Droit communautaire de la concurrence et commerce électronique

(1)

RESEARCH OUTPUTS / RÉSULTATS DE RECHERCHE

Author(s) - Auteur(s) :

Publication date - Date de publication :

Permanent link - Permalien :

Rights / License - Licence de droit d’auteur :

Bibliothèque Universitaire Moretus Plantin

Institutional Repository - Research Portal

Dépôt Institutionnel - Portail de la Recherche

researchportal.unamur.be

University of Namur

Droit communautaire de la concurrence et commerce électronique

Jacquemin, Hervé

Published in:

Revue Européenne de Droit de la Consommation

Publication date:

2003

Document Version

le PDF de l'éditeur

Link to publication

Citation for pulished version (HARVARD):

Jacquemin, H 2003, 'Droit communautaire de la concurrence et commerce électronique', Revue Européenne de

Droit de la Consommation, Numéro 1, p. 28-56.

General rights

Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain

• You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ?

Take down policy

If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.

(2)

r

c - ,,="-~~

:~"

"

" Doctrine '" -:3:;r."'--Q.""'O(')~'~ 3 ""~:3-"'Q.~(")~

-:r.

CD..r-1 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 _.a ~ -~, e:.. 0 ~ ~, 1:: -o. Z -""' ~ 3 ~ 3 N ~ 0 ;1> s ...~ f); ;;1 g :3 ~ .tT1 ~ '" ~ ~ == 1:: 8 ~. ~. ~ :3 r-' -t ~ CD ~ o g, ~ " ~ 8~ co ~ 3 ~ -.D .D ..:6' .--Q. :;' ~,.D :3 ~ :3 ~. :3 Q. ~ ~ ~ " n ~ ~ Ô.D o. a =;. 3 ~ ~

...

C 1:: go 1:: ~ -' Q -5. ~ ~ ~ (") Q 0 ~ :3 (")0 0 .~ !:!" rl-' "~"'I:'CO".CO '"'. '--,-, ' ""-~ C --: ' ~ fn' SI' ~ ~ co 0. = ~ '0 ad ~ =.: 0". ". :3 _.~ ~ -'" :- -~ ën 'i:6 3 ).. 0 n ~ ~ § ~ ~ ~ ~;, g ~: f); :. § ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g, ~ ~ '-g g ~ 33 (D" 1 3 ~ ,8 ~. 0 ~ ~ o.. .(b. z ~ ~ ."" (") "'~' ~ _.~ 0 ~ C (") ~ '" '0 ~ -t c: ..0:3 " 0. "" .:... ~ ~ ~ ~ 1:: _

o

.~.D (") ~, -~ ;::0 ~ :3 S! ~. ...~ (") ~ ~, ~ (=! 0 -rT1 ,.. 0 -.<: " .., ,.. ~ 1:: C 0 -~ .-+ '-' :=; " ~. (") :=; (") ...S:'" ~ 3 ~ s: ~ .g 0. -:'< ~ ~ :3 :;' f); 3 ~ ~ ~ .--~ o' g ~ ~ ...~ 0 '0 ::r 0' ~ Z -CD:3 ~. g e-~ h ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f); g. 3 ~. (") 0 ~3-;? ; :3 ;; ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ :2 ~. 'fi ~ S ~~~~l:c3~ ...'" ("):3 0 ~ :3 Q.I::""- -"" -"",-", g. § a g: S' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, 0 3 Q. ~ ~ ~o ~ ~ ~. f); ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f); ~ â ~ .., 0. = = c::. c ~ ~ '" (JQ ~:3""... ~ Q. ~ .D' .'" ~ Q. ~ (") 0". :3 ...t-E." ~ .., 8 ~ tA' 0. ~ (D" '0 ~ 3 ~ ~,(JQ @, 1:: :3 0". :3 '2. _.~, 0 :;r..:6' Il) ~ g'O E. 3 :!'" ~ ~ :3 '" Q ~ 'E ~ _.a. :;r. ~ ~ ~ g § (")0 ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ 1:: -. ~ -1: ~ ~ _.~ 3 ~ .-+ ---~ ~ :3 --'" '"

3

1 ~ ~ ;v (b""1 '" , ~ .D ~ '0 ~ ~ 1:: ,., _.~ ?,; _.Q. 3 ~ c:T 0 ro ="'g co 8 5' ~ g. ~ 3 3 'g 0 '" ~ f); 0". (") :3:3 ~ ~ ~ 1:: :3 ~ Q. :3 ~ '" ~ 3 fO '-' ~ 0". ~ -_.<' 1:: 0 ::r (") C!9 0 1:: 0". ~ (") ~ ~ Q.. ~~~ ..,'.., ~ 3 :30 '" :3 0-1::'"' ~""o--,"'(") '" '" '?:' "g ~ g. ~ OQ Q. ~ Q. 8 '"" ~3 3 ~ '" a -b:3 ~ ~ _.~ ro::J °e- ~~ ~ -"' ".,'" -0(") ~. .~-:3'" :'J 3 ~ 5. a: co '" Q. ; '0 f); ~ Q 9. ~ 1:: '0 3 ' 0 ~ '" Q. :3 ~ ?< CD" ~ n:;-::~ ~'<~O= -~I::~ (")""""~ 3 Q.1::~':3~ "'~ ~ '" 0 ::r=o. = I::Q. -.""(")(") .:3 '" ~:3~,~n~Q. n"" ...,g~;;;-_. 0' o~<:~ (D"~0~~~~t"'"~~. ~""~~~~~ 0 < ",'O~'" ~-°3 '.""~1:: ,,(") 1:: e-~co~'" 3 """':3' 3 ~(") ~ _.(")~""' 0 :3 ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ (=). ~ c:T 3 ::r '"' ~ ~ 1:: ='"' ~ '0 0 ~ ,. -' ~ go ~ g. ;tj~. ~. '" '" ~ g '1't. ~~, ~ ~. ~ a :3 D. ~ '0 3 1:: '" Q. n ôJ ~ 3 ~ ~.g -0 ~ 0 "" § ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :3 ~ CD" e:. ~ ~ <: ~ ~' t: 0. = co ;;. fn' ~ .--C ...0 Q. Q. ~ ~ 0". '" 3 '" ~ ",':3 ~ '" ~ '" ~ ~ a:co5~0 ~ '""::3 ~'~ ~ ~ 1::'2.~ 0 Q.~;Q.~ Q.'" f;; Q.~ 0 0" ro g ~ ~ c::. = ~ ~ ~ ~ '"":.D ~ S' :3 ~ ...~.(=! ~ (") ~ :3 '0 2:. co :: ~,,~ ~ o' i' o' S 1:: ~. ~ ~ Q. ~ ~ ~ C '" f;; ~ (") 3 ~,'O ~ ~ ::r N 03 0 :3 _.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~"""",~"'" 0 ~ OQ ~ n = ~

§

"., ~ ~, (") ~ '"' "" (")

3

-~ ...ro 0 co '< '0 r ~ &.. ~ ~ ën'.D -;::0 0.-- 0 ~ ~ 0" ::r ~... ~... ~ O".:g co ~ ~ :;;0. ~ g"" ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ :3 _.:3 c:T ~ '" ~' 3 Q. po r ro g =::g 10 a: ~ ::-': (=). ~ 0"0 ' '" ":-" = ~ ~. D ~ Q. &.. .2 S' ';;:" ~ ~ _.~ ...t-"'~--o 1: ~.'"' ~'-"-~'" "" ,.", -1: ~ '< 1 -= ~ ~ ~ § ~ :3 ~ ~.'" ~ (D" :::t c:T ~ Q. f); ~ '" Q 8 '" :3 n '" _.~ (b. <:s ~ Q. ,., Q. +oô '" ~ 0 -C .a (") ,. .Q. 0 2. ~ ~ ? ~; ~ S' 8 8 ~ ~ 5' ~ ? 00 ~ a. f); Q. ~. ~ 0

3

~ ~ s',g' ~ ""'~ -'8. co = ~ ~ :::t 3 ~ 0"' (") ;: -~ ~ ~ a ~ ' ~ ~ '0 ~. :3 ~ go g ."" ~~. '0 ~ g 3 s.:g (D" ~ ~ ~ ~ (D" ~ ~. (D" ~ ~ :;' CD" ~ Q. :3 e--~"?o;il ~"'O".I:: CD"~"' 3 *ool::"'~(") ~"':3° ~1:: ro ~ ~ co -=~. ..~:3 8 3 ~ ~ N (") ~ 0 ~,o ~ =..D Q. 3 ~ 'Oa=.'""Jf;~. ~o"'(=). ~~g~::::'-Q.°a"'3 ~~S"oI::~~ n ; ~ ~ .D -~ ~ :3 ~ ~ "":3 0 Q Q. 1:: 3 c:T ,e. 3 ~ 1:: e:. ~ _.~ :3 ro "O~o 0 3

",""-"--';7;"".

'---"

3 --1:::3'" ",-,,0 0 a' = 5.,--. Z '0 0 c' 0 =. Q.~, ~:;' ~'... §)< ~ 0 ~ 1:: 1:: ~ co 0 ~ 5. 0 -:3 '" :3 ":-" Q. '" (D" 1:: ~ ~ 3 ~,~ N'o. '" 1:: '" ~ 0 ~ 2. ~ ~ ~ !!., (JQ 0". ~ ~, Q. (") :;' ~. (") ~ 0.9. 1:: 1:: Q. -~ ~ Q. ...,o."...'~ 0 .~oC "'~I~~'~"'O 0 "'~~I ~ ,,~ Q.~ Q.:3(")~ r-- "'-3 '"" -~, .." -, ~~5.!:".<ôJ8 ~§~fG.5.~g.~nCH~5.'Oc:~."n~ CD";I> § g,0 3 CI) >"tJ 9.e?"c ~ ( .0 ~ '0 ;:s ~ 0. ~ = ~. _.~ 0 ü: ~ ?' ~ ., g 0 0 ...<: "':3 _.n ~ ~ :3 ~ . ~ ~. ~ :-3;:3"8 ~ !:J. ~ ~oa ~ ~ g ~ .g 0" ~ n ~ ~~. a .g ';< 3 § S" 3 3 -0 0 ~, e:. (=). a ~ '" ~ ~ :J:: R ? ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ [ 5. ~ ~ >= ~ '& S' ~ ., ~ ~ g S' Q. 9. ~~. Z ~ ~ ~ ~ '0 ( "Q -c' §';. N ~ ..., -;:s g. 6. ~ = ~ ~. C'J 1: ~ c::.:!'" ~ ~ ~. q ~ Q.;t:. ~,:3 (") '0 n r-3:3 ~ _.O. t ~ co ;:s ~ ~ 0 ,.. = ~ ~ ;:s 3 ~ ~ -.m'" "", ~ = _.~ :;r. '" ~ ~ C m' ~ 0 ~, -.g 8 ~ ~ Q 8 ~ ~ & ~ a: ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~.g 'g ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~. g ~ =. '" ~,~ ~ ~ 9. ~ :3 CD", ~ ~ = ..~ -=. =. ~ =;;;- _."'- co " ~ = ~.v q < ~ -~ ~ m :3"" ( SI' a ~ ~ 3 3 :g ~ ~. & ~ ~ ~ ~ ~3~ ~ = rjQ' g r; ;:;- & ~ ~ r; ~ ~~. 3 o' '0 ~ 0". m VI '" ~ ~ g ~ -~ = .'oVco '" \Qe-". o=-a~. "'~ ~ :30""0 Z 'O'J_~ -~~~~§:~"fl~~i~a~I:8;~~W~:~::'.g~ oI~~' go~ ~.~ ~ ~- § ~~.g ~ '0 ~ ~ 0". ~ ;;,- ;:s ~ '- ~ fO ~ ~ ~ :3 c: o.~ ~ go 0. 8 ~ -~ ~ ';;:" ~ 3 '"" ~ C > ~. ~ ~ Z 11 'O."O~.~,- -~~ ~_.~ ,- "',. ~ --' ._.;: =" ;: ~ ~ 0 = '"' 0 ~ 100'v ~ -.-0 '" ~ ~ ~ ~ Q. C > Q. n 3 ~ c ~ = ~ 2:. â a t:; .-.~ ~ 0. :1. ':: ~= -;" e: ~ ~ fn' ~ 5~ 2. g ~ ~,~ (") e .-a n r- ~ b ~ ~ c ~ ~ ~ "" '0 _.~ -'< '" '" ~ c 's, ~ .:3 OQ ...::r ~. ~, _.~ ~. ~~2. ~,; Q"?=;:sne-~5.lIs,,~;tj"'~:v"'~ 3 ' ~ ~-~ 3 "" 0 > g ~""-ë: r '" r-.~ '0 .g ~ N '0 ~ ~ ~ 03 ~ 3 co ..=- g ~ ~ ~.:;: .v tA' ~ ~ ~~. (") ~ ~ 1:: '?; ~, ~ c .ZNO~ ;. 8. VI.. ~:-:"g:J::;:;-"",g.r;;"~t"1~ ~ ~ ~~ <:TO , ~ ",' -:3 11 ,.. § ~ ~ -'" --1 tA' ". 0 "'. ~ ~ ~ "';:., _.'0 Q. -.~ ~ (D" 3 ~ ~ CI) .'" -z co ~ :g J;.. -< ::0 ...:1. :z r ,- _.~ ~ 0 Q,. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 m n g _.S' -D

--i.

o.=e- C'O. -I--i\O~~ ,-'---z ';;;-~fO=;:~t--o'" (") '" ...:3 G, ~ ~ """ -~ .(" .",,' VI--i\O"'~'U~">< .'" ~ ~(") C "'...~ c g = 0 s2. """ N \Q.. rn. ~ 0 ~ 0 1: ~ c:, " ~ ~ ~ 0 <:T ~ ~ :3 _.~:3 n -t :3 ~ ~ o..,~ ~NOOn~="' ~ ~'ë.rn~ ",0~-;'O -~ ~ ~-~ m- """",g v tA' -co 0. ~ ~ ~. m 0 0 r<2 =: ~ ~ go'O 3; ~ '0 ~ -'", .0". 5. 1:: m- 0 'g. s:- :;' a-" C rn\O~~.., -<~-~ ,..fO"~::;" N~=~NO "'!::.. ~- 0", r-Z ...,CI:: -~ j'o) n ;" co;;:: ~ ~. 00 =' n ~ ~. ~ -8 0". 0 '" 8 ~ ~, ~ Oq :3 ~ e:. m ~ ~3 (") = "T1"? 0" :g 'c< ..c ?'.oo ~ ;;' ~ -~ ~ 00 ,0 g. ~ ~ .CH § S" '" 3' Q. ."'" ~ n c ~ ~ Z o. = ~ N ~ g ~ ~ ~;: 'T1"? ~ ~ 'j1, :8 ~ .-.0 ~ 8 e .-~'O ~: '" ~ ~ 1:: Q. Q. ~ c: e; '" ~ :3 ~ C 0\ 0" .'" t1 ~ rn '" ~ \Q ~ '0 '0 _.V tA';:s '0 1.; ::.. t"'I (") ~ ~ 0 "":3 Q. C ","..., "'0 ~_I:~~' 1 ~ c. ~ '" '" ~ ,-. ~ Q ~ :3 n :I: ?> ~ :;J} ~ ~ ~ go ~ ~ 3 'g tA' ~ :fi ~ g &; 3 go '0 S" ~~, S" ~ go '" : Ehg,~ j'o) ~ ~ ~~ (")g,~~ 3 ~ ~g.~"8.~ ~~.~ g g' N 3 .g a (")0 .0 ~ ~ § ~, 'g -;: ..I:~ '0 -<:I:. t--o ::::0= ""0'" ~- ""Q. ~ <:T Cm -""""3 C ~ tA'

_o

p, ~ :.,. 2. ---~ m r!! ~ ~'O o ~.~ tÏQ

8

N:O ;! :.. ~ ~ ~ ~ 1:: ~ ~ ~ ~ m VI CD" 'E ~ '" ,ç ..~ -l'''A--i.~~...,'''~~ 'O'.".~ 3 1:: '-- ~ ~~ô'~ .~.n~ ~~'~o ~ ..~- 3 ~ ~ ~ n "'cQ. ~ ,.. .., b '" g 0 0 ~ ~ ~ Q § 'g Q E .0 N 0 !:J. 5~ (") ~ ~ ~ E" :g ~ ~ 0 ~ _.~ -~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .g .~ '" ~ ~ '0 ~ ~ 2:. Il ~ ~ '--. §Fi '& ~ ..~~.:. ~:3 ~ c:T0 g Q.

o

'" -."I:~~""'" -(b"~"Q"'1: ;]--i- ~'(")"'(") -~. r- 5. ~ ;,. a g. m ~. m"? g, S' = ~ tT1;. =: N ~ ttj '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a. ~ 3 ~. ~ ~ 0 ~ '0 o. h '" ~ ~ CH ~ c:, ~ ~ tT1 ~ [ 8 ~. ~ ~ 0 ~ _.~' ~, C ~, :3 e:. ~,..~o -~'=. ~=p,\Qco8"'on. CHcrn"' o .'~J ~ Q _. Z '" ~:3 ~ ~ -\0 = n ~ ~ '" CH _." tE ~ N' ;:s ~ ='" --'. ~ ~~~.p -f'"~r;~~a;l>n~~5.~8o§:gI.--i] ~ ~ Q."§S': ~ D.("),:;-, ~ .~ 0". N ::O' ~ '0 :;-' ~ ~. 5.;:;- e- ~ z. .~ ~ = (") Q C ~ CD" -t .'"'" 0 Q. ~ ;:. = .P' ~ co ~ ,... ..5. -< 5. 0 ~ tT1 ~.~ ~ ~ a ~ n § ~ ...'" 8 > .D 3 ~ ~. ~ ~ i ~ [g, g: ~ ~ .~ c ~.g 3 ~.VI &, ~ ~ ~. g. ~ ~. ~ 03:] ~ ~ :': 3 ffi ~3~!"' ~~~::s~~~~0~.~:J::goco~"'~0.3 g ~ 31::~ :;: -~~, ~ ~ ~ = ~ ~ " r- -0. ~ 0 3 0".1ia '-.. oô 3. 1: .:. ~ ~ 1: = ~ <: :3 Q. 0 -._0 ,,~co -.'<'00-'0 ~.., ...~ 0 ~ "'~,,~ ",,~0"""'-=;:"'~~.20,..,0tA'~-~. Q. t"'I ~ -~ c --3 .~ ,. "'""'<:""O~',"'-u~'-..'-.."'o.~co'< ~ ~ ::'1:: m ~ën,

Doctrine

(3)

~- ~~~-~

---

--~~ -~

Doctrine

-0

~

'"

...Q..

0

Q. ;'"'

'fP'

9 e-.

c.

n

g:.=-.

~

Q..

~

!II

~=~'~

~"""'~

~

(")~~,

;;.

(')'<

0. -:

3 ..,

..,

0 N

(')

~

-D.

~

t""'

V)

'0

~

N

(')

S. ~

0. t""'

'"

-~

0 (")

~

a.::;

'"

r-

a,

~

'"

t""'

"'.

~.-.ooi..,~\.-j-.

o~=.=S\.-ji..,-"'o~

~

"'0

0 =

°:i?.-

(")

~

'"'~

0 ~

~

~'""-3

"';o===0.

""-.~

="""(j"_.~.

~~3'"

(")

~

'""~

~

-"'...

=

'"'

~'.I~

"'~."""",..,(')'~="T10...,"'~"'00(')==

=;1=.;:1'"'1'

=

~'~

~

"'~.--

'"

0 =

~

0 ~

~

_.-=:

->

...~

~

-0

-.1.

~

0. =

~.

~

<

..,

'0

~

0

0 -'"

-~

~,

.~

!=

~

g.

a.

E;

~

g.

[T1

:...

[

~

!=

IJ,

50 ~

0 ~

0. [T1

e

~

a

g

~

g

.g

Jg.

g

~'"

=

8 g.

~.."

8 ~

'0

S'

~~;11."'~'

=="'~

\O_~oV)("O'~~~~~~s~'"

'"

-~

=

~

-.9

=

(")

~

=

~

~_.

~

0 :

g

"!;;

6 ~

~

N

8 ~

.~

~

~.z

~

-g

~

g

~!=IJ

~

~.g.

s'

~

s-;

9 ~

§:

9 Q..

&

~

Q..

~

g,

3 ~

~

3 ?1

;...

~

'"

3 ~

'0

9'.

~

<

~

:::.

>1

-~

~

2'.

-fD"

(")

'"

~

""

~

,,'

-00

=

~

=

~-=~"~J

~~

.~-

.ë.

~"O'.I""""

~"'=..,<~

It:.

~

~O"

5. ~

&c

(0:

~

!""

~

::s

2. ~

$

'\8

~

~.

R"

~

a::::

g:

I;:J

:-

s'

~

§;

~

g.

~

fD"

;.

§

~

~~.

(")

;;;'

"',~'

s'

go

;0

~

g

=

~

Q

g

-0.

~

§.

3 ~

=

~

-~

-.1

~

S

~

-=

=

;5.

~

00 ~

-~~

~

0 -~

=

(JQ

(")

~

6'

~

@

n

~

g.

a:

~~

:--J',f;;

~~,

~

*

c

~

g:

~

g.

[T1

~

g

§

~,

~

'fP'

~

~,

~

o

'g.

~

g.

;-,0"'=0.

0.;0-

'0\"'~3.~-

~.~=.

-r::;"""~"'-

~;:I

<

~~

~. ~ ;- ~ ~ ~ ;:: --= 8 .~ '2' ~ Y' ~ ~. ~ g. "'. ~ ~ ~ ~ ::;! ~ '" ~ 0 9 g ~. ~ g-;:3 ~ go ~ ~ g..§ ~!=..,~~~... 3= ~=: ~\.-j .(')rn<~ 3 ~~o. ~ < = ~ '"'1 ~-O"'" (") '" ~,

(;)

.-<

g

~

['g

~

[

,~~,

'-11

t:t,.."

~~.

~

e!.

~..

~~.

-~

~

.g

s.

'fP'

s:

~~

~

Q..

C::

';:

~

g

~.g

~

Et

~'-

.-=.

~,

2:

~

!=IJ

~

C:;

~

-N

~

(')

~

8. ~

~.

fD"

2 fD",

g

=

E. ~

oS

§

~

Q

~.;

~.~'

~

g

S

-:

$

~

Q

g

~

g.

Ji'!E

g

~,

'fP'

::.

~

'8,

'0

.g

g

~

fD",

~'g

:.

'g.

.~

~

e;

~

3 wo

3 ~

8'

9'

~

8 ~

~

S

~

~.

N

s.~

';;

~

'"

't;;

0 ~

=

0 ~

p..

-~

~

'"'1

~

(")'

~

0. ~

~.

8 [.""!i

s'

~

.-~

'?

9'

-:

.-~

"\Q.g.

~

'-

~

::

~

=

§'

0'

9 (")

~'

g

§

8 ~

"'~

=lA

go

Q

~.

~

0 ~

DO'

~

N

0. g

..,0

'?;.,o

~

~:s

0 N

!'D

.g'

~~'

..,0

S

~

e?,

=

=a

§

g

~

~.

(")

2..

~.E

(")

9-

Q

1:~."'-~

8 ~'"

~

\O

~.o.

"'-~"";4

=a

=;:1""'.00'

...,

0-""

~

r:;

..,

~.

~

a.

0 ~

..~

~

:...

(')

~

=;;.

~

e

n.

3 ~

-.~

~;

~,

~

Q

=

~

'0

~

"_.~..,~

".c,,,~~

---:1:

~

";""3"""

(")'"'l'''-;:I..,~;:I

"'~

;:IQ..N

;:;

'g'8

..,

S. ~

~

\O!"'

~

-.1

F

~

0 .~

~

-~

~

fD"

~

Q. oS

~

~,'

'0

9 ..0

'0

=

~

§

g.

s'

a.

~

~:

~.

~

.~

h

~

.0

~.

§'

~

'?

~:::§

~

g

~.

§

~.

§

8 ~

g

s'

~

g

(") 0

~,

~=-0.1\.-j-. ~ .'~"'t':1=~..0\(;).~ --"'~ = ~~ 9= ~ -. ~ Z ~ Si. ~ ~ ~ ~ §: ~ [T1.- ~,.: 1: ~. -5 ~ ~ ~ e!. ~ g. ~ =~ ~ '" ~ 0 ~ 9 g 0" -9 9 ~ '" =-_.~:::."'~ 0\ ~_;o=o~...g~-~(;)~8. (")~ =~="'~ ""~ ~9Q. :.- ~ 3 ~ ~ '"" ë @ 0;. :;CI ::I! \0 ~ ~ ~ -~ ~ ':-";0 ~." 0 '" ~ ~ (") ~, (") = ~, ~ =~ = ~ = ;o~ ~'.I~_. .O\.N"\O"'" ~~"' 9--"'-..0

---"!i;~~~~§:'~8

:

~:~~~~~8.~'.:8'

9~

~..§'g

~

~'g.~.

o-~

'8

§~,

~ '" ~ ~ 0 _.~ S 3 ~ 00. ~ ~ (;) t':1'g ~ S .-E =: ~ (') ~ Q.. Q.. '0 ,E. < § 1;; ~ (") g ~, _. N ~ 0. -~ ~. Q '0 ~ ..9' ~ ~ -~ ~ '" o. DO' --.g ~ !E (") 0 = g = 2 't;; ~ ~. 0 '" 'fP' ~ 80.~oo03~= (') ~-.1~~3",'O=_~~~"'0 ~ = 8 = ~ -~ 9 ~ ~

.N

m

~

g

~

i3

r6~.

:-

~

n

Y'

~.

~

a.

~

~.

.~;.

g

~

fD"

9 g

~

><

8. '8

~,

a

~

;

Q

3' ~ ~ g; ~. ~ ~ g. ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~. ~ ~ -: ~ g ~. g ~ ~ ~ 'i a] 8" § ~ ~ ~;§. ~ -:::. ~ --~ 0. ~ m;- ...'0 -.:::. -= () '" ,. -= '"'1 ~;:I -':-' 3 g 'g 7 ~ '" 3 ~ ~ _.: = ~ DO' ~. g. ~ -cr;; = ~ ~ ~ ~ -0 -~ (JQ = Q.. ~ Q.. ~ g ~ ~ 0 ~ g ~;- .~ ~ Q, -: ~ .., ...~ '" ~ 'fP'~' ~ ~ ~ = ~ g ~.. (") ~~~~~aS(') (') .oo!=IJ!(5 ("\ ~Y'o(')~o.~'" t:;1", ~~9 '"'1 ~ ~ ~ '" ~ 'fP'= ..~ ~ = !" '0 ~ 0 k ...~ 0 (;) ~ 'Oo .§ i.., ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ~ ~ ~. g =. ~ -'" ~ "-.0 '" --N "'~..- < ...'"'1 '"'1'" -~ ~

»

:::.

3 =

~

'(6'

3 ~

t--

g;

.~

~.

~

0 (')

'0

~

'0

'"

~

a

~.

(")

~,

~

=

n

o

'"

Q

=

= < ~. -= ~ 3 --~ 0\'0 ~ ~ ~ ~ iT1'O a S 0 ~ a. = = ::r ~ = (") (") g. .~:;, ~ g ~ o.~. ~ ~ ~ .E. 0. ~. 3' ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ ..0 .E' g ~, -.J ~ g ~ .g ~ fD", ~ 2 ~ ~. 'g .g ~ ~ rg. 0. ~ ~!:j cs. ~ ~ g ~ U; ~ ~ g. ;: ~ = ;1 Q.. ~ ~ (") Q.. a. = @ ~ ~~=:~~~;-= ~ J,-.:.oo ;. ~-_:""I..~,~.= ""~~ ~_."'~~ , ,'"

'"

..'-'

N

-0:0

:;!Q..m(")~(")(")~'"'1"'_.",--"",,-

,. ~ = 0 = ~ ~ ;:1 ;:1 ~ (0' = = ~ = 0 " ;

~8=-=-=[~C&,?>'?~gQ'-~8§,~g.~

O

g,~--

9sacggg~r::;-~fD"~

~~

~

~3

(r.~3

""

~'<\O.

---"

33

0=.

(")'""

~,.~,-';:I

,.~~,.,

a

(") ~~

tn

3 &-

3 ~

~.

~

(')

-=.

~

~"T1

o.

';;

\0

=.

3 _.~.

'"

h

...0

~

;:J

'0

~

Q..

0"

't;;

=

'"

'0

'"

..0

-~.

0 ~

~

~'.~

~

'~.

~

§

~

;~

5 ~

8

3

~

~.§'

§

~

"'

~.

::;;

~

8 ~

g

~.

~

~~

g.

g':

;

~

~~ .~tn~ -'i..,z ",""O~ c.c: ~... tr1~ -=~;:I .., =~ ,. -~ g. g. ~~ ~ 0 > != "fi ~ ~ h '0 ~ g. '\8 ,'" S =: ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~~ ~~, = ~ .N ~:g 3 :::;"' ~ r::; e:. a ~ C: -i -'" ~. 'J'O~>,",,'O~.~~=~- 3="'~ ~ ~ Q..~ 0 _.-= ~ 0 ~ ~ --~ /1 '"" ~ 3 r.., '" r..,'O 0 :s: èJ ~ tn tI1. '" -' 'i!{~. ~ .., 0 Q.. (") Q.. ~ 0" .~ -_.= = = ~ ~ -~ ~ /1 ~.l0.~.~..Qt""'-<3"'r"""""'0.'.~~~,~0 ~o~ ~..o=oS(")~~ '"'I5~ ~= : (') ~ ~ ,?=': .:~ ë > ~ " ;. ~ ~~. rft:.!J' ~ ~ _.~ g. 5. ç' -..ca = Q~' oS ::. '0 _.§. = ~. ~ '" .-a, ~ : :1:"'=- '0 =tXj-~- ..,. -~ ~o.~ tXj ~""o """"" '"'l'''''-'-'''-Q..;:3-..o- /1 FO"'N:""N~.~O~O.~~,?~~ ~;g~~g.> (") ~~ .E'Q..~ @ ~'" ~E.~ ~ = ~ ~ = ~ c 0~"' § -.l8n.c. E= \ON"'~~. :::.';;o.=~ 0 ~;:I = ~ '" = ~ Q..fD",~ -Q..'"'I '" (") ~ (") /1 .~ 0 \.-j \.-j '" tn (') ;..., ~ 00 ~ 0

3

-r"" >

N

='

~

Y'

tn

==

a.

go

~

=

fD"

~

=

'"'

'"

0'"

~

~,

~

0 :::-:

~

C (;)~3'" .:1:~~O~N ~ ~"'~._-' ~O' ~ ",...,'. -"""-9 a::; ~ g 3'? =°'0 g ~ 5 !-..:g:. ~.. 3 .., ~ ~ ~ Si. ~ ~ ~ 0" = g e?, Q.. 9 ~ g. (") ~ ~ ~ (") ~ -.9 ~'~ ë

a.@

5 ~

'i:

'?

50 ~

.,..

>

~

Q

Ï"

C

§

~

:-=-

~

8 ~

[

Q

c;;

><

~

~,

=

~

-<

~

Q

=

!.

~

~.

(")0

;: .: ~'.. ~3~';-' -o..~~-~.I"'o.=OQ~ ~ '0 (") ~ (");:l'O-'"'I''''''''~'"'I -C =~ ~ ~ ;. ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ ~.5 ~ ~ ~. 0. P h ~ 5' g [~ g. ;1> a '(; ~ 'fP' ~ ~ 'g ~ 8 8 '8 ~ ~ ~ ~ §: ~ N ~.'O ~ -< \.-j S ~ ~. ~ -(;) -.1.: ~ ~ (') iT1 ~ '" ~ "'. ~ = (") 0" 'fP' ~ '" :::-: ."... :4 ~ = = 9 a ~ ~ ~ 0". B "Oa~>.":'30.' l:.o~~:.o"'~=.:~.~=~- ~~~ (")"'~~0~3(")~9~ ~ ~o ("

~

È

S:

~

g.

~

g

p..

~3

~

~.

~

:

~

§:

~

~,~

~~.

12:

~

g.

~

g'

~

§.

~

";

~

~;~

~

~~-=~ 0.'",0 ~~"'~(').vS.~- ~~'" 9"'~~""'I= .= ==~= "'~ c ~ â ~... .> ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. =~ [ ::! 8 [ ~ ~ ~~:8 g ~ 'fP' a. '0 ~ ~ ~ [ ~ :. 'p:- ~ ~ ;1 ~ ~,E' ~ ~ =

'O"'~..~m~

~

N

o.=!"~.~

("0'=:--

"'~

~

'"'I;:I-~'"'I=~,.

(")(")'.;:3=

~'O

::

~

t

~

f

~

i

!

~

!

~

1 ~

~

i!

~

i

~

i

~

~'

~

~:

~.

~

1 i!

~;

~

~;

~

.g.g

;d

e..

=

~

p.

~

!'D

3'

;:;

n

~.

§

~

=

~

~.

g

Q..

g

~

'"'1

~

Q. g

~

~~'

g.

'E.

~

0 ~

;0

(')

~

...

3 ~ E:; o.. ~ ~ '" = = ~..., = -= -'" ~, '" ~::r = _.r-; ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ==

0<

~

-~.

'"

~

"'..,

_.~

~

'"'

~

--~

'"

~

Q..,.e;

-~

Q)

~~

C 0.~"' 3 .v ~ ~ -..,(')=~_.~ "'- -~""- ~"'" .~~=;;;;.

~3~3.v

Y'~

~~

c

~.~=ë~

-~'"'I

~(")'"'I~'-o

'=O'"'l'O.~~

~~

c

=

~

m

~

3 (;)

~

3 m'O

';;

~

.,.

~,'"

0 ~

=

...,

(")

~

-~'

o ~' '""'~ '" = '"" "'=. -~~ "'= 0-- -(j"' ~=:::.(;) -(") '" -~ ~.(") = ~ C:;' ,J'. Q..(")

~

-(')..

=

..c:..

0 (;)

~

;;!

~

0 ~

~

0 '."'=~"='

'"'

~

--9

~,

~.

(")

~

'"

-0

'"

--~

'"

"-"'~=

,."'-

,

...,-'.-'--""~~--

,.~

~0.(')3-<-.

o.~

",'-

-:""ln.

"""

'"

=

~on~~

'"

~a.~_.N~_~

~.

0 ~

!"'

~

3 ."

~

\0

~

'"

,Q

'0

~.

~

Q..

'"

't;;

~

---'(;

~

0 g

=

;:

~

m

=

3

0. (')'0

'0

\0

~

-~

.~

~

,.,

Q..

~...,

_.-=

~

0::

'"

(")

~

S~'O2.°'?

~~

'8

.-~g"~~:g

oS

a~

9 ~

"'~~

~~.g

~

Q..'fP'<;:3

g

0 oS

~~n>_.3\O

r-.

!",I:

...Ç')~-=3.

0 ,

~~~-~-

~"'~~-

=

1 ~

g.

~

-.1.

.~

~

0. ~

~

\0

~.

~'

9 =

'0

~~

-0

Q..

~

=

0::

~

B

~

:::. ~ o' -.:::. -:0 ~ ~ :- .s. ~ '~::'. 0' S ~ fD", ~ ~ 0".:-'" '0 = '0 ~. ~ 0 '" ~ ~ ~,g '"'1 < ~'O==-~'> -= ~-~~_.\O """ '"'1 ~--~(")O"_'"'I .""~,

'"

~.

t""'oa

o...

-tT1

\0

~

r:;

;0

-~

'"

=

\0

(")

~~'..o

~

=

~~,.

<

'"

=

g

~

--~

~

=

~

gg

~

9 '2'

0. ~

~

n

g

§

g

"'-

r::;

~

'g

0)

C::

~

~.

~

C:;'

~

-=

(")

:::r)

~

i

~

g

~

[

-~

~

'g

~

.g~,

g.

oi'-

~

g

~'..g

§

S'

g

~

a

~~

~

~::::'

("0'

=:

0. a:

c;;

'?

R

~

-~

~

-e;

~.

-~

~,

'"

...,~'

(")

~

tr1

'"

,~C::

Q..

~

[

~,

g-

~

g-

.@

~

~.

~

g.

~

a

~

§

g'

;.

~

",

Q. g

~

§

g.

~

§

.,. ""'1 -, .., '" ~ '" '" ~ 1

Doctri

ne

.

(4)

-~- ---~ ~~

Doctrine

N '" (") (") c:r ~ t:". ~ ("\ -..~ (") '" ~ Co (") ~ --01 '0 = 0 ~ ~ a- o. _.-0 0 _.= o' o' ~ 0 -~ _.~, ~ '" .~ ~ '0 = '" 0 -: r-- = CI) r-- ~ (j 00 (j CI) = g ~ 3 = ;e;: q = ("1 ~ a ~ ~ =. 3 ~ ~ ~ ,0 ~ "'-0 ".c c =. ~ .~ 0 o. 0 '-o." C --'" Q ~, ~ = 0 ~~, -~ ~ '" 2. ~ ~ C ~ ~ '" c -c = =

a

c -..'"' _.-0 'O~, ---'l) ~ 0 --~ -~ ~,'" ~"O '(; 0. ~ =: '(; (") ~ =... ~ Q. ;j ~ ~ ~:3 3 = ;j. ~ ~. ;:; g: §. ~ a a. Co ~ :S. ~ ~ ~ ~ (") ~ : 90;~' ~ ~ ~ ~. '" 0

...

~~. ~ S r S g ~ s '" ~ 0:; ~ =: -a-."-'" "'tT1=. 0 "<= ,.Co o' 0-== -~. ~~ ."'"g ~ g g. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g. ~ ~

8"

g ~, Q; 3 ~ g g~ "'- ~ ~, g.:3 :: g. g g go § Q. ~ 0 .s. Q: '0 '" C < =. ~" s 0 = 00 0... OQ C 0 = .-~ '" = 3 :3 ~ ~ = ~ t:". ~ -

",

'~, ~ ~ 0 -, ..0. (") '" -_.VI. ,. -~ 8. '8 ~. ~ .N fô ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ fJ;" g. ~ ~ ~- == ~ C §: ~ ~ 3 == 3 ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ S' Co ~

3

c ~';:' --'" ~ ~ ~ ~ .c o' < ~ ~ Co (") ~ ~ =" S, 3 ~) ~ 3 -~ = ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ;; " ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ n = ~ .Q. 'g ~ g ':-" ~ !'l" ~, c 3 ~ g ~ :r 8 =. 0:; 5' ~ g -=c'OCoa a.=-)oo.o.t'1". o~"'

",

=<

z

~o-J- ~ ~--=~'...~~ :3 >-~"' ~'" "'. ."'~ ~- ~.-,,~ :s oQ.""" -a, ~ g ~ ~,~ .~ ~

8

~ ~"r--';; :c ~ ~ g: Q.

§

g 8 S' 8 ~ ~ ~~' g t:", § s ëD" g ~ ~ 'g " " ...'" .c ~ ,,- e '"' -("1 ~ -'" ~ _CIO ' _.~ ~ ~

-3 0 '" _. 3 -= C '" """ -'c 0. -, = ~ ~J 0 ,. (") ~ -= ~ ~ ~ ~ '0 ~ -~ ~ ~ .-z '(; ~ ~. t'1 : 3 0:: '" g = '" (") ëD" ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ ëD" -~ ~ ~ .:ë' Co g g i g. ~ @ ~: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ --5. 3 ~' § ~ ~ Q g 00 ~. ~ ;; ~ (") ~ a. 0:; ~ ~ ~ ~ "'.. = n. g 0 -a " \0 --, =r ~ ~ C -Co -~ =... ~ ...~ :3-S ~ = -.~ = =~.g ~ ~ = \0 ~ '" ~ '0 ~ Q. ~' _.:3 -~ ...Co '" ~'c:r ~ ::; 0 _.= ".c c:T 0. '" V1 ~ '" '0 ~ -_.t:" Q. '0 ~... ~ '0 C ' '0 ~ ~.'O ~ ~~: 0: ~ '" t'1 -=: "= 5 o'"g ...Q. ~ ~, o' C ~ @ o:;:g ~ = ~ '" ~ ~, ~ ~~, 0 ..g g; ~ y.. n ~ [ r--" C = ...~ ~ § ~ ~:::;3 '§ ~: g g. ~ '" d. ~ ~ ; " " a c 3 '" '8 '0 ~. =: \0 '" 0 ~, ~ -'" (") '" e: VI '" 'iD ~ -go = -.t:". '" (") '0 '" '" 'ô:: D. :... ~ '0 ", V1 = C (") -~~ ,., 0 0 -.~ ~ = ': ~ "' 0 :3 0 '0 " 0 (") =:" ~ .." .0 ~ _.'0 -= =~, VI -c:r = Q. = ~ = a '" ~ 0 0 c =. ~ IV -0. '0 C (") 0

--~ -s: (") -" -..c ~ ...~ ...0 -~. ~ '" o.'"="'~ 0 .o~~. '" '"'"""C \.l 'v c", '. "'- ~ g.,* ~ ~ :. '8 ~ ~ .8 G ~ ~ s' 8- S' ~,~, ~ @ .2 ~tt1 ~ ~ ~ ~' ~ =.. 8 g' ~ '" (") ~.:s. ~~. " 'c< '0 '< -: ~ 'iD ;j -0 (6' Q. = C -:3 ~ ~ ~ r (") ...(") g g;" c ~~. :' ~.;., ~ ~ ...' ~ ~ = ...~ (") _.~ ~ Q. ~ 3 -, 0 3 ~ Q. 0 (") ~ ij.rI! 8. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, a ~~, 90; ~ Q. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~VI ~, C g;- '" ~ ~ ~ -.g @, c" ~ .:-. ~ ~. @ <-:1 ~ 3 (") _.§ (D; ~ ~:3 C 5' '" --~ § ~ _.~ '" = ...'" (") --, -,",' ...~ t:", ..0 ~ -_.Co -,. ~, = 0 " " -." =. 0. .c ",' \.1 ~ '"-0 = 0

-'"

3 C -'" ~ -~ -'" = ,., ~, -."'...0" c .-" ~~'j -"" ="":3 -_.,. -,,- ... 0.'0 ~ < = c " ~ ~ <:: ~ .= = ~ ëD" ~ = -VI 0 '" (") '" ~ (6' S, ~ ~ g; _.~ 0 ~ ~ :I::!i ~ s: ::0 "'~, ~ ~ (") =-- ~ ~ ~ = 0 0 ~ ~ t:". =: = c= 0 -'" ~\O -C ~ -3 0 ~ (") ~ Co'" = '" e: '" 0 a g- &- ~ ~~ S! ~ @ ~ c .00 g = '" ~ ~ = = (") "' 0 ~ C a: 'iD =. ~. _.8 = _.,,~- ~ " ..;; -C '.'... Q. Q. 0 ...,. -~ 5 ~ 0. ~. g, ~.g ~ §, =0 '0 @"" ~ g. =" ~ as'&; 3 g ~ .s. :.,.. ~ Co ~ ...~ '" C ~'" '" C.)oo. ~ OQ ~ 0_' (") -, ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ (") ~ ~, -,,=. -'" "3 ~ l --~ '"' =' Q. ~ < -~ ~ '" =: S:~ ~ "':3~. 6... -a. ~ (J" '0 (") = ~ g- -~ Q. 0 Q. ~ ~ 0 3 (") 0 s, (") o.~c". ~', J (")3~ :ro"", ~ 3 ~"'= g ~ ~ '(; =. ~ .c ~.:o ~ ~ ~ C ~ ~ ~. =' -~ < a ~ ~, _.~ 0 -'0 ~ Q. (") '" ...C 0" c "(5. '0 Z :--. '0 =-- =' -(") ~~ =-- 0 _.0 = = C Co 0 ~ ~ c""...=~ ~ ;:.",. ~'-Q.C~---'iD ~ ~~ ~~= '" ~ = s '" ~ c ~ r--. ~;j < ~ ~ Q. C~ !'l' 8 'iD ;::.: § '" -.'.:: =' ..8 '0 ~, ~ q ~ ~ ~ ~ Po' § '" ~ .g ~,:.. ~ ~ .3 ~~ 0 ~, 5' _ 3.'iD- ~ ~ o. 'iD C ~ Ë. 3 ~ ~ ~ 'go o. " ~ ,E, " .:"".. ~ ~ ~ '" 'iD '" :3 C 0 g. (") _.g 0' ~ "'='O°c '8.1;:; ~- 0~ 3 Q. ~ -gg~ ~ ~c~~~-= '" ~ '" ~ §- ~ -.", tTJ ~ -~,... ~, --= '0 -0 ~ ~ Co .c ~ _.~ -0. ~ .~ ~ 'O~. --~ ~ (") ~ ~ ~ ~ _.~ -_.~ ~= F;j", ~; ~.I.- Co 0 ~~o,.o "',., ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ Q Q. t:". Q. ~ (") t:". '" 0 ~ 0 00 -'0 Co IC 3 ~ Q. \.-J Q. ~ ,. ~ -~ ~ 0 0 ;j ~ = '" \0 = ~ ~. '" ~ ~ ~~, ;?j ~ g ~ ~ C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ 3 a. ~ = ~. ~ 'il' ~' go r- ~ g; ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ,o J'.~'8a=<' =r~ (")c~(")o)~"'~,.- (D'.'c~ :r-~(")~-3 (") }::! a, .n ~ <; '" " ~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ..0 ~ 0 2. ~ 'rD' c ~ 'iD g 0_' ("1 (") ~ ~ ~ ~,_. ~ ~ t:". ~. -.-~ t'1 tTJ ~ ~. = -~ (") c (") ~ ~, ,. (") = _.-"'..0 ~ ,. '" -..1" C ~ ; m -."c. 0 --.~ ...\.-J Q. (") ..0 ~ ~ 0 0 0 ~ (") (") '" < :r ~, c -0 m = ~ <-:1 = ~ ~ g 8: ~ ~"roo 0 ~ ~ Q..g ~ ~ ~ ~ 5. = 3 Co ~ s, ~ ~ ëD" ~ g g: ~ ~ o' -f:: ;:, "'. 0:--. ~ '" -.Y' (") '"" (") Q. = @ ~, Q. c&o -=.. ~ ~ ~ ~ 8) ~ Q. _.Co ~, ~ '" = 0 -, ~ [g ;t'1 ~ !'j ~ ~ s; g a ~ 3 c ~ ~ :el ~ .N ~~ ~ @ § s, 8 ...; ëD" ~, ~ ~ ~ ëD" 'iD ~ 8 ~ ~ -<. (") =0 ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ = ni Q. ~, @, =' ~ o' c:r.E ~ 0 s, ~, s' =' go (") c ~ Q. s, '" § =' ~ --J ~ = ~ r-- §- ~ ~ 2'. -;;':; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ (") = ëD" 8' ~3 C 90; (6" ~ ~ N 0 3 ~ g c .g ~ :':. ~ ~~ ~ Q o -c (") '0 \0 ~ ~ 0 ,., --~ ~ (") ,., = " ~ '" ~ ~ .'" ~ 00 '"" r ~ _.~ 0 0. 3 = = ~ 0 ~ c:r (") ~ 0 '0 q Q. 3 8. @.-" 0 ~ ~ ~, _.-(") g o' 0 ~ ~ ~ 00 ;; c ~. ~ ~ '" g (") .s...o ëD" :r ~ = g ~ ~, C "'; '" =- ~ ~ ~ ::g ~ g. ~ §- ~ c;; ~ .-'0 ~ o. " a ëD" = 0 ~ c 0 ~ 3 q Q. o' ~ ~ E. s;. ~. 8 ~ 3 ~ ~ \0 .b @ g ~" ~. ~ ': ~"g ~ g. ':-" (") q ~ ëD" ~ C Q. ~ ~ § = 3 .s. ;; ~~, -0' ~. ~ Co C IV =; c g. ,,~ ~ =. '" ~. @ -:r ~ ~ '" -Q. ~~ s, ~ 'iD ~ c:r e: c '" ~ ~ c _.> ~ ~ 1 ";5 '8 ~ =: ~ :. '!:' g.g 2'. ~. ~ o' s, ."., ~ ~ ~ 0 0:: '" ~ @ @. ~ ~~ 0 '" 8 § (") c&o -, ~. ~ ~ :. ~ ~-.§ :. ~ ~ ~ ~ .g ~ ~. ~ @, ~ ~' :. ~ ~~, ~ ~ § ~ ~ ~;' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

.'"

\O.

-'"

00. '"

-0 -~ ~ ,. = ,. _.=:. ,. ~, ~ _.,. ~, ~ 0 ' = '0 \0.\0 '" ~ '" -'0 '" Q. ~ , =' Co ~ 0 _.00 '" '" (") (") C < Q. c ( 0 :1. -..J 3 ~ -.'"' ~. ._.~ ~ =' 0 0_' ~ , 0 0 '" \0 (") ~ -, -~... -~ -" 3 . ~ ~.. ;:,.. \.I(")..,..IV ~= = """~-=~'NO"'~ ~ "'=""~'-" , 9' '" ~ g, ~. ~ ~ g 0.;; :- ~ ::g ~ ~ '" 0 Co Q. ~ @ ~ ~ CIo = ~. '" ~ ~ ~ ~, 0 8. 2. ~ ~ ?'c< Si ~~ a a. .~ '" =-- ...'" 0:: 0:: c~ ~ -'0 g ~ tt1 (") ~ ~ c ~ Q. -0 -'" : (H r-- ~ '" ~ IV ~. '" ~ 0 (") o;g ~ c c = ~ ~3 ;j. ~ .e.. = g ~ ...'" ~, ~ '" ~, ~. : " " 'O~V1 ""8- '" ~ = 0 = ~ -'" 0 --'" <::'0 ~ ~ ~O i ~ ~ ;: '"" 0_.= 0. ~ t:".@ '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c 0-< ~ "' ..e: Q. -~ ~ c ,., = . '" "'o"'~ -", 0 o",...~, ~- '"'~ ...", . .(JQ '0 ~ ~ " = _.(") ~ = (") Q. ~ ~ C ~ -E c:r ~ ~ t:", C '" ~ '" (") Q. ~ Co ( ~o...'- o.~~ ocs,o (")~ '-"'..cc 0 "'0'" ~~ëD"~,"'c . ~ a:~ ~ ~ .§.~'~: .g go 3 3 c&o ~ ~ ~ Q ~ g 0" ~ Co ~ § ~ ~ ~. ~ N ~ g N ..: = 0 ,,~~ '0 C = ~ -'0 ...,. -, ...~ ~ ~ ~ =" '" N... -N , (; ~ 3 ."";;:,, ~ ~ .§ =. @, c ~ ~ ~ ;j. ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N C O' g \.-J ='" ~~' Q. ( tTJ"g ~ ~~'2- o~~c:ro~~ ",~ cce;~ §='= (")O O~~ < Q~, ~ \0 ~ -_.0 ~ c '-"' 0 _.0 ~ ~ ,., ~ (") ~ '" J r- -",' ~ 3 -~ 0 (") ~ 0 0 c c _.OQ ~ 3 Q. ~ ~ '" ~ ~ ~ ...(JQ '"" 00 5 ~ _.c:T Q. ~. 3 0 c c =.. =' 0 (") _.c:r ~ 0 ~ Co ~~ ...'" 3 ~ [ ë:o z ~ r;;' ...~ g ~. z _.3 ~ 'è '" § ~ c ëD" ~ (6. ~ 3 ;:; c :g .g Q. c:r '" " ~.. g go ~ --~~ 0 .g 3 ~ c e; ~ 0 ~ \.-J... =:r 3 -~ ~~ 1 8 s -..J ~.g ~ <. ~ ~ ,--. ~ c ~ c c --0 c c Co ~ '0 ~, ~ 3 ~ .E' g Q = 0 J. '"" Q.<='" 0- '"'C'O'" ,. "'Co- 'O"'c ,,-g §- c .'" 0. S ~ ~, 0 Co = ~ ~ @ ~ S;. '0 Z" (6. C @, ~'~, a 0 (") ~ < Q \0 = (j Q Fo' """, g ~ ~ ~ 0 -~ '" -~ -'" c @, OQ _.'iD ~ ~ g..c ~ Q. ::g ; g ~ ~ ~ ~. a. ... 3 ~ ~ ~ g g g@ Q. ~ (6' ~ ~ ëD" ~ ;j" ~ '0 s: C "' < ~ =."'" '0 ="'" -.""- 00- ~-'C~~ 3 N~\.l -~,. ("): o,,=:. =1'-< 0"'~=--33 "'3-~"'-3 ~ ~...",Q.~ o1 ==: ~o." '. 3 ~ ,", ",... ~ = ,."",,_.~~ : '" ...0. '"" (") ~ ~ (") '" ~ '" '" 0 ~... q ~ 0 ~, '" -5' A -_.0: ~ "c ~ =..,g: ~ -_.~ -'" '< ~ '" '" ~ 0 -~ 0 ~'- A ~ (") (") ~ -(H ~ 0" (") 0 ~ --, ..., ~ _.~ ~ --" ~ ,. -~ ~ ~ (j~O " =-~ ='0

3

~ (") '" '" = (") ='" ~ ~..- Q.c 0 = ~... C'" ="-0 -0. C 0 0...0 '" ~ ~ _.-'" 0 G- < -, --"'" = O""c' ~.?< ,.,_. =~'" "'...0"""'0\ ~o ...",,",~'~~ ~ ~ -.~ c c -= ~ = '" = ~ -~ ~ = ~ 0 ~ = _.-c ~ -~ 0 ~ c = ..~ = c -'" '" 0 _.~ 1 1 0 '" ~ -, ...~... ~ ~ --

r~=:-~~-~

(5)

-=~c~cc~~ ---~

Doctrine

'" '" "'!:j ~-"""' oS "'~""<~'" ~..o(\)~~=.~

O

C:"'(\)'1:j~ S

(D-'" -0 ~ (\),"""'" 0 O-.N. '.C::S'.(\)"'t") :S(\)~""I""I "'~ (") '" ~ ~ Po ~ ,., (") :;:J (\)~ ~.:g e', .-' @ a @. 0 ~ _.t") .g ~ & 0 :s (\) '" 0;;. 8. ~ ~ ~ . tn ~. ~ c s: ~ o

a

=. S 'it (\), 9- ~ :s ~ '" ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ c: t") S e-. 8 g 'it c: (\) (\) ~ ~ ~~c:::;::~.: a =.(;:r" s(\)(\),c:t")(\)"'E.(D ~ :sc:", ~:1'"~", :St")~:=..."'~,r;; ~~~~.,.,=c~ ~~ (\)< ",':g"8",t") ;:;.. e-."".(\)~(]CI§(\)=. t")~(\)""it""(\) s )8 t"" '" co: ;:.. (1); ~ = = (\) :s~. ~ (\) ""1 3 ..0 c o =. (\)@ ) '" ~ (\) (JQ ~.a c: c: '" ,c :J -': -~--i~<-..J~_. ..' :s C:(D 0 c:'. (\)_u," ';!"'t")C:=:S(\)'" ~~$:~~.~S2 ~=':' ,"":e-.",~ ~~~ ~ :s ""I~~~""C: (\)(\)O(\)(\)""s~ .'" c::.' , -eJ. =. ~ ~ "E?. _.=. ~ e:. -(\), Q.. '" ~ -(a ..0 g: § (\) :s o:s '" §, (\) ~ ~ ~ 5- ~ :0 ~ ~ g (\), ~ ~ ~ § c: ~ ~ ~ ~ s: ~~. oB '1:j ~ ~ '" ~ @ c: 8 ~ ~ (\). ~ 'it ~ ~ J ~ ~ Po :;:J -""1 :s ~ '" _.0" ~ t") _.c: :J. -0 ~ (\) ~ ';! '" (\) ~ 0 ~ 83 ~~ -~ =.'1:j ~ ~ ~a 0".'ô~'1:j Q o~ ~~ =':c: '" S ;12.~(\) ~ ~~s c:~ ~I ~ ~~r;;~ 0 =.(a'~"".~:=".""I00~ ~ ~C:'fD'~"""~e', ~(\)~~,"",c:'1:j 0 (\) _0 cCo t") ~(\)- "':S'1:j(\):3- c:(\)"" "'C:";t") """"_.\J,c :s ..:::: § s. ~. ~ (") :s 0;;. ~ ~ ~ t") ~ a ~ s ~ :J ~ t") § § g" 8.:s" ~. (\) ""ISO c: ~ S 31 Po ;::-c0 3 ~(\) ~ ""I° s ",~(\),(D ~ ~(\)ot") =.c:(\), (\)sg-(DS~§~ 2.g_. ~~~ C:""I (\)~(\), c:"",,~ ~ :S"':S(\)~"":='" ~'1:j"":ss""", ~ -'0 r;; ~ Po g ë. s,c S ~ '1:j s <. (\) ~ ~~. @ N e-. 3 (D ~ '" ~ N (\) l" ~. _.~ (\) ~; e-.Po~ -~,.,~ ~c:~ ().°C:~:S~c: ~ O=.(\)'~(;:r"(\) --Jt")t")0~(\)"""1 =-'"""~ ~_.~_. ""1-. e',0:S:s:s :s ~ '<~o(\)S'-~'1:j ':g'~:s-.~(\)(\) os' ~ ~ § 'go ~ g 9-;;;- 9-:s ~ ~ 'it oQ. :. 8 ~ e-. '" ~ ~ ~ ~ § a ""1 ~ (JQ § Ci ~ ~ (JQ,-,,'" .= a", (\)"" (D,8(\) :s(\)S Q.. t:b(]CI~Ov(\)",~ ~(;:r"g'~ (\)~ ~ .g ~ ~ ~ ~ '1:j ~ ';! ~ e:. '"": (\) t") S Q ~ (\), (D ~ ~v. :s (\) E. ~~ 'fD' (JQ ~ -(\) 8 ~ .., ~'~ ~ -~ ~ (D (\) t") (a _.1 ~ (\) ~ (a ~ t") (\) ,c ~ ~ ';; 0.9. '" ""1 ~ ~ :J :s ::r 0 _.~.~ """" "':s~ ~'1:j""l""l :S""lO:SC: ""I~~~t")=t") ~ 3 * (") -= Po S. (a) (\) =. '9. 0 (D ~ (\) @ ~ ~ :s (JQ § '8 @ ~ _.(\) 'g. ~ § ~ c: -'0 ..0 0 ~ (\) S :s (\) c: 3 ~ ~ ("'\ ~:I'" t") ~ :s '" :s '1:j _.:;:J ';! ~ g. ~ ~ ~ §'. ~ (\)s @ ~ ~ "'~ ~ ~. ~ ~ '&. 3.E. ~ i ~ ~.g ~ .'!;;- ~ .g =. g g g ~ o' :-~-..Jg. ~ ~"'1:j~t") St") ~ ~~g", (\)(\)S (\)(\)(D='(a(\)@ j :; ~~. ~ ~ S g ~. ~ § ï: ~ ~ s ) ~ â ~ ~; ~ @ § ~ g 'fD' ~ 5. ~ "go § ~ ~ ~ -~ .=. Po C (\), ~ '" '" ""1 =. :1'" =. -(a 0 '" '" § ~ t") t") ~""I _.C:: (D ~ ~ ., ~..,~, <-. (\) ~ (\)(\),c. -.0 0:1'" S-""c:(\) ~~ .~ ~ ?! rr. f? 3 g. ~ ~ ~ '1:j § c: (\) CIO' c: 5,. ~~. ~ '"": po Q ~ (\), S (\) '1:j :s ~ Q; (\), .N ~ 3 ~ c: t") ~ '1:j _.~ ~ ~ (\) -'1:j:S 0 _.'""t 0 (]CI (\) t") (\) ""1 (\) :;:J ~ ~ :::!;- g: g. !p, =.: 0 ~ ~,.g Z. ~ (D ~ ~ (a, ~ ~ ~ ;; ~ S (\), ~ o s 3 s (\) a g. 0 -..J g ~ ~, \N (\) 'it""l _.(\) c: ~ (\) ~ t") '1:j ~ @ ~ 'it, S 0 e', (\) ~. '0 0- ~ 3 -~ 0 ~ :s t") (\) S c: ~. 0;;. --~. ~ '" ~ ~ :J ~, O;?; ~ '1:j ~ t") ~ ~ ~ ,.. ~ Po -0= ~ :I'"""I < '" -~~(\)"";:;' '.0"":1'"""1'.'" .:... ë. c 3 ~ tt1 ~ ~. (\), '" ~ :s. (\) :J os g: Q S '" 'it ~ (\) ~ '" ~ (a (\), (\) ""1 ""' ~!= ~.~.., ~~ "'."'SS' (\)'. (;:r":S .c:'"' ~(\) ~~(D-~ ~ ~< ; ~ ~ ;. a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g go ' ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~. ~ 1 8 !lj ~ ~ ! ~ ~. ~ ~ .0 VI~ :s(\)(\). '''':l'"N'''' ~ ""~:s(\) '" -a ~. n ~ c '1:j""l:S ~ ~ :s (\), -o:S ~ (\) :1'" ~ ~ ~~.' 0 ~, <.. ~ Ci ~ ..,. ,-,,>< (D c: "":s ~ ""1:j q cr" :s 0 (\) ~t""' :s ~(\) (\) "'C:;:J:I'" g :0 fi -=0 5' S ~ O;?; ;; 2' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ S

o

r1" 3 'fD' fJ( (D ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ =. (\), 3 -..J~ '" t") ~"'c:

s

=,c_.:S ~ 'C:(\) c: (\) ""1 ""l'1:j oo~!'"'~ O ~ ~ ~ -.-=.'" ~(JQ~o""l,,",'9 ~:S:S~'""I""~ 'O" -'.'- '.(\)"""'0 _.(\)"._.~'" (\)""(\)-(\)(\)~ g. ~ (") c ~. 'g ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ § ~ E. ~ ~. (a :J. ~ 3 ~ (a ""1 ~ ~ '1:j S' 0- ~ ~ :s :;:J < (D '" _.'" t") '" ~ S _.""1 '1:j '" ~ (\) (\), (\) g ~::J 0 (\), '" :s (\) S- ~ ~ !p, !] (\) (\) c: (\) ~ (\) Q::3. -': (D :s :J. :s --~N::'. ,(\) -., '" , :" "'""1 ,.""1,."""""""

.

'" '" '" '" '" -'1:jt")~ëë-(a(\)S"'S-_.""/'""".""""I ~ ~ ~o ~ z f? ~ Œ: ~ Coc 3 (") m ~ :p ~ n .., 0 'g .., 0 ;1;- Po ~ ~ .g. ~. ~ (a ~ ~'~ (\) !p, (\) ~ .a i g g !p, j ..;:_._~"'~o.o-ao' 3 ~. (\), -'.(\):S :s '"""' ~~ ~ 5. ~ ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ g: Po 3 -< () ~. 3 ~ g- 3 ~ ;- c: (D (D ~ ~ ""' ~ (ÎQ' g 0 ~~."":S ~ 1 VI ;::"0 5 -&' ë a .: ~ 2. '0 0 ô 3 ("'\ a c tn. 3 Po ~ '1:j c: ~ (D ~ ~ :s '" (\) "':s "" S. ~ , .0 -S ;::- ~ a 3 2.":::0 [ 5. ~. E g: '" ~ c ~ ~'§ g Q ~ e; : ~ ~ t") ~ ,c (D ~ ~ ~ '1:j (D, ~ ~ ~ ~ ( s ~ -.., ~.., ~ rr,;.c -= (JQ =. ,., ~ =. = =.c _.'" 3 --i -~ 0 c: S (D (;:r" (\) < ~ -.,-o~-"~""c~==.ot!'.,~-=...,c.c -_c-S -~ (D _.~,- _.c ""' S t") . ~-O [" ~~~_.- ~ " .c~=> .u,"'" (D"'~-""~:s -(\) ( ~ 00... ~ ~ .;:: (JQ (JQ = tT1

§

1 0 ~ rr. ~ ~ = =. .~ ~ (\), ~ 'it ~ t"):S ,. (;:r""" (\) (\) ~ ~ --~ ~ g' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r- ~ (") (") o. ...~ Po < ~ ~ ~ § ~. ~ :s ~ (\) ';; ~ :s ~ "'~ :s (a,.1 S '" ; ~.'-~~ -.Co~' ~o ="'~~c-.= ,~ c:...' '" -"""_. (\);;;0. , "'~"';::-m~ ~~g.~A'- N ='O~g -:s 3 ""I:I'"",:s °'g""l 0 (\):s '" ~ (\):s .

~

1:

i

f

~

i

~

.~

~ i

;

~

r

1. ~

~ 1

i

~ :!

!

~

~.

~

[

i

~

~.

i

~

1. ~

~

i

~

;

~ g g,. 6 ~ tn. q.,.. ;1;- -~ ~ Y' ~ ~ ~ ~ = ~ ~ !:; ~ Po 'g :: ~ S' ""

",

:S c: ""1"" -~ ~ 0."., ~ = (\),.g ( ~""~- .~A=3'" "';:: -~.c-~"_. (;:r"-(\)t") ~:s ~(JQ(\) ""1:j -"" ~ ~ ~ m =. M ~ ~ "& -'< ~ Co 0 3 '" c ~ ~ g 1n" -~~ < < S (\), (\) ~ ~ _.'" :J 'it _.(\) (\) ( " '" ~ g ~ g a .., Po.., g 5. .-~ g- ~. 0 ~ (") g. ~ ~ (). t") (\) '" _.~ :;:J~' 0 s ~ =:s 0 ~ '"": ; ~ ~ Po ., = '< -..'" ~ '(0 ~

a

~. -.~ ~. a -0 3 = _.~ t") :s ""' ~ ~ :s:s c 0 ~ ~ ~ =. :s _.:;. , ";"'~'-0.V)-".t:::= 00 0 ~ ë~ ""(\)'c:~ " -' S =.' ~ =... .-,=0 3 -"Po",,=~~~,-.~N

8

=<!E"' a Po-'" (\)"" '" (\) ~:I'"'" ""1 "'. 0 t") ~ (\) (\) ~ f -~"'O ""<;~ (JQV__.~- ,~ "' (\) -0 ""1(\)'" ,. '-" f:; ~ 1'" Ej.. ~. ~ ~ 5."c .~ g ~ g .0 [ ~ e-. ~. § g -;; ~ 'ë: ~ -~ 0: (\) s' ~ (\), :s ~. ~:s :. ~ 3 i ~ > '" '0 ;1;- ~ .., F (JQ ~ ,-' ,,' ~ ~ ~ ~ _ o .~ Po = ~ Q (\) (\) S '" t") ~:s ~ 0 1 (\) C f c'O~t!',<o '" ~']:.., 000=.-' ~-.., -':S:S"'3 "'0... =.0-' g. Q §. :... 5. ~ V) ~ 8 ~ ~. n.~ N @ ::e ~ â g :. ~ ~ ~ §: '" ~,c (\) ~ ~ ~ ~ S S ~ § ~ :s § 8 ~ @ ~ Po ~ -~ ;1;- ~ -:;g:; r--.g 8 Po ':-' ~ g r;; ~ ~ ~ '0 e:. 'fD' ~ c: .:-' 8. :1'" (a '1:j S ~ g :s =. C:: ~ :s S N C ~ ~ g- ~ .~ ~. .v '0 ~. .-~ ~ >< -3 0 ~ = ~ ""1 (\) (\) '"": c: ~ :=" c: _.~ (\) 0 (\) ~ ~ : § ~-- ='0 .'~"'o '0 --q-. (\)t")""'-~'_.""'_."":S(\)' -:s u,"c -~ ~. '" -'8 0 .., '0 5. ~ -.= ~'< :: ~ 0 ~ Co ~ _ 0-.""' ~ ~ (\) ~ ~.,; '" ~ ~ c: 'fD' ""1 S

_.-("\>0. =z"'~. :::jN'" O~.(JQ"'Po-~'O= -CIO ~'" Hl" ,. ~,~ c: ,. (\) '" ~(\) (\) g .c '8 '(O

a

.g. ~ ct ?: '-" § -? ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~..~ c:

'"

~ (\), ~ (\), ~ ~ '" ~ S- ~.: ~ (D (\), :s ~, ~ ;:;", A'",O ~ ~'" Q) -,~~ ~"'t")"'-O ~-_"""' (D-""""~ C ~'" ~~'(O_.'~_.~ -"'Po=Poc~..,c :="'C(\) '""' (\)-'""It")~ ~~""I- -fi53' -.4' .., ~ ct '" '0 '-" C _.:;.~. ~ N~ 0 ~ (\) :s :s ~. w 0\ J ~ '" '" (\) 0 '""t t") t") cr" (\), t") -~ ",o::r ~;.'Ooo ~ ~ 00'" 3 ~.- c: '" O""l=:(\)"; -~.~ 3=~:-:j ...:J:-"""~Po '" ~ (\)~(\):=.. ~S -'~(D~...~ S O(\) (\), ;::~;' oC tT10 (") a'...,q-~.~_a;::.. ""t")..(\),S' r;;- Q _./'""".~ 1-.-~ ~ o"'~t!'.\O. c,-,,_.Oq..,~c' -t") "' S =--'.n S "'~~ < N :;. < S.(JQ ~ ~ 51 -< 0;.1 -< = 51 f? = _.=: ~ = '0 ~ (\)' '"": ~ (\) _.0 e:. ~ _.:s 0 (\) '" < ~ o' < 00 ~ s' ~ ,,' § ;" ~ > -0 t ~ ~ '" ...g" N -~ ~ 0' '" ~ ~ 3 ~ c: (a ..0 S q S ""1 § ~ -:s u E: ~ ~ 5 -~ [~ ~ ~ ::t;> ~ ~ n ~ 3 g. § ~ ~ .g ~ 'i @, ~ ~ o. 'fD':, c: ~. ~. S @ @ t") ~. ~ =". ~.., '!" :J ~.. '-" (") ,., :I: -0 = '-' _.~ _.~ '< "':S :s S _.(\) 0 _.""' (\) '-' Nf'" ~ N.c.."T1~.~ o~~~",.eJ.~", :=...~(\)t")~(\) ~(\)'~~':S~ N~~(\)~ § -o~oo~gtT1<m;l;- 3-"'Poor-"'~~ C::S"'~"""" ""I~-'""II"'. (\) (\) 0 = = = .~ tT1 ~ .3 ;1;- ~ ~ a ~ Po ~ <:T ""1 Co '" ~ =. t") 0 (\) 0 '"": ë c: c: ~ $ 0 ~ 0 ,0 a ~ z ~ 0 ~. ~ Po (") ~ ~ ~ (\) ~ ~ '1:j S :l'"~,:s '1:j S:s _.~ :s ~ -.'0 '" < C ~ > < !!! > ~". .., _.::r 0 -~ ~ ~ ~ '1:j c: (\) (\), (a e: \N :s (\) '" -~ 2. '< ~ ~ g. ~ 8 tT1:I: ~ ""~. ~ ~ 3 -~ ;;3 '" (D ~ '< e', (JQ '"": O:s .\N 'it '" (\) ~ c tn. _0 [E ~'."O ~ Z Z Co ~ g. 6: g 3 a ...~ t") '1:j ~ g;..g (D, s c: ~ :. 1 ""1 ~ ~ (]CI s =~ r;; ~c 0""" ~>=cc-.~""'- oc'1:j~t")"" 0-.<""1 ~ S eJ. ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ ~.tT1' ~ Z ëi; '" C". ~ ~ a 9' ~. :s (;:r" ~ (D _.(\) (JQ ~ (\) (\) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ (\) ..,~.", ,. ~o.~' o-_.~::.c ""l'''''''''''""I'''""I ~ (\)'.:s (")o~ ~ ~ a:g § ~~. ~ 9 ~ .~. ~ >. ~. S ~ ~ ; ~ 8. S 5: 'fD' '8 ~ ~ .g. "" o~' 'iD ~ S g ~ ~ ~ r;; =- ..,~.><="'(JQ..,~ ~.."..,_.= o~'" 'it"'cO- _.~'1:j=. ~ _.~ ~ ~- _.~"'::,.;::m ~=~t:::-~,<-~ '" 'O.,;:S"",c:S-'""t""l(\) '.~""I~ ~ ~ ~ g' g c ~ ~ ~ .Po eJ. ...~ ~ ~ .=. (\) (D c: n '" 3 c: ""' (JQ (\), '" ~ '1:j ~ ~ '< .., '" ~ '" ...:-: Ç"J c@ Y' ~'= ~ g ~ '" '1' (\) '" =. _.(\) S- (\) c: D. 'fD' 0 =1. ~ ~ ". -'" , l' :s (\) -';;

Doctrine

~-- -~-~--~-=c;"~,,, ~,,=,~"'"