Queueing Analysis of Simple FEC Schemes for IP Telephony

Texte intégral

(1)Queueing Analysis of Simple FEC Schemes for IP Telephony Eitan Altman, Chadi Barakat, Victor Manuel Ramos Ramos. To cite this version: Eitan Altman, Chadi Barakat, Victor Manuel Ramos Ramos. Queueing Analysis of Simple FEC Schemes for IP Telephony. [Research Report] RR-3998, INRIA. 2000, pp.34. �inria-00072647�. HAL Id: inria-00072647 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072647 Submitted on 24 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Queueing analysis of simple FEC schemes for IP Telephony Eitan Altman — Chadi Barakat — Victor Manuel Ramos Ramos. N° 3998 September 2000. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--3998--FR+ENG. THÈME 1. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4)

(5) "!$# %'&()*,+-/. 0 (1& 2,354*687:9;<4>="687@?BADCE68F'3GH6/I>6/JK684L?M3<NO4>PQIRS6/7UT'VO;XW6/=YPQZ[W6/=YPQZ \^]U_a`Lbdcegfh*ibkjmlQnobap iq/ip_a`Lb*i r(stmuvbapwyx5ips jmz fjm{|{'t}sp,~|bsb*]Ubas ]Ub Ye/ba{|pba`'basD 1em{jmb*i *kO| xKpbas j}apxbt}x5*b jm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Uik¡D¢£X¤¥i]Uba`Lb*iYjmsb"Ub**b*ii jmsq§¦¨t}sop]Ub sb**t©basqª¦«st}`¬z5t ip{j}bapik®S\^]Ub*ib¯i ]Uba`Lb*iUb*b*~Spt"'b¯ix`{|z5b¯°±xp]²j"zx ]KpL*t/~Qx| jmU~ ~|b**t/~Qx|Ytkbas]Ubkj}~:it³j}iHUt}ppt¯x`{j}app]UbxKpbas j}apx/xp´q®L\^]Ubt}Qub*apxbtm¦^p]|x5i {jm{'basLx5idptµiplU~Qq²j°Xbazz8Ut©°±@ix`{|z5by¢£¶¤·i ]Uba`LbYp]jmpd]j}idb*ba¸{|st}{t ib*~@jmU~ x`{|z5ba`Lba8pb*~E¡'x"°±]|x5 ]y¦¨t}sbabasqy{j}bap¹(¡it}`Lbsb*~Ql|U~UjmKpxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}"x5iHj}~|~|b*~pt i t}`Lbil|Uib*º8lUbaKp[{j} bap¹³»½¼B® ¦^{j}bap¹$x5iz5t ipk¡¾xp°±xzz'bsb**t}UipslUapb*~µx:kj}ib {j} bapd¹"»¿¼²x5i°¶bazz,sb**baxb*~E®§\^]Ub³º8ljmzxp´q$tm¦Dp]Ub¯sb**t}UipslUapb*~¸*t}{Kq§tm¦{j} bapd¹ °±xzz~|ba{baU~t}yp]Ub1jm`Lt}l|KpHtm¦xQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}tm¦{j}bapH¹µkjmssx5b*~"Kq³{j} bapD¹»@¼À®^Áµb {|st}{'t ibjo~|bap jmxz5b*~ ºKlUbalUbax|YjmjmzqQix5iHj}ib*~t}µjjmzz5t}pDp]Ub*t}sba`Y¡ÀjmU~ t}|p jmxix`{|z5b b>nQ{|sb*iix5t}Ui±¦«t}s±p]UbjmlU~Qx5tdºKljmzxpÂq³j}ij¦Ãl|Uapx5t}ytm¦p]Ubjm`Lt}l|8ptm¦sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq³jmU~Yxpi sbaz<jmpxbD{'t ixpx5t}¯°±xp]¯sb*i{b*ap^pt1p]UbHt}sx xjmz'xQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}¾®X¢Ut}s,j[l|pxzxpÂqd¦«l|Uapx5t}¯p]jmp x5izxUbkjmsxp]Ub jm`Lt}l|Kp¶tm¦xQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}¾¡8p]Ub,jmjmzq/ix5iÄi]Utk°,iÄp]jmpp]|x5i¢£X¤$i ]Uba`Lb,~|t/b*i Ut}p[i kjmz5b°XbazzXjmU~:jmKqµjm`Lt}l|Kptm¦,j}~|~|b*~ sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq `x ]8pkjmlUibLj¯~|ba s j}~Ujmpx5t}Sx p]Ubt©bas jmzzÄº8ljmzxp´q®1Áµbp]Uba xKpst/~QlU*bdjmU~µjmjmzq/Åkbt}p]Ubas[l|pxzxp´q"¦Ãl|Uapx5t}Ui[xµt}s~|bas pt1t}|p jmxYjº8ljmzxp´qd¦Ãl|Uapx5t}¯p]jmp^x5i¶bappbas±j}~Ujm{|pb*~¯ptp]UbD ]jms j}apbasx5ipx5*i,tm¦¾p]|x5i^/xU~ tm¦jm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Uik® ÆYÇÈ'ÉÊË OÌ

(6) r²pbaz5ba{|]Ut}Kq¡jmzz5t}p,p]Ub*t}sba`Y¡¢£X¤D¡jmlU~Qx5tLºKljmzxpÂq¡|l|pxzxp´q¯¦«l|Uapx5t}¾®. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.

(7) 1 (´ d +

(8) 1( (%E& 1 (¸!$# 1 (@ 0 (& +-/. b*i`Lh*kjm|x5i`Lb*i¯~|b¢£¶¤ it}8pxU~Qx5i{baUi jm|z5b*i{'t}l|sz x`{|z<jm8p jmpx5t} ~|b*i jm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Ui~|bps jmUi`x5iix5t}:~|bz<jot}x nba pba`{Uish*baz({'t}l|ssh*al|{'hasbas~|b*i{'baspb*i~|b {j}º8lUbapik®Ä¤¶b*i¶`Lh*kjm|x5i`Lb*i,~|t}xba8p apsbHix`{|z5b*ik¡QbapXz5bD{|st/*b*iilUi^~|bH*t8~UjmbHbap^~|bH~|h**t ~UjmbXUb¶~|t}xp{j}iÀxKpst/~Ql|xsb^'bkjmlU*t}l|{~|b¶il|s ]jmsbX{'t}l|sUbÄ{j}i(j Eb*apbasÀz x8pbas j}apx8xph ® bL|l|p~|bd*bap1jmspx5az5bob*ip1~ haplU~Qx5basl|S`Lh*kjm|x5i`Lbo~|bd¢£X¤ ix`{|z5bL`djmx5ips_*il|pxzx5i h ¡ º8l|x(jdhaph{|st}{t i hbapH`x5iHba! Hl|/sb ¡'~UjmUiDz5b*ºKlUbaz{'t}l|sD ]j}ºKlUb1{j}º8lUbapD¹St}jOut}l|pb1~|b z<j1sb*~|t}U~UjmU*bil|s±l|³{j}ºKlUbap±{'t iphasx5bal|s ¹»§¼À®Ä8xEz5bH{j}ºKlUbap,¹ b*ip¶{'bas~Ql¾¡QxzE{'bal|p apsb sb**t}Uipsl|xp[ixz5b{j}º8lUbap[¹o»¼ªb*ipH|x5ba s#h "al¾® j¯º8ljmzxph~|b1z<j*t}{|x5bsb**t}Uipsl|xpb~Ql {j}º8lUbap±¹y~|ha{'baU~Qs j1~|bz<jº8ljmKpxph~|bH¢£X¤²º8lUbDz t}¯jOut}l|pbHil|s¶z5b{j}º8lUbap±¹»ª¼À%® $Dt}lUi {|st}{'t it}Ui¶l|Ubjmjmzq/i b~|hap jmxzz5h*bH~|'b &Uz5b*i^~ jmppbaKpbHj}ih*bHil|s¶l|p]Uh*t}s_a`Lb~|)b (+*-,.,0/21¨¡|bap Ut}lUit}|pbaUt}Ui~|b*i1b>nQ{|sb*iix5t}Uiix`{|z5b*i[{'t}l|sz<j³º8ljmzxphd~|bdz jmlU~Qx5tybaµ¦¨t}Uapx5t}:~|bdz<j º8ljmKpxphD~|bsb*~|t}U~UjmU*bDbap^baL¦¨t}Uapx5t}¯~|bi j[{t ixpx5t}d{jms¶s jm{|{t}s4p 3z xQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}³t}s5x xjmz5b ® jmjmzq/i bH`Lt}Kpsbº8lUbH{t}l|s^l|UbD¦¨t}Uapx5t}¯~ l|pxzxphºKl|xEb*ip^zxUhkjmxsbH{jms±s jm{|{'t}sp 3dz<jºKljm8pxph~ xQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}¾¡'xz6 b*ipD{j}iDsb**t}``djmU~Ujm|z5bL~ l|pxzx5ibas*b`Lh*kjm|x5i`Lb ¡¾bap º8lUb16 x`{t}spbº8lUbazz5bºKljm8pxph~|b1sb*~|t}U~UjmU*bdjOuvt}l|ph*b{'t}l|ss jmxp[j 'b*apbas[~|b¦ -j "*t}U7h KjmpxbYz<jºKljmzxph¯pt}p jmz5b 8® $Dt}lUi{|sh*iba8pt}UidbapdjmjmzqQit}UiL~ jml|psb*iL¦«t}Uapx5t}UiL~ l|pxzxph {'t}l|st}|pba|xsDl|Ub¦¨t}Uapx5t}~|bº8ljmzxph[`x5balQnj}~Ujm{|ph*bjmlQnYkjms j}aphasx5ipx5ºKlUb*iH~|b1*b[pÂq8{'b ~ jm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Ui©® 9 Ë k É ; : Y \±haz5ha{|]Ut}|x5bil|s 8pbasUbapk¡|p]Uh*t}s_a`Lb~|bHjmzz5t}pk¡¢£¶¤D¡UºKljmzxph~|b[z jmlU~Qx5t|¡ ¦¨t}Uapx5t}y~ l|pxzxph ®.

(9) * *-,

(10) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / . . Q- + % wb*]jm|x5i`Li,¦¨t}s,sb**tkbasx|o¦«st}` {j}bapDz5t iib*ikjmy'b[az<j}iix5&b*~j}i t}{'bayz5t/t}{Y`Lb*]j |x5i`Li[jmU~ az5t ib*~z5t8t}{ `Lb* ]jm|x5i`Li)(c+*-,´®/.1032+4576803292;:=</57>@?BA-CEDF4#<)4zxbHGfJILK3Gl|pt `djmpx51f ba{'bkjmp s+b IlUb*i;p M jmsbUt}pDj}~|b*º8ljmpb¦«t}ssbkjmz5 px`Lbx8pbas j}apxbLjm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}UiixU*b p]UbaqxUasbkj}ibH*t}Uix5~|bas jm|zqop]UbDbaU~ pt ´baU~³~|baz<jkqo~QlUbDpt1{j}bap±sbaps jmUi`x5iix5t}¾O® N:P5QC 032 2;:R</57>S?BA-CEDF4Q<)4Lzxb¢£XT ¤ K«¢Ut}s°^jms~:£sst}s1¤¶t}ssb*apx5t}B M[jmsb'bappbasj}~Ujm{|pb*~ªpt¯sbkjm5z px`Lbjm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Ui[ xbaµp]jmp[{j} bap[z5t iib*ijmsbsb**tkbasb*~:°±xp]Ut}l|p[p]UbUb*b*~¦¨t}sjos7b ps jmUi`x5iix5t}V UBi t}`Lbsb*~Ql|U~UjmKpxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}µx5ips jmUi`xppb*~ °±xp] p]Ubj}ix5~Ujmp Xj Wt©°[® Y U*b¯jy{j}bapx5iz5t ipk¡p]Ubdsb**baxbaslUib*/ i KÃx ¦,{t i ix|z5+b Mp]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmKpxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}§pt sb**t}UipslUap¶p]Ubz5t ipXxQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}¾®¢£X¤@i ]Uba`Lb*i±jmsb sb**t}``LbaU~|b*~¯°±]UbaUbabas^p]UbDbaU~ pt ´baU~y~|baz<j*q¯x5i±z<jmsb[itp]jmpDj1sbaps jmUi`x5iix5t}y~|bapbasx5t}s jmpb*ip]Ub[t©bas jmzzÀº8ljmzxp´q® '. 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2. 1. 2. Z\[ ZZ \[ Z\[ \[ \[ \Z\Z ZZ[ ZZ[ Z[ Z\ \\Z[\[ \\[ \ Z\[ Z \[ Z \Z\Z \Z[Z\[ 3. 4. 4. Original stream. FEC. FEC. Forward Error Correction. Packet loss. Reconstructed stream. ¢x l|sbD^c ]Bwb*~Qx<j xU~|ba{baU~|ba8p¢£X¤D®O\^]Ub¶¢£X¤µ{j}bap{|st}pb*apij±|z5t/tm¦¹`_)a{j}bapik¡ xp i,p]Ubsb*il|zp,tm¦b Y f,x|Lp]Ub[t}sx xjmzB|z5t8 ¯tm¦{j}bapi©® cVd&c. ePfVg^h/ijg9kmlngogpfVgrqXfVgpgpsut vpw&fyx. §xKpbas j}apxb"sbkjmz5 px`Lb*t}``l||x5kjmpx5t}¾¡,¢£X¤ pb* ]||x5ºKlUb*i¯jmsbYlUi b*~§pt sba{jmxsLz5t ii b*i tm¦D~Ujmp j"~Ql|sx|ps jmUi`x5i ix5t}¾® rÀbas/xUiLjmU{~ zt/~|it}|(c~},±az<j}iix ¦«qª¢£X¤pb* ]||x5ºKlUb*ij}i </576pDA DC6E5S:P5QC6E5QCB .¶¡jmU ~ </576pDA 34S:57>QD>.¶® ¢£¶¤]j}i,'b*baYtm¦ÃpbaylUib*~¯¦¨t}s±z5t ii±sb**tkbasq³xjmlU~Qx5tL*t}``l||x5kjmpx5t}pt8t}z5i©® p±x5iDj i baU~|bas j}ib*~sba{jmxs`Lb*]jm|x5i`Y® G b dax5baKp¶¢£X¤Si]Uba`Lb^x5iÄt}Ub^p]jmp(x5ijm|z5b^ptHsba{jmxs p]Ub[`Lt ip tm¦({j}bapz5t iib*ik® $t©°[¡U°±]Uba"¢£X¤¦¨jmxz5i ptsb**tkbas ¦Ãst}`

(11) jz5t iik¡Ujm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Ui 1Ê;.

(12) ',51 * * +** 1 * / 1. 2. 1. 1. 2. 1. 1. 2. 1. 2. 3 2. 3. . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. 4. Original stream. 3. 4. Media−specific FEC (redundancy). 3. 4. Packet loss. 4. Reconstructed stream. ¢x l|sb^ ]Bwb*~Qx<j í{'b*a5x &¶¢£X¤D®m\^]Ub¶ix`{|z5b^¢£¶¤ `Lb* ]jm|x5i`°±]UbasbÄ{j} bap¹Ä»XaXkjmssx5b*i sb*~Ql|U~Ujm8p xQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}"tm¦{j}bapD¹(® kjm¯sb*it}sp±ptt}p]Ubas^sb**baxbas j}ib*~³sba{jmxs±`Lb* ]jm|x5i`Li±zxbHxUibaspx5t}¾¡Qx8pbas{t}z<jmpx5t}¾¡t}s sbabaUbas jmpx5t}¾¡¶lUix| °¶bazz,/Utk°±²`Lbap]Ut/~|8i (+c *+,´®$\^]Ub³¢£X¤ i ]Uba`Lb*i{|st}{t i b*~$x§p]Ub zxpbas jmpl|sbLjmsbtm¦«pba ix`{|z5b ¡Eitp]jmpDp]Ub*t/~Qx|YjmU~p]Ub1~|b**t/~Qx|³tm¦Äp]Ub1sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq kjmybº8l|x5/zqo~|t}Ub[°±xp]Ut}l|p,x`{j}apx|dp]Ubx8pbas j}apx8xpÂq® 9¿Ç Ì Ã É ÀÌ Ç Ç ÀÌ Ç

(13)

(14)

(15) 576pDA DC6E5S:P5QC6E5QCB. x5i1tm¦ÃpbaSx`{|z5ba`LbaKpb*~SlUix||z5t8 µt}sjmzba|s jmx5o*t/~|b*ik¡zxb {jmsxpÂqo*t/~|b*i,jmU~³f b*b*~ /t}z5t}`Lt}Y*t/~|b*ik®(\^]Ub*ib*t/~|b*i^°Xt}soKqp jm8x|dj1*t/~|ba°Xt}s~Ytm¦ ~Ujmp j{j} bapiHptbaUbas jmpb¹ _"j}~|~Qxpx5t}jmz]Ub* "{j} bapiD¦«t}sHps jmUi`xppx|Y¹:{j}bapi t©basp]UbdUbap´°¶t}s®\^]Uboj}~|~Qxpx5t}jmz¶{j}bapiLjmsbdxKpbaU~|b*~Spt"jmx5~:xªp]Ubsb**tkbasx| tm¦ z5t ip±{j}bapijmp p]Ubsb**baxbask® G ob>n|jm`{|z5bDtm¦¾{jmsxp´qd*t/~Qx|1]j}iÄ'b*bao~|babaz5t}{'b*~¯jmU~dx`{|z5ba`Lba8pb*~¯KqLf t i baK'bas ( - ,´¡O°±]|x5]1*t}Uix5ipiBxjm{|{|zq8x|Hj b Y fªt}{'bas jmpx5t}1j}ast i iÀj^ st}l|{1tm¦/{j} bapiBpt±baUbas jmpb p]Ub*t}ssb*i{'t}U~Qx|³{jmsxp´q{j}bapi©®[¢x l|sb³c1~|ba{|x5apiHp]|x5ii ]Uba`Lb ® Y Ub{jmsxpÂqy{j}bap KÃp]Ub¢£¶¤{j}ba;p M±x5i±baUbas jmpb*~"jO¦«pba` s b Y f,x|d¹ _ a~Ujmp j{j}bap+i U|x ¦p]Ubasb[x5iu lUip,t}Ub z5t i i±xyj1 st}l|{"tm¦¹{j}bapik¡p]jmp,z5t ii^x5i±sb**t©bas jm|z5b ® rÀbas/xUiD]j}iDkjmzz5b*~"p]|x5i8xU~tm¦Ä¢£X¤½`Lb* ]jm|x5i` </576pDA DC6E5S:5QC6E5QCj 'b*kjmlUibp]Ub ¢£X¤St}{'bas jmpx5t}d~|t/b*iUt}p~|ba{baU~t}p]Ub±*t}8pbaKpi¶tm¦p]Ub^{j} bapik®(\^]Ub^{|sxUax{jmzj}~Q jm p jmbDtm¦¾p]|x5iîx`{|z5bDi]Uba`Lbx5i¶xpiXix`{|zx5axpÂq¡UjmU~dxokj}ibDtm¦¾z5t iiÄp]Ubsba{jmxs¶¦«t}sXp]jmpXz5t i i x5i±t}|p jmxUb*~¯8q¯j1ix| z5b b Y ft}{bas jmpx5t}¾®\^]UbH`djmxY~Qx5i j}~Q}jm8p jmbx5i^p]UbH~|baz<j*qYjmU~op]Ub xUasbkj}i b*~jmU~Q°±x5~Qp] x`{t ib*~t}p]Ubps jmUi`x5iix5t}¾® G ]|x ] ~|baz<j*q°Xt}l|z5~ ~|bapbasx5t}s jmpb p]Ub xKpbas j}apx/xp´qotm¦¾j*t}Kbasi jmpx5t}¾¡|jmU~p]KlUiXp]Ub,8l|`'bas¶tm¦¾{|st}pb*apb*~{j}bapi¶x`{'t ib p]UbH{|z<jkqt}l|p~|baz<jkq³jmp p]Ubsb**baxbas,xykj}ibtm¦z5t iik® "!#$.

(16) * *-,

(17) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / . 9¿Ç ÌÃ É ÄÇ .

(18)

(19) . . . 576pDA 34&:P57>QD>O.¿*t}Uix5ipi^j}ix5kjmzzqoxyj}~|~Qx|Lptbkj}]y{j}bapj1sb*~Ql|U~Ujm8p {'t}spx5t} mt ¦p]UbH{|sba/x5t}lUi t}Ub ®\^]|x5i±j}ix5{|sxUax{|z5b[x5i^xzzlUips jmpb*~yxY¢xU®ÄQ® ¯p]|x5i±¢£X¤i ]Uba`LbH°XbHsb**t} |xÅkbp]Ub 2 #D pDCBA-0V4~ 5A-<·°±]|x5 ]Y°XbHx8pbaU~¯pt{|st}pb*ap ¦«st}` {j}bap±z5t iib*i©¡/jmU~op]Ub. 4+ 5A-< p]jmp^x5i¶t}x|pt'bps jmUi`xppb*~¯p]|st}l| ]¯p]Ub UbapÂ°Xt}s'®\Bt±bap¾p]UbX¢£X¤ipsbkjm`Y¡O°Xb¶j}~|~pt±{j}bap¹À» aÄj±sb*~Ql|U~UjmKp{t}spx5t}t}|p jmxUb*~ ¦«st}`·{j}bapD¹(®(\^]|x5i±sb*~Ql|U~UjmKpD{'t}spx5t}³x5i,t}|p jmxUb*~YlUiljmzzqoKq³*t/~Qx|L{j}bap¹°±xp] j"z5t©°Xbas jmU~Q°±x5~Qp]¾¡¶z5tk°¶bas ´ºKljmzxpÂq²baU*t8~Qx|pb*]||x5º8lUb ®S\^]Ubo ]Ut}x5*b³tm¦p]Ub¯baU*t/~Qx| pb* ]||x5ºKlUbx5i±Ut}p t}88x5t}lUik¡jmU~³p]jmp,{|st}|z5ba`¥]j}i±b*ba"iplU~Qx5b*~Yb>nQpbaUixbazjq U ¶t}z5t}pDjmU~ baKj jms <j ( ,À]jkb{|st}{'t ib*~"p]Ub[lUibtm¦z5tk° |xp s jmpb1*t8~|b**iDilU] j}i rX¤D¡'jmU~Y¦«l|zz |xp±s jmpbilU]"j}i [/wS¡UjmU~³pt/t}z5i^zxb[¢|sb*b*r(]Ut}Ub (ck- ,ÀjmU~³fjmp (c -,¾]jkbx`{|z5ba`LbaKpb*~ xpk®(\^]Ub*i bHpt8t}z5i±baUbas jmzzq¯°¶t}s8qx`{|z5ba`Lba8px|p]Ub¢£X¤@`Lb* ]jm|x5i` uvlUip±~|b*iasx'b*~E¡ i tp]jmp,x ¦À{j} bap¹x5i,~Qst}{|{'b*~³x³p]UbUbapÂ°Xt}s'¡Uxp,kjmY'bHsb**tkbasb*~jmU~³{|z<j*qb*~"t}l|p,x kj}i b,{j}bap±¹[=» a,x5iX*t}ssb*apzqLsb**baxb*~u lUip¶j}iÄxp iXxzzlUips jmpb*~ox¢x l|sbHQ®\^]8lUik¡/x ¦Ep]Ub sb**t}UipslUapx5t}ilU**b*b*~|i©¡|p]Ub[z5t ip {j}bap x5i {|z<j*qb*~"t}l|p °±xp]"jLz5tk°XbasDºKljmzxpÂq¡|l|p p]jmp °¶t}l|z5~³'bHbappbas,p]jmypt{|z<j*qoUt}p]|x|ojmp±p]Ubsb**baxbask® \^]Ub(`djmxj}~Q jmKp jmbtm¦Q`Lb*~Qx<j í{'b*a5x &Ä¢£X¤x[*t}`{jmsx5it}°±xp][`Lb*~Qx<j xU~|ba{'baU~|baKp ¢£X¤ x5i1xpi1z5tk° z<jmpbaUaq¡('b*kjmlUibo°±xp]$p]|x5i1ix`{|z5bi ]Uba`Lb³t}Ubo]j}ipt"°¶jmxpDuvlUipt}Ub {j} bapx kj}ibtm¦¶z5t iik¡xUipbkj}~tm¦¶jm baKpxsb|z5t/tm¦Ä{j}bapij}ixp]Ub1{|sba/x5t}lUikj}ib ® \^]|x5i,z5tk° z<jmpbaUaq³]jms j}apbasx5ipx5`djmb*i±xpil|xp jm|z5bH¦¨t}s±xKpbas j}apxbjm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Uik® pD]j}iHb*ba{|st©b*~ p]jmpHz5t iib*iHxp]Ub 8pbasUbapjmsb1tm¦«pba |l|sipÂq¡¾jmU~p]jmpD`LbkjmUi p]jmpx ¦,{j} bapL¹¸x5i1z5t ipk¡p]Ubasb¯b>nQx5ipijYUt}|Uba zx x|z5b¯{|st}jm|xzxpÂq:p]jmp{j}bapL¹ym » a x5i[jmz5i tz5t ipk®[Áµb*t}l|z5~ it}zbp]jmpHKqi{j}ax|³p]Ubsb*~Ql|U~Ujm8p*t}{KqKq"`Lt}sbp]jmµt}Ub {j} bapk¡K|l|pXp]jmpÄ*t}l|z5~j Eb*app]Ub±x8pbas j}apx8xpÂqdtm¦Bjib*iix5t}¾®À\^]8lUiÄp]Ub,i{j}ax|'bap´°Xb*ba p]Ubdt}sx xjmz{j}bapjmU~ xpi[sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq x5ij¯*t}`{|st}`x5i bL'bap´°Xb*ba:z5t iisb**t©basqªjmU~ x8pbas j}apx8xpÂq® . . . .

(20). . . . . cVd. . . kw&fPiSw v. \^]Ubasbob>nQx5ipi1jyKl|`bastm¦±¦ j}apt}si1p]jmp1kjm§j 'b*apjm§jmlU~Qx5t"*t}8basi jmpx5t}¾® ¢xsipk¡x p bas j}apx/xp´q:x5ij'b*apb*~$~Qxsb*apzqµ8qªp]UbobaU~ pt´baU~§~|baz<j*q ~UXib**t}U~E¡'uvxppbasjEb*api1p]Ub WUl|x5~QxpÂqµtm¦±p]UbLi{'b*b*]VU(jmU~µp]|xs~E¡À{j}bapz5t iijEb*api[p]UbdjmlU~Qx5t"ºKljmzxpÂq {bas*baxb*~Sjmp p]Ub1~|b*ipxjmpx5t}¾® pDx5ip]|x5iHz<j}ip ¦ j}apt}sH°±]|x5]x5iDp]Ub`djmx *t}U*bas tm¦Xt}l|sH°Xt}s"xp]|x5i {jm{'bask® . $. ;. . @. @. ;. . . !#"$##%'& %()"$* +",(.-/10325476890-:;2<%=?>5@+"A" B(DC>5&;C" B(E()"GF'HGIE%'JF"G#J>5@+H LKNMNO;PJGQ% BR$FSB(D% +TUPJ"G()%'H. ;. . . ;. ;. . R$&()% +TVH B(W()",RX&()% +TDQ +"X>3YZ&;[5\J>#[7H +#%]>^H +(W@)&_ >a`+SDb1"$[5% +TWcdGeNfg. 1Ê;.

(21) ',51 * * +** 1 * / }. \^]UbY`Lbkj}il|sbYtm¦jmlU~Qx5t:ºKljmzxpÂq§x5iUt}pojm¸t}88x5t}lUi{|st/*b*~Ql|sb ¡^b*kjmlUibYxpdkjm¸'b `Lbkj}il|sb*~x¯~Qx5EbasbaKp±°¶jkq/i©® obaUbas jmz ¡Qp]UbasbHb>n/x5ip¶p´°¶tkjmpbat}sx5b*i^pt1az<j}i ix ¦Ãqp]UbD°^j*q °¶b`Lbkj}il|sbjmlU~Qx5tdºKljmzxpÂjq ] À Ç Ç |k Ç k Ç ¡jmU~ Ç Ç |k Ç © Ç ¡ bkj} ]"tm¦(p]Uba`¥~Q5x Ebas,x"p]Ub°¶jkq³p]Ubaq¯*t}U*baxb1º8ljmzxp´q®

(22) 7 57>+3D 5 A4Q45 4Q4Q</5QCB¶x5i,tm¦«pba `dj}~|b Kq{'basv¦«t}s`x|1zx5ipba|x|pb*ipilUix|jz<jmsb Kl|`'bas±tm¦¾il|Quvb*api©® x5ipbaUbasiÄzx5ipba pt jibaptm¦jmlU~Qx5t ix jmz5i°±xp]Ut}l|pbax| pt}z5~²jm't}l|pp]Ubaxsjmpl|sb {® G lU~Qx5tº8ljmzxp´qSx5i ba jmzljmpb*~³8qop]UbHzx5ipbaUbasi,Kq¯ x/x|dji*t}sbHp]jmp,s jm|b*i bapÂ°Xb*baScHpt UEcH¦¨t}s±j}~E¡ ¦¨t}sHb>nQ*bazz5ba8pk®\^]Uba¾¡¾joi*t}sb1x5iHkjmz5al|z<jmpb*~ Kqj*bas jm x|³p]Ubzx5ipbaUbas ii *t}sbsb*il|zpx| x$j³wbkjm Y {|x|x5t}²/*t}sb K«w Y E M>¡¾ x/x|yp]Ubdsb*ºKl|xsb*~$jmlU~Qx5tyº8ljmzxp´qµ`Lbkj}il|sb ®³\^]Ub \ ´\$jmU~ \ ´f ( ^ }Q¡ -,Qsb**t}``LbaU~Ujmpx5t}Ui¶il| b*ipi(i kjmz5b*i¦«t}sj}iib*i ix|t}x5*b^ps jmU+i `x5i ix5t}Ytkbas,pbaz5ba{|]Ut}Ub[Ubap´°Xt}sQik¡x`djmbºKljmzxpÂq¯t©bas,pbaz5ba/x5ix5t}YiqQipba`Lik¡UjmU~Yjmz5it1¦¨t}s `l|zpx`Lb*~Qx<jjm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Uik®(Áªjmpit}³jmU~³Qj}iib ( ,az<jmx` p]jmpXp]Ub*i b \ sb**t}``LbaU~|b*~ `Lbap]Ut/~|i¦¨t}sil|Qub*apxb±º8ljmzxp´q1j}i ib*ii`Lba8p(jmsb¶Ut}p(il|xp jm|z5b¶¦¨t}sj}i ib*iix|Hp]Ub^ºKljmzxpÂqtm¦ `djm8q¯Uba°Xbas ibas/x5*b*i jmU~yjm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Ui©¡jmU~³p]Ubaq¯~|b*iasx'bp]Ubaxs,pb*ipx|L`Lbap]Ut/~|t}z5t} q® Dxbadp]jmp¶p]Ubasb b>nQx5ipiXp]|x5iX~Qx5i jm sb*ba`Lba8p,jmU~Lp]|x5i¶~Qxbasixp´qdtm¦E°^j*qQi¶tm¦¾`Lbkj}il|sx| il|Quvb*apxb±jmlU~Qx5tDºKljmzxpÂq¡ 2 7 57>+3D 5 A4Q475 4Q4#</5QCB¾x5iÀipxzz/°Xbazzj}~Ujm{|pb*~1ptDiplU~Qq[p]Ub^7b Eb*api p]jmp³*basp jmx)¦ j}apt}si¯]j*btkbasyjmlU~Qx5t§º8ljmzxp´q® ½t}Qub*apxb"pb*ipik¡jmlU~Qx5t§º8ljmzxp´q@x5i ba jmzljmpb*~²8q$`Lbkj}il|sx|ªp]Ub"~Qx5ipt}spx5t}¸'bap´°¶b*ba@p]UbY~|b**t/~|b*~@jmlU~Qx5t:ix jmzDjmU~²p]Ub t}sx xjmzEix jmz ® Y Qub*apxbHpb*ipi^kjm¯b`dj}~|bDlUix|j sbkjmp±~QxbasixpÂqtm¦B`Lbkj}il|sb*ik¡/zxb $Df ~Qx5ipt}spx5t}¾¡z5t ii±s jmpb ¡Ubap ® G lU~Qx5t"ºKljmzxpÂq]j}i'b*baªiplU~Qx5b*~µxª}jmsx5t}lUi°¶jkq/ik® ^t}z5t}pbap1jmz ® ( ,X]j*bLsb**ba8pzq {|st}{'t ib*~ jozxUbkjms[t}{|px`xÅ©jmpx5t}µ`Lbap]Ut/~ x8x|³p]Ub'b*ipibaptm¦X{jms jm`Lbapbasi[pt³t}|p jmx p]Ub`djOnQx`l|`¬{t i ix|z5b K«il|Quvb*apx+b Mº8ljmzxp´q¡jmU~S]j}ix`{|z5ba`Lba8pb*~§xp1xS¢|sb*ba{|]Ut}Ub ® Qjm|Ub* [bapÀjmz ® ( ,{|st}{t ibXjÛba°ª¢£X¤ i ]Uba`Lbp]jmpBp]UbaqD]jkbÄkjmzz5b*~Âi{b*b* ]{|st}{'basp´q j}i b*~¢£X¤D°±]|x5]Yj}~mu lUipiXp]UbHjm`Lt}l|Kp,tm¦j}~|~|b*~sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq¯j}~Ujm{|pxbazqdptp]UbD{|st}{ baspx5b*itm¦p]UbYi{'b*b*]@ix jmz ¡^jmU~¸lUib*iLt}Qub*apxbyº8ljmzxp´q²ip jmU~Ujms~QxÅkb*~ ( p *+, `Lbkj}il|sb*i pt¯ba jmzljmpbjmlU~Qx5toº8ljmzxp´q®w"ba/q"jmU~µQj j}~Uj*°±Ox (ca ,(lUibs j}~Qx<jmz(j}ix5i¦«l|Uapx5t}UiHUbal|s jmz UbapÂ°Xt}sQi±¦¨t}s,{|sb*~Qx5apx|di{'b*b*]"ºKljmzxpÂq® p]|x5iH{jm{'basD°¶bLj}~|~Qsb*iiHp]Ub{|st}|z5ba` tm¦^jmlU~Qx5t¯º8ljmzxp´ql|U~|basp]Ub1`Lb*~Qx<j í{b*a5x & ¢£X¤@i ]Uba`Lb~|ba{|x5apb*~¯x³¢Àx l|sbQ®ÁµbHba jmzljmpb[jmjmzq8px5kjmzzqp]Ub[jmlU~Qx5t1º8ljmzxp´q¯jmp^p]Ub ~|b*ipxjmpx5t}:j}i[j¦Ãl|Uapx5t}µtm¦^p]Ub{jms jm`Lbapbasitm¦¶p]Ub¢£X¤ i ]Uba`Lb ¡Btm¦Xp]Ubj}ix5LjmlU~Qx5t Wt©° jmU~tm¦¶p]Ub1Ubap´°Xt}s'®[\^]Ub{'basv¦«t}s`djmU*btm¦Äp]|x5i¢£X¤¿i ]Uba`Lb]j}iDb*ba ba jmzljmpb*~ /x<jSix`l|z<jmpx5t}Ui (ckQ¡Dck ,´¡jmU~pt8t}z5i¯zxb¢|sb*ba{|]Ut}Ub:jmU~fDjmp¯]j*bx`{|z5ba`LbaKpb*~ xpk® E. . "!#$.

(23) * *-,

(24) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / *. (ck ,´¡Bp]Ubdjml|p]Ut}si{|st}{'t ibptYxUasbkj}ibp]UbdtEibap'bap´°¶b*ba:p]UbLt}sx xjmzX{j}bapjmU~ xpiosb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq® \^]Ubaqaz<jmx` p]jmpop]Ubz5t iio{|st/*b*iiox5io|l|sip´q@jmU~p]8lUik¡ xUasbkj}ix| p]Ubt EibapH*t}l|z5~ xb'bappbasH{basv¦¨t}s`djmU*b1p]jm]j*/x|³p]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq{|z<j}*b*~xp]Ub {j} bap¦¨t}zz5tk°±x|1x``Lb*~Qx<jmpbazqp]Ub,t}sx xjmz U/]Utk°¶babask¡8p]Ubaq~Qx5~Q6 pX{|st}{t ibDjmKqLjmjmzq/px5 b>nQ{|sb*iix5t}³p]jmp {bas`xpi ptiplU~Qqp]Ub[x`{j}ap tm¦p]|x5i i{j}ax|dt}Yp]UbjmlU~Qx5tdºKljmzxpÂq® Áµb,lUib {|st}jm|xzx5ipx5 `Lbap]Ut/~|i^jmU~jjmzz5t}pXp]Ub*t}sba8` ( mp ,pt &UU~jmob>n/{|zx5axp^b>nQ{|sb*i ix5t}¦¨t}s¶p]UbHjmlU~Qx5tº8ljmzxp´qx¯p]UbDkj}i bDtm¦jbaUbas jmz¾t Eibap¶Ut}pÛb**b*ii jmsxzqb*º8ljmz'ptt}Ub ® Áµb,lUib,jix`{|z5b^¦«l|Uapx5t}L¦¨t}s(p]Ub jmlU~Qx5tºKljmzxpÂq1{|st}{'t}spx5t}jmzpt[p]Ub±t}zl|`Lb tm¦¾~Ujmp jH°¶b sb**baxb ®,ÁµbkjmzzBp]|x5iHj , j * ±l|pxzxpÂq³¦Ãl|Uapx5t}¾® Y l|s sb*il|zpiDi]Utk° p]jmp °¶b1jmz°^j*qQiDz5t ib xYº8ljmzxp´qo°±xp]Yp]|x5i±ix`{|z5b¢£¶¤i]Uba`Lb ®X/t}`Lbix`xz<jms±UbaKjmpxbsb*il|zpi±]jkbjmzsbkj}~Qq 'b*ba¯t}|p jmxUb*~¯lUix|Ljmjmzq8px5kjmz'pt/t}z5iÄ¦¨t}s¶`Lt}sbDi t}{|]|x5ipx5kjmpb*~¯`Lb*~Qx<jxU~|ba{baU~|ba8p,¢£¶¤ i ]Uba`Lb*ik¡ib*b ( */¡Äc¡c c ,´®¯\^]Ub¦ j}ap[p]jmp°¶bjmz°^j*qQiz5t/t ib8qªj}~|~Qx|"¢£X¤kjm:bd~QlUb pti babas jmzE¦¨j}apt}s+i ]JKÃx M¶p]Ub¢£X¤x5i^xUb dax5baKpk¡ KÃxx MXp]Ub`Lt/~|bazx|dtm¦p]Ub~Qq8jm`x5*i x5i^x j}~|b*º8ljmpb y¡ KÃxxx MXp]Ub`Lt/~|bazx|dtm¦p]Ubl|pxzxp´qo¦«l|Uapx5t}³x5i±xj}~|b*ºKljmpb ®Áµb[b>n|jm`xUbHp]Ub*i b {'t}xKpixµp]Ubdp´°Xt"z<j}ipi b*apx5t}Uitm¦±p]UbL{jm{'bask® ª{jmspx5al|z<jmsk¡°Xbdb>nQpbaU~µp]Ubojmjmzq/ix5i ptybaUbas jmz¶i bas8x5*bdpx`Lb*ik¡(jmU~:jmjmzq/Åkbdp]Ubdp]Ubdkj}ibtm¦,`l|zpx{|z5b>nQx|'bap´°¶b*baSi babas jmz x|{|l|p Wtk°,i KÃp]UbjmlU~Qx5t Wtk°jmU~ojmb>n|t}baUt}lUPi Wt©° M>®Áµb i]Ut©°¸p]jmp¶babadp]Uba¾¡Qj}~|~Qx| ¢£X¤ z5bkj}~|ipt³{'t8t}s{'basv¦«t}s`djmU*b ¡jmzp]Ut}l| ]µxªi t}`LbLkj}ib*i°¶bL~|t³t}UibasbLit}`LbLKjmx¾® Áµbp]Uba:i]Utk° p]jmp[¦«t}s[t}p]Ubas[l|pxzxpÂq¦Ãl|Uapx5t}Ui1j}i{|st}{t i b*~ Kqµ8]Uba|bas ( - ,´¡j}~|~Qx| ¢£X¤½kjmYx`{|stkbil|Uip jmKpx<jmzzq¯p]Ub{'basv¦¨t}s`djmU*b ® Gzp]Ut}l| ]Yp]Ub*ibz<j}ip±sb*il|zpi(uvlUipx ¦Ãq p]UblUib[tm¦(`Lb*~Qx<j í{'b*a5x &¢£X¤)¦«t}spbaz5ba{|]Ut}Kqyt©bas KpbasUbapk¡°Xbbazx5babp]jmp p]Ub{t/t}s {'basv¦¨t}s`djmU*bdtm¦±¢£¶¤ lUix|yp]UbLzxUbkjms[l|pxzxp´q¦«l|Uapx5t}ªx5ij³t8t/~ xU~Qx5kjmpx5t}ªp]jmpp]Ub `Lb*~Qx<j í{b*a5x &¢£X¤ x5i xUb dax5ba8pk¡¾jmU~"i]Ut}l|z5~"'b[sba{|z<j}*b*~KqY`Lt}sb1b dax5baKpt}Ub*~i U°¶b ~Qx5i alUii±p]|x5i±x5iilUbHx³`Lt}sb[~|bap jmxzBx³p]Ub[*t}UazlU~Qx|oib*apx5t}¾® \^]UbÄ{jm{'basÀx5it}sKjm|xÅkb*~j}iÀ¦«t}zz5t©°,ik¡mx/b*apx5t}L °Xb¶~|b*iasxbXp]UbXbaUbas jmzQi *bajmsx5t,¦¨t}s jm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Ui¶lUix|1¢£X¤D¡/jmU~d°XbD~|7b &UUbjºKljmzxpÂq¦Ãl|Uapx5t}o°±]|x5]o°X2b zzlUib,p]|st}l| ]Ut}l|p `Lt ipHtm¦¶p]Ubsb*iptm¦Xp]Ub{jm{'bask® ª/b*apx5t}ªo°XbiplU~Qq"p]Ubix`{|z5bkj}ib1°±]Ubasb{j}bap ¹¯» akjmssx5b*iHsb*~Ql|U~Ujm8p[xQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}:tm¦Ä{j}bap[¹$j}iil|`x|yjm 9a º8lUbalUbax| `Lt/~|baz ® §/b*apx5t}ª"°Xbdi t}zbLp]UbL{|st}|z5ba` xªp]UbdbaUbas jmz¶kj}ibL°±]Ubasbd{j} bap1¹Y»½¼ kjmssx5b*iDsb*~Ql|U~Ujm8pxQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t} tm¦Ä{j} bapH¹ª°±xp] ¼ ma®Áµbz5t/t}Yxµ/b*apx5t} djmpDp]Ub º8ljmzxp´qyx"p]Ub1kj}ib1tm¦Äx &U|xpbi{j}ax|³

(25) ¼ )®Áµbjmjmzq8Åkbp]Ubkj}i btm¦Ä`l|zpx{|z5b>n/x| 'bap´°¶b*ba"ibabas jmzBx|{|l|`p Wtk°,ni KÃp]UbjmlU~Qx5t Wtk° jmU~yjmyb>n|t}baUt}lUì Wtk° M^x/b*apx5t} }Q® /b*apx5t} *°¶b±{|st}{'t ib¶p]Ub^lUib±tm¦~Q5x EbasbaKpl|pxzxpÂq1¦Ãl|Uapx5t}Ui(ptt}|p jmxdjHº8ljmzxp´q¦«l|Uapx5t} p]jmp~|ba{baU~|iDt}Yp]Ub[ ]jms j}apbasx5ipx5*iHtm¦p]Ub1jm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}¾®¶Áµb[{|sb*iba8pit}`Lb[*t}UazlU~Qx| sba`djmsQi±x/b*apx5t}Q®. 1Ê;.

(26) ',51 * * +** 1 * / . :j¯z<jmsbdUbap´°¶t}s:j}ip]Ub 8pbasUbapk¡jXWtk° tm¦^{j} bapiast iib*ii babas jmzÄst}l|pbasib>¦¨t}sb sbkj} ]|x|"p]Ubdt}p]UbasbaU~E®¯w"t iptm¦±p]UbLz5t iib*i¦Ãst}` jWtk° t8*al|sxµp]UbLst}l|pbas]j*/x| p]UbHi`djmzz5b*ip j* jmxz<jm|z5bHjmU~Q°±x5~Qp]Yx¯p]UbD ]jmxytm¦Bst}l|pbasik¡|i tp]jmp,t}UbD`djkq`Lt/~|baz'p]Ub °±]Ut}z5bH ]jmx¯tm¦Àst}l|pbasiX8qt}UbDix| z5bst}l|pbas^kjmzz5b*~ p 3?5 2o#3035QC57>

(27) ®\^]|x5i±j}iil|`{|px5t} ]j}it}p]ªp]Ub*t}sbapx5kjmz^jmU~:b>n/{'basx`LbaKp jmz ( Qy¡ }-,¾uvlUip5x &kjmpx5t}¾®¯ÁµbLi]jmzzXlUibp]UbLix`{|z5b 9a º8lUbalUbÄpt `Lt8~|baz8p]UbÄUbapÂ°Xt}sjmU~p]KlUiÀp]UbÄz5t i i¾{|st/*b*iiÀtm¦jmlU~Qx5t{j}bapik® t}p]Ubas^°¶t}s~|ik¡Q°Xbj}iil|`Lbp]jmp^{j}bapi jmssxbjmp^p]Ubt}ppz5baUb* ¯j}**t}s~Qx|ptj1rÀt}x5ii t} {|st/*b*iiÀtm¦Qx8pbaUixp´q B¡}jmU~[°Xb¶j}iil|`LbÄp]jmpBp]Ub(px`LbÄsb*ºKl|xsb*~pt,{|st/*b*iiÀj^{j} bapjmpBp]Ub 't}ppz5baUb*x5iÀ~Qx5ipsx|l|pb*~j}**t}s~Qx|pt jm1b>n/{'t}UbaKpx<jmz8s jmU~|t}`¿ jmsx<jm|z5bÄtm¦|{jms jm`Lbapbas (® \^]UbrÀt}x5ii t}j}iil|`{|px5t}"t}Yp]UbxKpbas Âjmssx jmzpx`Lb*i *t}l|z5~Y'b¶uvlUip5x &b*~³Kq¯p]Ubs jmU~|t}` ~|baz<jkqoj}~|~|b*~opt{j}bapi^KqUt}st}l|pbasi^z5t/kjmpb*~ol|{Uipsbkjm` p]Ub 't}ppz5baUb*'®\^]UbHibas/x5*b px`Lbsba{|sb*i baKpi³p]Ubpx`Lb'bap´°¶b*ba p]Ubba x||x|¸tm¦1p]Ubps jmUi`x5iix5t}½tm¦jmjmlU~Qx5t {j} bapt}p]Ub't}ppz5baUb*xKpbasv¦ j}*bz5bkj}~Qx|³ptp]Ub1~|b*ipxjmpx5t} l|Kpxzp]Ub1ba x||x|³tm¦ p]Ubps jmUi`x5iix5t}otm¦¾p]UbUb>n/p¶{j}bap¶¦«st}` p]UbDi jm`LbHjmlU~Qx5t Wt©°[®X8xU*bp]Ub pÂ°Xt{j}bapi `djkq"'bi{j}*b*~µjm{jmsp8qjos jmU~|t}` 8l|`'bastm¦^{j}bapiH¦«st}` t}p]Ubasjm{|{|zx5kjmpx5t}Uik¡Àt}Ub `djkqLlUibp]Ubb>nQ{'t}UbaKpx<jmzE~Qx5ipsx|l|px5t}Yj}i±jkjmU~Qx5~Ujmpb¦¨t}sX`Lt/~|bazx|p]Ubibas/x5*bpx`Lbtm¦ jmlU~Qx5tY{j}bapijmpp]Ubt}ppz5baUb* ®\^]Ubsbkj}it} ¦¨t}s[]Ut/t ix|"p]|x5i[ix`{|zx5ipx5`Lt/~|baz(¦¨t}s p]UbHUbapÂ°Xt}s¯x5i^pt'bHjm|z5bHptt}|p jmx"ix`{|z5bH`djmp]Uba`djmpx5kjmz¾¦¨t}s`l|z<j}i±p]jmp± xbHlUi it}`Lb xUix ]Kpi t}³p]Ub[Kjmx³¦Ãst}`·lUix|d¢£X¤D® bap 'bp]UbHx8pbaUixp´q³tm¦(jmlU~Qx5tps -j d ®¢Ut}s a¡Qp]UbHz5t ii^{|st}jm|xzxp´q³tm¦j {j} bap xYipbkj}~Qq¯ip jmpbx5i, xbaYKq (ck , aO_ Kv+c M aO_ jmU~³¦«t}s axp,x5i,b*º8ljmzEpt . . .

(28) . . . . . . . . a. ·». a. $t©° °¶b j}~|~@sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqpt$bkj}]){j}bap³x jª°¶jkq@p]jmp¯x ¦1j:{j}bap³x5ioz5t ipk¡ xp kjm'bipxzz ´{jmspx<jmzzqsbapsx5bab*~x ¦Äp]Ub1{j}bap*t}8p jmx|x|YxpiDsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqyx5iDUt}pHz5t ipk® \^]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqx5iHz5t/kjmpb*~ª¼µ{j} bapijm{jmspH¦«st}`p]Ubt}sx xjmz({j}bapk® p*t}Uix5ipix j³z5tk° º8ljmzxp´qµ*t}{8qtm¦±p]UbLt}sx xjmzX{j}bapk® bap 'bp]Ubs jmpx5t"tm¦^p]UbLt}zl|`Lbdtm¦^p]Ub sb*~Ql|U~Ujm8pxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}jmU~1p]Ub^t}zl|`Lb±tm¦p]Ub±t}sx xjmz|{j}bapk® Yx5ibaUbas jmzzqz5b*i ip]jm t}Ub n® Gz5t}|³°±xp] p]Ub{t iix|xzxp´qptsbapsx5babLp]UbxQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}µz5t ipDx p]UbUbapÂ°Xt}s'¡¾°¶b i]Ut}l|z5~o*t}Uix5~|bas±p]UbUbaKjmpxbHx`{j}api tm¦Àp]Ubj}~|~Qxpx5t}Ytm¦¢£X¤@t}³p]UbDz5t ii¶{|st}jm|xzxp´q® \^]|x5ij}~|~Qxpx5t}$`dj*qµ]jkb³jmªx`{j}apt}ªp]Uboibas/x5*bdpx`Lb*i1ixU*b{j}bapisb*º8l|xsbdUt©° . !. "!. "!#$.

(29) * *-,

(30) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / . . `Lt}sb[px`LbptbHsbaps jmUi`xppb*~"jmp±p]Ub[t}l|p{|l|p tm¦p]Ub't}ppz5baUb*'® p±`dj*qYjmz5it]j*bjm x`{j}apt}µp]Ub|l Ebasx|ykjm{j}axp´qªjmpp]Ub't}ppz5baUb*µixU*bLbkj}]µ{j} bapUt©° *t}Kp jmxUi `Lt}sb¶|xpik®ÀÁµbî]jmzz/p]KlUi{|st}{'t ibÄp]UbX¦¨t}zz5tk°±x|pÂ°XtD{t i ix|z5bÄUbaKjmpxb^x`{j}api(tm¦¢£¶¤D¡ xYt}s~|bas ptLiplU~Qqoz<jmpbas,p]Ubps j}~|b*t bapÂ°Xb*ba"p]UbH{t ixpxbjmU~³UbaKjmpxbx`{j}ap~i ] | Ë Ë Ç # Ã Ç Ç Áµbj}iil|`Lbp]jmpDjmlU~Qx5tL{j} bapi xUazlU~Qx| sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq sb*ºKl|xsbdUtk° j³z5t}|basibas/x5*bLpx`Lb°±]|x5 ]:x5ib>n/{'t}UbaKpx<jmzzqµ~Qx5ipsx l|pb*~y°±xp]{jms jm`Lbapbas ®,\^]|x5ikjm'b[p]Ub1kj}ib[°±]Ubat}l|sHjmlU~Qx5t Wtk° ]j}iHjm x`{t}sp jm8pdi]jmsb³tm¦p]U b¯' t} ppz5baUb*SjmU~Q°±x5~Qp]¾® ¦xpx5iUt}pp]Ub³kj}ib ¡p]|x5ij}i il|`{|px5t}okjmo]Ut}z5~o°±]Ubap]UbDb>n|t}baUt}lUiXps -j djmp¶p]Ub 't}ppz5baUb* K«t}s^jmp¶z5bkj}ip^jm x`{t}sp jm8p[{jmsp[tm¦Xx;p Mx5iD¦¨t}s`Lb*~ tm¦^jmlU~Qx5Xt Wt©°,ip]jmpx`{|z5ba`LbaKpp]Ub1i jm`Lb¢£¶¤ i]Uba`Lb ® {| st8 *b*|~Ql| sbË xyt} U btmË ¦()p]U b ¦¨t} zÇz5tk °± x|

(31) °¶\^jk]Uq/b~i ]z5t Kvi+c iM {|8sxt}U*jmb|{xzj}xp´qyba°±piHxzzÀjmsb[b1Uj t©'°b*az5pt}b*|~"baKs qy8pqy]|x5j i ¦¨j}apt}s a^» ¡°Xb1kjm"*t}Uix5~|basDp]jmpDp]Ubjm`Lt}l|Kptm¦|l Ebasx|dx5iD~Qx`x|x5i]Ub*~"Kq p]|x5iº8ljmKpxpÂq¡t}/s K¨p MÁµbkjm§j}iil|`Lbdp]jmpp]Uboº8lUbalUbkjm{j}axpÂqµx5iUt}p¦«l|Uapx5t} tm¦D{j} bapdz5ba| p]¾¡¶|l|pLs jmp]Ubasdtm¦HKl|`basotm¦D{j} bapik® §p]jmpdkj}ib ¡¶p]Ub³º8lUbalUb kjm{j}axp´qox5iÛt}p j 'b*apb*~¯8qdxUibaspx|L¢£X¤D®|\^]UbHz5t ii^{|st}jm|xzxpÂq¯xop]UbH{|sb*i baU*b tm¦¢£X¤p jmb*i,p]UbH¦«t}s`·xU~Qx5kjmpb*~yxy£ºJ® K¨p M>® . . !". . °±]Ubasb ¡ . . . aJ_. !. . aO_. . a¶». . a¶». . . . . !. K¨pM. ¨¦ t}s,kj}ib)Kvc+M>¡ K¨pM ¦«t}s kj}i b)K¨pM>® ¶b>¦¨t}sbH°Xb~|b7&UUbp]UbºKljmzxpÂqotm¦jmlU~Qx5tsb**baxb*~yjmp±p]Ub~|b*ipxjmpx5t}¾¡U°XbHx8pst8~QlU*b1j s jmU~|t}` }jmsx<jm|z5bdp]jmp±xU~Qx5kjmpb*iDjilU**b*ii¦Ãl|z¾jmssx jmzBtm¦(j1{j} bapDjmp±p]Ub~|b*ipxjmpx5t} t}s±Ut|®Ä\^]Uba¾¡ . !. 1Ê;. x ¦{j} bap ¹x5i±z5t ipk¡UjmU~ . a. . x ¦{j} bap ¹x5i,*t}ssb*apzq¯sb**baxb*~E®.

(32) ',51 * * +** 1 * /. ck. bap¼³'bDp]UbD}jmsx<jm|z5bHxU~Qx5kjmpx|Lp]Ub~Qx5ip jmU*bHbapÂ°Xb*baYp]UbHt}sx xjmz¾{j} bap jmU~¯xpi sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq®ÄÁµb`djmbp]Ub[ix`{|z5b[j}iil|`{|px5t}yp]jmp±p]UbjmlU~Qx5tLºKljmzxpÂq¯x5i±{|st}{t}spx5t}jmz ptDp]Ub,jm`Lt}l|8pÄtm¦xQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}L°Xb^sb**baxb*~E® G@ºKljmzxpÂqoc^xU~Qx5kjmpb*ip]jmp(°Xb,jmsb^sb**bax/x| jmzz/p]UbXxQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}8 KÃp]Ub¶j}ix5^jmlU~Qx5Ot Wt©° M>®\^]UbXº8ljmzxp´q°XbXbap(jO¦«pbasp]UbÄsb**t}UipslUapx5t} tm¦¾jmdt}sx xjmz{j}bapX¦Ãst}` p]Ub,sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqx5i(p jmbab*º8ljmzUpt X¡°±]Ubasb yx5ip]Ub,s jmpx5t[tm¦ sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq"t}zl|`Lbptt}sx xjmz({j} bapt}zl|`Lb ®HÁµb1p]KlUi~|7b &UUb1p]UbºKljmzxpÂqY¦«l|Uapx5t} j}i©¡ !. !. . a_. . . a. !". '» . a a_! !. . a . !. . . . KÃ9M. \^]|x5idb*º8ljmpx5t}¸ xb*iLlUidp]Ub"jmlU~Qx5t:ºKljmzxpÂqSt}p¯jmpLp]Uby~|b*ipxjmpx5t}¸l|U~|basojµ¢£¶¤ i ]Uba`Lb¶tm¦Us jmpbOaK» X¡KjmU~tm¦~Qx5ip jmU*b^¼1'bap´°¶b*baLjm1t}sx xjmzQ{j}bapjmU~xpiBsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq® ¢t}s±p]UbDkj}i b Q¡|t}l|s,~|b7&U|xpx5t}¯¦¨t}s^p]UbºKljmzxpÂqo*t}xUax5~|b*i,°±xp]³p]Ub{|st}jm|xzxpÂq¯p]jmp j{j}bapÄx5iX*t}ssb*apzqsb**baxb*~E®¢Ut}sp]Ubkj}ib,tm¦ ma¡xpÄ*t}xUax5~|b*iX°±xp]dp]Ub±{|st}jm|xzxpÂq p]jmp¶p]UbxQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t}ox¯jm¯t}sx xjmz{j}bap^x5iX*t}ssb*apzqdsb**baxb*~E¡|baxp]UbasX'b*kjmlUibxpÄ°¶j}i Ut}pz5t ipk¡Bt}s'b*kjmlUibxp°^j}i¦«l|zzq"sbapsx5bab*~µ¦Ãst}` p]UbLsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq® Y Ub`djkqx`djm xUb ptylUibjmUt}p]Ubasº8ljmzxp´q ¦«l|Uapx5t}Sp]jmpp]Ubt}Ubd°¶b ]Ut ib ® ª{jmspx5al|z<jmsk¡(t}UbokjmSlUib jº8ljmzxp´qY°±]|x5 ]x5iUt}pt}|zqyj¦«l|Uapx5t} tm¦p]Ub1jm`Lt}l|8p[tm¦Ä~Ujmp jo*t}ssb*apzqYsb**baxb*~|l|p jmz5i tYtm¦¶p]Ubd*t8~Qx|"jmzt}sxp]|` lUib*~E ® 5x EbasbaKpjmzt}sxp]|`Li[]jkbL'b*baµlUib*~ x (ckU¡(c , ¦¨t}s[*t/~Qx|Yp]UbLt}sx xjmzÄ~Ujmp jYjmU~µp]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq® p]Ubsb*ip[tm¦^p]Ub{jm{'bask¡¾°XbL°±xzz lUi bHp]UbH¦«t}zz5t©°±x|LUt}p jmpx5t}V ] Áµbj}ip]Ub±¦¨t}zz5tk°±x|º8lUb*ipx5t}V ] 2

(33) 6E295 43?5À 6pD32 o A-0D A XA4À C>+3D32~C 2 ³\^]jmp^°Xt}l|z5~¯{'bas`xp±lUiXptba jmzljmpbHp]UbDbaU7b &Upi¶¦«st}`·ilU]Yjsb**tkbasqo`Lb*]jm|x5i` jmU~ªpt &UU~:p]Ubjm{|{|st}{|sx<jmpb³jm`Lt}l|Kptm¦,sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq p]jmp1`lUip'bdj}~|~|b*~:pt"bkj} ] {j} bapk® @p]UbUb>nQp³ib*apx5t}Uio°X!b &UU~p]Ub jmlU~Qx5tSº8ljmzxp´q¸¦«t}s³~Q5x EbasbaKp³ jmzlUb*i¯tm¦¼À® \^]Ubt}|zq¯`x5iix|d{jms jm`LbapbasDx5i,p]Ub{|st}jm|xzxp´qYp]jmpp]Ub[sb*~Ql|U~Ujm8pxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}t}j {j} bap^x5i¶*t}ssb*apzqsb**baxb*~o xbaop]jmp¶p]UbD{j}bap^xpibaz ¦Bx5iXz5t ipk®(\^]|x5i¶x5i¶p]Ub {jms jm`Lbapbas a xª£º® KÃ9 M>® µp]Ub¦¨t}zz5tk°±x|ib*apx5t}Ui°Xbd{|l|pt}l|sibazb*ix p]Ub ip jmpx5t}jmsqosba x`LbjmU~³°Xb[kjmz5al|z<jmpbp]|x5i±{|st}jm|xzxp´q®. 1 ,% Yp]|x5iib*apx5t}y°¶b1jmjmzq/Åkb[p]Ubkj}ib°±]Ubasb[p]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmKpHxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}t}Y{j} bapD¹µx5i kjmssx5b*~dKq{j}bap¶¹» a¡x ® b ®¡/¼ a®\^]|x5i`Lb* ]jm|x5i` x5ix`{|z5ba`LbaKpb*~¯b ® U®x (ck- ,´®\^]Ub !. !. !. . ). !. . !. . . "!#$.

(34) * *-,

(35) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / . c c. \Àjm|z5bLc^] $Dt}p jmpx5t}YlUib*~¯xyp]|x5i±{jm{bask® Ç k Ë Ç Ë \^]UbjmlU~Qx5tLºKljmzxpÂq® ¼ \^]Ubt 'ibap±'bap´°¶b*bayp]Ub[t}sx xjmzB{j}bap jmU~Yp]Ub{j}bapxUazlU~Qx|Lxpi sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq® \^]UbixÅkbtm¦p]UbºKlUbalUbûvlUip j}i±xp i ~|7b &UUb*~ x"£ºJ® K¨p M>® \^]Ub[s jmU~|t}` jmsx<jm|z5b°±]|x5]Ysba{|sb*i baKpi p]Ub[Kl|`'bastm¦{j}bapi xYp]Ub[iqQipba` uvlUip±'b>¦«t}sbHp]Ubjmssx}jmzBtm¦p]Ub p] jmlU~Qx5tL{j}bapk® \^]Ub[s jmU~|t}` jmsx<jm|z5b°±]|x5]Ysba{|sb*i baKpi p]Ub[Kl|`'bastm¦(ibas/x5*b*i±'bap´°Xb*ba"p]Ub jmssx jmz5i tm¦p]U b n_ a p]"jmU~³p]Ub p] jmlU~Qx5tL{j}bap

(36) i O® . !. $. ^ %. H;[5". . . = [5". S+". #"$[ %'R$"G >5@BH;>. . . >5F]IV(D& )"_QYZ"a% BR$FS+()" &RGR$SD[. Y. @)%F'". %. >5@+" ID >5"GP. 1)&N> & +F]I. . % "GP. . [5",HNFB#"X[ D%'R$"$. y . `+SD>. @. )>I ;>5@S+ H;> >5@+"" B(. HNF#&. &;>5". >5%'HNFB#"$[ %'R$"G. &;= #S+R7@VH#"$[ % RX". )&. BHNR7\"X>. >5@)"G#". F",H "$Gg. {|st}jm|xzxpÂqp]jmpp]Ub^sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqx5i(*t}ssb*apzq1sb**baxb*~L xbap]jmpp]Ub±t}sx xjmzU{j}bapÄx5i z5t ipk¡x5iUtt}p]UbasÄp]jmp]Ub,{|st}jm|xzxp´qp]jmpÄp]Ub Ub>n/pÄbaba8p^jO¦«pbasÄp]Ub,z5t iiÄtm¦¾p]Ubt}sx xjmz {j} bap x5i,j~|ba{jmspl|sb1jmU~¯Ut}pjm"jmssx jmz ®\^]|x5i±]jm{|{'baUi,°±xp]³{|st}jm|xzxpÂq¡ . . . . a . . . 8l|Uipxpl|px| K pMXx=KÃ9M>¡U°Xb[t}|p jmx. . a¶». a. '». !. a. K#pM . #. aJ_. #"paO_. !". !. !. . 1Ê;. . !". . a^». !. '»|a%$ \Bt1iplU~QqLp]Ubx`{j}ap^tm¦B¢£X¤@t}op]UbDjmlU~Qx5t1º8ljmzxp´q¡Q°Xb{|z5t}p Äj}i¶j[¦«l|Uapx5t} tm¦ ¦«t}sL~Qx5EbasbaKpL jmzlUb*iLtm¦ jmU~ ® ²¢x l|sbYQ¡X°XbYi]Utk°·p]U& b³sb*il|zpiL°±]Uba§p]Ub |l Ebasx|dkjm{j}axpÂq³jmp p]UbHt}ppz5baUb* ³x5i,j}iil|`Lb*~³pt ]jm|b[°±xp]Yp]Ub[jm`Lt}l|8ptm¦(¢£¶¤D¡ jmU~µxª¢xU®Y°Xbi]Utk° p]Ubsb*il|zpi¦¨t}sp]UbLkj}ibL°±]Ubasbp]Ub|l Ebasx|"kjm{j}axp´q x5i[Ut}p ]jm|b*~E®:\^]Ub¯pÂ°Xt kj}ib*iLjmsb³~|b*i asxb*~Sx¸/b*apx5t}@Q® Áµb³ib*bop]jmpk¡¦«t}s't}p]$kj}i b*ik¡ jmlU~Qx5tyºKljmzxpÂq~|bapbasx5t}s jmpb*i1°±]Uba @xUasbkj}ib*Xi KÃ°±]Ubaª°¶bdj}~|~ `Lt}sbLsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq M>¡jmU~ p]|x5i~|bapbasx5t}s jmpx5t} 'b**t}`Lb*i`Lt}sb1x`{'t}sp jmKp°±]Uba p]Ub1ps -j dxKpbaUixpÂq"xUasbkj}i b*i[jmU~ !. !. . !" .

(37) ',51 * * +** 1 * /. ck ρ = 0.1. 0.9995 0.999 0.9985 K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.998 0.9975. ρ = 0.6. 1 Audio quality Q(α). Audio quality Q(α). 1. 0.9 0.8 0.7 K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.6 0.5. 0.997 0. 0.2. 0.8. 1. 0. ρ = 0.9. 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.6 0.5 0. 0.2. 0.2. 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. 0.8. 1. ρ = 1.5. 1 Audio quality Q(α). Audio quality Q(α). 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5. 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. 0.8. 1. 0. 0.2. 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. 0.8. 1. ¢ x l|sb ]X¼ a1jmU~³p]UbºKlUbalUbkjm{j}axp´q¯x5i,]jm|b*~E® °±]Uba¯p]UbH|l Ebas±ixÅkbH~|b*asbkj}ib*ik®(\^]UbD`djmx³xKpbas{|sbap jmpx5t}tm¦ÀilU]³'ba]j*/x5t}s^x5i^p]jmp^p]Ub z5t i iX{|st}jm|xzxpÂqotm¦Àjm³t}sx xjmz'{j}bap±xUasbkj}i b*i^°±xp] ¦¨j}ipbas¶p]jm¯p]UbDKjmxox¯º8ljmzxp´q °¶bdt}p¦«st}` sbapsx5ba/x|"p]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmKpxQ¦¨t}s`djmpx5t}¾®"\^]|x5ii]Ut}l|z5~ªUt}p'bdil|s{|sx5ix|U® U~|b*b*~E¡(baba$x:`Lt}sboit}{|]|x5ipx5kjmpb*~$i ]Uba`Lb*ix:°±]|x5 ]²jyix| z5bsb*~Ql|U~UjmKp{j} bapx5i j}~|~|b*~:ptY{|st}pb*apj³°±]Ut}z5b|z5t/µtm¦ {j}bapi©¡xpx5i[/Utk°±Sp]jmp¢£¶¤tm¦«pba:]j}i1jm t©bas jmzz|UbaKjmpxb±7b 'b*apk¡ i b*b ( *Q¡/c¡/c c ,´® ÄbapxilU ]Li]Uba`Lb*ip]Ub¶UbaKjmpxb±7b Eb*aptm¦Ej}~|~Qx| p]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqYx5i i`djmzz5basp]jmt}l|si ]Uba`Lb ¡ixU*b[p]Ubjm`Lt}l|8pDtm¦Xj}~|~|b*~yxQ¦«t}s`djmpx5t} {'bas[{j} bapx5ii`djmzz5bas K«ixU*bjYix| z5b{j}bap{|st}pb*api1j³°±]Ut}z5bL st}l|{:tm¦ {j}bap;i M>® $Dt}pbD]Utk°¶babask¡Up]jmp^¦¨t}sîlU]Yi ]Uba`Lb*i±°XbH/Utk°½p]jmp±x³kj}ibtm¦zx ]Kp±ps -j dHp]Ubtkbas jmzz *t}8psx|l|px5t}tm¦¢£X¤x5i {t ixpx)b (c ¡¾c c ,´®X\^]|x5i,`Lt}px jmpb*i,lUi,ptjmjmzq8Åkb`Lt}sb{|sb*ax5ibazq p]UbHx`{j}apDtm¦¢£X¤)xYt}l|s ix`{|zx5ipx5[i ]Uba`LbxYkj}ibtm¦zx ]8p,ps -j d ® D7b &UUb¶p]UbX¦«l|Uapx5t} a -_ ÀjmU~*t}Uix5~|basp]Ub¶kj}i bX°±]Ubasb¶p]Ub¶|l Ebasx| kjm{j}axpÂq1jmpp]Ub¶t}ppz5baUb* x5iÀUt}p(j Eb*apb*~Kq[p]Ub±jm`Lt}l|Kp(tm¦¢£X¤D®}\^]|x5ix5ijmt}{|px`x5ipx5. !. . . . . "!#$.

(38) * *-,

(39) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / ρ = 0.1. 0.99999 0.99998 0.99997 K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.99996 0.99995. ρ = 0.6. 1 Audio quality Q(α). Audio quality Q(α). 1. ck. 0.9 0.8 0.7 K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.6 0.5. 0.99994 0. 0.2. 1. 0. ρ = 0.9. 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.6 0.5 0. 0.2. 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. 0.8. 1. ρ = 1.5. 1 Audio quality Q(α). Audio quality Q(α). 0.4 0.6 0.8 Amount of FEC α. K=5 K=10 K=20 K=50 K=1000. 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5. 0.2. 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. 0.8. 1. 0. 0.2. 0.4 0.6 Amount of FEC α. 0.8. 1. ¢ x l|sb]Ä¼ ajmU~Yp]Ub[ºKlUbalUbkjm{j}axpÂq³x5i±Ut}p ]jm|b*~E® i *bajmsx5tL°±]Ubasbxp x5ibasq³{|st}jm|z5bptib*bp]UbKjmxy|st}l| ]KpH8qY¢£¶¤D¡tm¦Ä*t}l|sibx ¦p]|x5i Kjmx"b>n/x5ipi©®ÀÁµb[]j*b ¡ aO_ m_ " a^H» »|a $ " aJ_ K }pM » J a _ $ a_ ¢ÀxU~Qx| H°Xt}l|z5~S{'bas`xplUiptba jmzljmpbp]Ub³jmlU~Qx5tº8ljmzxp´q ¦¨t}sj"basq z5t©°¸ps -j dxKpbaU i

(40) xpÂq ®(Áµb,pt/t} gxd£º`® K }pMjmU~L°¶bb>nQ{jmU~|b*~ Àx¯j\Àjkq8z5t}s i basx5b*ik®ªÁµb¦¨t}l|U~$p]jmpdjmzz±p]Ub &Usip*t8b dax5ba8pidtm¦Dp]Ub³ibasx5b*i _§jmsb b*º8ljmzpt¯Åkbast|¡jmU~ p]jmp[p]UbL*t/b dax5baKp x5iUbaKjmpxbdjmU~µb*º8ljmzpt _ ® ^x5i p]Ub*t/b dax5baKpDtm¦ x5i±p]Ub\Àjkq8z5t}sDibasx5b*i,tm¦ ¶jmU~ykjm³bkjmz5al|z<jmpb*~yKq. .

(41) . .

(42) .

(43) .

(44) . . . . . . . . . . 1Ê;. . ! . . . . .

(45) . .

(46) ',51 * * +** 1 * /. ca. ^\ ]KlUik¡¦¨t}sDi`djmzz ¡ ,kjmb°±sxppbaµj}in_ » ,jmU~p]UbKjmx¦«st}` p]Ub1j}~|~Qxpx5t} tm¦Ä¢£¶¤ kjmb*t}Uix5~|basb*~j}i UbaKjmpxb ®Á@xp]p]|x5iDix`{|z5b¢£X¤i ]Uba`Lb ¡ °¶bDz5t ibDx³jmlU~Qx5tº8ljmzxp´q°±]Ubayj}~|~Qx|¢£¶¤baba¦¨t}s,jbasqLz5tk°½ps j-dHx8pbaUixp´q®X\^]|x5i z5t i i±xYºKljmzxpÂq³~|b*asbkj}ib*i,°±xp]Yp]UbHxUasbkj}i bxY|l Ebas,ixÅkb ® (+ ¯%À ,% D $Dtk°[¡O°XbX*t}Uix5~|basBp]UbÄ`Lt}sbbaUbas jmz/kj}ib(°±]Ubasbp]UbXi{j}ax|,'bap´°¶b*bap]UbXt}sx xjmzK{j}bap jmU~xpiHsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaqx5iD sbkjmpbasp]jm²c ®[\^]Ub1x5~|bkjoba]|xU~p]|x5iHp´q/{'b1tm¦¶i{j}ax|³x5iDp]jmp z5t i ib*ix:sbkjmzXUbapÂ°Xt}sQipbaU~ªptjm{|{'bkjmsxS|l|sipijmU~ªp]8lUi1i{j}ax|"p]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq ¦«st}` p]Ub¶t}sx xjmz|{j} bap(Kq`Lt}sbXp]jmt}Ub¶{j}bap(x`{|st©b*i(p]Ub¶{|st}jm|xzxp´q1ptDsbapsx5bab xpDx kj}ib1p]Ubt}sx xjmz{j} bapx5iHz5t ipk® U~|b*b*~E¡¾jL{j} bapz5t iiD`LbkjmUiHp]jmpDp]Ubº8lUbalUb1x5i ¦«l|zzjmU~¸p]Uba@p]Uby{|st}jm|xzxp´q¸tm¦[z5t ix|:p]UbYUb>nQpL{j}bap¯x5id]|x ]Ubasdp]jmp]Ubyipbkj}~Qq ip jmpb{|st}jm|xzxpÂqµtm¦Xz5t ix|yj{j} bapk®\^]Ubi{j}ax|³ xb*ip]Ubsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq tm¦^j{j}bap `Lt}sb³ ]jmU*bYp!t &UU~²jUt}$¦«l|zz±|l 'basdjmpp]Ub¯'t}ppz5baUb*'¡±jmU~$p]KlUipt'b³*t}ssb*apzq sb**baxb*~E®ÁµbHUt}pbHp]jmp±p]UbH{|]UbaUt}`LbaUt}ytm¦Àp]Ub*t}ssbaz<jmpx5t}Y'bap´°¶b*bayz5t ii b*i¶tm¦{j}bapi °^j}ijmzsbkj}~Qqª`Lt/~|baz5b*~$jmU~$iplU~Qx5b*~Sx$t}p]Ubas{jm{bas~i ] ( */¡Xc¡¶c c ,´®w"bkj}il|sba`LbaKpi]jkb jmz5i ti]Utk°±Yp]jmp `Lt ip tm¦p]UbHz5t iib*i jmsb[*t}ssbaz<jmpb*~ ( |¡UQ¡Qc ,´® zbasb ¡|°¶bjmsbx8pbasb*ipb*~Yx &UU~Qx|dp]Ub{|st}jm|xzxpÂq³p]jmp {j}bapD¹d»²¼"x5i±z5t ip xba p]jmp {j}bap¹x5i jmz5i tz5t ipk®(\^]|x5i,°±xzzB xblUi a Ä°±]|x5 ]yxYpl|sy xb*i lUi,p]Ub[b>n/{|sb*i ix5t}³¦¨t}s,p]UbjmlU~Qx5tLº8ljmzxp´q K«£º®9 M>®^8xU*b°Xb1j}iil|`Lbp]jmp,p]Ubiq/ipba`·x5i xdxpiÄipbkj}~Qqip jmpb ¡K°Xb kjmt}`xpÄp]Ub±xU~|b>nL¹yjmU~Lil|Uipxpl|pb,xp8qÅkbast|® bap ~|baUt}pb p]Ub1|l EbasixÅkb1jO¦«pbasHp]Ubj}~|~Qxpx5t}µtm¦X¢£X¤²u lUipj}iDxp i~|7b &UUb*~xµ/b*apx5t}ªQ®HÁµb1]jkb °±]|x5]"`LbkjmUi ®XÁµbjmsb[xKpbasb*ipb*~"xYp]Ub[{|st}jm|xzxpÂqYp]jmp ® ¢t}s(p]Ub,bkj}ib±tm¦kjmz5al|z<jmpx5t}°Xb±*t}Uix5~|basÄp]Ub±kj}ib ¼ ®Áµb^'bazx5bab±p]jmp(p]|x5i(x5i(º8l|xpb baUt}l| ] xba p]jmp[jz<jmsbi{j}ax|¯bapÂ°Xb*ba p]Ubt}sx xjmz({j}bapjmU~p]Ub1sb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq z5bkj}~|i,ptdjm³x`{t}sp jm8puvxppbasjmU~yj1{'t8t}s±x8pbas j}apx8xpÂq® µt}s~|bas[ptyt}|p jmx:jmªb>nQ{|zx5axpb>n/{|sb*i ix5t} ¦¨t}sp]Ub{|st}jm|xzxp´q ¡°¶b &Usip{|stk/x5~|b1jmb>n/{|zx5axpDi jm`{|z57b {jmp] b>n/{|sb*iix5t}Y¦¨t}s,p]Ubbaba8pDtm¦z5t iitm¦(p]Ub {j} bapkjmssq/x|Lp]UbHsb*~Ql|U~UjmUaq¡ xbaYp]jmp±p]Ub[t}sx xjmzB{j} bap,xpibaz ¦°¶j}i z5t ipk®.

(47) Ç8Ë Ç

(48) 1 * a@¼ 1 "4*p 1(¼ /21 ,5/ 71 * / ,

(49) . .

(50) . . . . . . . . . "!#$.

(51) * *-,

(52) / , #/ !#"%$ , & / . . /^.

(53) *2, 1 , V p* . . . . . _ a. ». /. . _. . . . . c. / . /. » » :_ ¼ ,0/ 71 * / , _ a. 1Ä¼. . . . ». . . ». . . * . . _. * . K *^M. . * . » »m» _:¼ 292 ÀÁµbkjmob>n/{|sb*iiXp]Ub,8l|`'bas±tm¦¾{j}bapi¶p]jmpXp]UbK»=a p]¯jmlU~Qx5t{j}bap^°±xzz &UU~ x³p]UbºKlUbalUbl|{'t}yjmssx jmzÀj}i^¦¨t}zz5tk°,~i ] K¨p M " » a _ $ °±]Ubasb jmU~ jmsbosb*i{'b*apxbazqªp]Ub¯`x|x`l|` jmU~:`djOnQx`l|` t}{'bas jmpt}sik®:\^]Ub¯sb*ip tm¦p]Ub{|st/tm¦t/b*i1x$p]|sb*boipba{Uip]jmpjmsb¯il|``djmsxÅkb*~$x ba``dj$c ¡ ba``dj jmU~ ¤¶t}st}zz<jmsq cH'baz5tk°[® $t©°[¡|°Xb[~|7b &UUb U| » a _ K¨p M \^]|x5i,Uba° jmsx<jm|z5b[*t}ssb*i{'t}U~|iptp]Ub[8l|`'bastm¦({j}bapip]jmp °¶t}l|z5~Y'bH¦«t}l|U~yx p]Ub1º8lUbalUbl|{'t}yp]Ubjmssx}jmztm¦Ä{j} bap E|» a1x ¦p]Ub1ºKlUbalUb1ixÅkb1*t}l|z5~y'b**t}`LbUbaKjmpxb ® ÁµbHUb>nQp i]Ut©° p ]jmp,xp,kjmY'bHlU ib*~Yj}i jz5tk°Xbast}l|U~o¦¨t}s ® ÄÇ µ

(54) ! 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1Ê;.

(55) ',51 * * +** 1 * /. c~}. 292 ¾ÁµbÄ{|st8*b*b*~xp]UbX{|st/tm¦UKqxU~QlUapx5t}¾®\^]|x5iBsbaz<jmpx5t}x5iÀ}jmzx5~[¦«t}s p]jmp xp±x5i±}jmzx5~o¦¨t}s Q ®(Áµb[i]Ut©° p] jmp±xp,x5i± jmzx5~o¦«t}s '» a¡ . ÄÇ. . . µ 1 1 . . _. _ $ _ $ . . _ a _ a . . . . . . . _ _ " . . .

(56). . . . _. ;

(57) . _ . . _. . _. . _. ; / . ». . a a . . . _

(58) _ . _ _

(59) ». ®. ®. ». . _ . _. . . . . . . . . . Ë Ë : : | È. . . 292 . . . . " » a " » a . . . Q®(8l|{|{t i b. . » . . . . . . . /-, . . . . . _

(60) (» a . .

(61) `_{a _ . . . J_ a _ . . . J_ a. _ a . . . . . a$ . .

(62) _. . »

(63). . . . . . _ _ a . . * ¼ . "!#$.

(64) * *-,