HAL Id: halshs-00278091
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00278091
Submitted on 8 May 2008
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Compte rendu La Nativité et le temps de Noël,
XVIIe-XXe siècle, sous la direction de Régis Bertrand,
Aix-en-Provence, Publications de l’université de
Provence, 2003, 252 p.La Célébration de Noël du XVIIe
au XIXe siècle, liturgie et tradition, sous la direction de
Bernard Dompnier, Siècles n°21 (2005), Cahiers du
Centre d’Histoire ” Espaces et cultures ”, université
Blaise Pascal Clermont-Ferrand II, 123 p.
Anne Piéjus
To cite this version:
Anne Piéjus. Compte rendu La Nativité et le temps de Noël, XVIIe-XXe siècle, sous la direction de
Régis Bertrand, Aix-en-Provence, Publications de l’université de Provence, 2003, 252 p.La Célébration
de Noël du XVIIe au XIXe siècle, liturgie et tradition, sous la direction de Bernard Dompnier, Siècles
n°21 (2005), Cahiers du Centre d’Histoire ” Espaces et cultures ”, université Blaise Pascal
Clermont-Ferrand II, 123 p.. Rivista di storia e letteratura religiosa, L. S. Olschki, 2007, XLIII (2007/1),
pp.240-241. �halshs-00278091�
L>M*N'BE7N(O!@4!P7BEQC5B*2O!6IR*8S>;C5:D(>;4*ET3U<*BV8AWS6E7>PB@3>D'H<*BVO@X4!P7BETC5B*2ZY7[[7\2]Y^7Y`_Ia
b? !c !d7e'* cf=*`g hi#j%T&k&(`7hV#l&k#gm/.01n"$nokh!e'p7c`*qer7!c cfZ2g3546Q3`8;:`<?>n@B!C1Ds>;4E`<7B KB@'E:7@<ut]4vV_7E*>;B@w2yx?c.0(czE{YZ|~}'Y*[I[^*s2Z:7>;B@3<6~,BED(@B~<Wn>;3(D'4>n@B 3!_Q:!C5B3BD C!678Ds6@B3*2l6E7>P7B*@3>D'HK?8;:>35B`O:3C5:8]8;B@wv4EDN(B@w@:E<'r2g|!Y7\y_a
ZB3i<7B*6QM9476!P?@:J*BQ32j_*6IR8A>;H3i<7:*ET3<7B3C548S8;BC(D(>;4*EQ3`67E>P7B@3>D:>n@ B32g35B7vR8;BED$C4E6T3`_!476@35B C54vV_*8HD'B@sa-B_7@ Bvi>;B@@:353B*vVR8;B8;B3:C(D'B3<6C54*8n846B~6*>3W;BQ31D<*H@4*6I8;HL>MN'B*E7N O@4!P7BEC5BVB*EV<7HC5BviR*@B`Y[7[*[B!Dj:<74EEHy8S>;B6V-67EBV<*46R78B-_76R78A>;C:D(>;47E 8;By_*@HQ35BED¡@BC6B*>n8 35B¢C54ECBED(@BG36@i8;:£_QH@w>;4<7B£v4<7B@wEB¢BDVC4ED'B7v_Q4@:>AETB*2D:*E<?>3?6QB¤8B36*>nET¥1B¢:@ D>C8;B3 @B8;:D¦>§ 398AWL¨EQD>;?67>D'HB!D$:69©4!ª7B7E«lJ*B`4ED$H!DH`H!<?>D'HQ335463V8BVD(>D¦@XB~` 5c `*cy 7mg !¬,m¯®°fZ+c±*hc i*hV²¡!³7!f°pI*2l3546!3i8;:V<?>A@BC1Ds>;4EV<*Bi´aoN¦O7aµKI4!ª7B*@gB!D¶¡aµt]4@'>P7:78A2lCB¥ 8;B`v¸·vBH<?>DB*6@saZ5W;B!M7CB*8S8;BEDB>nED(@4<6C(D(>;4E<*B`FIH!J?>;3K4ª7B@w2,6>_@4_!43B`6*EB31ªEQD¹3B6D(>A8B <7Bº8SWnQH@'>D':J7B_!:78;H4*N'C@HD¦>BEB!DUvH<>;H!P7:*8A2g:3536@B`<W;:>/8A8;B76@38;B8n>;B*Ey:P7BC8;B_7@ Bvi>;B@P74*8n67vB <7B3:CDwB3aZ»,6@D'46D2lB8A8B:RQ46D¦>Dj`6Ey_Q:*E4@:v:i<*By8;:V¼6QB31Ds>;4EV<B-8;:V<7HP74!Ds>;4EV-8;:y½,:D(>P?>DH ¾8AW;H_Q4?6!Bv4<*B@'EQB*2=>nED(@4<¼67>;35:7E!D£8B335B>¥5B:7@ D(>CQ8;B!36>i36>P7B*E!D¿<*:EQ38;B76@<>P7B7@3!>DH*2 8;:?6B*8S8;B¾@B§'8;¹D'Bu_7@ HC!>35Hv¸BED8;:v:8S8;H:R>n8S>DkH<6~Ds¹*vBzBD8;:¾_8n6*@:8S>DkH<7B3:_*_7@4CBQ3 _Q4353!>nR8;B3<W/67E361À'B!DB*E!PI>;35:J7H<*:7E36ED'BvV_3@ B8;:!Ds>P7B7vB7E!DV8;4EJ¢BD<*B3B3!_!:QC5B39<>P7B@ 32 :8n8;:7E!Dy<?6O4@ D6TJ*:788:O48;4J¼ETB?at]BÁ_@HC>;B6Q35B!3£_Q:J*B334EDyC4E35:!CQ@XHBQ3¢:*6!MC546D(67vB3 @HJ¼>4E:*8;B32¢R*@k>n8A8:vivBED@B_7@XHQ35B*EQD'HB!3z_!:@£8;BÂC!6@:D'B76@¢<?6P748S6vB?a=1B3ÃC54ED(@w>nR76D¦>;4*E3 @B8;:D¦>PB3¢8;:O@4!P7B*EC5B}tl4vi>AE>6B¤´¦:P7B8$3Q6@y8;B3¢C:7E!Dk3G<7B½Z4Ä8$BEO@4!PBEQC5B*2FHJ>;3 KB@ Ds@:E<3!67@8:½Z4Ä8,BEO@4P7BEQC5B8AWH*_Q4¼6TBC14E!DB*vV_!4@:>SEB*2¡©:@C5B*8K7B@wET43`36I@8BC68DB <7B3>SE3ÅD¦@w6v¸BED'3<By8;:9O:353>;4EViL>My:*6VƼÇwkB3Q>¹C!8B*2,§4E<*HQ336@<7B3i@BCB@C!B!3i>nEQH<?>D'B32 :_7_!4@ D'BEDy6*ETBG<?>SvBEQ3!>;47E¢:E!DI@X4_Q48;4J>;?6B£R>;BEP7BE*6TBG£8AWH!Ds6<*B¢<Wn67ED(Q¹vB¢?6*>:3354C>B 8n>D(67@XJ?>;B=B!DC546D¦6*vB3@ HJ?>;47E:8;B!32$D(@:<>D¦>;4E!3=@B*8n>;J>B6!35BBD`_Q:ÈBE*EB*2É_*@:D¦>;6B!3=>AET<¼>P?>;<6B78n8B3 46¢C548S8;BC(D(>P7B32UBD'CaU5Wn67EB¢<7B!3_7@X4R78;H7v:!Ds>;6B3=@XHCQ6*@'@B*E!DB!39Ds>;B*E!DV:76¢3ÅD:!D6DV3!_QH!C!>§k>;6B¢<7B C5B!DD'Bi§·!DwB`:761À'46I@X<W/*67>3>Z_Q4_68;:7>n@B*2]?6*>IC@'>31D':78n8A>35B:6D'46@g<*BV35:`CH*8;HR7@:Ds>;4EVB!Dq<7B3i@'>D'B3¸?6*> 8AW:C5C54vV_!:JETB*E!D2É8AWn><BED(>D'H*2¡P74*>/@XBÊ8;:£@ B!P7B*E<?>C5:!D>4E£>;<7B*ED(>D':>A@B*2Ë<7BÌE:!Ds>;4E!346<*B£@HJ>;4EQ3a ¨T:ED'3¸<7B`½Z4Ä87<7:*E3¸<7B!3i8;:7EJ6B3i@ HJ?>;4*E:8B!3i}XDkB88;By_*@4!PTBE5:*8Sj6*W;4EEB-_Q:@w8;By_Q:!3i8By@B3ÅDB <7BG8AW:EEQHB*2U@'>DkB3`§:vi>n8S>;:*6!M?6*>C54E!§4@+D'BEDV8;:=?6!·!D'B¢>;<7B*E!Ds>D':>n@ B¢_!:@8;B6@Ë:*EC!@:J7B36_7_!43H <7:E3G67E_!:335H>SvVvH7v4@'>;:78A2¸B!DkCaÉ»,Wn>S8jB3ÅDy6ETBG?6B3(D(>;47EÌ?6*>¡_Q:@XC4*6@ Dy8AWB*E3BviR*8;BÊ<*B¢C5B3 H!D(6<B32CW;B3(D¾R*>B*E C5B8S8;B <*B 8;: _Q4_*678;:@'>D'HÍ<?6ÍD(!¹vB BDz<7B 8;: v6D':D¦>;4E <*B 35BQ3 @B_*@H35B7ED:!D>;4ET32E4D':vivBED`:76D'46I@<7B£8;:¢C!@¹CB*2É6>$@B*8;¹!PTB*2¸6B86B3C5:3vi>;3_!:@D }wC4vvB`8;B3¸C!@¹!C!QB3iE:_Q4*8n>D':>SEB3i@X4!ª7:78;B352l<*By_*@:!D(>6B3¸:!ª7:*EDq:C¼67>;3¸:*6VC546@3¸<7B!3¸3!>¹C!8B3 6EB£<?>SvB7E3>4EÁ_Q4_68;:7>n@B?a5W;46!P?@:J7B_*@4_Q435B6E_Q:@:8A8¹*8;B>SE!D'H7@XB335:*EDB*E!Ds@B8;:C@¹CTB*2 J7HEH@:*8;Bv¸BEDUH_7H7v¹@B9BD¸J7:@wE*>B<*B3ÅD':!Ds6BDwD'B!3v4R>n8B!32jBD8;ByDTHÎ!D(@ B<7B½,4Ä8A2D'B78]6*W/>A8 3WB31D$<?>§ §w635H:*69O4@ D(6TJ*:78Z}©$>C¹78;B´¦:E*>nE7N¯Ïl7>P743a]O46@?a¨©:EJ7B*2C5B!DD'B9_Q4_*678;:@'>35:!D>4E`<7B 8;:C5H8;H*R7@:!D>4E9<7B½,4Ä8Z3W;:CC54vV_!:JEB*2Ð:6-§k>n8,<¼6`D'BvV_32Ð<W/6EB<*HP7:8A6:D(>;4EBDË<¼6`D¦@X:EQ31§B7@¯D <7B8AW/>AEQD'H*@·!DË<*BQ3:@ Ds>;3ÅDB3mP7B7@X3V<7B3D(¹*vB3P74>;3>nEQ3-}k:EE4*ETC5B9:76!MRQB@J*B7@X3VB!DË:<*4@:D¦>;4*E<*B3 v:J*B3Åa9O!8n6Q3!>;B76@ 3:@+D(>CQ8;B!32<7HP748S63:76CQ6*8DkB<7B8AWSE§:EDNw´¦H!3!632vBDD'BEDBEÃH!P>;<7B*ECB 8AW/>nvV_!4@D:*EC5B¢6B=D(>;B*E7EBEDiP>;3>;4E3B!D`vV>A@:C!8B3}:6£_*@B7v>;B7@@:EJÊ<B356B838;B!3J?6QH@r>354E3 vV>n@:!C!678;B*6T35B3¡C54vivByH8;H*vB*EQDw3i§4*E<7:!DkB6@ 3V<*B`<7H!P74!D(>;47E3i8AW/*E!§:7E!D¡CB¥`8;B3`E47vR7@B*635B3 <7H!P74!D'B3Uy8AWSE§:EDNk´(HQ3!6!3i}kC5:@wvH*8n>D'B3U<7HCT:6!353HB!3i_!46I@Ñ8:-_8n6I_!:7@¯DsJ?@X:!Ds>§k>;HB!3¸<7BP?>;3>4E!3¸<7B 8AW/*EQ§:*E!D:6~v:>S8n8;4D46zv·vBÃ<WS6Ez7E!§:*ED<7B?6B8;6TB3:E7EHB!32y?6>i>nEQ31D>D6¹@B7ED<*B3 <7H!P74!D(>;4*ET3_!:@D¦>;C678n>;¹7@B32Ò8SWn>SE3(D':@Ì<7B¾C5B@D':>SEQB3~C54E!§'@ H@'>;BQ3a»]>;JE:78;4E3~:6Q353>8;:Ó_*8;:CB ?6*W;4CC!6_BED8B3-3D':D(6QB!DD'B3yB!D8B3º@B_7@H!35BED':D¦>;4*E3>;C4E4J¼@:_7>;?6B!3<*:7E38;B39<7HP74!Ds>;4E3 8AW/*EQ§:*E!DÔ 8;: _8n6Q3ÍC5H78;¹R7@XB HD':EDÓ8AWS7E!§:EDsNw´(HQ3!63Í<7B O@:J6B*2Ã?6*W;HD6T<¼>;B >;C>»,>n8P7:ET4 ¶$>;4@<*:7E4ÔÕ:*633!>R>;B7E6TB<7:E!38B3yC1H8;HR@:!Ds>;4E3y<7B8;:G½,:!Ds>P>D'H*2ÖB!D¸¼6TB8;:<>P7B*@3!>D'H<B3 H!D(6<B3¸@:3535B7vR78HB3¸>;C>*vB!Dj_!:@D¦>;C678n>;¹7@BvB7ED$R>B*EiB7EP7:8;B76@sa
× E_QB*6!D@XBJ@B!DD'B@`67EB£C5B@D:>AEB>n@'@HJ6*8;:@'>D'H£<7:*E3Ì8:£6:8A>D'H£<7B3:@D(>C!8;BQ3` 3>U8;BQ3 C54E!D¦@w>nR6!Ds>;4EQ38;B!3_78A6T3J*H7EH@:*8;B32ÉE4!D':*vVvB*EDVB*E£7>;3ÅD4>n@BG<B£8AW:@D2EQB£_*@4_Q435BEDy_Q:3<B @HB8A8B`E46!P7B:*6D'H*2g>A873W:J?>DjCB_!BE<7:*EDj<*BV31ªIED(Q¹3B3ÖÀ¦6<?>C!>B*63B3¸BD¡R*>B*EVC54*ET6B3ØC5B@D:>AEB3 H!D(6<B3z<7BuC46Ds6vB!3¾@XHJ>4E:*8;B3~B!DET:Ds>;4E:8B!32¿BEÓ@XB!P7:7ECB*2£_@H35B7E!DwBED6EÓ>SEDH@X·D v4>nE<@B*2]36@D46D$84@X36*W;4E8;B3UC547E!§'@4ED'Bi:6M:@D>C!8B3¸<Bi§4*E<<*B`_7@B*vV>¹@BV6:*8n>D'H*2,C54vVvB
3!_7>n@w>Ds6:8S>DH<*B3VC54E!§k@XH@k>;B39}'KB@wET:@X<¢t]4vV_E>B@s246<7:E3VC5B@D':>SEB3VC54EJ?@ HJ7:!D>;4ET3C54vVv¸B 8;B3,:@wvH78n>D'B3<HCT:6313HB3-§'@:*E:*>;35B3=}KIB*@'E:@ <]46@ 3s2Ë6>$_@4_!435BED`8B3@ H36I8D':!Dk3<7B @BC!QB@XCB3i_Q46*@j8;:-_78S6_!:@+D>SEH<?>DB!3¸B!Dj46P?@B*EQDq`8SW;H!P?>;<7B*ETC1BV<*ByE46P7B8A8B3m_QB*@3!_QB!CD>P7BQ32l¼6> J7:@X:EQD>n@47E!DiC5BD46!P@:J7B*2,4E`8AWB3_Q¹@B*28;:i<>§ §k63>4Ei?6*W/>A8vH*@'>D'Bi:6_@¹3U<7B3I>31D4@w>;B*ET3U<*B`8: _QBE35H!B`@B78n>;J>;B7635B?a
O:@gC54ED¦@X:3(D'BV:P7BC8:`vi68Ds>n_78A>C>DHi<*B3Ds¹7vB3U:R4@<7H3i_!:@C5B3U:C(D'B3U<7BiC548n846B*28;B 35BC54ET<476!P?@:J*Bi<74*E!Dj>n8QB31Dj>;C>T6B3ÅD¦>;4*E*2>3536<WS67EiC548S8;4?6Bi4@J*:7E*>;3H`_!:@KIB@wE:@<yt]4v_EI>;B*@ B!DV8AW/6*E>P7B@3>DwHÌK?8;:>35BÌO:3C5:*8gµ8B@rv4*EQDNs5B@'@:*E<Ìw'2¸@B*EQ§B@wvB¢67>DH!D6T<*BQ39C54EQ35:C!@H!B3G8: C5H8;HR7@:Ds>;4EÃ<*Bz8;:½,:!D>P>D'H*2 :*6ÃC546@3<WS6ETBH*_Q4?6B_78A6T3Á@B3(D(@B*>nED'B*2_767>;356BÃ35B*678;B8: C54E!D¦@w>nR6!Ds>;4Ey<7BºFIHJ>;3`KB7@ D(@:*E<:R!4@<7Bº8BÆZÆlB-3>¹C!8;B?aO@'>P?>S8;HJ>;:ED¸8AWH_!46Bv4<*B@kEB}wC>nE :@ D(>C!8;B!3V36@8B!3ÆZÇ]'kByB!D$ƼÇw'kB-3>;¹C8;B32Ð<B6M31B768;B*vB*EQD¡36@¡8;B`ƨÆ]B*2j8;B3i:6D'B76@3i4ED_6 :RQ4@X<7B@~8;:Í?6B3(D(>;47EÍ<7B3 _7@X:!Ds>;6B3 B!D~<7B 8: 8n>Ds6@J>;BÍ<Wn>SE31Ds>D(6D¦>;4*E3 46Í<7B vi>n8S>;B6M J7H4J¼@:_7>;6BQ331Ds@r>C1D'B7vB7E!Dg<*H!§k>nE*>3 V8;B£<>;4C5¹3BÌ<7BO:@'>;3Ì}w,H!C!>S8;Bt]:!PQPN(F,>;J*:76!M2CB8S6>$<B ¨8B@rv4*EQD9}'»*DH_:EB̶4vi>;32i8BvV>A8S>;B6R!HEQH<¼>C(D(>AE }t]:7E>;B*8SN × <*47E6@ B8As24*6£B7EC54@B£<*BQ3 _7@X:!D¦>;6B!3zC5:@:C(D'H@w>;31Ds>;6B3¾}8B3zC54vH<>B346§:@C5B3z<*B ½Z4Ä8S2¢H!Ds6<>;HB3¾_!:@KIB*@'E:@< t]4vV_*EI>B@w¡46y3!_QHC>§w>;6TB3i<W/6*ETBº@HJ>;4E72¨DB*8S8;B8AWL6!P7B@JEByBD¸8;B`ÇZB8:!ª}sO!>;B@'@B-»4@r6Q3s2468B K46I@rRQ4E7E:*>;3z}X´¦B:E N¦!@:E!4>;3©:!M7476 ]B7>nED¥5B*E*Åaº©:>38;:P7H@'>D':R8;B?6:78n>DH<*BÂC5B _QB!D>D 46!P?@:J7BmD(>BED$y8AW;:vVR7>Ds>;4E`<7BV354EVC!6@:D'B76@¡ ]BE`@H6*EI>353:ED¡>31D'4@w>B*E3BDUvi6T3>;C48;4J6B32lC5B @BC!6QB>A8v:@6B67E_Q:3Ì<7HC!>3!>§_!46I@8AWn7>;3(D'4>n@ B <*B8:8n>D(6*@J?>;B*2V6>Ë:GÀ(6T356*W/>;C>Ë:!DXD¦>n@ H8;B3 vV63>C54*8;4J?6B3yR>;B*E=_78A63V6B=8B3y*>3ÅD'4@'>BE3iB6MNv·vB!32ÐB!D¸v:E6TB9B*ETC54@B9<W;HD(6<7B!3V<*4ED 4E`vB36I@XB*2,`8:`8;B!C1Ds6@Bi<7BiC5BE67vH@X4i<7Bx?c.0(c!2,C4vR7>;BEiB78A8;B3Ë<*H_Q:313BED$8B31D(@k>;CÅDÐC!:*vV_ <?>;35C>n_*8S>SE:>n@ By<7B98;:98S>Ds6@J>;B9_Q46@46!P@'>n@8AWn7>;3(D'4>n@ By<7B98AW
J8S>;35B`B!DÖ<*B`3B3@H!§4@wvB32<?6`C:ED BC5C!8H3!>;:Q31Ds>;¼6QB*2j<?68A>P?@ B*2j<*B3v:cD(@w>;3B!32jB!D'CTaq1:¼6T:8A>DkH_7@XBvi>¹@XB<7B8SW;BEQ35BvVR8;B-D(>B*ED¸8;: vV>;31BBE=_7@X:!Ds>;6B<7B9CB<*HC8;4>;3547EEQBvB7ED¸<?>35C!>n_8S>nE:7>n@B}¯P74>/@UE4!D':7vvB*EDi8;BQ3`C54ED(@w>nR6!Ds>;4E3 <7B9K]a¨tl4v_E7>;B@q8S6>ANsv·v¸B*2<7B9taoN
×
a]¨6I@XB78A246VB*ETC54@B`<B`at]:!P!ªN¦FZ>;J7:*6!MBDÖ<*BiÆa]KZ>35:*@4*2 P7BE763¤D4*63<*B76!M~<7B8:vi63>;C548;4J>B*a$6*WB*8/8B3_7@4_!435BEQDÌ67EHC8;:>S@:J*Bz>AEH<>D46Ã<*B3 31ª?ED(Q¹35B32D46!DwB3 8;B!3ÍC4ED(@'>nR6D(>;47E3 vH@w>D'BED :!DwDwBED(>;47E*2ÃB!DÓ_7@H31BED'B*EQD 6ETB @XHQB8A8B 4v4J*HEQH>D'H*2˼6BÊ8AW;4E£_Q46@'@:*>Dy@HQ3!6*vB@V_!:@i67EB¢J¼@:E<B¢C!8:@D'H¢<*B£8;:£_7@H!35B7E!D':D¦>;4*E¢<7B3 <74EEHB!3B!D`8;:Ê_*@HC>;3>4E<7BÌ8;:<74C!67vBED':!Ds>;4EBDi<7B39:EE4D':!Ds>;4E3aÙ»IB678q_QB!D>D`RQHv478] 8: v4<*B31Ds>;B¢<7B¤8:GC48A8;BQC1Ds>;4EÌÔ8:¤@B!PI6Bx¼.0Åc52ËH<¼>DwHB£_Q:@8;B¢gaao?angaU}wZBEQD@B¢<W/>;3ÅD4>n@B y3Q_!:QC5B3`B!D¸C68D(6*@B3¸=<*B8AWS6IE*>P7B7@3!>DH<*B=]8;B@wv4E!DNs5B@'@:*E<''ÑÔ2$BD¸354E9§4@'v:DV@H<6*>D }1|MZ|ÃCQvÌETB _QB@wvB!DXDB*E!D¢_Q:3<7B~@B_*@4<?6!C1Ds>;4E~>;C4E4J¼@:_7>;?6B<*BÃ6:8A>D'H?a'83W;:J?>D C5B_QBE<7:*ED24E=8AW:9C54vV_*@'>;32<Wn67E946QP?@X:JB<*ByD(@¹!3yR!4EIEB-D'B7E*6TB*2B!D˼6B354*E=_7@r>Mv4<>;¼6TB }1|I| lÊC54ED¦@w>nR76!Bz<?>§ §k635B@:67_7@X¹3<Wn67E¾8;BC(Dw4@:!DÊ<*BzC!4>M2v:*>;3:633!>V:67_*@¹3<*B3 H!D(6<>:*E!Dk3a