HAL Id: jpa-00210125
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00210125
Submitted on 1 Jan 1985
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Structural study of the charge-density-wave phase transition of the blue bronze : K0.3MoO3
J.P. Pouget, Claudine Noguera, A.H. Moudden, R. Moret
To cite this version:
J.P. Pouget, Claudine Noguera, A.H. Moudden, R. Moret. Structural study of the charge-density-wave phase transition of the blue bronze : K0.3MoO3. Journal de Physique, 1985, 46 (10), pp.1731-1742.
�10.1051/jphys:0198500460100173100�. �jpa-00210125�
Structural study of the charge-density-wave phase transition
of the blue bronze : K0.3MoO3
J. P. Pouget, C.
Noguera,
A. H. Moudden and R. MoretLaboratoire de Physique des Solides (*), Bât. 510, Université Paris-Sud,
Centre d’Orsay, 91405 Orsay Cedex, France (Reçu le 8 avril 1985, accepté le 7 juin 1985)
Résumé. 2014 Nous présentons une étude par diffusion des rayons X de la transition de Peierls du bronze bleu
K0,3MoO3
incluant la variation thermique de l’intensité des réflexions satellites du 1er et 2e ordre en dessous deTc, une complète caractérisation des fluctuations structurales (dépendance en température et anisotropie) au-
dessus de Tc et une mesure précise du vecteur d’onde des ondes de densité de charge au-dessus et en-dessous de
Tc. L’analyse de la transition de phase dans le cadre d’une théorie de champ moyen est justifiée. Elle conduit
à des valeurs raisonnables du couplage électron-phonon et de l’interaction de Coulomb entre ondes de densité de charge. La valeur du vecteur d’onde de la distorsion résulte de la présence de 2 bandes de conduction quasi
unidimensionnelles coupant le niveau de Fermi EF, et d’une 3e bande située vers 650 K au-dessus de EF. L’ouverture d’une bande d’énergie interdite au niveau de Fermi se produit à la transition de Peierls par recouvrement d’une bande de conduction sur l’autre. Il en résulte un état semiconducteur au-dessous de Tc. Finalement, nos mesures ne montrent pas clairement l’existence d’une transition de phase, commensurable-incommensurable en fonction de la température.
Abstract 2014 We present an X-ray study of the Peierls transition of the blue bronze K0.3MoO3, including the tem- perature dependence of the intensity of the first order and second order satellite reflections below Tc, a complete
characterization of the structural fluctuations above Tc (both their temperature dependence and their anisotropy)
and an accurate determination of the wave vector of the charge density wave above and below Tc. An analysis of
the phase transition within a mean field theory is justified and yields reasonable values of the electron phonon coupling and of the Coulomb interaction between charge density waves. The value of the modulation wave vector is explained as resulting from the presence of two conducting quasi one dimensional bands crossing the Fermi
level EF and of a third one located about 650 K above EF. The opening of an absolute gap at the Fermi level occurs at the Peierls transition due to the folding of one conduction band on the other, and leads to a semiconducting
state below Tc. Finally our measurements do not reveal any clear commensurate-incommensurate phase transition
in temperature.
Classification
Physics Abstracts
61.50K - 64.70K - 71.30 - 72.15N
1. Introduction.
The so-called blue bronzes are ternary
molybdenum
oxides of formula
Ao,3Mo03
where the alkali metal Acan be K or Rb
[1].
In thesecompounds
the alkalimetal
usually
donates its outer electron to the transi- tion metal which thus fillspartially
the d states whichwould be otherwise empty in the oxide
Mo03.
KO.3MOO3
belongs to the monoclinic space groupC2/m
with twenty formulae per unit cell[2].
The crys-tallographic
structure is built with infinite sheets ofMo06
octahedraseparated by
the K ions. If the (*) Associe au CNRS.stoichiometry corresponds exactly
to the formulaKo,3Mo03
all the available alkaline sites areoccupied
The
Mo06 layers
consist of clusters of octahedra linkedby
corners in the[010]
and[102]
directions;the cluster itself contains 10
Mo06
octahedrasharing edges.
The clusterpacking
issteplike along
the[102]
direction and in column along the
[010]
direction. Inspite
of itslayered-type
structure,Ko,3Mo03
exhibitsa very
anisotropic
electricalconductivity [3],
of maxi-mum value in the monoclinic b direction made of infinite chains of
Mo06
octahedra.Actually,
recentoptical
measurements have shown that, at room tem- perature,KO.3MOO3
can be considered as aquasi
one-dimensional
(1 D)
metal [4].Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:0198500460100173100
Physical
studies established that the blue bronze shows a semiconductor to metal transition in thevicinity
of 180 K(Tc)
[3-5]. Moreprecisely
an X-raydiffuse
scattering study
[6]proved unambiguously
that this transition is a Peierls transition towards an
incommensurate
charge-density-wave
(CDW) state, with the formation belowTc
of well defined satellite reflections at the reduced wave vector qc = (0, qb, 0.5),where the in-chain component is incommensurate and temperature
dependent.
AboveTc,
the structuralphase
transition is announced
by anisotropic
X-ray diffusescattering [6]
whichcorresponds
to a Kohn anomalyin the phonon spectrum
[7-9].
Simultaneously, nonlinear
conductivity, presumably
due to asliding
of theincommensurate CDW
[10],
was evidenced, stimulat-ing
animportant
work on non-linear transport in these compounds [11].Following
the earlier X-rayfinding
of a CDWdriven Peierls transition in
Ko.3Mo03 by
aphoto- graphic
method [6], we shall present here aquantita-
tive
study
of this structuralphase
transitionby
acounting
method. The purpose of this paper is multi- fold :- to characterize the structural fluctuations above
T c
and their temperature evolution;- to measure
accurately
the temperaturedepen-
dence of the wave vector of the modulation and inves-
tigate a
possible
commensurate-incommensurate transformation[14] ;
- to
provide
asimple description
of the Peierls transition and of the temperaturedependence
of theincommensurate modulation.
2.
Experimental
procedures.The
single crystal
used in thisexperiment
was grownaccording
to reference[12].
It is aplatelet
of 3 x 1.5 x0.2 mm3
parallel
to the(201)
cleavageplane
with the baxis
being
along thelong
direction.The
experiment
wasperformed using
an X-raydiffractometer
equiped
with aclosed-cycle
heliumrefrigerator providing
a controlled temperature bet-ween 10 K and 300 K. We used the normal beam geo- metry with a
lifting
scintillator detector. Thecrystal
was mounted with the b* and 2 a* - c* directions in the horizontal
scattering
plane. TheCuKa
radiationwas obtained
by
reflection on a monochromator of the X-ray beamproduced by
a conventional 1.5 kW generator. Two monochromators weresuccessively
used :
- a
doubly
bentgraphite
monochromator[(002) reflection], giving
alongitudinal q
resolution with ahalf width at half maximum
(HWHM)
of 0.015A-1,
for the measurements of the
integrated intensity
of qand 2 q satellites and of the diffuse
scattering
aboveTc;
- a flat LiF monochromator
((002) reflection) giving
animproved
resolution of 0.003 A - I (HWHM)for an accurate determination of the q wave vector.
Before the X-ray
study,
the crystal had been usedfor non linear transport measurements. At 77 K, it presented a well defined threshold field with a switch-
ing
from the Ohmic to the non Ohmicregime,
announc-ed below this field
by
precursor voltagepulses
whenthe dc current was varied
[13].
3. Results and analysis of the data.
3.1 T
T c.
- BelowT c
we have selected for the measurements four strong firstorder
satellitereflec-
tions,
namely the (17, -
1 + qb, 8.5),(17,1 - qb, 8.5),
(17, -
1 - qb, 8.5) and (17, 1 + qb, 8.5) as well as a weak second-order satellite reflection (16, 2 qb,8).
(As
in reference [6] we define qb inside the first Brillouin zone, i.e. qb -0.25-0.30.)
At 12 K the
integrated intensity
of the first order reflections(17,
± 1 + qb,8.5)
that we measured, isabout 3 x 105
counts/min
while that of the second- order reflection(16,
2 qb,8)
isonly
about 800 counts/min. These intensities are
respectively
about two andfour orders of
magnitude
less than that of the two closest main Bragg reflections,(16,
0,8)
and (18, 0,9).
Figure
I shows the temperature variation of theintegrated intensity Iq
of the first-order satellite reflections.Iq extrapolates
to zero around 170 K.This
gives
a critical temperature a fewdegrees
lowerthan that usually found (180 K) for the structural and the metal-insulator phase transition of the blue bronzes
[1 1].
This shift can be ascribed to some diffi- culties with the measurement of the absolute tempe-rature of the
sample.
It has nosignificant
effect on theanalysis
and theinterpretation
of the data. The tempe-Fig. 1. -
Normalized
integratedintensity
of the(17, + 1 ± qb,
8.5)
and (17, ± 1 ± qb,8-5)
first order satellitereflections,
7q,
as a function of the temperature. The dotted line gives the temperature dependence of the square of the B.C.S. order parameter. The insert gives the temperature dependence of the integrated intensity,I2q,
of the (16,2 qb, 8) second order satellite reflection (the solid line is the square of
Iq).
rature
dependence
ofIq
is ingood
agreement withprevious
structural measurements [7, 14] and with the square of thequadrupole splitting
obtained in arecent NMR
study
ofRbo.3Mo03 [18].
For a
given
reflection, the satelliteintensity
isproportional
tor¡2,
where q is the order parameter associated with the lattice distortion [16]. The dottedline of
figure
1gives
the temperaturedependence of q
calculated in a mean field treatment (BCS
theory)
ofthe Peierls transition [17]. It fits
roughly
theexperi-
mental curve.
The temperature variation of the
integrated intensity
,2q
of the second-order satellite reflection(16,
2 qb,8)
is shown in the insert of
figure
1. Withinexperimental
errors, it behaves like the square of the normalized
intensity
of the first-order satellite reflection(Iq)’.
This weak (16, 2 qb,
8)
satellite reflection, observedfor the first time in this work, can be considered either
as a second order diffraction harmonic of the first- order satellite
peak,
or as the 2 q,,: = (0, 2 qbl 0) compo- nent of a non sinusoidal modulation, or as a combi-nation of the two effects. However, with a ratio of
intensity I2q/Iq comparable
to the one between aprimary
satellite reflection and thecorresponding
main Bragg reflection, the
2 qc
satellite islikely
to bemostly
a diffraction harmonic.Below
Tc,
the incommensurate component qb of the modulation wave vector was obtainedby recording the
separationalong
b*between
the (17, ± 1 T qb, 8.5) and (17, ± 1 ± qb, 8.5) reflections, the crystalbeing accurately aligned
with the six closest mainBragg reflections. Figure 2 shows, with the
improved
resolution, two scans
along
the (17, 1 - qb, 8.5)reflections obtained at 130 K and 11.5 K. It demons- trates
clearly
that the 1 - qb component increases as the temperature decreases, and that, at 11.5 K, the reflection is notperfectly
centred on the commensurate value 0.75.Figure
3 reports the temperature variationFig. 2. - Peak profiles along b*, of the (17, 1 - gb, 8.5)
satellite reflection at 11.5 K and 130 K. In these scans a flat LiF crystal has been used as a monochromator.
Fig. 3. - Temperature dependence of the incommensurate component 1 - qb (== 2 k,) of the satellite reflections
(below Tc) and of the diffuse scattering (above T,). Crosses
and filled dots correspond to diffractometric measurements
performed with flat LiF and doubly bent graphite mono-
chromators respectively. Circles correspond to photographic
measurements. The solid line corresponds to the best fit
by equation (15).
of 1 - qb, a
quantity
which is more closely relatedto 2
kF
of the I D bands(see
ref. [6] and thediscussion).
At
Tc, 1 - qb
amounts to 0.737 ± 0.002 then increasesas the temperature decreases and saturates below about 80 K at the value 1 - qb = 0.7495 ± 0.0005.
Below
T,,,
the temperaturedependence
of 1 - qb is in agreement with that of reference [14]. Our valuesare
slightly
greater,by
about 0.002 than that of refe-rences
[7, 15].
Below 80 K, figures 2 and 3 show that, although the value 1 - qb = 0.75 is included in theerror bars, all our determinations
give
valuesslightly
lower than this
simple
commensurate value. Thesame observation can be made on the data of refe-
rence
[14].
Other determinationsgive
a low tempera-ture saturation of 1 - qb at values 0.748 [7, 9] and
0.746 [15], which differ
markedly
from 0.75. All these data show that there is not anunambiguous
commen-surate-incommensurate
phase
transition in the blue bronzes. Differences in thepurity
and the stoichiome- try of the variousinvestigated samples might
be theorigin
of thisdispersion
in the low temperature values of 1 - qb (see part 4).3.2 T >
Tc.
- AboveTr
satellite reflections broad-en into an
anisotropic
diffusescattering.
The diffusescattering corresponding
to the (17, ± 1 + qb’ M.5)satellite reflections was followed up to room tempe-
rature. At each temperature scans
through
the diffusescattering
wereperformed along
threenearly
perpen- dicular directions related to the structuralanisotropy : namely
the directions [010], [102], andperpendicular
to the
(201) layers
ofMo06
octahedra(scans
along b*, 2 a* + c* and 2 a* - c*respectively). Figure
4gives
an example of such scans at 180 K ( =T,,
+ 10 K).Fig. 4. - Peak profiles along the b*(a),
2
a* + c*(b), and2 a* - c*(c) directions of the (17, 1 - qb,
8.5)
diffuse scatter- ing at 180 K. The experimental resolution is indicatedThe maximum of the diffuse
scattering
above thebackground I(qc),
moreeasily
definedby
the scansalong
b* and 2 a* + c*, was measured as a functionof temperature
(Fig.
5). At room temperatureI(q,)
is about 0.3
counts/s,
above abackground
of 1.8counts/
s. At this temperature
I(q,, ,)
is about three orders ofmagnitude smaller
than thepeak intensity
of the(17, -
1 + qb, 8.5), satellite reflection at 11 K(300 counts/s). Figure
5 shows thatI(qc)
increasesstrongly
as the temperatureapproaches T c.
The diffuse
X-ray scattering intensity,
at the scatter-ing
vector Q = G + q isgiven by :
where G is a
reciprocal
lattice vector,Fd(Q)
(thestructure factor of the unstable lattice
mode)
andS(q, t
= 0) the Fourier transform of the instantaneous correlation function of the order parameter. For tem- peratures kT greater than a characteristicfrequency nroc
of the fluctuations, the classical limit of the fluc-Fig. 5. - Temperature dependence of the
peak
intensity I(q,r ,) of the diffuse scattering at (17, - 1 + qb, 8-5), and ofthe inverse quantity corrected by the thermal population factor : T / I(qc). For this last quantity the dotted line is a
fit by a log (T/Tc) dependence and the solid line by the equation (7).
tuation-dissipation
theoremgives :
where
X(q)
is thesusceptibility
associated with the order parameter tlq. Thus, in this limit,I(Q),
dividedby
the thermalpopulation
factor kT, measures thesusceptibility X (q).
As, for q equal to the criticalwave vector qc of a second order phase transition, this
quantity diverges,
it is more convenient toplot X-’(q,,,)
as a function of temperature.Figure
5shows that
X-’(qc)
decreaseslinearly
below about 210 K, thusfollowing
a Curie-Weiss law, and extra- polates to zero at the critical temperatureT,,
= 170 K.A
systematic
deviation from this Curie-Weiss beha- viour(or
moreprecisely
from a LogTIT c dependence (see
part 4) - dotted line infigure 5)
can be observed above about 210 K inspite
oflarge
uncertainties in thehigh
temperature data. In this respect it is interest-ing
topoint
out that the square of thefrequency
ofthe Kohn
anomaly, (JJ2,
which is alsoproportional
to
X-I,
in a soft modedescription
of structuralphase
transitions, shows the same deviation from the Curie- Weiss behaviour athigh
temperature[8].
Let us now present the q
dependence
of the diffusescattering,
which enters in the qdependence
of the sus-ceptibility
X(q). Thissusceptibility
is maximum at acritical wave vector qc’ and
decays
with additional bq components with agenerally
well verified Lorentzianlaw :
where ç, the correlation
length, given by
the inverse HWHM ofX(q),
measures the range of the fluctua- tions in thebq
direction. Realprofiles
are in fact aconvolution of X(q) and of the resolution function.
Moreover when resolution corrections are small and when the base line is well defined the Lorentzian
profile
can beclearly
observed, as in scan(b)
offigure
4. Inanisotropic compounds
such asKo,3Mo03, ç-l
is ananisotropic quantity.
It was measuredby
scans of the diffuse
scattering, along
the three abovequoted nearly perpendicular directions,
related tothe structural
anisotropy.
Figure
6gives,
as a function of the temperature, the observed half width at half maximum(HWHM), Aq,
of the diffusescattering along
the b*, 2 a* + c*and 2 a* - c* directions.
As
T c
isapproached,
Aq decreases towards theexperimental
resolutionR 11
andRl
in the chain and in the transverse directionsrespectively.
In addition tothe diffractometric measurements,
figure
6 containsphotographic
determinations of the HWHMalong
b* and 2 a* + c* and, for
comparison
with theX-ray
data, it includes the HWHMalong
2 a* - c* of the centralpeak
in energy observedby
neutronscattering
a few
degrees
aboveTc [8].
Fig. 6. - Temperature dependence of the half width at half maximum (H.W.H.M.) of the diffuse scattering along the
b* (A, A), 2 a* + c* (0, 8) and 2 a* - c* (D, +) directions.
The hollow symbols correspond to data obtained by diffrac-
tometric measurements. The solid symbols result from photo- graphic measurements and the crosses come from elastic neutron scattering measurements. The dotted line gives the
JT - Tc
dependence for the 3 quantities. For Jb*, the solidline corresponds to a fit by equation (12). Above 180 K, the solid line for A,.*-, is just a guide for the eyes. We have used the convention b b* = 2 x to express reciprocal
distances.
Because of some limitations at
high
temperatures in thesignal
to noise ratio, and in order to extract anintrinsic correlation
length
we choose, instead ofusing
standardfitting
routines, tosimply
subtractfrom the width of the
experimental profile,
the reso-lution width
measured
at low temperatures on the(17,
± 1 :¡: qb,8.5)
satellite reflections. Thisgives
at180 K very
anisotropic
correlationlengths
of 200A,
35 A and 12 A
along
the[010] [102]
and 1(201)
directions. At 250 K correlation
lengths
are respec-tively
40A,
10 A and 7 A. Theanisotropy
of thecorrelation
lengths
follows the structuralanisotropy
and
corresponds
to theanisotropy
of electrical pro-perties [3].
The dotted lines in
figure
6 show that in thevicinity
of
T c’
all the inverse correlationlengths
vary ascharacteristic of a mean field behaviour close to
Tc.
-’Ol
increases morestrongly
thanpredicted by
this law above about 210 K, at about the same tem- perature at which
systematic
deviations from the Curie-Weiss law can be detected(see Fig.
5). Atroom temperature the fluctuations in chain direction still include about 7
M006
octahedra. Withinexperi-
mental errors,
-I
follows the square root beha- viour for all the temperature range. At 250 K,[1023
is
comparable
to the transverse size of the cluster of 10Mo06 octahedra. çL(Ol)
follows the square root law up to about 180 K(Tc
+ 10 K). Above this value its curvature decreasesmarkedly
and it has a tempe-rature
dependence
which is difficult to estimate because of the large uncertainties in the measure- ments. Around 210 K,C;1.(20Í) is comparable
to theaverage distance, 8
A,
betweenlayers
ofMo06
octahedra. At this temperature and above, the diffuse
scattering
is so broadalong
the 2 a* - c* direction that it haspractically
theshape
of the diffuseplatelet
described in an earlier work [6]. The structural fluc- tuations appear as
decoupled
betweenneighbouring layers.
Above
T c’
the diffusescattering
remains centred around the (0, qb, 0.5) reduced wave vector. Becauseof the narrowness of the diffuse
scattering along
b*,the incommensurate component qb can be
signifi- cantly
determined at all temperature. 1 - qb has been obtained betweenTc
and room temperatureby measuring
theseparation
between thediffuse
scatter-ing passing through
the(17,
± 1 T qb, 8.5)reciprocal points. Figure
3gives
the temperaturedependence
of1 - qb. At room temperature 1 - qb is equal to
0.71 ± 0.01, in agreement with the
previous
X-rayphotographic
determination[6],
from which somedata
points
were added in thefigure.
1 - qb increases when the temperature decreases. Withinexperimen-
tal errors there is no
change
in the rate of increase of 1 - qb, at the Peierls transition.4. Discussion.
4.1 GENERAL FEATURES OF THE PEIERLS TRANSITION IN THE BLUE BRONZE
Ko.3Mo03. -
It waspreviously recognized [6]
that the observed value of the wave vector of the Peierls distortion along the chaindirection qo # 0.75 b*
gives
a strong indication that two one dimensional bands cross the Fermi level in thiscompound Considering
that, in the chains built with theMo06
octahedra, all the conduction elec- trons areprovided by
thepotassium
atoms, andassuming
aperfect stoichiometry,
each cluster has three conduction electrons : theresulting
2kF
value, in asimple
one bandpicture,
should thus beequal
to 1.5 b* while qo is
only
half this value.It is thus
interesting
to consider the various aspects that a Peierls transition may present in a two band system and to discuss how the Fermi surface is affectedAlthough
thecomplete
discussion deservesa separate
study
[19], we present infigure
7 threedifferent situations that we believe to be represen- tative :
- In
figure
7a, the two bands aredegenerate
andas a consequence there is
only
one Fermi wave vectorkF,
The Peierls distortion will occur at the wave vector qo = 2kF
= pob*/4 (where po
is the number of conduc- tion electrons per units) which thus should notdepend
upon the temperature. The distortion will open a gap at the Fermi level so that, as in the usualone band
compounds,
the Peierls transition will reveal itselfby
a metal-insulator transition in the transportproperties.
Fig. 7. - Schematic band structure of a two band one-
dimensional conductor, in the presence of a deformation of the lattice of wave vector q : in a) the two bands are dege-
nerate and qo = 2 kF, in b) the two bands are non-degenerate
and qo = k,,
1 + kF 2 :
there is nesting of one band on theother; in c) each band can nest only on itself. The system remains metallic.
- In
figure
7b : the two bands are no longerdege-
nerate ; in the absence of a distortion two Fermi
wave vectors
kFl
andkF2
may be defined, which arerelated to each other through the law of conservation of the number of electrons
kF1 + kF2
= pob*/4.
ThePeierls distortion which takes
place
has the wavevector
qo - kFl + kF2
and there is afolding
of oneband upon the other. In that way, an absolute gap appears on the whole Fermi surface so that the Peierls transition and the metal insulator transition
occur at the same temperature. In a way similar to the
degenerate
case(Fig 7a)
one may notice that qo= kFl + kF2
= pob*/4
isindependent
on tempe-rature.
- In
figure
7c a Peierls distortion at a wave vector qo different fromkFl + kF2
isrepresented.
This mayoccur if there is no
possibility
offolding
of one bandon the other; then a
compromise
between the insta- bilities on the two bands leads either to twophase
transitions or to
only
one with 2kF
qo 2kF2. It is
this last case that is
depicted :
it isquite
clear that the Peierls transition is not a metal-insulator transition : the wave vector of the modulation is temperaturedependent
above and below the Peierls transitionTp.
At a temperature
T, TP
it may occur that, due tothe increase of the individual gaps, there appears an
absolute gap in the electronic spectrum (metal insu-
lator transition). Then the minimization of energy
combined with the conservation of the number of electrons gives the wave vector qo at the value qo
= kFl + kF2
for all temperatures TT,
[19].This discussion shows that the blue bronze
KO.3MoO3 belongs
to one of the two firstcategories
since the Peierls transition leads to an
insulating
state. It is not
possible
to discriminate between thedegenerate
and thenon-degenerate
case although some arguments favour the nondegenerate
one. The firstargument lies on the consideration of the orbitals which
participate
to the formation of the bands[20] :
among the d orbitals ofmolybdenum of t2
character which
give
rise to the firstantibonding
states of the 7r* type of the
Mo06
octahedra, twomay
give
rise toqua.si-1 D dispersive
bands, namelydxz
anddyz,
with z the direction of the chains. But due to the considerable deformation of the octahedra in the directionsperpendicular
to the chains, and thevery low symmetry of the
crystal,
adegeneracy
between these states is very
unlikely.
Moreovernon-degenerate
ID bands of thebonding
and anti-bonding
type may be built with each of these d orbi- tals, due to a small transversecoupling
betweeninequivalent molybdenum
sites inside each cluster.The second argument is
just
a hintprovided by
thevalues of the transverse components of the modula- tion. In the direction
perpendicular
to the sheets of octahedra thevalue q,,
=1/2,
which indicates an outof
phase ordering,
is wellexplained by
a Coulombcoupling
between CDWbelonging
toneighbouring
sheets [6]. But in the
layers
of octahedra the value q,, = 0 is ratherpuzzling,
since it is generally admittedin one band systems that the best transverse
nesting
vector component is 1/2. A
possible explanation
isdepicted
onfigure
8 if one assumes that the two bandsare not
degenerate
and possessopposite
curvaturesin the transverse direction, so that the best
nesting
wave vector of one band into the other at the Fermi level has a qa = 0 transverse component
Finally
one should note that in cases a and b offigure
7 the wave vector of the Peierls distortion cannot vary with temperature. We will come back to thatpoint
at the end of this section. We believe that it is due to an additionalcomplication
of the band struc- ture.Fig. 8. - Schematic representation of the Fermi surface of
a two-band compound in a two-dimensional reciprocal
space. When the curvatures of the Fermi surfaces correspond- ing to the two bands are opposite, a possible good nesting
wave vector is (kFl +