HAL Id: jpa-00246956
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00246956
Submitted on 1 Jan 1994
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Characterization of the Fermi surface of BEDT-TTF4[
Hg2Cl6] .PhCl by electronic band structure calculations
Luis Veiros, Enric Canadell
To cite this version:
Luis Veiros, Enric Canadell. Characterization of the Fermi surface of BEDT-TTF4[ Hg2Cl6] .PhCl by electronic band structure calculations. Journal de Physique I, EDP Sciences, 1994, 4 (6), pp.939-947.
�10.1051/jp1:1994237�. �jpa-00246956�
Classification Physics Absb.acls
71.25P 71.45L
Characterization of the Fermi surface of BEDT.
TTF4[Hg~cl~].Phcl by electronic band structure calculations
Luis F. Veiros
(')
and Enric Canadell(2)
(~) Centro de Quimica Estrutural,
Departamento
de Engenhana Quimica, InstitutoSuperior
Tecnico, P-1096 Lisboa Codex, Portugal(2) Laboratoire de Chimie
Théorique
(*), Université de Paris-Sud, 91405 Orsay Cedex, France(Received 19 November 1993, ievised 2 Februaiy 1994, act.epted15 Februaiy 1994)
Abstract.
Tight-binding
band structure calculations for the room temperature structure ofBEDT-TTF41Hg2CI6"Phcl
show the existence of closed electron and hale Fermi surfaces, in agreement with the 2D metallicconductivity
of this sait. It is shown that these closed Fermi surfaces result from thehybridization
of two hidden lD Fermi surfaces. However, ourstudy
aise shows that a transition associated with either a usual or a hiddennesting
type mechanism isunhkely.
Thisexplams
why this sait retains its metallic properties without anyresistivity anomaly
down to 1.3 K. Our study suggests that
BEDT-TTF41Hg2C16"Phcl
is a somewhat anisotropic 2D semimetal and should exhibit Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations corresponding to a cross-sectionalarea of
approximately
13 fb of the first Brillouin zone.Charge
transfer salts of the orgamc donor moleculebis(ethylenedithio)-tetrathiafulvalene (BEDT-TTF, 1)
have led to more than twentysuperconductors Il -3].
However,superconduc- tivity usually
competes with different electronic instabilities which canpartially
ortotally destroy
the metallic properties of many of thesecharge
transfer salts. Some of these instabilities arelargely
determmedby
thetopology
of the Fermi surface. It seems quite clearby
now
[1-3]
that even minor modifications in thecrystal
structure of these salts can havelarge
effects on their Fermi surface and
hence,
on theirphysical properties. Thus,
there is a need to understand how thecrystal
structure and Fermi surface of these salts are related. For thisS s s ~
= l
~~~s~ ~s~l~~
BEDT-TiF
(*) CNRS URA 506.
940 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE I N° 6
purpose extended Hückel
tight-binding
band structure studies have been ofmajor
value[4].
Recently, magnetoresistance
studies onhigh purity crystals
of BEDT-TTF salts havegiven
important informationconcerning
the Fermi surface of some of theseorganic
metals[5-7].
However, fuit
exploitation
of these results is sometimes difficult without aprevious knowledge
of the
general shape
of the Fermi surface. Ingeneral,
the main results of themagnetoresistance
studies are in excellent
agreement
with the calculated extended Hückel Fermi surfaces.Thus,
extended Hückel studies of the Fermi surface of BEDT-TTF metallic salts are notonly
usefulin
understanding
theorigin
of their transportproperties
but aise inproviding
a basis for theinterpretation
of the magnetoresistance measurements and inbuilding
a link between the Fermi surface and thecrystal
structure.Recently, Lyubovskaya
et ai.[8]
havereported
thesynthesis
of a serres oforganic charge
transfer sains with the
general
formulaBEDT-TTF~,[HgX~]~
PhX(X
=
Cl, Br).
Four of these salts are menais at roomtemperature [8-9]. However,
their low temperature behaviour seems todepend
on the nature of the anion and the solvent. Forinstance,
whereas BEDT-TTF4[Hg~clô].Phcl
is a metal down to 1.3 K[8-10], BEDT-TTF41Hg~Brô].PhBr undergoes
a metal to semiconductor transition at 125 K
Il Ii
Here we report our results conceming theelectronic band structure and Fermi surface of
BEDT-TTF41Hg2Cl~].Phcl
for which thecrystal
structure has beenrecently reported by D'yachenko
et ai.Il 0].
Ourtight-binding
bandstructure calculations
[12]
use an extended Hückel Hamiltonian[13]
and adouble-(
basisset
[14]
for ail atoms excepthydrogen.
It tums out thatBEDT-TTF4[Hg2Clô].Phcl
has apecuhar
Fermi surface and it is alikely
candidate for the observation ofangular magnetoresist-
ence oscillations.
Crystal
structure and donor donor interactions.The
crystal
structure ofBEDT-TTF4[Hg~cl~].Phcl loi
containslayers
of the donor BEDT-TTF molecules
altemating along
the a direction withlayers
of the[Hg~clô]2-anions.
Theaurons occur as dimeric units and two ends of the dimer make a weak interaction with a solvent
molecule
leading
to[Hg~cl~ Phcl](
units. Aperspective
view of a donor moleculelayer
ofBEDT-TTF4[Hg~clô].Phcl (in
thecrystallographic
bcplane)
is shown infigure
la~ Each donor molecule offigure
la is viewedapproximately along
the direction of its central C=C bond. The repeat unit of this slab containseight
donor molecules pairwise relatedthrough
inversion centers,
resulting
m four symmetryinequivalent
BEDT-TTF molecules(A, B,
C andD in
Fig. lb).
As can beeasily
seen fromfigure
la the four different BEDT-TTF moleculesbelong
to two different conformational types(A, C)
and(B, D).
Structurally,
the slab offigure1
can be described as a serres ofparallel
inclined stacks runningalong
the(b
+ c direction(hereafter designated
as the adirection).
The four differentBEDT-TTF molecules form a sequence B-A-C-D
along
the stack and every stack is related to itsadjacent
onesthrough
inversion centers.Altematively,
the slab offigure
can be descnbedas a serres of
step-chains running along
theydirection.
This arrangement gives rise to14different
types
of interactions between donor molecules: 4along
the adirection(ai.
a4 inFig.
lb andTab.1),
5along
the p direction(pj p~),
and 5along
the y direction(yj y~).
Short mtermolecular S... S contacts smaller than 3.85À (see
Tab.I)
are observed for both the
step-chains (.. yj-y~-y~..)
and the mclmed stacks(...
a -a~-a ~-a~
),
as well as for the w-type chains(... p~-p~-p j-p
~ running
along
the pdirection
(see Fig.
l).Despite
some differences in the intramolecular geometnes, the calculated energies of thehighest occupied
molecular orbital(HOMO)
of the four different BEDT-TTF molecules are very similar.Consequently,
the HOMO bands of the donor moleculelayers
will result from a strong mixing of the HOMOS of the four different donors. In order to discuss the rote of the'
£X' 7
' '
~f~
,'~~~Ù
1'
''~
/
~
~~Î~
'-"",C ,'
~ lj~
'~
~
1' "'
Ù/
~ i~
Ôl'
~~Î~
, /
~
', /
',
",
//
~ ~Î~~
/
"
", / '
~ ~
",,/
(a)
A c
= B D
la '-
l' '''-fi (
_~ / / '
~/ ~
-..,~___ ÷A
_.~'
,
, c
/~
2 '1[
~
/~
7~%
'/ D
~ i ; /
/~ Î~ fi"'Ù~"; Î
~/"~~..--. A
/~
13~( ( %/~
f,
",,
B~__~_
~o /Iii De
', j?"'~
' ''- /
', /
' '- /
(b)
Fig. l. la) Perspective view of a BEDT-TTF layer of
BEDT-TTF41Hg~CIô
Phcl. Each molecule is viewedapproximately along
its central C C bond. lb) Schematicrepresentation
offigure
lashowmg
the different types of molecules and donor., donor intermolecular interactions.
different types of chains in the transport properties of
BEDT-TTF4[Hg~Cl6l.Phcl,
wecalculated the
p~o~~_~o~~
interactionenergies[15] corresponding
to the 14differentdonor... donor interactions of the BEDT-TTF
layers.
The results arereported
in table I. The strongest interactionenergies
are those associated with thestep-chains running along
the ydirection
(0.21-0.30
eV). Even if the shortest sulfur... sulfur contacts are those of the chainsrunning along
the pdirection,
the w-type interactions between the HOMO orbitalsimposed by
the nature of these chains result in reduced interaction energies
(0.Il-0.15
eV). Theseinteractions are however
considerably
stronger than those within the inclined snacksalong
thea direction
(0.04-0.09 eV).
Thus, from the electronic viewpoint, the BEDT-TTF slabs ofJnLR~'L »F PHY~'QLL' T 4 ~ 6 JU'r1,'4 4
942 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE I N° 6
Table I. S... S distances smaller than 3.85
À
and absofute i,ali~esof
triep~o~o_~~~o
mteractmn eiieigies
(eV) foi-
thedij$eient
BEDT-TTF...BEDT-TTF inteiac.tioiis mBEDT-TTF~[Hg~cl~]
Phcl(see Fig.
lfor labelliiig).
Interaction type S S distances
(À) p~o~~_~~,j~
(eV)a-type
ai 3.820 0.045
a~
3.847,
3.855 0.059a~ 3.800, 3.841 0.085
a~
(4.023, 4.026)a
0.038P-type
pi 3.395,
3.403, 3.430, 3.514, 3.809 0.133p,
3.411(x 2),
3.589(x 2),
3.759(x 2)
0.148pî 3.463,
3.470,3.480, 3.534,
3.826 0.138p~
3.400, 3.479, 3.575, 3.576, 3.888 0.131p~
3.408(x 2),
3.616 (x2)
Ù-118y-type
vi
3.580, 3.647, 3.764,
3.840, 3.969 0.277Y2 3.599, 3.691,
3.716,
3.721 0.234Y~ 3.821 (x
2),
3.855 (x2),
3.856 (x2)
0.287Y4 3.725 (x
2),
3.779, 3.789 0.295y~ 3.676 (x
2),
3.853 (x2)
0.213id) Shortest S... S contacts of this interaction type.
BEDT-TTF41Hg~Clô].Phcl
seem to be best described as a series ofstep-chains along
the y direction interactingthrough
weaker w- and «-type contactsalong
the other directions of the slab.It is worth
pointing
out that the neatpartitioning
of thep
interaction energies of table in three groups is not apeculianty
of the present ~ystem, The interactionenergies
calculated forother BEDT-TTF slabs which
geometncally
can be considered to be built fromparallel
indined stacks like
BEDT-TTF~ReôSe~CI~[guest] (guest=DMF,
THF, dioxane)[16]
BEDT-TTF~XCI~, H~O (X
=
Ni [17a], Cu
[17b, ci)
orBEDT-TTF~[M(CN)~] (M
= Ni,
Pt)
Il 8],
ail have the same characteristics(a)
strong values(0.2-0.3 eV)
for the interactionsalong
the
step-chains, (b)
medium values(0.15-0.11 eV)
for the interactionsalong
the w-typechains,
and(c)
smaller values(<
0.1 eV for the interactionsalong
the inclined chains. This is in clearcontrast with the situation for the BEDT-TTF slabs built from
parallel
columnar snacks likeBEDT-TTF~ReO~ [19], p-BEDT-TTF~X (X
= I~, IBr~)
[lsa]
orBEDT-TTF41M(C204)il (M
= Cu, Pt)
[18],
for which the interaction energies associated with the donor,.. donorinteractions
along
the columnar chains arealways by
far the stronger ones.Thus,
ingeneral,
the columnar snacks are the natural
building
blocks for the second type of BEDT-TTFslabs,
butthey
are thestep-chains
which are the appropnate ones for the first type of BEDT-TTFslabs. A more detailed account of these results will be
presented
elsewhere[17b].
Thedistinction is however
important
in the context of the present work because it has akey
rote in the discussion ofpossible
hidden Fermi surfacenesting
mechanisms[18, 20].
Band structure and Fermi surface.
The
analysis
of the previous section makes clear that there are strong interactions between theBEDT-TTF HOMOS
along
thestep-chains
and that the interactions between those of thedifferent
step-chains
arequite
sizeable. This suggests thatBEDT-TTF~ [Hg~cl~
Phcl should be a somewhatanisotropic
two-dimensional(2D)
conductor. The repeat unit of the donor slabs containseight
BEDT-TTF molecules so that there will beeight
HOMO bands. With the formai oxidationrequired by
the stoichiometricformula, (BEDT-TTF )( +,
there are twelve electrons per unit cell to fill theeight
HOMO bands.Thus,
it is not clear if the system should be a 2Dsemiconductor or a 2D
menai,
i e., whether there is or non a band gap between the sixth andseventh HOMO bands. The calculated band structure for the BEDT-TTF slabs of
BEDT-TTF~[Hg~cl~]
Phcl is shown infigure
2a. It is clear that the sixth and seven bands (frombottom) slightly overlap
so that the system is a semimetal. The calculated Fermisurface,
shown infigure 2b,
contains electronpockets
centered at M(or
theequivalent point S)
and holepockets
centered at Z. Both the electron and holepockets
are closed so that the systemshould have 2D metalhc
conductivity,
in agreement with theexperimental
results.The Fermi surface of
figure
2b is quite unusual and contains a nestedportion.
As shown infigure
2c, this Fermi surface can bethought
of asoriginating
from the weakhybridization
of an almost ideal lD electron Fermi surfacealong
the(b*
+c*) direction,
and awarped
lD hole Fermi surfacealong
c*. Detailed examination of bands a and b infigure
2a shows that this isactually
the case. For instance,along
r~
M,
bands a and b result from aweakly
avoidedcrossing
between a very flan band and adispersive
one(The
intended bandcrossings
areindicated with dots m
Fig. 2a).
However, band a isquite dispersive along
the r~
S direction
(although
this is maskedby
the fact that whenraising
in energy the band intends to cross the two next bandsleading
to thebelly
appearance of the bandsalong
thisfine). Thus,
band a is an mtended 1D bandalong
a directionapproximately perpendicular
to the(b
* + c.* direction. If avoidedcrossings
wereignored,
this band would lead to the hidden ID Fermi surfacealong (b*
+c*)
offigure
2c. It is also easy to see that band b at rundergoes
an avoided crossing with band aalong
both r~ Y and r
~ Z. If these avoided crossings were
disregarded,
band bwould be a lD band
approximately perpendicular
to c*. However, thedispersion
of thisintended band b
along
r~ Z is greater than the
dispersion
of the intended band aalong
r ~ M. This means that band b is an intended
pseudo
1D band andconsequently,
as shown infigure
2c, its associated hidden lD Fermi surface will beslightly warped.
Once it is realized that the Fermi surface of
figure
2b can be deconvoluted into two 1D Fermi surfaces, two questions come into mind.First,
where are in the structure the chainsleading
to the two lD Fermi surfaces offigure
2c ?Second, why
the system seems to be immune to somekind of Peierls distortion associated with these hidden lD Fermi surfaces ? The chains in the
crystal
structure should beperpendicular
to the direction of the hidden lD Fermi surfaces.Neither the
step-chains
nor the w-type chains(1.e.,
the chains associated with the strong donor... donorinteractions)
fulfill this condition. Let us recall that there areeight
donormolecules per unit cell of the slab. Thus, there are
eight
bandsresulting
from the combinations of theeight
HOMOS of the unit cell. Theprevious
results mean that the nodal properties of atleast two of these
eight
combinations, must be such thatthey
make strong nearestneighbors
interactions
along only
one direction to grue use to the hidden lD Fermi surfaces, due mostlikely
to thespecial topology
of the lattice. Work is in progress toprobe
apossible relationship
between the
topology
of the lattice with inclmed stacks and the occurrence of hidden nesting.The nested portions in
figure
2b(1.e.,
the flat portionsparallel
to the b* + c*direction),
944 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE I N° 6
-8
uJ
-8
v r z r r
(a)
(b)
/ /
j' ,' / 1
' 1' ' >' ,' ' ' ,~
' ,~~>," ,' ~'i ,,' i r ~,
~ '
'/ ,
&' / ,' [,'
J~ '/ ~" ,,/ ' ,' ~n
,"( ,' ,Ô ,' ' ~" ,'/
," ,f'
,
,,' ',' ,'
,,~~,,'
'," ' ' ,' ,'( ' ,' ,t /
,' / ' ,' ' ,' ,' i /
'
,)", '
Î,"
" /,,'~
' ' ,' 'i ," ,' 1' ,'
' ~'
, ,,' , /" ,'
' / '' ' , é'
,' '/ >'
, , ,
' ,'/
"Î ,' ' ,,
' 'j
"','Î'
'"'ÎÀ"'," ,"'Î'
,' , , ,,
~' ' ' ,' l'
,
' /
,' )" ' ' "
' /~
, ," ," ,~' ,~ '
',' ,'
, ,' S' , , ,' , ,' ,'
~'
,'~'
/ ",f' '"',("
,'1 ' ' ,/ ,',
1','~
,,' ]" ,' ,,~>,' , ,,6 , ~/
,"'
' ,' ," ,'$ ,' ," (" '' ,' ,' >'
(c)
Fig.
2. (ai Dispersion relations for the HOMO bands of the donor slabsin
BEDT-TTF4 ÎHg~CI~ Phcl, where the dashed fine refers to the Fermi level. Dots are used to indicate the
intended band crossings discu~sed in the text. r, Y, Z, M and S refer to (0, 0). (h~/2, 0),
(0, t */2 ). (h*/2, c*/2 and (- h~/2, t */2 ), respectively. (b) Fermi surface associated with the partially filled bands of (a). (c) Hidden ID Fermi surfaces associated with (b).
represent
only
a moderate fraction of the Fermi surface. Thus thedriving
force for apenodic
lattice distortion is
probably
small.However,
ouranalysis
shows that the Fermi surface offigure
2b can beapproximately
deconvoluted into two lD Fermi surfaces. In such cases, it is essential toanalyze
if aperiodic
lattice distortion(or
even aspin density wave)
associated witha hidden
nesting
mechanism[18,
20,21]
can occur. The concept of hidden Fermi surfacenesting [20]
is that some weak local structuralchanges, possibly slight displacements
of the BEDT-TTF moleculesperpendicular
to the stack direction, orslight
rotations of the BEDT- TTFmolecules,
canmodify
the relativemagnitudes
of the transferintegrals, affecting
thedimensionality
of the system andultimately leading
to the appearance of the otherwise hidden nested Fermi surfaces. Essential for this mechanism is that the energygained by
thepenodic
lattice distortion (or the
spin density wave)
associated with the hiddennesting
more than compensates the energy needed for the reduction of the interstack interactions. Thus,only
when the system is
structurally prepared
toreadjust
the Fermi surface withjust
minor structuralchanges,
it willundergo
the structural transitionstabilizing
this hiddennesting
vector.BEDT-TTF~ReO~
seems to be a systemundergoing
a Peierls distortionthrough
this type ofmechanism
[20]. However,
there are three reasonswhy
this mechanism isunlikely
to beeffective in
BEDT-TTF~ [Hg~cl~
Phcl.First,
thehybridization
gaps between the two hiddenID Fermi surfaces are
quite
sizeable.Second,
it has beenrecently argued [18]
that,independently
of themagnitude
of thehybridization
gaps, BEDT-TTF slabs built from columnar stacks arestructurally prepared
to sustain a hidden nesting type mechanism but this isnon the case for those built from inclined columnar snacks. These two observations lead to the conclusion that the
energetic
cost forreadjustment
of the Fermi surface will bequite
important.Third, there is no common
nesting
vector for the two hidden 1D Fermi surfaces.Consequently,
even after read
justment
of the Fermi surface, thedriving
force for thepenodic
lattice distortion would not be very strong. We conclude that a hiddennesting
type mechanism is alsounlikely
andthus, BEDT-TTF~[Hg~cl~]
Phcl retains ils metallicproperties
without anyresistivity anomaly
until very low temperatures.The Fermi surface of
figure
2a contains closed electron and holepockets.
SinceBEDT-TTF4 lHg~cl~
Phcl is metallic down to 1.3 K it should bepossible
tostudy
its Fermi surfaceby
magnetoresistance experiments. Oufstudy
suggests the existence of Shubnikov-de Haas oscillationscorresponding
to a cross-sectional area ofapproximately
13 % of the firstBrillouin zone. Since this value has been obtained from the room temperature structure, the actual value obtained from the low temperature measurements could be
slightly
different. Letus note that the cross-sectional area of the electron and hole Fermi surface
pockets
isstnctly
the same. This is in contrast with recent results for the molecular
superconductor
BEDT-TTF~ReO~ H~O [?
Ii. In this sait, the electron Fermi surface consists of two symmetry related closedpockets
with a cross-sectional area which is half that of the hole Fermi surfacepocket, leading
to the observation of two different Shubnikov-de Haasfrequencies.
It is alsoworth pointing out that,
although
the Fermi surface offigure
2acorresponds
to a 2Dsemimetal, our
analysis
offigure
2b in terms of two hidden lD Fermi surfaces suggests thatBEDT-TTF~[Hg~cl~]
Phcl should be somewhatanisotropic,
with betterconductivity along
the
perpendicular
to a direction between b* + c* and c*.Concluding
remarks.Tight-binding
band structure calculations for the room temperature structure ofBEDT-TTF4 lHg~cl~
Phcl show the existence of closed electron and hole Fermi surfaces, inagreement with the 2D metallic
properties reported
for this sait. These Fermi surfaces exhibitsome nestmg features but
they
seem to be non strongenough
to lead to aperiodic
lattice distortion. However, ourstudy
also shows that these closed Fermi surfaces result from the946 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE I N° 6
hybridization
of two hidden lD Fermi surfaces. This observation suggests thepossibility
of aperiodic
lattice distortionthrough
a hidden nesting type mechanism. However it is shown thatthere are structural and electronic factors
against
this mechanism. Thus,BEDT-TTF~ [Hg~cl~
Phcl exhibits metallicproperties
down to 1.3 K without anyresistivity anomaly. Magnetoresistance
experiments and a detailedstudy
of theresistivity anisotropy
would be
interesting
in order to further caracterize the unusual Fermi surface of this sait. Inview of the present results, it would be very
interesting
tostudy
the structure andphysical properties
of the other sains withgeneral
formulaBEDT-TTF,,,[HgXi]
PhX IX= Cl, BT
recently reported by Lyubovskaya
et ai.[8].
Acknowledgments.
L.F.V. thanks
Fundaçao
Calouste Gulbenkian for a travel grant.References
[1] Williams J. M., Ferrare J. R., Thom R. J., Carlson K. D., Geiser U., Wang H. H., Kini A. M.,
Whangbo
M.-H.,Organic Superconductors
(Prentice Hall : New Jersey, 1992).[2] lshiguro R., Yamaji K., Organic
Superconductors (Springer-Verlag
Berlin, 1990).[3] Williams J. M., Schultz A., Geiser U., Carlson K. D., Kini A. M., Wang H. H.. Kwok W.-K., Whangbo M.-H.. Schirber J. E.. S<.ience 251 (1991) 1501.
[4] For instance, see chapter 8 of reference il].
[5] Tokumoto M., Swanson A. G., Breaks J. S., Agosta C. C., Hannahs S. T., Kinoshita N., Anzai M.. Tamura M., Tajima H., Kuroda H., Andersen J. R.,
Organic Superconductivity,
V. Z.Kresin and W. A. Little Eds. (Plenum : New York, 1990), p. 167.
[6] Wosmtza J., frit. J. Med. Phj~s. B 7 (1993) 2707.
[7] la) Kartsovnik M. V., Laukhin V. N., Pesot~kii S. I. Schegolev I. F., Yakovenko V. M., J. Phys. I Fianc.e 2 (1992) 89 ;
(b) Kartsovnik M. V., Kovalev A. E., Kushch N. D., J. Phys / Fiafic.e 3 (1993) II 87 ;
(c) Kovalev A. E., Kartsovnik M. V., Kushch N. D., Sand Stale Comm. 87 (1993) 705.
[8]
Lyubovskaya
R. N., Afanas'eva T. V.,D'yachenko
O. A., Gritsenko V. V.,Mkoyan
Sh. G..Shilov G. V., Lyubovskii R. B., Laukhin V. N., Makova M. K., Khomenko A. G., Zvarykina A. V., I=v Akad. Naiik. SSSR, Ser. Khim. (1990) 2872.
[9] Lyubovskaya R. N., D'yachenko O. A., Gritsenko V. V., Mkoyan Sh. G., Atovmyan L. O.,
Lyubovskii
R. B., Laukhin V. N., Zvarykina A. V., Khomenko A. G., Synlh. Met. 41-43 (1991) 1907.10]
D'yachenko
O. A., Gritsenko V. V., Mkoyan Sh. G., Shilov G. V., Atovmyan L. O., /=i>. Akad.Naiik. ,ÇSSR, Ser. Khini. (1991) 2062.
iii Gritsenko V. V.,
D'yachenko
O. A., Shilov G. V.,Lyubovskaya
R. N., Afanas'eva T. V.,Lyubovskii R. B., Makova M. K., Izi. Akad Nauk. SSSR, Ser. Khini. (1992) 697.
12] Whangbo M.-H., Hoffmann R., J. Am. Cfieni. Soc. 100 (1978) 6093.
13] Hoffmann R., J. Chem. Ph»,i 39 (1963) 1397. A modified Wolf~berg-Helmholz formula (Ammeter J., Bürgi H.-B., Thibeault J., Hoffmann R., J. Am. Cheni. Soc, 100 (1978) 3686) was used to
evaluate the
nondiagonal
H~~ values.14] Clementi E., Roetti C., Al. Nu<.l. Data Tables 14 (1974) 177. The exponents and parameters were
taken from
Whangbo
M.-H., Williams J. M.,Leung
P. C. W., Bene M. A.,Emge
T. M.,Wang H. H., Carlson K. D., Crabtree G. W., J. Am Cheni. Soc., 107 (1985) 5815.
15] (a) Whangbo M.-H., Williams J. M., Leung P. C. W., Bene M. A., Emge T. J., Wang H. H., Inoig. Chem. 24 (1985) 3500.
(b) Williams J. M.,
Wang
H. H.,Emge
T. J., Geiser U., Bene M. A., Leung P. C. W., Carlwn K.D., Thora R. J., Schultz A. J.,
Whangbo
M.-H., Piog- Innig Chetn. 35 (1987) 51.(c) Since overlap is
explicitely
included in extended Hückel calculations, these interaction energies (p ) should net be confused with the conventional transfer integrals il ). Although the twoquantities
are obviously related and have the same physical meaning, the absolute values of p are somewhat greater than those of1.(16] Pénicaud A., Boubekeur K., Batail P.. Canadell E., Auban-Senzier P., Jérome D., J. Am Chem.
Soc., ils (1993) 4101.
(17] la) Martin J. D., Canadell E., Fitzmaurice J. C., Slawin A. M. Z., Williams D. J., Woollins J. D., submitted for publication.
(b) Veiros L. F.. Canadell E., to be
published.
(c) Day P., Kurmoo M., Mallah T., Marsden C., Friend R. H., Pratt F. L., Hayes W., Chasseau D., Gaufrier J.. Bravic G., Ducasse L.,./. Ami. Cheni. Soc. l14 (1992) 10722.
(18] Martin J. D.. Doublet M.-L., Canadell E., /. Phj>.i. / Fiance 3 (1993) 2451.
[19]
Whangbo
M.-H., Bene M. A., Leung P. C. W.. Emge T. J., Wang H. H., Williams J. M., Solid Slale Conimiifi. 59 (1986) 813.(20] Whangbo M.-H., Ren J., Liang W.. Canadell E., Pouget J. P., Ravy S., Williams J., Beno M., Dini,q Cheni. 31 il 992) 4169.
[2 Ii Kahlich S., Schweitzer D.~ Rovira C., Paradis J., Whangbo M.-H., Heinen I., Keller H. J., Nuber B., Bele P., Brunner H., Shibaeva R. P.. Z Phv.i. B, Cnfid Mal., in press.