How to prevent pressure oscillations in multicomponent flow calculations~: a quasi conservative approach

Texte intégral

(1)How to prevent pressure oscillations in multicomponent flow calculations : a quasi conservative approach Remi Abgrall. To cite this version: Remi Abgrall. How to prevent pressure oscillations in multicomponent flow calculations : a quasi conservative approach. RR-2372, INRIA. 1994. �inria-00074304�. HAL Id: inria-00074304 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074304 Submitted on 24 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. How to prevent pressure oscillations in multicomponent flow calculations : a quasi conservative approach Re´mi ABGRALL. N˚ 2372 Octobre 1994. PROGRAMME 6 Calcul scientifique, mode´lisation et logiciel nume´rique. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche. 1994.

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6) % '&() *+

(7) ,- ./ 01%2 !"# $ * 3 4 5!6 7 82:9 ;=>@< ?BA

(8) C%DFE ; % C G4G H IJLKNMOJQPSR2R2TUV W:P"XZY [@X]\QY_^`T aObL^dcfeg[hTjikR2K@l T_m Xd^Z\nP"bL^`KOa T_boXZKNMj^`Y_^ZT_X]ag[hRpT m Jq^Zeg[hT IJLKjrLT_b)sj^Zag[h\ t#PSuhukKOJqbvlwTJLT YnxhT JLYnxwTya-zg{N|~}S{4V

(9) Y_bQKOwJLT8"NS)V 7ufPSMOT \ 8 _hSO ahT_ag[hR2T,Jq^`YPX\YnxhT R2TKOJ Y KNR2uh[@bL^àhM$R-[@XdbL^ZY KNR2uKNahT aNb fK*\ ^Z\8uwJLT,\T,aNbQT lb ^`\ Pj@X`TbQK(xfPSahl@X`T1\bQJLKOahM/\QxhK@Y~\ i^`\8uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLTKN\QY_^XdX PbL^`KOa¡JLT T bQxhJLKN[hMOx+bQxhT4Y KOaNbnPSY6b:l~^Z\QY KNaNbL^Zag[@^dbL^ZT \*PjahlMO[fPSJQPSaObL^`T \ bQxhT4ukKO\^bL^d¢g^b£ Kj¤R8PS\Q\JQPSY6¥ bL^ZKNah\,sOKOR2Tvag[hR2T Jq^`Y"P"XfTn¦wuT Jq^`R2T,aNbQ\ KNa2\QxhK@Yn§bQ[hT \^àhl@^`Y"P"bQT:bQxwTvY KOaN¢NT,JLMNT ahY T:bQK bQxhT8Y KOJLJLT Y_b4:TPj\QKSX`[@bL^ZKNaW KNR+u¨PjJq^`\QKNah\

(10) v^dbQx(Y_X Pj\Q\^ZYP"Xcfa@^dbQT2¢OKSX`[hR2T+\YnxhT R2T \ PjJLTP"X`\QK2uhJLKOukKN\QT l ©1ªN«¬L®5¯¨°j²± K@lh[hawK¢g¥³b£wukT\QYxhT R2T,\ ihR[@XdbL^ZY KNR+ukKNahT aObofK*\ ´Zµ2·³¶ ¸q¹º · ¶ 3» ¼½¸¾¿_À ÁqÂ6Ã"Ä6ÅÆÂnÇÈÇÊÉ3Ë³Ì_ÍÎÏÐÂÑ ÏÐÒÅÏÐÂÑ ÓÅ. Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 93 65 77 77 – Te´lećopie : (33) 93 65 77 65.

(11) . .

(12). % +

(13) , Q

(14) !, % %+ ! 4:01 * # / 3 * . % 5 !9% 0%2 * 3 4 5! . . . lqT,ªgm Y KN[@X`T,ªR2 T aNbQ\4

(15) R-a1[@uwXdJ~bLT,m^d¥\TT,\QaNubQTT Y [hT \,akahX KO[~T \L¢Ob4TPjY[PSuf\QPjY~x!XZT m TRlhP2T5ag\[h^ZRR¡[@T m XZJqT ^è~J4[wlhT5T \4ukT YJLxhR+K@YT_\#bLbnPSKNaNJqb§bQ\,XìTM~YPSP"JQXZPjY a~[@¥X bL^bX½ PSh\QY T ahY T+lÈ KN\QY_^XdX PbL^`KOaw\-Pj[bQJQP ¢OT JL\7lhT \Xd^ZMNahT \lhTMjXd^Z\\QT R+T aNb-T_b-MgPjJQPSaNbL^b)X P uKN\L^dbL^¢g^dbwT5m lwT,\*JQPSY_bL^ZKNah\

(16) R8Pj\Q\^Zeg[hT \,# [hT_XZeg[hT \

(17) Tn¦hu T,m Jq^`T ahY T \4\Q[hJ

(18) lhT \*bQ[hT \P8 YxhK@Y ^Zawl@^Zeg[hT aNb7X PY KOaN¢NT,JLMNT ahY T8¢OT JL\XZT \7KNahahT \\QKjX`[@bL^`KOaw\4³P^`@X`T \-lh[¡uhJLKN@XT R2Tji3@^`T,a . eg[hT-Y T\QYx T m R8P2ahT\QKS^b*ufPS\#\LbQJq^`Y_bQT R+T aNb

(19) Y,KNah\QT Jq¢jP"bL^

(20) a1uwJLKOukKO\TPj[h\\L^]lhT \#Y KNR5¥ ufPSJQP^`\QKNah\vP ¢NT,Y)lhT \v\QYx!T m RPS\:¢NKjX`[hR2T \vcä@^Z\oY_X PS\Q\L^èg[hT \ ¯h_¬Q ª sgYx T m R8Pj\olhT4b£wukT ± K@lw[hahK¢i!T m Y KO[@X`T R2T,aNbQ\oR-[@XdbL^¥T \Qu T Y T,\. !". .

(21)

(22)

(23)

(24)

(25) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(26) -,.$/0+*+01. |. qabQx@^`\4ufPSuT J6if:TPSJLT^ZaNbQT JLT \LbQT l%^ZabQxhT2\L^ZR[@X PbL^`KOa%KS R-[@XdbL^`Y,KNR2uKNahT aNbahKNa JLTPjY_bL^àhM7fK#\ *2oxhT4bQxhT JLR2K@l@£@afPSR7^ZYP"XPj\Q\[hR2u@bL^ZKNah\vPSJLT43 5 bQxwT4M~PS\ ^`\#P7R7^d¦~bQ[hJLTKj7698

(27) YP"XZKNJq^`Y"P"XdX£ ukT JqT,Y_bvMgPS\QT \&:<; -2vxhT_^`JvT eg[fP"bL^ZKNaFKS \bnPbQT

(28) ^`\ G H = ;?>A@0;BDC ;FE *xhT JLT = ;^`\bQxhTo^ZaNbQT JLafP"XT ahT JLMS£8KjbQxhT*\QukT,Y_^`T \I:<;³i@0;k^Z\^dbQ\ lhT ah\L^db £Oi E ^`\bQxhT bQT R2ukT,JQP"bQ[hJLT-PSahlbQxhT\QukT Y6^dcfY4xhTP"bJB C ; ^`\:^àhlhT ukT ahlhT aNb§KS E i 5 bQxwTuhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT

(29) ^`\*Mj^d¢OT aFN£LK4PXdbQKOa È\ X P MB^dbQxhKN[@bvX`KO\\:Kj3MOT ahT JQP"X^db £Oiw:TR8P £Pj\Q\[hR2T#bQx¨PbN6O8P> {@ 2ox@^Z\)O^àhl/Kj uhJLKN@X`T,R x¨Pj\P"XZJLTPSl@£%T T av^`lhT_Xd£\LbQ[hl@^`T li]\T,TLQÈ}Oi UwiSR~iTKNJ Tn¦fPSR2u@X`TN2oxhT:Y_X Pj\Q\^ZYP"XOcfa~^bQT ¢NKjX`[hR2T b£@uToKjf\YnxhT R2T \PSJLT:[h\Q[fP"XdX£4³PSY T,l)v^dbQx-b:K R8PrLKNJ:l@^FUY [@XdbL^`T,\3~bQxhTR8PS\Q\:JQPSY_bL^ZKNah\WV PSahlNXYV R8P £FkT Y,KNR2T4ahT M~P"bL^d¢OTji~bQxhT uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLTR8P £ uwJLT,\T,aNb8KN\QY_^XdX P"bL^`KOah\bQxhJLKN[hMNx Y KNaNbnPjY_b2l@^Z\Y,KNaNbL^Zag[@^dbL^`T,\ i^àh\LbQTPjl$KS JLT RP"^à@^ZawM Y KOaNbL^à~[wKO[h\ %2vxhT \QTl@^ZU8Y [@XdbL^ZT \4PSJLT^àObL^`R8PbQT_Xd£1JLT_X PbQT lbQK8bQxhT_^`J\[cfa@^dbQT ¢OKSXZ[wR+T]2afP"bQ[hJLTj ^]T_b*[h\vlhT \QY Jq^`T)\QKOR2T4JLT R2T l@^ZT \, _

(30) ¯f`à`bc``« R2K@l@^dcfYPbL^`KOa/Kj!bQxhT8ag[hR2T,Jq^`YPX ¨[~¦¡^àNbQJLK@lh[hY T lpN£d^¤PSJLJLKN[@bQ[hJLKN[ QeRaTT afPS@XZT \ bQK7MN[fPjJQPSaNb £2bQxhT4ukKN\L^bL^d¢g^b£ KS¤RPS\Q\JQPSY_bL^ZKNah\ [hahlwT,JoP+W.f7^Xd^ZST Y KNahl@^dbL^ZKNa-2vx~^Z\*R2K@l@^cŸ"P"bL^`KOa lwK@T,\oahKSb#uhJLT_¢OT aNb

(31) uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT4KN\QY_^XdX PbL^`KOaw\gQ T³ _ªg ¤ª s¨?hPSJLa@^xfPS\*^ZaNbQJLK@lh[wY,T lP8awKOaY KOaw\QT Jq¢jPbL^d¢OT7\QYnxwT,R2TbQxfP"b)T afPS@X`TbQK uwJLKOukT JqX£\L^`R-[@X PbQT)bQxhT7Y,KNaNbnPjY_b

(32) l@^`\QY KOaNbL^à~[~^bL^`T \ G \QT TiQ |~iTHQj2vxwT5ukKO\^bL^d¢g^b£ KSfR8PS\Q\]JQPSY6bL^`KNa-^`\P"XZ\K#MN[fPSJQPjaNbL^`T,l2vxhT Y KNah\QT Jq¢jPbL^`KNa5T JLJLKNJL\PSJLT:Y KOaNbQJLKSXX`T l w[@b4bQx@^`\-\QYxhT R+T2YPSahahKSbxfPjawl@XZT2\LbQJLKNahM\QxhK@Yng\,c2vxwT+Y KNah\QT Jq¢jP"bL^ZKNah\T JLJLKNJL\ kT Y KOR2T-\K8X PSJLMNT-bQxfP"b

(33) bQxhT2\QKSXZ[@bL^`KNa%ahK8X`KOahMNT J

(34) Y,KNaN¢OT JLMNT,\

(35) bQKbQxhT7Jq^ZMNxNbKOahTj sOT,Tk*KN[1PSahlL^]Tf]X`K@YnxlQnmoT]KOJoP5\bQ[hl@£1KS¤bQx@^`\*O^àhlKj3uhJLKO~XZT R2\,. . . . . q ( % *:% 2vxhT ^ZaNbQT JLafP"XfT ahT JLMj£7KjkT"PSYnx7\QukT Y6^`T \r:s;hKjXdX`K#\ G HbQxg[h\bQxhT:bQKSbnPX@^àNbQT JLafPX¨T,awT,JLMS£ ^Z\ G {tH = >/@BDC E p. u9u Ò<vawxoyzw.

(36) . ". #xhT JLT@ >/@

(37) l@ PSahl DB CP> V B C lV BDC 2vxhT)JLT6X P"bL^ZKNaFkT_b :T T aFbQxwTuhJLT \Q\Q[hJLTPSahlbQxhT4^àNbQT,JLa¨PX¤T ahT JLMS£ ^Z\ \> G X H = G |tH #xhT JLT lV B > VV

(38) B BC l G H V D B C . . \5[h\[fPX³i :TFx¨P ¢OT\QT_b B > ;$BDC ; SMpTFKS bQT aplwT,awKjbQT \ X= N£! 2vxwT bQKSbnPX T ahT JLMj£FukT J:[ha@^db*¢OKSXZ[hR2T4^`\ " > = { @$# % xhT JLT&#^Z\!bQxhT4¢NT6X`K@Y_^b£O sgT_¢NT,JQP"XvT eg[@^d¢jPX`T aOb2\QT_bQ\-KSvufPSJqbL^ PX:l@^('T,JLT aNbL^ PX:T eg[fP"bL^ZKNapR8P £/T Y KNah\L^`lhT JLT l KOJ bQx@^Z\*R2K@lhT_X-2oxhT_£1PjJLT§#Jq^dbLbQT,aPS\ )+* )+- G * H >10 ), )/. PjawlFxfP ¢NT4bQxhT\PjR2T

(39) :TPj\QKjX`[@bL^`KOaw\, N4sj£wR2R2T_bQJq^ZY§KOJLR[@X P"bL^`KOa G Q U T]KNJ:Tn¦fPSR2u@X`TH 233 @

(40) 566 233 @

(41) # 566 3 @ 6 3 @ # 6 * > * < H > G G RtH 8 7 4 @$" # 7 4 # @$G # "9 : cH {w<;*ah\£wR2R2T_bQJq^ZY§KOJLR[@X P"bL^`KOa G QnR@i¨T]KNJvTn¦¨PjR2u@X`TH @$# 233 @ 5 66 233 3 @"V 6 3 @"V=# * > @$# - G* H > : 4 " 7 4 # $@ G # "> ? cH. 5 66 7. 6. G UtH. @BA7uC@BD.

(42)

(43)

(44)

(45)

(46) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(47) -,.$/0+*+01 |w [ ± PSR2RP]KOJLR[@X P"bL^`KOa G 233 @ 3 * > @@$# 4 " ¨ KOJLR[@X P"bL^`KOa. QÈ}aTKNJvTn¦¨PjR2u@X`TH @$# 5 66 233 6 3 @ # - G* H > : 7 4 # @$G # "> : jH 5 66. 233. @ @ 3 * > X² 4 @$" # 33. 66. 7. 6. 5 66 6. G }0H. 7. 233. @# @ # 3 - G * rH > X $ @ 8 4 # G # "> 8 jH. R. 5 66. 33. 66. 7. 6. G mtH. 2vxhT \QT)KO[wJvKNJLR-[@X P"bL^ZKNah\4PjJLTT e~[~^¢jP"XZT aNb\L^àhY T ^`\4PjaxhKNR2KOMNJQPSuhx@^`Y[hahY_bL^`KOaKS bQxhTR8PS\Q\:JQPSY_bL^ZKNah\, 2oxhT4R8PrLKNJ lwJQP #fPSYn2KSbQxhT

(48) cfa@^dbQT*¢OKSXZ[hR2T

(49) KNJLR-[@X P"bL^ZKNah\,ijbQxfPboY"PSa8kT§JLT_*Jq^bL¥ bQT a G ^àFbQxwT6^`J:c¨JL\Lb§KNJLlhT J ¢NT,JL\^ZKNaH:PS\ * * % > " ^Z\ awKjbbQxhT

(50) T_¢OKSXZ[~bL^ZKNa8KOukT JQPbQKNJ " G \L^àhY T#T_¢NT,a2*xhT a8^db ^`\ Tn¦¨PjY_b,iNbQxwT§\PjR2TvuwJLKO@X`T R KOa2bQxwT#uhJLT \Q\[hJLT

(51) T_¦~^`\LbQ\H3h[@b Xd^`T,\^à8bQxhT*uhJLKSrLT,Y_bL^`KOa8KNukT,JQP"bQKNJ 5 2K§^XdXZ[w\LbQJQPbQTobQx@^`\,i XZT_b7[h\-Y KNah\L^`lhT J4bQxhT8\L£@\LbQT R G RtH*KNJ-P\Q[hukT,JL\KOa@^`Y2Y KOaNbnPSY6bl@^Z\Y,KNaNbL^Zag[@^db£p\QKbQxfP"b bQxhT\QYxhT R2T4JLT,lw[hY T,\obQK * ; + > * ; X - G * ; + HOX - G * ; H

(52) M xfP"b*KjXdXZK,#\o^Z\*¢jP"X^`lKOJ

(53) PSaO£cfa@^dbQT¢OKSXZ[hR2T7ag[hR2T,Jq^`YPX3\QYnxhT R2Tj M¡T5PS\Q\Q[hR2T4KNJ bQxhT4\nPSjT*Kj¤\^ZR2u@Xd^ZY_^db £8bQx¨Pb:bQxwT§uwJLT,\\Q[hJLT*^Z\![ha@^dKOJLR G > iOKOJ:P"XdX *H PS\:T_XX]PS\ bQxhT¢NT_XZK@Y_^db £ # >1#jHQ \v^dbv^`\

(54) \QxhK*aF^àdQ U TPjahl\L£@\LbQT R8PbL^`YPXdXd£1Tn¦wu@XZKS^dbQT,l^à Q zTi bQxhT4cfJL\bv^dbQT,JQP"bL^`KOaKj bQxhT4\QYnxwT,R2TuwJLT,\T,Jq¢NT \vbQxhT§¢OT_XZK@Y_^db £ #w[@bvbQxhT§¢jPX`[hTKS ; + ^Z\4l~^ 'T JLT,aNbKS fa Q $T³ikbQxwT+\PjR2T-N^àhlKS:PjafP"Xd£w\^Z\*^`\4lhKOawT-KNJ*bQxhT+toK@T7\QYnxhT R2T Pjl¨Pju@bQT lbQK2¢jPjJq^`KO[w\vR-[~XbL^`Y KOR2ukKOahT aNb

(55) R+K@lwT6X`\, 2oxhTFTn¦wu@X PjafP"bL^`KOa¡^`\-bQxhTKjXdX`Kv^àhMhO2vxhTT6¢NKjX`[@bL^`KOa$KS#ufPSJqbL^ PXvlwT,aw\L^bL^`T \,i3R2Kj¥ R2T,aNbQ[hR PSahl$T,awT,JLMS£ PSJLT ^àhlhT ukT ahlhT aNb,<2vxwTFuhJLT \Q\Q[wJLT ^`\+KN@bnP"^ZawT,l¡bQxhJLKN[hMNx¡bQxhT u9u Ò<vawxoyzw.

(56) U. ". T ahT JLMj£2N£ iSbQxhT

(57) lhT ah\^b£PSahl2bQxhT

(58) R2KNR+T aNbQ[hRFt2oxhT*¢jPX`[hT*Kj ^`\ Y KOR2uh[~bQT,l2JLKNR bQxhKN\QT5KS @ PSahl(@ c2vxhTKO[wJ4Y,KNah\QT Jq¢NT,l%eg[fPSaNbL^bL^`T \-PSJLT+P ¢NT JQPjMNT5KSbQxhT2Tn¦fPSY_b ¢jPX`[hT \4^à%bQxhT2Y T_XX`\,j2oxg[h\4bQxhT7¢jP"XZ[hT2KS ^`\Pja [nP ¢NT JQPjMNT l*]8¢jP"XZ[hT7bQxfP"blhK@T \4ahKSb Y KOJLJLT \QukKOawl%bQxhT8¢jP"XZ[wT2bQxfPb):KO[@X`l(x¨P ¢OT kT T a(ahT T lhT lbQKuhJLT \QT Jq¢OT2bQxwT uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLTj

(59) ahY T4bQxhTuhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT§^Z\o#JLKNahM2^à1KNahTY T_XX³i¨bQxhT§¢OT_XZK@Y_^db £v^dXX3MOK7#JLKNahM P"bvbQxhTahTn¦~b bL^ZR2T7\LbQT ui]PSahl\QK KNa2vxhT\L^bQ[¨PbL^`KOa^`\

(60) R2KOJLT7KOJoX`T,\\§\T,Jq^`KN[h\,iklhT ukT ahl@^àhMFKNabQxhT ^Za~^bL^ PX Y KNahl@^dbL^ZKNah\,

(61) [@^`JLPjawldhPSJLa@^PQ { T Mj^d¢OT PSaTn¦¨PjR2u@X`T2#xhT JLT2bQxhT8ag[hR2T Jq^`Y"P"X \QKSXZ[@bL^`KNa(xfPS\T_ bQK%lhKv^dbQx(bQxhTT_¦¨PSY_b5KNahTj]b2Y"PSa(kT8TPj\^Xd£[hahlhT JL\LbQK@K@lbQxfP"b ^ZaY KORh[h\LbL^`KNaFKNJvlhT_bQKNafPbL^`KNaFuhJLKN@X`T,R2\,iwbQxwTuhJLT \QT ahY T4KjP7\LbL^ '\KO[hJLY T

(62) bQT JLR YPSa PjR2u@Xd^d £ bQx@^`\#lhT_cfY_^`T ahY_£g qa(Q T³iSbQx@^`\ uwJLKO@X`T R ^`\\QKSX¢NT,l7N£+[w\L^ZawM-P

(63) ahKNa+Y KNah\QT Jq¢jP"bL^¢NTvKNJLR-[@X P"bL^ZKNa2Kj¨bQxhT [@XZT J:T eg[fP"bL^ZKNa8o^bQxuhJq^ZR7^dbL^¢NT4¢jPSJq^ PS@X`T,\ s¨*hPSJLa@âhKSbL^ZY T \ bQxfP"b:bQxhT4T_¢OKSX`[@bL^ZKNa KS (KNa@Xd£lhT uT ahlw\,i^ZabQx@^Z\)KOJLR[@X PbL^`KOai¤KNa%bQxhT8MNJQPSl@^ZT aNbQ\-KS $Pjawl # sN^àhY T2bQxhT_£ ¢jPja~^Z\QxwT,\!bQxhJLKN[hMOxP7Y KOaNbnPSY6b*l@^`\QY KOaNbL^à~[~^b£Oi \QxhKN[@XZlJLT RP"^à1Y KNah\LbnPSaOb, qa *xfPbKSXX`K*\,iN:T*\QxhK²xhKBbQKR2K@l@^ £ P§cfa@^dbQT#¢NKjX`[hR2T

(64) \QYnxwT,R2To^ZaKOJLlhT JbQK uhJLT_¢OT aNb uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT:KN\QY_^dXX PbL^`KNah\,oMpT ^dXdXZ[h\bQJQPbQT!bQx@^Z\3bQT Ynxha~^Zeg[hTo#xhT a2tvKNT È\t!^ZT R8Pjawa \QKSX¢NT,J§^Z\T R2u@X`K£OT lSM¡T2\QxhK bQxhT2cfJL\Lb7KOJLlhT J-PSahl\T,Y KNahlKNJLlhT J4¢OT JL\L^`KNa(KS:bQx@^`\ \QYnxwT,R2Tj0M¡Tv\QxwK bQxfP"b^b ^`\ JLKOw[h\Lb T ahKO[wMOx7bQK-x¨Pjahl~XZT*\LbQJLKNahM-l@^`\QY KNaObL^àg[@^dbL^ZT \,$MpT \QxhK²O£8Y KNR+u¨PjJq^àhMbQxwT§\KjX`[@bL^`KOah\o^bQx+bQxhT

(65) T_¦¨PSY_b:KOahTobQxfP"b:R2T,\x8Y,KNaN¢OT JLMNT,awY,T*bQK bQxhTuhJLKNuhJLT4:TPS8\QKSXZ[@bL^`KNaF^`\:^àhlhT T l1JLTPSYnxhT l. . . . 4 4: /!9 % 4 2:"

(66) ( (: 8 %. !9% MpT4\LbnPSJqbvJLKNR bQxh4T c¨JL\Lb#KNJLlhT Jv[huNo^Zahl\QYxhT R+T * ; > * ; X - ; + X - ;

(67) 2vxhT)a~[wR+T Jq^`YPX]f[g¦ - ; + > - G * ; % * ; + H^`\*Mj^d¢OT aO£tvKNT È\!X^àhTPjJq^

(68) PbL^`KNa 3 - G * % * H<> { - G * H - G * HOX G * X * H

(69) a#xfP"b4KSXX`K#\

(70) bQxwT2KOJLR[@X P"bL^`KOa G RtHo^`\Y KOah\^ZlhT JLT lc2vxhT2R8P"bQJq^d¦ lhT ukT,awlh\KNa V

(71) i V i #]i i > G > % {tHPSahl > <2oxhT_£pxfP6¢OT bQxwTFKSXX`Ko^ZahM. . @BA7uC@BD.

(72)

(73)

(74)

(75)

(76) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(77) -,.$/0+*+01 ¢jPX`[hT \. }. V > @ V @ @@ V > % { # > @ # @ @@ # > @ @ @@ 2vxhT

(78) ¢jP"X`[hTKS ^Z\oMj^d¢OT aO£ G -H*xhT JLT V

(79) PSahl\V PjJLT4JLT u@X PSY,T lN£ bQxhT4Y KOJLJLT \L¥ uKNahl@^àhM8P ¢NT,JQPSMNT

(80) ¢jPX`[hT \#lwT6cähT lPSK,¢OTj-2vxhKN\QT4KS ?;PSJLTlhT_cfahT lO£ > @ @ = % G tH :TxfP ¢NT\QT_b @ >A@ X @ i¨T_bQYjiwbQK8\L^`R2u@X^d £ bQxhT)ahKjbnP"bL^`KOah\ \Q\Q[wR+T

(81) ahK, bQxfP"b bQxhT

(82) bQxhJLT T4\LbnP"bQT \ * ; + i * ; i * ; xfP ¢NT

(83) bQxhT4\nPSR2T§uwJLT,\\Q[hJLT PjawlpbQxwTF\nPSR2T8¢OT_X`K@Y6^db£ # \LbQJQP"^ZMNxNbLKOJqvPSJLl$Y"P"X`Y,[~X P"bL^ZKNa¡\QxhK*\bQxfP"b,i3^d§KNahT \QT_bQ\ ; + >/@"; Xd@0; ; > ; X ; % + ;

(84) + >/@ ;

(85) Xd@ ;

(86) ; >A@ ; + X @ ; :TMNT6b 233 5 66 # ;

(87) + 33 66 33 66 # ; + 33 66 66 ; + * ; + X * ; > 33 33 66 # # ; + 4 #

(88) : 7 k*T,JLT

(89) :T)xfP ¢OT§bnPjST,a^àObQK PSY Y KO[haNb:bQxwTJLT_X P"bL^ZKNa G Hv^dbQx >10@. u9u Ò<vawxoyzw.

(90) m. " ;*\L^àhM8PXdX]bQx@^`\,i~^b*^`\vTPj\£8bQK+\T,T§bQxfPb @ ; > @ ; X # G HOX # G X # ; + > # " ; + >. " ; X . . # Q { . T X. . # # Q X. {. H . TB. G 0tH. # # Q X T T X sN^àhY T " ; > @ ; # PSahl " ; > @ ; # i":T YPSa\QT TbQxfP"bPvawT,Y T \Q\nPSJq£ Y KOahl~^bL^`KOaKOJ ; + > ^`\ > X # Q T X # ZQ T G OH ; ; { ; ; 2vxhT)T,eg[fP"bL^`KOa G OH^`\#ahKSbQx@^àhM2R2KOJLT4bQx¨PjaP7l@^Z\Y,JLT_bL^

(91) PbL^`KOaKj # >10 XdX]bQKOMNT_bQxhT J6i¨KO[hJ!a~[wR+T Jq^`YPX¤\QYxhT R2T4^Z\!bQxhT4KSXX`Ko^ZahM 3 N*[wulfP"bQT4KS7@fi*@ #%PSahl " N£ bQxhT)Y6X PS\Q\L^`Y"P"XR-[@XdbL^Z\uT Y_^ZT \

(92) tvK@T4\YnxhT R2Tji {w*[wulfP"bQT*Kj N£ G NHQt2vxwT§R8PS\Q\JQPSY6bL^`KNah\<V

(93) PSahl V PSJLT#KN@bnP"^¥ awT,lN£F^àO¢NT JqbL^ZahM G HQ sN^àhY T Q R5^à*; G H % R8P"¦ ; G H T^ R8P¦-; # ; =ji~bQxhT4R8Pj\\ JQPjY_bL^`KOaw\ V

(94) Pjawl V JLT R8P"^Zah\^à Q 0 % zT§o^bQx bQxhT\nPjR2T(W.f7^ Y KNahl@^dbL^ZKNa Pj\^ZabQxhTKNJq^ZMS^Za¨PX \QYnxwT,R2Tj # Q . . . . .

(95) . . . . . . . . . . . . @BA7uC@BD.

(96)

(97)

(98)

(99)

(100) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(101) -,.$/0+*+01. . . 9 8 % 4 , MpT4PS\Q\Q[hR2T

(102) bQxfP"b#P7x@^`MOxKOJLlhT J:Tn¦~bQT ah\L^`KOaKj bQxhT4KOJq^`MS^ZafP"Xcfa@^dbQT

(103) ¢OKSXZ[wR+T)\QYnxhT R2T

(104) ^`\ KO~bnP^àhT l2bQxhJLKN[hMOx2bQxwT 8;4shW.^R2T6bQxwK@lNqa TPjYx8Y T6XdX³iN:T

(105) MOT_b:PJLT Y KNah\LbQJL[hY_bL^`KOa8KS bQxhTY KNah\QT Jq¢jPbL^d¢OT§¢jPjJq^ Pj~XZT \3 * ; G . H<> * ; * G. H G "{tH 2vxhT*\LX`KOukT ^`\Y,KNR2uh[@bQT l8\QK4bQx¨PbbQxhT

(106) P ¢OT JQPSMOToKj G "{tH ^ZaLQ . ; % . ; Tf^`\ * ; t2oxhT ¢jPjJq^ P"bL^ZKN a * G . H)^Z\7KN@bnP^àhT l¡O£$Y KOR2uh[~bL^ZahM%\XZKNuT \T6^dbQxhT J7KOa/bQxhTFuwJq^ZR7^dbL^¢NT1KNJ YnxfPSJQPSY6bQT Jq^`\LbL^`Y#¢jPSJq^ Pj@X`T \, 2vxhT4\LX`KNuT*R8P £8T

(107) Xd^ZR7^dbQT l v^dbQx8bQxhT4xwT6Xù KS]X^`R7^bQT JL\,iwKNJ Y KOR2uh[@bQT l%o^bQxbQxhT8xhT_XZuKjbQxh T 4 R2T6bQxwK@lqakKjbQxY"PS\QT \,if:T+PS\Q\Q[hR2TbQxfP"b ^PXdX]bQxhTuKS^ZaNbQ\

(108) KS¤bQxhT-\bQT,awY6^dX[h\T,lbQK8Y KOR2uh[~bQ

(109) T * \QxfPSJLT4bQxhT\nPjR2TuwJLT,\\Q[hJLT Pjawl5bQxwT#\nPSR2T:¢NT6X`K@Y_^b£ # iSbQxhT a2bQxhTo¢OT_X`K@Y_^b£PSahl2bQxhTouhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT*lhT_cfahT l8N£ G "{tHPSJLT #%Pjahl= 23K-\L^`R2u@X^d £2bQxhTobQT_¦~b,i~:T

(110) Pj\Q\[hR2T:bQxfP"b bQxhT

(111) \LbnPSahlfPSJLl8x@^ZMNx8KNJLlhT Jcä@^bQT*¢NKjX`[hR2T \QYnxwT,R2T

(112) ^`\vbQxwT4KjXdX`Kv^àhM7\QT Y,KNahlKOJLlhT Jo\QYnxhT R2T43 * ; > * ; X - G * ; HOX - G * ; G H. * ; + > * ; X - G * ; + % * ; + OH X - G * ; + % * ; HX G H G "|tH k*T,JLTjiw:T4xfP6¢OT\QT_boKOJ ?>/6KNJW6 ² S{ *; > * ; * G { . H % *; > * ; * G X { . H 2vxhT4Tn¦¨PSY6b ¨[~¦^`\:[h\QT l ^à bQxwT4uhJLT l@^ZY_bQKNJ:\LbQT ui~#x~^X`T

(113) bQxhTtoK@Tvf[g¦^Z\!T,R2u@X`K£NT,l^Za bQxhTY KNJLJLT,Y_bQKNJvKNahTj 23KY KNah\LbQJL[hY_b7KO[hJ)R-[@XdbL^ZY KNR2uKNahT aNb5\QYxhT R+TjibQxhT \^ZR2u@X`T \Lb-vP £%^`\bQK%[wulfP"bQT ^à \[hYnx P¡vP £ bQxfP"bPSa²^Za@^dbL^ PXY KNahl@^dbL^ZKNaBR8PSlhTKS5P$Y KOaNbnPSY6bl@^Z\Y,KNaNbL^Zag[@^db£ G v^dbQx¢OT_X`K@Y6^db£?#PSahl%uhJLT \Q\Q[wJLT jH o^XdXJLT R8P^à%P8Y KOaNbnPSY_b§l@^`\QY KNaObL^àg[@^db £Oa%KNJLlhT J bQK$\L^ZR2u@Xd^d £ bQxhT%bQTn¦~b,i!:T%^àObQJLK@lw[hY TNi!KNJFPSaN £ ^Za @fi #=PSahl ]i bQxhT%KSXX`Ko^ZahM ahKSbnPbL^`KOaw\ 3 ; r; % ; > ; X ; . u9u Ò<vawxoyzw.

(114) 0. ". 2vxhT ;PSJLT1Y KNR2uh[@bQT l JLKNR G { HQs2vxhT_^`J8Tn¦huwJLT,\\L^ZKNah\8lhT ukT ahl KOa$bQxwTN^àhl KS ¢jPjJq^ PS@XZT+:T xfP ¢NT [h\QT l/bQK%lhT_cfahT * Y Y KNJLl@^ZawM1bQKbQxwTFPj\\Q[hR2u@bL^`KOah\):T xfP ¢NT R8PjlhTji~^d P"bvbL^`R+T , i * lhT_cfawT,\*P7Y,KNaNbnPjY_b*l@^Z\Y,KNaNbL^Zag[@^db£gikPSahl:TxfP ¢NT3 @ ; + >/@ ; a@0; @ ; >A@ ; + X o@"; # ; > # ; > # ; + ; > ; > ; + > > X { ; ; { ; + ; ; ; + sgKNR2T\LbQJQP"^ZMNxNbLKOJqvPSJLlY"P"X`Y,[~X P"bL^ZKNah\o\QxhK*\vbQxfP"b§P" bQT J:bQxhT)uhJLT l@^ZY_bQKNJ#\bQT,uiwbQxhT ¢OT_X`K@Y6^db£ JLT R8P^àh\bQxhT\nPjR2TFPSahl¡bQxhTuhJLT \Q\Q[hJLTPX`\QK%JLT R8P^àh\7^ZaN¢jPSJq^ PSaNb8uhJLK¢g^ZlwT,l bQxfP"b > X 2 # X # 5 G ,H ; + ; ; + 7 4 ; ; ; + + + 2vxhT aifbQxhT7\nPjR2T7JLT \Q[@Xdb§^`\

(115) bQJL[hT2P bQT J*bQxhT2Y KOJLJLT Y_bQKNJ§\bQT,uiuhJLK¢g^`lhT lbQxfP"b ^`\4[hu@¥ lfP"bQT,lN£ > X # ; + Q T X # ; ZQ X T . ; { ; ; Xp{ ; ; > { ; X ;+ > { G RtH

(116) [wJvR2K@l@^dcfT l1\QYxhT R2T

(117) ^Z\obQxhT4KSXX`Ko^ZahM N

(118) IJLT l@^`Y_bQKOJo\LbQT u 3¨[huklfP"bQT@fi*@ #PSahl?" N£ G | HÆ¥ G P H Pjahl N£ G HQi {w4W KOJLJLT Y_bQKNJ:\LbQT u 3¨[wulfP"bQT @fi-@ #PSahl "yN£ G |tHÆ¥ G H!Pjahl N£ G aRtHQ 2vxhT\QYxhT R2T^Z\¤\bnPj@X`T[hahlhT J]bQxwT \nPjR2T:WWfO^8Y KOawl@^bL^`KNa 2vxhTR8Pj\\]JQPjY_bL^`KOaw\¤JLT RP"^à uKN\L^dbL^¢NTj . . . @BA7uC@BD.

(119)

(120)

(121)

(122)

(123) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(124) -,.$/0+*+01 O 4:*+² $ 4: abQx@^`\-\QT Y_bL^ZKNai:T7vPjaNbbQK^XdX`[h\LbQJQP"bQT2bQx@^Z\R2T6bQxwK@lhKjX`KNMj£%PjawlbQKY,KNR2ufPSJLT5^dbbQK bQxhTTn¦~^Z\bL^ZahM2cä@^bQT§¢OKSXZ[hR2TKNahTji¨Pjawl1\QxwK ^db#YPSaFxfPSahl@X`T\LbQJLKNahM2\QxhK@Yg\, MpTP"XZ\QK v^`\Qx bQK8YxhT Yn8*xhT_bQxhT J:bQxhT)a~[wR+T Jq^`YPX\KjX`[@bL^`KOaY,KNaN¢OT JLMNT,\!bQK7bQxhT4:TPjKOahTj

(125) !"#%$ &'" (#)*+"#, (#- MpT Y KNah\L^`lhT J]bQxhTKSXX`Kv^àhM*bQT \LbYPS\QT&3N2vxwT JQPbL^`K

(126) Kjf\uT Y_^cŸ xhTPbQ\PjJLT JLT \QukT Y6bL^d¢OT_Xd£. V @ # ^]T_ b 0 0 {"R t:^`MNxOb 0 w0 0h 2PS@X`T203wqa@^dbL^ P"X¤Y KOahl~^bL^`KOaw\ U8PSahl¡ NvbQxhT J#bQT \Lb

(127) YPj\T,\*xfP ¢NT-kT T,aukT JqKOJLR2T l G ^ZaufPSJqbL^`Y,[~X PSJ*bQxhKO\TKjPQ TH h[@ b]bQx@^`\¤KNah TuhJLK¢g^`lhT \]X PSJLMNT,Jl@^`\QY JLT ufPSahY_^ZT \, #KSbQTbQxfP"b¤T6¢NT a4v^dbQx-PoY,KNah\LbnPSaNb inbQxhT ag[hR2T,Jq^`YPX@\QKSX`[@bL^ZKNa^`\]³PSJ]JLKNR=T T_^ZawM#ukT JqT,Y_bW3bQx~^Z\ bQT,\bYPj\QT\QT T R2\]bQK

(128) T l~^ZU8Y [@Xdb KOJ)cfa@^dbQT ¢NKjX`[hR2TF\QYxhT R2T,\ O2vxhT f^ZMN[hJLT \Ni{@i|wi3%MS^d¢OT \-bQxwTFlhT ah\L^db£gi ¢NT_XZK@Y_^db £Oi uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT PSahl X=P"bbL^`R2T , > 0 0 0"m > 0 0w{8KNJ4bQxhT2cfJL\Lb7KOJLlwJLT8\QYnxhT R2Tj fhJLKNR f^ZMN[hJLT \2+PSahl{@i¨^db4^Z\4Y_X`T"PSJobQxfPbKN[hJ

(129) ahT_ ¢NKjX`[hR2T5\YnxhT R2T5kT xfP ¢NT,\4R[hYnx T_bLbQT J*bQxfPSa1bQxwT-Y_X PS\Q\L^`YPXcfa~^bQT¢OKSXZ[wR+TKOawTNha(f]^`MN[hJLT4R8PSahl%U@i¨:T-uhJLT \QT aNb*bQxhT uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLT4PSahl2bQxhT*¢OT_X`K@Y_^b£8KOJbQxhT

(130) \nPSR2TvbQT \Lb:YPS\QTov^dbQx8bQxhT

(131) \QT Y KOahl8KNJLlhT J \QYxhT R+Tj 2vxhT

(132) JLT Y KOaw\LbQJL[hY_bL^ZKNa8^`\vPSuhu@Xd^ZT l KNa2bQxhT4uhxN£@\L^`Y"P"Xk¢jPjJq^ Pj~XZT \,MpT

(133) PX`\QKuhJLT \QT aOb:\KOR2T Y KOR2uh[@bnP"bL^`KOafP"X@JLT \Q[@XdbQ\KNabQxhTIh)PjJLa@^@PSahl #[@^ZJL \¤bQT \LbY"PS\QTI3, bY KOah\^Z\LbQ\3KjfP*\QxwK@Yn bQ[hkTchXdXZT lv^dbQx%P^`J G > % BDCP> 0 }S{ H#xhJLT-P+\QxhK@Yn+vP ¢OTR+K,¢OTbQK2bQxwT-Jq^`MOxNb, abQxhT2uhJLT_¥ \QxhK@YFvP6¢OT2\LbnP"bQTNi P w[hh@X`T2KjWk*T_X^`[hR'^Z\4\T6b G > U~} % BDC> { g{ HQ MpT7[h\QT8{ 0 0Y,T_XdXZ\ ikbQxhT8\QxwK@YnvP ¢OT2^`\

(134) ^Za~^bL^ PXdXd£(Pb . > 0 {"R PSahl%bQxwT+w[hh@X`T8\L^dbQ\ T_b:T T,a . > 0 PSahl . > 0 U@%2vxhTJLT,\[@XbQ\4PSJLT-uhJLT \QT aNbQT lPb*bL^`R+T , > 0 |0RwikPSJLT KO~bnP^àhT l8v^dbQx8bQxhT4\T,Y KNahl8KNJLlhT J¢OT JL\L^`KOaKj]kKjbQx \YnxhT R2T \ v^dbQxFTn¦~bQJQPjukKSX P"bL^ZKNa8KNa bQxhTYnxfPSJQPjY_bQT Jq^`\LbL^ZY¢jPjJQP"^`@XZTjs2vxhT%WWfO^ ag[hRT J2^`\ 0 }$R@ 2oxhTif^ZMN[hJLT%}¥qP%\QxhK*\ bQxhT8uhJLT \Q\Q[wJLT+KN@bnP"^ZawT,\§v^dbQx%bQxhT8uhJLT \QT aNb-\QYxhT R+Tji#x@^dX`T f]^`MO[hJLTF},¥ %\xhK#\§#xfP"b ^Z\4KN@bnP"^ZawT,\*o^bQxbQxhT7Y KOaw\QT Jq¢jPbL^d¢OT2\QYxhT R+T7KSJQeRT³¤sOuh[hJq^`KO[h\4KN\QY_^dXX PbL^`KNah\,ikPS\#o^bQx. . u9u Ò<vawxoyzw. .

(135) "{. " 0.9 ’fort.17’ ’BL/fort.17’ ’fort.27’. 0.8. 0.7. 0.6. 0.5. 0.4. 0.3. 0.2. 0.1. 0 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. f]^`MO[wJLT $3!T_X`K@Y_^b£Oi ,\Lb*KOJLlwT,J6 3fuhJLT \QT aOb

(136) \QYxhT R+Tji 3¨cfa~^bQT)¢OKSXZ[hR2T\QYnxhT R2TKS QnR T³ihlwKjbLbQT lX^àhT43¨Tn¦¨PjY_bv\KjX`[@bL^`KOa 25 ’fort.18’ ’BL/fort.18’ ’fort.28’ 24. 23. 22. 21. 20 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. f]^`MO[wJLT{3]IJLT \Q\Q[wJLTNi \Lb4KOJLlhT J 3uhJLT \QT aNb\QYnxwT,R2Tji 3cfa@^dbQT7¢OKSXZ[wR+T2\QYxhT R2T5KS QnR T³ihlwKjbLbQT lX^àhT43¨Tn¦¨PjY_bv\KjX`[@bL^`KOa @BA7uC@BD.

(137)

(138)

(139)

(140)

(141) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(142) -,.$/0+*+01 "| 1 ’fort.16’ ’BL/fort.16’ ’fort.26’. 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. f]^`MO[wJLT|3SK

(143) T,aw\L^b£Oi \LbKNJLlhT J 3]uwJLT,\T,aNb-\YnxhT R2Tji 3cfa@^dbQT7¢OKSXZ[hR2T8\QYxhT R2T5KS QnR T³ihlwKjbLbQT lX^àhT43¨Tn¦¨PjY_bv\KjX`[@bL^`KOa 0.6 ’fort.14’ ’BL/fort.14’ ’fort.24’. 0.58 0.56 0.54 0.52 0.5 0.48 0.46 0.44 0.42 0.4 0.38 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. ]f ^`MO[wJLT%3 X Ni \LbvKNJLlhT J 3ühJLT \QT aOb*\QYnxwT,R2Tji+ 3wcfa~^bQT4¢NKjX`[hR2T\QYxhT R2T4KjIQeR Ti lhKSbLbQT,lXd^ZahT 3hnT ¦¨PSY6b*\QKSXZ[@bL^`KNa u9u Ò<vawxoyzw.

(144) ,. " 1 ’fort.17’ ’BL/fort.17’ ’fort.27’ 0.8. 0.6. 0.4. 0.2. 0. -0.2 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. f]^`MO[wJLTR-3 T_XZK@Y_^db £Oiw{jahlKOJLlwT,J6i 3ühJLT \QT aNbv\QYnxwT,R2Tji+ 3~cfa@^dbQT4¢NKjX`[hR2T4\QYnxwT,R2T4KS QnR T³ihlwKjbLbQT lX^àhT43¨Tn¦¨PjY_bv\KjX`[@bL^`KOa 25 ’fort.18’ ’BL/fort.18’ ’fort.28’ 24. 23. 22. 21. 20. 19 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. f]^`MO[wJLT)U3wIJLT \Q\[hJLTjih{Sahl KNJLlhT J6i 3@uwJLT,\T,aNb:\QYxhT R2TNi/ 3Ocfa@^dbQT*¢OKSXZ[hR2T

(145) \QYxhT R+T

(146) KS QnR T³ihlwKjbLbQT lX^àhT43¨Tn¦¨PjY_bv\KjX`[@bL^`KOa @BA7uC@BD.

(147)

(148)

(149)

(150)

(151) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(152) -,.$/0+*+01 R. I¤KN\Lbv\xhK@Yn IJLT\QxhK@Y w[hh@X`T. V @ # N ½|~}SU0R @0 Ð|Njtm j R~} 0 0 0w"| m 0 . 2Pj@X`T{3sOxhK@Yn h[hh@X`T4^àNbQT,JQPSY_bL^ZKNa. 1.6. 1.6 ’fort.18’. ’BL/fort.18’. 1.5. 1.5. 1.4. 1.4. 1.3. 1.3. 1.2. 1.2. 1.1. 1.1. G PtH G H f^ZMN[hJLT5}t3ÏJLT,\\Q[hJLTjik{jawlFKNJLlhT J6iühJLT \QT aOb*\QYnxwT,R2T G PtHQiŸ KOaw\QT Jq¢jPbL^d¢OT\YnxhT R2T G H 1. 1. 0. 20. u9u Ò<vawxoyzw. 40. 60. 80. 100. 120. 140. 160. 180. 200. 0. 50. 100. 150. 200.

(153) "U. ". . .

(154) [@^`JLPjawlhPSJLa@^ È\¤JLT \Q[~XbQ\PjJLT¢g^Z\^Z@X`TKNJ]bQxhT Y KOaw\QT Jq¢jPbL^d¢OT \QYxhT R2T:PjahlPjJLT:PSh\QT aNb KOJ bQxhTuhJLT \QT aNb#\QYxhT R2TN M¡T8Y"PSa\QT T7bQxhT \QT f^ZMN[hJLT \,ibQxfP"b-KO[wJahT_ \YnxhT R2T PX`\QKT xfP ¢NT8R-[hYxpkT_bLbQT J bQxfPSa1bQxwT-KSXZlKOawTN%2ox@^`\§Y KNahY_XZ[w\L^ZKNa ^`\obQxhT-\nPSR2T4#x¨PbQT_¢OT JobQxhTbQT \Lb

(155) YPj\T4:TxfP ¢NT JL[ha 4 8 * !9 *8 o 4 1! 12 ’fort.16’ ’fort.26’ 10. 8. 6. 4. 2. 0 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1. ]f ^`MO[wJLTim37K

(156) T ah\^b£Oi{jahl¡KNJLlhT J6i<R 0 0w+R2T \Qx¡uKS^ZaNbQ\,i 3uwJLT,\T,aNb7\QYnxhT R2Tji3lhKSbLbQT,l X^àhT43¨Tn¦¨PSY6bo\QKjX`[@bL^`KOa 2vx@^`\ukKj^àNb4^Z\4\bQ[hl@^`T,la~[wR+T Jq^`YPXdX£OS2vxwT5ahT_ \QYnxhT R2T7^Z\§bQT,\bQT,lv^dbQx R 0 0w-R2T,\x uKS^àObQ\*^à^bQ\4\T,Y KNahlKOJLlhT J*¢OT JL\L^`KNa G JLT,Y KNah\LbQJL[hY_bL^`KOaKNabQxhT-uwJq^ZR7^dbL^¢NT5¢jPSJq^ Pj@X`T \HQ ahT_BbQT \LbvYPS\QT*^Z\oT R+u~XZK£NT li~bQK+MNT_b:\LbQJLKNahMOT J:l~^Z\QY KNaNbL^Zag[@^dbL^ZT \,\2oxhT4\QxhK@Y %PjYx ag[hR-kT J G lhT_cfahT l(PS\

(157) ^`\5} g}gi¨^bQ\

(158) ¢NT_XZK@Y_^db £^`\2 Oj 2oxhT5Y KNaNbnPjY_bl@^`\QY KOa~¥ bL^Zag[@^db£ ¢NT_XZK@Y_^db £¡^Z\ 0 }S|@i ^bQ\2uhJLT \Q\Q[w JLTF^`\ } 0@SMpTuhJLT \Q T aOb2bQxhTlhT ah\L^db£p^à Q 0 % T G f]^`MO[wJLT mtH*PjawlP K@KOR G f]^`MO[wJLTtHobQxfP"b4T,a¨Pj@X`TbQKFkT6bLbQT J

(159) bQxhT2Y KNaObnPSY_b4l@^Z\Y,KNaNbL^¥ ag[@^b£(PSahlbQxhT7\QxhK@YnvP ¢NTNMpTY_XZTPSJqX£%\QT TbQx¨Pb4bQxhT7ag[hR2T Jq^ZYP"X \QKSX`[@bL^ZKNa^`\

(160) ¢OT Jq£ Y_XZKN\QT2bQKbQxhTT_¦¨PSY_b5KNahTj a$ufPSJqbL^ZY [@X PSJ6i3bQxhTFY KNJLJLT Y6bXZT_¢NT6X`\2KjolhT ah\L^db £$PjJLT KN@bnP"^¥ @BA7uC@BD.

(161)

(162)

(163)

(164)

(165) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(166) -,.$/0+*+01 S}. V @ # 0 0 N ½U 0 { ¥ N . ^ T6 b t!^ZMNxNb. 2PS@X`T|-3~qa@^bL^ P"XY KOahl~^bL^`KOaw\:KNJ bQxhTY KNaO¢NT JLMOT ahY T\LbQ[wl@£. 12 ’fort.16’ ’fort.26’ 10. 8. 6. 4. 2. 0 0.9. 0.91. 0.92. 0.93. 0.94. 0.95. 0.96. 0.97. 0.98. ]f ^`MO[wJLT:-3kK@KOR KS@bQxhT lhT ah\L^db£giS{Sahl-KNJLlhT J6iR 0 0wR2T \QxukKj^àNbQ\,i lhKSbLbQT,lXd^ZahT 3hTn¦¨PSY6b*\QKSXZ[@bL^`KNa. u9u Ò<vawxoyzw. . 0.99. 1. 3,uhJLT \QT aNb\QYxhT R+Tji.

(167) m. ". ahT likbQxwT+l~^Z\QY KNaNbL^Zag[@^dbL^ZT \4R2K¢NTP"b

(168) bQxhT7Jq^ZMNxNb\QuT T l 2oxhT7cfJL\Lb4Y KOawY6X`[h\L^`KNa1^`\

(169) bQJL[hTji #xfP"bQT_¢OT J:bQxwT4¢jPjJq^ PS@XZT G uhJLT \Q\Q[hJLTjiw¢OT_X`K@Y_^b£Oi+1KNJ %PSYnxag[hR-kT JHQ 2ox@^Z\Y KOahY_X`[h\L^`KOa^`\ahKSbJLTPXdXd£\Q[hJLuhJq^`\L^àhM 3 lhK@T \ahKSbYnxfPSahMNT5^à(P³PjaKOJP \QxhK@Y8vP ¢OTjiwbQxhTuhJLT \QT aNb§\QYxhT R2T4^Z\*ahKSbQx@^àhM8R2KOJLT4bQx¨PjabQxhT-Y_X Pj\\L^ZYP"XKNahT4^àbQx@^`\ YPj\QTjSqa P4Y KNaObnPSY_b l~^Z\QY KNaNbL^Zag[@^db £OiObQxhT*MOJQPSl@^`T,aNbKjkbQxhTo¢OT_X`K@Y6^db£R[h\Lb¢jPSa@^Z\xhsN^àhY T :T4^àObQT MNJQPbQT4\^ZR[@XbnPSahT KN[h\LXd£1PjuwuhJLK,¦~^ZR8P"bL^ZKNah\oKj # >10 % @ G @ #jH >10 PSahl . . . . . . ^bo^Z\!XZT MS^bL^`R8PbQT§bQK+Tn¦wukT,Y_bobQxhTJq^`MOxNb#Y KNaNbnPjY_b#l~^Z\QY KNaNbL^Zag[@^db £\QukT,T l

(170) MpT x¨P ¢OT uwJLT,\T,aNbQT l PahT_ \QYnxhT R2T8KNJ-R[@XbL^`\QukT Y6^`T \5Y KNR2uhJLT \Q\L^`@XZT+fK \L^`R-[@X P¥ bL^ZKNah\,h b4^`\

(171) Y,KNah\LbQJL[wY6bQT lbQK \[huhuhJLT \Q\

(172) KNJ#R7^à@^ZR7^

(173) T-bQxhT7\Quh[wJq^ZKN[h\

(174) KO\Y6^dXdX P"bL^ZKNah\obQxfP"b PjJLT!MOT ahT JQP"bQT,l7N£5Y KNaO¢NT aObL^`KNafPX@cä@^bQT!¢OKSXZ[wR+To\QYnxwT,R2T \,2ox@^Z\uhJLKNuT Jqb£-^`\ P"X`\QK*bQJL[hT KOJOhPjJLa~^ \\YnxhT R2Tjiw[@bbQxwT:uhJLT \QT aNbKNahTji"JLKOR=^dbQ\Y KNah\LbQJL[hY_bL^`KOai"^Z\Pj~XZTbQK4xfPSahl@X`T \LbQJLKNahM \QxhK@Yg\, ¤¦~bQT,aw\L^ZKNah\

(175) bQKR+KNJLTbQx¨Pb{ \uT Y_^ZT \*^`\§\bQJQP^`MOxNbLKNJqvPjJLl G Y KNah\L^`lhT J * > G @ % @ % % @ % % @$# % ")H:PSahl1PSuhu@Xd£ bQxhT)\nPjR2T4uhJq^àhY_^ù@XZT \, 8 ¤¯g® ªg ° ¨ª

(176) ª k 4:KN[@XZl/Xd^ZST8bQKbQxfPjaw~\8sfOhPSJLa@^:Pjaw l @ @

(177) [@^`JL%KNJ bQxhT_^ZJo\Q[huhukKNJqbv^àFbQx@^`\*\LbQ[hl@£O. . . . . . . g 4 * QÊzTgK-SW xfPSJLMj£Oi"t) hMNJQPXdXi ^ fhT KO[~ÔT_b# ^¤PSJLJLKO[@bQ[wJLKO[wW KNah\QT Jq¢jP"bL^¢NT ag[hR2T Jq^`Y"P"X \QYxhT R+T \*KNJ#R[@XbL^`Y KOR2ukKOawT,aNb

(178) ^àO¢g^`\QY_^Zl¨K#\,9

(179)

(180)

(181) &

(182) *00+

(183) 6i{wi ON{w Q{ T @ @

(184) [~^ZJLfi@sf"hPjJLa~^]#a-bQxhTol@£@afPSR5^`Y \KjP4\QxhK@YO¥h[hh~XZT ^àNbQT JQPjY_bL^`KOa12T Ynx@¥ a@^`YPX¤toT,ukKNJqb§Sj¥L}$R@iNQW s :i3OSh Q | T5sfhPSJLa@^³

(185) ^Z\QY KN[h\]uhJLKSchX`T,\3PjahluhJq^`R5^dbL^d¢OT KNJLR-[@X P"bL^ZKNah\, !#" ' $N0 Êi {NwiON{w. . @BA7uC@BD.

(186)

(187)

(188)

(189)

(190) !"#$%&(')*+#'&*

(191) -,.$/0+*+01 " Q T5sfchPjJLa~^ [@XbL^d¥ Y KNR2uKNahT aNb#fK, Y"P"X`Y,[~X P"bL^ZKNah\*N£P8Y KNah\L^`\LbQT aNb§uhJq^`R7^bL^d¢OT8P"X¥ MNKOJq^dbQxhRF t 0? $'N*"#$ " $iO{wiOS¨ QnR T #t^ PjJLJLKN[@bQ[hJLKN[jk*K bQK4uhJLT \QT Jq¢NTvbQxhToR8Pj\Q\3JQPSY6bL^`KNa+ukKN\L^bL^d¢g^b£7#xhT a2Y KOR2uh[@¥ bL^àhM Y KOR2uhJLT \Q\^Z@X`T-R[@XdbL^¥Y,KNR2uKNahT aNb#¨K#\, t "O '& * 00 . Qi¨"R@i"Nhj Q U T-t4 hMNJQPXdX³ ± T ahT JQPXd^Z\PbL^`KOa4KSgbQxhT JLK@T\QYnxhT R2TKOJkbQxhT Y KNR2uh[@bnP"bL^ZKNa4Kj@R7^Ê¦@bQ[wJLT KSuT JqT Y_b#MgPj\T,\ +

(192)

(193)

(194)

(195) *00+

(196) 6ikU@i%K1T,m Y T R-wJLT8"0m0mw Q½}oT-I¤ ^ toK@TN ahT_ PSuhuhJLKgPjYxpbQK/Y KOR2uh[@bL^àhM¡l@^`\QY KOaNbL^à~[wKO[h\7fK,#\8KS)\T6¢NT JQPX ^`lhTPX]MgPj\QT \,72T Ynxha~^ZYP"X JLT ukKOJqb,iW JQPja~cfT_XZlah\bL^bQ[@bQTKjO2T YnxhawKjX`KOMS£Oi0mjh Qnm T2)

(197) 5 k*KO[iÏ¤ ^]TfXZK@Yx M xO£ahKOaY KOaw\QT Jq¢jPbL^d¢OT\YnxhT R2T \vY KOaN¢NT,JLMNT4bQK7#JLKNahM \QKSXZ[~bL^ZKNah\ 3¨T JLJLKNJ#PSafP"X£@\L^`\, " 'NÊiUN{ G { 0NU HQiOS¨. u9u Ò<vawxoyzw.

(198) Unite´ de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopoˆle de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique, 615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LE` S NANCY Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rhoˆne-Alpes, 46 avenue Fe´lix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex 1 Unite´ de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex. E´diteur INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France) ISSN 0249-6399.

(199)