HAL Id: hal-00893786
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00893786
Submitted on 1 Jan 1989
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Genetic study of Dandarawy chickens: I. Heritabilities
and genetic correlations of body weight and weight gain
M.A. Abdellatif
To cite this version:
Original
article
Genetic
study
of
Dandarawy
chickens: I. Heritabilities
and
genetic
correlations of
body weight
and
weight gain
M.A. Abdellatif
Faculty
ofAgriculture,
Animal ProductionDepartment,
AssiutUniversity,
Assiut,Egypt
(received 4-11-1987, accepted 5-5-1988)
Summary — Heritability
values ofbody weight
andweight gain
at the ages of 1 d, and 4, 8, 12, and 16 wk were estimated from 57 half-sib families of a strain of theEgyptian
breed Dandarawyrepre-senting
57 sires, 256 dams, and 1,605offspring.
Estimates were obtained for both of the sexes separately as well as for the two combined. The estimates ofheritability
ranged from 0.24 to 0.60 for males and females from sire components of variance, and 0.03 to 0.37 for males and females from dam components of variance. There were marked differences betweenheritability
estimates from sire and dam components of variance and between males and females. Theheritability
estimates from sire components weregenerally higher
than those from dam components, which indicated theimportance
of the additive genetic effect andpossible
sex-linked effects. It was also noticed that the environment had an effect on bothbody weight
andweight gain
which is reflected inheritability
esti-mates from one age to another.
The results showed that there were
highly significant
correlations between bodyweights
from 4 to 16 wk of age. There were no correlations between hatchweight
and weights at the other ages. This indicates that it is possible to consider the hatch weight as a traitcompletely
separate from the other traits in males, females, and the sexes combined. The highly significantgenetic
and environ-mental correlations showed that bothgenetic
and environmental factors had the same influences on bodyweight
from 4 to 16 wk of age. There were absent estimates of thegenetic
correlationsespe-cially
with the dam components of variance in males and females. The correlations betweenweight
gains
at differentperiods
showed highlysignificant
estimates up to 12 wk of age. These correlations reflect theimportance
of bothgenetic
and environmental effects onweight gain
at the different per-iods. Our results indicate that it ispossible
to select forbody weight
andweight gain
at an earlyrather than a late (16 wk) age because of the high correlations between the different ages.
Dandarawy
chicken -body
weight - weight gain - heritability - sex-linked effect -genetic
correlationRésumé — Etude
génétique
de la raceégyptienne
depoulets Dandarawy :
1. Héritabilités etcorrélations
génétiques
dupoids
corporel
et dugain
depoids.
Les héritabilités dupoids
corpo-rel et dugain
de poids auxâges
de1 jour,
4, 8, 12 et 16 semaines ont été estimées àpartir
de don-nées concernant 57pères,
256 mères et 1605 descendants dans une souche de la race Egyptien-neDandarawy.
Les données ont été analyséesséparément
pour les mâles et les femelles, puispour les 2 sexes ensemble. Les héritabilités estimées dans
chaque
sexe àpartir
de la composante«père"
varient de 0,24 à 0,60; celles estimées à partir de la composante «mère» varient de 0,03 à0,37. Les héritabilités déterminées à
partir
de la composante«père»
sontplus
élevées que celles déterminées àpartir
de la composante «mère». Ce résultatindique l’importance
de l’effetgénétique
Dandarawy.
Les variations des estimations d’un mois à l’autreindiquent l5mportance
de l’effet de l’environnement sur l’héritabilité dupoids corporel
et dugain
depoids.
Les résultats
indiquent qu’il y
a des corrélations hautementsignificatives
entre lepoids corporel
de 4 à 16 semaines. Aucune corrélationsignificative n’apparaît
entre lepoids
à l’éclosion et lesautres
poids,
cequi
permet de dire que lepoids
à l’éclosion estcomplètement
séparé
des autrespour les mâles, les femelles et les 2 sexes ensembles. Les
significations
des corrélations montrentl’importance
des effetsgénétiques
et de l’environnement sur le poids corporel de 4 à 16 semainesd’âge.
Les valeurs absentes des corrélationsgénétiques
déterminées àpartir
de la composante mère chez les mâles et les femellesindiquent l’importance
des autres effetsgénétiques
que les effets additifs sur ces estimations. Les corrélations dugain
depoids
ont été hautementsignifica-tives d’une
période
àI autre jusqu’à
12 semainesd âge.
Ces résultats montrent aussi le rôle de l’ef fetgénétique
et de l’environnement sur legain
depoids
d’unâge
à l’autre. Nos résultats indiquentla
possibilité
d’améliorer lepoids corporel
et legain
depoids
à unâge plus précoce
par la sélection car les corrélations sontsignificatives
entre les mesures aux différentsâges.
poulet Dandawary - poids corporel -
gain depolds -
héritabilité - liaison avec le sexe —cor-rélation
génétique
Introduction
Several
problems, especially concerning
nutrition anddisease,
are encountered inEgypt
whenattempts
are made toemploy foreign
strains in the field. At the Animal Pro-ductionDepartment
of AssiutUniversity
efforts have been directed towardimproving
theproductivity
of an oldEgyptian
breed named&dquo;Dandarawy’
which exists inUpper
Egypt.
The
productivity
of this breed ranges from 110 to 122eggs/yr;
the eggweight
ranges from 40 to 45 g; the age at first egg averages 212 to 218days;
and the adultbody
wt is 1kg
for females and 1.5-2kg
for males(Hassan
etal.,
1973;Sharara,
1974;Abdellatif,
1977).
Nogenetic
information about this strain is nowavailable,
therefore agenetic study
of certain
productive
traits seemed to be necessary before anybreeding
programme wasto be undertaken. Thus we
began
thegenetic
evaluation of the strain in a series ofstu-dies
by estimating
thegenetic
parameters
of variousproductive
traits which would be useful in abreeding
programme.First,
we will discussheritability
estimates ofbody
weight
andweight
gain.
The
heritability
estimates ofbody
weight
andweight gain
as summarizedby Kinney
(1969) ranged
from 0.35 to0.54,
which aremoderately high,
whereas Kaatz(1967)
sho-wed that the decrease inheritability
estimates at 10 wk of age was due tohigh
environ-mentalcomponents.
In
fowls,
for sex-linked traitstheory implies
that estimates ofheritability
from damcom-ponents
of variance arehigher
with males than withfemales,
while for sirecomponents
of variance the reverse is true
(Thomas
etaL, 1958;
Abdel-Gawad, 1970;
Bernon &Chambers,
1985).
On the other
hand,
Siegel
andEssary (1959), Gaffney (1964),
and Goodman(1973)
concluded that
heritability
estimates ofbody weight
werehigher
from the sirecompo-nents of variance than the dam
components,
but Amer(1965),
Marks andSiegel
(1971),
and Vaccaro and Van Vleck(1972)
showed thatheritability
estimated from damIn
Egypt,
inFayoumi
chickens,
several workers estimated theheritability
ofbody
weight.
El-Masri(1959)
found that it was0.02, 0.02,
and 0.11 at 8 wk of age from thesire, dam,
and sire-damcomponents
ofvariance,
respectively.
Abdel-Gawad(1961)
sho-wed thatheritability
estimatesranged
from 0.10 to 0.79 at 1 d to 12 wk of age from the sire and sire-damcomponents
of variance. Amer(1965)
found similar results and added that the environment had an effect onheritability
estimates at theearly
ages.Many
workersreported
correlations ofbody weight
andweight gain
at different ages(Marks,
1979;
Chamberset al., 1981,
1984). Kinney (1969)
summarized thosecorrela-tions,
which wererelatively high
andpositive.
Martin et al.(1953)
showed that thehigh
genetic
correlations betweenweights
at6, 9,
and 12 wk of age were morepersistent
during
thegrowth period
than other correlations(phenotypic
andenvironmental),
and thegenetic
effect did not vary from one age toanother,
although
environmental effects weregreatly
different from one age to another. Merritt(1966)
andPym
and Nicholls(1979)
mentioned ahigh genetic
correlation between 5 wk and 9 wkbody
weight
from the sire-damcomponents
of variance for males and females. Aman and Becker(1983)
found a similar result for 6 wk and 7 wkbody weight
from the sirecomponent
of variance. In thepresent
study
we estimate the correlations betweenbody weight
andweight
gain
at different ages inDandarawy
chickens toverify
the roles of bothgenetic
and envi-ronmental effects from hatch to 16 wk of age. These values willhelp
indesign
ofpro-grammes for
improving
bothbody weight
andweight
gain
by
selection at anearly
age.Materials and Methods
Animals
From a
population
ofDandarawy
chickens maintained at thepoultry
farm of Assiut University, 57 sires and 570 dams(leg banded)
wererandomly
mated in differentbreeding
pens (10dams/sire)
toobtain
pedigreed
chicks. After 2 wk of egg collection, all hens thatproduced
fewer than 5 eggs were eliminated; thus we had 256 dams thatproduced
more than 5 eggs.Accordingly,
the number of dams/sire and the number ofprogeny/dam
was different from onefamily
to another. The chicks wereweighed
to the nearest gram andwing
banded at 1 d.They
were brooded on the floor at a constanttemperature
(35°C)
until 8 wk of age, then moved to therearing
house(open system).
They werefed ad libitum on a commercial ration
containing
18% totalprotein
and 2,800kcaUkg.
Thephotope-riod was 24 h
during
the wk 1 and 10 h afterwards. The chicks wereweighed
to the nearest gram at 4, 8, 12, and 16 wk of age. A total !of 1,605 chicks from the different familiescompleted
their record up to 16 wk of age.Statistical
procedures
Components
of variance were obtainedby
nestedanalysis
of variance withunequal
numbers of dams and progeny in each sexseparately.
The statistical model in this case was :where
Y
ijk
is the record of the k+h progeny of theh
j+
dam mated to the i+hsire; M is thepopulation
mean; aiis the effect of the i+hsire;
f
i
jj
is the effect of thej+
h
dam mated to the i+hsire; ande
ijk
the uncontrolled environmental andgenetic
deviations attributable to the individuals(Becker, 1975).
where
Y
ijkl
is the record of the I+h progeny of the i+hsex of the k+hdam mated to thej+
h
sire; af is thepopulation
mean; ai represents the random effect andf3j
k
the fixed effect in this model, and9
¡
j
kJ
the uncontrolled environmental andgenetic
deviations(Harvey,
1977).The method for estimating
heritability
was, as indicated by Becker (1975) :where
6
2
is the covariance of half-sibs;a
2
is the covariance of full-sibs minus the covariance of sirehalf sibs;
a!&dquo;
contains theremainder
of
thegenetic
variance and the environmental variance. Standard errors of heritabilities derived from components of variance were determinedaccording
tothe method of Dickerson
(1960),
which was modifiedby
Becker (1975). Theheritability
estimates (+SE)
were calculated for males, females, and the combined sexes for bodyweight
andweight gain
from 1 d to 16 wk of age.The
genetic
and environmental correlations were estimatedaccording
to thegeneral
formula of correlations :after substitution of the
genetic
and environmental components of the variance so as to determine thegenetic
and environmental correlations from the sire, dam, and sire-dam components ofvarian-ce and covariance (Becker, 1975).
Results
Table
I presents
thebody weight
andweight gain
means + SD from 1 d to 16 wk of age formales, females,
and the combined sexes. The hatch means in males and femaleswere
equal,
but from 4 to 16 wk of age, the male means were 13-20%higher
than females forbody
weight
and 15-20%higher
forweight gain.
Theweight gain
increasedprogressively
from 1 d to 12 wk of age, but the rate of increase was reduced at 16 wk ofage.
The results of the
analysis
of variance indicate that the mean number ofprogeny/dam
was6.1,
the mean number of dams/sire was6.8,
and the mean number ofprogeny/sire
was 28.0. The
least-squares analysis
of the differences betweensires, dams,
and the combined sexes arepresented
in Table II. It was noted in theanalysis
that there werehighly significant
differences between sires from 1 d to 16 wk of age for all the traitsbody weight
at 8 wk of age andweight gain
from 4-8 and 12-16 wk of age. Thediffe-rences between the sexes were
highly significant
for all traitsexcept
body weight
athat-ching
time.As for
heritability
estimates ofbody weight
andweight gain
formales, females,
and the combined sexes(Table 111),
differences were observed betweenheritability
estimatesin the sexes from sire and dam
components
of variance. The estimatesranged
from 0.24 to 0.60 for males and females from the sirecomponent
ofvariance,
and from 0.03 to0.37 for males and females from the dam
component
of variance. Theheritability
The values of
heritability
of the combined sexes before and after elimination of sexeffect showed no
great
differences forsire, dam,
and sire-damcomponents
ofvariance,
and the estimates had the same trend. The results showed that
heritability
estimates ofweight gain
were not consistent and their values were lower than those of thebody
weight.
The
genetic
and environmental correlations ofbody weight
are shown in Table IV. It was noticed that thegenetic
correlations between hatchweight
andweights
at different ages had low andnegative
valuescompared
with the other estimates. Thegenetic
corre-lations between
body
weights
from 4 to 16 wk of age hadpositive
andhighly significant
values formales, females,
and the sexes combined estimated from thesire, dam,
and sire-damcomponents
ofvariance,
and for females estimated from the damcomponents
of variance.Missing
estimates were due tonegative
components
of variance.The environmental correlations between hatch
weight
andbody weight
at different ages showednegative
and small values(Table IV).
The environmental correlations ofbody weight
from 4 to 16 wk of age werehighly significant
andpositive
formales,
females,
and the combined sexes estimated from thesire, dam,
and sire-damcompo-nents of variance. These correlations were more
persistent
thangenetic
correlations atthe various ages.
The
genetic
and environmental correlations ofweight gain
at the differentperiods
ofage are
presented
in Table V. Themajority
of thegenetic
correlations betweenweight
gain
from oneperiod
to another hadhighly
significant
andpositive
correlations formales,
females,
and the combined sexes estimated from thesire, dam,
and sire-damcompo-nents of variance. The
missing
estimatescorrespond
to thenegative
variances in theanalysis
of variance.Environmental correlations of
weight gain
from oneperiod
to another had unstable estimates.Highly significant
andpositive
correlations were noticedduring
theperiods
ofgrowth
until 12 wk of age formales, females,
and the combined sexes estimated from thesire, dam,
and sire-damcomponents
of variance.Discussion
The
significant
differences between sires showed that in our local strainDandarawy,
additive
genetic
factors had agreat
effect onbody weight
andweight
gain,
and thesigni-ficant differences between dams for the
majority
of the traits studied may also reflect additivegenetic
effects. Bernon and Chambers(1985) reported
similarfindings.
Heritability
estimates from sirecomponents
of variance werehigher
than those from damcomponents,
confirming
theimportance
of additiveeffects,
since damcomponents
include more non additivegenetic
and common environmental effects than sirecompo-nents
(ignoring
sex-linkedeffects).
These results agree with those mentionedby Siegel
andEssary (1959); Gaffney (1964);
Goodman(1973);
Becker(1975); Pym
and Nicholls(1979);
and Bernon and Chambers(1985).
’Heritability
estimates for males based on damcomponents
of variance werehigher
increases the numerator of
heritability
for males but not females from the dam compo-nent of variance. Merritt(1966)
and Becker(1975) reported
similarconclusions
for the differences between the sexes estimated from the damcomponents
of variance.On the other
hand,
in the female progeny thegenerally higher
value of the sirecom-ponent
than that of the damcomponent
of variance may alsosuggest
thatpart
of the variance is due to sex-linked genes.Fluctuations of
heritability
estimates from one month to another may show theimpor-tance of environmental conditions
during
thegrowth period
and their effects onheritabili-ty values;
Kaatz(1967)
found a similar result.Comparison
between the estimates in thisstudy
and thosereported
in the literature is difficult because of the differences between ourpopulation
and the otherpopulations,
which had a
history
of selection andbreeding
programmes that did not exist in ourpopu-lation.
Lower estimates of correlations between
body weight
at hatch andbody weights
atlater ages lead to the conclusion that hatch
weight
had no effect on laterbody weight,
and thatbody weight
at hatch must be considered as aseparate
trait.Kinney
and Shoff-ner(1965) reported
a similar result.Significant
correlations betweenbody weights
within and across sexes reflect theimportance
ofgenetic
effects onbody
weight during
thegrowth period
from 4 to 16 wk of age. Martin et aL(1953)
indicated the same effect ofgenetic
factors onbody weight.
Genetic effects
depend mainly
on the fact that the genes that affectedbody weight
at the different ages were the same and hadpleiotropic
effects. Inaddition,
thegenetic
correla-tions show that additivegenetic
effectsgreatly
affectbody
weight during
thegrowth
per-iod(Becker,
1975;Falconer,
1981).
The absent estimates,especially
with the damcom-ponents
ofvariance,
indicate theimportance
ofgenetic
effects other than the additivegenetic
effects onbody
weight
(Becker,
1975;
Pym
andNicholls, 1979;
Aman andBec-ker,
1983).
The environmental correlations of
body weight
from 4 to 16 wk of age, which had all the environmental and non additivegenetic
effects,
showed morepersistent
estimates than thegenetic
correlations.Thus,
this result indicates that the environmental factorsaffecting
body weight
were the same and did not vary fromperiod
toperiod
during
grow-th.The
higly significant
correlations indicated thepossibility
ofimproving body weight
by
selection
at anearly
age. Aman and Becker(1983)
showed a similar conclusion.The
genetic
correlations ofweight gain
at differentperiods
of age formales, females,
and the combined sexes estimated from thesire, dam,
and sire-damcomponents
of variance confirm thepersistence
of the samegenetic
influences onweight gain
from oneperiod
to another. Thehighly
significant
correlationsagreed
with those mentionedby
Kin-ney(1969)
forweight gain
at various ages.Acknowledgments
I wish to express my thanks to those who
helped
meduring
data collection at thepoultry
farm,University for his
help
inpreparing
the computer programmes for the statisticalanalysis
of the data and to Dr. H.M. Mansour, Animal ProductionDepartment, Faculty
ofAgriculture,
Ain ShamsUniver-sity for his
help during
theanalysis
of data by the mixed model.References
Abdel-Gawad E.M.
(1961)
Genetic andphenotypic
parameters in theFayoumi breed
and their rela-tion to the environmentthrough breeding.
Ph. D. Thesis,Faculty
ofAgriculture,
AlexandriaUniversi-ty,
Egypt
Abdel-Gawad E.M. (1970)
Heritability
estimates and types of gene action of some economic traits in &dquo;Dokki 4&dquo;. II.Heritability
and types of action on 8 and 12 weeksbody weight. Agric.
Res. Rev. 48, 53-62Abdellatif M.A. (1977) Studies on some productive traits in
Dandarawy chickens
underUpper Egypt
conditions. M. Sc. Thesis,Faculty
ofAgriculture,
AssiutUniversity, Egypt
Aman N. & Becker W.A. (1983) Genetic correlations between six and seven-week-old broilers. Poult Sci. 62, 1918-1920
Amer M.F.
(1965) Heritability
ofbody weight
inFayoumi.
Poult Sci. 44, 741-744Becker W.A.
(1975)
Manual Procedures of Quantitative Genetics.Washington
StateUniversity,
Pull-man, WA, 3rd edn, pp. 170
Bernon D.E. & Chambers J.R.
(1985)
Maternal and sex-linked genetic effects in broiler parent stock. Poult. Sci. 64, 29-38Chambers T.R., Gavora J.S. & Fortin A. (1981) Genetic
changes
in meat-type chickens in the lasttwenty years. Can. J. Anim. Sci. 61, 555-563
Chambers T.R., Bernon D.E. & Gavora J.S.
(1984) Synthesis
and parameters in newpopulations
ofmeat-type chickens. Theor.
Appl.
Genet. 69, 23-30Dickerson G.E. (1960)
Techniques
for research inquantitative genetics.
In :Techniques
and Proce-dures in Animal Production Research. AmericanSociety
of Animal Production, pp. 56-105El-Masri G. (1959) A study of
feathering
and Itsrelationship
to body size in Fayoumi chickens.M. Sc. Thesis,
Faculty
ofAgriculture,
AlexandriaUniversity, Egypt
Falconer D.S.
(1981)
Introduction to Quantitative Genetics.Longman,
London, 2nd edn., pp. 340Gaffney
L.T. (1964) Studies ongrowth
rate and estimates of theheritability
of bodyweight
in broiler stock. Aust Poult. Sci. Conv. Proc. 74-78Goodman B.L. (1973) Heritabilities and correlations of body
weight
anddressing
percentage in broi-lers. Poult. Sci. 52, 379-380Harvey
W.R.(1977)
User’s Guide for LSML76. Mixed Model LeastSquares
and Maximum Likeli-hoodComputer Program.
Ohio StateUniversity,
Columbus, OHHassan G.M., Khatab M.S. & El-Gammal A.M. (1973)
Phenotypic
correlations between several mea-sures of eggproduction
in theFayoumi
and theDandarawy
chickens. Alex. J.Agric.
Res. 21, 367-374Kaatz C.
(1967)
Heritability andgenetic
correlations of differentfattening
and carcass characters ofa White Rock line. Part I. Arch.
Geflugelzuch.
Kleintierkd. 16, 175-189Kinney T. B. (1969) A
Summary
ofReported
Estimates of Heritabilities and of Genetic andPhenoty-pic
Correlations for Traits of Chickens.Agriculture
Handbook No. 363, U.S.Department
ofAgricultu-re,
Washington
DC, pp. 49Kinney
T.B. & Shoffner R.N.(1965) Heritability
estimates and genetic correlations among several traits in a meat-typepoultry population.
PoulG Sci. 44, 1020-1032 .Marks H.L.
(1979)
Growth rate and feed intake of selected and non-selected broilers. Growth 43,Marks H.L. &
Siegel
P.B. (1971) Evaluation of the Athens-Canadian random bred population. I. Time trends at two locations. Poult. Sci. 50, 1405-1411 1Martin G.A., Glazener E.W. & Blow W.I.
(1953)
Efficiency of selection for broilergrowth
at various ages. Poult Sci. 32, 716-720Merritt E.S. (1966) Estimates by sex of genetic parameters for body weight and skeletal dimensions in a random bred strain of meat type fowl. Poult. Sci. 45, 118-125
Pym
R.A.E. & Nicholls P.J. (1979) Selection for food conversion in broilers : direct and correlated responses to selection forbody weight gain,
foodconsumption
and food conversion ratio. Br. Poult. Sci. 20, 73-86Sharara H.H. (1974) Studies on some
productive
characters in different strains of chickens underUpper Egypt
condition. M. Sc. Thesis,Faculty
of Agriculture, Assiut University,Egypt
Siegel
P.E. &Essary
E.O. (1959) Heritabilities andinterrelationship
of live measurements and evis-ceratedweight
in broilers. Poult. Sci. 38, 530-532Thomas C.H., Blow W.L., Cockerham C.C. & Glazener E.W. (1958) The heritability of body
weight,
gain,
feed conversion in broilers. Poult Sci. 33, 862-869Vaccaro R. & Van Vleck L.D. (1972) Genetics of economic traits in the Cornell random bred control