HAL Id: jpa-00247567
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00247567
Submitted on 1 Jan 1991
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Spinodal decomposition in liquid crystalline materials
A. ten Bosch
To cite this version:
A. ten Bosch. Spinodal decomposition in liquid crystalline materials. Journal de Physique II, EDP
Sciences, 1991, 1 (8), pp.949-958. �10.1051/jp2:1991119�. �jpa-00247567�
J
Phys
II France I 11991) 949-958 AOOT 1991, PAGE 949Classificatlon
Physics
Abstracts64.70 64 60 61 30
Spinodal decomposition in liquid crystalline materials
A. Ten BOSCh
Laboratoire de
Physique
de la Matidre Condensie(*),
Parc Valrose, 06034 Nice Cedex, France(Received
5 December J990,accepted
mfinal form
26April J99J)
Abstract. The
theory
ofphase
separation m aliquid crystal by spinodal decompoSit1on
isdeveloped
The time evolution of twocoupled
parameters, the volume concentration (or molefraction),
and the orientational order parameter is calculated The conditions for penodic fluctuations are gJven and the structure factor for spinodaldecomposition
is studied1. Introduction.
The
dynamJcs
ofphase
separation inincompatible
solid or fluid mixtures has been studiedexpenmentally
as well astheoretically
m alarge
number of different systems frompolymers
to metals[I]. Cahn[2] proposed long
agothat,
besides the usualphase separation
m the metastable regionby
nucleation anddroplet growth,
a different process, calledspmodal decomposition,
may occur m the unstable region of thephase diagram.
Thepredicted
structure is descnbed in terms of a
superposition
ofpenodic
modulations of a fixed wavelength,
random mamplitude,
onentation andphase
On the otherhand,
Binder[1, 3]
fromresults on numerical simulation of cluster
growth, suggested
that there is no evidence of asharp
distinction between metastable and unstable states and that the process ofspinodal decomposition
can be viewed as ageneralized
nucleationphenomen.
Interest m this
problem
has been revivedby
the advent of a newtype
of matenal :liquid crystal polymers,
andby
the industnalapplications
of th~s matenal m compositedesign
Penodic versus random
dispersed
structures could beadvantageous
for mechanical(or other) properties
of thecomposite
and it is desirable to control and understand the fundamentalprocesses of
phase
separation in these systems New expenments in thebiphasic
region ofliquid crystal polymer
mixtures have beenreported Amsotropic droplets [4]
and even needle type structures[5]
have been observed and unusualpenodic
structures[6]
are formeddunng unmixing. Recently
neutronscattering
expenments have shown evidence ofspinodal decomposition
m the structure factor[7].
In the present paper weinvestigate spinodal
decomposition
in aliquid crystal
mixture. In asimple
model we show that concentration fluctuations need not beaccompanied by
order parameter fluctuations and that the range ofinstability,
the critical wavelength
and thegrowth
rate forspinodal decomposition
are not afsectedby
the presence ofliquid crystal
order for aquench
from theisotropic phase.
(*)
C N R S-U-A 1902.
Theory
forearly
time behador.2. I SIMPLE soLvENTs We consider first a solution of a
mesomorph~c
component in a non-mesomorph~c
matenal(simple
solvent orpolymer).
As discussed in theAppendix,
the free energy is givenby
F
=
(f(p,
«)
+j~ (VP )~
+~"
2(V«)~j
du.(2.1)
Here
lip,
«)
is the mean field free energydensity
of theinitially homogenous
matenal ofcomposition p
ofmesomorph~c component
with nematic orderparameter
S It has been useful to define the orderparameter
» « as theproduct
ofp
and the usual nematic orderparameter S The model free energy can then be wntten as a function of
p
and« alone.
lip, «) ~~~
=
gi*)- *Li«)
j 122)
with the
isotropic
part@=(in*+ii-*)inn-*)+*ii-*)x
L(«)
is the onentational entropy, which does not need to be considered in moredetail,
and uis the nematic mean field. The
degree
ofpolymenzation
is givenby L,
X is theisotropic
interaction parameter.
On
expanding
the free energy to includespatial
vanations mcomposition
and order parameter[9],
againonly
terms mVP
and V« occurWe therefore wnte in
(2. I)
terms inK~
andK~
due tocomposition
and « orderparameter
»fluctuations
respectively.
The kinetics of th~s systems are givenby
solutions of thedynamic
equations
[I]
for the conserved order parameterM
= r
v2 (- K~ v2~
+°f~*,
") j2.3)
at
d~
and for the nonconserved order parameter «
~"
= y
(K~ V~« ~~~~'" (2.4)
at am
r and y are mobilities for concentration of order parameter diffusion processes
respectively.
As usual
[2],
we look for a solutionlllilll 125)
where
(po, «o)
defines the initial average concentration and order parameters which fulfill the stationary state conditions~° ~o
~ ~"°
~~
~
~~ ~~
~~ Limo)
=
~~
= ~
°~o °~o
N 8 SPINODAL DECOMPOSITION IN
LIQUID
CRYSTALLINE MATERIALS 951Here R is a
generalized
chemicalpotential [8].
We consider aspatially homogenous
initial state and16 p,
&« denote the fluctuations around these valuesThe hnearised equations in Founer space are
3p 3p
w = M
(27)
3"~ 3"
Where the matrix is given
by
~ dL
rq2(q2 K~
+a
~~ @
(2.8)
~'
dL
y
(q2 K~
+fl
~
t
In order to obtain a nontnvial
solution,
the determlnent of the coefficients must vanish.This condition results in a relation between w and q
lW+rq~(q~K~+a))jw+yjq~K~+p))-yrq~())
=0.j2.9)
The two control parameters are a =
~~(, p
=~~(
dpo d«o
We will concentrate here On the case Of a
quench
from the initial disordered statefro =
0 and ~~
= 0
d«o
We find a solution w m0 for a finite range Of wave vectors from the first
parenthesis
Ofequation (2.9)
identical to theCahn-filhard theory [1, 2].
The condition on the concentrationpo
of the initial state is a < o or ~(<
o as in non
mesomorph~c
systems.dpo
Schematically,
the mixing free energy as a function of mole fractionp
at constant temperature can be given as an isotropic branch(«
= o at low values of
p
and ananisotropic
branch «
= 0 at
high
values of p. Phase separation occurs betweenpoints
ofequal
chemicalpotential
The twophases
can be both isotropic or one isotropic and oneanlsotropic phase [10].
The limits forstab1llty
ormetastability
of thequenched
fluidphase
are givenby
the conditions for thespmodal
of the isotropic branch. Within thespinodal
region of the isotropicbranch, phase separation
could takeplace though penodic composition
modulationsFor a
quench
from an initial isotropic state «o #0,
theequations (2 7)
aredecoupled.
The order parameter « is stable and we have apositive eigenvalue
associated with theinstab1llty
inconcentration p Similar to the results on
He3-He~ [1, 20],
the initial behaviour of the system afterquench
is one in which the conserved order parameterp
evolves towards a localequilibnum
state while the nonconserved orderparameter
remainsessentially
constantland equal
tozero).
The localequihbnum
state forp
w~llcorrespond
to one of the twoequihbnum
states
p~
or p_ on theisotropic
branch The transition to a stable anisotropic state could then takeplace,
forexample, through
nucleation of the anisotropicminority phase.
In
pnncipal,
aquench
from an initialhomogenous anisotropic phase
with mom o into abiphasic
zone is also feasible but has not yet been studiedexpenmentally
The situation is then morecomplex
and has not beenanalyzed
here. A new type ofspinodal decomposition
with
coupled
composition and order parameter fluctuations may then bepossible
fromequation (2.9).
2.2 BINARY MESOMORPHiC MiXTURES. We now go on to the
expenmental
situation of interest of abinary
mixture ofmesomorph~c components
The model free energy in this caseis given as
F
=
dr
I/i~,
«,«~)
+l~ iv~)~
+l' iv«1)~
K~2 ~
+
K,~(V«i
V«~)
+(V«~) (2.10)
2
Agaln lip, «1,«~)
is the free energydensity
of the initialhomogeneous phase.
Thecompos1tlon
ofcomponent
I is givenby p,
that ofcomponent
2by ii p)
The respectiveorientational « order parameters » are then «j and a~, again
products
of the usual nematic order parameters of thecomponents Si
and S~ and the relevant concentrations : «j =pS,,
«~ =
(l p)
S~(see Appendix)
The terms inK~, Kjj,
K~~ andKj~
takecompositional (K~)
and order parameter(K,~)
fluctuations in to account. The model free energy can bewntten as before
[8, lo].
lip,
«1,«~)
= g
i*) Lip,
«1«~) 12.i1)
where
~~~~
=
~
lnp
+~~
~~
ln
ii p)
+#(I #)
XKT
Li L2
L(~l,
"1,"2)
"
~l~l("1, "2)
+Ii
~L2("1, "2) (Ull "~
+ U22"~
~ U12 "1"2)
Lj(aj, a~)
andL~(aj, a~)
are the onentational entropies of the twoliquid crystalline components
and the terms in u,~ are the contnbutlons from the nematic mean fields.Lj
andL~
are thedegrees
ofpolyrnenzation.
Threedynamic equations
now control the kinetics ofphase separation
; one for the conserved vanable#
~4'
= r
v2 (- K~ v2~
+
°f j~,
«1,«~) j2.12)
St al
and two for the non-conserved variables «j, «~
~~~
= yi
(Kij V~«j
+Kj~ V~«~
~~ ii,
«j,
«2)
~~
~"~
(2.13)
~~~
= y~
K~~ V~«~
+Kj~ V~«j ~~ ii,
«j,
«~)
at
d«~
As before we investigate the existence of
penodic
fluctuations16 #, &«j, &«~)
around aninitial isotropic
phase.
After hneanzation of
equations (10)
andill),
the condition for existence of nontnvial solutions leads to thedispersion
relation. For an initial isotropic state with ml = «2 =0,
we find for the linearizedequations
in Founer space :&# #1
w
&"2~ &«j
=M3"2 Sal (2.14)
N 8 SPINODAL DECOMPOSITION IN
LIQUID
CRYSTALLINE MATERIALS 953Where the hneanzed matrix is now
rq ~(K~
q~ + a 0 0M
= 0 -1
°
(2_15)
z
=
Y>
iK»
q[
+P >i)
YiiK12 q[
+P12)
Y2(3°12
~ +~12) Y2(~°22
~ +~
22)The control parameters are
a #
~j~
,
fl
~j #
~~~
d
~
d« daj
The condition for a non-tnvlal solution is then det M
= 0 or
iw rq 21a
+K~ q2))
det z= o
Again
thecomposition
and orderparameter
instab1llties aredecoupled
We find aninstability
for #equivalent
to thespinodal
ofisotropic
mixtures for wl~ich «j and«~ remain constant
land equal
tozero)
A secondinstability
for «j and «~ at constant#
also exists for certain values of material constants and has been discussedpreviously Ill].
Which of the two instabilities will be chosen
depends
on the initial concentration, the finaltemperature
and the parameters of the mixture, inparticular
thephase diagram.
Theinstability
m composition occurs forquenches
witl~in thespinodal
curves of the isotropic mixture. Theinstability
in orderparameter
occurs for T<T*,
thelimiting temperature
formetastab1llty
of a stableisotropic
state m the mixture. At a giventemperature,
th~srequires
that the initial concentration
correspond
to a value for which theisotropic phase
is unstable after thequench.
The orderparameter
then evolves towards the valuecorresponding
to lower energy anisotropicphase (Figs
1,2)
T
Tc
-O
b ~
Spinodal
+
Fig
ITypical phase diagram
for a mixture of two mesogenlc components. The cntical temperatures 7~ (limite ofstab1llty
ofisotropic phase)
and T* (limit ofinstability
of isotropicphase)
aregiven
Atypical quench
from theisotropic phase
to within thespinodal ix
or to within the anisotropic zoneIO)
is marked.Free Energy F
ANisoTRopic 5'o
Concentration ?
Fig 2
Typical
free energy plot corresponding to figure I If thequench
results in point x spinodaldecomposition
of compos1tlon could occurleading
to a separation in isotropic states ~~, #_ If thequench
results in point O, penodic fluctuations of order parameter could occurleading
to an anisotropicstate #o
3. Calculations of the structure factor
[12, 131.
31 SOLUTIONS IN A NON-MESOMORPHIC SOLVENT We
Study
first SOlut1OnS m a non-mesomorphic
solvent. In these systems three correlation functions can be defined(&#~&#_~),
the fluctuation of concentration, givenby
the Founer transfortn&#~, (&a~ 8a~),
the fluctuation of «orderparameter
givenby &a~,
and the crosscoupling
correlation function
(
a~
3
#
~
These functions can be calculated from the set of
dynamic
equations(2.6). Following
the method of references[12]
and[13],
we mustsupplement
these equationsby
a random force~j~)
~
fq ~q
~
~~~~)
=M~~~~)
+~~ (31)
at
&«~ &«~ f~
Where M is the linear matrix glvcn earlier in
(2.8).
In vector form we wnte(
*
It)
=
Malt)
+ Git)
with a
it )
=
~
~~
~~~~&"q
We will
investigate
hereonly
correlations oversufficiently large distances,
so that the structure of theparticules
will notplay
a role The linearequation (3 2)
is solved as usuali
a = no
e~~
+e~~ o e~~~'Gil')
dt'(3 3)
leading
to the correlation functionsgiven by
thedyad inn *)~~
= a,
at
Inn *I
=
e~~~l I«o ail
+(2 M)-i Q(q)] (2 M~-~ Q(q)
~~'~~N 8 SPINODAL DECOMPOSITION IN
LIQUID
CRYSTALLINE MATERIALS 955We have used the
following
relations which holdby
definition[14]
:iG it)>
= o
iG it)
Git')>
=
Q iq) Sit t')
135)
and the coefficient
Q(q)
is related to theOnsager
coefficients~~
~(3.6) Q(q)
= 2 KT
/
Y
It is now
simple
to denve the static correlation functionsa a *
)
~ =
(2 M)-
'Q (q ) (3.7)
For a
quench
from theisotropic
state, we find for the static structure factorj
aw~ 2j
=~°~
~
13.8) K~ q~+
~ajo
The concentration fluctuations give identical behaviour to
spinodal decomposition
inisotropic liquid
mixtures. As intjese
systems, the static structure factor shows adivergency
at a cnticalwave
length q)=
~~~.
If the concentration#o
is within theisotropic spinodal,
°~o ~°~
exponential growth
of theintensity
with time ispredicted [14].
The crosscoupling
correlation functions are zero and for the order parameter fluctuations we findii&«qi~i
=
~
~~
~flj~~ ~~~~
«
~«j
Th~s is same form as for
homophase
fluctuations of the order parameter in theisotropic phase [15].
Thetypical divergency
at q = 0 of theamplitude
at the temperature T* of the mixture isfound T* is thus the
temperature
below which the isotropicphase
isabsolutely unstable,
andgiven
hereby
of d~f
o ~
~ o
am
d«2
'3.2 BINARY MIXTURE oF MESOGENS. An identical treatment can be made in the case of a
nuxture of two
liquid crystal
components. Forexample,
twoliquid crystal polymers
ofdifferent
degree
ofpolymenzation,
or a solution of aliquid crystal
and apolymer liquid crystal
have been studied inoptical
and in neutron scattenng expenments. In tins case two orderparameters
on each of thecomponents
exist. The correlation functions of interest arethe fluctuation of concentration, and the fluctuation of total «order
parameter»
« = «, + «~. The linear matnx for a
quench
from the isotropic state is givenby (2 15)
and the static structure factor is again of the form(3 8)
with behaviour as discussed m 3 On theother hand the order parameter fluctuations are
given by Sag (~)
=
~~~ ~~(- q~(Kll
+ 3°22 ~
~°12)
+ ~~
>2
~
>l
~
22)(3 1°)
det
~j
As discussed in 2.2 and in reference
[I I],
a second type of«spmodal
» can exist, with a cnticalwave vector for
divergency
of the scatteredamplitude,
which follows from the condition detjj
= 0
Decay
of the isotropic statethrough periodic
vanations of the orderparameter
can occurfor a
quench
from theisotropic phase
if the initial concentrationcorresponds
to a valuegreater
than the limit ofmetastabihty
of theisotropic phase.
The concentration remainsconstant
during
this process(Fig 1, 2).
Discussion.
In
conclusion,
we haveinvestigated
the existence ofperiodic
mstab1llties m the concentration and in the nematic order parameter forliquid crystal
mixtures. We have concentrated on theearly
stage, coarsepawed
limit of thephase
separation. We have shown that for a solution ofa
liquid crystal
m asimple solvent,
the usual isotropicspinodal composition
occurs forincompatible components
whenquenched
from thehomogenous isotropic phase.
ThJs resultsm a local metastable
isotropic phase
and can then be followedby
aphase
trans1tlonby
nucleation to a stableamsotropic phase
if such aphase
exists at the final concentration afterphase
separation. For a mixture of twoliquid crystal components,
the same scenano can takeplace.
In addition m certainmaterials,
if thequench
leads to an unstable(relative
to theanisotropic phase) isotropic phase,
aperiodic instability
of the order parameter can occur for which the concentration remains constant and wh~ch leads to a stableanisotropic phase.
In th~s paper, we have assumed the director fluctuations to be
damped
and the director to be fixedparallel
to an extemalmagnetic
field. Director fluctuations have been studied m reference[16]
and may beimportant
m non-onentedsamples. Strong
correlations mposition
may lead to concentration
dependence
of the constants of thegradient
termsK~,
K~
etc. Th~s would lead toh~gher
order terms and a different concentrationdependence
of the correlationlengths
of the fluctuations Such effects have been studied in isotropicpolymer
mixtures
[12]
We have concentrated on the
quench
from theisotropic phase
wh~chcorresponds
to thepresent expenmental procedure
and the present workapplies
to side chain[17j
as well asmain chain
[7] liquid crystal polymers
Concentration fluctuations withspinodal
type behavior should be visible m smallangle
neutronscattering
for which orderparameter
fluctuations would benegligable.
The case oflight
scattenng is morecomplex,
both concentration[18, 19]
and order parameter
[15]
fluctuationsplaying
a role Late stagedynamics [20]
can also be observed and would be of interest tostudy
as well as critical behavior[21]
as has been done mthe related case of
phase
separation withcoupled
conserved and nonconserved orderparameters
inHe~-He~
mixtures[22].
Appendix.
The free energy
density
of a solution of aliquid crystal polymer
and asimple
solvent has been derived in a mean fieldapproximation [8]
f(4r,«)= [(in~+ ji-~)inji-j)+~ji-~)xjKT-~Ljs,~)-~2us2j2jAi)
# is the volume concentration of the
liquid crystal polymer
with nematlcpolyTner
S. The first terms
give
theisotropic part
; the entropy ofmixing
and theisotropic
interactions.The fourth term L
IS,
#)
is calculated from the chainpartition
function anddepends
on the model of theliquid crystal
chain. The final term is the mean field contribution from the nematic interaction u corrected for the effect of dilutionby
a factor#.
The expression denvedm
(8)
for u is aspatial
average of thepairwise
orientationdependent
interaction.N 8 SPINODAL DECOMPOSITION IN
LIQUID
CRYSTALLINE MATERIALS 957The free energy of defornlation
f~ jr)
m onentationdependent
systems is given in reference [91.(x~
=ix,
y, z)
~~~~~ il~°~~~~"'~iPir,W~iPir,w~~w~w, ~~~~
The distribution function of
position
r and onentation w isp(r,w)
and the termc~~(w,w')
is related to the direct correlation function m thehomogenous
material. We consider monodomalnsamples
of uniformalignment
n.For
systems
charactenzedby
a second orderexpansion
mLegendre Polynomials Pi(w)
for aMaier-Saupe type
of amsotropicpotential
c~~
(w,
w'=
£
c~~, i Pi
(w ) Pi (w' ) (A3)
I o,2
We set as usual
PIT,
w)
=
~ jr) fir,
w),
wherefir, w)
is the orientational distribution function[23].
Thenfir,
w)dw
= I With the usual definition of the local nematic order
parameter
fir,
wP~(w
dw=
Sir ),
we findP
(r,
WP2(W>
dW= #r
jr) S(r)
= «
(r) (A4)
From
(A2)
to(A4),
we obtainFdir)
=
i ca~.o k
~(r) ) ~ ir)
+C«~.
2
k
«ir) ) «ir)1 iA5)
Consistent with the
symmetry
of the nematic for a radial distnbution ofliquid crystal entities,
equation(A5) simplifies
toF~jr)
=
( iV#r jr)
)~ +( iV«ir))~.
iA6)
If the
angular dependence
of distancedependent
correlations are considered in(A3),
aternl m
in.
V« )~ will appear m(A6)
and lead to directiondependent
order parameterfluctuations
[15].
Innonaligned samples
fluctuations in the director n could also occur[15].
The
K~
term is well known from interfacial anddynamic
studies onincompatible
mixtures[12]
The term in the elastic constantK~
relative to the nematic order parameter(VS)~
has been used in studies of thebiphase
of pureliquid crystals [15, 23]
In the present case,coupling
between order parameter and concentrationgradients
also occursTo denve the model free energy m the mixture of
mesomorph~c
components, theproceedure
is identical. The nematic order parameters on each individualcomponent
aregiven
by Si
and 6~, the volume concentrations are#
and I#
Asbefore,
we find that the free energydensity
can be written as a function of #, «, =pS,
and «~ =ii p ) 6~
and theirgradients.
References
[1] GUNTON J D., SAN MIGUEL M.,
chapt
3, Phase transitions and cnticalphenomena
», Eds C.Domb, J C Lebowitz, Vol 8
(Academic
Press, London,1983)
[2] CAHN J. W, J ChemPhys
42(1965)
93.[3] BINDER K, STAUFFER D., Adv Phys 25
(1976)
343.[4] CASAGRANDE C, VEYSSIE M, KNOBLER C M,
Phys
Rev. Lent 58(1987)
2079.[5] D'ALLEST J F., Thesis,
University
of Nice(1988)
[6] CASAGRANDE C, FABRE P., GUEDEAU M A, VEYSSIt M,
Europhys
Lett 3(1987)
73[~
FRIED F, LANSAC Y, SIXOU P, BLUMSTErN A, BLUMSTEIN R, 33 IUPACSymposium
onMacromolecules, Montreal
(1990)
[8] TEN BOSCH A, PINTON J, MAiSSA P., SIXOU P, J.
Phys
A 20(1987)
453[9] PONIEWIERSKI A, STECKI J, Mol.
Phys
38(1979)
1931 [10] MAiSSA P, SIXOU P., Liquid Crystals S (1989) 1861[11] LANSAC Y, TEN BOSCH A., J Chem
Phys (in press)
[12] BINDER K, J Chem
Phys
79(1983)
6387[13] COOK H E, Acta
Metallurgica
18(1970)
297[14]
METIU H., KITAHARA K, ROSS J,Chapt.
4 m « Fluctuation Phenomena », Eds. E W Montroll, J L. Lebowitz (North HollandPhysics Pubhshlng,
Amsterdanl,1976).
[15] SHENG P., PRIESTLEY E B.,
Chapt
10 m Introduction toliquid
crystals », Eds ED B Pnestley, PWojtowicz,
PSheng (Plenum
Press, New York,1974).
[16] SHIMADA T, DOI M, OKANO K, J Chem Phys 88
(1988)
2815,DOI M, SHIMADA T, OKANO K, J Chem
Phys.
88(1988)
4070ii?]
NOIREz L, thesis, UnlvOrsay (1989)
p 167[18]
VAN DER SCHOOT P, ODIJK T, J ChemPhys
93(1990)
3580[19] KOBERSTEIN J, RUSSELL T. P, STEIN R. S, J.
Polymer
ScilPolym Phys.
Ed ) 17(1979)
1719.[20] SAN MIGUEL M, GUNTON J D, DEE G, SAHNI P S,
Phys
Rev B 23(1981)
2334[21] HOHENBERG P C., HALPERIN B I, Rev Mod
Phys
49(1977)
435.[22] HOHENBERG P C., NELSON D R.,
Phys
Rev. B 20(1979)
2665[23] TELO DA GAMA M M, THURTELL J H, J Chem Sac