Allocation distribuée de ressources dans le système CONSENSUS
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Allocation distribuée de ressources dans le système CONSENSUS Sylvain Sécherre — François Fages. N° 0308 Juillet 2005 Thème SYM. ISSN 0249-0803. apport technique.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) ! "#$%&'
(7) (*)+ ,$-".0/'12.3/4%/ 56798;:=<9>25
(8) ?A@CB DFEGEHDJILKNMNEG:=> OAP=<RQSMJ:=TUDFQ VXWLY Z'[#\A]_^a`b\dcfehgiYHZj[Ge*eicAZlk;mFnporqAst[He uJvwmyxz[ gwe|{}m~Agwvwop~Agi[Ge *t;mFvhggw[HWt~Lo qAst[ ~= FFl`bsLopn np[ g|yA `ClLyF[He dH{}[Svyt=mvig#fGvwognrvwHeimn sfgio m~ st~tvwmktn Y Z'[S yn n mdHCgwopmF~¡t[Svi[GeieimsLvw [He¢eistvh£ m~Agivyo ~AgX¥¤F[H_n [ehcfehgiY Z'[ Z#sLngwo£¦sfgio n o ewCgw[ stv_{§_¨_\d©ª¨_\f«¬\U=®[Geeinpn [He st~¯HyZ'tsLeH°fviHLyvigio [He Ly~Le tn sLeiop[Hstve kL±CgwopZ'[ ~Age °eim~AgJ² C³U[Hgi[ vJ²_tn sLeiop[Hstve HqAsto ;[GeN[ ~j´µm~;¶gio m~'f[n [ stve k=[Heimo ~Le y®[He m~Agivyo ~Agi[GefsltvimFktn Y Z'[}eim~Ag
(9) n [He
(10) k=[Heimo ~Le f[He
(11) sfgio n o ewCgw[ stve y{}[Hek=[Heimo ~Le
(12) ~t[ei[ vwm~Ag;e
(13) ´µmvHZj[H~Ag ewCgwo eh´·yopgweH°U[g¢[¸ftvwo Zj[H~Ag fmF~L'f[He_tvw´µHvi[H~L[Ge_tnpstgi¹ygqAst[f[Ge_ m~Agivyo ~Agi[Ge¬fsLvi[Ge º¬[tnps;e_ [He mF m~¡~A~tgiv[yo ´·~Aygiopg#[Ge*LehFmFe¢~Ag_nR Wdfcd[j;fmogi³UWt YGvweh[ [~AgwqF[HsLe¬[~LnpC[Ggwestsfvi[Ggwope n °=o ew[Cg gw[ ~tst[jve¢ehmF[ ~F¸dg Lfvio mZ'~;[ ~ALg¢FgiemFsf´·gi [Gopen [ n Z'[ st[Hv~Fe¢g¢tvwmFZ'´µHLviy[H~Lvykt[Ge n [H°eH t[ ©Jn np~t[Gez»L£¼~o° gw~F®
(14) g* Zjtt givwWto eimf[Hfe[²jstLgio npvhorgwehHopv[f;[GmFest~tvJmy gw[Hn e stqAn s[ vJ opnrfe[GfeJmFeh~tmF~tnpst[ gi~Ao g|m~Le sf[G¸ezgJeimstn ~Lsfgi[o mZj~L eXgiWtLmfvimFf;[*mAteh[H[Hvie[GLWty[ vXvn [Wt[XehcfehtgiYHfZjgw[Fygio ¤[ ½¼nfeH opg st~L[Z' giWtmff[f[vi[GWt[ vWt[}npmf np[XVyk=ms#=[ vwZ'[gigwy~AgJf[viGehmFsLfvw[}f[GetvimFktn Y Z'[He eistvh£ m~Agivyo ~AgweX[H~vi[GWt[ vWLy~AgXst~t[#eimn sfgwopmF~¤do mnry~Ag*n [Z'mo ~Le=mFeweho ktn [n9 [ ~;eh[HZ#ktn [f[He¬mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[HeH «|~t[#fop¾SstnpgilLyvigiorsLnpo Y vw[¢[Hehg¬f[jWt[ vWt[ v*²Svi[H~Lfvw[¢np[Ge|mF~Agivyo ~Fgw[HeXWt giHvimFY ~L[He* mZ'LyvykLnp[Ge y»L~!qAst[_n #Z'giWLmdt[¬~ [ ~!´·¥¤mFvioreh[;e[ vigwop~L[He}tnps;e}qAst[ ysfgwvi[Ge d®J ytLvi[H~Fgwo ewewy[*t[He}tvi ´µ£ vw[ ~;®
(15) [H#eXvwfH[Geiemn sfsfgwgiopo n mo ew~!Cgw[ n stmvkLeXnp[H[_ehgXfgis!vytopvwgimkLqAnpYHsLZj~F[¬g*[H²jehgn stogwo vLCgivo ¤st[F~¿°´·tvio mFewy~AvgXyZ'eh[ Z'eh[|s; n op~LGHfy[ o vXvw[f [Ge}LWLei[Hef[¢ n stn e t[#ehmFnpstgio m~LeÀ9²Lvhgwopv_f[He|tvi ´µ vw[ ~L [He[ ¸ftvio Z' [Ge[g¬ttvwo ei[HeÁ¶°;[g¬t[He*LWLei[He*t[#~tmgwCgwopmF~f[He eimn sfgwopmF~Le'Lyv!np[Gesfgio n o ewCgw[ stve °xzsLeiqAs ²ÂgivwmsL¤[ vsL~t[Ãeimn sfgio m~ÄmF~Lei[ ~Leist[ n n [°JqAsto|o ~LewCgwo eh´·yopgSnp[ Z'mFop~Le!ysL st~Äsfgio n o ewCgw[ stvG}ºl sL~Å;mFop~Agt[¯¤dst[tvwmvyZ'ZCgwopmF~°}{§_¨¬\f©ª¨¬\f«_\[Hehg m~Lehgiopgist st~ei[ vw¤[HstvXÆÇ[Hk[ g|f[¢n op[H~Agwen F[ ve °d[ ~AgwopYHvi[HZj[H~AgXo Z'tnry~Agi¢[H~È*giZ'n9°;ɬ^¯®ª°tu [ vwn [g¬\f opnryk vwÊÌ[ ~;ËLÍG[HeHΰtÏзmFd~A¡giv$yo ~FmFgwf[HgieHo Z'°fyo tewCtgwvwop[ mF~A~¡gwo ewmeiZlkt[ op~;CgimFopvw[°
(16) yn npmf ygio m~¡f[Svw[HewehmFstv[HeH° vw[HWt[HvwWt['n mf yn [°tvi ´µ£ ѪÒ;ÓÕÔ¼Ö×NØ¥×NÓrÙ Ò=ÚÛHÜfÝ}ÞGß9àRáâ¶ãäáãÕå9×Jæ}ÓrÙ çµÚèçéÝÃØG× ê ë¼ÖHå9ãÕ×zå
(17) æì9íGãÕÓÕÓÕ×zàî¶ï¶ï¶ðGñ. Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30.
(18) ¶¿S
(19)
(20) # }" ,$-".3/1Å.0/'4%/ &
(21) *).
(22) LvimFktHÍnp[H Z tÏs;Íeh o ~tVXgwWtWto e![|Zlvi[Hst;npmFgivhop£RgsLeif[ [Hvewehvwcfopehk=gi[H[HeSZ"giWt{[ǧ_eh¨_mF\dnp¤d©ªo ~t¨_\f«¬my´\UfVX~ÄWtmC[¬¤vi[ mdvi£¼mFZ'm~;eªezopgw~SvwgiopWt~t[ [Gfop³=vw[H[Heivim[Hst~Fgvkt[sto npnpo n ~tmfA eJCgwmyop´mF~ Hyvi[!Z'gitWtsL[¿e Zl~t[HsL[HehtgJejk;m[*´*FgieiWteiop[¿F~tsL[Hei#[ vgieHm_gw[HVXyWtZ[HeieH[°FF~L [ [HmFLvwejtop~tvi|[gim ~tmygwgWt[ ~to vJ[G~t[G[Hei[HewtyvweHopn c¡VXWLeiy[*giorezm»;~;ezktgwvwn [°ªop~Agw~Lem´LgwgiWAWLs;[*elt[ vw¸fmtktvin [ [GZeie Lvi[ ´µ[ vw[ ~L [HevwygiWt[Hv!gwWLy~ WLyv2 m~Lehgivyo ~AgweH"^mvwmC¤[HvH°XgwWt[Hei[ m~Lehgivyo ~Agweyvw[ÃWt[ gi[HvimF[ ~L[ ms;e L~Lvi[ ´µ[ gwvwWd[ sL~Le_ [H~teHmyg VX[HWtF[ ehc¢o npcvi [Jmn Z'[HLviy~Lv[Hy_kL´µnpvw[Fm Z gio ~LWty[}n ~tn cmy° gCgw[jopmFf~LmeF~topm¤Fg [ ~¢Feikdeic_stZ'giWt[#[gwsLWLeiC[ vg¢e ygin m*n gisLWtei[X[ vehe|mFnp[ st¸dgiLo mvi~L[Geiee_tyvin mFn;gimAWteh[H[Gop v kdcgwWt[eicdehgi[HZ¿ VXWt[jZ'[gwWtmfsLei[H¿gwmmFZ'tsfgi['eimn sfgio m~Le|o e_Lyfgwop¤F[#eh[GyvW°USV
(23) kts¯n mf yn ei[HyvW¿Z'[giWLmd HyLktn [Ãmy´#eimn ¤dop~L mC¤[Hvh£¼mF~Lehgivyo ~t[H tvwmktn [ ZekAcÄei[HvwWto ~t´µmFv m~f»;stvCgwopmF~LeS¤do mnrCgio ~t Z' mo Z'~to LZ#stvwZktnpei[F[°Hg#o ~'meh´sL mWl~L ehgiXvy¥o c_~AgwgieHWLyg
(24) §¬gw~LWt[S[XZj;[G[ gistWtn mforylvlftmdo[H¾Se~tsLmynggzc¡´µmfore¢sLegimÃmF~#Z'eh mFZ'[[Wt [ mgi~L[HviehmFgivy[ o ~L~A[ gwmeHs;e¢VXWtm[~;npez[Ggwyvwvw~topop~A~Lgw e m´gwWt[¢tvw[´µ[ vw[ ~;[HeXm´gwWt[¢sLei[ v*yvw[¢f[Hng opgiWjnpo ~t[GyvtvwmFvwZ eimn sfVXgwopWtmF['~Le¯FnpmFÀ· kLmy~Ln eivworf[H[ eimvwopn ~LsfÇgio mgw~ÇWt[Ãmy´ª[ ¸fgwWtt[vi[Gteieivw[Hm ktn m[ Zav!np[Go e yvwopgi~t[H[Hvw ygito ¤vw[[´µ°[Hvin[Hgw~L[ vw[G~LeCgwmyop~L´ giWLt[¯W;sLeiei[H[ e_vewmyÁ´X°mopZ'giWÄtstLgwWLCgwopeimF[H~Çemm´´ ~Lmygwygio m~Le}my´giWt[¢eimn sfgio m~Le}kdc'giWt[_sLei[ ve °dst~Agwopnlm~;eh[H~Lehs;eªore}´µmst~Lst~LewCgwo eh´µcdop~L#gwWt[¬n [HFezgy~dc s;n o eh[HWAvHg* tn opvw[Hm~FZ ge °LSog*LorvieXmF[ v~AygiZ'o vw[ Z'n cSop~topZ'=tmn [ o Z'~Ag_[H~Fmgw´ª[H¤dop[ o ¢~¿°È*{giZ'§_¨¬nR°t\dÉ|©ªZ'¨_nR\f°L«¬u \¯[ vwno e y~L m¿Z'\f; mAopnrehy[Gk my´ª!ÆÇ[HkÇei[ vw¤[Hv¬y~; U!Î #Ë" #lmZlkto ~LCgwmvwo nmtgio Zj%o $Hygio m~°Cvw[HeimsLvw [ªyn npmfHCgio m~°Gn mf ndei[HvwW°Htvw[´µ[Hvi[H~L[Ge °y m~f£ ehgivyo ~AgweH°dnp[Gyvw~top~L.
(25)
(26) . . l ª
(27) ®[tvwmyxz[g¢{}m~Agivyo ~Agi[HeX[Gezg_opZ'tn orqFsL#ty~;e*n [tvwmyxz[gjfm~Ag|n [ktstg¬[Hehg|nrZ'o ei[#s =mo ~Ag¬ st~¯mFsfgio n
(28) qAsto
(29) ´· opn ogw[ v'n SviHLyvigiopgio m~f[Ge*n mdHysf¸¿[ ~Agwvi[¢n [He¬fo³U vw[ ~Agw[He*GqAstop=[He*gimFsfg¬[H~ ewCgwo eh´·yorewy~AgXsZ'o [ sf¸np[HstveXk;[GehmFop~LeH;{}[g*mFsfgio nfmFog=[ vwZ'[ghgwvi[ ysf¸sfgio nporewCgi[Hstve [ ¸ftvio Z'[ vn [ stveXk=[Heimo ~Le °fn [ sLvweXtvw´µHvi[H~L[GeX[g|f[ ~tmgi[Hv*f[He*eimn sfgwopmF~Le ° f[ n stn [ v*f[GeehmFnpsfgwopmF~LeX[g|t[_n [He|ehmFstZ'[ghgwvi[¢sf¸!sfgwopn o ewCgw[ stveH° [Hehgio Zj[Hv*n [HeXtvw´µHvi[H~L[Ge}vw [Hnpn [Het[Hesfgwopn oreiygi[ sLvweH° ®ª vwWtopgi[G¶gwstvi[¢f[ nR mFsfgio n[Gezg|²'f[Hsf¸!~to ¤[Gysf¸ ®[Âtvw[ Z'op[HveH yttsLop[¡ehsLvnr Z' giWtmff[¡f[Âvi[GWt[ vWt[ÃFtyfgCgwop¤F! ´µmstvw~to v|st~L[jeimn sfgio m~¯stvwmktn Y Z'[l npn mf CgwopmF~mZ'fgw[gw[ ~dsÃf[G[e|tÕ#vw"¢´µ[Hgvi[H~L=[Ge*mst[ v¸dLktvisfo Z'g¯ f[H[e m®s[#yei[HL tmvi~Lorei¿[HeH~L op¤F[Hys¯ttvw[ ~Ln [He¬tvw´µ vw[ ~;[He|f[nR sfgwopn oreiygi[ sLv|[ ~Ãtvi[H~Ly~Ag*[H~ÃmF~LehorfHvwygio m~ np[Ge~tmgi[Heyghgwvio ktstH[Heyst¸ehmFnpstgio m~LeHynrstn [Ge o ~LewC®gwo [Hehe'´·yforei[ st~A¸g~tn [¢op¤FZ'[Hmsfo ~L¸ eXe ; [ mA~;eieiWLo kt% np$é[ ~t[ n [H~Aeg¬stxzgisLo einporqAeisygi ²Â[Hstvw[¿eH qFs st~L[eimn sfgio m'~ & m~Lei[ ~Leist[Hnpn ([ &eimopgjgivwmst¤F [°. . tHeiop®vw [H[Ge*e k=°[Hfeio meho gw~Le~L[ [¿¸ft²¯vio sLZ'~ He*kLei±ymgi~Ao Zjg|[Hf~A[#gH°Ntnpfs;orehezo g[ yst~Lv e[mF²Çvwfstvw[H~te)[L~tsfmFgiZ#vw[ktHvw[¢qAstfo [#;[Few°yn vwnp[ [GFe*vifmFHstei=o vi[ HZ'[HeH[ °f~Agzglcdf;[[#nRt G[#qFeisLopnp=n [H[e {}W;qAst[|k=[Heimo ~![Gezgeweimvigio; st~md[¾S op[H~Fgf[¬´·* m~²#;[HviZ'[ ghgivw[ ²st~t[_HqAsto =[ t[¬Z'[gigivw[¬nR ¶£ [ ~Ag*ehsLvXgi[ nmsgi[Hn k;[GehmFop~ m~Agi{}v[Gye|o ~Ak=gi[G[Heeim=o m~Lste|vweivimmF~A~Ag|g
(30) n +[Hgwe_vi[mF¤d~AopmFginpvHy[Ho eH~FHgw®J[He* mtsts¯gio ndttvwmmopktgn Y =Z'mst[¤F m§¬o v
(31) ~f´·mFy~topg_~t[Htv
(32) YHe*st~Ln [l[eitm n Lsfgivho mg|~lnR Z,WAcd+ =Z'my[gwWteiYHoAeinp[l[~tqAmstZl[#kt [Hvw[e t[ ewyn n [Hef[HZ'~LfH[HefHLeweh[ nr' y;opgi¢fsHyZ'tsLeH {}[Xtvwmyxz[ g fhxh²*´·ogNnR mFkfxz[gJ st~'ezgy[[gNst~'fH¤[ n mL;[HZj[H~Ag [H-~ .., "/ 0%"t[H~j mn n k;mFvwygio m~ ¥¤F [H[Hvi_vw[ n [stv¢tvwFmyeixzei[mfg_o {} [HmFe_Z'ytstnp¸Ç[ ¸ fLop®³='Hvit[H~FvwHgwei[H[ e ~AgwmF[¢~Agigivs;yfo ~F[#gw[HeHe [Gezfg¬[j ´·m ~L* m[ ~Â~Agi²vw eH[¢ eiewstehstv*vwnr[ 'v viqAGsf [ »;n np~t[Goe¢gwopehmFmF~¯~Fg f[H e¤C´µmnpst~LH[Hgie¢o mf~L[e ´· *mF~WLmZ'mFY ~t[F°t[#qAsto
(33) [Hehg*[Heweh[H~Fgwop[Hn=mstv¬~t[¢Le|ktoryoreh[HvÀ·ystgivw[ Z'[ ~Ag¬qAst[¢Lv*n [He* mA[ ¾So [ ~Agwe t[tvi ´µ vw[ ~L [HeÁnr¡Z'gwWtmff[¯ mfgwopZ'oreiygio m~ npmf np[¿[H~ LviGeh[H~L[f[mF~Agivyo ~Fgw[HejWt gi vwmFY ~t[Ge ºl ysfgwvi[LvhgG°nr¿Lyvigio [SytLvi[H~Fgwo ewewy['f[Ge¢tvw´µ vw[ ~;[He¢¿ giSZ'mffHnporehH[SmFZjZ'[st~LvimFktnpYHZ'[ mFfgio Z'o ewCgwopmF~npo ~tHopvw[°qAst[SnR mF~viGehmFsL¡f[S´· *mF~[¸tgi[SLv#st~ tvimFvyZ'Z'[npo ~tGyo vi[Fu mstv [ gj[HeÈ*vgiyZ'oreimn9J~L®ªeH°f o np~A[gi[Heicfvh´·ezFgwY [SZ'F[lvw{t§_Wt¨¬orqF\fsL©ª[!¨¬e \f y«_L\tst'o [gwei¢stvlopZ'n [Hte#nrygi~A[GgwWt~tehstmFv¬npmFf[Ho [He|e¢kLÆÄei2©[HeX1$~tmF stnpo ¤[ ~A[Hnpgn e[HeX n [H ~Ã[H\fvweH o °
(34) nryeik[ °tvw¤u [ [HsLviv n n mstv °tf[ ´· * m~¿²#´·Fo npopgi[Hvn9 sfgwopn o ewCgwopmF~f[ n9 msfgwopnLyvtn sLeiop[HstveXop~Agi[Hvi¤F[ ~L~AgweXforezgy~AgweH. ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78.
(35)
(36) . !" #$ %'& ()*+ %-,.0/213,. 541678(9*:/;=<=1
(37) > ? A@A?
(38) B. ED 5FG8%H,I()0%CJLKE<8/M8(9*:/;NO8(9*:
(39) 0P+Q%< R0+1I1S 7<7<8, TA Q%.U%-#*V 0W (*)+[Zz }
(40) ! . C X \^]`_. Y. a"bAcbAd:egfAhjilkVcnmlo`pqsr. ®[ehcfehgiY Z'[¢fGeho ~t[ st~¿[H~Leh[HZ#ktn [¢f[ewyn np[Ge}[ g*st~¿[ ~Lei[ Zlktn [ GqFsLop=[HeH ®[Heªewyn n [He*À9¶´z o LdÁ¼=[ sL¤[ ~Ag + givw[|f[|fop³U vw[ ~Agwe gzcd=[He}ehsto ¤Cy~Agªn [ stv}ehstvi´· [msn [ stveNGqFsLop=[£ Zgw'opmF[H~!~Fg[He ~S=®´µm[¢~;gz¶cdgi=o m[#~ f[ vwFeh¶[Ggwe vw o vieiop[¢giYHehvi[H[Gste nd«*st~L~L[#[_eiewynpn n np[[ [ lg¬sty~t [H[_ehg¬;mA²ehopnRgi o Fmf~Z'opn ~Lmo kLehgivnpC[_gwt[ sty~Lv|e}tn [#[_vwHHyyZ'n oreht[HsLve n SÀ· ´zn Feiopei;op»;P ¥yÁ¶£ §¬~¿=[ sfg f»;~topv¬ Ayn [ Z'[ ~Ag*st~t[#;mAehopgio m~Lv*vyt=mvig|yskL±ygio Z'[ ~Ag¬ yt;yvigi[ ~;y~L ['À·op~Agw[ vi´·[ ÆÄewyn © n [_1X=Á[ st«*g ~L+['givwew[ yn mn st['¤F[ tvigiL[ vhmgwsop[H´µ~F[ g¢vwZ'² st[F~ kL±CgwopZ'[ ~AgG° [g#st~¡~AsLZjHvim¿t~Le ['kL±CgwopZ'[H~FgG©J~f»;~°st~t[ «|~k;±Cgio Z'[ ~Ag|jnp[GeZ,+ Z'[HeHyvgi vworezgwo qAst[Ge}qAs st~t[ewyn np[F°fZyoreX~ ';ef[_gzcd;[F LopYG«|[He¢~t[#tHGeiqFopsLvw op=[Ge¬[#;[Gyezg¬v gzmcdZ';[F=° mF[ ei~¡ [# fn m[#o Zj~L[H[ Z#Z'kt[ ~Avw[Hg eHLLy©ªv¢npn v[lySt=tm[Hvie*g¢k=²[HeisLm~Âo ~Ln e¬o [ qFs¡sqF [HsLnpn oJ[#;[ [H¸dsfLg)vio +Z'gwvi[['[ st~~¡~tkLmF±yZ#gio ktZ'vw[#[ ~AfgH[ ° sL~! n mo ~L[ Z'[ ~AgXLyvvwt=mvig²lst~t[ ysfgwvi[_HqAsto ;[F°d[g[ ~f»;~![ ~gi[HviZ'[ f[ fo ei=[ veho m~A©Jn np[¢y³=[G¶gi[ ²! m~LWLehgw st~Agi~[ fC[#»L~[GqAe*sk= st[Hei~tm[¢o ~LHe*qAstsLo ~¯=[_md~L[[¾SehmFo o[ g~ALgG;Fe®!´·¥¤ehmFmZjvworehZ'H[¬[#Lt[HvXe|vw mdt[;¾SmFvho g*[ ~A²jgwe¬nR fsf[#givw[WL FqAst[¢HqAsto ;[l[Hehg|st~t[ çµÚèçéÝ.
(41) .
(42) . §¬~ Wt[ vWt[²ÇZC¸fo Zjorei[ vjn Çeiygiorez´·F¶gio m~ f[gimstgi[Hejn [HelHqAsto ;[Ge °J m~t~;yoreiewy~Ag#n [ stveltvi ´µ£ vw[ ~;[HeH u msLv' mZ'tn gw[ vjnp[tvwmktn Y Z'[°m~ [Hehgio Zj[¿qAst[np[Gelstgio nporeiygi[Hstvwel~t[;mAeh[H~AglLFelLviGorehHZj[H~Ag n [ sLvwe'tvw´µHvi[H~L[Ge ª½¼n*[HehgS;mAeieio ktnp[¯qAst[n [HeStvi ´µ vw[ ~L [He & fH n viH[H%e &S~t[ÇehmFop[H~FgLFe °}m~;ei op[HZl£ Z'[H~Fg_ms¯~Lm~°=np[Ge|Lvi ´µ vw[ ~L [He*vw [Hnpn [He_f[ln9 sfgio n o ewCgw[ stv fs´·og¢ st~t[jZ'st¤Cyoreh[lyttvwH o ygio m~¯f[ nR opZ'=mvigwy~;[t=mvigi [²ÃWLFqFsL[!tvw´µHvi[H~L[F°
(43) mFs[ ~L mvw[!fs ´·yopg'qAst[n9 sfgio n o ewCgw[ stvj~ ¯LFels Ltvi kt´µsf g}vw[ st~L~t [|[He
(44) k=vimH~L[ ~tn np[|[Ge
(45) mFm~t~t~L~Lo ewo eiewewy~L~Ag
(46) [n f[H[¬eteh[Gvweª´µfH[Gvi[Hehor~Lf[ [GveCo g~ttopygior½¼ynLn ´·[Hyesf[gg fnp[Gme~L*~tmy[ gw~d[H¤de o ewfymF~L[ ~tvN st[G~Se
(47) ²_tWLtvw[ qA~Astgi[oreiehewmFynpFst[gio fm[H~e \^]H\. cfAeo `cb. Ë;
(48) Í # ÃtÐ9Ð d
(49) ¥ÍHdзРd.
(50)
(51) . ®
(52) Z' giWtmff['sfgwopn o ei ['=mstv vwHeimsLtvi[j['tvwmktn Y Z'[jvi[H;mAeh['ehsLv_nR [¸fH sfgio m~¡f[';[HviZlsfgwygio m~Le ´·o ewy~AgJH¤mn st[HvJn ¢´µm~Lgio m~SvwopgiY vw[|t~LeJn [|ei[ ~Le}fHeio viFA{}m~L viY gi[HZj[H~AgH°nr¢Z'gwWtmff[*gw[Hehgi[gwmsfgw[He n [He =[ vwZ#stgwCgwopmF~LeN=mFeweho ktn [HeNf[¤Cnp[HstvweNt[*f[ sf¸l¤¥viorykLnp[Ge [gJvw[gio [ ~Agª [ n np[qAstof´·ogªH¤mFnpst[Hv np[tn sLe nr½¼ln [G´µmezg*~LfgimFo ~Lm~¿_~tvwHo gw[HY ewvwei[ opvw[ yxzmsfgw[ vys¿eicdehgiYHZ'[_f[Geeinpn [HeX¤do vhgwst[ n n [HeXC»L~¿f[ =mst¤Fmo vXewCgwo eh´·yo vw[¬n [He m~Agivyo ~Agi[Ge¢f['gzcd;[Sn [S~tmFZ#ktvw[f[!ewyn np[Ge¢fHeio viH[HeH
(53) \do} [Heewyn n [He ¤dopvigisL[ n np[Ge¢~ [¸fo ehgi[H~Ag#LeS°[g ~Ly '~Le}ys;np[_st ~tF[¢eJm WL!st~L~t[ [¢eh opgi msLktygigi[ o m~L~opv*o f~t[Gopgie*oryewn y[¬n np~[Ge} C;³Uy[Hv*gi[_[ ghygwsL[¢ stZj~t [¬giWtewymfn fn [¬[F ²¢st~L[¬GqFsLop=[¬fmF~t~tH[°d[gigi[_HqAsto ;[ ®ewy[Hn e*n [ ewyLn yn [H~LeeX¤dnro vhgwehstopgi[ s;n Cnp[Ggie*o mei~¿m~Afg|[Cf³UHHLygivi gH[G;e®o ~t[HeXogwo =[ npvw[HZ#Z'st[ ~AgwCg¬gwyopmFst~L¸eHeiqAmst~Ao g=[ [H~Leei~st op¥gicF[¢~Agwg*sLfLo e[Ge*n [¢ehsL~tv*mFZ#n9 [ kt~;vweh[[HfZ#Hkteio n vi[¢ff[H[e ewyn n [HeH°A¤do vhgwst[ n n [He[ gXvw [Hnpn [HeH dÏË
(54) HÍ UÍ d AÍ'Ð d Ð d #
(55) Ä Í d º_y~LeXnr'ehsLogw[f[¢[¢fmfstZ'[H~FgG°LC»;~f[ Z'mff n oreh[Hvnp[ tvwmktn Y Z'[F°An [HeX¤Cvioryktn [Hesfgwopn orehH[Heeim~AgH° =msLv*fH Lvi¤o vi[H[ gin [¢[Hstehvcfehfgi[HY eZ'¤C,[ vi oryktn [HeXfseicfezgwY Z'[Àµ¤mFopvLnpsLeXk;eÁ¶ f~tmZlktvi[_gwmygwn HqAsto ;[F° Ç[Gezg*sL~o ~Lfor[eistvn [HeGqFsLop=[HeH t n [_mZl~LmktZ#vi[¢kLfvi[¢[ fgzcd[¢=kL[¢±yfgio [¢Z't[ o ~AYHg|[fts¿o³Uehcf ehvwgi[ Y ~AZ'g*[Ff° s*eh[Gcfezehg*giYHsLZj~[Fo ~Lfor[eistvn [HekL±ygio Z'[ ~AgweH f t ~ t~tmZlktvw[_f[¢LopYG[¢f[ gzcd;[ t p n ¢ [ L ~ m # Z L k i v ¬ [ i g m w g y
(56) n f . [ t p o G Y . [ w g. [ n A q t s [ tn [ gimgwnf[HeXto YH [Hefs¿kL±ygio Z'[ ~Ag gw[ nqAst[ L p n. [ t ~ F m # Z t k w v _ [ i g y m g y n f ¢ [ L p o G Y H [ e t . [ Z y L ~ t . H [ X e ; y v R n f s w g p o n r o i e y i g. [ L s v N L t ~ m l Z t k i v. [ f ¢ [ t o H Y. H [ e f . [ z g d c = [ ª f H [ ' Z L ~ f . L v 9 n f s i g o n o w e C w g. [ t s v N t~tmFZ#ktvw[ f[¢to YH[Gef[ gzcd;[ }qFs o n ´·ys;fvwog*yxzmsfgw[ vX;mFstv*ewCgiop´·yo vw[¬gwmsfg*n [ Z'm~Lf[F C ehmF~Agnp[ mgwmy~LgweiorfnL fvw[G e [Gteop YGmZ'[GeNZ'qF[¢s npo [Gnde´·yysLsftgwvwvi[GoeXgJZCxzymForsfegieh[HmFv~Fgig*[ n;fqFGsLnr[ yvw [Ge}¤do vhgwst[ n n [HeHC uNyvNnr ehsLogw[X [He to YH [He .
(57)
(58) . . . !. . . . . . ". %$. !# &. ('). +*-,.*0/21434,. !7. $. (' ?. !C+D !C+) D G ) (H. ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78. &65. 798(:(;)=<> '4). '?08@:. ;)A<B> ' ) ? E". +*. F". +*. HI8. :. ;)=<> G ).
(59)
(60) 0. NZCgivwor[¿f[He'forezgy~L [Hej[ ~Agwvi[np[GejtopYG[Gel[ gnp[Gelk;±Cgio Z'[ ~Agwelgw[ n np[qAst[ m *[Hehg¢n9 o ~Lfor[';mFvhgy~AgehsLv_n [He LopYG[He [ g nR o ~Lfor['=mvigw~Fg¢eistv¢np[Ge kL±CgwopZ'[H~Fge ®[ e LyvigiorsLnpo [ v gwvwFfstopgn9 yt;yvigi[ ~;y~L [_f[¢nrjto YH[ sk;±Cgio Z'[ ~Ag ¥ CZCgwvior[f[GeJforezgy~L [He [ ~Agwvi[WLFqFsL[LopG[°C;yvJf »L~topgio m~ehcdZ'gwviorqAst[°yt[*fo mF~Lyn [ ~dstnpn [
(61) }¤[Hgi[Hstv!fmF~t~Ly~Ag!n [gzcd=[Ãf[Heeinpn [HeHª^ +HZ'[HeSo ~Lfor[Ge!qAst[ Ju mstvSn [Heeinpn [He ¤dopvigist
(62) [Hnp^¯n [HCe gw vi or[Sf [Ge¢tvw
(63) ´µH vi[H ~L [G e_gi [ n n [SqF sL[S WLqAst['n opF~t[SmFvivw[Hei;mF~Lò¿sL~t[SmF~Fgwvwop~Agw[° [g WLqAst[¢ mn m~t~t[¢ mvwvi[Geh=m~L²jst~t[¢HqAsto =[ L^¯ygivwo [¢f[He mA[ ¾So [ ~AgweFeieimfo He²'WLqAst[_tvw´µHvi[H~L[F L^ÃCgivwor[ f[HeXtvwmyxz[G¶gwopmF~LeXehstvn [HeX¤Cvioryktn [HeHf®[Ge}o ~Lfor[Ge*f[¢mFnpmF~t~t[Geeim~Ag[Hsf¸f[ ½¼nc!sfgw~Fg*f[ n opF~t[HeqAst[t[m~Agwvwop~Agi[Ge F^¯Cgwvior[f[GeNtvwmyxz[Hgio m~LeNeistvNn [HeNGqAstop=[HeJ;mFstvJWLqAst[GeNmF~Fgwvwop~Agw[HeH¥^ + Z'[Xgwopn np[*qAst[ !#",A¨|mZlktvi[¬f[¬ m~Agivyo ~Agi[HeJ[¸ftvwopZykLnp[GeNgzcd;[_forezgy~L [|²¢kL±ygio Zj[H~AgHt{}m~Lehgw~Fgw[»t¸f [ LyvnR fZ'o ~to ehgivCgw[ stvG !$ L½zf[ Z;mFstvnp[GemF~Fgwvwop~Agw[He}gzcd;[forehgwy~;[¢²jHqAsto ;[F &% ('¦Ë ÏyÍ ·Ë ÄË AÏÍ )'!*ªË= SÐ dÏ + CÏ + # ¯GË=з
(64) Í ·Ë ®[¬tvwmkLnpYHZj[_ mfgwopZ'oreiygio m~S=mFei¬LvimF;mAeh[|t[¬Z'o ~topZ'oreh[HvXst~t[¬´µm~Lgio m~SmFkfxz[Hgiop´
(65) qAstoU[HehgnR o ~f£ ewCgwo eh´·gio m~Åf[GeSsfgwopn oreiygi[ sLvweHX{}[ ghgi[ôµm~Lgio m~Å~ [GezgLem~L~AsL[òtvwopmFvio_ vSnp[ÂehcfehgiYHZj[Ã~ m~t~;yoreiewy~L [f[*ei ¤Cnp[HstvªqAst[*n mveiqAst[XnR stgio nporeiygi[Hstvª~tmgi[st~L[|ehmFnpstgio m~AVmFsfgi[ ´µmoreNopn;[HehgJ;mAeieio ktnp[ Hy [Gnrezgwstopn=Z'[H[ ehv gª´·F[ gho gwnp[lopgi_~tmLgi[lv}[ nr~ÇZ'HynrgwWtstmfnryf~A[ g_fnp[¬[Ge|vwH[Heivimvw[ n sfstgwvope*mF~¯[H~AÀµgivwvw[H[#Wtst[H~tvw['Wtei[¬mn sftgio mf~¯gwy[ gig_o ¤n [G[HÁªe¬qAk=st[Ho=eimWLo ~L[ e|v[ Wt¸f[|t²lvio Z'ZjHo ~teH o Z'{}o[ £ ei[ v* [HeX[Hvivw[ stveH «|~t[~Lmygi[[Hehg' sfgw~Fgjtn sLej n Y ¤[qFsL[nR o ~LewCgwo eh´·gio m~[Hehg'kLeweh[F\do 0/2103 [Gezgjn LnpsLe#WLystgi[!~Lmygi[!;mAeieiopkLnp[F°
(66) yn mve¢mF~ Wt[ vWt[S²Z'o ~to Zjorei[ v#sL~t[S´µmF~L¶gwopmF~ 4 -5 ,. ,gi[Hnpn [qAst[ 4 5 6,7®, [H0eJ/2¤C10viory39ktn 8 [Heª;f:sS FehcfehgiYHZj[¬ehmF~Fg}np[GeNto H[Geª²yghgwvio ktst[HvH°ynr¢¤Cyn [ sLv}f[|W;sL~t[*f[¬ [HeN¤Cvioryktn [He gw~Fgn [¢~dstZ' vwmjf[¢nR HqAsto ;[²'qAsto[Gezg*yn n mstH[_nrjto YH[F ®[¢¤[Hgi[Hstvf[He¤Cvioryktn [He [Hehg*f»L~Lo gi[HnqAst[ . # 2*. #. $. $. ). $. ). ?. $. ). 8. ?. 8. 7. . C. ,. ,. 7. . C. . 3. 8&. !C+C. !C !C. . ". C+C " $ " $.
(67)
(68) . . %. . . . . 8. 2". . < 1. m = > [Hehg*n9 o ~Lfor[f[¢nrjtopG[ =mst¤Cy~Ag + givw[_vw [Hnpn [ ms¤dopvigist[Hnpn [ ®[HeX¤Cyvwo ktn [HeXm~Agn [fmZyo ~t[¢f[¢f »L~topgio m~ehsLop¤Cy~Ag 8. 4. /213,. 7. H. 5. 5. 5?5?5 /. ,. ,. ,. çµÚèçéÝ.
(69) .
(70) . ®
(71) l¤Cnp[Hstv givfstopg*n [ ´·yopgqAs st~t[¢LopYG[¢~ [Hehg*C³U[H¶gw [²'ys;st~t[ GqFsLop=[ n [ ~t§¬mZl~Skt~Lvwmy[ gi[t[¢t opYG[GeXNvin9H [ [ n ~Lnp[Geie[ Zlf[_ktn gz[¬cAf=[G[ e}ªewyn npnpn [GmeJstHvw [H[Henpn ²'[He[ fgh[*gw[¢gzcdH=qA[sto N;y[n n mstH[Heª²#n9 HqAsto =[ N N[Gezg ). " ,. *. . ". +*. . ) ). . . . " , " ,. . . < 1. 8 8. " ,. 8. " ,. ). /213, 7. 5. ,.
(72) C. 8. *. ). " ,. . À GÁ À9Á 5. . ®
(73) #´µmF~L¶gwopmF~¿mkfxz[G¶giop´NqFsL[_~LmsLeWt[HvwWLm~LeX²jZ'op~to Z'o ei[ v|[Hehg74 ¶ .
(74) .
(75)
(76) . . dÏËUÍ UÍd. ®[HeXmF~Fgwvwop~Agw[HeªtseicdehgiYHZ'[_eim~Ag m~t~dst[GeªFvw±F[|sf¸Stvw´µHvi[H~L[Geª[ ¸dLvio Z' [He}Lv}n [He}sfgio n o ewC£ gw[ stvejÀµZCgwvior[Ge [g Á ©Jn np[Ge¬eim~Ag_t[#tn sLeiop[Hstvwe|mvfvw[HeH;«*~Çsfgio n o ewCgw[ stv_;[Hsfg¬LviGoreh[Hv|=mstv eim~HqAsto ;[_st~¿[Hvhgyo ~!~tmFZ#ktvw[¬f[ tvw´µHvi[H~L[Geª[ g[ ~mZ'[gigivw[_ ystgivw[HeHF½¼nf »L~topg Fnp[HZ'[ ~AgsL~ md[¾So [ ~Ag_ o Z';mFvhgy~L [#=mstv WL st~t[jf[jei[He¬tvw´µHvi[H~L[Ge =«*~t[jtvw´µ vw[ ~;[lt[j mA[ ¾So [ ~Ag¬~dstn [Gezg* m~Leio t vw [¢mFZjZ'[ ~tmF~=mFei [F §¬~ ~tmygw[ np[~tmFZ#ktvw[f[gzcd;[Ge'f[Lvi ´µ vw[ ~L [Hel[¸ftvwopZykLnp[Ge ®[tvwmyxz[geH [Gezgjop~Agi[Hvi[Geiei² gzcd=[He*f[¢Lvi ´µ vw[ ~L [He¢Àµ~LmZ#kLvi[¢f[ewyn np[Ge*fGeho viH[HeXLvXgzcd;[F°Lforezgy~L [²'st~¿npo [ s°;fo ehgw~L[ ²#st~t[_HqAsto ;[F°d[gfo ei=[ veho m~;Áf{}W;qAst[_HqAsto ;[_;[Hsfgf»L~Lopvys!Z'y¸fopZlstZ$st~!~LmZ#kLvi[ »t¸f_f[ Lvi ´µ vw[ ~L [HeXf[ gzcd;[ °fHFyn [_;mFstvgimFsfgi[GeXnp[GeHqAsto =[HeH ®[Hejtvw´µ vw[ ~;[He#;mAehH[Hejeh[givtsto ei[ ~Agj[ ~ m~Agivyo ~Agi[Ge#eistv °
(77) ¤F[H¶gw[ stv'f[Ge#¤Cyvworyktn [HeH
(78) ©ªnpn [He eim~Ag~tmgi [Ge X¥¤[G 5<5?5 ° 5?5<5 °f[ g ®[!md[¾S op[H~Fg#yghgwvio ktst!sf¸ÇLvi ´µ vw[ ~L [He¢Lv¢st~t[SGqAstop=[ [Hehg#~tmgi °¥¤[G'np[Ge¢,Z + Z'[He o F~L°ff[org [GeJqAst[tvwH Hf[HZjZ'[H~FgG°y[gªgi[ n=qAst[;mF stvJst~L[HqAsto ;[ ¿fmF~t~t [ mF~ C+C. 8. ). +*. )D. . * /213,. ,. /.143,. 5. ,. F"./.1434,. ) 5. ". F". 3. . . . . D). 8. 3. ©N¸ftvw[HeweiopmF~f[GeXtvw´µ vw[ ~;[HeXstgio nporeiygi[Hstvweeims;e*\fo n k ®[HeXtvw´µHvi[H~L[GeehmF~FgZ'mff n orehH[HemFZ'Zj[¢eistopg) )=<> <>. ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78. . 5. BD) * /.1434,. 5. BD).
(79) .
(80) .
(81) " " " " " " " " " " " " 8 8 3. C+C. 3. 3. 8. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. +3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. ²jst~L{}[WLFmqA~Astgw[}vw mop~An mgi[_~t~tL[}vhvigw[Ho t vwstHnpeio Y [ vw~A[gi°f[} stn F~#eisfei gw[ opn orLeiygivX[ gzsLcAv=`À [¢H*f[¢=mWLsLvsfg* [[ g ~[¸fkL[ Z'et n [GÁy{}W;qAst[ªn o ~t[XmFvivw[Hei;mF~L º|[#n jtvw[ Z'o Y vw[ mn m~t~L[ ²'nr'mFnpmF~t~t[ LmF~Fgwvwop~Agw[HeXehsLvnp[GeXgzcd;[f[ewyn n [HefGeho viH[HeH°fLyv mfv[ fZvw[~Lfvw m[Goreie ew y~Ag*f[¢gzcd=[L½z o ;®[He¤Cyn [ sLvwe*eim~Ag|n [~tmFZ#ktvw[f[LopYG[He|fsgzcd;[ º|[ÂnrmFnpmF~t~t[ Dz Xm~Agwvwop~Agi[GeSf[ÃgzcA=[Çto ehgw~L[ò kL±CgwopZ'[H~FgG}u mAehopgiop´ ;mFstvXst~vwttvwmdWL[ Z'[ ~AgH°A~tHFCgwo´;mFstvXst~ n mo ~t[HZj[H~AgHd®l¤¥np[HstvX[Hehgnp[_~dstZ' vwmjfsn op[Hs mF~L[Hvi~tFG\doAnr*¤Cyn [ stv
(82) [Hehg
(83) o ~f´µ vwo [ stvw[ªys#~tmZlktvi[}f[ªkL±ygio Z'[ ~AgH°Gnp[}npo [ s#[Hehg
(84) n [ª~dstZ' vwm| mvfvw[ fsÂkL±CgwopZ'[ ~Ag²n np[G¶gwstvi['fsÇ»;Wto [ v !#"LL\do ~tm~Ây [Hehg¢st~Ç=mo ~Ag o ~Agi[ v +gf »L~to LyvnR [HqAsto ;[Ft½zo "¿À·npo ~t[Ge*l[g 0'f[¢nrlZ ygivwo [G Á¶' [ ¢²#nr'mFnpmF~t~t.[ t m~Agivyo ~Agi[ f[¢forezgy~L [ ² º|[¢nr'mFnpmF~t~t7 HVqAmFstsfo gª;[FmF;Z'®
(85) 'Zj¤¥[nrnp [Hst%f$v[ st[H ¸dehg*o Y n Z'[[*~dst mZ'~A givwvm'yo ~Agi mF[vw°¥fnr vw[¢¤Cyfn [¢[ &stnR$ vN[GqF[G sLezgJop==[#mFei²'o gwnrop'¤F[Xnp[Gm¶s'gisL~tvi [¢AfCs¿gwop¤F»;[¥WL½zop[Ho (v ' *)%+, !' #"L º |"[HÀµvin op~LFop~tYH[Hvi[¯e¬#n o [ ~tg|[ jt[¢mFn ~FjgwZvwCop~Agwvigwor[¯[¥fÁ¶o ei=[ veho m~X\do|nR HqAsto ;[¡;mAehà [gigi[Ç m~Agivyo ~Agi[nr¤Cyn [ stv ¤Cysfg ° eiop~tmF~ =º_y~Le¬gwmsLe¬np[Ge_tvimFktn Y Z'[He .- °Ust~L[jei[ stn ['m~Agwvwop~Agi[lf[j [#gzcd=[l[Gezg [¸ftvwopZktnp[F ®
(86) ZCgivwor[Ãf[Ge md[¾So [ ~Agweewehmf opGe[Hehg!orehmFZjmFviLWt[¯² ½zo|=msLv!n [Heo ~Lq Lvi[HZjo Y vw[He GqAstop=[He &. >8@&. 3. &. 8. " $. &. " $. " $. 8. 8. 3. " $. " $. 8. 3. . . .8. . 5 "" // 5 "/ 5 "/ 5 "/ 5 5 5 *" / $ 5 "/ $ 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 5 *"*" // 5 "*/ 5 "*/ 5 5 "*/ 5 "*/ $. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. C+C. 3. 3. 8. 3. 8. 55 ""// 55 ""// "/ . " $. 3. 5 "" // 5 "/ 5 "/ 5 "/ 5 5 "*/ $ 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 5 *"*" //
(87) 5 "*/ 5 "*/ 5 "*/ 5 5 "/ $ 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. ®[He md[¾S op[H~Fge| gw~Fg ~tmFviZyn orehGe*=mstv WLqAst[lHqAsto ;[F° m~¯=[ stg ¤F vwo»;[ v¬qAst[jnr!eimZ'Z'[jf[ W;qAst[ mn m~L~t[ ¤¥sfg t«|~md[¾So [ ~Ag*~dstnUgwvwFfstopg*st~t[¢mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[_~Lm~[¸ftvwopZ' [F 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. çµÚèçéÝ.
(88)
(89) . . ®ª GqFsLop=[jSfmF~L#f[HZy~Lf'to YH [He_f[lgzcA=[ F° Sf[gzcd=['t°U!f[gzcd=[l![g lf[#gzcA=[ mZ'Z'[*gwmsfgw[Henp[Ge}sfgivw[He}HqAsto =[HeHd^Ãyoreª[Hnpn [¬jysLeweio=f[HZy~Lf_²)+ givw[¬tvwmfWt[|f[_nR GqFsLop=[7_¥¤[G sL~¿ md¾So [ ~Ag*f[tS d©J~f»L~°;[ n np[¢'f[HZ'~Lf² +gwvi[ vw[ FvimFst;H[. ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78.
(90) G.
(91) . . X 3
(92)
(93) ®
(94) #Z'gwWtmff[ f[¬vwHeimn sfgwopmF~Ssfgio n o ei [ [HehgXn #vi[GWt[ vWt[¬FtytgwCgwop¤F[°AfH viopgi[ ty~;e Õ#"¦;{¬ [GezgXst~t[ Z' giWtmff[S mtgio ZjorewCgio m~ mZ#kLop~LygimFopvw[jFtytgi [Ss e gisLtopFu mstv¢sL~tvimFktn Y Z'[j´µmvigi[ Z'[H~Fg m~Agivyo ~Ag}=mstvn [HqAst[Hn n9 [HeiLF[ f[Heeimn sfgio m~;e}=[ stg + givw[ ¤Aorf[F°f[ n np[ =[ vwZj[ g*f[¢ ynrsLnp[HvsL~t[¢ehmFnpsf£ gwopmF~ÂqAsto gw[ ~Agi[f['¤do mn [ v np['Z'mo ~Le =mFeweho ktn [ln [He¢ m~Agivyo ~Agi[Ge|[ ¸dLvio Z' [HeH{¬ [Gezg¢st~L[Zj giWtmff[f[ vw[HWL[ vWt[¬n mf n9 . ^]`_. . . qse 9c^fAr. ®
(95) tvw[ Z'opYHvi[N gw;[J[Gezg Feieimfo [ v²*W;qAst[JmF~Agivyo ~Fgw[ st~t[J´µmF~L¶gwopmF~ [ vwvi[Hstve yLLyvw[ ~Agw~Ag ² sLFei~tei[}mf=o ~;[_y[Hn o ehewg|CeigwyopmFgi~orez´·[¸dogigwH[vi°fo [ [ sLgXvi[H[ªnpn t[[ª´µvwmFm ~L$rg*¶gw²jopmFZj~#[GehvwsLogwviY [¢vw[qA¥st«*[¢~tnrj[}´µ mm~;~A¶gigivo ymo ~j~Agi [_ [ [Hvwehvig*[Hst¤dvopmF[GnpezHg [~dstnpn [XehoAn ¬mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[ uNyv}[¸f[ Z'tn [°AehmFog}n m~Agivyo ~Agi[=mvigw~Fgehstv}st~t[*¤Cvioryktn 0[
(96) °F¤F vwo»LH[*eho F«|~t[*´µmF~L¶gwopmF~ [Hvivw[ stvFeieimfo [_;mFstviv- +givw[
(97) eio eiop ~Lm ~ ¥¤F[H
(98) °tms °tmFs[H~LmFvi[ 8 k;yn [º_°fy[~Lg*en [HsteX~!LtvimvimFxz[Hkt¶n gwY opZ'mF~L[¬eXfforei[;mA[ eighgw~F[¢gX[ fvw[|vi[HLstnpvsLeieho st[ vstvn [HeªeX¤C¤Cvivioryoryktktn [Hn [HeHeH° mF~!forezgwop~Lst[_st~t[¬¤¥np[HstvX [Hvivw[ sLvªn my£ º_y~Le'n [ Fe'm np[¿tvwmktn Y Z'[¿Âtnps;eho [ stvemF~Agivyo ~Fgw[HeH°W;qAst[¿m~Agwvwop~Agi[¿ei[Lvimxz[ghgw[eistv W;qAst[*¤Cyvworyktn [A§¬~fgw[ vwZjo ~t[_yn mveNst~t[¬tvimxz[Hgio m~'gimgwnp[|eistvWLqAst[*¤Cvioryktn [°AqAsto;=[ st g +gwvi[ sL~t[ehmFZ'Zj[¢f[GeXtvwmyxz[Hgio m~LeXf[W;qAst[¢mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[ ®ª npFmvwogwWtZ'[*Wt[ vWt[|qAst[Hnpn [*¤Cyvwo ktn [*¤dopmFnp[*n [*tn sLe}np[Geª m~Agivyo ~Agi[HeHV}cdto qAst[HZ'[ ~Ag [Gezg} [ n np[ ¤Ctmvi~Aorgyktnrln ['t¥vi¤m[Hxz[H#n gio m¤C~Sygwn [ mystgyvn [¬ [Gstez~Lg['nr#sftgin sLvw[jeX¤¥Hnp[Hvi¤ory kL[FFnp[Fuªst{}o eX[ gho gwn ['¤C't[ vwWt~t[ opvYHviWt[j[ [Hveh²jg;f[Hgwvi[ ZlvwsfZ'giop[H~tvHnr[ll[H¤¥~Ânp [Hmst~Lveiforf[¢ vy[ gh~AgigH[ ° ;yvwZjoUgwmsfgw[HeXn [He=[ vwZ#stgwCgwopmF~LeX=mFeweho ktn [HeH°t[ n n [ qAsto[ ~tF[ ~Lfvw[_n9 [ vwvi[HstvXn mkLnp[ Z'o ~topZlstZ¿ {}[ ghgi[Z' giWtmff[=mst¤C~FgJ m~LfsLopvw[²_t[HeNZ'o ~topZ_n mdHysf¸ °CnR stgio nporeiygio m~ st~t[Xn o ehgi[Xgyk=msj;[Hvh£ Z'[ g [ ~d¤do ewyF[ vf[He
(99) ;[HviZlsfgwygio m~Le
(100) ehsLvf[Ge¤Cvioryktn [He
(101) fm~Agn9 [ vwvi[HstvLvimxz[giH[ª~ [Hehg
(102) ;e
(103) Z'y¸fopZyn [ º¬[tn sLeH°tst~¿tvwmd Hft=[ n &¶vw[Hehgwyvi%g &|=[ vwZj[ g|f[¢vw[ Lvhgwopv* st~t[eimn sfgwopmF~o ~topgioryn [¢~tmsL¤[ n n [ n mvewqFsL[lqAs ysL st~t[';[HviZlsfgwygio m~ÂyZ' n opmFvw~Agi[#~ [Gezg¢=mFeweho ktn [ ©J~¡fop³=Hvi[H~Lory~Ag¢n eiogwsLCgwopmF~Âf[ t Lvhg_v±[j²Sst~L[jF ~tHvwygio m~¯npGCgimFopvw[#f['eiogwsLCgwopmF~°Uopn [Hehg¢;mAeieio ktnp[j mkfgw[ ~to v¢f[He eimn sfgio m~Le t[_Z'mFop~Ltvi[¢m fgH°;ei~Le +gwvi[¢eweistvi [H;[H~Lt~Fg|t[_nR mfgwopZyn opgif[ [ghgw[ehmFnpstgio m~ ®[HevwopgiY vw[He viv +gX;mAeieio ktnp[GeehmF~Ag ~tmZlktvw[ opgiHvwygio m~Le¢À·;[HviZlsfgwygio m~LeÁ¶° 8. 8. 8. 8. 3. . çµÚèçéÝ.
(104)
(105) . . ~tmZlktvw[ t[¢vi[GezgyvigweH° ¤Fmn sfgio m~Lets¿ m fgo ~f´µ vwo [ stv*²jst~ei[ sto n9 . ^]H\. ililo`d6B cb. . hjilkVcnm o pqsrRb9c. cb. B . gwopmF~Le|»L~ [Hvi vw [ ysttv|Lnpnporo qA [Gste¬[ v#²S [W;gigi[SqAstZ'[He|gwWtmmf~Afgw[vwop~As¡gi[GtevimF[ ~dkt¤dn Y orZ'ei[S[H=mFktein [H°eH;o n}{}[G[Heze|g´µ~Lm~LH[Ggio eimew~Lyo eHvw°L[Svw[ ft[!vworfeh [G»Le*~tfo [Hv#e*n [Hgive ¥´µ¤CmFy~Lsf¶¸ £ t m[HZ'eSLehgwvworktynpo [GvieX[Gel[ ~ALgivivwG[H[Htnpn [ [H~Ae¬gw²SeH°Nmmd~A[g¾S´· yop[HopgS~FgnRe* mFHkfFxzy[stg¸UL ©NFtgwy~Ffg gCgwewopmFeh[ ~ $¢ynpo »Lkt~Ävw[lqFqAssL [Hnp~Fn [Hg|eSeisÃmo [ Wt~AmFgo¸¿~tmFfvi[HZe*y´µmn or~LehHgi[Ho e'm~L[ge [Hvivw[ stvG°fo n[Hehg*;mAeieio ktnp[t[ ´·yo vi[ [ ~eimvigi[qAst[ n [ stve¤Cyn [ stveyo [ ~Ag*n [¢,Z + Z'[fmZop~t[t[f»L~Lo£ gwopmF~ ¨|H~tZ'mo ~Le ° mZ'fgw['gi[ ~dsfs~tmFZ#ktvw[jgivwYHe¢Hnp[H¤ [¸fH sfgio m~f[SW;qAst[j´µm~Lgio m~ [ vwvi[HstvG° opn [Gezg¬~tH [Heweiopvw[qAst[#[Hnpn [Heh£¼oeimo [ ~Ag|n [tn sLe_eho Z'tnp[#;mAeieiopkLnp[#y»L~¯f[~LH[Geieiopgi[ v¬;[Hs¯f[lHynrstnR gwn [Hogwe}vi´µ[mF~L ¶ [gw¸fopmF[H~LZjeL np[F [ °vwehvio[Hstmv~¡ehmFmF~F~LgXei o f¤CYHvinpst[lHst[H~¡est ~ty[¢Z'Ltvis;[He¢Zjfo Y ['vw[¬tnp´µs;me¢ore}f=[!mCsLv*WLeinpqAn [Hste [_ HmqAZ'sto Z';[F[j°f t[ stn storeXoJ;fmF['stn9v* ½z¨|WL*FqF½ sL[ ° gisLt[*f[X;[HviZlsfgwygio m~'f[*einpn [F{}[ ghgw[ gisLt[*f[~tmvwZyn o ewCgwopmF~#[GezgJyk=mvfH[s'W;ytopgivw[eisto ¤Cy~AgH ®
(106) #´µmF~L¶gwopmF~ [Hvivw[ sLvXFeieimfo [ ²jn m~Agivyo ~Agi[ [Hehg*~tmygw [ . )D. ®
(107) lLvimxz[H¶gwopmF~t[ ehsLvst~t[¢¤Cyvwo ktn [7 G[ ezg~tmgi [ : ) )D. )D. . /. . . )D. C. . ®[HeX¤Cyn [ stvef[GeX´µm~Lgio m~Le [Hvivw[ stveim~Ag*mFZjLvioreh[GeXty~LeXsL~¿tmZyo ~t[_gi[HnqAst[ )D. /. . ,. ). ). . ®[HeX¤Cyn [ stveXtvwmyxz[ gi [GeehmF~AgX[Hnpn [He mZ'tvwo ei[HeXt~LeXst~fmFZ'op~L[¬gw[ nqAst[ :
(108) ) ) D C. . /. ). ,. ). ·Í tÐ 9fÍ ·Ë ®[¬ktstgt[¬nR o ~topgioryn o ewCgwopmF~![Gezgf[¬´µmstvw~to vX²#n9 yn mFviopgiWLZj[_f[_vi[GWt[ vWt[|sL~t[_eiopgisLygio m~!o ~topgioryn [ §Z,¬~+HZjWt[[H[ vw~WLL[_²'vhgwn opop[Z'yopgisf[H¸¡v*npt[Gvwe*´µ vwn [ ~;stnre[Hel[ ~¿f[HLe#vhsfggiyo n ~Ao ewg*C gw[ sLst~tv[¢e ;®mAÇehopgifo opm¤F~[ vehnpopG»;CHgiCmFgiopo vwm[ ~Zfy[Gore#eXeivioHgw;sLmFC~LgwoptmFy~L~Aego gw~tmopgisforg|yn f[H[e [Gezg}~tH Heweiopvw[mZ'fgw[gi[H~ds!fs'´·yopgqAst[|n vw[HWt[HvwWL[*tfgwygio ¤[[Hehgªst~L[*Z'giWLmdt[¬f[*vw[HWL[ vWt[ n mf np[F°tWt[ vWLy~AgehcfehgiHZ'ygiorqAst[ Z'[ ~Ag*²l´·yo vi[ kLo ewei[ vXnp[ m fg*f[¢nrl´µm~Lgio m~vwopgiY vw[ §¬~ ;[HsfgopZyFop~L[ vjtnps;eho [ stvelZj giWtmff[Gef[ ~L vCgio m~t[eiogwsLCgwopmF~Lejop~Logwo np[Ge ° LviZ'oXnp[Gez£ qAst[Hnpn [He %.
(109) . . ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78. . . . .
(110) ¥.
(111) . . *\dopgisLygio m~¿[¸forezgy~Agi[Àé»L¸d[¥Á¶ fº|HLyvig*[ ~¿ewyn np[GeX¤Ao vigist[Hnpn [He¢Àµ»t¸f[GÁ¶ tº|HLyvig|yn HygimFopvw[°f¥¤[G|Lvi¢ewCgioreh´·¶gwopmF~[H~~LmZ#kLvi[¢f[ewyn np[Ge À·yn HygimFopvw[GÁ º|HLyvig¬npGCgimFopvw[°f¥¤F[H_tvw£¦viHLyvigiopgio m~¤do e*²'¤dore*f[Ge*kL±ygio Zj[H~Agwe[ g¬f[He*HqAsto ;[Ge*o ktn [HeH°L[g tvw£¦viHLyvigiopgio m~f[Heewyn np[GeXLyvXgzcd=[SÀ·npGCgimFopvw[GÁ f*\dopgisLygio m~¿[¸forezgy~Agi[F°t¥¤[H¬Z'mst¤F[ Z'[ ~Ageyn HCgwmo vi[GeJ´µmF~L¶gwopmF~Le*f[GeXtvw´µ vw[ ~;[He¢À9yn Hygimo vw[GÁ¶ ®[HeNgwvimFo eNt[ vw~topYHvi[GeNZ'gwWtmff[HeJ o ~topgioryn o ewCgwopmF~tviGeh[H~Agi[ ~AgNnR ¥¤Cy~Agy[f[|;mFst¤mFopvNF ~tHvi[HvJf[He eiopgisLygio m~Lef[¢fHLyvig|fop³=Hvi[H~Agi[Heewy~;eXnp[GeiqAst[Hnpn [Hen [Hevw[Hehgwvhgeei[ vyo [ ~AgXop~dsfgwopn [HeH ®
(112) tvw[ Z'opYHvi[#Zj giWtmff[ltvwHei[ ~Agi[nR ¥¤¥~AgwyF[¢f[#=mst¤Fmo v +gwvi[jmF~LehorfHviH[mZ'Z'[st~L[lf[Ge|eio£ gwsL stC~Lgwop[lmF~Lvw e}Lnp[Geªvhgwtogwn opsLmFe~t[vw¸fmforezWtgy[He~Agif[F[|;nr©Jjn n eh[lmFnp=sf[ gwvopmF¯~!ei[ o;ghgwmF[j~HyWtv[Hvw¶gwWt [¬vwo eh²giorsfqAgwstopn [#o eiei[ o
(113) vXn n [H[|e¬n msfFgwopo n o opew[HCn;gw=[ stmvste¬v[nR¸f mFtfvwgiopo Z'Z'[ o ~AewCg gwfopmF[H~ e k=[Heimo ~LeqAsto~L[ mvwvi[Geh=m~;f[ ~AgXLe²jn [ stv*eiogwsLCgwopmF~¿tviGeh[H~Agi[ ®
(114) lf[Hsf¸fopYHZ'[¬Z'gwWtmff[_~ [GezgXLFe}mFfgio Z#sLZ$[gLyvig}n mo ~t[¬nrleiopgisLygio m~ [¬qAsto [H~Fgwvwop~L[|st~t[ m~d¤[HviF[ ~L [|ewei[ $_np[H~Fgw[¢f[¬nR yn mvwopgiWtZ'[f®
(115) l mstvwk;[_gzcdtorqAst[_t[_nR ¤mFnpstgio m~t[Hem fgwe=mstvsL~ t Lvhg*mFZ'tnp[ g[ ~einpn [HeX¤do vhgwst[ n n [HeX[Hehg*fm~L~t [¢LvXn j»LFstvw[_eisto ¤¥~Agi[ . ⊕ 50 ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ 40 ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ 30 ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ 20 ⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕ 10 ⊕⊕ ⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕ ⊕ ⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕⊕. ¼½ ~togwo nporewCgio m~Lv*einpn [HeX¤do vhgwst[ n np[Ge fuNFef[¢vi[GezgyvigH ®
(116) #n m~tFst[_tWLei[ f[¢f[Hew[H~Fgw[¬n o ~tHopvw[¬ mvwvi[Geh=m~L!ysf¸S=[ vwZ#sfgCgwopmF~Le[ ~Agivw[_ewyn n [He}¤Ao vigist[Hnpn [He [ g ewyn n [He*vw [Hnpn [HeH{}[ghgw[lZ' giWtmff['S gi#o Z'tn Z'[ ~AgiH[l=msLv¬F ~tHvi[Hv¬f[Ge_eiopgisLygio m~Le¬op~Logwo np[Ge¬qAsto mF~Ag
(117) =[ vwZjore f[¤¥nporf[Hv
(118) nR o Z'tn Z'[ ~Agwygio m~jf [}nr¬vi[GWt[ vWt[ªFtyfgCgwop¤F[ u mFstv st~t[Xy~Lnpcfei[ªfgyo npn [ t[_nR C³U[H¶gCgwopmF~¿t[Heewyn np[Ge °f¤Fmo vnR y~t~t[ ¸f[ Ly~L®
(119) e¬np[Ggwe|vimFk;o ±CeiopgiYHo Z'Z'[ [¬~AZ'gwe_gwfWt[HmfZ'f[ ~L[HfehGge¬o Z'ewyt~Ln e| Z'gi[H[ ~t~Ao giv_H [mfZ'©Jn fn [ gi['WLf[ svgzWtcd[_=[j²ltvw[l Lewyvhn gwnp[Gopve¬npf[Ge[HZHqAyst~Lo f;H[G[HeeHUyn \fHoCgwk=m[Ho eivim[Ho Z'~[ °=~Anp[ g 0. 0. 20. 40. 60. 80. 100. 120. 140. 160. çµÚèçéÝ.
(120) G.
(121) . ~LmZ#kLvi[f[leinpn [He*t[ Zy~Lt [He|[Hehg¬ewCgioreh´·yopg*Lyv¬st~¯mFZjLnpHZj[H~Ag¬f[#ewyn np[Ge¤dopvigisL[ n np[Ge {}[ghgw[Z'£ gwWtmff[_[Hehgst~L[¬yZ'Hnpo mvCgwopmF~Sf[¬nrjeh[Gm~;f[t{}[ =[ ~LLy~Ag}[Hnpn [¬~L[¬tvw[ ~;SLFeª[H~mFZ'fgi[¬np[Gesfgivw[He t[Heio f[Hvwygwjf[HeXGqAstop=[HeH°t[ g*~ ttvwmfWt[¬;eeisf¾SeiZjZ'[H~Fg*nr'ehmFnpstgio m~ ®
(122) ¢qFs;Cgivwo Y Z'[Z'giWLmdt[*[HehgJopZ'tn Z'[H~Fgw [|eims;e np[*~LmZ &op~topgioryn oreiygio m~jn msfgwm~ &yF{}[ghgw[*Z'£ gwWtmff[¢Wt[ vWt[_²#vw Lvhgwopvs!Z'op[Hsf¸!n [HeHqAsto =[HeX[ ~´µm~;¶gio m~f[ np[Hstvet[ Zy~Lt[HeH°dewy~;eªgwmsfgw[´µmFo e Lvi[H~Lfvw[j[H~mFZjtgi[nr¯foreh=[ veho m~®[!Hyv¶gwY vw[jnpGCgwmo vi['[Hehgmktgi[ ~ds¡[ ~¡gwvwogy~Agn [He¢GqFsLop=[He LLviyo ~LZ'eª[ st~A~Sg|mgwmvfsfvwgw[|[He qAstf[ [Hnre¬mFk=~L[HqAeimsto [~Lfe|{}~L[ m=~Ã[ ~L Lmy~L~A gHst°dvi[H~A[ ghgwgiej[_À· f[HvwZ'F¶gi~LYHfvi[jorehgiforqF[lsLk;[±C;gio [HZ'sfg[ ~Aeigw[|e_=f[ opv³=fHvwvi[|[H~Aeho=gwen Á¶[He}{}HqA[ st=o [ ;~L[GLeJy[~A¸dgH£ ° vw[ Lvi[H~Ly~Ag n9 WdcA=mygwWtYHei['op~Logwo np[f[tvwmkLnpYHZj['eistvh£¼mF~Agivyo ~FgG°;mF~Ç=[ stglmF~LehorfHvi[Hv_qAst['n [HeeiogwsLC£ gwopmF~LeXH~t vw [GeXfo³U vw[ ~Ag|²'WLFqFsL[¬´µmFo eH 18. 16. 14. 12. 10. 8. 6. 4. 2. ¼½ ~Logwo nporeiygio m~n msfgwm~°dgwvimFo eXvw[Hehgwvhge ®
(123) #»;stvw[ tviGGf[ ~Agi[ Z'm~Agwvi[¢qAst[ n t[Hew[ ~Agw[_¤F[ vest~¿Zjo ~to Z#stZnpmfHyn [Hehg*tn sLeXvytorf[ ®
(124) ¬ op~LqAsto Y Z'[Z'giWLmdt[}~ ¬Le
(125) gwªgwvwogw [°¥Zyoreeh[Hvwogop~AgiHvi[Geiewy~Agw[ª=mstvnp[GeZ +HZ'[Hevwo eim~;e qAst[ nrjtvi[HZ'opYHvi[ Z'gwWtmff[ Ë UÍ UÍ
(126) Ë= # * dÏ A #d ¥ d % ®
(127) *tvw[ Z'o Y vw[ªmF~Fgwvwop~Agw[J[Hehg
(128) n opH[}²|n *to³U vw[ ~L [ª[H~Fgwvi[}np[}~tmZlktvw[ªf[}ewyn n [Het[Jgzcd;[ UCghgwvio ktstH[He ²jst~L[¢HqAsto ;[¢[ gXn [¢~tmFZ#ktvw[¢f[¢einpn [Hef[¢,Z +HZj[_gzcd=[f[ Zy~;f [GeXLyv* [ghgw[¢,Z + Z'[¢HqAsto ;[Ftu mstv À [gigi[¢mFÁ¶~F=gwvw®'op~AgwmF[|~Fstgwvw~opsf~Agigwo [¬n o ew[GCezgwg*[ stf v»L=~t[ o sf[g*fmZ' »LZ'~to [v*eiystsfogg y~Ag*f[_tvi ´µ vw[ ~L [_qAs o n [¸fo ehgi[¢f[_gzcd=[ t[ ewyn n [ 0. 0.
(129) . . . .. 200. 400. 600. 800. . 1000. 1200. 1400. 1600. 1800. 2000. . *. > 8!&. >D ) . . 8 . " ,. . § }[Hehg*np[ ~tmFZ#ktvw[¢f[¢to YH[Geyn npmFst [GeX²lnR HqAsto ;[ ÂLyvnr'ehmFnpstgio m~ . ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78. " ,. . C )D. ). . +". . .
(130)
(131) . ®
(132) #´µmF~L¶gwopmF~ [Hvivw[ sLvXFeieimfo [_[Hehg). 1. ,. 8 . " ,. .
(133) ® ¤Cyn [ stvtvwmyxz[ gi [¬ehstvn [Heeinpn [He}¤dopvigist[Hnpn [He}[Hehg}nr¤Cnp[Hstvt[|nr¢´µm~;¶gio m~ [Hvivw[ sLvª~tmFviZyn orehH[ [ gSmd[¾So [ ~Agw [Lyv'n [=mortef[¿nr¡m~Agwvwop~Agi[!»t¸f¿Lyv'nR sfgwopn oreiygi[ sLvHJ®
(134) äCyn [ sLvjLvimxz[giH[eistv n [Hejewyn np[Gevw [ n n [He[Gezgj[¸ftn o ogw [¿ty~;enr¯Lvhgwop[ &mF~Agivyo ~Fgw[He¢WLgiHvimFYH~t[He%&C®
(135) tvwmyxz[G¶gio m~eistv nR HqA½¼stZ'o ;t[¢n [GZ'ezg[ ~AnrgCehgimFo Zjm~¯Z'\f[¢ opfnr[¢yk [G e*f[Hsf¸!tvwmyxz[G¶gio m~;e ®
(136) #´µmF~L¶gwopmF~¯\fo n kW;yvw [ f[Hynrstn [ v[ ghgw[m~Agwvwop~Agi[_[Hehg ). d u msLv¢gimFsfgi[Ge¢np[Ge ´µm~;¶gio m~;e¢ [Hvivw[ sLvH° nr¿¤Cyvwo ktnp [ S[Gezgn [S~dstZ' vwm mvfvi['f[Snr¿mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[ À¤C·o vioorymFktZjn
(137) [ L vior[Heheh[¬g[ np~A[¢givw~d[ stZ'¬H[ vig m'fÁ°L[¢nRmF GviqFvw[HsLeiop;=mF[ ~Lgitvyop~FgigH[y sSgzcd=[¢f[¬LopYG[ ehstvXn [HqAst[Hn=mF~Hynrstn [|nR [ vwvi[HstvHd® > D ) . 3. 8. C )D. ). . 5. &. "! )" #%$ )' %("*)+,("-./ 0$1 203("/ #4$$.5 6 7 8 ) - :9+" 8 ";0;=<?>%$@ 0$=5 8 ) .B - :9+" 8C EDFG$=5 A 8 ) .BI; )%+,)(" 8 ) # 8 ).$05 H 8 ) :KLM?+5 J N " P )Q" 8 *K$RF>$ O 8 )UKL ; :9+" 8 "-=> .=<WVU$XL 0$ .'>5 TS :9(5 ) ; Y& +:("-Z=B 8 ))\:[^K$@] "*2 Q+ "-=Z? 00$^5 [!_ ) KQ"-=/ $=5 T6 7 YA " 203("/ #4$!DFE)U$!2 ) TH YJ ` ) a; (" _ ) KQ" ; :9+",_ ) KQ"W .0=<VQ/ 0$@Rb)$ .*c d$E$=5 +:ZKbg"a) ; (!h "e20]3"*("/2 #Q4" $ $i; :[ 9+"f)] "! a2 Q; "Wj>k.0[=<` VQ)/ 0E$@Rb[ )+$ 5 .*c d$E$=5 TN TO ("-. 8 )=$B +:ZK+5 &-S ) " ) &F +:ZKbk)+5 &;& :9(5 ) &-6 &7 "-=? 0$l +:Z% . +:ZK+5 &;A "mEnnnnnnnnn+5 &-H &;J )F :9 , F &. çµÚèçéÝ.
(138) ¥.
(139) . ®[He¤Cyn [ sLvwefs¤F[H¶gw[ stv 20¯[ g!f[¯nrÇZygivwo [ 203U°Nmvwvw[Hei;mF~Lf[ ~Ag'vi[Geh=[Hgio ¤[HZj[H~Agsf¸ L~ mZ#kLvi[GeJgwmygwsf¸!f[_to YH[GeviH[ n np[Geyghgwvio ktstH[He}LyvXHqAsto =[°d[g*yst¸S~tmZlktvi[Ge}t[¬to YH [Hevw [ n n [HeLyv gztcd[¬=gw[*mCsfgigwgi[Hvweopktn [HsLeX [H[HeJvivwL[ ysLvNvweHG qFsLop=[f{}[HeN¤F[H¶gw[ stveNeim~AgJ ynrsLnpH[HeJt~Le +:Z)) F " *)|¥¤Cy~AgNnp[*Hynrstn ®[| n stn;f[|n9 [ vwvi[HstvJ[Gezgª[ ³=[G¶gwst|[H~npo ~t[_f®
(140) ¢tvwmyxz[Hgio m~eistvJnR GqFsLop=[ '[HehgJ´·yopgi[|npo ~t[_ ®ª [Hvivw[ sLvH°t~LmvwZ'nporei [[ g mA[ ¾So [ ~AgiH[°L[Gezg tvwmyxz[ gi [lehstv_n [He|ewyn n [He¬¤Ao vigist[Hnpn [He¬f[lnR HqAsto ;[Àµn opF~t[He GFÁ°tfm~Agnp[GeXop~;fo [He*eim~Ag*f gi[ vwZ'op~LHeXn opF~t) [ HL°deio[Hnpn [HeX[ ¸dorehgi[ ~AgG ®~Lm[H~etÀ·vwnpo myxz~L[G[H¶e5gio mH~;AeÁ¶ ei®stvX[Ge¬n [H¤CeXeinp[Hstnpn vw[He_eXteimvwmy~Axzg[ gifHo³U[He_ vweh[ st~Av gw[Hn [Hee¢eistewyop¤Cn np[G~Fe|gvwqA st[Hnp[ n [Hnpe [GeXeimei~Anpg n [H[eX¸feitmn o ~A gogwvw [H[He npn t[He ~LÀ·npe_o np~t[[ WLGFtÁ¶°dopgimFvws [ & mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[He}Wtgw vwmYH~t[H%e &C ®[He'ZCgwvior[Ge _ )%[ g _ )K¯mF~Fg=mstv'ktstgt[~LmvwZ'nporei[ v#n [He m~Agivyo ~Agi[Ge#n [Hejst~t[Ge'Lyv vyL;®
(141) mFlvhgn o y~tsf[¸ylsfgwvwvi[ [G~Le eif[ ©Jo n ~Ln [H[¬e*stei~Lm[_~Ag*¤Cfnp[H»;st~tv*op[GqAe*stot~~L jeXLnp[¢eXWLf[teiopgi[ vw~L[ eXL= msLv*[gigi[ m~Agivyo ~Agi[_Z'o eXqAsto[H~ =msLvªn [HeJsfgivw[HeH©Jn n [|[Hehgªvw[ ~Lei[ o ~L [Xo o=Hyvª [Gezg}st~t[*¤Cyn [ sLvªvw[ ~d¤mCcF [Lyv}n _´µmF~L¶gwopmF~[g}nR yt=[ n t[He´µm~;¶gio m~;e [Hvivw[ sLv[HehgXF ~tHviorqAst[ % &% Ë UÍ UÍ # 9 Í
(142) Ï Í 9 UÍ =[ st«|g ~Â+ gistvw[!gio npstorei~ygik;[H±Cstgiv¢o Z';[ [H~AsfgHg° [mF¸fstvwsto Zj~[H=v msto ~A~tg'[fts vw ´µHyviZ'[H~Lts;[jel[ f~Â »Lgi~t[HvioXZ'L[v# nR sfn mgwo opn or~teiy[HgiZ'[ sL[ ~AvHg½¼²!nXst;~¡[Hsfn gjop[HHsF{}np[H['Zjn [Hop[H~As g ¤Fmstn mo 4v +givw[¡ehmFogys tnps;eLviYGe °Xms ys tn sLenpmFop~®[He¿mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[Hef[[ÇgzcA=[fmo ¤[H~Ag +gwvi[ ewCgwo eh´·yopgi[GefHeXn mveXqAst[ Xn9 HqAsto =[¢[Hehg|ystnps;etvwYHeH°f¤mo vty~;e °fn [¢kL±CgwopZ'[H~Fg|tm~t~tF°fms¿ys¿tn sLeXn mo ~¿tsk;±Cgio Z'[ ~AgH fXn _forezgy~L [}Z'mCcF[ ~t~t[f[He ewyn np[Gevw [Hnpn [ Z'[H~FgNCgigivwopkLst [Ges#n op[HslfmF~t~t[Hehg
(143) ´·opkLnp[F°GmFs#Fvw~Lf[ ®[HeNmF~Agivyo ~Fgw[Heyo ~LeioF´µmFviZlstn [Heo ~d¤Aopgi[H~Ag ²_Z'op~LopZ'oreh[HvmFsj²¬ZC¸fo Zjorei[ v st~t[Xforezgy~L [F{}[ehmF~Ag tm~L_f[He´µmF~L¶gwopmF~Lemkfxz[G¶gwo´·e²lLyvigX[ ~Agio Y vw[du mstvXn [Hegwvw~Lez´µmFviZ'[Hv}[H~ m~Agivyo ~Agi[He}tstvw[Heo nU´·ysfg yei[ xzvmjsfgwei[ yv}giorstez~S´·oLgw[vw ZjY givw[ fm~t~;y~Ag}st~L[¬forezgy~L [|[H~!f[ *HSÀµmFs!ysf[ nrFÁNt[|nrqAst[ n n [|nrmF~Fgwvwop~Agw[ \don9 HqAsto ;[ ¡f[HZ'~Lf[¢² +gwvi[ tvwmfWt[¢fs¿kL±CgwopZ'[ ~Ag ¥°fnr'mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[_=[ stg|e H vio vi[
(144) . . . +". . . . . . . $. . .
(145) D. 8 $. §¬~f »L~topg*st~t[ ´µm~;¶gio m~¿ [ vwvi[Hstvewehmf opH[ ²' [ghgw[mF~Fgwvwop~Agw[_ mZ'Z'[ eistopg) D . . D . . 8. :. :. . " ,. . ).
(146) D " , ? . . ?. . $ ). ?. {}[ ghgi['´µmF~L¶gwopmF~Ç[Gezgf »L~to [Seho ©Jn np[[Gezg ystgwy~Ag¢tn sLe vy~;f[jqAst['nr¿fo ehgw~L[ Z'mCcF[ ~t~t[ f[Ge*einpn [HeXyghgivwo ktst [Ge²'n9 H qAsto =[ Çy skL±ygio Zj[H~Ag *[Gezg*Fvw~Lf[d©Jn n [¢[Hehg*~AsLnpn [ehoUgwmsfgw[He n [HeXLopYG[Heyghgwvio ktstH[Heeim~Ag*ty~Le*np[ kL±ygio Zj[H~Ag ) " ,. . 8 +". $. $. ètÜ435Lï76¶ï78. .
(147)
(148) . #0. Erreur = moyenne(d1,d2,d3,d4,d5) d5 = 0. d1 d2 d3. d4.
(149) ® 'fo ehgw~L[ [Hehg*~AsLnpn [ n ewyn np[_[Hehg|t~LeXnp[¢k;±Cgio Z'[ ~Ag*¤do ei \don9 HqAsto ;[eimsLWLyopgi[ ys¿mF~Fgwvwopvw[+givw[ n mo ~tH[_t[ [¢Z,+ Z'[ kL±CgwopZ'[ ~AgG°tn l´µmF~L¶gwopmF~eH Gvwog D. . 8 8.
(150) D " , ? . :. . . ) ?. . gy~AgNn forehgwy~;[XZC¸fopZlstZ ei ;yvy~Ag f[GeNysfgwvi[Ge kL±CgwopZ'[ ~Age op~LeioR°yn9 HqAsto =[ ![HehgJ ysf£ gy~Agtn sLe*ewCgioreh´·yopgi[¢qAs [Hnpn [ei[ eiopgist[t~LeXn [_k;±Cgio Z'[ ~Ag*n [¢tnps;eX n mo ~t¢f[ ¥ ½¼n¬[HehgS;mAeieiopkLnp[F°N[ ~´µm~;¶gio m~Äf[Ge'LyvyZ'Y givw[He'o ~togwo sf¸ °ªf[¿´µmFviZlstnp[Hvtn sLeho [ sLvweS m~Agivyo ~Agi[Ge t[ [gzcd=[ª§¬vG°
(151) gw[ n np[qAst[¿f»;~top[ o£¼f[HeweisLe ° [ ghgw[¿ m~Agivyo ~Agi[;[Hsfg ~L vw[ v'f[He'eimn sfgio m~Le'f[ u m mFfstgvlZ' mopvw~tvio o Z#[HsLv#Z [[ ~2fy´·³=sf[GgH¶°gwn [H~Aelgtstvi~tm[Çxz[HHqAgio stmo ~L;el[Çeh[ st~Avlgivwnp[Ç[Ge#t¤C[ sfvi¸ÄoryktkLn ±y[Hgielo ZjehmF[H~A~AglgweZ'fmfmf~Aog»; mF[H~Åejf¤[![Hsfgig [ n + n [givw[Ãei mtvigivw[!mfqAWtst[[ =msLv_WLFqAst[#GqFsLop=[°Um~Ç~t['m~;eh[Hvi¤F[#qAst[lnr!to ehgw~L['²SkL±ygio Z'[ ~Ag_nrZjmFop~;e|Fvw~Lf[ o ~Leio9°U[H~ t[ Zy~LLy~Ag}² +gwvi[|tvimfWt[¬f[ [ gf[ ?"f°nR yn mvwopgiWtZ'[tnr [ v¬nR HqAsto ;[_ty~Le [g mFsSty~Le "f $. . E". $. $3. $. $3. b1. . $. b2 d5 = 0. d1 d2 d3. d4 Erreur 1 = (d1,d2,d3)/5 Erreur 2 = (d4,d5)/5. J® HqAsto =[ehmFstWLyopgi[+gwvi[Ly~Le [ g mFsLy~Le "t ½¼Z'tn Z'[ ~AgCgio m~¯\f opnryk ®
(152) #´µmF~L¶gwopmF~¯\fo n kW;yvw [ f[Hyn stnp[Hv[gigi[ m~Agivyo ~Agi[_[Hehg )K A F$3. . F$. çµÚèçéÝ.
(153) C.
Documents relatifs
C'est aussi le résidant pas chez leurs parents fréquentent deux fois parativement à la province, les étudiants de Nanterre ne lement ce moindre attachement à la ville
In this paper, we study the performance of an enhanced channel estimation technique combining estimation using an autocorrelation based method and the Expectation-
Selon Laeven et Valencia (2012) , le coût budgétaire de la crise bancaire s’est respectivement élevé à 44 et 41 points de PIB en Islande et en Irlande, ce qui place ces deux
Dans ce travail, nous comparerons les entreprises coopératives, détenues par leurs membres, dont le produit risqué est la ressource critique apportée et dont l’objectif est
L’indice EMBI a augmenté de 77 points de base entre le point bas de mi-septembre 2007 et fin février, en partie conduit par la hausse de 300 points de base du spread de l’Argentine
usual route to school and provide us with some details about their travel routine (e.g., schedule, mode of transportation, people accompanying them, etc.); 3) recent interventions
La question de l’extension des limites de Paris jusqu’à cette ligne avait été discutée mais ne fut tranchée que par un décret impérial du 9 janvier 1859 qui décidait de