HAL Id: inria-00072390
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072390
Submitted on 24 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Many TCP User Asymptotic Analysis of the AIMD Model
Dohy Hong, Dmitri Lebedev
To cite this version:
Dohy Hong, Dmitri Lebedev. Many TCP User Asymptotic Analysis of the AIMD Model. [Research Report] RR-4229, INRIA. 2001. �inria-00072390�
ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--4229--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
THÈME 1
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Many TCP User Asymptotic Analysis of the AIMD Model
Dohy Hong & Dmitri Lebedev
N° 4229
July, 2001
Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt
Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)
Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30
3$4/57698:4/;=<+>3$?A@CBEDE@GFIHKJLHKM=HKNO
PQRTSVUVWYX[Z]\_^)Ua`cb/deUTf]^&g/^&f)RTSVU_^
h2i)jcklUTfYPmZ]npo
ZY`cq7q=jri&fs7U'i)U_t"QUTi)t)QU#uvLwyxzxz{|X[}zb7~g(xzz/WX WTwVq(`cU_^
L_ac7zz ^&Sq7~Ub7seSVjs7UT~=jrif&QUkljrufmf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7f]UTjr~b7f&jruAjc2`^)UTfmjcGP]oh^"U_^)^&jru^
^&Q(`ci&u7`t_jrSSVjruAjrf&f&~UTuU_t"i)jrb7f)UTi]Q(`r^mU_UTu|uf&i)js/bt_U_sAu9xc (`r^)U_s|jru¡q7i)j¢s/btTf)^jci"`cus7jrS
S£`cf&i&t_U_^a¤PQ7^q(`cq=UTi:^&f&bs/U_^:f&QU`r^&g¢Sq7f)jrf&t_^:jcmf&QU£`cSVs¥SVjs7UT~I¦mQUTu§f&QUuyb7SUTi$jcP]oh
^)U_^)^)jru^'¨©j¢U_^ªf)j|u/«u7f¬g¤V9U^&Qj®¦f&Q(`cff&Q7^'~Sfq7i)j¢t_U_^)^ta`cu¥Us7UE«uU_s¯g9`i)U_tTb7i&i)UTut_U
i)UT~°`cf&jru¯u²±`cus+¦U^&Qja¦Qj®¦³f)jt"Q(`ci"`rtTf)UTi&´aUf)^ª^&f"`cf&jru(`ci&gµUTQ(`ajriªUTi&g+^)Sq7~gA(`r^)U_s²jru
f&QUei)U_tTb7i&i)UTut_U|i)UT~°`cf&jru ¤¶9U|^&f&bs/g§f&QU¡`rt_tTb7i"`rtTg¶jcªf&Q7^~SfSVjs7UT~]`cus·f&QUeSq(`rtTfVjcf&QU
^&g¢ut)Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jruµUE¸=U_tTfujrfYjru7~gjru¡f&QUªSVUa`cuAf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7f]7b7fY`c~^)jjruAf)^Y¹jyº¤
»|¼y½=¾)¿À cÁGz P]ohpÂcÃÄhL`rs7s/f&UmutTi)Ua`r^)US:b7~f&q7~ta`cf&UYs7U_tTi)Ua`r^)Uz¢¹jyºz^)gut"Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jru ¢`r^&g¢SÅ
f)jrf&t:`cu(`c~g/^&^a/i)U_tTb7i&i)UTut_U:i)UT~°`cf&jru
Æ¥ÇÉÈLÊLÇÉËÍÌCÎ(ÈÏÐYÑǬÐÒ_Ó·ÔÖÕcקØyÙÚGÛܪÐÝÞÓEßÞàÞáâ7ã)ÔÖäæå¯ç×&ØK×ÄèéáTÓaÐêKÔëã"ìcíl×Eî ÎÌ°Üã"äæÛïðÑñEò_ó_îôGñÞìcõ_öG×Äìcålî÷øÔ&Ð
ÑÜmäúùÔÖäîû×lüz×&Ø®×lýKöG×lìcålî÷þÔ
!L]$2! )$
u SVj¢s7RT~Uµb7s7U²^&Sq7~U²q=jrb7i~ú\Tjr~b7f&jru·k&jruyf)U¯s7U_^|s7\T7f)^|sb7uéUTu^)UTS7~U9s7U
^)jrb7i)t_U_^P]oh q(`ci&f"`cUa`cufmb7ui)jrb7f)UTb7it_jrSSb7uA`:\Tf)\uf&i)js/b7fs`cu^ªxc=(`r^)\^&b7ims7U_^pq7i)j¢s/b7f)^ms7U
S£`cf&i&t_U_^'`c~\a`cf)jri)U_^a¤oUTf'`ci&f&tT~U:\Tf&bs/U~U_^Y`r^)gSq7f)jrf&bU_^ªs/bASVj¢s7RT~U Ã~jri)^bU'~UujrS7i)U
s7U$^)jrb7i)t_U_^ªP]ohé¨f)UTus+UTi)^~u/«u7Ö¤jrb^]SVjruf&i)jru^ybU$t_Uq7i)jt_U_^)^)b^]~Sf)U$q=UTb7fTf&i)U$s7\E«u7
q(`cib7uUi)UT~°`cf&jru¶s7Ui)\_tTb7i&i)UTut_Us`cu^± UTfujrb^ta`ci"`rtTf)\Ti&^)jru^$^)jru9t_jrSqjri&f)UTSVUTuf$^)f"`cf&jru7u(`ci)U
f&i)R_^'^&Sq7~UTSVUTuf£q(`ci&f&is7Ut_UTf&f)U$i)\_tTb7i&i)UTut_Uz¤ jrb^ª\Tf&bs/jru^'~°`q7i)\_tT^&jru9s7Ut_USVj¢s7RT~U$~Sf)U
UTfm~Sq(`rtTfYs7U~°`^&gut"Q7i)jru7^"`cf&jruAujru+^)UTb7~UTSVUTuyf^&b7im~U's7\T7fSVjagUTu+S£`c^]`cb^)^& ^)b7i~°`V¹jyº¤
!.À a ¾ #" ¯ P]ohpÂcÃÄhGÍ`rt_tTi)jr^)^)UTSVUTuf)^:`rs7s/f&^:UTfªs7\_tTi)jr^"^"`cut_US:b7~f&q7~ta`cf&Uz¹jyº ^&gut"Q7i)jcÅ
u7^"`cf&jru (`cu(`c~g/^)U:`r^)gSq7f)jrf&bUz7i)UT~°`cf&jruAs7U'i)\_tTb7i&i)UTut_Uz¤
8 -/Y(='1
! )
ìu xcë2`+^&Sq7~U£SVj¢s7UT~p jri$f&QUk&jruyfUTjr~b7f&jru jcYP]oht_jruyf&i)jr~~U_s ¨:9Pmh³^)U_^)^)jru^^&Q(`ci&u7¯`
^&u7z~Um=jrf&f&~UTuU_t)£i)jrb7f)UTi ¦`r^ zUTu£(`r^)U_sjruVq7i)j¢s/btTf)^ jc i"`cus7jrS S£`cf&i&t_U_^a¤2ìuVf&Q7^ SVjs7UT~<;`r^Iu
xK=¦pU¦m~~ta`c~~=ff&QU.0=1Å s7s/f&UìutTi)Ua`r^)Uz +b7~f&q7~ta`cf&U U_tTi)Ua`r^"UÅSVjs7UT~?>E/P]oh·^pujrf
i)UTq7i)U_^)UTuf)U_s¥`cf'q(`rt)UTf~UTUT~Ö 7b7f'°`^&Sq7~U$b7s¯U b(`cf&jru^ªf&Q(`cfs7U_^)tTi&=Uf&QUkljrufUTjr~b7f&jru^
jc f&QUY¦mus7ja¦^uf&QUYt_jru7U_^&f&jru¡`_jrs`cut_Uq7Q(`r^)Uz¤2PQU`r^)^&b7Sq7f&jru^jc f&QU Ã SVj¢s7UT~¦UTi)U
SVjrf&z`cf)U_s yg·f&QU|^&S£`c~~f&SVUA^)ta`c~U¡`cu(`c~g¢^)^£`cus u q(`ci&f&tTb7~°`ci£g·f&QU`rtTfVf&Q(`cfUTUTu u f&Q7^
^&Sq7~«(U_s|SVj¢s7UT~ i"`rtTf"`c~ =UTQ(`_¢jri]jc2`czzi)UTy`cf)U_sAf&i"`A@£t'¦`r^`c~i)Ua`rs/geq7i)U_^)UTuyfa¤
PQUq7i)U_^"UTuyfq(`cq=UTi:^&f&bs/U_^:f&QUV`r^&gSq7f)jrf&t à SVj¢s7UT~I¦mQUTu9f&QUub7S:=UTijcm^)U_^)^&jru^¨
j¢U_^mf)ju/«u7fëg¤pPQU'S£`cu+`rs/z`cuyf"`cU:jc2^&bt"Q+`t_jru^&s7UTi"`cf&jruA^f&Q(`cff&Q7^m~Sfq7i)j¢t_U_^)^m^mUTi&g
Ua`r^&~gs7UE«uU_sg`$jruUªs/SVUTu^&jru(`c~ i)U_tTb7i&i)UTut_U'i)UT~°`cf&jru 7UTUTu|¦mQUTuef&QU~jz^)^q7i)jr(`c7~fëge^i"`cf)U
s7UTq=UTus7UTuyfa¤PQ7^UTu(`c7~U_^b^Yf)j^)f&bs/g|u+q(`ci&f&tTb7~°`ciªQja¦.f&QU$^&f"`cf&jru(`ci&g¡~°`_¦jc f&QU:¦mus7ja¦³s7UEÅ
q=UTus7^jru¡f&QU'^&g¢ut)Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jruµi"`cf)Uz¤
ìuCBÞx/¦U:i)U_ta`c~~7i&UEg¡f&QU ÃSVjs7UT~Ö¤ªÃ¬uCB7/¦pU$q7i)U_^)UTufª~Sff&QU_jri)UTSV^¦mQUTu²f&QU~jz^)^
q7i)jr(`c7~fëg|^i"`cf)U'us7UTqUTus7UTuf`cus|uDB)w£¦pUt_jru^&s7UTi]f&QU'i"`cf)Us7UTq=UTus7UTuyf]ta`r^)Uz¤
E , .-¢0 '1$2%
PQU Ã SVj¢s7UT~'^¡`§b7s `cq7q7i)j_d/S£`cf&jrujc$¦mus7ja¦ UTjr~b7f&jru^Au t_jru7U_^&f&jru`ajrs`cut_U
q7Q(`r^)UAjri¨F9Pmh ^"U_^)^&jru^a¤é9U+i)U_ta`c~~f&Q(`cf^&~j®¦^)f"`ci&fe`cus f&SVU_jrb7fe`ci)U+ujrff"`cUTu `rt_t_jrb7uf
u¶f&Q7^SVjs7UT~Ö¤HGja¦UTUTiaIf&SVU_jrb7f^$us/i)U_tTf&~g§q7i)U_^)UTufyg¥f&QU£Ö`rtTf$f&Q(`cff&QUf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fVta`cu
=Ue`ci&7f&i"`c~g tT~jz^)Uf)j9I; tE&¤ xK,>E¤KJU_^&s7U_^MLNONð^V`r^"^&b7SVU_s·f)jµU|t_jru^&f"`cufVu·f&SVU¡`cus·f&QU
^"`cSVU¡jri`c~~^)U_^)^&jru^;ÉQjrSVjrUTuUTfëgP>E¤ Ãëf&QUA¦mus7ja¦ ^&´aU¡jc^)U_^)^)jruRQ`cff&SVUTS^VUXW,YZ([,S]\E
f)^u^&f"`cuyf"`cuU_jrb^:f&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fjriª~jta`c~f&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7f`cfªf&SVU^S^`cq7q7i)j_d/S£`cf)U_s²yg+f&QU yb(`cuf&fëg
_`W,YZa[,Sb\dcXUeW,YZ([,S]\bf&LNON¤
PQUhg=ÅÖf&Qi"]kj6! #C! ,l^s7UE«uU_sµ`r^]f&QU(g=ÅÖf&QµUTqj¢t)Q²`cf]¦mQ7t)Q²jruU~jz^"^Yjri^)UTUTi"`c~L^&Sb7~Å
f"`cuU_jrb^~jz^"^)U_^mS£`_gej¢t_tTb7i]jru¡f&QU'^&Q(`ci)U_s|i)jrb7f)UTia¤I9U'b^)Uªf&QUªjr~~ja¦mu7ujrf"`cf&jrum
n ¨ ^mf&QU'ub7S:=UTiYjcq(`ci"`c~~UT~9Pmh^)U_^"^&jru^a/¦mQ7t)QA¦pU`r^"^&b7SVUªf)jU't_jru^)f"`cuyf]uAf&SVUo
nIp
[¨D\qcsrT¨ ^mf&QU:ta`cq(`rtTfëg|jcGf&QUjrf&f&~UTuU_t"i)jrb7f)UTi5o
n
LN/NscsLt;t_jru^&f"`cufu¡f&SVU:`cus¡U b(`c~=jri]`c~~Í^)U_^)^&jru^>o
n
Nvu^f&QUwg=ÅÖf&Q¡t_jru7U_^&f&jruAf&SVUo
nix uy{z
c|N uy{zd}
N u
^f&QU'f&SVU'=UTfë¦pU_UTu+f&QUg=ÅÖf&QA`cus|f&QUl[,g~s\ëÅë^)f]t_jru7U_^&f&jru¡f&SVU_^5o
n _ W,YZ
u c_W,YZh[?N
y
u
\^mf&QUªf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fjc^"U_^)^&jru2Q klb^&f]`K f)UTimf&QUwg=ÅÖf&Q¡t_jru7U_^&f&jru¡f&SVUo
nI
Zu ce
Z
W
z _ W?YZ
u o
ni
W,YZ
u c_ W,YZ [?N(
u
\p^mf&QUf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fYjc2^)U_^)^&jru2Q klb^&fm=UE jri)Uªf&QU(g=ÅÖf&Q¡t_jru7U_^&f&jruAf&SVUo
n
"+6bP 5! #b6b6 ?$ ,!mq Wuv
6
^w6fk5&_ÅÖz`c~bU_s²i"`cus7jrS z`ci&°`c7~Uz¤Ã¬f^YU yb(`c~ f)jf
^ªf&QU^"U_^)^&jruQ]UEd¢q=UTi&UTut_U_^`~jz^)^`cfNvu¤:ìf)^~°`_¦³^`r^)^)b7SVU_s+zUTu¥`cus¯s7UTq=UTus9`q7i&jri&
jru
¦mQ7t"Q¡^mf&QU'f&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fjcGf&QU^"U_^)^&jru2Q klb^&fm=UE jri)UNvu¤
9U^)UTf[
\(ct[?Wu
6
cf\E¤µÃë _ W,YZ
u
^$^&f"`cf&jru(`ci&gf&QU^&f"`cf&jru(`ci&g¯q7i)jr(`c7~fëg§f&Q(`cf
W
u
c fVs7UE«uU_^f&QU^"+6bP 5! #*¡f&Q(`cf¦Us7UTujrf)U'yg=¢ ¤
GUTi)UV¦U`c~~j®¦ f&Q(`cf
x u c 7¤¡PQ7^Sq7~U_^$f&Q(`cf¦U£S£`ag¯Q(`_UV_
W,YZ
uy{z
c _
W,YZ
u G7b7f:¦mQ(`cf$^
uyf)UTi)U_^)f&u7:^f&QUq7i)jrq=UTi&fëgf&Q(`cfIzUTu
Wuv
6
s7j¢U_^2ujrfIs7UTq=UTusjruMQ"¤ÃÖ¦pUmSq=jz^)U
x
u7zzUTu
kWu
s7j¢U_^mujrf]s7UTq=UTus¡jru2Q t_jrus/f&jru(`c~LjruAf&QU`rtTff&Q(`cfmf&QUTi)U^]`cf~Ua`r^&fjruU'~jz^"^a¤ ~~j®¦mu7
x
uc^&Sq7~«(U_^mSVjrSVUTuyf)^]ta`c~tTb7~°`cf&jruµ`cuseQ(`r^ujSq(`rtTfjru|f&QU`r^&g¢Sq7f)jrf&t`cu(`c~g¢^)^5mus7U_U_s
¦pU¦m~~Í^)U_Uªf&Q(`cfu|f&QU'~Sf]SVjs7UT~
x
u¦mf&Q¡q7i)jr(`c7~f¬g9Wz¤
PQUTu 7¦U'Q(`_U
_
W?YZ
uy{z c|
W
u W,YZ
u
W,YZ
u
;lW>
¦mf&Q
W,YZ
u
c_ W?YZ
u
~Kr } Z
u
¨
9jri^)Sq7~tTfëg ¦UV`r^)^&b7SVU$f&Q(`cfªf&QUu7f&°`c~Is/^)f&i&7b7f&jru9jc _ W,YZ
-]r
^zUTu¥`cusµf"`cUTu
us7UTq=UTus7UTuyf&~gµjri`c~~Q" ^)bt)Q¯f&Q(`cfw¢ _ W,YZ
s7jU_^ujrfs7UTq=UTus¯jruI[,Q0)¨D\E¤ ^Y¦U¦m~~I^)U_U$f&Q7^ª^
ujrfi)U_^&f&i&tTf&U:^&ut_Uªjri]`c~~ ¨§ _ W,YZ
u
^UTi&j¢s/tz¤
-/$121$2Y %)(2
! "$#&%'#)(* +%-,!.0/1*32$465)4'*7#8.053(:9;4<#)(:%=
GUTi)Uª¦pU:`r^)^)b7SVU'f&Q(`cf W
uv6
^us7UTqUTus7UTufYjc
`cus|f&Q(`cf?> [?W
u c f\qcA@2c¢ ¤
BDC ¼yÀ ¼ FEHGJI (+k8&^,+-q)$,$8K , jDL z4NMOMO$ ,^ !P
QSRUT
ZWVYX
Z
u
¨
c¢ _ W?YX
uF
K<+-]_
W,YX
u
'hH3MZMO$% , , *) _
W,YZ
u M
PQUmq7i)j¢jc jc=f&QUY`cj®Umf&QU_jri)UTS ^2zUTu£uVf&QUmuUEd/fI^)U_tTf&jruVu`ªSVjri)UUTuUTi"`c~(t_jruyf)UEd/fa¤2PQU
`c=jaU'f&QU_jri)UTS Sq7~U_^f&Q(`cf QSRST u
VYX QSRST
ZWVYX\[3]
^
Z
c [* } @ f\ rc¤
BDC ¼yÀ ¼ `_'G?a<b
dcWe a [gf#z5
hfji\
dc i e
¢lk
i
m
n z [,_
WSoYZ
u
\qp or
} i
m
n z ¢ [,_
WSoYZ
u
\qp o
cs [*fE¨H\ ;x>
K<+-]Qbz
bQqi ]1t 4 ubO$ ,a*)
c M
b5*)OMYPQU'q7i)jjc^mgus/btTf&jruµjru¡f&QU's7UTzi)U_UDfc in z fn
¤d9jrivfc /¦pU'Q(`aUm
¢ _ z YZ
uy{z _xw
YZ
uy{z
c ¢ z uy{z
wuy{z zy
¢ _ z YZ
u _ w YZ
u
~ir
w
~i¢|{
[ Z
u \ w
¨
w }
} &¢ _ w YZ
u Z
u
¨
U~
c [,¢ \ w y r w ~
¨
[,¢ _ z YZ
u _ w YZ
u } ¢ [,_
z YZ
u \ w \ ~
c [,¢ [,_
z YZ
u \ \ w
~sl[¨ z \
ja¦éjri]`$zUTu [gf#z5
hfiw\m
c¢ k i
m
n z [,_
n YZ
uy{z
\ p oZr
c {¢ k i
m
n z y [,_
n YZ
u
~Kr } Z
u
¨ \ po ~ r
c {¢ i
m
n z po
o
y fnn ~ [,_
n YZ
u } Z
u
¨ \ o r po
o
¦mQUTi)U c
in z ¢
[?
nz \ po
¤9jrif&QUq7i)j¢s/btTf$jc]f&QUSVjrSVUTuf)^a2f&QUUEd¢q7i)U_^)^)jru^:jr~~ja¦ u¶f&QU
^"`cSVUª¦`_g
c i
m
n z ¢¡[,_
n YZ
u \ p
o
c i
m
n z ¢ k y _ n YZ
u
~Kr }
Zu
¨ ~ po r
c i
m
n z po
o0
y n
fn ~ ¢ [,_
n YZ
u } Z
u
¨ \ o r po o
ja¦ jruU:ta`cu¡Ua`r^&~geq7i)jaU'f&QU'i)UT~°`cf&jrum
¢ [,_
z YZ
u
\
ZZ [,_
n YZ
u
\
y Z
u
¨
~O
c¢ [,_
z YZ
u
\
ZZ [,_
n YZ
u
\k_
n
y{z
YZ
u
ZZ
_ n y YZ
u
~s [¨ z
\
jri'`c~~!
W
"H$#
c
¤|ºut_Uf&QUt_j¢U@£tTUTuyf)^:jcpf&QUUEd/q(`cu^&jru¯jc
`cus% `ci)U`c~~IU yb(`c~Ö
}
zU_^mf)UTi&SV^YjcGf&QUªjri&STm
¢'&
i)(
m
n z [,_
n YZ
u \u o+*
}
i)(
m
n z ¢-,6[,_
n YZ
u \ u o.
¦mf&Q
b0/21|b
`cusg
n3
fn 4#
3 b n g
n53
fl¤9(jrif&QUf)UTi&SV^ª^&bt)Q²f&Q(`cfh
n g n56
fl¦pU$b^)U
us/btTf&jruµ`r^"^&b7Sq7f&jru¡f)j=jrb7usefyg sl[*fE¨D\E¤IPQUf)UTi&S ^&bt)QAf&Q(`cf n g n c f2`cus b /Pc b ^
U b(`c~Lf)j7 [ } \m¦mf&Q8
6
z(QUTut_U$f&Q7^Yf)UTi&S ta`cuµ=USVjaU_sµf)jf&QU:~UE fQ(`cus+^&s7Uz¤9jrif&QU
f)UTi&SV^]^)bt)Q¡f&Q(`cf
n g n
cf2`cus b /6 b 7¦pUi)Ua`cq7q7~gf&QU`cj®U:UEd/q(`cu^&jru¡SVUTf&Qj¢s ¤ ìuA`$«u7f)U
uyb7SUTijc^)f)UTq^a/¦pUª«usAjru|f&QU'i&zQyfYQ(`cu^^&s7U'jru7~gef)UTi&SV^jcf&QUªjri&S
¢ & p
m
n z [,_
n YZ
u \
u9(
o * } p
m
n z ¢-, [,_
n YZ
u \
u9(
o .
¦mf&Q
n g /n 6
fĤ :;
< À À ""É7 ½ EHG .?)4=C4>= / ]wgKq@?BA b44 'DC ,{FEP5,wb)/5_
W?YZ
u
W
zGHG
Z e
,+-,+-l](&/JI
! #"]$,$%l ?4 ¡ 4 M
< À À ""É7 ½ _'G +-! #PM$ ? !vb5"0h ?("+kb"¡ Ab4`3P
_ X
uy{z
c| uy{z [,_
X
u ~
@r
\ ;#7>
aKLE jA$!$`3P
_ X
X c
@r
X
u z u
m
W
z W
^&u7f&QU:i)U_tTb7i&i)UTut_U$i)UT~°`cf&jruR;lW>]`cusK;#7>Tjruµta`cu²Ua`r^&~g¡UTf'`c~~GSVjrSVUTuyf)^'jcd_JX
Z
`cus_JX
X
ygeus/btTf&jru ¤dGUTi)U:`ci)U'f&QU(7«i)^&fmSVjrSVUTuyf)^5m
¢ _ X
X c ¢ _
W,YZ
X
c [* } @ \ r
¢ [,_ W?YX
X \ w c [* } @
\[* } @ \ r w
¢ [,_ W,YZ
X \
w
c ¢
[,_ W,YX
u \
w
[* ~ } @ ¨ \ z
¢ [,_
W?YX
X
\
c r
[ } @v\[# } @v\[ } @v\
¢ [,_
W,YZ
X
\
c r
[ } @v\[# } @ \[
} @v\ ~
Z
[* } @ \[
} @v\[ } @M~x@
w \
- ~
Z
[* } @v\ ~
Z
[ } @v\[* } @v\ ~ w
Z
[* } @v\[* } @v\
w
z#&4<#)(:%=$465& ,$( #85N(!#)(:%=|" /:% #&
9Gzb7i)UeW^&Qj®¦^f&QUi)UT~°`cf&Us/¸ UTi)UTut_U$UTf¬¦pU_UTuD_
W,YX
X
`cus_
W,YZ
X
¦mf&Qµ¨ cZ-5Z&jriYf&QUxcus
`cus7ci)s£SVjrSVUTuyf)^b^&u7f&QU`cu(`c~g¢f&tmjri&S:b7~°`r^zUTu`c=jaUª`cus£^)S:b7~°`cf&jrui)U_^&b7~f)^a¤9U]^"U_Umf&Q(`cf
jri f&QUªxcus`cus=7ci)s£SVjrSVUTuf)^a¢f&QU]~Sf¨c zU_^ b7q7q=UTip=jrb7usU_^&f&S£`cf&jrujri`c~~z`c~bU_^pjc
@L¤pPQU:s/¸ UTi)UTut_U:s7U_tTi)Ua`r^)U_^`c~SVjz^&f]q7i)jrq=jri&f&jru(`c~~g|f)jT
}
@²`cus fE¨ `cus @`cVzU_^Y`=jrb7us
jru9f&QUi)UT~°`cf&Us/¸=UTi)UTut_Umjri'f&QUxcus9SVjrSVUTuyfaLf&QU=jrb7us¯^
z
Z
~-[*fE¨H\E2`cus²jri'f&QUl7ci)s
SVjrSVUTuyfa(f&QU'=jrb7us|^
zGz w
Z
~ [*fE¨H\E¤
PQUpt_jrSq(`ci&^)jru¦mf&Q^&Sb7~°`cf&jru$^&Qj®¦^Gf&Q(`cf Z2f)UTi"`cf&jru^GzU` b7f)UIj¢js:`cq7q7i)jad¢S£`cf&jru ¤
PQ7^$zU_^`cu§s7Ua`+jcf&QU£ub7S:=UTiVjcf)UTi"`cf&jru^f&Q(`cf^$uU_U_s7U_s§f)jAQ(`aUi)UT~UTr`cuf$i)U_^)b7~f)^:i)jrS
^&Sb7~°`cf&jru^]u|f&QU'i"`cf)U:s7UTqUTus7UTufY^&g¢ut)Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jruµta`r^)Uz¤
-0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
x=p
Rel. error, N=10 M2 Rel. error, N=100 M2 Rel. error, N=1000 M2 Rel. error, N=10 M3 Rel. error, N=100 M3 Rel. error, N=1000 M3
-0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.1
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
x=p
Rel. error(theory), M2 Rel. error(theory), M3 Rel. error (simulation 1M), M2 Rel. error (simulation 1M), M1 Rel. error (simulation 10M), M2 Rel. error (simulation 10M), M3
9Gzb7i)UeWm]PQU_jri)UTf&ta`c~2i)UT~°`cf&UUTi&i)jriªq7~jrf;É~UEÉf> ojrSq(`ci&^)jru¯¦mf&Q¯^&Sb7~°`cf&jru ;Éi&zQyfadZ `cus
Zf)UTi"`cf&jru^>
9Gzb7i)U'x:^)Qja¦^f&QUUTSq7i&ta`c~ s/^&f&i&7b7f&jruC;n (> q7~jrf`cusf&QUªtTb7S:b7~°`cf&U's/^&f&i&7b7f&jrue b7utEÅ
f&jru2;Öo 9d> q7~jrfGjc7f&QUt_jruyf&uybjrb^f&SVU^&f"`cf&jru(`ci&g^&f"`cf)Upjcf&QU f&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fGf&Q(`cfG¦pU`cq7q7i)j_d/S£`cf)U
ygMZ f)UTi"`cf&jru^Ljc ;#7>¦mf&Qhr/c Z]`cus'zi"`cub7~°`ci&fëgjru"!2c /¤/Wjri @
h
h
kh
h
$#
5&¤
ìfLi)jrb7zQ7~g:^)Qja¦^f&Q7i)U_Upfëg¢q7ta`c~/^)Q(`cqU_^jc(f&QUn b7utTf&jru^2s7UTq=UTus/u7ªjru @{m @ 3 /&
3 @ 6
`cus @=c z¤
0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001
0 5 10 15 20 25
x granularity 0.01
p=0.1 p=0.3 p=0.5 p=0.7 p=0.9 p=1.0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
x granularity 0.01
p=0.1 p=0.3 p=0.5 p=0.7 p=0.9 p=1.0
9Gzb7i)U:x-m2n `cus+o 9§q7~jrf
9Gzb7i)U(7^&Qja¦^f&QU:¹jyºtTb7i&U'q7~jrf]`r^`Éb7utTf&jru+jc0@L¤2PQU's7UE«u7f&jruAjc ¹jyº7#^ms7UE«uU_sA`r^
f&QUS£`Kd¢Sb7S u^&f"`cuyf"`cuU_jrb^ªf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fl;Cjri]f&QUt_jruyf&ubjrb^'f&SVUq7i)jt_U_^)^>mf&Q(`cfªjruU:UTf)^
jcf&SVUm
¹jyº7 c !8> [,_K[,Sb\ !v\ 1 <fkZ&k
;tE&¤7r(jri SVjri)Us7UTf"`c~^pjruf&Q7^ps7UE«u7f&jru>E¤ Ãëfp^p^&b7i&q7i&^)u7f&Q(`cfp¦mQUTuf&QU^&g¢ut)Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jruei"`cf)U
utTi)Ua`r^)U_^a/f&QU:¹jyº tTb7i&U_^jriQ7zQfmr`c~bU'jc 9^utTi)Ua`r^&u7£¦mQUTi)Ua`r^f&QUªSVUa`cu|f&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7f
^s7U_tTi)Ua`r^&u7¤IPQ7^mta`cue=UYq(`ci&f&°`c~~gUEd¢q7~°`cuU_seg£f&QUYÖ`rtTff&Q(`cff&QUz`ci&°`cut_U'jcÍf&QUf&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7f
^'`£s7U_tTi)Ua`r^)u7eÉb7utTf&jru¯jc @9`cusµf&Q7^YQ(`r^`£S£`Kk&jriSq(`rtTf'jruµQ7zQUTi¹jyº¤Ã¬u²^&bt)Q9`t_jruyf)UEd/fa
f&QU:^)gut"Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jruµQ(`r^ª`q=jz^&f&UUE¸=U_tTfªjruAf&QU:Q7zQ¯¹jyºYuU:ta`cu²`c~^)jVujrf)Uf&Q(`cfYf&QU:i)UTzjru
$^]`c~SVjz^)fu^)UTu^&f&U'f)jf&QU:^&gut"Q7i)jru7´®`cf&jru+UE¸ U_tTfa¤
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
x=synchronization rate
QoS 10%
QoS 20%
QoS 30%
QoS 40%
QoS 50%
QoS 60%
QoS 70%
QoS 80%
QoS 90%
QoS 95%
mean
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
x=synchronization rate
QoS 50%
QoS 60%
QoS 70%
QoS 80%
QoS 90%
QoS 95%
mean
9Gzb7i)Uh7-m ¹jyºq7~jrf
ìuV9Gzb7i)Uw7/¢¦pU'`c~^)j^)U_UYf&Q(`cf jrim`c~~=r`c~bU_^jc0@Gyf&QUSVUa`cuef&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7fm^UTf¬¦pU_UTu+¹jyº£wy
`cus9¹jyº8z¤9U`c~i)Ua`rs/gµuj®¦.f&Q(`cf'f'ta`cu7ujrf'=U$UTf&f)UTiªf&Q(`cu²f&QUs7UTf)UTi&Su7^&f&tta`r^)U @Hc
¦mQ7t)Qet_jri&i)U_^&q=jrus7^ f)j¹jyºz¤<9jriz@
6 ¢f&QU]SVUa`cu£f&Q7i)jrb7zQ7q7b7f^Izb(`ci"`cuf)U_U_swy jc f&SVUz¤
0 2$12Y %)(2
! ! "$#&%'#)(* +%-,!.0/1*32$465)4'*7#8.053(:9;4<#)(:%=
ìu¶f&Q7^^"U_tTf&jru 2¦pUezUei)U_^&b7~f)^(`r^"U_s¶jru tT~°`r^)^)ta`c~m`cu(`c~g/^&^$jri µ`ci&j®¥q7i)j¢t_U_^)^)U_^jru·UTuUTi"`c~
^&f"`cf)UY^&q(`rt_UmGf&QU](`r^&t]ujrf&jru^jru£i&i)U_s/btT7~fëg|`cuslGª`ci&i&^pi)U_tTb7i&i)UTut_Uta`cuUjrb7usu;tE&¤ ,>E¤
BDC ¼yÀ ¼ G Zu
c [,_
z YZ
u
b_
ZdYZ
u \ ?hMD8b5"0ZM
.?) R
[
\c 4
[
\c 6 e
,+- a ¨
dcWe
Z c Zu 5u
?q & !!
( 'h4l,+-b,)]^ !d ?(#j54 !" M
b5*)OMYPQU ²`ci&jaq7i)jrq=UTi&fëg:^GtT~Ua`cia¤
Z¶^(ÅÖi&i)U_s/btT7~U(;tE&¤ ëcq ¤ >Er¦mQUTi)U^ÍjriLu^&f"`cut_U
f&QU UT=U_^&zbUSVUa`r^&b7i)Ujru²±
y
¤$PÍjeq7i)jaUf&Q7^® fª^'^&b-@£tTUTuyff)j|^)Qja¦³f&Q(`cfªi)jrS `cugµ^)f"`cf)Ua_¶
Zu
t_jrSVU_^ (`rt)f)j:`cug$zUTujrqUTuVuf)UTi&r`c~t_jruyf"`cu7u72[!rfk
]r5f\¦mf&Q£qjz^&f&Uq7i)jr(`c7~fëgvm
I`c~~ ^)jrb7i)t_U_^]UEd/qUTi&UTut_U`$~jz^)^]`cf N u /f&QUTu
Zu fE¨csr5f/(`cus
_ W,YZ
uy{z } r5f
c
_ W,YZ
u } r5f
PQ7^UTUTuyf'jt_tTb7i)^Y¦mf&QAq7i)jr(`c7~f¬gA~°`ci&UTif&Q(`cuD
Z
`cusµta`cuA=Ui)UTq=Ua`cf)U_sµ`cug|«u7f)Uub7S:=UTiªjc
f&SVU_^¦mf&Q|q=jz^&f&U'q7i)jr(`c7~f¬g¤
9Gu(`c~~g
Z
^qjz^&f&UwGª`ci&i&^ge`cq7q7~ta`cf&jruµjc<9(jz^&f)UTi ú^]tTi&f)UTi&jruAjru
Zu
;tEl¤] ë/q ¤x x>E¤
:;
BDC ¼yÀ
¼ G
.?) R
[
\ac e
[
\ac 6 4 )^X ?V"]! , E E I
46b"bb , j e ,+-<P
QSRUT
ZWVYX
Zu
¨
cuP , LOz^4=3MZM
K<+-]uc|¢ _ X
u c QSRST
ZWVYX
¢ _ W,YZ
u M
a g
dc e _ W,YZ
u _
W,YX
u 3MZM4V,+6 ?$ ,^ !v*5"0(! ?? (,+-h]b" Ek]"M]$! !<P
_
W,YX
uy{z c|
W
uy{z
_
W?YX
u
~ir } u
[,_
W,YX
u
~Kr } u \
5_
W,YX
u
W!
bl :M :M?43M4
X c 5_ X
u
5u
"
?^! ##j54 #"
e
+-"0 ,,! !T$&KX ?
"+k*"5¡ ]4`,+ w]$! !
_ X
uy{z
c uy{z
_ X
u
~$#
[,_
X
u
~$# \
K<+-]#Mcsr } ¢ _JX
X M
b5*)OM]9U¡«i)^&fe^&Qj®¦~Sf)^ejc(_
W?YZ
u `cus
[ ]
^
Z
yg us/btTf&jru ¤ 9jriVg c 7 _ W,YZ
c _
W?YX
yg
t_jru^&f&i&btTf&jru§`cus²g²`r^"^&b7Sq7f&jruK5_
W,YZ
W
z Y GHG
YZ
^ªÖ¤Ö¤ús ¤ QUTut_U
[ ]
%
Z ¢ _
W,YX
`/¤ú^a¤ygµ~°`_¦jc
~°`ci&U'ub7S:=UTi)^a¤ ^)^&b7SVUªf&Q(`cfO_
W,YZ
u _
W?YX
u `cus'&
]
(*) ,+- (./
^ - (0.
]
^1+
Z £`/¤ú^a¤9U'Q(`aU
_
W?YZ
uy{z c|
W
uy{z W?YZ
u [ W,YZ
u \
ºut_U
W,YZ
u _
W,YX
u
~er } u `/¤ú^®¤ ¦U¡Q(`aU`_
W?YZ
uy{z
_
W,YX
uy{z
`/¤ú^a¤ ;Éf&QU+`/¤ú^®¤ t_jruUTi&UTut_UAjri
W
uy{z W,YZ
u
^s/bUªf)jf&QUt_jruf&uyb7f¬g¡jc>E¤
9jrif&QU`/¤ú^a¤~Sf]jc
[ ]
^
Z
7¦U'b^)Uªf&QUªuU b(`c~fëgvm
_ W,YX
uy{z } _
W,YZ
uy{z
3 W
uy{z W,YX
u 32
W,YX
u }
W,YZ
u 4 ~ W
uy{z W?YX
u } W
uy{z W,YZ
u W,YZ
u
3
W,YX
u }
W,YZ
u ~ W
uy{z W?YX
u } W
uy{z W,YZ
u W,YZ
u
