How alternative is alternative medicine?

(1)

Article

Reference

How alternative is alternative medicine?

STRASSER, Bruno J.

STRASSER, Bruno J. How alternative is alternative medicine? Nature Medicine , 2007, vol. 13, no. 7, p. 237-239

Available at:

http://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:17023

Disclaimer: layout of this document may differ from the published version.

1 / 1

(2)

" / / + 2 % 6 ) % 7

(OWALTERNATIVEISALTERNATIVE MEDICINE

-AVERICKSOF-EDICINE

#ONVERSATIONSONTHE&RONTIERS OF-EDICINE

$AVID*AY"ROWN

3MART0UBLICATIONS PPSOFTCOVER )3".

**2EVIEWEDBY"RUNO*3TRASSER**

)FYOUAREINTERESTEDINLIVINGLONGERANDIMPROVINGYOURSEXUALPER FORMANCE-AVERICKSOF-EDICINEMAYBETHEBOOKFORYOU$AVID*AY

"ROWNPRESENTSBREEZYINTERVIEWSWITHUNCONVENTIONALBIOMEDICAL THINKERSINCLUDINGLEADINGFIGURESINALTERNATIVEMEDICINE3OMEOF THEPERSONALITIESINTERVIEWEDARERENOWNEDSCIENTISTSWHEREASOTH ERS ARE BETTER KNOWN FOR THEIR POPULAR BOOKS AND DIETS )N ANSWER TO"ROWNSQUESTIONSMOSTLYABOUTAGINGANDSEXTHEYDISCUSSTHE VIRTUESOFOMEGACOENZYME1STEMCELLSANDOTHERPRODUCTS FOUNDORSOONTOBEFOUNDINVITAMINANDSUPPLEMENTSSHOPS4HEY PRESENT VARIOUS BIOLOGICAL THEORIES OF AGING AND REFLECTIONS ABOUT THE!MERICANHEALTHSYSTEMINGENERALANDTHE53&OODAND$RUG

!DMINISTRATION&$! INPARTICULAR!SSUCHTHISBOOKOFFERSAVALU ABLELOOKATALTERNATIVEMEDICINEANDANOPPORTUNITYTOREFLECTONITS ENDURINGPOPULARITY

"ROWNISTHEAUTHOROFTHREESIMILARBOOKSANDTWOSCIENCEFIC TIONNOVELS)N-AVERICKSOF-EDICINEHEASKSQUESTIONSINTHESAME CRITICALSPIRITASTHE02OFFICEROFACOMPANYPREPARINGAPRESSRELEASE WITHHISORHER#%/FOREXAMPLEh#OULDYOUTALKALITTLEBITABOUT SOMEOFTHEBENEFICIALEFFECTSYOURPATIENTSHAVEHADWITHCARNOSINE SUPPLEMENTSv

4HUSREADERSMAYDISMISSATTHEOUTSETANYEXPECTATIONSTHAT"ROWN MIGHTCONFRONTSOMEOFTHEGLARINGCONTRADICTIONSBETWEENTHESEDIFFER ENTDIETSORCHALLENGETHEWILDESTASSERTIONSOFHISSUBJECTS.OTTHATHE SHOULDHAVEDONESOTOAVOIDANYLEGALTROUBLESINCETHEBOOKCONTAINSA DISCLAIMERTHATTHEAUTHORANDTHEPUBLISHERSHALLHAVEhNEITHERLIABILITY ORRESPONSIBILITYTOANYPERSON;FOR=DAMAGECAUSEDv

"ROWNSWRITINGSTYLEISREPETITIVEhHEWASRIDICULEDBYHISMEDICAL COLLEAGUESWHOTHOUGHTTHEIDEARIDICULOUSv ANDHISEDITINGMINIMAL 2EFERENCESTOTHEPAPERSMENTIONEDBYTHEINTERVIEWEESTOSUPPORT THEIR VIEWS ARE ALMOST NEVER GIVEN PERHAPS BECAUSEhTHE SCIENTIFIC LITERATUREINTHISCOUNTRYISENTIRELYCONTROLLEDv)NSTEAD"ROWNPRO VIDESTHEADDRESSESOFTHEAUTHORSWEBSITESFORTHOSEINSEARCHOFAN INDEPENDENTOPINION4OENLIGHTENTHEREADERFURTHER"ROWNOFFERS

AGLOSSARYDEFININGPEPTIDESAShCHEMICALMESSENGERSvANDVITAMINS ASCOMPOUNDShWHICHCANNOTBESYNTHESIZEDBYTHEBODYv(EALSO MAKESCLEARTHATGREATMINDSINHABITALMOSTEXCLUSIVELYMALEBODIES INTERVIEWEESOUTOF

"ROWNSRATIONALEFORFOCUSINGONTHISPARTICULARSETOFINDIVIDUALS ISTHAThALLSCIENTIFICANDMEDICALPROGRESSvHASORIGINATEDFROMhMAV ERICKTHINKERSv4HISCOMMONVIEWOFHISTORYISEITHERTRIVIALLYRIGHTOR FACTUALLYWRONG)FhMAVERICKvDESIGNATESANYONEWHOCOMESUPWITHA NEWTHEORYITISTRIVIALLYTRUEASPROGRESSENTAILSNOVELTY)FhMAVERICKv REFERSTOPEOPLECONSIDEREDTOBE@QUACKSITISFACTUALLYWRONG7ILLIAM (ARVEYAND'ALILEOWERENOMORE@REGARDEDASQUACKSINTHEIRTIME THAN*AMES7ATSONAND$AVID"ALTIMOREAREINOURS&URTHERMORE

"ROWNSEEMSTOTHINKTHATBEINGCONSIDEREDWRONGTODAYINCREASES YOURCHANCESOFBEINGCONSIDEREDRIGHTTOMORROW4HISLOGICISHARD TOFOLLOW

(OWEVERTHISBOOKMUSTBEVALUABLE!FTERALLTHEBACKCOVERBLURBS INCLUDESTRONGENDORSEMENTBYTWOINDIVIDUALSWHOPRAISETHIShWON DERFULvBOOKANDTHEhINTELLIGENTvVIEWPOINTSITCONTAINSINCLUDING THEIROWNSINCETHEYAREINTERVIEWEDINTHEBOOK

3OMEOFTHESCIENTISTSINTERVIEWEDOFFERMOREINTERESTINGIFCON TROVERSIALINSIGHTS#ELLBIOLOGIST,EONARD(AYFLICKFOREXAMPLEWHO DEVELOPEDTHEFIRSTNORMALHUMANDIPLOIDCELLLINEPRESENTSREASONABLE ARGUMENTSABOUTTHECELLULARAGINGPROCESS(EMAKESAGOODCASEFOR PUTTINGMOREEMPHASISONSTUDYINGTHEAGINGPROCESSITSELFRATHERTHAN THEDISEASESTHATGENERALLYOCCURINLATEAGE

!NUMBEROFTHEINTERVIEWEESAREHIGHLYCRITICALANDRIGHTLYSOOF POSSIBLECONFLICTSOFINTERESTATTHE&$!ANDOFTHEPHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRYSGREED"UTTHEYFAILTOMENTIONAND$AVID*AY"ROWNISTOO SHYTOASKIFTHEYTHEMSELVESHAVEANYFINANCIALINTERESTINTHESUPPLE MENTSTHEYADVOCATE4HE@ADDTOCARTBUTTONSDECORATINGTHEIRWEBSITES SUGGESTTHATTHEIRCONFLICTSOFINTERESTAREBLATANTASTHEYSELLTHESUPPLE MENTSTHATTHEYRECOMMENDSUPPOSEDLYBASEDONTHEIRhRESEARCHv

4HEHIGHPRICEOFPRESCRIPTIONDRUGSTHEEMOTIONALDETACHMENTOF SOMEDOCTORSANDTHELACKOFAUNIVERSALHEALTHCARESYSTEMINTHE53 AREALSOCRITICIZEDSEVERALTIMESINTHEBOOK4HESEPROBLEMSSERVEAS GOODREMINDERSTHATASCONSUMERSBECOMEINCREASINGLYDISILLUSIONED WITHORTHODOXMEDICINEMANYOFTHEMFINDALTERNATIVEMEDICINEMORE PALATABLE4HEREISCERTAINLYMUCHROOMFORIMPROVEMENTINTHE&$!S INDEPENDENCEINTHEDOCTORPATIENTRELATIONSHIPINTHEPHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRYSPRICINGSTRATEGIESANDINMEDICINESEXAGGERATEDLYOPTIMISTIC PROMISESOFMAGICBULLETS

5NFORTUNATELYMOSTOFTHEPROPONENTSOFALTERNATIVETHERAPIESINTHIS BOOKACTUALLYCONSTITUTEACARICATUREOFTHEMOSTQUESTIONABLEASPECTSOF CONTEMPORARYMEDICINE4HEIRRELIANCEONSIMPLISTICMODELSOFBIOLOGI CALPROCESSESTHEIRBLINDFAITHINWONDERPILLSTHEIRVESTEDINTERESTSIN THEIROWNDRUGSANDTHEIRCONSTANTPRESSURETOCONSUMEMOREOFTHEM CANHARDLYBECONSIDEREDAN@ALTERNATIVETOMAINSTREAMMEDICINE!S RADICALASTHEYTRYTOAPPEARTHEYSTRONGLYCONTRIBUTETOTHEONGOING MEDICALIZATIONOFMODERNLIFEBYSTIMULATINGANXIETIESABOUTSEX AGINGANDINTELLIGENCEANDBYPROMOTINGTHECONSTANTCONSUMPTION OFDRUGSASTHEANSWER

#/-0%4).').4%2%34334!4%-%.4 4HEAUTHORDECLARESNOCOMPETINGFINANCIALINTERESTS

"RUNO*3TRASSERISATTHE3ECTIONOFTHE(ISTORYOF-EDICINE9ALE5NIVERSITY .EW(AVEN#ONNECTICUT53!

EMAILBRUNOSTRASSER YALEEDU

.!452%-%$)#).%6/,5-%\.5-"%2\*5,9

(3)

#/ 2 2 % 3 0 / . $ % . # %

3)6MACWHEN3)6MACPRODUCTIONISSUBOPTIMAL3)6MACBECAMEMORE SENSITIVETOTHELATERESTRICTIONWHENLOWERCONCENTRATIONSOF3)6MAC PROVIRALPLASMIDWERECOTRANSFECTEDWITHARHESUS42)-AnEXPRESS INGPLASMIDIN4CELLS&IGE )NTRIGUINGLYWESTERNBLOTANALYSIS SHOWEDTHATWILDTYPE3)6MACPRODUCTIONALTEREDTHE42)-AEXPRES SIONPATTERN&IGF 5NDERCONDITIONSWHERE3)6MACTITERSWERENOT STRONGLYAFFECTEDBYRHESUS42)-A3)6MACPRODUCTIONAPPEAREDTO REDUCETHEABUNDANCEOFRHESUS42)-AINPRODUCERCELLS&IGF

!LTHOUGHFURTHEREXPERIMENTSARENEEDEDTHESEOBSERVATIONSSUGGEST THAT3)6MACCANRESISTTHISRESTRICTIONBYSATURATINGORCOUNTERACTING THE42)-ALATERESTRICTIONMACHINERY4HISMAYNOTBESURPRISING GIVENTHATMANYVIRUSESAREKNOWNTOCOUNTERACTANOTHERANTIVIRALFAC TOR42)-REFS

)NCONCLUSIONOURDATACOMPRISINGTHERESULTSOFNUMEROUSEXPERI MENTSCONDUCTEDUNDEROPTIMIZEDCONDITIONSSTRONGLYSUPPORTTHE BIOLOGICALSIGNIFICANCEOFTHERHESUS42)-AnMEDIATEDLATERESTRICTION

&URTHERINVESTIGATIONOFTHEMECHANISMSMAYPROVIDEIMPORTANTNEW LEADSINTHEFIGHTAGAINST()6

3TREMLAU-ETAL.ATUREn

3AKUMA2.OSER*!/HMINE3)KEDA9.AT-EDn 5CHIL0$1UINLAN"$#HAN74,UNA*--OTHES70LO30ATHOGE :HANG&0EREZ#ABALLERO$(ATZIIOANNOU4"IENIASZ0.AT-EDn 3AKUMA2-AEL!!)KEDA9*6IROLn

(ATZIIOANNOU4ETAL3CIENCE

5LLMAN!*2EICH.#(EARING0*6IROLn #HEE!6,OPEZ00ANDOLFI002OIZMAN"*6IROLn

2YUTA3AKUMA3EIGA/HMINE!MBER!-AEL*OSH!.OSER9ASUHIRO )KEDA

$EPARTMENTOF-OLECULAR-EDICINE#OLLEGEOF-EDICINE-AYO#LINICST 3TREET372OCHESTER-INNESOTA53!

EMAILIKEDAYASUHIRO MAYOEDU

6/,5-%\.5-"%2\-!2#(.!452%-%$)#).%

4OTHEEDITOR

)N "RUNO * 3TRASSERS REVIEW OF MY BOOK-AVERICKS OF -EDICINE IT APPEARSTHAT3TRASSERISDOINGTHEVERYTHINGTHATHEISACCUSINGMEOF DOINGNOTPRESENTINGASCIENTIFICALLYOBJECTIVEVIEWPOINT

3TRASSERCRITICIZESMEFORNOTINCLUDINGREFERENCESTHATSUPPORTTHE MEDICALCLAIMSMADEBYTHECONTROVERSIALRESEARCHERSTHAT)INTERVIEWED ALTHOUGHREFERENCESARERARELYGIVENININTERVIEWCOLLECTIONSTHATARE PRIMARILYINTENDEDFORALAYAUDIENCEANDPARTOFTHEINTENTIONOFMY BOOKWASTOUSESCIENTIFICALLYINFORMEDSPECULATIONABOUTTHEFUTUREAS AWAYTOHELPPROVOKECREATIVETHOUGHT

3TRASSERALSOCRITICIZESSOMEOFMYINTERVIEWEESASHAVINGhBLINDFAITH INWONDERPILLSvANDFORBEINGASSOCIATEDWITHWEBSITESTHATSELLTHESE PRODUCTSANDCLAIMTHEIRHEALTHBENEFITS&OREXAMPLE)NTERNETSITESTHAT HOSTARTICLESBYBIOCHEMIST"ARRY3EARSABOUTTHEBENEFITSOFOMEGA FATTYACIDSUPPLEMENTATIONANDBYNEUROCHEMIST*OSEPH+NOLLABOUT ADRUGTHATHEDEVELOPEDCALLEDDEPRENYLALSOSELLOMEGAFATTYACID SUPPLEMENTSANDDEPRENYL!LTHOUGHTHESEPRODUCTSARENOTTHEPRIMARY FOCUSOFMYBOOKSOMEOFTHEMAREDISCUSSEDANDTHEYAREGENERALLY BEINGPROMOTEDBYMYINTERVIEWEESNOTBECAUSEOFhBLINDFAITHvINTHE PRODUCTSBUTBECAUSETHEYAREWELLSTUDIEDNUTRITIONALSUPPLEMENTSOR

4HEVALIDITYOFALTERNATIVEMEDICINE

DRUGSTHATHAVEUNDERGONECLINICALTRIALS

3EARSCLAIMFOREXAMPLETHATOMEGAFATTYACIDSUPPLEMENTSCAN HAVESIGNIFICANTANTIINFLAMMATORYEFFECTSISSUPPORTEDBYRESEARCHAND STUDIESHAVEALSOCONFIRMED+NOLLSASSERTIONTHATTHESELECTIVE-!/"

INHIBITOR THAT HE DEVELOPEDDEPRENYLCAN SIGNIFICANTLY IMPROVE COGNITIVEPERFORMANCEINSOMEINDIVIDUALS

)FSPACEALLOWED)COULDVERIFYVIRTUALLYALLOFTHEASSERTIONSMADE BYTHEINTERVIEWEESINMYCOLLECTION(OWEVERASMYBOOKPOINTSOUT SCIENTIFICEVIDENCEMAYBEIGNOREDBYMAINSTREAMMEDICINEIFITDOESNT EASILYFITINTOCONVENTIONALPARADIGMS!SARESULTTHEREISACOMMONLY HELDBELIEFTHATALLOFOURMISTAKESABOUTFRINGESCIENCEAREHISTORICALAND THATWERETOOSOPHISTICATEDNOWTOMAKETHOSESAMEMISTAKESTODAY)N MYBOOK)EXPLORETHEPOSSIBILITYTHATWEMAYBEREPEATINGSOMEOFTHE SAMEERRORSTODAYTHATWEVEMADETHROUGHOUTHISTORY

$AVID*AY"ROWN

3TRASSER"*.AT-ED

*HO $( #OLE 3- ,EE %- %SPAT .*)NTEGR #ANCER 4HERn +NOLL*-ED2ES2EVn

3TRASSERREPLIES

"ROWN HAS IT EXACTLY RIGHT HISTORY CAN TEACH USIMPORTANT LESSONS 5NFORTUNATELYHEMISREADSTHEMUSESCLEARINSTRUCTIONSFOREXAMPLE TOREMEMBERTHATPILLPEDDLERSHAVEHISTORICALLYBEENUNCONCERNEDWITH CONFLICTSOFINTERESTTHATTHEYHAVEMADEOVERREACHINGCLAIMSONTHEBASIS OFLIMITEDSTUDIESWHILEIGNORINGCONTRADICTORYEVIDENCEANDTHATTHEY HAVERARELYHESITATEDTOBOASTTHEYHAVEEVIDENCEABOUTTHEEFFICACYOF THEIRREMEDIES

)DONOTSEEHOWTHISHISTORICALPICTURESIGNIFICANTLYDIFFERSFROMTHE HEALTH@INFORMATIONWEBSITESMENTIONEDBY"ROWNTHATSELLDRUGS@JUST ONECLICKAWAYFROMHISCLAIMSOFIMPROVEDhCOGNITIVEPERFORMANCEIN SOMEINDIVIDUALSvWITHOUTMENTIONINGTHATTHEhINDIVIDUALSvINTHATSTUDY ARERATSFROMHISOMISSIONSOFTHESTUDIESTHATHAVECOMETOTHEOPPOSITE CONCLUSIONINHUMANSORFROMHISCLAIMTHATHECOULDhVERIFYVIRTUALLY ALLOFTHEASSERTIONSvMADEBYhMAVERICKSvINCLUDINGASSERTIONSABOUTA

MYSTERIOUSh2.!NUTRISWITCHv BUTDOESNOTDELIVERWHENGIVENABOOK LENGTHOPPORTUNITYTODOSO

7EMAYFORGIVE"ROWNFORWITHHOLDINGREFERENCESFROMHISLAYAUDI ENCEBUTNOTFORFAILINGTOPROVIDEHISAUDIENCEWITHEVIDENCE7ITHOUTA DESCRIPTIONOFTHESTUDIESHEMENTIONSITISIMPOSSIBLEFOR"ROWNSREADERS TOEVALUATEHISBOOKCRITICALLYANDMAKEUPTHEIRMINDSABOUTWHETHERTHEY WANTTOBELIEVEINDEPENDENTNONPROFITORGANIZATIONSEVALUATINGCLINICAL EVIDENCESUCHASTHE#OCHRANE#OLLABORATIONORFINANCIALLYINTERESTED MAVERICKS5NLIKETHEAUTHORCITEDBY"ROWNTHE#OCHRANE#OLLABORATION AFTER REVIEWING CLINICAL TRIALS OF SELEGILINE LDEPRENYL CONCLUDED THAT THERE WAS hNO EVIDENCE OF BENEFIT OF SELEGILINE FOR !LZHEIMERS DISEASEv

"ROWNISRIGHTAGAINWHENHESAYSTHATSCIENTIFICCLAIMSTHATDONOT hEASILYFITINTOCONVENTIONALPARADIGMSvRUNTHERISKOFBEINGIGNORED/F MUCHGREATERCONSEQUENCEHOWEVERISTHERISKTHATADRUGWHOSEEFFEC

(4)

#/ 2 2 % 3 0 / . $ % . # %

TIVENESSANDSAFETYISPOORLYSUPPORTEDBYSCIENTIFICEVIDENCEWHETHER PRODUCEDBYALTERNATIVEORORTHODOXMEDICINEBECOMESAPRODUCTOFMASS CONSUMPTION

"RUNO*3TRASSER

3ECTIONOFTHE(ISTORYOF-EDICINE9ALE5NIVERSITY.EW(AVEN#ONNECTICUT 53!

EMAILBRUNOSTRASSER YALEEDU

(ELFAND7(1UACK1UACK1UACK4HE3ELLERSOF.OSTRUMSIN0RINTS0OSTERS"OOKS

%PHEMERA'ROLIER#LUB.EW9ORK +NOLL*-ED2ES2EVn

7ILCOCK'+"IRKS*7HITEHEAD!%VANS3*)NT*'ERIATR0SYCHIATRY n

"IRKS*&LICKER,#OCHRANE$ATABASE3YST2EV#$

4OTHEEDITOR

'IVEN THAT SHE IS HEAD OF THE .ATIONAL !SSOCIATION FOR "IOMEDICAL 2ESEARCH&RANKIE4RULLSPROFESSEDCONCERNFORANIMALWELFAREINHER INTERVIEWISDISINGENUOUSCONSIDERINGHERORGANIZATIONSHISTORYOF CAMPAIGNING TO ENSURE THAT RATS MICE AND BIRDS BE EXCLUDED FROM

!NIMAL7ELFARE!CT!7! PROTECTIONS4HEIDEATHATTHESEANIMALSARE NOTWORTHYOF!7!COVERAGEISUNSCIENTIFICANDUNETHICAL2ATSANDMICE INPARTICULARCONTINUETOBEEXPOSEDTOSUCHTORMENTSASINESCAPABLE

,ABORATORYANIMALSDESERVEBETTERLEGALPROTECTION

ELECTRICSHOCKSANDFORCEFEEDINGS!RETHESEREALLYWHATANYONEWOULD CONSIDERhTHEMOSTHUMANECONDITIONSv

*ONATHAN"ALCOMBE

3ENIOR2ESEARCH3CIENTIST0HYSICIANS#OMMITTEEFOR2ESPONSIBLE-EDICINE 7ISCONSIN!VE.73TE7ASHINGTON$#53!

EMAILJBALCOMBE PCRMORG

"JORN'.AT-ED

!NIMALEXPERIMENTShREPRESENTOUTDATEDSCIENCEv

4OTHEEDITOR

7HILE GRIPING ABOUT SECURITY MEASURES AT LABORATORIES &RANKIE 4RULL NEGLECTEDTOMENTIONTHATOFALLANIMALSUSEDFOREXPERIMENTATION

MICEANDRATSARESPECIFICALLYEXCLUDEDFROMTHE!NIMAL7ELFARE!CTTHE ONLYFEDERALLAWCOVERINGANIMALSIN53LABORATORIES-ICEANDRATSHAVE NOPROTECTIONATALLUNDERFEDERALLAW-EANWHILETHELABORATORYCOMMIT TEESTHATBYLAWARESUPPOSEDTOOVERSEEALLSTUDIESINVOLVINGANIMALSAND PREVENTREDUNDANTEXPERIMENTSAREFAILINGDISMALLYATTHEIRJOBS

)NMYPERSONALOPINION4RULLSROLEASAPOLOGISTFORANYTHINGAND

EVERYTHINGEXPERIMENTERSDOTOANIMALSISANANACHRONISMGIVENTHE BURGEONINGFIELDOFNONANIMALRESEARCH&ORWARDTHINKINGSCIENTISTS AREREADYTOADMITTHATEXPERIMENTSONANIMALSOFTENREPRESENTOUTDATED SCIENCEANDTHATSUCHEXPERIMENTSAREALWAYSUNETHICAL

+ATHY'UILLERMO

$IRECTOROF2ESEARCH0EOPLEFORTHE%THICAL4REATMENTOF!NIMALS&RONT 3T.ORFOLK6IRGINIA53!

EMAIL+ATHY' PETAORG

.!452%-%$)#).%6/,5-%\.5-"%2\-!2#(