New Insights from a Fixed Point Analysis of Single Cell IEEE 802.11 WLANs
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. New Insights from a Fixed Point Analysis of Single Cell IEEE 802.11 WLANs Anurag Kumar — Eitan Altman — Daniele Miorandi — and Munish Goyal. N° 5218 June 2004. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5218--FR+ENG. Thème COM. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) "!# %$&')(+*, -. / 0'
(6) ( 2134(0(57686#6 9.:);=<0>.>@? AB$C D EGFIHKJML7NPOQHKRSL7JMT UWVYX[ZL7F#EG\[Z]RSL7FK^ U`_aL7FXcbd\cbfegXihJ]L7FjKXlkU`L7FKjgegHKFXcm0npoQhrqL7\cs tvurw0xzy){ |~}&Wy 4}w0xzy0yM dxzx)rr d 4d4 yYy0ury0uyp7K r¡0¢5£rry. ¤d¤¥§¦¢z¨y0 ·[© ª x=«0¬ y0 »½y®rd¯¬¾°Cź¨durr± y4º³y²³r ´ yMd=² =µdx=²º¶r³r½¹º´ º³y0=0¹µ 7µµµ5¶¸·[Q=x,¨d7y y ¹µrµ·[y0x=º¹ºd)µ·yÆaxzury¼yM·W»½y0rur¹ºyz¹y0¾¶Wy0» ¹º r=¹ºµ0µrÁ4¨~ÃŵQ·[ durxÇWµ¼º·Àx=¿y¼y.¨uy0cr Á y µ± y0Ày ¹Á ÈÆx,rÂÉd¹µ¹º yMy y0r¼ÀyMÁKÃl~ ·½4x=urµuy=»º³rd'´ y05uydvdÁ.º¶utv.y~uryzYury0¨r¨d¨dÊry0ur¨d¹µrµ ur4y~y0I·urÁ, ¶ºx=¨Ìrur¹µry'»#r²» ²Ëµ¹º¹ÀʨdÊ7dy yYrry0Ê7 yMr¹ ËrurÊy0aGrÊu¨dy)urruy0 y²Yºrd·[dr yYx) » r¹Íº¹µduG~·½ururyyy u·xzrdy0r0,Åyx=´ ry0¹µSº4·4·[urxyr¹·[dx= uyµÎd¹º¹µµµyM aÁfrÃÄSÊSÊrº¹µºxzÅ ruryµ'¨d¨y0y ¨¨¶µx=y~y'» ºy0uSxzËrƹµ¨dyy.rGxÊ7ury y µ¨x¨dry0¹¨dºdyY uÅrdra¨ur¹ =.» ºyzuQaÂy ´ dy0+ÀÆÁ=}Qtvury,¾dÂ,y0xzr¹º ¼y0·[¹Idx@·uuryYy,ʾ¶Òl¹º Óµ~r y,y0d0ÁxzÃl¼µ y0ur» » ºauurÏл Ñ 0ury y00Á ryMfry»¾f¹µ .0ÎÊ7y'y0BÊrµStÆ{Ô·[y .urr¨durr .µSdx=y Õ»QÖ¶×¾ Ø ÙÅ{vÚ rÛ}«ß²° à{ÃßÜ`ÅrÜ`7Ü`y ¢d¤d·[ Áµx=¡¡dŽy²y ·[·W}Qx,߯{8 y'ry0Â] ¹ºd¹µ µÍŽÝÞ´ yMS7µ¶=yMɶºdIŸ» µy0¹ºyMzry Ò ì]õ]ñ]áðéÍâIúécã]ðäæåíå ðçë éiè+ðùlécî]ãYê²ëùéiçÀè+ïcýõ ëåKïcðécõ åíëì]ïùïîMôöî õ]è+ñ]è é[äïc ëð
(7) õ²ñ
(8)
(9) ôöòõ] ó²÷öåcôöïcïcâä ã]ïíì0ðïíôöð`õ]èñMûè÷ö0øùécäæððõ]õ]ùùíð
(10) ã,úÀðëõ õ ïcécëð¸æè+ûµè+écð
(11) éüôéiè+ ý ôöèþ ïíäæè+õ.èûþIñMÿ+ëõ]ùðñÍðåíðëéiùlãµôöørúÀüþ ô Iôöþ 0è+îMã]ä ë÷öþõïcäæî
(12) è æä å ]ø IþKú ! ô Iôöþ 0è+îMã]ä ë÷öþõïcäæî
(13) è æä å ]ø IþKú "# ú ðî]ëéiïcý ðõ ïôöõ]ñ]ä ëõ²ôöõ]åcïcä ïíì0ïíð`èû0ùäæðõ]ùð
(14) Àëõ ëæè+écð
(15) ô ôöþ. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(16) .4( ( 5 ˸ . %
(17) )'(*,Í Ë 0'
(18) Í G( ½4(0( G( G ? AB$ 68686 9:);=< >> ° ºdvrry~·[dx)r¹µG radº¶ ³r´ yY y~¹ ¹µy~¶y~ry.¿½urcÁ « rd¶d=rryµxz¹ºº³ µ8 µ Êr¹µyay¨!0 ¹µdz¹ ¹º yÁ " µ 77y µ¶·[~~x,³ry,´ 0y&Á y0%ÆYy)yMɶ²r¹º·[½~y x ¨# r$ ¹µy0M0~¹cºÅÀx=¹ºy0¹drGM¹µy0Á d~¹º y ~ºd#¨ )5 $ 0 Bx=¹ºryM¶~ Êdf¹ºw0xz~ y=¹ Êr r ºry=7dº
(19) ¶Gµ²d ~dy,Ê ³r´ ¹y0y,¶dy0µ¹º0rÁ Wµ ÉdÎyz ²Î¹µy0x=~rx=¶yMÊr¹µrw x=²y0y~ɶr yyy ¹µy)¨¨d
(20) 0Êr!¨ ºÆ~yM' rÊ7Ì ´Ë~ɶry ¹*¹ dºÂɶy0ry.y~yM ²yYʹµzdx= )y0r²r¹µy²y.u x=´ ry.ɶryY y0xz µ´GQ ¹µy~yr¹µ²x=7yµº0ºÁ)d(I yz+Á $%² ÊÞ ¹µy y4´ r, ¹º¨dººx=yMy4²drx=~ ¹µGrÉdÊy4 Êrµ¹ºº
(21) z¨ y,)r¹µ¹µdµxºdÊrIÅÀy4¹µy yÆ. -Y´5r¨ ¨d/ixzy0¨!d.Êrµ ¹ºyMyz, 0Ådy0¶rd`ºÂddy0Ê ~y0 ryz` y0x=`·[ºxdr¹µyy0 ¹*r aY r ¹ºr Êry,ºÆyz r¨dBr¨, , 0!¨ udy0yzÁ 5(Íx,y0v,¾d0
(22) ¶zrµ¹Þy y0r y>ry =yY´ d¹ y=+ y=rº¹º¹µ f:,y²7 ¶ryM4~·[ddx=~r r2yº,Y1,03!¹µvy,4658$r7: 9<´ Ê; ÞÁµx y,¹µ ~µrx=rdy ´ dºdd Y~tÆ ){dy gxzÆx=y0d y ºv00Á ?3Ú ¬M« Ø !¯ @ «5° ÃÜ`Ü`ܸ¢¤d rÁº¡d¡Å AW¹µµB y)7y ·[x, y00Å A`ɶºdË7µd~³r´ ydÅ {vr}Qß²àd{ß.Å 0y0r´'³¹.
(23) öÏ Ï ]Ð Ð Ñ ¦ > , ¸ ) ±y,rdxzr, µy0fY» ºfy ¹µx=y0x=yQy0² r¹ºµ ¹r x r¹`ryM0Py0y0'y´~ryy0d»dµd¾ ,¹Æ0Ág/c}QuÃÄ߯ .{0&yz/cy0µu y ryz¹ ¢"Ãܸ!`MŽÜ`·[»Üp.yQ¢¤¶ yÁµ¡ ¡)dµy,y0 y0rryMPrµ ¼ºPµ·[dfYuµr'u·ur7yM y y ¹ »'º ufµury=y)ry·`»yM¾uQurury ºÆy0ur¼y0d~r ¹ºay0rdr+yYyMfºÎÝx=º¨drºdy Q¡d Á=tvËuÊy yzy=y,ºy y0Âdy ¼¹r a y0~d» º¶º²urµ·Kεx=yu Á ±/cur߯yy¼ 0¼¶7¹ºur¹`y0vurryMur¨dyau5» Ð#»öÏurµ$%&uB7:ur4y²'¹µ¹K³v¨rr y .y»½Å¶zdíÁxyd¾ ÁºÅ&3/iY)y (y9Ý4Y µÅÍ*Ϩr'/
(24) ,+ yaö9 0Ï ¡-0+5M-
(25) Áaм3#Ð |¼µ
(26) 1'-#r2.» .43ur
(27) 1 24-5u= 6Ï ur3y
(28) 1µ+y²Î9"µ- ½50Ð,rÂd=µy 5Æy » ¶ruy µ»½uB¹7dd ¾ B~yM߯½Ô·7Ê7µdu drvµ7)y º .Ê dr yMQÞ Ê7y¹µ» µy ~y µ Yºd¹µuµ xzy²·[º»yMµB+y ¹µºy0da ½ur/ %Yy'y{»Þ+Ý 04¾=» ºÞdÎurGºrBÆ» » µuuryM)y )u9¼7¶µ ¹µ·[¹`ydr´ y yM.+ºdy= ydÁ /c8'uÃÄy'aµKt4rÃÜ`rÞàܸ{ºÜ8dt4I¢fÅ ¤¶º ÊÁµd¡¡ uyM8y µ 0 /iÊr Æy y/ : !I·[d r y ´¶y µ·uyY»½d¾,µGuryYry0y ¶ y0 0Á tvury0y,y=y0Ây0¹Ï 90+Ð+Å y0uf·» uru5x,]u]Âdyzy Âdy ¹Kru ¹ 4,9Ï*Ï ,43
(29) , 9ÏrÐ 9 - 3ÐÐ 9 7 43 3
(30) , 9ÏÐ.» ÞuËy Ây0¹uy 4r yM Á4|¼Qy0duGu rryM+ºd uryµÊr¹º y (]#Ð 4 3 KÒ x=rr7µxy)¹Þx,ºr]¹µyaÊy= ºxzÓ7y0y0¶µ0PÁtvuryzyM rÅ u P ¹ ury˹]y0¼ ry ³rPºµµ¹µ²µ yM,urx=y=y0ÃÜ`uÜ`rÜ µ¢x,¤d= rÁº¡du¡ 7y rx=Þ µr²y0½·½=r ¨dyM¼y0y4ury0Gy,.y ;x=9"+KÐzµ» udyy4urudr ¨uy0r ·[dYx,y0½·[»½dy0¹ºx,¹Ê7y»y)y »½y0y,uy=y xaÁ`¿yy »ryMy y » y0ºduIu'ÁzÃlYµu ídÁ yÁµrÅ ÃÄËx=ury0y0yYuudy~r¨¹µy0ur»d] µurÅrd»Wy)¾y½yYy0K=µ¶uy ¸y0x=¹µyM¹aºÌvºË» »4uWy Ê Qy½zµµr rº³ ¨' ÞyYɶy ¨¹µy ¶Ê dº=¾duÒlµ¹µÂy~¨¨d·[y²dy0.x),rK ¹µ,durÆy0ºWÁQɶxz¹µÞºy ºÂd3 y < µº¨du¶Â udµ¹µ ,·²uryË»v] u ury5ÃÜ`Ü`Ü ¢¤d rÁº¡d¡Ë{vr}Qß²àd{ß@r ¹ 9
(31) 3 3 9 . C2. Cu1 AP. C1 Cj. Cn. Cd 1 Cd 2 Cd 3 Cu 2. Cu 3. »Ýurµµ¨yzy0rfry,ryz¡%y=vQ»µrur¾¨y=¹µÁ,y.Ãĵ¨By0u¶¹º²¹ urõy'Ü`²Ü`¹ºµy Ü8·ö¢du¤dyz µÁµ y ¡·[¹?¡²>Ary @4»½d+y=r¾ ur0y< yx=ury ur µyy rÂÅÀyY» Êrdº¹ºay,uËuru¶ury. y=¹µyµßÆ·ö0¼ ¹KµÆy0ºaµurrx=y¨ dG4µurfur y,Yx=0y0 .y0 yd fÅGury >GD yMy7·[y04 ) º7¨ »dr rÒl¹ºy0µr¾ µ8Y0ÁKÃÄx=urµy~µµQ¨u¶vy00rÁÆy0B¹ÃÄË>?CEurD½yzy ÷[Ü`y ½Ü`ÜgF ¢7r¤d r ÒlÁº¡d¹ºµ¡.r¾ 84x=µºy0d y µÂy ¼yM Å xzºy 4¨y y²az x=x=Gru ¹x=µµ ydÁ Cõ HJI
(32) LKM.
(33) ¥. Ï. Ï Ï. 2&3"-
(34) &3 )
(35) 9"-
(36) 3 * 3 6
(37) 9"!3 . d¾Ê7¹ºy y=¹µf y ´ 7ry0ry0¼+]y0´ ur˺yx,»Qµµuy0B¹ºyMx,d²+x= y0y0y ʵyYrBx ur¿y,µadury0ury, r¦ µ r!lÁ ¨'y=tv7urµ¶.¹µ~y0x=º·¸Yy0u5y=0Á a |¼³rr´ y .y0xaBÁ=r7rtvµurd¶µ)²y0³u5ɶ´µyM²ËQµ7IʵŶy0¨Y» µBy0urɶ»u Þ uBºd 7 µ¶rz yMɶdº¶ ºdI·Á ± y y urry0SyÁ yM± Êry5¹µµµuSxzf¹ºº·[µ8x=r¹µyŸ¨dy rÎy0r¹ºyQ ur¹µyf¹µBr7¹º y0µ¹µµr¹º¨yMÅ` µr¨ º µur·[yz³r´ yMur y ¹µy0rdµÎɶry0Ëry0ur)dr·4¨uurry' z³´·[yM x7r¹µ¶z·[µ zuruµyGzx=Âdy y'¹µ¹¸¨dy rry y0»½d¹`¾Î·[x=Îy »·[d)¾Áfuryadºx= yGºÂº x=r¹µ¹½yGÌÊ»4 y ÁÂtvurµyMy ·[rdx=x)ºr¹4yMv¹º¹µu»#yYur4¨ury0r rÂÆy0vy0ur·[dy.»x,y ¹µ¹Í¾ydrÁ ±» aydʹy0µ¹º Gy~uuryY4³u´yyMa¹µ»dºy0¶Æ µauy)x=µµx=a y urury ¨dy'yQºx=Êudy=r¾d·4rÒly0aÓ ¹¸¹x)0r¨y0¹Þy=º~r¹ºµxy MyÊ7Žy » ufd· ryGu y y ry0·iyr»¹º5¾Q³¹µrurByQdy µrS´ ¨ru¹ºurryQº .0ÃÁa·[Ü`dÜ`ß-x)Ü-¾dry ¢d¹µdˤd² Áµ·[¡¡aY}Qx=uryy'߯{%y Y¹µµ¹ºBµurrByrSµÊ Êr µ<d¹ºº¹W»½µy Å rx=± y0y ¹º¹µÂ y Ïr Ð+Ñur»8µxur¹µyYʵ¾¶Òly0ÓQrx¹º¹Þ·[ºr.¹µµy urÆyaÓ7yM¹µ+¹µµºdÎury~ruÊdrÊr¨º¹µurºµ y00Á Burdr¨ur z ·[» ºx=x uGurQdy~y y²´rur·[y0+dYy.x-}Q» ºuruy~¾³Â y0´yMrGu¹º4µQddºÊ ¶x=4ºry y0¹ G¹º·[ ·[4µ0xÁ uryurÊy.³¾¶´ÒíyMaÓËrd º¶~y0ƹº Qµ0¹Á '± ydxz¹µ,ry~urÂyMµ y)yyMyMrr¹º¹º ³7 ¾ß¼ºy d,Q¸Ê¹µyMG¾ ¹µf4¨¨ddy0yzº·[¶r¹ y0'º ay Ây0 urMyYzÅW·[durd¹º¹µryQr» y0ºÊ¨zµÂdy'»vI]Á` y0 Á½ÃÄu'µÊ,yM dÐ x=3 x=
(38) ,y.24 -
(39) 3"ºy
(40) 1¹µ9ºÏ ¨fµ3dÐÐ42rÞÆx= uy0
(41) ,9 ÏaÊ7uy ½y0=a)ur·[dy0xzx=yax=¹ºd¹µ''y µ¹ºx=»vÂdr]y0 ¹µÞ Ò /cury0yÊr޵r¹ºº¨d·[urS,r y ´ ·¼ x=ururyy ra¹ºÉ¶ydrÅ ury yr !yMɶ0)3 r<Æy ucÁ y0y,4ÁµÅv»Þu·.µy¹µ¹Iu]yMÂry.u=ºÉ¶dr dy ry0uya0Ådurrdy˨º¶ur¼ ºÂr¹µÂ¶ yQ yMµz µB¹ºyM4=µÊr. uµµy P¶Í'Á½urÃÄyad urºµ4rµ7º·[dy ³»¹ºy~y²}a¹ z y0·[¹ºry0µrrv¨Î¹µ,ururyYr¨durrr ¹µ vººQd, ·¼y ur» µµy0G¹º¨yM¹ºur rz rrv¹Iy »½y0d)¹µ ¾ r)y`µ»==y ´r¾y Âx=y y y¼¹µÎº¶ º x=Á7¹µ d`·[dd Å`tƵ{ r ¶ºµ ¹µ¹ºyM y0Âd¹ºÂ µrº¨'¨'r7y ·[x=¹~fyzy0r¹Þr ÅÍrÞY0Ázury0tv¹ºur²y=a¹µry) ·y0ufxzQ ur yy0¹ºµr¨ay0rµ5¨µu¶~y r5y¹µººx=r¨aºy ´º7dy ~µxzy0·½¶ury ¹ x=y0 r ¹ºy0¹r~·[½ËÃÜ`µÜ`fÜ u¢y0¤d r¾Áºº¡d¡v¨ ryºx)»r¹µ¾ µÅ5= r y Yu0½rud`~¹µÊy0zy,.Âdy x,Òíy0xzzurr¹µµµ0y0IÁ~ºdtv¸uyzx==¶y´Yy07rºrd¹ Å uruyur.Êyud]¾¶ÂrÒíy=yÓËy0y 7dy0yMxzBay ºG y00u ¦ Å!ldÁÆurd߯¨4rurÊ7y y0ur y 7~y0rdx,¹º y0¹ºaµ08)Årµ µÎu "¥ ò!lÜ`ÁÆÜ`tv¹Ü ury¢dµ¤dy0 r Áºy ¡d¶¡)Ædry »½y0y0d ¾ uræE 0y<Í!K·[íµy0ÆÁ ydÁºÅrrºy)·y.ur·K·¸y,durry)y x, »½dº¾¨ uuKGtv¹µur» »SyËu74y 7µyMvy =,dÊ ,rºry0yM¨dGµrʶ0yMÅ ury ÂdyYdy z¹µ)·[»gur¹µ¹ºy »4ury0µ0y0¨Á8Gu=ÃÄd8ry0ry0y0y0zµµ#r0y0Á 5»µyQKry ´Â7y yGµy ur yËy½¾ury Sr¨dÊurry ÂWr~µÊ7yy µµ55rryM]·i+´ µººx,d¹µ5a¨ ºy0Á¼dr'ÃÄy 5d ¹Ky0» y urµºuGr¨ÁYury.tvuryuryur³¹µ ´yMv¨ÒlurvrdÊrº¶Æ~·[y0y0ÀɶÁWxÃŵºddÆyM+¼ºy.dar¦z»µ ry.y0y0aÀÁƵftv¹º uyMy)yÆ+ºurdy.Ëx=Ê¥ad ¾¶Òí.Óa ¹µ ¹º yMyMµ y0Ây ¹µ7y0 µQ y0+ºd ÁWtvuryY¹µr¨dy vr¶·i y¼µGury.߯r7y º´ÀÁ ôIôöþ.
(42) öÏ Ï ]Ð Ð. Ñ. . 9
(43) 3 3 9 node 1. 2. 3. 4. !" !" !" " ! " ! " ! "!"! . 6565 6565 %%%%% 33 #$ #$ $# # $ # $ # $#$# &%&&%&&%&&%& &%& 2121 2121 2121 2121 434434 $
(44)
(45)
(46)
(47)
(48)
(49)
(50)
(51)
(52)
(53) ''('(' ('(' ('(' ('(' ('(' ('(' ('(' ('(' 8787 8787 :9:9 :9:9 :9 :9 +++++ )* )* )* )* * ) * ) * ) * ) *)*) ,+,.-.- ,+,.-.- ,+,.-.- ,+,.-.- ,+,.-..- .- .- /.- /0 .- /0 //0 /0 successive backoffs. successful transmission collision. Ýy µy0¨Qry u 4~= tvÊuy½¾¶y0ÒlÂÓÀ¹µÆ ºdyµ¶·y0uryvrÊ dy0¾¶ÒíÊÓ=Q7uy µrry ¹KzµÂuÞdrÅ7íy Á y¹ ÁµÅÀµÂ¶º¾dyYÆ·[d ·[drxzKr µ y00¼ÁÃlW50Kzt4Ê y ¹µ¹ººd Á ; $ ;v= * <?>GÍ ¼Y "' "$ ' ~ ) @BADC EBFBG?HJILKNMPOQOSRUTVMXWZY\[X]^K_OS`aKcbdWeHgfPhjilknmpoqRBHrKN]s]. ±» µyƹµ¹Ê7y ¹µ¹º¨dº»P,Ê=Ky.´ y dÂd+y ¹µµrz¨~·[uy4x ¹º yMµ 0Á µ ݵº¨dr,yÆ· ~uruy²»4 y0urxÇy4y0Âurdy4¹º ¾dy ºzd)xz · y0ur¹ºµy4r¨z Êy x ·[d`µ¥YrK uyM3 < ÊÃܸurÜ`»¾¶Ü8ÒíG¢Ó'¤¶ y4rÁµ¡u¡0Êy²º0+dÊÁyxÆW¾¶Òí»½yvy0Óº0,y0Åd0x)Å urry²ur¹Þƺ ¹ºyMWx= ·Iy ~yYºdryY µ·Ky0¹µ¹µ)urµy.ºdºÊx=d0y Á¾dµÃÄdÒl ÓÀy uÂy¼ ¹Ãy00Ü`4ܸ¹µr¹ºÜ yMz¼¢z¤d rÓ7#Ð ÁºyM¡d9"+¡Æ
(54) 4/[yurÁ ¨yYÁµrÅ^·[dtj¹ºuw¹µÀvI» ŶWºurµ¨y ºur¨dÊry0d4x=ry ¾¶ ¶Òí 0ÓzÁy.± µ )urx=Ýy0µrG¨¹µry)yvyMr4 # 0+ºÅy~ º`Êy0x=y ¾¶r¾ Òí¹µ yÓ˼y0Ê7y0yº·[y vÂ]ÊyYdurµyM¾dYÒlºÓ r·r¨z/ö·[urdy urvµy4u´rrx=rry0¹µ¹dx=yÊŵ.r ºy d 'yz ¡¼µrur¨~y ½azurury²y³t4K.t4½Gzy¾dÓ yy0Mx=ÁÍrµÃl·¹µyy r¹µy urury0yyGy KÂyMt4yM½y0ÅÍÂuryº5duÎurry0ry05y0µ¹À ·[urSy 4yzurη[yY¹µ³¹ºur»4y ÆYrG r y'yddÁu¾tvy ²zury0y~·[dxz¹ºx=¹µÞ»44µyMÎ'f{ut4yGB'Q·[}Q¾x y ߯z{ ury.¹ºx=y0µÂ¶ry ¹µ¹`y0y0z߯ {{ y0az=ry0ÁI»y0tv ºuʵdºYy0dy0¾d4ÒlrÓ · µ3"¶ y0
(55) 1(ÂF¹í
(56) 1Á -
(57) 3 ÏrÐ )y²Ðu#Ð 94}Ï »½|3yY2J'd2JrÐ x=3 y²-.urÐ 3
(58) ,24r-
(59) ¨d3 ur
(60) rÁ ½u4r yM ¹µ»] ½u]Ây²d¾y½=x=º0 < íÁ ydÁºÅ yMµ=Ý u)Ãlµ·`¨r ur y=y4yv ¼»t4r ËÞ y0d·[½¹º ¼¹µ`µr¼y04zµx=» ¦²yº µu˶¹µ¹ºy0u y²¹ ·ö%¼·¸y ÃKÝWr)uryvÊur³y y0·[¼Ky»ryy~Å7rurry0y º5x=¨Æ ·ö¼ y ¼/[urÊ·[y.rʹµr¹ºdG ¾dyMÒlvÓ¡vx=º=y¦rºÁKrŨ Ýry0dKu7yy y0´rµ+²ºx=KÂdt4y r¹µ¹µ y0 Å dyYº¹ ur yy0y0·[¹cÁv·Wtvurury.y=Kurt4y0a4r y00x=źÆdµ0ÂŹµÂyMa'urµay05uy¹µ'd¹º¹µµµÆIÅrur¹µy µ) y %ÆaÃÝW=aurºyx=y0u0rÁ²rtvy0¹Íu²µÂ¶·öºy Cõ HJI
(61) LKM.
(62) Ï. Ï Ï. 2&3"-
(63) &3 )
(64) 9"-
(65) 3 * 3 6
(66) 9"!3 . node 1. 2. 3. 4. . aggregate attempt process. .
(67)
(68)
(69)
(70)
(71)
(72)
(73)
(74) . ! "! "! ! "! "! ## $#$# $#$# # $# $# % &% &% % %& %& '' ('(' ('(' ' (' (' collision. x. x. x. x. successes. Ýtvµu¨y0ry=yQr¦ y=fy0ßx=·öµy0ry=y ux=yºurryM¨f rur¹µºy˨Gu·vrruy ¹¼rr+y0¹`ºÂº0Îy0·[0Áx ßYݵur¨ry,Ê7yË fx ¹ºSµurury»Ê5¾¶uÒíyÓ=¨¨dy x,y0¨dºIy Á y x= 4r y0Guy.ury ¹íÅ » Þu ury yY yMy0vGryYd¹º¹µµIÁ SÃl·À¹µ¹µxzµºdy 8µx=' ¹µ¹Æµxzr~ yY yMy0·K'Gy0urKryvx=t4 yQdr¾ur¹µyy W µ "KÊ%¼urÃyvÝK¾¶urÒíÀy0Á Ó#drÒíu·ödÒcuryM'yÒl¹µº·ör)y y G/ x~|#(0 x=x=y ry ¶K'» º·Yu=µxzy Ây5y0y0ɶ¹¶¹40y0SºurÂdyy ·irº¹µrury0y 0¼ÅÀuµY¾dy²»¾y ÞYºrµY¨ G Êy= yMy0À¶Á¼¿ÊGurryz.rdr7ry x=²¹µ ]dºdy 53=v·vy0Þury r¼uryMy=Ëɶx=ry yy00dÅI¾uy Æy yz¼.uryz¹º»vr]y ´¶ dry~± ºay¹µºy y~yÁ ·[xuryY³¨dry~uÆ» ury Q¶ r y.ud y0y Ây0ury)ury ¹Id4» ury y Ây0vury0y 4·¸=uryd¹º¹µuµIrÅy ¹`¹µd¹I+µurÂÞy r ·ö y0yM.v·[Îy y*)0y~y x=ury0 ºÆYÊ. ¾¶y Òly Óax=µºx=µy Á Á=± Ãl.y.~¹µy =ºrury0~µ y~ury=uºx= y=ury.y0¾Ây0d˹º ·[dº~d ryxz rµr5y0²²ur·[y.audr¹º¹µy ¹íÁµtvIÁzury,Ãl·¹ury0y .y= Yy0'y0 y0xzy' µx=Ëy0YurÊy05d .ury=Ê7y0 µx=y,y) y 7ury y=Yfx=» urºdu ºx=yYµ· y=¹µd¹4¾ry y0 ,y0·[y0y0*y r) yGd'ury µury~Êd¾dÒlx=ÓÀµ= ºdr'º¨ yYurGury y ¹4 y~µÂ ÞdurŸy~uryQx=¹vººµrxz¨,y57ry y¶Á µ ÊÆÝ¾¶ºÒí¨drÓyYr=¦z» )uruQ.urºx=»4y,+Ådµur`yYurÊyYdоd3 Òl/ÓÀ4·[½·Wy ݺ¨dy0ry.r z » yÁº±uGºuu=y.uuµ¸rÊy ¹Íy dÂ+µÂµÞÍ'Źºy y0¸xz¸Âdy0rÀÁW» tv¹µu¾ µurrvrµurry=y Ê7Ädºx=¾dÒl#y8ÆÓÀ² y)x)rur¹ÞyYºr¹ºyMx)~r¹·¸µurÂy,y¼Ê¹µ²¾¶Òlµx=ÓGyÁ=µx=ß-y² yMyMu'¼ rryÁK²Ãĺ·vGury~ºrÃÜ`¨d¹ºÜ`yzÜPÊd¢¤d¾d rÒlÁº¡dÓ ¡ y0Ê7r)r)QÁKtv¹ºury~Ê7r r yM rÅK¹uB]Ây¼ rÞ¹µÓ¹ºy µy B¶v Ê r¾¶ÒlYÓa» ury Bx=»yQy xz/[dury~y,x=Êy0'¾¶ÒíÊdÓ.¾¶y ÒíÓGε¶)y Q¹µ¹ Å u'»3¾duryy0 0+yÁYÃlYy,µ~ ¹ºyMºyM5MÅ7µuλ½y0y0Ây dMÅyzu˼urdy¹º¹µµ/[µY dx B04y0ɶ0ry yMy0yz0Å º5» furµuruËy'¶ury=xrÊ7 y .yM~·y0y y¾Gµy0rY · '0yMvury)urry0¹ a» uryury ¼¼rÆyMuuy0xzr² y y0Æ y0y0r4dr¹µ dQury ôIôöþ.
(75) öÏ Ï ]Ð Ð. Ñ. 9
(76) 3 3 9 . ʵ'd¾¶Òíry Ó`r) y0 y u»=GµurQyYݺu¨drry.ry0¦¹7Á¸Ãl¹ºÆ¹µ vurºdy yr·[d yYy040.Átvµury ¶y²4rº¹µd 'y²urry.x=Ê dµ¾dÒlÓv yM ¹ uuy yÆ4tvx,uµ]0 ,ÅKyŶ º » Þrru,4x= x,urrµr¨,År»½ux=y r0ºy d¹II Ŷy0»½¹ºy µy²Ây,Þ .urr7y'y ½µuu]rÂd ryvÁ y ¹½.+¾dºÂyƺ 57y4y ·Iµ )ÅKy ´By »y¹dy,¾¹µyy·ö)» ºµÂu ¹ 7d ºµ¹¸ºx='y 8 » uruS»y'» µ¹º¹ ¹º =¶rµy Þ¹º drury0Gy.ray0ºÊ7y y0µ r¨y0µQ·[dÊx,¾¶ÒlÓQy²x=ºx=y0y¹ Ár1,Ãl3!Æy046»587:µ9<¹ºÂ;¹Íy0 ur
(77) 1y0 ¹µQ¹ ÊÁ µxzy.± ydurÁ yG» » aº¹µ¹4ur»g¹µury,Æurya¹µ Ê ¾¶ ÒlaÓ Êy. yMyM @BA @ TK [ T oqRXI W OqILRPM tv-,3 u d'r
(78) '¨-urÐ+dÁ 4x ~y ury'yzyMury=.Ê·½d¾¶urÒíyÓfry0 yM+~3urÐл2 Ë µf
(79) ($Ý3 µ
(80) ¨r3 y=
(81) 1¦'( ~Ï 90x=+Ð x=2yÐ3)
(82) 1(Âdy м3 ur y=1
(83) r3# 4 58 7:yM9< ; Á ± $3 y 7. »0uruyY¹µ¹4µÃuÎÜ`urÜ`µ ܺÓ7y0ur¢d¤dy y0 r¶ ÍÁº.¡dÚ ¡ r y¼
(84) Ú y0 7YÖ Íx,rÖ]Ú 2Í«S/iy y¯y ®r « º¢EÓÖ ! y 0ÁSy ¶ .ʵr¾¶¨ÒlrÓ u Þ·[x=yx y00uÅÍ y d ÅÍÚ ·[ . ÍÚ y ´ Ú x= rÖ ¹º ydÅÍÖ¶Úr « 7d0y05yµµ Âur µÃĵƲÝ,µr¨ r x=yMy.Yr¦=¹µy»½´ yzy.r ¹µr y0¹ºyM ur5År»8G5urÞyÆ ¨d¨¹¨y ¹µ=a¨¶ ¹ºyMy~vy0y0ɶ¹µury yM4ÀÁyYurÃÄy. ·W yM + y0 µy0 ByM¢G4a»½yzda¹º» ¹µ µ¹ºµ¹µ¹¸¹ºGrµy0r º Á½Ê7y0ÃÄy,GyM¨dËvy ry ·y0´rur+¹cy Å µ}¶ ÍÖ¾GÂ.Ö Ê¯ ¹ºuydÚ ÁKº,tvux=@ y¼ ·[ dy ¹º©¹µ¹·[»¸ µr ¨=urÚyW¾y dB º¶® ¸r¬rÊÚ ]´ ¾° ºx,(IÓ'y rµ y0y Krx,·yz ury~yÆuµy,r ¹º d E¦ r!lyMÁ ¨a ÅdÊrr B½]urÂy0`x=¨ y. Êy ¹µ½¾¶ÒíÓ ¹º¶µy0/ ¹µö¹ºÏ 1,3#¶4 G58y07:Ê9< ; µr¶
(85) 1 ¨Gx= x=80vy·[ddÆx=Åry0ÞºdƵy0uQÆ0rÅI ryx=BÁ¼yM¿½ ' uµury.Æy Y·i¹ºG¹ÍÆr¨ µÂu y y05~4dr¹µ ¹Íur rµyy Á y²tvyM4uuryzy¾dy.y Ëx=ury)yYrÂrx=¹µr]´ yYyYºÊx,·d`¾dºÁ Òld(IÓfy ²ury x=yYy Ê7ry y x=0 y Å u ½yMur4y~·W¨d¨uyy ¨¶¨µÂy y0Qry0 x= y Á¼ÃÄQ ÃÜ`yMÜ``Ü ¢·À¤¶ uÁµy¼¡¡²urury0y) Ê!#" ¾¶Òl$&%KÓfry  dy0¹º½Âdy0µ½ µÂd y y Æ7y ¹µ 0y Ŷuvy ·À y)uyÆÊ d¾dÒlyÓ y ºux=~y=ºx=·` ur y=y ¹/iy xy0xzÊ7ry0² y0fy7Yy ²¹µrY Ê7 y)r' r ºyM,y00Æxz r5²Ê7y,y0Y ¹µd & yM/ Àu)Á(*tv+ury0(,Ë$ur0Åy,urry0r]·[´ ºxCx,urµyz7]µd ·4yYÂíºÁy0c»-Á ÀÁÆ·¿µruy x=¨dºÂd¹Iy rr xCy'Â]uryGrÊx¹ºyMÊ7y » zÞu·Æy x=xz y zy0Ê-f./ur"0y $1%½ury z)r` Á4 y0Ãl¼)x=µ µ¨u¶Æ Ê7y0yy µ´Â7y'y0¹µyM u,xzºuSy Ëvry0 dy0rrµr¹µº¨)¨5ury.ru]´ rµrx,y0¹cÁ µ urdr¹µS»½d¾f»y ¹µ¹½» ury0 ury y z¹¨y'rx)Êy0)· 2 $&'(*, -SK'4 3Ç> 56J<87 !p" ½ ±y y0y~0¨Á y0ry ¹µµy4ury~ʾ¶ÒlÓaÊy0u]ºdr·Íury~r y00Å G y ³ry²ury²·[d¹º¹µ» º¨Êd¾dÒlÓax)Ò 9;:=< ß u>y .9@?A$&%iuQy x= Æy0Þury vuryYd¾y y y0v µ ry0 BDC :=< tvuryYx=y0 ʾ¶ÒíÓË rºd /iºQ¹º 0½vurFy E¶uQy x= ·[d4=¾dy0SÅ uG(EH(9 Cõ HJI
(86) LKM.
(87) ¢. Ï. Ï Ï. 2&3"-
(88) &3 )
(89) 9"-
(90) 3 * 3 6
(91) 9"!3 R 1= 2. 1. 0. successes. R 2= 1. B1. B1. R 3= 4. 0. 0. B2. B3. 1. B3. R 4= 1 R 5= 2. 2. B3. 3. B3. B4. 0. B5 B15. 0. X4. X5. collisions X1. X2. X3. ݵ ¨ r¹ºydy4Á 8 ¥ =ÜWÂd¹µ µ'·ÀuyÆÊd¾dÒlÓÀW·Í.r ydÁKܸuy0xzry0'¾dy½¸Yy » Êd¾dÒlÓ ¹ºº¹ ÃÄury~ByY»½Ýry~º ¨d ryMyÆyz Á¹µº¥Gx=»½ºyzµr¨=ur» ry ur¹µy=Ây0y ¸Âdz¹µ urµy~Ëur·`x=ur¨dy=y rÊy0¾¶½Òl ÓBdrydÅd ury0y04y~·[d~Gx=ºy r¨dy ¹ºyzr y4 ydÁuy~tvury x=y=y¼·[y ~y x= 4r¶µ¹I0yM½·[vur y uG¾dy /[r,0y²·= 0@ y0'¾dyvµ ur» ºGuµ rµ¨¹ÀÊx d0+¾dÅÒlÓa·[durvyYury0y ɶry0uay²d¾·Íy Êvv¾¶¨ÒíµÂÓy0¸ ·[Ê ury u ¾y ½
(92) uG( ( " $ÁWtvuury 7. <. . @. @. » ºu!" $ @ # < B @Á ± yÊy Ây²u4uryy0ɶry y% '& $ y~y0ry »v¹I¹µº·[yYµx=y00Á xÆy yÅ Ây µy » y »vµr¨Q¹Wur y'¹µy=rx)·vʹºy0y0r¨u(·Æy Å x=»½ y=Êr=µ5·[d·[.durx@yuyzuSy y ¾d»vy)¹Wdy »v 7Qy0»uy 8=y x@u µ²yMur5y,» ʺduS¾dÒlurÓ y y~µv¨dºÂdy Gʶ* )) , + Á »#¹µy -Ê7y²ury. ¹µ¹ºµGrÊÊrµ¹ºº'y y GÊ'zr yÅcÁ yÁµÅ - : </.10 cQy x= 4Ê'zr y~·iº¹vÊyM y~·K=d¹º¹µµ % ·[ dº²y² µy¹º¹ ury ury7y=y Êdr y ¾¶ ¶Òíy000Á¸ÓzÁ.ÃlÊ74¿y aµu]Âururµy,y arKy0dr·7µ]¹µ´ '¹µ¹µx,uy0y y µr Qu y0x, Kd y)urµyf y0x=+yºÅdfury4 rÅ ¹µur¹ºy,µ) ry0ʵÂyzÊrº¹µº¹µY¹µµµºdury4y Âdy ¶x=y. % < $ ?-#?3-5476"686 ?-9 C % < B ?- B ?;-<4 B 4 ?=6"686?- B C ?=6"686?-9 B 9 » uµuGºy0¹µr ury~·[d¹º¹µ» º¨·[dx)r¹µ)·[dvury.y0x= 4y²·[4z¨dºÂdy ¹µ¹ººd rÊÊrµ¹ºº>?B -#?=? 6"68- 6 4 ?6"68- 6 C ?B C - ?=9 6"686?3- B ? :-% :=< B ?- B ?;- $ 2 :. . 4 4. 9 9. ôIôöþ.
(93) öÏ Ï ]Ð Ð. Ñ. 9
(94) 3 3 9 0 Zk back−off stage. 1. 0. : 0. 1. 2. 3. 0. 0. 1. Y(t): residual back−off process. X1. X2. X3. X4. X5. Ý0µ¨y¼rµy.a4» =`urÜWÂdu ¹µ uryYµÊGd¾d·ÒluÓÀyYvÊy²¾¶ Òl¶Ó˵r¨dyv/ Â]C 0vʹº yM Á uryYy0 ¹Àʾ¶ÒíÓaµxzy/ + % 0½·[d ury . . /¡0 3
(95) ,
(96)
(97) cÐ 43-4Ð# "9
(98) cÁ. yvu0ŵyvury4Êd¾¶ÒíÓ,µxzyM¸yvµ¹µ ÅuryÆy0x= ¸y ? -% µWµ Ö B® I« ¡Á y~u uy #Ð
(99) 1-#1'24
(100) , 9Ï· uryYʾ¶ÒlÓ rºd y0v4x,y MÁ Á Êrß4 ¹ºdÅd4Êy0y~Âd y²µuy y ur/[yíÁ ydÁºÊÅrurÂdyYyYÊd¾¶¹º ÒíµÓ y y x,Âd¹µÂºy²vÂy0u¹º¨ y00G» ury yYury0d duºy.rÊd0¾¶Á ÒlÓË ÞÒ ¦rÁvÃÄQuy)Êd¾¶ÒíÓËx=ry ¹K y y0aµ ¦ ! 9 < <7·[ruy MÅury y¼ & $uQu B C < 4 4 # ¹º0Å ·[X uG(AE( "$År B C < 4 4 # ¹µ Å·[d' E & 5Á ºx4¶y0=y > uryYy ´YyMµ`~ºd7d·[dº µÂ? y :-µd%`y º¨dQy Ü`/ɶt µ)µfury4¡²ÃÜ`µy ܸ¹rÜ ¢¤¶ Áµ¡¡vr 0+ÁWrʺ º¨YuryMy . .
Documents relatifs
cosinus (en bleu à gauche) et d’une droite (en noir à droite) sur les données simulées pour 4 années à une température de 45°C, avec un bruit de fond interne réduit de 100,
Florence CARRÉ ~ Réoccupations funéraires de sépultures collectives néolithiques dans la boucle du
2 Vue plus en détails dans le chapitre 1... 2 phénomène d’agrégation des protéines amyloïdes en fibres et d’autres facteurs impor- tants doivent être pris en compte comme
In this chapter, we prove an a posteriori error estimates for the generalized overlapping domain decomposition method with Dirichlet boundary conditions on the boundaries for
Revue française d’héraldique et de sigillographie – Études en ligne – 2020-10 © Société française d’héraldique et de sigillographie, Paris,
Dans ce cas, comme les coulées du Bras de Sainte-Suzanne appartiennent au massif de La Montagne daté à plus de 2 Ma (McDougall, 1971), l’ensemble des coulées pahoehoe
In infantile Pompe disease patients, the glycogen storage diffusely affects brainstem motor and sensory neurons, and the whole spinal cord sensory neurons, interneurons, and
De ce point de vue, il est possible d’affirmer que la mission est accomplie : les projets de renouvellement urbain (GPV et ORU) élaborés depuis 1998 dans une centaine de villes