Building a Reference Combinatorial Modelfor Dynamic Networks:Initial Results in Evolving Graphs
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Building a Reference Combinatorial Model for Dynamic Networks: Initial Results in Evolving Graphs Afonso Ferreira. N° 5041 December 2003. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5041--FR+ENG. THÈME 1. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !#" %$&'( )+*,-. '0/213 )4256$879!&:<;>= ?@ A$ !B;&.C$;D FEHG')AG3
(6) JIK 'L M;N O PRQTS(UQWVYX[Z\Z\X[]^Z\_a` bdcfeg<h-ikjmlnophqsruthvopwuoRvxe g<ho yYzx{}|Rh v~qsox{svvxh lqsf{[zv uhzxhCc8h zCCcfhYs}8ijJh h g)hzk}s[jisi8q}[ho. f}[H zxh hoxo>vph\Ccff{s {s h\odq}8 vpcfh uhf {w¡g<h[v{s¢&g<{s h%qs8 f{sg-qs %oph zx£ h\odq}zxh uz £ f)vpcfhhg<h zp¤ sh8h{}¢ {sg<f ht¥q[ ¦¤§c8{¦fhvR¨{szx©uo ª(vxc8qv<c8q«£[hq¬c [cf wB fw¡q}g h c8q«£ {sz\®~{¦ fh fBopr8Cc¯ uw¦8qsg o ª°qs8 zxhq}v f!q!zph ¢±h zxh 8 hg<{¦ fh T{s3¨c Cc3zxhoprf²vxo>{sr8 -h%{sg<8qszph\ -q}8 3zphfzp{u urh <¨dqsoovxqvxh 3q[o³q'¢±rf8 fqsg´h¡vxq} opoprfh!¦wq-zxh h ¡vµ¶u·¸¨>{[zp©uopcf{s {[¹fhvR¨{szx© 88º»¹vxc ok8qshzª¨h)opcf{¨¼cf{¨¼vpcfh)g<{¦ fh f{}¢°v g<h ¤½Cc8qsfsh\o rf8ophvpvp ho!{s¾ À¿¡rfh\oRv {[8oq} ®q} ²{¨o¢±{[zfh ¨ 8o sc¡vCo ¡vx{¹h ¡vxzxqsYfzp{[f h g-o À8hvR¨{szx© fªÁ ©sh-zx{srfv fg<hv¤ z o ª({[ffhv £ vRw[ªqs8 ®oq}f fvxzphho ¶ur8Ccag<{u uh 8 o!g<q[ uh3{[oxo f h-vpc8zp{[rfscàīÅ}ÆÇÄÈÊɦËË}ÌxÍCÎ8Ï[ÐAª°q¹o g<f h {[g! 8q}vp{sz q}Tg<{¦ fh @¨c Cc cfh 8o qsuvpr8zphvpc8hhc8q«£ {[z{s¢( fw¡q}g fh vR¨>{[zp©uoÅÄ Ì'Ñ^ÈÊÒ- ÓÔ¡ÕTÖp×!Ø Ù&[ ¨ zph²h\opo>fhvR¨{szx©uo ª¦ uw¦8qsg fhvR¨{szx©uo ª¡zx{sruv fª¦h fhzp[w<q«¨dq}zxhsª¡h £[{s £ f)szCq}fco ª¡szCq}fcvpcfh{szxhvp¤ q}@g<{u uh oªÚÛ&ÜÁÝuÞªußftuh u¤½oxCcfh frf²h% uw¦8qsg %fh vR¨>{[zp©uoª¡oph 8op{sz8hvR¨{szx©¦oªuàâá>ãäopq}vph² vxhfhvR¨{szx©uo . ÿ åd' @üæâ@üç\ûèêûéâë@)ìA(8íïîí^ìCë@ýïö»ðCò+é&*-ñðCðCú«,/í±÷.1ò^èÇ0)ðCò^2/ç«óêó 3)öYô%35ÿé§4)õ\6ñ«% ñ}78ìAíï ò^9:"öR!$÷!#%±üø& ûôkÊò§ÿ;ç«ö> ùìAñ«õ\ç«í^ìAèÇðñ}öÿ&ðCú ú'ò^èêûuñ}æ&ìAóêü+èêé<& ñ«íïìCý^öRþ»ò(ÿûâÿ@üù«ò^ç«ö³ùõ«íïìAñ}öpðCú8ùæ¹ñ«íïìCýïöRþRò@û&ù
(7) \ò§ç«ö. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(8) ; . - ! ". %$! . L+!0 ; ;& ! 13 ! -;2=¼.; ;A$& %$&; L 4 !;;;
(9) ' 'L M; dG'! 3$;
(10) àÁho(q«£q}n h\oâ uh\oÁvxhCcf8{s {s ho&opqs8o¤^ß8¡hv( h unf { h g<h ¡vY uh>oph zx£ ho&g´{[ ²h\oâh vf{[g-qs uh\oâhfsh8 uzxh ¡v ng´hzp[h 8 h+ uhÀzpn\oh\q}rutH{[g<f²h tuho fh¬{[g<g!rf q}v {sÁª¿[r 8zpn\oh[vxh ¡vrf {[g´{szpvphg<h ¡vvxzpe\o uw¦8qsg ¿¡rfhs ln\h g<g<h ¡v\ªârfBszx{sr8h- uh<vxzxq«£q ° uh-¾q µ¶u· or8z²h\o%zpn\oh\q}rut¬q un\¾q}zxn-¿[r8h- nvCq}f oxoph g<h ¡v' rfBg´{u ue²h3 fh zxn¢±n zxh h+ rffh+vph² h+ uw¦8qsg ¿¡rfh¬¿¡r hzpg<h vvph¬ q¯{[g´q}zCq o{[¯h v¾q®zphfzx{¦ fr8Av vxn+ uhozxnoprf vCqvCo un\z vCo fqs8o¾qa vvpnzxq}vprfzxh¹n vxq v rffh¬¿¡rfh\oRv {[H¢±{s fq}g<h ¡vCq} h¬ fqs8o3 hÀ f{sg-q fhsqs8o.h+zCq}8{[zv\ªf{sro3g<{s¡vpzx{so ¿¡rfh uho<zxnoprf²vxq}vxo<{[f¦r8o< fq}8o´ ho<zxnophqsrutaoRvCqv ¿¡rfho<8h o q}ff ¿[r8h ¡v´qso-q}rftazpn\oh\q}ruta uw¦8qsg ¿¡rfhoª³h v3¿[r8h ¾qg<{u un opq}v {sÀ uh-hvpvph3 uw¦8qsg ¿¡rfh´hzpg<h v! uho%f{[rf£sh² hoh zCohv £sh\ooprfz uh\o%fzp{[f e g<ho%h¡vpzCq}rut+ fqs8o% h u{[g<q 8h uh\odzpn\oh\q}rut@ª¡vph o¿¡rfh% hodg<nvxz ¿¡rfho{srfz h%zp{[ruvxqssh[ª[¾q<{s8fhv £ vpn[ªu{sr.h 8 {szxh hodqszpfzxhod {srf£¦zCq}¡vxo 8h3vph² h.g´{u un oxqv {s®h\oRv´zph8 urfh{¡opo f²h8q}z) ruv oxqv {[¥ uh\o´ËsÌpÍCÎϦ РīÅ}Æ uÑ§È xÐCª³rf¥g<{u ue h {sg) qvp{ zxh o g<f h'¿¡r q uh <hzpfhzd²h' {sg<{[zvxh g<h ¡v uh\odzpn\oh\q}rut uw¦8qsg ¿¡rfh\o'Í !CÅuÌCÐ "Ñ»ÂÒÎ8ÐA #äØ Ö % $ lnophqsrutoxq}8o¤^ß^ª¦zxnophq}rft uw¦8q}g ¿[r8hoªuszCq}fcfh\on £s{[²rfv ¢ïo ªfzxnophqsrut uh qsuvphrfzCo ªuzx{sruvCq}[hs.
(11) @? !$&-.°$(!. bdcfhqs f£sh ¡v{}¢&¨ zxh hoxo> {sg<g!rf qv {sfhvR¨{szx©uo ª¦opr8Ccq[oq[ ¦¤½cf{u}ªuoh8op{sz\ª¦qs8 à&á>ãoxqvxh vphfh vR¨>{[zp©uoª[c sc8²w g<{}v £qvxho%vxcfh3ovpr8 uw¬{}¢doh£sh zCq}¢ïq[hvCo{}¢vpc8h z! uw¦8q}g ´hc8q«£ {[z-bdcfh-rf uh zx²w f g<{s vRw+{s¢rohzxoqs8 «{[z zxh ¾q«w¦o o>|Rr8ov%{sfh´{}¢°vxcfh)¢ïqsAvx{szCovxc8qv'{[¡vpz frfvph'vx{vxcfh z% uw¦8q}g o)ãkvpcfhzxo r8 uh´£«qszpw f3 8©¹{s8shov {s⪠f{u uh'qs8 f©3¢ïqsrf vCo ªfqs8 {[g´{s8h ¡vxoq[ f v {s q}8 uh²h v {s ²i« § ¶¦r8Cc u¢±zCqsovpzxr8Avxrfzxh¤½²h\opodg<{s h!{[g<g!rf q}v {sh¡£ zp{[fg<h ¡vxofzph\oh¡vq<8q}zCqs [g0opc ¢Êv¢±zp{[g0qsC©¡¤§{s8h fh vR¨>{[zp©uoª\opr8Cc!q[o& h ²rf¾q}z&vph²hfcf{[¡w[ª !vpc8q}v fq}vxq o&vpzCq}oR¢±hzph\ ¢±zp{[gf{u uh°vx{f{u uh>£ qkhh zp¤^vx{}¤½hh z ¡vphzxq[Av {so q} Bf{}v´{£sh z'qs®rf8 uhzp w 8¹8qsC©¦{sfh-{s¢zp{[ruvphzxo µkqvxrfzCq} ²w[ª&vxc o'h 8sh uh zCo'fh¨ fzp{[f h g-o'zxh ¡q}zC 8.{}vxc {sfv g<qs@zp{[ruv f<{}¢Y fq}vxq<q}8 vp{[{[²{[sw3 {s¡vpzx{s§ªurf8 uhz£q}z {[r8od{s v {[8od{£shzvpcfh\oh' uw¦8qsg fh vR¨>{[zp©uo f¢±{szpvprf8q}vph²w[ª¡c8{¨>h£sh z\ª¡g´{¡oRvdzxhoprf vCo>¢±{srf8 vxcfh% vphzxq}vprfzxhh vxcfh z uh\q}T¨ vpc.fhvR¨{szx©uo°vxc8qvq}zxhovxq}v }ªu{[z q}zxhkcq}zC u²w<zxh fzx{u ur8 f hs(bdc od uzxq«¨qsC©´fzp{u f fh <vxcfhq}fhTq}v³vxcfhµ¶u· {szx©uocf{[3{s·frf8 8q}g<h ¡vxqs@lhophqszxCc µkhvR¨{szx© f is i
(12) >vx{3oRvCqvphq´zxh{[g<g´h8 fq}v {s3vx{ É CÅuÌxÍ Ë¡Â'ÌpÂÐ ÂCÍÌ ÏÑ^ϦÍ}ѳРÂC \Ð%ÌpÍ "}È xÍ}Æ&ÈÊÉÉÅ}Ä«Í}Ñ^ÈïÅ}ÉÀÍÉ "ÎfÍÌxÍ "È ËsÒÐCÏ[È CÑ^ Ð ª q} É CÅuÌxÍ Ë¡ÂkÑ^Ϧ "[ÂÄÂÆ ÅCÎÒ- É8ѳŠkÌp ÂÌpÂ É CÂÒ-Å "[ÂÆêÐ%Å Ì xÂ É Ï[Ò-ÍÌ \ÐkѽŴÂCÍ«Ð ÂÑïÏu uÌ "[ÂÉÅ kÌpÂRÎÌpÅ " ÈAÆ Â Â ÎfÂÌAÈÊÒ-ÂÉÑïÐ'ÅÉ CÅÒÎƲ Р«ÐAÑ»ÂÒ)Ð !C º»8 uhh @ª°q[o'¨h¨ ²doph h¾qvxh z avpcfhvpht¦v\ª°hovxqsf opcfh a {s8 h uvCo ¯ovxq}v 3fh vR¨>{[zp©uoª& ©[h {sffh\Av £ vRwÀqs8 op8q}f fkvpzxh h\o ªg)r8oRv(h>zxh £ o vph\ ´ uw¦8q}g °fh vR¨>{[zp©uoâbdcfhzph ¢±{szxhsª«¨>h>fh h\ vx{h¡£ o {s!g´{u uh fkv g´h ¤§£qszpw f fzx{sh zpv ho({s¢ÁÚkÛâÜÁÝu#Þ " -{szC uhz(vp{fr ¾ -q{sg) 8qvx{sz qsuzph ¢±h zxh 8 hg<{u uh^ª¦q}8 )vxcfh zxh ¦w 8 zph\qsophzxh 8zp{u ur8 vRw {}¢(fh vR¨>{[zp© f!zxhophqszxCc{sruvC{sg<h\o bdc o o){srfz)zph\oh\q}zCCc¬¢±zCq}g<h¨>{[zp© ®vxc o´qszph\qfª¨cfh zxh¨h-¢±{uro){[Bvpcfh uh\o s®{s¢g´{u uh o´q} aq} s{[z vpcfg vph\Ccf ¿¡rfhovxc8qvkq}.c8q}zxfhoxovpc8h% {sg<f ht vRw3{}¢(h £[{s £ f´h ¦£ zx{s8g´h¡vxo $&%'$. ()+*',.-/1032. º».vpc ozxh {szpvªu¨h uhoxz h'q<o g<f hfruv{¨>hz¢±rf&{sg) 8qvx{sz qsg<{u uh Ávpc8q}vk q}fvprfzxhodg<{[ovkCc8qszxq[Avphz ov o>{}¢ v g<h¤½£q}zxw f.fhvR¨{szx©uo ´bdcfh<¨z v f ¨ ²°h<©shuv'{s oh-q} u¢±{szxg-q} ¬{[zx fh zvp{ c scf sc¡v%vpcfh g´{szpvxqs¡v ¢±hq}vprfzxhoq} g´qsAv%{}¢Yvxcfh´g´{u uh^ h´zph ¢±h zvpcfh ¡vxh zxhovph +zph\qs uhzvx{vxcfh)zxh¢±hzph8h\o £[h +q}vvxcfh)h8 ¹{s¢°vpc8h 8qshzd¢±{szq)¢±{szxg-q}@fzxhoph ¡vxq}v {s{}¢vpcfhzxhoprf²vxoopcf{¨c8h zxhs bdcfhf{}v {[{s¢d īÅ}ÆÇÄ\ÈÊÉ¡Ë´Ë}ÌpÍAÎ8Ï[ÐCª ¡vxzp{u ur8 h zph\h ¡vx²4w 56½ªu8qso q} w3{so oRvCo ¢±{szxg-q} 8 7 f<q!v g´h u{[g-q szCq}8c8o (¶¦rfzxfz o 8s wsª«vpc o( hq[ fo&vp{qf²h vpcf{[zxq{}¢ ¡vxh zxhov f¿¡rfh\oRv {[8o -qs²[{sz vxcfg ³szCq}fc!vpcfh{szxwsª}¨ vpc g<g<h¤ qvxh'q}ff qv {[8o vx{s{s {s[w3{s¡vxzp{[@{}¢&g<{[ :h 9 ¦<¤ ;{u%fh vR¨>{[zp©u=o ^ÚkÛâÜÁÝu#Þ "> Aª8zxh ¾qvxh vp{<£shz ¢±w 8´8zp{[hzv h\o ©[h{[uv g 8 7 h .zx{sruv f-qs8 {sf8hAv £ vRw¬ÅÄ Ì'Ñ^ÈÊÒ- 9ko)q}®h tuqsg<f²h[ªY{so uh z'vpcfh¢±{srfz´o8qs8opcf{}vCovxqs©shBq}v´ 8 ? h zxh ¡v'v g<h ¡vph zx£q}¾o'{s¢q¬ÚÛâÜÁÝfÞ&ª°q[o! uh Avph\ W· srfzxhBis@ 9o<{sfhq}¥zxhq[ ²w®{[8ohzp£[hsª°8{¦ fhBo Aq}8D C qszph.fh £[h z-{[ffh\Avph\ ¥q}v-qBo 8s hv g<h [vxh zx£q}§ µ{svR¨ vxc8ovxq} 88Eª A q} 8 uhh ®oph 8 Bg<h\opoxq}[hovpF{ C´ª(r8o fvpc8h-ÎuÍ}ÑïÏaÅÄ ÌѧÈÊÒ<Â!{sg<{[oph À{}G¢ A4HIHJBHKLHC´ ¶¦rfzxfz o fs wsª¡vpc o{svpcfhzp¨ ophvxz £ qsT¢ïqsvk q}8f{}vh' zxhvp w3g<{u uh h .¦w3r8opr8q}@[zxqsfc8o áY£[{s £ fszCq}fc8o&zxh fzxhoph ¡vYq¢±{[zpg-q}uqs8oRvxzxq[Av {['{}¢ fw¡q}g >fh vR¨>{[zp©uoª}q}8 ) q})hopr vph )hq[o w%vp{vpc oY q[oh[ M {s oh²w[ªqs+h £[{s £ fszCq}fc oqs 8 uhtuh\ +oph¿¡rfh h!{s1 ¢ N0oprff[zxqsfc8o{s¢>q3 £[h [zxqsfcÁªT¨cfh zxhvxcfh´oprff[zxqsfc qv%q- £sh 8 uht{ ¡v{[zpzxhop{s8 fovp{3vxcfh!8hvR¨{szx©{[ffh\Av £ vRwq}vkvpc8h'v g<h ¡vphzp£q} qvxh ¦w.vpcfh uht ¦rfg!h z\ªqsooc8{¨ !· srfzxhf&bdcfh³v g<h> u{[g<q o⢱rfzpvpcfhz 8{[zp{szCqvxh [vx{vxcfh>g<{u uh[¦w%zph\oRvxz Av 8& O Å uÌAÉ «Ð hs ªuvpcfhh\¿¡r £qs²h[v{s¢&ÎfÍÑ^ÏsÐ!ÅÄ Ì'Ñ^ÈÊÒ- >vp{<fh £[h zg<{£sh [vx{<h u[hod¨c Cc ht ovph\ {[f w 8q[oRvoprff[zxqsfc8o 9 |R{srfzxfh w ¬qs+h £[{s £ fszCq}fc ovpc¦r8o%q3qvpc +vpcfh´rf8 fh zx²w f[zxqsfc¨cf{¡oh)h u[h!v g<h¤½¾q}h ¾oqszph Àq f{[u¤½ fhzxhq[o f'{[zx fh z\µk{¨ª v o>h\qsopw<vp{-oph h · [rfzph'vpc8q}Pv AQHIHJRHKLHC oq|R{[rfzp8h wsªuq[o>g<h[v {[fh q}{£sh[ ·fr8zvxcfh z\ªYf{}vxh3vxc8qBv A4HIHJBHC o´q}¾o{Àq-|R{[rfzp8h wsªY¨ vpc¥²h\opo)cf{so ªYfrfv< uh £shz fvxcfh.g´h\opoxq}[h3¾qvphSz ¥v g<h [vxh zx£q} 8ovph\qs <{s¢ÁT Aª¡ £ f!zxq ophdvp{! U ? h zxh ¡v>{[u|Rhv £shd¢±rfAv {so°vxc8qvg<q«w)h{suv g 7 h\ @°~ {szxh {£[h z\ªf{}v h vpcqv>qs vxcf{srf[c<vpcfh{sg<g)rf qv {[-fhvR¨{szx© · [rfzxhi o>ow¦g<g<hvxz }ªsvpcfhcf{su¤» oRvCq}8 h{£shz(v g´hk¢±zp{[Vg A vxW{ C XY o 8 ? h zxh ¡vd¢±zp{[Z g C¼vx[{ A\X] AYº»vpcfh%zxh g-q 8 uhzªu¨h¨ âoph hvpc8q}vvpc o o|RroRv{[fh{s¢âvxcfhr8opr8q}Á {s8 h uvCo vpcqvc8q«£[hkvx{-h%¢±{[zpg-q} w-zph£ o vxh rf8 uhzvpcfh sc¡v{}¢ v g<h !g<{¦ fh f ûâûú^`_abdc.
(13) · [rfzxh´i°bdcfh%h £[{s ruv {s.{}¢(q<ÚkÛâÜÁÝuÞ+{£shz>v g<h[°bdcfh ho {szxzph\o{s <vp{3opr8 hoxo £sh%op8q}8opcf{svxo. · [rfzxh! ³áY£[{s £ f<[zxqsfc{szxzxhop{[8 f!vx{<vpcfh´~49kµá°b · srfzxh-isá° ush\oq}zxh¾q}h h .¨ vxc¹{[zpzxhop{[8 f fzxhoph 8 hkv g<h [vxh zx£q}¾o ³ã8oph zx£shkvpc8q}vPJRHC HK od8{}vq´£«qs |R{[rfzxfh w[ªfo 8hvxcfh%h u[h´ª ·ht oRvCo>{[f w vpc8h 8q[oRv¨ vpc zph\ohvvp{ \᪠¡ bdc oÁ8qshz oÁ{szx[qs 7 h %q[oT¢±{s ²{¨oâbdcfh> uhß8 v {[8oâ{s¢uh £s{[²£ fdszCq}fcoÁq}8 %{s¢fo{[g´h³{}¢¦vpcfh z&g-q 8q}zCq}g<hvxh zCo q}zxh- £sh Bvxcfhfh t¦v)oh\Av {[Ábdcfh Áª ¥¶¦hv {sa8ª&¨hopcf{¨vxc8qv){s¾ ®{sh fvxo ¥ovxqv <8hvR¨{szx©¦o' £sh-z oph vp{-oprfzxfz o f´fh¨ 8o [c[vCo uw¦8qsg fhvR¨{szx©uo ª g<f²w f´vpc8q}v .{szC uhz>vx{3qsCc h £[hq< {sg! 8q}vp{[z q}zph ¢±h zxh 8 h g<{u uh 8¢±{sz°¨ zph²h\opo°fhvR¨{szx©uo(¨>h8h h 8 uhh ´vx{'w h -oprf8ovxqs[v qs ff{£qv {[<qs8 ´vp{)qs h uv°q}zCqs sgoc ¢Êvxo(º» ¶¦h\Av {s!8ª«¨>hoc8{¨Àc8{¨¬vxc oâfh¨®8q}zCqs [g qs'cfh²!op{s £ 8 g<{szpvxqs[v¿[r8hov {s8o ´ÚÛâÜÁÝfÞ "}ª¨ vpc!qsff qv {so vp{[r8Cc fhfh zxsw¡¤»q«¨qszphvp{[{[²{[sw {[[vxzp{[^ªTq} zp{[ruv f· 8q} ²w[ªT¨>h´ {[oph'vpc8h!8qshz¨ vpcÀ{s r8 fzxh g-q}zx©uo q} oph £[h zCq}T¨q«wuo>¢±{szd¢±r8zvxcfh zzxhophqszxCc .vpc o£[h zxw- vvx²hh tuf²{[zph\ 3ßh ¾ @
(14) ' 'L.Mm$M!&$ > )À4-+
(15) '& !;âL
(16) $879!&:JdG'! 3$ !. .
(17) 9kodopcf{¨ · srfzxhfª¦qsÀ īÅ}ÆÇÄ\ÈÊÉ¡Ë´Ë}ÌpÍAÎ8Ï'{[rf¾ -hoph hqsodq'8hvR¨{szx © "!$# HJ%#'&pªu¨c8h zxhkhq[Cc3f{u uh%q}8 f© c8q[okq-fzxhoph h!oxCcfh frf²h) uhß88h ¢±{[z vª@qso¢±{s ²{¨o M {szxzph\o{s8 f<vx{h\qsCc f)© ( F J%# ïzph\ohv £sh wsªf{u uh * ) !+# vpcfh-Æ ÈÊ`É %ÎÌpÂÐ ÂÉ CÂ'РϦ "uÆ : ±zxhophAv £[h wsª@ÉTÅ "[ÂÎÌpÂÐÂ É CÂ!Ð AÏu "uƲ 8 qvxhodvxcfh%v g<h 8oRvCq}¡vxo ¨c Cc vpc8h- f@© ïzph\ohv £sh²w[ªÁvpc8h-f{u uh ofzxhoph ¡vªq}8 ¬{[oxo f w+{}vxcfh zq}zCq}g<hvxh zCokvxcfh w+vxqs©sh- urfz 8hqsCc [vxh zx£q}§ º»¹vxcfh´zph\orf²vxofzxhoph ¡vph\ +vpc o8q}h z\ªT{svpc¬fzph\oh8h)opCcfh\ urf hoq}zxh)oprff{[oph vx{h) £[h +q[oqo{[zvxh ov%{}¢ [vxh zx£q}¾o YàÁh vkq}¾o){ , !$#-,.0/ qs81 , J2#3,04 ±üû Êÿ .
(18) ·f{[z³g<{[ovd{}¢@vpc8h opoprfh\o> oxr8oxoh\ -vpc o8q}h z\ª¡vpcfh f¢±{szxg<qs fhß8 v {s £shq}{£shkopr3h\o (·f{[zqs8q} w¡v qs frfzx{[ophod{s8²w[ªu¨>h% £sh%h {¨Ãvxcfh%¢±{szxg-q}Á uh ß8 v {s {}¢&vpcfhg<{u uh § .Ô ± Ø
(19) & GÑ xÂËsÈÊÄ«Â ÉÀÍ´ËsÌpÍCÎBÏ C "!1HJ&Í}É "ÍÉÀÅ}Ì "s Ìp "3Р8ÂÉ CÂ)Å %ÈÊÑïÐ%Ð §Ë}ÌpÍAÎ8Ï[Ð CHC H HC Ð AÏ3Ñ^ϦÍ}Ñ C CB!
(20) &Â"Ñ # % $'& H($ H$ H H($ xÂ'Í}É+ÅÌ "[ÂÌp "´Ð  8 ÂÉ x ŠÑ^ÈÊÒ-Â%ÈÊÉfÐAÑ»ÍÉÑïÐ *)ÁÏuÂ+É (Ñ^ϦÂ%Ð «ÐAÑ»ÂÒ 0 C H,PH- # &(/.(Ϧ ÌpÂÂx%Í AÏQC ȾÐ<Ñ^ϦÂ3Ð §ËsÌpÍCÎϬÈÊÉÎÆ²Í CÂ"uÌAÈÊɦ1Ë 0 $ 2 dH$ 03kȾРxÍ}ÆÊƲ "¬Í}ɹh £[{s £ f.szCq}8c 54´Â "s ÉÅ}ѽ , ! ,.0/4ÍÉ " , J ,.04 64<ÂÆ²Â Ñ !$# 0!7>Í}É "WJ2# J 8L%'$. 9;:=<- /10`2?>@A<`*'BG*'<DCE>F/GHGICJFJ>K. 8L%^8. fX>< ) , /Bg:#0h<`*-Ki:kjXl /nmG0+Fo:=CG,. ~L%'$. l /gmG0+Fo:=CKi:=< 03*(@ ,. *-@ ,. H vpcÃvxcfhÀcfh {s¢vpcfhÀh u[h¬qs8 Ãf{u uhÀopCc8h urf hoªkq¥g´h\qsoprfzxh+{}¢'c8{¨2g!r8Cc qs h£s{s £ 8aszCq}fcÃCcq}f[ho vxo vp{[{[²{[swaq}¸h¹ fhß8fh\ @ · zxovª>vpcfh¥Í%ѧÈÊÄ\ÈÊѥŠ¹ÍBÄ«Â ÌAѻ *¥ qs¸h¹ uh ß8fh\ Wq[o´vpcfh¦rfg)hz-{}¢ vCo-fzxhoph 8 h [vxh zx£q}¾o ªYq} ® uh f{svph\M LON *$&pª°qs8 Bvpc8hÀÍ Ñ§ÈÊÄÈÊÑBÅ Í}ɸ " Ë¡Â( qs®h. uhß88h aq[o'vxcfh¦rfg)hz!{}¢ vxo)fzxhoph 8 h [vxh zx£q}¾o ªTq}8 + uh f{svph\P LRQ (&p%bdcfh âªvxcfh.Ä«Â ÌAѽ¹Í%ѧÈÊÄÈÊÑ'{s¢>q}¹h£s{[²£ f3szCq}8c o uhßfh ¬qsovxcfh´g<q}t g)rfgK{}¢ vpc8hk£shzvxht-qsv £ v h!o LON1TS7UOVXWRLYN * &H*[Z)!+#=\¡ª¦qs8 ´vpc8h< " Ë¡Â'%Í Ñ§ÈÊÄÈÊÑ kq[oYvpc8hg-qt g!rfg {s¢@vpcfhh u[hkqsv £ v ho LRQ1 S7UOV1WRLRQ (&H2(]ZJ%#=\¡³bdcfhÍ Ñ§ÈÊÄÈÊÑ Å )ÍÉÀ ÄÅÆÇÄ\ÈÊÉ¡Ë-ËsÌpÍCÎÏ odvpcfh¹ uhßfh qsovpcfhg-qt g!rfg0h vR¨>hh .vpc8h f_a` {u u(h'b qs8 vpcfhh\ ushqsv £ v h\Jo L S7UOV ^LYN HLRQ&x³· q} ²w[ªuvpcfh "ÉÍ}Ò)È Ð)Å !Í}ÉÀ īÅ}ÆÇÄ\ÈÊÉ¡Ë-ËsÌpÍCÎÏ) qsh! uh ß8fh q[o 9koq< {s8oph¿¡rfh8h[ª¦o 8hr8opr8qs@szCq}fc8oc8q«£[ch L edsª¦vpc8h wcq«£sh uw¦8q}g o 7 h zx{8 2 1. . bdcfhv g<h% f{sg-q o>¢±rfzvxcfh z 8{[zp{szCqvxh ¡vp{)vpcfhg<{u uh 3vxcfh uhß8 v {[{}¢O ÅuÌAÉ «ÐAª8qso³¢±{s {¨o (àÁh vIp¼h%q 8 q}vpcqp ( H ( H H (Or´¨ vxc ( ZFJ # àâhv/ps ut H(t H H(tAr<h´q´v g<h)oxCcfh ur8²h 8 q}v f-vxc8qvh u[h( o vp{-hvxzxq«£[h zCoh\ qvv g<ht h! fhß8fh'q=O Å uÌAÉ v wp H(ps$& ¢Yq} {[f w ¢ps o qs{szC fqs8h%¨ vpcxpqs8 >ª h[²ªyvqs² {¨o>¢±{szq)vpzCq«£shzxoxq}{£shz>v g<h%¢±zx{sg?z¹vp{* )> º½v o g<{szpvxq}¡v>vp{!8{}v hkvpc8q}vâ|R{[rfzp8h wuo³ {sffh\Av>vR¨>{)f{u uho³{£sh z³v g<hsª¦h £[h 3vpc8h q[ohkvpcfhf{u uhoq}zxhfh£shz {[ffh\Avph\ hq[Cc. {suß8[rfzCqv {s⪦q[oohh q}{£sh[ b&zxq«£[h zCopqsYv g<ho´¢±{sz´vxcfh f©uo ª³zphfzph\oh¡v f¹vxcfh urfzCqv {s¯{}¢vxzxqs8opg vv 8¬{[fhqsC©sh v´{£[h z´q+ 8© ¯vpc8h fh vR¨>{[zp©.g-q«w qs op{3h´ fhß8fh\ @%bâ{.o g<f ¢±w¹{[g<fruvxq}v {s8oª v oqsoxoprfg<h @ªT¨ vpcf{[ruv {[oxo{s¢°shfh zCq} vRw[ª8vxc8qvvpc8h [vxh zx£q}¾ok{s¢³fzxhoph 8 h){s¢³hq[Cc¹h u[ h (-qszph´ {[oph +qs8 vxc8qvvpc8h w¹q}zxh! {s8sh zvpcq}¹vxcfh´v g<h)zxh¿¡r zph\ vx{3vpzCq«£shzxoph vpc8hh u[hs ¶¦h£sh zCq}â{}vpc8h zkq}zCq}g<hvxh zCog-q«wh) uh ß8fh\ {£shzvpcfh´h £[{s £ f-[zxqsfc8ok¶¦r8Cc¹q}zCq}g<hvxh zCo ªf ©sh! f©.vpzCq«£sh zCoxq} v g<hsª8qs8 .f{u uh%{sz 8©{¡oRvCo ªug-q«w3{[zg<q«wf{}v£q}zxw3{£shzv g´h[ ; }¹ 7 ;&
(21) )M'$; { | >) L3$n º»¡vphzph\oRv f[²w[ªuo{[g´h{s¾ {s8 h uvCo .fhvR¨{szx©)g<{u uh f´g!r8ovhzph£ o vxh ¨cfh .oRvxr8 uw 8)fzx{sh zpv hoÅ}Ä«Â Ì%Ñ^ÈÊÒ- bdcfh\oh 8 r8 uh[ª}¢±{sz 8ovxq}hsª}vpcfhf{sv {s8o({s¢8q}vpc8oªs ovxq}hdg<hvpz oªs{[ffhv £ vRw[ªsq}8 !vpzxh h\o ª[qso v°¨ uhopcf{¨ vxc ooh\Av {[Á kok¢ïq}z%qsog<hvxz oq}zxh!{[8hzp8h @ªToh£shzxqs@¢ïqsvp{szCog<q«w.h´oph h+qso g<{szpvxq}¡vvp{h´{suv g 7 h ¹¨cfh À uho [ f ocf{[zvxhov !Y|R{sr8zpfhwuo³q} s{[z vpc8g<oº»g<qs fhsª[¢±{sz oRvCq}8 hsª¡vpc8q}v>{[fhqsff qv {szph\¿[r zxho³g´h\opoxq}[ho(vx{!h fh £[h zxh qsoop{¦{sBqso%{[oxo f hsR9kf{}vxcfh z'qsff qv {sÀg-q«w¹h-h fhzp[w[¤»q«¨dq}zxhsªTq}8 ¬zph\¿¡r zxh´vpc8q}v'g<hoxopqssh< uh £[h zxw¹r8ophoq[o ¢±h ¨ cf{[8oqsod{[oxo f hs>ãzw[hvªfvpcfh{[u|Rhv £sh{[rf h%vp{-g g 7 h%vpc8h' uh £[h zxw uh q«7w ¹È Ê ³vpcfh%v g<h'oph[v¦w vpc8hg´h\opoxq}[h¨ vpc .vpc8hfhvR¨{szx©Tª¡{[8h v o |Rh\Avxh @ bdcfh¹áY£[{s £ f zCq}8cHg´{u uhqs² {¨o<£shzpw¯hqso ²w¥vp{®vCq}©sh¹opr8CcH 8 ? hzph¡vg<hvpz o ¡vp{aq[ {[rf¡v hÀocq} htuhg´8 ¢±w3vxc o¢±hqvxrfzxh¨ vxc qs²[{sz vxcfg-ovpc8q}vß88 o f[²hop{srfzCh Å}ÌpÂÒ-Å«ÐAѧªâÒ´ÈÊ+É ½ÏuÅCΪq}8 ÍÐCÑ»ÂÐCÑf|R{srfzxfh wuovx{<qs² {}vxcfh z³f{u uho <vpc8hfhvR¨{szx©Tª}¨c Cc´ß88 @ª¡zph\ohv £sh²w[ªvpcfhkhq}zx h\oRv³qszpz £qsf fqvxhsª}vxcfhg g)rfgcf{su¤½¦rfg!h z\ªsqs8 vpc8hg g!rfg uh ¾q«w3g<hoxoxq}sh% uh £shzpw3ovpzCqvxh hoYbdcfh z8q[o vphCc8 ¿¡rfh\oq}zxh uhoxz h vxcfh%¢±{s {¨ f 9. ûâûú^`_abdc.
(22) âØ Ô Ø Ø â &Ô¡Õ bdcfh!fzp{[f h gD{s¢Y {sg<fruv 8<¢±{szxh g<{[ov(|R{srfzxfh wu:o hs ª}|R{[rfzxfh wuovpcqvqszpz £[hkvxcfh'h\q}zx hov {[oxo f h ¢±zx{sgq'o{[rfzChf{u uhvp{'qs²{}vxcfh z°8{¦ fhoª[c8q[oYh h oRvxr8 h -oph £shzxqs¦v g<ho <vpc8hk vxh zCqvpr8zph[ª[qso³ocf{[zvxhov v g<hqvpco av g<h ¤½ uhh8 uh[v´vpzCq}o{szpv)fh vR¨>{[zp©uo ïoph Fh i dqs8 azxh¢±hzph8h\ovxcfh zxh Aabdc8h.áY£[{s £ f zxqsfc g<{u uh âqs² {¨o>¢±{szq´fzxhoph ¡vxq}v {s¨ vxc q´¢±{[zpg-qsTqs8 uhvCq ²h\ {sg<f ht vRwq}8qs²wuo oªfqso>¢±{[² {¨o lhg 8 <vxc8qv\ª {szC uh zYvx{) {sg<fruvxhopcf{szpvph\oRv8qvxc8o ª[vpc8hr8opr8qs |R©uovpzCq o>qs²[{sz vxcfZ g 6Tfzx{uh h\ fo°¦w<fr ¾ 8 q<oh +v Iä{s¢ ƲūР "%£shzv hoª¡¢±{sz¨c Ccvxcfh'opcf{szpvph\oRv8q}vpc8odc8q«£[hqs²zxhq[ uw-h h {sg<fruvxh @ª¦vxcfh Ccf{¦{[o f´q´£[h zpvpht z8{}v I ¨cf{¡ohopcf{szpvph\oRv>8qvxc-hov g<q}vph[ª $ z3&pª o°g g)rfg ª¦qs8 -qs 8 8 z3vxW{ I´ª hs ª¡ ²{¡o f z& 9v°vpc o>{ ¡vª q} Áq}zC o>¢±zx{s? g z.vx{ ! Iqszph-ÅCÎf É "ª hs ªuvpcfhwq}zxhhtfq}g fh .q}8 vpc8hzxhophAv £[hocf{[zvxhovqvpc.hov g-qvxhs ª ª o rfT fqvxh ¢±{[zqs²&h 8 ¦¤½{ [vCo º»+{szC uh zvx{3c8q«£[h'¿[r C© qshoxovx{-vpc8h!hovopcf{szpvph\oRv8q}vpc¹h\oRv g-q}vphsª8vpcfh´q} s{[z vpcfg ©shh 8oq'g u¤½cfhqsfz {[z vRw<¿[r8h rf h
(23) ¼¨ vpc q} £[h zpv ho ! QI´ªu¨ vpc©sh w °µ{svphvxc8qv o v q} 8 7 h -vx{ #¢±{[z q} @£shzv hodfrfv¢±{sz [ªf¨c Cccqso f bdcfhg-q H{sohzp£qv {[ |R©uovpzCq o-g<hvxcf{u o3vpc8q}vfzxhßftW8qvxc8o3{s¢opcf{[zvxhov38qvxc8o3q}zxh¹opcf{szpvph\oRv38q}vpc8o vpc8h g-oh²£[ho u¢±{[zvxrf8q}vph wsª v o´{s¦£ {[r8o'vxc8qv3q+fzph ßft|R{sr8zpfhw®{}¢q+¢±{szxh g<{¡oRv|R{srfzxfhw o<f{sv´fh\h\opoxq}z wBq ¢±{szxh g<{¡oRvd|R{sr8zpfhws3µk{}vR¨ vpc8ovxqs8 f8ª v!q}Bh-8zp{£[h ¹vxc8qv!vpcfhzph<ht oRvCo'qv hq[oRv'{[fh´¢±{szxh g<{[ovd|R{srfzxfh w¬¨ vxc opr8Cc.q´fzx{sh zpvRw q}.h £s{[²£ f´szCq}fcÁ bdcfhzph ¢±{szxhsªÁvxcfhqs²[{sz vxcfg ¢±{[z¢±{szxh g<{[ov|R{sr8zpfhwuo ª(o©[hvCCcfh Àh {¨ª(q}Bhoph h ®q[o!q zph\Av)q[ fq}fvxqv {[B{}¢ |R©uovpzCq ovphCc8 ¿¡rfh[ i[kh²h vphzx{¡{sv{s¢c8hq} [vx{<t@ f·f{szdh\qsCc.{sh fh sc¦{szd£{s¢ât u{ ïTq M {sg<frfvph%ß8zCoRv£q} h\ ushoxCcfh frf²hv g<hszxhq}vphz{[zdh¿¡r8q}Ávp{-rfzxzxh ¡vdv g´h'ovph ± º»8oph zpv£ vxcfhcfh\q} ¢ v¨dqsod8{}vdvpcfhzphqs²zxhq[ uws 8º½¢fhh uh\ @ªurfT fqvxh' oRvCq}8 h%vp{<£q} vxo©sh w[ T fqvxh%vpcfhcfh\q}Á f M ²{¡oht@Yº»8ohzv v .vxcfh%¢±{szxh g<{[ov(|R{srfzxfhw¦o>vxzphhs 9®¢±{[zphg<{[ovu|R{srfzxfh w¢±zx{sgqop{srfzCh°8{¦ f h ³vp{qs²[{}vxcfh zCoÁf{u uh\o&q}%vxc¡roâh> {sg<fruvxh 4 nL Q /& & v g<hs(bdcfh>vph zxg gL Q oRvxh g-o⢱zp{[g vxcfh²{¦{s©¦rfo ¡vp{vxcfhdopCcfh\ urf h³ ov({}¢ ¡vph zx£q}¾o ª«zxh¿¡r zph\ vp{% uh fh°vpc8h>h\q}zx hov v g<h ¡vxh zx£«qs ¨c Ccvp{3zx{[oxohq[Cc£ o vph\ h\ ush[ # Á!Ö &Ø#" Ø â &Ô¡Õ bdcfh 3rf²vRw®vp{B{[g<fruvph.g f¤§cf{[+|R{[rfzxfh wuo´oRvxh g-o)¢±zp{[g vpcfh 8qszxqsg´h vphz!g<hq[orfz f vpc8hh u[hvxzxq«£[h zCopqs8v g<h\o ªf¨c Cc q}¡q g-q}©[hvxc8qv8zph ßft{}¢(oc8{szpvphov(|R{srfzxfhw¦oqszphf{svfh hoxopqsz ²w3opcf{[zvxho=v ^ohh · [rfzxh%Y A [1] A. [2]. [3] B. [4] C. D. E. F. G. H. · [rfzxh (bdc8hg u¤§c8{s'|R{[rfzxfh w<¢±zx{s% g $Bvp{'& vCq}©sh\o 5)cf{[8odqvv g´hovphPdsªu¨c8h zxhqso³vpc8hopcf{szpvph\oRv|R{sr8zpfhw<vp{[A vxqs©sh\od{sf w3{s8hc8{sÁªufrfvqvdv g<h'oRvxh 8 µh£shzvxcfh hoxo ª¦¨h%f{}vxhvxc8qv ¢vpcfh¾qsovh u[hsªfoxq«w) z H *$&pªf{s¢q<g f¤§cf{[!|R{[rfzxfh w3hvR¨h h£[h zpvph t('q} £[h zpvpht *+qszpz £[hoqvv g<[ h $CªÁvxcfh Àvxcfh-fzxhßft3|R{[rfzxfh w ïs{ f.¢±zx{s) g -vpX{ z oopcf{szpvphz%vpc8qsÀqs²°vpcfh%|R{[rfzp8h wuo¢±zp{[g*´vx{ zÀh 8 f. p ÅÌx/ $C%bdcfhzph ¢±{szxhsª8{[fh)q}+ {s8o uh zh zpvxq q zxo z H($ &q}8 ¹ {sg<fruvxh'vxcfh!g u¤§c8{s-|R{[rfzp8h wuo¢±zx{sg )vp{£shzvxhx t zÀqszpz £ f x ÅÌpÂv g<7h $Cº»¹vxc og-q}8fh z\ªvpcfh´fzxhßftfzx{sh zpvRw ozph\ohvph\ @ªTvpc8q}v oªTqfzxhßft{s¢³q g f¤§cf{[|R{sr8zpfhw<¨ Tc8q«£shkq!g g!r8gD¦rfg!h z{}¢Ácf{[8o vCoh ¢Rªurf uh z>vpcfh%{[8 v {s-vxc8qv vdqszpz £[ho³h ¢±{szxhop{sg<h v g<h´ovph1 $,+^ ko 83vpc ofzx{sh zpvRwsªTq3vxzphh!{s¢Á|R{srfzxfhw¦okh vR¨>hh - <q}8 q zx o z H($ & qs¹h´fr ²vª +¨c Cc+h\qsCc £shzvxh6t z¹qsfhq}zCodqv hq[oRv{sBh ïoph h· [rfzxh] A ¶¦r8Cc¯q}aq} s{[z vpc8g6 {sg<fruvxho)g u¤½cf{s¹|R{srfzxfh wuo'¢±zp{[g q¬o f[²hop{sr8zx (h vp{¬qs²>vpc8h£shzv ho >ª ¢kopr8Cc |R{sr8zpfhwuo!h t ov®º½¢ o<{[ffhvph\ @ªYvpc8h avxcfh{[g´8²h t vRwB{}¢vxcfhq} s{[z vpcfg 'o "4/.1032 LRQ&xª³¨cfhzp4h o)vpc8h hh[vxz vRw3{s5¢ [Yº½¢ od8{}vk{[ffh\Avph\ 3vxcfh'{[g<f²h t vRw3{s¢&vxcfh'q} s{[z vpc8g 6o / 4 7gL Q&p S. [1]. [1−2]. [1−3]. [1−4]. [1−3]. [1−2]. [1]. ±üû Êÿ .
(24) (A,1). (B,1). (C,1). (D,1). (B,2). (C,2) (D,2). (E,2). (C,3). (D,3). (F,3). (D,4). (E,4). (E,1) (F,2). (F,1) (G,1). (H,1). (G,2). (S,0) (E,3). · [rfzxh$°bâzxh h%{s¢opcf{szpvph\oRv8q}vpc8od{s¢&vxcfhh £[{s £ f´szCq}fc.oc8{¨ · sr8zphf 8 Ô Ø â âÔ¡Õ ;hzph[ªfvpc8h'{su|Rh\Av £[hvp{-h!{[uv g 8 7 h ovpc8h|R{srfzxfhw "[ÂÆ²Í kbdc ok¿¡rfh\oRv {[ og)r8Ccg<{szxh {[g<f²h tvpc8qs!vxcfhvR¨>{k¢±{szxg<h z({sfh\o ªhq}r8ophdq¢ïq[oRvxh z|R{srfzxfhwg<q«w'qsfhq}z¨h fq}cfh\qs 'v g<h[ªs{sz( qs!c8q«£[h>g-qs¡w g<{szxh'cf{[8ok {sg<8q}zxh vx{-vpcfh)g u¤½cf{[<|R{srfzxfh wuok~ {szxh {£[h z\ª¦vpcfh´oh h\ {}¢°q%|R{[rfzp8h w.fzph ßft oq} g<{[ov zxzph²h£q}¡v zxh [qszx f vxcfhoph h a{}¢vpc8h¨cf{[²h!|R{srfzxfh w[¹º»8 uhh @ª°q¹¢ïqsov)fzxhß8tÀg-q«wÀ¨>h² g<f w®q¹ {sf+¨q v f¹v g´h Wq f{u uh[ª[{ ? ophvpv f'vxcfhqsf8q}zxh ¡v³¡q oh h\ @³ã<vpcfh{}vpc8h z³cq}8 @ªuop{sg<hfzxhß8t|R{[rfzp8h wuo³qszphdvx{¡{´o {¨Hq}8 <c8h 8 h r8oph hoxovp{´vpc8h'{sg<frfvxqv {[8o 9ko ¹vpc8h<qsoph'{}¢>g u¤½cf{s|R{srfzxfhw¦oªvpcfh-q} s{[z vpc8g0fzx{uhh focf{s+¡wc8{sÁª@o 8 h!vxcfh´¡r8g!h z{}¢³cf{[8o Àq ¢ïqsovph\oRvY|R{[rfzxfh w oqs op{-{srf8 fh .¦w /®d·f{[zhqsCc ªq´ oRv{}¢(zph²h£«qs¡vY|R{srfzxfh w.¾qsoxoh\od{}¢(²hf}vxc oRvCq}zpv f ofr ²vª8¦wvxqs© f<vxcfh' ov¢±{szkcf{su¤»{[rf¡v 5d!q}8 .h t¡vxh 8 f vCozxh h £q}¡vY|R{sr8zpfhw q[opophovx{ cf{so bdc o o u{[fh'¦w htfq}g 83hq[Cch u[h'{}¢Yvxcfh!h£s{s £ 8-szCq}fcÁªfr fvpcfhk|R{srfzxfhw¦o¾qsoxoh\ovxc8qv% q}[{-vpc8zp{[rfsc vxc o h fshsªfqs8 vpcfh.h g qv f zpzxh h £q}¡v|R{srfzxfhw¾qsoxoh\o & 9¢Êvph z /6cf{[8oª¦vpcfh¢ïqsovph\oRvY|R{[rfzxfh wuoh²{[f´vp{´vpc8h%ß88q} ov³{}¢@zxh h £q}¡v@|R{[rfzp8h w) q[opopho&bdc8h zxh¢±{szxhsª vdor 3 ho(vx{!oh\q}zCCc!¢±{[zYvpc8hg g!r8g |R{[rfzxfh wuo <vpc o° oRv°vx{{suvCq vpc8h3zph\¿¡rfhovph\ ¹¢ïq[oRvxhov|R{srfzxfhw¦obdcfh-¦rfg)hz'{}¢zxh h £q}¡v'¾qsoxopho o{[rf8 uh\ B¦w¹vpc8ho 7 h-{s¢ >ª(q}8 ¬vxc¡rovpc8h {[g<f²h t vRw3{s¢âvxcfh'q} s{[z vpcfg zphg<q o>{sr88 uh Á bdcfh%cf{[u¤½ {srf¡v or8oh\ 3vx{-oRvx{svpcfh'qs²[{sz vxcfg ïq}¢Êvph zc8{su¤»{[rf¡v / hd A°b&zCqsC©-{}¢zph²h£q}¡v(|R{srfzxfh wuo od©sh fv qsoY¢±{s ²{¨o- £sh)vR¨ {|R{srfzxfhw¦no vgq}8 v¢±zp{[g dvx{ *ª¡¨ vpc3 uh8q}zpvprfzxh fqvxhko $ dH$ dq} ´qszpz £«qs fq}vph/o $ H$ }ª{[8ohzp£[hvpc8q}v ¢°{svpqc $ $ q}8x $ $ %cf{[ @ª8vpcfh¹f{sv {s8²w)|R{srfzxfhxw v ovxq}zpvxoq¢Êvxh z°|R{[rfzxfh qw v ª8ruv³|R{[rfzp8h xw v qszpz £shodh¢±{[zphk|R{srfzxfhXw v º»vxc oqsoph|R{srfzxfhXw v odr8oh²h\opo¢±{[zdvpcfh'qs²[{sz vxcfg ªu¨c Cc©[h h ovpzCqsC©-{s8²w3{s¢|R{[rfzxfh w v bdcfh-q} s{[z vpc8g {sg<frfvpho¢ïqsovphovd|R{srfzxfhw¦o¢±zx{sg q.o fs h-o{[rfzx 'h -vp{q} (vpc8h-£sh zpv h\o 1 / / 4 L Q & ovph o Bu Õ ~ {u uh fv g<h ¥ÚÛâÜÁÝfÞ "- £sh-zCq oh<vx{+oph £shzxqs° 8 ? hzph[v)g´h vpz o%vpcqv!g-q«w¬oph zx£sh3q[o{sf|RhAv £[h ¢±rf8v {s8o -zx{srfv foRvxzxq}vph h\o ;hzph¨hkopcf{¨>h\ !c8{¨¥vx{{suv g 7 hvxcfhkq}zxz £q}f 8qvph[ª}vxcfhcf{[u¤½ {srf¡v\ª}{szYvxcfhk uh q«w {}¢(g<hoxopqssh% uh £sh zxws(bdcfh\oh%vxcfzphh%8q}zCq}g<hvxh zCod q}.h{suv g 7 h {[²w¦f{[g q}v g<hs . . . .
(25)
(26) . . . . . . .
(27) .
(28) . . . .
(29) . . . . . ~L%^8. /gF/FJ:@A<`*,BP*,<YC. /Bg:#0h< *(Ki:. M {sg<frfv fÀq¬g-qt g<qs {sf8hAvxh ¯{sg<{sfh¡v ¯q¬r8opr8q}szCq}fc o´£shzpwBh\qsopD w 6½ ruv<¨c8qv<¨>{[rf¾ ac8qsfh ¨cfhvpcfh)f{}v {[8o{s¢Y8qvxc8oqs8 {[ffh\Av {sokq}zxhvx{3h)rf8 uhzxovp{¦{u ¥Å}Ä«Â Ì!ѧÈÊÒ< ¯àÁhvr8oovxqszv¡w uh ß8 f3v g<h¤ {[ffh\Av £ vRw3¢±{szxg<qs² ws 9h£s{[²£ f-szCq}fc okoxq .vp{3h3ѧÈÊÒ< CÅÉ8ÉT ѻ " ¢Yvxcfh zxh'h t ovxoY|R{[rfzxfh wuo ¥h vR¨>hh ¹q}¦wvR¨>{-£[h zpv h\o ) !+#â .Ô ± Ø g-qt g-q}v g<h¤»{s8fhvph B {sg<{[fh ¡v h) ¹ÈÊɯÍ}ɯ īÅ}ÆÇÄÈÊÉ¦Ë Ë}ÌpÍAÎ8ÏÀȾдÑ^ϦÂÒ<>Í [ÈÊÒ<Í}Æ(РÑÅ ÄÂÌAÑ§È CÂAÐ # ! # Ð AÏ.ÑïÏuÍÑ ÅÌ´Í3É 'ÎuÍ}ÈÊJÌ z H *6Z # ³Ñ^Ϧ ÌpÂ< [ȾÐAÑ^Ð'+Í O Å uÌAÉT  CÌpÅE Ò zWѽŠ*®Í}É ".GÍ O Å uÌAÉ CÌpÅ}Ò * ѻŠz ¦ÐAÈÊɦËÅÉÆ 3ÄÂÌAÑ§È CÂAÐÈÊÉ # bdc¦r8oªvxcfh³h£s{[²£ for8fszCq}fc + ur8h\ ¦w{so uh z f£shzv ho 'vxcfh~b MPM # o&qg-q}t g-q} ²w%{[ffh\Avph\ h £[{s £ f<[zxqsfcÁ>·8{szh tfq}g<f hsª ¹· [rfzxh!u=ª W H dH O\¢±{szxg<okq3~b MPM o 8h%vxcfh zxh'q}zxhd|R{sr8zpfhwuod¢±zp{[g vp{ %qs8 £ h%£sh zCoxq!¨c Cc.vpzCq«£shzxophk{[f²w£sh zpv h\o .vpc8h'oh v W H dH \[ "!. #. %$'&. )(*. 10 32. ,+-+/.. 40. 50. 0. 6 7 8. 96. ;6 7 8. ûâûú^`_abdc. :8.
(30) · [rfzxh ³~qt g-q}Áb g´h ¤ M {[ffh\Avph\ M {[g<{[fh ¡v ã<vpc8h{svpcfhz³c8qs8 @ª · sr8zph fª¦q}²vpcf{[rfsc<vxcfh zxhkh t ovâ|R{sr8zpfhwuo°¢±zx{sg )vp{ q}8 -¢±zp{[g dvx{ ªAW H H +\ o>f{sv q}+~¹b MPM o 8h'vpcfh){sf w!|R{[rfzxfh w¢±zp{[g vx{ %vpzCq«£shzxophod£ q «º»8 fh h vpcfh´orf8szCq}fc 8 ur8 h ¦w W dH \ of{sv g-qt g<qs² w {sffh\Avxh @ª8q[ {szC 8!vx{<vpcfh! fhß8 v {sqs{£[hs°bdc o odh\ q}roh[ªfrff ©[h'oRvCq}8 8q}zC [zxqsfc8oª¦vpcfhzph qs h!q%|R{sr8zpfhwhvR¨h h.vR¨>{3£[h zpv h\o vxcfh)~b MPM vxc8qvvpzCq«£sh zCopho£shzv ho{[ruvxo fh # dbdc¦r8oª v o{[oxo f h¢±{[z vR¨{£[h zpv hocz H * Z # vx{h\oRvCq}f ocBq)|R{srfzxfh whvR¨h h+vxcfh g ¨ vxcf{srfvvxcfh3{[8ovpzCq [vvpc8q}v!q} (£sh zpv h\o Àvpc8h |R{sr8zpfhw3g!roRvh¨ vxc # ³¶¦{ªu¨>h%{ ? hzq<²{¦{[oph z uh ß8 v {s {}¢({[ffhv £ vRwq[o¢±{s ²{¨o 6. 6. :8. 8. 8. :7. 6. ;6 8. 7 8. 0. 0. )0. · srfzxh ³ãh ¹~b MPM .Ô ±Ø É-{sh g-qt g-qs8v g<h¤»{[ffh\Avph\ {sg<{[fh ¡v RÅO h) <ȾÐ%Ñ^ϦÂ%Ò-Í [ÈÊÒ-ÍÆTÐ ÂÑÅ Ä«Â ÌAÑ§È xÂÐ # !+#®Ð ÏÑïÏuÍÑ ÅÌ)Í}É3%ÎfÍÈÊÌIz H *[Z # °Ñ^Ϧ ÌpÂ)Â[ȾÐAÑïÐ'ÍPO Å uÌAÉ CÌpÅÒEz¥Ñ»Å*®ÍÉ "ÍGO ÅuÌAÉ CÌpÅ}Ò *ÀѽÅz¥ÈÊÉ 9vßzxov o sc¡vª v g<q«wHoph hg{u f Ãvpc8q}v.h£s{[²£ faszCq}8c8oq[ ug v.vR¨>{W 8? hzph[v f{sv {s8o{}¢v g<h¤»{[ffh\Avph\ {[g<{[fh ¡vxoYbdc ooRvxh g-o¢±zx{sg vxcfh g<f vk{szC uh z ¡vpzx{¦ fr8h\ ¦w-vxcfh%v g<h%¢ïqsAvx{sz\ªu¨c Cc.qs² {¨o¢±{szq´£shzvxht-vx{ h {sf´vp{<vR¨{< U ? h zxh ¡v~b MPM oª .{[f{[o v {[vx{<vpcfh'qsoph r8orq}@szCq}8c8o ·fzx{sg vxcfh {sg<frfvxqv {[¯ {sg<f ht vRw®£ h ¨{ ¡vª°vxcfh.¢ïqsv)vxc8qv3{[g<fruv f|R{srfzxfhw¦o o´{[²w¦f{[g q} g<f ho vpcqv3vxcfh+£[h z ßqv {[¯{s¢v g<h ¤½ {sffh\Av £ vRw o3{s w¦f{sg q}§äãWvxcfh+{svpcfhz3c8q} @ª v qsWh+8zp{£[h ¯vpc8q}vvpc8h uh\{sg<{[o v {[{s¢q}.h £[{s £ f´szCq}8c [vx4{ ±{} ¤ ~¹b MPM o oµkyY¤ M {[g´8²h vphsª8¡wzph\ ur8 f)vpcfh
(31) fzx{sf h g vx{ )
(32) )âª8 uh ß8fh\ h {¨ )
(33) ) $ £sh.qsh£s{s £ 8´[zxqsf c "!$# HJ%# &³qs8 qs ¡vphsh z ª ovxcfh zxhq3~b MPM {s¢(o 7 h Bu Õ bdcfh%zph\or8 vCodfzph\oh¡vph q}{£sh g<f w3vxc8qv{[g<fruv f<q´g<q}t g-q}@ {sffh\Avxh .{sg<{sfh¡v{£[h zv g<h {}¢qÚÛ&ÜÁÝuÞ oµy(¤ M {sg<f hvph[!·fr8zvxcfh zxg<{szxhsªvR¨>{. uhß8 v {[8o{}¢>opr8Cc¬ {sg<{sfh[vCoqszph){¡opo f²h[ª@{sfh)¨cfh zxh)qs² {[ffh\Av f|R{[rfzxfh wuo°h {s8vp{!vpcfh{sg<{sfh¡vª¦q}8 -qsf{}vxcfh z>¨cfh zxhkop{sg<hf{u uh\o³{[ruvxo fhvpcfh{[g´{s8h ¡v> qs3h r8oph vp{<h8or8zphv g<h¤»{[ffhv £ vRw[ . &. (. *. ,+ +/.. 0. 2. 0. 3+. +. *. +. *. . #. . ±üû Êÿ .
(34) B /,BP*(F. ~L%^~. <]0+:": ,. bdcfhd£shzpw8{}v {s){}¢Ñ^ÌpÂC o(f{}v g´g<h\ q}vph²wvxzxqs8op q}vxq}8²h>¨cfh ´g<{¦ fh fv g<h 3ÚkÛâÜÁÝuÞ#"}bdc o o&hq}r8ophvpzxh h\o Àror8qs(szCq}fc8ozxh fzxhoph ¡vq.g g!rfg6oRvxzprAvpr8zph< qsuvprfz f{s8fhv £ vRwsªâ¨c Cc oq} zph\qs uw¹q {[g<f²h t¹f{}v {[ ¨cfh.r88 uh zCovp{¦{u {£[h zv g<hsª8q[oohh .vpc8hfzph£ {[r8odoh\Av {sâ º»{szC uhzvp{-¢±{[zpg-qs² w uh ß8fhvxzphhok{£sh zdv g<h[ª¨h'fhh .ß8zCoRvkvp{ ¡vpzx{¦ fr8hvxcfh'fzx{[q[ uh z{sh fv{}¢³oprffszCq}8c8o {}¢q}h£s{[²£ f![zxqsfcÁª¦{szÐ Â Ä«Å}ÆÇÄ\ÈÊÉ¡Ë´Ë}ÌpÍAÎ8Ï[ÐC³º»[vxr v £sh wsªuq´or8u¤§h£s{[²£ f![zxqsfc oqsh£s{s £ 8!szCq}8c ¨c Cc vpc8hfzph\oh8h [vxh zx£q}¾oq}zxh {s¡vxq fh\ .vpcfh8zph\oh8h ¡vxh zx£«qs od{s¢âvxcfh{sz q}Th £[{s £ f´szCq}fc⪡g<h\q} f´vpc8q}vq oprfu¤½h £s{[²£ f´szCq}fc. q}.h orfzxh%{sf wq-oprf8ophv{}¢vpc8h'{sg<g)rf qv {[8o{¡opo f²h .vpcfh{[z 8q}Th£s{s £ 8)[zxqsfcÁ .Ô ± Ø
(35) &ÂÑ C H,PH $ # &pÂ!ÍɹÂÄÅÆ ÄÈÊɦË)ËsÌpÍCÎ]Ï +$ C +H,+ H-+ &ȾРxÍ}ÆÊƲ "Í)Ð ÂÄÅÆÇÄ\ÈÊÉ¡Ë!Ë}ÌpÍAÎ8Ï.Å ¸È C +( È ¾ÐÍ!Ð § ËsÌpÍCÎÏ Å C Í É ")È ÑïÏu ÂÌxÂkȾÐ%Í!Ò-ÅÉTÅÑ»ÅÉT uÉ Ñ§ÈïÅÉ
Documents relatifs
In infantile Pompe disease patients, the glycogen storage diffusely affects brainstem motor and sensory neurons, and the whole spinal cord sensory neurons, interneurons, and
De ce point de vue, il est possible d’affirmer que la mission est accomplie : les projets de renouvellement urbain (GPV et ORU) élaborés depuis 1998 dans une centaine de villes
cosinus (en bleu à gauche) et d’une droite (en noir à droite) sur les données simulées pour 4 années à une température de 45°C, avec un bruit de fond interne réduit de 100,
Florence CARRÉ ~ Réoccupations funéraires de sépultures collectives néolithiques dans la boucle du
2 Vue plus en détails dans le chapitre 1... 2 phénomène d’agrégation des protéines amyloïdes en fibres et d’autres facteurs impor- tants doivent être pris en compte comme
In this chapter, we prove an a posteriori error estimates for the generalized overlapping domain decomposition method with Dirichlet boundary conditions on the boundaries for
Revue française d’héraldique et de sigillographie – Études en ligne – 2020-10 © Société française d’héraldique et de sigillographie, Paris,
Dans ce cas, comme les coulées du Bras de Sainte-Suzanne appartiennent au massif de La Montagne daté à plus de 2 Ma (McDougall, 1971), l’ensemble des coulées pahoehoe