• Aucun résultat trouvé

Tomographie à partir de corrélations de bruit de fond sismique

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Tomographie à partir de corrélations de bruit de fond sismique"

Copied!
174
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: tel-00377770

https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00377770

Submitted on 22 Apr 2009

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Tomographie à partir de corrélations de bruit de fond sismique

L. Stehly

To cite this version:

L. Stehly. Tomographie à partir de corrélations de bruit de fond sismique. Géophysique [physics.geo-

ph]. Université Joseph-Fourier - Grenoble I, 2007. Français. �tel-00377770�

(2)

&* +,$" .-/0$%01-2'+34# 5-6!# #%&'7

'(,&" ,$" #2-8!#9:<;) 2=>0?"@%"?9<;"

A6BDC8E:F

G HJI H=KMLON=PRQTSVU W PRN=LYXOSVL Z[U \]H=LOL_^a`bN.XOSVHJcTd

Z[U eTL1fTSgX Z[U hiHJcTZ djSbdjI Sbklf[U

monqpsrutsvwxpytOmz{n

|~}*Y€o>‚ƒ E ƒ7>„j…‡†

m+ˆŠ‰onˆ‹7wxtsvoŒnŽtOwxŒwn<t’‘“t•”%ˆ7–—wxts‰on‘“t

'i3˜™ >š#+" # ›!# #%&'7)

œ

mips–yŒzgŽŒwupŸž¡ $¢£¥¤b¦§¢Š¤b¨ª©?¤.«¥¬›­¤V®¯®¯¤i°@©?¤.«‡±²¦?£¥³i¤V®¯¨ª¤´µ©?¤2«‡±¶_¦³·£¸®¹i¦§¦?¤7ºJ¤b¦´

»

ˆ¼½m+ˆŠrxŒwŒˆŠva‘o‰)¾Š‰“n<¿Àž

Á¸ÂÃÅÄƐÃÅÇÈuÉʸÄÌËÍÃÅθÄÂÏ ÆÐύÑÓҊȘÔÕÖƗ×ƐÃÅÏÙØÛÚ ÜsÃÅÝÝÓʸÏÖË͏ÇÏ

ÞßʸàbÄØÛáÊVׯØâÃÅÏäãØÛÄØ ÆÐύÑÓҊȘÔåçæsè@é‡êÏÙØÛáìë ÜsÃÅÝÝÓʸÏÖË͏ÇÏ

íqÇØÛÚsÜsØî¥ÂÏäà ÆÐύÑÓҊȘÔå—ïð™æ"ðÌËÍÏäÃÅÚÍñÓʸÇÏÙÎ åòÃÅàbØÛÄÃóË͏ÇÏ

ô ÄÄÂ{ƐÃÅÇÈ Þ¯ØÛϏÑãŠÜyáìëqÑÃÅÇoí×¯Õ4æׯÏٍÄʸñÈÛ åòÃÅàbØÛÄÃóË͏ÇÏ

õsØÛö¸Ê¸ÈâÃÅØxð™ëÃÅÝØÛÏäÊ Þ¯ØÛϏÑãŠÜyáìëqÑÒȘÔÕÖƗ×#ƐÃÅÏÙØÛÚ åòÃÅàbØÛÄÃóË͏ÇÏ

÷Ðî¥ÂÚø—ʸÈÛØÛÄ(ãÂùçÏÙãØÛúÏÙ ÆÐύÑÓҊØÛÄÚäËäØËÍǙËßûʸÇÏäØۏÏsãÂgׯÏäÄʸñÈÛ Õ4Ä¥î™ØËÍü

Á¸ÊÌáÂÈý™ÄiׯÇØÛÈÛñӏÏÖË Õ4ÄθüÄØۏÇÏÖþÙø—ëÏÙáìëÇÏíxÞ×ßþÖøyå ôŠÿ

ÆÐÃÅÏÙØÛÚ ø—ÊÅþ4ãØÛÏäáË͏ÇÏsãÂËäëúÚÍÂ

ÉØÛáÍëÈxø ÃÅàbÝØÛÈÛÈÛÊ ÆÐύÑsÄØî‡ÑÁ¸Ê¸Ú͏ÝëûʸÇÏäØÛÂÏ ÿ í×¯Õ4æ ÞßØÛÏäáË͏ÇÏsãÂËäëúÚÍÂ

” zwxt5‘(t’ruˆŠ‰(wxtsvz{vo– tŸžŽt•v“ˆŠts¼~‹on<t

(3)

"!#$% %

& '( )*#) ( &

+

­-,/.b¹+®¯£Ì¤ 0

1 '(

)*#)

(

*%23) 4!565)

(

78 9#:;<)

( =

>6?A@ B/CDFEHGFIKJMLONQPSR3EHLOT$IMDU?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y

>6?A@3?A@ Z[R3E\EH]F^`_9PSLORabMDXcME\I LdPebMDgf#R3aMbKN\LdN\h:LOT$IMDi?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @3@

>6?j> B/C CME\RklJMDFNePSJ ]FR3EHLOT$IMDFNm?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @>

>6?j>6?A@ noT$IMLApq_^ODaMkFDWDFarPSEHDVkR3E\EH]F^O_qPSLdR3asbMDVc E\IMLAPtDP/Dvu6Cw]E\LODaMkFDVbMDxEHDP\R3IMEQy

aMDFh:DFarPePSDhzCR3E\D^{?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @>

>6?j>6?j> |}a$P\DFEHCME\]Pl_qP\LOR3ash:R6b_q^OD ?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @~

€ 

)‚ 9 4!# #)

(„ƒ…

:…†A

(

‡5 95*5)

(

)!ˆ‰5Šm-F) 93

&M‹

Œ ?A@ |}arPSEHR6bMI kPSLdR3a„?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?

Œ ?j> ŽCRPSJ ‘FN\DN ?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?

Œ ?“Œ ”/]•aMLdP\LOR3a–b DW^O_—f#R3aMkP\LOR3a–b Dx˜gE\DDFaKb_aMNe^dDgbMR3hz_LOaMDtf#E\]FT$IMDarPSLOD^™?W?V?W? @Y

Œ ?“Œ ?A@ štRr_IKLOarP\]F›3E\_^bœIMaKR3Cw]ES_qP\DFIMEž?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @Y

Œ ?“Œ ?j> Ÿ‚RaMkP\LOR3a–bMDV˜gE\DDFaKb_aMNe^ODgb R3h _qLOaMD/f#EH]FT$IMDa$P\LOD^x?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @Y

Œ ?~ Z[R3EHE\]F^O_qPSLdR3abMDXcMEHIMLdPeb DXf#RaMb¡?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?

£ 

)w¤¥!¦†§4Š#¨M #5)

(

  4$!54m !#©)‚ 9z¥ˆ‰5!#

~M?A@ |}arPSEHR6bMI kPSLdR3a„?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?

~M?j> ”/]•aMLdP\LOR3a NªCME\]F_^`_c ^ODFNm?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? >q~

~M?j>6?A@ «mR6b DFNeCME\RCME\DNb¬œ“IMaKh:LO^OLdDFIb Ld­wIMNS_arPX?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? >q~

(4)

~M?>?> ©E\RHDFkP\DFIME6CDFkPSES_q^z?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? >q~

~ ?jŒ LdDFasDFarP\E\DW^`_—kFRE\E\]^`_qP\LOR3a–DPe^ODgCMEHRHDFkPSDIMEtNHCwDkP\ES_^*bMDX^œ“R3C]FE\_qPSDIME

L

?V? >

~ ?“~ LdDFa¥Da$P\E\D‡^OD8CME\RHDkP\DFIMEsN\CDFkPSE\_^gbMD-^ œR3C]FE\_qPSDIME

L

DPs^`_Uf#R3a kPSLdR3a¥bMD

˜XEHDFDFaKbMIKhzLd^OLdDFI2?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? >

+6+

®£i£Ì¦?¤8©§®§£Å´ª©§¤¹i¦?© ¨s£¥¨¯ºJ£?¤ !

" # q#

(

)‚;%$8Fˆ

(

)w5F

€*&

?d@ |}a$P\E\RbMIMkPSLORa'&7^œj_EQPSLdkF^OD ?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Œ @

?> _cMNHP\ES_kP ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Œ(

?jŒ |}a$P\E\RbMIMkPSLORa ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Œ(

?“~ B/NHh:hzDPSEQ–Rf Z[E\R3NHN/Z[RE\E\D^`_qP\LOR3a ?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Œr

?) *gEHLO›3LdaRf!6DFLdN\h:LOkXšR3LONHD+*gc N\DFEQp3DbLOaKZ _^dLdf#R3EHaML`_ ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Œ3’

?, *gEHLO›3LdaRfPSJMD@¢yQ>¢7NeštRLON\D ?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~3~

? Z[R3aMkF^dIMN\LdR3aMN ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~rY

?j’ B/CMCDFaMb LAu ?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ¢

?jY _k.-$aMR%/e^ODFb ›3hzDarPSN ?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? 3>

+6++

 ´ß¬0"£¥«¥£Å´6. ©?¤b¨1¹¡¦?¢g´ß£¥¹i¦§¨2©?¤32a®¯¤b¤b¦ ®¯¤b¢¹i¦§¨ ´s®4§£Å´ß¤b¨15"¬+®.¢Š¹i®76

®M.b«¥¬´ß£Ì¹i¦ ©§¤?®4§£Å´ª©§¤8¹i¦§© 9!:

; <

9r!…5ˆ $ 6ˆU

(

7;< )wˆ

(

)3)‚ 9!# #)

( "="

6?d@ ]N\IMh:] ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?

6?> B/cMNQPSES_qkP ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?

6?jŒ |}a$P\E\RbMIMkPSLORa ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ’

6?“~ ” _qPl__a bmh:DP\JMR6b N ?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Y

?“~ ?d@ ” _9Pl_IMN\Db¡?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?

?“~ ?> «mDF_N\I E\DFh:DFarPtRfPSJMDgPSLdhzD/bMDF^O_ ?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? r>

6?) DN\IM^APSNx?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?

?)?d@ LdhzDgbMD^`_Lda–PSJMD>yS@¢—NeCwDE\LORbsc_aMbKcDP?/ DFDFaU@Y3Y3Y_a b8>q¢3¢( ? (

?)?> LdhzDgbMD^`_Lda–PSJMD@¢9y¦>¢—NeCwDE\LdR6bsc_a bKcDP?/ DFDa‰@Y3YY:_qaMbm>¢3¢( (

?)?jŒ pLObMDaMkFDWRfLOaMNQPSEHIMhzDarPl_^¬P\LOh:D N\J Ldf PSNebMI E\LOa ›K@Y3Y @yS@Y3Y?X?V?W?V?

6?, Z[R3aMkF^dIMN\LdR3aMN ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? q~

6? _k.-$aMR%/e^ODFb ›3hzDarPSN ?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? 

(5)

+

­¹¡ºJ¹ +®¬05 ,?£¥¤ 5"¬+®s´¯£¸® ©§¤.¢Š¹i®ß®M.b«¥¬´ß£Ì¹i¦?¨ª©?¤§®§£Å´µ©§¤ ¹i¦?© 0o0

‹

;<3 r

<

)‚‚ M¨ $ )‚;

)*$

(„

!5#;<)‚

(

#

‹ =

6?A@ |}arPSEHR6bMI kPSLdR3a &7^ œ“_EHP\LOkF^dD ?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y

6?j> _cMNQPSE\_kP ?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’3¢

6?“Œ |}arPSEHR6bMI kPSLdR3a„?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’3¢

6?~ ”/LdN\CDFE\NHLOR3askIMEHpDFNLOamZ _^OLAf#R3E\a L`_–?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’ @

6?, B/C CM^OLdk_qP\LOR3a P\R6BtE\ES_–bM_qPl_—?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’3Œ

6? ”/LdN\kFI N\N\LdR3am_aMbsLOarPSDE\CMEHDPS_qPSLdR3asRf"b LON\CDFEHN\LdR3ash _C Nx?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’3Œ

6?j Z[R3aMk^OIMNHLOR3a N ?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’~

< )‚‚ M¨ $ )‚;e$–!#¨" ( ‰65ˆ‰5ˆ-5 ( ( ) ¬‹

’ ?A@ ” _qPS_ oEHR6kDFNHN\LOa ›‰?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y3¢

’ ?A@3?A@ u6DhzCM^dDgRfB/|Q˜ "y ?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y @

’ ?j> |}arp3DE\N\LdR3ai?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Yr>

’ ?j>6?A@ 6DF^dDFkP\LOR3a–Rqf"PSJ DgC_qPSJ NV?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Yr>

’ ?j>6?j> |}a$pDFEHN\LORamh:DP\JMR6b ?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y~

’ ?j>6?“Œ t_^ODLO›3Js_a b *Rp3D _pD—˜gE\RIMCoDF^ORkFLAP}s«8_qCMN—?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y

’ ?j>6?~ DN\R3^dI PSLdR3a–Rf ˜XEHR3IMCoDF^dR6kLdP}«8_CMN ?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y3’

’ ?“Œ Œ3” |}arp3DE\N\LdR3ai?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢3¢

’ ?“Œ ?A@ «mDP\JMR6b ?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢3¢

’ ?“Œ ?j> u6DhzCM^dDgRf!$y /[_p3DWCME\R•M^OD ?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢ @

’ ?“Œ ?“Œ «mR3JMRhz_C ?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢3Œ

’ ?“Œ ?~ Z[R3hzCM_E\LdN\R3a /eLAPSJsRPSJ DFEeNHP\IMbMLODNt?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢~

’ ?~ Z[R3aMk^OIMNHLOR3a ?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢~

’ ?, Bªk.-$aMR%/e^ODbM›3DFh:DFarP\N ?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢

= 

)‚ 9 4!# #)

(

7-3)* 3)‚ 46!# #)

(

Y ?A@ |}arPSEHR6bMI kPSLdR3a„?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢r

Y ?j> «m]PSJMRbMD2?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @¢3’

Y ?“Œ tasDvu DhzC ^ODXbMDXkFR3EHE\]^`_qP\LOR3a–bMDXkR6b_7bMDXkR3E\EH]F^`_9PSLORaMN=…«ty¦˜X|Q«' ?W? @¢3Y

Y ?~ ŽtRbMRklJME\RaMDFNt?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @@¢

Y ?, DI PHy<R3a›r_q›3aMDFE/bMDx^œ“Lda f#R3E\hz_qP\LOR3asDFa-kR3E\EH]F^O_arP/bMDNgkFRb_ bMDxkFR3EHE\]F^O_qPSLdR3aMN

_Is^OLdDFI–bMDXkR3E\EH]F^ODEª^ODgcMEHIMLdPeb LOE\DkP\DFh:DFarP ?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @@3@

Y ? Z[R3aMk^OIMNHLOR3a ?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @@~

(6)

55¤b¦§©?£Ì¢Š¤

&‰

)S3)‚ 9 !# #)

(

)‚;ª

(

!

ƒ ˆ %$ˆ 3! ¨¨ )M $i

(

iM¨

¨!53 5)

(

&1*&

@¢ ?d@‰_cMNHP\ES_kP ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @>3>

@¢ ?>i|}a$P\E\RbMIMkPSLORa ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @>3>

@¢ ?jŒ _k.-$›3E\RIMaMbm_aMbKh _qP\JMDFhz_qP\LOk_q^¬_C CME\Rr_qklJ ?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @>Œ

@¢ ?“Œ ?d@ ŽLONHP\R3E\Ldk_^wc_k.-$›3EHR3IMaMb ?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @>Œ

@¢ ?“Œ ?> JMDWk_qN\DXRfJMR3h:R3›3DFa DFR3IMNH^d bMLONQPSE\LdcMI P\DFb /eJMLdP\DXaMR3LONHDgN\R3I E\kFDN ?V? @>

@¢ ?“Œ ?jŒ JMDWk_qN\DXRf"_NHk_qPHPSDE\LOa ›zh:DFbMLdIMh ?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @>3

@¢ ?“Œ ?“~ JMDWES_9PSDgRfkFR3arpDFE\›DFaMkDVPSR%/[_E\b NP\JMDV˜XEHDFDFa¬œ“Nªf#IMaMkPSLdR3a ?X?V?W?V? @Œ @

@¢ ?“~ 6IMEHf5_qkFD / _pDWP\R3hzR›3ES_C J$ Rf oI E\R3CD ?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @Œr>

@¢ ?) Œ9y¦” $y / _p3DXPSRhzR3›ES_CMJr RfP\JMD+©LdPSRaKb DW^O_7ŸR3IME\aM_LONHD p3R3^dk_aMR ?X?V?W?V? @Œ(

@¢ ?, y / _pDFN/DvuPSES_qkPSLdR3a–f#E\R3h N\DLON\h:LOkga R3LONHDgkFE\RN\NQy<kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a ?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @Œr

@¢ ? 6h _q^O^N\k_q^ODg›3DR3CMJrN\LOkNeIMN\LdaM›7N\IMEQf5_kFD /[_p3DFNDuP\ES_kPSDFbsf#E\Rh aMR3LdN\D kE\R3NHNQy

kFR3EHE\DF^O_qPSLdR3a? ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @~$>

@¢ ?j’ "_NHN\LdpDVkR3E\EHDF^O_qPSLdR3a–LOhz_›3LdaM›xRf"_7cMIMEHLODFbKN\kF_qP\P\DFEHDFEi?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @~3~

@¢ ?jY Z[R3aMkF^dIMN\LdR3a ?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @~r’

@¢ ?d@¢r”/DPS_LO^dDFbsk_^dkFIM^O_qPSLdR3aRfPSJ DWkE\R3NHNQy<kFR3EHE\DF^O_qPSLdR3af#IMaMkPSLdR3a ©T‚?*@¢ ?~ ?V?W?V? @~rY

5!55)‚‚ M¨ $#

& "*&

(7)

@3?A@ DFh:CMNgbœ“_E\EHLdp3]DhzR3DaMNXbMDbMLd­w]FEHDFarPSNgP}CDFNXbœR3aMbMDNVDa‡f#RaMkP\LOR3a‡bMD7^O_

bMLdNHPl_qaMkFDg]CMLOkDFarPSE\_^ODž?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? >

@3?j> «mRbM‘F^dDsES_bMLO_^ªbMDsPSDE\E\D' …« ©E\DF^dLOh:LOa_qEH …_qEHPSJ «mRbMDF^…CM_E

Q@Y’ @ CMEH]FN\DarPl_arP7^dDFNXp6LAPSDN\N\DN—bMD:CME\RC_›r_qP\LOR3a

bMDNRaMbMDFN DPK_LdaMN\L¬TI DW^O_7bMDFaMNHLdP\]WDaKf#RaMkP\LOR3a–bMDW^`_—C E\Rf#R3a bMDFIME?8?W? >

@3?“Œ 6LdN\h:LOkFLAPS]thzR3a bML`_^dD/kIMh—IM^d]FDXCwDaMb_arPW@¢_aMN? ?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Œ

@3?~ ©aME\D›3LONQPSEHDFh:DFarPgbœIMa‡N\]LON\h:D—NHLdPSI ] &–Y3¢ -$h b D7^`_ NQPl_qP\LOR3a ‚•^APSE\]VDFarPSEHDs@

DP—@¢Ž!q?* a-bMLONQPSLdaM›3IMDWPSR3I P bœj_qcwR3EHb^ODN R3aMb DFN "wN\IMLApLODFN/bMDFNgR3a bMDFN+w?

_-kFRb_-DFNHP:kR3aMNHP\LdP\IM]FDsbMDN:b DFE\a LO‘FEHDFNz_E\EHLdp]FDFNDPCME\]N\DFarP\D8IMaMDs^dR3aM›3IMD

bM]kFE\RLON\N\_aMkDWDvu6CwR3a DFarPSLdDF^O^dD?z?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ~

>6?A@ *DFNzbMDFI6u Dvu C]FEHLODaMkFDNN\IMLApq_arPSDFNzN\R3arP ]FT$IMLdpq_^dDFarPSDN …_ * a2kFRE\E\‘^ODK^ODN

cMEHIMLdPbMDXf#R3aMbK]Fh:LONeDFaZ DPtDFa E\DF›LONHP\E\]WDFamB DP/?‚c ]Fh:DPtIMa8NHLO›3a_q^

Z„^dD E\DPSR3I E\aMDWDPe^dDgE\DFarpR3LODXp3DE\NBx?7?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?

>6?j> *DFNobMDI6u:Du6C]FE\LdDFaMkDFN…N\IMLApq_arPSDFN…N\Ra$P…DTI Ldpq_^ODarPSDFN $_ "B ]hzDP I azNHLO›3a_q^ ?

Z[DF^dIML3kL3DFNQPDFaMEHDF›3LdNHPSEH]©C_E*IMaXDaMN\Dh—cM^OD©b D…EH]FkDFC P\DFIMEHNT$IMLr^dD E\DPSR3I E\aMDa$PDP

^ODeEH]FDFh:DPHPSDa$PF? *gazDFaMEHDF›3LdNHP\E\DDFa t?rc * azkFR3EHE\‘F^dDe^ODFNoDaME\D›3LONQPSE\DhzDarPSN[Da

B2DP ‰bMD c E\IMLAP ]Fh:LONC_EIMa7DFaMNHDFh—c ^OD bMD[N\R3IMEHkFDN©bMLONHCwR3NH]FDN©kFR3arPSLda$#MhzDarP

_I P\R3IMEªbMDXB DPt?g?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @~

~M?A@

γ

I CwDI PHy&%PSEHDªbM]FkR3h:CwR3NH]ªDFabMDI6ukFRa$P\R3IMEHN

γ

I+ _a b

γ

I T$IMLMNHR3arPokFR3h:CM^ODvu6D kFRaHIM›3IM]NeDPkFR3EHE\DN\CR3aMbMDa$P&7bMDFNbMLdE\DFkPSLdR3aMNªR3CMCR3NH]FDFN??W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? >

6?A@ _ ©aMEHDF›3LdNHP\E\DFh:DFarPXbMD7c E\IMLAPgbMD—f#R3aMb‡NHLON\h:LOT$IMDxC_Eg^`_zNHPl_9PSLORa Ÿ * 5Bt^Ay

^ODh _q›3aMD X^OD-@ \_qa$pLdDFE:>¢3¢6?"c ES_qaMNHf#R3EHhz]DsbMDsŸR3IME\LdDFE—b D–kFDsh'%hzD

DFa E\DF›LONHP\E\DhzDa$PF? DWCMLdkVbMDxqNbMR3h:LOaMDX^dDWNHCwDkP\E\D(w^ODXCMLdkVbMD:@~3NCM^dIMNth:Rqy

bM]E\]XDFNQPt]›r_^dDFh:DFarPªpLON\LdcM^ODq? ?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Œ3Œ

(8)

?> 6klJMDFhz_qP\LOkeLO^d^OIMNQPSES_9PSLORaxRfwPSJMDeD­wDFkP[RqfLOa JMR3h:R3›3DFa DFR3IMN©a R3LONHDNHR3IMEHkFDFN…bMLdNQy

PSE\LdcMI P\LOR3a–R3a–P\JMDXbMDF›3EHDFDWRfNHhzh:DP\EH Rf"kE\R3NHNQy<kFR3EHE\DF^O_qPSLdR3a? ?V?W?X?V?W?V? Œ3Y

?jŒ Z[E\R3NHN kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a:cwDP?/[DDFa'V_qaMb@¢xNHDFkR3aMbMN RqfR3aMDtD_E >¢3¢3> RfaMR3LdN\D

E\DFkR3E\b DFb8Ra8«'BZ _aMb NQPl_k.-qDFbh:R3arPSJsCDFEehzRa$P\J? ?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~r¢

?“~ Z[E\R3NHN kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a:cwDP?/[DDFa'V_qaMb@¢xNHDFkR3aMbMN RqfR3aMDtD_E >¢3¢3> RfaMR3LdN\D

E\DFkR3E\b DFb8Ra8«'BZ _aMb NQPl_k.-qDFbh:R3arPSJsCDFEehzRa$P\J™?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~M@

?) Rk_9PSLORa–Rf"NHDFLdN\h:LOkgNHPS_qPSLdR3aMNªIMNHDFbKLOa–PSJ DWa DP?/ R3E -s_aM_^dN\LdNªLOamZ _^dLdf#R3EHaML`_ ? ~M@

?, štR3EHh _^dL!DFbm_hzC ^OLdP\IMbMDgRf©P\JMDxkE\R3NHNQy<kFR3EHE\DF^O_qPSLdR3aKRf©N\DLONHhzLdkVaMRLON\Dx_qPtCwDEQy

LORbMN[cDP?/ DFDa —_aMb-@¢—Ne_Nª_xf#IMaMkPSLdR3a–RfPSLdhzD/_aMbs_(!LOh—I P\J–LOasZ _q^OLdf#RE\aMLO_ ?/~rŒ

? štR3EHh _^dL!DFbV_hzC ^OLdP\IMbMDoRfMP\JMD kE\R3NHN kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3aV_p3DFE\_›3Db7bMIME\LdaM›tP\JMD /eLda6y

PSDFE_a bsP\JMDXN\IMh:h:DFE p3DE\NHIMN _(!LOh—I6PSJf#R3E pq_EHLOR3IMN f#EHDFT$IMDaMkKc_a bMNF?–?W?V? ~7

?j’ štDP?/ R3E -NtRfcME\Rr_qbMc_aMbsNQPl_qP\LOR3aMNªI N\DFb¬? ?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~(

?jY BpDFES_q›3D aMR3EHh _q^OL!DFbz_h:CM^OLAPSIMbMDeRfkFE\RN\NQy<kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3aMN…Rf*a R3LONHDtp3DE\NHIMNe_(!FL§y

h—I PSJ f#R3EWp_qE\LORIMNVa DP?/ R3E -‰b IME\LdaM›8PSJ D /eLOarPSDE—_a b‰PSJMDNHIMh:hzDExLOaUPSJMD

yl@¢qNe_aMb‡@¢9y¦>¢NªCDFE\LdR6b–cM_aMb?‰?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~$

?d@¢ Z[R3hzCM_E\LdN\R3aWcwDP?/[DDFaN\DF_N\Ra_^6pq_EHL`_qP\LOR3a N*RfPSJMD ^ORk_qP\LOR3aXRfMN\DFNHLOh:LOk…aMR3LdN\D

N\R3IMEHkFDN/_a bmNHLO›3aMLA•k_qa$P / _p3DVJMDFLd›3JrP?–?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~r’

?d@3@ *gEHLO›3Lda RfWPSJMD‡c_qk.-›E\R3IMa b aMRLON\D‡_9P‡@¢9yQ>q¢‰N\DFkR3aMbMNsNHDFaMNHDFb bMI E\LOa ›‰PSJMD

/eLOarPSDEcrP\JMDXbMLd­wDFEHDFarPaMDP?/ R3E -N??W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ¢

?d@> *gEHLO›3Lda RfWPSJMD‡c_qk.-›E\R3IMa b aMRLON\D‡_9P‡@¢9yQ>q¢‰N\DFkR3aMbMNsNHDFaMNHDFb bMI E\LOa ›‰PSJMD

N\IMh:hzDEªcrPSJMDXbMLA­¬DE\Da$PaMDP?/[RE -$NF? ?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? 6@

?d@Œ Rk_q^OL!F_qPSLdR3aWRfPSJMD[c_k.-$›3E\RIMaMbaMR3LdN\D R3EHLO›3Ldax_9Pª@¢9y¦>¢N/eLdPSJ R3I P©IMNHLOaM›tPSJMD

k_^dLdf#R3EHaML`_azaMDP?/ R3E -?[?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? 6@

6?d@ 6klJMDFhz_qP\LOkgE\DCME\DN\Da$PS_qPSLdR3a8Rqf"EHDFkFRaMNHP\E\IMkPSLORamRfPSJ DVkF_IMNS_q^_aMbsPSJMDW_arPSL§y

k_IMN\_^*C_EQPSNeRf ˜XEHDFDaKf#IMa kPSLdR3a–f#E\R3h PSJMDXaMRLON\Dq? ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @

6?> «8_C Rf R3I PSJ DFE\a Z _^dLdf#R3EHaML`_:N\JMR%/eLOa ›KP\JMD^ORk_qP\LOR3aRqf P\JMDŒKc E\Rr_b c_aMb

NHPl_9PSLORaMNªIMN\Dbmf#R3E P\JMLONªNQPSIMb63? ?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @

6?jŒ Df#DFE\DaMkFD y kFE\RN\NQy<kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a8f#REX˜> Z…ywB8•^dP\DFE\Db-cwDP?/[DDFa @¢–_aMb

>¢7Nt_qaMbmkE\R3NHNQy<kFR3EHE\DF^O_qPSLdR3a–Rf «8_K>¢3¢¢ ?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? r>

6?“~ E\_pDF^*PSLdhzDpq_E\LO_qPSLdR3aMN Rf _6^dDFLd›3Js_aMb'*RpD / _p3DN‚f#R3E[P\JMDXC_qPSJm˜+MZ…y

wB shzDF_N\I E\DFbmf#E\R3h R3a Dy}h:R3arPSJKkFEHR3N\N¦y}kR3E\EHDF^`_9PSLORaMNeLOasPSJMD yl@¢7NtCwDE\LORb

c_aMb?¬?W?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? ~

(9)

?, …_EHL`_qP\LOR3agRf6PSJMD…N\I EHf5_kD /[_pDFN"P\ES_p3D^P\LOh:DFNh:D_NHIME\DbxLOaXPSJ D CDFEHLORbVc_qaMb

yS@¢—Nªf#R3EªbMLd­wDFEHDFarPC_qP\JMN ‚˜> Z…ywB ˜+MZ…yoŸ * _aMb'wB$yoŸ *—?7?V?W?

? Z[R3h:C_EHLON\RazRfwPSJMDtN\IMEQf5_kFD/ _pD/PSE\_pDF^‚PSLdhzDªpq_E\LO_qPSLdR3aMN©h:D_NHIME\Db LdazPSJ D

@¢9y¦>¢—NeCwDE\LdR6b–c_qaMb /eLAPSJsR3aMDW_a bmNHLAush:R3arPSJsNHPS_k.- f#R3E PSJMDXC_9PSJ8˜>MZ…y

wBK_qaMbm˜>MZ…y?oŸ *—? ?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?

?j 6IMEQf5_kFD /[_pDtP\ES_p3D^‚P\LOh:D pq_E\LO_qPSLdR3aMNo_p3DES_›3Db R3a _^O^ kFR3h:CwRaMDFarPSNof#R3E©PSJ D

C_qP\Jm˜>MZ…y?wBK_qPeCDFEHLORb–ES_a ›3LOaM›7f#EHR3h xPSRs@¢7N_aMb @¢—PSRz>¢7N? ?V?W? 3Y

?“’ eDF^`_9PSLdpDLOa NHPSEHIMh:DFarPl_^[DFE\EHR3E7cDP?/ DFDFa¥˜>MZ _aMb wB‰hzDF_N\IMEHDFbiLOažPSJ D

yS@¢—N_aMbsPSJMD7@¢yQ>¢7NeCwDE\LdR6b–c_qaMbMNF?6?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ¢

?“Y |}aMNQPSE\I hzDa$PS_^ DE\E\RE\NgkFRhzCMI6PSDFb‡IMNHLOaM›–DT$I_qPSLdR3a ?j>zf#R3E bMLA­¬DE\Da$PXCM_qPSJMN

˜+MZ…yB ‚˜+MZ…y?…Ÿ * 5k wB$yoŸ *—? ?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? 6@

?A@¢1yS@¢7NtNHIMEHf5_kD+/[_p3DWPSES_pDF^PSLOh:D pq_E\LO_qPSLdR3aMNª_pDFES_q›3DFbRa8_^d^*kFR3h:CR3aMDFarP\N

f#R3E P\JMDV˜>MZ…y?wB–CM_qPSJm_qf PSDEªkFR3EHE\DkPSLdaM›7PSJMDXLdaMNHP\E\IMh:DFarPl_q^DFEHE\R3EHNF?©?W?V?W? q~

6?A@ Z[R3h:C_EHLON\RaMNRf o_EHP\JMT$I_-qDE\DkFR3EHbMN_a b2N\DLONHhzLdkmaMRLON\DKkFRE\E\D^`_qP\LOR3a Lda

N\RI PSJMDE\a8Z _^OLAf#R3E\a L`_ ?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’r>

6?j> 6?,qN _aMb@9N_^dDFLO›Jz›3EHR3IMC:p3DF^dR6kLdP}:hz_CMN…RfZ _^dLdf#R3EHaML`_gR3c PS_LOa DFbzf#EHR3h

kFEHR3N\N¦y}kR3E\EHDF^`_9PSLORa–Rf Œ¢bM_NeRf _h—cMLdDFarPªaMR3LdN\D ?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? ’~

’ ?A@ «8_CsNHJMR%/eLOaM›PSJMDX^dR6kF_qPSLdR3aRfcME\R3_bMc_a bmEHDFkFRE\bMDE\NIMN\DbKf#R3E P\JMLONeNQPSIMb ? Y @

’ ?j> Z[E\RN\NQy<kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a‰RqftRaMD3DF_ERfE\DFkR3E\b N:cDP?/ DFDa Bt|Q˜+ {c_aMby

C_NHN\DbmLdaKNHDpDFES_q^CDFEHLORbsc_aMbMNªf#EHR3h @¢7PSR 3¢qNF? ?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Yr>

’ ?“Œ Z[E\RN\NQy<kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a Rqf6RaMD©3D_qE*Rf EHDFkR3E\bMN*cDP?/ DFDaxBt|Q˜+8_qaMb> ‰c_aMby

C_NHN\Db–LOaPSJMDV@¢9yQ>q¢N CDFEHLORbzcM_aMb–_ _^dDFLO›J /[_pDFNªR3c6Pl_LdaMDFb:f#E\R3h

„_aMb kFR3EHE\DF^O_qPSLdR3a:c *Rp3DFN/[_p3DNªR3c Pl_qLOaMDb f#E\R3h kFR3EHE\D^`_9y

PSLdR3a?¥?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y3Œ

’ ?~ _ e˜gE\R3IMCsp3D^ORkFLAP}sh _Csf#R3E_^dDFLO›J /[_p3D7_9P9NtCDFEHLORb? JMDxc ^`_k.-–^dLOaMD

bMD^OLOh:LdP\NP\JMD_E\DF_ /eJMDE\Dt_qPo^ODF_NHPe@¢WC_9PSJMN…_EHDkE\R3NHN\LdaM›VDF_klJ:kFDF^d^ ?3c …«m_C

N\J R/eLdaM› P\JMDa$IMh—cDFEzRfXC_qP\JMNkFEHR3N\NHLOaM› D_klJ¥kDF^O^f#R3EPSJMD 9N t_^ODLO›3J

C_qP\JMNF?¬k /Œ~3¢3¢ C_qP\JMN/eJMDE\DE\D^OL`_qcM^ODW›3E\RIMCp3D^ORkFLdP}mh:D_NHIME\DhzDa$P / DFEHD

R3c PS_LOa DFb–f#R3EqN _6^dDFLd›3J / _p3DNF?™?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Y(

’ ?, _DFLd›3J 5^ODf P —_a b *Rp3D 5EHLO›3JrPkFR^OIMh:a V›3EHR3IMC p3D^ORkFLdP} h _qCMN:_qP:_ H’qN

c v@%Nªk QŒ(qN?¥?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? Yr

(10)

’6?, _ "|}N\RP\E\R3C LOkªE\DN\R3^dI PSLdR3a7c ES_kDeRfwP\JMDeE\DN\R3^dI PSLdR3a7h _9PSE\L§uVk …_^OI D RfPSJMD

DN\R3^dI PSLdR3azLdazP\JMDtcDFNQP bMLdE\DkPSLdR3a:b …_^dIMDRfPSJ DtEHDFN\R^OI P\LOR3a:LOa:PSJMD/[R3EHNHP

bMLOEHDFkP\LOR3a ?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? Y3Y

’6? _ B!FLdh—I P\JKf#R3E /eJMLdklJKP\JMDWE\DFNHR3^OI6PSLORaKRqf"PSJ D qN _^dDFLO›JK›E\R3IMCsp3D^ORkFLAP}

h _C‡LdNXP\JMDcwDNHPF? J DzkR3^OR3EgNHk_^dDLOaMbMLdk_qP\DFN P\JMD:pq_^dIMD7Rf PSJMDE\DN\R3^dI PSLdR3a

^ODFa ›PSJf#R3E©PSJMLdNobMLOEHDFkP\LOR3a¬?rc LObMDh™f#R3E©PSJMDbMLOEHDFkPSLORa /eJ DFE\DPSJMDE\DN\R3^dI PSLdR3a

LON PSJ DW^dR%/[DNHP? ?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @¢3¢

’6?j’ _ «m_CN\J R/eLdaM›xP\JMD/^dR6kF_qPSLdR3a /eJMDFEHD / D CME\DN\Da$P $y /[_p3D CMEHR•^dDtR3c6Pl_LdaMDFb

_qfPSDEWLdarp3DFEQPSLdaM› _^ODFLd›3J / _pD bMLdN\CDFE\NHLOR3a‡kIMEHpDFNF?c k b g|}arp3DFEHN\LdR3a Rf

t_^ODLO›3J/[_p3D…bMLONHCwDE\N\LdR3aXkFIMEQp3D…LOarPSR /[_pD[CMEHR•^dDo_qPŒªkFDF^d^ON*EHDFN\CDFkPSLAp3DF^A

LOaXPSJMD Ro^O_LOa B/IMNQPSEHL`_aWB/^dCMN9_aMb 6R3I6PSJMDE\a˜gDFEHh _ar? JMD EHLO›3JrPC_a DF^

N\JMR%/eN P\JMDhzDF_N\IMEHDFb t_^ODLO›3J /[_pDFN bMLONHCwDE\N\LdR3a:kFIMEQp3DFN 5cM^O_k.-—bMRP\N o_aMb

PSJMDªbMLdN\CDFEHN\LORa:kIMEHpDFN _N\NHR6kL`_qP\DFb /eLdP\Js@¢ cwDNHP oN ©E\R•M^ODFN©NHJMR%/ea Lda7N\R3^dLOb

^OLOa DFNªR3a–PSJ DW^dDf PeC_qaMDF^?{?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @¢r>

’6?jY _ \«8_qCKRqf"PSJ Dx«KR3JMRbMDFC6PSJKc e«mLONQ•MPRfP\JMDX|}arp3DFEHN\LdR3a??V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @¢3Œ

’6?d@¢2Œ3” pLdD / Rf P\JMDz«mR3JMRKbMDC PSJU_ tf#E\Rh R3IMEgEHDFNHIM^dP\NWc XŸEHR3h _^Ob J_IMNHDFE

DPt_^˜XDR3CMJrN\LOkF_^ R3IMEHa_^*|}arPSDE\a_9PSLORa_^w@Y3Y3’ t??V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @¢(

Y6?d@ Ÿ‚RaMkP\LOR3a:bMDX˜gE\DDFaDa$P\E\D « DPª˜X|Q« #P\E\LO_aM›3^dDEHR3IM›3DN\I E ^`_Xk_EQPSD

R3c PSDa$IMD DFaxkFR3EHE\]F^O_arP"I a7_axb D[cMEHIMLdP 5EHR3IM›3D DP"DFa—kR3E\EH]F^O_arP"bMDN"kR6b_qN"bMD

kFR3EHE\]F^O_qPSLdR3aMNebMD—c E\IMLAP #cM^ODI ?štRIMN h:R3arPSE\RaMNtb DFI6u8c_aMb DFN bMDxCw]E\LORbMD

yl@¢qN #DFa8cM_N eDP—@¢9yQ>¢qN #DFaJM_I P v? DN/NQPl_qP\LOR3aMNt_r_arP/N\DFEQpLODFN/CwR3I Et^dDFN

kFR3EHE\]F^O_qPSLdR3aMN b DWkR6bM_NHR3arP/LdaMbMLdTI ]FDFNªCM_Ee^ODFNª]PSR3Ld^ODN \_IMaMDNNHIMEe^`_—kF_EHP\D? @3@¢

Y6?> _ ªZ _EHP\DXLOaMbMLdT$I_arPe^ODNNQPl_qP\LOR3a NªDFarPSEHDW^dDFNHTI DF^O^dDFNeaMR3I NEHDFkR3aMNHP\E\IMLdN\R3a Nt^dDFN

f#R3aMkP\LOR3agb D[˜gE\DDFa?Fc ¬k "u6DFh:CM^ODN*bMD©f#R3aMkP\LOR3agb D[˜gE\DDFaXE\DkFR3a NHPSEHIMLdP\DFNDFa

kFR3EHE\]F^O_arPbMDFNtkFR3EHE\]F^O_qPSLdR3aMN 5c ^ODFI ªDP/DakFRE\E\]^`_arPbMImcME\IMLAP 5E\RIM›3D ªCR3IME

^ODFNtPSES_%HDPSNX”t|ty DPWŸ 6| *ty W?¬štR3I N hzRa$P\E\R3a N bMDFIu‡c_aMb DFNgbMD

Cw]E\LORbMD yl@¢qN DPW@¢9y¦>¢NªCR3IME #c *@¢yQ>¢N[DP/>¢9y<~r¢NªCR3IME 5k v??X?V?W?V? @3@3@

Y6?jŒ Z[R3E\EH]F^`_9PSLORaMN bMDkFRb_gbMDekFR3EHE\]^`_qP\LOR3aMN©Da:f#RaMkP\LOR3abMDe^`_ b LONHPS_aMkDCR3IMEo^dDFN

c_aMbMDNtb DWC]FEHLORbMDFNe_ yl@¢qNªc /@¢9y¦>¢NªDPk >q¢9y}~r¢qNF? ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @3@>

Y6?“~ Ÿ‚RaMkP\LOR3a bMD‡˜gE\DFDa DFarP\E\D‡« * DP ” Rc PSDaI D-DFa kR3E\EH]F^`_qa$P IMa _a

bMD7cME\I LdP #E\R3IM›D tDPgDFa‡kFRE\E\]^`_arPg^dDFN kR3E\EH]F^O_qPSLdR3aMN/b D7cME\IMLAP 5c ^ODFI ?šR3IMN

hzR3arP\E\R3aMNªb DFI6uKc_qaMbMDFNbMDXC]FE\LdR6b D yl@¢N 5DamJ_qI P [DPV@¢9yQ>¢qN 5DFaKc_N ? @3@>

@¢ ?d@

γ

I

kF_a–cwDgNHCM^OLAP[LdarPSR—P?/ R:kR3arPSR3I E\N

γ

I+ _aMb

γ

I /eJMLdklJm_qE\D kR3hzC ^ODu kFRaHI6y

›r_qPSDX_qaMbKf#R^O^OR%/ DFb–LdaKRCMCwRN\LdP\DgbMLOEHDFkPSLORa?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @Œ3¢

(11)

@¢ ?j> JMDtŒ3¢3¢3¢XN\D^ODkPSDb C_9PSJMN /eJMDFEHDV@%WN _^ODFLd›3J / _pD ›3E\RIMC:pDF^dR6kLdP}7h:D_9y

N\I E\DFh:DFarP\N'/ DFE\D R3c Pl_qLOaMDb„f#EHR3h kFEHR3N\N¦y}kFRE\E\D^`_qP\LOR3a NKRqf_h—cMLdDFarPKN\DLON\h:LOk

aMR3LdN\Dq? JMLdP\D PSEHL`_aM›^ODFN[N\JMR%/ NQPl_qP\LOR3aMNªI N\DFbKf#R3E PSJ LONªNHP\IMb ?©?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @Œ3Œ

@¢ ?“Œ _^dDFLO›J _ x_qaMb *Rp3D#c >/ _pDm›3EHR3IMCžp3D^ORkFLAP}‰hz_CMN_qPs@%-N7CDFEHLORb

kFRaMNHP\E\IMkPSDFb-f#EHR3h Œ )¢¢_aMb-~ ~r¢3¢zLOarPSDEQy}NQPl_qP\LOR3a8kFE\RN\NQy<kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3aMN wEHDFN¦y

CDFkP\LdpDF^d? ^`_k.-7PSJ LOk.-^OLdaMDtb DF^OLdhzLAPSN P\JMD _EHD_>/eJ DFE\DtPSJMDE\Dg_EHD/h:R3E\DePSJM_a

@¢7C_qP\JMNeCwDE>

×

> -$h kFD^O^?-?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?X?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W? @Œ~

@¢ ?~ ?«m_C‡RfoPSJMD ©LdP\R3a-bMD7^O_–Ÿ‚RIME\a_qLON\DVp3R3^dk_aMR ? 6DLON\h:LOkxNHPl_9PSLORaMNg_EHD7E\Dy

CMEHDFN\DarPSDFb‰_NVLdarp3DFEQPSDb PSEHL`_aM›^ODFN? JMD:›3ES_ !R3aMD:LOaMbMLdk_qP\DFNgPSJ Dz^dLOh:LdPSN/Rf

PSJ D E\LAf P !FR3aMDq? J D PSJMLdaUbM_N\JMDbžE\DkPl_qaM›3^OD:kFRE\E\DN\CR3aMbMNVPSRmP\JMD ^dLOh:LdP\NgRf

PSJ D/CMEHDFN\DarPSDFb–P\R3hzR›3ES_C JMLOkªLdh _›DFNF?6˜gDFR3›ES_CMJ LOkekFRR3E\b LOa_qP\DFN[_E\D/˜W_qIMN\N¦y

_cR3E\bMD -$LO^dR3hzDPSEHLOk—kR6R3EHbMLOaM_qPSDN E\_aMNHpDFEHN\DK«mDE\k_9PSR3E ?Z[R3arPSR3I Ex^OLdaMDFN

_EHD-N\C_kDFb Dp3DEH @¢¢ hK?

? / RiJMR3IMEHNKRqf—_hxcMLODa$PsNHDFLdN\h:LOkaMRLON\D _qP

NHPS_qPSLdR3a7B š W? ?rZ _IMNS_q^‚_aMb:_k_qIMNS_^EHDFkR3aMNHP\E\IMkPSDb _^dDFLO›J / _p3DN #CwRqy

N\LAPSLAp3DX_aMbsaMD›r_qP\Ldp3DgP\LOh:DFN6bMR3h:LOa_qa$P CwDE\LORbs~N [cDP?/ DFDFa8NHPl_9PSLORa

5a RP/NHJMR%/ea-R3amP\JMDxhz_C e_aMbmPSJMDVE\DFNQP Rf"PSJMDVaMDP?/ R3E -‚? JMDxPSE\_kFDVDFarp3Dvy

^ORCwDNe_E\DgEHDFCMEHDFN\DarPSDFb_NªPSJMLdaK›ES_–kFI EHp3DNF?t?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @Œ

@¢ ?, Œ9y}”$y / _pDtp3D^ORkFLAP}hzRbMDF^? UDtNHJMR%/ VJMR3EHL !R3arPl_^NH^OLOkDFN…DuPSE\_kP\DFb f#EHR3h

PSJ DŒ9y}” hzRbMD^[_qPVbMLA­¬DE\DFarP7b DFC P\JMNF?BpDFES_q›3D $y /[_p3D pDF^dR6kLdP} LONVN\JMR%/ea

LOa /eJMLAPSDscRu6DN R3a PSJMDKcRP\P\R3h Rf/kFR3EHE\DFNHCwRaMbMLOa ›UNH^OLOkDFN? [^`_k.- b_N\J DFb

^OLdaMD:_qPVbMDFC P\J y¦¢ ?, -$h N\J R/eN—P\JMD ^dLOh:LdP\NgRf PSJ D E\LAfP !R3aMDq? UD_^dN\RmCM^ORP

_:Œ9y¦” pLOD / Rf"P\JMDXhzRbMDF^? JMDxŒ9y¦” cM^OI DWCM_qPSklJmbMDF^dLOh:LdPSN PSJMDWLONHRqy<pDF^ORkFLAP}

CDFEHP\IME\cM_qPSLdR3a–N\IMEQf5_kFDWkFRE\E\DN\CR3aMbMLdaM›7PSR:_:>6?, p3DF^dR6kLdP}–CDFEQPSIMEHc_qP\LOR3a? @Œ3’

@¢ ? R3CwR›3ES_C JMLOk©hz_CXRf P\JMD "_E -r•DF^db—_EHD_ _a:@3@y -h ^`_EH›3D©N\T$I_EHD *N\JMR%/eLdaM›

NHPS_qPSLdR3aMN PSE\LO_aM›3^dDFN [_aMb'6B/Ÿ #cM^OIMD ??V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @Œ3Y

@¢ ?j2B/a ›3IM^`_qEQy}NHCwDDFbgbMLdNHP\E\LOc I PSLdR3a RfCMEHDy}C E\RkFDFNHN\DbVLdaMkFR3h:LOa › aMR3LdN\D R3agP\JMD "_E -3y

•D^Ob2a DP?/ R3E - _p3DFE\_›3Db Rp3DFE R3aMD8h:R3arPSJ¬? ©^O_aMD / _p3D8cwDF_h:f#RE\h:LOaM›‡LON

N\I hzh:DFbmLOaMkR3JMDFEHDFarPS^A8RpDFE—@¢¢zf#E\DTI DFaMkLODFNtf#E\R3h _ t¢ ?j>:PSR¢ ?)zŽ!—_qaMb

5c [¢ ?xPSR–@3?“Œ7Ž!q? JMD/u$y¦_9u6LdNªkFR3EHE\DFNHCwRaMbMN PSR7a R3LONHDgbMLOEHDFkP\LdpLdP}

θ

6aMR3EHP\J

LON

0

? ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @F~r¢

@¢ ?“’ _aM›3Dvy<PSLdhzDgEHDFCMEHDFNHDFarPl_qP\LOR3a8Rf PSJ D y kFR3h:CR3aMDFarPtRf P\JMDxaMRLON\DVkFR3EHE\D^`_9y

PSLdR3asPSDFa N\R3Eg_pDFES_q›3DFb-Rp3DE R3aMDVhzRa$P\JLOaKP?/[Rf#EHDFT$IMDaMk8c_aMbMN _ “¢6?d@y

@3?“ŒXŽ!$_aMb 5c “¢ ?9yS@3?jŒXŽ !?7…_qklJ CM^dRP©J_NocDFDazaMRE\hz_^OL!FDFb7crLAPSN©R%/ea

hz_9u6LOh—IMhK?g?W?V?W?X?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? @F~M@

(12)

@¢ ?jY 6DFLdN\h:LOkN\DkPSLdR3a Rc Pl_LdaMDFb‡f#E\Rh PSJMD:kFR3EHE\D^`_qP\LOR3a‡CMEHR6kDFN\N—_qfPSDEV_q^O^o_p3DES_9y

›3LOaM›/R3CwDES_qP\LOR3a NF? JMDªN\Ld›3a_^§y<PSR9y}aMR3LdN\D©E\_qPSLdR LON"_cwRpDeŒ3¢/b f#R3E"D_klJ—P\ES_kD?

[RPSJsCMJM_N\DWbMLONHCwDE\NHLOR3as_a b8_qPHPSDaIM_qPSLdR3aK_E\DgR3c N\DFEQp3Db? JMDVNHDFLdN\h:LOk CMEHRqy

C_›r_qP\LOR3a:E\Dp3DF_^ON[P\JMD/C E\DFNHDFaMkDgRf*P?/ R7N\IMEQf5_kFD/ _p3DN /eLdPSJz›3E\RIMC p3D^ORkFLAP}

Rf _qcwR3I6PY3¢_aMb @>¢7h9NF??V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @~rŒ

@¢ ?d@¢rŸ‚EHDFT$IMDaMk /[_p3DFa$IMhxcwDE Ÿy PSE\_aMNQf#R3E\h Rqf P\JMD7N\DLON\h:LOk7NHDFkPSLORa Rc Pl_L§y

aMDFbLdaŸ"Ld›M?@¢ ?“Y ? JMD/^O_E\›DFNHP h:D_NHIMES_c ^OD / _p3Da$IMh—cDFEe_kkFR3EHbMLOaM›WPSRWPSJMD

6J_aMa R3a-kFEHLdPSDE\LdR3a8LdN

2 π

qb /eLdP\J-b > h #›3E\DDFa-^dLOaMD ? JMD_^dL`_NHLOaM›LOa PSJMD:Ÿy bMLO_›3E\_h LdNgE\DN\R3^Ap3DFb cr-IMa(/eES_qCMCMLOa ›sP\JMD --_9u6LON? JMDN\JM_CwDRf

PSJMDgP?/ Rzh:R6b DFNªR3asPSJMDWŸy b L`_›3E\_h EHDpD_^dNb LON\CDFEHN\LAp3DXhzRbMDNF?X?X?V?W?V? @~3~

@¢ ?d@@6DPQy}IMCRqfPSJMDIM^APSES_qN\R3aMLdkeDu6CwDE\LdhzDa$PF? J D/N\RIME\kD N\kF_aMN P\JMD/NHIMEHf5_qkFD /eLAPSJ

@ hzh NQPSDFC Nª_^ORaM›—_x^dLOaMDRf 3¢WhzhK? JMD bMLdE\DkPSLApLdP}

o@Y3’3’ /Rqf R3aMD:^`_qN\DFEXNHJMRPVLONXN\JMR%/ea f#REWNHJMD_qE PSES_qaMNHpDFE\NHD

T

/ _pDFN

_aMb /[DF_-DEtkR3hzC E\DFNHN\LdR3a_^#^OR3a ›3LdP\IMbMLOaM_^

L

/[_pDFN? ?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @~(

@¢ ?d@> LOh:Dy}b LONHPS_aMkD/ _pD•D^Ob 5^OLdaMD_qE N\kF_^OD _E\c LdPSE\_EH:IMa LdP v? o_klJm_I PSRkFRE\E\Dvy

^`_qP\LOR3a

C

ii

(τ)

LdN—CM^ORqP\PSDb‰f#R3E—bMLA­¬DE\Da$PCR3NHLdPSLdR3a

i

_q^OR3aM›P\JMD ty}_9u6LON _aMb PSLOh:D

τ

?0R3NHLdP\LOR3a ¢-hz_E -$NxP\JMDskFDFarP\DFERfePSJMDK_EHES_ _9y<D —_EHD–bMLd­wDFEHDFarP E\DMDFkP\LOR3a N #N\DDWP\JMDgPSDuP ?:?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?X?V?W?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W?X?V?W?V? @~(

@¢ ?d@Œ(DDFkPSLdpLAP} #^OLOa D_EzN\k_q^OD([_E\c LdPSE\_EHiIMa LdP :RfXPSJMD-_q^OIMh:LOaMLdIMh cM^dR6k.- _N

CME\R3cDFbKcr–cMIM^-N\J D_E /[_pDFN? JMDW_EHES_–Rf 3¢7^`_qN\DFEªNHR3IMEHkFDFNLONe_9P! ¢ ?

[^`_k.-VLOaMb LOk_9PSDFNo_gJMLd›3JE\DDFkPSLdpLAP}3? JMDªPSRC:RqfwP\JMDeJMR3^ODªLdN kF^dD_EH^dVp6LdN\LdcM^ODq?

JMDW_kP\I_^*CR3N\LAPSLORa–RfP\JMDXk^OLdaMbMDEªLONªbMLdN\CM^O_DFbKLOa–PSJ DWb RP\P\DFbs^OLdaMD?„?V? @~$

(13)

?A@ Bp3DFE\_›3Dpq_^dIMDFNzRfXPSJMDEHDF^O_qPSLAp3D8LdaMNHP\E\IMh:DFarPS_^/DE\E\RE\N f#R3E:PSJMEHDFD-NQPl_qP\LOR3aMN

C_LdE\N‚˜+MZ…y?wB ˜>MZ…y?oŸ * _aMb'wB$yoŸ *—? ?V?W?W?V?X?W?V?W?V?W?W?V?W? 3>

?j> |}arPSDE\CMEHDPl_9PSLdpD7p_q^OIMDNgRf…LOaMNQPSE\I hzDa$PS_^ DE\E\RE\N f#R3E P\JMD7NHPS_qPSLdR3aMNW˜+MZ _qaMb

* IMaMbMDEP\JMDW_N\NHIMhzC6PSLORaPSJ_qPeP\JMDFEHDWLdNªaMRDFEHE\R3E_qPB ?W?V?W?W?V?W? Œ

(14)

c X_LOH ZTfT\~X_SVHJc

 $¹º ºJ¬i£¸®¤

!"#$!%#&'#(#$)#+*'*'*,* -

./)#01!2)#345)6)#3 74896:; =<2#>4@?A72#B*'*,*'*'*,*'*,**,*'*'*,* C

DE !F47G !%72#65H**'*,*'*,*'*'*,**,*'*,*'*'*,*'*,**,*'*'*,* I

' ˆ M‚$ !#-$ 9 KJ !¦†§58…†§

(

$ 6ˆU

(

7F4ˆU6

©œIMa¥bMDFN R3c HDFkPSLAf#N bMD^O_UNHLON\h:R3^dR3›3LOD–DP–CM^dIMN ›3]aM]FE\_^ODhzDarPbMD^O_U›3]R3CMJrN\LdTI DDFNQP–bMD

bM]PSDE\h:LOaMDE[^`_WNHP\E\IMkPSIMEHD bMD ^O_WPSDE\EHDg_p3DFkg^dDtC ^OIMN b D/CMEH]FkFLdN\LdR3aCR3N\NHLOcM^dD? oa–b R3aMa_arP[IMaMD

Ldh _›D bM]PS_LO^d^O]D bMD^`_gNHP\E\IMkPSIMEHD/_kPSIMD^O^dDªbMDt^O_ PSDFEHE\D ^O_ ›3]FRCMJr6NHLOT$IMDtDFNHP kFRhzCM^d]Fh:DFarPl_qLOE\D

bMDz^`_s›3]FRklJMLdhzLdD:DPxb D ^`_s›3]R3^OR3›LODT$IML ]PSIMb LODFarPxbMDFNVCME\RkFDN\N\I N—LOarPS]›3E\]Nxb_qaMNx^dD:P\DFh:CMN

CDFEHhzDP\Pl_qa$P…bMDE\DPSE\_kFDE ^œ“JMLdNHP\R3LOEHD bMDe^`_gPSDE\E\D rh _qLONo_p3Dk/IMaMDE\]N\R3^dI PSLdR3aN\C_9PSL`_q^ODª^OLdhzLAPS]D?

_/NHLON\h:R3^dR3›3LOD©CDFEHhzDP"b D kFR3a a_MLOP\E\D…^`_ep6LAPSDN\N\D[bMDFN RaMbMDFN!‡DP x_qI—N\DLOa—bMD[^`_P\DFEHE\D?Z[DF^d^ODvy

kLbM]FCDFa bKb DFNªC_E\_h:‘PSEHDFN ]^`_NQPSLdTI DFN DPebMD ^`_VbMDFaMNHLdP\](MT$IMLDI6u$y}h %Fh:DFN NHR3arPªf#R3aMkPSLORabMD

^O_—hzLdaM]FE\_^OR3›LODDPbMDFNkFRaMbMLdP\LOR3a N[PSJMDE\h:R6b66aM_hzLdT$IMDFN #CME\DN\N\LdR3a MP\DFh:Cw]ES_qP\IME\D ?

aMDeCME\DhzLd‘FE\De]Pl_CD_X]PS]bMDebM]P\DFEHhzLdaMDFE©^O_XNQPSEHIMkP\IME\DES_b L`_^dD hzRDFaMaMDbMDe^`_ P\DFE\EHD?Z[D^`_

_ ]PS]ªCDFE\h:LON"C_E ^œ“R3c N\DFEQpq_qPSLdR3a—bMDN PSDFh:CMN©bœ“_EHE\Ldp]FDªbœR3aMb DFNo›3]Fa ]FE\]DFNoC_E"bMDFNoN\]LONHhzDN bMD

f#R3EQPSDehz_›3aMLAPSIMbMDeDP[EH]]klJMLODN _IzN\DFLdazb D/^`_ P\DFE\EHD($DFazf#R3aMkP\LOR3abMDt^`_gbMLdNHPl_qaMkFD]FCMLdkFDa$P\ES_^dD

•›3IMEHD @?d@ v?…Z[DFN:]P\IMbMDFN:R3arP:hzRa$P\E\]sT$Iœ“_I C E\DFh:LODE7R3E\b E\Ds^ODNpq_EHL`_qP\LOR3a N—^`_qP\]FE\_^ODN—bMD

pLdP\DFNHN\DbMDN—R3aMb DFN DP _I‰NHDFLOažb D ^`_sPSDE\E\D ]Pl_qLODFarPVf5_LOcM^dDFNXbMDp_qa$P—^ODFNWpq_E\LO_qPSLdR3aMNXbMD

^O_‡pLdP\DFNHN\DDa2f#R3aMkPSLORa2bMDm^`_UC E\Rf#R3a bMDFIME? |}^DFNQPbMRaMk8^d]F›3LAPSLOh:D–bœ“_CMCMEHRu LdhzDEz^O_ P\DFE\EHD

C_qE IMa–h:R6bM‘^ODES_b L`_^kFR3h:CR3N\]tbMDgbMLd­w]FEHDFarPSDN kFRIMklJMDFNekR3aMkFDarPSE\LdT$IMDFN kE\R #6PSD/P\DFE\EHDFNQPSE\D

hz_arPSDF_I-N\IMC]FEHLODIMEgCMIMLdN LOa f#]E\LdDFIME waMR3_I‡DuPSDE\aMDDP LOarPSDE\aMDq? *D7hzRbM‘F^dDxbMDxkFD—P}CwD^dD

CM^dIMNgkFRaMa$IUDNHPX^OD7h:RbM‘F^dD …«

¦@Y3’ @ tCMEH]FNHDFarPS]:N\IMEg^O_

•›IME\D@3?j>6?

(15)

>

=<2#= ()B$0"!!2# 4@?(!%##!M<A)# 01!2)#=!%$01!2601! F4# !26)

(<6)!M

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

0 1221 3480 5 600 6371

Velocity (km/s) / Density (103 kg/m3) VP VS

ρ Graine

Noyau Manteau

Manteau supérieur + croûte

&(')* 0M,+B 14 BBD.-0/* 1DE55=5!; 2!3/ :4*F0 65 <; 879:6;=<.>@?BADCE:GF@?IH

J ?IHK;=LDAM>@?N1 -"OQP4-ER2R=5 <()# !% !% )#S 5)##)# <01<; % 01! )#901!2)#9D UT 5!2#V%72

!2#5(!W$01!2601!F/<0X$01!27 *

(16)

Œ

# I

TM#=65(,$01!24 677()'<A!22 !% -$ !2# *

_XkFR3aMaM_LONHNS_aMkD/bMIzhzRbM‘^ODehzRDFa b Dt^O_XP\DFE\EHD($cMLdDFa T$IœLOh:CR3EHPS_arPSD(ra¬œ“DNHP[P\R3I P\Df#R3LdN…CM_N

NHI:NS_arPSDKCR3IME7_p3RLOE7IMaMD–kR3h:CME\]JMDFaMNHLOR3a CMEHRf#R3aMb D–bMDs^`_8b a_qhzLdTI DPSDFEHE\DNHPSEHD? R3IME

_^d^ODEgCM^OIMNW^ORLOa‡LO^©DNHPVaM]FkDFN\N\_LOEHD bœR3c P\DFaMLdEVI aMD:p]FEHLdPl_qcM^ODLOhz_›3DŒ” bMIU›3^OR3cDT$IML NHDFIM^dD

CDFI PEH]p3]^ODE PSR3I P\DX^`_—kFRhzCM^dDu6LdP\] bMDX^`_—kE\R #6PSD PSDE\EHDFNHP\E\D ^O_—›3]FRhz]PSE\LdD bMDg^O_—^OLdP\JMR3NHCMJM‘FEHD

R3IžDaMkFRE\Dh:DPHPSE\D DFaž]pLdbMDFaMkD–bMDFNxCMJM]Fa R3hz‘aMDFN7^dLO]N &8^O_8kFR3arpDFkP\LOR3ažhz_arPSD^O^dLOT$IMDPSDF^dN

T$IMDX^ODNeCwR3LdarPSNªklJ_I bMNF?

*DFNh:]PSJ R6bMDNDhzC ^OR3]DFN"CR3IMEbM]PSDE\h:LOaMDE^O_NQPSEHIMkP\IME\D N\LONHhzLdT$IMDobMD ^O_ PSDFEHE\D E\DFCR3NHDFarP"NHIME

IMazCME\LdaMkFLdCwDªNHLOh:CM^ODrLd^MNFœ“_›3LAP…bMDehzDN\IMEHDFE…^`_ pLdPSDN\NHDtbMDCMEHR3C_›r_9PSLORa:b DFN…R3aMbMDN NHLON\h:LOT$IMDN

Da$P\E\DtIMa ›3E\_aMbzaMR3h—cMEHDtb D/N\]LONHhzDN DP bMDNHPS_qPSLdR3aMN$DP[bMDtklJMDFEHklJMDFE[DFaMNHIMLdP\DtIMa hzRbM‘F^dDªbMD

P\DFE\EHD CDFEHhzDP\Pl_qa$PVbœDu6CM^dLOT$IMDFEV_I‰h:LODI6u‡^œ“DaMN\Dh—cM^OD:bMDzkFDFNVhzDN\IMEHDFN?!_mEH]FN\R^OI P\LOR3a bMI

h:R6b ‘F^OD _LOaMNHLR3c P\DFa$I8b ]FCDFaMbKbMLOEHDFkPSDFh:DFarPbMIKaMR3h—c E\DgbMDgPSE\_HDP\NtCR3IMEª^dDFNHTI DF^ONeR3aK_CMI

h:DFNHIME\DEªbMDFNªpLdP\DFN\NHDFNbMDgCMEHR3C_›r_9PSLORa–DPebMR3a kgbMIma R3h—cMEHDgbMDgN\]LON\h:DFNªDaME\D›3LONQPSEH]FNF?‚”tDW^&

bM]kFR3I ^ODFarP/^ODFNCMEHLOaMkLOC_^dDFNe^OLdhzLAPl_qP\LOR3a N[bMDWkFDN hz]PSJMRbMDN ‚bMDV^`_EH›3DFN !FR3a DFN/NHIMEtP\DFEHE\DWN\R3arP

_NHLONHhzLdTI DFN •›3IMEHD@3?“Œ DP f5_I P\D—bMD—NHR3IMEHkFDFNgb¬œ“R3a bMDFNgaMRIMN aMD7CR3I pR3aMN ^dDFN ]PSIMbMLdDFE/_pDFk

IMa D cwRaMaMD/EH]FNHR3^OI P\LOR3a¬?6”/_aMN ^dDFN…E\]F›LOR3aMN N\LdN\h:R3›3‘Fa DFN^ODN P\E\DFhxcM^ODhzDa$P\N[bMDPSDE\E\DtPSDFa bMDFarP

& C E\Rp3DaMLOE/P\R3IHR3I E\N/b DFN h %Fh:DFN!FR3aMDNgbMDVf5_qLO^O^dDFN kFD—T$IML^OLOh:LdP\DX^`_zb Ldp3DE\NHLdPS]VbMDFNtPSES_%HDPSN?

©œ“_cMN\RE\C P\LOR3aUES_CMLdbMD:bMDFNVR3aMbMDN—bMD NHIMEHf5_qkFD b D C]FE\LdR6b DzLda f#]FEHLODFI E\D &>¢KNE\DaMbžbML:kLO^OD

^œ“]PSIMbMDgb ]Pl_qLO^O^d]FDbMDg^`_—kE\R #6PSD PSDE\EHDFNHP\E\Dq?=_xf5_qLOcM^dD/RkFkFI E\E\DaMkFDXbMDNªN\]LON\h:DFN MT$I_arP &—DF^d^OD(

Lda$P\DFEHbMLdP…^ œ]P\IMbMDbMDFN bM]f#RE\hz_qPSLdR3aMN©LOa bMIMLdP\DFNoC_E…^`_gPSDkP\R3aMLOT$IMDt_I:p3R3LdN\LOaM_›3DebMDFN…f5_LO^d^ODN R3I

DaMkFR3EHDW_ImNHDFLdaKb¬œ“IMam]FbMLA•kFDgpR3^OkF_aMLOT$IMDq?

(17)

~

−20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140

−0.03

−0.02

−0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03

Tremblement de terre

Temps en secondes

Amplitude

Onde P directe

Onde S directe

Coda sismique

/ !"#$!% 7!#(#$ #572(>O /# 01! 525(!M- >- *3!

4#5!"72&017 A01 )# 01!2)# D5 #7 M)# )# 01!2)#0T * 6)0 2)# 6)01!2#572()/)# !+)#

())#3<()#!%'7!2,01!"72'()601## !26) 8 <A01!2!%5"*

Bt•aKbœ“_^O^dDFE[_I6y}b DF^&—b DgkFDFN^OLdhzLAPl_qP\LOR3a N3aMRIMNeN\R3IMJM_LdP\R3aMN p3RLOE b_qaMNeTI DF^O^dD h:DFN\I E\DXLO^wDFNHP

CwRN\N\LdcM^OD:bMD:f5_LOEHDzbMDz^`_sPSR3h:R3›3E\_CMJMLdD7DFa‰NHDN\DEHpq_arP—IMa LOT$IMDFh:DFarPxbMI‰cMEHIMLdPVbMDzf#RaMb‰N\LdNQy

hzLdT$IMD? ©œj_pq_arPl_›D[bMI—c E\IMLAP"C_qE"ES_qCMCwREHP"_I6uVN\]LON\h:DFN DNHP T$IœLO^DFNQP bMLdN\CR3aMLdcM^OD…C_EQPSR3I PDP

& PSR3I Poh:R3h:DFarP?qB/LdaMN\LR3aDFNHCw‘E\DeCR3I p3RLOE ]PSIMbMLdDFE©^O_ kFE\R(# PSDªPSDE\EHDFNHP\E\D_p3DkI aMDehzDLO^O^dDFIMEHD

E\]N\R3^dI PSLdR3aN\C_qP\L`_^dD(qDP %PSEHDek_C_qcM^ODªbMDbM]PSDFkPSDE bœ]pDFarPSI DF^ON klJ_aM›DFh:DFarPSN…N\DCME\RbMIMLdNS_arP

_IKN\DFLdasbMImh:LO^dLODIbMDXCME\RC_›r_qP\LOR3a¬?

6) ( z# 9—*%¥$ˆ ¨:…

n PSIMbMLdDFE ^O_WP\DFE\EHD &x^œj_LdbMD/b D cME\I LdP bMD/f#R3aMb–NHLONHhzLdTI D/CM^dI PP T$Iœ“_pDFkXbMDNªDFaMEHDF›3LdNHPSEHDFh:DFarPSN

bMD–N\]LONHhzDN7E\DFC E\]FNHDFarPSDKIMa klJ_a ›3DFh:DFarP:kFR3a kFDFC6PSIMD^ªLOh:CwR3EQPl_arPF? *R3EHN\T$IMD–^œR3až]PSIMbMLdD–^`_

CME\RC_›r_qP\LOR3a8bœ“RaMbMDFNX›3]aM]FEH]FDNWCM_E bMDN PSE\Dh—cM^dDFh:DFarPSN b D—PSDFEHE\D R3a-N\I CMCwRN\DT$IMD7kFD^O^ODNQy

kFLWR3arP8I aMD P\ES_HDkP\R3LOEHD b ]PSDE\h:LOaMLdNHP\D T$IœLO^XDNHPmCwR3NHN\LdcM^OD bœ]FkFEHLOEHDUDvu C ^OLOkLdP\DFh:DFarP?eZ[DP\P\D

_CMCMEHR6klJ DWDNHPCDFEHP\LOaMDarPSDgCR3IMEªbMDNh:LO^dLODI6u:N\LdhzCM^dDFN 6PSD^*T$IMDXbMDFNeh:LO^OLdDFI6u:J R3hzR›3‘FaMDNMRI

NHP\ES_qP\Ld•]NWJ R3E\L!FR3arPl_q^ODFh:DFarPF? ©^O^dD7aœ“DNHPXPSRI PSDf#R3LONgC_qNWNHI:NS_arP\D b_a NW^dD7k_NXbœIMa hzLd^OLdDFI

bMLd­wIMN\_arPVDPxa D:CDFI6PVEHDFaMb E\D:kFR3h:C PSDbMDPSRI PSD^`_–kR3hzC ^ODu6LAPS]—bœIMaUN\LONHhzR›3ES_h:h:D DF^d^OD

CwDE\h:DP[bœ“Dvu6CM^OLdTI DFE ^œj_EHE\LAp3]FDbMDN R3aMbMDN "4zDP[bMDFN[R3aMbMDN N\IMEQf5_kFD Mhz_LONoC_N[^ODFN[_E\EHLdp]FDFN

Pl_EHbMLdpDFNekFRaMNHP\LdPSIM_arPt^O_—kFRb_N\LONHhzLdT$IMD #•M›3IME\D@3?~ v?

©a8D­wDP‚^`_7kFRb_7E\]N\IM^APSDWbMDX^`_7bMLd­wIMNHLOR3asbMDNtR3a bMDFNC_Ee^ODNeJM]P\]FE\R›3]FaM]LdP\]FNCME\]N\DFarP\DFN _qI

N\DLOabMD ^O_ kFE\R(# PSD[P\DFEHE\DFNQPSEHD

Q@Yr

(

Q@Y3’¢

Q@Y3Y’ v?‚Z[DPHPSDWbMLd­wIMN\LdR3ash—IM^APSLOC ^OD LdhzCM^dLOT$IMD I aMDV›ES_aMb DWkR3h:CM^ODvu LAPS] N\L*cMLdDFaKTI D

^ODeklJ_h:CbœR3aMbMDN aMDeCDFI P %P\E\De]FkE\LAPoDu6CM^OLdkFLAPSDFh:DFarPF?3|}^DFNQP b L:kFLd^ODªbMDeh:R6bM]^OLdN\DFE"^`_/f#R3EHhzD

bœR3aMbMDbMDe^`_gkFRb_gkFRaMa_LdN\NS_qa$P ^ODªh:LO^dLODI 5CMEHR3cM^d‘Fh:D bMLOEHDFkP DP…LOh:CR3N\NHLOcM^dD bMDebM]P\DFEHhzLdaMDFE

^ODgh:LO^dLODFI &^œj_qLObMD b DFNR3aMbMDNb DW^O_7kFRb_7TI L*^OD PSE\_p3DFEHN\Da$P 5CMEHR3cM^d‘Fh:D LOarp3DE\NHD ?

Z/œ“DNHP©CM_ES_b Ru _^dDFh:DFarP kDPHPSD kR3hzC ^ODu6LAPS]oT$IML CDFEHhzDP"bœ“_cR3I P\LOE &/bMDFN"CME\R3C E\LO]PS]N"N\LdhzC ^ODFN

Références

Documents relatifs

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des