Quadratic Integral Solutions to Double Pell Equations
FRANCESCOVENEZIANO(*)
ABSTRACT - We study the quadratic integral pointsÐthat is, (S-)integral points defined over any extension of degree two of the base fieldÐon a curve defined in P3by a system of two Pell equations. Such points belong to three families ex- plicitly described, or belong to a finite set whose cardinality may be explicitly bounded in terms of the base field, the equations defining the curve and the setS.
We exploit the peculiar geometry of the curve to adapt the proof of a theorem of Vojta, which in thiscase doesnot apply.
1. Introduction
LetCbe an irreducible curve defined over a number fieldk. We know, depending on the genus, the general structure of C(Q); on the other hand, of courseC(Q) is always infinite, so it is natural to ask what hap- pensif we consider algebraic pointsup to some fixed degree overQ.
Abramovich and Harrisin [AH91], and also Silverman and Vojta in [HS91, Voj91, Voj92] were among the first to study the set of points P2 C(Q) s uch that [k(P) :k]d, in particular whether it isinfinite or not.
In thispaper we deal with the analogousproblem forintegral points, sticking to the special case of d2. This case was already studied in generality by Corvaja and Zannier in [CZ04, Corollary 1] using Schmidt's Subspace Theorem.
We will further specialise the problem to curves defined by a double Pell equation, such as, for example,
y22x21 z23x21:
( 1
(*) Indirizzo dell'A.: Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa, Piazza dei Cavalieri, 7, 56126 Pisa.
E-mail: f.veneziano@sns.it
Double equationsof thiskind are historically relevant, being among the first curves of genus 1 ever studied.1
Of course, by Siegel's theorem on integral points on curves, there are only finitely many solutions inZto (1), but it may be easily seen that there are infinitely many solutions in algebraic integers of degree 2 overQ: in fact it is classically known that each Pell equation x2 dy21 hasin- finitely many integral solutions whendis a positive integer not a square, so one can solve the first equation to find infinitely many (xn;yn) such that y2n 2x2n1, and then setzn
3x2n1
p ; in thisway we can actually find three infinite families of solutions. We will fully describe the set of quadratic integral pointson these curvesand give a geometrical meaning to the familiesjust mentioned.
Going back to the general context, Abramovich and Harrisconjectured that the set ofP2 C(Q) such that [k(P) :k]disinfinite (up to a finite extension of the basefieldk) if and only if there exists some non constant morphismW:C !Xof degree at mostd, whereXiseitherP1or an elliptic curveEwithjE(k)j 1.
Note that thiscondition isobviously sufficient; ifWisdefined overkthe preimage throughWof a rational point inXisa point of degree at mostdinC.
While the general conjecture wasproved false by Dabarre and Fahlaoui in [DF93], Abramovich and Harris managed to prove it in some cases as, for example, whend2;3.
The first step in their proofs was to consider the d-fold symmetric product of the curve, C(d); this is a variety whose set of points may be identified with the set of all unordered d-tuplesof pointsofC. Pointsof degree at mostdonCnaturally correspond tok-rational pointsonC(d), s o the said authors could work on the varietyC(d) and apply results by Falt- ingsafter mappingC(d) in an abelian variety.2
If we consider only points of degree 2 over the base field, the existence of infinitely many quadratic rational points is surely necessary to have in- finitely many quadraticintegralpoints, but it is not sufficient, as we shall see.
In [CZ04] Corvaja and Zannier prove a theorem on integral pointson surfaces and apply it toC(2)to get the following theorem:
THEOREM1. LetC~be a projective non-singular curve defined over a number field k, and C C n fQ~ 1;. . .;Qrg be an open affine subset, for
(1) See for instance [Wei07] or [Mor69] for a discussion of some classical cases.
(2) For an account on thisproblem see [EE93].
distinct Qi2C(k). Then~
1. If r5 then C contains only finitely-many quadratic-integral points over k;
2. If r4there exist finitely many rational mapsc: ~C !P1of degree 2 such that all but a finite number of the quadratic-integral points onC over k are sent toP1(k)by at least one of these maps.
Asit happensfor the structure of thek-integral points, what matters in thisproblem isthe number of pointsat infinity.
2. Setting and statement
Asmentioned above, thispaper will study quadratic integral pointson some special curves inP3of genus1 and with 4 pointsat infinity, defined by a double Pell-like equation; let thena;b;c;dbe algebraic integerssuch that abcd60 andad bc60, and letCbe the affine curve inA3defined by
y2ax2c z2bx2d:
( 2
Let~Cbe itsprojective completion, defined by homogeneousequations Y2aX2cW2
Z2bX2dW2: (
Let usindicate with P1;P2;P3;P4 the four pointsat infinity of ~C n C, which, in the coordinates(X:Y:Z:W) are the points
P1:(1:
pa :
pb :0) P2:(1:
pa
:
pb :0) P3:(1:
pa :
pb :0) P4:(1:
pa
:
pb :0):
Letkbe a number field containing
pa
;
pb
;candd, and letS Mka finite set of absolute values ofkcontaining all the archimedean onesand all the primesincd(bc ad); letsbe the cardinality ofS.
THEOREM2. The set of quadratic S-integral points onCis the union of:
Three families consisting of the preimages through the three
mapsC !P1
(x;y;z)7!(x;y) (x;y;z)7!(x;z) (x;y;z)7!(y;z) of the S-integral points ofP1;
A finite set of cardinality at most22835s3;
A finite and effectively computable set whose cardinality is at most321121(sH 1)1, where H is the class number of OS.
REMARK3. The three familiesof quadratic pointsare indeed easy to spot. If for example the first of the two Pell equations definingC hasin- tegral solutions (xn;yn), then (xn;yn;
bx2nd
p ) are quadratic integral pointsonC. Similarly if (xn;zn) are integral solutions to the second equa- tion, then we have a second family (xn;
ax2nc
p ;zn), and if (yn;zn) are integral solutions toby2n az2n bc ad, we get
y2n c a r
;yn;zn
! for a subsequence of (yn;zn).
REMARK4. We also note that this theorem allows for a bound on the number of exceptional solutions outside the three infinite families, while Theorem 1 doesnot.
While the Subspace theorem isnot effective, there isa semi-effective version due to Evertse which provides an explicit bound for thenumberof exceptional hyperplanes; it is not possible, however, to use it in the proof of Theorem 1 to get such a bound for the quadratic integral points. This is because, in the proof of Theorem 1, the Subspace theorem is applied to a surface, and each exceptional hyperplane for the Subspace Theorem gives an exceptional curve on thissurface which may contain pointscorre- sponding to quadratic integral points; but even if we can bound the number of such curves, they are not effectively computable and so it is not possible to bound the number of pointson them.
REMARK 5. We finally remark that we can not expect in general a bound for the finite sets of points which is uniform in the coefficients a;b;c;d; for example it isknown3that there isa constantC>0 such that for infinitely many positive integers A, the number of positive integer solutions to the equationX3Y3 AexceedsC
logA p3
.
(3) This result is essentially due to Mahler in [Mah35] and improved by Silverman in [Sil83].
3. Sketch of the proof
To study quadratic integral points we proceed as [AH91] and [CZ04]
and consider the symmetric square of the affine curveC, which isdefined asthe quotient of the productC Cby the involution which exchangesthe couple (P;Q) with the couple (Q;P). Thisquotient isan irreducible surface which can be identified with the set of unordered couples of points, and the quotient map is
C C !W C(2) (P;Q)7! fP;Qg:
Consider a pointPdefined on a field of degree 2 overk, and letP0be its conjugate. Then the point fP;P0g on C(2) isfixed by every Galoisauto- morphism ofQ=k, and hence isdefined over k. If furthermorePisan in- tegral point so is the pointfP;P0g.4
The special geometry of curves defined by double Pell equations carries to their symmetric square and allows one to study quadratic integral points directly and to give an explicit description of the maps mentioned in Theorem 1; for the proof we will mimic the proof of a theorem by Vojta ([Voj87]):
THEOREM 6 (Vojta). Let V a projective, nonsingular variety over a number field k. Let r be the rank of the group of k-rational points ofPic0(V), rthe rank of the NuÃÁron-Severi group of V and D a divisor with at least dimVrr1distinct irreducible components, all defined over k. Then all sets of quasi-S-integral points on V n jDjare degenerate.
REMARK 7. Thistheorem hasbeen improved later by Vojta himself, removing the assumptions on the Pic0, in [Voj96] and also by Noguchi and Winkelmann in [NW02].
While thistheorem doesnot apply to our case, the proof adaptswell because on the curveCthe difference of any two pointsat infinity istorsion in the Picard group.
The first step of the proof, following the strategy already illustrated, will be to study instead the structure of the set of integral points on the surfaceC(2)obtained by taking the symmetric square of the original curve.
(4) See, for example, [Ser88] for more on the symmetric product.
We will then follow the proof of Theorem 6 and build three functions a;b;g without zeroesand poleson C(2). These functions, up to constant factors, take integral points of the symmetric square toS-units.
We will then find a relation amonga;b;g, so that taking them as co- ordinatesgivesa map fromC(2) to the subvariety of G3m defined by this relation; it will turn out that thisrelation islinear.
Thismeansthat the functionsa;b;g take integral pointsofC(2) to so- lutionsof theS-unit equation, which isthe object of the following theorem.
THEOREM8 (Evertse, [Eve95]). Let k be a number field, let S be a finite set of places of k containing all the archimedean ones, let s jSjand let a1;. . .;an2Q. Let A0(a1;. . .;an;OS) be the number of non degenerate solutions x1;. . .;xn2 OSto the equation
a1x1. . .anxn1;
3
where a solution(x1;. . .;xn)is calleddegenerateif there is a proper van- ishing subsum in the left hand side of(3).Then
A0(a1;. . .;an;OS)235n4s:
Using this theorem we will then proceed to bound the number of non degenerate solutions and to examine degenerate solutions, which come from special subvarieties.
We will show that three of these special subvarieties are curves of genus 1, hence each givesonly a finite number of quadratic integral points, while the other three have genus0 and give three familiesof quadratic integral points.
The strategy outlined here would also work for any variety such that the difference of any two components of the divisor at infinity is torsion in the Picard group.
4. Proof Theorem 2 Three functions onC
Let usconsider the functions f Y
pa X
W cW
Y
pa X gZ
pb X
W dW
Z
pb X h
b p Y
pa Z
W (bc ad)W
pb
Y
pa Z:
They are functionson the curveCdefined overk.
By explicit computation one has xf2 c
2
pa
f g2 d 2
pb g yf2c
2f bc adh2 2
pb h zg2d
2g bc ad h2 2
pa
h ;
so we have that
k(f)k(x;y); k(g)k(x;z); k(h)k(y;z);
andk(C) hasdegree 2 over each of them.
The divisors of the three functions are (f)P3P4 P1 P2 (g)P2P4 P1 P3
(h)P1P4 P2 P3:
These three functions are ink[C], as we can see by their explicit expres- sions and the expressions for their inverses, or by observing that their di- visors are supported on the points at infinity.
By direct computation using the first and then the second definition of f;g;hone immediately checks that they satisfy the linear relations
b p f
pa gh (4a)
c
pb f
d
pa g h:
(4b)
Three functions onC(2)
Let us now consider the Cartesian productC Cgiven by equations y2ax2c
z2bx2d y02ax02c z02bx02d;
8>
>>
>>
<
>>
>>
>:
and let usindicate byf0;g0;h0 the functionscorresponding tof;g;hin the primed variables. Let C(2) be the symmetric product of C obtained from C Casa quotient by the action ofZ=2Zthat actsswapping the two co- ordinates.
The ring of regular functionsoverC(2)isAk[C C]Z=2Z, the subring of k[C C] consisting of the functions invariant for this action, and the pointsofC(2)can be thought asunordered couplesof pointsonC.
C C !p C(2)
k[x;y;z;x0;y0;z0]A:
Let usdenote bypthe quotient map fromC CtoC(2).
LetPbe a quadratic integral point onC, and letP0be itsconjugate.
The pair (P;P0) isa quadratic integral point onC C, and the unordered couplefP;P0g isan integral point onC(2) which isfixed by any Galoisau- tomorphism overkbecause any such morphism either fixes bothP;P0or swaps them.
The pointfP;P0gistherefore defined overk.
Let usnow define three functions a cd
ff0gg0(y
pa
x)(y0
pa
x0)(z
pb
x)(z0
pb x0)=cd bc(bc ad)
ff0hh0 (y
pa
x)(y0
pa x0)(
pb
y
pa z)(
pb
y0
pa
z0)=c(bc ad) gd(ad bc)
gg0hh0 (z
pb
x)(z0
pb x0)(
pb
y
pa z)(
pb
y0
pa
z0)=d(ad bc) 1
aff0gg0
cd (y
pa
x)(y0
pa
x0)(z
pb
x)(z0
pb x0)=cd 1
b ff0hh0
c(bc ad)(y
pa
x)(y0
pa x0)(
pb
y
pa z)(
pb
y0
pa
z0)=c(bc ad) 1
g gg0hh0
d(ad bc)(z
pb
x)(z0
pb x0)(
pb
y
pa z)(
pb
y0
pa
z0)=d(ad bc):
We clearly see that they belong to k[C(2)], and so do their inverses; the functionsa;b;gare the three regular and nonvanishing functions that we need to follow Vojta'sstrategy and viewC(2)asa subvariety ofG3m.
The functionsa;b andgare defined on a surface, so they must be al- gebraically dependent. Our next step is to find a relation between them.
Multiplying together equation (4a) for the primed and unprimed vari- ablesone gets
hh0bff0agg0
pab
(f0gfg0);
5
doing the same for equation (4b) gives hh0c2b
ff0 d2a
gg0 cd
pab 1 f0g 1
fg0
: 6
If we now multiply (6) by ff0gg0
cd and subtract it from (5), after some tidying up and using the definitions fora;b;gwe obtain
abg1:
Computing degrees
From what we have said until now we have the mappings C C !p C(2)(a;b;g)! HG3m
whereHisthe subvariety ofG3mdefined byXYZ1.
The corresponding homomorphisms between the rings of regular functionsare
k X;Y;Z; 1 XYZ
[Z!7!1 X Y]k X;Y; 1
XY(1 X Y)
X7!a Y7!b
!Ak[C C]:
To find the degree of the mapC(2)(a;b;g)! Hwe must find the degree [k(C(2)):k(a;b;g)]:
One findsdirectly that (ff0)2 c2g
ab, so that [k(ff0;gg0):k(a;b;g)]2, and from
f2 c pa
f g2 d pb
g (ff0)2 cf2
pa
(ff0)f (gg0)2 dg2 pb
(gg0)g
followsthat [k(f;f0;g;g0):k(ff0;gg0)]4, so by our previous remarks we have
[k(C C):k(a;b;g)][k(f;f0;g;g0):k(a;b;g)]
[k(f;f0;g;g0):k(ff0;gg0)][k(ff0;gg0):k(a;b;g)]8:
Obviously [k(C C):k(C(2))]2, asthere are two ordered pairsfor a generic unordered couple; therefore we can conclude that the degree of the map given bya;b;gbetweenC(2)andHisat most four.
IfPisan S-integral point onC(2)the values a(P);b(P);g(P) will be S- integers, and so will be their inverses 1
a(P); 1 b(P); 1
g(P).
The pointPwill then provide a solution inOS of the equation x1x2x31:
Non degenerate solutions
Theorem 8 tellsusthat there are only finitely-many non degenerate solutions, and that we can bound their number. If we apply the theorem with n3 we obtain that the number of non degenerate triples (a;b;g)2Hisat most 23534s22835s.
We already bounded in the previousparagraph the degree of the map (a;b;g), which isat most four. For every integral point on C(2) we have two quadratic integral pointsonC, hence the number of quadratic integral pointson C corresponding to non degenerate solutions is at most 22835s3.
Degenerate solutions
The degenerate solutions to abg1 are those with a subsum equal to 0, that isthose for which one of the three functionsa;b;gisequal to 1; let usthen define
Wa:a1; Wb :b1; Wg :g1 the subsets ofC(2)thusobtained.
Using the definition ofa;b;gwe see that, for example,
a1; b g
ff0gg0 cd; c(bc ad)
ff0hh0 d(ad bc) gg0hh0 ff0cgg0
d c2; ff0cgg0 d (ff0)2 c2; gg0ff0 c d
and similarly for the other two cases, so we see thatWa;Wb;Wgare com- posed of two subvarieties each, and
WaWx [Wx WbWy [Wy WgWz [Wz; where
Wx :ff0c;gg0d Wx:ff0 c;gg0 d Wy :ff0 c;hh0ad bc Wy:ff0c;hh0bc ad Wz :gg0 d;hh0bc ad Wz:gg0d;hh0da bc:
These six subvarieties give all degenerate solutions; to understand them better we use the following simple lemma:
LEMMA9. Let P((x;y;z);(x0;y0;z0))2 C C. Then ff0(P) c)x x0and y y0;
gg0(P) d)x x0and z z0;
hh0(P) (bc ad))z z0and y y0. PROOF. For example, ifff0cthen
x0(f0)2 c 2
pa
f0 c2=f2 c 2
pa
c=f c f2 2
pa
f x;
and similarly for the other five cases. p
If we define six subvarieties ofC C
Vx:x x0;y y0;z z0 Vy:x x0;y y0;z z0 Vz:x x0;y y0;z z0;
then the lemma tellsusthat each of them correspondsthrough pto the similarly named subvarietyWx;y;z ofC(2)(we denote byVx;y;z any of the six varietiesVx;Vx;Vy;Vy;Vz;Vz, and we do the same withWx;y;z ). In short we have that
pjV
x;y;z :Vx;y;z !Wx;y;z
Note also thatVx;y;z ' Cthrough the projection on the first component of C C, so that these six curves all have genus one.
Points on Wx;y;z
Consider for example
pjVx :Vx!Wx
((x;y;z);(x; y; z))7! f(x;y;z);(x; y; z)g:
A generic point in Wx hastwo preimages, obtained by exchanging the order of the pair; the points which have just one primage are those such thatyz0, but we see from the defining equations (2) ofCthat thiscan never happen becauseby2 az2bc ad60. The mappjVxistherefore an unramified covering ofWx, and the Riemann-Hurwitz formula tellsus that
02g(Vx) 22(2g(Wx) 2) g(Wx)1:
The same is true forWyandWz, because there is no point onCwhere two ofx;y;zboth vanish.
We have thus shown that the three subvarietiesWx;y;z are all curvesof genus 1, so they carry only a finite number of integral points, which in turn correspond to a finite number of quadratic integral points onC.
We might also argue the finiteness of quadratic integral points coming from the curvesWx;y;z asfollows: letKk(
pe
) be a quadratic extension of k, we may supposee2 OS; letP(x0;y0;z0) be aK-integral point on C, andP0(x00;y00;z00) itsconjugate. Suppose that (P;P0) belongstoVx; if it is so, after enlarging S to anS0 so thatOS0 hastrivial classgroup, we can writex0 t;y0u
pe
;z0v
pe
for somet;u;v2 OS0.
Substituting back into the equations forCwe getbeu2 aev2bc ad, soedividesbc ad; differente differing only by a square factor give the same extension, and given that OS0=(OS0)2 isfinite we see that K must
belong to a finite set of extensions ofk, whose cardinality may be bounded in termsof the cardinality ofS0.
We know, by Siegel'stheorem, that there are only finitely many in- tegral pointsonCdefined over a fixed number field; sinceChasfour points at infinity, thisnumber may be bounded effectively, asdone in [CZ03], in termsof the degree ofK and the cardinality of the extension ofS0 toK, which in turn are both bounded in termsofkandjS0j.
The computationsinvolved in thisbound are quite heavy, but again the special structure of the curve C providesuswith a simpler argument:
equation (4a) givesthe unit equation
b p f
h (P)
a p g
h (P)1;
7
so the number of solutions may be easily bounded using again Theorem 8.
For a fixedKand extensionS00of the set of absolute valuesS0, there are at most 23524jS00j21120jS0j solutions; the number of extensions K isat most jOS0=(OS0)2j 2jS0j; the functionsf=handg=hhave degree two, aswe can see computing their divisors, so each solution gives at most two points. Com- bining all, we have that the number of quadratic integral pointsPsuch that (P;P0) lieson any of theWx;y;z isat most 321121jS0j1321121(sH 1)1, whereHisthe classnumber ofOS.
I thank the anonymous referee for suggestions about this bound.
We should also remark that, since the relevant curve has genus 1, it is in fact possible, as is well known, to boundthe heightof the solutions them- selves; tha same can be done on equation (7), using effective results ontwo- termunit equations(derived from Baker'stheory of linear formsin loga- rithms). So the quadratic integral points arising from Wx;y;z are, in fact, effectively computable (in contrast with those arising from the ``non de- generate solutions'').
Points on Wx;y;z
Reasoning as we did before, we consider, for example pjVx :Vx !Wx
((x;y;z);( x;y;z))7! f(x;y;z);( x;y;z)g:
Thisisagain a map of degree 2.
In this case however, we see that it is ramified at points wherex0, and there are 4 such points onC, namely (0;
pc
;
pd
), each of them of
course ramified of index 2. Therefore this time applying the Riemann- Hurwitz formula we obtain
02g(Vx) 22(2g(Wx 2)4 g(Wx)0;
asWx hasgenus0, it may contain infinitely many integral points.
The composition of the maps
C ! Vx ! Wx pj!Wxfby2 az2bc adg (x;y;z)7!((x;y;z);( x;y;z))7!f(x;y;z);( x;y;z)g 7! (y;z) givesa map of degree two fromCto a curve of genus0, that takesquadratic integral pointsarising fromWx to integral points; this map together with the same compositions forWy andWz, that is,
C ! fz2bx2dg (x;y;z) 7! (x;z);
and
C ! fy2ax2cg (x;y;z) 7! (x;y);
are the mapsin Theorem 1.
Acknowledgments The author thanks Professors Corvaja, Evertse and Zannier for the substantial advice received in the preparation of this article, and the anonymousreferee for the thorough report and for having suggested some improvements.
REFERENCES
[AH91] D. ABRAMOVICH - J. HARRIS, Abelian varieties and curves in Wd(C), Compositio Math.,78, 2 (1991), pp. 227-238.
[CZ03] P. CORVAJA- U. ZANNIER,On the number of integral points on algebraic curves, J. Reine Angew. Math.,565(2003), pp. 27-42.
[CZ04] P. CORVAJA- U. ZANNIER,On integral points on surfaces, Ann. of Math.
(2),160, 2 (2004), pp. 705-726.
[DF93] O. DEBARRE- R. FAHLAOUI, Abelian varieties in Wdr(C)and points of bounded degree on algebraic curves, Compositio Math.,88, 3 (1993), pp.
235-249.
[EE93] Edited by B. EDIXHOVEN- J.-H. EVERTSE,Diophantine approximation and abelian varieties, Lecture Notesin Mathematics, vol. 1566, Spring- er-Verlag, Berlin (1993), Introductory lectures, Papers from the con- ference held in Soesterberg, April 12-16, 1992.
[Eve95] J.-H. EVERTSE, The number of solutions of decomposable form equa- tions, Invent. Math.,122, 3 (1995), pp. 559-601.
[HS91] J. HARRIS- J. SILVERMAN, Bielliptic curves and symmetric products, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.,112, 2 (1991), pp. 347-356.
[Mah35] K. MAHLER, On the lattice points on curves of genus 1, Proc. London Math. Soc.,39(1935), pp. 431-466.
[Mor69] L. J. MORDELL,Diophantine equations, Pure and Applied Mathematics, Vol. 30, Academic Press, London (1969).
[NW02] J. NOGUCHI- J. WINKELMANN,Holomorphic curves and integral points off divisors, Math. Z.,239, 3 (2002), pp. 593-610.
[Ser88] J.-P. SERRE, Algebraic groups and class fields, Graduate Textsin Mathematics, vol. 117, Springer-Verlag, New York (1988), Translated from the French.
[Sil83] J. H. SILVERMAN,Integer points on curves of genus1, J. London Math.
Soc. (2),28, 1 (1983), pp. 1-7.
[Voj87] P. VOJTA,Diophantine approximations and value distribution theory, Lecture Notesin Mathematics, vol. 1239, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1987).
[Voj91] P. VOJTA, Arithmetic discriminants and quadratic points on curves, Arithmetic algebraic geometry (Texel, 1989), Progr. Math., vol. 89, BirkhaÈuser Boston, Boston, MA (1991), pp. 359-376.
[Voj92] P. VOJTA, A generalization of theorems of Faltings and Thue-Siegel- Roth-Wirsing, J. Amer. Math. Soc.,5, 4 (1992), pp. 763-804.
[Voj96] P. VOJTA, Integral points on subvarieties of semiabelian varieties. I, Invent. Math.,126, 1 (1996), pp. 133-181.
[Wei07] A. WEIL, Number theory, Modern BirkhaÈuser Classics, BirkhaÈuser Boston Inc., Boston, MA (2007), An approach through history from Hammurapi to Legendre, Reprint of the 1984 edition.
Manoscritto pervenuto in redazione l'11 ottobre 2010.