The Pandore Compiler: Overview and Experimental Results

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00074208

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074208

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

The Pandore Compiler: Overview and Experimental Results

Françoise André, Marc Le Fur, Yves Mahéo, Jean-Louis Pazat

To cite this version:

Françoise André, Marc Le Fur, Yves Mahéo, Jean-Louis Pazat. The Pandore Compiler: Overview and Experimental Results. [Research Report] RR-2467, INRIA. 1994. �inria-00074208�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

The Pandore Compiler:

Overview and Experimental Results

Franc¸oise Andre´, Marc Le Fur, Yves Mahe´o, Jean-louis Pazat

N˚ 2467

Octobre 1994

PROGRAMME 1

(3)

(4)

!

" #$ %'&(")* ,+-.0/21+/

3547698":

;=<?>A@BC 8DE4GF

BIHKJL 694

;M)B 35N54

HH=J5OQPRBS@L 69TF

BU<HHVHKJWXB 698GY[Z

< N

>\@^]

6`_`69a

HHHH

bdcVe`f`c#gUhihjklnm,c#oVpXqsrjKotruRcjKv*wxgUc#gzy{y}|jty~jKvxxg`vjKvXjXe`R"jjKvXcRjKvjKgUuX

jr,vvrK|jhjKv"9qvrcqsRu"jKv

bce`jrbxmbEm

gUwRwxe9cr,XjcjKoVpRjc#oVpRj.XU?Xl ,otrVe`Rcjk=`U^lUwxgUf9jKv

()K =¡x¢U`£¥¤¦pXq§v¨wxgUwEjc"wRcjKvjXr#vgUij?©9qsce`RhjXr¨ª\e`cdwRcVe`f`c#gUhihQqsRf9qvrcqsRuRrjKhijh«

e`cV¥ote`hwRuRrjc#v¦uxv[qsRf¥¬,b¨)«®y{qs¯`jRgUrtg9qvrcqsRuRrqse`°ªAjKgUruRcjKv±²hwRpxg`v[qv¦qvwRuRre`³ote9h«

wXq´ygUrqse`rjKoVpRXqµ`uRjKvgUx(9qvrcqsRuRrjKgUcVc#g=hgUxgUf`jhjXrK±d"jKvuXysr#vgScjvpRez¶*ª\e`cve9hj

¶"jty´y·¯XReU¶?uRhjcq§ogzyg=ysf`e9cqsrpRhv±

¸º¹?»¼½Q¾G U¿)`£ÁÀe`hwXqýgUrqse`9qvrcq~RuRrVjKÂhijhe`c'hgòpXqsRj`RgUrtg³9qvrVcqsRuRrqse`ÿse?e`w

e`wRrq~hÃq~ÄKgSrqse`xwxgSc#g=y´ysjty{qsÄKgUrq~e95cuR?rq~hijvuRwRwEe`crK±

Å\ÆQÇ

ÈÉÊKË

Ç

ÈdÌdÍ~ÉÏÎ®ÐKÑ

ÒAÓÔVÕKÖK×AØÙ2ÚÛ×®ÚÛÜ}ÔÝÓs×

Ò}Ò}Þ¨ßØ[ÓsàK×}Ù2ÚÛ×®ÚÛÜ}ÔÝÓs×

Ò[Ò}ÒÞ ÔVáKØâ7Ù2ÚÛ×®ÚÛÜ}ÔÝÓs×

Ò}Ò[Ò}Ò}ãUÔäÔVå}Ù2ÚÛ×®ÚÛÜ}ÔÝÓ~×

Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – Te´le´copie : (33) 99 84 71 71

(5)

"/5* ,+"+)# + "/21+"+/ ¨&Q") * + 1&

¹ ¹¥£QÀjc#gUwRwEe`cr"wRcRjKvj?rVjuR(j?©9qsce`RRjhjXr,XjwRce9f`c#gUhhgUrqse`XjKv"hg`opXqsRjKv

|gih jhieUqscj9qvrcqsRu" jjKv*uRrq´y´qvgUXrXjKv,9qscjKotrqs©`jKvXjQ9qvrcqsRuRrqse`XjQXe`R"jjKvxv[qshQq´yg=qscjKv

|gQotjtyýsjKv,Xj¬b"±Ûg9ootj?r"jKvr"hQqvvuRcÿsjKv"rjKoVpRXqµùRjKvXjote`hwXqýgUrqse`¥jrvuRcÿgQf`jKvrqse`

XjKvr#gUXysjKgUuX9qvrcqsRu"jKv±jKvcjKvuXysr#gSr#vjtRw"jcq~hij?r#gSuX ve`XrwRcRjKvj?rRjKv"wEe`uRcµ`uRjtyµ9uRjKv

ReU?gUuX¥Ûg=ysf`e9cqsrpRhjKv"XuRh jcq§µ9uRjKv±

!¾EK¼¢¹£ Àe`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9hg`oVpXqsRj³|gih jheSq~cVjÃ9qvrVcqsRu0 jj`9qvrcqsRuRrqse` XjXe`R"jjKv

e`wRrq~hÃq§vVgUrqse`³Xj^xe`uxoVysjKvEwxgUc#gzy{yjty{qvgSrqse`xjt"jKotuRrq{ª±

(6)

9 : ,+^1 d+)#

¤"pRj9q; otuXysr(eUªIwRcVe`f`c#gUhihQqsRfhg`vv[qs©`jtyswxgUc#g=y´ysjty·gUc#oVpXqsrjKotruRcjKv¦¶"qsrp¥9qvrcqsRuRrjKºhj«

he9cqvgvj©9jcjqshwEjK9q~hij?r^rerVpRjuxvjQeUªrpRjKvjwxgUc#gzy{ysjtyhg9opXqsRjKv±2<[³rVpRjwxg`vr*ªAj¶

`jKgSc#v`¶"jpxg=©`j,¶¦q~rVRjKvvjK(gQvuRxvr#gS?rqg=y5j-=e`cre9rpRjwxgUcr"eUªcjKvjKgUc#oVpRjc#v¨reXj->xRjwxgU«

c#gzy{ysjtywRce9f`c#gUhhÃq~RfiwxgUc#g`9qsf`hv*g`RgUwRrjKºre *qvrcqsRuRrjK°jhe`cV bdgUctg=y´y~jty¨Àe`hwRuRrjctv

?+@BADC6E

v-F#±

m,he9RfrpRjh¥XrpRj.GH/0IJK#XheRXjty·vjjhv"reQxjQgUqs?rjcVjKvrqsRfgUwRwRceXg`opL rpRj

wRce9f`c#gUhhijc5qvwRceU©9qXjKg¨ª}gUhQq´y´qgUcIuRXq´ªAe`ch yse`fUqog=yxg`RXcjKvvvwxg`otj0gUx^gvjKµ9uRj?rq§gzyMxeU¶

eUª0ote9?rcVeUy}±G¬*jote`XrceSy§v*rpRjQ9q§vrcqsRuRrjK'g`vwxjKotreUªrpRjote9hwRuRr#gUrqse`X¥vwxjKoVq´ªA`qsRf°rpRj

RgUrtg9qvrVcqsRuRrqse`ez©9jc0rVpRjyseRog=yIhjhe9cqsjKv"eUªIrpRjwRcVeotjKvve`c#v±R¤"pRjote`hiwXq{ysjcf`jRjc#gUrVjKv

oteRXjg`oote`ct9q~Rf(rVe(rpRj)N C,AO@

heRXjty0gUx°rpRj^y´qsR¯v^xjr¶"jjrpRjoteXjijtjKotuRrqse` gUx

rpRjRgUrtg9qvrcq~RuRrq~e9'qvjXªAe`c#otjK°?°rpRjP%Q +R%Q$7/043cuXysjL5jKg`oVp³wRcVeotjKvve`c,jtRjKotuRrjKv

e`Xys(rpRjvr#gUrjhjXr#v¨rpxgUr*he9q´ªA(rpRjRgUr#gig`vv[qsf`RjKreÃq~r*?rpRj9qvrVcqsRuRrqse`±

S0g9vjK(e`°rpXqvgUwRwRce?g9opRrVpRjrjKoVpRXqµ`uRjKvq~xote9cwxe`ctgUrjKqsrpRjUTVQW

@XZY2[

ote`hiwXq{ysjc

wEjchQqsr(f`jRjc#gUrq~Rf vog=ygUXysjoteRXj`±¨m\>xc#vrrjKopRXqµ9uRjg=y´yseU¶,vrVpRj³ote`hwXq´ygUrqse` eUªgS?

wRce9f`c#gUh eUªIrVpRjve9uRc#otjygURf9uxgUf`jRuRr,vu=jc#v·ª\cVe`h q~Rj-;(oVq~jxoVqsjKv±2<[¥g`R9qsrqse`xgQvjKote`x

hjrVpRe pxg`vEjj Xj->xRjK rVe(e`wRrqshQqsÄjwxgSc#g=y´ysjty0yseXe`wxv±2m, j-; oVqsj?rQcuRXrqshjvuRwRwxe`cr=

rpxgSr ote`hiwRcqvjKve9wRrqshQqsÄjK hjKoVpxgUXqvhvÃª\e`crpRj°hgUxgUf`jhij?reSª9q§vrcqsRuRrjKgUcVc#g=v

ote`hiwXy~jrVjKvrpRjKvjr¶"eÃvVopRjhjKv±

¤"pXqvwxgUwxjc^wRcjKvjXr#vrVpRjTVZW

@XZY[

jX©9q~cVe`RhjXrgUxºª\eRotuxvjKve`'ve`hije`wRrqshQqsÄKgU«

rqse`xv¦eUªIrpRjote`hwXq´ygUrqse`vopRjhijgUxrVpRj,cuRXrqshjvuRwRwEe`crK±<[r"qve9cf?gUXqsÄjK(g`vªAeUy´y~eU¶,v]L

rpRjRjtRr¦vjKotrqse`Rcq~j-MxiwRcjKvjXr#v¨rpRjHTVQW

@2XQY2[

jX©9q~cVe`RhjXr¦gSxvjKotrq~e9 R±fUqs©`jKv"gU

eU©`jc©9qsj¶eUªIrVpRjTVQW

@XQY2[

ygURf`uxgUf9j`±^`jKotrq~e9_8^jtwXyg=qsxv*rpRjote`hwXq´ygUrqse`¥wRcVeotjKvv*gUx

rpRj*e`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`xv¨uxvjKÃª\e9cdwxgUc#g=y´ysjtyGRjKvrVjKQyseXe`wxv±?¤¦pRj,gUcc#g=hgSxgUf`jhjXrdqvXjKvVotcqsxjK

qsÂvjKotrqse` ³gSx'cjKvuXy~rtvgScj9qvotuxvvjK qs vjKotrqse`a`R±I uRruRcj¶"e`c¯³gSx'jtRrjxv[qse`xv^eUª

e`uRcvvrjh gUcjwRcVjKvj?rVjKqs¥rpRjote9xoVy~uxvÏq~e9±

b % #2 * +

cedgf hPiej'klinmojqp

r'j"pxg=©`jXj©`jtyse`wEjKgU^jtwEjcqshj?rtg=ywRcVe`f`c#gUhihQqsRf,jX©`qsce9Rhj?r2ªAe`c

@BADC6E

±U¤"pRj¯`jcVRjty

eUª5rpXqvdjX©`qsce9Rhj?rqvdrpRjHTVZW

@XZY[

ote`hwXq´ysjcKXRuXq´ysr¦g9oote`c#9qsRfrerpRjxg9v[qo"wRcqsxoVqswXy~jKv

9qvotuxvvjK³gSxeU©`j`±

r pRj°¶"jXjKv[qsf`RjK°rpRjote9hwXqý~jc=xeùRc*e`RjKotrqs©`jKv"¶"jcjrpRjª\eUyýseU¶"qsRfL

(7)

/045I.56 P]* /0 ,34]$"2#4

<}'e9c#Xjcre(xjgUXysjreqs?rVjf`c#gUrjQRj¶ rjKopRXqµ9uRjKvjKg`vÏq{ysg9oote`c#9qsRf(re(rpRjvr#gUrj

eUªgUcrKX¶"jcjtys(e`(rpRjQvwxjKoVq>GogUrqse`eUªgUqsXrjchjK9qgUrjQwRce9f`c#gUh cjwRcjKvj?r#gSrqse`

¶pXqop Xe?jKvRe`rXjwxjx e`rpRj^qsRwRuRrygURf9uxgUf`jgUxe`¶pXqoVpg=y´y¦gSxg=ysv[qv^gUx

rc#gUxvÏª\e`cVhgUrqse`rjKoVpRXq§µ9uRjKv)hg=r#gU¯`j)wXyg`otj`±z¤¦pRj0ote`hwXq´ysjcdpxg`v5EjjQ¶cqsrrjuxv[qsRf

rpRj E V

A

ygURf`uxgUf9jm z "!E¶pXqopiqvgªAuRxotrqse`xg=y5ygURf`uxgSf`jxg`vjKÃe`rVpRj,

ygURfùxgUf`j¨wRceU©`q9qsRfwxeSy~Xhe`cVwRpXq§o¦rÏXwxj"vX?rpRjKvÏq§vKwxgUrVrjchgUr#oVpXq~RfgUxªgòVqý´qsrqsjKv

re'Xj->xRj(wxgUc#v[qsRfªAuRxotrqse`xv±d°e`cjeU©`jc=¶"jpxg=©`j(Xj->xRjKÂgS gUxvrc#g`otr^hg`oVpXq~Rj

ysj©`jty·rVeÃg9opXqsj©`j^rpRjf`jRjc#gUrq~e9¥eUªIhg`opXqsRjq~xXjwEjxXj?rQoteXj`±

/0P534# #2 ')34$4./0%]6 '&#543#

uRcgzq~h qvrVe9qvrcqsRuRrjQgUx(wxgUctg=y´y~jty´qsÄjgUXwRce`f`c#gSh ¶pXqopºª\uXy>Ry´yvrpRjQopReXvj

qsRwRuRr)y§gSRf`uxgUf`j"v?Xr#g=±K¤"pXuxv=¶"jcjtyse`QgUqshwXysjhjXr#gUrqse`QeUªxrVpRjeU¶Rjc«A¶cq~rVjKv

cuXysj¥rpxgSrpxg9vQxjj wRceU©`jK rexjote`ccjKotr(S*À*)`¤*`!}±d°e`cjeU©`jcK2? g'vuXqsr#gSXy~j

cuRXrqshjvvrjh gUxve`wRpXqvrqogUrVjK'ote`hwXq´ygUrqse`'rVjKopRXqµ9uRjKv¶"je9Rr#g=qsj-; oVqsj?r

jtjKotuRrq~e9(ªAe`c,gQcjKg9ve`xgUXysiy§gScf`joVyg`vv*eUªdwRce`f`c#gShv±

¤"pRjaTVQW

@2XQY2[

jX©`qsce`Rhij?rºq§v°vpReU¶ qs >xf`uRcjÂk9±n<[r³ote`hwRcq§vjKv¥g ote`hwXq´ysjcKg

hg9opXqsRj«®qsxXjwxj5Xj?rcuRR«Arq~hijgUxijtjKotuRrq~e9³gUxg=ysRv[qv"reXeUyvq~xoVysux9qsRf¥gQwRce >Ry~jcgUx

gQrVc#g`otjf`jRjc#gSre`cK±

mrctgUxv[ygUre`c ª\ce9h ¬brVerpRjTVQW

@2XQY2[

ygURf`uxgSf`jdqvg=yvewRceU©9q§XjK+,)UmÀ-zU!}±¬,b¨

qsxoVysuxXjKvve`hj/.vr#gUxRgUc#10jtRrjxv[qse`xvªAe`cRgSr#gwxgUc#g=y´ysjty´qvhgUx RgUr#g(9qvrcq~RuRrq~e9 q~

rpRjRe`cVrc#gU ºygURf`uxgUf`j`±<}ripxg`vQxjj XjKv[qsf`RjK ? rpRj¬"qsf`pÂb)jcªAe`chgUxotj¥Re`cVrc#gU

e`cuRh ª\ce9hgUc#oVp kK`9reg= k=`8R±¬b!wEjchQqsr#vre 9qvrcqsRuRrj'gUcVc#g=vgShe`Rf

©9qscruxg=y"wRceotjKvVve`cgScc#g=v

?

¤²b m¤²^,F%2vjjÛRe9c#83!ª\e9cg¥ote`hwXysjrj(XjKvotcqswRrqse` eUª

rpRjygURf`uxgUf`j`±

¤"pRjTVZW

@XZY[

cuRR«ArqshjuxvjKv"gf`jRjcq§ohijKvvgUf`j*wxg`vv[qsRf^y´q~RctgUcog=y´ysjK(b",

?

bdgU«

c#gzy{ysjtyxvjc©zgUXysjQ³g9opXqsRj465³S7!0F#±X¤"pXqv¨y´qsRc#gUcel=jc#v)y´qshQqsrjKºRuRrj-; oVqsj?rvjcV©`qotjKv±

<[rg=y´y~eU¶,v2recuRQrpRj0vVgUhjwRcVe`f`c#gUh!e`Qg¶"qXjctgURf`jeSªG9q§vrcqsRuRrjKQhjhie`cote`hwRuRrjc#v±

ced c 8:9nj<;=?>A@CBkjEDF=?>AGIHC=?Gj

¤"pRj TVQW

@2XQY2[

ygURf`uxgUf9jqvdxg9vjKe9gvjKµ9uRjXrqg=yxqshwEjc#gUrqs©`j*ygURf`uxgUf`juxv[qsRfgvuRxvjr

eUªÀ

?

jt oVysux9qsRfÂwEeUqs?rjctv-Fg`vg xg`v[qv±r'jpxgK©9j³g`RXjK g vhgzy{yvjreUªv[qshwXysj RgUr#g

9qvrcq~RuRrq~e9Qª\jKgSruRcjKvEqse9c#Xjcre,XjKvVotcqsxj¨ª\cVjKµ`uRjXrysuxvjKXjKote9hwxe?vÏq~rq~e9xv±^`jjF´À¨pRjK8"!

ªAe`cdghe9cjdwRcjKoVqvjXj->xXqsrqseèUªxrpRjygURfùxgUf`j`±<Aªxe9rpRjcIcVjfùXygUc·XjKote9hwxe?vÏq~rq~e9ªAuRxotrqse`xv

gUcVjvjj¥reixjRjKotjKvvgSc`xrVpRj¶"qýýdxjg9RXjKrerpRjygURfùxgSf`j`±

(8)

C-Pandore

PANDORE Compiler

Pandore Run-time

Traces

Visualization

Paragon XP/S

PVM iPSC/2 Cluster of

Workstations

C Code HPF

Translator

Simulator POM Library

Trace

Analysis Results

(9)

¿® lR6l34

?

3/0-]56/0- .#/03/7F

lR47

¤"pRj9q§vrcqsRuRrjK wxgUc#gUhjrVjcy´qvrgzy{yseU¶,v^vwxjKoVq´ªA`qsRfrpRjQwxgUcrqsrqse`XqsRfgUxrpRjQhgUwRwXqsRf

eUª)rpRjRgUr#g^uxvjKiqs(rpRj9qvrcq~RuRrVjK(wRpxg`vj`±E¤"pRjgScc#g=Qqv"rpRje`Xys RgSr#g^rÏXwxjrVpxgUr"hg=

Ej³wxgScrqsrqse`RjK5±"¤"pRj¥hjKgSxvQreXjKote`hiwxe?vjgU gScc#g=qvre'vwXy´qsrq~riqs?rVeXyseRo¯Rv±"¤"pRj

vwEjKoVq>GogUrqse` eUª"rpRjwxgUcrq~rq~e9Xq~Rfºª\e9cg`«}9qshjxv[qse`xgzy*gScc#g=qvfUqs©`j'XrpRj¯`jX¶"e`c#

s¾¢

?

F¶*pRjcj

q~x9qogUrVjKvrpRjv[qsÄjQeUª·rVpRjXy~eRoV¯v¦qs³rVpRjQ9qshjxv[qse`±¤"pXqv

qvvÏq~hÃq{ygUcQre(rVpRjÃ¬b !#"$%'&)(9qvrcqsRuRrqse` ÛRe9c#83!djtxotjwRrªAe`crpRjihgUwRwXqsRfx±I e`c

jtxgUhwXysj

*(,+.-! ,/0-!55» §¾¢1

? k

/2- F

qsx9qogUrjKvrpxgSr0rVpRjgUcc#g=3* eUª4+.-657/0- jtysjhjXr#v¨qvXjKote`hwEe?vjKiqs?rVeXyseoV¯v*eUª·vÏq~Äj

k85./2-ULXrpRjgUcVc#g=qvXjKote`hwEe?vjKqsXre9+.-!y´qsRjKv±

¤"pRjrpRjQhgSwRwXq~Rf°eUª0rVpRjXyseoV¯ve`XrerVpRjgUc#oVpXqsrjKotruRcj¶¦q{y´y"xjg`oVpXqsj©`jKXrpRj

ote`hiwXq{ysjcq~gcjf9uXy§gScde`c·otRoVy´qo¶g=g`oote`c#9qsRfrerpRj"hgUwRwXqsRfwxgUctgUhjrjc#v

?

=¹;: s¡x "e9c

½ =¡=<<)¹¿ZF#±,<[ TVQW

@XQY2[

R¶"jote`xvÏq§Xjce`Xyse`Rj9qshjxv[qse`xg=ydwRceRotjKvve`c,gScc#g=v¨¶pReXvj

v[qsÄjq§v¦Re`r,vwEjKoVq>xjKºqs(rpRjve9uRc#otjoteXjRuRr*uxvjK¥g`v"gQwxgSc#gUhjrjc"XrpRjote`hiwXq{ysjcK±Emv

¶"jgzy{yseU¶ rpRj^hgUwRwXqsRf(eUªhQuXysrq9q~hijxv[qse`xg=y¦XjKote9hwxe?vÏq~rq~e9xv5qsr*q§vRjjKXjK reQqsx9qogUrj

rpRj^e`c#Xjc"ªAe`crVpRjhgUwRwXqsRfeSª·XyseRo¯Rv4L>%1?A@CB#(vrtgUrjKv¨ªAe`c,oteUysuRh >xc#vrKD%EBD@F?(vrtgUrjKv¨ªAe`c

ceU¶ >xctvrK±

¤"pRjyg`vrvwxjKoVq>GogUrq~e9³fSq~©9jq~(rVpRjwxgUc#gUhjrVjcy´qvr,ote9xotjcxv"rpRjrctgUxv[ªAjc0hieXjªAe`c

©Ug=ysuRjKvxjr¶"jjrpRjog=y´ysjcgUx°rpRjQ9q§vrcqsRuRrjK wRpxg`vjL5g=y´y~eU¶"jK°heRXjKvgUcjHGJILK>MHNO

gUxPGJI.MHNO±x¤¦pXq§vvwEjKoVq>GogSrqse`°q§vv[qshQq´ygUcrerpRj e`crc#gSx 3" QSR;T;QSR(gUrrcq~RuRrVj`±

2q~f9uRcjvpReU¶,vgS(jt gUhiwXy~j^eUªg9qvrcqsRuRrjKºwRpxg`vj`±

U)VWUXVWU

MQ YG¹R Z2¹?¡R =¹

^è`hije9rpRjcote9xvrcuxotr#vpxg=©`j^xjjg9RXjK¥rVerpRjÀ ygURfùxgUf`jÈ¶"qsrpRe¥9qscjKotrcjtygUrqse`

¶"qsrpÂ9qvrVcqsRuRrqse`dreºq~hiwRceU©`jrVpRjjKg`vjeUªwRce9f`c#gUhhÃq~RfE±dc#9qsxgUc À!ª\uRxotrq~e9xvgScj

Re`rg=y´yseU¶"jKqs rpRj TVQW

@XZY2[

y§gSRf`uxgUf`jRuRr^q~Âg9R9q~rq~e9 re'9q§vrcqsRuRrjK wRpxg`vjKvIr¶"e

ªAjKgUruRcjKv*gUcjel=jcjKreirpRjwRce`f`ctgUhhjc#L'. #l3,gUx l3- $456 #/07 ,3±

_ K"XjKoVygUc#gUrq~e9xvIgUcVjv[qshQq´y§gScdrewRceRotjKXuRcj0Xj->xXqsrqse`xvRuRrIwxgSc#gUhjrjctvGgScjwxg`vVvjK

.tX¥xgShj70(gUxog=y´yvre(g . #gUcj^qsR«®y´qsRjK ?°rpRjote`hwXq´ysjcK±nl34$$456 #/07 ,3,gScj

v[qshQq´ygUc°re À ª\uRxotrqse`xvRuRr(ogURRe`r(g`ootjKvvifUyse`xg=y©zgScqgUXysjKvRe`chie9q´ªAÂ9q§vrcqsRuRrjK

gUcVc#g=v±EÀdyse?vjKªAuRxotrqse`xv,gScjvÏq~hÃq{ygUcrVeÃ¬b b\[,*² ªAuRxotrqse`xv±

(10)

!"$#%&'#%&()* !+,-/.0132457684559:.<;132=?>@1

A

BC.ED:.F,'G

8H0,!I;:GJ,KL<?M1GN,!OO1

A

?8HPI,OG3PKGQOO1

"'#<&$#R,?&IS"$#E&$#R,&UTS"$#R,?&$#R,&-G

?8HPI,OG3PKGQOO1

?8HVDI,OGWDK-GWDOO1

"$#<9&$#XD&I*"$#E&$#XD&YM*"$#<9&$#R,&YZ*"$#R,&'#XD&-G

[

2qsfùRcjqLC\jcRjtydeUªIrpRj [ ª}gòtre9cqsÄKgUrqse`¥g=ysfè`cq~rVpRh

cedR] ^ jL_ =L`j@ba BBkc

gUXQe`rpRjc"cjKvjKgUctopwRcVe`jKotr#vgUcVj,g`RXcjKvvÏq~RfirpRj,Xj->xXqsrqse`¥eSª wRcVe`f`c#gUhihQqsRfjX©`qsce`R«

hjXr#v¨ªAe`c"cuRRXqsRf(RgUr#g^wxgUc#g=y´ysjtyIwRce9f`c#gUhv¨e`¥9qvrVcqsRuRrjK¥ <Ï !ote`hwRuRrjctv±Xm,he9Rf

rpRjh°5rpRjedqsjRxg¥ e`crctgU'Àe9hwXq´y§gSrqse`a^`Rvrjh

?

ddÀ^,F¦gUx°rpRj e`crc#gS .vvrVjh

gUcVj,¶"jty´yI¯XRez¶*±?bdcVjty{qshQqsxgUcV(cjKvjKgUc#oVpcjtygUrjKre^rpRjKvjwRce9ÏjKotr#v¨gUxireQrpRjTVZW

@XZY[

wRce9ÏjKotrdEjf?gUQqs¥k=ffR=pRjxotj,Re9crc#gU QdqsjRxgQRe9crc#gUQgUxQrpRjOTVQW

@XQY2[

ygURf`uxgSf`j

pxg=©`jEjj Xj->xRjK°gUXrjcqse`cysre¬b"±

dÀ"^qv)xg`vjKQe`QrpRj ^`uRwxjcrVe?eUyIhgS-5iff"!RrpxgUr)pxg`v)xjj(XjKv[qsf`RjKQX± 5,jcVxXr

gUx¬^±gRqshgR±,^`uRwEjcqvg^vjhQqs«}gUuRre`hgUrqo"reXeUy 2?RgUrtg9qvrcqsRuRrqse`iqvq~Xrjc#g9otrqs©`jtysvwxj«

oVq>xjKÂgSxRe`r^qsxoVy~uxXjK qs rpRjveùRctotjygURfùxgSf`j`±d¤"pRjjd*qsjRxg'Re9crc#gU°ygURfùxgSf`jpxg9v

Ejj³Xj->xRjKygUrVjce` hgÀ0`"!}±<[rqsxoVysuxXjKvRgUr#gQ9qvrcq~RuRrq~e9(ªAjKgUruRcjKv"gUx(g=y´qsf`RjhjXr#v

RuRrXeXjKvRe9ruxvjrjhwXygUrjKv?g`ve`wRwxe?vjKreQ¬,b¨"±dÀ"^qv"gve`uRc#otjreve9uRc#otjrc#gSxv[ygU«

re9c72=qsrdqshwXysjhjXr#v¨rpRj"ez©9jcygUwote`xotjwRr"gUxve`hij¦vuRwRwxe`crª\e9c)q~cVcjf`uXygUc0ote9hwRuRr#gUrqse`xv±

Re`crVc#gU pxg`vixjj qsXqsrqgUrjK X\Q±k\jRRjKX ¶pRe y§gzq§ rpRjºª\e9uRxRgUrqse`ÂeSªrpRj

eU¶Rjc«A¶*cqsrjKvdcuXysjgUxirpRjcuRR«ArqshjcjKveSy~uRrq~e9rjKoVpRXqµ`uRj`±<[rpRjRe`crVc#gU ygURf`uxgUf9j`

gUcVc#g=vgUcVjg=y´qsf`RjK'¶¦q~rVp©9qscruxg=ydqsxXjtÂvwxg`otjKvogzy{ysjK XjKote`hiwxe?v[qsrqse`xv^rpxgSrgUcj9qvrcq~«

RuRrjK e` rVpRj¥wRceRotjKvve`ctv±¤"pXqviygURf`uxgUf9j(qvcVjty§gSrqs©`jtys oVyse?vj°re ¬b"±¨¤"pRj³ote`hiwXq{ysjc

wEjcª\e9chv¥ve`hje`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`xvºy´qs¯`j y~eXe`wEe`uRxRv°cjKXuxotrqse` gUx hjKvVvgUf`j©`jKotre9cqsÄKgU«

rqse`<Û¤vjK87![±

(11)

¤"pRjKvj(rpRcjj(jX©9q~cVe`RhjXr#vgUcj¥vrq´y{ywRce`re`rXwxjj?©9qsce`RhjXr#v)Re`Rj°eUª,rpRjh ogU

pxgUx9ysj'j-;(oVq~jXrysg ©`jc ygUcf9j vjreUªgUwRwXy´qogUrqse`xv"jKg`oVp eUªrpRjhnveSy~©9qsRf 9q=jcjXr

ote`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9wRce9Xy~jhv±"jKvjKgUctopRjc#v*ªAce`hrVpRj dÀ"^ gUx TVQW

@XZY2[

f`cVe`uRwxvgUcjQ¶"e`c«

¯9qsRf¶"qsrpXqs rpRjbdcjwxgUcVj¥²duRce`wEjKgU ²¨vwRcqsrbce`jKotr¶pRe?vj¥g=qshvQqvire'RuXq´y g'¬,b¨

wRce9f`c#gUhhÃq~Rfij?©9qsce`RhjXreUª)qsxXuxvrcqg=yµ`uxgzy{qsr m8"!}±

t#

¤"pRjote`hwXq´ysjc(uxvjKvQr¶"erjKopRXqµ9uRjKvref`jRjc#gUrVj N C,AO@

oteRXj(ªAce`hrpRj(uxvjc«}vuRwRwXy´qsjK

RgUrtg¥XjKote`hwEe?v[qsrqse` ¶"qsrp cjKvwEjKotrre°rpRjeU¶Rjc«A¶cq~rVjKvcVuXy~j`±d¤"pRjU>xc#vr^e`Rjiq§v^¯XReU¶

g`v.-5 /07 I43456/07 ~Àk\iff"!gUxºqvjhwXyseU`jKºqs'he?vrote`hwXq´ysjc#vªAe`c¬b)«®y´qs¯`jQygUR«

f`uxgSf`jKv32RrpXqv"rVjKopRXqµ9uRjXeXjKvRe`r"cjKµ9uXqscjote9hwXy´q§ogSrjK¥gUxgzy~Rv[qv¦ª\ce9h rVpRjote`hwXq´ysjcgUx

ogU xjuxvjK°¶"qsrp gU?ºqsRwRuRrwRce`f9c#gUh rewRcVeXuxotj(g9qvrVcqsRuRrjKoteRXjwRcjKvjc©`qsRf°rpRj

XjwEjxXjxotjKveUª)rpRj"qsRwRuRrwRce`f9c#gUh¥±` e`cwxgUctg=y´y~jty5yseXe`wxv¨e`c"cjKXuxotrqse`xv¨rpxgUr"ogUEjgSxgU«

ysXÄjKgUrote9hwXq´y~jrqshj`)ghe`cjve`wRpXqvrq§ogSrjK'rVjKopRXqµ9uRjqvuxvjKre(f`jRjc#gSrjQj-; oVqsj?r

N

C,AD@

ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`³gSx(ote`hwRuRr#gUrq~e9¥oteXjKv±

]Qdgf 8:9nj7^ HC> `m j^ j B _ H `m BI> 8Oj 9C>nm Hnj

¤"pRjgUwRwXy´q§ogSrqse`eSª0rpXqvxg9v[qovoVpRjhjcjKµ9uXqscjKvg(v[qshwXysj(gUxg=ysRv[qvªAce`hrpRjote`hwXq´ysjcK±

"e9uRf`pXysÂvwxjKgU¯9qsRfx¨rpRj(rjKoVpRXq§µ9uRj'ote`xv[qvr#vq~ rc#gUxvÏª\e`cVhQqsRf³jKg9opÂg`vVv[qsf`RhjXreUªrpRj

wRce9f`c#gUh L=ªAe`cdjKg`oVpcqsf`pXrdpxgUxvÏq§Xj

?

w3-Fcjtª\jcVjxotj,reg9qvrVcqsRuRrjKgScc#g=`UrpRj,ote`hiwXq{ysjc

f`jRjctgUrjKv5rpRj"gUwRwRce`wRcq§gSrj3 gUx. $!0vrtgUrjhjXr#vEre"jxvuRcj"ote?e`wEjc#gUrqse`^xjr¶"jj

rpRj(wRcVeotjKvve`c#vQeU¶XqsRf'cjKvwxjKotrqs©`jtysÂrVpRj +3gUx rpRjysjtªArpxgUx v[qXj

? 3-Fcjtª\jcVjxotj`±

¤"pRjErpRjote`hiwXq{ysjcqsxvjcrtv,gQhg`v¯(verpxgUr*rpRjg`vv[qsf`Rhij?r*qvwEjcª\e9chjKe`Xys(e`°rpRj

wRceRotjKvve9ceU¶XqsRf'rpRj 3cjtªAjcjxotj`±2qsf`uRcVj 8'vpRez¶vgS jt gUhiwXy~j(eSªg'v[qshwXysj(qsRwRuRr

wRce9f`c#gUh ¶"qsrp(rpRjote9ccjKvwEe`x9qsRfwxvjuxXe`«}oteRXjwRceRXuxotjK(¶¦q~rVp(rpRjcuRXrqshjcjKveUysuRrqse`

rjKoVpRXqµ`uRj`±

<}r*q§v*¶"jty´yI¯?ReU¶(rVpxgUrrpXqv*rjKopRXqµ9uRjQ`qsjtyRv*qsRj-; oVqsj?roteRXj`±xmv¨qsrogU¥Ejvjj°e`

>xf`uRcVjD8R`ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`xv¨gUcj"wxjcª\e`cVhjKQjtysjhjXrÏ¶¦q§vj,gUxQrpRj*j?rqscj¦q~rVjc#gUrqse`Xe`hgzq~

g`vVveoVqgUrVjK¶"qsrp^rpRj)qsRwRuRr)y~eXe`wq§v2vogURRjK^?g=y´y?rpRj¨wRceRotjKvve`c#v]LªAe`cjKg9opq~rVjc#gUrqse`vrVjw

jKg`oVpwRceotjKvVve`c"j©zg=ysuxgUrVjKvhg`v¯RvdreQ9q§vVotez©9jcq´ªqsr"pxg`v¨re^wxjcªAe`ch gote9hhQuRXq§ogSrqse`RgU

g`vVv[qsf`RhjXrKRe`cRe9rpXqsRfx±

(12)

!"$#%'&)(+*-,-.0/123457698: !";%'&)(+* ,-.=<>1?@A576

? B CDFEHGJI EHGLKM<>1?@A5N3%%'&)(+*-, .7/1234576

/13O5QP2R<>1?@A5 !";%'&)(+*-,-.0/123457698: !"$#%'&)(+* ,-.=<>1?@A576

CDFEHGS'E+T'EH0UE<1?VW5X0,%?YZ%'&)(+*-,-.4<1?VW576

!";%'&)(+*-,-.0/1234576[CDFE\GM/12O5FP]<1^@W5

2qsf`uRcj8qLx"uRXrqshjcjKveUysuRrqse`

]Qd c _ B a`nm0_om >AG ;=2k =:_X_gjC_DFBBb` (=?>C@ ^ j@AH `m B >

Z) =¡¹X½¾5 F

¤"pRjote9hwXqý~jc*e`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`(j-=e`cr"ote`xotjXrc#gUrjKvë`cjKXuxotrqse`xv*gUxwxgSc#g=yýsjtyyse?e`wxv¦¶"qsrp

e`RjvrtgUrjhjXrK±5¤"pXqv¯`qsxeUª¨yse?e`w°qv*ªAcjKµ`uRjXrysuxvjKºqsvoVqsj?rq>GoiwRce`f9c#gUhv32ª\uRcrVpRjc«

he9cj`x¶*pRj³rVpRj¥gUcjRe9r,jtRwXy´q§oVqsrys wRcjKvjXrKErpRjKvjyseXe`wxvogUxjQwRceRXuxotjK°rpxgUR¯Rvre

gUuRrVe`hgUrqoºwxgUc#g=y´ysjty´q~ÄKgSrqse`rjKoVpRXqµ`uRjKv± e`cjtxgUhwXysj`g;Rj«AXX«}vr#gUrjhij?rvVopRjKXuXy´qsRf

*`R gSc#`"!GogU(EjgSwRwXy{qsjKºe`yseXe`wRjKvr#v¨¶"qsrp(uRXq´ª\e9ch e`c0g;RjXjwEjxXjxotjKvgUx

wRceRXuxotjKv(g'vjKµ9uRjXrqg=y,yseXe`w qsxXjtRjK ? rqshj`¨¶pRe?vj(EeX qvote`hwxeXvjK eUªwxgUc#gzy{ysjty

yseXe`wxv¶¦q~rVp¥e`RjvrtgUrjhjXrK±

mv5rVpRje`wRrqshQqsÄjK^hjrpReR¶"jdpxg=©`jXj©`jtyse`wEjKq§v)xg9vjKe`rVpRjQ dc6- ^heRXjty=¶"j

vuRwRwEe?vjQrpxgUrgUcc#g=cjtª\jcVjxotjKv,gUx yse?e`w°xe`uRxRvgScjg;RjªAuRxotrqse`xveSª·rpRj^jxoVyse?v[qsRf

qsx9qotjKv±*Àe`xotjcXqsRfRgUrtg³9qvrVcqsRuRrqse`d¶"j g9vvuRhj(rpxgSrgUcctgKRvgScjwxgScrqsrqse`RjK qs?rVe

XyseRo¯Rv¶"qsrp ote9xvr#gUXrv[qsÄj 2"rpRj°e`wRrqshQqsÄjK vopRjhij(qv(XjKvotcqsxjK ¶pRj jKg`oVpÂXyseRo¯ qv

eU¶RjKº?e`Xys¥e`RjwRcVeotjKvve`c,RuRr*rpRjrjKoVpRXqµ`uRjogU°xj^rcqs©`qg=y´ys¥jtRrjxXjK°repxgSx9y~j

XyseRo¯^cjwXy´q§ogSrqse`±6S¨jKogUuxvj"rpRj"hgSwRwXq~RfeSªrpRj"XyseRo¯Rv2qv)Re`rIrtgU¯`jqsXreg`oote`uRXr·XuRcqsRf

rpRj°e`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse` wRceRotjKvvdj©`jcVhgSwRwXq~Rf qvvuRwRwEe`crjK ª\e`cQrpRj°XyseoV¯vieUªgSÂgUcc#g=`±

m*y´q~f9Rhj?r¦q§v¨Re`rg=©zgzq{ygUXysjqs(rpRj TVQW

@XZY2[

ygURf`uxgSf`jverpXqvª\jKgSruRcj*q§v¨Re`r¨wRcjKvjXrys

rcVjKgUrjK5±52q~xgzy{ys` q~rvpReùXyEjQRe`rjK(rVpxgUr,rVpRjgUxg=ysRv[qvogUccqsjK°eùRr*qs³rVpRjÃote9hwXqý~jcqv

vXhQxeUy´qoU5rpxgUr¨qv*revg=QqsxXjwxjxXjXreSª·rpRjXuRhQxjceUªdXy~eRoV¯v*eUªdrpRjgUcc#g=Rvq~X©`eUys©`jK

qs¥rVpRjwxgUc#gzy{ysjtyyseXe`w¥e9crpRjcjKXuxotrqse`±

<}rVpXq§v)ctgUrpRjcf`jRjctg=y`ªAc#gUhj¶"e`c¯5te`uRc)e`wRrqshQqsÄjKQote`hwXq´ygUrqse`voVpRjhjjhQxjKRvdvj©`j«

c#gzyGe`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrq~e9xv0vuxopg9vdcjKvrVcqotrqse`eUª5qsrjc#gUrq~e9 Xe`hg=qsxvgUxQhijKvvgUf`j*©`jKotre`cqsÄKgUrq~e9±

(13)

i¹ §¡R¹R¿ ¾G

rpRjcijt?qvrqsRf ote`hwXq´ysjc#vÃª\e`c¬b)«®y´qs¯`j(ygURf9uxgUf`jKvQeUªArj r#gScf`jrg³y§gScf`jcgUwRwXy´qogUrqse`

Xe`hg=qs¥rpxgU TVQW

@XZY2[

wRcjKvjXrys¥XeXjKv

?

vuxoVp³g`v¦wRce`f`c#gShv¨¶"qsrp(qsccjf9uXy§gScyseXe`wxv-FgUx

rpXuxv"uxvj©UgUcqse`uxv*rc#gUxvÏy§gSrqse`¥gUxjtRjKotuRrqse`¥rjKoVpRXqµ`uRjKv±G¬*eU¶0j©9jcKRote`xotjcXqsRfrVpRje`wR«

rqshQqsÄKgUrq~e9eUªcjf9uXy§gScwxgUc#gzy{ysjty¨y~eXe`wxv2rpxgUrqvqsgªAc#gUhj¶"e`cV¯¥ote`hwxgUc#gSXy~jre(rpRjie`Rj

XjKvotcq~EjKgSxeU©`j`ErpRjote`hiwXq{ysj«Arqshj(gUxg=ysRv[qvrpRj¥wEjcªAe`chgUr,wRcVjKvj?rogUxjgUwRwXy´qsjK

e`gQhe`cVjcjKvrVcqotrjK¥oVyg`vv*eUª)yse?e`w°xe`uRxRvg`ootjKvv"wxgUrVrjcxvgUx¥9qvrcq~RuRrq~e9xv±<[rpRj

d*qsjRxg Re`crVc#gU Àe`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9 ^`Rvrjh

?

F SÀ gG`"!}drpRjyseXe`w xe`uRxRvgUx rpRj

gUcVc#g= g`ootjKvVv"ªAuRxotrqse`xvgUcjQg;Rjª\uRxotrqse`xveSªe`RjjxoVyse?v[qsRfqsxXjt±2<}rpRj e`crctgU

ote`hiwXq{ysjcK2rpRjcVjKvrcqotrqse`xvgUcVjrpRjª\eUy´yseU¶"qsRfL5rpRj^yse?e9w³Ee`uRxRvhQuxvrxjote`xvr#gS?rK rpRj

gUcVc#g=g`ootjKvv·ª\uRxotrq~e9xv0gScjeUªrpRj"ªAe`ch

?

qv¨gyse?e9wqsxXjt gUxg^ote`xvr#gS?rd¯XReU¶

gUrote9hwXq´y~j«Arq~hijlFgSx¥e9Xy~e`Rj9qshjxv[qse` eUªgU'gUcc#g=¥ogUxj9q§vrcqsRuRrjK5±I e`cxe9rp

ote`hiwXq{ysjc#vgUcc#g=Rv¨qs?©`eSy~©9jK(qsrpRjQwxgUc#gzy{ysjtydyseXe`w¥hQuxvrxjQhgUwRwEjKºq~'vuxoVp³gi¶g=(rpxgUr

jKg`oVpwRceRotjKvve`ce`Xys(eU¶xve9RjXyseoV¯¥eSª0gU³gUcVc#g=`RpRjxotjQrpRj¥ogU¥Re9r,pxgUx9ysjQf`jRjc#gzy

otRoVy´q§o^9qvrcqsRuRrqse`±RRuRcVrpRjche`cVj``xe9rp ote9hwXq´y~jctvwEjcªAe`ch gXe`hg=qs gUxgzy~Rv[qvª\e9cjKg`oVp

wRceRotjKvve9cK9y~jKg99q~RfregQote`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9¥rqshjrpxgSr¦XjwEjxRve9(rpRj,XuRhQxjceSª·wRceRotjKvve9c#v±

<}

Rote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`¥oteRXjf`jRjc#gUrqse`(gUx(ote`hihuRXqogUrq~e9(e`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`

?

g`v

¶"jtyý¦g`v^vre`ctgUf`jg=yýseogUrq~e92FcVjty~ e`gU&!##--& dc343±Re9cjKgòp wRceotjKvVve`cgSxªAe`c

jKg`oVp gScc#g=gUwRwEjKgUcqsRf'qs rpRj w3?)rpRj°ez©9jcygUwÂgUxg=ysRv[qvg=qshvgUrgUwRwRce=XqshgUrqsRf rpRj

uRXqse`eUªrpRjvjreSªxyseogzyGjtysjhjXr#v"gUxQrpRj,vjrdeUªI9q§vr#gUXrdjty~jhij?r#v¨RjjKXjKi?QgcjKotrtgUR«

f`uXygUcvjKotrqse`

?

!#$- K-lF#±'SjKogSuxvjQrpRjote`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9'rjKoVpRXq§µ9uRjQcjty´qsjKve`°rpRj N C,AD@

heRXjty})rpRjQez©9jcygUwgUcjKgiªAe`cgU'gUcVc#g=(qvXj->xRjK g`vrpRjvhg=y´ysjKvrcjKotrtgURf`uXygUcvjKotrqse`

rpxgSr¦ogS ote`Xr#g=qs(g=y´yrpRjeU©`jcygUwgUcVjKg`v"ote`hwRuRrjKÃª\e9c0jKg9opwRceRotjKvve`cK±EÀe9hhQuRXq§ogSrqse`

oteRXjQf`jRjc#gUrqse`'gUx°ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`e`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrq~e9¥ªAe`cgU³gScc#g= gScjrpRjwxjcªAe`chijK5

XjwEjx9q~Rf e` rVpRj³gUxg=ysRv[qveUªrpRjºq~Xrjc#vjKotrqse`xvEjr¶0jj rpRj°eU©`jcygUwÂgUcjKg gUx rpRj

9qvr#gS?rXyseRo¯Rv±Re9c,rpRjQf`jRjctgUrqse`eUª0rVpRjote`hwRuRrtgUrqse`'oteXj`5rVpRjÃote9hwXq´y~jc^wxjcªAe`chv

g(vXhQxeUy´qoÃy~eXe`wxe9uRxRvcVjKXuxotrqse`L5rpRjRj¶!yseXe`w'xe9uRxRvXjwxjxRv^e`rpRjQwRceRotjKvve9c

qXjXrqsrÏ`±

¤"pRjRe`crVc#gU ote`hwXq´ysjcwxjcªAe`chvXe`hg=qs'gUxg=ysRv[qvuxv[qsRf¥cjKotr#gSRf`uXygUc«ArcqgURf9uXy§gSc

vjKotrq~e9xvog=y´y~jK K#5 3 #/07 q37±RRe9c,jKg`oVp w3cjtªAjcjxotj

?

F !IgUxªAe`cjKg`oVp¥wxg=qsceUª

wRceRotjKvve9c#v

?

F#UrpRj,ote`hiwXq{ysjc,ogSccqsjKvde`uRr"ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`(oteXj*f`jRjc#gUrqse`(gUxote9h«

hQuRXqogUrqse` e`wRrq~hÃq~ÄKgSrqse` rpxgUR¯Rv re rpRj ote`hwRuRrtgUrqse` eUªr¶"e q~xXjt vjr#v4L

+ ?

?

F!

FgSx "!

?

F!

#

F#±X¤"pRjKvjvjr#v¨Xj->xRjrpRjqsx9qotjKv%$eUª&vuxoVp

rpxgSr

huxvrdcjKotjtqs©`j'($?!Xª\cVe`h

?

+ F gSx

hQuxvrvjx($?!Rre ?

"!HF#±U"jf?gUc#9qsRf

ote`hiwRuRr#gUrqseòteRXjf`jRjc#gUrqse`9rpRj,ote`hiwXq{ysjcwEjcªAe`chv·y~eXe`wEeùRxRv¨cjKXuxotrqseìª\e9cjKgòVp

wRceRotjKvve9c

±?¤"pXqv¨cjKXuxotrqse`qv¨xg`vjKie`rpRjote9hwRuRr#gUrqse`ieUªrpRjqsrjctgUrqse`(vjrg`vveRoVqgU«

(14)

rjKi¶"qsrp(rpRj.3dcjtªAjcjxotj4

?

F !}UrpxgSrdqvXrpRjvjr"eUªqsrjc#gUrq~e9xvrVpxgUr0ogUuxvj+

?

F !Ere

g`ootjKvVv,RgUrtgeU¶RjKX

±

rpRjc,e9wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`rjKoVpRXq§µ9uRjKv*ªAeotuxv[qsRfe`¥wxgSc#g=y´ysjtyIyseXe`we`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`gUx(uxv[qsRf

rpRj"wEeUys?pRjKXce9heRXjtyGgUcj"g=yvexjtqsRfq~X©`jKvrq~fXgUrjK(<[mÀk\8"!RRuRrgUcVj0Re9rqshwXysjhjXrjK

`jr=±

m9q=jcjXrgUwRwRcVe?g`oVpRrpxgUr¨qvRjtqsrpRjcxg9vjKe`¥wxgSc#g=y´ysjtyIyseXe`w(e`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`Re`c*e`

rpRjQeU¶Rjc«A¶*cqsrjKvcVuXy~j`Eqv^vjr,e9uRrqs m 8"!}±5¤"pXqvrjKoVpRXqµ`uRjpxgSx9y~jKvyse?e`wRjKvrtv¶"qsrp

g;Rjy~eXe`w xe`uRxRvigUx g`ootjKvvªAuRxotrqse`xvgUx r#gS¯`jKvg`vqsRwRuRrgRgUr#gXjKote`hiwxe?v[qsrqse`

gUxigote`hwRuRrtgUrqse`XjKote`hiwxe?v[qsrqse`±<}r"opxgUctg`otrjcqsÄjKvnN C,AD@

ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`(vjr#v

?

uxv[qsRf

/0lR"% Ac33FdgUxrpRjN C,AO@

ote`hwRuRrtgUrqse`¥vjr¶¦q~rVp(wxeUysXpRjKXce`xv5ote`hwRuRrjKv¦rpRj

yseXe`wxvrpxgUrQjXuRhjc#gUrj°rpRjKvjvjr#vgUx rpRjÂwEjcªAe`chvP- 3o27/0/07 # re'wRceRXuxotjrpRj

>xxg=yr#gUcf`jrQoteXj`±¨¤"pXqvQrjKoVpRXq§µ9uRj(pxg`vQRe9rEjj ª\uXy´ys qs?rVjf`c#gUrjK qsÂgote`hwXq´ysjc(gUx

vjjhvrexjgSwRwXy{qogUXysj(e`Xys°q´ª0rpRjote`hwXq´ysjcogU'j-=jKotrqs©`jtyspxgUx9ysjgiyse`r^eUªwxe?vVv[qsXy~

ote`hiwXy~jt'wEeUys?pRjKXce9xvgUx°q´ª¨y~eXe`w'vwXy´qsrrqsRf'Xe?jKvRe9ry~jKg9¥rVe¥gUuRxg`ootjwRr#gUXysjr#gScf`jr

oteRXjªAc#gUf`hij?r#gSrqse`±

MH<F `¡RF§¾ ^ =¾ ¢S¹=

m ote`hwXysjrjXjKvotcqswRrqse` eSª¥rpRjote`hwXq´ygUrqse` voVpRjhj eUª TVQW

@XZY2[

ogU.Ej ªAe`uRx

qs bEm8"!}±<[rVpXq§v^wxgUwEjcK)¶"je`XysXjKvotcqsEj(eùRcgUwRwRcVe?gòVp'rpRceùRf9p'rpRjjt gUhiwXy~jeUª

rpRj [ ªgòtrVe`cqsÄKgUrqse`¥g=ysfè9cqsrpRh fSq~©9jq~ >xfùRcjQR±

2q~ctvrKXcjKXuxotrqse`xvgSxwxgUc#g=y´ysjtyIyseXe`wxv"¶"qsrp(e9RjvrtgUrjhjXr"RjjK(reQxjqXjXrq>xjK

?

g`v

XjwEjxXjxotjrVjKvr#vgScjRe`r"`jrq~xoVysuxXjK q~(rVpRjote`hiwXq{ysjcK ¶0j*cjtyse`uxvjcgURRe`r#gUrq~e9xv-F#±

<[rpRj [ ª}gòtre9cqsÄKgUrqseÙrpRj8&X«®yse?e`wiqv¨Re`rwxgUctg=yý~jtyIve^rpRj"qsrjc#gSrqse` Xe9hg=qs g9vveRoVq§gSrjK

qv^cjwXy´qogUrjK e`gzy{yrpRjiwRceotjKvVve`c#v±rVpRje`rpRjc^pxgUx5rpRjiqsRRjcHA«®yse?e9w gUx

?

F[«

yseXe`w"wxgUc#gUhijrjcqsÄjK X &50gScj¥wxgUctg=y´y~jty}±¤"pXuxvdrVpRj³ote`hwXq´ysjc³gSwRwXy{qsjKvrpRj°e`wRrqshQqsÄjK

ote`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9voVpRjhjªAe`c(Ee`rpeUªQrpRjh¥±¤"pRj cjhg=qsXqsRfÂeUªQrpXqv¥vjKotrq~e9 Xjr#g=q´yv°rpRj

oteRXjf`jRjc#gSrqse`(ªAe`crpRj

?

F[«®y~eXe`w±x¤¦pXq§voteRXjote`hwRcqvjKvgote`hhQuRXqogUrqse` wxgUcrgUx

gote9hwRuRr#gUrqse`(wxgScrK±

¾ ¢U¡RF§¾ ¾¿¹¹G¹R =¡RFs¾

¤"pRjote`hiwXq{ysjc¨wRceXuxotjKv¨g,vjKµùRjxotjeSªGote`hhQuRXqogUrqseòteXjKvUe`Rjote`hhQuRXqogUrqseòteXj

Ejtq~RfXj->xRjK°ªAe`c,jKg9opaw3cjtªAjcjxotjQre g9qvrcqsRuRrjK gUcctgKiqsrpRj

?

F[«®y~eXe`w¥g`vVv[qsf`R«

hjXrK±X²g`oVpote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`(oteRXjqv"ote`hwEe?vjKQeUªIg^vjxwxgScrgUxgXuxg=y5cjKotjtqs©`j,wxgScrK±

e`c0vgS¯`jeUªRcj©9qsrÏ`X¶"j¶"q´y´y5ª\eRotuxvde9rpRj*wRceXuxotrq~e9(eUªrpRj,ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`(oteRXj,cjtygU«

rjKire^rpRj ,&

!RcjtªAjcjxotj`±RÀëXjKvªAe`crpRj*e`rpRjccVjtª\jcjxotjKv"ogUxjrpRjjKg`v[qýs.>xfùRcjK

e`uRr=±

(15)

2q~ctvrKdvuRxvotcqswRr#vigUxgScc#g=wxgUcrqsrqse`XqsRfgUxgzy~Rv[qv^qvQwEjcª\e9chjK ªAe`c3cVjtª\jcjxotj

,

!GgUx +3"cjtªAjcjxotj&

!GveirpxgUrrpRjote9hwXq´y~jcote9xvrcuxotr#v¦rpRjvRvrjh eUªg ;Rj

ote`xvrc#g=qsXr#v4L

& kKX

& k=X

& k kKX

& k

kKX

&

& &

? &

&

F`qsQ¶pXqoVprpRj0gScc#g=,jtysjhjXr

!}

yseRogUrjKqs°rpRjXyseoV¯XuRhQxjc & eUª ^9qvRjjKXjKºreQwxjcªAe`ch rVpRj¶cqsrqsRf?v"e`(rVpRjrpRj

XyseRo¯'XuRhQxjcH& ¨eUª ?

gUcc#g= qvwxgScrqsrqse`RjK q~Xre kKfiy´qsRjKvQ?uRhQEjcjK°ªAce`h ºre

¶pXqoVpQqv)rpRjwRcVe`jKotrjKQg=yse`Rf,rVpRj V

g=Xqv32=rpXqv)cjKvuXysr#v2qsgRj¶wEeUys?pRjKXce9

¶pReXvj

jXuRhjc#gUrq~e9³oteRXjqvote`hwRuRrVjK(XrpRjhijrpRe°XjKvotcqsxjKºqs 5jKdU!}±R¤"pXqv9qsjtyRvrpRj

RjKvrVjKyse?e9wL

¾5 &

& k k=X

¾5 3&

& &

¾G

& &

¾G

& k kK

cjtªAjcjxotj ,&

![±7 e`c)rpRj0vjxioteXj¨ªAe`cqsxvrtgUxotj`UrpRj0ote9hwXq´y~jcqsxvjcr#v34# '0vrtgUrjhjXr#v

gUxgUwRwRcVe`wRcqgUrjQhg`v¯v¨qs'rVpRjyse?e9w ve(rpxgUrrpRjQhgSwRwXq~Rf(eSªrpRjQXy~eRoV¯v*qvr#gU¯9j(qs?rVe

g`oote9uR?r,gSrcuRXrqshjL

¾5 &

& k kK

c3$

eU¶Rjc Xy~eRoV¯

? & gF

¾G 3&

& &

c#34#$

eU¶Rjc XyseRo¯

? & F

¾G

& &

¹ ¿

!! 1&"Âk#

kKX

rVeeU¶Rjc XyseoV¯

? & gF

mysrpRe`uRf9prpXqv2yse?e`wote`?rtg=qsxv)hg`v¯Rv=qsr)qv)qshwxe9cr#gUXrIrVeRe`rqotjrpxgUr)rpRjKvj*hg`v¯RvIgScj

(16)

kKX 5

? &

& F}«®yseXe`w±

Rce`h rVpRj XjKvVotcqswRrqse` eSªrpRjjtysjhjXr#v

!re xjvj?rK"rVpRj³cVuR?rqshj y{qsRc#gSc

*qscjKotrote9hhQuRXq§ogSrqse`(qv*wxjcªAe`chjK¶*pRj¥wxeXvv[qsXysjL5¶pxgUr"qv"rctgUxv[ªAjccjKiqs¥rpXqv

rpXuxvjty´qshQqsxgUrqsRfgUXÂRjjK eUªoteR9q~RfzXjKote9qsRf e`c(ote`wX`qsRf xjr¶"jj hjKvvgSf`j

Ru=jc#vgUx y~eRog=yIhijhe`cqsjKv±

°jKvvgUf`jgUf`f`cjfXgUrqse`°qvg=yve³ogSccqsjK'e9uRrgUx cjKXuxotjKvQrpRjij-= jKotrQeUª"ygUrjxot ?

f`ce`uRwXqsRf(vhg=y´yhjKvvVgUf`jKv¨qsXreg^ygUcf9jhjKvvgUf9j`±

rerpRjvVgUhj9qvrcqsRuRrjK°gUcc#g=gSwRwxjKgUc#v¦qs¥rpRjcq~f9p?rpxgSx¥v[qXj`±

¾ < G¡RF§¾ ¾¿¹ ¹ 5¹ =¡RF§¾

¤"pRj"N C,AD@

ote`hwRuRr#gUrq~e9oteRXjdqvf9jRjc#gUrjK^g`v5ªAeUy´yseU¶,v4LrpRj"ote`hwXq´ysjc0gUxgzy~XÄjKv)vuRxvotcqswRr#v

gUx°gUcc#g=wxgScrqsrqse`XqsRfªAe`c"rpRjI3cjtªAjcjxotj ,

!xreQRuXq´yrpRjvjreSªote`xvrc#g=qsXr#v4L

& kKX

& k kKX

& k

kKX

& &

? &

?

Fdqvvuxop rpxgUr)3cj«

ªAjcjxotj ,

!d¶*cqsrjKvq~ XyseRo¯ & eSª"^±d¤"pRj(jXuRhjc#gUrqse` oteRXjª\e`c^rpRj(wxeSy~XpRjKXce`

qs¥rVpRjote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`oteXjf9jRjc#gUrqse`L

¾5 &

&Âk

kKX

¾5 3

& &

¾G

&Âk

kKX

Rce`h rpXqv¨RjKvrjKiyse?e9w?rVpRjote`hiwRuRr#gUrqse`oteRXjqvZ>xxg=y´y~f`jRjc#gSrjKXQqsxvjcrq~RfgU

g`XjKµ9uxgUrj^hg`v¯verpxgUr*rpRjeU¶Rjc«A¶cqsrjKv¦cuXysjqv"jxvuRcjK2L

(17)

¾5 &

&Âk

kKX

c3$

eU¶Rjc Xy~eRoV¯

? & HF

¾G 3

& &

¾G

&Âk

kK

,

! ,

& !

&

!

mvqsrVpRjote`hihuRXqogUrq~e9 oteRXj`Xe`RjogSRe`rjrpxgUr¨rpRj,XuRhQxjc¨eUªIrjKvrtvdwxjcª\e`cVhjK

kKXX±

* + #/x+) 1+0 2Q/

Qdgf ^ =L`m BI>A=:_oj

"jwRcVjKvj?rtgUrqseèUª09qvrcqsRuRrjK gUcc#g=Rvg`v"¶"jtyýg9v,gòotjKvVvjKvrejtysjhjXr#veUªrpRjKvjgUcctgKRv

ote`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9 vVopRjhjqv"uxvjtysjKvv*q´ªRej-=e`cr¨qv,Xe9Rje`¥rpRjhgUxgUf`jhjXreUªd9q§vrcqsRuRrjK

gUcVc#g=vqs¥rjcVhv"eUªdrqshjj-; oVqsjxot³gSxhjhe`ccjKµ9uXqscjhjXrK±

e`wEjc#gUrqse`xvvuxoVp¥g`v gUxS

f`e9cqsjKv4LGg9ootjKvvjKv*reQyseogzy·jtysjhjXr#vq}±j`±Ejtysjhj?rtv,g`vVv[qsf`RjK(re

X(rpRj9qvrVcqsRuRrqse`

ote`hiwXq{ygUrq~e9³voVpRjhjf`jRjc#gSrjKv"oteXjqs(¶pXqoVp¥ote`hhQuRXqogUrqse`qvvjwxgUctgUrjKÃª\ce9h ote9h«

wRuRr#gSrqse` gUx Re 9q=jcjxotjºqvQhg`XjqsÂrVpRj¥ote`hwRuRr#gUrq~e9ÂoteXj°xjr¶"jjÂg`ootjKvvjKvire

uxvjK

?

ªAe`cdqsxvrtgUxotj,Xg=y´yseogUrq~RfgvuRR«}gUcVc#g=ªAe`c)yseRog=yIRgUr#ggSxQhgUxgUfSq~Rf^Ru=jc#v"gUx

gUr*cuR?rq~hijªAe`cjKg9opg`ootjKvv¨qse`c#Xjcreuxvj^rpRjgSwRwRce`wRcqgUrjg9ootjKvvhijKopxgUXqvh°xcjKXuR«

oVqsRfrpRjxjRj->xr*eUªIrpRje`wRrqshQqsÄKgUrqse`xv¦hg`Xj?rVpRjote`hiwXq{ysjcK±q<}rvpRe`uXyxjg9RXjKrpxgUr

oteRXjªAc#gUf`hij?r#gSrqse`±

(18)

rcq~RuRrq~e9'wxgUc#gUhijrjc#v

?

Re`r*ªAce`hrpRjoteRXjqsr#vjty{ªFgUx°rpXuxvote`xv[qXjcrVpxgUre`Xys¥fUyse`xgzy

qsx9qotjKvgUwRwEjKgUcqs rpRjf`jRjc#gSrjKoteXj`±)¤"pXqvqsxXjwEjxXjxotj(ª}g`oVq´y{qsr#gSrjKv^rpRjuxvjeSª¦9q´ª\«

rpXqs rpRj(vote`wEj(eUªe`Rj¥9qvrcqsRuRrqse`±Z<} rpXqvog`vj`dRgUr#gºcjKgUcctgURf`jhjXre`cQg`R9qsrqse`xg=y

gUcVc#g=hgUxgUf9jhj?rvopRjhijregURe`rVpRjcK±

m,Re`rVpRjcduxvjtª\uXyRwRce`wEjcrote`xotjcVXq~RfrVpRjyg=`e`uRr)eUªG9qvrcq~RuRrVjKgUcVc#g=vEqv)rpRjote`xvjc«

Qd c ^ jL_ =L`j@ba BBkc

XjXrysªAce`h ote`hwXqýgUrqse` rjKoVpRXqµùRjKvqs'jtXq§vrqsRf ¬b)«®y´qs¯`jQygURf9uxgUf`jKvote9hwXqý~jctv±d¤"pRj

>xc#vrrjKopRXqµ9uRjeSª¦vre9c#gUf`jª\e`c9qvrVcqsRuRrjKgScc#g=ve/76I!#- hgS-5iff"!Ipxg`vxjjqsh«

wXysjhjXrjKºqs¥rpRjid*qsjRxg e`crc#gS¥Àe9hwXq´y§gSrqse` ^`Rvrjh gÀ0`"!IgUxiqs°rpRjRe`cVrc#gU

cjKvrcqotrjK(XuRhQxjceUª9q§vrcqsRuRrqse`xvgUx(g`ootjKvVvwxgUrVrjcxvgUxhgKiysjKg`(rVerpRjcjwXy´qogU«

?

Ru=jc#vgUxºpxg`vpr#gUXysjKv-F"¶pRj°qsrogUvjwxgUc#gSrj

yseRog=yjtysjhj?rtvgUx°rjhwEe`c#gUcq~jKvgScjwxg`oV¯`jKg`oote`ct9q~Rf(rVe(rpRjgUcc#g=(9q§vrcqsRuRrqse` gUx

g=y´qsf`RhjXrK)rpRjQyseXe`w'Ee`uRxRvQgUx'rVpRjgUcc#g=¥vuRxvVotcqswRr#v^?'oVpxgURfUqsRfrpRjxg`v[qveUªrpRj

e`cq~fSq~xgzyGqsxXjt¥vwxg`otj`±XmootjKvvjKv"re^jtysjhj?rtv0gScj,wEjcªAe`chjKÃqs¥gRe`R«AuRXq´ªAe`ch ¶g=Q¶"qsrp

rjcÏjj #/-´À5 ^?¤8"!wRce9wxe?vj¥gS g`ootjKvvÃhjKopxgSXq§vh ª\e`c^yseRog=yjtysjhjXr#vixg`vjK e`

g2qsXqsrj ^`r#gSrjg`oVpXq~Rj

?

^? Ft±I¤"pRjKvjjtysjhjXr#vgUcj(g`ootjKvvjK ?'jtRjKotuRrqsRfg^?