HAL Id: jpa-00248114
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00248114
Submitted on 1 Jan 1994
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Pulsed field gradient spin-echo NMR experiments in micellar solutions of the water/cetyltrimethylammonium
bromide system
L. Coppola, R. Muzzalupo, G. Ranieri, M. Terenzi
To cite this version:
L. Coppola, R. Muzzalupo, G. Ranieri, M. Terenzi. Pulsed field gradient spin-echo NMR experiments
in micellar solutions of the water/cetyltrimethylammonium bromide system. Journal de Physique II,
EDP Sciences, 1994, 4 (12), pp.2127-2138. �10.1051/jp2:1994251�. �jpa-00248114�
Classification
Physics
Abstracts61.30 66.10
Pulsed field gradient spin-echo NMR experiments in micellar
solutions of the water/cetyltrimethylammonium bromide
system
L.
Coppola,
R.Muzzalupo,
G. A. Ranieri and M. TerenziChemistry Department, University
of Ca[abria, 87036 Arcavacata di Rende,Italy
(Received19 April 1994, revised13 September 1994, accepted 14 September 1994)
Abstract. Pulsed Field Gradient NMR experiments, in their original time domain, have been carried out to separate both water and surfactant self-diffusion coefficients in the micel[ar solution of the system
cety[trimethy[ammonium
bromide/water. These results have been supported by thoseobtained by NMR experiments
performed
with a Fourier Transform spectrometer. The water self- diffusion coefficients were used to calculate the obstruction effect of the micel[ar aggregates in accordance with a stoichiometric modelalready
used for[yotropic mesophases.
It was found that the mice[[ar aggregateschange shape
with the concentration and are characterizedby
an averagehydration
number ofapproximately
9 +/- 3.Introduction.
Water and surfactant self-diffusion studies in micellar surfactant solutions have
recently provided
useful information at the molecular level,regarding
motion, aggregateshape
andstructure. The water self-diffusion coefficients in surfactant systems at concentrations
higher
than the critical micellar concentration, are
generally
found to be smaller than in pure water, the reductionbeing mainly
related to thehydration
of surfactant molecules as well as toobstruction
effect, decreasing
the mean freepath
of water molecules. Such reduction can be accounted forby
ageometrical
parameter(obstruction factor, f) depending
on theparticular
structure and on excluded volume to molecular motion. In the
liquid crystal regions
theobstruction factor has been found for lamellar
~f
=
0.66
), capillary ~f
=
0.33 and
hexagonal
structure
~f
m 0.76ii.
The self-diffusion coefficient can be
experimentally
measuredby
thespin-echo
NMRexperiments
in the presence ofmagnetic pulsed
fieldgradients (PGSE) [2].
In theoriginal
form the PGSEexperiments
areperformed
in the time domainapplied
tomulti-component
systemsthey
cannotdistinguish
between individual contributions tomulti-exponential
echodecay
unless rather restrictive criteria are fulfilled with
regard
to relations between individual diffusion rates and transversespin
relaxation rates. In thisregard,
there is theimportant study
of Boss et al.[3]
who used the PGSE method for the determination of the diffusion coefficientof the benzene in the
benzene/polyisobutylen
system. Von Meerwall et al.[4]
have used@Les
Editions dePhysique
1994similar PGSE
experiments
to measure the self-diffusion coefficients of all three components of the solutioncontaining polystyrene,
hexafluorobenzene andtetrahydrofuran
as a solvent.Recently
the determination of self-diffusion coefficients has beenperformed
on avariety
of commercial spectrometersby
means of Fourier Transformexperiments (FT-PGSE).
In asingle frequency
resolvedspin-echo experiment,
oftenrequiring
less than 20 min measurement and evaluationtime,
one cansimultaneously
determine self-diffusion coefficients of severalconstituents in a solution. The
typical procedure
has been described in detail in a 1987 review[5].
FT-PGSEexperiments
are of difficultapplication
inorganized solutions, anisotropic
phases
and in viscous systems. With theexception
ofproblems
due to short relaxationtimes,
these systems are characterizedby
molecules or aggregates with low mobilities. Inpanicular
aqueous surfactant
solutions,
theviscosity
isstrongly dependent
on the surfactant amount.High
viscosities are observed in solution close to theliquid crystal
boundaries or inbiphasic region.
In consequence the molecularmobility
isstrongly
reduced and the self-diffusionexperiments by
PGSE sequences must beconveniently performed
in the time domainby using
stronggradients. Also,
stronggradients
can be used like a selectiveprocedure
to separate thecontributions to the echo
signal
due tospecies
withappropriate
different rates.Here we report studies
employing
the PGSE method for the determination of the self- diffusion coefficients of both components in the systemcetyltrimethylammonium
bromide(CTABr)/water.
We are interested inanalysing
the microstructure in the solution micellarphase
and thechange
of the aggregateshape
in solution mixtures close to thehexagonal liquid crystal phase,
present athigh
surfactant concentrations.The paper also focus on accuracy and
applicability
of time domain PGSEexperiments
tomonitor the molecular mobilities in surfactant aqueous
systems.
The aim is to demonstrate that thisprocedure
may be viewed as a useful tool for the measurement of the self-diffusion of onecomponent in the presence of a second.
Finally
the water self-diffusion coefficients have been used to calculate the obstruction factor of theCTABr/water
micellar solution and deduce some information about the aggregateshape
and size.Experimental
section.MATERtALS.
Cetyltrimethylammonium
bromide,Fluka,
waspurified by recrystallization
from etherlethanol
[6].
The critical micellar concentration at room temperature was foundby
conductimeter
analysis
to be about 0.02 §b CTABrweight
percent, in agreement withprevious findings.
Water wasbidistilled,
deionized anddegased
whenrequired
it waspanly replaced by D~O, Merck,
with a 99 §bisotopic
enrichment.The
samples
wereprepared by mixing
the components in a 5 mm NMR test tube. The tubewas sealed under
nitrogen
and the mixture washomogenized by
alternatecentrifuging
andheating
of thesamples.
METHODS. PGSE
experiments
wereperformed
on a home-made NMR spectrometerworking
at 16 MHz on'H [7] using
aspin-echo
sequence. Twomagnetic gradient pulses
ofmagnitude
g, duration andseparation
A wereapplied during
thedephasing
andrephasing period, respectively [2].
Apulsed
currentsupply, giving
a dc current up to 20A,
feeds the coils to obtain a fieldgradient
up to 170G/cm.
Thegradient strength
was calibrated to values of the self-diffusion coefficientDo
in pure water for different values of temperature andcurrent.
The temperature was measured with a calibrated copper-constantan
thermocouple,
whichwas
placed
near thesample.
The temperature was measuredimmediately
before and after thespin-echo experiments
; we have obtained an accuracy of about +/- 0.2 °C.The self-diffusion measurements
using
apulsed
fieldgradient experiment
in FourierTransform mode
(FT-PGSE)
wereperformed
on a Bruker WM 300 NMR spectrometer. Allmeasurements were made at room
temperature (about
25°C).
Theimplementation
of the FT-PGSE method, for
measuring
self-diffusioncoefficients,
was describedby
Stilbs[5].
In the presentstudy
the interval(A
between themagnetic
fieldgradient pulse
iskept
constant andequal
to interval(r
between the 90°-180° rfpulses.
The proton diffusion measurements weremonitored
by using
Aequal
to 400 ms while was varied in the range of 5 to 90 ms. Themagnetic
fieldgradient (about
1.5G/cm)
was calibrated to I §b accuracythrough parallel
measurements on trace amounts of protons in
D~O, using
established values from theliterature
[8].
Results and discussion.
The
isotropic
micellar solutions andliquid crystal phases
have been studiedby preparing
solutions in the range of concentration 5 -40 wt§b of surfactant
(CTABr).
In table I arereported
the mixtures
analyzed
in this work.Microscopy
and D-NMRexperiment
were used to define thephase equilibria
and thephase
transitions observedby varying
the temperature[9].
For unrestricted
isotropic
self-diffusion and forvanishing steady
fieldgradient,
the echoamplitude
due to self-diffusion can beexpressed
as follows[2]
A
(2
r,g)
=
A°(2
r) exp(- KD) (1)
where K=
(y&g)~(A-
~), A(2r, g)
andA°(2 r)
are the echoamplitude
at time3
2 r with and without
pulsed magnetic gradient, respectively,
and y is thegyromagnetic
ratio of the observed nuclei.Table I. Ll and E are the
isotropic
micellar solution andhexagonal liquid ct.j,stal phase, t.espectively.
Mixtures wtfl CTABR Phase at 50 °C
10~~ D~ (cm~/s)
a 4.75 Ll 3.55
b 10.07 Ll 3.40
c 15.03 Ll 3.16
d 19.92 Ll 3.10
e 25.07 E 2.43
f 29.05 E 2.07
g 40.05 E 1.90
In surfactant/water solutions above the CMC
concentration,
the measuredsignals
aremainly
due to protons in two different environments : the solvent and the surfactant in the aggregate
state. In this case, as for
general binary
solutions in which the two components diffuse atdifferent rates, the
expression
for the echoamplitude
becomesA
(2
r, g)
=
A°(2
r exp(- KD~)
+B°(2
r exp
(- KD~ (2)
where
D~
andD~
are the self-diffusion coefficients of two components,A°(2 r)
andB°(2
r)
are therespective
contributions to the total echosignal
in the absence ofmagnetic
fieldgradients, they
do not contain any effects of diffusion but include terms of relaxation andspin population.
JOURNAL DE PHYS'QUE i' T 4 N.12 DECEMBER 1994 XV
Liquid crystal mesophases
present differentanisotropic propenies
notdisplayed
insimple
solutions. When we measure the self-diffusion in
liquid crystalline mesophases (e,g.
hexagonal, lamellar, cubic, gel)
the protons of the surfactant molecule do not contribute to the echosignal,
because of the short transverse relaxation times.Consequently,
theanalysis
of the PGSEexperiments
issimplified
and can be carried outusing equation (I which,
ifapplied
in the condition KD wI, gives
theapparent
self-diffusion coefficients[10,
II].
In the CTABr/water system the micellar proton transverse relaxation times were studied
using
mixturesprepared
withheavy
water. For thesample
c, at 50°C,
we found a relaxation time for the surfactant micellar aggregates(T~ ~)
of about 120 ms. We alsomeasured,
for thesame
sample,
the micellar aggregates and water self-diffusion coefficientsusing
FT-PGSEexperiments. Figure
la, b shows the NMR spectra and the echo attenuation behavior at room temperature as a function of differentgradient
durations (&).
The micellar and water diffusioncoefficients were
D~
=
2.8 x
10~~
andD~
= 1.7 x10~~ cm~/s, respectively,
obtainedby fitting
the echoamplitude
in accordance withequation (1).
~
Ron
CTABr
a=s
a=9
d=11
6=14
fi~
6=25
~
6=So
o soo iooo isoo 2000
, ,
' ~~~~~
a)
Fig.
I. a) A proton FT-PGSEexperiment
in aCTABr/D~O
solutionperformed
at 300 MHzusing
A
= r = 400 ms, g = 1.41 G/cm b) the
logarithm
of the normalized echoamplitudes
vs. theexperimen-
tal parameter K in
sample
c at room temperature.W
~
~
S CTABr
E
< HOD
O
~ u Ld
o-i
K*10~ (sec/cm~)
b) Fig. I
(continued~.
Considering
thepreliminary
results we decided to carry out two different types of self- diffusionexperiments
in the time domain. A first set of PGSEexperiments
is carried out with fixed values of r, g and A(20
ms, 63.5 G/cm and 20 ms,respectively),
while is varied in the range 0.2-2 ms and therepetition
time of sequences is 7 s. In such asituation,
while the termKD~
is close to one, theexponential
factorexp(-KD~)
varies in the interval 1.05-0.99corresponding
to a variation of about I §b of the second term inequation (2),
less than theexperimental
accuracy.Neglecting
this smallvariation,
it ispossible
toanalyze
theseexperiments by
theexpression
A(2
r,g)
=
A°(2 r) exp(- KD~)
+ C(3)
where C is a constant term.
In a second set of PGSE
experiments,
monitored with other fixed values of r,g and A
(40
ms, 110.2 G/cm and 40 ms,respectively),
is varied in the range 0.75-4 ms, and therepetition
time of sequences is 2 s. Theexponential
termexp(- KD~
is very close to zero,while
KD~
isalways
close to one.Equation (2)
can then be reduced to :A
(2
r,g)
=
B°(2 r) exp(- KD~) (4)
with a trend very similar to
equation (I).
Using
the methods describedby equations (3)
and(4)
it ispossible
to obtainseparately
self- diffusion coefficients for surfactant and waterprotons.
Thisprocedure
can beapplied
to similarbinary
micellar solutions when therespective
diffusion coefficients differby
at least one order ofmagnitude.
WATER SELF-DtffusloN. In
figure
2a, b isreponed
the echoamplitude
of a PGSEexperiment
made with the first set of parameters for the mixture c at two differenttemperatures
the data are both fittedby equation (I)
andequation (3) using
non-linear least- square programs. In all mixtures thespin-echo
data are well fittedby equation (3), confirming
.o
W 0.8
7J
2
~-
E
o.6<
O
~ u Ld 0.4
0.2
o-o
i i i i
K*1 0~ (see /cm~)
a)
.o
© 0.8
j
~
E
0.6<
O
~ U Ld 0.4
0.2
o-o
i i
K*10~ (sec/cm~)
b)
Fig.
2. Theplots
show the normalized echoamplitudes
vs. theexperimental
parameter K ina PGSE
experiment
insample
c with g = 63.5 G/cm, A= r = 20 ms. The solid line indicates the best fits to
equation
(3). a) at 35 °C D~ = 2.69 x 10~~cm~/s.
b) at 55 °C D~ 3.23 x 10~~cm~/s.
that this numerical
procedure
can be utilized to obtainselectively
anddirectly
the water self- diffusion. Water self-diffusion trends, as an Arrheniusplot,
arereported
infigure 3a,
b for two different mixtures. The self-diffusion coefficients obtainedby equation (3)
arephysically
correct and with
slopes
similar to pure water, while the coefficients calculatedby equation (I
decrease
inexplicably
when the temperature increases. A similarimproper
behavior can be observed in thestudy
of Blinc et al.[12]
on the water self-diffusion for thewater/potassium palmitate
system when theliquid crystalline phase changes
in the micellar solution.The water self-diffusion in a surfactant solution system is influenced
by
micellehydration
and
by
obstruction effect due to the micelle. It has been demonstrated that the latter effect can bestructurally interpreted
and it is thenpossible
to deduce the structuralconfiguration
orstructural defectiveness. In accordance with the above considerations the measured water self- diffusion coefficient,
D~,
can beinterpreted using
thefollowing equation (13, 1)
D~
=/ (i
P~
D~
+ P~
D~ (5)
where
P~
is the fraction of bound water,D~
andDo
are the bounded and free water self-diffusion coefficients, respectively.
Physically
the obstruction factorf
accounts for the constraints to water self-diffusion due to micellaraggregates
and therefore its value ranges between zero(no diffusion)
and I(free
waterdiffusion). Singular
considerationssupported by experimental
results havepermitted
us toobtain the obstTuction factor for different
lyotropic mesophases.
As demonstrated inreference
[14],
the obstruction factor can be obtainedby applying equation (5)
to two mixtures andj
of the same solutionhaving
a differentcomposition,
with the same structure. Thefollowing
relation holdsD~
K,~D~
f
=
(6) (1 K,~) Do
where
K,~ is the ratio
P~,/P~
between the fraction of bound water in thesample
andj,
respectively.
Under reasonablehypotheses,
as in reference[14],
the term K,~ can be obtainedfrom the water
weight
fraction for the mixture andj
W~(100 W,)
~'J (7)
W,(100 Wj)
The
composition dependence
of the obstruction factors for the present system are shown infigure
4. Each value has been obtainedby combining
theexperimental
databy
two differentmixtures,
almost similar incomposition.
In a temperature range of 30-55°C,
we did notobserve any
particular
effect on thecomposition
behavior of the obstruction factor. This indication issupported by
the observation that the water self-diffusion as a function of the temperature shows an Arrheniusplot.
Within theexperimental
errors, the translational activation energy found is very close to the value of the pure water.Figure
4clearly
shows that the obstruction factor remains constant in mixtures with 5- 20 wt§b surfactant. This interval can be considered to be theregion
in which the micellarshape
is
approximately globular
with littledependence
on thecomposition.
A considerable decrease in obstruction factor can be observed at concentrationshigher
than 20 wt§b. Here the micellar aggregateprobably changes
fromglobular
to rod-likeshape.
In addition it can be observed thatnear the
liquid crystal
boundaries the micellar aggregatesprogressively
increase in size assupported by
the continuouschange
of the obstruction factor which in thehexagonal liquid
crystal phase
limit becomes close to 0.77(Fig. 4).
This value is the same as that found in the__-~
___w"
_,--""'
Q _---«'
©
~
____,--."'
$~ _,_,--"""'
E _,--""'"
U .-=""- .
~_ w
~/ w w
i
~'m, 'm
lo ~~
3.4 3.3 3.2 3.1 3.0 2.9
10~/T(K)
a)
5
4
_~__.
-
_--«"""~'
U 3 _,»"
g
~__~____;--""'~ ,,<'~'~~-
.- ~
u ~ _.--%" '
,
~-/ -.z' ,
' e
° ,
'm
',
m
lo ~~
3.4 3.3 3.2 3.1 3.0 2.9
0~/T(K)
b)
Fig.
3. Theplots
a) and b) show thelogarithm
of the water self-diffusion vs. the inverse absolute temperature for the sample c and d,respectively.
Thesymbols
(m) and (.) refer to self-diffusion coefficients obtained by the fits toequation
(I) andequation
(3)respectively.
The solid lines indicate the pure water self-diffusion trend.m
o.9s
0.
M>C£LLAR UQUID
f
SOLUT>ON CRYSTALREGION
0.
o. m
o.
i o
Wt% CTABr
Fig.
4. The obstruction factor f to water self-diffusion, as a function of the surfactant wt%, at 50 °C.hexagonal liquid crystal phase
of the systemwater/potassium palmitate by
means of water self- diffusion data[141.
The results
analyzed
above are insatisfactory
agreement with the studiesby
Ekwall et al.[15]
where theviscosity
measurements were used to calculate the activation energy for viscous flow. The increase inviscosity
and activation energy in CTABr solution above 15 wt§b were ascribed tohydration
of the micelles and toresulting
deformation to more or lessrod-shaped
micelles. Above this concentration an
exceptionally rapid
increase inviscosity
and activation energy for viscous flow was observedsuggesting
afairly rapid
increase in the size of rod-shaped
micelles.MICELLAR SELF-DiffusioN. In
figure
5 arereported
the echoamplitude
of PGSEexperiments using
the second set of parameters for the mixture c at two different temperatures.Both sets of data are
satisfactorily
fittedby equation (4),
whichgives
the micellar self-diffusion, D~.
Assuming
that the bound water molecules have the samemobility
as the surfactant(D~
=D~),
it ispossible
to obtainP~ by
means ofequation (5).
FromP~,
the averagehydration
number(n)
of bound water molecules per surfactant molecules caneasily
be calculatedby [1]
:n =
P~ ~~"~~
(8) Csuw
where C~~~~~ and
C~~~
are the water and surfactant molar concentration in the system,respectively.
The n-values found in different micellar mixtures wasequal
to 9+/-
3 and no clear trend was observed as a function ofcomposition
because of toolarge
anuncenainty.
.o
.4
' ,
© 0.8
~,
~ ~
'~~ 'i ~ '~
E
0.6~ ''
< , ,
. 'A
,
O , ,
~ , '
u . ,
,
~
~ °'~
' '
%~
' ,'m
, ' ~'0.2 ' ~m~ ~
' .,
(sec/cm~)
Fig.
experiment
in
equation (4j. symbols (A) and (m) refer to measurements obtained at
35°C
(D~ = 2.89 x10~?
m~/s) and 55 °C D~ 6.54 x 0~?0.
§~
q~
m 0.
E
~
CELLAR
0.
i
ti
Fig.
6. Variation of thelongitudinal
relaxation timeT,~
with the surfactant concentration. The frequency is 16 MHz and the temperature 50 °C.Equations (3), (4)
allowed theseparation
of water and surfactant self-diffusion contributions in thesolution,
under the condition that these differby
at least one order ofmagnitude.
Themethod used here is very close to a
biexponential analysis
that isapplied
to a set of echoamplitudes
collected in a wide range of theexperimental
parameter K. Both mathematical treatments present similarapplicability
limits[16],
but theproposed methodology
is more efficient because each measurement set is aimed at asingle
self-diffusion coefficient.Transverse and
longitudinal
relaxation micellar times have been carried outusing
equation (9) varying
the rfpulses
distances and the sequencerepetition time, respectively.
Water self-diffusion measurements have been used to calculate the obstruction factor as a
function of the surfactant
composition.
The calculation ofhydration
number has beenperformed
in different mixturesby
the surfactant self-diffusion. The obstruction factor and thelongitudinal
relaxation timeprovided
evidence of thechange
of the micellarshape,
in agreement with theviscosity
results obtainedby
Ekwall et al.[15].
Acknowledgments.
Acknowledgments
for financial support go to MURST(Italian Ministry
forUniversity, Technological
and ScientificResearch)
and CNR(National
Council forResearch).
References
[1] Holmes M. C., Sotta P., Hendrikx Y., Deloche D., J. Phys. II Franc-e 3 (1993) 1735 and references therein.
[2] Stejskal
E. O., Tanner J. E., J. Chem.Phys.
42 (1965) 288.[3] Boss B. D., Stejska[ E. O., Ferry J. D.. J. Phys. Chem. 71(1967) 1501.
[41 Von Meerwall E. D., Amis E. J., Ferry J. D., Macromolecules 18 (1985) 260.
[5] Stilbs P.,
Progress
in NMRSpectroscopy
19 (1987) 1.j6] Hertel G., Hoffmann H.,
Progr.
Colloid Polym. Sci. 76 (1988) 123.[7] La Mesa C.,
Coppola
L., Ranieri G. A., Terenzi M., Chidichimo G.,Langmuir
8 (1992) 2616.[8] Mills R., J. Phys. Chem. 77 (1973) 685.
[9] a) Wamheim T., Jonsson A., J. Colloid
Interface
Sci. 125 (1988) 627 b) Wolff T., Bunau G. V., Ber. Bunsenges.Phys.
Chem. 88 (1984) 1098.[10] Tanner J. E., J. Chem. Phys. 65 (1978) 1748.
Ill
Coppola
L., La Mesa C., Ranieri G. A., Terenzi M., J. Chem. Phys. 98 (1993) 5087.[12] Blinc K., Dimic V., Pirs J., Vilfan M.,
Zupancic
I., Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. 14 (1970) 97.[13] Nilsson P. G., Lindman B., J. Phys. Chem. 87 (1983) 4756.
[14] Chidichimo G., De Fazio D., Ranieri G. A., Terenzi M., Mol.
Cryst. Liq. Cryst.
135 (1986) 223.[15] Ekwall P., Mandell L., Solyom P., J. Colloid Interface Sci. 35 (1971) 519.
[16] Hamilton W. C., Statistic in