HAL Id: jpa-00247539
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00247539
Submitted on 1 Jan 1991
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Second harmonic generation in a liquid-crystalline elastomer
Harald Hirschmann, Dolors Velasco, Helmut Reinecke, Heino Finkelmann
To cite this version:
Harald Hirschmann, Dolors Velasco, Helmut Reinecke, Heino Finkelmann. Second harmonic genera- tion in a liquid-crystalline elastomer. Journal de Physique II, EDP Sciences, 1991, 1 (5), pp.559-570.
�10.1051/jp2:1991189�. �jpa-00247539�
J
Phys
III(1991)
559-570 MAI 1991, PAGE 559Classification
Physics
Abstracts42 65K 61.30 6141
Second harmonic generation in
aliquid-crystalline elastomer
Harald
Hirscl~mann,
DolorsVelasco,
Helmut Remecke and Heino FinkelmannInstitut fi~r Makromolekulare Chemie der Un~versitit
Freiburg, Gerrnany
(Received
29 October 1990,accepted
mfinal form
IFebruary 1991)
Smmnary. A
liquid-crystalline
elastomer with NLO active nJtrogroups bonded covalently to asiloxane network has been
investigated
By means of polarizingmicroscopy, X-ray
diffraction and UV-VIS spectroscopy it was found that the elastomer exhibits a S~phase
and ismacroscopically
ordered The elastomer is transparent for
wavelengths
above 450nm and the amsotropy of refractive index at room temperature is about 01Applying
an extemal electricpoling
field breaks centrosymmetry and second harmonic generation similar tocrystals
can be observed. Thepoling
process issingle
exponential with an activation energy of 190 kJ/mol and is identified as a &- process In contrast to low molar massliquid crystals
no director reorientation is observedby
the laser fieldstrength.
From Makerfnnge
expenments m theliquid crystalline phase
at roomtemperature the second-order
susceptibilities
are X=:: = 0 92pmiv
and X=xx = 0 06pmiv
for apoling
field of 19V/~Lm1. Inwoduction.
Apart
from organic and inorganiccrystals, polymers
have beenintensively investigated
with respect to their non-linearoptical
properties[1, 2].
Twoapproaches
aregenerally
used to obtainpolymenc
materials containing NLO activechromophores
the firstapproach
is to swell apolymer
matrix w~th thechromophores.
Thisprocedure
is often limitedby
the poorsolubihty
ofchromophores
m the matnx To overcome thisproblem
the secondapproach
is tocovalently
link thechromophores
to thepolymer
matnx. With thisprocedure
matenals withh~gh
non-linearsusceptibilities
are available.However,
notonly
the chemical structure of thechromophores
but also thedegree
of order of the matr~xstrongly
influences the non-linearsusceptibilities.
Theoretical considerations show that the value of thesusceptibilities
is smaller for an isotropic medium than for thelimiting
case of anIsmg
medium[3]. Considenng liquid crystals
their state of order is between theperfect
order of thecrystalline
state and the disorder of an isotropic medium This fact makesl~quid crystals
very interesting matenals for non-linearoptics
because m the I c state the molecules can beeasily macroscopically aligned
with
respect
to thelong
molecular axis(director) by applying
extemal electnc ormagnetic
fields. For
polymeric liquid crystals, however,
aperfect alignment
of the director often fails in the electnc or magnetic field and defect structures remain in thesamples.
These defects causeh~gh optical damping
whichprevents
theirapplicability
To overcome theseproblems
we560 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
II M 5choose a new way Detailed investigations on crosslinked lc. side chain
polymers (lc.
elastomers) proved,
that uniform onentation of the director can be obtainedby applying
amechanical field. The effect of the mechanical field
strongly
exceeds magnetic and electric field[4]
In this way I-c- elastomer films can beprepared
whoseoptical
properties are similar to theoptical
properties ofanisotropic single crystals.
Furthermore theopt~cal damping
ofthese elastomer films is very low in the range of1-2
dB/cm [5].
In th~s paper we investigate a
liquid crystalline
elastomer where the NLO activechromophores (e.g n~trogroups)
arecovalently
bonded to thepolymer
network. Thephase
structure, thepoling
behaviour and the second-orderoptical susceptibilit~es
w~ll bereported.
2.
Experimental.
2, I SYNTHESIS oF THE ELASTOMER. It is well known that matenals
containing h~ghly polar end-groups (e.g. -NO~ groups)
are ideal matenals to observe second harmonic generation[6].
Therefore we choose an elastomer with a chemical structure shown infigure
I. Theliquid
crystalline
siloxane network with the mesogenic side chains M issynthesized by
aPt-catalyzed
addition reaction of the
liquid crystalline
molecules and the crosshnker CLA to a linearpolyhydrogensiloxane, according
to a well knownsynthesis
route[7]
Elastomer films of 100- 200 ~m th~ckness areprepared by
spin castingtechnique
Forpunfication
the elastomer isextracted
by swell~ng
in toluene anddeswelling
inpetrolether.
The elastomer is charactenzedby
aglass
transition at T~ = 258 K w~th achange
ofspecific
heatAC~
= 0.21J/gK
and a first order transformation at T= 373 K
(Onset)
with anenthalpy change
of AH= 4
Jig.
AboveCH~ CH3
-o-f
o-f
-o-[M]~~
(cH~)~c~$[~~
~M]~~ (cH~j2
-o-S o -s -o-
Ci§ Ci§
cLA
-S(c~)~~o-S(CH~)~)~-o-s(CH~)~-
M~~(@)n~o"[~f~o~fjRi
~o R~
n F~ R~
a 4
N~
Fb 3 CN H
c 3 OC~H~~ H
a-b c = 03.005 065
Fig
I Chemical structure of the elastomer(M Mesogen,
CLACrosshnkmg agent)
M 5 SHG IN A
LIQUID-CRYSTALLINE
ELASTOMER 561this
temperature
the elastomerdisplays
an isotropicphase
The values forAC~
andAH indicate the existence Of a smectic A or a smectic C
phase.
The elastomers arecompletely transparent
and do not absorb above 450 nm2 2 CHARACTERIZATION oF THE ELASTOMER
Thermodynamic properties
were determ~-ned
by
differential scanningcalonmetry (DSC-7,
PerkmElmer)
andpolanzing
m~croscopy(Leitz-Ortholux
2 PolBK).
Structuralinvestigations
wereperformed by X-ray
diffraction(CuKa
=
0 154
nm)
andrecording
of the scattered intensity on flat filmplates
The refractiveindices at A =1064nm
(fundamental
m SHGexpenments)
and A= 532nm
(second
harmonic)
were calculated from measurements of theangle
of total reflection.2.3 SHG-EXPERIMENT For the SHG
experiment
the elastomer film has to bepoled
toobtain the
noncentrosymmetric
structure. The film was sandwiched between two conductiveglass plates (Balzers)
which are connected to a DC sourceThe SHG
expenmental
set-up is shownschematically
mfigure
2 Apulsed
Nd-YAG Laser(DCR 3G, Spectra Physics,
A=1064nm, pulse
width 8 ns,10pulses/s)
with a Gaussian beamprofile TEMOO
is used Thesample
is mounted on a temperature controlled rotation stage Theangle position
of thesample
is directedby
apersonal
computer. The incidentpolarized light
is focussed(lenses L)
m thev~c~nity (4-5 cm)
of thesample.
After passing thesample
the fundamental wave is blockedby
a filter-element(Schott BG39)
and a monochromator(filters).
Theintensity
of the second harmonic beam is detectedby
aphotomultiplier
tube(PMT)
and thesignal
is thenpassed
afteramplification (AMP)
via agated integrator
and boxcar averager(BOXCAR)
to apersonal computer (PC).
To avoid absolute measurements of theintensity
of the fundamental wave a reference method was chosenusing
aquartz crystal (010
onentation, xXxX= 0.5
pm/V)
The measured makerfringe
data are fitted with theoretical calculated curves to determ~ne the second-order
susceptibilities
x~~; and x~~~
SAMPLE /
Nd YAG
PMTL FILTERS
pMT L
BOXCAR AMP
PC
Fig
2.Expenmental
set-up for SHG expenments~Pol
Polan2er, L Lens, HVHigh voltage,
PMT
Photomultiplier
tube, AMP :Amplifier,
BOXCAR Gated integrator and boxcar averager, PC Personalcomputer).
3. Results and discussion.
3 STRUCTURE. For a quantitative
description
of the NLOproperties
of thesynthes~zed
elastomer,
ananalysis
of thephase
structure isrequired,
because thepolanzation
m a medium562 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
II M 5caused
by
an incidentl~ght
beam isdirectly connected
to the symmetry class of this medium.
In our case the type of smectic
phase
and the onentation of the dJrector withrespect
to themacroscopic
dimension of thesample
has to be known for the second harmon~cexperiments [8]. Polannng
m~croscopic observation indicate a uniaxialphase
structure, where theoptical
axis is
parallel
to the fihn normal To decide whether the elastomer exhibits a smectic Aphase
or a two
dimensionally
ordered smecticphase, X-ray investigations
wereperformed.
X-ray scattering diagrams
were recorded at room temperature with the incident beamperpendicular
andparallel
to the film normal(Figs. 3a-c). Perpend~cular
to the film normal(Figs.
3a and3b)
thediagram
is characterizedby
a diffuse vndeangle
reflection B(d=0.42nn1)
and several smallangle
reflections Acorresponding
todi
=
3.3nm, d~
=2.2 nm,
d~
= 1.2 nm,d~
= 0.84 nm, d5 = 0.65 nm, where
only
-the reflectioncorrespond- ing
todi
issharp.
Parallel to the film normal(Fig 3c)
the reflect~on B(d
= 0.42 nm
)
and areflection C
(d
= 0.71 nm
)
are observed as diffuse nngsconf~rm~ng
theopt~cal
observation, With respect to thephase
structure of the elastomer apositional long
range order isonly
indicated in the
sharp
reflectioncorrespond~ng
to alayered
structure with theperiodicity di.
This is consistent with a smect~c Aphase.
Thelayer
thicknessdi
does not coincide with theI'
-'
~/ S
.~
i'
cj
Fig
3 X-Raydiagrams a) perpendicular
to film normal(sample-film
d~stance 7cm),
b)perpendicular
to fflln norrnal
(sample-fihn
distance 17 cni), c)parallel
to fihn normal(sample-fihn
distance 7cn1).
lK° 5 SHG IN A LIQUID-CRYSTALLINE ELASTOMER 563
length
of the monomer units(2.0
nm for the -CN and-NO~
substituted and 2.4 nm for thehexyloxy-substituted
monomerunit)
anda
partially bilayer
has to be assumed. The diffuse reflectionscorresponding
tod~ d~
charactenze short range order Reflection B is attributedto the mean distance between the side groups. Reflection C
m~ght
be due to Si-Sicorrelations
3.2 THEORY oF sEcoND HARMONIC GENERATION It is known that a
light
wavetravelling
through
a medium can excitelugher
harmonic waves m th~s mediumdepending
on its intensity The i-th component of thepolanzation P,
in the medium is then givenby
~< " X~j~~
l~j
+ X~j~~l~jk
+X$~i l~jki
+Ii )
where
E,
denotes the i-th component of the laser fieldstrength
and thex~~~
are the components of thesusceptibility
tensor[9].
The second term in equation(I)
isresponsible
for the secondharmonic,
the third term for the third harmonic etcThe
poled
and thereforenon-centrosymmetric
structure of the elastomer under investi- gation isrepresented by
aC~
symmetry. For the chosen beam geometry(Fig 4)
with the electricpoling
fieldEo parallel
to the Z axis the elements of the second-orderpolanzation
pN~ =
(Pm P~, P=)
aregiven by [10]
P~
=2 x
zxx
E~ E= (2a)
P,
= 2 xzxxE,. E~ (2b)
P=
=x=xx(Ej
+Ej)
+ x===Ej (2c)
where x;<x and x=;= are the second-order
susceptibilities
The second-ordersusceptibilities
arerelated to the molecular
hyperpolanzabihty
elementp;== by
xz;= =
Np
;~~
F
(cos~
if) (3a)
x:xx =
Np=== F( (cos
if) (cos~
if) )/2 (3b)
where N is the number
density,
F includes local field factors and if is theangle
between the molecular axes of thesingle
non-linearoptical
moieties and the externalapplied
electnc fieldEo
For thelimiting
cases of apoled isotropic
medium and apoled Ising
medium thefollowing
expressions have been denved from
calculating
equations(3a)
and(3b) [3, 8]
Component
Poled isotropic PoledIsing
medium medium
x=;=
fl
;== H
Eo/5
kTp
=~~
»Eo/kT
~~~xzxx
fl
==z H
Eo/15
kT 0x:xJx;z= 1/3
o» is the
dipole
moment of the moleculeExpressions (4)
show a l~nearrelationship
between the non,linearsusceptibility
and theapplied poling
fieldEo.
As the distnbution function for aliquid crystalline
matenal is intermediate between these twolimits,
the ratio of the second,order
susceptibil~ties xzxjx===
should also he in betweenThe
dependence
of the second harmonic power on the second-orderpolarization
as afunction of incident
angle (Maker fnnge expenment)
has been calculated[11, 12]
For spolanzation
E=
E(0,1,
0(see Fig 4)
and from equation(2a-2c)
follows10
PN~
=p~(&)
0(5a)
xxE~~
564 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II lK° 5
Z
ELASTOMER ~~
HV
'~°'
x~y
8
Q S POL LASER BEAM
1064 nm
/ P POL
Fig
4 Beam geometry forpoling
m SHG expenment (HVHigh Voltage)
The intensity of the second harmonic is then g~ven
by
~(2
W)
"
~(W
)~~~L l~~(8)
X1/(~$ ~~w)~
XSIn~( ll') (5b)
ll'
=
arL/2) (4/A )(n~
cos8~
n~~
cos
8~ ~) (6)
For p
polarization
E=
E(cos &~, 0,
sin&~) (see Fig 4)
and fromequation (2a-2c)
follows 2 x~~~
E~ cos
&~
sin&~
P~q~ = p P(& 0
(7a)
x=xx
E~ C°S~ 8w
+xzzz
E~
Slll~ &w The intensity of the second harmonic is then givenby
~(2
W= I
(W
)~Pj~L ~( 8)
XI/(n$ n~w)~
X
SIn~( ll') (7b)
&, &~
and &2w
denote the extemal and the internal
angles
ofincidence, I~
is the intensity of thelight
wave atfrequency
w,T(&)
andp(&)
are transmission factorsresulting
fromboundary
condJt~ons, n~ and n~~
are the refract~ve indices at the fundamental
respectively
the secondharmonic,
and L is the thickness of thesample.
The sinusoidal behav~our mequations (5b)
and(7b)
descnbes the interference of the second harmonicsproduced
at different points in the medium.3 3 DYNAMICS
Poling
of an elastomer m an extemal electnc fieldy~elds
a relaxation of the molecules from acentrosymmetric
to a non-centrosymmetnc structure[13]
To determineabsolute values of the non-linear
susceptibilities
it is important to be m anequilibrium
state Therefore it is necessary to know the relaxation of the molecules as a function of temperature.The relaxation of the molecules from the
poled
non-centrosymmetnc to the centrosymmetnc structure isdirectly
indicatedby
thedisappearance
of the second harmonicintensity
The intensity of the second harnlonic as a function of time whenapplying
or removing an electnc DC field was measured Due to the lowglass
transition temperature of the elastomer therelaxation times are below the resolution of the
expenmental set-up
in atemperature
intervalnear room temperature. To obtain information about the relaxation
mechanism,
weanalysed
a
corresponding
elastomer which containsonly
theN02-substituted
mesogen~c side chains For this elastomer T~ is elevatedby approximately
15 K causing aslowing
down of therelaxation in the
investigated
temperature regime. Thediagram
of these measurements(Figs.
5a and5b)
show that the relaxation behaviour issingle exponential reaching
anequihbnum
state w~th the same relaxation times for rise anddecay
of the intensity From anM 5 SHG IN A LIQUID-CRYSTALLINE ELASTOMER 565
' ~ . ~;
~~.
:'
..°_°
,
.
in
- '
"O-,' ,
. o.
m ,
.-' ' '
% ,
-
~j
;,
.
.'
,f8
~°~' Mm' ~
"*
N
<' ~
~
Hfl
*<
.C
-
f.
o
o Baa ieoa 27aa asaa <50a
TIME/s.
*, m *'<.«
, ._+
~
',f,
' ~',,
fn ~ ./
,-',
' ~~
- m $~_-
B ~
C~Q '/
*m'
'~-
h~
~'/.
o
o Boa ieoa 27no asno <son
TIME/s.
Fig
5 Second harmonic intensity versus time at 293 K fora) poling
field onb) poling
field off566 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II lK° 5
Arrhenius
plot
of thelogarithm
of the relaxationfrequency
versus thereciprocal
temperaturem the
liquid crystalline phase
close to T~(Fig. 6)
we achieve an activation energy of 190kJ/mol
This value isonly slightly higher
than the activation energy of the&process
found forliquid crystalline
side chainpolymers [14].
From these results we can conclude that due to thesingle exponential
relaxation behaviour and themagnitude
of the activation energy, thepoling
process is determinedby
the&process
of the mesogenic moieties. The&process
is due to a rotation of the side group around the main chain m the direction of theapplied
electricpoling
field Allfollowing
experiments wereperformed
m theequilibrium
state which is reached whenswitching
on thepoling
field.34 STATIC SHG PROPERTIES In
equations (4), (5b)
and(7b)
a linearrelationship
between non-linear
susceptibilities
andapplied poling
field and aquadratic relationship
between second harmonic intensity and
applied poling
field ispredicted.
From low molarmass systems it is known that the
intensity
of the laser field can influence the onentation of the director.Depending
on the laser fieldstrength
a director reorientation can occur whichcan be
easily recognized
if thepredictions
made mequations (4), (5b)
and(7b)
are not fulfilled[15].
Toverify
whether director reorientation occurs m the elastomer the behaviour of the second harmonic as a function of the incident laser powerrespectively
as a function of theapplied poling
field wasinvestigated. Figures
7 and 8 indicate aquadratic dependence
of the second harmonic on the incident laser power as well as on the electricpoling
fieldstrength
This is m agreement with theprediction
m equations(5b)
and(7b)
and proves thatno director reorientation processes occur. The elastomer behaves similar to a conventional organic material in the
crystalline
state.-- 1
-~
~
~ 6
6 w
a. 25 a. a a. as a. 4 a. 45
j~-
I*iQ3 /~-
lFig
6 Activationdiagram
from second harmonic intensity versus timelK° 5 SHG IN A
LIQUID-CRYSTALLINE
ELASTOMER 567m
tO 6
'
'~ N
e
C~Q
FR
o
o
' 12 lu) la,u,
Fig.
7 - Second
linear fit
m
t~ /
' ,
j
m/
i~
~ /~
o
o i z a
El la.u.
Fig
8 Second harmonic intensity versw square of electncpoling
field, (li) measured points,(-)
linear fitJOURNAL DE PHYSIQUF -T N' MAT 199> N
568 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
II lK° 535 MAKER FRINGE EXPERIMENT. To prove whether the second harmonic can be
descnbed
completely by
equations(5b)
and(7b)
and to determ~ne the second-ordersusceptibilities
xzxx and x==z the intensity of the second harmonic wave was measured as a function of the incidentangle (Maker fnnge expenment).
Theexpenment
wasperformed
fors- and
p-polanzed
incidentlight
at roomtemperature
for a definiteappl~ed pol~ng
field.Figure
9 shows adiagram
forp-polanzed
incidentlight.
Asymmetric
increase of second harmonic intensity is observed starting from the 0deg. position.
Athigher angles fnnges
occur
resulting
from thephase mismatch,
because refractive indices n~~~, n~~ and
optical path length change continuously by
rotating thesample. Interestingly, sharp fnnges
areobserved,
wh~ch indicates the uniform director orientation. Forsamples having
lowerorder, only
theenvelope
of tins curve is observed. To check whether the measured values can be fittedby applying
equations(5b)
and(7b)
the refractive indices of the fundamental and secondharmonic wave m the elastomer have to be known. Table I shows the measured refractive indices The
birefnngence
is 0 at room temperature. With these values and equations(5b)
and
(7b)
theexpenmental
results offigure
9 can bereproduced
The calculated curve is indicatedby
the solid line mfigure
9 On the basis of tins fitted curve and measurements of the absolute intensity of the second harmonic with the quartzreference,
the second-ordersusceptibilities
are determ~ned For apoling
field of 19V/~m
we found x=z= = 0 92pm/V
and x=xx = 0.06pm/V
The ratio ofx~~jx===
is about1/15.3 indicating
that the state of order of the elastomer is w~tlun thelimiting
cases of an isotropicpoled
and anIsmg poled
field system(Eqs (4)).
The value is ingood agreement
with the values found fordoped polymer
films in a smectic Aphase [12].
5
6
~~i
H
6
6
6 o
52.
ANGLE/deq.
Fig
9 Makerfnnge diagram
forp-polanzed
incidentlight
;(li)
measured points,(-)
calculatedcurve
M 5 SHG IN A LIQUID-CRYSTALLINE ELASTOMER 569
Table I.
Refractive
indices as calculatedfrom
measurementsofthe angle oftotal reflection for dfferent wavelengths of light
A/nm
n~ no532 1.608 1.494
632.8 1.598 1.485
064 1.580 1.478
4. Conclusion.
We have shown that
liquid crystalline
elastomers are suitable materials for non-linearoptics.
A uniform director onentation can be
easily
achievedby
asimple
mechanical deformation of the elastomeravoiding
defect structures whichnormally
appear m low molar masshquJd crystals
andliquid crystalline
side chainpolymers Although
the elastomers are not m a solidstate but m a
hquJd-crystall~ne
state, the behav~our iscomparable
to solid bodies Thenetwork prevents any director reonentation
by
the laser fieldstrength.
On the one hand the non-linearsusceptibilities
can be enhancedby
vanation of the chemical structure. On the other hand ferroelectnc I-c- elastomers should allow to observe second harmonic generat~onwithout any extemal
poling
fieldAcknowledgements.
Financial support
by
the DeutscheForschungs
Gememschaft and Verband der Chem~schen Industrie isgratefully acknowledged
References
[1] ULRICH D. R, Mol
Cryst Liq
Cryst 160(1988)1.[2] GARITO A F, TENG C C, WONG K Y, Mol Cryst Liq Cryst lo6 (1984) 219
[3] WILLIAMS D J, Nonlinear
optical
properties ofguest-host polymer
structures » m « Nonlinearoptical
properties of organic molecules andcrystals
», Vol I, Ed D S. Chemla and J Zyss(Academic
Press,Orlando)
1987, p 405[4] GLEIM W and FINKELMANN H., Side-chain
liquid
crystalline elastomers m « Side-chainliquid
crystal polymers », Ed C B McArdle and Blackie(Glasgow)
1989, p 287[5j FRANKE H., Osnabruck, pnvate communication
[6] MEREDITH G R Prospect of new nonlinear organic matenals » m I< Nonlinear optics Matenals and devices », Ed C.
Flytzams
and J. L Oudar,Spnnger
proc phys 7 (SpringerVerlag,
Berlin) 1986, p l16.[7] FINKELMANN H, KOCK H J, REHAGE G, Makromol Chem.,
Rapid
Commun 2(1981)
317.[8] MEREDITH G R, VANDUSEN J G, WILLIAMS D. J., «Charactenzation of
liquid crystalline
polymers
forelectro-optic applications»,
m «Nonlinearoptical
properties of organic andpolymenc
matenals », ACSSymp
Ser233,
Ed D J Williams~washJngton) 1983, p.109
570 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
II M 5[9] « Nonlinear opt~cs », Eds N. Bloernbergen, W. A Benjamin, INC
(Reading)
1965, p. 2.[10] KURTz S. K., JERPHAGNON J., CHOY M M
,
Landolt B6mstem Numencal Data and Functional
Relationsh~ps
m Science andTechnology
III(11) (Springer,
NewYork)
1979, p 671.[ll]
JERPHAGNON J., KURTz S., JAppl Phys
41(1970)
1667.[12] KUzYK M. G., SINGER K D., ZAHN H E, KING L. A, J
Opt.
Sac Am B 6(1989)
742.[13] SINGER K D, SOHN J. E, LALAMA S J,
Appl Phys.
Lett. 49(1986)
248[14] WILLIAMS G, «Dielectnc properties » m