Detecting user's interests based on the accuracy of collaborative tagging information

HAL Id: hal-01225774

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01225774

Submitted on 6 Nov 2015

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Detecting user’s interests based on the accuracy of

collaborative tagging information

Manel Mezghani, André Péninou, Corinne Amel Zayani, Ikram Amous,

Florence Sèdes

To cite this version:

Manel Mezghani, André Péninou, Corinne Amel Zayani, Ikram Amous, Florence Sèdes. Detecting user’s interests based on the accuracy of collaborative tagging information. 13th International Con-ference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work (ECSCW 2013), Sep 2013, Paphos, Cyprus. pp. 21-26. �hal-01225774�

O

pen

A

rchive

T

OULOUSE

A

rchive

O

uverte (

OATAO

)

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.

This is an author-deposited version published in : http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/

Eprints ID : 12678

The contribution was presented at ECSCW 2013 :

https://ecscw2013.cs.ucy.ac.cy/index.php

To cite this version : Mezghani, Manel and Péninou, André and Zayani, Corinne and Amous, Ikram and Sèdes, Florence Detecting user's interests

based on the accuracy of collaborative tagging information. (2013) In: 13th

International Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work

(ECSCW 2013), 21 September 2013 - 25 September 2013 (Paphos, Cyprus).

Any correspondance concerning this service should be sent to the repository

!"#"$#%&'()*"+,*(%&#"+"*#*(-.*"/(0&(#1"(

.$$)+.$2(03($044.-0+.#%5"(#.''%&'(

%&30+6.#%0&(

7.&"4(7"8'1.&%

9:;<

:(=&/+>(?>&%&0)

;<

:(@0+%&&"(=6"4(A.2.&%

9<

:(BC+.6(

=60)*

9D

(.&/(E40+"&$"(FG/"*

;<

(

9_{F3.H(I&%5"+*%#2:(7BJ=@K(K.-0+.#0+2:(F3.H:(L)&%*%.M(};_{?.)4(F.-.#%"+(I&%5"+*%#2:(} BJBL(K.-0+.#0+2M((

<

*)+&.6"N%+%#M3+

:(

D !"#$%&$%'()*!)+,)&#-(&.-

(

!"#$%&'$()_{!" #$%&" '&()*+%" ,-$" .(" &%)+%/." .,%"}XVHU¶V0%%1$"-//(&1*02".(",*$"/,-&-/.%&*$.*/$"

3'%&$(0-+" 1-.-4" *0.%&%$.$" -01" '&%)%&%0/%$54" ,*$" /(0.%6.4" -01" ,*$" $*.#-.*(07" 80" .,*$" -&.*/+%4" 9%")(/#$"(0".,%"'&(:+%;"()"-1-'.-.*(0"<#-+*.="*0"$(/*-+"0%.9(&>$4"9,*/,"*$"-))%/.%1":=".,%" DFFXUDF\ DQG UHOHYDQFH RI WKH XVHU¶V" *0.%&%$.$7" ?,%" (&*2*0-+*.=" ()" (#&" -''&(-/," *$" .,%" SURSRVDO RI D QHZ WHFKQLTXH RI LQWHUHVWV¶ GHWHFWLRQ" :=" -0-+=@*02" .,%" -//#&-/=" ()" .,%" .-22*02" :%,-A*(#&" ()" .,%" #$%&" *0" (&1%&" .(" )*2#&%" (#." .,%" .-2$" 9,*/," -/.#-++=" &%)+%/." .,%" UHVRXUFHV¶FRQWHQWB#&"-''&(-/,",-$":%%0".%$.%1"-01"%A-+#-.%1"(0".,%"C%+*/*(#$"$(/*-+" 1-.-:-$%7"

B&#+0/)$#%0&(

F0$%.4(%&30+6.#%0&(%*(O"+6.&"&#42('+0P%&'M(@0&*"Q)"&#42:(#1"(./.O#.#%0&(O+0$"**( -"$06"*( 60+"( $06O4"HM( L1"( ./.O#.#%0&( %*( .( O+0$"**( *#+0&'42( +"4.#"/( #0( )*"+¶V( O+03%4"(60/"44%&'M(=(O+03%4"(#1.#(+"34"$#*(#1"(.OO+0O+%.#"($1.+.$#"+%*#%$*(R%&#"+"*#*:( O+"3"+"&$"*:( "#$MS( $0)4/( .50%/( $0'&%#%5"( 05"+40./( .&/( /%*0+%"&#.#%0&( 03( #1"( )*"+( P1"&(.$$"**%&'(#1"(%&30+6.#%0&(*O.$"M(B&(0)+(P0+C:(P"(.+"(%&#"+"*#"/(%&(/"#"$#%&'( #1"()*"+,*(%&#"+"*#*(#1.#(P%44(-"()*"/(%&(3)+#1"+(P0+C*(30+(.&(./.O#.#%0&(O)+O0*"M(

!"#"$#%&'( *0$%.4( )*"+¶V( %&#"+"*#*,( %*( .( &0&( #+%5%.4( O+0-4"6( R7%4%$"5%$( +.( .4M:( ;T9TSM( B&( 3.$#:( #1"( )*"+¶V( O+03%4"( -)%4/%&'( O+0$"**( *)33"+*( 3+06( #1"( 4.$C( 03( %&30+6.#%0&( O+05%/"/( -2( 1%6*"43M( B&/""/:( #1"( )*"+( '"&"+.442( /0"*&,#( '%5"( .44( #1"( %&30+6.#%0&( +"4.#"/( #0( 1%*( %&#"+"*#*M( F0( 1%*( O+03%4"( $.&( &"5"+( -"( $0&*%/"+"/( 3)442(

" "

C&0P&( -2( .( *2*#"6MB&( 0+/"+( #0( 05"+$06"( *)$1( .( O+0-4"6:( #1"( +"*".+$1"+*( 1.5"( .&.428"/( #1"( *0$%.4( "&5%+0&6"&#( 03( #1"( )*"+( *)$1( .*( 1%*( &"%'1-0)+*( R#1"( O"+*0&*( $0&&"$#"/( #0( #1"( )*"+( "HO4%$%#42( 0+( %6O4%$%#42S:( 1%*( #.''%&'( -"1.5%0)+( R#1"( $044.-0+.#%5"(.$#%0&(03(#.''%&'(+"*0)+$"*S:(0+("5"&(#1"(0-U"$#*( R#1"(+"*0)+$"*S(1"( %&#"+.$#*(P%#1(R*""(30+("H.6O4"(R=*#+.%&(+.(.4M:(;T9TSSM(

B&( #1%*( O.O"+:( P"( 3%+*#42( O+"*"&#( *06"( "H%*#%&'( P0+C*( %&#"'+.#%&'( #1"( *0$%.4( "&5%+0&6"&#(03(#1"()*"+(#0(/"#"$#(%&#"+"*#*M(L1"&:(P"(*10P(#1"(/%33"+"&$"*(03(0)+( .OO+0.$1($06O.+"/(#0(#1"(0#1"+(.OO+0.$1"*(%&(#1"(*.6"($0&#"H#M(V"(#1"&(/"*$+%-"( 0)+( O+0O0*.4( 30+( /"#"$#%&'( %&#"+"*#*( .&/( #1"( "HO"+%6"&#*( /0&"( #0( 5.4%/.#"( %#M( E%&.442:(P"($0&$4)/"(.&/(/%*$)**(*06"(3)#)+"(P0+C*M(

J"4.#"/(P0+C*(

=$$0+/%&'( #0( R=*#+.%&( +.( .4M:( ;T9TS:( %&#"+"*#*( $0)4/( -"( /"/)$"/( 3+06( #1"( *0$%.4( "&5%+0&6"&#( -.*"/( 0&( #1"( !"#$:( #1"( %&'#()* 0+( "5"&( #1"( )+,M( L1"( $044.-0+.#%5"( #.''%&'( -"1.5%0)+( %*( /"*$+%-"/( .*( #1"( $0&&"$#%0&( 03( #1"*"( #1+""( "4"6"&#*W( %#( +"O+"*"&#*(#1"(.$#%0&(03(#.''%&'(.(+"*0)+$"(R0-U"$#S(-2(".$1()*"+M(

E0+(#1"(!"#$:(%&#"+"*#*($0)4/(-"("HO4%$%#42(O+05%/"/(%&(#1"()*"+¶VO+03%4"(RA.2.&%(

+.(.4M(;TTXS:(0+(%6O4%$%#42(/"/)$"/(3+06(1%*(-"1.5%0)+(03(&.5%'.#%0&(RJ"-.%(+.(.4M:(

;T9;S(0+(-"1.5%0)+(03(#.''%&'(RY%6(+.(.4M:(;T99SM(L1"()*"+Z-.*"/(%&#"+"*#($0)4/(-"( /"/)$"/( 3+06( 0#1"+( )*"+*( %&( #1"( &"#P0+C*( R&"%'1-0)+*S( RY%6( +.( .4M:( ;T99S( RL$1)"&#":(;T9[SM(

E0+(#1"(%&'#():(%&#"+"*#*(.+"(/"/)$"/(-.*"/(0&(#1"(0-U"$#*(#1.#(#1"()*"+(.$$"**"*( RV1%#"( +.( .4M:( ;TT\S( R7.( +.( .4M:( ;T99SM( ]-U"$#*( $0)4/( -"( .&2( #2O"( 03( +"*0)+$"( RIJK:(P"-(O.'":(%6.'":("#$MSM(=4#10)'1(#1"*"(P0+C*(.+"(0-U"$#Z-.*"/:(#1"2(/0(&0#( .&.428"( 0-U"$#,*( $0&#"&#M( L0( .&.428"( +"*0)+$"( $0&#"&#:( /%33"+"&#( #"$1&%Q)"*( "H%*#( *)$1( .*( #1"( %&/"H.#%0&( #"$1&%Q)"M( B&/"H.#%0&( %*( )*"/( %&( 0+/"+( #0( "H#+.$#( #1"( *%'&%3%$.&#( #"+6*( 3+06( +"*0)+$"*M( =3#"+( %&/"H%&'( +"*0)+$"*( /%33"+"&#( *$0+%&'( 3)&$#%0&($0)4/(-"(.OO4%"/(%&(0+/"+(#0(/"#"$#(#1"(60*#(+"4"5.&#(+"*0)+$"(.$$0+/%&'( #0(.(*O"$%3%$(Q)"+2(R^.44"#(+.(.4M:(;T9TSM(

E0+( #1"( )+,:( %#*( )#%4%#2( 1.*( -""&( O+05"&( #0( /"#"$#( )*"+,*( %&#"+"*#( RY%6( +.( .4M:( ;T99SM(-+,Z-.*"/(%&#"+"*#(/"#"$#%0&($0)4/(-"(/"/)$"/(-2(.&.428%&'()*"/(#.'*(R!"( 7"0(+.(.4M(;T9TS(0+(-2(.&.428%&'(#1"(*"6.&#%$(03(#.'*(RY%6(+./.4M:(;T99SM(

F2&#1"*%*(

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

" "

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

?+0O0*"/(.OO+0.$1(

B&(#1%*(*"$#%0&:(P"(P%44(O+0O0*"(0)+(.OO+0.$1(30+(/"#"$#%&'(.$$)+.$2(03(#1"()*"+,*( %&#"+"*#M(L1%*(.OO+0.$1(%*(-.*"/(0&(#1"(12O0#1"*%*(#1.#(.()*"+:(P10(#.'*(.(+"*0)+$"( P%#1(C"2P0+/*(+"34"$#%&'(%#*($0&#"&#:(%*(+".442(%&#"+"*#"/(P%#1(#1"(#1"6.#%$(03(#1%*( +"*0)+$"M( L1%*( 0-*"+5.#%0&( P%44( -"( "HO"+%6"&#"/( .&/( 5.4%/.#"/( 0&( #1"( !"4%$%0)*( *0$%.4(/.#.*"#M(

!"#$%&'(&)*+

B&( 0)+( .OO+0.$1:( P"( .&.428"( #1"( #.'*( .**%'&"/( #0( #1"( +"*0)+$"*( #0( /"#"$#( )*"+,*( %&#"+"*#M(L1"(+"*0)+$"*(.+"('"&"+.442(.(*"#(03(IJK*(/"*$+%-%&'(#1"6M(V"("H#+.$#(%&( #1"(3%+*#(*#"O(#1"(#.''%&'(-"1.5%0)+(+"4.#%0&*:($06O0*"/(-2(#1"(#.'*(.OO4%"/(#0(#1"( +"*0)+$"*(-2(".$1()*"+M(`"&"+.442(#1%*(.$#%5%#2(%*(+"O+"*"&#"/(%&(.(#+%O.+#%#"(60/"4( P1%$1(/"*$+%-"*(#1"()*"+*(Iab(01&&&(2c:(#1"(+"*0)+$"*(-"%&'(#.''"/(Jab#01&&&1#%c( .&/(#1"(#.'*(Lab.01&&&.-c(W( ( ( ( ( L.''%&'(+"4.#%0&(WdI:(L:(Je( ( ( ( R9S( P1"+"(2(#1"(&)6-"+(03()*"+*:(-(#1"(&)6-"+(03(#.'*(.&/(%(#1"(&)6-"+(03(+"*0)+$"*M+ B&(#1"(*"$0&/(*#"O:(P"("H#+.$#(#1"($0&#"&#(03(#1"*"(IJK*(.&/(%&/"H(#1"6(.*(*"6%Z( *#+)$#)+"/( Rf7KS( 3%4"*:( )*%&'( #1"( K)$"&"( %&/"H%&'( #004( =?B9_{M( V"( P%44( )*"( %#( %&(} 0+/"+(#0(3%')+"(0)#(#1"(60*#(.$$)+.#"(#.'*(P%#1(+"'.+/(#0(#1"($0&#"&#(03(#1"(#.''"/( +"*0)+$"*M(K)$"&"(+"4%"*(0&(.(3%"4/Z-.*"/(%&/"H.#%0&(#"$1&%Q)"M(L1%*($1.+.$#"+%*#%$( ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((

" "

"&.-4"*(%&/"H%&'(#1"(/0$)6"&#*(.$$0+/%&'(#0(0&"(0+(60+"(3%"4/*M(])+(%&/"H.#%0&( O+0$"**(%*(/0&"(.$$0+/%&'(#0(#1"(3%"4/*W(#%#4":($0&#"&#(.&/(IJKM(=3#"+(%&/"H%&'(#1"( $0&#"&#( 03( #1"( +"*0)+$"*:( P"( .**%'&( .( +.&C( #0( ".$1( +"*0)+$"( .$$0+/%&'( #0( #1"( .**%'&"/(#.'M(L1%*(+.&C(%*($06O)#"/(3+06(.(*%6%4.+%#2(-"#P""&(#1"(+"*0)+$"(R.*(.( f7K( 3%4"S( .&/( #1"( Q)"+2( R.*( .( #.'SM( 7.&2( *%6%4.+%#2( 3)&$#%0&*( "H%*#( %&( #1"( 4%#"+.#)+"(*)$1(.*(#1"(*%6%4.+%#2(3)&$#%0&(*)OO0+#"/(-2(K)$"&";_M(

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

E%')+"M(9M(L1"(%&#"+"*#(/"#"$#%0&(O+0$"**M(

./0&,/(&)*+

V"( 5.4%/.#"/( 0)+( .OO+0.$1( )O0&( #1"( !"4%$%0)*( /.#.-.*"( #1.#( $0&#.%&*( *0$%.4( &"#P0+C%&':(-00C6.+C%&':(.&/(#.''%&'(%&30+6.#%0&M(B#(O+05%/"*(%&30+6.#%0&(.-0)#( #1"()*"+,*(3+%"&/(+"4.#%0&*1%O*(.&/(#1"(#.''%&'(+"4.#%0&(%&30+6.#%0&(dI:(L:(JeM(L1"( )*"+*( I( .+"( /"*$+%-"/( #1+0)'1( #1"%+( B!M( L1"( +"*0)+$"*( J( .+"( /"*$+%-"/( #1+0)'1( #1"%+(B!:(IJK(.&/(#%#4"M(L1"(#.'*(L(.+"(/"*$+%-"/(#1+0)'1(#1"%+(B!(.&/(5.4)"M(V"( 1.5"(#"*#"/(0)+(.OO+0.$1(0&(.(*"#(03(9TT()*"+*M(L1"*"()*"+*(1.5"(/%33"+"&#(&)6-"+( 03(&"%'1-0)+*(R5.+2%&'(3+06(9(#0(;TSM(L1"(&)6-"+(03(#.'*:(/0$)6"&#*(.&/(#.''%&'( +"4.#%0&*(%*(/%33"+"&#(30+(".$1()*"+M(L1%*(&)6-"+(6.2(+0)'142(5.+2(3+06(9T(#0(hTT( 30+(#1"(#.'*:(3+06(9T(#0(hTT(30+(#1"(/0$)6"&#*:(.&/(3+06(;T(#0(iTT(30+(#1"(#.''%&'( +"4.#%0&*M( E0+( #1"( +"*)4#( 03( #1"( #0OZC( /0$)6"&#*( +"4"5.&#( #0( .( Q)"+2:( P"( 1.5"( $10*"&(Ca9TTTTM(L1"(5.4)"(03(C(%*($10*"&(.$$0+/%&'(#0(#1"(4.+'"*#(O0**%-4"(5.4)":( .*(P"(P.&#"/(#0(#"*#(R%&(#1%*(3%+*#(*#.'"S(P%#1(#1"(6.H%6)6(03( +"*)4#*(.$1%"5.-4"( R"5"&(#10*"(P%#1(40P"+(*$0+"*SM(=4*0:(#1"($10%$"(03(#1"(C(5.4)"(%*(O+0O0+#%0&.4(#0( #1"(&)6-"+(03(+"*0)+$"*(Ri\;;i(IJK*S(.&/(#.'*(Rh[[jj(#.'*S(%&(#1"(/.#.-.*"M( 1"(2#+ (/3"+ /#+ /*+ "4/5'0"+ (6"+ (/7+ 85/(68+ /##&7*",+ 9:+ /+ ;#"%+ ()+ ,&<<"%"*(+ %"#);%$"#-+=6&#+(/7+6/#+/+6&76"%+#$)%"+/$$)%,&*7+()+(6"+%"#);%$"2#+(&(0"+8>?1+@/(68A+ B6&$6+$)*(/&*#+5/(6+%"0/(",+(6"5/(&$A+(6"*+(6"+%"#);%$"+(&(0"+8C*0&*"+!&$"+D)00"%8A+ B6&$6+,)"#+ *)(+ $)*(/&*+/*:+ &*<)%5/(&)*+ %"0/(",+ ()+(6"+(6"5/(&$-+E)A+ /$$)%,&*7+()+ (6&#+ "4/5'0"A+ (6"+ (/7+ 85/(68+ &#+ %"0"F/*(+ ()+ (6"+ %"#);%$"+ 8>?1+ @/(68-+ G<("%+ ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((

" "

,"("$(&*7+ (6&#+ %"0"F/*(+ (/7A+ B"+ B&00+ F/0&,/("+ (6&#+ %"#;0(+ 9:+ ;#&*7+ (6"+ ;#"%2#+ *"&769);%#-+ =6"+ F/0&,/(&)*+)9H"$(&F"+ &#+()+ #6)B+&<+ (6&#+ %"0"F/*(+ (/7+&#+ /$$;%/("+ ()+ (6"+;#"%+)%+*)(-+ >*+(6&#+"4'"%&5"*(A+(KHQHLJKERXUVDUHWKHH[SOLFLWIULHQGVKLSUHODWLRQWKHXVHU¶V "7)$"*(%&$+*"(B)%3I-+=6"+5"(6),+)<+F/0&,/(&)*+;#"#+(6"+#)$&/0+"*F&%)*5"*(+)<+(6"+ ;#"%+J(6"+*"&769);%#I+()+,"("$(+&*("%"#(#-+>*+</$(+(6"+*"&769);%#+'%)F&,"+&*<)%5/(&)*+ (6/(+UHIOHFWWKHXVHU¶VLQWHUHVWV7FKXHQWH:HFDOFXODWHWKHSUHFLVLRQRIWKH GHWHFWHGLQWHUHVWVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHWDJVLQWKHQHLJKERXUV¶SURILOHV7KHSUHFLVLRQLV FDOFXODWHG DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH QXPEHU RI DFFXUDWH WDJV ZKLFK H[LVW LQ WKH XVHU¶V *"&769);%#+'%)<&0"I+/*,+(6"+()(/0+*;59"%+)<+(/7#+'%)F&,",+/#+/$$;%/("-++

7KLVSUHFLVLRQLVFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKVLQJOHXVHU¶VQHLJKERXU7KHRYHUDOOSUHFLVLRQ LV WKH DYHUDJH RI DOO WKH QHLJKERXUV¶ SUHFLVLRQ )&7;%"+ KA+ #6)B#+ (6"+ )F"%/00+ '%"$&#&)*A+<)%+(6&#+#"(+)<+;#"%#A+9"(B""*+(6"+$/0$;0/(",+%"0"F/*(+(/7#+/*,+(6"+;#"%2#+ (/7+J%"/0+(/77&*7+9"6/F&);%I-+

E%')+"M(;M(?+"$%*%0&(03(#1"(.$$)+.#"(%&#"+"*#*(/"#"$#"/(30+(.(*"#(03(9TT()*"+*M(

!&#$;##&)*+

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

G0#)A+ (6"+ /$$;%/("+ &*("%"#(#+ '%)F&,",+ 9:+ );%+ /''%)/$6+ /%"+ $)5'%"6"*#&90"+ 3":B)%,#+ B6&$6+ %"<0"$(+ %"/00:+ (6"+ %"#);%$"2#+ $)*("*(+ 0&3"+ ³("$6*)0)7:´A+ ³<);%#N;/UH´A+³6&#()%:´A+"($-+=6&#+&#+/*+/,F/*(/7"+#&*$"+(6"+(/7#+/%"+;#"%Q7"*"%/(",+ 3":B)%,#-+ C;%+ /''%)/$6+ 6/#+ <&0("%",+ (6"+ /59&7;);#+ (/7#+ J&-"M³7LV´+ (6/(+ /%"+ *)(+ $)5'%"6"*#&90"+ 9:+ )(6"%+ ;#"%#-+ =6"+ (/7#2+ /59&7;&(:+ 6/#+ ,"$%"/#",+ <%)5+ RKS+ ()+ KTS+/$$)%,&*7+()+P)%,U"(T_-(

@0&$4)*%0&(

>*+(6&#+'/'"%A+B"+6/F"+'%)')#",+/*+/''%)/$6+<)%+,"("$(&*7+/$$;%/("+;#"%2#+&*("%"#(#+ (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( [ (_{1##OWggP0+/&"#MO+%&$"#0&M"/)g(}

" "

9/#",+ )*+ (6"+ #)$&/0+ "*F&%)*5"*(-+ P"+ 6/F"+ "4'0)&(",+ (6"+ $)*("*(+ )<+ (6"+ (/77",+ %"#);%$"#+ &*+ )%,"%+ ()+ <&7;%"+ );(+ (6"+ (/7#+ %"<0"$(&*7+ %"/00:+ (6"+ (6"5/(&$+ )<+ (6"++ %"#);%$"#-+P"+6/F"+F/0&,/(",+);%+/''%)/$6+ (6%);76+(6"+(/77&*7+9"6/F&);%+)<+ (6"+ *"&769);%#+J6&#+"7)$"*(%&$+*"(B)%3I-++

>*+ <;(;%"+ B)%3#A+ B"+ B&00+ ("#(+ );%+ /''%)/$6+ )*+ /+ 0/%7"%+ ')';0/(&)*+ )<+ ;#"%#+ &*+ )%,"%+()+6/F"+5)%"+#$/0/90"+%"#;0(#-+G0#)A+B"+B&00+("#(+)(6"%+<)%5#+)<+*"&769);%#+ #;$6+ /#A+ ;#"%#+ (/77&*7+ (6"+ #/5"+ %"#);%$"#A+ )%+ "F"*+ ;#"%#+ 9"0)*7&*7+ ()+ (6"+ #/5"+ ³F)55;*&(:´-+>*+</$(A+/+;#"%+5/:+#6/%"+$)55)*+&*("%"#(#+B&(6+)(6"%+'")'0"+(6/*+ 6&#+ "4'0&$&(0:+ <%&"*,+ %"0/(&)*#6&'-+ C;%+ /''%)/$6+ $);0,+ 9"+ ;#",+ <)%+ /*+ /,/'(/(&)*+ ';%')#"+ J&-"-M+ "*%&$65"*(+ )<+ (6"+ ;#"%¶V+ '%)<&0"A+ %"$)55"*,/(&)*A+ "($-IA+ #&*$"+ &(+ '%)F&,"#+/+#)0;(&)*+<)%+,"("$(&*7+XVHU¶V&*("%"#(#-+

D"<"%"*$"#+

=*#+.%&:( kM( kM:( @0+/0-.:( =M:( l$1.+#":( EM( .&/( ^%44./.&'0*( kM( R;T9TSW( m=&( .4'0+%#16( 30+( #1"( %6O+05"6"&#( 03( #.'Z( -.*"/( *0$%.4( %&#"+"*#( /%*$05"+2mM( Fl7=?J]W( L1"( E0)+#1( B&#"+&.#%0&.4( @0&3"+"&$"(0&(=/5.&$"*(%&(F"6.&#%$(?+0$"**%&'M(;T9T:(OOM(n\ZhnM(

!"(7"0:(?M:(o).##+0&":(`M(.&/(I+*%&0(!M(R;T9TSWm=(Q)"+2("HO.&*%0&(.&/()*"+(O+03%4"("&+%$16"&#( .OO+0.$1( #0( %6O+05"( #1"( O"+30+6.&$"( 03( +"$066"&/"+( *2*#"6*( 0O"+.#%&'( 0&( .( 304C*0&062mM( I*"+(70/"4%&'(.&/(I*"+Z=/.O#"/(B&#"+.$#%0&M(;T9T:(;TR9S:(OOM(n9±jiM(

Y%6:(_MZpM:(=4C1.4/%:(=M:(F.//%C:(=M(lM(.&/(k0%(`MZFM(R;T99SW([email protected]+.#%5"()*"+(60/"4%&'((P%#1( )*"+Z( '"&"+.#"/( #.'*( 30+( *0$%.4( +"$066"&/"+( *2*#"6*mM( ( lHO"+#( F2*#"6*( P%#1( ( =OO4%$.#%0&*:( ;T99:(OOM(jnjj±jn\iM(

7.:( qM:( A"&':( qM:( J"&:( fM:( A10&':( pM( R;T99SW( mI*"+( B&#"+"*#*( 70/"4%&'( r.*"/( 0&( 7)4#%Z*0)+$"( ?"+Z*0&.4( B&30+6.#%0&( E)*%0&( .&/( F"6.&#%$( J".*0&%&'mM( =$#%5"( 7"/%.( L"$1&040'2( R=7LS( ;T99W(9\hZ;ThM(

7"8'1.&%:(7M:(=6"4A.2.&%:(@M(=M:(=60)*:(BM(.&/(`.+'0)+%:(EM(R;T9;SW(m=()*"+(O+03%4"((60/"44%&'( )*%&'(*0$%.4(.&&0#.#%0&*W(.(*)+5"2mMVVV(R@06O.&%0&(^04)6"S:(;T9;:(OOM(\i\Z\XiM(

7%4%$"5%$:( =M( YM:( p.&0O0)40*:( =M( .&/( B5.&05%$:( 7M( R;T9TSWmF0$%.4( #.''%&'( %&( +"$066"&/"+( *2*#"6*W(.(*)+5"2(03(#1"(*#.#"Z03Z#1"Z.+#(.&/(O0**%-4"("H#"&*%0&*mM(=+#%3M(B&#"44M(J"5M(^04M([[(&0M( [:(;T9T:(OOM(9jXZ;T\M(

J"-.%:( JMA:( A.2.&%:( @M( =M( .&/( =60)*:( BM( R;T9;SW( m=&( =/.O#%5"( p.5%'.#%0&( 7"#10/( 30+( F"6%Z *#+)$#)+"/(!.#.mM(=/5.&$"*(%&(!.#.-.*"*(.&/(B&30+6.#%0&(F2*#"6*(=!rBF(R;S:(;T9;:(OOM(;TXZ ;9hM(

F0&':( qM:( A1.&':( KM:( .&/( `%4"*:( @M( KM( R;T99SW( m=)#06.#%$( #.'( +"$066"&/.#%0&( .4'0+%#16*( 30+( *0$%.4(+"$066"&/"+(*2*#"6*mM(=@7(L+.&*M:(V"-M^04Mh:(&0M9:(=+#%$4"(n:(;T99:(OOM(9Z[9M( L$1)"&#":(!M:(R;T9[SW( m70/>4%*.#%0&("#(/>+%5.#%0&(/"(O+03%4*)#%4%*.#")+*s(O.+#%+(/"(+>*".)H*0$%.)H(

W.OO+0$1"(.(O.+#%+(/"($066)&.)#>*(/"(+>*".)H(CZ"'0$"&#+%Q)"*mM(!0$#0+.4(#1"*%*:(I&%5"+*%#2(03( L0)40)*":(;T9[M(

^.44"#:( !M:( @.&#./0+:( BM( .&/(k0*":( kM( R;T9TSW(m?"+*0&.4%8%&'( V"-( F".+$1( P%#1( E04C*0&062Zr.*"/( I*"+( .&/( !0$)6"&#( ?+03%4"*( =/5.&$"*( %&( B&30+6.#%0&( J"#+%"5.4mM( =/5.&$"*( %&( B&30+6.#%0&( J"#+%"5.4:(;T9T:(^04M(h\\[:(OOM(n;TZn[9M(

V1%#":(JM:(r.%4"2(?M(.&/(@1"&:(KM(R;TT\SW(m?+"/%$#%&'()*"+(%&#"+"*#*(3+06($0&#"H#).4(%&30+6.#%0&mM( B&#"+&.#%0&.4( @0&3"+"&$"( 0&( J"*".+$1( .&/( !"5"40O6"&#( %&( B&30+6.#%0&( J"#+%"5.4( RFB`BJS:( ;TT\:(=@7:(p"P(q0+C:(pq:(IF=:(OOM([i[±[XTM(

A.2.&%:(@M(=M:(?>&%&0):(=M:(7.+%"ZE+.&t0%*":(@M(.&/(F"/"*:(EM(R;TTXSW(mL0P.+/*(.&(=/.O#.#%0&(03( F"6%Z( *#+)$#)+"/( !0$)6"&#( o)"+2%&'mM( ?+0$""/%&'*( 03( #1"( @BJ,TX( V0+C*10O( ( 0&( @0&#"H#Z r.*"/(B&30+6.#%0&(J"#+%"5.4(@BJ(;TTX:(@lIJZVFM0+':(^04M([;iM(