Qualitative Simulation and Related Approaches for the Analysis of Dynamical Systems
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE.
(3) ! "#%$& '( ! $ )*&+& '-, *) #. /)*&0 & Hidde de Jong. N° 5128 Fevrier 2003. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5128--FR+ENG. THÈME 3. apport de recherche.
(4)
(5)
(6) "!#$#% &('$)+*,
(7) % '-!.$/0) )1* 2 /3&450/)6 73) $8 9;:(:(<=:(<?>A@CB(D EFHGJILK$M$NPORQTSKJUVXWJSY[ZXQ\FHZXI=ILK^]_I`VXWF6YaQHKcb YaI`VedfK,ghbHi6ZXQ6QHj,K,gkbHW,ZXQ6QlVeY[ggVeQHW,K,g mUZen KJSgpopqsrtORu vpVew6w(ZXUSi6KUK,WFHKJUWFHKxQ y{zC|h}c~N{KJAUY[KJU}cccM$NP c =wlVedfK,g. hh6ccp KJSFHZAi6gtZXUTlVeaYaSVeSYafKsgYaI6VeSY[ZXQLVea[Zhw6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHg4SZ(KI`VXi6KZXQ$SFHK7(KJFlV,AY[ZXUZe V
(8) gAgSKJI ZXU0
(9) F6Y[WFQHZTlVeQ SYaSVeSYafK=YaQCZXUI`VeSY[ZXQY[gV,cVeYaVe6[Kc¡¢ORQVXi6iCYaSY[ZXQtb£SFHKJ¤FHKJawZX6SVeYaQ¥VW,ZXI=w6UKJFHKJQHgY[ZXQ¥Ze SFHKUVeQ6dfK¦Zew ZcggYa6[K?TlVeaYaSVeSYafK(KJFlV,AY[ZXUgLW,ZXI=wlVeSYa6[K¦
(10) YaSF§SFHKgSUHWJS6UK¦Ze0V¨gCgSKJI¡©EF6Y[g=UKJw ZXUS UKJAY[KJgª«AO VeQHi`ZXSFHKJU¬ lVeaYaSVeSYafKpgYaI6VeSY[ZXQ?ILKJSFHZTi6gk¡4OSsiCY[gWJHggK,g7SZ$w6UZX6[KJILgsSFlVeSFlV,fKgKJUY[ZXHga W,ZXI=w6UZXI=Y[gK,iSFHK?Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQZeSFHK,gK`ILKJSFHZTi6g$SZUKhVeaY[gSY[WLw6UZX6[KJILgYaQ©gWJY[KJQHW,K?VeQHi¥KJQ6dcYaQHK,KJUYaQ6dH®=SFHK ZAW,WJ6UUKJQHW,KpZetgw66UY[ZXHgs KJFlVhTY[ZXU¬w6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHgVeQHiLSFHKW,ZXI$6YaQlVeSZXUYVe£K^¯Aw6[ZcgY[ZXQZe(SFHKQ 6I$ KJUZe£ KJFlVhTY[ZXU w6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHgh¡OQ¢UK,gw(ZXQHgK¬SZ0SFHK,gKw6UZX6[KJILghbcUKJVeSK,i`Vew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gZXU{SFHK
(11) lVeaYaSVeSYafKVeQlVeaCgY[gZe(iCTQlVeI=Y[WhVe gCgSKJILg
(12) FlVhfKKJILKJUdfK,i£® lVeaYaSVeSYafKw6FlVXgK°gwlVXW,K°VeQlVeaCgY[gpVeQHi\gKJI=Y±]R lVeQTSYaSVeSYafK$gYaI6VeSY[ZXQt¡sEFHKUKJw ZXUS VeUdcHK,gZXULV\gAQ SFHK,gY[g=ZeSFHK,gK¦Vew6w6UZfVXWFHK,g=SZ5ZX6SVeYaQ²V¨W,ZXI=w66SVeSY[ZXQlVe
(13) ³UVeILKJZXU´ZXU¢SFHK lVeaYaSVeSYafK VeQlVeaCgY[gLZeiCTQlVeI=Y[WhVepgAgSKJILgh¡µEF6Y[gLgFHZX6[iµw6UZhAY[i6K¤V5gZXaY[iµlVXgY[g¢ZXU¢¶6USFHKJU=6wHgWhVeaYaQ6dVeQHiµ³ZXU=SFHK i6KJfKJ[ZXw6ILKJQTSZe{ILZTi6KJ±]_lVXgK,i¦UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d?Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQHgpZeV=
(14) Y[i6KJUgW,ZXw(Kc¡ ·¦¸ ¹(º»$¼ ½4c ªplVeaYaSVeSYafK$UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6dHb TlVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQtb£ª«AO blTlVeaYaSVeSYafK$VeQlVeaCgY[gZe7iCTQlVeI=Y[WhVe gCgSKJILghbCgKJI=Y±]RTlVeQ SYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQtb6YaQTSKJUXVetgYaI6VeSY[ZXQtbCILZAi6KJaYaQ6dHblª0}Cblª0MCbT[ZAZXwC]RgSUHWJS6UK,igAgSKJILg. Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4 76 61 52 00 — Télécopie +33 4 76 61 52 52.
(15) 0 $ $ 4 1)
(16) ##$%(&('$) )#%1 _/)l- )H/)6 73) /3 $) rtK,g0ILjJSFHZAi6K,gpw(ZX6U0V`gYaI6VeSY[ZXQTlVeaYaSVeSYafK¢w KJUILKJSSKJQTS°i6K°_VeYaUK¢i6K,gpw6Uj,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHgiC¨W,ZXI¢] w(ZXUSKJILKJQ S¦i 6Q gAgSGJILK\i6ZXQ6QHj¨ lVeQHi VeHWJ6QHK,g?YaQC³ZXUI`VeSY[ZXQHgTlVeQ SYaSVeSYafK,gQHK¨gZXQ SiCY[gw(ZXQ6Ya6[K,gh¡qQ ZX6SUKcbHKJa[K,gpVeY[i6KJQ S ¢ZX6SKJQ6YaU6QHKW,ZXI=w6UjJFHKJQHgY[ZXQ¤i6K,gW,ZXI=w(ZXUSKJILKJQ SgTlVeaYaSVeSY±³g
(17) w(ZcggYa6[K,gw(KJUI=Y[g
(18) wlVeUV gSUHWJS6UKi 6QgAgSGJILKc¡ ¬KLUVew6w(ZXUS$VeYaS$6QHKgAQ SFHG,gKi6Kª«AO KJS¢i Ve6SUK,gILjJSFHZTi6K,g¢i6K`gYaI6VeSY[ZXQ TlVeaYaSVeSYafKc¡OtSUVeYaSKi6KJC¯¦w6UZX6[GJILK,g0 6YZXQ S0gjJUY[KJHgKJILKJQ S0W,ZXI=w6UZXI=Y[gp Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQ5i6K$W,K,gILjJSFHZAi6K,g i6K,gw6UZX6[GJILK,g$gWJY[KJQTSY l HK,gKJS°SK,WF6QHZX[ZXdcY[ HK,g$UjhVeaY[gSK,g`®° K^¯AY[gSKJQHW,Ki6K=w6Uj,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHgi6KLW,ZXI=w ZXUSKJILKJQTSg _VXWJSY[W,K,ghb£VeYaQHgY HK K^¯Aw6[ZcgY[ZXQ5W,ZXI$6YaQlVeSZXYaUKLiC¨QHZXI6UK=i6K$w6Uj,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHgi6KW,ZXI=w(ZXUSKJILKJQ Sgk¡qQ5UjJw ZXQHgK W,K,g0w6UZX6[GJILK,ghbi Ve6SUK,gVew6w6UZAWFHK,g°w(ZX6U VeQlVeaCgK= lVeaYaSVeSYafK=i6K=gAgSGJILK,giCAQlVeI=Y[THK,g°ZXQ S°jJILKJUdfj® VeQlVeaCgK¦TlVeaYaSVeSYafK¦i6K K,gwlVXW,K¦i6Kw6FlVXgK?KJS¢V¨gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ gKJI=Y±]RTlVeQ SYaSVeSYafKc¡µrtK?UVew6w ZXUS=w6U XQHK?6QHK gAQ SFHG,gK¤i6K¤W,K,g?Vew6w6UZAWFHK,g¦V HQ i ZX6SKJQ6YaU6Q WhVXiCUK¨VeadfZXUYaSF6I=Y[THK¨w ZX6U VeQlVeaAgK¤ lVeaYaSVeSYafK5i6K¤gAg] SGJILK,g°iCAQlVeI=Y[THK,gh¡ ¬K,WJYi6KJTUVeYaSnKJSKJU06QHKlVXgK¢gZXaY[i6Kw KJUILKJSSVeQTS°VI=Y[gK ` j,WFHKJa[K=i6KVgYaI6VeSY[ZXQ TlVeaYaSVeSYafKKJS
(19) [K°i6jJfKJ[ZXw6w(KJILKJQ Si6K,gpVew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQHgw6aHgVeUdfK,giCUVeY[gZXQ6QHKJILKJQ S =wlVeUSYaUi6K0ILZTi6GJ[K,gk¡ ¼ h º ¦ vpVeY[gZXQ6QHKJILKJQTSTlVeaYaSVeSY± b6gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ\TlVeaYaSVeSYafKcb ª«AO bHVeQlVeaCgK0 lVeaYaSVeSYafK°i6KgAgSGJILK,g iCAQlVeI=Y[ HK,gkbAgYaI6VeSY[ZXQgKJI=Y±]RTlVeQ SYaSVeSYafKcbHgYaI6VeSY[ZXQi YaQ SKJUcVea[K,ghbCILZAi6jJaY[gVeSY[ZXQtblª0}CbHª0MCbCgAgSGJILK,g¬KJQ (ZXHWJ[K,g . . .
(20) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(21) p l%($& VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVeILZAi6KJaYaQ6d Y[g¢V¤lVXgY[WYaQ6dcUK,iCY[KJQTS`ZeUK,gKhVeUWF²YaQµw6UVXWJSY[WhVeaaKJfKJUi6ZXI`VeYaQ²ZegWJY[KJQHW,K¦VeQHi KJQ6dcYaQHK,KJUYaQ6dH¡ 6Y[W´`gWhVeQZetSFHK c6a?}ccc}°Y[ggHKZe "!#$% &!(' )$*$!+ YaaaHgSUVeSK,g¬SF6Y[g¬w ZXYaQTSh®{SFHKQHKJg KhVeS6UK,gVeQHi`lVXW´TdcUZX6QHiVeUSY[WJ[K,gUK^KJU¬SZ$I`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVe£ILZAi6KJ[g³ZXUgHWFiCYafKJUgKw6UZX6[KJILgVXg¬w6UK,iCY[WJSYaQ6d SFHKp66Q6´fKJU ]_6HgSYaQ6d¢w ZXSKJQTSYVe£ZetQ HWJ[KhVeU¬VeUFHKhVXi6ghbCKJcVealVeSYaQ6d¢SFHKiC-Y ,(HgY[ZXQ?ZetdcUZX6QHiSZ,¯CYaQHghbCi6K,gWJUYa6YaQ6d SFHK lVeQTS6I gSVeSKZetQ HWJ[KJY_b6VeQHi`6QHi6KJUgSVeQHiCYaQ6d¢SFHKpKJILKJUdfKJQHW,KZe W,ZXI=w6[K^¯LwlVeSSKJUQHg¬YaQKJfZXa6SY[ZXQt¡«TYaQHW,K ILZcgSZe4SFHK0ILZTi6KJ[g
(22) i6KJfKJ[ZXw(K,iZXUUKhVe Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQHgpVeUKSZTZ=iC-Y .`WJ6aS
(23) SZ=gZXafK°VeQlVeaTSY[WhVeaafbHgWJY[KJQ SY[gSgVeQHi KJQ6dcYaQHK,KJUgUZX6SYaQHKJaHgK¬Q 6ILKJUY[WhVeHgYaI6VeSY[ZXQLSZYaQ fK,gSYad VeSKSFHK KJFlVhTY[ZXUZe SFHKgCgSKJILg4SFHKJ$gSHiCf¡EFHK VhXVeYaVe6YaaYaS¢Ze gZXw6F6Y[gSY[WhVeSK,i=gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ=SK,WF6Q6Y[THK,gsVeQHiYaQHWJUKhVXgYaQ6dca$w(Zh¬KJU ¶6HW,ZXI=w66SKJUg7FlVXgW,ZXQ SUYa66SK,i SZ=SFHK°w ZXw66VeUYaSZe{Q 6ILKJUY[WhVe4gYaI6VeSY[ZXQ¤SZTZX[gk¡ paSFHZX6dcF
(24) Y[i6KJaµHgK,i£bQ 6ILKJUY[WhVe0gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ FlVXg=YaSg`aYaI=YaSVeSY[ZXQHgh¡ 4YaUgS`Ze°Vea_bYaQ ZXUi6KJULSZi6KJUYafK w6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHg¶UZXI SFHK¢ILZAi6KJ[ghb K=QHK,K,i QT6ILKJUY[WhVescVeaHK,g0ZXUSFHK¢wlVeUVeILKJSKJUgVeQHi5YaQ6YaSYVesW,ZXQHiCYaSY[ZXQHgk¡LORQ I`VeQT¥gYaSlVeSY[ZXQHghb{K,gw(K,WJYVeaa ZX6SgY[i6K`SFHK`SUVXiCYaSY[ZXQlVe¬gWJY[KJQHW,KVeQHi¥KJQ6dcYaQHK,KJUYaQ6d i6ZXI`VeYaQHghb{gHWF¥cVeaHK,gVeUK QHZXS$VhXVeYaVe6[Kc¡=OQ 6Y[ZAWFHKJI=Y[gSUfb ³ZXUK^¯HVeI=w6[KcbtUKJaYVe6[K=cVeaHK,g0ZXUSFHK¢´TYaQHKJSY[W¢wlVeUVeILKJSKJUgi6K,gWJUYa6YaQ6dSFHK UVeSK,gZeW,KJaa6VeUUKhVXWJSY[ZXQHg°VeUKHglVeaa¤iC-Y .`WJ6aShb£Y±sQHZXS0YaI=w ZcggYa6[Kcb SZ?ZX6SVeYaQ5
(25) YaSF WJ6UUKJQ S°K^¯Cw(KJUYaILKJQ SVe ILKJSFHZAi6gh¡EFHKV,cVeYaVe6[KYaQC³ZXUI`VeSY[ZXQ¨Y[gHglVeaa lVeaYaSVeSYafKYaQ\QlVeS6UKcb(gHWF¨VXgpSFlVeSZXQHK$UKhVXWJSY[ZXQ5ZTW,WJ6Ug _VXgSKJUSFlVeQ¥VeQHZXSFHKJUh¡`«AK,W,ZXQHi£b£¬K`VeUK=Ze¶SKJQ QHZXSYaQTSKJUK,gSK,i YaQ SFHK¢(KJFlV,AY[ZXU°ZeSFHK=gCgSKJI K^¯CF6Ya6YaSK,i¨³ZXU wlVeUSY[WJ6VeU¬XVeaHK,g¬Ze£SFHKwlVeUVeILKJSKJUgVeQHiLYaQ6YaSYVe(W,ZXQHiCYaSY[ZXQHgh¡vpVeSFHKJUhbTKZX6[iaYa´fKSZ´AQHZh
(26) F6Y[WF?WJVXggK,g Ze= lVeaYaSVeSYafKJaT]RiC-Y ,£KJUKJQ S\(KJFlV,AY[ZXUg\VeUK W,ZXI=wlVeSYa6[K¥
(27) YaSF SFHK gSUHWJS6UKZe$SFHK gAgSKJIbpdcYafKJQ1W,KJUSVeYaQ W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSg¢ZXQ©SFHK`XVeaHK,g$ZeSFHKLwlVeUVeILKJSKJUg=VeQHi¥YaQ6YaSYVe¬W,ZXQHiCYaSY[ZXQHgh¡HZXUYaQHgSVeQHW,Kcb4
(28) FHKJQµiCYVedcQHZcgYaQ6d5V I`Ve±³6QHWJSY[ZXQ6YaQ6d°w66I=wtbXYaS4Y[gYaI=w(ZXUSVeQ SSZ´AQHZhµ
(29) FHKJSFHKJU{SFHK
(30) VXgg6I=w6SY[ZXQ=Ze V[KhVe´TYaQ6d0w6Yaw(KWhVeQ=K^¯Cw6VeYaQSFHK ZXHgKJUcVeSY[ZXQ\SFlVeSSFHK¬VeSKJUpw6UK,gg6UKY[g[ZhKJUpSFlVeQQHZXUI`Ve_¡¬ORQ¦I`VeQTWhVXgK,ghb6gHWF¤TlVeaYaSVeSYafK°w6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHg VeUK°g/ .`WJY[KJQ SZXU_Ve6aS
(31) [ZTWhVeaY 0kVeSY[ZXQt¡ op6I`VeQ²UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6dVe ZX6S=SFHK¦w6FTAgY[WhVe
(32) ZXU[i Ze³SKJQ§YaQ fZXafK,g`I`Ve´TYaQ6dTlVeaYaSVeSYafKw6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHgZeSFHK STw(K$i6K,gWJUYa K,i5Ve ZkfKc¡pEF6Y[gpY[gpSUHK°ZXUSFHKW,ZXI=ILZXQC]RgKJQHgKUKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6dSFlVeS0KJQlVe6[K,gpILZcgSw(K,ZXw6[KSZYaQC³KJU
(33) FlVeS°FlVew6w(KJQHg
(34) FHKJQ¥VeQZXw(KJQ lVeSF S6Y[g Ha[K,iVeSVW,ZXQHgSVeQ S°UVeSKc¡ 1¬6S°K^¯Cw KJUSg0YaQ ILK,iCY[WhVe7w6FTAgY[ZX[ZXdc VeQHi¤KJ[K,WJSUZXQ6Y[W$WJYaUWJ6YaS0i6K,gYadcQtbHSZ`dcYafK°66SSZ?K^¯6VeI=w6[K,gkb Ve[gZ`i6KJILZXQHgSUVeSKVL lVeaYaSVeSYafK$6QHi6KJUgSVeQHiCYaQ6d Ze¬SFHKJYaU°g6Cn K,WJShb(UK,gKJI6aYaQ6dSFHK=W,ZXI=ILZXQC]RgKJQHgK¢UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6dZeVhTILKJQ YaQ5I`VeQ VXgw(K,WJSgh¡EFHK¢$K .`WhVXWJ5Ze FT6I`VeQUKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d5Ve(ZX6S$w6FTAgY[WhVeILK,WFlVeQ6Y[gILgFlVXg$YaQHgw6YaUK,iSFHK?i6KJfKJ[ZXw6ILKJQ SLZe3 2 4
(35) 65$78-9 ILKJSFHZAi6g`SFlVeS?VXi6iCUK,ggLSFHK\aYaI=YaSVeSY[ZXQHgZeSUVXiCYaSY[ZXQlVeQT6ILKJUY[WhVepILKJSFHZAi6gh¡ qsVeUa§ZXU´§ZXQ lVeaYaSVeSYafK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQK^¯Aw6aY[WJYaSa ILKJQ SY[ZXQHK,i F 6I`VeQ UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d²VXg?YaSgUK^³KJUKJQHW,Kcbpi6K HQ6YaQ6dSFHK VeYaI VX;g : ³ZXUI`VeaY 0,YaQ6d W,ZXI=ILZXQC]RgKJQHgKLUKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d ZX<U : i6ZXYaQ6d¤TlVeaYaSVeSYafK=w6F CgY[W,g = ?>A@> Cb B zC|cEb D9FAb ~czCb7|c?| GHI^¡LORQ©g6HgK,THKJQ S°¬ZXU´ b SF6Y[gW,ZXdcQ6YaSYafK=YaQHgw6YaUVeSY[ZXQ FlVXg0dcUVXiClVeaa¤UK,W,K,i6K,i5SZ?SFHKlVXW´AdcUZX6QHi£btdcYaAYaQ6d¬V,¨SZ?YaQHWJUKhVXgK,i W,ZXQHW,KJUQHg Ve(ZX6SI`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVetZX6QHiHVeSY[ZXQHgh¡ XVeUY[KJS$Ze TlVeaYaSVeSYafK
(36) gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ=ILKJSFHZTi6g{FlVXg4(K,KJQ¢i6KJfKJ[ZXw(K,iYaQ¢SFHK lKJ[i¢Ze 4
(37) CJ(K5#L@ M NJCO ¡CEF6UK,K0
(38) FlVeS
(39) I=YadcF S
(40) (K0WhVea[K,i¦WJVXggY[WhVetVew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gFlV,fKKJILKJUdfK,i£®SFHKW,ZXI=w(ZXQHKJQ S ]_lVXgK,i¤Vew6w6UZfVXWF Ze{i6QK P0[K,KJUVeQHRi 1¬UZh
(41) SQ B zcMCbCze9 HN=³gK,K0Ve[gTZ Ba?| G9FUHI^bCSFHKw6UZAW,K,gg ]_lVXgK,i¦Vew6w6UZfVXWF\Ze4HZXU6Hg BVDc~Cb FXz HRbCVeQHiSFHK W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTS ]_lVXgK,i¤Vew6w6UZfVXWF\ZeW P06Yaw KJUXg Ba|hc~6b(|c|J lb(|c|h HR¡EFHK0Y[ggHK,gUVeY[gK,i ?SFHK,gKVew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gpFlV,fK0SZLV VeUdfK=K^¯CSKJQ S°gFlVew(K,i¤SFHK¢ZXU´¤ZXQ TlVeaYaSVeSYafK=gYaI6VeSY[ZXQtb4VeQHi5ZXQ5TlVeaYaSVeSYafK¢UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d¦ILZXUKdfKJQHKJUVeaafb 6wSZLSF6Y[giHV,Y =³gK,)K B }cMCbt?| GcZz HtZXUW,ZXa[K,WJSY[ZXQHgpZe{wlVew(KJUgpVeS
(42) SFHKZXUYadcYaQ¤Ze4SFHKVe ZkfKILKJSFHZTi6gVeQHYi BAFX}6b£|c|hM6b |c|h}6bH}cC#| H£³ZXU
(43) UKJSUZcgw(K,WJSYafK,[g I^¡ OQ`SFHKpNq \ ]O«A_O ^Q\ Vew6w6UZfVXWFZe i6K P0[K,KJU¬VeQHTi 1¬UZh
(44) `Q B zcMCbTze HRbCV°TlVeaYaSVeSYafKILZAi6KJ ZeVgAgSKJI Y[gsW,ZXQC] gSUHWJSK,i¶UZXISFHK7ILZTi6KJ[gtZeCYaSg£YaQHiCYaAY[iClVeTW,ZXI=w(ZXQHKJQ Sgh¡4EF6Y[gtILZAi6KJfSVe´fK,g£SFHK³ZXUI1ZeHVgKJStZe6W,ZX/Q aHHKJQHW,K,ghb >7U> W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSgZXQSFHK0 lVeaYaSVeSYafK0cVeaHb K =³gYadc%Q IZegCgSKJI cVeUYVe6[K,gh¡7EFHK0W,ZX/Q aHHKJQHW,K,gVeUKHgK,i?SZYaQCKJU
(45) V i6K,gWJUYaw6SY[ZXQ¦Ze£SFHKp KJFlVhTY[ZXUZe£SFHKpgCgSKJI SF6UZX6dcFgYaI$6VeSY[ZXQt¡7EF6Y[g¬UK,g6aSgsYaQVeQKJQTTY[gY[ZXQ6ILKJQTShbHVdcUVew6F Ze
(46) Vea7 lVeaYaSVeSYafKLgSVeSK,gZeSFHK¢gCgSKJI gVeSY[g ³TYaQ6dSFHK=W,ZX/Q aHHKJQHW,K,ghb4VeQHi5Veaw(ZcggYa6[KSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg° KJSK,KJQ SFHK,gK$gSVeSK,gh¡
(47) EFHRK cQdfeZgh ije8i h klnmWoqp8r#lts+sbuwvxl#p?ozy|{}cCm uE~°Vew6w6UZfVXWF i6KJfKJ[ZXw K,i¤ ¦HZXU6Hg BVDc~Cxb FXZz Hw6UZhAY[i6K,g V?w6UZAW,K,gg ]RW,KJQTSKJUK,iAY[KJ ZXQSFHK¢w6F CgY[WhVe7¬ZXU[i
(48) F6Y[WFµVea[ZhgZXQHK¢SZ¦K^¯Cw6UK,gg°W,ZXI=ILZXQC]RgKJQHgK=´AQHZh
(49) [K,iCdfK Ve(ZX6Sw6F CgY[WhVe7gCgSKJILgh¡ YafKJQ¥V?gW,KJQlVeUY[Z¦ZeVwlVeUSY[WJ6VeUgYaSlVeSY[ZXQVeQHi5V?´AQHZh
(50) [K,iCdfKLlVXgK¢ZeVeHgSUVXWJS . . . . . . . w
(51) zC|h}c~.
(52) ILZAi6KJC¶UVedcILKJQTSg7i6K,gWJUYa6YaQ6d°ZXCnK,WJSghbfTlVeQ SYaSY[K,ghb UKJVeSY[ZXQHg(KJSRK,KJQZXCn K,WJSghbfVeQHi¢w6UZAW,K,ggK,g{YaQ¢SFHK
(53) i6ZXI`VeYaQtb ªm7E dfKJQHKJUVeSK,g
(54) VILZAi6KJ ZetSFHKw6F CgY[WhVe gAgSKJIx6QHi6KJU¬gSHiCf¡{EFHKpILZTi6KJ Y[g7lVXgY[WhVeaa?VgKJSZe W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg ZXQ©SFHKTlVeaYaSVeSYafK`cVeaHK,gZecVeUYVe6[K,ghb{WhVea[K,iYa/Q aHHKJQHW,K,gk¡ pgYaQ¥SFHKNq \ ]0O«A_O ^Q\Vew6w6UZfVXWFtbs lVeaYaSVeSYafK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ`Y[g{HgK,i¢SZW,ZXQHgSUHWJSsVeQLKJQ AY[gY[ZXQ6ILKJQ S¬i6K,gWJUYa6YaQ6d°SFHKw(ZcggYa6[K¬ KJFlVhTY[ZXUgsZe SFHK
(55) gCgSKJI¡ Q6aYa´fK Nq \ ]0O «AKO ^Q\1VeQHi¦ªm7E/b P06Yaw KJUg C Vew6w6UZfVXWY F Ba|hc~Cb |c|h6bl|c|J
(56) H(FlVXgs³ZAWJHggK,i?ZXQSFHKgYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ?w6UZAW,K,gg VeQHi£bAVeS7[KhVXgS7YaQLYaSgsZXUYadcYaQlVeHZXUI6VeSY[ZXQtbTFlVXgYadcQHZXUK,iLSFHK
(57) ILZAi6KJ±]_66Ya[iCYaQ6dVXgw K,WJSsZe£TlVeaYaSVeSYafKUKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6dH¡ EFHK? lVeaYaSVeSYafKILZAi6KJ¬ZeV¤gAgSKJI Y[gV\ lVeaYaSVeSYafK?iC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVe
(58) K, lVeSY[ZXQtb7VeQµVeHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQ§ZeV\WJVXgg$Ze ZXUiCYaQlVeU iC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVeK,TlVeSY[ZXQHgh¡ªplVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQ©K^¯Aw6[ZXYaSg$W,ZXQ SYaQ 6YaS w6UZXw KJUSY[K,g$Ze¬SFHKLXVeUYVe6[K,g VXg=¬KJaVXgLW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSgLZXQ§SFHKJYaU`TlVeaYaSVeSYafKXVeaHKYaI=w6aY[K,i§T©SFHK¦TlVeaYaSVeSYafKiC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVeK,TlVeSY[ZXQt¡µORS w6UZAiCHW,K,gw(ZcggYa6[KgK,THKJQHW,K,gZe lVeaYaSVeSYafK$gSVeSK,gZe{SFHK°gCgSKJIb6gZe]RWhVea[K,iTlVeaYaSVeSYafK(KJFlV,AY[ZXUgh¡ ^SFHK¢SF6UK,KLVew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gILKJQ SY[ZXQHK,iVe ZkfKcbª«AO FlVXg0(K,W,ZXILK¢SFHK¢ILZcgS
(59) Y[i6KJa ]_HgK,iVew6w6UZfVXWF¥SZe] VeUi6gTlVeaYaSVeSYafK=gYaI6VeSY[ZXQt¡=OSgWJ[KhVeU°i6K HQ6YaSY[ZXQ¥Ze
(60) W,ZXQHW,KJw6SgaYa´fK= lVeaYaSVeSYafKLILZTi6KJ_btTlVeaYaSVeSYafKLgSVeSK VeQHi¢(KJFlV,AY[ZXUhbTVeQHi¢YaSg7K^¯Cw6aY[WJYaSUKJVeSY[ZXQL(KJSR¬K,KJQ` lVeaYaSVeSYafKpVeQHi¢Q 6ILKJUY[WhVe gYaI6VeSY[ZXQtbfFlVXgVXWJYaaYaSVeSK,i=SFHK VXiHVew6SVeSY[ZXQ VeQHi¦YaQ SKJdcUVeSY[ZXQ5ZeUK,g6aSg³UZXI 6UVeQHWFHK,gZeI`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[W,gpi6KhVeaYaQ6d
(61) YaSF¤ZXUiCYaQlVeU¦iC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVe K,TlVeSY[ZXQHgh¡OQVXi6iCYaSY[ZXQtbAYaS¬FlVXgVea[ZkK,iSFHKpw6UZhAY[gY[ZXQZe dclVeUVeQ SK,K,g
(62) ZXQ?SFHKcVeaY[iCYaSR?ZetSFHKpZX6SW,ZXILK0Ze SFHK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ¤w6UZAW,K,ggh¡q \ ]0O «AKO ^Q\.VeQHi¤ªm7EFlVhfKK^¯6KJUSK,i\V¢W,ZXQHgY[i6KJUVe6[KYa/Q aHHKJQHW,KZXQ¤Ve6SZXI`VeSK,i\ILZTi6KJ±] 66Ya[iCYaQ6dH¡©EFHK?W,ZXI=w(ZXQHKJQ S ]RW,KJQTSKJUK,i Vew6w6UZfVXWF ZepNq \ ]O«AKO ^Q\FlVXgYaQHgw6YaUK,iµILZTi6KJ±]_66Ya[iCYaQ6d¥Vew6w6UZfVXWFHK,g lVXgK,i`ZXQLZXU´¢YaQ`gCgSKJI iCAQlVeI=Y[W,ghb gHWFVXg(ZXQHi=dcUVew6FHg B }c}6bf}cz6b6|hc}6b6|hMe
(63) HR¡ gsVp³6USFHKJUsW,ZXQ SUYa66SY[ZXQZe Nq \ ]0O «AKO ^Q\$blZXQHK°I`V,¤WJYaSK°SFHK$K ,£ZXUSgSZL³ZXUI$6VeSKVL lVeaYaSVeSYafK¢VeadfKJ6UVCbllVXgK,i\ZXQ¤gYadcQ¨VeHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQHgZe UKhVe£QT6I(KJUgh¡sEF6Y[g
(64) FlVXg
(65) WJ6aI=YaQlVeSK,iYaQ\V¯AY[ZXI`VeSY 0kVeSY[ZXQHgaYa´fK0SFHKgYadcQC]_UKhVe VeadfKJ6UV=Ze YaaaYVeILg Ba?| G
(66) D6b6}cc H VeQHi SFHK=ZXUi6KJU ]RZe¶]_I`VedcQ6YaSHi6K?WhVe[WJ6aHgZe
(67) vpVeYaI`VeQ Ba|J ~ HR¡¢EFHK=w6UZAW,K,gg ]RW,KJQTSKJUK,i¥ZXQ SZX[ZXdc Zeªm7E aY[K,gVeS SFHKUZAZXS0Ze
(68) VLQT6I(KJUZesILZAi6KJW,ZXI=w ZcgYaSY[ZXQ SK,WF6Q6Y[ HK,6g = ?>A@> Wb BVDcMCb DczCb{|h}e Hb{|h
(69) } D6b|h
(70) M DHb|hzCq| HRb(UKJAY[KJK,i5YaQ Ba|h9 FCb£?| D
(71) DHbH}ccM HI^¡ ^pfKJU
(72) SFHK0fKhVeUgkbTSFHKªv1W,ZXI=I6Q6YaSRFlVXgYaI=w6UZkfK,i£b6dfKJQHKJUVeaY 0hK,i£b VeQHiK^¯CSKJQHi6K,iSFHK°Ve ZkfK lVeaYaSVeSYafK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ²ILKJSFHZAi6g`VXg¢KJaVXgLV¤VeUdfKQ 6I$ KJUZeZXSFHKJU=ILKJSFHZAi6g =³gK,`K BVDe lb?| Gcz HVeQHi©SFHKw6UZAW,K,K,iCYaQ6dfg Ze¬SFHKVeQ6QTlVe [ j$*$%
(73) %
(74) * ?5 8 /
(75)
(76) 3J K5q
(77) L78@ ³ZXU0W,ZXa[K,WJSY[ZXQHg°ZeswlVew(KJU[g I^¡ ¬ZXI=w66SKJU YaI=w6[KJILKJQTSVeSY[ZXQHgZe7SFHKILKJSFHZTi6gpFlV,fK$(K,KJQ\i6KJfKJ[ZXw K,i5VeQHiHgK,i¦YaQ¨V¢cVeUY[KJSRZesVew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQHghb YaQHWJaHiCYaQ6d ILZAi6KJ±]_lVXgK,i iCYVedcQHZcgY[ghbpi6K,gYadcQtbVe6SZXI`VeSK,i ILZTi6KJaYaQ6dHbI`VXWF6YaQHK5[KhVeUQ6YaQ6dHbpgAgSKJIY[i6KJQTSY lWhVeSY[ZXQtbILKhV] g6UKJILKJQTS`VeQlVeaAgY[ghbsVeQHiS6SZXUYaQ6dHY¡ paSFHZX6dcF VeS HUgS$UK,gSUY[WJSK,iµSZ¨SUVXiCYaSY[ZXQlVegWJY[KJQHW,K¦VeQHiµKJQ6dcYaQHK,KJUYaQ6d i6ZXI`VeYaQHghblaYa´fKWJVXggY[WhVetILK,WFlVeQ6Y[W,g0VeQHiKJ[K,WJSUY[WhVe{KJQ6dcYaQHK,KJUYaQ6dHb Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQHgpYaQ¤V¢
(78) Y[i6KcVeUY[KJSRZei6ZXI`VeYaQHg QHZk K^¯CY[gSh¡ VeQ §ZeSFHKUK,W,KJQ S?Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQHg?i6KJUYafK³UZXIi6ZXI`VeYaQHgL
(79) FHKJUK\SFHKiC-Y .`WJ6aSY[K,gLYaQ Vew6w6aTYaQ6d QT6ILKJUY[WhVeILKJSFHZAi6gVeUK°K,gw(K,WJYVeaa³KJaShbHgHWF¤VXg
(80) ILK,i6K,WJYaQHKcbH6Y[ZX[ZXdcfb VeQHiK,W,ZX[ZXdcf¡ ³SKJUSFHKLYaQ6YaSYVeFHKJAiHVhAg$YaQ¥SFHKKJYadcF SY[K,g=VeQHi¥KhVeUa Q6YaQHKJSY[K,gkbSFHK`YaQ SKJUK,gSYaQ¥TlVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQ FlVXg¬g6HgY[i6K,iV6YaSh¡EFHK0Vew6w6aY[WhVeSY[ZXQ¦Ze lVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQSZ$UKhVe±]_ZXU[i?w6UZX6[KJILg¬FlVXgsUKJfKhVe[K,igZXILK ³6QHiHVeILKJQ SVepw6UZX6[KJILgLFlVeI=w(KJUYaQ6d¥K^¯AY[gSYaQ6d ILKJSFHZTi6gh¡§4YaUgSLZeVea_bsYaS=VXg=ZX6QHiµSFlVeS=SFHK¦w6UK,iCY[WJSY[ZXQHg ZX6SVeYaQHK,i SF6UZX6dcF© lVeaYaSVeSYafKLgYaI6VeSY[ZXQI`Vh¤(KKhVe´ VeQHi56Q6YaQC³ZXUI`VeSYafK¢³UZXI V?I`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVe7w(ZXYaQ S Ze
(81) AY[KJ°¡ ZXUK,ZkfKJUhb YaSS6UQHK,iZX6S°SZ¦(K=iC-Y .`WJ6aSSZ¦6wHgWhVe[K=SFHK=ILKJSFHZAi6ghb iCHK=SZSFHK`K^¯Aw6[ZcgY[ZXQ©ZeSFHK QT6I(KJUZew6UK,iCY[WJSK,i¦(KJFlV,AY[ZXUg
(82) FHKJQi6KhVeaYaQ6d=
(83) YaSF¦VeUdfK°VeQHi¦W,ZXI=w6[K^¯¦gAgSKJILgh¡{ORQSFHK0W,ZX6UgKZeSYaILKcbHV QT6I(KJUpZe7VeaSKJUQlVeSYafKVew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gpFlV,fK°KJILKJUdfK,iSFlVeShb6
(84) F6Ya[Kw6UK,gKJUAYaQ6dLcVealVe6[K0Y[i6KhVXg
(85) ³UZXI lVeaYaSVeSYafK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQtbHYaQTSKJdcUVeSK°W,ZXQHW,KJw6SgpVeQHiSK,WF6Q6Y[ HK,g¶UZXI ZXSFHKJU lKJ[i6g
(86) YaQ¦I`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[W,gVeQHi¦W,ZXI=w66SKJUgWJY[KJQHW,Kcb YaQwlVeUSY[WJ6VeUiCAQlVeI=Y[WhVe£gAgSKJILgSFHK,ZXUfblW,ZXQ SUZX£SFHK,ZXUfbHVeQHi?YaQ SKJUcVe VeQlVeaAgY[ghW¡ 1¬LSVeYa[ZXUYaQ6d=SFHKILKJSFHZTi SZ WJVXggK,gLZeiCAQlVeI=Y[WhVegCgSKJILgZXU=
(87) F6Y[WF gSUZXQ6d I`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVeW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ SgK^¯AY[gShbsZXULT©SVe´AYaQ6d YaQ SZ VXW,W,ZX6QTTS =³gKJI=Y±z] I TlVeQ SYaSVeSYafKYaQC³ZXUI`VeSY[ZXQtb SFHK,gK 2 4
(88) 85#b5 /9![R% 5[75 VeQHi 5#$ 2
(89) 5$78-
(90) Vew6w6UZfVXWFHK,g¢FlVhfK? K,KJQ§gFHZk
(91) Q§Ve6[KSZ¤YaI=w6UZhfK6w(ZXQ©SFHK?UK,g6aSg¢ZX6SVeYaQHK,i
(92) YaSF§ lVeaYaSVeSYafK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQt¡ EFHK©VeYaI ZeSF6Y[g¦UKJw(ZXUS¦Y[g¦SZµUKJAY[KJ SFHKWJVXggY[WhVe°TlVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI$6VeSY[ZXQILKJSFHZAi6g¤VeQHi iCYVedcQHZcgK SFHKw6UZX6[KJILg¢SFHKJ FlV,fKKJQHW,ZX6Q SKJUK,i£¡ EF6Y[g¢VXggK,ggILKJQ SY[g°ZXa[Zh¬K,iµ ¥V¤iCY[gWJHggY[ZXQµZeSFHK? lVeaYaSVeSYafK w6FlVXgK`gwlVXW,KLVeQlVeaAgY[gVeQHigKJI=Y±]RTlVeQ SYaSVeSYafK?gYaI6VeSY[ZXQVew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gh¡ORS66Ya[i6g6w ZXQKhVeUaY[KJU°UKJAY[KJgZXQ TlVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQtbgHWF§VXgSFHKWFlVew6SKJUYaQTSUZTiCHWJSY[ZXQHgLYaQ Ba?| GcZz HRb{SFHK¦ª«AO ZAZX´Ze P06Yaw KJURg Ba|c|J
(93) HRb UK,W,KJQTS7 ZAZX´$WFlVew6SKJUg7THZXU6HgVeQH<i P06Yaw KJUg BAFXMHb6|c|hZz HRb VeQHiLVeQLK^¯ASKJQHgYafKUKJTY[KJ²ZXQLTlVeaYaSVeSYafK
(94) UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d . .
(95) . . . . .
(96) . . . . . . . . w. .
(97) T¨SFHK ª Ve6SFHZXUW,ZXa[K,WJSYafK B H|$H =³gK,K`Ve[gZ B zc}CbwFXCb|c|hHI^¡bQK^¯6W,KJa[KJQ S$UKJTY[KJ w6VXWJYaQ6d¨ lVeaYaSVeSYafK gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ\YaQSFHK°
(98) Y[i6KJUW,ZXQ SK^¯CSZe{ILZTi6KJ±]_lVXgK,iUKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d`Y[gVhXVeYaVe6[K°YaQ;0KJUI`VeQ Ba|UFDHR¡W+QHKJ1K,iCYaSY[ZXQ ZesVLHUKJQHWF¨SK^¯AS(ZTZX´ZXQ¤TlVeaYaSVeSYafK°UKhVXgZXQ6YaQ6d;Ba|UFGZHRbl
(99) YaSF¤WFlVew6SKJUg0ZXQI`VeQTZeSFHK°SZXw6Y[W,giCY[gWJHggK,iYaQ SF6Y[g$UKJw ZXUShb4UK,W,KJQTSa©Vew6w KhVeUK,i£¡\EFHK`WJUYaSY[WhVeiCY[gWJHggY[ZXQZe lVeaYaSVeSYafK?gYaI6VeSY[ZXQ 0ZkT[K?VeQHiµ«CVXW´Ag Ba?| Dc HtFlVXgVe[gZ¢Ya/Q aHHKJQHW,K,iSFHK0SF6UHgSZe4SF6Y[gUKJTY[KJ°¡ OQ\gK,WJSY[ZXQ5}CblVeQ¤ZkfKJUTY[KJZe7 lVeaYaSVeSYafK$gYaI6VeSY[ZXQ¨ILKJSFHZTi6g
(100) Yaat(KdcYafKJQt¡ aSFHZX6dcF¤SFHK0³ZAWJHg
(101)
(102) Yaa (KZXQ\ª«AO bCIHWF\Ze
(103) FlVeS
(104) Y[g
(105) gVeY[iVe(ZX6S
(106) SF6Y[gILKJSFHZAi¦WhVeUUY[K,gZhfKJUSZ¢Nq \ ]0O «AKO ^Q\+VeQHi\ªm7E¡ 1¬KJYaQ6d=SFHK SK,WF6Q6Y[WhVeaa$ILZcgS ]Ri6KJfKJ[ZXw(K,i¢ lVeaYaSVeSYafK¬gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQILKJSFHZAi£b ª«AO FlVXgYaQTSKJdcUVeSK,iI`VeQ °Y[i6KhVXg{ZXUYadcYaQlVeSYaQ6d YaQSFHKZXSFHKJUILKJSFHZTi6g
(107) YaQ¦SFHKW,ZX6UgKZe4SYaILKc¡¬«AK,WJSY[ZXQ¤M¢g6I=I`VeUY 0hK,gSZWJVXggK,g
(108) Ze{w6UZX6[KJILgW,ZXQC³UZXQ SYaQ6d ª«AO VeQHi5YaSg0UKJVeSYafK,gkbtw6UKJwlVeUYaQ6dSFHK¢YaQTSUZTiCHWJSY[ZXQZeSFHK=TlVeaYaSVeSYafK=w6FlVXgK=gwlVXW,KLVeQlVeaCgY[gVeQHi gKJI=Y±] TlVeQ SYaSVeSYafK?gYaI6VeSY[ZXQ§Vew6w6UZfVXWFHK,gYaQSFHKgK,WJSY[ZXQHg° ¨VeQHi©zCbUK,gw K,WJSYafKJaf¡EFHK=UKJAY[KJ HQ6Y[gFHK,g°
(109) YaSFV iCY[gWJHggY[ZXQ\ZegZXILK0w KJUgw K,WJSYafK,gZXUTlVeaYaSVeSYafK°gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQt¡ ' . 34 ' $ )l EFHK`lVXgY[W`W,ZXQHW,KJw6Sg¢VeQHi©VeadfZXUYaSF6ILgZepª«AO
(110) Yaas(K=YaaaHgSUVeSK,i© ILKhVeQHg$Ze
(111) SFHK`gYaI=w6[K`SVeQ6´5gAgSKJI YaQ Hdc6UK |c¡ ¥VeSKJU alZkg¢YaQ SZ5SFHKSVeQ6´µVeS=V =³W,ZXQHgSVeQT[S I$UVeSK ¡EFHK¦ZX6_S alZk Zep¬VeSKJU¢³UZXI SFHKSVeQ6´ Y[gi6KJSKJUI=YaQHK,i SFHK?VeILZX6Q S Ze¬VeSKJU¢YaQ¥SFHKSVeQ6´¥VeQHi©SFHKVeUKh V
(112) \ZeSFHK`ZXUY lW,KZe
(113) SFHK`SVeQ6´(¡EFHK ZXa[Zh
(114) YaQ6d?iC-Y ,(KJUKJQTSYVeK,TlVeSY[ZXQILZTi6KJi6K,gWJUYa K,gSFHK KJFlVhTY[ZXUpZe4SFHK°gAgSKJI® . . . = |UI.
(115) "!$#%#&. EFHK³6QHWJSY[ZXQ'Y[gsYaQHW,ZXI=w6[KJSKJaLgw K,WJY lK,i£b YaQ=SFHKgKJQHgKSFlVeS7KZXQ6a¢´AQHZh²SFlVeSsSFHKZX6S_alZh UVeSKYaQHWJUKhVXgK,g VXg=SFHKVeILZX6QTS`ZepVeSKJULYaQ§SFHKSVeQ6´¥YaQHWJUKhVXgK,g =)(+*,( .-0/fI¢VeQHi²VXg=SFHKVeUKhV5ZeSFHK¦ZXUY lW,K¦YaQHWJUKhVXgK,g =)(1+*,(2
(116) 3-4/fI^b6FHKJUK°Ve66UKJTYVeSK,i\S5 Z 6 ! #%# =³gK,KgK,WJSY[ZXQ¤}C¡ }ZXU
(117) SFHK0ZXUI`Ve i6K HQ6YaSY[ZXQ\Ze7 ! #%# I^¡ . . . 9 ;. 8 :. 4Yadc6UK|c®«TYaI=w6[KSVeQ6´LgAgSKJI¡4EFHKcVeUYVe6[K,g7FlVhfKSFHK³ZXa[Zk
(118) YaQ6dYaQ SKJUw6UKJSVeSY[ZXQt®< $VeSKJU¬VeILZX6QTShb=
(119) °VeUKhV ZeZXUY lW,Kc2b 7Ya/Q alZk°?b >¢ZX6_S alZh°<¡
(120) LVeQH@i VeUK°W,ZXQHgSVeQTSg K`
(121) Yaa HUgSK^¯Cw6VeYaQFHZkxSFHK=(KJFlV,AY[ZXU$ZeSFHKLgCgSKJI WhVeQ¥(K=i6K,gWJUYa(K,i YaQ©V¦TlVeaYaSVeSYafKLV,| =³gK,W^] SY[ZXQ}C¡aU| I^bf³ZXa[ZkK,i=T¢SFHKVeHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQ`ZetV0 lVeaYaSVeSYafK
(122) ILZAi6KJC³UZXI SFHK
(123) iC-Y ,(KJUKJQTSYVe K,TlVeSY[ZXQ =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ`}C¡ 9} I^¡ EFHK?W,ZXI=w66SVeSY[ZXQ§Ze
(124) TlVeaYaSVeSYafK?gSVeSK,gVeQHi©gSVeSKLSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg$Y[g$i6KJSKJUI=YaQHK,i SFHK`W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg¢ZXQ©SFHK TlVeaYaSVeSYafK0XVeaHK,gYaI=w(ZcgK,i? SFHKILZTi6KJ VeQHi?SFHKVXgg6ILK,iW,ZXQ SYaQT6YaSRZe SFHKcVeUYVe6[K,gVeQHi?SFHKJYaU
(125) i6KJUYaXV] SYafK,g =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ}C¡ 9M I^¡{EFHKª«AO VeadfZXUYaSF6I VeQHi¢YaSgW,ZXUUK,WJSQHK,ggsw6UZXw KJUSY[K,gsVeUK
(126) iCY[gWJHggK,i¢YaQLgK,WJSY[ZXQHg7}C¡ VeQHi }C¡ zCb£UK,gw K,WJSYafKJaf¡EFHK=i6K,gWJUYaw6SY[ZXQZe
(127) ª«AO WJ[ZcgKJaZXa[ZhgSFHK=ZXUYadcYaQlVesVeUSY[WJ[K Ba|hc~ HsVeQHi5SFHK¢SK^¯CS ZAZX´ Ba|c|J
(128) HR¡lZXUILZXUK°i6KJSVeYa[gSFHK°UKhVXi6KJUY[g
(129) UK^KJUUK,i¦SZ=SFHK,gKgZX6UW,K,gk¡ . ACBED. . F G<HJIEK)LMH1LK)NOPNJH%IQG<O?RSTRULMH1LMO?RPSVH%W<XZY[O\7H]N7K_^`aR ª«AO W,ZXQHgY[i6KJUgLSFHKcVeUYVe6[K,g5b ced ?gfghji lk<mE n ZeV5iCAQlVeI=Y[WhVegCgSKJIb7
(130) FHKJUK bopd qrsutututq hVv³b. gfwxk bVeQHik m UKJw6UK,gKJQTSg$SFHK?K^¯CSKJQHi6K,igKJS$ZeUKhVe¬Q 6I$ KJUgYaQHWJaHiCYaQ6dy VeQHixzy ¡EFHK?XVeUYVe6n [K,g. w
(131) zC|h}c~.
(132) VeUK°W,ZXQHgY[i6KJUK,iSZ=(K *K+5q"$ ³6QHWJSY[ZXQHgZeSYaILKcb6
(133) F6Y[WF¨VeILZXQ6d?ZXSFHKJUSF6YaQ6dfgdclVeUVeQTSK,K,gpSFlVeSSFHKJ¦VeUK W,ZXQTSYaQ HZXHga\iCY-,£KJUKJQ SYVe6[Kc¡ EFHKw ZcggYa6[K lVeaYaSVeSYafK$cVeaHK,g
(134) SFlVeSV¢cVeUYVe6[K°WhVeQ¤SVe´fKVeUK°i6KJSKJUI=YaQHK,i¤ YaSg32 <5 /9!t ¡EFHK TlVeQ SYaS\gwlVXW,KY[gV=SZXSVeZXUi6KJUYaQ6d?Ze - <* < L[5 r ¡,¡,¡ ¡qsVXWF\VeQHiCI`VeU´cVeaHKcbHZXUpVeQHiCI`VeU´ ZXUgFHZXUShbTUKJw6UK,gKJQTSg¬V°HglVeaa=6Q6´TQHZk
(135) QcVeaHKYaQ k m SFlVeSWhVew6S6UK,g¬V lVeaYaSVeSYafKJa=YaI=w(ZXUSVeQ S
(136) iCY[gSYaQHWJSY[ZXQ ZXU{SFHKXVeUYVe6[Kc¡{HZXU{YaQHgSVeQHW,KcbcSFHK
(137) TlVeQ SYaSgwlVXW,KsZXU{SFHKVeUKhzV
(138) pZe SFHKZXUY lW,KYaQ=SFHK¬SVeQ6´$K^¯HVeI=w6[K
(139) WhVeQ¢ K i6K HQHK,i¦SZ=W,ZXQTSVeYaQSFHK0VeQHiCI`VeU´CgC b
(140) 4bHVeQH i y bC
(141) YaSwF /
(142) y ¡OQSFHKW,ZX6UgKZeSFHKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQ w6UZAW,K,gghbsª«AO I`VhYaQ SUZAiCHW,KQHKJ-VeQHiCI`VeU´¥cVeaHK,g Ba|c|J HR¡ zy b /6b7VeQHi y VeUKVeQHiCI`VeU´Cg¢
(143) F6Y[WF§T i6K HQ6YaSY[ZXQI`Vew¥SZ¦´AQHZh
(144) Q©XVeaHK,g$ZXQ¥SFHKLK^¯CSKJQHi6K,iUKhVeaYaQHKc¡EFHK 5[@ 2 /
(145) 5 /f!t W,ZXQHgY[gSgZe
(146) SFHK,gK SF6UK,K0VeQHiCI`VeU´Cgh¡EYaILK0Y[g¬YaSgKJ±{V$cVeUYVe6[K
(147) YaSF?SFHKTlVeQ SYaS?gwlVXW,K ¡,¡,¡ y W¡ SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTS 7Y[g V
(148) 5q 7@
(149) 75 / SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTSY±7V¢cVeUYVe6[K°WFlVeQ6dfK,g¶UZXI ZXUSZLV=VeQHiCI`VeU´?cVeaHKVeS J¡ EFHK 2 /4
(150) 7 b Z
(151) L) Z*$ q q
(152) 7) / Y[g0K^¯Cw6UK,ggK,i¨YaQ5SKJUILgZeSFHKVeQHiCI`VeU´Ag0YaQ5YaSg TlVeQ SYaS¤gwlVXW,K¢VeQHi¨SFHK$iCYaUK,WJSY[ZXQ ZesWFlVeQ6dfKc¡ ZXUKgw K,WJY lWhVeaafb SFHK lVeaYaSVeSYafKcVeaHK$Ze& q1 ^b lq^b
(153) YaSFUK,gw K,WJSSZ¢SFHK lVeQTSYaSR¦gwlVXW,K r ¡,¡,¡ bCY[g
(154) SFHKS6w6[K J "!$#&%('^b6
(155) FHKJUK #&243 Y±5 %q [- /6b ,+ ± Y C 1 q 7 -+ b 0 5*) VeQHi "!$#&%j ./ 576 ! Y±5%q < /6b h ,+ -+ # r d3Y± -+ q1 -+ # rhb !893 Y±5 %q /6¡ /1 : LVeQH; i !$#%°VeUK
(156) WhVea[K,i=SFHK 2 4 9 7 <?@
(157) L f VeQHi 2 /
(158)
(159) *KK!? bfUK,gw(K,WJSYafKJafb Ze% bVe<S ^¡4HZXU K^¯HVeI=w6[KcbHSFHKVeUKh3V
(160) =Ze4SFHK°ZXUY lW,KVeS Y[g
(161) UKJw6UK,gKJQ SK,i¤ SFHK°TlVeaYaSVeSYafK°cVeaH;K l
(162) 7=
(163) ?> @A'^¡ «TYaQHW,PK
(164) Y[gVW,ZXQHgSVeQ Shb0YaS
(165) YaaFlVhfK SFHK gVeILK TlVeaYaSVeSYafK XVeaHK VeS\VVeSKJU¦SYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ ShB ® l
(166) gr
(167) ?> @C'^¡¥ORpSFHKZXUY lW,KY[g=ZXQ6a¥wlVeUSYVeaaµZXw(KJQHK,i£bsSFHKJQµSFHK¦TlVeaYaSVeSYafKXVeaHK¦ZeYaSgLVeUKhVC b DFE l
(168) U^b K,TlVe[Gg h /
(169) d ?> @C'X= f$ ³ZXU
(170) VeSKJUSYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTS[g I^¡ EFHRK 2 4
(171) LbT Z*$ H$ q T 7) }7% j$*[ hIJ KJ # rUdCZXa[Zhg³UZXI SFHK lVeaYaSVeSYafK$XVeaHK VeSSFHKSYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTSgYaQSFHKYaQTSKJUXVe_¡7ORL JVeQHMi KJ r
(172) VeUK0VXienVXW,KJQ S
(173) iCY[gSYaQ6dc6Y[gFHK,iSYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTSghbCSFHK0 lVeaYaSVeSYafK cVeaHK=Ze& q¨ZXQ hIKJ KJ # rUd±b lqKJ J # r^b£Y[gi6K H# QHK,i5SZ K¢K,TlVeSNZ lq³ZXU°VeQ O j hIJEJ # r d±¡ORSFHK SVeQ6´Y[g Ha[K,i`³UZXIKJI=w6SRfbCSFHKJQ¦(KJSR¬K,KJQ¦SFHKpYaQ6YaSYVe£SYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ S VeQHiSFHK0QHK^¯CSiCY[gSYaQ6dc6Y[gFHK,iSYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ S rpSFHK$SVeQ6´
(174) Yaa{W,ZXQ SVeYaQVLw(ZcgYaSYafKVeQHi\YaQHWJUKhVXgYaQ6dVeILZX6QTS0Ze7VeSKJUhb(ILZXUKwlVeUSY[WJ6VeUaP ?,gr T h / y.d RQTS'^¡ 2 /4
(175) 7 5$ 9 j ZeV`iCTQlVeI=Y[WhVegCgSKJI VeSVLiCY[gSYaQ6dc6Y[gFHK,i¨SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTS0ZXUZXQ5VeQ¨YaQ SKJUcVe4 KJSK,KJQ SZVXienVXW,KJQ SpiCY[gSYaQ6dc6Y[gFHK,iSYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ SgpY[gVeVQ U]_S6w6[KZe{TlVeaYaSVeSYafKcVeaHK,ghb6ZXQHK³ZXU
(176) KhVXWFXVeUYVe6[K°YawQ b® . . .
(177) . . . . .
(178) . . . . . . . . . . . . . XWTbCKJQBY lqruKJQutututU( lq KJQ' n XW&bJ KJ r BY lqruKJ J rgutututU( lq JEJ. #. #. n. # r '.
(179) FHKJUKZJ7VeQHi[KJ # rpVeUKiCY[gSYaQ6dc6Y[gFHK,iSYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ SgZegZXILKcVeUYVe6[K q + b]\Z^`_a^NU¡ EFHK 2 /
(180)
(181) + / ?* Ze6ViCTQlVeI=Y[WhVeAgAgSKJI
(182) YaSF°XVeUYVe6[K,g b=ZXQ5d ?gfghAY[g£SFHK7gK,THKJQHW,K7Ze6 lVeaYaSVeSYafK gSVeSK,g . b7BYXWTbCs(XW[bC,r (XW bCr ututut (XWTbCdfe%r gda(XW[bCda'
(183) YaSFh ¥VeQHiigd ef ¡ \ZXSY[W,K?SFlVeSSFHK?gK,THKJQHW,K¦VeaSKJUQlVeSK,g= KJSK,KJQ§SYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ S`VeQHiSYaILK^]_YaQ SKJUcVe cb. gSVeSK,gk¡
(184) W,W,ZXUiCYaQ6d5SZSFHK + 8
(185) ?
(186) *R$5$ *K9!# SFHK,ZXUKJI Zeª«AO b gHWFµV¤ lVeaYaSVeSYafK(KJFlV,AY[ZXUWhVeQ K 6Q6Y[THKJaLVeHgSUVXWJSK,i¢ZXU7KhVXWFLfK,WJSZXU<b¦Ze(UKhVXgZXQlVe6[K³6QHWJSY[ZXQHgh¡{EFHK³6QHWJSY[ZXQHg7bVeUKgVeY[i¢SZ0(K !+L5[75$ j$ j ZXUSZ 5#
(187) 5 SFHKp lVeaYaSVeSYafKp(KJFlV,AY[ZXUh¡ORQdfKJQHKJUVe_bAV lVeaYaSVeSYafKp KJFlVhTY[ZXU¬
(188) Yaal(Kg VeSY[g lK,iLT`V°WJVXgg Ze{UKhVXgZXQlVe6[K³6QHWJSY[ZXQHgh¡ . . . . w. .
(189) ACBlA. F G<HJIEK)LMH1LK)NOX&K O2`aO?W LMKQH%I OCG7H1LK_^ W<R. ª«AO ILZAi6KJ[giCAQlVeI=Y[WhVe gCgSKJILg ?ILKhVeQHgZe 2 /
(190)
(191) q*K$% 2
(192)
(193) 5 M 5jO ¡W.ª 0q§Y[gVeQ eV HgSUVXWJSY[ZXQ©ZeVeQZXUiCYaQlVeU5iCY-,(KJUKJQTSYVeK,TlVeSY[ZXQ|= ^ qCI^b(HglVeaa¤
(194) UYaSSKJQ¥YaQ¨SFHK³UZXI ZeV?gCgSKJI ZeXQ W,ZX6w6[K,i¤K, lVeSY[ZXQHg < =9} I
(195) FHKJUK d rsutututs =hVvlY[g¬SFHKfK,WJSZXU
(196) Ze4gSVeSKcVeUYVe6[K,gVeQHi Zd +rsututut hVvlSFHKwlVeUVeILKJSKJUfK,WJSZXUh¡EFHK ³6QHWJSY[ZXQHg d =ruututut g Mh v bc
(197) YaSF J6c 4i k m 4b \Z^ ^ Q7bfVeUKVXgg6ILK,i¢SZ(K
(198) W,ZXQ SYaQTHZXHgaLiC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVe6[K YaQHgY[i6K$V¢WJ[ZcgK,i¦UKJdcY[ZXQ $lk<ma YaQ¦
(199) F6Y[WF\SFH3K ^ 0q²Y[gi6K HQHK,i£b6SFHK q*_
(200) @T*+@ ¡ EFHK`UYadcF S ]_FlVeQHiµgY[i6KLZe =9} II`Vh K`W,ZXI=w ZcgK,i©Ze¶6QHWJSY[ZXQHg$SFlVeS$VeUKLYaQHW,ZXI=w6[KJSKJa©gw K,WJY lK,i£bYaQ¥SFHK gKJQHgK¢SFlVeSSFHKJ5VeUK=ZXQ6a5gw(K,WJY lK,iVXg KJ[ZXQ6dcYaQ6d\SZVW,KJUSVeYaQ ILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WJYaSRWJVXggh¡ P06Yaw(KJU<g Ba|c|J
(201) H7aY[gSg°V QT6I(KJULZeILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WJYaSRµWJVXggK,gh6¡ ! # Y[gSFHK?WJVXgg¢ZeILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WhVeaa©YaQHWJUKhVXgYaQ6d\³6QHWJSY[ZXQHghb{SFlVeS¢Y[ghb³ZXU KJfKJe U o ! # VeQHi JYaS¢FHZX[i6g¢SFlVe S @E+* @ o- / ZkfKJU=SFHK¦i6ZXe I`VeYaQ²ZepSFHK?³6QHWJSY[ZXQt¡«TYaI=YaVeUafb ! Y[gSFHKWJVXggZeILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WhVeaa\i6K,WJUKhVXgYaQ6d³6QHWJSY[ZXQHgh[¡ ! # VeQH6 i ! VeUKSFHK°WJVXggK,gpZe{ILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WhVeaa YaQHWJUKhVXgYaQ6dLVeQHii6K,WJUKhVXgYaQ6d¶6QHWJSY[ZXQHghbTUK,gw(K,WJSYafKJafbCgHWF?SFlVeSsZXUKJfKJULKJ[KJILKJQTS ¦KpFlV,fK /a7/6¡{EFHK ILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WJYaSWJVXggK,g
(202) WhVeQ¦(KpdfKJQHKJUVeaY 0hK,iSZ$I$6aSYaXVeUYVeSK°¶6QHWJSY[ZXQHgYaQ¦VeQZXTTY[ZXHgI`VeQ6QHKJUh¡7HZXU
(203) YaQHgSVeQHW,Kcb ! #%# Y[gSFHKWJVXgg¬Ze£³6QHWJSY[ZXQHg . 2^bAgHWF?SFlVeTS (1+*,( "- /¢VeQH' i (1+*,( '- /ZhfKJU¬SFHKi6ZXI`VeYaQ?Ze SFHK ³6QHWJSY[ZX"Q {¡ ZXUK0w6UK,WJY[gKJafbHV=ª 0q§W,ZXQHgY[gSg
(204) ZeV$gKJS¬Ze{W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ SgZXQSFHKgCgSKJI XVeUYVe6[K,gkb6gZe]RWhVea[K,Yi 2
(205) !+
(206) 5$ *K 5 ` ¡ ª 0q.Y[gVeHgSUVXWJSK,i¥³UZXI"VeQ ^ 0q HUgSi6K,W,ZXI=w(ZcgYaQ6d5SFHK?VeSSKJU$YaQTSZ V\gKJS¢ZelVXgY[W I`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVe K,TlVeSY[ZXQHghb6VeQHi?SFHKJQI`Vew6w6YaQ6dSFHK0K,TlVeSY[ZXQHgSZSFHK0W,ZXUUK,gw(ZXQHiCYaQ6d= lVeaYaSVeSYafKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg =¶SVe6[KU| I^¡EFHKgCgSKJI XVeUYVe6[K,ghbAi6KJQHZXSK,i 5 b{bTYaQHWJaHi6KSFHKgSVeSKcVeUYVe6[K,g VeQHiSFHKwlVeUVeILKJSKJUg
(207) bf66S Ve[gZVeQ ¦VeC¯AYaaYVeUcVeUYVe6[K,gYaQ SUZAiCHW,K,iSF6UZX6dcF\SFHKUK,iCHWJSY[ZXQ¤Ze{SFHK ^ 0q²SZ=lVXgY[WK,TlVeSY[ZXQHgh¡ . .
(208) . . . . . . . . . . .
(209) . . . . . . . . . . . . . !"$#&%&'(")'*%,+$-/.10$243'(5("$%&26'(3. 78"93:%;.-=<6")'*%,0$23. > ?!@ACBEDF*GIH. GJBEK:HCLMDNBOK:H. @PPQBODRF:GJF*STH. S4BEK:HULVGWBOK:HRXYDNBOK:H. ?!AI[\BODF*GJF*STH Z. S4BEK:HULVGWBOK:HIDRBOK:H. ?!`aBEDF*GIH. Z^]_. P\deP[\BODF*GfH. GJBEK:HCLbcDNBOK:H. hci _. Zml Z. l. r Zmlal. `f[R@ _. GJg BEK:HCLMDNBOK:H [\BODJH. DN g BEK:HULkj. BEDF:GfH. GJBEK:HCLknoBEDRBEK:H:HFnmp^q. BEDF:GfH. GJBEK:HCLknoBEDRBEK:H:HFnmp^q. l. l r S4BEK:HULtnoBEGJBEK:HF*DRBOK:H*HF!nmpmq. BEDF*GsF(S6H. lal. E4Ve6[K=|c®ªplVeaYaSVeSYafKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ SgVeQHi?SFHKplVXgY[WI`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVetK, lVeSY[ZXQHg
(210) Ze
(211) F6Y[WF¦SFHKJVeUKVeHgSUe VXWJSY[ZXeQHgh¡ pQlVe[ZXdfZXHgW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ SgZXU4g66SUVXWJSY[ZXQ = QI^beiCYaAY[gY[ZXQ =_*
(212) I^bXILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[WhVeaa$i6K,WJUKhVXgYaQ6d³6QHWJSY[ZXQHg =)! Mb ! I^b VeQHiZXSFHKJUI6aSYacVeUYVeSK°ILZXQHZXSZXQ6Y[W³6QHWJSY[ZXQH3g =)! e]e ?b ! # e 2b ! e # IFlV,fK K,KJQZXI=YaSSK,i£¡ ¬ZXQHgY[i6KJUSFHK ^ 0q.ILZTi6KJi6K,gWJUYa6YaQ6d5SFHKSVeQ6´¥gCgSKJI YaQ Hdc6UK5|c¡¤EFHK?iC-Y ,(KJUKJQTSYVeK, lVeSY[ZXQ
(213) ^=b ""! #%# bcWhVeQ K¬SUVeQHgVeSK,iYaQ SZSFHK¬lVXgY[WK,TlVeSY[ZXQH g PQ7b PQ >CbcVeQHi > . ?
(214) a^bX
(215) FHKJUK Q¦VeQHi >VeUK¬VeC¯CYaaYVeUcVeUYVe6[K,g4UKJw6UK,gKJQ SYaQ6dSFHKQHKJS alZh²VeQHi$SFHKZX6_S alZk²ZelSFHKsSVeQ6´(¡4EFHK¬W,ZXUUK,gw ZXQHiCYaQ6d TlVeaYaSVeSYafKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSg
(216) VeUK E Q ]^8b z Q > ^bAVeQHi #%#
(217) U >^N¡
(218) i6iCYaQ6d$SFHK lVeQTSYaSRLgwlVXW,K,g7³ZXU SFHKcVeUYVe6[K,ghb6¬K°ZX6SVeYaQSFHK$ª 0q gFHZh
(219) QYaQ Hdc6UK}C¡ EFHK 5$ *$/!# 8*K $5$ *K9!# SFHK,ZXUKJI Zesª«AO gSVeSK,gSFlVeSKhVXW`F ^ 0q²WhVeQ\ K°VeHgSUVXWJSK,iYaQ SZ`VLª 0qb gHWF\SFlVeSpVeQT¦gZXa6SY[ZX"Q b c6d gf h+i lk m n ZeSFH3K ^ 0q²Y[gW,ZXQHgY[gSKJQ Sp
(220) YaSFSFHK°W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSgpZeSFHK$ª 0q¡ EFHKgSUHWJS6UVeVeHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQ SFHK,ZXUKJIi6ZAK,g=QHZXSLYaI=w6aµSFlVeSLSFHK¤ª 0q Y[g`ZX6SVeYaQHK,i² ²VeHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQ ¶UZXI gZXILK$w6UKJAY[ZXHga ]_´AQHZh
(221) SQ ^ 0qb(VXgYaQ¤SFHKK^¯HVeI=w6[Kc¡ ZcgS0Ze7SFHKSYaILKcb gHWF VeYQ ^ 0q i6ZAK,gpQHZXS0K^¯CY[gSVeQHi SFHK¦ª 0q+FlVXgSZ¤ KiCYaUK,WJSa¥gw(K,WJY lK,i³UZXI SFHKV,cVeYaVe6[K lVeaYaSVeSYafK?YaQCZXUI`VeSY[ZXQt¡¤oZh¬KJfKJUhbZXUI`Veaa . . u. wv. . . w
(222) zC|h}c~.
(223) . . . j
(224)
(225) j b j j. F H F F H B F F H. P\deP[\B. j. @PPQB Zmlal hci _. `f[R@ _. [\B H. hci _. `f[R@ _. [\B. =V9I. H. =¶%I. 4Yadc6UK=}C®ª 0qVeHgSUVXWJSK,i¤¶UZXISFHK^ 0q ILZAi6KJ{i6K,gWJUYa6YaQ6dSFHKSVeQ6´\gCgSKJIZe Hdc6UK?|c® =V9IpTlVeQ SYaS gwlVXW,K,gpZe4SFHK0cVeUYVe6[K,gpVeQHiS=¶%I¬ lVeaYaSVeSYafK$W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sgh¡ gw(KhVe´AYaQ6dSF6Y[gª 0qµY[g
(226) VeQVeHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQZe4VeQ ^ 0qbCZXU¬ILZXUKw6UK,WJY[gKJafb6Ze{V$WJVXgg¬ZeW^ qsghbA
(227) F6Y[WF¦w6UZhAY[i6K,g SFHKlVXgY[gZe4SFHKW,ZXUUK,WJSQHK,ggw6UZXw(KJUSY[K,gZe{SFHKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQ5VeadfZXUYaSF6I =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ¨}C¡ 9z I^¡ . ACB. '^W<RULM`H%KQW. LR^W C G7H%IQK_LMHLK_NOPNJHJIEG7O?R. EFHKW,ZXI=w66SVeSY[ZXQ¦Ze lVeaYaSVeSYafKgSVeSK,gVeQHigSVeSKSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg¬Y[gi6KJSKJUI=YaQHK,i?T=SF6UK,KSTw(K,gZe W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg ZXQ? lVeaYaSVeSYafKpgSVeSK,gh®{gSVeSKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSXg =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ?}C¡ MC¡aU| I^bTSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sng =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ?}C¡ MC¡ 9} I^bCVeQHiLdc[ZXlVe W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSg =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ¤}C¡ MC¡ 9M I^¡ !"#%$ & hC ¸ ¼ ' ,he) ( ' h EFHK HUgS`STw(KZe°W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ S?w66SgLUK,gSUY[WJSY[ZXQHgZXQ SFHK\TlVeaYaSVeSYafKcVeaHK,g`ZeXVeUYVe6[K,gYaQ V¥ lVeaYaSVeSYafK gSVeSK XW&JQLZXhU XW J KJ # r ^¡.EFHK,gK5VeUK\SFHK5TlVeaYaSVeSYafK¨W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ SgI`Ve´AYaQ6d6w Vµª qbVe[gZ©WhVea[K,i 5q
(228) j!t5$ *K 5 ¡ 0YafKJQ¦VeQYaQHW,ZXI=w6[KJSKJagw(K,WJY lK,i?TlVeaYaSVeSYafKgSVeSKcb6W,ZXQHgY[gSYaQ6d¢Ze4 lVeaYaSVeSYafK0cVeaHK,g¬³ZXU ZXQ6agZXILK?XVeUYVe6[K,ghbsSFHKgSVeSK¦W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg`iCY[WJSVeSK
(229) F6Y[WF VeaSKJUQlVeSYafKW,ZXI=w6[KJSY[ZXQHg`VeUK?w(ZcggYa6[Kc¡©qsVXWF TlVeaYaSVeSYafKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ S=YaQSVe6[K5|W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQHgSFHK? lVeaYaSVeSYafK?I`VedcQ6YaSHi6KVeQHiiCYaUK,WJSY[ZXQ²ZeSFHK?XVeUYVe6[K,g YaQTfZXafK,i£¡sEF6Y[g
(230) Yaa( KYaaaHgSUVeSK,i(KJ[Zh ZXU¬SRZ`K^¯6VeI=w6[K,ghb6VXgg6I=YaQ6d=SFlVeS¬SFHKcVeUYVe6[K,g
(231) SVe´fKSFHKJYaU
(232) XVeaHK ³UZXI1SFHK7gYadcQ lVeQTSYaSRgwlVXW,K7iCY[gWJHggK,i$Ve ZkfKc¡EFHKsXVeaY[iCYaS0Ze6SFHKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg4WhVeQ(KKhVXgYaai6KJILZXQHgSUVeSK,i T?UK^KJUUYaQ6dLSZ=SFHK0I`VeSFHKJI`VeSY[WhVe{K,TlVeSY[ZXQHg
(233) ³UZXI
(234) F6Y[WF\SFHKJ?FlV,fK° K,KJQ¤VeHgSUVXWJSK,i£¡ ¬ZXQHgY[i6KJU?SFHK¤ lVeaYaSVeSYafK5W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTS z 1 =^¡+EF6Y[gW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTS¦i6KJSKJUI=YaQHK,g
(235) F6Y[WF lVeaYaSVeSYafK cVeaHK,ag +* "!$#&%,*'^b .-a !f#&%/-$'^btVeQHi : .0, !$#%,0 'ZesSFHK¢XVeUYVe6[K,g b (btVeQHi VeUK¢w KJUI=YaSSK,i£¡ gg6I=YaQ6d SFlVeS=SFHKI`VedcQ6YaSHi6K,gZe b bVeQHi ¥VeUK HQ6YaSKcbsSFHK W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ SLY[g=i6K HQHK,i§YaQ§SVe6[K}C¡ EFHK?i6K HQ6YaSY[ZXQZe -YaI=w6aY[K,ghb4ZXU°YaQHgSVeQHW,Kcb{SFlVeSY±G 21 ,3 * h / y d #&243f'VeQHi 41$ ,3 - / 576 !4'^b4SFHKJQ QHK,W,K,gg VeUYaa 21 ,3%0B h / y.d #243f'^¡ . . . 1. w o. . . V. . . . 5 6 B. 6 8 5 9sb>kF*j?; j. 9 jfF=;. 5 6 7 94b:kF*j<; j 94b:k F*j<;@9b:VF(j<; 94b:k F*j<; j A 9 jfF C;. 9 jfF=; A 9 jfF=; 9 jfF=;. 5ED4FG B. 5ED4FG 7 DIHKJ L MND F O+J A ID HKJ DPH J ID HKJ L MND FO+J A FOQJ FO+J. 5D2FG 8 DIH J L=MND FO+J. E4Ve6[K?}C® 0K HQ6YaSY[ZXQµZe¬SFHK6z-W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSh¡T-THK,gSY[ZXQI`VeU´5ILKhVeQHg°SFlVeS$SFHKLTlVeaYaSVeSYafKLI`VedcQ6YaSHi6K =³iCYaUK,WJSY[ZXQ%IZe WhVeQ¦ KVeQT?Ze h y /2d±b2/6bHZXUTh / y.dw=!893 b 576 !£b6ZXUF#&243ZI^¡ EFHK` lVeaYaSVeSYafKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ S S R ]YaI=w6aY[K,i J 4 ! # b£Y[gi6K HQHK,i¥VXag !f#&%,* "!$#&%,- ¡ EFHKJUK¢VeUK°QHZW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg0ZXQ\SFHK$ lVeaYaSVeSYafK$I`VedcQ6YaSHi6K,ghb(gYaQHW,KSFHK$w(ZXYaQ SVeSp
(236) F6Y[WPF WJUZcggK,gSFHK l]V¯AY[g Y[g
(237) QHZXS´TQHZk
(238) Qt¡7O_7 ¤KJUKVeQKJ[KJILKJQ SpZe7 ! # bHSFHKJQ¦K°¬ZX6[i\VXi6iCYaSY[ZXQlVeaa¦FlV,fK * B : - ¡ . . . . . . w. w. .
(239) \ZXSY[W,KSFlVeS0SFHKHgKZeTlVeaYaSVeSYafKYaQC³ZXUI`VeSY[ZXQ I`Vh\[KhVXi¤SZVeI$6Yadc6YaSY[K,gh ¡ YafKJQ5SFlVeXS z 1 =^b eV QHi : Q*'zh% y /2d±bc .- zh / y d±btSFHK=TlVeaYaSVeSYafK¢I`VedcQ6YaSHi6K`Ze ¦WhVeQ SVe´fKLVeQT¨gYadcQt¡$EFHKb W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSi6ZAK,g£QHZXStU6[K7ZX6S4VeQ ZeASFHK,gK7VeaSKJUQlVeSYafK,ghbXgYaQHW,KsVea ZeCSFHKJI+VeUKW,ZXQHgY[gSKJQTS
(240) YaSF°SFHKs lVeaYaSVeSYafK YaQCZXUI`VeSY[ZXQt¡36UYaQ6d\gSVeSK=W,ZXI=w6[KJSY[ZXQSFHK=ZAW,WJ6UUKJQHW,K`Ze
(241) VeI6Yadc6YaSY[K,gWhVeHgK,gSFHK=gYaI$6VeSY[ZXQ©VeadfZXUYaSF6I SZ=w6UZAiCHW,K°gKJfKJUVe lVeaYaSVeSYafK°gSVeSK,gW,ZXQHgY[gSKJQTS
(242) YaSFSFHKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSg =³gK,WJSY[ZXQ¤}C¡ I^¡ EFHK?cVeUYVe6[K,gYaQ©SFHK?gCgSKJI I`Vh¥FlV,fKZXSFHKJU¢ lVeQTSYaSRgwlVXW,K,gSFlVeQ©SFHK?gYadcQµ lVeQTSYaSR©gwlVXW,Kc¡¤EFHK Ve(ZhfK W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSgUKJI`VeYaQ XVeaY[i YaQ SFHK¨dfKJQHKJUVe0WhVXgKcb66S¦WhVeQ K¤UK HQHK,i Y± !+*$*K$5 / 78@ Z
(243) L[5 VeUK SVe´fKJQ5YaQ SZVXW,W,ZX6Q Sh¡ ¬ZXUUK,gw(ZXQHiCYaQ6dXVeaHK,gVeUKS6w6[K,gZeVeQHiCI`VeU´XVeaHK,gpZXU
(244) F6Y[WF V`W,KJUSVeYaQ K, lVeSY[ZXQ Y[gLg VeSY[g lK,i£¡ -lZXU=YaQHgSVeQHW,Kcbs[KJS * b - bVeQHi 0 (KVeQHiCI`VeU´XVeaHK,g¢ZXU b b¬VeQHi Hb7UK,gw(K,WJSYafKJafb¬gHWF SFlVeS zy / * y Tb zy / - y b{VeQHxi zy / 0 y ¡\«T6w6w(ZcgKSFlVeMS * - 0 '0Y[g V¨W,ZXUUK,gw(ZXQHiCYaQ6d XVeaHK?SUYaw6[KZXU$SFHRK W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSh¡ YafKJQµSFlVe;S * zh * y.d{VeQHi - - b SFHKJQ5KWhVeQ¨YaI=ILK,iCYVeSKJa\YaQCKJUpSFlVe:S Q0 zh 0 y.d±¡pOQ¤ZXUi6KJUSZ`³ZXUI`VeaY 0hK$SFHK$gSVeSK$W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSg0YaQ5VeQ Vew6w6UZXw6UYVeSKVeQHi¦dfKJQHKJUVe V,fb P06Yaw(KJUg Ba|c|J
(245) HtHgK,g
(246) SFHK°gYadcQC]_UKhVeVeadfKJ6UVLZe YaaaYVeILg B }ccZ HR¡ e ' P (;P ( ¼ ' ¼ ' hh) ( ' h !"# ²TlVeaYaSVeSYafK(KJFlV,AY[ZXU7W,ZXQHgY[gSg{Ze VgK,THKJQHW,K¬Ze lVeaYaSVeSYafKgSVeSK,ghbfVeaSKJUQlVeSYaQ6d KJSK,KJQLgSVeSK,g{W,ZXYaQHWJY[iCYaQ6d
(247) YaSF1V¥SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTS\VeQHi gSVeSK,g?VXgSYaQ6d§ZhfKJU\V¥SYaILK^]_YaQ SKJUcVe_¡ EFHK5gK,W,ZXQHi STw(K5Ze$W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ S¦YaI=w(ZcgK,g UK,gSUY[WJSY[ZXQHgZXQSFHK *K5$ 5 ³UZXI.VwlVeUSY[WJ6VeU{SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTS7gSVeSFK XWTKJ_£SZgHW,W,K,ggZXU SYaILK^]_YaQ SKJUcVeHgSVeSK,g XWTKJ KJ r grsutututs XWTKJ J rg kbCZXU³UZXIVSYaILK^]_YaQTSKJUXVetgSVeSM K XWTKJ J # rsSZ¢gHW,W,K,ggZXU¬SYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ SgSVeSK,g # # XWTKJ r gruututut XWTKJ r k¡{EFHK,gK0gZe]RWhVea[K,i *K5[. !+L5$ *K7% 5 VeUKplVXgK,iZXQ?SFHK0W,ZXQ SYaQ 6YaSw6UZXw(KJUSY[K,g Ze{SFHK# cVeUYVe6[K,gpVeQHi¦#SFHKJYaUi6KJUYacVeSYafK,gh¡HZXUW,ZXQ SYaQTHZXHgaiC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVe6[K¶6QHWJSY[ZXQHgSFHKYaQ SKJUILK,iCYVeSK$XVeaHK VeQHiILKhVeQ`cVeaHKSFHK,ZXUKJILg³UZXI iC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVe(WhVe[WJ6aHQg BaU| FXZ H£Vea[Zh ZXQ6a`V0KJ w(ZcggYa6[K
(248) SUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHgs³UZXIxZXQHK TlVeaYaSVeSYafKXVeaHKSZ¢VeQHZXSFHKJUh¡7HZXU¬YaQHgSVeQHW,KcbASFHKTlVeaYaSVeSYafKI`VedcQ6YaSHi6K0Ze4V°cVeUYVe6[KWhVeQ6QHZXSWFlVeQ6dfK¶UZXI w(ZcgYaSYafK
(249) SZ0QHKJd VeSYafK
(250) YaSFHZX6S7wlVXggYaQ6d°SF6UZX6dcF /6¡4EFHKSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQ`W,ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSgsU6[KZX6S7WhVeQHiCY[iHVeSKpgHW,W,K,ggZXU gSVeSK,g
(251) FHZcgKcVeUYVe6[K,gFlV,fK lVeaYaSVeSYafKXVeaHK,g
(252) SFlVeSVeUKQHZXSW,ZXQHgY[gSKJQTS
(253) YaSFSFHK,gK0UK,gSUY[WJSY[ZXQHgh¡ E Z¢´AYaQHi6gZetSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQ¦VeUKiCY[gSYaQ6dc6Y[gFHK,iYaQª«AO ® SUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHgs³UZXIVSYaILK^]_w(ZXYaQ SSZVSYaILK^]_YaQ SKJUcVe = /
(254) 7 *_
(255) 5[.
(256) 5 ZXU } *K5$ 5 I¬VeQHiSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg³UZXI VSYaILK^]_YaQTSKJUXVeSZLV$SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQT3 S = 7% j$*[ E *K 5$ 5 ZXU } *K5[. 5 I^¡4EVe6[KM0g6I=I`VeUY 0hK,gSFHK
(257) w ZcggYa6[K
(258) gHW,W,K,ggZXUUKJVeSY[ZXQHg7¶UZXI ZXQHK lVeaYaSVeSYafKXVeaHK SZ¢SFHK0QHK^¯CS³ZXUV¢W,ZXQTSYaQ HZXHgaiC-Y ,£KJUKJQ SYVe6[K°¶6QHWJSY[ZX@Q q c d ?gfghJi kmHbT
(259) FHKJUK + e%r + + # r VeUK0SF6UK,K VXienVXW,KJQ SpVeQHiCI`VeU´AgYaQ¦SFHK° lVeQTSYaSRgwlVXW,KZeC q ¡ 1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. /
(260) 0*1 1.
(261) . BsF:KH. #$&%. F. #$&%. F. #$&%. F. #$&%. F. #$ %. F. 9$%. #. L=MND(' L=MN(D ' L=MN(D ' FOQJ ' DIH J ' F. #. 9$%. $ % $ %. #. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. 9$%. F. 9$% # #. 9$%. l" l" l" l" l". !BsF:K*F:K #)$&%. 9 $&%. #. F. $&%. 9 $&%,+ #. 9 $&% #. 9$% #. ". F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. 9$% #. 9$% #. 9$% # #. 9$%. F. l" $&%. " $&%. F. 9 $ %,+ #. ; F FO+J' ; F DPH J ' ; F L=M%(D ' ; F L=M%(D ' ; F L=M%(D '. L=MND*'. F. F. l" $ %. l" l" l" l" l". l". H. BsF:K*F:K. ! #$&%. ; F F O+J' ; F PD H J' ; F FO+J' ; F DPH J ' ; F FO+J ' ; F DPH J ' ; F L MN*D ' ; F FO+J ' ; F DPH J '. 9 $&%. #. L=M%D('. F F. #. 9 $&%. $&%. F. $&%. F. $&%. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. F. $ %. 9 $&% #. 9$% #. 9$% #. 9$% #. 9$% #. 9$% # #. 9$%. l". H. BsF:K. l1" l1" l1" l1" l1" l1" l1" l1" l1". l". H. L=MND*' F L=MND*' #$&% F J' l" FOQ # 9 $&% F $&% ; F FO+J' l" # 9 $ % F $ % ; F L=M%*D ' l" #$ % F L=MN*D ' #$ % F DIH J ' # 9 $ % F $ % ; F DPH J ' l" # 9 $ % F $ % ; F L=M%*D ' l" # 9 $ % F $ % ; F L=M%*D ' l". ;&F FO+J' ;&F FO+J ' ;&F FO+J ' ;&F FO+J ' ;&F DPH J ' ;&F DPH J ' ;&F DPH J ' ;&F DPH J ' ;&F L=M%D '. #$&% #$&%. F. l". 4E Ve6[KMC® ¬ZXQHgSUVeYaQTSgZXQSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHgt³UZXI+V
(262) TlVeaYaSVeSYafKsgSVeSKSZgHW,W,K,ggZXUt lVeaYaSVeSYafKgSVeSK,gh¡4m{]_SUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg VeUKSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg$¶UZXI V\SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTSSZ5V¦SYaILK^]_YaQTSKJUXVe_bs
(263) F6Ya[KOR]_SUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg=VeUKSUVeQHgYaSY[ZXQHg$¶UZXI V¦SYaILK^] YaQTSKJUXVeSZLV¢SYaILK^]_w ZXYaQTSh¡ . 24365/798;:< T(5R. . . <.748/=?>A@B8,C>A5. HGNSGNM<<9`AaBb c de. w
(264) zC|h}c~. . 5/DECFG<IHG<.J. . >KC>A5. . 5 DEL5/7M7<NMO(5. HG>. :QP 8 =AR6<NSUT68 NM<BHV5. . CFG<RGNM<5/DW>. . C<.7P 8 =ANYXZ>ACF[=?8. . HG\]8,7^_P 8 =AR6<.
(265) ¼ 4 ¼ ' ,he) ( ' h EFHK$ lVeaYaSVeSYafKW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ Sg0iCY[gWJHggK,igZLVeUpVeUK[ZTWhVe_blYaQ\SFHK°gKJQHgK°SFlVeSpSFHKJ?w(KJUSVeYaQ\SZ?VLgYaQ6dc[K$ lVeaY±] SVeSYafK=gSVeSK¢ZXU0SZ¦VwlVeYaU0ZegHW,W,K,ggYafK¢TlVeaYaSVeSYafK=gSVeSK,gh¡EFHK¢[ZAWhVeaYaSR¨ZeSFHK=VeQlVeaAgY[gpI`Vh¤[KhVXiª«AO SZ dfKJQHKJUVeSK¤ lVeaYaSVeSYafK¤gSVeSK,gL
(266) F6Y[WF VeUK¦QHZXS`XVeaY[i§YaQ§SFHK\aYadcF S`ZeSFHKgK, HKJQHW,KZeTlVeaYaSVeSYafK\gSVeSK,g w6UK,W,K,iCYaQ6dYaSh¡{ORQ`ZXUi6KJUSZ HaSKJU¬ZX6SsSFHK,gKTlVeaYaSVeSYafKgSVeSK,ghbTVSF6YaUiLSRAw(KZetW,ZXQHgSUVeYaQ S¬WhVeQ`(KZXUI6VeSK,i
(267) F6Y[WFw66SgUK,gSUY[WJSY[ZXQHg$ZXQgK, HKJQHW,K,gZe¬TlVeaYaSVeSYafKLgSVeSK,gh¡¢OQ5gK,WJSY[ZXQ©MC¡a|cbtgHWF @-HKC!t5$ *K 5
(268) Yaa (KiCY[gWJHggK,iYaQ¦ILZXUK°i6KJSVeYa_¡ !"# ". . . . qualitative simulation. Qualitative behavior. Qualitative differential equation (QDE). abstraction. abstraction analytical solution or. Ordinary differential equation (ODE). numerical simulation.
(269) . 4Yadc6UKMC®NpHgSUVXWJSY[ZXQUKJVeSY[ZXQHgYaQ\ lVeaYaSVeSYafKgYaI6VeSY[ZXQt¡. ACB. F G<HJIEK)LMH1LK)NOR,K
Documents relatifs
If the temperature of the collapse increases due to an increase in the specific heat ratio (for example by lower initial concentrations of the chlorinated compound) the ratio
If a reproducible evolution of the refraction index with temperature and degree of conversion could be available, an absolute value of the degree of conversion would be
À partir du moment où la montagne Pelée se réveille, temps au bout duquel une grande éruption peut se reproduire (d’après la population interrogée
Contanto, é importante ressaltar que as cultivares ‘Salustiana’, ‘Pera’ IAC, ‘Pera’ “Jetibá”, são mais propícias para suco, podendo a ‘Salustiana’
Ainda segundo os autores, outro ponto importante a ser levado em consideração no combate à disseminação seria o rastreamento, por parte dos órgãos competentes, a partir
En vertu du principe frégéen de compositionnalité qui règle dans les linguistiques formelles les rapports entre syntaxe et sémantique, la composition syntaxique est
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
Les acteurs sont d’une part les entreprises, animées par tout type de structures porteuses ayant une légitimité à fédérer les acteurs économiques autour de projets communs