Cooperation of Decision Procedures for the Satisfiability Problem
23
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Cooperation of Decision Procedures for the Satisfiability Problem Christophe Ringeissen. N˚ 2753 Décembre 1995. PROGRAMME 2. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) ! "$#% &'
(6) (%*)
(7) ,+- /.$ 101 2
(8) 435 .$076 /8 9;:=<?>A@=BDC;9;E-F<HG;IDEJ<K>>AEJGL M;NPORQ&NTS1U UV!WXZY[S1\^]`_a\,bdcJUefOR\hg^iR_jVRk1laNPORQRN`S1U U%S1mPghO1nV2moQ V2p njgqV \hORQ&g^]`ghV2\ M;NdOrsV2mM;NPORmPtaV2O u!S1ljlDO&Ndm[vJV/NdV=]dtjV2NT]PtaVn7wxWRy&zR{XZ|}Vp ]`V2UeaNPV~&RzoX~7lDS1Q&V2b A =1D1 &YORnabPmdN`S1ghnJmljNdORQ&NTSUUgnaQgqb,bdmPNdORnjQR\hc/eDSbdVv7ORnmdtaV_abPV[O1DbPOR\hRV2NPb;[tag^]dtS1NdV!Sea\hV mdO ]PtaV]PbTSmdghbK4S1eagh\hghmKcO1]sORnabPmdNTSghnxmPb VbPtaO1gqn mdtaghb[lDSlDVANS7Nd_a\hV`KeDS1bPVv}S\qQ&ORNPgqmPtaUORN[bPOR\hJghnaQ ghnSU OavJ_a\^S1N[[S=cmdtaVb`S1mdghbS1eagh\hghmKclaNdO&ea\hV2U/ N m=S]s\Sbdb/OmdtjV2ORNPgqVAb!,/[taV]AS1bdV[tjV2NdV ! ghbmPtaV _anaghORnO mKOvJghbqrsORghnJmmPtaV2O&NdghV2b[!¢¡£SnDv!f¤[ghbJnaO1[nORN[S7\qO&naQ mdghUV[ej_amV!bPmd_Dv¥c taVANdV}vJg¦VANdV2nJm]2S1bPV2b[tjV2NdV_anD]`mPghORnbdcJUefOR\hbSNdV bdtDSNdVv§exc$!¢¡S1nDv$!f¤1[taV]PtaO&bdV2n¨S1lJ laNPOxS&]dt\hVSRv¥bmPOS£taghQRta\hc!njORnJdvJV2mPV2NdU gqnjgqbPmdg^] vJV=]`ORU lDO&bdghmdghORn/S\qQ&ORNPgqmPtaUea_am vJNTSbdmPg]AS1\h\hc!bdghU la\hg©fV2b mPtaV_anDvJVANdbdm`S1nDv¥gqnjQ}O1[mdtaV]sORUeaghnDSmdghORnlaNPORea\hV2U$/[taVO&eamTSgqnjVv-v¥V]`ORU lDO&bdghmdghO&n-S1\hQRO&NdghmdtjUªgqb gh\h\h_abdmPNTS1mPVv eJcmdtjV]sORUeaghnDSmdghORnOnaO&nJv¥gqbhr`ORghnJm Vi&_DSmdghORnfS1\4mdtjV2ORNPgqVAb « ¬J4®d¯/°fR±;1-]sORnabPmdNTSghnxm laNdO&QRNTSUU gqnjQDkv¥V]`ghbdghORn laNdOa]`V=vJ_aNdV&kabTSmdghbK4S1eagh\hghmKcxk1]`O&UeaghnDS1mPgqO&n/laNPOReJ \hV2U. ¾d¿^À Á,¿^Â4Ã^ÄJÅ`ÆHÆ?ÇsÈÊÉRË ÌÍfÁ ¿^À ÎÏËÃhÐ!Ç`ÈÊÑ^ÒÍjÓ1ÆÈ©ÔHÕHÅ`Ö1ÓRË2× Á¢ÈÊÉRØTËÈ©ÔÔÙËKÉxڢѩÅ`Æ^È©Ç1× ÛÊÆ. ²^³µ?´ ¶K·¸ µ´ ¹ ºh¶K»K¼`½. Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine Technôpole de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique, 615 rue de Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LÈS NANCY (France) Téléphone : (33) 83 59 30 30 – Télécopie : (33) 83 27 83 19 Antenne de Metz, technopôle de Metz 2000, 4 rue Marconi, 55070 METZ Téléphone : (33) 87 20 35 00 – Télécopie : (33) 87 76 39 77.
(9)
(10) " } "$# ª"} " #% 0 } .$07 6Z "} ;
(11) & ; /.$ 101 2
(12) ´
(13) ¬ ,SljNdORQ&NTSUU%SmdgORn%S=&V]]`ORnJmdN`S1ghnJmdV2b7V2bdm/efS1baVAp Vbd_aN/\ _amPgq\hghbTSmdghORnvJVbdOR\h&V2_aNdb]2S= lDSea\hV2bvJVV2p NPgDV2N/\^Sb`S1mPgqb?S1ghb`S1eagh\hghmaVp vJVAb]`ORnJmPNTS1ghnJmdVAb
(14) [OR_jb/laNaVAp bdV2nJmdO&nab_an S\hQRORNPghmdtaU VS eDSbdV vJV NV2 QR\hV2blDO&_aNNaV2p bPOR_DvJNPVvJV£?S]` O&nU O¥v¥_a\^S1ghNdV \hVolaNdO&ea\V2 UV!vJVobTSmdghbK?SghbTS1ejgq\hghmaV[p lfS1NNTS1ljlDO&NdmS _anaV ]`\^SbdbdVv¥Vmdt[V2p O&NdghV2b/!,4V]2Sb O_$ !$V2bdm/_jnaV_jnaghORnvJV v¥V2_ mdt[V2p O&NdghV2bv¥gqbhr`ORghnJmdVAb!!¢¡/V2m !D¤ V2bPm]`ORnjnx_jV%vJV2lj_aghb\hORnjQRmdVAUlab U%SghbnjOR_ab V2p md_fvJghORnabg^]`g v¥V2b ]AS1bO_ \hV2bbdcJUefOR\hV2b/vJVORnD]smdghORnab bPORnJmlfS1Ndm`S1Q V2p b lDSN !4¡V2m !f¤R ÊSlalaNdOa]PtaV!]PtaO&gqbPghV!]`ORnDv¥_aghm S _anS\qQ&ORNPgqmPtaUVvJV!vVp ]`O&UlfORbPgqmPghORn O&NdmPV2UV2nJmnaORn¥vVAp mdV2NPUghnaghbdmPVi&_ag4bdghU la\hg©fVlfOR_aNPmTSnxm[\^S/]sORUljNaV2p taVAnabdghORnvJ_laNdO&ea\V2 UV!v¥V]sORUeag nDSghbdORn, ! S\hQRORNPghmdtaU V vJV vVp ]`O&UlfORbPgqmPghORnV2bPm[gq\h\h_abPmdNaVop lDS1N\hV!U V2p \^S1naQ&V vJV mPt V2p ORNPghV2b%Vp i&_DS1mPghORnanaVA\q\hV2b naO&n}vJghbqr`O&gqnJmPV2b "°f ÏA®T$# ¬ laNPORQ&NTS1U U%SmdghORnS=&V]]`ORnJmPNTS1ghnJmdVAbk4laNPOa]DVp vJ_aNPVvJVvVp ]sgqbPghORn kfbTSmdghbKKS1ghbTSeagh\qghmaVRp kalaNPO1 ea\V2 U VvJV]`ORUeaghnDSghbdORn.
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18) !"# %$&(') * +
(19) ,,-. 0/
(20) 213
(21) 45 0/167. {.
(22) "$#%[
(23) :Kn$NdV]sV2nJmc&VS1NPbk4mPtaVlaNdO&ea\hV2UªO1!]`O&UeaghnaghnaQvJV]`ghbPgqO&n-ljNdOa]`VvJ_jNdV2beDV=]2S1U VOQRNPVS1mPV2bdmghnxmPV2NdVAbdm ghn$U%S1nJc DV2\^vJb7O1 ]`O&Ula_jmdV2N bT]sgqVAnD]`VRk;V2bPlDV=]`g^S1\h\hc}O&N/]`ORnabPmdN`S1ghnJmljNdORQ&NTSUUghnaQS1nfv-S_amdO&U%S1mPVv vJV=vJ_D]`mPgqO&n &[taVU OavJ_a\^S1N ]`O&nabdmPNd_D]smdghORnO¢vJV=]`ghbdghORnlaNdOa]`V=vJ_aNdVAb[tDS1b;efV2V2n]`O&nabdg^vJV2NPVvHORN mPtaVDNPbdm mPgqU V!eJ<c ;JtaO&bdmTS> =h~yJk,#~ ?*@ gqnO&NTvJV2N mPObdOR\h&VtjV2mdV2NPORQ&V2naV2O&_aboORNPU_a\^S1V!ghnJRO&\hxghnaQS1NdghmPtaUV2mPg^]!S1nfv S&vavJghmdghORnfS1\j_anD]`mPghORnbPcJUeDO&\qb=0 AolalaNPO ¥ghUS1mdVA\qcghnmPtaV bTS1U V!mPgqU VRk [V2\hbdO&<n BDC!ljlDV2En =q~=WJk4~{jk4~RF~ @ laNPORlfORbPVv¨S1n S1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaUvJVvJg^]2SmdVv§mdO}mPtaV_jnaghORnO1!mPtaV2O&NdghV2bS aghORU%Smdg G2ghnaQNPVS1\hbk;S1NPNTS=cJbk,\hghbdmdb SnDv}SRvjvJghmdghORnDS\aH_anD]`mPgqO&nbdcJUeDO&\hbJ[taVSghU Sb[mdO ea_agh\^vSRS1\hg^vJghmKc]PtaV]PRVAN[O&N!laNPORQRN`S1U Ug©njQ \^S1njQR_DSQRV2b[ghn[tjg]Ptbd_f]dt ORNPU_a\^S1V NdVi&_aVAnxmP\hc%S1ljlDVSN HjORNPU%S\q\hcRkmdtaV 7I/
(24) 2J vJV]sgqbPghORn}laNPORea\hV2Uª]2Sn%efV/bPmTS1mPVv}SbOR\h\hO1[#b K L ghRV2nmKO/fNdbdm?O&NTvJVAN mPtaV2ORNPghV2b !4¡SnDv!f¤ ea_agh\hm[NdVAbdlfV]`mdgh&V2\hc-O&n%mPtaV/bPgqQ&nDS1mP_aNdVANb Mo¡ S1nD<v M[¤kDtjO1 ghb!ghm[lfORbPbdghea\hV/mdO ea_jgq\^v/SovJV]`ghbPgqO&n S\hQRORNPghmdtaU ORN,mdtaOV Mo*¡ POM[¤sKmdtaV2O&Ndc/!¢*¡ P!f¤ mdtDSnaJbmPO!mPtaV v¥V]`ghbdghORnS1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaUb laNPO1Jgv¥VvORN[mPtaV Mo¡dKmdtaVAORNdc !4¡!SnDv mdtaQV M[¤T?mPtaV2ORNPc!f#¤ R S£nJmdgh\;naO1/kamPtaVU%SgqnS1bPbd_aU lamdghORn gqbomdtaVvJghbqrsORghnJmdnaV2bPb O1bPgqQ&nDS1mP_aNdVAQ b M ¡ SnD<v M ¤ T A H_aNdmPtaV2N Sbdbd_jUlamPgqO&nnaV2Vv¥Vv¨ghn mPtaVN`S1U V2O&Nd$O1[V2\hbdO&"n BUC!ljlDV2n¨ghbmdtDSmbPgqnjQR\hVmPtaV2ORNPghV2bU_abdm7eDV _anjgq&V2Ndb`S1\;S1nDv V W/ 1X4Y
(25) 2 -Z[
(26) V [tag^]dtU VS1nabmdtfS1m!SORNPU_a\^S \ghb[bTSmdghbK4S1ea\hV!gS1nfvORnj\qcg mdtjV2NdV V aghbdmPb/SUOavJVA\ O1mdtaV/mPtaV2O&Ndc}[ghmdt$S1n}ghnJDnjgqmPVvJO&U%S1ghn bTS1mPghbKcJghna]Q \^ ;JODkjV2RV2n O&N!mdtjV vJghbhr`ORghnJm ]2SbdVRk,S1eabPmdNTS&]`m/S1bPbd_aU lamdghORnjb[ORnmdtaVAORNdghV2b/SNdV/naVAVvJVv$ghnORN`vJV2N mdO OReam`S1ghn}S]`O&Ula\hV2mPV2naV2bPb!NdVAbd_a\hm OmPtaV/vJV]`O&UlfORbPgqmPghORn%S\hQRORNPghmdtaU$ AonaORmPtaV2N UOavJ_a\^S1NPghmKc}laNdO&ea\hV2U tDS1befV2V2n mPtaORNPOR_aQ&ta\hc bPmd_DvJghVv vJ_aNdghnaQ$mdtjV}\^S1bdmv¥V]2SRv¥VORN _anjg©4]2S1mPgqO&"n =h~=Jk Wa~1_k ?jk #~ `Jak `ak { @ghn$mdtaV_jnaghORn$O1[mKO Vi&_DS1mPgqO&nDS1\ mdtaV2O&NdghV2Qb b¡SnDcv b!¤k4mdtDSm gqb O&N bdOR\hJghnaQV=iR_fS1mdghO&nab gqn mdtaVmPV2NdUS1\hQRV2ejNTeS dYf+MoZ¡ PM[¤ gheikjYl(manVoWm^pR¢[taV2n k4mPtaV]`ORUeaghnDSmdghORn mPV]Ptanag^i&_aV2bvJV2&V2\hORlfVvghn$mdtaghb]sORnJmdV amtDS=RVefV2V2n V amdV2nfvJVv ghn-mKO-vJghNdV=]`mdghORnj#b K¢DNdbPmk;mdO$S1\h\hO1 O&mdtaV2N]`ORnabPmdN`S1ghnJmdqb = raka~=zJka#~ s@Dghn dtf+Mou¡ P(M[¤ gheikjl(m_nkoWm^p[S1nDv7bdV]sORnDv4kmdO lDVANdUghm,bdtDSNdVv7_jnD]`mdghO&n bPcxUefOR\hb =h ~ rakay @d :KnmPtaghblfS1lfV2Nk;VlaNPV2bdVAnxm]sORUeaghnDSmdghORn}mPV]Ptanag^i&_aV2bO&N/bdO&\hxghnaQmPtaVORNdghQ&gqnfS1\;bTSmdghbKSeagh\hgqmKc laNPORea\hV2U ghn SnjORnJdvJV2mPV2NdU gqnjgqbPmdg^] U%SnanaV2 N fHmdtaV$bdghUlj\qVAbdmORnj#V iSnDv¨ghn¨mdtaV$naORn¥vJghbhr`ORghnJm ]AS1bdV& ;JV=]`mdghORnWNdV=]2S1\h\hb!mPtaV/eDSbdg^]/vJV`fnaghmdghORnaboO1 mdtjV/naORmPghORnabo_abdVv gqn mdtaV HOR\h\hO1[gqnjQDW :K> n ;JV]`mPghORn-{jkaV laNPV2bdVAnxm[mPtaV!NP_a\hV`KeDS1bPVvvJV]`O&UlfORbdghmPgqO&n S\hQRORNPghmdtaU [tag^]Ptghb]sORNdNPV]`m!SnDv]`ORU la\hV2mdVHORNS\q\j_anaghORnab OmdtaVAORNdghV2b ]`ORnjbdg^vJV2NPVv-S\hORnaQmPtaV/lDSlDV2N=^ ;JV]`mPgqO&>n rQ&ghRV2bomdtaV/Q&V2naV2N`S1\ ]`O&nabdmPNd_D]`mPghORn$O1SUOavJV2\ O&N;mdtaV[_anjgqO&n/O1fmdtaV2O&NdghV2b !¢0¡ P[!f¤RW ;JV]`mPgqO&n zoghnJmdNPO¥v¥_D]`V2b bP_ v%]`ghV2nJm S1bPbd_aU lamdghORnjb ORnvJghbqrsORghnJm ORN naO&nJdvJghbqr`O&gqnJm,mdtaV2O&NdghV2bmdO efV!]`ORUeaghnaV=v42Vghnx&V2bdmPghQxS1mPVmPtaV!]2SbdV![tjV2NdV[bPtDS1NPVv7_anD]smdghORnbdcJUefOR\hb SNdV[ghnJmdV2NPlaNdV2mPVv ghnmPtaV[mdNPgqJg^S1\J[S=Yc fgK VR1bPcJnxm`SR]`mPg^]2S1\h\hc i ghneDO&mdtU O¥v¥V2\hb O14mdtjV[mdtaV2O&NdghV2b=u ;JV=]`mdghOR]n ` laNPV2bdVAnxmPbbPORUVSlala\hg^]2S1mPghORnab NdVA\SmdVv§mdO$Vi&_DS1mPghORnDS\ mdtaVAORNdghV2b=Z :Kwn ;JV=]`mdghORn¨yak,V]`ORnf]`\h_DvJV[ghmPt DnfS1\ NPV2U%SNdJb[S1nDv_amP_aNdV ORNPxb= !+§} 2
(27) % x V DNPbdmejNdghV yDc gqnJmPNdOavJ_D]`VbPORUV eDS1bPg^]njORmTSmdghORnjb 4VAzm M{l|f%}zgV~QieDV$S}U ORnaO?bPORNdmPVv$fNdbdm O&NTvJV2NobdghQRnfS1md_jNdV [taV2NPV } gqb[SDnaghmdV bdVAm!O14H_anD]`mPgqO&nbdcJUeDO&\hbS1nDIv ~ ghb[S7DnaghmdVobdV2moO1ljNdVvJg^]2SmdV bPcxUefOR\hb=R[taV bPV2.m ~ vJOJV2b[njORm!]`O&nxm`S1ghzn l [tag^]Ptghb!S1\h[S=cxb gqnJmPV2NdlaNPV2mdV=v}S1b[mPtaV gv¥V2nJmdghmKcNdV2\^SmdghORn 8. 9. Á,Á É# !.
(28) r. $u
(29) V!$&.
(30) 2
(31) # . [taVobd_aejbdV2m[OD_jnD]`mdghO&nbdcJUeDO&\hbghnY} fNdVAbdl JlaNPVvJg^]2SmdV bdcJUefOR\hb ghn5~Qi O¢SNdghmKcghbvJVAnaORmPVveJc } fHNdV2bPl ~iAJ[taVSNdghmKcOS_anD]smdghORnbPcxUefOR\ fNPV2bdl fS/ljNdVvJg^]2SmdV bdcJUefOR\ Ti ghb[vJV2naO&mdVv eJc
(32) fTi5fHNdV2bPl
(33) f Tiki2f[taVbdVAm/O1 M KmdVANdUboO1RV2N S bdV2mS1nDv O1taVAgqQ&tJmghb vJV`DnaV=v$NdV]`_jNdbdgh&V2\hc SbOR\h\hO1[#b K ~R. df MgiZlk Wa. dTf+MgiZl f
(34) i"!#%$ }Qg&
(35) $cfd#' ¡ f+MgiFi )( Ped', ¡ f+MgiA [taV bPV2m!O M KmdV2NPUbO1RV2*N ghb def+Mgi l P + d f+MgiA A!nV=iR_jgqRS\hV2nD]`V NdVA\SmdghOR%n , O&-n ]2Sn efV/V amdVAnDvJVv}Sb[_abd_fS1\ O&%n K f
(36) *¡ g/./.0.g
(37) qi1,Df
(38) 2 ¡ g/.0./.kg
(39) 32 ig5 4768$c=h0~ g95@kg
(40) : ,
(41) 2: SnDvvJV`DnjV2b S]`O&naQRNP_aV2nD]sV%NPV2\^S1mPgqO&;n , ORcn dYf MgiSb O&\q\hO1[b K7 f<
(42) ¡ i,= f<
(43) ¤ i g>
(44) ¡ ,?
(45) ¤ S1nfv @$ }% [O&mdV mdtDSmV!_jbdV RV]smdORNPb[mdOv¥V2naORmPV md_ala\hV2b=J[taV Vi&_aghRS1\hV2nD]sV]`\^S1bPbO
(46) $%/ N= m ,gqb vJVAnaORmPVveJ>c =
(47) @BA ¢V2m_ab]`ORnjbdg^vJV2NmPtaVbdV2mON M KmdV2NPUb/O1&V2]N h[taV2NP>V h gqbS1n ghnJDnaghmdVvJV2nJ_aU V2NTSea\hVbdV2mO RSNdg^S1ea\hV2b=R[tjV!mdVANdUDb C E F SnDGv C#= HJILKM!@¢v¥V2naORmPV NdV2bPlDV]smdghRV2\hc mdtaVobd_aeamPV2NdU O1 CSmmPtaV!lfORbPgqmPghOR)n H SnDv mdtjVNPV2la\^SR]`VAUV2nJm ghn C O C E F eJ"c MR=[taVbdcJUefOR\1ON C Oa]2]s_aNdNPgqnjQSm mPtaVlfORbPghmdghOROn HcfNPV2bdl mdtaVmdO&l bPcxUefOR\jO1 Ci;ghb[NdghmdmPV2)n C fPHi fNdVAbdl C fQikiAR[taVobdV2mO1 RSNdg^S1ej\qVAbOa]2]s_aNdNPgqnjQghnS7mdV2NPRU CgqbvJV2naO&mdVv eJ-c S.fTCi24VAVm U efVS M dS1\hQRVAeaNTS [ghmPt S1b[vJORUS1ghn A!nSbdbPgqQ&naUVAnx*m W}ghbS US1laljgqnjQ[NPORU h mdO )Xaghm_jnag^iR_jV2\hcV amdV2nDv¥b!mdOSntaO&UO&UORNPlataghbdY U W NdO&U dYf Mghei mPO U J[taV NdV2bPmdNdg^]`mPghORn}OD W$mdO S7bdV2m[O RS1NPgSea\hV2b Z ghb v¥V2naORmPVv eJ[c W E \ J[taVoNTSnaQRVoO1D W ghb v¥V2naORmPVv eJ-c ]
(48) af^W iA0 A_U KbdOR\h_amPghORn OS/i&_DS1nJmdgDVANKHNdV2V M HORNdU_j\(S \}ghbSnS1bPbdghQRnaU V2nJ<m W}bP_D]PtmdtfS1m W f \ i;taOR\^vJb gqn U &[taVO&NdU_a\^S \§gqb[RS\hgvgh% n U kavJV2njORmdV=veJ-c U !l \kjgS1nJcSbdbdghQ&naUV2nJm Wghb[)S U ?bPOR\h_amdghO&nO1Z \ A ! /! +
(49) W +
(50) % ghb SnS1bPbdghQRnaU V2nJm,NdO&U h mPQ O dYf Mghei,[gqmPtORna\hc7DnaghmdVA\qcU%SnJcRSNdg^S1ej\qVAb naORm US1lalfVv mPOmPtaV2U bdV2\hRVAb A¨bd_aeabPmdghmd_jmdghORn_anag^i&_aV2\hc V amdV2nfvJb mdO/Sn/V2nDvJO&UO&NdlataghbPU O) dYf Mghei2AV _abPV\hV2mPmdV2NP<b `^gaZgb_g9c g0././.KmdO!vJVAnaORmPVbP_aeabdmPghmd_amPgqO&nabSnDv vJO[naO&mvJghbdmPghnaQR_aghbPdt `S1nf"v ` Aolala\hg^]2S1mPgqO&n!O bP_aeabdmPghmd_amPgqO&nab ghb![NdghmPmdV2n$OR_amoeJclfORbdm aVvr`_ amTSlDO&bdghmdghORn,aV]2S\h\ 0(7I
(51) 2 O1 mdtaVbd_jeabdmPgqmP_amdghO&n `mPta V f^DnaghmP#V ibPV2mORS1NPg^S1ea\hV2)b e[f& f`^i lg &hi! h_$ h S1nfjv hk`mln l h k 0 O1" `mdtaVbPV2mO mPV2NdU b o
(52) af`^il{Pqp3r s<t vuPw&x &h` ( S1nDzv y
(53) W/ 1Y 0 O1{ ` mdtaV bdV2mO1[RS1NPg^S1ea\hV2"b S|o
(54) af^`^il Pqp3r&s<t uPw&x S.f^h`^iAT A bd_aeabPmdghmd_jmdghOR} n ` gqb
(55) W 7(&* V gD `]l_` `; ~ 3¬ <iH/ k ° J A M ?mPtaV2ORNP c fNPV2bdl J_jnaghRV2NPbTS1^\ M KmdtaV2O&Ndc i gqb[5S fHlDO&bdbdghea\hcghnJDnaghmdV i;bdV2m[ODfNdbdm?O&NTvJVAN M KbdV2njmdV2nD]sV2] b fHNdV2bPl ,_anaghRV2NPbTS\q\hciR_fS1nJmdgDVv DNPbdmKKORN`vJV2N/bPV2nJmdV2nf]`V2b iAk [tjV2NdVbPV2nJmdV2nD]sV2b SNdV7ORNPU_J \^S1VAb[ghmPtaOR_am£NdVAVRSNdg^S1ea\hV2b=a[taYV M KmdtaV2O&Ndc fNPV2bdl,4_anaghRVANdbTSZ\ M ?mPtaV2ORNPc i!O ]S M KbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPV U gqb vJVAnaORmPVveJ5c d<fBU i.fHNdV2bPl J! fBU iki S1nDvghb vJV`DnjVvSb mdtaVobdV2m O14DNPbdmKKORN`vJV2ON M ?bPV2nJmdV2nf]`V2b fNPV2bdl, _anjgq&V2Ndb`S1\h\hc-i&_DS1nJmPg©fVvfNdbdm?O&NTvJVAQN M ?bPV2nJmdV2nf]`V2b iY\ bd_D]PtmdtfS1"m U !l \^ A M ?bPmdNP_D]`md_jNd-V U ghbS U O¥v¥V2\4O1 YS M ?mPtaV2ORNPc!,kavJV2naO&mdVv ex8c U !l¨!,kagq U !l \$O&N Snx]c \$! [ A ]`ORnrs_anD]`mPgqO&nO SmdORU g^] MO 1X
(56) V 1 fHgK V&xSnS1mdO&Ug^]ORNPU_a\^Sak1S1nVi&_DSmdghORnO&NghmPb naV2QJS1mdghO&Jn i [ghmPtbdORU V[_anaghRVANdbTS\h\qc i&_DSnxmPgDVv RS1NPgSea\hV2bgqbbdghU la\hc]2S1\h\hVv taV2NPV/YS MO # 75 16 0 A vJghbqr`_jnD]`mdghO&n%O M HORNPU_a\^S1VU_abdm eDV JghV2VvSb_abP_DS1\ Sb S7bdV=iR_jV2nD]`V/O M HORNdU_j\SV mdO]`O&nabdg^vJV2N[bPV2lDSNTS1mPV2\hcxJ[tjV!bdVAm[O14NPV2V RS1Ndg^Sea\hV2b Oa]2]`_jNdNdghnaQ$ghn SO&NdU_a\^YS \ ghbv¥V2naORmPVveJc S f+\ i2a A O&NdU_a\^YS \ gqb #
(57) 2- W/ 1 / N mf!§g©[mdtjV2NdV ¿^À,Á ¿^Â.
(58) z.
(59)
(60)
(61) !"# %$&(') * +
(62) ,,-. 0/
(63) 213
(64) 45 0/167. V aghbdmPbS}U OavJV2\<U ¡ O!!¨S1nDv S}U KbdO&\q_jmdghORnO\ fORNVi&_aghRS1\hV2nJmP\qc U !l S f+\ i<KZ\ i2,[taV #
(65) 2- W/
(66) 21X
(67) 4 y 13 OSO&NdU_a\^S\ / N mj!}ghb vJV2naO&mdVv eJc>f \ i %SnDvghb!V=iR_fS1\;mdO fHmdNP_aV#i g \§ghb[bTS1mPghbKSea\hV/ N= m=J! kJVA\qbPVYf+\ i l fÙ?S1\hbPV#i2 ¢V2m M eDV!SbdghQRnDSmd_aNPV[bd_D]Pt mdtDSm M M :H5U ghbSM KbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPVRkJmdtaVAn-U 4vJV2naO&mdV2bmdtaVqM bPmdNd_f]`md_aNPV2 [ghmdtmdtaV7bTS1U V/vJORUS1ghnS1nDv 2 [taVANdV7_anD]`mPghORn}S1nDv laNPVvJg^]2SmdV/bPcxUefOR\hb[S1NPV/ghnxmPV2NdljNdV2mPV2v Sbghn U T A lfORbPghmdghOR%n H O1[zS M KmdVANdU C ghbS1nS1\hghV2n}lfORbPghmdghORn$/ N mT M g< C fPHioghbnjORm ghn M S1nfv g O&N!S1nJcORmPtaV2N lDO&bdghmdghO&-n H 2 ORn mdtaVlDS1mPtNPORU mdtaVNdOJORmomdO H£#k C fTH 2 io2 ghb!gh<n M 2 a[taVbdV2m O 2 S1\hghV2n lfORbPgqmPghORnab[O5 C[/ N= m M 2 ghb!vJV2naO&mdVv ex8c / "f&M fTCi2 o6 2
(68) 0 2
(69) ( 6 V[laNPV2bdVAnxm[ghnJHORNdUS1\h\hc!ghnmdtaghbbdV]`mPghORn%S vJV=]`ORU lDO&bdghmdghORnS1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaU O&N bdO&\hxghnaQ mPtaV[bTSmdghbKSeagh\hgqmKc laNPORea\hV2U/ N m=OS Mo¡ PZM[¤s?mPtaV2O&Ndc!!¢ ¡ P;!D¤[taV2NdV !4¡ ghb OS Mo¡P?mPtaV2O&NdcJk`!D¤ OS M[¤sKmdtaV2O&Ndc S1nDv Mo¡ M[¤/SbdV2moO1;_anf]`mdghORnbPcxUefOR\hb Z}UfmdtjV2NdVghb[naObPtDS1NPVvlaNPVvJg^]2S1mP#V i2f[taghb S1\hQRO&NdghmdtaU mdNTSnabKHORNdU b SnxcotaV2mPV2NdO&QRV2naVAOR_ab Mo¡ PZM[¤`HO&NdU_a\^S;ghnJmdOV2ghmdtaVAN ORN mdtfS1naJb mPO!vJV]`ghbPgqO&n laNdOa]`Vv¥_aNdV2bvJVvJg^]2SmdVv NPV2bdlfV]`mPgq&V2\hcmPOlj_aNdV Mo¡KHORNdU_j\SVS1nfv/la_jNdV M[¤TO&NdU_a\^SVR2[taV[NPVSRv¥V2NghbSbdbP_aUVv?SUgh\hgS=N4[ghmPt S\qQ&ORNPgqmPtaUb7eDS1bPVv¨ORn¨mPNTS1njbKO&NdU%SmdghORnNP_a\hV2>b =Ê @dZ AonJc Nd_j\qVQ&gq&V2n¨ghn mPtaghblDS1lfV2N mdNTSnabKHORNdU b S O&NdU_a\^<S \ ghnxmPO \ 2 gqn bd_D]Pt S$[S=cmdtfS1]m \ ghbb`S1mdghbS1ea\hVgSnDv ORna\hcgN \ 2 ghbb`S1mdghbS1ea\hVR. ;JODk mPNTS1njbKO&NdU%SmdghORn$Nd_j\qVAblaNPV2bdVANdRV taV2NdVb`S1mdghbS1eagh\hghmKcc fej_amnjORmnaV]`V2bPbTSNdgh\hc mdtjVbdVAmO1!bdO&\h_amdghORnjb i2 £ORmdV/S\qbPO/mdtfS1m[mdtjVvJg¦4V2NdV2nJmPb!bdmPV2lab!SNdV V aV]`_amPVvbPVi&_aV2nJmdg^S1\h\hcS1nDvVSR]PtO1 mPtaV2bdVDnaghmdV2\hcUS1nJc bPmdV2labmPV2NdU ghnDS1mPV2b/OReJJghOR_abP\hcx4YORnjbdVi&_aV2nJmP\qcJk,mdtaV [taOR\hVS1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaUªmdV2NPUghnDSmdV2bSnDv$mdtjgqbghb/ORnjV O!mdtaVQRNPVS1mPV2bdmS&vJRS1nJm`S1QRVO1!mPtaVnaORn¥vJVAmdV2NPUghnaghbdmPg]SlalaNPOxSR]Pt ,[taV naORNPU%S1\,O&NdUO1 \[ghmPt NPV2bdlfV]`m/mPOmPtaV/mPNTS1njbKO&NdU%SmdghORnNP_a\hV2b[ghb[V2ghmdtaVAN gZ \ghb[bTSmdghbKSea\hV ORN g \ghb_jnabTSmdghbKSea\hVR [tjVDNdbPmbPmdV2l O1[mdtaVvJV]`O&UlfORbdghmPgqO&n-S1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaU ]`O&nabdghbPmdbgqn$bdlj\qghmPmdghnaQmdtaV ghnala_am/tjV2mdV2NPORQ&V` naVAOR_ab HORNdU_j\SghnJmdO la_aNPVVi&_DS1mPgqO&nab/S1nDv O&NdU_a\^S1V& [V2nD]sVRkS taVAmdV2NPORQRVAnaV2OR_jIb M ¡ P<M ¤ HORNPU_a\^S ghb mdN`S1nabORNPUVv ghnJmdO%S ]`ORn=r`_anD]`mPghORcn \ ¡ \ ¤ [taV2NdYV \ [ghb]S M ÙHORNPU_a\^SoORN l 0~ g`Wa [ORmPVmPtDS1m O&NdU_a\^SV!ea_agh\hmORn}mPtaV/bdVAm!O1 bPtDS1NPVv _anf]`mdghORnbPcxUefOR\hb Z} l } ¡ e} ¤ S1NPV]`O&nabdg^vJV2NPVv eDO&mdtghn \ ¡SnDv gq n \;¤ :Kn mdtaV bPV]`ORnfv}S1nDvmdtaghN`vbPmdV2ljbkamPtaV bTSUV!bPtDS1NPVv Vi&_DS1mPghORnab!SnDvvJghbPVi&_DS1mPgqO&nab[S1NdV/S&vavJVv mdO VS&]Pt}la_aNPV!HORNdU_j\[S K :Kn ;¥mdV2l WjkS&vav Vi&_DS1mPgqO&nab/S1nDv$vJghbdV=iR_fS1mdghO&nab O1[mdtaVO&NdU hl CS1nfv zl l C [taV2Nd) V C ghbS Z}7?mPV2NdU fHO1RV2 N h]iO1 taVAgqQ&tJ{m }bP_D]Pt}mdtDSm!VS&]Pt}RS1NPgSea\hV!Oi C[Oa]2]`_aNPb ORna\hcO&nD]`VSnDvvJOJV2b naORmS1lalfVS1NV2\hbdVA[taV2NdV7gqnmPtaV]s_aNdNPV2nJmORNPU_a\^Sa2[tjV!ghnJmdV2Q&V2vN ghb bPORUVAtaO1 S lfS1NTSUV2mPV2N O mdtaVvJV]sORUlfORbPghmdghORnS1\hQRO&NdghmdtaU$RV [gh\h\4bdV2V\^S1mPV2N!gh>n ;JV=]`mdghORn$zORn}[tDSm!NPV2\hgqVAb!mdtjV]PtaORg^]`V O1< ; :Kw n ;JmdVAl {ak,SRvav$Vi&_DSmdghORnjb SnDvvJghbdVi&_DSmdghORnjb/eDVAmKV2VAn RS1NPg^S1ea\hV2b/O mPtaV%]s_aNdNPV2nJm/O&NdU_a\^S \hgq&V hel SnDv %l l j :KnmdtjV[\Sbdm bPmdV2l,kRmPtaV[bdO&\q&V2Ndb NdV2\^S1mPVvmdO7VSR]PtmdtjV2ORNPc SNdV!]2S\q\hVvghnORN`vJV2N mPONPV2la\^SR]sV!VS&]dtlj_aNdV O&NdU_a\^S eJcmPNd_aYV f iORN ?S\qbP5V f iA Ë fÈÊÑÊÑ RÔË;ÕÙÓRË JÅÅsÑ©ËdÇ`É[Å`ÖxËÆ?ÇAÕÅ`ÆKÔ 7ÛhÅ`Æ4Ð!Ç`É1ÈÊÖ 1Ñ©Ç2ÕÙÈ ÉRØ;ÔHÇ2ÕÙÈ©Ô RÇ 1ÈÊÑÊÈ©Õ `Ç`Ñ RËPÔd× . . . . .
(70). . . . . . . . . !. ". $#. '&. %. &. (. . . +*. ). . ). ,*. *. /. 1/2. 3. 54. Á,Á É# !. 6. .-. 0. 87 9:. ;4. < 6. >= ?. @4.
(71) $u
(72) V!$& `. ~R
(73) \.
(74) 2
(75) # . ¡. \ % ^ fTC g/.0./k. g C#g/.0./.g^C i. fPC g0./.0.g C#= HJILKh @kg/.0./.kg Ci % Y h l C EF %$e~ &g H $j( / "f&M fPCig h $ c j . S f \ % fPC g0./.0.Fg^C#g/./.0.g C iFi .. %. g. 2¡. ¡. . g. Mf^Qi*$ M & g HJ $} / "f&M ^f M#ig h>$ j S f+\ % Mql Ci .. g%$. Md$zdYf Mghei&Wh<g hag * $ j . S f \ % M l l Ci .. Mql C MW= H ILKh&@)lzC % hYl_M E F. \ %. \. %. ! " # \. \. %. helM %. Ml l C. l *. %. C. hl, l * %. ' )(#* +. ¡ ¡ l hYC ¤ l C ¤ g $ Chcq$}j$ S.dYf f \ M gCh]¡ i,lz&dYC ¤f Zi . }zgh]iO&N ^l ~WgTW[g Wa-./ , 0/ * 1 \ ¡ \¤ 2 f+\ ¡HG G J I i f \¤)G G J I i r4658794;:< \. \ % C helzC. %. 0&. &. %. . . %. %. %. %. 3 =?> @ nBA @ pCED*F {a-*K
(76) L \ ¡ % ;\ ¤ 2 f \ ¡,P %QP;J I i % +f \ H¤ P %RP6J I i rM NHO n p A C =;>*@ @ rD
(77)
(78) H S B# 0T .U WV f+\ & i . g\ ghb[bTSmdghbKSea\hV / N= mJ! &. &. %. .. X / ! B 0T".U YV. g\ ghb[_anab`S1mdghbS1ea\hV / N mJ! . H,ghQR_aNPV0~ Ka|oV]`O&UlfORbdghmPgqO&nS1\hQRO&NdghmdtjU Z)[fÓ1È©Ô[ÔHÕËÖÈ©Ô!Ô 1ÖxËKYÆ \ RÅ 1Ô;ÛqÅs^Æ ]=È©.Ô _Å`ÈÊÉ1ÕÕ^ÓRËPÅ`ÆÈ©ËPÔd× `=ËdË ` RÔ,Ë adÕÙÈ©Å`ÉI=× ÛqÅsÆ ÕÙÓRË]1Ë 1É1È©ÕÙÈ©Å`ÉÅ`Û b#ced^b× f `=ËdËg` RÔHË aPÕ^È©Å`OÉ =× h;ÛhÅ`Æ ÕÙÓR9Ë ]1Ë 1É1È©Õ^È©ÅsÉ Å` Û iHj × f+\ & i. &. 4. 4;6. &. ;4 4. 4;6. <. <. ¿^À,Á ¿^Â.
(79) y.
(80)
(81)
(82) !"# %$&(') * +
(83) ,,-. 0/
(84) 213
(85) 45 0/167. [tjV%vJV]sORUlfORbPghmdghORn S\qQ&ORNPgqmPtaUghbvJV2b`]`NdghefVv¨ghwn H,gqQ&_aNdV~SnDv\hOJORJb\hgq&VORnaV O1!mPtaVUORbPm bPgqU la\hV/V ]`O&_a\^vghU%SQRghnaVR :Km/]`O&nxm`S1ghnaboO&N!ghnabdm`S1nD]sVORna\hcO&naVnaORnJdvJV2mPV2NdU ghnaghbdmdg^] bPmdV2lg }ªgqb V2U lamKcJ :Kn}mdtaVOR\h\hO1[ghnaQDk&VS1NdV7gqnJmPV2NdV2bPmdVv$ghnmdtjVS1bPbd_aU lamdghORnjb[naV2VvJV=v}O&n}mdtaV7gqnjla_am!mPtaV2O&NdghV2b SnDv O&NdU_a\^S1V£ORNolaNdO1JghnaQmPtaVbPOR_anfvJnaV2bPb/O1 mdtjV vJV=]`ORU lDO&bdghmdghORn}S\qQ&ORNPgqmPtaU-&V DNPbdm V2bPmTS1ej\qghbPt SeabdmPNTSR]sm!laNPORlfV2NdmPgqVAb![tag^]Pt}S1NdV7laNdO1&Vv bd_ v%]`ghV2nJm!SnDv naV]`V2bPbTSNdcJ %,
(86) #%£
(87) Zo6 .$ 1% " 6Z"}70 V bdtjO1 taO1mdO]`ORnabPmdNP_D]`m/QS Mo¡ P]M[¤s?bPmdNd_f]`md_aNPVeJc]`O&UeaghnaghnaQ5S Mo¡dKbdmPNd_D]smd_aNP"V U¡!S1nDv5S M[¤` bPmdNd_f]`md_aNP-V U¤1f[taghb/]`O&nabdmPNd_D]`mPghORn$cxghV2\^vJb S UOavJV2\,O1 S Mo¡ P<M[¤s?mPtaV2ORNPc}!¢¡ P!f¤7[taV2}n U¡ SnD8v U¤SNdV NdVAbdlfV]`mdgh&V2\hc%U OavJV2\hbO5S Mo¡dKmdtjV2ORNPc!¢¡£SnDvQS M[¤sKmdtaV2O&Ndc !D¤1JV/Sbdbd_jUV!mPtDS1m Mo¡!S1nf] v M[¤obdtDSNdV ORnj\qcS7bdV2m[O _anf]`mdghORnbPcJUeDO&\qbvJV2naO&mdVv eJc Z} :KnmdtjVNPV2bdm[OmPtaV lDS1lfV2Nk \ vJVAnaORmPV2b/QS M HORNdU_j\S£O&N ^l W~ gTWj ~ 3¬ <iH/ k ° ¢V2{m U¡ efV]S Mo¡KKbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPVS1nD%v U¤eDVeS M[¤`KbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPVbP_D]Pt-mPtDS1momdtaV2NPVV ¥ghbPmdb SO&naV`KmdO1KORnjVUS1laljgqnjLQ f HNdORU mdtaV/vJO&U%S1ghn 7¡ O< U¡ mPOmdtaV/vJO&U%Sgqn ¤oO1< U¤oRV2NPg©HcxghnaQ 47@$ Z})Yg14}
(88) ¡ $j ¡ g14}
(89) d¤ $j ¤ g
(90) ¡ l t
(91) ¤ wnf<
(92) ¡ iFl t cpf<
(93) ¤ i [taVANdYV l t vJV2naO&mdV2b mdtjV/Vi&_aghRS1\hV2nD]sV/NdV2\^SmdghORnOR%n 7¡ P8¤bd_D]Pt}mPtDS1m K
(94) l t g
(95) l O&N
(96) l fWf i O&N l fWf
(97) iA4[taV 7Y/
(98) 2J e + &! u O1V U¡SnD@v U¤gqb mPta]V Mo¡ PM[¤PKbdmPNd_D]`mP_aNd%V U ¡ t U¤ vJVsDnaVv}SbOR\h\hO1[#b K ghmdb!vJO&U%S1ghngh(b fB ¡ P ¤ iFjl t k 4
(99) $cf} i^Yg14[
(100) $% g Encpf=
(101) @ J i l = f
(102) i%@ J &k 4N q$cf ~ i g14[
(103) <$% gq n pf=
(104) @ #igJ ¦ f
(105) i2 A ]2]`O&NTvJghnaQ mdO mPtaV[laNdVAxghO&_ab vJV`DnaghmPgqO&n k=mdtaV!]sORUeaghnaVvobPmdNd_f]`md_aNP V U ¡ t U ¤ V agqbPmdb O&na\hc g©fmdtaV Vi&_aghRS\qVAnD]`V/NPV2\^S1mdghO&zn l t ghb!laNPV2bdVANdRV=v-SÏmdV2N[NPV2bdlfV]`mPghRVS1ljla\hg]AS1mdghO&nO1 bdtDSNdVv%_anD]`mPghORnab=J S[nfvJV2N mPtaghb[V agqbPmdV2nf]`V SbdbP_aUlamPghORn k&V/]2Sn}]dtjOxO&bdV/mPtaV/]`ORUejgqnjVvbPmdNd_f]`md_aNPV Sb!SUOavJV2\fO1;!4¡ P!f¤& 1° °4 H/ k° J :H< U¡ t U¤V agqbPmdb!SnD8v U¡!ghb!YS Mo¡dKUOavJV2\fO1 !¢¡!S1nD8v U¤ ghb!YS M[¤s?U O¥v¥V2\ O!f¤1kjmdtaV2%n U¡ t U¤oghb!5S Mo¡ P M[¤`KUOavJV2\fO1;!4¡ P!f¤& [tjgqb[]`O&UeaghnaVvbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPV/QRghRVAb_ab[ghU la\hg]sgqmPV2\hcS7bTS1mPghbKSeagh\qghmKc]sNdghmdV2NPghORn ORNmdtjV]sORnr`_jnD]`mdghO&n O 5S Mo¡PO&NdU_a\^S S1nfv%5S M[¤sO&NdU_a\^Sj 1° °4 H/ k° AHORNdU_j\S \ ¡ \;¤ ghb[bTSmdghbKSea\hV / N= m&!4¡ P !f¤og© S1nDv O&na\hcg©;mdtaVANdVV agqbPm ~R[YS M KUOavJVA\ U O1 ! S1nDvGS U KbdO&\q_jmdghOR%n W O \ O&N _l0~ g`Wa Wa[S ORnjV`?mPO1KORnaV[US1laljgqnj{Q f[HNdORUmdtaV!v¥ORU%Sgh"n /¡ O5 U¡ mdO mdtaV vJORUS1ghn ¤£O1 U¤bd_D]PtmPtDS1m 4 }$ Z})Yg<4}
(106) ¡ $% ¡ g14}
(107) O¤ $} ¤ g
(108) ¡ l t
(109) ¤ nEnf<
(110) ¡ ikl t pf<
(111) ¤ i S1nDv 47h8$}S.f \ ¡ \;#¤ ig{W ¡ fhTikl t W;¤ fhTi2 . &. . &. . . ) ). &. &. &. &. &. ). $&. &. &. &. $&. &. &. &. $&. &. &. %. &. &. . &. %. Á,Á É# !. &. &. &. .
(112) $u
(113) V!$& ?.
(114) 2
(115) # . 1°4°2f"i[tjVSbdbPgqQ&naUVAnxmWcK0h. 7¡ ¤ v¥V`DnaVv S1bO&\q\hO1[b ¡ ¤ ¡ ghb!OReJJghOR_abP\hcS)U¡ t U¤PKbdO&\h_amdghORnO ¡ ¤aV]`O&_a\^vS1\hbdO]PtaOJORbPV ;¤ ghnabdmPVSRv O1VW ¡ ghn%mPtaV/vJV`DnjgqmPghORnO1<W$bdghnD]`V ¡ ;¤ 1 f i(:HVU ghb/S]Mo¡ZP<M[¤`KUOavJVA\ O1!4¡ !f¤RkfmdtjV2n ghb S KUOavJV2\,O1! V]2SnOReJJgqO&_abd\hc]PtaOJORbdV7mdtaV g^vJV2nJmdghmKcO&vN fS1nfvmdtjVU KbdO&\h_amdghORn%W ORNmdtjVU KbdOR\h_amPghORn W [tjgqb!]sNdghmdV2NPghORn}ghb[naO&mvJghNdV=]`md\hc_jbTS1ej\qV&DV [gh\h\4laNdO&lDO&bdV/ghnmdtjV/naV am!bPV]`mPgqO&n}UO&NdV laN`SR]`mPg]AS1\ ]`NPghmdV2NPgS ea_am NdV2bPmdNPg]smdghnaQ-S\qbPOmPtaV]`\^S1bPb/O1 ]sORnabPgv¥V2NdVv§mdtaVAORNdghV2b= [O1V2&V2Nk4mPtaghb laNdO&lDO&bdghmdghORn]2Sn efV/OReJJghOR_abP\hc Slala\hghVv mdOmdtaV]AS1bdV7[taV2Nd5V \ ¡ SnD v \ ¤ S1NdV bPgqU la\hcmPtaV mdNP_aV O&NdU_a\^Sa °D1° # #a1 ¨[taO V Mo*¡ POM[¤PKmdtjV2ORNPc/!4¡ P!D¤ ghb]`O&nabdghbPmdV2nJm;gS1nDvORna\hc g¥mPtaV2NPV[V agqbPm qS M ?U O¥v¥V2\ U O! O&N al W~ gTW7bd_D]PtmdtfS1m U ¡ n p SnD8v U ¤ n p S1NPVghbPORUO&Ndlatjg] MNdORlfORbPghmdghORn¨W}ghbS1\hbdO$OReJJghOR_abP\qc Slala\hg^]2S1ej\qV[tjV2n¨!4¡S1nfv !f¤S1NPV%g^vJVAnxmPg^]2S1\[U O¥v¥_a\hO S NPV2nDS1U ghnaQ/O1 bPghQRnDSmd_aNPV2b!S1nDvg \ ¡!SnD]v \;¤!SNdV g^vJV2nJmdg^]2S\DU OavJ_a\hO mdtaV bTSUV[NPV2nDS1U ghnaQD1[tjV2n kJV SNdVS1ej\qV7mdObdO&\q&V/mdtjVb`S1mdghbS1eagh\hghmKclaNdO&ea\hV2Uª/ N mf!¢¡ P!f¤7gqn$SU OavJ_a\^S1N[[S=c}S1nDvVARV2ng !¢¡S1nfv!f¤obdtDSNdV/bPORU V[_anf]`mdghORn bdcJUefOR\hb
(116) 4
(117) #¬ YORnjbdg^vJV2q N b _l &h ^f{hJiZl s ( ORN ^l0~ g`WSnDvmPtaVoORNPU_a\^S \>l fh ¡ f{hTiZl h ¤ f{hJiFio[tag^]dt gqb Vi&_aghRS\qVAnxmomdO f+\ ¡ l fh ¡ f{hJiOl Wiki f+\ ¤ l f^h ¤ f{hTiql 0ikiA4[taV O&NdU_a\^S \ghbbTSmdghbKSea\hV!/ N m= b )¡ Peb!¤ vJ_aV mPOmPtaV bdOR\h_amPghORjn W l>W ¡ lW;O¤ l h|s[g s ( O \ ¡SnD v \¤ :Kn mdtaV/V jSUla\hV/S1efO1RV&kaORnjV ]`O&_a\^vNdVAU%S1NPmPtDS1m f+\ ¡ \¤ i nko pl f+\ i SnDv bdOmdtjV2NdV ghb naOnaV2Vv§taV2NPVmdO}]`ORUejgqnjVvJV]`ghbPgqO&nlaNdOa]`V=vJ_aNdVAb;[taVNdVS&vJV2NbdtaO&_a\^v}njORmdVtaO1 V2RVAN/mdtDSm mdtaV laNPORea\hV2U O bdOR\hJghnaQ/S ]`ORnrs_anD]`mPgqO&nOmKO/NdVAnDS1U Vv HORNdU_j\SV ghb naO/U ORNPVO&exJghOR_jb ghnmPtaV]`O&nJmdV am O_jnag]2S1mPghOR>n =Êy @d ; #}6Z
(118) %ª
(119) (% V/bPmd_Dv¥c}naO1mdtaNPV2V]2S1bPV2b O1 v¥gqbhr`ORghnJm!S1nfvnjORnJdvJghbqr`O&ghnxm[_jnaghORnaboO1 mdtaVAORNdghV2boO&N![tag^]Pt}V/QRgh&V bP_ v%]`ghV2nJmSbdbd_jUlamPgqO&nab ORNbTSmdghbKcJghnaQmdtaV7bdV]`O&nDvlfORghnJmOM;NPORlfORbPgqmPghORn}Wa Bf P8 iFjl t K 47h%$}S.f+\ % \ i gW fhTi l = W ^f hJi+@ J \ % \ LW ]= W ^f hJi+@ J Ol = W fhTi%@ J ZP U & l U8 zM &. &. &. &. #. &. &. &. . . &. . "&. . . . *. *. %. *. %. . . . & . "!$#&%')(*,+*-( ".0/-(132546(*6 7 "8&.946:"(.91. jt V2nmdtaVobdghQRnDSmd_aNPV2b[O1 mPtaV2O&NdghV2b!S1NPV/vJghbqr`O&gqnJm=k1mdtaVAn%ghmghbbP_ v%]`ghV2nJmmPO SbdbP_aUVomdtDSmVS&]PtmdtjV2ORNPc S&vJUghmdb=kJO&N!VS&]PtbTS1mPghbKSea\hVi&_DS1nJmdgDVANKHNdV2VHORNdU_j\SjkxS U O¥v¥V2\ tDS=JghnaQS1n}ghnJDnjgqmPV v¥ORU%Sghn%S1nfv [tag^]Pt¨bTSmdghbKDVAbmdtaVHORNdU_j\SjT:HmdtjgqbSbdbP_aUlamPghORntaO&\v¥bk;mdtjV2n¨gqmghbVS1bPc mPO-laNPO1RVmdtfS1mmdtjV2NdV V aghbdmPb!S1\hbdOS/U O¥v¥V2\D[ghmPtS1nghnJfnaghmdV W [ u7Y 0/16 vJO&U%Sgqn,< ; ORNdVAO1RV2N=kJmdtaV2NPV/V aghbdmPbO&exJghOR_jbd\hc S O&naV`KmdO1KORnjVUS1laljgqnjQ/eDVAmKV2VAn}mKOghnJfnaghmdVv¥V2nJ_aUV2N`S1ea\hV bdVAmdb ¿^À,Á ¿^Â.
(120) .
(121)
(122)
(123) !"# %$&(') * +
(124) ,,-. 0/
(125) 213
(126) 45 0/167. ~ 3¬ <iH/ k ° =h~RF~ @ZA M ?bPmdNd_f]`md_aNPVghb
(127) -Z
(128) k gghmdb/vJO&U%S1ghn gqb ghnJDnjgqmPVRTA _anaghRV2NPbTS\M ?mPtaV2O&Ndc ! ghb V W/ 1X4Y
(129) 2 -Z[
(130) V g;ORN S1nJc%i&_DSnxmPgDV2NKHNPV2VQM HORNPU_a\^S\ bTS1mPghbKSea\hV// N mj! kjmdtaV2NPVV ¥ghbPmdb Sn%ghnJfnaghmdVM ?bPmdNP_D]`md_jNdV)U RV2NPgcJgqnjQLU !l !}SnDvU !l S.f+\ i(K0\ [tjV!HOR\h\hO1[gqnjQljNdORlfORbPghmdghORnlaNPO1xg^vJVAb[gqnJmPV2NdV2bPmdghnaQV DSUla\hV2bO1;bdmTSea\hcghnJDnjgqmPV mdtaV2O&NdghV2b= 1° °4 H/ k° :H U5ghb S1n ghnJDnaghmdV;bPmdNd_f]`md_aNPVRk1mPtaV2n/! fBU i¢gqb4bPmTSea\hc!ghnJDnaghmPVSnDv S1nJci&_DSnJmdgDV2N NPV2V O&NdU_a\^Soghb[bTSmdghbKSea\hV / N= mJ! fBU igSnDvO&na\hcgghmgqb[b`S1mPgqbS1ej\qV gh-n U 1°4° 2q:H SiR_fS1nJmdgDV2NHNdV2VoO&NdU_a\^S \$ghb[bTS1mPghbKSea\hV!gh-n U kJmPtaV2<n \ghbbTS1mPghbKSea\hV!/ N mJ! fBU i bdghnD]`)V U gqb[O&eJxghO&_abd\hc%SU OavJV2\4O1 ! fBU iADYORnJ&V2NdbPV2\hcxkjg© \ ghb[_anab`S1mdghbS1ea\hV/gh%n U kamPtaV2n U ! lZ\ SnDvbPO!^ f U i{!lZ\j[taV2NdVsORNPVRJk \§gqb[_jnabTSmdghbKSea\hV / N= mJ! fBU i2 ¬ J A iR_fS1nJmdgDV2NHNdV2VO&NdU_a\^S bTSmdghbKSea\hV/ N= m S£bdmTSea\hc/ghnJDnaghmPVmPtaV2ORNPc/!ghb;bTS1mPghbKSea\hV ghn}S/U OavJV2\4O1;![ghmdtS1nghnJDnaghmdV W 7Y 0/16 v¥ORU%Sghn 1° °4 H/ k° D:H* U ¡ SnD%v U ¤ SNdVgqn¥DnaghmdV/bPmdNP_D]`md_jNdV2b[ghmdt-vJVAnx_jUV2N`S1ea\hV/vJORUS1ghnab[ea_jgq\hm[O&n vJghbhr`ORghnJm bdghQ&nDS1mP_aNdV2b=kamPtaV2nmdtaVANdV ghb S7ORnaVs?mPO1KORnaVoU%S1ljlaghna"Q f bd_D]PtmdtfS1*m U ¡ t U ¤ V aghbdmPb!S1nDvgqb Sn%ghnJfnaghmdV bdmPNd_D]`mP_aNdV[ghmdtSvJV2nJ_aUVANTS1ej\qV vJORUS1ghn :Km NdV2US1ghnab;mdO/&V2NdgcmdtjV!S1bdbP_aUljmdghORn[tag^]PtbdmTSmdV2b[mPtDS1m bdOR\h_amPghORna<b W ¡ SnD v W;¤O14NdV2bPlDV]smdghRV2\hc \ ¡SnD] v \;¤ S1NPVV=iR_jgqRS\hV2nJm UOavJ_a\hQO l t £V2nD]`V&kDmKORS1Ndg^Sea\hV2b U_abPmtDS=&V!mPtaV bTS1U V[bdO&\q_jmdghORn fORN U_abPm tDS=RVvJg¦4V2NdVAnxmbdO&\h_amdghORnjb iobdghU_a\hmTSnaV2O&_abd\hcghn-efORmPtUOavJV2\hbf[taghb/V ¥lj\Sghnab [txc$VnaV2Vv mPO]`ORnabPg^vJV2N!S1\h\flDO&bdbPgqej\qV g^vJV2nJmPg©4]2S1mPgqO&nabO1RSNdg^S1ej\qVAbOa]2]`_jNdNdghnaQgh n \ ¡ \ ¤ HjORNdUS1\h\hcxk=mPtaV bdV2m[O( g^vJV2nJmPg©4]2S1mPgqO&nab[O1 RSNdg^S1ea\hV2bghn Z ghb \ l P ! e[f& f P i Z g*o
(131) af P i Z g P ghbgv¥V2UlfORmPV2nJm . L gh&V2n}S1ng^vJVAnxmPg]2S1mPghORn P $ \ k P6J I vJV2naO&mdV2bomdtaV7Vi&_DS1mPgqO&nDS1\jO&NdU_a\^S . $#. %.
(132).
(133) h r \s<t u M x. p. ll.
(134). *.. ¢ V2m[! ¡ S1nDv ! ¤ eDV mKOvJghbqr`O&gqnJmbdm`S1ea\hcghnJDnaghmPVmPtaV2O&NdghV2bj[taV2n 2 f+\ ¡ \;¤#i nko pOl f+\ ¡ P RP J I i n f+\;¤ P RP J I i p rM N!O B n A p C =?> @ @ [taVANdVQ\ ghb!SYM HORNPU_a\^SoO&N al ~WgTWj 1°4°2f "i :HZ f+\ ¡ \ ¤ i n o poghbmdNd_jVRkJmdtaVAnmdtjV2NdV V aghbdmPb!S"U KbdO&\q_jmdghORnW$O1 \ ¡ \ ¤ kJ[tjV2NdV U ghb SUOavJV2\f! ¡ P! ¤ J[tx_jbkJmdtjVvJghbqrs_anD]`m[]`ORNPNdV2bPlDO&nDvJghnaQmPO Sng^vJV2nJmdg]AS1mdghO&n P bd_D]Pt mdtDS*m 47hag )$}S.f \ ¡ \;#¤ igvh P l P W fhTi l_W f Wigqb[mPNd_aV& f iO:H O&naVvJghbqrs_anD]`mogqbomdNP_aVRkfmdtaVAn-mPtaV2NdVV aghbdmPb S U ?bPOR\h_amdghO&n W O \ ;O&N l 0~ g`Wbd_D]Pt mdtDSOm 47h_g 8$;S f+\ ¡ \ ¤ igW ¡ f^hJiOl W ¡ f Wi W ¤ f^hJiOlYW ¤ f 0i .a;JODkjVS1NPV Sea\hV/mdO]dtjOxO&bdV mdtaV7ORnaV`KmdO?O&naV U%Slalaghna"Q f/bP_D]Pt}mdtfS1m 47h8$}S.f+\ ¡ \;¤ i g{W;¤ f^hJi l_fWfW ¡ fhTiki . 1° °4 H /°k. %. &. . &. . %. %. %. . . %. *. %. *. &. *. %. *. %. Á,Á É# !. . . %. *. . '&. *. '&. .
(135) ~s. $u
(136) V!$&. [taV2n kjmdtaVS1bdbPghQRnaU V2nJmVW$NPORU.
(137) 2
(138) # . mPO]f /¡ P8 ¤#iFjl t v¥V`DnaVv exc^K 47h%$}S.f+\ ¡ \ ¤ i gW fhTi l = W ¡ f^hJi+@ J ghb!S"U¡ t U¤sKbdOR\h_amPghORnO \ ¡ \;¤17 °D1° # #a1 :H!!¢¡ S1nfv!f¤S1NPVmKO-vJghbqrsORghnJmbPmTSea\hc-ghnJDnjgqmPVmdtaVAORNdghV2b=k;mdtaVAn !¢¡P !D¤gqb bPmTS1ej\qc ghnJDnaghmdV& °D1° # #a1 [taVvJV]`O&UlfORbdghmPgqO&n-S1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaU vJVAbT]`NPgqefVv§gqwn H,ghQR_jNdV} ~ fH[gqmPtaOR_jNm ;¥mdV2l¨W0i bPOR\hRV2b mPtaVbTSmdghbKSeagh\hgqmKc laNdO&ea\hV2UªO1[iR_fS1nJmdgDV2NHNdV2VO&NdU_a\^SV!/ N mfmPtaV_jnaghORn}OmKO}vJghbhr`ORghnJm[bdm`S1ea\hc ghnJDnjgqmPV mdtaV2O&NdghV2b= ;¬J°f1¬ '^
(139) 2- 0/
(140) 213
(141) , +4Y
(142) - M ¡ P M ¤ # 7Q 1 0
(143) N W
(144) W 0/16 2 ! ¡ P! ¤
(145) Mo¡ M[O ¤ l
(146) #
(147) 2- 0/
(148) 213
(149) , +4Y
(150) - M 75 16 0
(151) 0
(152) % 0 0/16 2 ! !
(153) 5 V W/ 1X4Y
(154) 2 -Z[
(155) VN %$& 4X# _l0~ g`W VmPtx_jbQRVAmmdtjV}NdV2bP_a\hm%vJ_jV}mdO £V2\hbdORn B ColalfV2n =h~={Jk!~R!~ @[ghmdt SvJg¦4V2NdVAnxmlaNPOJO1T :Km gqb ghUlfORNPmTSnxm,mdOonaORmPV[mdtDSmVARV2n7ORN;mPtaV v¥gqbhr`ORghnJm]AS1bdV&k1V[tfS=ROV fH\qgh&VmPtaV2zU i,SRvav¥gqmPghORnDS\xS1bPbd_aU lamdghO&nab ]`O&nD]`V2NPnaghnaQ/mPtaV[ghnDvJghJgv¥_DS1\&mdtaV2O&NdghV2b=R[taghb;NdVAbd_a\hm taO&\^vJb;taO1VARV2N,O&NbPORU V naORn¥?_anjgq&V2Ndb`S1\amPtaV2O&NdghV2b bPgqnf]`VV]2S1nS1\hbdO]`ORnjbdg^vJV2N/S1NPeaghmdN`S1Ndc mdtaV2O&NdghV2b ! TkflaNPO1xg^vJV=v}VS&]Pt i&_DSnxmPgDV2NKHNPV2IV M ÙHORNPU_a\^S ghb/b`S1mdghbS1ea\hV/ N m=4! g¦ ghm gqb7bTS1mPghbKSea\hVgqn S UOavJV2\;O1!! [ghmdt Sngqn¥DnaghmdV W 7Y 0/16 vJO&U%Sgqn, :KnmdtjVOR\h\hO1[ghnaQDkAV[laNPV`V2NmdO _abPV!mPtaghbnjV2 S1bdbP_aUljmdghORnbdghnD]`V[U ORNPVmPtaV2ORNPghV2b SNdV[m`S1RVAn ghnJmdOS&]2]`OR_jnxm= h. %. %. . ). &. ). &. ). &. . &. &. . 8-.. &. &. 46:"(.9171 "!$#&%' .9*-. :"! ".9/. # '. 158&!$:.9/. ".9: 1. jt V2n mPtaVbPgqQ&nDS1mP_aNdVAbO!mdtaV2O&NdghV2bbdtDSNdV _anf]`mdghORnbPcJUeDO&\qb=kfV tDS=RVnaO1 mPO-V2njbd_aNPV%mPtDS1m7mdtaV Slala\hg^]2S1mPgqO&n-O mPtaV]`O&NdNdVAbdlfORnDvJghnaQ$ghnJmdV2NPlaNdV2m`S1mPgqO&nab/O_jnD]`mdghO&nbdcJUeDO&\hb!laNPV2bdV2NPRV2bmPtaVORnjV`?mPO1 O&naVU%S1ljlaghnaQefV2mKV2V2n mPtaV%vJO&U%SgqnjbO!UOavJV2\hb/O!!4¡SnDv!f¤1;[taV gv¥VSHOR\h\hO1Vv taV2NPVgqb bPgqU la\hcmPOS1bPbd_aU V!mdtfS1m[bdtfS1NdV=v _anD]smdghORnab!SNdV ghnJmdV2NPlaNdV2mPVv bdcJnJmTSR]smdg^]2S1\h\hcghneDO&mdtUOavJV2\hb= ~ 3¬ <iH/ k ° DA M KbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPVLU ghb 0 T k e/ 4 }% V 7 fO1RVANig ghmdb!vJO&U%S1ghngh.b d]f Z}zgi [taV2NP"V ghb!S1nghnJDnaghmPVv¥V2nJ_aUV2N`S1ea\hVobdV2m=k 47@$ }L5g^4<
(156) $<dYf Z} gi g{ f
(157) iZl> f
(158) i2 L gh&V2n}S/bPV2" m Z h}kJmPtaV/]`ORnrs_anD]`mPgqO&nO1v¥gqbPVi&_DS1mPghORnab
(159) 47h *¡ g/./.0.g9h 1! u x K h l_ l fh 0¡ g/./.0.g9h 1! u x i p3r \ r . . ). ). . .
(160). ¿^À,Á ¿^Â.
(161) ~R~.
(162)
(163)
(164) !"# %$&(') * +
(165) ,,-. 0/
(166) 213
(167) 45 0/167. hg bvJVAnaORmPVv$eJc
(168) M \ ^A ORNPU_a\^ScO1[mdtjVORNPU \
(169) M \ k4[taV2NPVz\¨ghbi&_DSnJmdgDV2NNPV2VS1nfv Z S.f \ i2kfghb[bTS1g^v & +1X4]/
(170) J[taV/bdVAm!O1;eDS1bPg^] RS1NPgSea\hV2bgqn}cghb VS(f^c^iZl ZA lDSNdmP\qc eDS1bPg^] O&NdU_a\^Scgqb /
(171) g VS fc^iZl_S.fc^iAA M KmdtaVAORNdc7!ghb k 0/134O0 T k 5/4 }% V 7 gaHORN S1nJc eDSbdg^O] M HORNPU_a\^S \b`S1mPgqbS1ej\qV[/ N= m==! k=mdtjV2NdVoV agqbPmdbSM KbdmPNd_D]`mP_aNdVOU Q&V2naV2N`S1mdV=vexc Z}/KmdVANdUb &V2NdgcJghna)Q U !l !}S1nDv U !l S.f \ i(K0\ :H" U ghbS$bdmdNP_D]`mP_aNdVQ&V2naV2N`S1mdV=v eJc }/KmdV2NPU b fHO1RV28N i2k mdtaVAn S1n S1bPbdghQRnjUV2nJm W KOh def Z} gighbS U ?bPOR\h_amdghO&nO1
(172) M \ gS1nDv ORna\hcgV ]
(173) afW E \ i o_DS1nJmdgDVANKHNdV2V7O&NdU_a\^S1V SNdV!lfS1NdmP\hceDSbdg^]HORNdU_j\SV \$[ghmdt VS f+\ iZl
(174) a [ORmPVS\qbPO/mdtfS1m[S bdm`S1ea\hcgqn¥DnaghmdV[mPtaV2ORNPcghb bdm`S1ea\hc Q&V2naV2N`S1mdV=v}eJc Z}7?mPV2NdU b[g Z}ghb[V2U lamKcJ ;¥gqU gh\SNd\c!mdO/M;NPORlfORbPgqmPghORn{ak=V!]AS1n_abdV!So_anag^i&_aVbdmPNd_D]`mP_aNdV Q&V2naV2N`S1mdV=vexc Z}?mPV2NdU b mPO/ea_agh\hm SmPtaV2ORNPcbPmTS1ej\qc QRV2njV2NTSmdVveJc Z}/KmdVANdUb= 1° °4 H/ k° :H* U ghb/SbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPVQRVAnaV2NTSmdVv$eJc Z}KmdV2NPUb=kDmPtaV2n d<fBU ioghb bdm`S1ea\hcQRV2njV` N`S1mdV=veJc Z}7?mPV2NdU bk SnDv$S1nJc}eDSbdg^]7ORNPU_a\^Sghbb`S1mPgqbS1ej\qV/ N= m=T d<fBU i g!S1nDv ORnj\qc g©[ghm gqb b`S1mdghbS1ea\hV gh%n U 1°4° 2![taVRVAc}lDO&ghnxmoghbmPOlaNPO1RVmdtDSm/SeDSbdg^] HORNdU_j\S7[tag^]Pt}ghb _anabTSmdghbK4S1ea\hV/ghn U gqb/S\qbPO _anab`S1mdghbS1ea\hV / N m dd<fBU i=4V2{m cel \
(175) M u x eDVS/eDSbdg^]£ORNPU_a\^So_anabTSmdghbK4S1ea\hV ghn U J[taV DNPbdm?O&NTvJV2NobdV2nJmPV2nD]`V c-v¥V`DnaVv S1bO&\q\hO1[b K 2 47S.f \ iqK f \ h ¡ g0././.g9h 1 u x K hYl> fh 0¡ g0././.kg9h 1! u x iki p r u x r ghb!mdtjVnaVAQxS1mPghORnO1v cSnDvbP-O U !l c;a[taV2n,Jk dG<fBU i"!l cSnD}v c$ghb!_jnabTSmdghbKSea\hV// N m d<fBU i= 1° °4 H/ k° :H* U ¡ S1nDv U ¤ SNdV/bPmdNd_f]`md_aNPV2bQRV2naVANTS1mPVv exc Z}7KmdV2NPUbkjmdtaVAn-mPtaV2NdVV aghbdmPbS O&naV`KmdO1KORnjVUS1laljgqnjLQ f/bP_D]Pt}mdtfS1m U ¡ t U ¤ gqb!SbPmdNP_D]`md_jNdVQRV2naVANTS1mPVveJc }/KmdV2NPUb= 1°4° 2 c SbdbP_aUlamPghORn kjmdtaV2NPVV aghbdmdbSO&naV`KmdO?O&naVUS1laljgqnj-Q fNPORU ¡ mP%O ¤ [tag^]Pt ]AS1n$eDV _abdV=vmdOvJVsDnaVS]`ORnjQRNd_jV2nD]`VNdV2\^SmdghORn OR n dYf }zg ¡ P8 ¤ i K 47%$ Z}<g f<
(176) ¡ i l t f<
(177) ¤ igJ
(178) ¡ l t
(179) ¤ . [taV Mo¡ P M[¤`KbdmPNd_D]smd_aNPLV U¡ t U¤ ghb[S1bO&\q\hO1[b K ghmdb!v¥ORU%SghngqOb dtf Z} g f /¡ P8 ¤ ikjl t i 47@$ Z})Ig14<
(180) $fdYf Z}zgfB7¡ P8¤ ikjl t iFi gwn cpf
(181) i l_^f
(182) i [taV2NPV`ORNPVRkk U¡ t U¤oghb[bdmdgh\h\ S7bdmdNP_D]`mP_aNdVQRV2njV2NTSmdVveJc Z}/KmdVANdUb= V[S1NPV[naO1KSR]`Vv[ghmPtmPtaV?SR]smmPtDS1m NdV2bPlDV]smdghRVola_aNdVobdO&\q_jmdghORnab;U_abPm efV[Vi&_aghRS1\hV2nJm;UOavJ_a\hO l t gqn ORNTv¥V2N!mPO%]`O&nabdmPNd_D]`mS]`ORUeaghnaV=vbPOR\h_amPgqO&ngq@ n U¡ t U¤1T Aon}g^vJVSHORN!vJVS\hgqnjQ[gqmPt}mdtjgqb ]`O&nabdmPNd_D]smdghORn¨ghb/mdOS1ljla\hc-bPgqU_j\qm`S1naVAOR_abP\qcghnVS&]dt mdtaVAORNdcmPtaVb`S1U VxghnDv$O!bdtDSNdVv ghnabPmTS1nf]`VR £V2nD]`VRkflDSNdmP\qc eDS1bPg^][HORNdU_j\SV!S1NPVmPNTSnabKO&NdU VvghnJmdOeDS1bPg^]!O&naV2b= . %. . .
(183). . . . . . . . .
(184). . . . . . . .
(185) . %. . . . . . . . . . . . . ) ). . . . #. Á,Á É# !.
(186) ~=W. $u
(187) V!$&.
(188) 2
(189) # . ~ 3¬ <iH/ k ° A O&NdU_a\^S]\ ghb[jKbTSmdghbK4S1ea\hVghn S<M KbdmdNP_D]`mP_aNdV}U Q&V2naV2N`S1mdV=v eJc Z}KmdV2NPUb/g mPtaV2NdV7V agqbPmdb S"U KbdO&\q_jmdghORn O1 \§bd_D]PtmdtfS1m[ghmdb[N`S1naQ&VghbghnD]`\h_DvJVv ghn dTf Z} gi2 AHORNdU_j\S\§gqb jKbTSmdghbKSea\hV[/ N mRSmdtaV2O&Ndc!g_\$gqb<jKbTSmdghbKSea\hV[ghnS UOavJV2\JO!QRV2naVANTS1mPVv eJc Z}7KmdV2NPUb :H \gh{b jKbTSmdghbKSea\hV!/ N m=J! kJmPtaV2n}V/vJV`DnaVtf+\ i ]l k&V2\hbdVYf \ i ]l [tjgqb7NdV2bPmdNdg^]`mPVv§ORNPUO1[bTS1mPghbKSeagh\qghmKc}ghb/ghnJmdVANdV2bPmdghnaQ$gqnljNTSR]smdg^]`VbPghnD]`VV%SNdVnaO&m/\hOJORJghnaQ O&NSnxc bdO&\q_jmdghORnea_amoORna\hcORN S dbdtjORNdm bPOR\h_amdghO&>n fHghmvJV2lfV2nDv¥b/ORnmdtjV ]PtaO&g]sV/O1 mdtjVtaVAgqQ&tJm{^i2 £O1V2&V2NkfO&_aN!naO&nJdvJV2mdVANdUghnaghbPmdg^]/S1ljlaNdOJSR]Pt}\hVSRv¥b!_abomdOVAnx_jUV2N`S1mdV7bdcJbdmPV2U%Smdg^]2S1\h\hc%S\h\ lfORbdbPghea\hV bPOR\h_amdghO&nab;O1DtaVAgqQ&tJm \hV2bdb mdtDSLn ;=[taghbV ¥lj\Sghnab mPtaV[_abdVO14S <qH ¬[bPV2m \ O1DbP_aeabdmPghmd_amPgqO&nab bP_D]Pt mdtDSmmdtaVAgqNvJORUS1ghnabSnDv NTSnaQRV2bS1NPV%NPV2bdlfV]`mPghRV2\hc ghnD]`\h_Dv¥Vv gq_n ZS1nfwv d#Jf Z}<g h] i2,[taV RSNdg^S1ea\hV2b,[tag^]Pt SNdVnaORm;bd_jeabdmPgqmP_amdV=vORN;mdtaO&bdV[ghnJmdNPO¥v¥_D]`Vv7eJcS[bP_aeabdmPghmd_amPgqO&n G $
(190) \ U_abPm tDS=&V/eDSbdg^]oRS1\h_aV2b!Sb[bdOR\h_amPghORn fgK VRJgh%n i2a[tjgqb[ljNdORlfV2NPmKc-]2S1nefV/V2nD]sO¥v¥Vv}eJc mdtaV]sORnr`_jnD]`mdghO&n O£vJghbPVi&_DS1mPgqO&nab G JI v¥V`DnaVvSboOR\h\hO1[#b K#G JI l
(191) M u \ s<t u 3 xPx2o 1 Nu 3 x fVS1bPbd_aU V S\hbdOmPtDS1m VS&]PtRS1NPg^S1ea\hV gh-n S|o
(192) afYGui;Oa]2]s_aNdb[O&nD]`V[gh)n o
(193) afWGui S1nDvvJOJV2b naORmSlalfVS1N VA\qbPV2[taV2NPV gqnmPtaV[ghnala_am O&NdU_a\^Sj 1° °4 H/ k° :H !¢¡!S1nDv !f¤SNdV mKOmdtaV2O&NdghV2bobdmTSea\hcQRV2njV2NTSmdVv eJc Z}/KmdVANdUb=kJmdtaVAn f \ ¡ \¤ i nVo #p Yl 2 2 fkf \ ¡ G G J I i P RP6J I i n fkf \ ¤ G G J I i P RP6J I i p r3 4;5794;:< n A p C D*F M r NHO n p A C A C =;> >*@ @ =?> @ @ 1°4° 2f "i :HZ f+\ ¡ \¤ i nko p ghb mdNP_aVRk&mdtaV2]n \ ¡ \;¤[ghb b`S1mdghbS1ea\hV[ghnS UOavJV2\JO !4u¡ P!D¤ QRV2njV2NTSmdVv eJc Z}7?mPV2NdU b fO1&V2N iAkabTS=8c U kaS1nDv mPtaV2NdVV aghbdmPb)S U KbdOR\h_amPghORjn W$O \ ¡ \;¤ bd_D]PtmdtDS}m ] af^W i dTf Z} gi2[taV$bdmPNd_D]`mP_aNdzV U /ghb OReJJgqO&_abd\hc¨SUOavJVA\!O1! ORN l W~ gTWj
(194) V}]2Sn S1\h S=cJb]PtaOJO&bdV G $ u [n px bd_D]Pt mPtDS1mmPtaV2NdV V agqbPmdbSn S1bPbdghQRnaU V2nJ-m W <Kqh dYf Z} giRVANdgcJghnaQ 47h $=S.f \ ¡ \ ¤ i g%W fhTi l W fh#Gui[ghmPt ]
(195) af^W i J[taV2n,kJV vJV`DnaV P SbOR\h\hO1[#b K3h P l P g ¦ W fhTiZlW Ff 0iAJ[taV/S1bPbdghQRnaU V2nJm W ghb!) S U KbdO&\h_amdghOR%n W O1. ¤ f+\ WG G JI i P RP6JI ORN al W~ gTW/SnDv bdOO&naV/vJghbqr`_anf]`m[ghb[mdNd_jVR f i;YORnJRVANdbdVA\qcJk1g4bdORU V fFf+\ YG G I i P P6I i ghb;mdNd_jV[O&NSnghnabPmTSnxmPg^S1mdghO&n GS1nfvSn g^vJV2nJmdg]2SmdghORn P k1mPtaV2nmPtaV2NPV!JV a¡ ghbdmPbS UOaJ vJVAN\ U J 4O! Q&V2naV2N`S1mPVveJc Z}KmdVANdU.b fHO1RV2<N +i ORN ^l0~ g`Wa1[taV/]`O&UeaghnaVv7bdmPNd_Dt ]`mP_aNdGV U ¡ t t U ¤ ghb[S UOavJV2\fO1 ! ¡ P! ¤ QRVAnaV2NTSmdVv eJc Z}7?mPV2NdU q b fHO1RV2N f /_¡ P)¤ ikjl iA A>U¡ U¤PKbdOR\h_amPghORnO1Z \ ¡ \;¤ ]2Sn%efV/]`ORnjbdmdNP_D]`mPVv mdtDSnaJb;mdO!mPta*V U ?bPOR\h_amPgqO&n O1_ f \ G G JI i P P JI HORN ^l0~ g`Wa H,gqNPbdm=kÏv¥_aVmPO!mPtaVg^vJVAnxmPg]2S1mPghORn O1aRS1NPg^S1ea\hV2b=k`V]AS1nSbdbd_jUV;[ghmdtaO&_am4\hORbdb4OaQRV2naVANTS1\hghmKc!mPtDS1m 4 )$S.fFf+\ ¡ \;¤ iGuig5W #¡ f 0iZl t W;¤ f Wi .f[taV2n kjmdtaV/SbdbdghQ&naUV2nJ m WcK0h dTf Z} g f /¡ P8 ¤ ikjl t ibd_D]PtmdtfS1m N = W ¤ f^hG i%@ J #i 47h8$S.f \ ¡ \ ¤ i g{W f^hJi l f= W ¡ fh#Gui+@ J i fOR ghb!"S U¡ t U¤sKbdOR\h_amPghORnO \ ¡ \;¤ S1nDv bd O f \ ¡ \¤ i nVo #p gqb[mPNd_aV&7 V/SNdV/naO1 S1ej\qV mPOlaNdV2bPV2nJm/SnaV2 S1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaU[tag^]Pt}\hOJORJb[\hgq&V!mPtaV/ORnjVvJV2&V2\hORlfVv O&N[mdtaV vJghbhr`ORghnJm/]2S1bPVR;[taVvJg¦4V2NdV2nf]`Vgqb7mdtDSm/bdO&UVbdtDSNdVv ORNPU_a\^S1V/U_abPm eDVm`S1RVAngqnJmPO-SR]2]sOR_anJm/eJc efORmPt%mPtaV2O&NdghV2b!mPtDS1njxb[mPOS1n}SRvjvJghmdghORnDS\DnjORnJdvJV2mPV2NdU gqnjgqbPmdg^][bPmdV2laK . . . . . . #. . &. . . . %. . %. . %. %. . . %. %. %. . %. . %. .
(196). . . '&. '&. '&. . (%. .*.
(197) . '&. &. . '&. %. %. '& *. . %. '&. &. &. '&. %. . &. &. ! . "&. . . %. &. &. %. . 8%. *. *. %. *. . %. %. %. . . ¿^À,Á ¿^Â.
(198) ~{.
(199)
(200)
(201) !"# %$&(') * +
(202) ,,-. 0/
(203) 213
(204) 45 0/167. -./ , 0/ * # \ ¡ % ;\ ¤ 2 f \ ¡HG % G J I i r3 4;57e46:< n A p,C D*F =;> @ @. ;¤ G JI i [tjgqbnaV2 bdmdVAl}U_abdm eDVolDV2NORNPUVv S=mPV2N
(205) SnDvefV`O&NdVQ-*K # ) xj[taV/]`ORNPNdV2b lfORnDv¥gqnjQS\hQRORNPghmdtaU ]2S1nefV Slala\hghVv/mPOi&_DSnxmPgDV2NKHNPV2VqM ¡ PqM ¤ HORNPU_a\^S1V;ea_am S\qbPO!U ORNdV QRV2naVANTS1\h\hc O&N[lDS1NPmd\hceDSbdg^]Mo¡ P M[¤`HORNPU_a\^S1VR °D1° # #a1 [taVv¥V]`ORU lDO&bdghmdghO&n%S1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaUvJV2bT]sNdgheDV=v}ghn<H,gqQ&_aNdV~ bPOR\hRV2bomdtaV)j?b`S1mdghbS1eagh\hghmKc laNPORea\hV2UªOlDSNdmd\hceDSbdg^] HORNdU_j\SV!/ N m=DmPtaV_anaghORn}O mKO mdtaV2O&NdghV2b/bPmTSea\hc%Q&V2naV2N`S1mPVv$eJc }/ mPV2NdU b 1° °4 H /°k jKbTSmdghbK4S1eagh\hghmKc!O1flDS1NPmd\hc/eDSbdg^] Mo¡ PqM[¤PHO&NdU_a\^S1V;ghbv¥V]`g^vaS1ej\qV[/ N= m=2!¢0¡ P[!f¤ g M ¡ M ¤ l }%k bTSmdghbKSeagh\hgqmKcOeDSbdg^] M HO&NdU_a\^S1Vghb!vJV]`g^vaSea\hV / N= mJ! k ! gqb[bPmTSea\hcQRV2naVANTS1mPVveJc }/KmdV2NPUb fÙORN _l0~ g`0W iA MNdORlfORbPghmdghORcn ?}S1nfvM;NdO&lDO&bdghmdghORn SNdV%S\hbdO}S1lalj\qg^]2Sea\hVmPO}eDSbdg^Y] M ¡ P>M ¤ HORNPU_a\^S1VR[ :KnmdtaV lDSNdmPg]s_a\^S1N!]2SbdV/OeDSbdg^]£ORNPU_a\^S1VR0k sÏ?b`S1mPgqbS1ejgq\hghmKc]`ORghnD]`g^vJVAb![ghmdtbTSmdghbK4S1eagh\hghmKcx °D1° # #a1 :H !4¡ S1nDv!f¤/SNdV bdm`S1ea\hcQRV2njV2NTSmdVveJc Z}7?mPV2NdU bkJmPtaV2n}!¢¡ P !f¤ ghb[bdm`S1ea\hc Q&V2naV2N`S1mdV=v}eJc Z}7?mPV2NdU b ;¬J°f1¬ '^
(206) 2- 0/
(207) 213
(208) , +4Y Q/ *!
(209) % Mo¡ P M[/¤ 75 16 0
(210) 0
(211) % 0 0/16 2 !4¡ P!f¤
(212) Mo¡ M[O ¤ l } #
(213) 2- 0/
(214) 213
(215) , +4Y Q/ *!
(216) % M #7Q 16 W
(217) Q 0
(218) 0 W/ 1 2 ! !
(219) ( k 0/134)0J k ]/4 Z}- k 7 X# al 0~ g`W HjNdO&UmPtaVvJV]`O&UlfORbPgqmPghORnS1\hQRO&NdghmdtaU$kaV]2S1nV=S1bdgh\hc-vJVANdghRVSbPV2UgdvJV]`ghbPgqO&n-ljNdOa]`VvJ_jNdV ORN mPtaV/bTSmdghbK4S1eagh\hghmKclaNdO&ea\hV2U ghn}SUOavJVA\DO! ¡ P ! ¤ QRV2njV2NTSmdVveJc Z}/KmdVANdUb=a[taghb[laNPOa]`VvJ_aNPV ORNPxb!Sb HOR\h\hO1[#b K1mPtaV/]`ORnrs_anD]`mPgqO&nabO1lj_aNdVoO&NdU_a\^S1V[S1NPV!V2nJ_aU V2NTSmdVv SR]2]sORNTv¥gqnjQmPO S7eaNdV=SRvJmPtJ DNPbdm bdmdN`S1mPV2QRc§NdO&U bdUS1\h\hV2bdmbdtDSNdVv gqnjbdmTSnD]`V2b mdO$\^S1NdQ&V2NORnjV2bS1nDv¨SNdVbdO&\q&Vv ghn lDSNTS1\h\hV2\Ka :H S$i&_DS1nJmdgDVANKHNdV2VORNPU_a\^]S \ghb/b`S1mdghbS1ea\hVRk,mdtjV2n¨mdtaV2NPVV agqbPmdbS1nghnJmdV2Q&V2N ¨bd_D]Pt mdtDSIm \ghLb j b`S1mdghbS1ea\hVo/ N= m1!¢J¡ P!D¤oS1nDvbPOmPtaV2NPVghbSÏmdVAN SofnaghmdV!mPghUV[S/]`ORn=r`_anD]`mPghORnO la_aNPV[O&NdU_a\^S1V O&N/[tag^]PtVSR]Pt V2\hV2UV2nJm`S1Ndc bdOR\h&V2N/mdVANdUghnDSmdV2bS1nDv$NPV2md_aNPnab T :Knmdtjgqb]2SbdVRk,V]AS1n tfS1\hm mdtaV laNPOa]`V2bdb/SnDv NdV2mP_aNdn S1b[NPV2bd_a\hm= '^
(220) 2- 0/
(221) 213
(222) , +4 134/ *
(223) Mo*¡ POM[¤ #7Q 16 W.
(224) 2] (7I 01JV !4¡ P!D¤ 0 T k ;¬J°f1¬ f+\ HG. %. %. . . , . ). &. ) ). $&. &. . . . . . ). , . &. ) ). $&. . &. . . . . /4 Z }% k 7
(225) ,q# 75
(226) W
(227) W 0/16
(228) . Á,Á É# !.
(229) ~r. $u
(230) V!$&. o¡ M[¤Ol M ) ). } #
(231) 2- 0/
(232) 213
(233) , +4Y Q/ *!
(234) % M & #7Q 16 W
(235) # 75
(236) W
(237) W 0/16 4 0J k ]/4 Z}- k 7 X# al 0g &
(238) ( k 0/13) . , . ! ). ~ `W. 8-.. . !. 46:"(.9171 "!$#&%' .9*-. :"! ".9/. # '. # 4-*&/-.9/. &.
(239) 2
(240) # . . 158&!$:.9/ . : . 1. Kn mdtaghbbdV]`mPghORn k;VbPmd_DvJc taO1 mdtaVlaNPV2JghOR_abbdV2U gvJV=]`ghbdghORnlaNPOa]`VvJ_aNPV-]2Sn efVmd_jNdnaVv ghnJmdO-S vJV=]`ghbdghORn S1\hQ&ORNdghmPtaU'ORNmdtaVb`S1mdghbS1eagh\hghmKc-ljNdORej\qVAU / N m;!¢¡ P$!f¤1;[taghbghblfORbPbdghea\hVg!mdtaV vJVsDnaghmdghORnO¢SobPmdNd_f]`md_aNPV QRV2naVANTS1mPVveJc Z}7?mPV2NdU b]AS1nefV!NdVAbdmdNPg^]`mdVv mPOSeDO&_anDvJVvbPV2mO14bdtDSNdVv mPV2NdU b1[taV[U ORbPm mdNPghxg^S\xV jSUla\hVSlalfVS1NPb [taV2n Z} ghb;bdghU la\hcSobdV2m O14bdtDSNdVv]`O&nabdm`S1nJmdb=R[tjV2n k Z}KmdVANdUb[S1NPV naV]`V2bPbTSNdgh\hc%O taV2ghQRtJm ~R
(241) 4
(242) #¬ :H ! gqb!SbPmTSea\hcgqn¥Dnaghmd V M KmdtaV2O&Ndc bd_D]Pt}mPtDS1m 4 g 2 $ } g "ll 2 ! ! l )ll 2 g mPtaV2n}!ghbbdm`S1ea\hcQ&V2naV2N`S1mPVveJc Z}s?mPV2NdU qb fHO1 taV2ghQRtJm #~ iA :KnmdtjVlDSNdmPg]s_a\^S1N ]2S1bPV[O1DbPtDS1NPVv]`O&nabdm`S1nJmdb=ka~`KbTSmdghbKSeagh\hgqmKc ]`ORNPNdV2bPlDO&nDvJbmdO bTSmdghbK4S1eagh\hghmKcS1nfv mPtaV2NdV ghb naO _anjgq&V2Ndb`S1\h\hci&_DS1nJmPg©fVvRS1NPgSea\hV2b;ghnmdtaV£ORNPU_a\^S
(243) M /E \ghnJmdNPOavJ_D]`Vvghn |oV`DnjgqmPghORYn rD A ]2]`ORN`vJghnaQmPO MNdORlfORbPghmdghORn}akJV OReam`S1ghnmPtaV O&\h\qO1[ghnaQ NPV2bd_a\hm K ;¬J°f1¬ '^
(244) 2- 0/
(245) 213
(246) , +4Y
(247) - Mo¡ P M[/¤ # 7Q 1 0 2 !¢¡ P !D¤
(248) , W
(249) W 0/16
(250) M ¡ M ¤ l } 5# O Q& k & #
(251) 2- 0/
(252) 213
(253) , +4Y
(254) - M 75 16 0
(255) 0
(256) % 0 0/16 2 ! !
(257) 5 V W/ 1X4Y
(258) 2 -Z[
(259) VN %$& 4X# _l0~ g`W !$] %$& 4 g 2 $ Z}0g )ll 2 ! ! l )ll 2 . V ]`OR_j\vS\qbPOghnJmdNPOavJ_D]`V UO&NdV ]`ORU la\hg]AS1mdV=ev f?S1nfvU ORNPVS1NPmdg]`g^S,\ i bdmPNd_D]smd_aNPV2b QRV2naVANTS1mPVveJc Z}KmdVANdUb[[tjV2NdVORna\hcSbdV2m O1 mPV2NdU b[O1 taV2ghQRtJ m }ghb!bP_ v%]`ghV2nJm!mPO%vJVsDnaV/naO&nJKbdtDSNdVv _anD]smdghORnab SnDv laNdVv¥g]AS1mdVAb
(260) 4
(261) # ¬ YORnjbdg^vJV2N/mPtaV]`OR( nJRVANdQRVAnxm7NdV2[NPgqmPVbdcJbdmPV2n U ] lm Ï f^^f^hJiFi f
(262) i ( ej_agh\qmoO1RV2N mPtaVbdghQRnfS1md_jNd]V M l &TgT g
(263) f[ta]V M S\qQ&V2eaN`]S ( dtf+M ghei O1njORNdUS1\hg G2VvmPV2NdU b / N= m ] US=c-efVbdV2V2n Sb S bdmPNd_D]`mP_aNdV$QRVAnaV2NTSmdVv eJc KmdVANdUbO1RVANmdtaVbdVAm O1!naO&NdUS1\hg G2Vv$mdVANdUb [ghmdtjOR_aLm S1b/mPORlJKbdcJUefOR\K Ao\h\ mdV2NPUb gh>n dtf Z}<g ieDV2tfS=RV\hghRV
(264) [ghmPtNdV2bPlDV]smmPO}mdtaVnjORnJ bPtDS1NPVv_anD]`mPghORn% J[taV!b`S1UV[NPV2U%SNdtaO&\^vJb S\hbdO O&NmPtaVo( OR\h\hO1[ghnaQ]sORnJRV2NP(QRV2nJm[NPV2[NdghmdV bPcxbPmdV2U ] l h f 0i |sgf 0i h sg9h s|sgs h|s [taV2NdV!S\h \ gs KmdV2NPUbSNdV[US1lalfVv O&nxmP]O s/eJc :. . . . . . . . . ). , . &. ) ). $&. $&. .
Documents relatifs
2) Le développement local c'est-à-dire les expériences d'intervention en développement économique communautaire, en économie sociale et en économie solidaire mises
La définition générale du concept d'évaluation formative des apprentissages retenue pour cette recherche constitue une synthèse découlant de la recension d'un ensemble
Effets et pouvoirs de la voix dans la philosophie et la littérature antiques Paris, Classiques Garnier, 2021 (Kaïnon - Anthropologie de la pensée ancienne, 19), ISBN :
relève de traités, et que les États membres sont des États au sens du droit international public, c’est à ce juste titre que J. Fischer peut qualifier l’Union actuelle de
Afin de saisir le déploiement de ce discours, j'analyserai dans un premier temps les représentations liées au temps dans le roman, en m'arrêtant d'abord sur toutes celles qui,
Cette recherche, de type qualitatif, consiste en une exploration de la littérature dont les buts sont de décrire selon divers auteurs, différe ntes expériences
For each sam- pling point is also given the value output of the merging process with the difference between the SH degree 100 expansions subtracted, the index corresponding to the
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
