y >8;8C Q<Q %B ACIBZ`H4> ý ;Z`D4H B@>8F 3CED\B@Z`ù.CB6CoCI36>^>öx>8;B6:SW`> Q øç; Q Z`M@>87 D4H ýý 7\>93 MNøXHA!; 436ZEHA:SOrCB@:<ZEH 4 :S%B üAHA:B6> CID4B@ZEù.CIB6 C =0>9HJ;> 4
(143) >à_`>Bè8B ACB CEHXø ú ùË?J>r747\>r7 Y02f a ^%$M_;9CEH÷?J> MN>8>9H CEMÓCTZEH4> ý ;9ZED4H B6>93CID4B@ZEù.CIB@ZEH aX:<HA;> ZEH4> ý ;9ZED4H B@>83CID\B6ZEù.CBGC & ZE36ùC^M@D4?ª; Q C`M@Mº)Z &#ADA*M J7\5Z 4 HÓCID4B@ZEù.CIB6( C 4A:<!; rJCWE>$>9öª>r;B6:SW`> ø^36>8;9ZE_`H4:SOrCI? >ß36>8C`!; CI?4: Q :SB{øTMN>9B6M^CIHA7 C Q MNZ 7\>8;9:<74CE? Q > - þ - CIHA7 L
(144) þ - ù,ZX74> QSý !; 4>r;GKXQ :SH4_ . H F $51 F 4Q>ËZE?\BGCI:<H ý B%4>n& Z QSQ 5Z 4 :SHA_Ë36>8M@D Q B " . . . . m. m. m.
(145) wG°. îXñJòî. Ã Ê
(146) |6y{³Ey{|6{|9zXì. ' ` DAB+Cs cdE= Vc0S= ?>@!A!BCBA8B"DNORF\ILG 9E)G ?[QMUVG\Q= A(?>A7?[Q= VI7I ,+>A7KMA< G E)KMA AZPA!F7GfILK5A7c0S %A!F!Q + TI:E@HczA. %A!ECF/ EC@7ILc0ILGJS$U7A7GZU7+ - Q %A!Q5K5A! 4 5 4oE BF) 5 4o?[Q:BAHc p*F A8F 2)I ,+ E= %A BCA!F7IZBCEC@7cdA 1HQ rG I U$FHcdE5U!U1+. . M±C ;Z`HAMN>2e D4>9HA;9> C B84>[#436ZE? >9ù.M^Z)&:SH B6>936>8MNB±CE3@>,7\>r;:å74CI? > & ZE3 ùË?J>r747\>r7 0Y 2fa P 4 :S%B TCIB0ùoZ M{B Z`H4>F ùoQSQ >8ù,ZE36:SO8:SH4_,Q >8WE>9H B0CIHJ7 Co36>9_ED Q CE3
(147) >8HXW :<36ZEH4Q ù,>9H B2 ú. $
(148). .
(149) . / , . \ /. [ r
(150) . ÿùoH >8ù,%B A:ZE<36M :SO8MN>8>r7T;B6>8:SZ`WEH >9H F BG4
(151) MR> H4Z`;9H ZEHA7\M@>9:å7\B@>8>93@3 ù,D4:<H4H4:<36MN> B@Q :å:<;9CEC ? Q > øC ú ùËùË?J?J>r>r74747\7\>8>87j7 Y0Y 2f>rCEa;B6B8:SACW`>ËB 2ù,:SöªCZTø aXQ ø\ZXM{Z`B6M@>9> ù.M@MZECIù,36>> >:e D4z: # #J>r{7 4 :S%B TB84> Q Z`M6MNø ;9CC #ACI?A: Q :B{ø ?Xø QSQ >9[XB@ú >9HJ7\:SHA_ç7\>üJH4:B6:SZ`H 3[4 :SB%TB84>r& Z QSQ Z54 :<H4_ 3@D Q > " H hq , w, q i −→ hq , w , q i d: & w 4 w þ 4> Q Z`M6MNø CE;B@:<ZEH l ùËDAM{BoC Q MNZà?ª>çC`747\>87ÅB@Z A B6ZàZE?4B6CI:<H CIH = ?>@!A!BCBA8B4 QMU!UVS DA!ECF7GfILK5AN I PQ RSMUVG3A7? YZ='?[@!A!BCBCA!B4 QMU!UVSDNORC]5 0ZEB@:å;>8B ACBß8B 4> Z`M@:SH4_±C`;B@:<ZEHoZEH ø CE;BGM0Z`H %B 4>Ëùo>8ù,ZE36:SO8:SH49_ e D4>8D4> F 44: Q > R CEHA7 E CI36>H4ZEBVCöx>8;B@>87àQ ? ø :S:B ; X> #43@ZW`Q > B%ACIB - Z M@M@ø¿Y02fa 4 :S%B 4
(152) > Q<QSý MNB@36DA;B6D436>87'>9HXWX:S36ZEHAùo>8H B6MèCE3@{> 4
(153) > Q<Qý MNB@36DA;B6D43@>r7¿%B 4>8ù ý MN> Q W`>8M: %$ î `9ò 5 ) 5 òîXó =ò ô 7Z7dTñ ï 7ô rî ' ô A7cLc0p3RTG VsK FHGJ& sZE %3ßA!8BB 4>R5 %CEE HA C UVILø\GJIZMNQ=:åMf b)Z RT&/SM:<H\UVGWüAAHH4?X:SB@U >VYM{BGCR B@>V5`MNRCø\][MNB@.G$>9Hù.F :M $ m\aXF >8$(WE$ >8F 36$:C l F 7\3)>1üA#4HA36:ZB6WX:SZ`:<74HA>ËMßC.CZ &_`;>9H4a4>8þ036C a Q & 36CEùo:> 4Z`3@r >[\:<MNB F & 36ZEù %B 4>üA3GMNBZ`H4Q >8MCZ &2:<H4KE> Q .G$ $ F $ m 1 CIHJ7 P ?ª7\D QSQ hC AHG Q E5c3+ . 351/B6ZË8B 4>±D4H4d: & øX:SHA_ & 36CEùo:> 4Z`3@K.CZ &2:<H4KE> Q CIHA7 a\!; 4HAZ >8?J> Q >8H .G$H)13 ;a\þ0a CI36> B@3GCIHAM@:B6:SZ`H M@ø\M{B6>9ù.M >:e D4:z# #J>r7 4 :S%B C94(e`Z ZEHT8B 4>ËMNB6CIB@>8M 44:å!; à:åMR;Z`ù ý ≤ q q ∀ #ACIB@:<? Q >o4 :B8 ≤B%4>8:S3æB@3GCIHAM@:SB@:<ZEH3@> Q CIB@:<ZEH " → ?& ZE3TC Q<Q q ≤ q CIHA7 B@3GCIHAM@:SB@:<ZEH q → q B%A>936>>[\:åM{BGMRCèM@>:e D4>8HA;> M@DA;! B%ACIB l. R. E. SkE. R. 0. 0. E. SkE. . . 0 1. 1. @. 1. 0 1. 1. ∗. 2. q10 −→ q20. q2. ≤. q20. ∃. :> #J>8HA7\:<H4_RZ`H±%B 4>M@:> e D4>9HJ;> CEHA7"& Z Z54 :<H4_r. $<HC1 B%A>;Z`ù>#ACB6:S?4: :B{ø <: MhU!G %Q ,+T:d& σ :<MçZ)& Q >9H4_EB% 1 ÿ σ&^=B84>q M@−>:→e D4q>8HA;> σ =Q<Q q →− q →−F . . . →− q →−Q q ;ZEH BGCI:<HAMVCIB >8C`M{B^ZEH4>ËB@3GCIHJMN:SB@:<ZEHæCEHA7àù,Z`3@>8ZWE>93 q ≤ q , ∀i ∈ {1, . . . , n} B%A>9H :B :<M0C UVGJs GfGWA! VI Q +^;ZEù>#ACIB@:<?4: Q :SB{øC þCIKX:SHA_Ó:<H`B6ZoC`;9;9ZED4H B
(154) %B 4> Q CE?J> Q M
(155) ZC& B%4>^B636CEH ý ∀ q ≤ q M@:B6:SZ`H÷M@ø\M{B6>9ù F 4
(156) >,ZE?\BGCI:<H÷C ^dM{B63@Z`H4_ Q øà;Z`ù ý C C #ACIB@:<? Q >M_ A7cLc0p3RTG VsFHGJs %A!B 4 EC@!A7cdA!B 5 8E= UVILp GJIZQ= hRSMUVG3A7? Y R4 5`RC]X.G$H)1 ; a ^ - _{þ09a ACEnM AfPA!FHGJILKMA %A!B5p*@!E5U!I U(. $<HC1Jd: & %B A>936>R>[\:åM{BGM$CEqHçC Q _EZ`≤3@:S%B 4ù q ;Z`ù>#4∃D\B ý P :SH4_ CoüAH4:SB@> ý ?AC`MN:åM0CZ & ↑& %A!B = (↑q) & Z`3VC,_`:SW`>9HTM{BGCB6> q ^k7\>8H4ZIB6>87 pb(q)_Vx þ 4>8H F & Z`3RC ; a ^ - _{þ0a 4 :8B T7\>8;9:<74CE? Q > ≤ CIHJ7ç>9öª>r;B@:<WEn> #436>87 ý ?AC`MN:åM F :SB0:åM #JZ M@M@:<? Q >^B6Z,;9ZE>ù #4D\B6>C q2 ≤ q20. 0 1. ∗. 0 2. 1. 0 1 0 1i. 0 11. 0 1n. 1. 0 1. 2. 0 2. 0 2.
(157) ¾ |6y{²Îä 9{²´ro8Í É Ü^³\|}`}`|}c$|86{²´À|0x²ÎÚ4lgEÛ{|Gܱ w8w üAH4:SB@>$?JCEM@:<MºZ)& & %A!B (↑q) F CEHA7±:SB & Z Q<Q Z540M/B%JCBºB84>;9ZWE>83@:<H4_ #436ZE? Q >9ù:åMº7\>r;:å74CI? Q >. $<HC1J 24D43@B%4>83@ù,Z`3@> : &
(158) B%4>[;`a ^ _Nþ0ba ACEM±MNB@D4BNB@>83@:<H4_à;9ZE>ù #ACB6:S?A: Q :B{øà%B 4>èù,Z\7\> Qý !; 4>8;GKX:<H4_ Z)&B%4>n& 3GCI_`ùo>8F H B ú ] )Z &$L
(159) þ - - :<MR7\>8;9:<74CE? Q > . $:l F $H)13 # ' 8$îXóóîXó $ñªô8ô8*ï % \òîTðÓî :ô 9ò 5 C 5 òî ó î 7Z7kñ ' 8$îXóóîX ó $ñªô8ô8ï 'M (q ;a ú ùÓ?ª>87474>87 - Z M@M@øàY02fa I UrE j='?[@!A!BCBCA!B 4 Q5U!U!S$DN\R A< %ArG A A< K2I %Q= T?>A< G'I U$E R4 5`R + >- B S k E ?ª>^CEH ;a ú ùÓ?ª>87474>87 - Z`M6M@ø,YR2Æa 4 :S%B XC 4
(160) > Q<Qý M{B63@DJ;B@DA3@>r7.>9HXWX:S36ZEHAùo>8H B ; >Ó7\>8H4ZIB6> %B A>?4:<HACI36øç36> CB6:SZ`H Z`H %B 4>Ó;9ZEH\üJ_ED43GCB6:SZ`HAM:SH 74>üAH4>r7 (E, v) ?
Documents relatifs
Each time an interaction α ∈ γ is executed, all the history clocks corresponding to the actions participating in α are reset synchronously, and then become identical at the next
Particularly, in the paper we (1) propose a heuristic to determine an order of consideration of hardware resources of the configurable device, depending on its functional and
Keywords: embedded systems, verification, security, networking, timing analysis, WCET, hard real-time, timing predictability..
Nous reviendrons successivement sur ces trois questions au plan théorique et illustrerons, à partir de la méthode IDEA (Indicateurs de Durabilité d’une Exploitation Agricole),
It consists of two computers (disengageable) that control the autopilot and provide information to the crew, flight parameters (Pilot Flight Director), navigation
We then solve variants of the problem for reachability, safety, B¨ uchi, coB¨ uchi, parity, Rabin, Streett and Muller objectives when the rationality of processes is modeled using
Next, we share our experience with the application of those techniques that seem to be mature enough to be used in an industrial context: Static analysis based on
The proposed approach is based on the Architecture Analysis and Design Language (AADL), which is suitable to describe the system’s architecture.. It contains a sequence of
