Appendix Tables

T... A-l:PubIi< _ .Slatistics

0'

Arrico by Sub·Regi.os, 1988-91

,-1987 ," ^{1988 1989 1990 1991' 1992}

COlIIftI'/drica '

_("<>fGOI') 15 14.5 14.4 15 15.9 14

TftdoT,-,(ll\ of ...) 50.45 44.89 46.28 55.5 65.15 62.21

Bxpondib.",(II!af.GOp) 21.7 21.3 19,8 21.\ 21.3 24,8

Cllrnlllllxp. (" afExp.nditu...) n.• n.• n.a n.• D.' D••

CopiIaIIIxp.(!Iiof Exp.ndltu...) D.' n.e n.e D.' n.a _D.'

Bud...Deficit(lliaf GOp) 6.7 6.8 5.3 6.1 5.4 10.1

Externalfinancin. of deficit (lI) 72.47 81.3 99 99 68.36 64.46

DomolticfinlDCinaof deficit(t.) 27.53 18.7 31.64 35.5.

Nanb Alii••

llovoauo(!liofGOP) 16 29.2 28.9 27.8 29.1 29.1

Trido TaXU:(~'ofrevenue) 28.06 52.2 21.36 54.81 60.19 63

Bxpondlture(lliofGOI') 17.7 44'.1 41.5 32.2 33.6 34.7

CUnelllExp.(llioflIxponditu...) 61.6 62.1 52.8 70.• 72 71.1

Capilalllxp.(!Iiof,E..,.nditure) 38.4 37.9 47.2 29.6 28 21.9

1IudptDefi.i.JlIi, 9f <lOP) 1.7 15.6 12.6 4.4 •• 5 ·4.9

.BxtemaJtina~I.s:aa~ofdeficit(%) 23.3 31.\ 24.2 53.6 38 27.1

DomNtic tinancina of deficit('l') 76,7 68.9 75.8 46.4 62 72.9

SouthAllioa

Rov....(lliof!GOp) 16.9 24.6 25 24.8 28.2 30.6

Tndo Taxe'_(~.ofrevenue) 47.4 38.89 28.02 25.65 22.17 27.73

ExpoadilliiO(lIi'Df GOp) 22 31.5 32.9 34.1 37.4 40

CIIrnaIElqi. (lliof Exponditu,.) 80 77.6 76.9 78.r 76.1 58.4

CapitalB:iP.(lliof Exponditure) 20 22.4 23.1 21.4 22.9 22.2

1IudptDeficl. (lliof GDp) 5.1 6.9 7.9 9.3 9.2 9.4

_I

fibanol"ll of d.ficit (lIi) 68.7 48.5 42.1 39.6 36.6 45.8

~Ilicfiuocina: of deficit(%) 28.3 51.5 57.9 60.4 63.' 5•.2

WoatAtlioa

Ilovonu.(lliof GOPL 16.' 13.8 13.9 16.3 16.8 17.6

T... T.... (lIiof ...v....) 46.25 40.89 26.23 37.69 46.7 35.17

Bxponditu...(lliaf GDp) 21.3 21.8 21.4 23.3 19.7 22.5

CUnealExp.(lliof Exp.nditure) 72.9 72.9 70.8 69.4 73.5 73

CapitalExp.(lliof Expond;'.",) 27.1 27.1 28.2 30.6 26.5 25.1

1IlJd...Defi.i.(lliof GOp) 4.9 8 7.5 7 2.9 4.9

_malfibanoi., ofd.fi.it (lIi) 78,2 54.1 71.6 55.1 99 60.7

Do?1Iiefinancin, of deficit(Ii) 21.8 45.9 28.4 44.9 I 39.3

D.'~Notavai1abJ&

C~weiabuarenotappliedtand oil tans arenot included inthe trade taxes

n..re bilit)'ofthe ...tittle.itnotguaranLacd Souroe:Computed fromUN-BCAdata bank

Monetarv oalicv

"'...1""''''

V' 0' A r ^o' Y' 0' A r ^o'

Perf",' . .nltaImnbilitv ^{. .}

...

^{, ..., IM}w" roJ• "'.

~ ! ! t ~ ~ ._____________________________

--+--

^_t._

^.t.

^-_:.

.. ^...

^·

. r.: .

^.:

.. .

^{,;.- --"';.}

. ---

^+...

Fordeindexation. '. ••+.-

.t._

^1-

..t._

^{· +}

•t •. .t•. ...t.

⁺

.... . ... ^_-- ... _ ... --.--- ^{... ...} .- ^..

_.--HomeiN1eY-tion 0 I O· 0 O. +

... -

^{+ +}

III. .J~.IM^{•••roJ'} (holtt~^{Dlrl .'}

.~~~~~--._

... ^{__ ..} --. __ .. -_ ... -

^__0._

^.s,

^{_!i. ••0__} _ p o ,⁰ -~+.- .-'-0

. ....

0 ...:to. ^~

__o....,

~inde.adon

..

^.~-_

... ^_ ...

^_

... - ... - ... -._ .. ....

0

- ^..

0

.s, ^....

⁰

.2•. ^{. ...}

⁺

--.-

^{+ ..~}_+~- ••'t•• ^{1iII• • •+}

Homeiadexation 0 0 0 0 0 + +

·

^{+ +}

""''''' ...IM_.mIP

1"'';/...1

JrJ!~_~~~______________________________

._+-- ~.--⁰ • !i.

..t. ..

^0_-

.:_- ----

⁰

^{- ...}

^{0 .jo.- _..0_ • '1}

,~~l!i~~~L~._.

___•___••••___••___•••• _{_.t.}

_{~_:}

.. ^{•r, .•t .} . :.- . ^:.-

^_t••

^{. t •. ...t •.}

^{,~ -},

^.J;;.-:

^I;;

HomoindeXltion 1-

.

₊ 1- 1- 1- 1- · _..

...

1-

,

Zero canital mobWtv

" ' _• •''',,"w," "".

Fixedvi~a . . . ..t.

..t•

^{1- a}

.

^.;;

..

^{••+.- + + ••0..••}

^.

... . ..•...••..• -- ^...

^_~_

^{.. _-_.-}

^~

... _"' .... ^. _. ^_ ...

._--~~~!~~~t~~_.____._.._..___.._._____

_.t.

_{_!.-~-!. ~._a_. -;.-}

--+-- ^_t.

^{.t__ _}

..

^0,;.

^.. .':._'

Home indexation + + + a · + + + 0

.

" ,-,

7

Fbtod , ' ... flo.";' " ..1 ^.

~~.~~._--

..._ ...

-~.--_._-_.

..t.

•!!.- •9• .."t. _

. ^__

⁰

^.. .t..

_-~

. _{.-.. ...}

^{a + .~}

..

~~I!~~~~_.----_

..._-_..._---_....-

^{_.of: ... .t._ _t_ ._"':.}

--.-

^{+ ~_.+.-~.t. _:t__ ..'t•.}

-j"--Homeindention '. 1- +

.

_{+ + + + · + +}

~., , "". If.NiP" ...1

' '..

F'lXedwW,a + a 0

•.t . .s.

^{••+••}

•2. .g.

^{+ 0}

~...

.. ....•... - ... - ... .... .... .... . ... -._ ^.

.~i~~~~~_.__.._._.•____..__.._____ _{+ + + + + + + + + +}

--- ---- --- .-

^....

--Home indexation

+ + - + + + + -

^.+

+

I

yd =domestic output

r:

= foreign. output r: =domestic pnces

p. '"foreign prices . h:=exchange rate

Source: Adapted from Mckibbin and Sachs (1991:21)

1---Table A-3: Commodity Composl!ion of ArrieJl',ExpoltJ(1m}

EIIC' Prt."Q' Come!, ^{Mannl ,Mi}r

, AJFda

95 0.6 4.4

CealroI Amc,nRep. ^{55 42 3}

Chad 11 ^{84 3.6 1.4}

COIIlOI'OI

c....,o ^{91 4.6 4.4}

Coled'Ivoire 6.5 82 10.9 0.6

Djiboud 52 12 36

SiernLeono ^{5.1 80 11.6 2.2}

Somalia ^{2,4 97 .•}

Source: Computed from African Developmenl Bank (J993) fables.

Table A-4:S/uu'eof Ml\lor African Commodity Exports in World ExPorts

Average 1970-79(%) Average 1980-87(\Il) Percentaaecbanae betweenlint andaecond

7he.hares were calculated with data from UNCTAD, Commodity Yearbook (various issues) Source: Elbadawi,

et.

al. (1992, p. 40)

Tal!1eA-5: WorldSharesof Agricultural Commodity Exports forSSA and other Developi"ll Regions: 1,!~.

85.

LOCs ^SSA America South& South

tf:'

_.__•__••••_ (%) _ . _

Table A..(i: Comparative Statistics on Aid and EconomicPerformance, 1980-88, Sllb,-Saharan 8therc' ,

Atrica ev, ountnes

Aid Indicators:

~~r~~~g:ltaiJlcome ~198 3.:,~

~~::

1:=1

~f ~r&0m. ^mvestment: ~H ~ ~

Performance indicators (annual rates of change)

i k _ m p t i o n

II UI

Figures relate to net disbursements of overseas development assistance from all sources.

Source:KilIick(1992: 201)

1---,'. .,' ^"

! _~ 5 ! =

§

! , ! _~ , _{~ ~} = ^! ~ = I ; ! ! i U; _~ i ~ ~ ,

. -~

.

! ! ; ! ! 5 ! ! ! _{~ ~ ~ ~} 5 ! , ; ; _{~ ~} S ; _~ I : = ; _{~ ~}

' . ' .. ' ' ' ' : ' - , ' .

"

•

D

li

~j-I

"

J

{' \'. ,

,

"

;'~

I '"

^{,. r:'}

It>

~. ^I

"

c::>

CD

g ! ! !

~ ~

!

~

!

~,

!

~

, !

~ ~

;

~ ~

,

~ ~

=

~

I I , ,.

;.;

,f;!

II.. 8 Ii ' 4 4

..-, ^..'~

:!_." .0" . -

::

^~

T8bIe C·1 :DeiIlIIIIoIaor EXIElINAlDEBT FORGIVENESS shockfrom BASEUNE (FlEX) V8flIlon With FI8IcibIe Exchange ^IlIle In the DOe)

INDEBTED DEVELOPING COUNTRIES

I

'11---i.'

Referent8$

·'t···

'-';Adedeji, A. (1988), What ProspectS for African Economic Recovro1, Uriited Nations

£C6nOmic Commission for Africa, Addis Ababa.

,..:~,:J

Aghevli, B.B., M.S. Khan, P. Narvekar, and B. short, (1979), "Monetary-Policy in Selected Asian Countries", IMF Staff Papers, 26 (4).

:/"Aghevli,'B.B, M.S. Khan, and P.IMontiel, (1991), "Exchange Rate Policyin Developing Countri~s: Some Analytical Issues", IMF OCcasional Paper No. 78

Andie, F.M., S. Andie, and LT. De Alonso (1990), "An Exploration into theFeasibility of an Export Tax Revenue Stabilization Fund", in V. Tanzi, ed., Fisca1Po'iRY InQpen Develgpjpi Economies. International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.

~.,;.'• '):.:', : j. .. :';.... ;!

. ··ArtaU;

1'.

and S. Claessens (1992), "Commodity Stabilization Funds", Policy Research Working Papers, WPS 835, The World Bank, Washington, DC.,

"Balassa,B. (1983), "Policy Responses to External Shocks in Sub-Saharan African

Countries", JOurnal of Policy MOOeHn!:, 5 (1), pp.75-105.

'Balassa, B. (1984), "Adjustment Policies and Development Strategies in Sub-Saharan Africa, 1973-1978", in M. Syrquin, et al (eds) Economit Structur¢"'al1dPerfoonance, Academic Press Inc, New York.

Balassa, B. (1990), "Incentive Policies and Export Performance in Sub-Saharan Africa",

World DeyeJopmc;nt, vol. 18, No.3, pp.383-39J.

Bevan, D., P. Collier, and l.W. Gunning (1990), "Temporary ShQeks and Dynamic Adjustment", AWlied Economics Discllssion Paper Series, No. 93, Institute of Economics arid'S\i1tistics; Oxford.'

-"'Bevan, D., P. Collier, and l.W. Gunning (1991), "The Macroeconomics of External Shocks" ,in V.N. Balasubramanyam and S. Lall, eds, Current Issues In Deye\OJ1rnent Economies, Macmillan, London

Bevan,D.; P. Collier, and l.W. Gunning (1992a), "Nigerian Economic Policy-and Performance: 1981-92", rnimeo, Centre for the Study of African Economies, University-of Qxford .

. Bevaa, D:, P . Collier;andl.W. Gunning (l992b), Nigeria: Policy Response" to:Shoe!cs.

1970=1990, An International Center for -Economic Growth Publication, ICS Press, San

Francisco.

).-,,' B~k, S.W. (1981), "The Impact of Changes in the World Economy on Stabilization Poli.ci~ in tJieJ979~.:~.jn W.R. Cline and S, Weintraub, eds, Bc0n()mic Stabilizatjonjn DevelOJljne Countries, The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC. . . -. . _,~

,~fYant.

RC.

and C.C. Soludo (I993), "The Consequences of

u.s

Fiscal Actions in a Global Model with Alternative Assumptions About the Exchange RegimeIn, Developing Countries', expected in D. Vines and D. Currie, eds, Macroeconomic InteractionsBetween

the

Industrial

and

DevelOJline Countries (?), April 1994.

" .., . .. :.. ;J~'

Camdessus, M. (1987), "Opening Remarks" in V. Corbo, M. Goldstein, and M. Khan, eds, GTlJlItl!-Oriented AdjustmentProerams, International Monetary Fund,Wa~hingtQn,DC.

Chu,K. (1989), "External Shocks and Fiscal Adjustment in Developing Countries: ReCent Bxperiences", in Blejer,

t.1.l.

and K. Chu, (eds) Fiscal Policy, Stabilization, and Growth in Developing Countries", International Monetary Fund, Washington: PC, '. .

Collier, P. (June 1993), "Trade Shocks: Consequences and Policy Responses, Theory

aila

Bvidenc;e from Africa, Asia and Latin America", mimeo, Centre for the Study of African Economies, University of Oxford.

Cooper,R.N.(~971) "Currency Devaluation in Developing Countries", in G. ~~~t(ed.)

Government and Economic Development, New Haven, Yale University Press; .• ',.

,CQOper,R.N.(199n,,,Ex~momicStabjlizationin Develol2ing Countries. OCcasional Paper No. 14, International Center for Economic Growth, ICS Press, .SanFrancisco.. ".'.. . __,\ i. .' . . ' . .

.. Fajana, F.O. (1993) "Nigeria's Debt crisis", Development Research PaIJer Sm, No.

I~! UnitedNations Economic Commission for. Africa. .i.. . .

Fleming, J.M. (1962) "Domestic Financial Policies under Fixed and Floating Exchange Rates", Staff Papers. vol. 9: 369-80, International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.

i

-/

~

Ghai, D. (1991), ed., The IMF and The SQuth: The SCX;ijll Impact Qf Crisis and Adjustment, ZedBooks Ltd, London.

Gupta, S. and K. Miranda (1991), "Commodity Booms and Government Expenditure Responses", IMF Workim: Paper, WP/9I144, International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.

Isard, P. (1988), "Exchange Rate Modeling: An Assessment of Alternative Approaches", in R.C. Bryant, et al, eds, Empirical Macroeconomics for Interdependent Bconornies", The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.

Killick, T. andJ. Sharpley (1984), "Extent, Causes and Consequences of Disequilibria", in T. Killick, ed., The Ouest for Economic StabilizatiQn: The IMF and The Third WQrld, Heinemann, London.

Killick, T. (1992), "Just HQW Important Is Finance for African Development?", in 1.G.

Patel, ed., Polici~s for African Deye1Qpment: From 1980s to the 1990s. International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.

Krueger, A.a. (1981), "Interactions between Inflation and Trade Regime Objectives in Stabilization Programs", in W.R. Cline and S. Weintraub, eds, Economic S~j1ization in

DeveIQPiDl~ Countries, The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC. '

Krueger, A.O. (1993), Economic Policies at Cross-PurPOses: The United _S~tes and Deye10ping Countries, The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC. ., '

Linn, J.F. and D. Wetzel (1990), "Public Finance, Trade, and Development: What Have WeLearned?", in V. Tanzi, ed., Fiscal PQlicy In Open Develooing EcQnomies, International

Monetary Fund, Washington, DC. . . ' ) ,

Mansfield, C.Y. (1980), "A Norm for Stabilizing Budget Policy in 'Less Developed , Export Economies", Journal of Development Studies, Vol. 16,pp.401-11. '

, Mansur, A.H, and D.J. Robinson (1989), "Transmission of Effects of the ElSca\Deficit in Industrial Countries to the Fiscal Deficit of Developing Countries", in Blejer,M.l;.and K. Chu, (eds) Fiscal Policy, Stabilization, and Growth in Developing Countries", International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.

Masson, P .• S.,Symansky, and G. Meredith (1990), "MULTIMOD Mark II: A

i~ised

and Extended Model", IMF Occasional Paper No. 71, Washington, DC.

Mckibbin,W. and

r.n.

Sachs (1991), GIQbal Linkag\J$:MacrQeconomic Interdependence and Coo.peution in the World ECQnomy, The Brookings Institution, Washirig~n,DC.

Mundell, R.A. (1963) "Capital Mobility and Stabilization Policy under Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates", Canadian Journal of Economic and Political Scjence, 29: 475-485.

".c. .

Mundell, R.A. (1968) International EconQmics, Macmillan.

66

. Muscatelli, A. and D. Vines(1989), "Macroeconomic Interactions Between the North and South", in R.C. Bryant, D.A. Currie, et al (eds) Macroeconomic Policies in<,lln Interdependent World", The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC. . ..

.;Musgnlve, P.B. and J. Desormeaux (1981), "Stabilization and Development with.

Fluctuating Export Earnings", in R.A. Musgrave, ed., Fiscal Reform in Boliyia: Final Report of $be Bolivian Mission onTaxReform, Harvard University Press, Massachusetts.

Ndulu, B. (1992), "Resource Gaps and Financing for Growth in Africa", in I.G. Patel, ed, Policies for African DevelOJ)ment: From 1980s to the 1990s, International Mone\8rY Fund, Washington, DC.

,Policy Research Department, The World Bank (June 1993), Adjustment in Sub-Saharan Africa: ProiTeSS. Payoffs. and Challenges; Draft Policy Research Report Number 2, The World Bank, Washington, DC.

,Powell, A. (l993), "Commodity Stabilization Funds: A Review of Selective Issues";

Paperpresented at the CEPR conference on 'Macroeconomic Interactions between Northanci South', University of Oxford.

Ri,edel, J. (1987),. Myths and Reality of External Constraints on Development, Trade Policy Research Centre, London.

. $h~ey, J. (1984), "The Potential of Domestic Stabilization Measures", in T. Klllick,

I

ed., The Quest for Economic Stabilization; The IMF and The Third World, Heinemann, ' London.

Soludo, C.C. (1992), "North-South Macroeconomic Interactions: ComparativeAnalysi~

Using the MULTIMOD and INTERMOD Global Models", Brookin&s Discussion Papers in International F,s;onQmil<s, No. 95, The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC. ...

Soludo, C.C. (1993a) , "Simulating Global Policy Scenarios: The Effects ofAlternative LDC Closure Rules", A paper presented at a CEPR international conference on 'North-South Macroeconomic Interactions' at the Institute of Economics and Statistics, Oxford University,

April 23/24. ^!

Soludo, C.C. (1993b), "Macroeconomic Adjustment, Trade and Growth in an Interdependent World: Policy Analysis Using A Macroeconomic Model of Nigeria", final

~ch report submitted to the African Economic Research Consortium, Nairobi.

Soludo, C.C. (1993c) "Growth Performance in Africa: Further Evidence on the External Shocks Versus Domestic Policy Debate", Paper prepared for publication under the Develo,pment Rf}5^Pf1mh Paper Series, United Nations Economic Commission for Africa, Addis Ababa. .

Sundb~rg,

M. (1988), "TheTransmission of fiscal policy shocks to developing

co~ntries~

Preliminary Simulation Results", Mimeo, June.

~I""i

-Sundberg, M. (1990), The International Transmission of Macroeconomic Policy Disturbance Amoni Countries of the pacific Basin, Draft Ph.D thesis, Harvard University.

Svedberg, J. (1991), "The Export Performance of Sub-Saharan Africa", Economic Deye!opment and Cultural Change, vol 39; No.3: 549-64.

Symansky, S. (1991a), "Closure Rules and A New Developing Country Region for MULTIMDD", Paper presented at the conference on "Global Interdependence: Theories and Models of the Linkages Between DECD and Non-DECO Economies", held in Seoul, South Korea, May 27-2~.

Symansky, S. (1991b), "Changes to MULTlMDD since July 1990 Occasional Paper No.

71", July 1991, Mimeo.

Tanzi, V. (1989), "Fiscal Responses to Exogenous Shocks in Developing Countries", in Blejer, M.1. and K. Chu, (eds) Fiscal Policy, Stabilization, and Growth in Developing Countries", International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.

Taylor, L. (1981), "IS/LM in the Tropics: Diagrammatics of the New StructuralistMacro Critique", in W.R. Cline and S. Weintraub, eds, Economic Stabilization in DeveIoojn&

Countries. The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.

& ^{Author Title Date}

1 Mamou Kouyate-Ehui Optimal Pricing Model for Primary Commodities April 1992 in Developing Countries: An Application to the

Cocoa Subsector in Cllte d'lvoire and Ghana (Ref: ECAfSERPD/19911003)

2 Sylvanus Ikhide Financial Deepening, Credit Availability and the October 1992 Efficiency of Investment: Evidence from Selected

African Countries

(Ref: ECA/SERPD/1992/004)

3 H. M. A Onitiri Devaluation and Structural Adjustment: The November 1992 Nigerian Experience

(Ref; ECA/SERPD/1992/006)

4 Osman Mohammed Salama The Food Gap in Egypt December 1992

(Ref: ECA/SERPD/1992/008)

S F. Olufemi Fajana Nigeria's Debt Crisis May 1993

(Ref: ECA/SERPD/1993/009)

6 Charles Chulcwuma Soludo Growth Performance in Africa: Further Evidence November 1993 on the External Shocks Versus Domestic Policy

Debate

(Ref: ECA/SERPDII993/011)

7 Gietan Rusibane Le Comportement de l'lnvestissement December 1993

Prive au Burundi et au Rwanda (Ref: ECA/SERPDII993/020)

Dans le document Implications of alternative macroeconomic policy responses to external shocks in Africa (Page 60-73)