Étude des divines proportions entre le visage et le sourire à travers une analyse faciale par imagerie 3d-stéréphotogrammétrique

Texte intégral

(1)Étude des divines proportions entre le visage et le sourire à travers une analyse faciale par imagerie 3d-stéréphotogrammétrique Adrien Tellier. To cite this version: Adrien Tellier. Étude des divines proportions entre le visage et le sourire à travers une analyse faciale par imagerie 3d-stéréphotogrammétrique. Médecine humaine et pathologie. 2017. �dumas-01978502�. HAL Id: dumas-01978502 https://dumas.ccsd.cnrs.fr/dumas-01978502 Submitted on 28 Jan 2019. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) . .

(3) 4/?(9:/;*'(/%(S57./4;/752/: 'N5'54;525-/(S %<2;*'(%./9<9-/('(4;/9( ikB%4=%$%;,!2%;2%=;Zgmjln,"%%$%Dgk . _R

(4) . 44'%ighn . . . . . . . +&;%dkiZlnZhnZgi.

(5) . . :';%4<'%%<8=!2,9=%3%4<;5=<%4=%$%B4< 2 "=2<'$%+,:=:*,%%4<,:%$%,"% 2%ik04B,%:ighn8: . 54:/(<9 '9/(4. . '2%giB:,2hpph,"% 85=:5!<%4,:2%*:$%$%.

(6) T/7263('N ;;U. A3/4;(<9:L $3%2%:5)%;;%=: $3%2%:5)%;;%=: 54;,%=:2%5"<%=: 54;,%=:2%5"<%=: 54;,%=:2%5"<%=: . . S

(7) Z

(8) Z S S

(9) S

(10) . S

(11) . . :';,$%4<%$= =:E ;;%;;%=: ;;%;;%=: ,:%"<%=:$%<+&;% %3!:%,4B,<'.

(12) . Anné e universitaire 2016/2017. CORPS ENSEIGNANT 56èm e section : DEVELOPPEMENT, CROISSANCE ET PREVENTION Sous-section 01 : ODONTOLOGIE PEDIATRIQUE ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-(! $hè'! î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(!

(13) ', --$-.).

(14) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!(! / ,!2 Sous-section 02 : ORTHOPEDIE DENTO-FACIALE ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-(! ,(!''! --$-.).!--*$é!,.$$!)--*$é!(! ,'!..! --$-.).

(15) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,! '*,$). Sous-section 03 : PREVENTION, EPIDEMIOLOGIE, ECONOMIE DE LA SANTE, ODONTOLOGIE LEGALE ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-(! /,!)! --$-.).

(16) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!(!

(17) ))!/,! --$-.).

(18) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!(!!-'$! . 57èm e section : SCIENCES BIOLOGIQUES, MEDECINE ET CHIRURGIE BUCCALE Sous-section 01 : PARODONTOLOGIE î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-

(19) 0!- î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(! é0!,$)! --$-.).

(20) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,! 1!)ë' --$-.).

(21) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!

(22) !)%($) Sous-section 02 : CHIRURGIE BUCCALE, PATHOLOGIE ET THERAPEUTIQUE, ANESTHESIE ET REANIMATION ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é---*$é!-(! '$-!.. î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-

(23) .,$! î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é- #,'!- --$-.).

(24) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,! ,$!) Sous-section 03 : SCIENCES BIOLOGIQUES ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-(!

(25) -!''! î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(!

(26) é'è)! î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(!

(27) #,$-.$)! 58èm e section : SCIENCES PHYSIQUES ET PHYSIOLOGIQUES ENDODONTIQUES ET PROTHETIQUES Sous-section 01 : ODONTOLOGIE CONSERVATRICE, ENDODONTIE ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-(! ,$! ,)! ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é- .$!))! ,*"!--!/, (é,$.!!)/' î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(!

(28) .#'$! î.,! !*)"é,!)!---*$é !-)$0!,-$.é *($) --$-.).

(29) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,! #*(- --$-.).

(30) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!(! /, --$-.).

(31) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!

(32)

(33)

(34) $,2( Sous-section 02 : PROTHESES ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-(!'$,! î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-0!- î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-

(35) '$0$!, î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(! 'é,$! --$-.).

(36) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!(! Lé*)*, --$-.).

(37) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,! ).*$)! --$-.).

(38) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!!) /2 --$-.).

(39) *-+$.'$!,)$0!,-$.$,!,)/ Sous-section 03 : SCIENCES ANATOMIQUES ET PHYSIOLOGIQUES ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-, ,*"!--!/, !-)$0!,-$.é-

(40) .,$& î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é-(!

(41) '* $! î.,! !*)"é,!)!- !-)$0!,-$.é- ,$. .

(42) (3(9%/(3(4;: . A Madame le Professeur LUPI-PEGURIER Laurence !""! !",# !% +! " # !% * ! !

(43) " + ! %#!*%* !%*. !% . # #

(44) $

(45) $

(46) $ A Madame le Professeur BERTRAND Marie-France !""! !",# !% +! " # !% * ! !

(47) " + ! ! #!+! $% % . V%;< =4 ,33%4;% 82,;,: 9=% $% B5=; "538<%: 8:3, 2% 0=:E $% 3 <+&;%S % <,%4; B5=; :%3%:",%: 85=: B5<:% *:4$% 8<,%4"% %< B5<:% <:&; *:4$% ,382,"<,54$4;2%!54$':5=2%3%4<$%45;'<=$%;S5=;B%F<5=05=:;),<%4 ;5:<% 9=% 2%; '<=$,4<; ;% ;%4<%4< !,%4 =<4< = ;%,4 $% 2 )"=2<' 9=V%4 "2,4,9=%S %B5=;%4;=,;<:&;:%"544,;;4<S V%;8&:% 9=% B5=; <:5=B%:%F <:B%:; "% <:B,2 2 +=<% %;<,3% 9=% 0V, 85=: B5=;,4;,9=%3%;:%3%:",%3%4<;S .

(48) A Monsieur le Docteur LEFORESTIER Eric !""! !",# !% +! &!% # !% ! ! " + ! !" !$ " . . 5=; "538<%: $4; "% 0=:E '<,< =4% 'B,$%4"% %< 0% 4% 2V=:,; 8; ),< ;4; B5=;P 0% B5=; :%3%:",% *:4$%3%4< $V%4 ),:% 8:<,%P "V%;< =4 +544%=:S 5=; B%F'45:3'3%4<885:<'35488:%4<,;;*%9=%"%;5,<%4"2,4,9=%5=2 )"=2<'S 5=; 3VB%F 8%:3,; $V(<:% 2 5> 0% ;=,; =05=:$V+=,P 85=: "%2 0% 4% 8%=D9=%*:4$%3%4<B5=;:%3%:",%:$%45=B%=S %=,22%F<:5=B%:$4;"%<:B,2<5=<354:%;8%"<%<3*:<,<=$%S . A Monsieur le Docteur CEINOS Romain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l.

(49) A Monsieur le Docteur BORIE Gwenaël !""! !",# !% +! !! !+# ! " + ! ! . %

(50) $ $ % . $ $ . . m.

(51) 24 .

(52) 4<:5$="<,54. . . . . . . . . h. . . . . . . . j. hZhZ'),4,<,54$=453!:%$V: hZiZ%453!:%$V:R2%;35$'2,;<,54;*'53'<:,9=%; . j. . hZ%453!:%$V:. . . l l l l m m. . . n o o o hh hj hk hk hl hk hm. iZ%;$,B,4%;8:585:<,54;$4;2%;5=:,:%%<2% B,;*%R=4%:%B=%$%22,<<':<=:% . ih. hZiZhZ%;%*3%4<$V: hZiZiZ%:%"<4*2%$V: hZiZjZ;8,:2%$=:%"<4*2%$V: hZiZkZ%;<:,4*2%;$V: hZiZlZ;8,:2%$%;<:,4*2%;$V:. . hZjZ><:5=B%Z<Z542%453!:%$V:O . . hZjZhZV:"+,<%"<=:% hZjZhZhZ%9=,4%"533%,4;<:=3%4<$%3%;=:% hZjZhZiZ+%);Z$V7=B:%:"+,<%"<=:=D2,';ϕ hZjZiZV:< hZjZjZ3=;,9=% hZjZkZ4<=:% hZjZkZhZ8+E225<D,% hZjZkZiZ":,;<225*:8+,% hZjZkZjZV;<:5453,% hZjZkZjZ%:&*4%4,32 . . iZhZ%;8:'"=:;%=:;R53!:$,P%B,4P,"1%<<;T iZiZ,;*%P;5=:,:%P$%4<;%<8:585:<,54;$,B,4%;. iZiZhZ%453!:%$V:B=8:2%;2%$%:;$V58,4,54; $%2V%;<+'<,9=%$%4<,:% . . iZiZhZhZ 52$;<%,4542$ iZiZhZiZ+,"+% %::$P5=<,%:4:$ iZiZhZjZ:,; %4Z+:,;<58+%P ="+%:4$:'Z %4 iZiZhZkZ*4%;"2P%2;%::; iZiZhZlZ4,4,5:%4F5 iZiZhZmZ A:%2 2,8 iZiZhZnZ :$%4,=:5 . . . ih. . io io ip jg jh ji jj jk. . io. n.

(53) iZiZiZ%;'<8%;W"2%);X$%;<+'5:,%;$%8:585:<,54; ,$'2%;$4;2"5385;,<,54$%4<,:% . jm jm jn. iZiZiZhZ:%;<54 SR2%;8:585:<,54;$V::%B,;,<'%; iZiZiZiZ45CSSR2%;85=:"%4<*%;$V: iZiZiZjZ<%::%<< SR$%2V'<=$%$%;:<,5;$%2:*%=:;Y 254*=%=:;=D*=*%;%;<+'<,9=%;$%4<,:%;$%+=S S jo iZiZiZkZ:$S SR2%;8:585:<,54; jp iZiZjZ%;4'5Z8:<,;4;$=453!:%$V: kh iZiZkZ%;B,;,54;<%38':'%;$=453!:%$V: km iZiZlZ%;$'<:"<%=:;$=453!:%$V: ko. . jZ:585;,<,54$V=48:5<5"52%$V'<=$%$%;8:585:<,54; $,B,4%;%4<:%2%B,;*%%<2%;5=:,:%8:42E;% )",2%jZ<':'58+5<5*:33'<:,9=% lh . . jZhZB4<Z8:585; jZiZ!0%"<,);P8%:<,4%4"%$=8:50%< jZjZ:5<5"52%%D8':,3%4<2 jZjZhZ<':,%2 jZjZiZ'<+5$% . . . . . lh. . . . . lk lk ln ln lp mg mj. . jZjZiZhZ:5<5"52%$%8:,;%$%"2,"+'; jZjZiZiZ5,4<;$%:')':%4"%$%2V'<=$% jZjZiZjZ'<+5$%$%3%;=:%; . jZjZjZ';=2<<; . . . . . . lh. . . . . . 54"2=;,54 ')':%4"%;!,!2,5*:8+,9=%; . . . . . mp. . . . . ng. jZkZ,;"=;;,54 jZlZ%3%:",%3%4<; . . . . . ml mn. . o.

(54)

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

(56) 2%D,;<%=4%"%:<,<=$%R2%453!:% $V:,::$,%=4*:4$453!:%$%$,;",82,4%;%<%;<%4"5:%$V"<=2,<'S

(57) 2;%:%D85;'$4;=4%$%=D,&3%8:<,%2V88:58:,<,54$%"%<<%"54;<4<%3<+'3<,9=% $4;2%354$%3'$,"2%<82=;8:<,"=2,&:%3%4<$4;2V5$54<525*,%%;<+'<,9=%S%"+8,<:% ;%:2V5"";,54$V88:'+%4$%:2%;$,B%:;"5=:4<;$%8%4;'%;$%28:5)%;;,54$%"+,:=:*,%4Z $%4<,;<%<5=<%4),;4<=42:*%845:3$%;'<=$%;;",%4<,),9=%;9=,54<<:,<'2%;=0%<S 4),4 $4; 2 $%:4,&:% 8:<,% $% "% <:B,2P =4 8:5<5"52% $V'<=$% $= 453!:% $V: %4<:% 2% B,;*%%<2%;5=:,:%<:B%:;=4%42E;%)",2%8:,3*%:,%jZ;<':%58+5<5*:33%<:,9=% ;%: ;=**':'S ,B%:; ;%*3%4<; )",=D %< $%4<,:%; ;%:54< '<=$,'; = <:B%:; lg ,4$,B,$=; 85=: <%4<%: $% $'**%: $%; '2'3%4<; $% :'854;%; 8:'2,3,4,:%; 9=4< 2 B':",<' $% 2 8:';%4"%$=453!:%$V:S V5!0%"<,)$%"%<:B,2%;<$V=4%8:<$%),:%2%85,4<;=:2%;"544,;;4"%;"<=%22%;$%2 <+'3<,9=%%4<:%%;<+'<,9=%%<:<,5$V:%<$V=<:%8:<2%B%:2%B5,2%;=:2%;F54%;$V53!:% %4<5=:4<2%2,%4%4<:%2"5385;,<,54$%4<,:%=;%,4$=;5=:,:%%<2%B,;*%B%"ϕS . . h.

(58) . Le meilleur creáteur sera seulement celui qui aura appris a` reconnaiˆtre les bords de la superficie et toute sa qualite´ donc j affirme qu il est nećessaire que le peintre apprenne la geóme´trie. '54<<,;<2!%:<,. . . . i.

(59) hZ%453!:%$V: . hZhZ'),4,<,54$=453!:%$V:. . jPhlPimPliPknPhig. %453!:%$V:%;<=4453!:%,::<,544%2S

(60) 28%=<;%$'),4,:$4; ;54%D8:%;;,543<+'3<,9=%282=;8=:%8:\ht√l]YiS49=5, "% 453!:% $V88:%4"% ;,382% %;<Z,2 8:<,"=2,%: %< 9=%22%; ;54< ;%;5:,*,4%;O %<<%"54;<4<%%;<"544=%$%8=,;2V4<,9=,<'S8:%3,&:%<:"% '":,<% :%354<% 2V4 jgg BS SS $4; 2V7=B:% 3-<:%;;% $V="2,$%$V2%D4$:,%W%;'2'3%4<;$%*'53'<:,%XP%22%4%)=< "%8%4$4<;E3!52,;'%8:22%<<:%*:%"9=%ϕ\),*h]9=V=$'!=< $= &3% ;,&"2% 8: 2% 3<+'3<,",%4 :1 :: \;%254 2% 05=:42,;<% +'5$5:% 551 %4 +533*% +,$,; \),* j]P ;"=28<%=: <+'4,%4 $= &3% BS SS 8:<,;4 $= 8:%3,%: "2;;,",;3%*:%"2V5:,*,4%$%;;<<=%;$=:<+'454\),*k]]S . /-<9(^. /. /-<9(^L<%2/'( ^ L<%2/' 2/'(. /-<9(_L./'/: . /-<9(]L7./ O2(453$9('N9P. /-<. /. /-<9(`L;.*49;.*454 -<9( 9(` ` L ; ;.* .*4 .* 4 9 9;. ;.* ;. *4 54 *454.

(61) 2%;<45<%:9=%;5=;282=3%$`="2,$%\),*i]P:,%44%:<<"+%2%453!:%$V:9=5,9=% "%;5,<$%$,B,45=$`%;<+'<,9=%S4%))%<="2,$%$'":,<"%<<%58':<,54*'53'<:,9=%8:"%; 35<;RW;%$,<$,B,;'%=4%2,*4%$:5,<%%4%D<:(3%%<35E%44%:,;549=4$2%<5=<%;<2 8:<,%P"%9=%2*:4$%%;<28%<,<%XP=<:%3%4<$,<$%34,&:%82=;"54",;%P5485=::,< <:$=,:%8:W2%<5=<%;<28:<,%"%9=%28:<,%%;<=<5=<XS . . j.

(62) 54;,$':54; =4 ;%*3%4< P %< 8:<*%54;Z2% %4 $%=D 8:<,%; 8: =4 85,4< S 8:<,<,54 58':'%;%:"54)5:3%2$,B,4%8:585:<,545=W;%"<,54$V:X;,2%:885:<%4<:%%< %;<'*2=:885:<%4<:%%<P AC AB = =ϕ $54";, CB AC . hS. V'9=<,54 8%=< ;% <:4;":,:% $% 2 34,&:% ;=,B4<%R ;, 2% ;%*3%4< %;< 8:,; "533%,4"544=%xP CB = 1 %<9=% AB = AC + CB = x +1 x x +1 iS 25:; = '9=,B2%4< x 2 − x −1 = 0 1 x 1+ 5 jS %<<%'9=<,54$=;%"54$$%*:'<:5=B%85=:;52=<,5485;,<,B% x = 2 B2%=:4=3':,9=%$%ϕ%;<$V%4B,:54hSmhogjS 54 882,"<,54 $4; 2% $53,4% :"+,<%"<=:2 %< $%; :<; :%354<% $54" = *:%" 4",%4S % 453!:% 2V5:,*,4% *'53'<:,9=% ;V88:%4< $%; ;,&"2%; 82=; <:$ B%" $%; ):"<,54; ,;;=%; $V=4% ;=,<% 8=:%3%4< :,<+3'<,9=% *: "% = 3<+'3<,",%42%82=;:%3:9=!2%$=5E%4Z*%R%54:$5 ,;45 ,!54"", \),* l]S ;=,<% $% "+,)):%; :%8:';%4<'% 8: 2%;453!:%;;=,B4<;RhPhPiPjPlPoPhjPihSSS$54<2V$$,<,54 $%;$%=D453!:%;8:'"'$%4<;$544%2%;=,B4<0=;9=V2V,4),4,P %;<4533'%W;=,<%$% ,!54"",X5=%4"5:%W:&*2%$V:XS %:<,535E%4$%2;=,<%$% ,!54"",%;<'9=,B2%4<hSmhoP. /-<9(aL(549'5/:45 2%W453!:%$V:XS. /$54%%/ % B':,<!2% %;;5: $= 453!:% $V: $4; 2% 354$% $% 2V:< %< ; 3,;% %4 :%2<,54 B%" =4 2 ;8%"< $,B,4 :%354<% 2 %4,;;4"%S 4 hkpoP =" ",52, \),* n] ),D% 2%; 8:585:<,54; :%;8%"<%: 85=: <<%,4$:% 2 !%=<' ;=8:(3% $4; ;54 2,B:% W$% $,B,4 8:585:<,54%XS %< 5=B:*% %;< ,22=;<:' 8: 2% *'4,% '54:$ $% ,4", \),* m]P 54 E :%<:5=B% 2%; $%;;,4; $% mg 852E&$:%;,4;,9=%2%"'2&!:%W 533%$%,<:=B%X!;';=:8+,S'54:$$%,4",22,:< %< 3<+'3<,9=%;P 54 :%<:5=B% $% 34,&:% 534,8:';%4<% $4; ;54 7=B:% 8,"<=:2% 2 8:';%4"%$%;8:585:<,54;$,B,4%;S . /-<9(bL*549''(/4%/. /-<9(cL<%%/52/. k.

(63) hZiZ%453!:%$V:R2%;35$'2,;<,54;*'53'<:,9=%;. jPhlPimPliPhio. . hZiZhZ%;%*3%4<$V: 4;%*3%4<%;<8:<*';=,B4<2;%"<,54$`:5=28:585:<,54$,B,4%;,2%*:4$\t!]%<2% 35E%4\];%*3%4<;54<$4;2%3(3%:885:<9=%2%35E%4%<2%8%<,<\!];%*3%4<\),*o]S . /-<9(dL2(:(-3(4;'V9. hZiZiZ%:%"<4*2%$V: %"::'$54<2%"6<';%:22:*%=:$=:%"<4*2%$V:S"5::%;854$=3,2,%=$="6<'P 2V:"$%"%:"2%$%:E54"5=84<2$:5,<%%4=485,4< S254*=%=:$=:%"<4*2%$V: "5::%;854$ S %;<=4:%"<4*2%$V:S=3(3%<,<:%P %;<2=,=;;,=4:%"<4*2% $V:%<;,54,4;":,<=4"::'$%"6<' P2%:%"<4*2%)5:3' %;<;54<5=:=4:%"<4*2% $V:\),*p]S . /-<9(eL2(9(%;4-2('V9. hZiZjZ;8,:2%$=:%"<4*2%$V: 533% $'":,< 8:'"'$%33%4<P ;, 54 ,4;":,< =4 "::' = ;%,4 $V=4 :%"<4*2% $V:P 54 ":'% $% 45=B%= =4 =<:% :%"<4*2%$V:S,54:'8&<%2V58':<,54P 54 5!<,%4< =4% ;':,% $% :%"<4*2%; $V: $% 82=; %4 82=; 8%<,<;S :'=4,54 $%; 9=:<; $% "%:"2% E4< 85=: :E54 2% "6<' $%; $,B%:; "::'; !5=<,< =4% ;8,:2%$V:\),*hg]S. . /-<9(]\L2:7/92('<9(%;4-2('V9. l. .

(64) hZiZkZ%;<:,4*2%;$V:

(65) 2; ;54< = 453!:%$%$%=DS+"=4$%"%;$%=D<:,4*2%;,;5"&2%;85=::885:<%4<:% 2% *:4$"6<'%<2%8%<,<"6<'2B2%=:ϕS%=:;4*2%;:%;8%"<,);;54<$%jmdPjmdPhgod%<jmdP nidPnidS %8%4<*54%:'*=2,%:%<;%;$,*542%;)5:3%4<2%;$%=D<E8%;$%<:,4*2%;$V:\),*hh]S IO IC = =ϕ SO IS . /-<9(]]L;9/4-2(:'V9 . hZiZlZ;8,:2%$%;<:,4*2%;$V:. % 2 3(3% 34,&:% 9=% 2V,4;":,8<,54 $V=4 "::' = ;%,4 $V=4 :%"<4*2% $V: ":'% $% 45=B%==4:%"<4*2%$V:P2%<:"'$%2!,;;%"<:,"%$%2V4*2%$%nid$V=4<:,4*2%$V:":'% =445=B%=<:,4*2%$V:S,54:'8&<%2V58':<,54P545!<,%4<=4%;':,%$%<:,4*2%;$V:$% 82=;%482=;8%<,<;$54<2%;;533%<;;%:'=4,;;%4<%4=4%;8,:2%$V:\),*hi%<hj]S. . /-<9(]_L2:7/92('<;9/4-2('V9'V<47(4;-54( 9*-<2/(9. /-<9(]^L2:7/92('<;9/4-2('V9. m.

(66) hZjZ><:5=B%Z<Z542%453!:%$V:O 4;3(3%%4B5,:82%,4%3%4<"54;",%4"%$% <:&;453!:%=D5!0%<;$=9=5<,$,%4:%2&B%4<$% 2 B2%=: ϕS 8:'$53,44"% $= 453!:% $V: B,%4<;V,385;%:45=;$4;2%;5!0%<;$%;82=; $,B%:;"533%2%;":<%;$%":'$,<;\),*hk]$4; 45; 85:<%)%=,22%;P 2% $%;,*4 =<535!,2%P 2%; 25*5; $% 3:9=%; \),* hm] 5= !,%4 %4"5:% 2 "54"%8<,54$%;;,<%;,4<%:4%<$%:%453;jPimS. /. /-<9(]`L%9;(:'(%9*'/;K?/;2K'V*;<'/4;MMM:54; <;4;'(9(%;4-2(:'V9'4:45:759;(,(</22(:. . /-<9(]aLV:;549;/4YeK<4(?5/;<9(W/379*-4*(W'(ϕ . /-<9(]bL;/542 (5-97./%Y%.5/:/<4. 9(%;4-2('V9%533((3$2)3( 882%c %;< 2:*%3%4< "544= 85=: 2 :'=;;,<% $% ;54 $%;,*4S V=4 $%; )"<%=:; $% "%<<% :'=;;,<%B,%4<8:5!!2%3%4<$=),<9=%2),:3%28533%,4<&*:%2%453!:%$V:$4;;%; ;<:="<=:%;*:8+,9=%;\),*hn]S%3(3%C,<<%:c;V%;<;%:B,$=:<,5ϕ85=:;5425*53,; =;;, $% 2 ;8,:2% $5:'% 85=: "54;<:=,:% 2 ;<:="<=:% $% ; 8*% \),* ho]S V=<,2,;<,54 $% ϕ :%8:';%4<% '*2%3%4< =4% 8:< ,385:<4<% $4; 2 "54"%8<,54 =<535!,2% "533% %4 <'35,*4%2p\),*hl]S % 2 p p \) \),* ,* hl] l]SS . . /-<9(]cL2(25-5772(. /-<9(. / ]c L22( 25-5 772( 2 Y(;/25<' (;; /2 25<' 'Y. /-<9( ( ]dLL 2( 255-5 5 (; 27 7-( -( '< :/ :/;( ;( @( @((; (;(9Y. /-<9(]dL2(25-5(;27-('<:/;(@((;(9 %; %D%382%; ,22=;<:4< 2 8:';%4"% $% ϕ ;% "538<%4< 8: "%4<,4%; 45=; :%<,%4$:54< $4; $ "%<<%<+&;%=4,9=%3%4<"%=D2%;82=;3:9=4<;$%23,4$%2V 533%\2V:"+,<%"<=:%P2V:< %< 2 3=;,9=%] 3,; =;;, "%=D $% 2 4<=:% <:B%:; 2 8+E225<D,%P 2 ":,;<225*:8+,%P 2V;<:5453,%%<2%:&*4%4,32S. . n.

(67) hZjZhZV:"+,<%"<=:% . hZjZhZhZ%9=,4%"533%,4;<:=3%4<$%3%;=:% %9=,4%\),*hp]$'),4,<2`=<,2,;<,54$% ",49 3%;=:%; '<2544'%; ;=: 2%; $,3%4;,54; $= "5:8; +=3,4S 54 =;*%%45"",$%4<;`'<2%$%2`4<,9=,<' = hp&3% ;,&"2%S % ;E;<&3% $% 3%;=:% %;< 2V5:,*,4% $V=4 W5=<,2 ;":'XR 2 44% 5= 2 ,*% $%; 3-<:%;$`7=B:%\),*ig]S "44% %;< )5:3'% $% l =4,<'; )54$3%4<2%; :<,"=2'%; 9=, ;% "2"=2%4< ;%254 2 ;=,<% $% ,!54"", R hS 5=$'%u,%$t384 iS ,%$u384t23% jS 384u23%t=3%. /-<9(^\L9;/5'(:<4/;*:'<8</4(. /-<9(]eL2(8</4( %<,4;<:=3%4<$%3%;=:%)=<8:,B,2'*,'8:$%;:"+,<%"<%;%<$%;! <,;;%=:;$%"<+'$:2%;P $%; '*2,;%; :534%; %< *5<+,9=%;S %< 5=<,2 ;;5",' 2 :&*2% %< = "538;P 8%:3%<<,< $`5!<%4,:8:<,9=%3%4<<5=;2%;<:"';*'53'<:,9=%;$%;'$,),"%;:%2,*,%=DP245<,54$=$,B,4 %<;542,%4B%"ϕ'<4<8:<,"=2,&:%3%4<$%3,;%25:;$%28':,5$%$%2%4,;;4"%S. hZjZhZiZ+%);Z$V7=B:%:"+,<%"<=:=D2,';ϕ % <5=; <%38;P 2%; <+'3<,9=%; 54< '<' = ;%:B,"% $% 2`:< %< $% 2V:"+,<%"<=:%S %; 8E:3,$%;$`*E8<%=D<%382%;*:%";P$%2`'859=%$%2%4,;;4"%45;05=:;P2`=<,2,;<,54 $% ϕ "54<:,!=' 2 :'2,;<,54 $% *:4$; "+%);Z$V7=B:% *: "% 2 :%"+%:"+% $4; 2V+:354,%$%;B52=3%;%<=4:%;8%"<$%;:&*2%;%;<+'<,9=%;S%34,&:%454%D+=;<,B%54 8%=< ",<%: $4; 2V5:$:% "+:54525*,9=%R $%; 8,&"%; :"+,<%"<=:2%; $54< 2% 2,%4 B%" ϕ :%;<% "54<:5B%:;'"533%28E:3,$%$%+'58;P285:<%;52,:%,C41=P2%:<+'454%<$%; '$,),"%; $54< 2 "54;<:="<,54 :%)2&<% 2% 453!:% $V: ;4; '9=,B59=% <%2; 2% <+' <:% $`8,$=:%P2"<+'$:2%5<:%Z3%$%:,;P2%0+2P2%3=;'% =**%4+%,35=!,%4 %4"5:%2%;<:B=D$%%5:!=;,%:jPhlPliPmmPhigPhipPhjpS E:3,$% $% +'58; \),* ih] 88:<,%4< 2V%4;%3!2% $%; 8E:3,$%; $% ,F%+ ! <,%; %4 2V+544%=:$%;5,;*E8<,%4;,2E82=;$%klgg4;S%;*'53&<:%;B4"%4<9=%2%:885:< $% 2 +=<%=: B%" ; $%3,Z!;% ;%:,< 8:5"+% $% ϕ 5= !,%4 %4"5:% 9=% ; +=<%=: "5::%;854$:,<2:",4%$%ϕS W,$+,)&"(,!%,%,$!%,'*"$%#)8 )$*"8) ++,)/'+ $$4!$ ',.!%,+)(,8,$%,+6 "*+ $ "#%$+))(,8 "$8/!%,,,$)&"4+ " *+ **0 " #%$+)) (, " )&" (,8%$ ')% * -%,", ", ) !%,) + $+ '",* "8 # $+ %$*%##$++,)*(,"8 $+$+ %$*) ++*XZ,%::%$%2 :8%Z . o.

(68) 5:<%$=52%,2%;<2%354=3%4<2%82=;,385:<4<$%2,<'$=52%,2$%2",B,2,;<,548:'Z ,4",C41=;,<='8:5D,3,<'$=;,<%$%F%452,B,%P%22%%;<$<'%$V%4B,:54hlgg 4; B4< 45<:% &:%S 2*:' 2 8':,5$% <:&; :%"=2'% $% ; ":'<,54P ;54 %;<+'<,;3% %;< 2% :%)2%< $V=4 %4;%3!2% $% hl :%"<4*2%; $V:P "%8%4$4< =4% ;,382% "5.4",$%4"% 4V%;< 8; '":<%:\),*ii]S . /-<9(^^L259;('<52(/2/@41<. /-<9(. / ^^ L22 59;( '<522(/2/2 /@41< 1 %:<+'454;,<=';=:2V":5852%$V<+&4%;%;<2V=4$%;354=3%4<;*:%";"2;;,9=%;2%;82=; "544=;\),*ij]S54;<:=,<;8:2V:"+,<%"<%

(69) "<,45;%4klgBS SS;)#$%254*<%38;'<' ",<'%%4%D%382%85=:,22=;<:%:2V882,"<,54$%ϕ%4:"+,<%"<=:%P"%8%4$4<"%22%Z",W"522%X =453!:%$V:=4,9=%3%4<;,542=,:%<:4"+%;8:%3,&:%3:"+%T 4 :%B4"+%P 2% <+' <:% $`8,$=:%P "54;<:=,< ;=: 2% ;,<% $= ;4"<=,:% $V;"2'8,5; =

(70)

(71)

(72) &3% ;,&"2% BS S S "5385:<% ll *:$,4; :'8:<,; %4 jk %< ih *:$,4;S % ;54< <:5,; 453!:%; ;=""%;;,); $% 2 ;=,<% $% ,!54"", %< 2%; :885:<; jkYih %< llYjk ;54< <:&; 8:5"+%; $= 453!:%$`:S:<4<$=8:,4",8%9=V=<%38;$%2 :&"%4<,9=%P2%;3<+'3<,9=%;%<2 8+,25;58+,% ;54< <:&; 8:5"+%; \2 !%=<'P 2 8%:)%"<,54P '<,%4< $54" 3<+'3<,;!2%;]P ,2 ;%3!2%8%=8:5!!2%9=%"%<<%$,;<:,!=<,54;5,<2%):=,<$=+;:$\),*ik]S. /-<9(^]L27B93/'('(.*57:. /-<9(. / ^] L22 7B93/' /'(' '( .* .*57:. /-<9(^_L2(9;.*454. /-<9(. / ^_ L22( 9;. ;.* *454. . /-<9(^`L2(;.*";9('V7/'<9(. /-<9(. / ^`L22(;.* .*"";9( 'V7/' /'<9(. p.

(73) %; 34,)%;<<,54; $% 2 $,B,4% 8:585:<,54 = 5E%4 *% ,4;, 9=V 2 %4,;;4"% ;54< 9=4< %22%; ,4$,;"=<!2%; ": !,%4 $5"=3%4<'%; %< <5<2%3%4< ;;=3'%; 8: 2%; :"+,<%"<%;hnS"<+'$:2%5<:%Z3%$%:,;$'!=<'%%4hhmj"54<,4=;54'$,),"<,54 ;=:82=;,%=:;;,&"2%;S)#$%5=%;<"5385:<%$%453!:%=;%;:')':%4"%;=D35$'2,;<,54; *'53'<:,9=%;$%ϕ\),*im]S % 0 +2P 05E= $% 2V:"+,<%"<=:% 5*+52% %;< =4 3=;52'% %4 3:!:% !24" ':,*' =

(74)

(75) &3%;,&"2%%43'35,:%2V'85=;%$%2V%38%:%=:+ + +48:2V:"+,<%"<%;<$+3$ +=:, %4

(76) 4$%S%$63%"%4<:2%P2)#$%%<2%;9=<:%3,4:%<;;54<=<4<$V'2'3%4<; ;V""5:$4<ϕ\),*il]S . /-<. /. /-<9(âL2(0.2 -<9( 9( âLL 2( 0 . .2 2. %; :"+,<%"<%; "54<%385:,4; ;% ;54< 5=B%:<%3%4< :%B%4$,9='; 8:<,;4; $= 453!:% $V:S :4125E$,4;,$%;;,4'2"'2&!:%:38% $= 3=;'% =**%4+%,3 $% %C 5:1 ;%254 =4% ;8,:2%$V:\),*in]S %5:!=;,%:\),*io],4B%4<'2%W5$=25:X%4 hpkk \),* ip]S %<<% 45<,54 :"+,<%"<=:2% ,22=;<:'% 8: =4% ;,2+5=%<<% +=3,4% ;<4$:$,;'% ;%:B4< "54"%B5,: 2 ;<:="<=:% %< 2<,22%$%;=4,<';$`+!,<<,54%;<"29='%;=:2 ;=,<%$% ,!54"",S. . /-<9(^dL(59$<:/(9. /-<9(. / ^d L( 59$<:/ $ /(9. /-<9(^bL2%;.*'92(5;9(R3('(9/:. /-<9( - ( ^bL22%;.* ;.*' '92( 2 5;;9(R 3( '( 9/:. /-<9( ^cLL 2 93 37( 7( (4:7 :7/9 /92 2( ('< '< 3<: <:*( *( <<--( -(4. 4.(/ (/3 3. /-<9(^cL2937((4:7/92('<3<:*( <--(4.(/3. /-<9( ^. / ê e L 22( ( 5'<259 5' '<259 2. hg.

(77) hZjZiZV:< %$'B%2588%3%4<$%28%:;8%"<,B%%<2:%"+%:"+%$%2!%=<'<:B%:;2%;8:585:<,54; ,$'2%;B54<),:%"54B%:*%:2%;B,;,54;$%;:<,;<%;%<$%;;",%4<,),9=%;S(3%;,29=(<%$% !%=<'%;<=4,$'2$4;2%;$,))':%4<%;"=2<=:%;%<"%$%<5=<<%38;P"V%;<;4;'9=,B59=%2 %4,;;4"% 9=, 3:9=% 2V%D825;,54 $% 2 8:';%4"% $% ϕ = ;%,4 $%; 7=B:%; 8,"<=:2%;S % *'4,% %54 <<,;< 2!%:<, \),* jg] :'B52=<,544% 2%; 45<,54; $% 8%:;8%"<,B%; %< '$,"<% $%; :&*2%;<+'5:,9=%;%<8:<,9=%;B,;4<8:),:%23-<:,;%$%;8:585:<,54;"+%F2%;:<,;<%;S %;'":,<;<%2;W%;<<=<XPW%8,"<=:X%<W%:%%$,),"<5:,X354<:%4<=4%B':,<!2% );",4<,5485=:2$,B,4%8:585:<,54S547=B:%,4)2=%4#8:2;=,<%'54:$$%,4",5= 2!:%"+<A:%:\),*ji]$54<2%<:,<'W%23%;=:%X%<W%;=<:%;,B:%;$%;8:585:<,54; $= "5:8; +=3,4 XP 2%=: 8%:"%8<,54 $% 2 !%=<' 2,'% 2V+:354,% $%; )5:3%;P $%; 8:585:<,54;P$%;"5385;,<,54;%;<,4$,;;5",!2%=453!:%$V5:jS . /-<9(_\L(54;;/:;2$(9;/. /-<9( _\ L (54 ;;/ ;;/:;2 ; 2$ $(9;/ ;. /-<9(_]L2N.533('(/;9<?(. /-<9(_] L2N.533('( /;9<?(. /-<9(_^L2$9(%.;>9(9. /-<9( _^ L 2 2$ $9(%.; .; >9(9. . %54:$$%,4",882,9=%2"544,;;4"%;",%4<,),9=%$%;8:585:<,54;$="5:8;+=3,4=D '<=$%; % =" ",52, %< $% 2V:"+,<%"<% ,<:=B% ;=: 2 !%=<' 85=: :%8:';%4<%: W2V 533% 8:),<X82"'="%4<:%$%2V4,B%:;;E3!52,9=%3%4<,4;":,<$4;=4"::'%<=4"%:"2%\),* jh]S%;8:585:<,54;$544'%;8:"%$%;;,4282=3%;=:88,%:"5::%;854$%4<ϕ;5,<2% :<,5%4<:%2%"6<'$="::'%<2%:E54$="%:"2%S%<:&;453!:%=D<!2%=D54<'<'8;;'; =":,!2%$=453!:%$V:),4$%$'<%:3,4%:2%;,4<%4<,54;$%;:<,;<%;$4;2"5385;,<,54 $% 2%=:; <5,2%;S %8%4$4< =4% W*:,22% $= 453!:% $V:XhlP liP hig !5=<,< =4 9=$:,22*% "5382%D%5>9=;,3%4<<5=<%;2%;)5:3%;8%=B%4<E(<:%,4;":,<%;%<,4<%:8:'<'%;S,4;,,2%;< 2'*,<,3%$%8%4;%:9=V,2E,<%==4%<%4<<,B%$%$'"5=B%:<%85;<%:,5:,$%2:%2<,54$V: $4;"%:<,4;"+%);Z$V7=B:%;4;9=%2V:<,;<%%4,<%==4%=<,2,;<,54"54;",%4<%\),*jj]S. . /-<9(__L2(3::%9('(:/445%(4;:'(<$(4::5<:2-9/22('V9. /-<. / -<9( 9( __ L2( 2( 3: :: :%9 %9( ( '( '(::/4 /445 45%( %(4; 4;::'( '( < <$( $(4: 4: :5< 5<::2 2 -9/ 9/2222( ( 'V ' 9. hh.

(78) 5:< $= "54;<< 8:'"'$%4<P 2 "5::'2<,54 %4<:% 2%; 8:585:<,54; $,B,4%; %< 2%; "5385;<,54; $V=4% 8%,4<=:% 8%=< (<:% ;;=0%<<,% 2V,4<%:8:'<<,54 $% 2V42E;<% %4 :<P "%8%4$4< 2V=<,2,;<,54$%ϕ;%3!2%4%),:%*=&:%$%$5=<%3,;(<:%="54<:,:%=48:<,8:,;;;=3' 85=:!54453!:%$V:<,;<%;imP lgP mmS%34,&:%454%D+=;<,B%548%=<",<%:!,%4%4<%4$= '54:$$%,4",3,;=;;,5<<,"%22,P,"+%24*%P

(79) 4*:%;P 523%:P54$:,4P2,T\),*jk kg]S. /-<9(. /-<9(_`L2%)4(K*549''(/4%/ (_`L2%)4(K*549''(/4%/ _` L 2 %)4( *549' '( /4%/. /-<9( _a L 2 4/::4%( '( (4<: 5;;/%(22/. /-<9(_aL24/::4%('((4<:K5;;/%(22/. /-<9(_bL2%9*;/54'V'3K/%.(24-(. /-<. / /-< -<9( 9( _b L2 2 %9* 9*; *; ;//5 /54 'V /54 ' ' '3 '3 3KK//%. .(22 44-( (. /-<9(_cL2-94'(5'2/:8<(K 4-9(:. /-<. / -<9( -< 9( _cL 2 2 -94' 4'( '( 5' 5'2 2/2/: /:8< /:8< 8<( (KK 4( 4-9( 9(:: 9(. . /-<9(. /-<9(_dL2(:,2(<9:'N9K 523(9 _d L22( 2(: ,2 2(: ,2(< (<9: (< 9: 'N 9K 9K 52 523( 23( 3(99. hi. /-<9(_eL%5375:/;/5495<-(K. /-<9( _eL%5375:/;/5495<-(K $2(<(;0<4(K54'9/4. /-<9(`\L2'(94/)9(%)4(K2/.

(80) hZjZjZ3=;,9=% 54453!:%$%3=;,"525*=%;8:585;%$%;42E;%;),;4<88:-<:%2%453!:%$V:$4; $%;7=B:%;P;4;<5=<%)5,;9=%2%;"5385;,<%=:;'<=$,';4V,%4<3%4<,544'=4%;%=2%)5,;2% 453!:%$V:$4;2%=:;'":,<;S,4;,P$%;3=;,",%4;;54<<:&;2:*%3%4<;;5",';ϕ<%2; %4 '!;<,%4 "+P 5F:<P 2=$% %!=;;EP '2 :<61 3,; 32*:' $% 453!:%=D 2,%4; 85;;,!2%;%4<:%2%=:;"5385;,<,54;%<ϕP="=4%"%:<,<=$%4V%;<'<!2,%S%=2%=4%85,*4'%$% "5385;,<%=:;$3%<<%4<5=B%:<%3%4<=<,2,;%:2%453!:%$V:"533%

(81) 44,;'41,;nPhlS %8:%3,%:8:'2=$%$=2B,%:!,%4<%38':'\8:%3,%:2,B:%]$%"+%;<<:&;"544=%<$V=4% *:4$%;,382,",<'S5=:<4<2%35<,):E<+3,9=%=<,2,;'%;<<5=<),<5:,*,42S%;+=,<$5=!2% ":5"+%; ;`5:*4,;%4< %4 ltjR 2%; 8:%3,%:; <%:3%; $% 2 ;':,% $% ,!54"",S

(82) 2 "5385:<% jk 3%;=:%;\jkuihthj]\),*kh]S . . . /-<9(`]L2(79*2<'('<%2?/(9'(%.K<475;(4;/(2.533-(. /-<. / -<9( -< 9( `]LL 2( 2( 79* 9*2 *2< 2<'( 2<' '( '<%2 %2? 2? ?//( /(9' /(9 '( % '( %. .K <475 75;( 75 ;(4; ;( 4;//( 4; /(2 .5 /(2 .533 .533 33-( ( ϕ. 43=;,9=%"54<%385:,4%P23=;,9=%$%:<61%;<:'8=<'%85=:22,%:!%=<'%<'9=,2,!:%S W=;,9=%85=:"5:$%;P8%:"=;;,54;%<"'2%;<X%;<=4%D%382%$%"54;<:="<,54)5:3%22%R $4;2%8:%3,%:35=B%3%4<P54:%3:9=%9=%2%;%4<:'%;$%"+9=%*:5=8%$`,4;<:=3%4<; \2<5;P B,5254;P B,5254"%22%T%<"]P $% 2 )=*=% "5::%;854$%4< =D 4=3':5; $% 2 ;=,<% $% ,!54"",S 4;;547=B:%85=:5:"+%;<:%W%<;<;,;X

(83) 44,;%41,;\),*ki]=<,2,;%%4<,&:%3%4<$%; 8:5"'$';3<+'3<,9=%;S&;2%;8:%3,&:%;3%;=:%;23=;,9=%;%$'B%2588%%4*2,;;4$5; $%; "5:$%; $4; =4 %;8"% 9=, $%B,%4< $% 82=; %4 82=; "538"< "533% =4% 3'<;<;%S

(84) 2 "54;<:=,<"%<<%8:<,%B%"$%;;=,<%;$%hi<54;P2%;$=:'%;'<4<"2"=2'%;"54)5:3'3%4< 2;=,<%$% ,!54"",nlS. /-<9(`^L 44/:*41/:. /-<. / -<9( -< 9( `^ L 44 44 44//: /: *4 *41 1/ 1/: /:. . hj.

(85) hZjZkZ4<=:% . hZjZkZhZ8+E225<D,% 8+E225<D,%B,%4<$=*:%"W8+E22%XZ)%=,22%Z%<W<D54XZ5:$:%ZS8+E225<D,%'<=$,%2 $,;85;,<,54$%;'2'3%4<;!5<4,9=%;R2`5:$:%$4;2%9=%22%;*:,4%;P2%;)%=,22%;P2%;'",22%; ;54<,3824<'%;;=:2%;824<%;S4$,;<,4*=%$%=D)3,22%;R hS 2%;;<:="<=:%;B%:<,",22'%;R$,;85;,<,54%4"%:"2%P=3(3%4,B%=P;=:=43(3%D% iS 2%;;<:="<=:%;+'2,"5.$2%;R$,;85;,<,54%4)5:3%$`+'2,"%; 8+E225<D,%)5=:4,<$%453!:%=D%D%382%;$%28:';%4"%$=453!:%$V:$4;24<=:% =;%,4$%"%;$%=D)3,22%;jPhmPimPliPllPhhhS %; )%=,22%; $% 2 305:,<' $%; 824<%; <,*%; +=<%; ;% 82"%4< %4;8,:2%%4:%;8%"<4<=4%25,$% $,B%:*%4"% 5> "+9=% )%=,22% )5:3%B%"2;=,B4<%=44*2%$% $,B%:*%4"% 9=, ;V,4;":,< ;%254 2% 35$&2% $% 2 ;=,<% $% ,!54"", B%"=44*2%$V:\),*kj]R ⎛ 360 ⎞ ⎜ 2 ⎟ ϕ ⎠ hjnPld ⎝ S . /-<. /-<9(`_L724;(:79*:(4;4;<4(25/'('/?(9-(4%(:(2542V4-2('V9 <9( `_ L72 724 72 4;( 4 ;(::79 ;( 79*: 79 *:(4 *: (4; (4 ;4; ; 4; <4( 25/ '('/ '/?( '/ ?(9?( 9-(4 9(4%( (4 %( :(2 (254 54 2V44-2( 2( 'V 9 %3(3%2%;453!:%;$%;8,:2%;%))%"<='%; 8:2%;'",22%;$%28533%$%8,4P$="+5= :534%;"5P $%; *:,4%; $% 2 )2%=: $% <5=:4%;52P 5= !,%4 %4"5:% $% 2 3:*=%:,<% $4; 2%; $%=D;%4;$%:5<<,54;54<$%;<%:3%;"54;'"=<,);$%2;=,<%$% ,!54"",\),*kk%<kl]S. . . /-<9(``L%(9;/4(:724;(:54;<435')2('N59-4/:;/54:(254ϕK2(::7/92(:'4:2(: 2(::7/92(:'4:2(: ' ' ' * , ' 2 ' $ '(<A:(4:'(95;;/54%599(:754'(4;<A;(93(:%54:*%<;/,:'(2:</;('( /$54%%/. /-<9(àL:%.*3;/:;/54. /-<9(àL:%.*3;/:;/54 '(2 '(2V59-4/:;/54'(:-9/4(: '(;5<94(:52. hk.

(86) hZjZkZiZ":,;<225*:8+,% %;",%4<,),9=%4,%2+%"+<34:%#=2%8:,D5!%2$%+,3,%%4ighh85=:2$'"5=B%:<% $%; 9=;,Z":,;<=D $54< 2 ;<:="<=:% 4V%;< 8; 8':,5$,9=%S

(87) 2 %4 %))%< 8= 5!;%:B%: = 3,":5;"58%'2%"<:54,9=%=4%,3*%9=,;%3!2,<%4"54<:$,"<,54B%"2%;25,;$%24<=:%R $4;<5=<%;2%;3<,&:%;;52,$%;P2%;<53%;;54<"%4;';(<:%W%3!22';X$4;$%;":,;<=D $% 35<,); ;E3'<:,9=%; 8':,5$,9=%;S %<<% "54$,<,54 $% :'8'<,<,54; 8':,5$,9=%; '<,< ;5,< $,;4< 4'"%;;,:% ),4 $`5!<%4,: =4 ":,;<2S %8%4$4< "%:<,4; ":,;<=D 4% :'854$%4< 8; "%<<%25,\$V5>2%=:88%22<,54$%W9=;,Z":,;<=DX]P2%;<53%;E;54<;;%3!2';;%254=4 ;"+'34%85=B4<8;(<:%:'8'<';S\),*km] . . . /-<9(`bL2(:45'<2(:'(4'9/;/8<(:'(2V22/-('V2<3/4/<3R34-4):(79*:(4;(4;<4(. /-<9( `bLL 2( 2(:45 2(: 45' 45 '<2( '<2 '< 2(:' 2(: '(4' '( '9/ 9/;/ /;/ ;/8< 8<(: 8< (: '(2V2V2 2 22/ 22/2/-( ( 'V ' 2 2<3 2<3 <3//4 /4/< /4/ /<3R3 /<3 343 4-4 44) 4 ):(79 ):( ): 79* 79 *:(4 *:(4 *: (4;( ;(4; ;( 4; <4( 4( 9%;/54 *2(%;954/8<( :5<: ,593( '( 7(4;-54(: 5$:(9?*: < 3/%95:%57( *2(%;954/8<( .<;( '/,,9%;/54*2(%;954/8<(:5<:,593('(7(4;-54(:K5$:(9?*:<3/%95:%57(*2(%;954/8<(.<;( 9*:52<;/545445;(<4('/:;9/$<;/54.535-)4(4547*9/5'/8<('N;53(:'(,593(7(4;-542(M . . % :<,5 $%; $,;<4"%; %4<:% 2%; <53%; %;< 2,' = 453!:% $V:S %; 9=;,Z":,;<=D 54< 85=: 8:<,"=2:,<' $V(<:% "5385;'; $% )5:3%;*'53'<:,9=%;2,'%; ϕknPngPnpPhhg\),*kn]S . /-<9(]^L2(:%.*3. /;.*59/8<('V<48<:/R ;.* %9/:;2<4(:B3*;9/( %9/: -25$2(/%5:*'9/8<(K -25$ '95 '95/;(2('5'*%)'9( 9* 9*-<2/(9'(::/4*79 *549''(/4%/L<4( *5 (A79(::/54'(ϕ (A7 ϕ '4: 2V(:7%(. hZjZkZjZV;<:5453,% %:<,4;=<%=:;B4"%4<=4%:%;;%3!24"%$%;!:;$4;2"5385;,<,54$%;*2D,%;B%" 2%; ;8,:2%; $= :%"<4*2% %< $= <:,4*2% $`:jS %; 2'*&:%; $,))':%4"%; $% )5:3%; '<4< %D82,9='%; 8: 2%; =<:%; )5:"%; 9=, ;`%D%:"%4< $4; 2`=4,B%:; "533% 2 *:B,<<,54 9=, '":;%4< 2 )5:3% $%; ;8,:2%;S

(88) 2 %;< %4 <5=< "; %D<:(3%3%4< $,)),",2% $% $'<%:3,4%: $%; )5:3=2%; 25*:,<+3,9=%; $%; ;8,:2%; $%; *2D,%; 2`B4"% 8=,;9=% "%22%;Z", ;%3!2%4< ;% $'B%2588%:2'<5,:%3%4<%<;54<<5=<%;=4,9=%;S,;2%;;8,:2%;2,'%;=53!:%$`:;`%4 :88:5"+%4< $% 34,&:% '<5444<%P 8:3, 2%; *2D,%; 2%; 82=; ",<'%; 54 :%<:5=B% 45<:% 8:58:%*2D,%P2B5,%2"<'%,4;,9=%nj%<lh\),*ko]S 4% <+'5:,% ;",%4<,),9=% %D85;' %4 iggj $4; 2% 05=:42 <,542 %5*:8+,"c B4"% 9=% 2V=4,B%:;8:%4$2)5:3%$V=4$5$'"&$:%nmS . . /-<9(`dL2(:$9:'(:-2A/(:;(22(:2?5/(2%;*(Ka](;c_:54;:<7(975:$2(:<A:7/92(:'V9. /-<. / /-< -<9( 9( `dL dL 2(: $9 9::' '(:- '(: '( -22 - 2A/ A/(: /(: ;(2 (2222( 2(:22 2(: 2 ?5/ 5/( /( 2%;* ;*( *(K (K a] (;c c_ c _:5 :54;; :<7 <7(9 (975 (9 75: 75 :$2 : $2(: $2 (: <A :7/ 7/9 /9 922( 2(: 'V 2(: ' 9 9. hl hl.

(89) hZjZkZkZ%:&*4%4,32 % :&*4% 4,32 8:';%4<% $% 453!:%=D %D%382%; 5> 8+, 8%=< ;V,22=;<:%:S % 8:,4"% <,2 5;<,%;"5 +E1 8:';%4<' $4; ;%; $,B%:; 5=B:*%; "54;":'; = 453!:% $V: $54< W;<+'<,9=%$%;8:585:<,54;$4;24<=:%%<$4;2%;:<;X=42:*%84%2$%;,<=<,54;5> 2% 453!:% $V: ;%3!2% 882,"!2%jP imP hhhS %8%4$4< ;%; <:B=D 54< '<' 2:*%3%4< "54<:5B%:;'; %< ;%; 8:,;%; $% 3%;=:% :%3,;%; %4 9=%;<,54S 4 :%<,%4$: <5=< $% 3(3% "533% %D%382% 2% 82=; ):884< 2 ;%"<,54 $V: 534,8:';%4<% $4; 2%; 8:585:<,54; $% !%="5=8 $V+%D85$%; %< 2% 4=<,2=; 5> 2 ;8,:2% $`: ;% $'B%2588% B%" =4 :885:< $%; 8:585:<,54; $`: "+9=% :5<<,54 "5382&<% \hog $%*:';]S ;8,:2% $V: $= 4=<,2=; ;5=B%4< '<' 2V5!0%< $% "54<:5B%:;% 3,; $%; ;",%4<,),9=%; ;% ;54< 8%4"+'; ;=: 2 9=%;<,54 $V=4 85,4< $% B=% 3<+'3<,9=% %< ;<<,;<,9=% %< ,2 ;%3!2%:,< 9=% 2 ;8,:2% 2,'% ϕ ;5,< 85=:<4<!%2%<!,%4282=;$8<'%2"59=,22%$%"%"'8+2585$%hhp\),*kplh]S . /-<9(èL'(:/4:(%;(:54;'(:795759;/54:;+;(R. /-<. / -<9( -< 9( èLL '( '(:: /4 /4:( :(%; :( %;(: %; (: 54; '(: 795 9575 759; 75 9;/5 9; /54: /5 4: ;+; +;( (R ;.59AR$'53(4 9(:7(%;4; 2( 9;/5 'V9 ;.59AR$'53(49(:7(%;4;2(9;/5'V9. /-<9( a\L 2( 4<;/. / ;/2/2<: :<7(975:* * <4(:7//92('V 2 'V 'V 9. /-<9(a\L2(4<;/2<::<7(975:*<4(:7/92('V9. . . /-<9(a]L2:7/92('V98<:/R25-9/;.3/8<(%599(:754'2(3/(<A. /-<9(. / a]L22:7/92 / 2( 'V V V98<:/ /R225-9//;. .3/8<( / %599(:754' ' 2(3/(<A / 2%58</22('<4<;/2<: 2%58</22 /2222(' '<4<;/ ;/2/2<:. hm.

(90) %;)5:3%;<:,$,3%4;,544%22%;9=,"54<,%44%4<28:585:<,54$5:'%;54<:'84$=%;8:3,2%; 3,":5Z5:*4,;3%;S V,"5;&$:% %;< =<,2,;' "533% 35$&2% 85=: $'":,:% 2 ;E3'<:,% %< 2 ;<:="<=:% $%; B,:=; ,"5;'$:,9=%; %4 *'4':2 %< %4 8:<,"=2,%: "%22% $% 2 "8;,$% $%; $'45B,:=;\),*li]S. /-<9(a^L35'*2/:;/54'V<4'*45?/9<:K. /-<. / -<9( -< 9( a^LL 35'* '*2/ *2/2/: :;/ ;/54 /54 'V<4' '* '*4 *45? *45? 5?//9 /9<: /9<: <:K '95/;(2N/%5:)'9('(::/4* '95/ '9 5/;( /;( 2N/ N/%5 %5: :) : )'9( '(:://4* )'9( )' 4* *. 79(549''(/4%/L<4((A79(::/54'(ϕ'4:2V(:7%( 79 (549' '( /4%/ L <4( (A79(::/54 '( ϕ '4: 2V(:7%( 7 4:%<:5=B%=;;,=4%425*,%$4;2VB%"ϕhlPhhhR "+9=%<5=:"5382%<$%2$5=!2%+'2,"%$`3%;=:% ih$%2:*%8:jk$%254*\),*lj]Sjk%<ih;54<$%=D 453!:%; "54;'"=<,); $% 2 ;':,% $% ,!54"",S V=<:% 8:< 2 ;%"<,54 $V=4 !:,4 $V 8%=< (<:% ;"+'3<,;'% 8:=4%4;%3!2%$%$%=D8%4<*54%;:'*=2,%:;\),*lk]S %8%4$4< 2%; 3%;=:%; 4454"'%; 4% ;54< 8; "54;%4;=%22%;P 2 2:*%=: 2 82=; "533=4'3%4< ""%8<'% 4V'<4< 8; )5:"'3%4< ih 3,; igP 2% :""5=:", %4<:% ϕ %< =4% 9=%2"549=% :%2<,54 B%" 2V5:,*,4% $% 2 B,% :%2&B% $54" 82=; $= 3E;<,",;3% 9=% $V=4%88:5"+%8=:%3%4<;",%4<,),9=%S . . /-<9(a_L795759;/54:'<$9/4'V /-<9(a_ _ L795759;/ ;/54:' / '< $9/4' / 'V 'V 'V. . /-<9(a`L%5<7('<$9/4'VK:;9<%;<9((4'*%-54(. /-<. / -<9( -< 9( a`LL%5 %5<7 %5 <7( <7 ('< '< $9/ 9/4 4 'V ' K :;9 ;9<% <%;< <% ;<9( ;< 9( (4 '* '*% %-5 % -54( -5 4(. . hn.

(91) %:<,4; 35$&2%; $% 8:585:<,54; $= "5:8; +=3,4 54< '<' 8:585;'; %4 ;V:<,"=24< =<5=: $% ϕS ,;<5:,9=%3%4< 2%; 82=; "544=; ;54< "%2=, $% $52) %,;,4*liP 8+,25;58+% %< 3<+'3<,",%4 $=

(92) &3% %< "%2=, :4; %=)%:<P :"+,<%"<% $= &3%S ,; $V,4453!:!2%; :%2<,54; %4<:% 2% 453!:% $V: %< "+9=% 8:<,% $= "5:8; \B5,: 3(3% $V5:*4%;] 54< '<' 8:585;'%; $% <5=< <%38; \),* ll lo]S V,4<':(< %;< $% <,22% ": 2 35$'2,;<,54 $= "5:8; +=3,4 <:B%:; 2% 453!:%$V:85=:!=<$%8:585;%:=4"54"%8< $V%;<+'<,9=%hlPimPhhhS%8%4$4<;,45=;B':,),54; "%; 3%;=:%; ;=: 45<:% "5:8;P ,2 E $% *:4$%; "+4"%;9=V%22%;;5,%4<%::54'%;inS

(93) 2%;<%4%))%< $,)),",2% $% ;% :88:5"+%: $% "%22%Z",R "%; 8:585:<,54; ;54< "%22%; W$V=4% !%=<' ,$'2,;'%XS

(94) 24%;V*,<8;<5=05=:;$%"54)54$:% %;<+'<,9=%$%8:585:<,54;%<:'2,<'4<53,9=% 3(3% ;, $4; "%:<,4; "; <:&; 8:'",; %22%; 8%=B%4<(<:%"54)54$=%;kpPhkmS . /-<9(aaL2(:7.24-(:795-9(::(4;:(2542(9;/5. /-<9( aa L22(:7. .24-(:795-9(::(4; 2 ;:(225422(9;/ ;/5ϕ . /-<9(abL2(:795759;/54:'/?/4(:(4;9(2(::(-3(4;: %59759(2:9(2)?(4;'N<4(%(9;/4(45;/54'N(:;.*;/8<( /'*2/:*((;4(:54;7:,59%*3(4;<4(9*2/;*4;53/8<(

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ho. /-<9(acL2(:795759;/54:'<%597::(254(/:/4 /-<9(acL2(:795759;/54:'<%597::(254 (/:/4-. /-<9(adL2(:795759;/54:'<%597::(254(<,(9;.

(96) %;8:585:<,54;$%;;%*3%4<;$`=4"5:8;+=3,454<=4%45<,54W$E43,9=%XS<,22%P2 "5:8=2%4"%P 'B52=%4< ;%254 2%; '859=%; %< 2%; 858=2<,54;S 4; "%; "54$,<,54;P ,2 8%=< 8:-<:%,22=;5,:%$%:%"+%:"+%:=4%8:585:<,54=4,9=%9=,;%:,<2"2'$%B5=<%4<53,9=% $V=4 ,4$,B,$=S V=4 85,4< $% B=% ;",%4<,),9=% :%2,%: 2V,4<'*:2,<' $= "5:8; ϕ %;< =4% !%::<,543,;"%24%;,*4,),%8;85=:=<4<2`!4$54$%29=(<%$=453!:%$`:$4; 2% "5:8; +=3,4S 4 %))%<P 2V882,"<,54 $= 453!:% $V: $4; "%:<,4%; 8:<,%; $= "5:8; +=3,4 ;% :'B&2% =<,2% "533% 5=<,2 $,*45;<,"P 5= !,%4 %4"5:% ; :'"<=2,;<,54 %4 =4 W453!:%$V:35$,),'X\:%8:';%4<<,54$V=4:885:<$%8:5*:%;;,544%;=,B4<8;;<:,"<5 ;%4;= 2 ;=,<% $% ,!54"",kpP hkm 3,; ;V%4 :88:5"+4< ;%254 =4 8<<%:4 35$,),' $= :<,5 hRhSm] 8%:3%< $VB5,: =4% 88:5"+% $'",;,544%22% $4; 2%; 824; $% <:,<%3%4<; $% :%"54;<:="<,54 5= $V3'2,5:<,54 $4; 2%; $53,4%; "+,:=:*,"5Z8:5<+'<,9=%; %< 82=; 8:<,"=2,&:%3%4<%4"+,:=:*,%82;<,9=%%<%4$%4<,;<%:,%%;<+'<,9=%S. % 453!:% $V: ϕ %;< =4% :'2,<' 3<+'3<,9=% 9=, <:&; <6< '<' ;;5",'% $,B%:; "54"%8<;P :%2,*,%=DP 3E;<,9=%; %< %;<+'<,9=%;S 35$'2,;<,54 *'53'<:,9=%P 824% 5= $4;2V%;8"%,4;,;=;",<'=4%"%:<,4%);",4<,54=8:&;$%!54453!:%$V=<%=:;%< $V:<,;<%; 8:5"234< 9=% 2 ;%"<,54 $5:'% %< ;%; $'"2,4,;54; ;5=; <%4$%4< =4 ;E;<&3% $% 2 !%=<'S :,*' %4 <+'5:,% %;<+'<,9=%P 2%; ;",%4"%; 3'$,"2%; ;% ;54< =4,B%:;%2 88:58:,' 2% 453!:% $V: ),4 $V22,%: $%; 8:585:<,54; +:354,%=;%; 2%=: <:B,2 <+':8%=<,9=%S . %8%4$4< !,%4 <:58 ;5=B%4< ϕ '<' 3,; %4 B4< $% 34,&:% !=;,B% $4; $%; +E85<+&;%;,4%D"<%;=;;,!,%4$4;2%$53,4%$%;:<;9=%"%2=,$%;;",%4"%;inP jgP liP hho S 2 2=3,&:% $%; '<=$%; :'"%4<%; 3%4'%; %4 <5=<% 5!0%"<,B,<'P ,2 %;< $'354<:' 9=% "%:<,4%; ),*=:%; W,"54,9=%;X $= 453!:% $V: ;% :'B&2%4< (<:% <5<2%3%4< %::54'%;S ,4;,P"533%,2'<'8:';%4<'$4;"%"+8,<:%P="=4%8:%=B%<4*,!2%4%8%=<;;5",%: B%" "%:<,<=$% 2 8E:3,$% $% +%58; B%" ϕP 2 )#$% $= :<+'454 ;5,< $,;4< ,22=;<:<,54 %3!2'3<,9=% $= 453!:% $V: 4% ;V,4;":,< $4; =4 :%"<4*2% $V: 9=V 2 "54$,<,54$%"%:<,4%;"54"%;;,54;P2V42E;%$V=4%8%,4<=:%<:B%:;=4%*:,22%$V:8%=< !5=<,: $%; ,4<%:8:'<<,54; )4<;9=%;P $% 3(3% 2%; 35$&2%; 4<53,9=%; 2,B:'; 8: %,;,4*;54<;5=:"%;$V88:5D,3<,54;8:<,;4%;SSS"54<::,5P3(3%;,$%;=<%=:;54< <:58;5=B%4<:%<%4="%9=,2%=:"54B%4,<85=:;;%5,:2;=8:'3<,%$=453!:%$V:%< ,*45:%:"%9=,4%"54),:3,<8;2%=:;B=%;P544%8%=<4,%:28:';%4"%$%ϕ$4;$,B%:; $53,4%;S %; :<,;<%; 2V=<,2,;%4< $% 34,&:% ;;=3'% $4; 2%=:; 7=B:%; %< 54 8%=< ;V'<544%:9=V=4"54"%8<=;;,'B52='$%;3<+'3<,9=%;8=,;;%;%:%<:5=B%:$%34,&:% ,4$'4,!2% $4; 2 4<=:%P $%8=,; 2 ;<:="<=:% $%; 9=;,Z":,;<=DP 0=;9=V 2 )5:3% $%; 3,":5Z5:*4,;3%;P$%;B'*'<=D%<$%;4,3=DS 5=<%2$,)),"=2<'%;<$%$,;<,4*=%:2%;<+'5:,%;a$5=<%=;%;a"54"%:44<2%453!:%$V: $%;:'2,<';!,525*,9=%;P3<+'3<,9=%;B5,:%%;<+'<,9=%;S W " *+ " %# $) * ,. - * %$* , #%$ <* $ + )+= *$* ) *(,) *%#))$**%$,* %$*#$+"*4>*+;; )** # ") +* $+""*%)# (, $%))*'%$$+'*')%%$** # ") +*"*+),+,)7

(97) * ")*+">*'% ) (,*,.- * %$*,#%$', **$++)),$ *#$ )')*)-)"') * %$4 ">%!+ - ++">,+%) + (,"* $ $* (,">%!+ 4"#!*++"* #'" + ">)+7X Z

(98) 4S<%C:<Z3<+'3<,",%4. . hp.

(99) Les choses qui sont doteés de proportions correctes re´jouissent les sens. ,4<<+53;$V9=,4. . . ig.

(100) iZ%;$,B,4%;8:585:<,54;$4;2%;5=:,:%%<2% B,;*%R=4%:%B=%$%22,<<':<=:% 3'$%",4% %< 82=; 8:<,"=2,&:%3%4< 2 "+,:=:*,% 82;<,9=% %< 2 $%4<,;<%:,% 54< <:&; <6< "+%:"+' )54$%: ;=: 2% 453!:% $V: =4% %;<+'<,9=% $%; 8:585:<,54;S :%44< "533% 85;<=2< $V=4% 8:<P 9=% 2%; "454; $% !%=<' $% 2 :&"% 4<,9=% '<,%4< <:4;85;!2%; $4;2V:<=<:B%:;=4%;,382%)5:3=2%3<+'3<,9=%%<$V=<:%8:<P9=%ϕ;%:%<:5=B,< $4;24<=:%$%34,&:%534,8:';%4<%P,285=B,<$&;25:;(<:%%4B,;*%!2%$V882,9=%:2% 453!:% $V: $4; 2%; <+':8%=<,9=%; B,;'%; %;<+'<,9=%; 5= $= 35,4; ;V%4 ;%:B,: "533% :')':%4<,%2 $= W!%=XS %<<% ,$'% $% !;% %;< 25,4 $V(<:% )4<,;,;<%P $% 453!:%=D 8+'453&4%; ,385:<4<; $% 2 ;",%4"% %< $% 2`:< 54< =4% :",4% "533=4%S 4 8%=< ",<%: "533% %D%382% 2 "2;;,),"<,54 "<=%22% $%; "5=2%=:; ;%254 2%; <:5,; 8:3&<:%; )54$3%4<=D\22=3,45;,<'P2;<=:<,54%<2<%,4<%]9=,4V%;<2V,4,<,28;2V7=B:%$V=4 ;",%4<,),9=%3,;!%2%<!,%4$V=4:<,;<%8%,4<:%$=

(101) &3%;,&"2%P2!%:<=4;%22S%8%4$4< "%"54"%8<4V%;<8;;4;;5=2%B%:9=%29=%;,4<%::5*<,54;Rϕ,38:&*4%Z<Z,2$4;45;%;8:,<; =4 B':,<!2% ;%4<,3%4< $V+:354,% %< $% !%=<'O ϕ %;<Z,2 B':,<!2%3%4< :%<:5=B' 2V'<< 4<=:%2 $4; 2% B,;*% %< 2 "5385;,<,54 $%4<,:%O V%4;%3!2% $%; 3%;=:%; )",2%; %< $= ;5=:,:%5>2%453!:%$V:%;<;=885;'(<:%,382,9='Z<Z,285=:35E%44%ϕ;=:=4%'"+%22% ,385:<4<%$V,4$,B,$=;"533%2V)),:3,<2%;<<,;<,",%43!%:<$528+%='<%2%<O <:B%:;"%"+8,<:%"54;":'2V;;5",<,54$=453!:%$V:$4;2;8+&:%5:5Z)",2%P=4% :%B=%$%22,<<':<=:%B8%:3%<<:%$V%4"538:%4$:%;*%4&;%$4;2%;8:5)%;;,54;2,'%; 2V:<$%4<,:%P;54'B52=<,54P;54,4<%:8:'<<,54%<;%;"54<:5B%:;%;"<=%22%;S . iZhZ%;8:'"=:;%=:;R53!:$,P%B,4P,"1%<<;T. ,%49=%2%453!:%$V:4%;5,<8;%4"5:%3%4<,544'P,"1%<<;%4hpmo$'825:%2%349=% $V5=<,2; $4; 2V42E;% %;<+'<,9=% )",2% %< "54;,$&:% 9=V,2 %D,;<% =4% 2"=4% $4; 2%; 3'<+5$%; $V'B2=<,54; $% 2V'859=% $% 8: 2%=: 349=% $V5!0%"<,B,<'R W :%2<,54 %4<:% %;<+'<,9=% %< "54;,$':<,54; )54"<,544%2; $5,< (<:% 2% <:B,2 $= ;",%4<,),9=% %< 2% !=< <<%,4$:% $4; 2% $,*45;<," $= "2,4,",%4 9=, ;% $5,< $`,;52%: $%; "54$,<,54; ;8'",),9=%;XP W,%49=`,2;%3!2%9=%2V'9=,2,!:%%4<:%"54;,$':<,54;%;<+'<,9=%;%<)54"<,544%22%;;5,<2% 8:%3,%:$53,4%$%2:%"+%:"+%"2,4,9=%P=4%D3%4$%22,<<':<=:%:'B&2%9=%2%;":,<&:%; ;58+,;<,9=';P 9=2,<<,);P 8:%44< 2`%4;%3!2% $%; 8:3&<:%; $,*45;<,9=%; 4% ;5,%4< 8; $,;854,!2%;S 4 5=<:%P $%; 'B2=<,54; 8=:%3%4< ;=!0%"<,B%; ;54< ;5=B%4< =<,2,;'%; "2,4,9=%3%4<SXhhjS :&; B,<% 2%; 8:<,",%4; B54< ;V%49=':,: $% 2 "5::'2<,54 %4<:% "54"%8< %;<+'<,9=%P $,*45;<,9=%%<<+':8%=<,9=%S,4;,%4hpngP$4;=4:<,"2%,4<,<=2'W"54"%8<5))",2 %;<+%<,";XP%"1;<%4<%$V885:<%:=4'"2,:*%;=:2%;%4;$%2!%=<'=;%,4$=B,;*%hgiS 4:%<:#4<2%;35$&2%;,$'=D$%!%=<'$%2V*E8<%%<$%2 :&"%4<,9=%%48;;4<8: 2 %4,;;4"%P 2%; =<%=:; B54< "+%:"+%: "538:%4$:% 45<:% "54"%8<=2,;<,54 $% 2 !%=<'"54<%385:,4%2V,$%$%8+5<5*:8+,%;;<4$:$,;'%;$%;344%9=,4;$%2V'859=% \),*lp]S. . ih.

(102) V,385:<4"% $%; 8:585:<,54;P $= $%*:' $% ;E3'<:,%P $% 2V'9=,2,!:% %< $% 2V+:354,% ;54< ;5=2,*4'%;R W% 9=, %;< ,385:<4< 85=: 45=;P "`%;< 2`'B52=<,54 $% 2 8:%3,&:% "5385;,<,54 ,$'2%$%2)5:3%$=B,;*%+=3,4"54#=$4; 2`'9=,2,!:% %< 2`+:354,% %< %D'"=<' $4; $%; 8:585:<,54; "2;;,9=%; <:B%:; 2% *'4,% $V:<,;<%; "533% +,$,;XP W`+:354,% $= B,;*% %;< 2% <%:3% 2% 82=; ;=!0%"<,)P ,2 %;< $'),4, $4;"%<<%'<=$%"533%2`::4*%3%4<5:$544' %<*:'!2%$%;8:<,%;$=B,;*%SX. /-<9(aeL*;<'(7.5;5-97./8<('((%1:. /-<9(aeL*;<'(7.5;5-97./8<('((%1:. %;3(3%;8:,4",8%;;54<:%<:5=B';$4;2%;<:B=D$%%$%:%4hpnhW$4;2`'B2=<,54 *25!2%$%2`%;<+'<,9=%P45=;=<,2,;54;2%;8:,4",8%;$%8:585:<,54P$`'9=,2,!:%P$%:E<+3%%< $`%38<+,%X 3,; "%2=,Z", 4=4"% 2 8%:"%8<,54 $% 2 !%=<' $V=4 ,4$,B,$= 2V=<:% %4 )54"<,54$%;5488:<%44"%"=2<=:%22%RW8:%3,&:%3%4<P45=;$%B54;""%8<%:2%),<9=% 2%;*5@<;%4!%=<'P;54<<:,!=<,:%;$%2"=2<=:%%D,;<4<%XS%453!:%$V:%;<,",'B59=' 3,;="=4%D%382%4V%;<$544'85=:2,%:8:585:<,54;$%4<,:%;5=$=B,;*%B%"ϕhiS 53!:$,B885:<%:2%;8:%3,%:;0254;$%;"<=%22%;:&*2%;$V%;<+'<,9=%;%45$54<525*,%S %=D :<,"2%; )54$<%=:; 85=: 2 8:5)%;;,54 $% "+,:=:*,%4Z$%4<,;<% B54< B%4,: %4"$:%: 2%; 453!:%=D":,<&:%;;=,B:%85=::'=;;,:=4W;5=:,:%%;<+'<,9=%XP5=="54<:,:%P'B,<%:2%; %::%=:;85=B4<!5=<,:2V'"+%"B,;=%2$V=4<:,<%3%4<S4%4;%3!2%$%8:3&<:%;;54< $'":,<;\),*mg]R 2 "5385;,<,54R 2V=4,",<' $% )5:3%;P $% 85;,<,54;P $% "5=2%=:;P 2 $53,44"% $% 2V,4",;,B%"%4<:2%;54<=<4<$%)5:"%;$%"5+';,54S 2%;8:585:<,54;R28:585:<,54$,B,4%%;<,","2,:%3%4<%D85;'%%<;542,%4B%"2%; 8:585:<,54; $%4<,:%; %D82,9='R W%; '<=$%; ;=882'3%4<,:%; $%B:54< $'<%:3,4%: 28:';%4"%5=2`!;%4"%$`=4:885:<;8'",),9=%$%2:*%=:$%4<,:%'<4<*:'!2%S 5=:2`,4;<4<P<5=<"%9=,8%=<(<:%),<%;<$`=<,2,;%:2%:885:<'<!2,%4<:%22:*%=: $%2`,4",;,B%"%4<:2%%<2<':2%%<85=:;=,B:%"%:885:<$4;2%82"%3%4<$%;$%4<; :%;<4<%;SXmkPmlS. /-<9(b\L%9/;)9(:'(:795759;/54:'(4;/9(::(25453$9'/. . ii.

(103) %B,4B2;=,<%$%;<:B=D$%53!:$,:'2,;%:=4:<,"2%<:&; $'<,22';=:2%;8:585:<,54;$,B,4%;%<2$%4<,;<%:,%\),*mhmk]S

(104) 2%;<$3,;$%34,&:%"54;%4;=%22%9=%"%;54<;%;<:B=D9=, 4":%4<ϕ$4;2V42E;%%;<+'<,9=%$%4<,:%mhS%B,4B885:<%: $%;5=<,2;%<3'<+5$%;85=:85=B5,::%"+%:"+%:2%;%*3%4<$V: =;%,4$=B,;*%%<$%2"5385;,<,54$%4<,:%*: "%=DW*:,22%; $% %B,4X %< 2V=<,2,;<,54 $V=4 ,4;<:=3%4< "544= 8: 2%; :"+,<%"<%; R2%"538;$V: \$54<2%;$%=D!:;;V'":<%4<;%254 2%;%*3%4<$V:]S. /-<9(b]. /-<. / -<9( 9(b] 9( b] L2795-9(::/54'(:795759;/54:(4;9(2V/4%/:/?(%(4;92(K2 L 2 2 795-9 -9(: 9(::/ :/54 /54 '(: 795 9575 759; 9;/ ;/5 /54: (4; /54: 4;9( ;9( 2V//4% 4%//: /:/?( /:/ /?( %(4; 4;9 ;9 922( 2( 2 2(K2 2 2 2;*92( (; 2 %4/4( 9(:7(%;( 2 :</;( '( /$54%%/ :(254 (?/4 2;*92((;2%4/4(9(:7(%;(2:</;('( /$54%%/:(254(?/4. •. •. •. /-<9(b^L2(:B(<AK2(:'(4;:(;2(. /-<9(b^L2(:B(<AK2(:'(4;:(;2( :5<9/9(:54;2/*: ϕ ϕ :(254(?/4. 8:585:<,54 $%; $%4<; %4<:%; %22%; %;< $'),4,% 8: %B,4 "533% :%;8%"<4< 2 ;=,<% $% ,!54"",S,4;,22:*%=:$%2V,4",;,B%"%4<:2%8::885:<22:*%=:$%2V,4",;,B%2<':2% "5::%;854$ =4 :<,5 $% hRgSmho %< ,2 %4 %;< $% 3(3% %4<:% 2 2<':2% %< 2 "4,4% 8=,; %4<:% 2 "4,4% %< 2 8:'352,:%S %; 8:585:<,54; 4% "5::%;854$%4< 8; =D $,3%4;,54; :'%22%;3';,5Z$,;<2%;$%;$%4<;3,;2%=:;3%;=:%;8:50%<'%;$4;=4824):54<2S 8:585:<,54$%;$%4<;B%"2%;5=:,:%R2F54%4'*<,B%"54<%4=%%4<:%2%;$%4<;%<2%"5,4 $=;5=:,:%%;<2=,=;;,"54<%4=$4;=4:885:<$V:S%:885:<%;<$'),4,%4<:%2%"5,4$= ;5=:,:%P2%!5:$$,;<2$%2"4,4%%<2%3,2,%=,4<%:Z,4",;,)S 8:585:<,54$%;$%4<;B%"2%B,;*%\),*nh]R54:%<:5=B%=4 :885:<$V:%4<:%2%85,4<;5=;Z4;2P2%!5:$2,!:%,4",;,)%<2% 3%4<54S $,;<4"% $= !5:$ 2<':2 $% 2V7,2 $:5,< = !5:$ 3';,2$%2V7,2*="+%%;<;,3,2,:%2V'":<%3%4<$%;"5,4;$= ;5=:,:% %< 2 $,;<4"% %4<:% 2%; $%=D !5:$; 3';,=D $%; E%=D "5::%;854$2$,;<4"%$%"4,4%"4,4%S%;$,;<4"%;;54< 2,'%;%4<:%%22%;ϕS. /-<9( b_LL 79. /-<9(b_L795759;/54:(4;9('(4;:(; 7957 5759 57 59;/ 59 ;/54 ;/ 54::(4 54 (4;9 (4 ;9( ;9 ('( '(4; '( 4;::(; 4; ?/:-( ?/:-(5$0(%;/?*(:<%537 5$0(%;/?*(: < %537: %537 'V9 ?/:-(5$0(%;/?*(:<%537:'V9. AC = DE; BC = FG;. . /-<9(b`L2(:5<9/9((;2(:B(<A:54;2/*:79ϕ:(254(?/4. /-<9(b`L2(:5<9/9((;2(:B(<A:54;2/*:79ϕ :(254(?/4. BC DE = =ϕ AB FG. ij.

(105) 54B,4"=$=!,%4)54$'$%;54"54"%8<%;<+'<,9=%P"54)5:<'8:;54%D8':,%4"%"2,4,9=%P %B,44V=:$%"%;;%$%:'"<=2,;%:;<+'5:,%8:$%45=B%22%;8=!2,"<,54;mj \),*mlmo]S

(106) 24V+';,<%8;:'854$:%;%;$'<:"<%=:;%4W"5::,*%4<X2%;%::%=:;$V,4<%:8:'<<,54$% ;54<:B,2<:B%:;$%;"5::%"<,);*:'3%4<';$V=4%,"545*:8+,%%D82,"<,B%miS . . /-<9(baL(A(372('V<4(-9/22('((?/4(;:54<;/2/:;/54. /-<9(baL(A(372('V<4(-9/22('((?/4(;:54<;/2/:;/54. /-<9(bbL2W$544(W<;/2/:;/54'<%537:'V9. /-<9(. / / bbL22 W$544(WW <;/ ;/2/ /2/2/:;/ ;/54 / '<%537: 'V V V9. /-<9(bcL%537:'V9(;B(<AQ:5<9/9(. /-<9(bcL%537:'V9(;B(<AQ:5<9/9(. /-<. /-<9(bdL2(:795759;/54:/'*2(:'(:/4%/:/?(: <9(bdL2(:795759;/54:/'*2(: '(:/4%/:/?(: :(9/(4;%54;(4<(:'4:<49(%;4-2('V9. ik.

(107) :&; 8:52,),9=% %< B,;,!2%3%4< 8;;,544' %B,4 %;< 2V5:,*,4% $V=4 ;,<% ,4<%:4%< \+<<8RYYCCCS*52$%43%4*=*%S"5S=1Y]P,282'!,;",<%2V=<,2,;<,54$="538;$V5:pn\),*mp]%< ,4B,<% 2%; 8:<,",%4; =<,2,;%: ;54 25*,",%2 B%44< "5382'<%: ,4;, 2%; 5=<,2; "54B%4<,544%2; \+<<8RYYCCCS8+,3<:,DS"53Y]\),*nh]S48%=<3(3%2%:%<:5=B%:;=:2%;:';%=D;5",=D<%2 "%!551;5=;2%8;%=$5W 52$%4%4 =*%XS. /-<9( beL22(%537:'V. /. /-<9(beL2(%537:'V9 'V 9. /-<9(c\L%537:'V9(;79;/(/4,*9/(<9( '<?/:-('<94;2(:5<9/9(. /-<9(c]L./;9/A. /-<9( c] L ./;9/A. . . il.

(108) 4hpohP,"1%<<;B,%4<:')),:3%:2V,4<':(<$%2V=<,2,;<,54$="538; $V:$4;2V42E;%%;<+'<,9=%hhkS