• Aucun résultat trouvé

Structural analysis of a binary metallic glass model. I. — The Pd80Si20 alloy

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Structural analysis of a binary metallic glass model. I. — The Pd80Si20 alloy"

Copied!
8
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: jpa-00209962

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00209962

Submitted on 1 Jan 1985

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Structural analysis of a binary metallic glass model. I. - The Pd80Si20 alloy

F. Lançon, L. Billard, J. Laugier, A. Chamberod

To cite this version:

F. Lançon, L. Billard, J. Laugier, A. Chamberod. Structural analysis of a binary metal- lic glass model. I. - The Pd80Si20 alloy. Journal de Physique, 1985, 46 (2), pp.235-241.

�10.1051/jphys:01985004602023500�. �jpa-00209962�

(2)

Structural analysis of a binary metallic glass model.

I.

2014

The Pd80Si20 alloy (+)

F. Lançon (*), L. Billard, J. Laugier and A. Chamberod

Centre d’Etudes Nucléaires de Grenoble, Département de Recherche Fondamentale, Section de Physique du Solide, 85X, 38041 Grenoble Cedex, France

(Reçu le 13 juillet 1984, accepté le 23 octobre 1984 )

Résumé. 2014 Dans le premier papier de cette série consacrée à l’analyse structurale d’un alliage métallique amorphe

nous étudions un échantillon de Pd80Si20 obtenu par relaxation numérique. Nous discutons la reproductibilité

de la méthode et comparons avec les fonctions d’interférence expérimentales. Nous abordons l’analyse structurale

microscopique sous plusieurs angles : nous étudions le nombre de voisins de chaque type pour chaque type d’atomes, ensuite, nous effectuons une analyse en termes de polyèdres définis à partir de plans radicaux, enfin, nous montrons qu’on peut généraliser les cinq unités géométriques décrites par Bernal de façon à caractériser sans ambiguïté

l’environnement de n’importe quel atome de silicium. L’ensemble de ces méthodes révèle en particulier une certaine

tendance pour les atomes de silicium à avoir un environnement prismatique.

Abstract.

2014

In the first paper of this series devoted to a structural analysis of a binary metallic glass model, we study

a Pd80Si20 sample obtained by numerical relaxation. We discuss the reproducibility of the method and make a

comparison with the experimental interference functions. Then we undertake a microscopic structural analysis

from several points of view : we first study the number of neighbours of each type for each type of atoms; secondly,

we analyse the structure by means of the radical plane method; at last, we show that it is possible to generalize

the five fundamental characteristic units introduced by Bernal, so that we can define the environment of any Si atom without any ambiguity. All these methods reveal a certain tendency towards a prismatic environment for the metalloids.

Classification Physics Abstracts

61. 40D

1. Introduction.

Numerical relaxation of various random packings of spheres has been widely used to provide models for amorphous metallic structures. The first attempts were naturally done with one type of atoms and although only metallic glass alloys are stable at room tempera- ture, this first stage has been very fruitful towards

achieving a better understanding of the amorphous

state. It has yielded sample models having both a high density and a pair distribution function typical of

metallic glass structure, which are the two main features to be accounted for in a realistic model. On the other hand, a great deal of work has been done con-

cerning the microscopic analysis of these models [1-5] :

number of neighbours, local structural units, statistics

(+) The main part of this work is a part of the thesis of F. Laneon, University of Grenoble, France (April 18, 1984).

about the Voronoi cells, and the search for holes or

interstitial sites. It should be noted that these results

depend essentially on the potential used, but not on the starting configuration or on the details of the relaxation

procedure.

Naturally, the experimental situation has called for models with several types of atoms and some models have been proposed [6-15]. However, the situation is far from clear; on one hand, this is due to a greater com- plexity of the model : necessity for introducing several types of potentials, analysis in terms of partial pair

correlation functions, difficulties in finding an unambi-

guous description of local structures, etc. But on the other hand, this is due to a more fundamental diver- gence among workers on this subject. Schematically,

one can distinguish two ways of thinking : either one

considers that a good choice of potentials will lead naturally to a good representation, or one assumes that

a good choice of the initial configuration (even if it

needs a relaxation) will be the main ingredient in the

model.

Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:01985004602023500

(3)

236

We propose here an approach of the first type, where

the initial configuration is considered to be of lesser

importance. After having described the construction of the model, we discuss the reproducibility of the

results. Then, we analyse the atomic environments, using several methods. It appears that the local struc- tures are not as disordered as may have been supposed

in such a model : we find strong evidence for local

geometric units analogous to those which are imposed

« by hand » in other models, but which are here the

mere result of the relaxation. In a second paper, we

will study the composition dependence and show in

particular that the density can be well interpreted

if one makes the approximation that Si atoms are not neighbours.

2. Construction of the modeL

We first describe the construction of a model for a

Pd80S’20 amorphous alloy. We choose a modified

Johnson potential 4lj, which has given good results in

the monoatomic case [5]. For each type of pair ij (i, j

=

Pd or Si), we make a homothetic transformation

on Wj, so that the position rij and the depth eij of the minimum are given by

These values have been taken from [13].

We use periodic boundary conditions, and let the

size of the periodic box vary according to the minimi-

zation procedure, in order to obtain relaxed states under zero pressure.

Two classes of starting configurations are consider- ed, corresponding to two different methods :

2.1 THE SUBSTITUTIONAL METHOD. - First we consi- der a monoatomic sample relaxed in a Johnson poten- tial [5]; it remains stable after a change of the length

scale with a factor rPdPd/ro, where ro is the position of

the minimum of 0, with which the sample was relaxed, Starting with this « pure Pd amorphous state », we

construct a Pd80S’20 alloy by replacing 20 pct of initial atoms by Si atoms, at random. In order to test the reproducibility, two initial samples are built from

two monoatomic relaxed samples. Then, they are

relaxed in the previously defined system of pair potentials. The energy per atom, E, and the atomic

density po are shown on table I, together with the dispersion between the two states. We see that we

obtain a good reproducibility.

2.2 THE INTERSTITIAL METHOD.

-

It has been shown that [5] ] the monoatomic amorphous state can be fully analysed in terms of interstitial sites which are

deltahedra, i.e. polyhedra with triangular faces. Start- ing with the same two samples as above, we introduce

Si atoms in these interstitial sites, beginning with the

Table I.

-

Potential energy per atom E (in units of 8PdPd) and atomic density po (number of atoms per unit

volume, in units of 10-2 A- 3). The table gives the

means (x) over two configurations and the difference (Ax)

between them.

largest of these holes. This is reminiscent of the model of Polk [16], but it must be emphasized that, in a relaxed monoatomic model, there are very few large holes; in particular, to obtain a 20 pct metalloid concentration, some of the Si atoms must be introduc- ed in smaller (octahedral) sites.

Then, these two « interstitial type » alloys are relaxed, and the results are given in table I. Here also,

the reproducibility between these two samples is very

good.

2.3 THE FINAL METHOD.

-

However, it can be seen in table I that the dispersion between the states of the

substitutional method and those of the interstitial

one is rather large, being of the order of several per cent in relative value, instead of several per thousand for the dispersion between two states in the same class.

A better reproducibility is obtained by « anneal- ing » by means of a mechanical cycle, which has been shown to give good results in the monoatomic case.

For each sample a compression strain is applied step by step, up to 12 % : at each step, the dimensions of the cubic box are decreased by one per cent and the energy is minimized with respect to the atomic coordinates.

Then the strain is gradually decreased using the same procedure. Finally, full minimization is made with respect to coordinates and density variations. Thus,

each sample is subject to 25 new relaxations. The results are shown in table I, and it is seen that we have

now a better reproducibility between the two classes.

This is confirmed by the comparison between the pair

correlation functions. Figure 1 shows the partial pair

correlation functions and the partial interference functions obtained in the case of the interstitial build- ing after mechanical treatment. We have not repre- sented the curves obtained in the case of the substitu- tional building, because they are very close to the

previous ones.

(4)

Fig. 1.

-

Partial pair correlation functions and partial

interference functions for a Pd,,Si,o model (initial intersti-

tial construction followed by a relaxation and a mechanical

annealing).

2.4 COMPARISON WITH EXPERIMENTS.

-

We compare the results given by the simulation to the experimental X-ray diffraction curve. If we make the approximation,

Fig. 2.

-

Comparison of pair correlation functions with

experiments : a) experimental (dashed line) and simulated

(continuous line) curves for 4 I7po r[gx(r) - 1].

b) Neutron experiments obtained by [18] using several

values of the cut-off Km in the interference functions, and corresponding curve for the model.

which is shown to be very good in this case, that the weighting terms of the partial interference function in the expression of Sx(q) are q-independent, we have :

Figure 2a shows the curves 4 nrPo[gx(r) - I], experimental and simulated : in this latter case, a

rescaling of lengths with a factor 1.012 has been made to adjust the phases of oscillations at large r. This

leads to a value of the density po

=

0.0717 (A)- 3 or, for the volumic mass, p.

=

10.8 g/cm3, as compared

with known data of 10.63 g/cm3 [9], 10.3-10.5 g/cm3 [13]

or 10.25 g/cm3 [17].

The curves are also in good agreement : let us just

notice that the model yields a small pre-peak, which

is due to a contribution of Pd-Si pairs, and this is also obtained in the experiment.

Turning now to neutron diffraction experiments,

one obtains

which is compared to an experimental result of [18]

in figure 2b. The pre-peak is now clearly visible.

As for the partial correlation functions, we have experimental results of [19] which give the partial

Pd-Pd and Pd-Si functions obtained through X-ray

and neutron diffraction experiments and the assump- tion that Ss;s,

=

1. Combining equations (1) and (2)

Fig. 3.

-

Partial pair interference functions obtained by [19] using the hypothesis Ssis;

=

1 and corresponding curves

for the model.

(5)

238

one obtains Spdpd and SPdsi as functions of Sx, Sn and Ss;s;. It will be seen that this gives pseudo-partial func-

tions and

which we have calculated from the model and are

compared with the experimental results on figure 3.

The agreement with experimental results can be

considered as rather satisfactory, taken into account that we have used very simplified interatomic interac- tions.

3. Structural analysis.

3.1 NUMBERS OF NEIGHBOURS.

-

One can find in the literature on amorphous alloys different results for these numbers. This may be due to differences between

experimental situations or between basically different models, but it is also clearly due to the lack of a clear

definition of what is the nearest neighbour distance in a

disordered medium. As for us, it can be seen on figure 1

that the partial pair correlation functions gPdPd and gPdSi have a clear minimum with zero value, situated

at 1.26 times rPdPd and rPdSi, respectively, and it is

rather natural to define the corresponding neighbour- ing pairs as those which have a length less than this

limiting value. The situation is not so clear for Si-Si

pairs, as emphasized on figure 4 which shows the mean

number nij(r) of j-atoms at a distance less than r from

an i-atom. Thus, we take the same limiting value

1.26 rsisl for the Si-Si neighbouring pairs, but it is quite arbitrary. Table II shows the results obtained with those assumptions. The most striking feature is that most of the Si atoms have either 8 or 9 Pd neighbours :

let us recall that this strong ordering has not been pre-

imposed but is the result of the relaxation.

3.2 BERNAL ENVIRONMENTS.

-

For each Si atom, we have searched for a trigonal prismatic environment,

6 Pd atoms making two triangles linked by three

« square » faces : in fact, such a face is a cycle of

order 4, the diagonals of which are greater than 1.26 rpdpd (as discussed above), the sides of which are

less than 1.26 rPdPd (and so are the sides of the two triangles). Moreover, the distance from the central Si to each of the six Pd must be less than 1.26 rPds;.

We have found that the proportion of Si atoms in prisms varies from P

=

6 ± 1 per cent to P

=

22 ± 2 per cent in the substitutional case, before and after the mechanical treatment, and from P

=

36 + 6 per cent

Table II.

-

Number of neighbours in the model.

(6)

Fig. 4.

-

Mean number niir) of atoms of type j which are

at a distance less than

r

from an i atom : neighbouring of Pd

atoms (left curves) and Si atoms (right curves).

to P

=

30 ± 4 per cent in the interstitial case. The

dispersion between two samples in the same class is roughly of the order of magnitude of the fluctuation which could be expected for a set of N Si atoms (here

N - 300) having the probability P of being in a prism.

We notice that the mechanical treatment has not been sufficient to reduce the dispersion between the two

classes of models, but these differences represent very local variations, as compared to the reproducibility

of the density, the energy or the pair correlation func- tions. Some of these prisms may have one or more

square faces capped with a supplementary Pd atom, and we have found that about 2/3 of the prisms were capped three times, about 1/3 capped twice, and very few capped one time or not capped at all.

By the same method, other Bernal environments

can be searched for : we have found (after mechanical treatment) about 14 per cent Si atoms in Archimedean

antiprisms, 4 per cent Si in tetragonal dodecahedra, practically no Si (1 over 344) in octahedra, and none

in tetrahedra.

This describes the environment of about 40 per cent of the Si atoms and we need a more sophisticated

method to analyse the other ones.

3. 3 RADICAL PLANE METHOD.

-

A generalization of

the Voronoi polyhedra has been proposed [20] to analyse amorphous alloys, by means of polyhedra

defined by radical planes : these are the planes contain- ing all the points M for which the distances from M to the tangency points to two atomics spheres are equal.

Taking an atomic radius Rpd

=

rpdpd/2 and Rsi =

rPdSi

-

Rpd, one can thus obtain a full decomposition

into polyhedra associated with these radical planes.

Each polyhedron can be characterized by the set (n3l n4, n5...) of integers ni, where ni represents the number of faces of the polyhedron which have i sides.

As for the polyhedra around Pd atoms, we observe a

predominance of the (0, 2, 8, 4) type (about 11 per cent of Pd atoms) which was also the case for the mono-

atomic amorphous (in this case, using the Voronoi decomposition). But we are mainly concerned with the

polyhedra around Si atoms.

The analysis [20] of samples obtained by Gaskell (trigonal prismatic packing and distorted prismatic packing) [13-14], by relaxation under a Lennard-Jones

type potential had shown very few topologically- perfect prismatic polyhedra (0, 3, 6). In fact, other types of polyhedra were found, which can be considered

as resulting from slight distortions starting from a prism, but we have no measure of the amplitude of

such a distortion; for instance a type like (0, 2, 8) corresponds simply to an Archimedean antiprism

with its two square faces capped by half an octahedron.

In our samples, the analysis has given the following

results for the more frequent types of environments of the Si atoms :

22 pct : (0, 3, 6)

14 pct : (0, 3, 8)

8 pct : (0, 3, 6, 1)

7 pct : (0, 2, 8,1 )

etc.

Moreover, we can look at what type of neighbour (Pd or Si) each face corresponds and for instance, we

have found that the 22 pct of prismatic environments

can be decomposed into

16 pct : (OPd + OSi, 3Pd + OSi, 6Pd + OSi) and

6 pct : (OPd + OSi, 2Pd + ISi, 6Pd + OSi).

This corresponds truly to prisms of Pd capped with respectively 3 or 2 supplementary Pd atoms. Due to a

different definition, these numbers differ slightly from

those obtained in 3.2, but are in rather good agreement

showing the presence of prisms and antiprisms.

Nevertheless, a further refinement is necessary if one

whishes a complete description of all Si environments.

3.4 DELTAHEDRA AROUND SI ATOMS. - As previously,

the Pd neighbours of a given Si atom are defined as

those Pd atoms which are nearer than 1.26 rPdSi; then,

among these Pd atoms, the « nearest neighbours »

are defined as those which are nearer than 1.26 rpdpd from each other. We are now interested in the descrip-

tion of such a Pd environment. In fact, considering a given environment, we can find the Si atoms which have such one : that was done, in 3.2, for the Bernal environments. Can we find all possible environments, i.e., can we find the Pd environment of each Si atom in a systematic manner without having defined it at the

beginning ? This seems a formidable task [1] due to

the large variety of geometric figures which can be imagined, but we will describe now an easy method

to succeed in it.

In the case of a monoatomic sample, we have

shown [5] that the vertices of the Voronoi polyhedra

were associated to a tetrahedron formed by the four

atoms which are equidistant from each other. Here, similarly the vertices of the radical planes polyhedra

are associated to a tetrahedron formed by the four

atoms which have the same tangent length from

them. These tetrahedra form a network which is the

topological inverse of the network of the radical planes polyhedra vertices, and provides a complete and unambiguous description of the structure.

Now, we can work as previously [5] and cluster

together tetrahedra sharing long pairs, i.e. pairs of

(7)

240

neighbours in the geometric radical plane sense which

are longer than 1.26 rpdPd or 1.26 rpdS¡’ according

to the nature of the pair. As for Si-Si pairs, being

interested only in Pd environment of Si atoms, we do

not admit any Si-Si geometric pair as a short pair,

i.e. any Si-Si pair is considered as long and is thus

a nucleus for our clusterization procedure. The details of the method have been given elsewhere [5], and

we are finally left with units bounded by triangular faces, the edges of which are near-neighbour pairs

Pd-Pd or Pd-Si only, which do not overlap and completely fill the space, constituting a deltahedron network.

Now, let us consider any Si atom. It is a common vertex to several deltahedra, and thus we have simply

all the neighbour pairs Si-Pd from the central Si atom.

Moreover, we have the connectivity between these Pd atoms, because we know the short pairs linking them,

as being the edges of the deltahedra. For instance, let us

suppose that : (i) the Si atom is a common vertex of

deltahedra Dl, D2, ... etc..., (ii) this Si atom is linked

to Pd atoms X1, X2, X3 and X4 of the deltahedron Dj, (iii) there are links (short pairs being edges of D1) only between Xl X 2, X2 X3, X3 X4, X4 X1. If we

« rub out » the PdSi pairs from the central Si, we see it as the «centre» of an environment having a

« square » face Xi X 2 X3 X4. To characterize the latter, we imagine a fictitious vertex Y linked to X1, X 2, X3 and X4. thus constituting a cap as a half- octahedron : the square face X1 X 2 X3 X4 is now replaced by four fictitious triangular faces Y XIX 2’

YX 2 X3, YX 3 X 4, YX4 X1. In this manner, we have

defined for each Si atom an environment which is a

deltahedron (limited only by triangular faces) : it can

be characterized by the comer numbers (n4’ ns ...) where ni means the numbers of comers (vertices)

common to i (triangular faces). The description will be

complete when one says what are the fictitious caps, and we can give simply their numbers (m4, m5, ...).

For example, a trigonal prism with two square faces

capped is obtained, starting from a trigonal prism

with its three square faces capped and indexed by

p

=

(3, 6) by removing one cap, which is a vertex common to 4 triangular faces so that the missing caps indices are m

=

(1, 0).

Table III gives the more frequent fictitious del- tahedra environments for the 344 Si atoms in the model. Naturally, among them, one finds the Bernal environments discussed in 3.2, and it has been verified that the two methods of search coincide in these cases. However, some Bernal environments can

be parts of more complex environments and that

happened in a few cases.

4. Conclusion

Starting with a relaxed monoatomic model for an

amorphous metal, we have constructed binary samples, using two classes of methods : one corresponds to introducing Si atoms in substitutional positions, the

other to introducing Si atoms in interstitial positions.

After relaxation, both samples remain different but a

cycle of compression greatly reduces the disparities :

in fact, one obtains a very good reproducibility as far

as macroscopic values of energy, density or pair

correlation functions are concerned. Moreover, the agreement with experimental data is encouraging, taking into account the necessarily crude approxima-

tions which must be made in the choice of the inter- action potentials.

However, and unlike the monoatomic case, the mechanical treatment is not completely sufficient to obtain a state which is well reproducible at a micro- scopic scale. In fact, we have made a detailed analysis

Table III.

-

Local deltahedra around Si atoms.

(8)

of the local structure : it appears that the PdPd and PdSi pairs show distributions which are similar to those of monoatomic pairs. On the contrary, the Si

atoms have practically no correlation between them- selves, even at short distances. The microscopic study

can be developed from several points of view : one can

define the neighbour pairs as those which correspond

to the first peak of the correlation function up to its first (well defined) minimum, or one can use the radical

planes method for providing a full analysis of the

structure. The most frequent local structures around the Si atoms have been found to be the trigonal prism

and the Archimedean antiprism, in respective pro-

portions of 30 pct and 14 pct in the first type of ana- lysis, or 22 pct and 14 pct in the second type. Finally, combining the criterium for neighbour pairs with the decomposition through the radical planes, we have

been able to describe the local Pd environment of any Si atom in terms of fictitious deltahedra, and the predominance of the two local units just quoted has

been confirmed

This type of analysis can be pursued in any binary glass model, and in particular, it can be developed in Pd, -.,,Si., alloys to understand the composition depen-

dence of these properties : this is the field of a second paper.

References

[1] FROST, H. J., Acta Met. 30 (1982) 889.

[2] FINNEY, J. L., WALLACE, J., J. Non Cryst. Solids 43 (1981) 165.

[3] WHITTAKER, E. J. W., J. Non Cryst. Solids 28 (1978) 293.

[4] AHMADZADEH, M., CANTOR, B., J. Non Cryst. Solids 43 (1981) 189.

[5] LANÇON, F., BILLARD, L., CHAMBEROD, A., J. Phys. F :

Metal Phys. 14 (1984) 579.

[6] SADOC, J. F., DIXMIER, J., GUINIER, A., J. Non Cryst.

Solids 12 (1973) 46.

[7] VON HEIMENDAHL, L., J. Phys. F : Met. Phys. 9 (1979)

161.

[8] BOUDREAUX, D. S., Phys. Rev. B 18 (1978) 4039.

[9] BOUDREAUX, D. S., FROST, H. J., Phys. Rev. B 23 (1981)

1506.

[10] FUJIWARA, T., CHEN, M. S., WASEDA, Y., J. Phys. F. :

Metal Phys. 11 (1981) 1327.

[11] KOBAYASHI, S., MAEDA, K., TAKEUCHI, S., J. Phys. Soc.

Japan 48 (1980) 1147.

[12] HARRIS, R., LEWIS, L. J., Phys. Rev. B 25 (1982) 4997.

[13] GASKELL, P. H., J. Non Cryst. Solids 32 (1979) 207.

[14] GASKELL, P. H., J. Phys. C : Solid State Phys. 12 (1979)

4337.

[15] DUBOIS, J. M., LE CAER, G., J. Physique Colloq. C 9 (1982) 67.

[16] POLK, D. E., Acta Met. 20 (1972) 485.

[17] GARGILL, G. S. III, Solid State Physics, ed. H. Ehren-

reich, F. Seitz and D. Turnbull 30 (1975) 227.

[18] SADOC, J. F., DIXMIER, J., The Structure of Non-Crys-

talline Materials, ed. P. H. Gaskell (Taylor &

Francis LTD, London) 1977, p. 85.

[19] SUZUKI, K., FUKUNAGA, T., MISAWA, M., MASUMOTO, T., Materials Science Engin. 23 (1976) 215.

[20] GELLATLY, B. J., FINNEY, J. L., J. Non Cryst. Solids 50

(1982) 313.

Références

Documents relatifs

The purpose of the present paper is to obtain the physical spin correlation functions for this model, in particular, the one point functions for the local spin operators at distance

A decrease in Q-' was observed with annealing time, fig.(2-a), and was accentuated by incr- easing the annealing temperature, The cross-cut method was used to

elfect on tue structure factors of trie wavy boundaries of tue AS are very similar to tuat of tue perpendicular Debye-Waller factor. Tue experimental data cannot elucidate wuat is

To the best of our knowledge, we provide for the first time sufficient conditions ensuring the existence of a steady state regime for the Green-Keldysh correlation functions

no correlations between Si atoms and this is also revealed by a partial Si-Si pair correlation functions.. showing practically no structure, as previously

A comparison of our predictions for the spin-wave energy and damping with the experimental values deduced for CoF2 by neutron scattering [6] is limited by

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

On the basis of our S receiver functions, the lithosphere-asthenosphere boundary of the subducting African plate is at 100 km depth beneath the southern part of the Aegean region