Fully Bayesian Image Segmentation - an Engineering Perspective
22
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Fully Bayesian Image Segmentation – an Engineering Perspective Robin Morris, Xavier Descombes and Josiane Zerubia. N˚ 3017 October 1996 THE`ME 3. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !"$#&% '( )" *+ ),.-/ 01"2 35476,8:9<;<47=>=>8:?A@"BDCFEG8:HA=IHA?>JA47K/6LHM?NCO9"PRQO47?8SCO9,HUTVHM=XW"68SC Y[Z\^]D_a`bdcfehg$_^i$jFklgmonpeqZnp]D]D_Xrs]tjFk>Z7moe_pu mo]tjFvp_^wxu.ynpeez^_^wxuGk^npeeGjAmow$wjFek^_^w { inA|_lg{,} ~OY[c~ jF,npigy_5i_^kZ_^ik>Z_ea`p OMbklg$np_^ippb NGjFvp_^w /V^xMhh _lh_lonp]D_^ehg$w moe jFi¡pnx£¢¤ZGjAmoeqnpe¥g$_N¢!jFionUink^_^y¦i_^w ZGjxh_]tjFy_m§g , npw$wmo7o_¨g$n£,_^i©Snpi]ª©S¦7§§«+¬!jx«h_^wmjFeRmo]tjFvp_/w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯®¬¤«°g$Z7mow±¤_/]D_xjFe<g$ZGjAgDjA§ g$Z_qGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwUjFi_²g$i_xjAg$_^y³moy_^ehgmokxjA§§«hu[,_g$Z_l«<g$Z_qw$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe jF_lowu
(6) g$Z_´kljFww GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw!npi
(7) g$Z_ jFi¡pnx¨jFeynp]¶µVmo_loy/imonpi¤GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwx®¸·+_ _^i©Snpi]¶g$Z_jFeGjA§«Ow$mow ¥«+wjF]D7§moev£©¹inp]ºg$Z_/,npwg$_^imonpiy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe»nF©jA§
(8) g$Z_UGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwx®~7jF]D7§moev ©Sinp] g$Z_ q µ¼GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwUZGjFw/g$i$jFy7m§gmonpeGjA§§«³,_^_^e³k^npewmoy_^i_^y³m§©5enFg¨moe¥g$i$jFklgjF7o_qg$Z_^e½jAg o_xjFw$g k^np]D¦7gjAgmonpeGjA§§«°inpZ7mo7m§gm§h_p®c¾e£g$Z_DwgjAgmowgmok^w §m§g$_^i$jAg$¦i_Ng$Z_^i_tjFi_Ny_^w$k^imo7gmonpew nF©_X¿_^imo]D_^e¥g$w w$Znx±[moev/g$ZGjAg g$Z_q µÀGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw]tj^«´,_awjF]D7o_^y h«qjFinx¿Omo]tjAgr moev/g$Z_aGjFigm§gmonpe ©S¦eklgmonpe¯® Y[Z_^w__X¿_^imo]D_^e¥g$wjFi_jA§Áu,Znx±¤_lh_^i^u1npe+ÂÃg$n«,Ä,inp7o_^]Dw Å ©Snpi5g$Z_Ug¾«O7mokxjA[wmoÆ^_/nF©mo]tjFvp_²_^ek^np¦ehg$_^i_^y»moeR_^evFmoe_^_^imoev+jF7§mokxjAgmonpewDZGjFw$_¨g$i$jFew$mÇr gmonpe(_^ZGjxmonp¦inF©Èg$Z_t]DnOy_low5,_^k^np]D_^wj]tjM|npi§mo]Nm§gmoevq©SjFklg$npimoeg$Z_¨_^wgmo]tjAgmonpe(nF© g$Z_/GjFigm§gmonpe(©S¦eklgmonpe¯®É_lh_^ig$Z_lo_^w$wxuL±È_Uw$Znx±g$ZGjAga±[m§g$Z(wnp]D_¨kxjFi_puL©¹¦7§§«+¬[j^«h_^w$mjFe w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe´kxjFe,_ _^i©Snpi]D_^ynpei_xjA§mowgmokwmoÆ^_^y²mo]tjFvp_^wx®¸·+_5jAownDk^np]DGjFi_ g$Z_ ©¹¦7§§« ¬[jx«h_^wmjFeqjFinhjFkZq±[m§g$Zg$Z_ajFinx¿Omo]tjAg$_w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnnOyq]D_lg$ZnOy¯® Ê´ËhÌ"Í$ÎÏ MÐVh cf]tjFvp_w$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpe¯u1£jFi¡pnqkZGjAmoe°£npehg$_D¢!jFionu"GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i_^w$gmo]tjMr gmonpe¯u£jFi¡pn²jFeynp]ѵVmo_loy¯uGGjFigm§gmonpe´©S¦eklgmonpe ÒoÓÕÔ¾ÖÁ×xØÔÈÙLÚÇÖÁÛÝÜ^Þ ßà á âÈáGã äXåÝåSæèç¤é¯ê>ç!çSëAìMìpäXåSíÁîïDð^ñtê5òXåÁêóxíÈôÇåÝä>õöíÁ÷Aîø,äXõ[õ!æèçÝç¹æùäXó¨ä>ôÕíÁ÷Aîú.ëAåÝäXìpîê>óUø,äXõ[õ¤ëMóMæûíÝæùîç ëAóFïîå"íÁ÷AîVüø"ãýìAåÝä>òXåÁê>õ á ß>ß îõê$æùþoÿ Ø çSäXìM÷Mæèêá æùóAåSæèêxá ô å. Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 93 65 77 77 – Te´le´copie : (33) 93 65 77 65.
(9) !"$#¾º
(10) 0L#) .# s .-/ 01 .0¸$ 0V ý-¨#)ö s $ ).
(11)
(12) iFk^_ jF¦²yzlh_lonp,_^]D_^ehgiz^k^_^ehgy_^w[]Dzlg$ZnOy_^w ¢!¢uOm§"_^w$g!]tjAmoe¥g$_^eGjFehg ,npw$wmo7o_y_ izxjA§mow$_^i!y_^w!w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpewy¯Ä mo]tjFvp_O¦7m"w$nFmo_^ehg[k^np]D7o\lg$_^]D_^ehg Gj^«h_^wmo_^ee_^wx® ¢¤_ ¦7mÕw$movpe7mG_O¦_g$np¦wo_^w GjFi$jF]D\lg$i_^w w$npe¥gg$i$jAm§g$z^w y_5©Ýj^npemoy_^ehgmO¦_pu O¦¯Ä m§ÕwxÄûjFvFmoww$_ y_^wzlgmO ¦_lgg$_^wy_Dw$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpe¯uÕy_^wGjFi$jF]D\lg$i_^way_NkljFw$w_np¦_^ek^npi_Dy_^wGjFi$jF]D\lg$i_^w i_ljAgm§©Sw j°inpGjF7m§§m§g$z£j°imonpimy¦ÀkZGjF]D y_´£jFi¡pn,® ÄûjFeGjA§«Ow__^wgt_",! _^klg$¦zqGjFi z^k>ZGjFehgm§§onpeeGjFvp_# GjFigmoiVy_¤jy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpetj ,npwg$_^imonpimOy_¤g$np¦wVo_^w¸GjFi$jF]D\lg$i_^wx®% $ kZGjFeOr gm§§onpee_^i&N GjFigmoiy_^wGjFi$jF]D\lg$i_^wy¦kZGjF]Dqy_5 jFi¡pnx_^wg[g$i$jFy7m§gmonpee_l§o_^]D_^e¥gk^npew$mÇr yz^izDk^np]D]D_¨inpZ7mo7m§gm§©!y¯Äæe(nFmoe¥gay_NO¦_Nmoe7©Snpi]tjAgmO¦_p®'$ e+wgjAgmowgmO¦_pu1y_^w5GjF7mo_^iw yz^k^im§h_^e¥gay_^w_X¿z^imo_^ek^_^wn) ( o_^wGjFi$jF]D\lg$i_^w5y¦kZGjF]D(y_N jFi¡pnx w$npehg5z^k>ZGjFehgm§§onpeOr ez^wGjFi jFin^¿7mo]tjAgmonpe y_jD©Snpeklgmonpe y_aGjFigm§gmonpe¯®¢¤_^w _X¿z^imo_^ek^_^w w$npe¥gezxjFe]DnFmoew izxjA§mowz^_^w/w$¦iUy_^wUinp7o\^]D_^w/g$i\^wUwmo]D7o_^wx®ö{Lnp¦iUj+gjAm§§o_£y_^w/mo]tjFvp_^w²¦7gm§§mow$z^_^w²yGjFew y_^w jF7§mokxjAgmonpew iz^_l§o_^wxu.o_inp7o\^]D_ay_jDg$i$jFewm§gmonpeqy_5ZGjFw_5_^wg¦e©ÝjFklg$_^¦i]tjM|_^¦i y_N§mo]Nm§gjAgmonpe(_^¦°z^vhjFi* y UÁÄÃ_^wgmo]tjAgmonpe+y_jU©¹npeklgmonpe(y_GjFigm§gmonpe¯®DÉzxjFe]DnFmoewxuLenp¦w ]Dnpe¥g$inpe+w ¦¯Äæe_w$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpek^np]D7o\lg$_^]D_^ehgGjx«h_^wmo_^ee_ _^wg¤,npw$wmo7o_w$¦iÈy_^wÈmo]tjFvp_^w y_¨gjAm§§o_^wjFww$_^Ætvpi$jFey_^wxu¸,np¦iO, ¦ ¦_DÁÄÃnpeRi_^ee _ O¦_l O¦_^wiz^kxjF¦7gmonpewx®qÉ np¦wk^np]r GjFinpewtjF¦wwmÈÁÄûjFinOkZ_k^np]D7o\lg$_^]D_^e¥g¨Gj^«h_^w$mo_^ee_´j^h_^k²¦e_jFink>Z_ ¦7m!¦7gm§§mow$_Uj w_^¦ynArÁOi$jAmow$_^]7jFek^_p u O¦7m1e¯ÄÃ_^w g O¦¯Äæe_ajFin^¿7mo]tjAgmonpe¯® .öÏ x Í 0 /
(13) w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpeÀy¯Ä mo]tjFvp_puÈkZGjF]DÀy_²£jFi¡pn,u
(14) _^wgmo]tjAgmonpe»y_UGjFi$jF]D\lg$i_pu ¢!¢u7©¹npeklgmonpe´y_aGjFigm§gmonpe.
(15) `.
(16) !" $#
(17) #%&. # , ,. '. x Ï Ð Lp, Ï * . /10 Ë . Ï Ð Ë /¹ 2 ®Ç ~7jF]D7§moevtg$Z_a{LnFgg$wqnOy_l£®5®®a®®5®®5®5®®5®®a®5®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® 2 ® 2 Y[Z_¢ÈjFw$w¢¤npey7m§gmonpeGjAL{ inpGjF7m§§m§gmo_^w®®5®5®®5®®a®5®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® 2 ®û` Y[Z_5{Vnpwg$_^imonpi mowg$imo¦7gmonpe½®5®®a®®5®®5®5®®5®®a®5®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® Ë : A Ë Ë A 4 5 76 /%, *98 0 ; `7®Ç ~7jF]D7§moevtg$Z_aw$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpeqjF_low<®5®®5®5®®5®®a®5®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® `7® 2 ~7jF]D7§moevtg$Z_akljFw$w]D_xjFeqjFey²pjFimjFek^_aGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwU®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® `7®û` ~7jF]D7§moevtg$Z_a]Dny_lÁÄÃwZ¥«O,_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i ®5®®5®®a®5®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® `7>® = ~7jF]D7§moevtg$Z_a{ w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOny ®®5®®5®5®®5®®a®5®®5®®5®®5®a®®5®® Ð ? Ï * 0 / L , Ï * - /Ë /:xt * @ /10 Ë 5 ÎË * ÐL Ë * BÍ A *98 / 8 Ï ,: 0 (. )+*. àLà óEDGFHIKJ. 3. . . <. . p 2 (4 (C.
(18) =. &G & 1
(19) &B
(20) &! 9 G%. . 7),#Na0Õ,$# . cf]tjFvp_w$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpeÁjFey´Z_^i_ ±¤_ajFi_imo]tjFim§§«k^npek^_^ie_^y´±[m§g$Zg$Z_w$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpeqnF© ~O{¤Y¶mo]tjFvp_^wnF©jFvpimok^¦7§g$¦i$jA¤i_^vFmonpew mowNjkljFw$wmok/kxjFw$_¨nF©jFe(m§§Çrsnpw_^y(inp7o_^ ] ` Å´g$Z_DyGjAgj/g$Z_^]Dw$_l§h_^wajFi_DenFg5w!¦ tklmo_^ehgg$n¦eGjF]a7movp¦np¦w$§«y"_ Ge_tjUw$nFo¦7gmonpe¯# ® "wmoev npe7§« g$Z_tyGjAgj´jFey(enw$]DnnFg$Ze_^wwjFw$w$¦]D7gmonpew5o_xjFyw5g$nqjUh_^i«enFmow«w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯u i$jAg$Z_^ig$ZGjFeg$Z_±È_l§Ly"_ Ge_^y¯uGZnp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦w i_^vFmonpewg$ZGjAg jFi_5w$np¦vpZ¥$g p¥u" 2 Á® Y[ZGjAgLimonpiLmoe7©¹npi]tjAgmonpeNjFw1g$ng$Z_
(21) y_^wmoi_^yw$nFo¦7gmonpe5mow¸j^pjAm§jF7o_ ÝeGjF]D_l§«g$ZGjAgLg$Z_Èw$_^vAr ]D_^e¥gjAgmonpew$Znp¦7oy£k^npew$mowg nF© Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wi_^vFmonpe%w eGjAg$¦i$jA§§«qw$¦vpvp_^w$g$w ¦wmoevUj¨¬[jx«h_Xr w$mjFe/jFinhjFkZ¯uO±Z_^i_ g$Z7mow
(22) moe7©Snpi]tjAgmonpeU]tj^«¨,__xjFwm§§«¨jFey/eGjAg$¦i$jA§§«tmoek^npinpi$jAg$_^yUmoe¥g$n g$Z_tjMrsimonpimÈy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe+©Snpi g$Z_Dw$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯®/Y[Z_t¦w$_DnF©[j mow5y7mowg$imo¦7gmonp& e Ýnpi _ O¦7m§pjAo_^ehg§«huj<£jFi¡pn³ jFeynp]µLmo_lo' y Á£(µ ) * =+ ©¹npi¨g$Z7mowUjMrsimonpim y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe mow wnp]D_lg$Z7moevDg$ZGjAgZGjFwen±ö,_^_^ek^np]D]Dnpe´©Snpi[w$np]D_ gmo]D_p® Y[Z_U]tjAmoe»inp7o_^] ±[m§g$ZRg$Z_²¦w$_²nF© £µ¸wDjFwi_^vp¦7jFimow_^iwDZGjFwD_^_^eRmoeRg$Z_²_^wgmÇr ]tjAgmonpe°nF©Èg$Z_N]Dny_lÁÄÃw5GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw®Y[Z7mow mowy¦_Ng$nUg$Z_tjFeGjA§«OgmokNmoehg$i$jFklgjF7m§§m§gs«°nF©Èg$Z_ GjFigm§gmonpe£©S¦eklgmonpe¯u,jFey£ZGjFwo_xjFy£g$n¨jte¦]a,_^i nF©
(23) jFinx¿Omo]tjAg$_]D_lg$Znyw,_lmoev¨inp,nAr w_^, y ¥u 2 È©Snpi5g$Z7mowN¦i,npw$_p®q _^k^_^ehg§«(]D_lg$ZnOywNZGj^h_U_^_^eRinpnpw_^y(±Z7mok>ZR_^w$gmo]tjAg$_ g$Z_GjFigm§gmonpeq©S¦eklgmonpe´±[m§g$Z£w$!¦ tklmo_^ehgjFk^k^¦i$jFkl«´g$n/_^eGjF7o_5§mo¡p_l§moZnOnyqmoe7©¹_^i_^ek^_©¹npig$Z_ ]DnOy_lÁÄÃw¤GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwÈg$na_ _^i©Snpi]D_^ y Ã7u7- ÁuOjFeyUjAow$na_^eGjF7o_g$Z_,npwg$_^imonpi
(24) y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe ©Snpig$Z_N]Dny_lÁÄÃw5GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw5g$n_NwjF]D7o_^ymoe°j²£jFi¡pn k>ZGjAmoe+qnpe¥g$_/¢!jFionw$k>Z_^]D_pu i_^w¦7§gmoevDmoe´j²ÂéS¦7§§«U¬[j^«h_^w$mjFe¯Ä.jFeGjA§«Ow$mo.w à Á® c¾eg$Z7mow GjF,_^iV±È_y7mow$k^¦www$np]D_!nF©.g$Z_^w$_[wgjAgmow$gmokxjAmoy_xjFw©¹inp] jFeD_^evFmoe_^_^imoev5w$gjFeyOr ,nFmoehgx®!·+_aw$Znx± g$ZGjAgjFw$,_^klg$wnF©¸g$Z_]Dny_low k^npewmoy_^i_^y£]tjF¡p_ag$Z7mow©S¦7§§«¬[j^«h_^wmjFe jFOr inhjFk>Z°k^np]D¦7gjAgmonpeGjA§§« _X¿,_^ewm§h_a©Snpig$Z_w$moÆ^_^wnF©
(25) mo]tjFvp_^w_^ek^np¦ehg$_^i_^y°moei_xjAÇrÁ±Ènpioy inp7o_^]Dw®N·+_tk^np]DGjFi_Dg$Z_Di_^w$¦7§g$w5nF©!w$¦wgm§g$¦7gmoev´g$Z_tw$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOny°±Z_^e(wjF]r 7§moevtg$Z_5q µRGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwujFeyk^npeklo¦y_5±[m§g$Zqw$np]D_k^np]D]D_^ehg$w jFnp¦7gg$Z_5]Dny_low® /. 3 021 4. # $. ·+_£k^npewmoy_^i/g$Z_q±¤_l§Çrs¡en±e {VnFgg$w²]Dny_ljFwtg$Z_ i_^vp¦7jFimow$_^i^®öY[Z_q{VnFgg$w]Dny_l mow y"_ Ge_^yqh« GH 57698;: <>=@? ?. B C6 A <>=>DE!F. <$IJLKM7NO69P. JRQ P. M. =CST. É V¢ 698X=)= 6C<U W B 6CA > < =>DE!F. - . Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(26)
(27) !" $#
(28) #%&. 3. ±Z_^i_ B 6C<>= mowÕg$Z_
(29) GjFigm§gmonpe©¹¦eklgmonpe¯u J KM moey7mokxjAg$_^w¸jw$¦] nh_^iVjA§Oe_lmovpZ¥,np¦imoev GjAmoiw nF©V7mÇ¿7_low jFey N6 = mow!g$Z_y_l§gjN©¹¦eklgmonpe¯®
(30) Y[Z7mowi_^y¦k^_^w[g$nNg$Z_e¥¦]_^i nF©LZnp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦w kl§m O¦_^w[moeg$Z_i_xjA§mow>jAgmonpe¯u.ÉV ¢ 698X= ® Y[Z7mow[]Dny_l¯ZGjFw!_^_^e²_X¿7g$_^ewm§h_l§«/w$g$¦y7mo_^y²moe¨g$Z_wgjAgmow$gmokxjA"Z¥«Ow$mok^w!§m§g$_^i$jAg$¦i_puGjFey jae¥¦]_^i!nF©ÕjFeGjA§«OgmokxjA,i_^w$¦7§g$w!np7gjAmoe_^y¯®
(31) ©1moe¥g$_^i_^wg¤g$n¦w¤Z_^i_mowÈg$ZGjAg Smoe/g$Z_ moe Ge7m§g$_ w$moÆ^_ §mo]Nm§%g ¤g$Z_5]DnOy_lÕ_X¿7Z7mo7m§g$w jNZGjFw$_g$i$jFewm§gmonpeqjAg < ?. A.
(32) . 6. A . =. ±Z_^i_ mowNg$Z_e¦]a,_^itnF© kljFw$w_^w 3- Á®<cfeRg$Z_ Ge7m§g$_wmoÆ^_²kxjFw$_pu g$Z_ZGjFw$_²g$i$jFew$m§gmonpe ]tjFe7m§©S_^w g$w5jFwjFe°jFi¦7g5kZGjFevp_tnF©È_^ZGjxmonp¦inh_^i5j/w]tjA§¸i$jFevp_DnF©
(33) FjAo¦_^wnF© < klonpw$_ g$n < ® } w¨g$Z_qwmoÆ^_£nF©g$Z_qjAggmok^_£jFey _^w$_^klmjA§§«»g$Z_£e¥¦]a,_^iUnF©5kljFw$w$_^w¨k^npew$moy_^i_^y moek^i_xjFw_^wxu[g$Z_£jFi¦7g$e_^wwUnF©g$Z7mowUkZGjFevp_nF©5,_^ZGj^Omonp¦i/,_^k^np]D_^w²]Dnpi_£inpenp¦ek^_^y¯® Y[Z_D jFi¡pnx kZGjAmoe]D_lg$Znyw¦w_^y£g$nUwmo]¦7jAg$_Di_xjA§mowjAgmonpewnF© g$Z_N]Dny_l jAow$nU,_^k^np]D_ ]¦kZ<]Dnpi_¨won± g$nqk^npe¥h_^ivp_¨klonpw$_Dg$n´g$Z_¨ZGjFw$_Dg$i$jFew$m§gmonpe¯®/Y[Z7mowamow5g$Z_t]tjAmoe+kxjF¦w_ nF© g$Z_y7m tk^¦7§gs«»moe jF7§«Omoev°g$Z_²©¹¦7§§«R¬[j^«h_^wmjFe³jFinhjFk>Z g$n°i_xjA_^evFmoe_^_^imoev<wmoÆ^_^y inp7o_^]DwtÅ<g$n<y_^]Dnpewg$i$jAg$_qg$ZGjAg/g$Z_´]D_lg$ZnOy ±Ènpi¡Ow/moe imoeklmo7o_pujFe mo]tjFvp_£nF©wmoÆ^_ ¦ tklmo_^ehg Èmoe<j£i_xjA[jF7§mokxjAgmonpe»±È_U]a¦wgDy_xjA¤±[m§g$Z U 7mÇ¿_low±[m§g$Z kljFw$w$_^wmowNw$! mo]tjFvp_^w[nF©¸jAg!o_xjFwg
(34) U
(35) ÁjFeynF©¹g$_^e²]a¦kZ´jFivp_^ i !jFeyU]tjFe¥«U]Dnpi_kljFww$_^w Smoe²g$Z7mow GjF,_^i!±È_aZGj^h_ kljFww$_^%w X® . . "!$#&%('*),+.-/103254"--68794;:,0<%. ·+_¤¦w$_
(36) g$Z_!~±¤_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFev s~¥rÁ· ÕjAovpnpim§g$Z] 3 ¥g$nwmo]a¦7jAg$_!i_xjA§mowjAgmonpew¸nF©g$Z_¤{LnFgg$w ]DnOy_lÁ®Y[Z7mow[jAovpnpim§g$Z]Ñ]NmÇ¿7_^wSmo_ _X¿77onpi_^w¤g$Z_ wgjAg$_w$GjFk^_
(37) ]a¦kZ]Dnpi_©Si_^_l§«tg$ZGjFe²jAÇr vpnpim§g$Z]Dw
(38) ±Z7mokZt¦,yGjAg$_[npe7§«NwmoevFo_wm§g$_^w jAg
(39) jgmo]D_ Ýw¦kZ¨jFw¸g$Z_¦w¦GjAmo]D7o_^]D_^ehgjAgmonpew nF©Èg$Z_ mowa~7jF]D7o_^i5npig$Z_Dq_lg$inp,nF§mowr V jFwgmoevpwajAovpnpim§g$Z ] X®NY[Z_t~±È_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFev jAovpnpim§g$Z] mownp¦7g§moe_^ymoeqjF,_^ey7mÇ¿}® µLmovp¦i_t5w$Znx±wg$Z__lhnFo¦7gmonpeqnF©Vg$Z_e¥¦]a,_^inF©¸Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wkl§m ¦_^w[moe²g$Z_ai_xjA§mÇr w>jAgmonpew nF©g$Z_D~¥rÁ· jAovpnpim§g$Z]&©¹npij¨{VnFgg$w ]Dny_l¸nF©wmoÆ^_ U ±[m§g$Z kljFw$w$_^wu,jA©¹g$_^i g$Z_ Giwg 2 p ²m§g$_^i$jAgmonpew±È_^i_¨y7mowvhjFiy_^y¯®U¢Èo_xjFi§«g$Z_¨jAovpnpim§g$Z]k^npe¥h_^ivp_^w O¦7mok¡§«g$n g$Z_D_ O¦7m§§moimo¦]y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe¯uLjFey°g$Z_^e°_X¿7onpi_^w5©Si_^_l§«£g$Z_Di_^vFmonpe(nF©Èg$Z_DwgjAg$_DwGjFk^_ ±[m§g$Z£jFi_^klmjF7o_inpGjF7m§§m§g¾«´]tjFw$wx®È¢¤npe¥g$i$jFw#g Gvp¦i_ 2 u±Z7mokZ£w$Znx±wg$Z_5_lhnFo¦7gmonpe´©Snpi g$Z_{VnFgg$w[]Dny_l¯nF©1wmoÆ^_
(40) U
(41) ±[m§g$Z kljFw$w$_^w ÝenFg$_g$Z_ ZnpimoÆ^npe¥gjA1w$kxjAo_ X®Y[Z_^i_mow jaeGjFiinx± GjFeyUnF©¯FjAo¦_^w¤±Z_^i_ g$Z_ _X¿7onpi$jAgmonpe²nF©¯g$Z_ w$gjAg$_ w$GjFk^_ mow¤wo¦vpvFmow$Z¯®
(42) ¢Èo_xjFi§« g$Z7mowmow j¨nFg$_^e¥gmjAVkxjF¦w$_nF©_X¿Og$i_^]D_l§«moeGjFk^k^¦i$jAg$__^wgmo]tjAg$_^wÅ/©¹npiFjAo¦_^w nF© < klonpw$_ag$n g$Z7mow
(43) ZGjFw$_!g$i$jFewm§gmonpe¨]tjFe¥«Nm§g$_^i$jAgmonpew
(44) ]a¦w$g
(45) _[y7mowvhjFiy_^yDg$n_^ew$¦i_[g$ZGjAg g$Z_jAovpnpim§g$Z] ZGjFwk^npehh_^ivp_^y g$n¨g$Z_a_ O¦7m§§moimo¦]&y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe¯u"jFeyqg$Z_^e jFe£_X¿Og$i_^]D_l§«jFivp_e¥¦]_^i àLà óEDGFHIKJ.
(46) . &G & 1
(47) &B
(48) &! 9 G%. 2200. number of homogeneous cliques. 2000. 1800. 1600. 1400. 1200. 1000. 800 0. 50. 100. 150. 200 250 iteration number. 300. 350. 400. µVmovp¦i_N Y[Z__lhnFo¦7gmonpe´nF©Lg$Z_e¥¦]_^inF©VZnp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wkl§m O¦_^w!moe²g$Z_i_xjA§mowjAgmonpewnF© g$Z_{VnFgg$w[]Dny_l"h«/g$Z_ ~±¤_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFevtjAovpnpim§g$Z]u©SnpiÈjFe/mo]tjFvp_nF©LwmoÆ^_ U ±[m§g$Z kljFww$_^wxu7©Snpi!FjFimonp¦wFjAo¦_^wnF© < nF©,i_xjA§mowjAgmonpew
(49) ]¦wg ,_[¦w$_^y±Z_^eD©¹npi]Nmoev5jFe¥«N£npehg$_¢!jFion5_^wgmo]tjAg$_^wxupg$n_^ew¦i_!g$ZGjAg g$Z_wgjAg$_w$GjFk^_5mowjFy_ O¦GjAg$_l§«qwjF]D7o_^y¯®µVmovp¦i_¨moey7mokxjAg$_^wg$ZGjAgg$Z_^w_ak^npewmoy_^i$jAgmonpew yn enFgNZnFoy(±[m§g$Z<g$Z_/w>jF]D_¨©Snpik^_¨©Snpig$Z_/wmoÆ^_/nF©mo]tjFvp_^wN¦w$_^y<moe+g$Z_£ÂÃg$nx«"ÄVinp7o_^]Dw y7mowk^¦w$w$_^y²moeg$Z_ §m§g$_^i$jAg$¦i_i_lmonp¦w§«h® ¢¤npewmoy_^i[g$Z_§mo¡p_l§moZnOny´©¹npi!g$Z_GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i < vFm§h_^eqjNw$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonp e 8 ® 576C<;: 8 =>?. ±Z_^i_. B 6C<X=X?. É V¢ 6 8X =)= 6C< U W B 6CA > < = DEF I. DEF. É V ¢ 698X=)= 6C< U . Y[Z_a]tjM¿Omo]¦]ѧmo¡p_l§moZnnOy´_^wgmo]tjAg$_5mowvFm§h_^e´h«.
(50) . 5 6C< : 8 = ? <. ÉV ¢. = 6 8X. Q. B 6C<>= B 6C<>= ?
(51). jFey B 6C<>= B 6C<>=(? É V ¢ 698X= u7g$ZGjAgmowxu7g$Z_a]D_xjFe´e¥¦]_^i nF©¸Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wkl§mO¦_^w ¦ ey_^ig$Z_5y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe´y_"Ge_^y£h«Ug$Z_FjAo¦_anF© < ®Y[Z_a]tjM¿Omo]¦] §mo¡p_l§moZnOny´_^w$gmo]tjAg$_ mowg$Z¥¦wg$Z_ pjAo¦_5nF© < ©Snpi!±Z7mokZ É V ¢ 6 8X = ? É V ¢ 698 = Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(52) .
(53) !" $#
(54) #%&. 4. 14. x 10. number of homogeneous cliques. 12. 10. 8. 6. 4. 2 0. 0.5. 1. 1.5. 2 2.5 3 iteration number. 3.5. 4. 4.5. 5. µVmovp¦i_ 2 Y[Z__lhnFo¦7gmonpe´nF©Lg$Z_e¥¦]_^inF©VZnp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wkl§m O¦_^w!moe²g$Z_i_xjA§mowjAgmonpewnF© g$Z_¨{LnFgg$w]Dny_lÈh«g$Z_/~±È_^eyw_^eOrÁ·(jFevjAovpnpim§g$Z]uV©Snpi5jFe+mo]tjFvp_tnF©[wmoÆ^_
(55) U
(56) ±[m§g$Z kljFw$w$_^wxu©¹npi
(57) FjFimonp¦w¤pjAo¦_^w!nF© < ®É nFg$_g$Z_ y7m !"_^i_^ehg[ZnpimoÆ^npe¥gjA1w$kxjAo_©Sinp] Gvp¦i_ h® 4. x 10. Y[Z_¨vpi$jFZw5moe Gvp¦i_^w`qjFey =´w$Zn± ÉWV¢ 698X= ©Sinp]£npehg$_/¢!jFionqwmo]a¦7jAgmonpewx® ¢Èo_xjFi§«(©¹npiag$Z_qÂÃg$n«,ÄVinp7o_^] g$Z_/]tjM¿7mo]a¦] §mo¡p_l§moZnOnyR_^wgmo]tjAg$_UnF© < kxjFeR_xjFwm§§«+,_ ©Snp¦ey¯u7jFey¨g$Z_ FjFimjFek^_nF©¯g$Z_i_xjA§mow_^y/e¦]a,_^i¤nF©1Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦w[kl§m O¦_^w¤mow
(58) w$¦!tklmo_^e¥g§« w]tjA§g$ZGjAg¸g$Z_!_^wgmo]tjAg$_^w jFi_¤i_l§mjF7o_p®Vµ.npiLg$Z_!wmo]¦7jAgmonpew nF©jFemo]tjFvp_!nF©.wmoÆ^_
(59) U
(60) ±[m§g$Z 3akljFw$w$_^wxuOZnx±¤_lh_^i^um§g¤mow¤klo_xjFi¤g$ZGjAg!h_^i«¨]tjFe¥«¨mo]tjFvp_^w!±[m§§,©SjA§,moehg$nNg$Z_Æ^npe_ e_xjFi g$Z_ZGjFw_g$i$jFewm§gmonpe ÁjFwg$Z7mow[moeklo¦y_^w jh_^i«²jFivp_5i$jFevp_5nF©VpjAo¦_^wnF©VÉ V¢ 6 8X = X® . /,0. . . %* "6 6. 4 )1:&' -' 4 ), "% 2. 4 1 '*%*' -' 0 6. Y[Z_^w_qy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewUy_^w$k^imo,_´±ZGjAg¨±¤_£_X¿,_^klgtg$n(npw$_^ih_ jAgUj(7mÇ¿7_lÁu!¡Oenx±[moev<g$ZGjAg m§gmowmoeÀjqGjFigmok^¦7jFiDkljFw$w®°} k^np]D]Dnpe jFw$w$¦]D7gmonpeRmoe<g$Z_Uw_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe nF©w>jAg$_l§§m§g$_ mo]tjFvp_^i«mowg$ZGjAgg$Z_5vpi_l«´wkxjAo_FjAo¦_^wjFw$w$nOklmjAg$_^y´±[m§g$Z jDGjFigmok^¦7jFi kljFww jFi_5vhjF¦w$w$mjFe y7mow$g$imo¦7g$_^y¯u ±[m§g$Z j ]D_xjFe jFey»FjFimjFek^_y_^,_^ey7moev°npeRg$Z_kljFw$wxu
(61) jFeyRg$ZGjAgDg$Z_l«»jFi_ k^npey7m§gmonpeGjA§§«moey_^,_^ey_^ehgvFm§h_^eg$Z_5w$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpe¯®
(62) Y[Z7mow vFm§h_^w. : 8
(63)
(64) =. 576. J. ? . A . DEF. Q 6 J Q = . 2 . ±Z_^i_ jFey jFi_ g$Z_]D_xjFeqjFey²pjFimjFek^_ajFw$w$nOklmjAg$_^y²±[m§g$Z²g$Z_5kljFw$w!moey7mokxjAg$_^yqh« g$Z_ jF,_l P jAgonkxjAgmonpe
(65) jFeyÌ°mow[g$Z_npw$_^ih_^yqmo]tjFvp_p® àLà óEDGFHIKJ.
(66) . &G & 1
(67) &B
(68) &! 9 G%. 2200. number of homogeneous cliques. 2000. 1800. 1600. 1400. 1200. 1000. 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5. 0.6. 0.7. 0.8. 0.9. µVmovp¦i_N` [Y[Z_]D_xjFe°jFey wgjFeyGjFiy y_lmjAgmonpenF©g$Z_e¥¦]a,_^i nF© Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦w5kl§m O¦_^w moeNg$Z_!i_xjA§mowjAgmonpewÈnF©.g$Z_[{VnFgg$w
(69) ]DnOy_lh«g$Z_~±È_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFevjAovpnpim§g$Z]u¥©SnpijFeNmo]tjFvp_ nF©¸wmoÆ^_ U ±[m§g$Z kljFw$w_^wxuGjFwj©S¦eklgmonpe´nF© < beta. 4. 14. x 10. number of homogeneous cliques. 12. 10. 8. 6. 4. 2 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5 beta. 0.6. 0.7. 0.8. 0.9. Vµ movp¦i_ = [Y[Z_]D_xjFe°jFey wgjFeyGjFiy y_lmjAgmonpenF©g$Z_e¥¦]a,_^i nF© Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦w5kl§mO¦_^w moeNg$Z_!i_xjA§mowjAgmonpewÈnF©.g$Z_[{VnFgg$w
(70) ]DnOy_lh«g$Z_~±È_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFevjAovpnpim§g$Z]u¥©SnpijFeNmo]tjFvp_ nF©¸wmoÆ^_
(71) U
(72) ±[m§g$Z kljFww$_^wxujFwjN©S¦eklgmonpe´nF© <. Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(73) .
(74) !" $#
(75) #%& . . /,0.254 6 -
(76) 0. . '*4 . '(6 -. . ' ,-
(77) '*4 ). c¾g[mow¥«²jFeGjA§«7wmownF©Vg$Z_5,npwg$_^imonpi[y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe´g$ZGjAg±È_±[m§§1yi$jx± moe7©S_^i_^ek^_^w jF,np¦7g[g$Z_ w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯u"g$Z_aGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwnF©g$Z_kljFw$wk^npey7m§gmonpeGjA¸y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpew jFey£g$Z_NjMrsimonpim w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe³]DnOy_lÁÄÃwDZh«7,_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwx®ÀY[Z¥¦w¨±È_´jFi_²moehg$_^i_^w$g$_^yÀmoeÀwjF]D7§moev°©Sinp] 5 698
(78)
(79)
(80) < : Ì = ® "wmoev¬[j^«h_^wY[Z_^npi_^]jFey+eGjAg$¦i$jA moey_^,_^ey_^ek^_/jFww$¦]D7gmonpew5±¤_ ±im§g$_5g$Z7mowjFw 576 Ì : 8
(81)
(82) =L57698 : <X=L576
(83) =L576C<>= 5 698
(84)
(85)
(86) < : Ì =X? 576 Ì = Y[Z _ Giwgg$_^i]mowNvFm§h_^eRh«<g$Z_/kljFw$wk^npey7m§gmonpeGjAinpGjF7m§§m§gmo_^* w Ý_ O¦GjAgmonpe 2 jFey<g$Z_ w_^k^npeymow g$Z_D{VnFgg$w5]DnOy_l imonpinpe g$Z_Dw$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonp2 e Ý_ O¦GjAgmonpeÀ- X®Y[Z_Ng$Z7moiyg$_^i] mowg$Z_aimonpiwnpe´g$Z_5]D_xjFe£jFeypjFimjFek^_anF©¸_xjFkZ£kljFw$wx®
(87) ·+_5¦w$_ajD¦e7m§©Snpi] y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe npe²g$Z_ ]D_xjFewxujFey´j h"_ !,i_l«"ÄÃwimonpi = 1npeUg$Z_ FjFimjFek^_^w® µGnpi!g$Z_imonpi[npe < ±È_jAow$n ¦w_ajt¦e7m§©Snpi] y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe¯®csg k^np¦7oy£,_ajFivp¦_^y£g$ZGjAg±È_w$Znp¦7oy£kZnOnpw$_j¨imonpi±Z7mokZ ©Ýj^hnp¦iw!jFivp_^i < ©SnpiÈmoek^i_xjFw$_^yw$]DnOnFg$Ze_^w$wxu7¦7g[©¹npi¤wmo]D7§moklm§g¾«/g$Z7mow!±!jFw[enFgynpe_p®Y[Z_ g$_^i] 576 Ì = mowk^npewgjFe¥g©SnpijNvFm§h_^emo]tjFvp_p® . -N>a 1 *+ ), º V ). . fc e w$_^klgmonpe 2 ±È_ZGj^h_°y_"Ge_^y½g$Z_,npwg$_^imonpiy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe½©Snpi²jA§ g$Z_GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw´nF© moe¥g$_^i_^wgxug$ZGjAg mowxu.g$Z_[|nFmoehgnpwg$_^imonpinF©¸g$Z_aw$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpe jF_lowxu.g$Z_kljFww]D_xjFew jFey pjFimjFek^_^wxu¤jFey<g$Z_Z¥«O,_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw¨nF© g$Z_q µö]DnOy_lowx®(Y[Z7mowNmowNg$Z_²y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe ±¤_D±[mow$Zg$n´w>jF]D7o_puLjFey°©Sinp] g$Z_^w$_DwjF]D7o_^wa±È_D±[m§§È]tjF¡p_tnp¦imoe7©S_^i_^ek^_^wjF,np¦7gg$Z_ GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw® YÕnDwjF]D7o_©Sinp] g$Z_,npwg$_^imonpi!±¤_¦w__lm§g$Z_^i!g$Z_5£_lg$inp,nF§mowr VjFw$gmoevpw Ár V ¤jAovpnAr im§g$Z]¶npi¸g$Z_ mow wjF]D7o_^i^uy_^_^ey7moevnpeDk^npehh_^e7mo_^ek^_Åam§©,w$mo]D7o__X¿7i_^wwmonpew©Snpi¸g$Z_ ©S¦7§¯k^npey7m§gmonpeGjALy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewe_^_^y_^ymoe²g$Z_ mow[wjF]D7o_^ijFi_5jxFjAm§jF7o_jFeyi$jFeynp] pjFimjAg$_^wD©Sinp] g$Z_^w$_´y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpew/kxjFeÀ__xjFw$m§§«»jFey _ tklmo_^e¥g§«Àvp_^e_^i$jAg$_^y¯u!g$Z_^e»g$Z_ mowwjF]D7o_^i!mow¦w$_^y¯®c¾©LenFgxuGg$Z_^e²g$Z_]Dnpi_5vp_^e_^i$jAL£_lg$inpnF§mowr V jFwgmoevpwjAovpnpim§g$Z] mowg$Z_jAovpnpim§g$Z]nF©k>ZnFmok^_pu
(88) i_ O¦7moimoev npe7§«(g$Z_UkxjAok^¦7jAgmonpeÀnF©g$Z_Ui$jAgmon,_lgs±¤_^_^e»g$Z_ inpGjF7m§§m§gmo_^w nF©¸gs±¤n/y7m !"_^i_^ehg wgjAg$_^wx®!Y[Z_N~±È_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFevjAovpnpim§g$Z] mowjAow$n¨¦w$_^y´©Snpi w>jF]D7§moevt©Sinp] g$Z_aimonpi npe´g$Z_w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯u"g$Z_^w$_wjF]D7o_^w,_lmoev¨¦w_^y´g$n¨_^w$gmo]tjAg$_ g$Z_5jFk^k^_^7gjFek^_inpGjF7m§§m§gmo_^w±Z_^eqwjF]D7§moevtg$Z_]DnOy_lÁÄÃwZ¥«O,_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i^® ; . "!$#&%('*),+.-/10.6 0 + !$0 ) -
(89) <-'*4 ). . % . 0 %(6. Y[Z_5gjFw$¡/nF©wjF]D7§moev¨g$Z_5w$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpeqjF,_low[mowg$Z_awgjFeyGjFiy´gjFw$¡/moeqjFe¥«jAovpnpim§g$Z] ¦w$moev £µ¸wxuMjFeyamowL,_^i©Snpi]D_^ya_lm§g$Z_^iVh«5¦wmoevg$Z_È´r V»jAovpnpim§g$Z]upinp,npwmoevjkZGjFevp_ àLà óEDGFHIKJ.
(90) . &G & 1
(91) &B
(92) &! 9 G%. g$n£g$Z_UjF_ljAgg$Z_²k^¦ii_^ehgt7mÇ¿_lÁu
(93) jFey(g$Z_^e»¦wmoev g$Z_´r V jFk^k^_^7gjFek^_k^im§g$_^imonpe»g$n y_lg$_^i]Nmoe_/g$Z_¨e_X¿7gw$gjAg$_¨jAgag$ZGjAg7mÇ¿7_lÁu¸npia¦w$moev´g$Z_ mowawjF]D7o_^i^u¸h«+k^np]D¦7gmoev _X¿7§moklm§g§«5g$Z_¤k^npey7m§gmonpeGjAGy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpeDnxh_^iVg$Z_ÈjF_lowjAgVg$ZGjAgV7mÇ¿_lÁuhjFeyg$Z_^ew>jF]D7§moev ©Sinp] g$ZGjAgy7mow$k^i_lg$_ay7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe¯® Y[Z_onkxjA1k^npey7m§gmonpeGjAVy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe´moe¥hnF§h_^y´mow. : = A DE!F = < M I NO69P MWQ . J mow[g$Z_kljFww[jF_lVjFey moey7mokxjAg$_^wg$Z_e_lmovpZnp¦iwnF© $®
(94)
(95) 5769P. ±Z_^i_ ; . J. J Q GH Q 6. ?. . "!$#&%('*),+.-/10. %* "6 6. . . !$0 "). ")1:. . '* ). 0. #& "!$0-
(96) 0. Á` . += ST. 6. µ.inp]ªg$Z_¨,npwg$_^imonpi5y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpewag$Z_¨©¹nF§on±[moev£]tjFivFmoeGjA¤y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewa©Snpig$Z_/]D_xjFe jFey´FjFimjFek^_5GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw©¹npi[_xjFk>ZqkljFw$w jFi__xjFwm§§«Uy_^im§h_^y¯®ÈµGnpi[g$Z_5]D_xjFew±È_5ZGjxh_ J Q. = ST 576 :L= J I DEF GH ? A J I J
(97) ST ±Z_^i_ mow1g$Z_e¥¦]_^iVnF©77mÇ¿7_low¯moeakljFw$w jFey5É 6
(98) = y_^enFg$_^w1g$Z_ Énpi]tjA¥y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe¯® µ.npi[g$Z_ FjFimjFek^_^wg$Z_5k^npey7m§gmonpeGjALy7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe´mow J Q J Q. 6. = A J A 576 :L= DEF J Q GH Q "!#"$ DEF J I 6 = ST Y[Z_ ]D_xjFew[jFi_ jF¦w$wmjFeUy7mowg$imo¦7g$_^y¯ujFey/Z_^ek^_g$Z_e_l± pjAo¦_^w!kxjFe/,_vp_^e_^i$jAg$_^y _xjFw$m§§«h®¶Y[Z_°y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpew©SnpiUg$Z_FjFimjFek^_^w´jFi_moe¥h_^iw$_XrskZ7my7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewxu±[m§g$Z% y_^vpi_^_^w nF© ©Si_^_^ynp]u¯jFey£]tjx«£,_avp_^e_^i$jAg$_^y°¥«£jtg$i$jFew$©¹npi]tjAgmonpe ©Sinp] pjFimjF7o_^w±[m§g$Z j jF]D]tjy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe²±[m§g$Z& y_^vpi_^_^w!nF©1©Si_^_^ynp] = Á®Y[Z_g$i$jFew$©¹npi]tjAgmonpe²,_lmoev g$Z_]¦7§gmo7§mokxjAgmonpenF©Lg$Z_ jF]D]tjDFjFimjAg$_^w h«Ug$Z_©SjFklg$npi(' 6 J 6 JRQ = = ® · Z7m§owgÕg$Z_^npi_lgmokxjA§§«5g$Z_moe7m§gmjA§mowjAgmonpenF©7g$Z_ ]D_xjFewVjFey5FjFimjFek^_^wLmow1enFgÕmo]D,npigjFehgxu GH Q. 6. . . . . . . . . . i$jFklgmokxjA§§«hu"©Snpik^npehh_^ivp_^ek^_Nmoej¨i_xjFw$npeGjF7o_DjF]Dnp¦e¥g5nF© k^np]D¦7gjAgmonpe Ýnpi jAgjA§Vm§©g$Z_ inpGjF7m§§m§g¾«¨nF©¯w$np]D_k^npe Gvp¦i$jAgmonpew!mowÈinp¦ey_^y¨g$nÆ^_^ina¥«Dg$Z_"_ !"_^klg$w
(99) nF© Ge7m§g$_ i_^klmow$monpe Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(100) p.
(101) !" $#
(102) #%&. ^k np]D¦7g$_^iNjFim§g$Z]D_lgmok Xum§gmowae_^k^_^w$w>jFi«°g$nqmoe7m§gjA§mow$_/g$Z_¨]D_xjFewDjFey<FjFimjFek^_^wklonpw$_/g$n g$Z_lmoi g$i¦_FjAo¦_^wx®YÕi_xjAgmoevUg$Z_yGjAgj5|¦wgjFw j jF¦wwmjFeq]NmÇ¿7g$¦i_pu¯jFey jFeGjA§«7wmoev/g$Z7mow ]NmÇ¿7g$¦i_g$n/y_lg$_^i]Nmoe_Ng$Z_NGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iwnF© g$Z_Nk^np]D,npe_^ehg$w mowj/y7m tk^¦7§g5inp7o_^]u1jFey g$Z_ynp]tjAmoe²±Z_^i_klonpw_l§«Uw$GjFk^_^y²k^np]D,npe_^ehg$w kxjFe_ y7m !"_^i_^ehgmjAg$_^y´mow[i_^w$g$imoklg$_^y Á® cfe Ã` ÕjN]D_lg$ZnOy²±¤jFwinp,npw$_^y²±Z7mok>Z´¦w$_^w[g$Z_k^npe¥g$_X¿Og$¦GjALmoe7©¹npi]tjAgmonpeqjxFjAm§jF7o_5moe´jFe mo]tjFvp_ g$nNinhjFy_^eg$Z_ ynp]tjAmoenF©¸jF7§mokxjF7m§§m§gs«hujFey²m§g!mow!g$Z7mow[]D_lg$ZnOy²±Z7mokZ²±¤_¦w$_ g$n np7gjAmoe´moe7m§gmjA1FjAo¦_^w©¹npi[g$Z_]D_xjFewjFeypjFimjFek^_^wx® ;. 4 :10 % 6. "!$#&%('*),+.-/10.!. . /;# 0 #& . !. 0-
(103) 0. . ~7jF]D7§moev£g$Z_tZ¥«O,_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iN_X¿jFklg§«mow5moe¥g$i$jFklgjF7o_p® Vnx±È_lh_^i^u¸m§gamowa,npw$wmo7o_Dg$n£_^wr gmo]tjAg$_tg$Z_tGjFigm§gmonpe°©S¦eklgmonpe°g$n´jw$¦!tklmo_^e¥gay_^vpi_^_tnF©[jFk^k^¦i$jFkl« g$nq]tjF¡p_Dm§g5npwwmo7o_ g$n¨wjF]D7o_5pjAo¦_^w©Snpi[g$Z_Zh«7_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i^®}w_X¿7jAmoe_^y£jF,nxh_pug$Z7mowmow enFgg$im§OmjAÕ©Snpi g$Z_mo]tjFvp_NwmoÆ^_^w ±È_DjFi_amoe¥g$_^i_^wg$_^y moe¯® cfey_^_^y£moe à Lg$Z_jF¦7g$Znpiw moew$g$_xjFy£wjF]D7o_©Sinp] g$Z_¨w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnnOy¯ukljAmo]Nmoev´g$ZGjAgg$Z_l«+k^np¦7oy(w$_^_¨en±¤jx«+g$n´]tjF¡p_¨w>jF]D7§moevq©Sinp] g$Z_,npwg$_^imonpi¤©¹npiÈg$Z_ GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw[k^np]D¦7gjAgmonpeGjA§§«²i_xjFwnpeGjF7o_p®È¢¤npewmoy_^i¤g$Z_ ]tjFivFmoeGjA y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpew©Snpi!g$Z_5Zh«7_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw®. L= . É V ¢ 698X=)= 6C< U B 6CA > < = DE!F. 576C< :. = . ¢Èo_xjFi§«¨m§g¤mow
(104) g$Z_ GjFigm§gmonpeU©¹¦eklgmonpe B 6C<>= ±Z7mokZ²kxjF¦w$_^w¤g$Z_ k^np]D¦7gjAgmonpey7m tk^¦7§gs«h® ·+_ en± w$Znx± Zn±ým§g[mow[npwwmo7o_g$n_^w$gmo]tjAg$_.B 6C<X= ±[m§g$Zw$¦!tklmo_^ehg jFk^k^¦i$jFkl«hujFeyUw¦!Nr klmo_^e¥g§«a_tklmo_^ehg§«g$n_^eGjF7o_¤g$Z_¤npw$g$_^imonpiLy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpeNnF©g$Z_¤GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^iw¸g$n ,_
(105) w>jF]D7o_^y ©Sinp]®¸·+_5ZGjxh_g$ZGjAg B 6C<>= ? É V¢ 698X=)= I 6C<U W DEF. ? B C6 <>= B 6 = . ?. I. D EF B 6 = . Q. 6)6C<. A M I # M . . DEF. É V ¢ 698X=)= B 6 =L576 = =;U . Q. É V¢ 698X=)= =;U W M Q V ¢ 698 =)= 6)6C< = U É. 6)6C<. DEF. . mo_puAg$ZGjAgVm§gLmowV,npw$wmo7o_ g$n¦w$_ÈwjF]D7o_^w 8 yi$jx±e©¹inp] g$Z_Èy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe 57698;: = g$n _^w$gmo]tjAg$_ g$Z_Ni$jAgmonnF© g$Z_NGjFigm§gmonpe©S¦eklgmonpew©Snpig¾±Èn´y7m!"_^i_^ehgpjAo¦_^wnF© g$Z_NGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i^®c¾© ±¤_ ¦w_jN£_lg$inpnF§mowr V jFwgmoevpwjAovpnpim§g$Z] g$nNwjF]D7o_ < u7¦wmoevDjinpnpw>jA"y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe²g$ZGjAg mowa¦e7m§©¹npi]N§«°y7mowg$imo¦7g$_^y<moe(j²w$]tjA§
(106) i$jFevp_/_lm§g$Z_^iawmoy_DnF©!g$Z_tk^¦ii_^e¥gapjAo¦_puÕg$Z_^e+g$Z_ àLà óEDGFHIKJ.
(107) 2. &G & 1
(108) &B
(109) &! 9 G%. jFk^k^_^7gjFek^_inpGjF7m§§m§gs«©Snpi!g$Z_5e_l±ýpjAo¦_pu < 7u mow.
(110) A
(111) B B. 6C< <>=X?. . Q C6 <X=. <>= É V ¢ 698(=)= ) 6 C 6 < 6C< = DEF. [Y Z_²i$jAgmon B 6C< = B 6C<X= kxjFeR,_U_^wgmo]tjAg$_^yRmoe»j£wmo]N m§jFiN]tjFee_^iD¦wmoevwjF]D7o_^wNyi$j^±e ©Sinp]ºg$Z_Uy7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpeRy_"Ge_^y»¥«(g$Z_UGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i ® ·½ZGjAgmo wmo]D,npigjFehgDmowg$ZGjAgg$Z_ y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpew[nxh_^ijF´w$!¦ tklmo_^e¥g§«¨g$ZGjAg[g$Z_ wjF]D7o_^w¤©Sinp] 5 698;: = ZGjxh_5jFi_^klmjF7o_inAr GjF7m§§m§g¾«D¦ey_^i¸g$Z_nFg$Z_^i¸gs±¤nay7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewx®¸µGinp] Gvp¦i_^w[jFey 2 ±È_kxjFeDw_^_!g$ZGjAgm§©±¤_ ]tjF¡p_g$Z_inpnpw_^y k>ZGjFevp_Nw$]tjA§V_^enp¦vpZ¯u"g$ZGjAg g$Z7mow±[m§§ jA§±¤jx«Ow,_,npw$wmo7o_p®cfey_^_^y¯u g$Z_^i_ mowjNi$jFevp_anF©ÕpjAo¦_^w[nF© < ±Z_^i_ jFivp_k>ZGjFevp_^wkxjFe,_]tjFy_pu7±Z_^i_g$Z_ pjFimjFek^_ nF©Vg$Z_e¥¦]_^i nF©VZnp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wkl§m O¦_^wmow!jFivp_p® c¾e Ã7u¸
(112) jUw§movpZhg§«°y7m !"_^i_^ehgajFinhjFk>Z+±¤jFw5gjF¡p_^e¯®¬!_^kxjF¦w$_DnF©Èg$Z_Dw$]tjA§ wmoÆ^_^wnF© g$Z_mo]tjFvp_^wÈk^npew$moy_^i_^y¯um§g
(113) ±¤jFw¤npw$w$mo7o_g$nay"_ Ge_j5w$]tjA§,w$_lg
(114) nF©"pjAo¦_nF© < ±Z7mok>Z¯uO±Z_^e w>jF]D7o_^y¯u¸±Ènp¦7oy»jFy_ ¦GjAg$_l§«(k^nh_^ig$Z_¨_^ehgmoi_²i$jFevp_UnF© < nF©[moe¥g$_^i_^wgx® Y[Z_^w$_/w>jF]D7o_^w ±¤_^i_!g$Z_^eN¦w$_^yg$nk^npew$g$i¦klg
(115) j]NmÇ¿7g$¦i_[y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpeN±Z7mokZDZGjFyDjFi_^klmjF7o_inpGjF7m§§m§g¾« _lh_^i«O±Z_^i_ à Á®Y[Z7mow y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpeq±!jFwg$Z_^e ¦w$_^y´±Z_^e wjF]D7§moev < ®µGinp] Gvp¦i_ 2 m§g mow[klo_xjFi!g$ZGjAg©¹npi[jFe²mo]tjFvp_5nF©¸jFi_^klmjF7o_5wmoÆ^_ g$Z_e¥¦]_^inF©LpjAo¦_^w[nF© < ±Z7mok>Z±Ènp¦7oy ZGjxh_²g$n£,_²k^npewmoy_^i_^yÀ,_^k^np]D_^wDinpZ7mo7m§gm§h_l§«<jFivp_p®+} ow$nu±Z_^e»¦wmoev g$Z_²]NmÇ¿7g$¦i_ y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe¯uÕg$Z_DpjFwg5]tjM|npim§gs«°nF©¤g$Z_twjF]D7o_^w±[m§§
(116) ZGjxh_/j²inpGjF7m§§m§g¾«°h_^i«klonpw_Dg$n Æ^_^inD¦ey_^i!g$Z_jFklg$¦GjA¯FjAo¦_nF© < k^npewmoy_^i_^y¯®
(117) c¾g!mow!©¹npi!g$Z_^w_i_xjFwnpew[g$ZGjAg©SnpiÈg$Z_w$moÆ^_^w nF©!mo]tjFvp_^w±È_UjFi_¨k^npek^_^ie_^y<±[m§g$Z<Z_^i_¨g$ZGjAga±È_/ZGj^h_²jFy7hnkxjAg$_^y<g$Z_twmo]D7o_^iw$k>Z_^]D_ np¦7g§moe_^yUjFnh_p®Y[Z7mowÈwkZ_^]D_kxjFeUjAow$na,_[mo]D7o_^]D_^e¥g$_^y²jFyGjF7gm§h_l§«ÅNm§©"±È_ynenFgÈZGjxh_ w>jF]D7o_^w!©¹inp]Ñjy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpeqjFy_ O¦GjAg$_l§«Uklonpw_ g$ng$Z_ pjAo¦_^w[nF© < ¦ey_^i[k^npewmoy_^i$jAgmonpe¯u ±¤_5kxjFe´vp_^e_^i$jAg$_g$Z_^w_5wjF]D7o_^wnpeOrÁ§moe _ ÁjFey²g$Z_^e´wg$npi_g$Z_^]Ñ©Snpi[i_Xrs¦w$_ X®. . ;. "!$#&%('*),+.-/1032.
(118) . 6 0 1:14 %*'. 0 %*'(/,4 4;:. !¬ _^kxjF¦w$_nF©g$Z_y7m tk^¦7§gmo_^wy_^w$k^imo_^yjF,nxh_±Z_^e£w>jF]D7§moev/©Sinp] g$Z_y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe ©Snpi g$Z_ Zh«7_^iGjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i¤¦wmoevqnpe¥g$_¢!jFiona_^w$gmo]tjAg$_^wÈnF©"g$Z_GjFigm§gmonpe/©S¦eklgmonpe¯u¥g$Z_w_^¦Or ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOnOy´±¤jFw moehg$inOy¦k^_^yjFw jDwmo]D7o_jFin^¿7mo]tjAgmonpe Á®¤Y[Z_w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOnyqmow k^npew$g$i¦klg$_^yqjFw[g$Z_5inOy¦klgnF©Vg$Z_5k^npey7m§gmonpeGjALy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewjAg_xjFkZq7mÇ¿7_lÁug$ZGjAgmow. L=>? J5769P J : P
(119) <>= 5 C6C<;:. ±Z7mok>Zmowwmo]D7o_5g$ntk^np]D¦7g$_p® c¾eg$Z_!_X¿7,_^imo]D_^ehg$wuh±È_[¦w_^yg$Z_´r V jAovpnpim§g$Z]u¥±[m§g$ZtjinpnpwjAG¦e7m§©Snpi]N§«y7mow$g$imÇr ¦7g$_^y²moejw$]tjA§¯i$jFevp__lm§g$Z_^i[wmoy_ nF©Õg$Z_k^¦ii_^e¥g[FjAo¦_p®
(120) Y[Z7mow!o_xjFyw!g$ng$Z_5jFk^k^_^7gjFek^_. Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(121) `.
(122) !" $#
(123) #%&. µVmovp¦i_13
(124) ~O_^klgmonpeq©¹inp] jt~O{ÈY mo]tjFvp_ inpGjF7m§§m§g¾«©¹npi!g$Z_ae_l±ýFjAo¦_5,_lmoevtwmo]D7§« 6 A
(125) 5 6C< e_l± . ,ý . '. #0V>a,$#. 6C< nFoy. =%5. =)=. µVmovp¦i_3w$Zn±wDj´w$_^klgmonpe<©¹inp] j£~O{¤Y¶mo]tjFvp_U±Z7mokZ<±È_/±[mow$Z<g$nqw$_^vp]D_^e¥gNmoehg$n h_ kljFww$_^wx®¸µVmovp¦i_aw$Znx±w[g$Z__lhnFo¦7gmonpeqnF© < ±Z_^ewjF]D7o_^y´©¹inp] g$Z_w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOny¯u jFe, y Gvp¦i_´´wZnx±wg$Z_/_lhnFo¦7gmonpe»nF© < ±Z_^e»wjF]D7o_^yR¦wmoev _^wgmo]tjAg$_^wDnF©[g$Z_/i$jAgmonpw nF©g$Z_UGjFigm§gmonpe ©¹¦eklgmonpewx®(Y[Z__lhnFo¦7gmonpeÀnF©g$Z_]D_xjFewtjFeyRFjFimjFek^_^wDnF© g$Z_UkljFww k^npey7m§gmonpeGjA!y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpewmow5enFgwZnx±e¯®UY[Z_tpjFimjAgmonpe+moe < mowa]a¦k>Z<w]tjA§o_^i©¹npi5g$Z_ ÂéS¦7§§«£¬[jx«h_^wmjFe¯Ä¯kxjFw$_puÕjFey°jAow$n²g$Z_Nw$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOny(wmovpe7m GkxjFehg§«nxh_^i5_^w$gmo]tjAg$_^w g$Z_ GjFi$jF]D_lg$_^i^ÄÃwNpjAo¦_NÅ°©Sinp] Gvp¦i_ =´±¤_/kxjFeRw$_^_tg$ZGjAgDjqFjAo¦_/nF© < ? k^npii_^w$npeyw g$n²j/imonpi ±Z7mok>Z mow jAo]Dnpw$gk^np]D7o_lg$_l§« ¦e7m§©¹npi]® Y[Z7mow yn_^w enFg k^npii_^w$A ,Anpey£±¤_l§¸±[m§g$Z g$Z_¨mo]tjFvp_p®qY[Z_¨FjAo¦_^wnF© < w>jF]D7o_^y(©Sinp]ªg$Z_¨g$i¦_¨§mo¡p_l§moZnOnyRjFi_/k^_^e¥g$_^i_^yÀjFinp¦ey < ?
(126)
(127) ®<Y[Z7mowNmowNjq§m§ggo_jFnh_Ug$Z_Uk^im§gmokxjA[pjAo¦_pu jFeyR©¹inp] Gvp¦i_ =£moey7mokxjAg$_^w¨j ]Dnpi_²i_xjFw$npeGjF7o_²]DnOy_l§§mowjAgmonpe¯u moeRg$ZGjAgNg$Z_Ue¥¦]a,_^iDnF©Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wtkl§m O¦_^wNmoe<g$Z_ w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe mowth_^i« klonpw$_g$n(g$Z_qe¦]a,_^i/nF©Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦w²kl§m ¦_^w¨mo]D7§mo_^y ¥«»g$Z_ imonpi^® Y[Z_aw$_^vp]D_^e¥gjAgmonpe i_^w¦7§g$wmoe Gvp¦i_^w/jFey£¨jFi_ah_^i«´wmo]Nm§jFi^u.Zn±È_lh_^i Sg$Z_^w$_jFi_ £{
(128) _^w$gmo]tjAg$_^w!©¹inp] p p m§g$_^i$jAgmonpewjA©:g$_^i!y7mow$vhjFiy7moev 2 3F m§g$_^i$jAgmonpe%w X® Y[Z7mow!mow!,_^kxjF¦w$_ nF©Õg$Z_Z7movpZ O¦GjA§m§gs«UnF©1g$Z_ yGjAgjaÅNg$Z_mo]tjFvp_ mo e Gvp¦i_ 3mow!i_ljAgm§h_l§«²enFmow$_©¹i_^_ jFeyUg$Z_ àLà óEDGFHIKJ.
(129) =. &G & 1
(130) &B
(131) &! 9 G%. 1.16 1.14 1.12 1.1. beta. 1.08 1.06 1.04 1.02 1 0.98 0. 100. 200. µVmovp¦i_a Y[Z_a_lhnFo¦7gmonpe´nF©. 300. 400. 500 600 iteration. 700. 500 600 iteration. 700. 800. 900. 1000. ±Z_^e´wjF]D7o_^y©Sinp] g$Z_5w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOnOy¯® <. 0.64 0.635 0.63 0.625. beta. 0.62 0.615 0.61 0.605 0.6 0.595 0. 100. 200. 300. 400. 800. 900. 1000. µVmovp¦i_ Y[Z__lhnFo¦7gmonpe£nF© < ± Z_^e´wjF]D7o_^y´¦w$moevD_^wgmo]tjAg$_^wnF©(B. 6C<>=. ®. Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(132)
(133) !" $#
(134) #%&. µVmovp¦i_a Y[Z_5w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe i_^w$¦7§g¦wmoevDg$Z_w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOnOy. µVmovp¦i_a Y[Z_5w_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpeqi_^w¦7§g¦wmoevDg$Z_NÂéS¦7§§«U¬[jx«h_^wmjFe¯ÄjFinhjFk>Z. àLà óEDGFHIKJ. 3.
(135) . &G & 1
(136) &B
(137) &! 9 G%. kljFww$_^w
(138) jFi_[©Snpig$Z_]Dnpwg GjFig¤_xjFwm§§«Ny7mowgmoevp¦7mow$ZGjF7o_p® Y[Z_y7m!"_^i_^ek^_^wÈjFi_]tjAmoe7§«DjAg
(139) g$Z_ _^yvp_^w[nF©Lg$Z_i_^vFmonpewx® ¬!_^kxjF¦w$_g$Z_w$_^¦ynF§mo¡p_l§moZnOnynh_^iw$]DnOnFg$Z_^w!g$Z_ w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯u m§g²i_^w$¦7§g$w/moe Znp]Dnpvp_^e_^np¦wÆ^npe_^w®öY[Z_<Â鹦7§§« ¬!jx«h_^wmjFe¯Ä!w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe o_xjxh_^w]tjFeh« mownFjAg$_^y£7mÇ¿_lowjAgg$Z__^yvp_^wnF©g$Z_Æ^npe_^wx® Y[Z7mow mow,_^kxjF¦w$_pu.±[m§g$Z°jtFjAo¦_nF© < jFinp¦ey ¦ tklmo_^e¥g§«h®Y[Z7mow moey7mokxjAg$_^w
(140) g$ZGjAg
(141) u¥g$Z_{VnFgg$wÈ]DnOy_lGyn_^wÈenFg _^eGjA§mow_[mow$nFjAg$_^yt7mÇ¿_low
(142) w$! g$Z_{LnFgg$wÈ]Dny_lGmow
(143) enFgÈjFe¨jFy_ O¦GjAg$_imonpi^u¥±Z_^e¨np¦i imonpimoe7©Snpi]tjAgmonpetmowg$ZGjAg ±¤_ZGjxh_ ¦e7m§©Snpi] Æ^npe_^w
(144) jFeyDyn enFg±[mow$ZNg$nZGjxh_!mow$nFjAg$_^yD7mÇ¿7_low
(145) i_^]tjAmoe7moevmoeNg$Z_!w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe¯® 021. . #)" 1 . .µ npiÈwmo]¦7jAgmoevNg$Z_ {VnFgg$w[]DnOy_lg$Z_~±È_^eyw$_^eOrÁ·(jFev s~· ÈjAovpnpim§g$Z] ±¤jFw[y_lh_lonp,_^y¯u ±Z7mok>ZÀk^npehh_^ivp_^wDi$jF7moy7§«<g$n£g$Z_²_ O¦7m§§moimo¦]y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpeÀjFeyRg$Z_^eR]Dnh_^wti_ljAgm§h_l§« ©Si_^_l§«q±[m§g$Z7moeg$Z7mowy7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe¯®c¾g mow5jFe°_X¿jF]D7o_DnF©!jFe°jF¦O¿Om§§mjFi« FjFimjF7o_tjAovpnpim§g$Z]® Y[Z_5moy_xjN_^Z7moeyqjF¦O¿7m§§mjFi«²FjFimjF7o_a]D_lg$Znywmow!g$Z_©¹nF§on±[moev csg mow y_^wmoi_^yg$n²wmo]a¦7jAg$_tjUy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe 698X= ®a}¦O¿Om§§mjFi«£FjFimjF7o_^w jFi_moe¥g$iny¦Or k^_^y¯u"±[m§g$Zk^npey7m§gmonpeGjA y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe 6 : 8X= ®5Y[Z7mow vFm§h_^w5ja|nFmoe¥gy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe 698
(146) = ? 6 : 8X= 698 = u7±[m§g$Z²g$Z_y_^wmoi_^yq]tjFivFmoeGjAÕy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe©Snpi 8 nF© 698X= ®
(147) ~mo]¦7jAgmonpeqnF©Vg$Z7mow y7mow$g$imo¦7gmonpe¨mow¤vp_^e_^i$jA§§«¨,_^i©¹npi]D_^yUh«¨jA§g$_^ieGjAg$_l§«U¦yGjAgmoev jFey 8 Åg$Z_ moy_xj5,_lmoev g$ny"_ Ge_ 6 : 8X= w$¦k>Z¨g$ZGjAg!g$Z_¦yGjAg$_^w!kxjF¦w$_i$jF7moy²]NmÇ¿Omoev®Y[Z_ i_xjA§mowjAgmonpew!nF© 8 jFi_ g$Znpw_y_^wmoi_^y¯® µGnpig$Z_²~· jAovpnpim§g$Z] g$Z_²y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe 6 : 8X= mowy"_ Ge_^y»w$¦kZRg$ZGjAgg$Z _ J M jFi_ moey_^,_^ey_^ehgxu,jFeymow JM Q J M
(148) JM J M
(149) 3+ 5 6 : 8X= 6 < c P ? P = c
(150) . 6C<
(151) c P ? P = DEF DEF JM ±Z_^i _ M kxjFe< _¨k^npewmoy_^i_^y<jFwjk^npehgmoe¦np¦w²Âûnpey¯Ä¯pjFimjF7o_¨,_lgs±¤_^_^e(g$Z_/7mÇ¿7_low P J jFey P jFey´
(152) c mow[g$Z_moey7mokxjAg$npi©¹¦eklgmonpe¯®
(153) Y[Z7mowi_^w$¦7§g$wmoe Á 698;: = JL KM
(154) c
(155) J M 6C<
(156) c P J ? P M = DEF. ·½ZGjAg[yn_^w!g$Z7mow[k>ZnFmok^_5JnF©Ly7mow$M g$ imo¦7gmonpe´vFm§h_¦wq¢¤npew$moyJ _^imoev'M Giwg 576 JJ MM : 8X= u7©¹npi J M ±¤J _!]a¦wgZGM j^h_ upnpi¸_ O¦7m§FjAo_^e¥g§«hu P J ? P ®LM Y[Z¦w k^npewg$i$jAmoeAw 6 < c P ? P = D E F A wgjAg$_p®/¢¤npe¥h_^iw$_l§«huVm§© P jFey P jFi_Dmoe°g$Z_tA wjF]D_Dw$gjAg$_pu P jFey P g$nq_Nmoe°g$Z_¨wjF]D_t JM ±ZGjAgmow g$Z_ainpGjF7m§§m§gs« nF© <µGinp]&g$Z_ak^npey7m§gmonpeGjAy7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe moe _ ¦GjAgmonpe 3 A ±¤_5ZGj^h_5g$ZGjAg JM J M Q Q s+ 576 : P ? P =X? 6 <>= A A DEF JM ~moek^_£m§gUJ M mow/npe7§« mo]D,npigjFehg±Z_lg$Z_^ i mowUvpi_xjAg$_^i²npi¨o_^w$w/g$ZGjFe npe_£±¤_£]tjx« g$Z7moe¡ nF©!g$Z _ jFw57moeGjFi«+,npey°pjFimjF7o_^wx®UµGinp]_ O¦GjAgmonpeRUg$Z_/npey+FjFimjF7o_¨mowai_^w$_^e¥g Y[Z. à. Y9\.
(157)
(158) !" $#
(159) #%&. M. Q , _lgs±¤_^_^eDgs±¤n57mÇ¿_low¸moeNg$Z_[wjF]D_[wgjAg$_!±[m§g$ZDinpGjF7m§§m§gs« Q 6 <>= ®¸YÕnw>jF]D7o_ g$Z¥¦w moe¥QhnF§h_^wL7Q jFklmoev,npeywÕ,_lgs±È_^_^ee_lmovpZ¥,np¦imoev 7mÇ¿7_lowLnF©7g$A Z_
(160) DwEjFF ]D_ w$gjAg$_ ±[m§g$ZainpGjF7m§§m§g¾« 6 <>= jFey´np]Nm§ggmoevt,npeyw,_lgs±¤_^_^eqe_lmovpZnp¦imoev/7mÇ¿7_lownF©¸y7m !"_^imoevtwgjAg$_^wx® A DE!eF k^_²g$Z_npeywtjFi_UmoeÀ7jFk^_pu g$Z_k^npey7m§gmonpeGjA y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe 698;: = wj^«7wNg$ZGjAgtjA§ k^npe Gvp¦i$jAgmonpew!±Z_^i_,npey_^y/7mÇ¿_low¤jFi_ nF©¯g$Z_ w>jF]D_wgjAg$_jFi_ _ O¦GjA§§«tinpGjF7o_p® Y[Z¥¦w g$nR¦,yGjAg$_ 8 ±È_ ©Snpi]klo¦w$g$_^iwUnF©k^npee_^klg$_^yý7mÇ¿7_lowjFeyýjFw$wmovpe g$nRjA§ 7mÇ¿_lowUnF©ag$Z_ klo¦w$g$_^ig$Z_wjF]D_w$gjAg$_pu¥kZnpw_^et¦e7m§©¹npi]N§«N©Sinp] g$Z_jA§on±È_^yUwgjAg$_^wx®VY[Z7mow
(161) w$k>Z_^]D_ jA§onx±w ,nFg$_^ehgmjA§§«ÀjFivp_£klo¦wg$_^iw¨nF© 7mÇ¿_lowtg$n+k>ZGjFevp_£wgjAg$_£jAg¨_xjFkZ³m§g$_^i$jAgmonpe¯ujA§onx±[moev(g$Z_ jFi¡pnxk>ZGjAmoeg$nt_X¿7onpi_g$Z_y7mowg$imo¦7gmonpe´©Si_^_l§«h® µGnpi²w$]tjA§ < g$Z_£§moe¡wU±[m§§npe7§«³i$jFi_l§«³,_ 7jFk^_^y¯ui_^w$¦7§gmoevRmoe½j+jFivp_e¥¦]_^i nF©w$]tjA§ klo¦wg$_^iwx®ýcfe g$Z7mowUkxjFw$_£wgjFeyGjFiy³wmoevFo_Xrsw$m§g$_£¦,yGjAgmoevRjAovpnpim§g$Z]DwjFi_£]Dnpi_ _ tklmo_^e¥gx®ÀµGnpiNjFivp_ < ÁjFeyÀ_^w$,_^klmjA§§« < klonpw$_²g$n g$Z_k^im§gmokxjAFjAo¦_ Ýw_^_Uw_^klgmonpe 2 ) g$Z_Umo]Dinh_^yÀ]Dnp7m§§m§gs«»nF©g$Z_²~· jAovpnpim§g$Z]]Dnpi_Ug$ZGjFeRk^np]D,_^ewjAg$_^w©Snpig$Z_U_X¿7g$i$j k^np]D¦7gjAgmonpeqmoehhnF§h_^y¯® . ^ ), a0V ®.¬!_^wjFv®eqg$Z_wgjAgmow$gmokxjAVjFeGjA§«7wmow nF©y7moig¾«q7moklg$¦i_^wx®.7 &
(162) $#
(163) #% #% B
(164) & u =h!Á ` 2 3FÅO`p 2 uLpp7®. _^imoe jFey&V® $ §§monFggx® £ny_l§§moev<jFey w$_^vp]D_^ehgjAgmonpe nF©enFmow« jFeyÀg$_X¿7g$¦i_^y mo]tjFvp_^w¦wmoev mowi$jFeynp] G_loywx® K
(165) XuG û`pÅ 3
Documents relatifs
Mais elle y occupait une place modeste : il faudra la liberté et le goût de la transgression du roman en langue vulgaire pour que la situation soit renversée :
Les thèmes majeurs (tab.5.4) abordés par les îliens interrogés sont, pour la grande majorité, les mêmes sur toutes les îles : ils concernent les usages anciens
Chez l’Homme, les segments de gène V H ont été classés en sept familles (la famille 7 n’est pas représentée ici car aucun segment fonctionnel n’y a été décrit) qui ont
Le Négus consacra une énergie considérable en vue de gagner cet appui international, mais, malgré la force de son discours prononcé en juin 1936 devant ses pairs à la tribune de la
In this paper, we propose a novel approach based on the barycentric coordinates of automatically tracked 2D facial landmarks from videos to objectively evaluate the facial
Dirk Obbink (dir.), Doctrine and Doxography. Studies on Heraclitus and Pythagoras, Berlin / Boston, De Gruyter, 2013, p.. et le logos auquel les hommes devraient accorder
Les exorcismes ne sont pas publics, les sœurs noires elles-mêmes sont tenues le plus possible à l’écart, et c’est chaque fois Jeanne qui force les choses pour que, finalement,
Toute- fois, d’autres marqueurs des cellules POMC tels que NeuroD1 n’ont pas été induits dans cette expérience, ce qui indique que Tpit suffit in vivo pour provoquer la
