A Revised Presentation of the CENA Method
32
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. A Revised Presentation of the CENA Method Philippe LANGLOIS. No 4025 Octobre 2000. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4029--FR. ` THEME 2. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7) "!$#% &'( )+*-,/.0,/1-13254
(8) 687 9:4<;8=?>A@ BCEDGFIHJKMLONGPEQRH+SUTWVXQUY?QRHGS H?Z<Y?[\S]Y ^_Sa`cbdFefTWSUQ]gX^_H hjikT\lmH?ZonoikN?P_[WQRikH po[WqEqfTWirZ
(9) sEH+irHtYuCEH?iuYuCEHvPwWxXyXJXz:K|{OY}ZkTWeEikH+J\yWyXy+KMJW~Iq_[\VXHG` G? EWW BCEH(3nFH ZkCETs+Q]`[
(10) PEHG[\^ZkTWF[ZkQUY-FH ZkCETsZrTY TWikikHGY}ZZkCEH_iu`cZcTWiusH?iH?fHtY}Z TW TX[ZkQRP_V+qTXQRPZikTW^_P_sQUPEV+H?ikirTXik`jTWPZrC_HoirHt`c^_SZ(T\a[+Pd^EFH?ikQUYG[\S_[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF8n$_iu`mZ3q_irHt`cHGPXZu[ZkQRTXPITW ZkCEQ]`aFH ZkCETs+QU`qEikTWqfTX`rHGsOQRPZrCEHqEirHG dQRTX^_`ikH?qfTWirZpop¢¡W~XJW~£¤sHtY H?FeHGi¥t¦W¦X¦X§}aBC_H3Y ^EikikH?PZikH?qfTWirZ Y?TWFqESUH ZkHG`[\P_s¨ikH?qES][WY?HG`<ZrCEHqEikH? dQUTW^_`OTWP_HW©ªHC_[\ik«8e_[WYu«8ZkT ZrCEHqEikHG`rH?PZk[\ZrQUTWP¬TW3ZkCEH3<n FH?ZrCETs¨H CEQUeEQZkQRP_V P_H?"QUFqTXicZu[\PZ+[W`rqHtY}Zk`GI©¨HQUSRSU^_`cZriu[ZrHZrC_HIq_irT`m¢[\P_sY?TWP_`<T\3ZkCEHFH ZrC_Tds `rTWSU dQRP_V¬ZrikQ][\PEVX^ESU[WiSUQRP_HG[\i`rbd`cZrHGF`?BCEHt`cH8`cb`cZrHGF`I[\ikH®sEHG`rQRVXPEHGs¯ZkT¨VXH?PEHGik[\ZrH[ª`rQRVXPEQfY?[\PZkSRb QUP_[XY?Y ^_ik[\ZrHY?TWFqE^ZkHGsª`cTXSR^ZkQRTXPa©¨HIqEikTWqfTX`rH[PEH?"[WP_[\SUb`cQ]`T\ZrC_H[WP_[\SUTWVXb [WP_s¬sQ]`kY ikH?q_[WP_Y b efH Zm(H?HGPZkCEH+SUQRPEHt[\ioY?TWikirHtY}ZrQUTWP [\P_s Y TXFqE^ZrQUPEV
(11) QRZrC8H dZkH?PZrHtsqEikHGY?QU`rQUTWPa °5±²´³kµ¶ ·W n<^ZrTXF[ZrQ]Y(H?ikirTXi[WP_[\SUb`cQ]`G¸irTX^EP_sQUPEVOH?ikirTXiG¸ T[ZkQRPEVOqfTWQUPXZj[WirQRZrCEFH?ZrQ]Y\¸X[XY?Y?^Eik[XY bX¸ `cZk[WeEQUSRQRZmbW ¹]º»r¼½G¾»
(12) ¿ÀU¼Á/ à ãÝ+ÔÍÆuÌÄÔÍä ÑÐmÅEËÍǤÎ/ÆuÐmÌÎ0ǤÈßÈ0ÈoâÐmÇ3ÉuÉuÊ-ÊæUÜÈ0àËÍÔtÆÌÏé}ÎoÕìÚaÆuǤÔÍåcÐcÓ\ÖtÎ0ÐcÔÍèÆuÌÏÓtÇ0É}ÑÖÍÔ ËÇ0ÌÏæRÔtÒaçéÇ/ÆuÆuÎoËÍÔÍÌÏÓÍÑmÎ ÐrÉ}íèÔÍîÐOÆuÚjÔtÒî ÓIíËÍî ÒaÌÏïÕÏÐ<ÆuîtÎjë\È/ËtÐmätǤÐ+ÌÏÌÏÎ0ÉGÌ ÆuÈ/ÓÖtÌÏÔÍî È0é<ËÍÉ}È/Ç
(13) ËtÐÒaÆuê ÎoÐcëÍÆÆuǤ×
(14) È0×
(15) Ðm×(ÐmÔ?Ø\ÈÐmÇ(ÉuÊ ÉuÊÝ+È/ÆkËÍÈ/ÐOËÍÐmÙÛ×oÚ ÜÆkÈ0ÝÌÏÑmÙßÎ(ÞáÆkÈ3àdÈ/ÆuËtØWÐ É}Ç0ã ÆkÈ0ÔÍÉ}Ì Ç¤ä â ÐmǤÎ/ÆkÌ È
(16) ÈßâÈ/ËtÉuÐ Ê. Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France) T´el´ephone : 04 76 61 52 00 - International: +33 4 76 61 52 00 T´el´ecopie : 04 76 61 52 52 - International: +33 4 76 61 52 52.
(17) %# ®
(18)
(19) ? & ( ® "!$#.
(20) [5FN?ZrCETsH <n Ht`mZ^EPEH PETX^E WHGSRSUH FN ZkCETsH[W^ZrTXF[\ZrQ]g^EH sH®Y?TWikirHtY}ZkQRTXPªsH S H ´H Zs TXiksEirH^EPIsEHG` H?ikirHG^Eik`s [\ikirTXP_sQXQRPZrikTs^EQRZrHt` q[\iS [\ikQZkCEFN ZkQUg^EH T\ZrZk[WPXZkHWoPEHqEikH?FQUD?ikH sEHG`kY ikQRqZkQRTXP+sH3S][FN ZrC_TdsEH3n¤[\QRZS TXelmH Z-s^+qEikNGY?NGsHGPXZ ik[WqEqTXicZp<p¡X~XJW~O£0sNGY?H?FeEirH<¥G¦W¦X¦X§ HqEikNG`rH?PZ+ik[WqEqTXicZY?TWFqESUD ZrHH?ZirHGFqESU[XY HSUHqEirNtY HtsH?PZG®oTW^`+irHG WHGPETWP_``r^EiS][ qEirNt`cHGPZk[ZkQRTXP sEHSU[ FIN?ZrCETsH3<n H?P5H?CEQRe[\PZY HGicZu[\QUP_`<[X`cqfHGY Zk`<QRFqfTWirZk[\PZu`-lm^_`kgX^_H S P_TWP¬sNtY ikQZu`?o<TW^_` QUSUSR^_`cZrikTWP`<SUHG`[Í [\PZk[WVWHt`
(21) H Z+SUHG`OSRQUFQZkHG`sHISU[®FN ZkCETsHq[\iOSU[®irNt`cTXSR^EZrQUTWP:sH`rbd`cZrDGFHG`SRQUPENG[WQRikHG` ZkirQ][\P_VW^ES][\QUirHt`?HG`
(22) `rb`mZkD?FHG`
(23) `rTWPZo`cqfNGY?QU[WSRHGFH?PZsEN _PEQ]`
(24) qfTW^Eiog^EHSUHG`
(25) `rTWSU^ZrQUTWP`(YG[\S]Y ^ESUN?Ht`
(26) `cTXQRHGPZ `rQUVWPEQRY?[\ZrQU WHGFIHGPZQRFqEikNGY?QU`rHG`G oTX^_`q_irTXqT`cTXP_` ^EP_H¨PETX^E WHGSRSUH¨[WP_[\SUb`cH¨sHG`8[\P[\SUTWVWQUHG` H Z5sHG` sEQ´N?ikH?P_Y?HG`HGPXZkirH+Y?TWikirHtY}ZrQUTWP®SRQUPENt[\QUirHH ZoYG[\S]Y ^ESaHGP®q_irNtY Q]`cQUTWP N ZkH?P_s^_HW "¶ t ³ n<P_[\SUb`cH+s H?ikikH?^Ei
(27) [\^EZrTWF[\ZrQ]gX^_HW¸dH?ikirHG^Ei
(28) s [\ikirTXP_sQ/¸d[WirQRZrC_FIN?ZrQ]g^EH T\ZrZk[WPXZkHW¸qEikNGY?Q `rQUTWPa¸E`cZk[WeEQRSUQRZrNW.
(29)
(30) !"$#&%(')+*,- .. ¡. / - 1 03 . BC_H irTX^EP_sQUPEV5HGirikTWiu`QRPZkirTs^_Y?HGs¯edb TX[\ZrQUPEV5qTXQRPZ[WirQRZrC_FIH?ZrQ]Y Y TXPZrikQReE^EZrHZkT5ZrCEH®QRP[WY?Y?^Eiu[WY b WT jY TWFqE^EZrHGs8ikHG`r^ESRZk`[\P_s ZkTZrCEHQRP_`cZk[WeEQUSRQRZmb®TWj`cTXFIH+Pd^EFHGirQ]Y?[WS [\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`G2¢P8ZrCEQ]`oq_[WqHGiG¸H ÛTY?^_`TWPIZkCEH
(31) qEikTWq_[WVX[ZkQRTXPTWZkCEHG`rH
(32) irTX^EP_sQUPEV+HGirikTWiu`?-{<ZrCEHGij`cTX^EikY?HG`-TWfHGirikTWi`r^_YuC[W`jsE[\Zk[OH?ikikTWiu` [WP_sZkir^_P_Y?[\ZrQUTWP H?ikirTXik`[\ikHPETWZoY TWP`cQ]sH?ikHGs CEH?ikHWnsH Zu[\QUSRHts®[WP_[\SUb`cQ]`T\ ikTW^_P_sQUPEVHGirikTWiu`QRP®ZrCEH QUFqESUH?FH?PZk[\ZrQUTWP_`TW(S][\ikVWH[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`OQ]`Y TXFqESRH?¨[\Ps:ZkHGsQUTW^`?$ 3dT5[W^ZrTXF[\ZrQ]Y[\qEqEikTX[XYuCEHG`<K ZkC_[ZO^_`rH+ZrCEHIY TXFIq_^ZrHGi
(33) K|C_[Í WH+efH?HGP:sH? XH?SUTWqfHGs ZkT®Y TXFqESRHGFH?PZoZrC_HY S][W`k`rQUYF[\Pd^_[WS [WP_[\SUb`cQ]`? 4QRfHGirHGPXZkQU[WSFH ZrC_Tds_`o[\ikHHGSRSR/«dPET
(34) P®H E[\FqESUHG`TW`r^_YuC8[\^ZkTWF[ZkQUYOFH ZkCETsE`? 4Q´H?ikH?PZkQU[WS<FH ZkCETsE` ikH?SUb TXP ZrCEHªY TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXP T\ZrCEH:q_[\irZrQ][\S<sEH?ikQR [ZkQR XHG`TWZrCEH¬VXSRTXe_[\S ÛTXirC< [\iusHGirikTWiI
(35) QZkC irHt`cqfHGY ZIZkTªZrCEH5HGSRHGFIHGPZk[\ikbikTW^EP_sEQRPEVªH?ikikTWiu`? BC_H 657896:;<= >?A<@5D <F-E
(36) BA 5 Q]`ZrC_H5H?ikirTXiQUPZrikTdsE^_Y Hts edbHt[WYuC TX[\ZrQUPEV¯qTXQRPZ[WirQRZrCEFH?ZrQ]Y8TWqfH?iu[ZrQUTWP¸[\PsZkCEH 6<GHC JI;C>?K -BA6LMC< Q]`<ZkCEH[WYGY ^EF^ESU[\ZrHts¬H ´HGY Z+T\jZkCEHG`rHH?SUH?FH?PZk[Wirb8ikTW^EPsQRP_V®HGirikTWiu`oTXP ZkCEH_P_[WSirHt`c^_SZt N_TWiH E[\FqESUHW¸´SUH Z^_`Y TXP_`cQ]sHGi<ZkCEH TX[\ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPZOHG Í[WSR^[ZrQUTWP P O T\[irHt[\SÛ^EP_Y ZrQUTWP P [ZOZrCEH s_[ZkR[ QTSVU!WYXZ[[[YZ W:\:]
(37) CEHGirHQRPZrHGirFHtsQU[\ZrH Í[WirQ][\e_SRHt` W:O \F^_XZ[[[&Z W@O `a&XbZ[\ikH<Y?TWFqE^ZkHGsZkTbdQUH?S]s ZkCEH+ikHG`r^ESZ W@O `jBCEH+VXSRTXe_[\SfÛTXir[\ius HGirikTWi
(38) `k[ZrQ]`c_HG`
(39) C_H?ikH. WO `dc P UQe](Sgfih ckj hlZ. ` f h S m <\ ^_X pp q P O n U!Q,Z q ]lr q n Z no Q]`ZkCEH_iu`mZr/TXiksHGi
(40) [\qEqEikTÍQRFq [\ZrHOqT\ZrCEHVXSRTXe_q [\S´ikTW^EPsQRP_VH?ikirTXi(
(41) QRZrC8ikHG`rqHtY}Z
(42) ZkTZrCEH[We_`cTXSR^EZrHH?SUH FHGPXZu[\ikbikTW^_P_sQUPEVH?ikikTWiu` SVU \<^_X Z[[[Z ` ]VWHGPEH?iu[ZkHGsedbIZrCEHOY TXFIq_^Zk[\ZrQUTWP TWY TWikikHG`rqTXP_sQUPEV QU5sP-@ZrHG
(43) irF7tuHGsEQU[\ZrvH Í[WCirQ][\e_SRHt`? BC_H®S][W`cZZkH?ikF j áh QRP ZrCEH ZkCEH8VWSUTWe_[WS3ÛTXir[\iusH?ikikTWiikH?S][ZkQRTXP Q]`IZrCEH [W`k`cTY?QU[\ZrHGs
(44) QZkCwf h BCEH:irHGSU[\ZrQU WH5H?SUH?FHGPXZu[\ikb ikTW^EPsQRP_VH?ikirTXik` q nFx"y WO n?y [\ikH5eTX^EP_sHts
(45) QZkC ZrCEH TX[\ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPXZ q_irHtY Q]`cQUTWPalzoHGP_Y HX¸sQ´H?ikH?PZkQU[WSFH ZkCETsE`[\ikHoVWHGPEH?iu[\SUSUb^_`rHGsZrTY TWFqE^EZrH[_iu`mZr/TXiksHGi3efTW^EPsÛTWi ZkCEHVWSUTWe_[WS´ÛTWik([Wiks H?ikirTXi)U{ ¥?x| ¸&U{ ¥G¡b| ¸&{ ~b| (oz T(H? WHGi(`r^_YuC8Y TXFIq_^ZrHts®efTW^_P_sE`F[Íb efHZkTdTIS][\ikVWHZrT efH ^_`rH Û^_S}{ ¡</| ~N QRiu`mZr/TXiksEH?i+`mZu[ZkQU`cZrQ]Y?[WSjHG`cZrQUF[ZrHt`+T\(ZrC_H VWSUTWe_[WS-ÛTWik([Wiks¨H?ikikTWi+[\ikH [\S]`cT5sHGirQU WHts ÛikTWF [I`mZu[ZkQU`cZrQ]Y?[WSFTsH?SUQUPEVTWZrCEHHGSRHGFIHGPZk[\ikbIirTX^EP_sQUPEVHGirikTWiu`}Ï{ J\y/| ¸KU{ ¥tJu| ¸YR{ ¥t¡b| ¸@{ ~| ( T\ZrCZrCEHt`cH efTW^_P_sQUPEV[\Ps `mZu[ZkQU`cZrQ]Y?[WS[\q_qEirT[WYuCEHt`-PEH?VXSRHtY}ZjZkCEHoZkH?ikF`jT\aTXiksEH?ijCEQUVWC_H?ijZkC_[\PTXPEHo
(46) QRZrC ikHG`rqfHGY}Z ZkT ZrCEHH?SUH?FHGPXZu[\ikb¬ikTW^EP_sEQRPEV H?ikikTWiu`<QUP:ZkCEHVWSUTWe[\SÛTWik([Wiks¬H?ikirTXiG¸ -u ¸ZkCEHSRQUPEHG[WirQDG [\ZrQUTWP¨H?ikirTXi j -h ¢2 P5qEiu[WY ZrQ]Y HX¸_[\^ZkTWF[ZkQUYTXi<[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_FIQ]YsQRfHGirHGPXZkQU[\ZrQUTWP ZrHtYuCEPEQ]g^EHG`<qEirT dQ]sH+[VWHGPEH?iu[\Sa[WqEqESUQ YG[\eEQUSUQZmb[WP_s [\P8H6 Y QUH?PZ
(47) QUFIq_SRHGFIHGPZk[ZkQRTXP8T\ZkCEHG`rHsQRfHGirHGPZrQ][\SFH ZkCETsE` { b/| ©ªH+qEikHG`rH?PZoCEH?ikH+[IPEH?sQRfHGirHGPXZkQU[WSaFH ZkCETs®
(48) C_H?ikHZkCEH+H?SUH?FHGPXZu[\ikb ikTW^EP_sEQRPEVHGirikTWiu` q [\ikH P_H?QRZrCEHGieTX^EP_sHtsPETWijsHt`rY?irQUefHGsebI[`mZkTdYuC[W`cZrQ]YFTsHGS0¸XeE^Z) 8@>?
(49) lzoH?PY HW¸XHoY?TWFqE^ZknHZrCEH. Ú Ú Ô6.
(50) x. (?-5 F '. . ik`cZcTWiusH?iZkH?ikF T\ZrC_HVWSUTWe[\SaÛTXir[\ius H?ikirTXi
(51)
(52) QZkC:ikHG`rqHtY}ZoZkT ZkCEHHGSRHGFIHGPZk[\ikbikTW^_P_sQUPEV H?ikikTWiu` f O h S P U;f h ]?©¨HPET\ZkH P U f h ](ZkCEH TX[ZkQRP_VqTXQRPZY?TWFqE^Zu[ZrQUTWP5TWHf h `cQUPEVZkCEQU`<ZrHGirF [W` [Y?TWikirHtY}ZrQUPEV¤[WY ZrTWi(ZkTZrCEHY?TWFqE^ZkHGs irHt`c^_SZ W:O `¸E(H+sH?ikQR XHOZrCEH$ C6
(53) >?5s. W:` S P U W:O ` c f O h ][ 3d^YuCª[SRQUPEHG[Wi+Y TWikikHGY}ZkQRTXP5QU`q[\irZrQ]Y ^ES][\ikSRb8`r^EQZu[\eESUHI
(54) CEH?P¨ZrCEHIVWSUTWe[\S ÛTWik([Wiks5HGirikTWiQU`sTXFQ P[ZrHtsedbIZrCEH_iu`mZr/TXiksHGiZrHGirF`G¸WÛTXiH?E[\FqESUH<QUP ZrC_H 5 -K< 5 AB-! 8 (H<sH PEHQUP~3HGY}ZkQRTXP¡E ¡E. 3 WH?P8QR-Y?TWFqESUH ®[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF`
(55) [\ikHPET\ZoSUQRP_HG[\it¸dZrC_H[WY?Y?^Eiu[WY bTW-Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs8`rTWSU^ZrQUTWP_`F[Íb ikH?SUb TXP SUQUPEHG[WiOq[\irZk`T\ZrCEH[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF8IBCd^_`G¸a(HIYG[\P¯[\qEqESUb5ZkCEQU`+Y?TWikirHtY}ZkQRTXP¬ZrT _P[\SikHG`r^ESZu`OTWi`rH?P_`rQ ZkQR XHQRPZkH?ikFIHtsQ][ZrH [\ikQ][\eESUHG`OZkT5QRFqEikT WHZrCEH®[WY?Y?^Eiu[WY b5TWZkCEHikHG`r^ESZu`[\Ps:ZkCEH `cZk[\e_QRSUQZmb¨T\(ZrCEH [WSRVXTWikQZkCEF8 BCEQ]`<Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs SUQRPEHt[\i<Y?TWikirHtY}ZkQRTXPZkH?ikF[\S]`rT`r^´H?iu`ÛikTWF[IZkir^_P_Y?[\ZrQUTWP8H?ikirTXio[\P_s ikTW^EPsQRP_V HGirikTWiu`G BCEHirHGF[WQRP_QRPEVsQ´H?ikH?PY H<efH Zm(H?HGP ZkCEHY?TWikirHtY}ZrHtsirHt`c^_SZ W:`[\P_sZrCEHOH E[WY Z3ikHG`r^ESZ P U!Qe] Q]`(FHG[W`r^EikHGsedb [ C6
(56) <>5_C< ( NETWi(SUQRPEHt[\i
(57) [\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`G¸HY TXFIq_^ZrH[\P [\e_`rTWSU^ZrHOefTW^EP_ s
(58) TWZrCEQ]`irHt`cQ]s^_[WS_H?ikikTWijZkC_[Z(qEikT Q]sHt`j[Y?TWPsEH?P_Y?HoZrC_irHt`cCETXSUs[X`r`rTY Q][ZkHGsIZrTZrCEHY TXirikHGY ZrHtsikHG`r^ESRZG ©ªH+C_[Í XH y W@` c P U!Qe] y
(59) [ ©ªHP_[WFHZrCEQ]`I[\qEqEikTX[XYuCªZrCEH #&%(') 8 - ª3n Q]`+ZkCE1H N_irHGP_YuC[WY?irTXPbdF%T\ #(C M F6 %C>?
(60) H' >?86> )CK ¸XZrC_[\ZjFIHt[\P_`(TWikirHtY}ZrQUPEVo^EFHGirQ]Y?[WSEp
(61) TW^EPsQRP_V+jirikTWiu`G QRP_P_[\QUPEF[W[IC_[X`qEirT XH?P®ZrC_[\Z
(62) ZrCEHik`cZcTWiusH?i
(63) [WqEqEikTÍdQUF[ZkQRTXPT\ZrC_H+VWSUTWe_[WS´ÛTWik([WiksH?ikirTXi(Q]`o[WP H Y QUH?PZZkTdTWS(ÛTWiIH qfH?ikQRFH?PZu[\S[\P_[WSRb`rQU`T\oZkCEH P^_FIHGirQ]Y?[WS(`cZk[WeEQUSRQRZmbT\[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF$` {U¥G¡ |/BCEH <n$FH?ZrCETsH?ZkH?P_s_` QUPEP_[WQRP_F[X[ `jHGirikTWiSUQRP_HG[\ikDQ G[ZkQRTXPFIH?ZrCETsq_irT dQ]sQRP_VZrCEH<Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXP TW-[Y?TWikirHtY}ZkQRPEVI¤[XY}ZrTXi
(64) ÛTWioZrCEH+VXSRTXe_[\SÛTXir[\ius®H?ikirTXi[WP_s8[eTX^EP_s ÛTXi
(65) ZrCEHirHt`cQ]s^_[WSaH?ikirTXiT\-ZrCEH Y?TWikirHtY}ZkHGsikHG`r^ESZtBCEQU`(Y TXirikHGY ZrQUTWPQ]`3e[W`rHGsTXPZrCEHOPd^EFH?ikTW^_`ikHG`r^ESZu`3TXP H?SUH?FHGPXZu[\ikbHGirikTWi(Y TXF q_^Zk[\ZrQUTWP¯TWeZu[\QUPEHGsªefH Zm(H?HGPA¥GF¦ z ´¥G¦ Wzedb¨`rH? XH?iu[\Sj[\^EZrCETXik`G¸q_[WicZkQUY?^ES][\ikSR,b 4H?«d«XH?9i {Ïbz | ¸ +[WC_[\Pa¸ Pd^Zke C { ¦ |[\P_s®hjQ]YuC_[Z {U¥ b| [\PEVXSRTXQU`
(66) [WP_s®[ZkQR XH?SaC_[Í XHVWQU WH?P8[\P QUPXZkirTs^Y}ZrTXirb®sHG`kY ikQRqEZrQUTWP T\ZrCEQ]`o[\q_qEirT[WYuC®QRk P {U¥Gby |£¤QRP N_irHGP_YuC§[WP_ks {R¥X¥ |BC_H[\QUFTWZkCEQ]`oq_[WqHGioQU`oZrTqEikHG`rH?PZ<[ Y?TWFqESUH ZkH[\P_s5sH?_PEQRZrQU WHsEHG`kY ikQRqZkQRTXP TW ZkCEHI3nvFH ZkCETs `cQUPEV ©AQUSR«dQUP_`rTWP `ir^_PEPEQUPEVH?ikirTXio[\P_[WSRb`rQU`G¸(H9[\@S]`cT<s HGirQU WHCEHGirH[PEHG sEbP[\FQUY eTX^EP_s¯ÛTXiZrC_H irHt`cQ]s^_[WS3HGirikTWiZkC_[ZIQRFqEikT WHt`ZrCEHqEirHG dQRTX^_` irHt`c^ESRZVXQR XH?PQUP {U¥Gy |/ BCEHq_[\qfH?iQ]`aTWikVX[WPEDQ ?HGs+[X`ÛTXSRSUTo`? 2¢P+ZrCEHPEH dZ`cHtY}ZkQRTXPJ¸ÍH(sQ]`rY?^_`r`QRPZkirTs^_Y ZrTXirbOH E[\FqESUHG` YuC_TX`rH?P ZrT QRSUSR^`mZkik[\ZrH5ZkCEH¨q_irT` [\P_sáY TWP` T\+ZkCEH:FH?ZrCETs £ÛZrCEH¨H E[\FqESUHG`®[\ikH:sH Zu[\QUSRHtsAQUPAZrCEH n<qEqfH?P_sQR_§}ABCEH5F[\QUP `cHtY}ZrQUTWP T\ZrCEH5q_[WqHGiQU` 3dHtY}ZkQRTXP ¡ª
(67) CEHGirH8(H®qEikHG`rH?PZZrC_H q_irQUP_Y QUqESUHG` TWjZrC_H3n FIH?ZrCETs¸SUQUPEHG[WiO[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF`<[\Ps5ZrC_HIY?TWFqE^Zu[ZrQUTWP¨T\jZkCEHIirHt`cQ]s^_[WS HGirikTWieTX^EP_s ¬TWikH3ZkHGYuCEPEQ]Y?[WS[W`rqHtY}Zk`-[WirH(qEikHG`rH?PZrHtsQUPZkCEHPEH dZ-ZmT`rHGY}ZkQRTXP_`xO[WP_sz
(68) ZkC_[ZF[Íb+eH
(69) `r«dQRqEqfHGsI[Z ZkCEHik`cZikHG[XsQRP_V_BC_HG`rH`rHGY}ZkQRTXP_`oikHG`rqfHGY}ZkQR XH?SUb sEHG[\S
(70) QRZrC¬ZkCEHY TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXP5T\ZkCEHHGSRHGFH?PZk[Wirb ikTW^_P_sQUPEV¨HGirikTWiu`I[\P_s ZrCEH8q_[WicZkQU[WS
(71) sH?ikQR [\ZrQU WHG`ITW<ZrC_H¬Y TWFqE^EZrHGs ikHG`r^ESZ
(72) QRZrC irHt`cqfHGY ZZrTªZrCEHt`cH HGSRHGFH?PZk[Wirb+ikTW^EPsQRP_VOHGirikTWiu`Ga©¨HoZrH?ikFQRP[ZrH
(73) `r^EFF[\ik7Q GQRPEVOZkCEHo[\SUVWTXirQRZrCEF"T\_ZkCEHO3n FH ZrC_Tds QUwP 3dHGY ZrQUTWMP E Ù"!ÚaÙßÞ.
(74)
(75) !"$#&%(')+*,-. z. ® " v ® "!$# &'( 'Í / - 10 +M!
(76)
(77). 60( ©ªH3QUSUSR^_`cZriu[ZkHZrC_H3VWHGPEH?iu[\SWeHGC_[Í dQRTXiaT\ZkCEH3nFH ZkCETs`rTWSU QUPEV
(78) Zm(ToQUSRSY TXP_sQRZrQUTWPEHtsZrikQU[WPEVW^_SU[Wi SUQUPEHG[Wi`cb`cZrHGF`G <`rQRP_JV 2¢jj \z\x T[ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPZ [\ikQRZrCEFH ZkQUY:[\P_s ZkCEH5ÛTWik[\ius TXi e_[XYu«[\ius `r^Ee_`cZrQRZr^EZrQUTWP$[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F ¸((H¬Y TWFqE^EZrH5ZkCEH:`rQRPEVXSRH5q_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP `cTXSR^EZrQUTWPA[\P_s ZkCEH?PAQRZk`®Y TXirikHGY ZrQUTWP
(79) QRZrC ZrCEH+3<n FH ZrC_Tdsa©ªHY?TWFq_[WirH
(80) ZkCEQ]``rQRP_VWSUHoqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXPY?TWikirHtY}ZkHGs [\SU^EHo
(81) QRZrCZkCEH`cTXSR^ZkQRTXP Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs
(82) QRZrC ZrCEHsETW^EeESUHqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXPa BCEHY S][W`k`rQUY`c^Ee`mZkQZk^ZrQUTWPª[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF Q]`e[WYu«d([Wiks8`cZk[WeESRHX 2ZOQ]`HGSRSR/«dPET
(83) P¬ZrC_[\ZZkCEHVXSRTXe_[\S ÛTXir[\iusHGirikTWiQRZ VWHGPEH?iu[ZkHG`IQU` ^_`c^[\SUSRb XH?ikb`cF[WSRSoHG WHGP ÛTXiQRSUS<Y TXP_sQRZrQUTWPEHts ZrikQU[WPEVW^ES][\iSUQRP_HG[\i `rb`mZkH?F` { u|¯BCEH ÛTXSRSUT
(84) QRP_V5ZmT:ZrikQU[WPEVW^_SU[Wi`cb`cZrHGF`I[\ikHYG[\ikH Û^ESUSRbsH?_PEHts¯ZrT¨VWH?P_H?iu[ZrHSU[WirVXH ÛTXir[\ius HGirikTWiu`QRP8eEQUP_[\ikb T[ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPXZ<[WirQRZrC_FIH?ZrQ]Y (HsHG`kY ikQUeHOZrC_HG`rH`rb`mZkH?F`QUP8n<qEqfH?P_sQR . "!#%$'&)(%+*-,./0&12 34%&5! # BC_Hik`cZSUQUPEHG[Wi-`rb`mZkH?FvQ]` 6"7 W~S9Í8 ¸W
(85) CEH?ikH6 7 ¸W[WP^_qEqHGi-ZrikQU[WPEVW^_SU[WiF[ZkirQRT\TWiusH?i;:¸WsHGqHGP_sE` TXP8ZrCEHQRPZrHGVWHGioq_[\iu[\FH?ZrH?i=3< on<SRS H?PZrikQRHt7 `
(86) QUP>6a7 ¸08 [\PsMW¨[\ikH+QUPXZkH?VXH?io [\SU^EHt`? 4QU[WVWTWP[\SaHGPXZkirQUHG` QUP?67[WirHTXPEHG`j[WP_s`cTXFH
(87) T\ZrC_H?iu`[\ikH=@BA BCEH
(88) F[ZkirQRC6 I7 QU`3QRSUS_Y?TWP_sQRZrQUTWP_HGs8£¤`rH?H<n<qEqfH?P_sQR dU¥ ÛTXisH Zu[\QUSU`u§} BC_H a&X([W^EH?ir 3d«WHGH?SY TXFIqf7 TWP_H?PZm
(89) QU`rHY TXP_sQRZrQUTWPªP^_FefH?iTWZkCEHF[ZrikQRD6 7 `k[ZkQU`c_HG` Y?TWP_sYUE6 7 ](S'F y 6 7 yDy 6 7 y FHG SJI UK:A ]6[_BCEH`rTWSU^ZrQUTWP T\ ZrCEQ]`o`rbd`cZrHGF Q]`ZrCEH+^_PEQZo XHGY ZrTWi W~S UFL ZML Z[[[6ZHuL ]OHN [ ©ªH `cTXSR XH?6 7 W SP8
(90) QRZrC¯e_[XYu«:`c^_e_`mZkQZk^ZrQUTWP¸ -u ¸W UKQ ] SR8 USQ ] cT U\ o V ^_X 6 7 US
(91) Q ZXW ]W UYW ]}¸)Q S : Z[Z c LM\ ZHFL [Í©ªHYuC_TT`cH [\SU^EHt`ÛTWi5< `r^_YuCIZrC_[\ZYG[Zu[W`cZrikTWqECEQ]Y(Y?[\PY H?SUS][ZrQUTWP`[WqEqfHG[\iQUPZrCEH
(92) qEikH? dQUTW^_`. `r^EFF[ZkQRTXPal 2Z(Q]`(PET\Z
(93) `c^_irqEikQ]`cQUPEV+ZkC_[ZZrC_HOY?TWFqE^ZkHGs`rTWSU^ZkQRTXP_`3QUP$2¢3j \zx`rQRPEVXSRHO[\P_s®sTW^_eESRH q_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP`r^´H?iÛikTWF S][\ikVWH<ÛTWik([WiksHGirikTWiu`G-TWFqE^EZrQUPEV
(94) QRZrC5`rQRP_VWSUHTXi(sTX^EeESUHqEirHtY Q]`cQUTWPbQUH?S]sE`. W1O SVUS]"Z^]"Z[[[Z_]"ZHLFZHLu]ON(Z
(95) C_H?PikHG`rqfHGY}ZkQR XH?SUbW¸5<a`Acb[\P_s-<d`ef"[ BCEH_iu`mZ+£ÛPE¢JX§3HGPZrikQRHt`3TWZrC_HOY?TWFqE^ZkHGs `cTXSR^ZkQRTXP_`(C_[W` P_T `rQRVXPEQRY?[WPXZsQUVWQRZG 2ZQU`O(TWirZrC¨PET\ZkQRPEVZrC_[\Z+eTWZrC¬ZkCEH`cQUPEVXSRH[\P_s¨sTW^_eESRHIqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP:`rTWSU^ZrQUTWP_` `r^´H?iÛikTWF"[O`cQUFQRS][\iÛTXir[\ius+H?ikikTWieE^Z-ÛTWisQRfHGirHGPZZkCEikHG`rCETWS]s [\SU^EHt`? ¢2 P_Y ikHG[X`cQUPEV<ZrCEHqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP QUP ZrCEQ]`
(96) Y TXFqE^Zk[\ZrQUTWP8Q]`PET\Z<`r^? Y QUH?PZZrTbdQUH?S]s ZkCEH+H E[WY Z
(97) irHt`c^ESRZG. n<qEqESUbQUPEV8ZkCEH 3n FIH?ZrCETsªZkT8ZrCEHqEikH? dQUTW^_`+`rQUPEVWSUHqEirHtY Q]`cQUTWP¯Y TXFqE^Zk[\ZrQUTWPa¸ HqEikT dQUsEH ZkCEH¨Y?TWikirHtY}ZkHGs ikHG`r^ESZ W$ZkTWVWH?ZrCEHGi®
(98) QRZrC [\Pá[We_`cTXSR^EZrH¬efTW^EPs
(99) T\+ZkCEH¨ikHG`rQ]s^_[\SH?ikirTXiG¸ -u ¸ y W c BW CEyH Y?TW
(100) ikir HtjY}Zk HGs ikHG`r^ESRZ
(101) QU` W~S ULFZML Z[[[6ZHLu]ONHZ ÛTXi[\SUSo[WY?Y?H?qZu[\eESUH8 [\SU^EHG`TWg <¸ -u ¸ZkCEH5 [\SU^EHG``r^_YuC ZrC_[\ZZrCEH¬Y?TWikirHtY}ZrQUTWP qEirTY?HG`k`IsETHt`PET\Z T XH?i T+ { WH?i T [\q_qHt[\iu` ÛTXi [WSR^EHt` SU[WirVXH?i ZkC_[\P eTWZrC ZrCEHªqEikH? dQUTW^_` `cQUPEVXSRH¯[\P_s sTW^_eESR7 H q_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP8ZkCEirHt`cC_TWS]sE`?TWikirHtY}ZrQUPEVZkCEHI`rQUPEVWSUHqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP5irHt`c^_SZObQUH?S]sE` WeS W¨
(102) C_QRSU H < LhL[e¬i£ A Ú Ú Ô6.
(103) (?-5 F ' . . T XH?i To`+
(104) CEHGP < ` L A QRP 2¢jj `cQUPEVWSUHq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP§ BCEH?ikH ÛTXirHZkCEH H qHtY}ZkHGs `cTXSR^ZkQRTXPJW QU` ikHGY?T WHGirHts Y TXirikHGY ZrQUPEVZkCEH`rQRPEVXSRHqEikHGY?QU`rQUTWP®Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXP7 ÛTX\io[ SU[WirVXHiu[\PE VXHTW< [WSR^EHt`? BCEHI[\e_`rTWSU^ZkHY TXFIq_^ZrHts5eTX^EP_s
(105) VXirTo`<[W`=I UXA ]
(106)
(107) C_H?ikH sEH?PETWZrHG`<ZrC_HqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP TWZrCEH Y TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXPae 3dT¬ZrCEQ]`Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXPirH?Zr^EikP_`SU[WirVXH Í[WSR^_HG`[WP_s¯F[Íb¨T XH?i T+M 2¢PZrC_QU` H?E[\FqESUHW¸aZkCEH Y TXFqE^ZrHtsªeTX^EP_s
(108) Q]`+ WHGirb5qfHG`k`rQRFQ]`mZkQUY`rQRPY HZrC_HirHt`cQ]s^_[WSH?ikirTXiOQ]`[XY}Zr^[\SUSRb y W c W y SJ]"[. i. ) %!#%$'&)(% 4% .;
(109) .;# ! #"> # & 3 <Tá(HY TXP_`cQ]sHGiZkCEH+ZkirQ][\PEVX^ES][\i
(110) `cb`cZrHGF%$ 7 W~SJ8 7 ¸E
(111) CEHGirH&$ 7 QU`o[ISUTHGiZrikQU[WPEVW^_SU[Wi(F[\ZrikQTW TXiksEH?i2:BCEHY TdH6 Y?QRHGPXZu`(T\ZrCEHF[ZkirQR'$ 7 [WP_s ZkCEH+ikQRVXCXZr/C[\P_s®`cQ]sH 8 7 sH?qfH?Ps®TXP [WP®QUPZrHGVWH?i q[\iu[\FH ZkH?i;< £¤`rH?HnoqEqfH?P_sEQ dÏJÛTWisH?Zk[WQRS]`k§ ©ªH
(112) YuCETdTX`rH 5< `r^_YuCZrC_[\ZPET+sE[\Zk[H?ikirTXiH?dQ]`cZk`QRP($ 7 [WP_s 8 7 ¸ -u ¸[WSRSY TWFqfTWPEHGPZk`-[\ikH
(113) `cQUPEVWSUHqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP T[ZrQUPEVOa&X qTXQRPZjPd^EFeHGik`GBC_HY?TWFqfTWPEHGPXZm
(114) Q]`rH Y?TWP_sEQZkQRTXP:Pd^EFefH?iTWjZrCEHF[ZkirQR)$ a7 ¸aY TXP_s&U*$ 7 ]S F y $ 7 yDy $ 7 y F G ¸VWikTo`<H?qTXPEH?PZrQ][\SUSUb
(115) QRZrC :BCEHI`cTXSR^ZkQRTXPwWªQU`O`c^YuC5ZrC_[\ZOTXPEHTW3QZu`Y?TWFqfTWPEHGPXZu`<Q]`PET\Z+[_PEQRZrHGSRb5ikH?q_irHt`cHGPXZu[\eESUHeEQUP_[Wirb TX[ZkQRP_VqTXQRPZPd^EFeHGi£W_UObL ] S "] [ ])ÍL §}
(116) n<`<ZrCEHF[\ZrikQUY?HG`$ 57 [WirHQUSUS Y TXP_sQRZrQUTWPEHts5H? XH?P ÛTWiO`cF[WSRS [WSR^EHt`TW á: [WP_s < ¸`rTWSU dQRPEV+$ ?7 W S 8 7
(117) QRZrC ZrC_H `r^Ee_`cZrQRZr^ZkQRTXP [WSRVXTWikQZkCEF bQUH?S]sE``rQRVXPEQfY?[\PZkSRb
(118) . S][\ikVWHÛTWik[\ius H?ikikTWiu`?BCEH+irHGSU[\ZrQU WHÛTWik([WiksH?ikirTXiT\ZkCEHY TXFqE^ZrHts8`cTXSR^ZkQRTXP W¬O `k[ZkQU`c_Ht` N) U WYO ](S-X2,/1 V . 1K0 \ y WO UKQ y] W c UKQ ] W_y UKQ ] y S y WlO UK: y ]W UKc : ]W_y US: ] y [ £m¥t§ ©ªH<`rTWSU WHZrC_HZrikQU[WPEVW^ES][\ij`rb`mZkH?F3` $ 7 W1S 8 7 ¸XÛTW i < SJA Acb+[\P_ssQUFH?P_`rQUTWP_`-ÛikTWF¥
(119) ZrT¥tyE©¨H `r^EFF[\5ik7Q G4 H
(120) QRZrMC NQRVX^EikH¥ZrCEH+ikHG`r^ESRZk`(qEikHG`rH?PZrHts CEHGirHt[ßZkH?i
(121) [\P_s ZrCEH+Y?SU[X`r`rQUYHG`cZrQUF[ZkHGs [WY?Y?^Eiu[WY b efTW^_P_s Y?TWP_s U*$ 7 ]} 687 4 aL[] <B; §}CEjHn`r`^Ee_H `cZrqQRZrHt^EY}ZrZkQUHGTWsP¬¸dZk[\CESUVWHTXÛirTWQRZrikC_(F [Wiks QU`H?ikikir`cTXZoi qNHG) icÛU TXW@O ir](FQUP_HtsY ikQUHGMP [X`c2¢Htj`3jH?q \TXz\PExH?P`rZrQUPEQ][\VWSUSUSUH+bqE
(122) ikQHGZkY C®Q]`rZkQRTXCEPªH+s£ QUFIHGP_`re?QRTX[ 9-P : : <T¬`cQUVWP_QYG[\PZsQUVWQRZQRP WO Q]`+irH?Zr^EikPEHts:
(123) CEHGDP :>= eE NETXi+H E[\FqESUHHC_[Í X9H N ) U WYO ] 7 LF[ f A ÛTWi :wS9eE @?A7 4 aL[] &BXCB CE§ HG PBZrC_C_HH Y `kTX[\FIFq_H ^ikZrHGHt`rsTWSU`c^TXZrSRQU^TWZkPQRTXQ]P¯`qQU`HGicsEÛH?TXPEirFTWZrHGHGs¯s
(124) DO 8QRZrC BCE2¢jHjÛTWik \z\[\x:ius:sHGTXir^EikeETWSUi+HQ]`qEikZmHG
(125) Y?Q]QUY `rQRH TXP$efH £ZrZrH?iZrC_[WLFP¯[ LhL ZrCEH q_irHG QUTW^` Y TXFIq_^Zk[\ZrQUTWP$eE^EZ®T\Y?TW^Eiu`rH¬H CEQUeEQRZk`ZrCEHª`r[WFIH¨eHGC_[Í dQRTXiY TXPZrikTWSUSRHts eb ZrC_H¨H?dqfT\ P_H?PZrQ][\S7 iu[ZrH¨T\4 ZrCEH¯a<Y ; TXP_sQRZrQUTWPáPd^EFeHGiGnoefTW^Z5C_[WSZkCEH[WYGY ^Eiu[WY?b QUP DO Q]` SRT`mZ ÛTWi : S e £ N) U DO ] A?[ 9 e LH] §}¸[\P_sZrCEH+ikHG`r^ESRZ
(126) C_[W`
(127) P_T`rQUVWPEQRY?[WPZ
(128) sEQRVXQZÛTWi :E=F9E ©ªHo[\qEq_SRbZkCEH<3<n FH ZkCETsY TWikikHGY}ZkQRP_VoZrC_H`rQUPEVWSUHqEirHtY Q]`cQUTWP W -BCEH
(129) Y TXirikHGY ZrHGsirHt`c^ESRZ WC_[W` [ efH ZrZrH?iI[WYGY ^Eiu[WY?b8ZrC_[WP¨ZkCEH `rQRPEVXSRHqEikHGY?QU`rQUTWPªirHt`c^ESRZ WO ¸eE^Z+ZkCEQ]`O QUFIq_irT XH?FH?PZQU`+P_T\Z^EPEQRÛTWikF
(130) QRZrC irHt`cqfHGY ZZrT ::©¨H sQU`cZrQUPEVX^EQU`rC¯Zm(T:`mZkH?q_`G, N_TWi : b_¸ZkCEH®Y?TWikirHtY}ZrHtsªirHt`c^ESRZ W QU`[\efTW^Z [X`[WY?Y?^Eiu[ZrH[W`QRZk``cQUPEVWSUHqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP¨Y TXFqE^Zk[\ZrQUTWP¯[\SUSRTo `£¤HikHGY?[WSRSZkC_[Z+ZkCEH7 H E[WY Z4 `cTXSR^a<Zk;QRTX,P W `r^´H?iu`+ÛikTWF [\P^EP_[Í XTWQ]sE[\e_SRHikH?S][ZkQR XHH?ikirTXi+T\
(131) TWiusH?i § 5©¨H®C_[Í WH N) U WK] A"[ A LH] ¸ÛTWi :JS b_ NETXgi :G= e¸fZrCEHikH?S][ZkQR XH+ÛTWik([Wiks8HGirikTWi N) U WK]QRP_Y?irHt[W`rHG`<irTX^EVWCESUb8[W`ZrCEHÛTWik[\ius8H?ikirTXi TWaZrC_HsETW^EeESUHqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP®Y TXFqE^Zk[\ZrQUTWPª!£ 2¢jjj WzxsTW^_eESRHOqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP®[WirQRZrCEFH?ZrQ]Y<Q]`
(132) `cSUQUVWCZrSUbFTWikH q_irHtY Q]`cHOZrC[\P®Zm
(133) QUY?HZrCEH`rQRP_VWSUHOq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP§ Ù"!ÚaÙßÞ.
(134)
(135) !"$#&%(')+*,- . 1e+15 Single Precision Double Precision Corrected Single Precision Relative Bound for Correction (Single Precision) x (Condition Number). Relative Forward Errors and Bounds. 1e+10. 100000. 1. 1e-05. 1e-10. 1e-15 1. 2. 3. 4. 5 6 Dimension. 7. 8. 9. 10. NQRVX^EirH¥3TWSU QUPEV/$ 7 1W SJ8 7 ¸ÛTXi%<eSJA Acb[\P_s sQUFH?P_`rQRTXP_` OL ZrT L[]®. BCEH
(136) Y?TWFqE^ZkHGseTX^EP_s
(137) ® [\SUQUs_[ZrHt` ZrCEHo[XY?Y ^_ik[XY bT\ZrCEH
(138) Y TXirikHGY ZrHtsikHG`r^ESZu`? ©¨H XH?ikQÛb+ZkC_[Z ZkCEHIirHGSU[\ZrQU WH [\SU^EH
(139) x"y W y eTX^EP_sE` N)U WK] ¸´ZrCEH[WY Zr^_[WSÛTXir[\ius8H?ikirTXioT\3ZrCEHY TXirikHGY ZrHGs8ikHG`r^ESRZG n`+ÛTXi+ZrCEH ÛTWik([WiksªH?ikikTWit¸ZrCEH®4 eTX^EP_s
(140) QU`ZrQUVWCZÛTXi : b¸[WP_sªZrCEHGPT WHGicHG`cZrQUF[ZrHt`OZrCEH [XY}Zk^_[\SHGirikTWi(edb®[¤[WY ZrTWi
(141) TW;e LH]QUP ZrCEQ]`
(142) H?[WFqESRHX 2¢P:TWikTWSUS][\ikbJE¸HqEikT WHZrC_[\ZZrCEH`kY?[WSU[Wi`rTWSU^ZkQRTXP$W_USQ ]`r[\ZrQ]`m_Ht` W_USQ]dZ W_USQ] c
(143) (Z W UKQ ]
(144) \¸ZrC[ZF[Íb+qEirT dQ]sH[\P " ; Y TXPXZkirTXSXTW_ZkCEHPETWP¢Y TXirikHGY ZrHts+irHt`c^_SZ W_O USQ ]}lNETWi-H?[WFqESRH
(145) C_H? P : SJfE¸ WO Uif ] S A?[ ]h] ] A5L A 44 LH] aa Z W_Uif ] c
(146) S LF[ 99 9399 9 4 LH] a Zk[\P_s W_Uif ]
(147) S A?[ ]h] ]]h] ] A LH] Z q_irT XH<ZkC_[ZZrC_HÛTW^EioS][W`cZosQUVWQRZk`T\ W_O iU f ] [WirHPETWZ
(148) [XY?Y?^Eik[\ZrHX©AC_H?P : S d¸ WlO U F] S e"[ A e 9 e : A 4 4 L[] Z aYX W U F] c
(149) S c A"[ ]
(150) hecb 94 L[a&] X Zr[WP_s W U F]
(151) S [ b b e 9hb Acb L[] Z bdQUH?S]sªZrC_[\Z W_O U <]C[W`+PET¨`cQUVWPEQRYG[\PZsQUVWQRZk`G BCEQ]` 9b ; Y?TWPZrikTWSj[WVWikH?Ht`
(152) QZkC¯ZrCEH [WY}Zk^_[\S. ikH?S][ZkQR XH+ÛTWik[\ius8H?ikirTXi<T\ZkCEHIQRPEQRZrQ][\SUSUb¬`cQUPEVWSUHq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP¬Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs:`rTWSU^ZkQRTXP5ÛTWiZrCEHY TXP_`rQUsHGirHts [WSR^EHt`T\ :. Ú Ú Ô6.
(153) ~. (?-5 F ' . . J! 4 !O # . BC_HG`rHoZm(TH?[WFqESRHt`3H?CEQRe_QZ(ZrCEHF[\QUPq_irTXqHGicZkQRHt`3TWaZrCEH3n FH?ZrCETs®
(154) CEH?P®QZQU`[WqEqESUQRHtsZrT Y?TWikirHtY}ZZkCEHj_P[\SirHt`c^ESRZTW_[oY TXFIq_^Zk[\ZrQUTWP+QUP[oVXQR XH?PqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP £ÛCEHGirHX¸GZkCEHH2¢3jª`rQUPEVWSUHjqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP§} BCEH<_iu`mZ3H?E[\FqESUH
(155) QRSUSR^`mZkik[\ZrHG`jZrCEHOY?[X`cHt`
(156) CEH?P Y?TWikirHtY}ZkQRPEVZkCEH<`rQRP_VWSUHoqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXPIq_irTY Ht`r`jbQUH?S]sE` ZkCEHH E[WY Z+irHt`c^ESRZ
(157) CEH?ikHG[X`<ZkCEHsTW^_eESRHqEikHGY?QU`rQUTWP¨Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXPª`cZrQUSRSikH Zk^EikP_`QRP[WY?Y?^Eiu[ZrHirHt`c^_SZu`? BC_QU`
(158) «dQUP_s8T\-H E[XY}Z<Y TXirikHGY ZrQUTWP8sH?qfH?PsE`<`cZrikTWPEVXSRbTWP8ZrC_HY TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXP5TWiusH?it¸dZrC[Z<Q]`o[VWHGPEH?iu[\S ¤[XY}ZÛTWi TX[ZkQRP_V®qfTWQUPZ+Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXP_`?9 3d^_YuCª¤[Í XTWiu[\eESUHY?[X`cHt`H EY HGqZrHts¸ZkCEHVWH?P_H?iu[\S-6H Y QUH?PY b TWZrCEH 3n FH?ZrCETs5Q]`OH?FqEC_[X`cDQ ?Hts5
(159) QZkC¬ZkCEHI`rHGY?TWP_s8H?E[\FqESUHWBCEHH Y QUH?P_Y?b TWjZrC_HI`rQRP_VWSUH q_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP Y TWikikHGY}ZkHGsqEirTY?HG`k`QU`
(160) Y?TWPZrikTWSUSRHtsedb efT\ZkC ZrCEH`rQRP_VWSUH[WP_sZrCEHsTX^EeESUH+qEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP_`? ©ACEQUSUH+ZrCEHirHGSU[\ZrQU WH[WYGY ^Eiu[WY?b T\ZrC_HsTW^_eESRHqEirHtY Q]`cQUTWP5Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs irHt`c^_SZ<Q]`o`rF[\SUSRHGi
(161) ZrC_[WP8ZrCEH `rQUPEVWSUHq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWPa¸dZkCEHirHGSU[\ZrQU WH[WYGY -^Euiu [WY?bITWZkCEH`cQUPEVXSRHOqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXPikHG`r^ESZoY?TWikirHtY}ZrHts ikHG`r^ESRZQ]`T\ ZrCEH TXiksEH?iTW(ZkCEQ]``rQRPEVXSRHqEirHtY Q]`cQUTWP¸ ¸IZrCEH®eHt`mZqfTX`k`rQReESUH[XY?Y ^_ik[XY b¬ÛTXi[¬Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZrQUTWPQUP `rQRP_VWSUH q_irHtY Q]`cQUTWPaBC_HIiu[\P_VWHTW`r^_YuC:efH?C_[Í dQUTWiOT\Y TW^_ik`rHsHGqHGP_sE`TXP¬ZrC_HY?TWP_sEQZkQRTXP:T\ZrCEHIqEikTWeESUH?F8 ©AC_H?P¯ZrC_H qEikTWeESUH?F%QU``rT5QUSRS(Y TWPsQZkQRTXPEHGs¨ZkC_[ZZkCEH ikH?S][ZkQR XH[XY?Y?^Eik[XY b¬TWZrCEHsETW^EeESUHqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP Y?TWFqE^ZkHGsªikHG`r^ESZQ]`+(TWiu`cHIZkC_[\PªZrC_H`cQUPEVXSRHqEikHGY?QU`rQUTWPa¸ZrCEH Y?TWikirHtY}ZrHts¨`rQUPEVWSUHqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP¨ikHG`r^ESRZQU` [WeTX^Z([X`<£¤QRP§c[WYGY ^Eiu[ZkH[W`3ZrC_QU`(sTW^_eESRHqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP Y TWFqE^EZrHGsirHt`c^_SZt_ 2¢P®eTWZrCYG[W`rHG`G¸WZkCEHY?TWikirHtY}ZrHts ikHG`r^ESRZ
(162) QU`FTWikH+[WYGY ^Eiu[ZkH<ZkC_[\P ZrC_H+QRPEQRZrQ][\SUSUbPETXPY?TWikirHtY}ZkHGsikHG`r^ESRZG BCEHGirH?ÛTWikH<ZkCEH+Y TXirikHGY ZrQUTWP qEikTY Ht`r`QU`VXSRTXe_[\SUSUb`rQUFIQUS][\i(ZrTsTX^EeESUQRPEVZrC_HOq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWP®T\ QUPZrHGirFH sEQU[\ZrHY?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXP_`?oHG WHGicZkCEH?SUHG`k`?¸fZkCEHIY?TWikirHtY}ZkHGs5[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_FQ]`<P_T\ZH E[WY ZrSUb Htg^EQR [WSRHGPXZZrT®ZrCEH QUPEQRZrQ][\S3[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF q_irTY Ht`r`rHGs¨QUPsTW^Ee_SRHqEikHGY?QU`rQUTWPa 2¢PZkH?ikFIHtsQ][ZrH Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs¯ [\SU^EHt`+QRPªZkCEHY TXic ikHGY ZrHts[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF"[\ikHPET\ZZm
(163) Q]Y H
(164) FTXirH
(165) [WYGY ^Eiu[ZkH(ZrC_[WPZkCEHoQUPEQRZrQ][\SUSRbIY TWFqE^EZrHGsITXPEHG`
(166) £ÛZrCEHGbI[WirH
(167) `cZrQUSRS Y?TWFqE^ZkHGs8QUP8ZrCEHIY ^EikikH?PZoqEikHGY Q]`rQRTXP§}o{PESUbZkCEHQUPEQZkQU[WSRSUb8Y TWFqE^EZrHGs P_[\S irHt`c^ESRZ<Q]`oFTsQR_HGs8edb ZkCEH`r^EFF[ZrQUTWP8TWZkCEHY?TWikirHtY}ZrQUPEVIZrHGirF f O h 3TZrCEHIY TWikikHGY}ZkHGs®irHt`c^_SZu`
(168) F[ÍbefHsQRfHGirHGPXZT\-ZrCEH ikHG`r^ESRZk`aY?TWFqE^ZkHGs+
(169) QRZrCH dZrHGP_sHGsq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWPa BCEHj_iu`cZH E[\FqESUHQUSRSU^_`cZriu[ZrHt``r^_YuC[¤[Í XTWiu[\eESUHY?[W`rHW BCEH¯Y TXFqE^ZrQUPEV H?ikirTXiefTW^EP_s
(170) " [\SUQUsE[\ZrHt` ZkCEHª[XY?Y?^Eik[XY b T\ZkCEH¯Y TWikikHGY}ZkHGs ikHG`r^ESRZ [\Ps F[Íb8qEikT dQUsHI[\P " ; Y?TWPZrikTWST\3ZrCEHQUPEQZkQU[WSRSUb¬Y TXFqE^ZrHts¬ikHG`r^ESRZGBCEH`rHGY TXP_s5H?[WFqESRH QUSUSR^_`cZriu[ZkHG`OZkCEHG`rHZmT8qEikTWqfH?irZrQUHG`G BCEHikH?S][ZkQR XHIHGirikTWiefTW^EPs
(171) xy W y [\VXirHGHG`O
(172) QRZrCªZrCEH®[WY}Zk^_[\S [XY?Y?^Eik[XY bIT\aZkCEHY TWikikHGY}ZkHGsikHG`r^ESRZ ©ªH+[\S]`cT^_`rH<ZkCEHOY?TWikirHtY}ZkHGsikHG`r^ESRZ W5[\P_s ZrCEHOefTW^EP_ s
(173) ¬ZrT q_irT XH<ZkC_[ZZrC_HY TWFqE^EZrHGs ikHG`r^ESRZ W:O ([X`QUP_[XY?Y ^_ik[\ZrHW <H? WHGicZkCEH?SUHG`k`G¸_ZkCEQU`efTW^EP_s_``r^´H?iu`
(174) ÛikTWF ZrCEHHGSRSR«P_T
(175) P5SRQUFQZu[ZrQUTWP`<TW[W^ZrTXF[ZrQ]Y+ÛTXir[\ius HGirikTWieTX^EP_sE`G©ªHsEHG`kY ikQRefHQUP 3dHGY ZrQUTWP8¡E xZrC[ZZrCEH+Y?TWFqE^Zu[ZrQUTWP T\
(176) ¨F[\QUPESRbikH?SUQUHG`(TWP®ZrCEH Y?SU[X`r`rQ]Y©AQRSU«dQRP_`rTWP `+ik^EPEP_QRPEV:H?ikirTXi[\P_[WSRb`rQU` {ÏJ¥ |w 3dT¬qfHG`k`cQUFQU`cZrQ]YT XH?ikHG`cZrQUF[\ZrHt`TWZrCEH [WY}Zk^_[\S HGirikTWiF[ÍbOeH3irH?Zr^EikPEHGsa¸GÛTXiQUP_`cZk[\PY Hj
(177) CEHGPZrCEHqEikTWeESUH?F QU`QRSUSdY TWPsQZkQRTXPEHGsTXia
(178) CEHGPZrCEH([\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF Y?TWFqE^ZkHG`IQUPXZkH?ikFHGsQ][ZkH g^_[WPXZkQZkQRHt`
(179) QRZrC [\e`cTXSR^ZkH® [WSR^EHt`S][\ikVWHGiZkC_[\P ZrCEH _P[\SirHt`c^_SZu`?BCEH ik`cZSUQRP_HG[\i`rbd`cZrHGF QRSUSR^`mZkik[\ZrHG`<ZrC_QU`OS][ZcZkH?i`rYG[\SUQRP_V H ´HGY ZGBCEHI`cHtY TWPs5H E[\FqESUH[WP_s¬[X`r`rTY Q][ZrHts NQUVW^EikH¥H CEQUeEQZ
(180) ZkCEH+H ´HGY ZoT\ ZrCEHY?TWP_sQRZrQUTWP8TWZrC_H`cb`cZrH?F8 ÖÍÎ/ÖÆuïaÕÏÕ ËÍâoÐÖtØWÔ GÉ}ÖtÔtÔÍÉrÒÓ Ô ÌÏÎ
(181) ÆuëÍëtÕÏÌÏÐcÓÆuÎoÆuÔÆuØÍÎ0É}ÕÏÖtÈ/ÐOØWÉ}ÖtÔÍÓÈ0ÉÈ0ËÍÐÑcÉ}ǤǤÐcÑ¢È0ÐmÓ8Ç0ÐmÎ0ÖÍÕ ÈoÎ/ÌÏÔÍÑmÐ<È/ËÍÐOÐ tÆuÑ¢ÈoÎ/É}ÕÏÖtÈ0ÌÏÉ}Ô ÌÏÎ . .
(182) . . Ù"!ÚaÙßÞ.
(183)
(184) !"$#&%(')+*,- . ¦. "!á#% &'( 3.&)!#%$ !# &F"
(185) g4&5.&5! # C. H ZAefH[5`cH?ZT\ T[ZrQUPEV8qfTWQUPXZP^_FefH?iu`
(186) QZkCqEirHtY Q]`cQUTWP 4 jSUH?FHGPXZu[\ikb T[ZkQRPEV8qfTWQUPZTWq HGik[\ZrQUTWP_`ZkC_[Z Y TXirikHG`rqfTWP_s¯ZkT[\ikQZkCEFH ZrQ]Y TWqfH?iu[ZkQRTXP_`MU Z c Z Z x Z ][WirH8sH PEHGs TWP av©¨H [X`r`r^EFHIZrCEH®4 `mZu[\P_sE[Wiks¨FTsH?ST\ TX[\ZrQUPEV5qTXQRPZ[WirQRZrCEFH?ZrQ]YQU``r[\ZrQ]`m_Hts { |MNETWiRW Z D a¸
(187) [\Ps
(188) Z c Z Z Z ¸jH8sH?_PE H S W [WP_s S P U!W ]}3 Í[WSR^[ZrHts H?qEirHt`r`rQUTWP_`[\ikH sE H?PETWZrHGs eb P UCx r ] ¸d[WP_sY TXFqE^ZrHtsg^_[WPXZkQZk QRHt`3D Y?SU[X`r`rQUYGO [\SUSRbHt[\i( [D C_[\ZG-©AQZkC ZkCEH`cZk[WP_sE[\iusFTsH?S TW T[ZkQRPEVqfTWQUPZ<[\ikQZkCEFH ZrQ]Y\¸ RO S@UOL F]6Z y y Z £0JW§ [WP_s `cQUFQRS][\ikSRbX¸ O S x UL ]Z y y [ £¤¡X§ H Z P eH®[ Û^EP_Y}ZkQRTXPT\ : irHt[\Sj [\ikQ][\eESUHG`+[WP_s P U P ] S P O ¸ QRZk`+Pd^EFHGirQ]Y?[WSjH? [\SU^_[\ZrQUTWP¯TW P a N_TWi`cQUFqESUQUY?QZmbX¸H[W`k`c^_FIHZrC_[\Z P QU`[ ikHG[WSÛ^_P_Y}ZkQRTXP¬K [ XHGY ZrTWiÛ^EP_Y ZrQUTWP¨
(189) QRSUSeHY TXP_`rQUsHGirHts Y?TWFqfTWPEHGPXZm
(190) Q]`rHW BC_HoY TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXPTW: W@` S P U!Qe] ikH Zr^_irP_` W@` ÛTWi Q SVU!WKX<Z[[[YZCW:\]efH?SUTWPEVXQRP_V ZkT aoBCEHVWSUTWe_[WSdÛTWik([WiksH?ikirTXiQ]` W:O ` c P U!Qe] BCEHoY?TWFqE^ZuO [ZkQRTXPTWfHt[WYuCIQRPZrHGirFHtsQU[\ZrH [\ikQU[WeESUH WO n QRPZkirTs^_Y?HG`[\P£¤[We_`rTWSU^ZrHͧH?SUH?FH?PZu[\ikbikTW^EP_sEQRPEVHGirikTWi q n 4 ÛTWi $S : JLFZ[[[YZ NETWi WO V ¸ WO U [WP_s WO n QRP `c^YuC®ZkC_[Z L Q W ¸_[WP_s
(191) Z c Z Z x Z ¸ . WO n S P U WO V WO U ] S WO V WO U q n £Ûx§ S Wn qnZ £0zW§
(192) C_H?ikH WO U SJ ]I
(193) CEH?P S x ¸E[\Ps WO V S]Z WO U =]
(194) C_H?P S 3dT¸_ZkCEHPd^EFHGirQ]Y?[WSH? [WSR^_[\ZrQUTWP5TW P U!Qe] TXP! Q]` P O U!Q,Z q ]}¸fZkC_[ZOQU`G¸f[Û^EP_Y}ZkQRTXP:TWZkCEHs_[Zk[$Q [WP_sªZrC_H H?SUH?FH?PZu[\ikb:ikTW^EP_sEQRPEV5HGirikTWiu` q S U q \<^_X<Z[[[6Z q ` }] 5n ik`cZcTWiusH?i[WqEqEikTÍQRF[ZkHT\ZrCEH VXSRTXe_[\S´ikTW^EPsQRP_VIHGirikTWi(
(195) QRZrC8irHt`cqfHGY Z
(196) ZrTIZrC_H+H?SUH?FH?PZk[WirbirTX^EP_sQUPEVIH?ikirTXik`(Q]` ` p PO m f h S \<^_X pq n U!Q,Z q ]lr q n [ £X § no n` P U!Qe](S P O U!Qw^Z ] ] ¸ZrCEHVXSRTXe_[\S´ÛTXir[\ius ikTW^EPsQRP_VHGirikTWiQ]` P O U!QwZ q ] c P U!Qe]S fh ckj hlZ £ \§
(197) C_H?ikH j h Q]`ZrCEH 5s-@
(198) 7tuvC [W`k`cTY?QU[\ZrHGs
(199) QZkCwf h . Ú Ú Ô6.
(200) ¥ty. (?-5 F '. i. . . !#= !C g3O > C&)( " * > &5( 8. B iu[WsQRZrQUTWP_[WSPd^EFHGirQ]Y?[WS´[WP_[\SUb`cQ]`(eTdTX«d`(^_`rHOZrCEH T[ZkQRPEVIqfTWQUPXZo[WirQRZrCEFH?ZrQ]YFTsHGSj£0JW§([WP_s¨£0¡X§3ZrT efTW^_P_s¯ZrC_H®[\e`cTXSR^ZkH H?SUH?FHGPXZu[\ikb¨HGirikTWiu` q n QRPikH?S][ZkQRTXP$£§OK [\P_s`rT¬efTW^EPs y fih y ¸j[\P_sªZkCEH?P P_H?VWSUHGY Z j h¯ZkTsHGirQU WH[ _iu`mZr/TXiksHGioefTW^EP_s¬T\ZrC_HVWSUTWe[\SikTW^_P_sQUPEV H?ikikTWi { x<|¸l{R¥t¦b|/©¨HqEikTWqfTX`rH C_H?ikHZkTY TWFqE^EZrH fiO hMS P UfihY]ZrT sEH?ikQR XH[ C6
(201) >?5s P UQe]sH?_PEHGs [W` P UQe](S P P O U!Q,Z q ] c f O h [ £¤~X§ ©ªHY?TWFqE^ZkH f O h HG Í[WSR^[ZrQUPEVikH?S][ZkQRTXP¬£ §jQUP T[ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPZ[WirQRZrC_FIH?ZrqQ]Y\BCEHq_[\irZrQ][\SfsH?ikQR [\ZrQU WHG` [WirH
(202) Y?TWFqE^ZkHGsI
(203) QZkC[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEFQ]Y(sEQ´H?ikH?PZrQ][ZkQRTXPa3SRHGFIHGPZk[\ikbHGirikTWiu` [\ikH
(204) Y TWFqE^EZrHGsI^_`rQUPEVZrCEH ikH?S][ZkQRTXP_`qEirHt`cHGPZrHGs:QRPªPEH?ZB[\eESUH8¥WIBCEHG`rHZm(T «QUP_sE`TWY TXFqE^Zk[\Zrn QUTWP_`[WirHIHGSRSR«P_T
(205) P¬eE^Z FHGirVXQRPEVZrC_H?F qEikT dQUsEHG`[IeH?ZcZrHGi
(206) C_[\PsSRQUPEVTWP®ZrC_HOikTW^_P_sQUPEVHGirikTWiu`3ZrC_[WPZkCEHY S][W`k`cQ]Y<_ik`cZcTWiusHGi efTW^_P_s BCEHY TXirikHGY ZrHts5irHt`c^_SZ P U!Qe]<`c^´H?iu`ÛirTXF ZrCEHZrik^EP_YG[ZrQUTWP¨H?ikirTXi j h[WP_s:[®Y TXFIq_^ZrQUPEV H?ikirTXi j BCEQ]`Y?TWFqE^ZkQRP_VoH?ikirTXiaY TXFIHt`´ÛikTWF ZrCEHPEQZkH3qEikHGY?QU`rQUTWPOH? [\SU^_[ZkQRTXP+T\dZrC_Hjq_[\irZrQ][\SXsH?ikQR [\ZrQU WHG` [WP_sZkCEHHGSRHGFCH?6P Zk [W>irb<5 ikTW^ECP_sE QRPEVH?ikirTXik`aQRPirHGSU[\ZrQUTWP£ X§}¸\[WP_s+ZkCEH_P_[\S`r^EeZkik[XY}ZrQUTWPQRPZrCEHY TXirikHGY ZrQUTWP £0~X§ H 3dTIZrCEH eH?ZmHGH?P®ZrCEHY?TWikirHtY}ZkHGs ikHG`r^ESRZo[\P_s®ZrC_H+H E[WY ZikHG`r^ESRZ
(207) QU` P U!Qe] c P U!Q ]lS c U j h j H]6[ £¤¦X§ BC_H`rF[\SUSRHGiZrCEH+ikHG`rQ]s^_[\SHGirikTWi(Q]`?¸ZkCEH+FP TWikHH Y QUH?PZ
(208) ZrCEHY?TWikirHtY}ZkQRPEVIFH ZkCETs®Q]`G B TWVXH ZrC_H?i
(209) QZkCªZrCEH Y?TWikirHtY}ZrHts5ikHG`r^ESZ UQe]}¸ZkCEH®3n FIH?ZrCETsE`q_irT dQ]sHG`[ eTX^EP_s¨T\(ZrCEH Y?5s-TW@F
(210) qER^Zk<QR5 P_A V<H?--ik?8irRTXi j
(211) BCEQU`efTW^EP_s
(212) efTW^_P_sE`
(213) ZkCEHikHG`rQ]s^_[\S H?ikirTXio
(214) CEHGP j heS ]_¸_ZkC_[ZOQU`oÛTWi ¸f[q_[\irZrQ]Y ^ES][\i
(215) Y?SU[X`r`(T\[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`((H+sH _P_H+QRP ZrC_H+PEH dZo`cHtY}ZkQRTXPa . >(% !#%. "! .&)!O #P* ) ./# !#%. F 3O$ ! &)(. . z<QRVXCEH?i<ZrC_[WP¬_iu`cZcTWiusH?ioH?fHtY}Zu`<TWZrCEHIH?SUH?FH?PZu[\ikb®ikTW^EPsQRP_V H?ikirTXik`oF[Íb5Y?TWPZrikQRe_^ZrH+ZkT ZkCEHQUP. [XY?Y?^Eik[XY bTW[Y TXFIq_^ZrHts®ikHG`r^ESRZG ! H?Z P O XefHZrCEHH? [WSR^_[\ZrQUTWP T\ P U!W_Z D Z ]S W c D c
(216) QRZrC5n<SRVXTWikQZkCEF ¡E ¡E WKXS W Z W S D Z W S W " S WKX vW W$# S WKX c4 W W B S W " 4 W%# W$& S W W W ; S W B}c W & P O X U!W Z D Z ]lSgW ;. Ù"!ÚaÙßÞ.
(217) ¥X¥.
(218) !"$#&%(')+*,-. poH?S][ZrQUTWP¯£0zX§(bdQRHGSUsE`. P O X U!W_Z D Z ] c P U!W Z D Z ]lS q " U!W c D ] q # UW D ] q B c q & q ; q " q # [ BC_H?Pa¸_Y?TWFqE^ZkQRP_V P XU A # ZHLFZ^A # ](S c LUQ P12¢j3 Wzx `rQRP_VWSUHOq_irHtY Q]`cQUTWPª£ SJA <a " (§ VWQU WHG` P O XUiA # ZML Z^A # ](SJ]"Z [X` q " S c L Z q # S L [WP_s q B S q & S q ; SJ]"[. £c¥GyX§. 2¢P:ZrCEQ]`Y?[X`cHX¸fefT\ZkC:ZkCEH_ik`cZ+[\P_s¬`rHGY?TWP_s/TXiksHGioZkH?ikF`OQUP:ikH?S][ZkQRTXP £m¥tyX§o`rQUVWPEQRY?[WPZrSUb8Y?TWPZrikQUeE^ZrH ZkTIZrCEH+VXSRTXe_[\S´ÛTXir[\iusH?ikikTWit BCEH+TXiksEH?io[\PsZkH?ikF`(ZrC_[\Z<[\ikH`rQUVWPEQRY?[WPZQUP ZrCEHsH? XH?SUTWqEFH?PZ
(219) T\ZrC_H+VWSUTWe_[WS´ÛTWik([WiksH?ikirTXi
(220) QRZrCªikHG`rqHtY}ZOZrT ZrCEHHGSRHGFIHGPZk[\ikb8irTX^EP_sQUPEV H?ikirTXik`sH?qfH?Ps¨TXP¬ZkCEH[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF [WP_s5ZkCEHsE[Zu[En VXH?PEHGik[WSY?irQRZrHGirQUTWPÛTXi
(221) C_H?P ZkTI`cZrTXq®Y?TWFqE^ZkQRPEVICEQUVWCEHGiTXiksEH?ijZkH?ikF`Q]`s7Q Y?^ESRZZkTIsH?_PEHX-BC_H K YuCETWQ]Y HTW-[IF[QUF[WSaTWiusHGi`r^_YuC ZrC[ZoCEQUVWCEHGi
(222) TWiusH?i(ZkH?ikF`<[\ikHOP_T\ZoY TXP_`cQ]sHGirHtsF[Íb SUHG[Xs ZkT8PEH?VXSRHtY}Z`rQRVXPEQfY?[\PZOZrHGirF`ÛTXiZrCEHVXSRTXe_[\S-ikTW^EP_sEQRPEV8HGirikTWit 3^_YuC:ZkH?ikF`[\ikHC_H?ikHZu[\«XH?PªQRPZrT [XY?Y?TW^EPZQRP ZrC_H+SRQUPEHG[WirDQ G[\ZrQUTWP®H?ikirTXi j h¨sH?_PEHts®edb ikH?S][ZkQRTXP¨£ \§} n<P¬[WY?Y?^Eiu[ZrHOefTW^EP_s TW j h¨Q]`
(223) [\S]`cTs7Q Y ^ESRZ
(224) ZrT Y?TWFqE^ZkHWjoHG WHGicZkCEH?SUHG`k`?¸dZkCEHÛTWSUSUT
(225) QRPEVSUQRP_HG[\i [WSRVXTWikQZkCEF``r[\ZrQ]`m_Ht`(ZrCEH+QUPZrHGirHt`mZkQRPEVIqEikTWqfH?irZmb j h S]_ ± 4 ¤¶ <SU@QUPE 9HG[W
(226) > i [\MSUVW!"TWik<QR ZrCEF TX P w <5 AB-! 8 -i<5 = :;<-" M-,
(227) "C.
(228) Z c Z Z x Z b=98i>?5 K5 P U WO V 4 WO U ] < 6 WO V SgW V WO U SgW U
(229) <@ b=$ -u P U WO V;x WO U ] 6< WO U SgW U
(230) <@ b= 6><CRC< P WO U 6< WO U SgW U [ QRPEHt[\i[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`-[WirH(`c^_YuCZrC[Z-ZrCEHQ]sH?PZkQ_HtsITWqfH?iu[\P_sE` W `r^´H?iÛirTXF PETOqEikH? dQRTX^_`irTX^EP_sd QUPEVH?ikikTWitTWP_`cZk[WPZk`-[\P_sIsE[\Zk[OT\´[\PdbQUFIq_SRHGFIHGPZrHGsI[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F O n [\ikH`r^_YuC WO n -n
(231) Y?Y?TWiusQUPEV<ZkTOZrCEHGQRi Pd^EFHGirQ]Y?[WS Í[WSR^_HW¸X`rTWFHoY?TWFqE^ZkHGsg^_[\PZrQRZrQUHG`jF[Íb[\S]`cT+`k[ZrQ]`cÛb WO n SgW n -j XH?PQRfZkCEH_P_[WSEikHG`r^ESZ W@O `"Q]`PET\ZY?TWFqE^ZkHGs5
(232) QRZrC¨[ SUQRPEHt[\iO[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF8¸`rTWFHQUPZrHGirFHGsEQU[\ZrH [\ikQ][\eESUHG`
(233) F[Íb eHirH?Zr^EikPEHts edb SUQUPEHG[Wi
(234) q_[\irZk`TWZrC_H[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF8 d3 TXFHIe[W`rQUY[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`ÛTXi`kY QUH?PZkQYY?TWFqE^ZkQRPEV5[WirHISRQUPEHt[\i[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`G_N TWiH E[WFIq_SRHX¸aH FHGPXZkQRTXPIZrCEHoP[Zr^_ik[WSETWiusH?ij`r^EFF[ZkQRTXP [\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF TW :®ikHG[WSEPd^EFefH?iu`?¸WZrCEH<QRPEP_H?i3q_irTs^_Y ZjT\´Zm(T XHGY ZrTWiu`([\P_s ZrCEHGirH?ÛTWikHFTX`cZ
(235) T\aZkCEH n 3 ikTW^ZkQRPEHt`?¸dZkCEHqTXSRbdPETXFQU[WSfHG [\SU^_[ZkQRTXP^_`rQRP_Vi<z TWikPEH?i `. FH?ZrCETs8[\P_sZrC_H`c^Ee`mZkQZk^ZrQUTWP5[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F ZrT`rTWSU WHZrikQU[WPEVW^ES][\iSUQRP_HG[\io`rb`mZkH?F`G £¤Y TXPZrQUP^_HGs_§ O©ªHY TWFqE^EZrHZrCEHIqEikH? dQRTX^_`
(236) Û^_P_Y}ZkQRTXP P UW Z D ZB]o
(237) QZkC¬ZrC_HÛTXSRSUT
(238) QRP_V SUQUPEHG[Wio[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF ZkC_[ZoikH Zk^EirP` P O [ ©ªH+C_[Í XH q q q q q P P O UW Z D ZB] c U!W_Z D Z ]S }" c. Ú Ú Ô6. #. . B. c. &. . ;. [.
(239) ¥ÍJ. (?-5 F '. . WKXS W Z 4 W S D Z W S W " S WKX 4 WYX W$# S W W W B S W " c4 W%# W$& S W W W ; S W B}c W & P O U!W Z D Z ]lSgW ;. B C_HVWSUTWe_[WSÛTWik([Wiks:H?ikirTXi+T\(ZrCEHSRQUPEHG[Wi[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F P O Q]`[8SUQRPEHt[\i+Û^_P_Y}ZkQRTXPT\(ZrCEH GH SRHGFH?PZk[Wirb ikTW^_P_sQUPEVHGirikTWiu`GBCEQ]`
(240) qEikTWqfH?irZmbCETXSUsE`(ÛTXio[\SUSSRQUPEHt[\io[\SUVWTXirQRZrC_F`G ±d¶ ± 6\ W@O ` E
(241) $- <8}K>?;
(242) ,C6
(243) >?5s P U!Qe] E=ew5s-@
(244) 1<5 AB-! 8 6 < Q S. UWKX<Z[[[YZ W@\] @)AF57 E<5F 6GH<C 9>?@ <-BA16C< OW:` c P UQe] 95 -K<
(245) >? <e !" 578 =9>?@ <-BA~6
(246) }q SVU q \<^_XZ[[[Z q `)] . . ¶a¶ I*,- ;@ L _~ 578 =e
(247) "C< < <@ JSP: LFZ[[[Z GHR@C<bME= -K > <$!"< !"A<57 E
(248) 5>?@ <-BAi6 - WO n 5 -K<
(249) >? 1 -)578
(250) = >?@ <-BA C<
(251) q KU : 9L
(252) "] @ 5 -@
(253) < @C
(254) "A < < !" 657896:;<= C>?K - AC(q 89=R
(255) F<G_6 W )<@ !"R GH~6@ R$8i>?5 K5
(256) !"i -u 6<i $ <- < !" 6@ ~ O 9 >C <; < - 8i>?5 @5 < <k<@ : 9L
(257)
(258) WO n S WO 4 WO 6 4 q n 6 6 S U!W q ] U!W 6 q 6 ] q n 6 S W n qn q W q W q q [ &C<8 !"16 5 -K<15 A <--?8 F (:- <
(259) GH~
(260)
(261) >?89) 6~ 8@571!"< q
(262) S ]"[ @~@< 5 -K< 8 q q C
(263) K i- A<57 E
(264) 5KC>?K - A96C< WO n c W n )5 -K<\ G-!1C6 l q 6 <@ q n KR-K > <e -:- <5 7tu
(265) - R!" F<; Q S+U!W X Z[[[YZCW \ ] @9 -u JK 9 >C < b 6 C -8-57<K KC
(266) 9- 6. N_TWi+[VXQR XH?PªY TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXPa¸a[®SRQUPEHG[Wi+[\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF qEikT dQUsHt`[®SUQRPEHt[\iOVWSUTWe_[WSÛTWik([Wiks8HGirikTWit{< ?Y TW^Eiu`rHW¸ÍZrC_QU`3VWSUTWe_[WSXÛTXir[\iusHGirikTWi-Q]`PETWZjPEHGY?HG`k`r[Wirb`rF[\SUSRHGi-ZrC_[WPZkCEH
(267) H?ikikTWi-qEikTdsE^_Y Htsedb[WPET\ZkCEH?i P_TWPSRQUPEHt[\i
(268) [\SUVWTXirQRZrCEF8 ®£¤Y?TWPZrQUPd^EHGs_§ BC_HZmTOqEikH? dQRTX^_`-Y TXFIq_^Zk[\ZrQUTWP_`-TW P O X[\Ps P O `r^´H?i-ÛikTWFvZkCEHo`r[WFH ÛTXir[\ius HGirikTWiÛTWi UW Z D ZB](SVUiA # ZML Z^A # ]6[ <Tá(HsQU`kY ^`r`(ZkCEHY TXirikHGY ZrQUTWP TWSUQRP_HG[\io[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF`?. Ù"!ÚaÙßÞ.
(269) ¥t¡.
(270) !"$#&%(')+*,- . >(%. . ". . g4&)!# $'* ) ) P.;# ! & D 4=#.
(271) . !# .; G 3$ !O&5(. . .
(272). (%# ". ) )0&)!# $. . BC_HY TWikikHGY}ZkQRTXP P U P O f O h ]Q]`
(273) qfH?irÛTWikFIHtsQUP T[ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPXZ<[WirQRZrC_FIH?ZrQ]Y+[\P_s8`rTQRPZkirTs^_Y?HG`PEHG ikTW^_P_sQUPEV¬H?ikikTWiu`?ªBCEc QU`IY TXFqE^ZrQUPEV¨H?ikirTXi j
(274) Q]`sH PEHGs eb¯ikH?S][ZkQRTXP$£¤¦X§ BCEH Zm(T¬ÛTXSRSUT
(275) QRP_V Y?TWikTWSUSU[WirQUHG`Y?TWP_`rQUsEH?iZrC_QU`®Y TWFqE^EZrQUPEVH?ikirTXi
(276) CEH?P ZkCEH¬ikHG`r^ESZu`T\+[¯SUQRPEHt[\i[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF [WirH5Y TXic ikHGY ZrHtsn<`
(277) SUQRP_HG[\io[WSRVXTWikQZkCEF``r[\ZrQ]`mÛb j hMSJ]E¸dZkCEHG`rHirHt`c^ESRZk`
(278) sEH?ikQR XHÛikTWF irHGSU[\ZrQUTWP¯£¤¦X§ ¶ ¶ ¤ ² " P U!Qe] 8@>? G-! 5 -K
(279) w5 AB-! 8
(280) - C ;
(281) C6 >?5 P U!Qe] <5 = >
(282)
(283) C8 - <8}K>? - A1C j
(284) Q0 HW
(285) . . . . P U!Q ]lS P U!Q ] c j
(286) [ ¶ ¶ ¤ ² 6
(287) E
(288) R1E
(289) >?@ } 6 j
(290) !"<H j
(291) K"iB C 6
(292) >?5s P U!Qe] <@ !" C ;
(293) C >?5 P U!Qe] 95s-@
(294) <5 AB
(295) -! 8 C
(296) y > y - P U!Qe] ,S Z P U!Qe] c
(297) (Z P UQe]
(298) \;[ . . BCEH
(299) efTW^_P_s8T\-ZrC_HikTW^EP_sEQRPEVHGirikTWiu`QUPXZkirTs^Y HGs edb®ZrCEHIY TWikikHGY}ZkQRTXP®q_irTY Ht`r`oqEirT dQ]sHG`
(300) [ Y?TWPfsH?P_Y?HIZrCEikHG`rCETWS]s:ÛTWiZrC_H Y TWikikHGY}ZkHGs:irHt`c^ESRZ P U!Q ]u H?Z^_`[W`k`r^EFHI^_PXP ZkQRS3PEH dZ`cHtY}ZkQRTXP¨ZkC_[Z
(301) ¸[WP_s¬C_H?P_Y?HZkCEHIQRPZrHGir [WS 3¸a[\ikHIY?TWFqE^ZkHGsiNEikTWF%TXirTXSRS][\ikb8JE¸ U!Qe]<efH?SUTWPEV`<ZkT £¤eE^ZoQ]`^EPE«dPET
(302) P§ BC^`?¸dZkCEHY TXirikHGY ZrHGs [\SU^EH P U!Qe]([\Ps ZkCEH+Y TWPEsH?PY HOZrCEikHG`rCETXSUs
(303) ªY TX^ES]s efH3^`cHtsZrT<Y?TWPZrikTWSWZrCEH([WYGY ^Eiu[WY?b<T\dZkCEHTXirQUVWQUP_[WSWY TXFIq_^ZrHts+irHt`c^_SZ WO ` jTWFq_[WirQUPEV WO ` STP O UQwZ q ]
(304) QRZrCIZkCEH ik[WPEVWH(F[ÍbqEikT Q]sH[\PIHG`cZrQUF[ZrH
(305) TW_ZkCEH
(306) Pd^EFefH?iTW´Y?TWikirHtY}ZsQRVXQZu`-QRPIZkCEHoY TXFIq_^ZrHts ikHG`r^ESRZG 5£0Y TXPXZkQRPd^EHts_§}-©ªH[WqEqESUbZkCEHY?TWikirHtY}ZkQRPEV+q_irTY Ht`r`jZrT+ZkCEH<q_irHG QUTW^`jSUQRPEHt[\i([\SUVWTWikQRZrCEF P O jBCEH+Y TXirikHGY ZrHts ikHG`r^ESZoQ]` . . . P UXA # ZML Z^A # ](S c LS P UXA # ZML Z^A # ][ ©ªHY?TWFqE^ZkH<ZkCEHOeTX^EP_s
(307) ¬
(308) QRZr C noSUVWTW<a ik QR" ZrCE7 F ¡EÏz+s4 Ht`rY?ira<QUef; HGsQUP ZkCEH<PEH?dZ`rHGY ZrQUTWPa-©AQRZrC$2¢3j Wzx`cQUPEVXSRHqEikHGY?QU`rQRTXP®[WirQRZrCEFH?ZrQ]Y£ S A e?[ 9: L[] §}¸_HVWH?Z
(309) wS [ L[e A 4 LH] a%& [ N_irTXF TWikTWSUS][\ikbJI[WP_s P iU A # MZ L ^Z A # ](S c LF[ ]"Z ZkCEH+H E[WY Z
(310) irHt`c^ESRZo`r[\ZrQ]`mHG` P iU A # MZ LFZ A # ]HS c LF[ ]@ [ L[e A 4 L[] %a & [ 3TI(HqEikT WHZrC_[\Z
(311) ZrCEH+QUPEQRZrQ][\SY?TWFqE^ZkHGs® Í[WSR^_H P O FXU A # MZ L ^Z A # ](JS ]"[ ]E¸C[W`PET`rQRVXPEQfY?[\PZosQUVWQRZG ¢2 P ZkCEH5ÛTWSUSUT
(312) QRPEV`rHGY ZrQUTWPa¸(H¬sEH?ikQR XH¬[\PA[\SUVWTXirQRZrCEF ZrTY TXFqE^ZrH¬ZrCEH5efTW^EPs
(313) ÛTXiZrCEH Y?TWFqE^ZkQRP_VIHGirikTWi
(314) j . Ú Ú Ô6.
(315) ¥Gx. (?-5 F '. . >. =4&)!_#%$ &)( D 4=#. ".
(316) . . . . ©ªH
(317) ikQRZrH+ZkCEHY TXFqE^ZrQUPEV®H?ikirTXi j
(318) S j Z
(319) CEH?ikH j sH?PETWZrHt`
(320) ZrC_HirTX^EP_sQUPEV HGirikTWiu`QUP5ZrCEH Y?TWFqE^Zu[q ZkQRTXP T\ZkCEHOY?TWikirHtY}ZkQRPEV¤[WY}ZkTWi f O h [\P_s Q]`3ZrCEHOirTX^EP_sQUPEVH?ikirTXi3QUPZrCEH_P_[WS`c^EeEZriu[WY}ZkQRTXP P U P O U!Q,Z ] c f h ] BCEQ]`S][W`cZOikTW^EPsQRP_V®HGirikTWi `r[\ZrQ]`mHG`OirHGSU[\ZrQUTWP £0JW§<T\ZrCEH`cZk[WP_sE[\ius¬FTsHGSTW T[ZkQRPEV qfTWQUPXZ [WirQRZrC_FIH?ZrQ]Y\¸ -u ¸ £c¥W¥t§ y y y P U!Q ] y [ BCEH¨T\ZkCEH?i8Y TXFIqfTWP_H?PZ j S f O h c f h ¸OY TWFHt`ÛikTWF ZrCEH TX[\ZrQUPEVqfTWQUPZ HG Í[WSR^[ZrQUTWPATW ikH?S][ZkQRTXP q £ §}¸
(321) ZkC_[Z QU`G¸
(322) ZrC_H¨Y TXFqE^Zk[\ZrQUTWP$TWZrCEHªq_[\irZrQ][\SOsH?ikQU Í[\ZrQU WHt` p P O x pKq n ¸
(323) ZkCEH:HGSRHGFH?PZk[Wirb HGirikTWiu` [\P_s ZrCEH5QUPEPEHGiqEikTdsE^_Y}$Z fih+US: 'L e]} [WPEVWSUTWQ]`[\P_s <[\ZrQU WH?S
(324) q_irT dQ]sH [ ZkCEH?TXirH?ZrQ]Y?n [WS_[\qEq_irTÍQUF[\ZrHefTW^EP_sÛTWi j ZrC_[\ZsH?ik QU WHG`Û irTXF K @ < QRPEHtg^_[\SUQZkQRHt}` {U¥Gby | zoT(H? XH?it¸ ZkCEQ]`-eTX^EP_sI`c^´H?iu` ÛirTXFvZrC_HYuC[\iu[WY}ZkH?ikQU`cZrQ]Y(HG[W«P_HG`k`TW irHt`c^ESRZk` aZkCEH
(325) [WY Zr^_[WSHGSRHGFH?PZk[Wirb HKGirikTWiu`o [WirHPET\ZOZk[W«WH?P:QRPZrT [WYGY TW^_PXZ[W`O[\SUSZrCEHt`cHH?ikirTXik`[\ikHefTW^EP_sEHGs¬edb ZrC_H(TWiu`mZOTWPEHX+BCEH efTW^EP_s[WSU`rT8QRPY ikHG[W`rHG`
(326) QRZrC¯ZkCEH Pd^EFeHGiT\QUPXZkH?ikFHGsQ][ZkH Í[WirQ][\e_SRHt`+
(327) CEQ]YuC¯YG[\P¯efH WHGirb S][\ikVWH+QUP:[WqEqESUQUYG[ZrQUTWP`? 3dT¸_ZkCEHY?TWFqE^Zu[ZkQRTXP5T\-ZrCEQ]` K efTW^_P_s8ÛTWi j F[Íb®ikH Zk^EikP5SU[WirVXH efTW^_P_sE`
(328) [\Ps `r^´H?iÛikTWF T XH?i T+ ©ªHq_irTXqT`cHCEH?ikHoZkTY TXFqE^ZrH[`rC_[WirqfH?i(eTX^EP_s ÛTWiZrCEHY TXFIq_^ZrQUPEVHGirikTWi j ^`cQUPEV©AQUSU«QUP `rTWP `-ik^EPEPEQUPEVH?ikikTWi-[\P_[WSRb`rQU` {ÏJ¥ |-noSUVWTWikQRZrCEF"¡_ zOsHt`rY?irQUefHG`ZrC_HoY TWFqE^EZk[ZkQRTXPTW f O h ©¨HosEH?ikQR XH n<SRVXTWikQZkCEF"¡_ zZkC_[ZjqfH?irÛTWikF`-ZrCEH
Documents relatifs
Dans chaque ville et pour toutes les lignes de tramway considérées, il faudrait disposer des trafics avant et après ouverture d’une ligne et de plusieurs projections d’évolution
Le fait d’écrire à partir d’une oeuvre d’art visuelle ressemble à une forme de contrainte; nous croyons par ailleurs que cette pratique a eu un effet durable sur l’écriture
variables d'ordre psychologique: soit f.amiliale ou personnelle, soit so- ciale, soit professionnelle, soit une combinaison de ces facteurs. Ce patient a récupéré
For the two coolest objects in Figure 3.6, HD 4539 and PG 1716+426, both at Ta < 27, 000 K, there is a good match between the predicted synthetic spectra and the FUSE data: the
lui inculquer le registre li'lquistioue, les l1abitudes alimen- taires et vestimentaires ainsi que le comportement des bour- geois de Québec. Pierrette Paul doit
La conciliation emploi-famille : des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail Tableau 4 : Les dispositions favorisant la conciliation travailfamille dans les
Figure 2.4 Predicted (continuous lines) and observed values (filled circles: stands aged from trees with root collar; open circles: stands aged from trees without root collar)
Cette posture permet de dégager deux idées centrales : le poids des milieux professionnels locaux dans l’intermédiation et le transit des idées, modèles et pratiques
