The summary technical information on the analytical procedure is presented as reported by the participants against the percentage of score, for each participating laboratory the nuclides which need some corrective actions were listed. The following codes were used:
•
For performance evaluation A: Acceptable, W: Warning, N: Not Acceptable.
•
For applied corrections: 1: Moisture Content, 2: Decay Correction, 3: Self Attenuation, 4: Random Summing, 5: Coincidence Summing, 6: Cascade Correction, 7: Background Correction, NR: Not reported.
Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the IAEA or any of its staff members thereof.
In these tables, individual laboratory data is presented in ascending order of the laboratory
code.
TABLE I.1: S U MMARY OF TECHNIC AL IN FORM ATION REPORTED BY T H E P A RTICIP AN TS SORTE D B Y LABOR A TORY CODE Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 1 16 50 .0 0 12 .5 0 37 .5 0 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 K- 40 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 C s-1 34; C s-1 37; P b- 21 0 2 19 73 .6 8 10 .5 3 15 .7 9 NR M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 Am -24 1 C d- 10 9; M n- 54 3 23 78 .2 6 0. 00 21 .7 4 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3 Sr -90 ; U- 234 ; U- 23 8 Pb- 210 Pb- 210 4 18 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Geni e ESP M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 5 22 81 .82 0. 00 18 .18 G amma V isio n 6 .06 Mu ltin uc lid e stan da rd 1, 2 , 3, 5, 6 , 7 Pu -23 8; U- 238 Cd -1 09 Cd -1 09 6 16 81 .2 5 0. 00 18 .7 5 Assay er M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Zn -6 5 C d- 10 9 7 18 88 .8 9 0. 00 11 .1 1 Gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Pb- 210 Pb- 210 8 18 83 .3 3 5. 56 11 .1 1 Gam m aVision M odel A 66 -B 32 V er si on 5.20 Mathem atical approach 1, 2, 3, 5 , 7 Cd -1 09 ; Pb- 210 9 24 70 .8 3 12 .5 0 16 .6 7 Self m ade fo r ga mma s pectrometr y M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 5, 7 K- 40 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Pb- 210 10 17 94 .1 2 5. 88 0. 00 Int er wi nne r M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1 11 21 80 .9 5 0. 00 19 .0 5 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Am -24 1; Pu -23 9+240 ; Cd -1 09
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water Sr-90 12 20 85 .0 0 15 .0 0 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 7 13 22 90 .9 1 0. 00 9. 09 GEN IE 2 00 0 v. 1. 4 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Sr- 90; U -2 38 14 18 83 .3 3 0. 00 16 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 Pb- 210 15 15 93 .3 3 0. 00 6. 67 Gam m a Vision 3 2 A6 6-B 32 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 16 21 33 .3 3 14 .2 9 52 .3 8 G ammaT rac, Ox fo rd . M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 6, 7 K- 40; Pu -2 38 ; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr-90 Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 13 4; P b-2 10 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 18 24 75 .0 0 4. 17 20 .8 3 G E NI E 200 0 V er si on 3.1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 7 Am -24 1; Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr-90
C s-1 34 19 14 57 .1 4 14 .2 9 28 .5 7 gam m avi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR K- 40 C o- 60; C s- 13 7 C s-1 34 20 23 95 .6 5 0. 00 4. 35 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 21 18 50 .0 0 11 .1 1 38 .8 9 Gam a Vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 Am -24 1; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 23 24 79 .1 7 0. 00 20 .8 3 Devel ope d i n ou r Lab M at la b T M M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr -90 ; U- 234
24 21 85 .7 1 9. 52 4. 76 Spec Dec Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 7 Sr- 90 25 13 84 .6 2 7. 69 7. 69 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 34 26 17 17 .65 23 .53 58 .82 G E NI E PC Mu ltin uc lid e stan da rd 2, 3 , 4, 5 , 7 Cs- 13 7; U- 238 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 27 24 66 .6 7 12 .5 0 20 .8 3 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Am -24 1; C s-1 37; K -4 0; Pu- 238 Cd -1 09 28 18 83 .3 3 5. 56 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 6 , 7 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1 29 14 92 .8 6 0. 00 7. 14 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Zn- 65 30 21 38 .1 0 14 .2 9 47 .6 2 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0; Zn-65
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; M n-54 ; Zn-65 31 11 54 .5 5 0. 00 45 .4 5 Gam m aVi si on 32 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 Am -24 1; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 33 17 82 .3 5 0. 00 17 .6 5 Maestro-32 , G amma M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1; Pb- 210
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 34 16 87 .5 0 6. 25 6. 25 GEN IE 2 000\ , M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 6, 7 Am -24 1 35 18 83 .3 3 11 .1 1 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 7 C s-1 34 36 21 76 .1 9 9. 52 14 .2 9 Gam m avi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Sr- 90 Pb- 210 Pb- 210 37 18 38 .8 9 22 .2 2 38 .8 9 Pu lse Heigh t Analy sis S oftw are M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 Cd -1 09 39 18 38 .8 9 0. 00 61 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 7 C s-1 37 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 ; Zn-65
Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 134 42 17 35 .2 9 5. 88 58 .8 2 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 4, 7 Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240
Cd -1 09 ; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 Cd -1 09 ; M n-54 ; Zn-65 43 19 94 .7 4 0. 00 5. 26 W in Q fo r Sr -9 0; A pex /G en ie f or K- 40\ , C s- 137 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 44 13 69 .2 3 7. 69 23 .0 8 Gam m aTrac M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C o- 60; M n- 54; Zn-65 45 16 56 .2 5 6. 25 37 .5 0 AN GES f or spectrum /ROI pr ocessi ng M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; Zn -6 5 Zn-65
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 48 18 72 .2 2 22 .2 2 5. 56 Gam m a Vi si on by M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Zn- 65 49 18 88 .8 9 0. 00 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 Ot he r 1, 2, 3 , 4, 7 Pb- 210 C d- 10 9 50 23 56 .5 2 8. 70 34 .7 8 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; U- 23 4; U- 238 Cd -1 09 Am -24 1; C s-1 37; P b- 21 0 51 15 86 .6 7 6. 67 6. 67 Gam m aVi si on 6 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 34 52 18 61 .1 1 33 .3 3 5. 56 Ape x M at hem at ical app roach 2, 3 C s-1 34 53 18 83 .3 3 16 .6 7 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 55 18 88 .8 9 11 .1 1 0. 00 Geni e - 20 00 \, -US A M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 56 18 94 .4 4 0. 00 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 7 C d- 10 9 59 23 78 .2 6 0. 00 21 .7 4 Gam m a vi si on - A lph a v ision M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 5, 7 Am -24 1; Sr -9 0 Pb- 210 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 60 8 25 .0 0 0. 00 75 .0 0 Int er W inne r Selective standard nucl id es 1, 7 Am -24 1; U- 23 4; U- 238 Am -24 1 Am -24 1; Pb- 210 62 24 87 .5 0 4. 17 8. 33 GEN IE M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1 C d- 10 9 63 19 68 .4 2 26 .3 2 5. 26 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 4, 6 , 7 C s-1 37
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 64 18 83 .3 3 11 .1 1 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C s-1 34 65 22 81 .8 2 9. 09 9. 09 Ape x Gam m a M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 66 5 80 .0 0 0. 00 20 .0 0 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR Sr- 90 67 14 64 .2 9 14 .2 9 21 .4 3 G E NI E 200 0 w ith ProC ount M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 69 24 62 .5 0 12 .5 0 25 .0 0 Geni e-VM S 4. 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Am -24 1; K -4 0 Cd -1 09 ; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 C s-1 34 70 16 75 .0 0 25 .0 0 0. 00 Int er Wi nne r 6. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 71 11 45 .4 5 9. 09 45 .4 5 Gam m a vi si on 32 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 Zn- 65 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; M n- 54 73 18 55 .5 6 5. 56 38 .8 9 GEN IE 2 00 0 v . 3 .0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Pb- 210
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Pb- 210 75 15 40 .0 0 13 .3 3 46 .6 7 NR NR NR Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 134 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; P b- 21 0 76 4 0. 00 0. 00 10 0. 0 0 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR C s-1 37; M n-5 4 C s-1 37; M n-5 4 77 19 57 .8 9 36 .8 4 5. 26 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Zn- 65
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 78 18 83 .3 3 5. 56 11 .1 1 Gam m a Vision 3 2 V er si on 5.30 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Pb- 210 C s-1 34 79 16 0. 00 12 .5 0 87 .5 0 GEN IE 2 000 Ot he r 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Am -24 1; Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Am -24 1; Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 80 19 47 .3 7 5. 26 47 .3 7 ow n so ft wa re Selective standard nucl id es 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Co -6 0; Cs-1 37; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 Am -24 1; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 81 18 50 .0 0 0. 00 50 .0 0 M east ro 3 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7
Am -24 1; Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr -90 ; U- 234 ; U- 23 8
C s-1 34; Zn -6 5 C s-1 37 82 16 93 .7 5 0. 00 6. 25 NR NR 1, 2, 7 Pb- 210 84 16 81 .2 5 6. 25 12 .5 0 G E NI E ESP VMS Pr ocoun t M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1 85 24 58 .3 3 4. 17 37 .5 0 Accu spec M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7
Am -24 1; Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr -90 ; U- 238
M n- 54; Pb -2 10 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 86 12 16 .6 7 41 .6 7 41 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 M n- 54; Zn -6 5 87 18 83 .3 3 0. 00 16 .6 7 GAM M A VIS ION V. 6. 06 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, ,6 , 7 C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Pb- 210
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 88 16 87 .5 0 12 .5 0 0. 00 Int er wi nne r 5. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 7 89 16 0. 00 12 .5 0 87 .5 0 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65; 90 24 87 .5 0 4. 17 8. 33 Gam m a Vi si on Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2 U- 23 4; U- 238 91 13 7. 69 0. 00 92 .3 1 Int er Wi nne r 6. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 3, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Cd -1 09 ; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5
Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 92 18 38 .8 9 27 .7 8 33 .3 3 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 93 18 66 .6 7 16 .6 7 16 .6 7 Int er Wi nne r 6. 1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Co -6 0; Cs-1 37; Pb- 210 95 18 38 .8 9 0. 00 61 .1 1 GEN IE 2k M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 ; Zn-65
C s-1 34; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 34 96 22 45 .4 5 0. 00 54 .5 5 Gam m a Vision G 53W 4.21 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; Sr -90 ; U- 234 ; U- 23 8
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 97 14 42 .8 6 42 .8 6 14 .2 9 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 98 15 20 .0 0 6. 67 73 .3 3 soft ware f or ga m m a spectrom etry M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs- 13 7; M n- 54; Zn-65 99 18 72 .2 2 11 .1 1 16 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 6, 7 Pb- 210 Am -24 1; Pb- 210 10 1 16 81 .2 5 0. 00 18 .7 5 In h ouse Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 3 , 5, 6, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 134 10 2 22 54 .5 5 9. 09 36 .3 6 GEN IE -2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 3 Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; U- 23 4; U- 238
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Pb- 210 M n- 54 10 3 23 26 .0 9 30 .4 3 43 .4 8 VM S M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 6 , 7 Am -24 1; C s-1 37; K -4 0; Pu -23 9+240 Pb- 210 Am -24 1; C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 10 4 21 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 In H ou se M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 10 5 24 95 .8 3 0. 00 4. 17 Gam m a-Vi si on 6. 01 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 M n- 54 10 7 18 88 .8 9 5. 56 5. 56 Gam m aVision fo r analysis, Maes tro for da ta acqu isition M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C s-1 34
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 10 8 19 26 .3 2 0. 00 73 .6 8 INT E R WIN N E R VERSI O N 4. 1a nd fo r al ph a c ount ing MAESTR O OCTE- M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5
Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 11 0 16 87 .5 0 6. 25 6. 25 G E NI E 200 0 ver sion V 1.3 \,19 99 Mu ltin uc lid e stan da rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 C s-1 34 11 1 5 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 Ot he r 7 11 2 22 81 .8 2 13 .6 4 4. 55 GEN IE -2 00 0 2. 1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 6, 7 C d- 10 9 11 3 24 91 .6 7 4. 17 4. 17 GEN IE 2 000 Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 3 , 5, 7 C d- 10 9 11 4 24 62 .5 0 8. 33 29 .1 7
EA SY V iew 12 24- 53 4 Spect rum GEN IE 2 000; Gam m a Vision M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; U- 23 4; U- 238 Cd -1 09 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 11 5 18 94 .4 4 0. 00 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 Cd -1 09 11 6 20 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 SEI KO EG &G M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 5 , 7 11 7 18 83 .3 3 0. 00 16 .6 7 GS A W in gam m a M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Pb- 210 C s-1 37; Zn -6 5
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 11 8 22 50 .0 0 0. 00 50 .0 0 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 ; Zn-65
Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 134 11 9 20 90 .0 0 0. 00 10 .0 0 G ammaW fo r W ind ow s M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 12 0 16 75 .0 0 0. 00 25 .0 0 GEN IE 2 000 Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Zn -65 12 1 16 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Gam m a vi si on 32 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 12 2 18 50 .0 0 27 .7 8 22 .2 2 G en ie- 200 0 & LabS OCS Mathem atical approach 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 C o- 60; Zn -6 5 C o- 60; Zn -6 5 12 3 13 38 .4 6 23 .0 8 38 .4 6 Aptec Ve rsio n 7. 04 .0 0. 03 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Sr- 90 C o- 60; C s- 13 4 C o- 60; C s- 13 4 12 4 22 68 .1 8 13 .6 4 18 .1 8 IW 4. 1 fo r g amma and m anual f or al pha Selective standard nucl id es 1, 7 K- 40 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 Pb- 210 12 5 11 18 .1 8 18 .1 8 63 .6 4 NR NR NR C o- 60; Zn -6 5 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 12 6 21 80 .9 5 4. 76 14 .2 9 Vari ous Ot he r 1, 2, 3 , 7 Sr- 90; U -2 34 C d- 10 9
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 12 7 21 66 .6 7 0. 00 33 .3 3 GEN IE -2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Sr- 90 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34 12 8 15 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Geni e-2 000; Sr -9 0 B ert hol d LB 770W in- P C M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 12 9 20 20 .0 0 20 .0 0 60 .0 0 Target Ot he r 2, 6, 7 K- 40; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr-90;
Am -24 1; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 13 0 18 44 .4 4 16 .6 7 38 .8 9 Gam m a Vi si on 5. 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 5, 6, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Am -24 1 13 1 23 82 .6 1 8. 70 8. 70 APE X fo r gam m a Selective standard nucl id es 1, 7 Am -24 1 C d- 10 9 13 2 12 0. 00 8. 33 91 .6 7 NR NR NR Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5
Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 13 3 18 61 .1 1 38 .8 9 0. 00 GEN IE -2 000 M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 7 13 4 12 91 .6 7 0. 00 8. 33 EM C APL US 3. 0 Selective standard nucl id es 2, 7 C o- 60 13 5 20 85 .0 0 0. 00 15 .0 0 ISOC S, GE NI E 2000 Mu ltin uc lid e stan da rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 Pb- 210 M n- 54; Pb -2 10
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 13 6 17 70 .5 9 5. 88 23 .5 3 Gam m a Vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, ,3 7 C d- 10 9 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34 13 7 18 83 .3 3 0. 00 16 .6 7 Om ni gam M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Pb- 210 13 8 9 66 .6 7 11 .1 1 22 .2 2 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 Am -24 1 13 9 16 87 .5 0 0. 00 12 .5 0 Gam m a Vision V. 6. 00 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 7 Am -24 1 C s-1 34 14 0 13 84 .6 2 7. 69 7. 69 Ow n Selective standard nucl id es 2, 7 C s-1 34 14 2 18 77 .7 8 11 .1 1 11 .1 1 APE X gam m a analysis Mu ltin uc lid e stan da rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 Cd -1 09 ; Pb- 210 14 3 16 81 .2 5 12 .5 0 6. 25 Ind. , I nc. , Geni e VM S M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C d- 10 9 14 4 19 84 .2 1 15 .7 9 0. 00 GAM M A VIS ION - 32 M odel A6 6 - B 32 ( ) M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 7 14 5 13 53 .8 5 46 .1 5 0. 00 SAM PO 90 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 14 6 16 62 .5 0 12 .5 0 25 .0 0 G E NI E 200 0 Basic Spectrosc opy FitzPeak s M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C d- 10 9 C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 14 7 22 63 .6 4 18 .1 8 18 .1 8 Gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr-90 Pb- 210 C o- 60 14 8 14 35 .7 1 7. 14 57 .1 4 APE X - GEN IE 2000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 C s-1 34 14 9 17 88 .2 4 11 .7 6 0. 00 GEN IE 2 00 0 - US A M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 15 0 23 86 .9 6 0. 00 13 .0 4 Gam m aVi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 5 , 7 Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; U- 23 4; 15 1 19 52 .6 3 5. 26 42 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5
C s-1 34 15 2 20 55 .0 0 5. 00 40 .0 0 Geni e-2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5
C s-1 34 15 3 16 37 .5 0 0. 00 62 .5 0 NR NR NR Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb- 210 15 4 19 63 .1 6 10 .5 3 26 .3 2 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9; M n- 54 C s-1 34
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 15 5 11 90 .9 1 0. 00 9. 09 G E NI E 200 0 3. 0, Ori gi n 7. 0 Ot he r 1, 2, 4 , 7 M n- 54 15 6 18 83 .3 3 0. 00 16 .6 7 GEN IE 200 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 C s-1 34 15 7 18 61 .1 1 5. 56 33 .3 3 LabS OCS s oftware v4 .0 \, GENI E 2000 Analy sis s oft w are Mathem atical approach 1, 2, 3, 7 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; Zn-65 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; Zn-65 15 8 6 0. 00 0. 00 10 0. 0 0 NR Selective standard nucl id es NR Pu -23 9+240 ; U- 23 4; U- 238; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 Am -2 41 16 0 17 76 .4 7 11 .7 6 11 .7 6 Gam m a Vision -3 2 Versi on 6 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Pb- 210 C s-1 34 16 1 24 83 .3 3 8. 33 8. 33 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 U- 23 4; U- 23 8 16 2 18 55 .5 6 5. 56 38 .8 9 SPEC T R A N M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34
Am -24 1; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb- 210 16 3 24 79 .1 7 4. 17 16 .6 7 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR Am -24 1; C d- 10 9 M n- 54; Zn -6 5 16 4 24 66 .6 7 4. 17 29 .1 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7
C s-1 37; K -4 0; Pu- 238; Pu -23 9+240 ; Sr-90;
C s-1 34 C s-1 34
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 16 5 13 38 .4 6 7. 69 53 .8 5 M aest ro 3. 2 Ot he r 1 C s-1 37; K -4 0 M n- 54 C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 16 6 18 88 .8 9 0. 00 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 5, 6, 7 C d- 10 9 Pb- 210 16 7 23 52 .1 7 4. 35 43 .4 8 hom e m ade P. I.M .P. (gam m a), final calculations M S Excel
M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 ; Zn-65
Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 16 8 14 42 .8 6 7. 14 50 .0 0 E G &G Gamma Vi si on v. 5. 1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 K- 40 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34 16 9 18 72 .2 2 0. 00 27 .7 8 Gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 C s-1 37 C d- 10 9 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 17 2 18 66 .6 7 5. 56 27 .7 8 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9 M n- 54; Pb -2 10 17 3 11 27 .2 7 9. 09 63 .6 4 Excel \, GEN IE 2 00 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; Sr-90; M n- 54 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37 17 4 10 50 .0 0 20 .0 0 30 .0 0 GEN IE 2 00 0 , Excel M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37 M n- 54 C s-1 37 17 5 14 28 .5 7 7. 14 64 .2 9 M aest ro M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9; Z n- 65 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 17 6 19 73 .6 8 10 .5 3 15 .7 9 Int er wi nne r 6. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 17 7 18 72 .2 2 11 .1 1 16 .6 7 GEN IE M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Pu -23 9+240 M n- 54 17 8 18 88 .8 9 11 .1 1 0. 00 Gam m a Vi si on -3 2 Selective standard nucl id es 2, 7 17 9 21 66 .6 7 0. 00 33 .3 3 GAM M A VIS ION 6. 01 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Pu -23 8; U- 234; U- 23 8
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 Am -24 1 18 2 16 31 .2 5 6. 25 62 .5 0 NR Selective standard nucl id es 2 Pu -23 9+240 ; U- 23 4; U- 238; Cd -1 09 ; Pb- 210 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4 18 4 18 61 .1 1 11 .1 1 27 .7 8 Gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 K- 40 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 Pb- 210; Zn -6 5 18 5 24 50 .0 0 25 .0 0 25 .0 0 M aest ro A 65 -B 32 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Pu- 238; Sr -9 0 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 C d- 10 9; M n- 54 18 6 18 88 .8 9 0. 00 11 .1 1 Geni e2 K M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Pb- 210 Pb- 210 18 7 18 88 .8 9 5. 56 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 5, 6 , 7 Zn-65 18 8 16 93 .7 5 0. 00 6. 25 Int er wi nne r 6. 0 M ul tinucl ide st anda rd 2, 3, 7 K- 40 18 9 24 95 .8 3 4. 17 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 19 0 18 88 .8 9 0. 00 11 .1 1 Gam m a Trac M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 6, 7 C d- 10 9 C d- 10 9
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 19 1 16 31 .2 5 0. 00 68 .7 5 Gam m a Vi si on 3 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR C s-1 37 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5
Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34 19 2 21 85 .7 1 0. 00 14 .2 9 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 U- 23 4 Pb- 210 C s-1 34 19 4 19 57 .8 9 15 .7 9 26 .3 2 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 K- 40; Sr -9 0 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 Zn- 65 19 5 17 17 .6 5 0. 00 82 .3 5 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; Sr-90
Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5
Co -6 0; Cs-1 37; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 ; Zn-65 19 6 21 85 .7 1 9. 52 4. 76 Int er W inne r 6 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 5 , 7 Pb- 210 19 7 19 63 .1 6 10 .5 3 26 .3 2 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; Sr-90 Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 134 19 8 16 43 .7 5 18 .7 5 37 .5 0 GEN IE -2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; M n-54 Am -24 1; Co -6 0; Cs-1 34 19 9 17 94 .1 2 0. 00 5. 88 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Sr- 90; 20 0 18 94 .4 4 0. 00 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 Cd -1 09 20 1 15 73 .3 3 6. 67 20 .0 0 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 C s-1 34 20 2 21 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Gam m a Vision (Am etek) M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 7
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 20 3 21 95 .2 4 0. 00 4. 76 INT E R WIN N E R 6. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 7 Sr- 90; 20 4 18 72 .2 2 5. 56 22 .2 2 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Co -6 0; Cs-1 37; M n- 54 Zn-65 20 6 15 53 .3 3 0. 00 46 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2 C d- 10 9
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 20 7 18 83 .3 3 5. 56 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 00 0v 1. 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; M n-5 4 20 8 24 79 .1 7 4. 17 16 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 5, 6, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; U- 23 4; U- 238 20 9 18 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 M at hem at ical app roach 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 21 0 16 81 .2 5 18 .7 5 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 V er si on 3.0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 21 2 15 46 .6 7 6. 67 46 .6 7 NR NR 1, 2, 7
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 21 3 18 66 .6 7 5. 56 27 .7 8 Gam m aVi si on 5. 10 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; C s-1 34 Am -24 1; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 21 4 18 77 .7 8 11 .1 1 11 .1 1 Gam m aVi si on 32 v . M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 C s-1 34; P b- 21 0
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 6. 01 21 5 18 94 .4 4 0. 00 5. 56 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Zn- 65 21 6 17 76 .4 7 11 .7 6 11 .7 6 MAESTR O-32 AND O MNI GA M M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1 Am -24 1 21 7 19 47 .3 7 26 .3 2 26 .3 2 GEN IE 2 000 Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 7 K- 40 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 C s-1 37; M n-5 4 21 8 15 93 .3 3 0. 00 6. 67 AS AP Selective standard nucl id es 2, 3, 5 C d- 10 9 22 0 17 41 .1 8 23 .5 3 35 .2 9 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 4 , 5, 6, 7 C s-1 37 C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 Cd -1 09 ; M n-54 ; Pb- 210 22 2 18 50 .0 0 22 .2 2 27 .7 8 GEN IE 2 00 0 - P C M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0; U- 23 8 C s-1 37; M n-5 4 22 3 15 26 .6 7 26 .6 7 46 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 Am -24 1; C o- 60; M n- 54 22 4 2 0. 00 0. 00 10 0. 0 0 O X F R OA SI S ve r. 4. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 7 U- 23 4; U- 23 8 22 5 16 62 .5 0 6. 25 31 .2 5 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 7 Am -24 1; C s-1 34; Zn -6 5 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 22 6 16 75 .0 0 18 .7 5 6. 25 Eco gam m a M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 3, 7 Sr- 90
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 22 7 16 93 .7 5 0. 00 6. 25 G E NI E 200 0 V er 3. 0b M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 22 8 21 80 .9 5 4. 76 14 .2 9 Gam m avi si on (Am etek) M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 134 22 9 21 90 .4 8 9. 52 0. 00 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 7 23 0 18 50 .0 0 11 .1 1 38 .8 9 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Cd -1 09 ; M n-54 ; Pb- 210 C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 23 1 20 25 .0 0 20 .0 0 55 .0 0 G E NI E 200 0 (A lph a Analy st) M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 K- 40; U -2 34; U- 23 8 C s-1 34
Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb- 210; Zn -65; 23 2 18 16 .6 7 16 .6 7 66 .6 7 GEN IE 2K M at hem at ical app roach 2, 3, 5, 6, 7
Am -24 1; Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5
Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 23 3 17 64 .7 1 17 .6 5 17 .6 5 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 Pb- 210 23 4 12 66 .6 7 25 .0 0 8. 33 Gam m aVi si on Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 3 , 5, 7 Zn- 65 23 5 18 77 .7 8 5. 56 16 .6 7 Gam m aTrack M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 6 , 7 C s-1 37 Am -24 1; Pb- 210
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 23 6 18 44 .4 4 5. 56 50 .0 0 Self-m ade\, Ga mma- Analy sis Mathem atical approach 2, 3, 7 K-40
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54; Pb -2 10 ; Zn-65 23 7 24 95 .8 3 0. 00 4. 17 Int er wi nne r 5. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 5, 6, 7 Zn- 65 23 8 10 40 .0 0 30 .0 0 30 .0 0 Gam m a Vi si on 6. 01 Selective standard nucl id es 2, 7 Cd -1 09 ; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 23 9 21 85 .7 1 0. 00 14 .2 9 GEN IE -VM S M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 U- 23 4; U- 23 8 Pb- 210 24 0 19 57 .8 9 21 .0 5 21 .0 5 Gam m a Vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; Zn -6 5 Cd -1 09 24 1 16 68 .7 5 6. 25 25 .0 0 GEN IE 2 00 0 v 3. 1 M at hem at ical app roach 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9 C s-1 34 24 2 16 50 .0 0 31 .2 5 18 .7 5 G E NI E 200 0 V er si on 3.1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2 C s-1 37 Am -24 1 Am -24 1 24 3 20 20 .0 0 0. 00 80 .0 0 MAESTR O II EGG& Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2 , 3, 7 Cs- 13 7; U- 238 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37 ; M n- 54
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 24 4 8 62 .5 0 0. 00 37 .5 0 NR NR NR Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; Zn -6 5
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 24 5 18 94 .4 4 5. 56 0. 00 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 7 24 6 16 37 .5 0 12 .5 0 50 .0 0 GEN IE - VM S M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; Zn -6 5 24 8 24 58 .3 3 16 .6 7 25 .0 0 GEN IE 2 00 0 V3 .1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 Am -24 1; U- 23 4; U- 238 Pb- 210 C o- 60; C s- 13 4 24 9 21 95 .2 4 0. 00 4. 76 Gam m a Vi si on 5. 1\ , M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 25 0 23 86 .9 6 0. 00 13 .0 4 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Pu- 239 +2 40 C d- 10 9 Pb- 210 25 1 21 42 .8 6 14 .2 9 42 .8 6 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4, 5, 7 C s-1 37 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Cs-13 4; Cs-1 37
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34 25 2 16 93 .7 5 0. 00 6. 25 Gam m aTrac M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C d- 10 9 25 3 19 84 .2 1 0. 00 15 .7 9 GEN IE 2 00 0 V3 .1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 5, 7 U- 23 8 Pb- 210 Pb- 210 25 4 18 77 .7 8 11 .1 1 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 Pb- 210 25 5 16 50 .0 0 0. 00 50 .0 0 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; M n-54
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 25 6 15 40 .0 0 6. 67 53 .3 3 GEN IE 2 000 Selective standard nucl id es 7 Am -24 1; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0; Zn-65
Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; Zn -6 5 25 7 18 83 .3 3 5. 56 11 .1 1 SPU N AL M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2 C s-1 37; K -4 0 25 8 14 42 .8 6 0. 00 57 .1 4 Soft ware s pecially pr ep ar ed fo r the Lab orato ry w or ks
Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2 C s-1 37; K -4 0
Am -24 1; Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 25 9 16 87 .5 0 12 .5 0 0. 00 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 7 26 0 20 90 .0 0 0. 00 10 .0 0 GEN IE 2 000 Selective standard nucl id es 1, 7 Am -24 1 C d- 10 9 26 1 16 81 .2 5 6. 25 12 .5 0 Gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 C d- 10 9; C o- 60 26 2 18 88 .8 9 0. 00 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 26 3 16 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Gam m a Vision an d Gespecor M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 26 4 18 88 .8 9 11 .1 1 0. 00 Gam m a Vi si on 6. 07 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 4, 7 26 5 18 83 .3 3 5. 56 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 Am -24 1 Zn- 65
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 26 8 17 17 .6 5 41 .1 8 41 .1 8 M AESTR O M at hem at ical app roach 2, 7 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 37; M n-5 4
Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 26 9 20 75 .0 0 20 .0 0 5. 00 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 7 C s-1 34 27 0 19 57 .8 9 15 .7 9 26 .3 2 Gam m a Vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 4 , 5, 6, 7 U- 23 4; U- 23 8 C d- 10 9 C s-1 34; Zn -6 5 27 1 8 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 NR NR NR 27 2 18 94 .4 4 5. 56 0. 00 W in ner 6 .0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 27 3 4 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Ak Wi n Selective standard nucl id es 27 5 18 88 .8 9 11 .1 1 0. 00 Geni e-VM S M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 27 7 16 75 .0 0 0. 00 25 .0 0 Gam m avi si on- 32 ver . 5. 1 ( E G & G ) M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1; C s-1 34 27 8 18 61 .1 1 16 .6 7 22 .2 2 spect ra n AT M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9; Z n- 65 C d- 10 9; Z n- 65 27 9 18 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 GAM M A -99 Selective standard nucl id es 2, 3, 5 , 7 28 0 17 52 .9 4 17 .6 5 29 .4 1 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Am -24 1; Zn -6 5 Co -6 0; Cs-1 34; M n- 54
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 28 1 15 53 .3 3 0. 00 46 .6 7 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Pb- 210; Zn -6 5 C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Zn-65 28 4 19 31 .5 8 21 .0 5 47 .3 7 G en ie2 000 an d Tricarb 2200CA soft ware M ul tinucl id e st anda rd NR C s-1 37; K -4 0 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Zn-65 Cd -1 09 ; Pb- 210 28 5 18 66 .6 7 22 .2 2 11 .1 1 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 C s-1 34 28 6 20 55 .0 0 15 .0 0 30 .0 0 Gam m aVi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 3, 7 C d- 10 9; M n- 54 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; C s-1 37; Zn -6 5 28 7 17 70 .5 9 23 .5 3 5. 88 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 M n- 54 28 8 20 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Int er wi nne r M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 5, 7 29 0 22 86 .3 6 4. 55 9. 09 Gam m a Vi si on -3 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 Sr- 90 Pb- 210 29 1 21 61 .9 0 19 .0 5 19 .0 5 Gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 4 , 7 U- 23 4; U- 23 8 M n- 54; Zn -6 5 29 2 18 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Int er Wi nne r 4. 1. M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 7 29 3 21 85 .7 1 4. 76 9. 52 WI NN ER 6. 0 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 Am -24 1 C s-1 34 29 5 20 80 .0 0 5. 00 15 .0 0 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 6, 7 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 29 6 20 80 .0 0 10 .0 0 10 .0 0 NR M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 Pu- 238; Sr -9 0 29 7 24 83 .3 3 8. 33 8. 33 Gam m a vi si on 6. 01 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 K- 40 M n- 54 29 9 18 77 .7 8 0. 00 22 .2 2 Geni e2 00 0 M at hem at ical app roach 2 Sr- 90 C s-1 34 Am -24 1; Zn -6 5 30 0 17 35 .2 9 23 .5 3 41 .1 8 Gam m aVision -3 2 V5 .3 1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 Am -24 1; Pb- 210 Co -6 0; Cs-1 37; M n- 54; Zn -6 5 30 2 16 56 .2 5 0. 00 43 .7 5 NR NR NR C d- 10 9; P b-2 10 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5 30 4 18 83 .3 3 11 .1 1 5. 56 VIS U G AM M A M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 30 5 20 80 .0 0 0. 00 20 .0 0 LSR M -2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 6, 7 Pu- 239 +2 40 C d- 10 9 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 30 6 18 61 .1 1 0. 00 38 .8 9 Si le na EM C A PLUS Ot he r 1, 2, 3 , 7 Cd -1 09 ; Co -6 0; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 30 7 15 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 Gam m a Vi si on 6. 00 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 30 8 19 36 .8 4 5. 26 57 .8 9 Gam m aVi si on -3 2 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 7 K- 40 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 37; M n-5 4; Pb -21 0; Zn-6 5
Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; Cs- 13 4; P b-2 10
Nuclides need correc tive ac tions La b. code
Number of repor ted results
% A
% W
% N Gamm a Softw are Method of effi ciency calibration Applied correcti ons Spinac h Soil Water 30 9 14 35 .7 1 0. 00 64 .2 9 NUC L E US PC A I II M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 Co -6 0; Cs-1 37; Zn-65 Am -24 1; Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; M n-5 4 31 0 19 89 .4 7 0. 00 10 .5 3 W in Q, ve rsi on 1. 2 Selective standard nucl id es 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 C s-1 34 31 1 19 10 0. 00 0. 00 0. 00 INT E R G AM M A M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 3 , 7 31 2 5 60 .0 0 20 .0 0 20 .0 0 NR NR NR M n- 54 31 6 16 75 .0 0 0. 00 25 .0 0 NR NR NR Cd -1 09 ; C s-1 34; P b- 21 0 Pb- 210 31 7 17 82 .3 5 5. 88 11 .7 6 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 2, 6, 7 C s-1 34 C s-1 34 31 8 16 87 .5 0 6. 25 6. 25 gam m a vi si on M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 5 , 7 C d- 10 9 31 9 19 73 .6 8 15 .7 9 10 .5 3 Inter W in ne r V ersio n 4. 1 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 C s-1 34 32 0 18 44 .4 4 22 .2 2 33 .3 3 GEN IE 2 000 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 K- 40 C d- 10 9; C s-1 34 C s-1 34; M n-5 4; Zn-65 32 1 16 31 .2 5 37 .5 0 31 .2 5 GEN IE 2 000 Ot he r 1, 2, 7 C s-1 37; K -4 0 C d- 10 9 M n- 54; Zn -6 5 32 2 16 68 .7 5 18 .7 5 12 .5 0 M aest ro 32 M ul tinucl id e st anda rd 1, 2, 7 C d- 10 9 C s-1 34
APPENDIX II. PERFORMANCE EVALUATION TABLES SORTED BY
Dans le document
Worldwide Open Proficiency Test on the Determination of Radionuclides in Spinach, Soil and Water | IAEA
(Page 38-68)