Extracting Micro Ontologies from Interrogative Domains For Epistemic Agents
Tracey Hughes and Cameron Hughes
Abstract
Introduction
! " # $ # %
%# % # #&#
'(#)"*++,- %#%
" # # % '! # $ *++, . % % % " %#
" #0#0 #1 %% # # # '1 *+2+, # '0 2345, % ##
# % # #& % % % # 0-%#%
% 0 % #
# # - % % 6
%
# 7 %
Interrogative Domains as Sources of Knowledge
. # % $ # 8
$ # # # ' 2354, -
# ## % #
% 1&#
% %7 # % % - % #% 9 %%
%% # %% %
# # . # %
% " # # % 9 % " # #
##
-" #$ # # # 9
# '0 2345, # % % " # 0#
&##9 #
#%%" # % " #$
':#:*++3,- #%
%# " ##%
. # # " # $ -
$ # #
% % # - %#%#
% # 0 % 7
% # 1);<')0 ; < 8, % #9);<9 0 0###
);<
0 #
% " #$ #" # %
Interrogative Domains and Entailment
. 9 9
# .
% # % ## # # # - %
" '!
2345, 1 % % 9 # # %$ # -
$ # ###
-% %$
# & "
'!"#! *++,!$ # ## "#
% %
= $ #
> 9 $ # -2"% %
# # Question and Answer
Q6
A
Entailed Proposition
<2 Inferred Propositions
!" #
""
- % ? # 8 <2#% <2
% .2#.*- " # 9# % #
Notions of Knowledge and Truth
# %" ##
" #1- 8'@23A, %
@ #'-8@,%
8 - 8 # #';23AB,%
" - # #%
% . " # # # 7&#
%1@ "'@ "23AB,
- 8 #
< 8.%$@ "6 $%&'(')'')*'2, -)' +#' +
"# % # 9 % - 8 >
9 ## # #&# <
C':*++4,
Contrast of Agents and Epistemic Agents
. 9 % " # #&# # % 8 #
% %%%#%%#
#
" >21 % 'C 233B,') #; %%233,
#'1 ##*+++," % @ "
# C# " # 0 '@ "#C#2333,1 # '@ "#C#2333, ## 'C 233B, # ') #
; %%233, &#
% ':#:*++3,.'@ "#C#2333,
&#DD # - %
# ##$
# # 0 #
< ':
*++4,#% # $ 7% # " # #
% # % #>
E(8 'E# ( 8, ':
# : *++3, # !E.
'1 ##*+++,-E(8##
,6
,%-.'/''01'*, 6
. < C
/ ## %% .
' %
0 ## %
% .
- " # #-8@'7&#%,.
#
.%-2'2'3'4'51 ! 6
%"
%"
%7&
%
0 %
.
"#
$
% & ' ( )
* + ! , !-- .))/!
0 / '
## %%#&%
E # '##
?F8 % # # ,#% / "
# 0
Defining the Knowledge Space
%6.'.'.7''.8
% # % # - 6
1!
) % #
" # % # "
!#) % "
# 0 #-
% 2 "#
3
45
" "
*
* 6
2 5
2 5 7
* 8
+
4
9 45
9"'" #):
) %##" #
$ $ - $ -*
." #$ "
# ) $ # % # # $ 0 # $ '1*++5,9 % ': # : *++3, #% % / " # / %
.%6
GH ',
%E(8>#
< 89 #6
:0&:*) 0&:* ;,/&&:**$'A, - 9 # # % " % #
Ontological Artifacts
- % " # % " # % # .%
# %#
# # # # 9 % / " # C ',
# # # '@ "23AB,
"% 1#
': # : *++3, 9 # % - 9 % %% 6
Step 1: C " % ?F8
% /#
Step 2: %?F8 # 2B
%$ #
Step 3: ) #"
$ # "
Step 4:
?F8
Step 5: #6
9 %%
- & % ?F8
& ?F8 &
# % # .% ?F8 # #"
. # ?F8&
'@ # )233B,
C %6%6# ! "86
:!
% # %
Model Theoretic Semantic = Micro-Ontology % = #- 8 '=-8, 9 % % '!"#! *++, 6
%T
T
# 7T
( =-8%%
% 0 . % =-8 %&
# 0 % " # -# #%
);<6
# 8#
#"# # # %> 9 9 %% # -26
<26
.C B # 6
<2G 6
$2 $<+ $2 '$= ' $
>
-9# % #6 ?&$2 '?*
?&$= '?*
?&$>'?*
- % # # % : #
## #
%
# %
9 % # %# ' #%# 7 , ' , # " 5
# '!"#! *++, # # I #J0 % . 9 % $ '(, 8 .C.C 0 # ### ( - 0 % # %#
ROGUE Agent Architecture
8 #);<
9 % );<
')0 ; < 8, 9 0 0#
0 #
% " #$ #" # % - );< 9 % ' , % # -2 );<
" >* %
5+ #<@2A.+
);<
-);< ;)8==8) '.C.C,#.
?F8 > .C.C ' C .%
C, #(.'(.%, );<. # ?F8 # #8K .C.C % 1)E(<- # 9 . ?F8 > # " ?F8 1 . %" ?F8%
#%..% #%"
?F8% #.C.C % #- " ?F8 % % 0 ## % - ?F8 -.?F8>
# C' #,@ # -;(8<E.8 #" # # . 2 . '# 0 ,#
% # 1
# %# # 9#
. # # ;(8<E.8 ##-D #D" # $#
);< # #
;(8<E.8 % - D #D" # ##
%
Discussion And Future Work
. # % "
);< 9 0 # % # 1# % #7 - # # " #
$ $ %
# 0 : 7 # 0 % # # 7
% "##
% # . "# # : # 0 $% %" #$
##);< %
## % %
# 9 9 1 % 0# " #
> $ # $ > # *+L %?F8 # C # " # %
% # " # 1
% # 0#
## %
# # #%& %1 #
" ### %%
1 # .C.C(
%% 2++L %?F8 # 1# % # %
" #$
References
1@C; .#1#M
*+2+ . # @ # = -
>0# < E M %8&.% <E 8#=%K *6*0*5
0 C 2345 @ # = 6 8 8
@ #8$ E <<9 C M % < K B6 30A4
! @ = -" " 1 *++5 C1 - #8 (8C8= C#C %<6 C
: # : - *++3 - =
< 8#. < . # % .<<< . % . # . C K 2 4504A2!76.<<<
@.23A-$ %) (
@ C( "6C=
; < 23AB . M&# - !% @ #N 8K *B62*202*B
@ " C 23AB C # = # 8 > 2A64B03
: - : # 8 *++4 <
C# ) % - 8 8# # .% C #
<C 62+202+5
C 233B 8 # 8.
M A+'2,6203*
) 8C # ; %% = 233 8 8 8 % ) 8 . # % . % A5042
@M 6=.-
1 ##=*+++) 8 ) 8
#=6=.-
@ " ) # C# > 2333 >
# =08 C 8 %
=#8& .K * O6 B32023
@ :#)233B> E . # = # - C % ( > # E ) - (#6@8#
;<=2$-=.))1 >
< < * ? 9@
A>
! ; < !" ) # )# <C 2345 9 # (
#=6=.-
!" # ! M *++ ) # .% % ( C% # 86 C.
( C # )" K *++
C#=86=.-
1;2354- %? 8 :#(M6<8 .
