Multimodal Image Registration by Maximization of the Correlation Ratio
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Multimodal Image Registration by Maximization of the Correlation Ratio. Alexis Roche — Grégoire Malandain — Xavier Pennec — Nicholas Ayache. N° 3378 Août 98 THÈME 3. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !#"!$&%'( *)+ . ,-/.0213 4 !5&*. 687:9<;=?>@'ABDC/9FEHGJILKNMPOA=:KN9HQSRT7?RTU/V/RT=?UWG/XYR[Z\=:9FK]^9PU/U/9FB-GJ_=:BDC/A7?RT>'6`RaBDC/9 bdcfe gihjkmlonFpqh(rtsPupqvxw<ncfw<gigih*yzg s<u{cfvxnfhP| vxgis<}<hN~ |f[wPnfnf(h(~(|fu*w<nnsv~q~tsnau*h(~ rtwh p4 fvfsfrth 4sfTw<rqp4[h&rth(u{cfh(rtu{cfhnj<jFHkdw<fpPkas}<hN~ ( D f¡<<¢£^¤ h(r/pqcfh^¥xsP~p ¦ ¤ h4§<hNsr{~ |<nfh ¨ª© ¤ w¬«[h ¥y¯®as<~qh(F°+s<ffrtwPsPu{cfh(~/cs ¤ h4s¥x¥wD¨+h(#vxgiawPrp{snFpJ¥hNs~±vn g²f¥pqvxg#w[fs<¥ vxg s}<hrqh(}<v~ptrtspqvxw<n³|anfwp{s®f¥x§8ffhptw'pqchvxnu*rth(sP~vxnf} ~qhw<´Jvn[´µwPrqg spqvxw<n[y¯pqcfh(w<rth*ptvxu&~qvgivx¥xs<rqvp§0gihNs<~qfrqhN~ ¶^bdcfh vxr·¨v[h ~qu u h(~t~cs<~¥xh(Hptwptcfh frtw<}PrqhN~q~qv ¤ h²s<®snfw<n¸w<´+gihNs<~qfrqhN~¹~vxnf}L~ptsnafsr{¸vxg s}Phi~ptspqv~ptvxu(~ ºµgih(s<n»sn ¤ srtvxs<nu*h¬¼¶ ½·nPptv¥anfwD¨&|P~qu{cigih(sP~frth(~Jcs ¤ hdh(~t~qh nFpqvs¥x¥§®ah(h n ®sP~hN²wPn cfh rqv~ptvxu(~ ¶lon#pqcfv~JasTh rN|<¨+h4s<f[rth(~t~/ptcfh·[h pqh rtgivnasDpqvxw<n w<´s&nfh(¨¾gih(s<~qfrth4®sP~hN w<n0~pts<nfs<rt ~ptspqv~ptvxu(~J´µrtw<g¿sptcfh wPrqh pqvu s¥TTw<vxnPp+w´ ¤ vxh ¨&¶/ÀHh~qcfwD¨Ápqcsp+vpnspqfr{s¥x¥x§#¥xh(sPf~ ptw²sÂnfwD¨nu*w<nau*h fp±w´\rqwP®s®fvx¥xvÃp§²pqcfh(w<rt§<|PpqcfhiÄ{ÅDÆÆqÇ ÈÉDʯË:ÅD̸ÆqÉDʯË:ÅD¶/lon0wPfrfh rtv ¤ sDptvwPn³|F¨h·ptsÂPh·s<~±pqch·c§aw<pqcfhN~v~Jptcfh ´µfnaupqvxw<nas¥[h(ah(n[h(nu*h®Th*p¨+h h(n²ptcfhvxgis<}<hdvxnPpth n~qvpqvxh(~(¶/bdcvx~/gih(s<n~/ptcsDpJwPnfhdvg s}Phdvx~Ju w<n~qv[h rth(#s<~ s¹giw[[h ¥fw<´aptcfh w<pqcfh(r(¶/4¥pqcfwPf}<c~u{c'scF§Twptcfh(~qvx~±vx~±nfwp ¤ s<¥vfspqh4vxn'h ¤ h rt§²u vr{u*fg ~pts<nu*hP|<vph nas®f¥xh(~±~ ptwvnau*w<rtTw<r{sDpqhvxgif¥xvxu vÃpth ¥x§ s<nsfrtvwPrqv<~qgiwwpqcnfh(~t~giw[[h ¥¯¶\ÀÍhs<¥x~qw4[h giwPn~ptrtspqh frth ¥xvxg#vxns<rq§^rqhN~f¥pt~\w´[g¥Ãptvgiw[fs¥Prqvx}<vrth }<v~pqr{sDpqvxw<n¹vxn ¤ w<¥ ¤ vnf} ÎLs<}<nfh pqvu&h(~qw<nasnu h'º?ÎL·¼*|ÏwPg#[pqhNLb\wPg#wP}<r{sfc§ºzÏ+b4¼|as<nYwP~qvÃptrqwPnYJg#v~t~vxw<nLbw<giw<}Prts<fc§º:JJb4¼4vg s<}<h(~(¶ bdcfhN~h&rth(~qf¥pt~~qf}<}Ph(~pptcsDpptcfhu*wPrqrth ¥sDptvwPn'r{sDpqvxwifrtw ¤ v[hN~+s#}PwFw[0pqr{s<[h y¯w<ÐL®ah p¨h(h nLs<u(u*fr{s<u §'snrqwP®f~pqnfhN~q~(¶ ÑLÒFÓÔqÕ²Ö D×<¢ rqh(}<v~ptrtspqvxw<n³|g#hN[vu s¥+vxgis<}<hN~ |gf¥pqvxgiw[fs¥xvÃp§P|J~vxgiv¥srtvp§¸gih(sP~frth(~(|rts<n[w<g ¤ srtvxs<®f¥xh(~&}Ph w<gih pqrt§<| u w<rtrqh(¥xspqvxw<n0r{sDptvwa¶. dØ ÙaÚ4Û{ÜÞÝß[àÝÞáâ(ÜÞãqä å³æ çzè¬áqéã¯æê¬èNÜëÛNä ÜÞì¬í?ÜëÛNä îí ïð ÜÞáìñ(òFó Ûô Û{ì õ¹öoõ¯öáì¬í:á÷ÜÞã:õ¯í:öiÛ{òÚæÜÞã4ø¬áÚ4Û{í?ãùúúûNüçáí?Û{ê¬êæí:õ&øNá&í?áçzè¬áí:çzè¬áiáã:õ¹í:áã?õ?öçæìNý¬ø¬áì õ?ÜÞáÝ\þ:ò¬ã?ñ(òFó ÿiÝëÛ²øDÛtõ¯áø¬áã¯Û ê¬ò¬ÝÞÜÞçÛtõ?ÜÞæìFüÿ+ã¯Û*æÜÞí³çæò¬í?Û{ì õ/Û{æNõùúúûNä Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(6) ²*
(7) q 2
(8) 85 &%'( *
(9) Y H \
(10) 4*/*
(11)
(12). ¢ ·u*wPfrt~\[h(~u*vxn^fh rtnfve(rqhN~³snnf hN~ |¬[h±nw< ¤ h ¥x¥hN~³sfrqw[u{cfhN~f©wPrqvxh nFpq(h(~ ¤ w¬«[h ¥Ã°w<nFp\Th rtgivx~ vgiTw<rqptsnFpth(~ s ¤ snau* hN~h nYrth(u(s¥s}<h& vxgis<}<hN~gf¥pqvxgiw[fs¥xh(~(|fnfw<ptsgigih nFp·}PrPu*hi¥ (g#h(rq}Ph nu h[hgih(~qfrth(~c rtvÃpt h(~·[h¥s#pqcf(w<rtvh [h¹¥ vxn[´µw<rtg sDptvwPn³ ¶ \h fr+¥srt}<h4~qu u e(~+su*wPn[fvp ¥ s®asn[wPn frtw<}<rth(~t~qvô³[hN~±gih(~qfrth(~J´:sv~qs<nPpdsfTh ¥ fh(~+~p{sDpqv~pqv Ph(~ ~pts<nfsr{ÁºµgiwD§<h(nfnfh#h*p ¤ srtvxs<nu*h¬¼¶ a~ F! 0rqN~h(nPpN|\u*hN~&[h rtnfvxe rth(~¹w<nFp&*ptih(~t~h(nPptvh(¥¥xh gih(nPp&®sP~(h(~~qfr[h(~ch frtvx~y pt"v FfhN~ ¶¸Jnªnfw<a~f¥$s #(snFp²fs<n~fn u s<frqh ptcf wPrqv Ffh<|nfwP~frtw<TwP~qw<na~&vxu v+fh[ pqh rtgivnh rnfh'nfwP ¤ h(¥¥xh'gih(~qfrth0[h ~qvgivx¥xs<rqvpq©q~p{snFpts<rtF°&¶ %4w<a~+~qw<gigih(~+nspqfrth ¥x¥xh gih nFpsgih nfN'~ ²fnYu*wPnu*h([pdu ¥xsP~q~qv Ph¹[h¹¥sptcf wPrqvxh¹fh(~+frtw<®s<®fv¥xvpq(~(| ¥xh0Æq)É ($(fÅDÆ+Ê *PÇ Ä{ÅDÆÆ , ÈÉDʯË:ÅDÌa¶ - w<®[pth nFpqvxw<n[Hu*rtvÃpte rth&´:svps<fTh &¥ fnfh²cF§Twptcfe(~qh²[h#[ Th nafsnu h´µwPnuptvwPnfnfh ¥x¥xhh nFptrqh ¥xh(~^vnFpth n~qvÃpt(~[hN~·vxg s}<hN~ ¶&Ïh ¥s0~qv}Pnfv¦.h Ffh²¥ fnfh#[h(~¹vxgis<}<hN~4h(~p¹u w<n~qv[ rt hu w<gigihfnHgiwfe ¥xh²[h#¥ sfpqrth<+¶ /+vxh n F! fnfhipth ¥x¥hic§aw<pqcfeN~hinfh'~qw<vp&s<~ ¤ (rqv¦(h²h(nHptw<[pth u*vxrtu w<n~pts<nu*hP|h ¥x¥h nfwP~¹ah(rqgih p vxnu w<rtawPrqh(r^vxgif¥vu*vpqh(gih nFp fn0g#w[[e(¥h¹[h·u w<nFpqvxnfvÃpt²+É (aÆË:ÅÆË ¶Jw<fr±¦nfvxr(|Fnfw<a~Jfrt(~qh nFpqwPn~ nfwF~Jfrth givxh r{~ rt(~qf¥Ãp{sDp{~±[h^rqhNu s¥s}Phs ¤ h(ufh(~Jvxg s}Ph(~ s<rrqN~wPnsnau*h·g s<}<nf pqv Ph<|f~tu snnfw<}Prts<fcfvxh4h*pdpqwPgiw<}<r{scfvh¹s<r+(givx~t~vxw<n8[h&TwP~qvÃptw<n³¶±Ïh(~drt(~qf¥ptspt~d~}<}<e(rqh(nFp Ffh ¥xh&rts<fTw<rqpd[hu w<rtrq(¥xspqvxw<nh(~pdn8®Tw<nLu w<gifrtw<givx~+h(nPptrqh¥s#frqNu*v~vxw<n8h*p4¥s#rqwP®f~pqhN~q~qh<¶ 0WÖ ( Ô 2¡ 1
(13) Y¢ rqhNu s¥s}Ph<|[vxg s}<hN~dgi([vu s<¥hN~ |fvxg s}Ph(~dg¥Ãptvgiw[fs¥xh(~(|fgih(~qfrth(~4fh~vxgiv¥srtvÃpt<|f}P wPg# pqrtvh&[hN~ ¤ srtvs®f¥xh(~ s<¥NsDpqwPvrth(~(|rts<fTw<rqpd[hu w<rtrq(¥xspqvxw<n³¶.
(14) ^Ç <Ë Ê?ÆtÉDʯË:ÅDÌ . ¸É PË #Ë (ÉÊ?Ë:ÅÌ Å &Ê Ç ÅÆÆqÇ ÈÉDʯË:ÅDÌ ·ÉÊ?Ë:Å. .
(15) . . . . j. . 13 4 ( Ö × ¡ Ö ¶ £^¤ h r ¤ vh(¨ ¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ ¶ ÎL[pqs<¥³vxn[´µw<rtg sDpqvxw<n8¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ .
(16) . . . . . Ò i fiD × Ö f [ µ 1 Ò . "#. !. %$. '&. . (. ). × Ö f [ µ f 1 Ò ÒFÖ Ò Ó j¶ ~sPu*hH¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j¶ $ «Th(u*ptspqvxw<n3¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j¶ j ÏwPrqrth ¥sDptvwPn0u*wh u vh(nFp ¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j¶ ÏwPn[vpqvxw<ns<¥h*«[Th(up{sDptvwPn ¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j¶ $bwp{s¥ ¤ srtvsnu h·ptcfh wPrqh(g ¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j¶ ÏwPrqrth ¥sDptvwPn'r{sDpqvxw ¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j. *. +&. . (. ,$. -. /.10. 32.
(17) 4. 32. 5 . !. . 1 a¶ a¶ a¶ j a¶ . Ö lonvÃptvxs<¥v (spqvxw<n ¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ ÏwPgif[ptspqvxw<n8w´pqcfh&u w<rtrqh(¥xspqvxw<n0r{sDptvw ¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ ÎsD«[vgiv (spqvxw<n~tu{cfh(g#h¹¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ /s<rts<g#h pqh(rqv (spqvxw<n ¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶. 7$. 6. ( 8. 96. ;:. . . ;:. . ;:. . ÒÖ Ò :¡< 1¡ Ö [ µ Ö Õ Ö Ò Ò f ³ Ò f¶ ÀÍww[f~u*rtvÃpth rtvwPn-¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ f¶ ÎL[pqs<¥³vxn[´µw<rtg sDpqvxw<n8¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ f¶ j$ÀÍh vx}<cFpth(nfh vx}<c®Tw<r¥xvÂPh ¥xvcfww[ ¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ f¶ j¶ ÀÍh vx}<cFpth(8nfh vx}<c®Tw<rsfrqw¬«[vxg sDpqwPr¾¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ f¶ j¶ \vÂPh ¥xvcwFw[ ¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ 8. #<. 3. =. (. . >8. >8. ?. . . ! . . . Ó Ò µ¡ Ò Ò Ò ( ¶ «Th rtvxg#h(nFp ¶&&¶ ¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ < ¶ $ «Th rtvxg#h(nFp^ ¶&&¶ ¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ j @. 8. A. !. 3. . CB =. (. . "D. . !. Ò 1 [ Ó Ò 1 ( [¶ u(u*fr{s<u §'~pt[§¿¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ [¶ $4w<®f~pqnh(~t~~pt[§¾¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ [¶ j [§FnFptcfh(~qvx~!¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ P 7 . E#F. "%6. 5. . G!. H. ). Ö ¡21 \ Ö I. . åå5ì. . {û. GK%LMLN. . *J". .
(18) . ·ÅNÄ Ç ¸ÉDÈÉÌ *<ÉË Ì <É<Ä Ç4Ç*ÌaÌTÇ{Ä . 0 f ¶ ¶ ¶ j ¶ ¶. 3. . I. . \ 1 Ò ( [ Ö = . . . . Ò f µ¡P 1d× Ò Ö Ö
(19) ¬ × Ö f [ µ f 1 Ò ÎLh(s<~qfr{s®f¥xh~sPu*h»¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ ÎLh(s<~qfr{s®f¥xh¹gis<ffvxnf}¿¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ ÎLh(s<~qfrth ¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ ·sn[wPg ¤ srtvxs<®f¥xh5¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶ lonFpth }<r{sDptvwPn'´µwPrqg²f¥xsH¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¹¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶&¶¶&¶¶&¶¹¶&¶¶. 8. 3. 3. : f Ò × Ò ( f Ö . 3. 3. . . . &. (. .10. *J". j<j <j j <j j <j j <j j. * 6. . * 6. . å à.
(20) ^Ç <Ë Ê?ÆtÉDʯË:ÅDÌ . ¸É PË #Ë (ÉÊ?Ë:ÅÌ Å &Ê Ç ÅÆÆqÇ ÈÉDʯË:ÅDÌ ·ÉÊ?Ë:Å. .
(21) . . . . .
(22) Y ±* ² .
(23) . h(}<v~ptrtspqvxw<nÍvx~s®as<~qvxu#p{s<~qÂvn vxg s}<h rqw[u*hN~q~qvxnf}¶¹v ¤ h nÍp¨+wYvg s}Ph(~rth frth(~qh nFptvnf}pqch É Ç'wPr&h ¤ h(n ÉÌTÉÈÅ FÅ wP®[h(u*pt~(|JvÃp u*wPn~qvx~pt~vn }<h wPgih*pqrtvu s¥x¥x§¸ptrts<n~´µwPrqgivxnf}wPnfh0vxg s}<hͺ ptcfhdÅNÉDÊ¯Ë Ì »vg s}PhN¼&pqwptcfh8wpqch rLº ptcfhHÆtÇ *Ç ÆqÇ ÌTÄ{Ç vxg s}<h¬¼¹~wpqcsp ¤ w¬«[h ¥~·rth rqhN~h(nPptvn}'pqch'~qs<g#h#fc§[~vu s<¥ ~ptrqu*pqfrth#gis¬§L®Th'~qfah(rqvxgiawF~hN¶lonHpqch²¦ah ¥Hw<´±gih([vu s<¥ vxg s}<vxnf}a|rth }Pvx~pqr{sDptvwPn¸v~~qh*´µf¥±´µw<r&ptcfh0~pqf§Hw<´fvx~qh(sP~hN~ |[vxs<}<nfwF~v~(|\h ¤ s<¥spqvxw<n w´+pqrth(spqgih nFph 'u s<u §<|sn h ¤ h n u w<gif[pth rqyzsP~q~qvx~pqhN0~qfrt}<h rt§<¶ ÎYwF~pw<´\pqch&h*«[vx~pqvxnf}irth }<v~pqr{sDpqvxw<n0pqhNu{cfnfv Ph(~s<[rqhN~q~ptcfh&vxfh(s¥³u(s<~qh^¨ch rth^ptcfh&vxgis<}<hN~srth¹~qvgivx¥xs<rvn8vxnPpth n~qvp§ f-pqw sn fnfÂnfwD¨nª}Ph w<gih pqrtvxu(s¥Jptrts<n~´µw<rtgispqvxw<n³¶ wPg#hw´4ptcfh g ptsÂPh0vxnFpqwHsPu u w<fnFp²h(¥xsP~ptvxu[h*´µwPrqg spqvxw<n~²w´4ptcfh ptvx~t~h( ~ [| ¯ ¶ 4wD¨+h ¤ h(r(| vxnÁgis<n§ªu s<~qh(~(| ¨+h8s<rqh´:s<u h(ª¨vpqcÁcfvx}<cf¥x§ª[v~q~qvxg#vx¥srivg s<}<h(~²ptcsDpig sÂ<hN~²pqcfhLs®Tw ¤ h gih*ptcfw[f~vxnfh 'u vh(nPp4vxnYfr{s<uptvxu h<¶/ÀÍhu sn8v[h nFpqv´µ§'´µwPfr4[vÐTh(rqh(nFp·~wPfrtu h(~+w´/[v~q~qvgivx¥xs<rqvp§'vxnYg#hN[vu s¥vxg s}Ph(~ (. . C. 9. .
(24) 4. H. . . 4. ÇYÆqÇ (aÆtÇ Ç ÌÊoÉDʯË:ÅDÌ Å Ë Ì *ÅÆ iÉÊ?Ë:ÅÌ#" bdcfh8vxnPpth n~qvp§ª~h p²ptcsDpirqh(frth(~qh nFpt~#sLptvx~t~h8[h(ah(nf~iwPnªpqchvxg s}<vxnf} giws¥xvÃp§P¶%$fwPrh*«fsgif¥xh<|®awPnfh(~gis¬§ÍsfTh(s<r&¨vÃptc»¥wD¨ vnFpth n~qvÃptvhN~vxnªÎL'&ib ¨+h vx}<cFpqhN¸vxg s}Ph(~&¨cfvx¥xhipqcfh(§ u*wPrqrth(~qawPn ptwicfv}PcYvnFpqh(n~qvÃp§ ¤ s<¥fhN~dvn¸Ï+)b (vxg s}<hN~ ¶ ! Ç#ÌTÅ+Ì *oÆqÇ *,[Ì *<ÉÌTÄ 8Å Ë Ì *ÅÆ iÉÊ?Ë:Å#Ì "log s<}<h(~4w´±[vÐTh(rqh(nFp^giw[fs¥xvÃptvhN~4frtw ¤ vxfhu*wPg#¥h(g#h(nFptsrt§0vxn[´µwPrqg sDptvwPn³¶ $fwPrh*«fsgif¥xh<|fs<nsDptw<givxu(s¥vxn[´µw<rtg sDptvwPnv~s ¤ svx¥xs<®f¥hvxnÎLSvg s}Ph(~(|¨cfv¥xh´µfnu*pqvxw<ns<¥³vxn[´µw<rtg sDpqvxw<n8v~4s ¤ svx¥xs<®f¥h vnLJ±)b -&w<r [J+Ï+/b .vg s<}<h(~(¶ ! Ç Ç{É 0[ÆqÇ iÇ ÌÊdÌÅDË Ç 1²ptcfh#nfw<n[yzrth frtw[[u*vx®f¥xhs<rpw´ ptcfhivg s}Pvn}'frtwu h(~t~ ¶lzpvgif¥xvxh(~[v~ptw<rqpqvxw<n~^w´Jptcfh ~vx}<nas¥fsnaivx~ nwp±nfhNu*hN~q~tsrtv¥x§s<[vÃptv ¤ h<2| s~t~vsn\|<w<rJ~ptspqvxw<ns<rq§P3¶ $w<rJh «[s<gif¥hP|<®fvs<~Jvx~/´µrth Ffh(nFp±vn'ÎL vxg s}Ph(~ [fhLptw pqcfh¸gis<}<nfh pqvu8¦h ¥Ávncfw<giw<}Ph nfh(vÃptvhN~ ¶S½4¥pqr{s<~qw<fnaSº?½ f¼ vg s}Ph(~'s<rqhYÂnfwD¨nÁpqw»®Th¸u w<rtrqffpqh(Á¨vpqc ~Th(u{Â¥xh<|fs#cfvx}<cf¥x§ ptvx~t~h*yo[h Th nfh nFp(|fnw<v~hP¶ 54 ÄtÄ 6È Ë:ÅD7Ì "·bdcvx~^vx~¹s'u ¥xsP~q~qvxu(s¥\~qvpqspqvxw<n¨cfvu{cu s<nLw[u u*r^[fhpqw0pqcfh²}<rtwD¨dpqcYw´±siptfgiw<rN|ptcfh²fvÃÐ~qvwPnw´±s u*wPnPptrtsP~ps}Ph nFp(|[wPr~vxgif¥§¨cfh nYs<rp{~dw´pqcfhptvx~t~h(~srthg s<~qÂ<h(³¶ !. . M. . 3. M. . .
(25) . . 3. M. H. . >.
(26) . . H. 9. ¤ hL§<hNsr{~ |+~wPg#hYh ¤ v[h(nu*hLcsP~ ®Th h n ~qcfwD¨n pqcsp~vxgiv¥srtvp§ªgih(s<~qfrth*yz®s<~qh( sfrqwFs<u{cfhN~²~qcfw<¥x frtw ¤ vxfh+~tsDptvx~´:s<u*pqw<rt§rqhN~¥Ãp{~¨ch n²pqcfhdvxgis<}<hN~rqhN~h(nPp u*wPn~qvx[h(rts<®f¥xh[v~q~qvxg#vx¥srtvÃptvhN~ ¶bdcfh vxr/}<h nh r{s¥Ffrqvxnu vf¥xhu*wPn~v~pt~ w<´ FsnFpqv´µ§vn}ptcfh Fs<¥vp§ w´\s²rth }<v~pqr{sDpqvxw<n ¨vpqc8rth(~qahNup±ptwptcfh&~p{sDptvx~pqvu s<¥©q~vxgiv¥srtvp§<°4w<´³pqcfhvxg s}<hN~ Fw ¤ h(rq¥sfvn} ¤ w¬«h(¥x~(¶³lzp\vxn ¤ wP¥ ¤ h(~Tpqch±[h(~qvx}<nw´fs Ë ²Ë ÈxÉDÆË Ê Ç{É 0[ÆqÇJpqcsp\vx~s<~t~g#hN^pqw4®ThJg sD«[vxgis<¥¨cfh(npqcfhJvxg s}Ph(~³s<rqhJu w<rtrqhNupq¥x§ s<¥vx}<nfhN¶^bdch(~qhsfrqwFs<u{cfhN~4srth&pqc~^w´ pth nvxgif¥xh gih nFpqhNL~qvn}snLwP[pqvxgiv NsDptvwPn¸~qu{ch gih<¶ £ ptcfh r^vgif¥xh gih(nPp{sDptvwPn~ ~qhsi[§nsgivu s<¥frqw[u h(~t'~ ¯¶ ÎLs<n§~vxgiv¥srtvp§gih(sP~frth(~/cas ¤ hd®ah(h nifrtw<TwP~qh(#vxn²ptcfh4¥xvÃpth r{sDptfrqh&º?~h(8h ||P |Pj ´µw<r rth ¤ vxh ¨4~{¼¶JÏw<n~qv[h rtvn}^ptcfh h(¥h(g#h(nFptsrt§ifrtw<®f¥xh g w´\g sptu{cfvxnf}p¨+wv[h nFptvxu(s¥Tvg s}Ph(~(|<ptcfh^¦rt~pv[hNs¨ds<~ ptw²a~h¹s¥xh(s<~p+~ Fsrth(~u*rtvÃpth rtvwPn³¶ vgif¥xh u w<rtrqh(¥xspqvxw<n#g#hNs<~qfrth(~ ¨+h rthfrtw<TwP~qh(#vn0w<r{[h r ptwh*«pth n#ptcfvx~±gih*pqcw pqw~qvÃptsDptvwPn~J¨ch rthdpqcfh^vg s}PhvnFpth n~qvÃptvhN~±s<rqh 9: Û{÷ìNáõ?ÜÞç±å\áã?æìDÛ{ì¬çáä ;=< æÚê¬ò(õ¯á? ø >[æÚæ÷í?Û{ê¬è*ô*ä @=A æã?Ü õ¯í:æì&ÙaÚÜÞã?ã¯ÜÞæ ì >[æÚæ÷í?Û{ê¬è ô*ä B0C ÜÞì¬÷ÝÞá A è¬æ{õ?æEì DµÙÚÜÞã¯ã?ÜÞæì < æÚê¬òNõ?á' ø >[æÚæ÷í?Û{ê¬è*ô*ä $w<ripqch¥xsP~pi¦. . . >. :. 32. . H. åå5ì. {û. GK%LMLN.
(27) ·ÅNÄ Ç ¸ÉDÈÉÌ *<ÉË Ì <É<Ä Ç4Ç*ÌaÌTÇ{Ä !. . . . nfwY¥xw<nf}Ph r¹vxfh nFpqvu s<¥?|³®[p&¥vxnfh(s<rq¥x§u*wPrqrth ¥sDpth(¶²bdcfh(~qh#~qvxg#vx¥srtvÃp§Lgih(sP~rqhN~·cs ¤ h²®Th h(nHa~hN¸h «Fpth n~qv ¤ h ¥x§<|nwpts<®f¥x§Lvn gih(fvxu(s¥vg s}Pvn})¶ 4wD¨+h ¤ h rN|fpqch §8gis<Â<hs0~ptrqwPnf}'s<~t~g#fpqvxw<nLrth }Ps<rtfvnf}iptcfhrth ¥sDptvwPn~qcfv8ptcsDp¹h*«[vx~pt~·®ah p¨h(h nLptcfh vxg s}<hN~ ¶ bdcfh(§0}Ph nfh(rts<¥¥x§'[w s#}<ww[wP®8wPnf¥x§'vnYgiw<nw<giw[fs¥frtw<®f¥xh g ~(¶ ÎYwPrqh^rqhNu*h(nPpt¥§P|Pw<pqcfh(rgihNs<~qfrqhN~Jcs ¤ h·®Th h(n[h ¤ v~qh(iptw#sPu{cfvh ¤ h4rth }Pvx~pqr{sDptvwPn ¨cfh n0pqcfh¹vxgis<}<hN~±frth(~qh nFp+vgiTw<rqptsnFp [v~t~vxgiv¥srtvÃptvhN~ |¨cvxu{c v~ p§fvu s<¥¥x§ªptcfhHu(s<~qhLw´&gf¥pqvxgiw[fs¥¹vg s<}<h(~(¶ bdcfh¸ÀÍww~0u*rtvpqh rtvxw<n [|+ Efrqw ¤ v[h( s TwD¨h(r´µ¥as¥x}<wPrqvpqcgW´µw<rg sDptu{cvnf}²JJb vxg s}<hN~ ¨vpqcÎL¾vg s}Ph(~(|Ps<¥Ãptcfw<f}PcivÃp+nfh hNf~~qw<gihg sns<¥a~qh }Pg#h(nFptsDptvwPn#pqw ¨+w<rtÂYh 'u*vxh nFpq¥x§<¶²3rth(u h nFpq¥x§Lfrtw<TwP~qh(sPfs[p{sDptvwPn~qvnf}8rtw<®f~p^hN~ptvg spqw<r{~ E Jfrtw ¤ h(8ptcsDpptcfh#s<ffrtwPsPu{cu*w<¥x ¥xh(sP0ptw#´µf¥¥x§s<[pqwPg sDpqvu¹rqh(}<v~ptrtspqvxw<nw´ fJÏ+b snYÎLSvxgis<}<hN~ ¶ 5!. 4. . H. . .
(28) . Î fpqs<¥Jvnf´µw<rtgispqvxw<n f|\j[|³f| F| Jv~¹pqw[fs¬§Lfrtw<®s<®f¥x§YpqcfhigiwP~p&awPff¥sr&~vxgiv¥srtvp§Lg#hNs<~qfrth´µwPr¹g²f¥pqvxg#w[fs<¥ Y rth }Pvx~pqr{sDptvwPn³¶lzp&cs<~¹®Th h(n ~qu(u*h(~t~´µf¥¥x§sf¥vxh(¸pqwY~qh ¤ h(rts<¥giw[fs<¥vp§¸u*wPg®fvxnspqvxw<n~^vnau*¥x[vxnf}ÎL&|Ï+b|JJb|sn [±Ï+b¶ ¹v ¤ h n#p¨wvg s}Ph(~ s<n '|Fw<nfh·gis¬§#[h*¦anfhpqch vxr³w<vxnFpfrtw<®as®fvx¥vp§²fh n~qvÃp§´µfnu*pqvxw<n¸ºëw<vxnPp+T[´t¼| t| ®§~qvxg#¥h&nfwPrqg s<¥v (spqvxw<n0w<´ptcfh vxr^ 4yzcfv~ptw<}<r{sg º:wptcfh r4s<ffrtwPs<u{ch(~dsrthawF~q~qv®¥hP|f~h(hsfTh nfvëY^¼'¶ ³h*p ±sn J[h(nfwpth·ptcfh&u*w<rtrth(~qawPn[vxnf}g srt}<vxns¥Tfrtw<®s<®fvx¥vp§'[h na~vp§i´µfnu*pqvxw<n~&º:T´ ~{¼¶ÎL[pqs<¥vnf´µw<rtgispqvxw<n'®Th*p¨+h h(n s<n v~}Pv ¤ h n0®§ E . H.
(29) . ;:. . . "!$#%. '&. )(*%. )+,#%. -. .. /0 1!%)24365. "!$#%9,:';. "!$#%. 0. ( %)+<,#%<=. 78. db cfh g²[pqas¥±vxn[´µwPrqg sDptvwPnHgihNs<~qfrqh'u(snÍ®ahu*w<na~v[h rth( ¤ h(rq§H}<h(nfh r{s¥J~qvnau*h vpgis<Â<hN~ ¤ h(rq§L´µh(¨¿s<~t~fgi[ptvwPn~rth*y }Fsr{[vn}²ptcfh&rth ¥sDpqvxw<na~cfvxpqcsp4h*«[vx~pt~4®ah p¨h(h n8pqcfh&vxg s}Ph&vnFpqh(n~qvÃptvhN~º:~qh h Þ< \´µw<r4snYh «[u h ¥x¥h(nFp·[vx~tu*a~q~qvwPna¼¶ lzp¹[wh(~ nfw<p·s<~t~g#h¥xvnh(sr4u w<rtrqh(¥xspqvxw<n³|FnfwPrh ¤ h(n0´µnuptvwPns¥\u w<rtrqh(¥xspqvxw<n³|F®f[p4wPnf¥x§0~p{sDptvx~pqvu s<¥³[h Th nfh nu h<¶ %·h ¤ h(rptcfh ¥xh(~t~(|NwPnfh+w´vpt~/fvp´:s<¥¥~vx~ptw·ptrqhNsDp/vnFpqh(n~qvÃp§ ¤ s¥xfhN~vxn²s^ffrth ¥x§ ÉDÈëË ÊoÉDÊ¯Ë ¬Ç¨+s¬§P|D¨vÃptcfw<[p u*wPn~qvx[h(rqvxnf}¹sn§ nfw<pqvxw<n8w´/frtw¬«vxgivÃp§ vxn8pqcfhvxnFpqh na~vp§~qs<u h<¶/lonYs²rth(s<¥vg s<}<h<|wPnfh¹pqv~q~qfh&v~dnfh ¤ h rdrqh(frth(~qh nFpqhN'®§si~qvnf}P¥h¹vxnPpth n~qvp§ ¤ s¥xfh'®[pr{sDpqch r&®§ÍsLu h rqpts<vn vxnPpth r ¤ s¥¯¶bdc~(|nfhNsrt®§vnFpth n~qvÃptvhN~u*wPn ¤ h §HsL¥w<pw´ ([ÉÊ?Ë:ÉÈdvn[´µwPrqg spqvxw<n³|¨cfvxu{c»vp givx}<cFp&®ah rtvx~q§YpqwY®Th²´µwPrq}Pv ¤ vxnf}s<®awP[p(¶ $vx}<frth frth(~qh nFpt~&s8~q§FnFptcfh*ptvxui~qvÃptsDptvwPnHvxnH¨cvxu{cÍg[pts¥ vxn[´µwPrqg sDptvwPn¸v~ nfw<p4¨h(¥¥yos<fs<[pqhN¶ loni~wPgihdu(s<~qh(~(|Dw<nfhu(sn#rqhNs<~qw<ns<®f¥§g sÂPh+sPf[vpqvxw<ns<¥[c§FTwptcfh(~qh(~/s<®awP[p/pqcfhrth ¥sDptvwPn~cvpqcspJh*«[vx~pt~/®Th*p¨+h h(nptcfh vxg s}<hN~ ³pqcfh(nÍg²[pqas¥ vxn[´µw<rtg sDpqvxw<nHvx~n[h rqyou*w<na~ptrts<vnfhN¶ r{s<u*pqvu s<¥¥x§<|wPnfh²w<´ pqh(nÍwP®~qh r ¤ h(~·vÃp{~¹pqh(n[h nau*§ptwcasn[¥xh g sn§»¥xw[u s¥+g sD«[vxgis¶»lonªptcfvx~#s<ah(r(|±¨h8vn ¤ h(~pqvx}PsDpth'ptcfh8u(s<~qh0¨cfh(rqhYs =[ÌÄ*ʯË:ÅDÌÉDȹu*w<rtrth ¥sDpqvxw<nªu(snª®ThLs<~t~g#hN¶ ·wD¨h ¤ h rN|±givxnfvxgis<¥^sP~q~qfgi[pqvxw<na~'srthYgisP[hLrth }Ps<rtfvnf}HpqchnsDptfrthLw´¹pqcfhL´µnuptvwPn³¶Sbdch~vxgiv¥srtvÃp§-g#hNs<~qfrthL¨h frtw<TwP~qh±v~vncfh rtvÃpth(´µrqwPg frqwP®s®v¥xvÃp§ptcfh wPrq§&s<nv~ÂFnwD¨ns<~pqch&Ä{ÅÆÆqÇ*ÈxÉDʯË:ÅDÌ'ÆqÉÊ?Ë:Ŷ/ÀHh+¨v¥x¥f~qcfwD¨ pqcsp(|vxn²sPf[vpqvxw<n ptwsYrqh(¥xspqv ¤ hi}<h(nfh r{s¥xvÃp§P|pqch0u*wPrqrth ¥sDptvwPn¸r{sDpqvxw8pts<Â<h(~vxnFpqwsPu u*wPfnFp&frqw¬«[vxgivÃp§vxn pqch vnFpqh(n~qvÃp§Í~sPu*hP|\rth(~qf¥Ãptvn}Lvn rtw<®fa~ptnfh(~t~sDprth ¥sDpqv ¤ h(¥§ ¥xwD¨ rth(~qw<¥x[ptvwPn8s<n|pqc~(|sppqr{s<u*pqv ¤ hu*wPg#[pqvxnf}ipqvxgih<¶ 4´ pqh rvxnFpqrtwfu*vxnf}0wPfr^´µw<rtgis<¥v~qgvxnH~qh(u*pqvxw<nHf|Tpqcfh#pqch w<rth*ptvxu(s¥u*w<nau*h fp¹w<´u*wPrqrth ¥sDptvwPn8r{sDptvwvx~^ptcfh nHfrqhN~h(nFpqh( vxn ~qh(u*pqvxw<nªjf¶HÀHh8[h(~tu*rtvx®ah ptcfh8rqh(}<v~ptrtspqvxw<n»s¥x}<wPrqvpqcfg vnÁ~hNuptvwPn»¶ [h(uptvwPn [r{s¬¨4~spqcfh(w<rth*pqvu s<¥u w<gisrtv~wPn ¨vpqcpqcfhÀÍww~u*rtvÃpth rtvwPn³|Pg²[pqas¥vxn[´µw<rtg sDpqvxw<n8sn'pqcfh¨+h vx}<cFpqhN'nfh(v}Pc®awPr¥xvÂPh ¥xvcwFw[|[¨cv¥xh¹~qh(u*pqvxw<n ²rqwPawF~hN~s [v~tu*~t~vxw<nvn0pqcfh¹´µwPrqg¿w<´\p¨+w²~q§FnFptcfh*ptvxu^rqh(}<v~ptrtspqvxw<n'h «fsgif¥xh(~(¶/Jrqh(¥vxgivns<rq§irth(~qf¥pt~+vn ¤ w<¥ ¤ vxnf}iÎL&|aÏ+b|[snJJb vxg s}<hN~srth¹~qcfwD¨nYsnY[v~tu*~t~hN0vxnY~hNupqvxw<n¸[¶ ?>. A@. . . CB. . H. !. . å à.
(30) ^Ç <Ë Ê?ÆtÉDʯË:ÅDÌ . ¸É PË #Ë (ÉÊ?Ë:ÅÌ Å &Ê Ç ÅÆÆqÇ ÈÉDʯË:ÅDÌ ·ÉÊ?Ë:Å. .
(31) . . . . . . /. 1. 1. 0.99. 0.9. 0.98. 0.8. 0.97. 0.7 Correlation Ratio. Mutual Information. . 0.96 0.95 0.94. 0.4 0.3. 0.92. 0.2. 0.9 −5. 0.1. −4. −3. −2. −1. 0 tx (voxels). 1. 2. 3. 4. 0 −5. 5. 1. 1. 0.99. 0.9. 0.98. 0.8. 0.97. 0.7 Correlation Ratio. Mutual Information. 0.5. 0.93. 0.91. Ï. 0.6. 0.96 0.95 0.94. −2. −1. 0 tx (voxels). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. −4. −3. −2. −1. 0 tx (voxels). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 0.5 0.4 0.3. 0.92. 0.2. 0.9 −5. −3. 0.6. 0.93. 0.91. −4. 0.1. −4. −3. −2. −1. 0 tx (voxels). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 0 −5.
(32)
(33)
(34)
(35) "! # $%'&)(* +, -. #0/12(*431 0.*5 "%!,# 67%-&8:9:
(36) ;< =.4>?
(37) A@BC
(38) #A31(*D31C 0.*5 "%EF
(39) A@F B
(40) " B ;
(41) 4G IHJB >=K LDGM ON5 HP L(*HP
(42) Q:N@RN5 HJS,@ FT9 UC
(43) 8
(44) " ;
(45) .!WVXHP
(46) H5. ->= R
(47) YBZ[,\]?^`_ +9<
(48) A@BLN*5a
(49) b
(50) c#"5a
(51) " d +5a +9*%O@MO( eN? HP
(52) "9S>=SM ;HJ ,@0f-B
(53) 5W
(54) B 5a
(55) B O> ] HJ . (*;5 +4
(56) " "P5a
(57) ;R>*4+ g
(58) ". ,
(59) 5a
(60) =!ih5a
(61) *EjQ >*
(62) &7SHP
(63) H58 ->* R
(64) <M- *!F@P af'
(65) 5Q
(66) B 5a
(67) ;8!DkDa'@P
(68) &7
(69) A@B N *5a
(70) l
(71) :!F6D NBM B
(72) B&7
(73) A@B?HP5 5B
(74) B 5a
(75) XN P+9 4
(76) S
(77) A@B4N *Cm)@ C
(78) A@B?
(79) 4N?+50*
(80) "*5 SM *5an!FoT
(81) N
(82) A@
(83) )>*<
(84) ". L
(85) B 5a
(86) B& YBZ[p\]i^`_ G q*H5W
(87) 2r&?;
(88) H': O(HJ+9s#0BM-9:9t
(89) A@
(90) ]?^
(91)
(92) 5 5 T>=5 5 ,
(93) <
(94) A@B 9.*5 ;
(95) "9R(* [ %!Iuv?+Bg" B
(96) ". T
(97) 5a
(98) &` 5 50 ?M5 H Cp(* = M9d9H C
(99) SG
(100) " "P5a
(101) +!DVXHP
(102) H5 ->* R
(103) 29:'. +
(104) W +5aGd@mb
(105) L5 02
(106) A@T
(107) TG ] m`;
(108) A@d
(109) A@T
(110) TG [ !T#w8%'&)G-.T:(=
(111) G89L(*S+9:S5 C SHP
(112) .L
(113) A@BpN5 HJS 4> ] !VXHP
(114) HB5n =>=
(115) ;X(@M T 2
(116) A@BT TmI `>= # 67% mQ@J;50T
(117) A@BpN *5a
(118) X
(119) +mx
(120) 'y: 4+ gLBGJ> HP58M5 HB =!. $vx}<frth . åå5ì. {û. GK%LMLN.
(121) . ·ÅNÄ Ç ¸ÉDÈÉÌ *<ÉË Ì <É<Ä Ç4Ç*ÌaÌTÇ{Ä . 0
(122) 8 . . . ^/*8 . ^ ~~ptspqv~ptvxu(s¥<u w<nu h [p{~³frtw ¤ vx[hJs·u*w<n ¤ h nfvxh nFp´µr{sgih ¨+w<rt´µw<r\pqcfhu*w<giffptsDptvwPn&w´f~qvgivx¥xs<rqvp§<|N¨h©s<rptvæau vxs<¥¥x§P°/u w<n~qvxfh r ptcfh vg s<}<h(~sP~^r{sna[w<g ¤ srtvs®f¥xh(~iº:~qh h s<fah(n[v«H^¼*¶ bdcfvx~&u w<rtrqhN~Tw<naf~4ptwYvnFpqh(rqrqh pqvxnf}Lsn¸vxg s}Ph#cvx~pqwP}<r{sg s<~&s frtw<®as®fvx¥vp§Hfh n~qvÃp§¸´µfnu*pqvxw<n¾ºµ´t¼*¶¸ÎYw<rth w ¤ h rN|¨h's<¥x~qwLu*wPn~v[h(r&pqcfh8 ·y¯cfv~pqw<}Prts<g w´4sn vxg s}<his<vr²s<~s#wPvnFp ´¶ lon ptcfh¹u w<nFpqh «p±w´\~qvgivx¥xs<rqvp§#g#hNs<~qfrth*yz®s<~qh(#gih*ptcfw[f~ |giwP~p+s<[pqcw<r{~ }<h(nfh r{s¥x¥§#vxnPpth rtfrth*p±vxg s}<hN~±sP~ pqch^rth(~qf¥pt~ w<´/s#r{sn[wPg h*«[Th rtvh(nu*hP¶/ÀHh&vxn~qvx~ppqcspw<frTw<vxnFp4w´ ¤ vxh ¨Svx~~q¥xv}PcPpt¥§[vÃÐh rth nFpN¶Jbdcfvx~4g#hNsn~+ptcsDp4¨ch n8rts<n[w<gi¥x§ ~qh ¥xh(u*pqvxnf}Lw<nfh ¤ w¬«[h ¥ vxnªsn vg s<}<h ºµh(sPu{c w´+pqcfh(g cs ¤ vxnf}8pqcfh~qs<g#hifrtw<®as®fvx¥vp§f¼|\pqcfh'rqwP®s®fvx¥xvÃp§w<´+}Ph*pqpqvxnf}sn vxnFpqh na~vp§ Jv~~qvgif¥x§0frtw<Tw<rqpqvxw<nas¥Tpqw#pqch&nFg®Th rw´ ¤ w¬«[h(¥x~(| |vn cs ¤ vnf}²pqch&vnFpqh(n~qvÃp§ &. . 5. ?. .. . * %)2. -. 5. . º ¼ . =. db cfv~´µw<rtgis<¥v~qg v~nwp#u w<giff¥~qw<rt§<¶lzpi~h(h g ~asr{s<[w¬«[vu s¥/ptwHu w<n~qvxfh r²sDpts¸s<~²rts<n[w<g ¤ srtvxs<®f¥xh(~(¶ /+[p²vp²v~ sLu w<n ¤ h(nfvh(nFpvnFpqh(rqrqh ptsDptvwPnH}Pv ¤ h nHpqcspfrtw<®s<®fvx¥v~ptvxuiu w<nu h [p{~pqfrtn»w<fp&pqwL®Th'awD¨+h rq´µf¥ ´µwPr[hN~vx}<nfvxnf}L~qvgivx¥xs<rqvp§ gih(sP~rqhN~ ¶ £ nfhdgis¬§²s¥~w¹nfwptvxu h+pqcsp pqcfv~³©s<rptvæTu*vs¥Ã°rts<n[wPg#nh(~t~g²~p/nwpJ®Thdu w<n[´µa~hN²¨vpqc#ptcfh~ptwu{cas<~pqvunasDpqrqh w<´ptcfh&nfw<v~qh^ptcsDp·u w<rtrq[pt~pqch&vg s}Ph(~(¶ $w<ru w<n ¤ h(nfvxh nu h<|d¨h¸¨v¥x¥¹~qffTwP~qhvxn pqcvx~~hNupqvxw<n ptcsDp8¨hH[h(s<¥·¨vpqc j vxg s}<hN~ ¶bdcfhHfrth(~qh nFpqhN g#h pqcfw[ u(sn-hNs<~qv¥x§ ®ahYs<s[pth(»ptw vg s}Ph(~(¶ lon-w<r{[h(rptwÍ[h ¦nfhpqcfh²w<vxnFp#´¹w´^s<n-vxgis<}<hsvxr(|±¥h p#~iu w<n~qvxfh r²p¨w vxg s}<hN~ Jsn8s#~spqvs¥Tpqr{sna~´µwPrqg sDptvwPn ¾ptcsDpg sa~+pqcfh}<rtv'w´ | |pqw#ptcfh}<rtvxw´ -| [-¶ /+wpq c #sn s<rqh¦nfvpqhptrqv[vxgih n~qvwPns¥/~qh*pt~·w´ ¤ w¬«h(¥x~(¶ s<n ptsÂPh&pqch vxr^vxnFpqh na~vp§ ¤ s<¥h(~^vn¸s'¦nfvpqh#~h p ¿¨cvxu{c¸u(sn®Th sP~q~qfgih(0pqw ®Thpqcfh~tsgih¹´µw<rdptcfhp¨+w²vxg s}<hN~ ¶ b§fvxu(s¥x¥§P |
(123) F¶ &. '&. 1!%. . +. . +. . (. (. 1. 2. ( . !. !. ! !. . !. =C= =. +. =. ·ff¥x§Fvxnf} ptcfh&ptrts<n~´µwPrqg spqvxw<n ptw vg s<}<h '|a¨hfh*¦nfh²sinfh ¨ g sfvnf}'´µrqwPg pqch&pqr{sn~´µw<rtgih(8TwP~qvÃptvwPn~w´ . ptw .
(124) . !"#. $. + %. . !. %. &. (')+*-, . % /% . =. À h0~qcfw<f¥Í®ah's<®f¥xhipqwY¦nÍptcfh'vxnFpqh na~vpqvxh(~ptcsDpsY}Pv ¤ h n Tw<vxnPpw<´0 $ Ë [ÈÃÊzÉÌTÇ{Å È Lp{sÂPh(~vxn s<n 1±¶ Í ^~¨h&¨dsnFpdpqw'fh(s¥¨vpqcu w<nFpqvxnfw<a~+~qspqvs¥ptrts<n~´µwPrqg spqvxw<n~(|awPvnFpt~dw<´2 }<h(nfh r{s¥x¥x§'[w nfwpptrts<n~´µw<rtg¿pqwiTw<vxnPp{~ w<´- ¶ bdcFa~ |<´µw<rs}Pv ¤ h n#pqr{sna~´µwPrqg sDptvwPn |vxnPpth rtawP¥xspqvxw<niv~Jnfh(h([hNivn'wPrtfh r/pqw *<Ç/3JÌTÇ·ptcfh w<vxnFp±´³w´pqch4vg s<}<h(~(¶ lon8pqcvx~·¨wPrqÂ|[¨+h¹hN~ptvg spqhpqchvnFpth n~qvÃp§vn ~qvn}ipqrtv¥xvnh(srvxnFpqh(rqTw<¥sDptvwPn8s<n8rqwPfn[vxnf}#pqwD¨dsr{f~+pqch&nfh(s<rqhN~p vxnFpqh }Ph r¹vnÍw<r{[h(r4pqw8}<h p ¤ s<¥fhN~·vx4 n 5<¶w<vxnFpt~¹w6´ $ +pqcsp[wP!n p¹cs ¤ hh(v}PcPpnfh(v}PcF®Tw<r{~4vx7 n 8srthrthhNupth(¶ \h*p 8 :9^[h(nfwpth4pqch~qf®~qh*p+w´sPu u h [pth( Tw<vxnFpt~dsn< ; [h(nfwpth4pqch¹vxnFpqh(rqTw<¥sDptvwPn w´ ª¶/ÀÍh¹fh*¦nfh^pqch^vxg s}<h^svxrds<~ ptcfh´µw<¥x¥wD¨vxnf}ir{sn[wPg u*wPff¥xh . + %. . 9 . . . +. (. .. . . + %. + %. (. . =2>? 8 %. + %:9. . . 0 !. A & @ ; %. % ! . ' *-, % % . B =. ?õ è¬áíüÚæã?õ\Û{ççò¬í¯Ûtõ?á+Úáoõ?è¬æ ø¬ãÝÞÜGFá ã?ê¬ÝÞÜÞì¬á/æí\ã¯ÜÞìNç ÜÞì õ?áí?êæÝëÛtõ?ÜÞæì&Û{í?á õ?æ(ædõ?ÜÞÚá/çæì¬ã?ò¬ÚÜÞì¬÷H¬ã:õ¯ÜÞÝÞÝPÜ õ\ÜÞãê¬í:æDÛ ¬Ý ô^êæã¯ã?Ü ¬ÝÞá/õ¯æ+ÜÞÚê¬í?æ*á õ¯í:ÜÞÝÞÜÞì¬áÛ{í\ÜÞì õ?áí?êæÝëÛtõ?ÜÞæìI\è¬ÜÞÝÞá2FááêNÜÞì¬÷Û{ìÛ{ççáêNõ¯Û ¬ÝÞáçæÚê¬ÝÞáoâ(Ü õ ô*ä CED. . å à.
(125) ^Ç <Ë Ê?ÆtÉDʯË:ÅDÌ . ¸É PË #Ë (ÉÊ?Ë:ÅÌ Å &Ê Ç ÅÆÆqÇ ÈÉDʯË:ÅDÌ ·ÉÊ?Ë:Å. .
(126) . . . bdcfh(nY¨h&[h ¦nfhpqchdw<vxnPp4´/w´. . s<n . . . ¥xvÂPh¨h[v´µw<r4si~qvnf}P¥hvxg s}<hh º ¼0 . .
(127) =2
(128) %
(129) 2 *!$#% $ + % 9. ¯º <¼ bdcfh·gis<rq}Pvnas¥[´ ~w<´pqcfh4vxg s}Ph(~ s<n 1Hsrthh nFpqvxrqh(¥§#[h*pth rtgivnfhN ®§ptcfhJwPvnFp±´ t¶4wD¨+h ¤ h(r(|pqcfh(§ s<rqh&nfw<p·h Fs<¥+É(aÆË:ÅÆËptw pqcwP~qh¨h&¨+w<¥xYcs ¤ h}<wpqpqh(nL®F§Yu*wPn~qvx[h(rqvxnf} ~qvnf}P¥h&vxg s}Ph(~(¶ ^fhptw'vxnPpth rtawP¥xspqvxw<n³|fpqcfh(§ [h(ah(nYw<npqchpqr{sn~´µw<rtg sDpqvxw<n . "!$#%)2.
(130) . =. . . "!$#%. &. )( 7. %)2. 3 . "!#% !. )+. 3 5. #%
(131) 2 7. . "!$#% =. 8. 5²0
(132) 8 . ¹/*Y*¿ ² +" . lonL~qh(uptvwPnYf|[¨h&cas ¤ h[h*¦nh(pqcfhdwPvnFp´ w´\p¨+wivg s<}<h(~(¶/ÀHh&nwD¨ ~pq[§8s#g#h pqcfw[´µw<rh ¤ s¥xsDptvnf} ~qw<gih¹ÂFvxn8w´ [h(ah(n[h(nu*h¹®ah p¨h(h n0p¨w²rts<n[w<g ¤ srtvs®f¥xh(~±¨cfh n0pqcfh(vrw<vxnFp+´\v~+ÂnfwD¨n³¶ $fw<r+ptcfvx~+frqTwP~qh<|Ppqcfh¹}<h(w<gih*ptrq§iw<´ r{snfw<g ¤ s<rqvs®¥hN~frth(~qh nFpt~4p¨w0sP ¤ snFpts<}<hN~ )¶ $vr{~p(|apqcfh²nfw<rtg5wPn nasDpqrts<¥¥x§vxgiawF~hN~·s'u w<n~pqr{svxnFp·w´ frtw¬«[vgivp§ vxnªptcfh8~tsgif¥xh0~qs<u h0fn¥vxÂ<hvn[´µwPrqg spqvxw<n[y¯pqcfh(w<rth*ptvxu gihNs<~qfrqhN~ ¶Hbdcfvx~²v~#u w<n~qv~pth nFp¨vpqcªptcfhYs<~t~fgi[ptvwPn pqcsp²ptcfh vxg s}<hN~srth²~qg#ww<pqc³¶ [h(u*wPn|ptcfh rth²h «[vx~pt~s8~vxgif¥h#gih*ptcfw[´µwPr Fs<nFpqv´µ§Fvxnf}0pqcfh =[ÌTÄ Ê¯Ë:ÅDÌTÉÈ[h(ah(n[h(nu*h#®ah p¨h(h n p¨+wHr{sna[w<g ¤ srtvs®f¥xh(~(¶»ÀHhLs<rqhYs¬¨+s<rqh'pqcsp#ptcfhYnfwptvwPn-w<´·´µfnu*pqvxw<ns<¥4[h Th na[h nu hYvx~#giw<rthrth(~pqrtvupqv ¤ h0pqcs<n-ptcfh }Ph nfh(rts<¥Tnwpqvxw<nYw<´~ptsDptvx~pqvu s<¥³[h Th na[h nu h<¶ bdcfv~ ~qh(uptvwPn#~qfgig srtv (h(~ptcfhd´µfnfs<gih nFpts<¥fu*w<nau*h fpt~/w´r{sn[wPg ¤ srtvxs<®f¥hN~}<h wPgih*pqrt§<¶/ÎYw<rth[h*p{svx¥x~/¨vx¥x¥f®ahd´µwPfn vxn ¯¶ .. .. 0. 0. H. . :. !. / .10. 7. vx~[h ¦nfhN8sP~+pqcfh~qsPu*hw´/~ Fs<rqhvxnPpth }Prts<®f¥h¹rth(s¥ ¤ srtvs®f¥xh(~D|[ptcsDp4v~+pqcfh ¤ s<rqvs®f¥xh(~+¨cfvu{c ¤ h(rqv´µ§7 . . 0 %)2. . ! "$#&% 0. !. ¨cfh(rqh'S[h nwpqhN~pqcfhdh «Th(u*ptspqvxw<n#w<Th r{sDpqwPr(¶ £ nfh~cfwD¨4~ptcsDp v~ s?4vx¥®Th rqp±~as<u*h+¨vpqcirqhN~Th(u*p/pqw¹pqcfh[w<p frqw[[aup ( *) $ t¶JbdcFa~ |[ptcfhu*wPrqrth(~qTw<n[vxnf}²nfw<rtg v~dpqcfh~qh(u w<n[y¯wPrt[h(rgiwPg#h(nFpdw<´/s ¤ srtvs®f¥xh .10. 1! .
(133) 2. *. %. +. +0 2 , * . 0 %. º?jP¼ =. db cfh nw<rtg vx~ u ¥wF~h(¥§»rth ¥sDpth(ªpqwÍpqcfhu ¥xsP~q~qvu s¥dnfw<pqvxw<n~#w<´^h*«[Th(u*ptsDptvwPn³| ¤ s<rqvsnau*hYsnÁ~p{snsr{-[h ¤ vsDptvwPn³¶ -Fspqvxw<n»º:jF¼du s<n®Th&rqh(¨rqvppth n .10. + /.0* % + 0 1 2 , 243< . ^fh+pqw^vÃp{~ ·v¥x®Th rqpqvsn²~pqrtu*pqfrth<| ®Th*p¨+h h(np¨+w ¤ srtvxs<®f¥hN~ &. .. 0. = ? >A@. B ìdîxÛ{çoõqüDCFEÜÞãfõ?è¬áñ ò¬æ{õ?ÜÞáì*õã?êDÛ{çáæ{îFã¯ñ òDÛ{í?á\ÜÞì*õ¯á÷í?Û ¬ÝÞá. åå5ì. {û. GK%LMLN. . % =. csP~\vxnFpqh rth(~pqvxnf}^}<h wPgih*pqrtvu frtw<Th rqpqvxh(~(¶ £ nfh+u sn#[h*¦anfhs^nfwptvwPnw´aw<rqpqcfwP}<w<nas¥xvÃp§ . >³è¬ÜÞã³ø¬ÜÞã?õ?ÜÞì¬çoõ¯ÜÞæì¹èDÛ{ã³ì¬ædÜÞÚêæí:õ¯Û{ì¬çáJè¬áí?áä. 6587 9;: <. %)2. *. % 2. . =. {Û{í?ÜëÛ ¬ÝÞáã \I Ü õ?èdí?áã?ê<áçoõõ?æJõ?è¬áHG:Û{ÝÞÚæã?õá *áí:ôI\è¬áí?áJIáñ ò¬Ü {Û{ÝÞáìNçáí?áÝëÛtõ?ÜÞæì¬ã¯èNÜÞêFä .
(134) ·ÅNÄ Ç ¸ÉDÈÉÌ *<ÉË Ì <É<Ä Ç4Ç*ÌaÌTÇ{Ä . 2. . . db cfh#gih(s<nfvn}w<´±w<rqpqcfwP}<wPns¥xvÃp§vn rth ¥sDpqhN~·¨vpqcHpqch²nfw<pqvxw<nHw´±vxn[h(ah(n[h nau*h<|\®f[p&vnÍs0¥xh(~t~^rqhN~ptrqvuptv ¤ h¨ds¬§<¶ hNu s<¥¥ptcsDpp¨+w ¤ s<rqvs®f¥xh(~ sn srth~tsv ptw ®ahvxn[h(ah(n[h nFp4v´ptcfh vxr/w<vxnFpT´/v~h Fs<¥aptw#pqcfh&frtw[[u*pdw<´\ptcfh vxr g srt}<vxns<¥[T´ ~(|FpqcspJvx~ ³´µw<r p¨+w~qu{c ¤ s<rqvs®f¥xh(~(¶ t¶ £ nfhh(sP~vx¥x§~cwD¨4~/pqcsp bdc~ 0. .. . . . !. %
(135) 2. . . 3 . %. . %. . : : : 7 2 @. .0. . . =. %. %)2. .0. . . *%. % *%. =. ¤ h rN|[ptcfh²u w<n ¤ h(rt~qhvx~4´:s¥~hP¶ £ rqpqcw<}<wPns¥xvp§'vn v~·s ¨+h(s<Â<h(r4u*w<na~ptrts<vnFppqcasnLvxn[h Th na[h nu h<¶4lzp^gis¬§8®Th~h(h n sP~s²nwpqvxw<nYw<´vxn[h Th na[h nu h0ÅDÌHÊ [Ç²É ¬Ç ÆqÉ FÇ ¶ lon¸s0}<h(nfh r{s¥¨+s¬§P|fpqch#s<nf}<¥xh Á®ah p¨h(h nLp¨+w ¤ srtvs®f¥xh(~ sn ¿vx~[h ¦nfhNYpqcs<nfÂ[~4ptws0®s<~qvxufrqwPah(rp§8w´±fwp frtw[[u*pt~ ( ) + + + +
(136) º:F¼ ·wD¨h. 0. .. . @.
(137) . . 1!. /. '8. 2. . . . 0. 0. :. =. 0 ) . *u wPnPp{svxn~ptcfh'w<nh*yo[vgih(n~vxw<nas¥±~qs<u h w<´4[h*pth rtg#vxnfv~ptvxu ¤ s<rqvs®¥hN~ |v?¶ h<¶ ¤ srtvxs<®f¥xh(~¨cfvu{cªsrth'u*wPn~p{snFpw<n ptcfh ~ptspqh~qs<u h ¹¶ ¹v ¤ h(nYs ¤ srtvs®f¥xh -|[vÃp{~h*«[Th(up{sDptvwPnv~ .10. . 6
(138) % .2 ( 1! ) =. . %)2. . bdcfh(rqh ´µw<rth<|F vx~·nfwptcfvn}'®f[p4ptcfhwPrptcfw<}Pw<ns<¥frtwh(u*pqvxw<nYw´ w<nFptw¶+lonpqcfh~qh na~hw<´/pqcfh Ä{ÅDÌ ÊzÉÌÊ ¤ s<rqvs®¥h¨cfvu{c®Th(~p·sfrqw¬«[vxg sDpqhN~ º?u*¥s<~t~vu s<¥Tnwpqvxw<n8w´/gih(s<na¼¶ . %.
(139) . %. .10. nfwPrqgY|vp^v~ptcfh. . *. ; + /.! +. %)2. . 0. 0 =. X. ∆. 0. i*
(140) ;ND B
(141) " B*
(142)
(143) l >D N=
(144)
(145) 8!#" Z%$<_ 7
(146) A@Bi*
(147) A@:+5' '&'N=
(148) O> $
(149) T
(150) A@BFNB
(151) B
(152) Q9 N=
(153) )(2!. $vx}<frth
(154) . / *. E(X). . . / ,+ .
Documents relatifs
The first part of establishing a shape similarity measure across the segmented prostate images in the TRUS and the MR involves establishing point correspon- dences on the
Be different from above feature point based and direct approaches, joint face alignment methods work by simultaneously aligning a set of facial images.. Figure 2.9 illustrates
In order to determine the degree of prostate boundaries overlap, the mismatch between prostate contours in US and MR phantom images was calculated after the non-rigid
We show that solving variational problems on this partic- ular space is an elegant way of finding the natural patch- based counterparts of classical image processing techniques, such
Loin d’apparaître comme un fait social objectif qu’il suffirait de dévoiler, puis de sanctionner avec l’arme d’un droit traçant les frontières du légal et de l’illégal,
Une fois les vecteurs de mouvement identifiés, la séquence d'image peut être sonifiée en interprétant chacun de ces vecteurs comme paramètres de contrôle d'un
Ceci peut s’expliquer par le fait que la relation maintenue avec les collègues de travail est d’égal à égal, les participantes ne dépendent pas d’eux pour travailler,
Incurables, la maladie, les douleurs omniprésentes, dans leur constance, semblent tenir en quelque sorte, lieu d’existence : « C’est très dur de devoir demander de l’aide pour