Proof by reflection in semantics
21
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Proof by reflection in semantics Kuntal Das Barman — Yves Bertot. N° 5134 Mars 2004. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5134--FR+ENG. THÈME 2. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !"# $&%('*),+.-/&+.012+.345+.'76 8:9.;<0:1;<3)>=.) ?@*B>A CBD"EGFB>H IKJLBNMPORQSJPTUJLBM BVceTUWXd MYTUZ[M]\_^KC`aORMPJYb<Z[B OXfgBUVh\ijBC2C#B k WRlmlmO d VonKB d BT @ B d T @ B7I.pqKr>sXtuEwvW d \DXxSxXtEyr,zl[WRQRB\. {}| ~,[RR O<IS SBI<V_JPOSImWXMoWRl[l d OSWST @ V_OnKB\hT d JY`mBV @ B&\BC2WRI<VJPT\ORl d ORQ d WSC#C#JYIKQMYWRIKQ<Z[WXQSB Zm\Z[WRMLMP^ d BUMP^OSI d BUMYWXV_JPOSIm\UJPIlmW d V_JYTUZKMYW d JYI[n[ZmTV_JP RB d BMPWRV_JPOSI[\<JPCZKMYWXV_JYIKQl d ORQ d WSCBUB>TUZKVJLO<I V @ BI d BMLdJPB\d OSIl d OOX\BW d T @ VO<OSMP\uBnKB\hk T d JP`aB}WZ[I[TUV_JPOSI[WRMWSl[l d OSWRT @ VOWSd ZKV_O<C#@ WRV_Bl d OOX\ WS`mO<ZKVl OSQ WRC2C#JPI[QMYWRIKQ<Z[WXQSB\_B>C2WRI<V_JYTU\ BUmBTUV_JPOSIJP\NZ[\BnV_O:VWSXBWRTUV\ O<CV B2TUOSI<V_BUKV JYI<V_OWRTUTUd OSZ[I<V ?@ BoC2WXJYITO<I<V d JP`[Z[V_JPOSINORmV @ JYd \eO d JY\ V @ WX@ VBnKB RBMLO<lmB>n"W \^K\_VBC2WXVJPTeWRdl[l d d O<WRT @ VOnKB\hT JY`mBNWRImn}C2WRI[JPl[Z[MPWRV_B"Z[I[IKOI}B[l B\h\JLO<I[\JPIV B"\_^KC`aORMPJYTTUOSC2l[ZKVhWXVJLO<I}ORl ORQ WSC2\ O d O d C#WRMl d OdOXnKBU SBUMPOSl[C#BI<V ?@ BV_OORMoBO<`KVWRJPI5JP\WS\_VB d WRI[n C#O d BlaOeB d Z[MeV @ WRI V @ B TUOSI< RB>I<V_JPOSI[WRM.l OOXV_OORMY\U ¡:¢<£¥¤h¦§a,¨~R O d C2WRM]CBV @ OKn[\KV©^KlmBNV @ BUO d ^SKTUWXMYTUZ[MPZ[\oORTUOSI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\\BC2WSISVJPT\U d BaBTVJLO<I. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(6) :N : &":
(7) "#( ¢ ~¢ ijB>\ WRl[l d OKT @ B>\TUOSI< RB>ISVJLO<I[IKBMLMPB\#lmO<Z d nB>H T d J d BMYW\KB>H C#WSI<V_JYb<Z[BnKB>\2MPWSIKQSWRQRB>\nKB l d OSQ d WRC2C2WXV_JPOSI d BlaOS\BI<V @ WS`KJLVhZKBUMPMPBC#d BI<V2\Z d nKB\ d BUMYWXdV_JPOSImd \U(BI5l[W d V_JYTUZKMPJPB d \hZ d nKB\ d BUMYWXdV_JPOSIm\ JYI[n[ZmTV_JP RB>\Ud @ Id la@ BZKVNB>I[d\hZKJLVB#\JYCZKMPB M BUed B>H TUZKVJLO<InKB l ORd Q WS@ C2CB>\ B>I&WRJP\hWRI<V OSdI[TUV_JPOSI[IKB nKB\d O<ZKV_JPMY\nKB B>T d B T B n[B"d l B>ZK RBS d OSZ[\nBH T JP ROSIm\ZmIKBNWRl[l OKT B OSI[d TUV_JPOSd I[IKBMLMPBNlmO<Z WRZ[V_OSC2WR@ V_JY\_B MPB\d nBH C#OSI[\V WXVJLO<I[\olmO VhWRI<Vd \Z d MPW2\KdBH C2WRI<VJPbZKBNnKB>\MPWSIKQSWRQRB>\enKA B"l OSQ WRC2C2WXV_JPOSI] iW CBH V OKnKB n[B BUH mBKdJPOSIB>\_VZ[V_JPMLJY\KBH B"lmd O<Z l BImn d BB>ITUOSC2lKVBMPB\d WXJPV\nB_H f W TO<I[IZ[\n[WRIm\oMLB"TUOSI<V_BUVBNnKBNMPW nBH C#d OSI[\@ V WXVJLO<I*"iWTUOSI<V JY`[ZKd V_JPOSIud l d JPI[TUJPlmWXMPBnKB Td B2V W, WXJPM(B\VNb<Z[B#IKO<Z[\NW, RO<I[\neBUH SBUMPOSl[lB2H Z[IKB WSl[l d OKT d B\^K\_VKBH C2WXVJPdbZKBlaOSZ neBH T J BoBV C#WSIKJYl[d ZKMPB nKB>\d JYI[TO<I[IZKB\n[WSI[\ M BUeBH TUZ[V_JPOSI#\_^KC`aORMPJYb<Z[B n[B#l d ORQ WSC2CB"laOSZ MPB2neBUH SBUMPOSl[laBC#BI<VnKd B#l @ B>ZK RB>\O C#BUMPMLB>\U i O<ZKV_JPMb<Z[B#IKO<Z[\ OS`KVBIKO<I[\ B>\_V l[MPZ[\ WRl[JPnKBBVlKMPZm\l[ZKJY\\hWRI<VbZKBMLB>\WRl[l OKT B\oTUOSI< RB>ISVJLO<I[IKBMLMPB\ 7§m>~¤ " !#¢ ~& C5BUH V @ OKnKB\ O d C#BUMPMLB>\UaV @ BH O d JLBnKB\ V©^KlmB>\U¥TUWRMPTZKM nKB>\ TUOSI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\a\KBH C2WRI<V_JYbZKBR d BH aBKJLO<I.
(8)
(9)
(10) ! . s. #( #( #%$& >,§]¨ X('§ & ) ¨ ' ~ ~>¢ & 'R~ 1 *,+ -/. & 0 D[L3 r 25J 4 TZKMPV©^JYIWSZKV_O<C2WXV_JPOSI NNNNNNNNNNNNNNN 6 )87 & X( '§ & !' & >¢( 9,¢<K( '§ & : #BA ;=< ,§]!§ >|¥£ ,@¢ ?(¢<R '§ & taLr ?F @JP JPI[Q2d ImWRC#B\ N@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN rSr ta D BNJLVB WXV_JPOSIV_B>T IKJYb<Z[BNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN rt 18C§ & ! j(~ '§ & ~ #1 D E # # F IV @ B TUOSI<V_BUVOXeV @ BO d BCl d O JPIKQa¥V @ B d B2W d BV©O}oW,^K\ VO&nKB\hT d JP`aBV @ B \_B>C2WRI<V_JYTU\OXW}l d OHG Q dd WSC2CJYIKQ}MPWSIK?QSZ[@ WRQRBS ?@ B C#OS\VN@ TOSC2d C#OSd I[ML^Zm\_B>n*]OSlaB d WXVJLO<d I[WXM(d \BC2WRI<V_JYTU\ d BUMPdJLB>\ O<IJYI[n[Zmd TV_JP RB l O<lmO<\_JPV_JPOSI[\ BoBUB>TUZKVJLO<IORaV Bl OSQ WRC \VWXVBC#BI<Vh\ JY\ Bl B\BI<V_B>n`<^Wl OSlaOS\JLVJLO<I BUMYWXIV G JYIKQNdWl d ORQ d d WRCJPV\d JYI[l[d Z[V WRI[nJLVh\OSZ[Vl[ZKd VK JIKJP RB dd \hWXMP@ML^"b@ Z[WSISVMJ LaBnMLOSQRJYTUWXMO d CZKd MYWR\d Xl d B>\_dB>I<V_Bn#WR\ JYIB B>I[TB ZKdMPd B\aW Bcel d O JYnKBn@ V_O}nKB\hT JP`aBZ[d ImnKB d JYT TOSImnKJLVJLO<I[\ WQRJP RBI&l OSQ WRC WXQ<CB>I<V BUKBTUZ[V_B\TO BTUV_MPdh^Rd O JPIKQV WR@ VWQRJP RB>I@ l OR@ Q WRC d C2WRl[\oWQRdJP RBIJPIml[ZK@VV_O2Wd QSJLd SBIO<ZKVlmZKVeJYIW QSJL SBI2TO<I<V_BKV TUO B>\laOSImn[\V_O@ \ OJYIKd QNV WXd VeV Bl O<lmO<@ \_JPV_JPOSI BUMYWXVJPIKQNV JY\el ORQ WSCXJPIml[ZKVUWRImn O<ZKVlmN ZKVJP\W2d TUOSI[\BbZKB>I[Td BOX(@ V BNJYIB B>I[d TB ZK@ MLB>\oWRd I[nd V BTUOSI<V_BUKVU IWRMLVB I[WXVJL SB WRl[l O<WRT JY\jVOn[B\hT JP`aBeV Bol OSQ WRC2C#JPI[QMPWSIKQSZmWXQRBe\_B>C#WSI<V_JYTU\WR\(WZmI[TVJLO<I C2WSl[lKJYIKQ#l d OSQ d WRC2\eWSI[n}d JPI[d lmZKV\VO2OSZKVhl[ZKV\ ?@ JY\Z[I[TVJLO<I:TUWRI}`mB"Zm\_B>nVO2d TUOSC2l[ZKVBV @ d B d dB\hZKMPV OR BUB>TUZKVJPdI[Q#W#QRJP RB>Il ORQ WSd C OSI@ W#QSJL SBIJYI[l[Z[?VU@ m`[d Z[VJPVoJP\I[ORV\Z[JLVhWR`KMPB@ V_O B>WR\OSI O<Il ORQ d WSC2@ \ Zm\_JYIKd QNJYIO C2d WXV_JPOSI#TO<@ C#JPIKQ OSCV @ BTOSI<VBKVU B BJY\ WoW,^"V_OC2WSXBV BZ[I[TUV_JPOSI[WRMmWRl[l O<WRT C#O BlmOB ZKM [\_O2V WXVJPVZ[\_B>\oV B"TUOSI<V_BUd KVU@ d @ BVWRMPNWS`mO<ZKVZ[I[TVJLO<I[WXM[\BC2WSISVJPT\ WRV B V WRI#nKB>IKORVhWXV_JPOSImWXMK\_B>C2WRI<V_JYTU\(`aBTUWSZ[\BeO<Z d eO d n[O<B>?\IKORVTUOSC#BJLV@ @ V @ B"Z[\hZ[WXM]`mWRT <Q d OSd Z[Imn d OSI:nKO<C#WRJPI}@ V @ BUO d ^ d O d TUOSC2lKMPBUVBlmW d V_JYWXM¥O d nKB d \ O\_JYCZ[MPWRV_B:V B&BUKBTUZ[V_JPOSI OXNWl OSQ WRC Z[\JPI[QV BO<lmB WRV_JPOSI[WRM\BC2WRI<VJPT\UeB&IKBBn V_O TUOSd C`Kd JPI[BV @ JP\:\BC2@ WRI<V_JYTU\JLV @ W l d O<OR\_B>W d T @ l d OTUBn[Z d BS ? O \JPCZKMYWXV_BV @ BuBUB>@TUZKVJLO<d I OXd W l OSQ WRC Z[\_JYIKQV d B#Z[ImTV_JPOSImWXM@ \_B>C2WRI<V_JYTU\¥eF B2OS@ I[ML^IKBBnV_O:@ WRl[lKMP^WZ[I[TVJLO<IVO}V B l ORQ WR@ C WSI[nud JPI[lmZKV\Nd WSI[n Bnmd Z[TB#JLVNVO:V B2OSZ[Vl[ZKV IV JP\N\BIm\_BS]V B#Z[d ImTV_d JPOSImWXM \BC2WR@ I<V_JY@ TU\O<lmB>I[\V B n[O<O @ V_Ol d OOX`<d ^ BaBdTVJLO<I `aBT@ WRZ[\B:d JLVC2WSXB\#@ JPVlmO<\\JY`KMLB:VO B>l B>\_B>d I<V#@ `aORd V V B\BC2WRI<V_JYTU\ WSI[n:dV Bl O<OR l OKTUBn[Z BRP OZKVV Bd l d OOX(V_OORM d V d WRVB"OS`KVhWXJYI:JP\ \_VJLMPM WXV B @ eB>WR.m`aBTUWSZ[\B"JLVd TWRI Bn[Z[TUB2V_QO LaI[WRM WXMYZKB OSI[ML^O Q OSZmI[nul OSQ WRC2\WRI[nJPV"nKOB\"IKOSV"Z[\B V BTUOSI<V_BUKVU Z QS?OS@ WRMJY\NVO&OS`KVhWXJYdIuW:l d d OOXl d OKTB>n[Z d B2@ V @ WRVNJP\N@C#O @d B @ lmOB d ZKdMV @ WRITO<I< RBI<VJLO<I[d WXMl d OOX\BW d @ T @ d BC#OS\V JYC#laO VWSI<V B>\Z[MLVJY\ WV_BT IKJPbZKB JPT BUMYl[\VO BWS\_O<I}O<I&C#BUVW, W JYWR`KMPB\[JYI&ORV B O d n[\a\^Kd C`aORMPJPTWXMPML^ d B>l d B>\_B>I<V_BnBUKl d B>\\JLO<I[\WRImn&JPIm\_V d Z[TUV_JPOSI[\ ?@ JY\ VBT @ I[JPbZKB"JY\\_^K\V_BC2WRV_JYT WSI[n}QRBI[B WXM ". RKRTSUWVXYZ.
(11) t. H H H. O<C#C#O<IC#BUV @ Onm\eVOWSZKV_O<C#WRV_B V @ Bl d O<ORj\_B>W d T @ W d B `[WS\_B>n OSIZ[IKJ5LaTUWRV_JPOSIWSI[n d B\ORMYZKV_JPOSI* d @ @ N d B\l ORMYZKOORVJL(O<TI}WR`[I&WS`a\_B>B"n: lJLBd eOKB>TUBnn[WSZ \d BW MLQSOOSO<WX<M*\VJPOI<V_\O ORMPV R@ BRB"mMPQROKJP RTUWXBM I:TWOSI<TUVOSBI<KV_VBUKWRVI[n:OX V d JP^Bla\ORV_V OBC2\BWX\VhT @ V @Z[BIKJ5TLaZ TUdhWRd V_B>JPOSISI:VoQSWROSImWXn M WRQSWRJPI[\V V @ BNTO<I[TMYZ[\JLO<IOXOSIKBOXV @ B @ ^KlmOSV @ B>\_B>\U F JLV\hZ[TUTUBUBnm\UV @ BIJLV d BUVhZ d Im\W#\hZ[`KQRO<WXM.O d B>WRT @ ?@OX(V @ d B"l d BC#JY\_B>\OX(@ V @ B"C2WXd VhT @ B@ n @ d ^KlmOSV d @ B>\_JY\U@ @ d d d BNn W,`[WST <\eOXV JY\WRlml O<WRT W BSB L \_V<V WXVV BQRB>IKB WXM¥l O<OR\V WXVBUQR^2JY\IKORVOKTUZm\_B>n WSI[nMLO<d \_B>\*V_JYC#B JYIB[lKdhdMPO d JPIKQWMYW d QRB\BW d T @ @ \lmd WRTB WSI[n\_B>TO<I[n*@ >V @ WRV]JLV nKO@ B\]IKOSV d @ W, SB TOSC2l[Z[VWXVJLO<I laOB (d <O"B TWRI2W JP RBoJYIW"\JLVhZ[WXVJLO<I# B BRSBU RB>I2J *B @ W, SBBIKO<ZK@ Q JYIO C2WXV_JPOSI#VO"@ BKBTZKV_B WSI5JYI[\V Z[TVJLO<IB:eO<I V2`aBWR`KMPB:V_OBKBTZKV_BS B:JLMPM\ O \hZ[T WSI5BU[WRC2lKMPB}JYI V B&IKBUV \BTUV_F JPOSI* @ d I:V©^KlaBNV BO ^`[WR\Bnl d OOXWR\h\_JY\_VhWRI<VMLJYXB C§ 6 ]Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\W d BNl d O JPn[BnWRI[n d Bn[Z[TUV_JPOSI[\ W d BNZ[\d BnVOTO<C#lmZKV_BNV @ BC
(12) aZ[I[d TUV_JPOSd I[\ TOSC2l[Z[V_BNOSI:d n[WRVW2O<`@ fgBTU@ V\ d F I&Z[\hZ[WXM*d O d C2WRM]l d OOR\V @ B WSTVh\ BUMYWXV_B>n2V_O#TOSC2l[Z[d VWXVJLO<I[\ W B l d O JYnKBn @ WS\ WS\\B V_JPOSI[\X JYT W BJYI2d WSTV BUMYdWXV@ JLO<I[\ `aBUV©BUB>I nmWXVW OS`KfgBTVh\U uBoZ[\B BaBTVJLO<I"VO` JYnKQRBV JY\QSWSl"V_OZ[\B ZmI[TVJLO<I[\(JPIl O<ORa\BW T ]BTOSMLMPBTUV Vd @ B nmWXVWOS`fgB>TVh\ d OSC d V @ B @ QRJP RB>I2WRTUV\WRI[nl[ZKVV @ d B>C JPI\BU S@ B d WXMad VWR`[@MLB>\U J @IKMPJYXB ZmIKMJ L.@ TUWXVJLO<IWRImn B\ORMYZKVJLO<I `mWR\Bn WSl[l OSWRT BnKO IKORV}MLOO<O W5C2WRVT O W ^KlmOSV B>\_JY\JYI V BTUOSI<V_BUKV VOnKO&V @ BTOSC2l[d Z[VWXV@ JLO<I*jBd TO<I[\hZKMLVV @ B\B VWS`KMLB>\"WRImnZm\_B#Z[I[TUdV_JPOS@ I[\V_O&@ nKO&V @ d BTO<C2d l[@ZKVWRV_JPOSI*
(13) .Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[WRM.WSl[l OSWRT JY\eC#O B OTZ[\BnWSI[nnKOB\IKOSVIKBBn VO\BW T JYIV B B>ISVJ B \BW T \hl[WSTBR WS\ d B d TUWSInKJ d B>TVMLd ^2TO<d I[\Z[MLV V @ B lmW d V_JYd TUZKMYW d VhWR`KMPB d BUMYWXVBn2VO"V @ B Bd I[bZKJ d ^R
(14) aZ[I[TUV_JPOSI B WXMYZ[WXd VJLO<I2JP\ la@ B O C#Bn`<^V_B C d B>n[d Z[TUV_JPOSI@ WRI[n d BWR\OSI[JPIK? Q#OSI:Z[Im<I[OI}BU@ [l B>\\JPOSII[BUB@ nm\@ \laBTUJPWRM]TUW BS uB \ O WW,^2VOO W O<Z[I[n V JY\l O<`KMPBC O#JPC2lKMPBC#BI<VV BZ[ImTV_JPOSI JYT nKOB\oIKOSV OSMLMPO V @ B"\V d Z[TVhZ d WRM d B>TUZ d \_JPOSId eB d BTWXMPM d H d D BTMYWXJYC V©OC2WRJPI B>\Z[MLVh\U
(15) J \_VRZ[\JPIKQ BmB>TVJLO<IWRImnW Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[WRM[WRl[l d O<WRT @ VONWRZKVOSC2WXVB l d OOXd \_B>W d T @ B2l d OKn[Z[TUB @ WRIuBWR\JPB d WRd I[n`aBUV_VB d oW,^V @ WRIuV @ BTZ dd Bd I<VML^W, WXd JPMYWR`KMPBZ[I[MJ LaTd WXVJLO<I WSI[n B>\_d OSMPZKVJLO<I`[WS\_B>nVBT IKJYbZKB#JPId l O<ORWSZKV_O<C#WRV_JPOSI* <BTUOSd I[n]jC#O BJYC2lmO@ Vhd WRI<VU*B l B>\_B>I<V WQRB>IKB WXMoWRI[n5\_^K\V_BC2WRV_JYTd oW,^VO BWS\_O<IOSI Z[I[IKOIBUKl d B>\\JLO<I[\WSI[nV B B`<^@ WRTUd JLMPJPVWXVJPI[Q \^KC `aORd MPJPTTO<C2@ l[ZKVdWRV_JPOSI[\ d O TU@OSC2l[ZKVhWXV_d JPOSIm\eJYI< ROSML JYIKQ#C#BVW, W JPWS`KMPB\ JYI[\JPnKBV©^KlaBNV BO ^R B BJY\V B"\_V ZmTVZ BOX(V BNl[WSlmB F I<B>TVJLO<I2DBnKB LaIKBV @ B\_JYC2lKMPBJPC2laB d WXVJL SBMYWRI[QSZ[WRQRB + -/. BO d C2WXMP J UBoJLVh\ O<lmB d WRV_JPOSI[WRM \BC2WSISVJPT\ `<^&JYI[n[Z[TUV_JP RB d BUMYWXVJLO<I[\WRI[nn[JP\hTUZ[\h\WR`aOSZKVOSZ d C2WXJYI&OS`KfgBTVJL SBR*W\V_B>lVOW d n[\ WRBZ G VOSC2WXVJLO<I*<F QRJP <JYIKQ#W"MPO<O<#JPI<V_Od V @ BTUZ dd@ BI<Ve\JPVZ[WRV_JPOSI*uBNd \ @d O V @ BnK5J 4TU+ ZK- MPV_. JPB\JPV @ @ V @ BTU@ Z dhd B>I<V \ORMYZKVJLO<I* I<B>TVJLO<IusB2l B>d \_B>ISVV @ B2dZ[I[TVJLO<I[WXMJYI<V_B l BUVhWXVJLO<I[\ OR d ¥uB\ O O V_O TUORMPMLB>d TVWS@ I[n:F Z[\_Bn[WXVhW2OS`fgB>TV\ O<C @ V Bl O <JYd nKB>nWSTVh\V_OBUK@ BTUZ[V_BNJYI[\_V ZmTV_JPOSIm\JPI&W#d ZmI[TVJLO<I[WXM WSl[l OSWST I&<BTUV_JPOSItB QSJL SB V B JYnKB>WOR BmB>TV_JPOSIWRI[n O JPVeJPMLM]`aBZ[\_B>nJYIO<Z TO<ISVBKVU @ B l d O <JYnKB#W}@\^K\_@ VBC2WXVJPTWRI[nQRBI[B d WXd MV_BT @ d IKJPbd ZKB#V_d OO d }JPV @ C# BUHVhW, ,W Qd JY WR `[ML BSW ? O JPC2@ lKMPB@ C#B>ISV V BoZ[I[TUV_JPOSI# JYT nKOB\d IKOSV(d ORMPMLO \_V dZ[TUV Z WXM BTZ \JPOSI"BZ[\B R JPT TUWSI `aBN OSZmI[n@ JYI:nKBUVhWXJPM*JPIO<@ Z l BU JLO<Z[\eO D C§ MLM*V Bn[ B LaIKJPV_JPOSIm\ W, RB `aBUB>IJYC2lKMPBC#BI<V_B>nJYI WSI[nWRMLM¥V @ B d B>\ZKMPV\l d O RB>n2O d C2WXMPML^2JYI JPVUd B"Z[\B d@ d B d BNWRI}JPIO d C2WRM]C#WRV @ B>@ C2WXV_JYTUWRM]IKORVhWXVJLO<I* @ d WRVC@ §B d V @ WSd IQSJL JYIKQ C § TOKnKBS @ ?@< B Cd B§JP \ WNn[J BTUV TO B\hlmO<I[nKB>I[TB`aBUV©BUBI2V JY\ IKOSVWXVJLO<I2WRI[n2V B O C2WXMP J >WXV_JPOSI] J \JYIKQ"V B N. "! R$#.
(16) q.
(17)
(18) ! . Q d WSl @ JYTUWRM[JP?I<V@ B d CWRT§B W, WXJPMPWS`KMPB@ OSI V @ B B` B d WXMY\_OJPC2@ lKMPBC#BI<VBn\OSC#BOR]V @ JY\eC#O d BJYI<VZKJPV_JP RB I[ORVWRV_JPOSI* B LmMLB>\OXV B"n[BU RBMLO<l[C#BI<VW B O<IV BNB`R " !"# JYI[\hd XBM r>x ml d B\BI<V\(W\@ C2WRMLM[l d ORd Q d WSC2d C@ JYIKQ MPWSIKQSZ[WRQRB +- . JLV @ @
(19) M d MPOOSl[\ + -/. JY\W\_d JYC2lK@ MLB JYC2lmB WRd V_JP RBod MYWR@ IKQ<Z[WXQSBeJPV d JYI<V_BUQSB \URV ZKV WXMYZKBd \ WRI[n SSd C#B>CO ^MLOK?T@ WXV_JPOSImd \(V_O"\V_O Bod V B JYI<d V_BQRB \[W JLV C#BUV_JYTB[l B\h\JLO<I[\U[`aOORMPBWSIBUKl B>\\JLO<I[\WRImn}JYI[\V Z[TVJLO<I[\ BO C2WXVJLO<I ZKMPB\ W B W d JLV @ C#BUV_JYTB[l d B\h\_JPOSIm \ ! " $#&%('*)+'* -,/.0 '1 2,435 '1 2,76/ *8 `mOORMPBWSIBU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\9 :; " $#&<'= '1 2,>#? '1 2,A@B '-C :D'*:,7EF: '*:,7GF: 18 JPI[\V d Z[TUV_JPOSI[\9 H7 " $#? I=JLKM'1)ONP F'H , 8 H 'J >:;Q*RAH , 1 DH '=STQ1JU V:>WXMH d@ B d ;B % d WRIKdQSB\ O SB d JPI<V_BQRdB d \Y ) d WRI[QRB\ dO RB d MPOTWXVJLd O<I[\U2 d d WSIKQRB>\ O SB d W d d JPV @ CBV_JYT@ BUKl d B>\\JLO<I[\ : WRIKQSB\O RB `mOOSMLB>WRIB[l B\h\_JPOSI[\(WSI[M n H WRIKQSB\(O RB JPI[\V Z[TUV_JPOSI[\ BoO C2WXMP J BoV JY\ MYWRIKQ<Z[WXQSB JYI C§ `<^V @[d Bd BJPI[d nmZ[d TVJL SBV©^KlaB4\ Z\[]^K<` d_a[]2K<mWRImcn @ bdR9 i OTWXVJLO<I[@ \"W @ B Bl B\d BI<V_B>n`S^JYISVBUQSB @ \U IKB\ OS?Z[MP@ nd IKOSVd TO<IZ[\@ B V @ B}JPI<VBUQRB d nKB>IKORVJPIKQW MPOKTUWRV_JPOSI@ JPV V BJYI<V_BQRB TO<I<VWXJYIKB>nJYIV BMLOKTUWR@ V_JPOSI* d B BUO BRJPI}V B@ n[ B LaIKJPdV_JPOSIOXe Z\[]2K<KeB n[?B@ IKOSV_BV BNTO<I[\VWRI<V dWXMYZK@ DB %`<g^ f/h d iR (WSI[nV B"C#BC#O ^2MLOKTUWRV_JPOSIJLV WSn[n B\hk\ j`<m^ l1X2n po h B\hlaBT5J LaTWXV_JPOSI}OX(W JLV C#BUVJPTB[l B\h\JLO<I[\JP\WS\ORMPMLO\ Z\[]2Ke rq ¢< l1X-n is t vu0wxZ\[]2K fk-h s vu5w+Z\[]2K is.y s Z\[]^KTwxZ\[]^KTwxZ\[]^K. B\BUB&JYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[d \WR\\_VhWXV_BV d WRI[\_O d dC#B dd \Ue @ B d BW\VWXVB&JP\}Wl[W d V_JYWXM C#WSl d O<C C#BC#O dd ^ MPOKTUWRV_JPOSI[\V_OJYI<V_BUQSB \U u? BTWRI#WRTUVZ[WRd MLMP^ B>l d B\BI<VWN@\VWRd V_BWR\(WMPJP\V(OX*`KJYI[nKJYIKQSd \`aBUV©BUB>IC#BC#O ^ MPOKTUWRV_JPOSI[\oWRImn WXMYZKB>\U O#\VWRV_B>\W Bn[LJ z¥B BI<VoJ (V B B" \WXVoMLB>WR\VoOSIKBNnKJdz.B B>I<V`KJPImnKJPI[Qm { i=|} q ¢< = . { i=|. s-~wsd9s = vu5wu5w. { i=|;w. { i=|. @ BIV @ B TUOSI<V_B>I<V OXW"MPOTWXVJLO<Ij#JYIW#\_VhWXVB>&JY\eC2WSl[lmB>n V_OM%<eB d B>l d B\BI<VV @ BIKB \_VhWXVB WR\ jM~wx%a - ```- S= U= $|44 Y| S= 4 p ``- S U= $|44 ¢¡ £ S ¤¢¥ ¦e¢ §} \ S |¨|;. RKRTSUWVXYZ.
(20) H H H. laB d WXVJLO<I[WXM. \ BC2d WRI<VJPT\NTOSIm\_JY\_Vh\NJYIud V @[d BUB d BUMYWXV_JPOS@Im\d QRJP <JYIKQC#@ BWSIK@[JYIKd Q:V_Od W d JPV @ C#BV_JYT?BU@[l d B>\IG \JPd OSI[\ `aOORMPd BWRIuBd [l B\h\JLO<I[\U@ WRI[nJYI[\_V ZmTV_@ JPOSIm@ \U@ WRT d BMPWRV_JPOSI WS\V BUBW Q<Z[d C#@ BI<V\9 d BBU@G l B>\\JLO<IO JYI[\V Z[TVJLO<I* V B\VWXVB:JPI JYT V B:B[l B\h\_JPOSI5JP\2B WXMYZ[WXVBn O V B&JYI[\V Z[TVJLO<I BUKBTUZ[V_Bn][WRI[n}V @ B d B\hZKMPVoOX(V @ BBU WRMPZ[WRV_JPOSI}O d BUB>TUZKVJLO<I* isd9s s Z\[]2KDw { i=|;w+u0w < ,!§ 9 isd9s
(21) s _a[]2KDw { i=|;w w < ,!§ 9 isd9s s Y bdR9 aw { i=|;w { i=|;w < ,!§ 9
(22) aO d W d JLV @ C#BUVJPT B[l d B\h\_JPOSIm\ TO<I[\VWRI<Vh\eW d B BU WXMYZ[WXVBn VO2V @ B>C#\BUMP RB>\U(v&B>CO d ^2MPOKTUWXVJLO<I[\W d B JYI<V_B d l d BUVBnN`<^NMPO<O<<JPIKQ @ Z[l"V @ BUJ d ,WRMPZ[B\ d JPIV @ B\_VhWXV_BSd O<I[\JP\V_d B>ISVML^d JP@ V @ d V @ @ Bo\lKJ d JLV OXmO<lmB d WRV_JPOSI[WRM \BC2WSISVJPT\UBNnK B LaI[BNV BNMPOOSZ[l}OSlaB WXV_JPOSI}`<^nKB JP ,WRV_JPOSI Z[MLB>\ WXV B V WRI`<^WZ[I[TUV_JPOSI* @ BdB ORVJPTUBV @. | X2XI*-KVcjt% l1X2n o ¢ %. ,§. X-XvI*-K { i=|;w+u0w+u w < !9 X-XvI*-K pX-R=W pji%D vu 8 T { i=| | X2XI*-K jM~wx%a j!% X-XvI*-K "9n*-dJ o* pjiji%a % u 8 T { i=| j #& j w | X2XI*-KVcj!% ew i X2XvI*K j. . ~wx% . j %. . d @ d @ ? @ B d BO d BNWRJYVI[\_VBBWSnKn}OORI[ ORQRVJP WSJPIK\\QJPQSWInKWRBI<WS^ZK ,MLV WRMP ,Z[WRBMPZ[V_B"OuV_BOC2ZmlKIKV©JP^I[JLVMLOKJPWRTUMLWRJ UV_JPB>OSn:I[\ ,W d JYWRWRV `[MLBB>\UaMLB>V @W, RBB\BV C2BWSC ISVJPZ[TIm\nKnKB B>LaTI[JYnKBBn*\ VO \_?VOS@ l}BU WXMYdZ[WXVJLO<I* d d d BNO<lmB WRV_JPOSI[\oW BJPI<VB l BV_B>nJYIV @ BNOS`< JPOSZ[\oW,^RO d BU[WRC2lKMPBR p , +% , +% 2,k.0 %`,7. % . . @ B d BV @ B#@ \^KC`aORM7. JY\O RB @d MPOSWSnKBn}d \ 2,4.B n[BIKOSV_B\V @ B W d JLV @ C#BUV_JYTB[@ l d B\h\_JPOSI:O<`K@ VWRJPIKB>nd `<^ WSl[lKMP^JPIKd QV B\_^KC`aORM}. V_OV B B[l B\h\_JPOSI[\7 -, WRI[n 2%`, . % nKBIKOSV_B>\ V B \hZ[C OX]V B I[WRVZ WXM IZ[CF `mB @ \ %`d ,WSI[@ nF% d d @ d @ d BUMYWXVI:JLO<\I O VUKV BNOSlaB WXVJLO<I[WXM*\BC2WRI<V_{ JYTU\OR(W JPV C#B< V_JY,T §WBU9 [l B>\\JPOSI[\JY\nKB LaI[Bn:`<^V BNJYI[n[ZmTV_JP RB |s" s s Y Z\[]^KTw i=|;w+u0w o1 / f h p%D vu 8 > { i=| if/-h R +% o1 1l X2n} jr %T ru 8 T { i=| i X2XvI*Kgj!% ew il1X2n o +% o1 =v 2,Y Z\[]^K 8 %`,* % vu 8 > { i=| 2,* +%`, w p %`, ew 2,k.0 +%`,7.0% . . . "! R$#.
(23) z.
(24)
(25) ! . d `aOORMPBWSIBU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\(B @ W, SBWN\_JYC#JLMYW d O d COX*B ,WRMPZmWXV_JPOSI] ?@ B OSlaB d WXV_JPOSImWXM[\BC2WRI<V_JYTU\ OR`aOORMPBWRI}B[l d B\h\JLO<I[\ JY\nKBLaIKB>n}`<^V @ BJPImn[Z[TVJL SB d BMPWRV_JPOSI |s" s s Y _a[]^KTw { i=|;w w < ,§W9 o1 j¢ T { i=| Y += o1 7 !~>¢ T { i=| x o1 ¢<~>~ §. ¢ ! Z\[]2K 8 % i% ru 8 T { i=|
(26) aO. o1. &. §m ¢ ~~ §. ¢. p +% ew +% aw % @ % w p @B + ! Z\[]^K 8 % i % vu 8 T { i=| p % e w p +% w p % % w p @B + . ?@ B:O<lmB d WRV_JPOSI[WRMe\BC2WRI<V_JYTU\OXJPIm\_V d Z[TUV_JPOSI[\#\hlmB>TJ5LmB\ @ O WSIJYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I5C2WRl[\#\VWXVB\#V_O \@VWRV_B>\U
(27) aO d JYI[\_VhWR@ I[TUBR]V @ BWR\h\JLQ<I[C#B@I<DV ) N B WXMYZ[WXVB\V @ B B[l d B\h\_JPOSIc WRI[nV @ BIZ[l.n[WXVB\ V B"TO<I<V_BI<Vh\eORV BNMPOTWXVJLO<!I ) V_O2V BN WRMPZKBOR . p %
(28) )xNP @ B d B!
(29) WR\h\_FB d Vh\V @ WRV d JP\V @ B\_VhWXVBOS`KVhWXJYIKBn`<^ T @ MPOKTUWRV_JPOSI5)!VOg% JYI0( V#TUOSZKMYn`aB BWRMLJ UB>n`<^\JYC#l[ML^0 # ). WRI[QRJYIKQ:V @ B?TOS@ I<VBI<V\NORV @ B ~w %a JY\#\ORMYZKVJLO<IJP\ I[ORV B4TJPBd I<VUK\JPI[TUB JPVen[ZmlKMLJYTUWRV_N B>\eWS\\JLQ<d I[C#BI<V\ OX]BUJY\V_JYIKQMPOKTUWXd VJL@O<I[\ WSI[n JPVeOSZ[MPnl d OKn[Z[TUB @ @ ZKQSB \VWRV_B>\n[Z JPIKQTUOSC2l[ZKVhWXVJLO<I* `aBUVV_B \_OSMPZKVJLO<IJY\VO MLOO<2O V BN WXMYZKBNOX ) JPI WRImnT WRIKQSB JPVU is
(30) s Y { i=|;w u5w+u0w { i=|;w < ,W§ 9 ORVJPTUB"V @. K*W2=| `d 2 pji% i% u 8 T { i =| j ~wx%
(31) j w K*W2=| " i ^ pj ij % % vu 8 { i =| j #?
(32) ew j ~wx% . j~wx%
(33) j ~wx% . RW V B d BbZKJ d d B"WMLOKTWXV_JPOSI:VO`aB#WRM d BWSnK^}nKBLaIKB>n&JPIV @ B#\_VhWXV_dBV_O}Zmlan[WRV_@ BJLV B @?W,@ SB I[ORdhVd \hlmB>TJ5LmBn&WSISd ^}OSlaB d WXVJLO<I[@ WXM]\BC2WRI<d VJPT\oV_OZ[d l.n[WRV_BW2MPOKTUWXVJLO<I:IKORV l B>\_B>ISd VoJYI:V B\_VhWXV_BS JP\ TUO B>\laOSImn[\ VO B>b<Z[J JPI[QV WXVWRMLM* W JYWR`KMPB\oW BB[lKMPJPTUJLVML^}JPIKJPV_JYWXMPJ UBn`aBO BBKBTZKV_JPOSI] e ,WRMPZmWXV_JYIKQW\_B>b<Z[BI<V_JYWXM TUOSC2laOS\JLVJLO<5 I H H O<IW\VWXVB TO<I[\JP\V\JPIB WXMYZ[WXVJPIKQ H OSI ( O<`KVWRJPI[JPIKQ2W IKB \VWXVAB mWRI[n}V @ BIBU WXMYZ[WR1V_JY8 IKQ H O< I V_O OS`[VWXJYI}V @ B LaImWXM]\VWXVAB H H H 8 H . . B @ W, RB V©eO d ZKMPB\ O Td @
(34) M MLOO<l[\U F e :BU WXMYZ[WRV_B\eV_OM=S2HJP\BKB>TUZKVBnJPV @ VO#l d OKn[Z[TUB W d IKBU \VWXVB (JLV @ @ @ JYT @ V @ BMLOOS@ lJY\"B WXMYZ[WXVBnWXQ<WXJYI* F ;:2BU WRMPZ[WRV_B>\NV_Og XBUB>TUZKVJLO<I VB C#JPI[WRV_B>\WSI[nMLB>W, RB>\eV BN\_VhWXVB"Z[I[T WSIKQRB>n* :1 + H¢ S>Q*J$ V:>W-XH¢ S>Q*JU :>W-XMH¢ . RKRTSUWVXYZ. . . : x STQ1JU V:>WXH¢ . .
(35) H H H 6. ? @ B>\_B d ZKMPB\oWRI[n}V @ B d ZKMPB\eO d I=JLK"WRImn}TUOSI[nKJPV_JPOSImWXM¥B[l d B\h\_JPOSIm\eTWRI`mBO d C2WXMPJ BnJPI C § JYIW \_V d WRJLQ @ V_O d W d n2oW,^`<^WRIJYI[n[Z[TUV_JP RB d BUMYWXV_JPOSI] isd9s si bLR=iw { i=|;w { i=|;w < ,W§ 9 o1 IJUKe T { i =| 9I=JLK2 o1 = iJ vR { i=| 8 jr %T ru 8 k 1Z\[]2K +% ew
(36) w j P N o1 n9X^ XR { i=| 8 H iH bdR9 H w H aw pH 18 H . . o1 S>Q*JU =} o1 S>Q*JU . . . . 8 H- bLR=i 8 { i=| : + ew H¢ w S>Q*J$ M:;W-XMH e w S>Q*J$ M:;W-XMH : _a[]2K 8 H- bdR9 8 T { i=| : x e w S>Q*JU :;W-XMH . . . : _a[]^K. . .
(37)
(38) ! d OORjWR\h\_JY\_VhWRI<V\RMPJYXB C§ }b #"*1 %$ &('DlBKBTZKV_JYIKQJYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\. d @V BC WR\ MLB>C2C#WS\Um @ B d B"V @ BNWRTUV\ I[BUBn[Bn:V_O @ BUMYl&V @ BBKBTZKV_JPOSI:W d B"TWRl Id O`a BJPnK <B>JPn:BUWRB\ n @ ^KWS\elmOSl V @ OB> \_JYB>IK\UQ
(39) aO d JYI[\_VhWRI[TUBR*BOSZ[MPnMLJYXB#V_O:\ @ O WRIBKBTZKV_JPOSIOXeW\_B>bZKBI[TUBOR V©O}JYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\TH WRImn @ @ H \_VhW d V_JYIKQ" d OSC W2\VWRV_D @V B\VWRV_MB ^JLBMPn[\W\VBWRV_MB JPMLM¥WSI[OSn&`[VVWX@ JYIB#W \VLaWRV_I[BMWRM* \_ VhWXV_BAJPMLM( `a BKQRO<JP`K RVBWRIJPIKV B>n&B JYIWRTUWRV\oI&V BUKWXBVTUZ[BKV_JPBOSTI&ZKV_ORJPOSIH OXJP IH V @ JYI B \VWRV_AB ¢ #*)(+ { i=|-, + H H bLR=i., F Il. /. H . ew. 20 1 46587:9<;. H . . . . 3. w. /. pH 18 H 20 1 =@ !> 5?. . 3 ,. ? O WSZKV_O<C#WRV_BV @ JY\l d OOXg @ JYT @ JY\}\JPC#JPMPW d V_O V BuOSlaB d WXVJLO<I[WXM \BC2WSISVJPT\nKB>\T d JYlKV_JPOSI OR o1 n9X^ XRSSnKJ54TUZKMPV_JPB\W d JY\B V_ONnKB d JP RBV @ BJYI<V_B d C#Bn[JPWRV_B d B>\Z[MLVh\UV @ B\_VhWXV_B4 KJYIOSZ d TUWS\_BS @ JYT @ n[O<B>\ IKceOSdV WRl[laBW d JYdI2V d @ BQSd OSWRM J \hZ[WXMPMP^V @ JP\eSJYI[n2OR*d l d d OOX¥JY\ nKO<IKB `<@ ^ d B\ORMYZKV_JPOSI2WSI[n2d Z[IKJ5LaTUWRV_JPOSI* WS\NJYI ORMPORQ:JYISVB l BUV_B \ WSI[nC#JP\h\JPIKQ ,WRMPZ[B\"W B Bl[MPWSTBnJPV BUJY\V_BI<VJPWRM W JPWS`KMPB\NVO`mB JYI[\VWSISVJPdWRV_B>nMYWXdVB d V { @[d jOSZK§ Q @ Z[IK5J LaTUWRV_JPOSI*@
(40) mO d @ OSZ d B[WSC#l[MLBJYI Cd § SWZ[IKJ5LaTUWRV_JPOSI WR?Im@n d B>\_OSMPZKVJLO<I `mWR\Bn2l OTUBn[Z B @ LaImn[\ W"C2WXVhT JLV o* n X^ XvR WRI[n BlKMYWRTUBa\ `SB ^ ARrR BI#JPV IKBBn[\ VO\@ORMP RBV©eO:C#O d Bd \hZ[`KQR@ O<WX@ MY\U J SL pH CAX@ r od WSI[dn H .ARr h F VV @ B>I @ LaImn[\WC2WXVh@T @ JYIV B} TUOSI<V_BUV"d O `aORV V B\Zm`KQRd O<WXMY\"WRI[nV B BUO B d JPI[\VWSI<d V_JYWXV_B>D\ ARr@ VcO V Z[\\ORMP JPI[QV B d QSOSWRM OBU RB d WZmIKMJ L.TUWXVJLO<IWRImn d B>@ \_OSMPZ[V_JPOSI&`[WS\_B>nl OTUBn[Z BNWRJLMY\ BIuTOSC2l[Z[VWXVJLO<I&lmOB JY\IKBBnKB>n*
(41) mO JPI[\VWSI[TBS[TO<I[\_JYnKB V BORMPMPOJPIKQ#MPBC2C2W ¢ *E)(+ > { i=|-, + jk uF, i X2XvI*KM5jur w STQ1JU #s @ j WXKJML2HON , / 0.1 3 / 0.1 3 4G587H9I; 5? = > F JP RB>IV @ B#WRTVV @ WXVV @ B2MPOKTUWXVJLO<mI j&JY\N`mO<Z[I[nuV_Or2JPIV @ B \VWXVtB (]eB IKBBnV_O&l d O RBV @ WXV BUKBTUZ[V_JPOSI}OX(V @ BN @ JPMPBNMLOOSl}JPMLMjI[ORVT @ WSIKQRB\_VhWXVBR B @ W, RBNIKB>TB>\\hW d ^2JPIO d C2WRV_JPOSI[\oVOl d O SB "! R$#.
(42)
(43)
(44) ! . V @ WXV@ V @ B`aOORMPBWRIB[l d B\h\_JPOSI s@ r JPMLM*`aB BN WXMYZ[WXVBnVO"WRMP\BRKd `[ZKV\hZ[T @ W#l d O<ORjnKd OB\IKORd VBKJY\_V JYI#V @ BTUOSI<V_BUKV(WSI[n#IKBUB>n[\V_O"d`aBTd O<C2@ l[ZKV_N B>n* Z[IKJ5LaTUWRV_JPOSI#@ WRI[n d B\ORMYZKV_JPOSI`[WR\Bn#l OTUBn[Z BonKOB\ I[ORV W, SBTUOSC2l[ZKVhWXV_JPOSI2laOeB O V JP\ W,^NVO"\_OSML SBoV JY\ l OS`KMPBC7JP\VO"Z[\BeZmI[TVJLO<I[\JYI[\_VBWSn OR d NBUMYWXVJLO<I[\U@
(45) aZmI[TVJLO<I[\TUWSI}WRMP\O2d TOSC2l[d Z[V_BNJYISVB d C#BnKJYWXVB d B\hd ZKMPV\KV @ Z[d \ @ WSI[nKMPJPI[Q#MPBC2C2WrRd \"B W, RBC#B>ISVJLO<IKBn`aBO BSl BU JPOSZ[\MP^uTO<C2l[ZKV_B>n B>\ZKMPV\W B W, ,WRJLMYWR`[MLBWS\"WR\h\_B VJLO<I[\ @ JPT @ JP\eJPIdWRTUV d BUMYWXVJLO<I[\ `aBUV©BUB>In[dWRVWOS`fgB>TV\ OZKVeV @ d B Z[I[Td VJLO<I[\oTO<C#lmZKV_BOSInmWXVW@ OS`KfgBd TVh\U I[ORVd O<@ I&WR? \h\_B VJLO<I[\UP J I[MJ LaTWXVJLO<I&WRI[n B\ORMYZKV_JP@ OSI:`[WS\_B>n&l OTUBn[d Z B>\Z[@ \_BTOSI<VBKV@V_O}nKOd V Bd l Od OX \BW T @ O"Z[\_BZ[I[TVJLO<I[\S@ B IKBB@ n2V_O LaI[n2@ V B n[WX@ VhWNOS`KfgBTVh\( OS@ C@V B TUOSI<V_BUKV V WRV V d ZKd MP^ Bl B G \BI<VV BTUOSI<V_BUV OB\ O O V_OWRT JPBU SBeV JY\URWRMLO<IKQ JPV V BeZmI[TVJLO<I[WXMKJYI<V_B l BUVhWXV_JPOSIm\ OR V @ BNMPWSIKQSZmWXQRBS :#:
(46) 5U2 : o((U
(47) .Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\NW d B#eBMLM \hZKJPV_B>nVO:n[B\hT d JP`aB @ O7V_O&B WXMYZ[WXVB#W d JPV @ C#BV_JYT#WSI[n`mOORMPBWSIBUKl d B>\\JLO<I[\ MPOOSZ[l@ O d W d *
(48) JYWR `KHMPB" WXMY ZK B \ Od Z[ lanm WXV_BB# V @ BH\VWXVBRH* WR\ BV @ B^!OR MPML@O \V d Z[TVhZ d WRM d BTZ d \JPOSI* OZKV eB o@ WRI<VeV B>d \_B B`mZKJLMYn B VWS`KMPB\V_O2TOSMLMPBTUV V @ JY\oJPIO C2WRV_JPOSI d d OSC V @ B"TO<I<V_BKVoWRI[n}V @ BInKB\JLQ<IB WXMYZ[WXVJLO<I Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\oVO TOSIm\ZKMPV d BQSZKMYW d ML^ V B\BVWS`KMLB>\U
(49) aO JYI[\_VhWRI[TUBR ¢ ) )(+ ^Z\[]^K , + > { i=| . . . . /. . +% .0w 1 p % 3 @ d 4G58H7 9I; d @. w. /. p . . +% .0% 0.1 3. ,. ? O XBBl V B\BJPIKO C#WRV_JPOSI OSI W JPV C#BV_JYTB[l d B\h\_JPOSIm\U=D> 5 ? WRImn "eB T d BWXVBW VWS`KMLB VO `mB d BWSn WR\
(50) I
(51) M H / H/
(52) W ! H h uW MLJY\_V OR d V d JYlKMPBUV\ @ @ B d B:Bd WRT @ @ V d JPl[MLBVTOSd Im\_JY\_Vh\#OXNW@ \VWRV_BSeWRI W d JPd V @ C#BV_JYT}BU[l d dB>\\JPOSIWSI[n V @ B:JYISVB G QS B ,WRMPZ[BOXV JP\#W JPV C#BUVJPTB[l d B\h\_@ JPOSIJY@ IV JY\#\_VhWXV_BS
(53) aO BU[WRd C2lKMPBRO @ MLB>C#C2Wus d !# % i% uB BI[\hZ B V WXVeV JY\ VhWR`KMPB TUOSI<VWRJPIm\ JYIO C2WXV_JPOSI2V WXVJY\ O<IKML^2l O JPnKB>n JYI}V @ B" TUOS I<V_BUVo JPV @ V @ B H ! !H s | J i { i=|76kZ\[]^K 6/u vw < ,W§ 9
(54) . .
(55) . .
(56) .
(57) .
(58) . . ;-AR T
(59) .
(60) +. k Z\[]^K. ,+. %D vuF, + T { i=| ,p +% G. .
(61) . |
(62) ,. JPC#JPMPW d MP^"BT d BWXVBn[JLz¥B d BI<VVWS`KMPB\VO"TORMPMPBTVnKJdz¥B d BI<VV©^KlmB>\OX¥JPIKO d C#WRV_JPOSI d O<C V @ B TO<ISVBKVU BTWRI @ W, SB d d B>\ZKMPV\V_OMPOOSZ[l:JYI:V @ B#Cd B>C#O d ^}\VWXVB\mVOZ[d l.n[WXd VBWC#B@ C#O d ^}\VWRV_BSaB ,WRMPZmWXV_B>n `aOORMPBWSIuBU[l B>\\JPOSd I[\WRImnBKBTZKN V_B>nuJYI[\V Z[TVJLO<I[\d }@ BJPML@ M B>l B>\_B>I<VV d BC WS\ ? > > @ 5 @ 9 WRI[n B>\laBTUV_JP RBUMP^R Q<WXJYI*eB:BIm\Z B:V WRV2V B>\_B&VhWR`KMPB\ W B:TO<I[\_JY\V_BI<V2JPV V B TUd OS I<V_BUKVJPV @ W&;I9 \BUVNORoTUOSI[\JY\_@ VBI[TU^&Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\d j J RP ? >d > s 5 9 i@ s s WRI[n ;<9 is B\hla? BTVJL SBUMP^R 2 B LaIKJPV_JPOSId OXV B>\_BZmI[Td VJLO<I[\W BN\_JYC#@ JLMYW dhWRd Imn}BOSC#JPVV BC @ @ d d OB WXMYZ[WXVB WRI<^2B[l B\h\_JPOSI]RB L \_VeMLOO<JYIV BTO B\hlmO<I[nKJYIKQNVWS`KMLBSS BUV B eBWXM B>WRnK^ IKO V @ B d B\hZKMLVO d IKOSVU F IKOSVUmBNOSMLMPO V @ B\BC2WSISVJPT\U ?@ B d BUO d BR[V @ B"B ,WRMPZmWXV_JPOSIZmI[TVJLO<I .
(63) . RKRTSUWVXYZ. !. . " . . # . .
(64) . . !.
(65) r>x. H H H. O d W d LJ V @ C#BUVJPTB[l d B\h\JLO<I[\ JY\nKBLaIKBn:WS\ORMPMLO\9 s 9 rZ\[]2KTw. { i=|;w. | J i. { i=|/6/u 6/u w i J { i=|k6kZ\[]2K 6/u r w , , ,
(66) , , ,. XvK9 J XvRV u F, , , T F, , , ? > > ] S>Q*¥ >-k]
(67) '/Q*dS4J f/h iR i ? > >
(68) $#&% l1X2 n po ¢ ? > >
(69) $#vX2XI*-K 7o^ ? > > ? > > =
(70) . =
(71) ? > > . ?
(72)
(73) >? > >">
(74) . ? > > =
(75) ! U# *"X2 ? >>"
(76) . ? > >
(77) , 35 ? > >
(78) U# s s s , 6k ? > >
(79) $# s s9s. J. Jd O. #& *"X2 #? *¥X2 #&*"X2 # *¥X2. d @ B d d B vX2XIYK @is" s" s deJY\V @ d B#Z[ImT@ V_JPOSIuQRJP JPI[F QV @ B2d TUOSI<d V_B>I<V\OXoWMPOKTUWXVJLO<IJYIuW\VWXVBR]nKBLaIKB>nu`<^ d BBUMYTWXZ VJL\_O<JPI OS8I X-O<XvII*V -KNBNJP\\_V JPVZm\oTQ VZd WSlB@ OX(V B"BNZ[\V\_WRBV_VBR@ B<VXK=nK Jdz¥J XB RN\V©^K lmO<BC OR X2CXv§I* K"`aO dBTV©WR^KZ[lm\BBMPJLJ VoVJYJP\I[QmW Z[I[TVJLO<I*[IKOSVoW F IV @ B"\WSCBoW,^RBn[B LaIKBNV @ BNBU WRMPZ[WRV_JPOSIZ[I[TVJLO<I}O d `aO<OSMLB>WRI}B[l d B\h\_JPOSIm\ s 9 e_a[]2KDw. { i=|;w. i J . { i=|76/um6/urw | J i { i=|76kZ\[]^K 6/u w i J { i =|k6T_a[]2K 6 \w XvK9 J XvR. %,. BO RB d MPOSWRnVd @ BTUORV_Vo` d WRT RBUV\ s jV_O2nKB>IKORVBV @ BBU WXMYZ[WRV_JPOSI ZmI[TVJLO<I}`aORV @ O<I}W d JPV @ C#BV_JYT WSI[n`mOORMPBdWSIBU[l B>\\JPOSI[\ @ <JYC#JLMYW MP^RKBn[B LaIKBNV B"Z[l.n[WXVBZ[I[TVJLO<I s sG$2s 9 { i=|\w. u w+u5w. | J i. { i=|76/um6/um6 { i=| e w. XK= J XR. { i=|. ,. 2
(80) (# F IZ[\hZ[WRMO d C2WXM l d OOX\ @ ^KlmOSV @ B>\_B>\NWR`aOSZKV"TUOSC2l[ZKVhWXV_JPOSIm\NW d B d B>l d B>\_B>I<V_BnuWR\"WS\\B d V_JPOSIm\ V @ WXV \@OSC#B d BMPWRV_JPOSI @ ORMYnO d \_O<C#@B:l[JLB>@TB:OX@ n[WXVhW[ ?@ Bl d O<OR@ \BW d T @ C#B>T @ WRIKJY\hC#\2Z[\hd Z[WRMLMP^5\BW d T @ V B2TOSI<V@ BKV TUOSI<VWRJPIKJYIKQWXMPM V F B\B d ^KlaORV B\B\ V_O}\BUB#JL V B#QRO<WXM@ TUWRIud `mB2\ORMPC RB§n nKJ BTUV_MP^:J JPVd JP\ O<IKBOR d V B>\_B#WR\h\ZmC#d l[V_JPOSI[\ IW}l O<OR \_^K\V_BC `[WS\_B>n:OSI&V©^K@laB@ V BUO ^MPJPRB .Z[?I[@ TVJLO<I[\W B WRd MP\O}l O JYnKBn&WSI[n B@ n[ZmTV_JPOSITUWRIu`mB2Z[\Bnd V_O:d TOSC2@ l[Z[V_d B#JLV V d B@ \BZ[ImTV_JPOSIm\ z B#JPnKB>WOR BaBTVJLO<I:JP\ V_OZ[\BV B\B"Z[ImTV_JPOSIm\ VO}laB O C V Bl OOX \BW T OZKV ZmI[TVJLO<I[\ TUOSC2l[ZKVBO<I O d C2WRML J UB>n&n[WXVhWWRImn&V @ B @ TUOSI<V_BUV @ @ ^KlmOSV d @ B>\_B>\ W d B#IKORV O d d C#WR@ ML J UB>n&n[WXVhWWRdV V @ BMPBU RBM OR V @ @ B>\_B Zmd I[TVJLO<I[\`mZKVO<IKMP^WRVd V B}d MPBU SBUM OR@ V @ B}l O@ OX \^\V_B>C@
(81) mO V B@ I[BUd Bnm\OR BUmBTUV_JPOSI*(B W, SB WRM BWSnK^`[Z[JLMPVn[WRVW&VO Bl B\BI<VNV B ^KlmOSV B>\_B>\"WXV"V BMPBU SBUM B B Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\TUWRITUOSC2l[ZKVBR . "! R$#.
(82) rSr.
(83)
(84) ! . ? @ JP\NnKJY\hTUZ[\h\_JPOSIOSIuMLB RBMP\NTWRI`mB#OSZmI[nJPI r k BUmBTUV_JPOSIuWS\NlKJPOSIKBB d BnJYI Ob`S^WRCZKBUM OoO<ZKV_JYI s @ B d B d BUmBTUV_JPOSI2oWR\eZ[\_B>n V_O2nKB>TJYnKB B4 TUJLB>I<V_MP^# @ BUV @ B d V©OBU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\SnKB>IKORVJPI[Q @ WRMPZKd B>\JYIW d JYIKQmmW d d BNB>bZ[WXM <JYC#JLMYW d ML^S"Zd [C2W d BUB d WXfB dd C2@ W WRImnCRB§ WS IF OSZ[d `[WSZKMPVIdG i W dhd BTUb . WR\ B>TB>ISVML^NZ[\Bn BUmBTUV_JPOSINVON`[ZKJPMPnW TUB V_5J LmB n OP2 2 WXMPQRO JPV C JYI jO O<I BmB>TVJLO<I"JYI C§ TWRI`aB WRMP\ONO<Z[I[nJYI F I V @ BMPJLVB d WXVZ d BB n[OIKOSV LaI[n}WRI<^ d BUB d BI[TUB @ B d B d BaBTVJLO<I oWR\o? Z[\Bnd JYI}\BC2WSISVJPT\U d d d C Z[\JPI[Q d BUmBTUV_JPOSI*JY\WS\ OSMLMPO \ O<I[\O JPnKB l d OW RBl d WO<ORQR G JPWS RB\\I JY\_Vhl WRI<O<VlmB @V©^ B d B#eWSB#l[lKTUWRMPJLIuB>n `mOSV_O V @ \_nKO<CB\hBT d JPV_`aB B WSI[nl d O SBl d ORQ d WRC2\ ?@ BI d JPV_BW l dd OSQ d WR C @ V @ WXVVWSXd B>
(85) \ oWR\JYI[l[ZKV WRI[n @ d BUd VZ d I[d \V d ZKBNOSIKMP^JL @ B I @ OSMPn[\ F I:ORV @ B d O d n[\U l O SF B V WXd
(86) V # V ZKB WRImd nV B @ BO BOSI[BTWRIZ[@ \B JYI[\_VBWSnOR 2 @ @ IOSZ TWR\BRBOSZ[MPnMLJYXBV_ONl O RBeV WRV iH ORMYn[\QRJP RB>IW\BUVOX ^KlaORV B\B\ uB \ @ O<ZKMPn]mV @ B d BO d BRm d JPV_BW d Z[I[Td VJLO<I @ JYT @ VWR@ RB\ H Q @ V @ WRVV d ZK@ MP^ d Bl? d B\@ BI<Vh\ k WRI[g n HWR\JPIml[ZKV\NWSI[n BVZ I[T\ OSIKMP^&JLe B>I p H y OSMPnm\WRMLO<IKQJPV O W, SB V @ JY\oF MPWS\_VT d JPV_B d JYWB"IKBUB>d nVOl d O RB d \H¢ @ #& d cw d i@ H I\BTUV_JPOSI DB nKB>\T JY`mB>n#V©eOl O<`KMLB>C2\V WRV IKBBn2V_O`mB\_OSML SBn2`<^#l OOX*\_B>W T BIKQSJPIKB>\V_O `m?ZK@ JLMYnl d OOXeJPIu\_B>C#WSI<V_JYTU\ d ?@ B L d \V@ l d OS`[MLB>C JY\V_O LaI[nuJPI<VB d CB>nKJYWX?V_B@ WXMYZKB\ JPITd O<C2l[ZKVWRV_JPOSI* JP\#JY\\ORMP RB>nJPI WuImWXVZ WRM oW,^RV B}B ,WRMPZmWXV_JPOSI5TOSC2l[Z[VWXVJLO<I[\ B\BTUOSI[nl O<`KMLB>C JP\#V_O JYI<V_B d MPBW, SBW d JLV @ C#BUV_JYTTUOSC2l[ZKVh@ WXVJLO<d I JLV @ l dd OOX@ \BW d T @ WRImn V @ JP\ VO<d Oa @ TUWSI `aBud B>WR\JLMP^ \ORMPd RB>n JLNBU WXMYZ[WRV_JPOSI Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\TWXMPMV B BMLB d WRI<VW JLV d C#@ BUVJPTd Z[ImTV_JPOSIm\Ud @
(87) mO V B>\_Bl O<`KMLB>C2\Ul OOX VOORMY\d `mWR\BnuOSIZ[I[TVJLO<IB WXMYZ[WXVJLO<IW B2`mBV_V_B V d WRIl OORe\_B>@ W T Vd O<OSMP\`[WS\_d B>n@ O<IZ[I[MJ@ LaTd WXVJLO<d I WSI[n d B>\_OSMPZ[V_JPOSI* N
(88) aZ[ImT@ V_JPOSIBd WXMYZ[WXVJLO<IuJY\"WRMP\OC#d O B2OTd Z[\BnV WSIl d O<ORo\BW T WSI[@ nV B BUO d B C#O B: B 4TUJLB>ISV MLM V JY\l OKTB\h\ `aBTO<C#B\ SB ^5lmOB ZKMJLWR\V B>n[Z[TVJLO<I CB>T WRI[JP\hC2\ W B JYC2lKMPBC#BI<V_B>nJPIl d O<ORWS\\JP\VWSI<V q . . .
(89). "!$#. d @ d d d @ dl OSIKQ Bd WRC nKJ5 4TUZKMPV©^5W JY\_B>\ BI eB B>WR\OSIO<I ZmI[IKOIBUKl B>\\JLO<I[\ OSI[\JYnKB V BOSMLMPOJPI[Q ¢ ; )(+ > { i=|-, + jk uF, i X-XvI*-K 5js ew p STQ1JU Mj @yrWXt9I=JLK , F @ @ d d d F d BC#B>I CV`aB JPd \}XJPTUI WS\_\B:BTUV V_JPOSBI C#DKSBC#eBO n[^ B La\IKVWRB>V_n B&\_VhJY\ WXVQRBJP RWRB>\ I WSI `<^ F ImWn[Z[Z[TIKVJLJP S RBB V©\h^KWXlmMPMLB^5bBUVZ[WSI<JPV_V J5@ LmBV©n O" TW OSJPImWS\_`KV MPd B Z[TU(V_O d \NOSeIKBB n[B\hT d JP`aB\ V @ B2TUWS\_B @ BIV @ B#MLJY\V JY\ B>C2@ lKV©^WRI[nV @ B#ORV @ B d nKB\hT d JY`m@ B>\ V @ B#TWR\B@ @ B>I&V @ BMPJP\V@ JP\d I[OSI B>C#l[V©^R OZKVJLVonKOB\IKORVo\hW,^2WSI<^<V JYIKQ"JL B nKO<I VoIKO WRI<^V JPIKQ#WR`aOSZKVV JP\MPJP\VUJYIORV B O d F n[\JL(\hZ[T @ @ Wd MPJY\_VJY\nKB\hT d d JY`mB>n}`<^W2C#BUVhW, ,W d JYWR`[MLBSSO d B[WRC2lKMPBN`<d ^ ud WS\WR`aO RBSd d ? B d C IdV©B>^Kn[lmZ[BoTUV V_JPOSBUIO T ^"@ `[WSWSIK\_QRB>B>n\ lV @ OB OXV B G©dWRC \h\_JY`m\VBWRJPI[I<QVU\VZ[Z[ImnKTJPV_BJPn]OSIKOSBUIK MPWR^2MPZ[J jWRV_V JP@ OSBITUJPZ\dhlad B B>I<VeO n[C#WRVBWnC2`<^"WRVVT B @ CB>\ O<BIKn[B Z[ORTUjV_JPVOS@ I*B d BnmZ[TVJLO<I d ZKMLB>\U
(90) mO d JPI[\VWSI[TBS . ? >> d B>n[Z[TUB\(V_O ? > > . ? >> OZKV d Bn[ZmTV_JPOSInKOB>\]IKORVjOTTUZ d J KOSI[B OXV @ B B[l d B\h\_JPOSI JP\ d B>l d B\BI<V_B>n `<^ WNZmIK?JL S@ B d \WRMLMP^"bZ[WRI<VMJ LmB>n# ,W d JYWR`[MLBSO d JYI[@ \VWSI[Td B r ? > d > @ \VW,^K\ d ? >> BeTOSI<VBKV]TUWSI\V_JPMPMSTO<I<VWXJYI BIKO<ZKQ JYIO C2WXV_JPOSI BUMYWXVBnV_OV B\B C#BUVW, W JYWR`KMPB\¥VOBKBTZKV_B JYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\ TO<I[\_JYnKB d MPBC2C2Wtmd ?@ B d BUO d Bd BuIKBBn W5W,^ VO d BWR\OSI WS`mO<ZKVV @ B>C} ?@ B \ORMYZKVJLO<I JP\VO#WS\\OKTJYWXV_BWIZ[C`mB VO#C#BVW, W JPWS`KMPB\ MPJYXDB (uBnKO#JLVoJYIW#\_^K\V_BC2WRV_JYToW,^R(uB N. . . . RKRTSUWVXYZ.
(91) . .
(92) . . .
(93) .
(94) . . . " .
(95) .
(96) r,D. H H H. [n B LaIKBd WI[BUd JYI[d n[Z[@ TUV_JP RBV©^KlmBTUd WRMLMPBngd R { i=| V_O d BWRnWR\ TUOSI[\V Z[TUV_O O V B\B"IZ[C`aB Bn}V_B C2\ R { i=|} q ¢<. @ JYT @ TO<I<VWXJYI[\eWRIBUKV d W. !
(97) " ( . . }R { i =| sd9s. vu + w u w R { i =|;wR { i =| h> i9o1YJ # " ; w R { i=| { i=| /R { i=| { i=| { i =| h>i9o*YJ #" ; % s2w~ s"i% . 4% . s2w~. eMLB>CB>I<V\OX W d BImWRC#B\O d BU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\eOXV©^laB JPI}V @ BV @ BUO d B>C l d O RB d @ B>I WSd IdZ[I[IKOIB[l d B\h\_JPOSIOXV©^KlmB @ JP\W, ,WRJLMYWRd `[MLB2BWR\h\_JPQSIW&IZ[C`aB d W&I[WRC#B ;% WSI[nd eB Bl B>\_B>ISV JLVo`<^ B>IWSI B[l B\h\_JPOSI2ORjV©^KlmB JP\ s-~w s" $ .BTUOSI[\V Z[TUV V @ B I[WSC#B aO dd ¥WRI[n#@BQRJP RBoVd @ B @ I[WRC#B d mO d V @ B @ ORMPBd B[l d B\h\JLO<I*(<JYC#JLd MYW d MP^"eB WS\\OKTJYWXVBIZ[C`mB \VOWXMPM*V O<\_B"W JPV CBV_JYTB[l B\h\_JPOSIm\UK`aO<OSMLB>WRI}B[l B\h\_JPOSIm\WSI[nJPIm\_V Z[TUV_JPOSI[\ @ JPT @ W d BN<I[OI`<^V @ BUJ d \_^KC`mOSMLJYTI[WRC#B\
(98) mO d W d JLV @ C#BUV_JYTB[l d B\h\_JPOSIm\ JPVJP\WS\ORMPMLO9\ R Z\[]^Ke rq ¢< R l1X2n is vu w R Z\[]^K f -h is u0w R Z\[]2K R / s. !Bs - `R Z\[]^KTw R Z\[]^KTw. . hTi9o** J #"Y 5 ?w. R Z\[]2K. R Z\[]^K. ?@ B\hlmB>T5J LaTUWRV_JPOSI2O d ImWRC#Bn}`mOORMPBWSI B[l d B\h\JLO<I[\ WSI[nI[WSCB>nJYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\eW d B\_JYC#JLMYW d WRImn eB O<C#JLVoV @ BC I[TUB2eB2WR\h\_JPQSI[BnIZ[C`mB d \VOC#BUVhW, W d JPWS`KMLB>\ B IKBUB>nVO:RBUB>lV d WRT :OReV @ BC#uB nKO&\O `<^:T d BWRV_JYIKQ2BU7C#O d B"VhWR@ `KMPB\ d @ B d B"B @ W,@ RBNB>I<V d JLB>d \OSI[ML@ ^}O d CBVW, W d JYWR`KMPB\ WS\JYI:ORV @ B d TUWR\B\ JPV \2BWS\_^VOd QRBUV `[WST d V B:O d JPQRJYdI[WXM 5B W, RB}OSZ d \h@ Z[T VWS`KMLB>\UdI[WRC#BML^S 9 5 9 d WSI[n ;I9 d O C#BUVW,d W JYWR`KMPB\ Bl N B>\_B>ISd VJPI[Q2@ \VWRV_B>\U.W JLV C#BUV_JYTNBUKl B>\\JLO<I[d\m@`mOOSMLB>WRIB[l B\h\_JPOSIm\ WSI[n:JYI[\_V ZmTV_JPOSIm\U B\hlaBTVJL SBUMP^R VB B W, SB"WR\h\_JPQSIKB>n:I[WRC#B\V_OWRMLMW JLV C#BUV_JYTNWRImn&`mOORMPBWSI BU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\JPIm\_V d Z[TUV_JPOSI[\eWRI[n2\VWRV_B\<V_ONO d "JPV @ V @ B C#@ BUVhW, ,@ W d JYWR`[MLB>\(eB n[de B Lad IKB IKBU d Bd\hZKMLVVhWd G `[MLB>\U WRI[n <V WXV W, RBW\_JYC#JLMYW OSMLBWSI[n\V Z[TVhZ B VO2V @ B d B\h? > ZKd > MPVVhWR`KMPB\KJYIS5 9V d OKn[@ ZmTBn}JYI}@ \BTUV_JPOSIs[m`[Z[VTOSI<;<9 VhWXJYII[WSCB>nd BU[l d B>\@ \JPOSI[\ d <JYC#JLMYW MP^RKBI[BUBn}V_O T WSIKQRBV B"TOSIm\_JY\_VBI[TU^2Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\oVO#O 2JPV I[WRC#B>nBUKl B>\\JLO<I[\
(99) aO d JYI[\VWRImTBRKV @ BNTO<I[\_JY\V_BImT^ Z[ImTV_JPOSIO d W d JPV @ CBV_JYT Z[I[TVJLO<IJP\WS\ORMPMLO\ is Y i J { i=|76>R { i=| aw | J i Z\[]^K 6>R Z\[]^K §9 w | J iDR { i=|76>R Z\[]^K 6/u w < ,W.
(100) . !. !. . ! # !
(101) . !.
(102) . ! !.
(103) . !
(104) . . 9I5 9# . . !
(105) iR. <R -TR . Ds s9s` =. .
(106) Ds s s. . !
(107) !
(108) . . r +% G . J. %. J % . . I9 5 9 . !
(109) . . 9I5 9 . 9I5 9 . . . . .
(110) !
(111)
(112) .
(113) % . *¥X2 X2 % . . . .
(114) . . Y¥X2. "! R$#.
(115) r>s.
(116)
(117) ! F INV @. B WS`md O SBR % d @ 9I5 9 #d JY\]V @ B
(118) MH d O<C d V @ B I[WSCB>nN\_VhWXVd BV_O \VWRV_BR<JYC@ JPMYW d ML^ @ B IKBBnV_OV WSI[\MPWRV_B W JPV C#BUdVJPT(BU[l B>\\JPOSI[\U`aO<OSMLB>WRd I@B[l B\h\JLO<I[\*d WRI[nJYI[\V Z[TVJLO<I[\UjuB d T WRIKQSB V B"TO<I[\d JP\V_B>I[T^Z[I[TVJLO<I[\o?O @ MLOO<d<ZmlJYI&W d \_VhWXVBRmW JPV C#BV_JY@ TBd [l B\h\_JPOSI[\[`aO<OSMLB>WRI}B[l B\h\_JPOSIm\ WSI[n}JPI[\V Z[TUV_JPOSI[\WS\eBU@ MPM BU@ ^W BN\JPC#JPMPW WRI[n}eBNO<C#JLVoV d BUJ nKBUVhWXJPM @ BWRMP\OIKBBn:V_OT WRI[QRBNV BBU WRMPZ[WRV_JPOSI}Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\WRTTO nKJYIKQSML^Sm\_OV WRVeBTUWRIeO d JLV @ V @ BI[@ WSCB>nBU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\
(119) mO d JYI[\_VhWRI[TUBRRI[O5BU WRMPZ[WRV_JPOSIZ[I[TUV_JPOSIO d W d JPV @ C#BV_JYTeBU[l d B>\\JPOSI[\JPMLM `aBNV B OSMLMPOJYIKQm. s 9 . ]. ,,. | J iDR { w i J DR. R { i=|;w. R Z\[]^KTw. R F,. # . ,,,. R T . !. S>Q*¥ i R VR -k]. '/Q*dS4J ` . ? >>. ,,. . . i=|76/um6/u { i=|76>R Z\[]^K/6/u v w , !
(120) F , ,,. XK= J XRVu . . . !
(121) . R R. f/-h R i ! ? >> !
(122) . U#?% l1X2n o ! ? >> !
(123) . U # R v X2XIYK iR io2 ! ? > > % ! ? > > !
(124) . . % ! ? >>" !
(125) . % s s9s. #& *"X2
(126) % 9s s s. #? % . % ! ? >>" !
(127) . $# Y¥X2 *"X2 % s s9s. M#&*"X2 . % s9s s. #&Y¥X2 % 2, 3 % ! ? > > = !
(128) . t U# s9s s % 2,76 % ! ? > > = !
(129) . ! $# s s9s h>i9o*YJ # " 5 iR ! ? > > !
(130) . $# *¥X2. J. Jd O. d d @ ?@ d d @ @ d d
(131) (J \VUWRSl[el BTO<@ WRWRT IKQSJPB\n\_V ^K@ \BV_B>JYC#I[l[WRZ[V_JYV TXV_ ONV @ BUBJ d \_VI[WSZ[CTUVB>Z n2B TOSJYZm\ISXVB>B lKd l[VW Zmd VI[\(T WSI[WRI[n2QR\_BB>nTOSImJPn*V RV©BWROn[C2n[BWXn2JYIWRI#nKJdBz.KB V d B>W I[d TZKB>ML\UB VO nKBWRM*d JLV @ V @ @ B"C#BU@ VhW, ,W d JYWR`[MLBS Bl Od SB V WRV V JY\ B WXMYZ[WXVJLO<I@ Z[I[@TUV_JPOSd IWRQ d BUB>\*JLV @ V @ BeO<@ lmB d WRV_JPOSI[WRMS\@ BC2WRI<VJPT\jQSJL SBIN`<^NV @ d B JYI[n[ZmTV_JP RB d BUMYWXVJLO<I |d s" s @ s WXMPM*V BV BUO Bd C2d\QR@ JP RB>I`aBUMPO d W, SB `aBUB>IT BT XB>n JYI}W2TO<C2l[ZKV_B G WS\\JY\_VBnl OOX B BJY\oV B"\VWRV_B>CB>I<VeO W JLV C#BUVJPTB[l B\h\JLO<I[\U ¢§.>¢ #*). +. Z. +. . +. 9I5 9. R T `R { i=|, +. !. { i =| , + ! ? >>" i J <R { { i =|76/um6/u ,. + Z\[]^K , i =|76>R Z\[]2K46/u:, !
(132) i J <R R R Z\[]2#K , + T { i=|-, + Z\[]^K , + R vu ,. | J i { i=|k6;R i J ;Z\[]^K/6>R. #
(133) r . ? > > 9I5 9# w. R. . !. ? >> . R - w. RKRTSUWVXYZ. !. %. w. . 9 5 9
(134) . !
(135) . ? > > = . 5#. !
(136) . 9I5 9# . . w. . !
(137) . R. %. . . .
(138) . .
(139) rt. H H H. w r +% , BWXMY\_Ol d O RBnV @ WRV(BU WXMYd Z[WXVJLO<IZ[I[TUd V_JPOSI[?\@ O d `mOd OSMLB>WRI"BU[dl d B>\\JPOSI*@ ,dV_OZ[d l.n[WXVBCB>C#O @ d ^"\_VhWXV_B WSI[n}V_O2MLOO<<ZmlJYI<V_O W C#BC#O ^\_VhWXVBWRQ BUBS B^}W B\_JYC#JLMYW WSI[n}V B BUO B BOSC#JLVV BC 8.
(140) !. . . !. !
(141) !
(142) !. d B @ TUWSI[IKORVnKBLaIKB#V @ B2BU WRMPZ[d WRV_JPOSIZ[I[TVJLO<IO d JYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I[\d JPIuV @ B2\JYCJPMYW d d W,^WSd\\ @B
(143) MnK VJPn
(144) 5 O d W JPV CBV_JYT WSI[n`aOORd MPBWSI d B[l d B\h\_JPd OSIm\U\_JYI[F TUB BUd B>TUZKd VJLO<I OX JPI[\V d Z[TU V_JPOSI JPId l[W VJPTZKMPW " H n[ O< B>@\" IKOS V" ORMPMPO d \V Z[d TVhZ WXM @ BTZ \d JPOSI* IOSZ l BU JLO<Z[@ \d O D @Bl d B\BI<d V_B>n d V_OO }W O<Z[I[nV JP\l OS`KMPBCBQSJL SBW\ O V WRTTO<Z[I<V B BRaO C#O BnKBUVhWXJPMP\ eB \hZKQSQR?B@ \VV_O d B>WRn}V @ BNO d JPQRJYI[WRMaO d d . d B#d BU WRMPZ[WRV_JPOSI:ZmI[TVJLO<I&O d JYI[\_V ZmTV_JPOSd Im\ TWR@I`aB#l d O JYnKBn&JYIWW,^:V @ WXV d B>\laBTU@ V\ V© ^ l[JPIK Q WSHI[ n VB C#!JPI[WRHV_ JPOSII5>J eB: nK"OS I V2 V Y
(145) ^ HV_OnK B> \ T JY`mB V B B" WX AMYZ[
(146) M WXV JL O< IB Z[I[TUHV_JPOSWI JL?Vh\_@ BM `[ZKV2V B JY\ Z[ImTV_JPOSI}TUWSI`mB n[ B LaIKB>nJYIV©^KlmBNV @ BUO d ^`<^TWR\B\oOSI}V @ B"\_V d Z[TUVZ d BOX(V @ BNJYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I* . . . . " . R { i=|;w | J iDR { i=|k6/um67u rw | J iAR { i=|76/u 6/um6>R { i =| | J iAR { i=|76>R Z\[]^K 6/urw i J DR { i=|76>R _a[]^K 6 w | J iAR { i=|76>R bdR9 }6>R { i=| ew XK= J XRtR { i=| wR bLR=iw R { i=|;w | J iAR { i=|76/u 6/u w | J iDR { i=|/6/u 6/um6>R { i=| w | J iAR { i=|76>R Z\[]2K46/urw | J iDR { i=|76>R _a[]2K46 w | J iAR { i=|76>R bLR=i`6>R { i=| ew XvK9 J XvRtR { i=| F, , , % HF , , , % >F , ,, ! ? ! 5 9 F , , , , , , !
(147) , , , !
(148) F , , , ! ! ;I9 F, , , >>" . R bdR9 aw. w. . % STQ=Y" % 4% H¢4% '/Q*dS4J 9I=JLK % ! ? > > . . . !. ! ;I9 59. . ! !
(149) ! .
(150) . !. ! ;I9 U#&% . pS>Q*JU <% :>WX% H % ! ? > > ! 5 9# !
(151) !
(152) ! ! ;I9 S>Q*JU A% :>W-X% H % H% s s9s s s9s J
(153) % :1 ! ? > > !
(154) 1 !
(155) . #&= % H% s9s s # *¥X2. % : ! ? > > !
(156) = !
(157) . #B U# % J Y¥X2 J d % :1 ! ? > > !
(158) !
(159) . #?*¥X2 . O d % H7% s s s0 #&*"X2. O p S>Q*J$ V% :>WXM% H % H% s s9s s s9s #?Y¥X2 ihTi9o** J #"Y
(160) R . % . s s9s U#&Y¥X2. B#OSC#JLVV @ BZ[MLMnKB>\T d JYd lKV_JPOSIOX d V @ BB@ WXMYZ[WXVJLd O<I&Z[I[TUV_JPOS I
(161) M] WR\JPVC2WSXB\ V @ BVBKVZmI d B>WRn[WS`KMPB WSI[nTUWRI`aBNBWR\JPML^Z[ImnKB \_VOOn OSC V B"nKB\hT JYlKV_JPOSI}OX TMYWRZ[\BR "! R$#.
(162) r,q.
(163)
(164) ! . d JPV_JYIKQ V @ BZ[I[TUV_JPOSI JY\BUKWSTVML^}V @ B\hWRC#B"WS\ d JPV_JYIKQV @ B d BTZ d \JP RBZ[I[TUV_JPOSI* @ d BU[TBl[VV WXV B>TUZ d \_JP RB}TUWXMPMY\W d B\_JYC2lKML^ d Bl[MPWSTBn`<^Wu`mO<Z[I[n W d JYWR`KMPB @ B d B JYI d BTUZ d \JL SB TWXMPMP?\ @ B#Z[ImTV_JPOSI nKB\hT d JP`aB\V @ B#TUOSC2l[ZKVhWXVJLO<I[\V @ WRVW d B2lmB d O d C#B>nWXVBWST @ JPV_B d WXVJLO<I&OXV @ B BUKBTUZ[ V_JPOSI@ Z[I[T@ VJLO<I:WRI[d nV @ d BNBKBTZKV_JPOS I
(165) Z[I[WTU V_JPOSI:
(166) lm B d O d !C2 \o V @ B"\WSC#Bd TUOSC2l[ZKVhWXVJLO<I@ WS\oV @ BZmI[T G VJLO<I B>IV BMPWRV_VB JP\ BlaBWRV_B>n iWXVB eBJPMLM]Z[\BV BOSMLMPOJPI[Q I[ORVWRV_JPOSI # , s s9s Fs9s s / 0.1 3 LV_JYC#B\ N I[ n LaImWXMPML^V_OTOSC2lKMPBUVB"V @ BVWS\}OX d BaBTVJLO<I:eBl d O SB"V @ WXV V @ BB WXMYZ[WXVJLO<IZmI[TVJLO<I&O d JYI[\V d Z[TVJLO<I^JPBUMYn[\oV @ B\hWRC#B d B\hZKMLVWS\oV @ BNO<lmB d WRV_JPOSI[WRM¥\BC2WSISVJPT\U ¢§.>¢ *E) F I<VZ[JLVJL SBUMP^Rm. " ". + I9 5 9# +. . , +. i J <R , i J <R i J <R. ! | J i { i=|k6;R { i=| " { { ! | J i V R i = | k k 6 m u / 6 m u > 6 R i=| #
(167) i J ;Z\[]^K/6>R Z\[]^K !
(168)
(169) i J _a[]^K/6>R _a[]^K !
(170) ! | J iVbdR9 }6>R bLR=i ! ! i J VR. . + + + +. I} . 59. ;I9 . . , +. , +. R R 9 }R { i=|. ,+. I9 5 9#
(171) = . w. , +. . . w.
(172) = . R J R . R. a. . ,+. ? >>. . { i=|76>R Z\[]2K46/u:, { i=|76>R _a[]2K46 M, { i=|76>R bLR=i`6>R { i=| , { i=|, + J ebLR=i , T. ;<9 . R J ebLR=i., +. ! ;<9 . !. !. ? > > . 59. 9 5 9 . . ? > > !. w. . { i=|76/um6/u ,. ! # . . . !
(173) !. . 59. !
(174) ! . R. JL. ! ;I9 .
(175) .
(176) 1. ;I9 e#. ! !. !. R . ! ;I9 . . J. w i=|, R . G p ¢J PJ \WZ[I[TVJLO<I @ JYT @ \hZ[C2\"Z[lV @ B O d 9 59 `<^WRMLM TUOSI[\JY\_VBI[TU^&Z[I[TUV_JPOSI[\ImWRC#BUMP^ ? >> 5 9 WSI[n ;I9 ORV_B&V @ WXV2B&l d O JYnKB d BlKMYWRTUJPIKQV @ B`mO<Z[I[n ,W d JYWR`[MLB nKB>IKORVBn `<^ B>W d MLJPB d eV_OV @ B ZmI[d TVJLO<I[WX M @ VO:BKBTZKV_B#V @ B l d ORQ d d WSC d KBTZKV_JPOSIOXdhed W:d l d ORd Q d WSC WRJLMY\JYI@ BJLV @ B d OXV©eO:TUWSd \_B>\U
(177) (J \VU J V BBUKBTUZ[V_JPOSI B>I[TO<Z[I<V_B \WSI<^ Z[I<V_JYC#BB O O \BTUOSI[n]J "V BQRJP RBI IZ[C`mB OR JPV_B d WRV_JPOSI[\ @ B d B L JP\I[ORVBI[OSZKQ @ V_O L.IKJP\ @ V @ BNBUB>TUZKVJLO<I* " :
(178) U:. ?@ JP\}V_B>T @ IKJYb<Z[BV_O WR\h\JLQ<I I[WRC#B\}V_O C#BUVW, W d JYWR`KMPB\ @ WR\W WR\V:lmOSV_BI<VJPWRM F V}JY\\_^K\V_BC2WRV_JYT WSI[n nKOB\IKOSVnKB@ laBImn O<I5V @ BMYWRIKQ<Z[WXQSBR @ Z d C#BUV @ OKn V d JLB>\2@ V_OC2WKJYC J UB:V @ BlmOSV_B>ISVJPWR@ MO d WSZKV_O<C2WXV_JPOS`I *eB W, RBeJPC2lKMPBC#BI<VBn"W VWSTV_JYT V WXV(\hZ[TUTUB\h\gZKMPMP^ WSI[nKMPB\TO<C#l[MLBUQSOSWRMP\]B O<lmB V?O@ WSdl[lKMP^:d V @ B2\WSC#d BVBT @ IKJYbZKB"O d MPW d QS@ B d MYWR@I[QSZ[WRQRB\ WRI[nuZ[\_B#V @ BC JYIul d OOXd\WR`aOSZKd VTO<@ C#l[JLMPB d d \U B B2W B QSOOn BWR\OSIm\ VO`aBUMPJLB RB2V WRV"V JP\NJPMPMe`aBlmO<\\JP`[MLB`aBTWRZ[\B2OSZ WSl[l OSWST JY\N RB ^ \^K\_VBC2WXVJPTR F I d BTUBI<VO d OSI&W C#O d BTUOSC2lKMPBUVB"l d OSQ d WRC2C#JPI[Q#MYWRI[QSZ[WRQRBJLV @ l d OTUBn[Z d BS[eB {. . ! . RKRTSUWVXYZ. !
(179) . !.
(180) . !. !. . . !. " .
(181) r. H H H. UT OSZKMYn:@\_BBNV @ @ WRVV @ BNZ[I[TUV_d JPOSI[WRM d WRlml d O<WRT @ TUW dhd JLB>\oO RB d d I[JPTUBUMP^V_OMPW d QSB d l d ORQ d WSC#C#JYIKQ#MPWSIKQSZ[WRQRBS B RB>IF V OS@ ZKQ \Bd C2WSISd VJPT\ B>b<Z[J B\oCZ[d VZ[WRM]JPImn[Z[TVJL SBNN l O<lmO<\_JPV_JPOSIm\U d I V BMPJLVB WXVZ BueBuOSZ[Imn O `<^ WRI[TU^ 2W,^ WSI[n RBz BU^ [
(182) RO^KTB @ B d BV @ BU^ n[@ JP\hTUdZ[\h\WRd `aOSZKV *
(183) *
(184) *
(185) H t OdZKVo@ V @ JY\ed O d JP\onKJdz¥B d BI<V d OSC O<Z d d \UdWR\JYI V BUJ eO \_^KC`ad ORMPJYToZ[I[TUV_JPOS@ I[WRMa@ B ,d WRMPZmd WXV_JPd OSI2JY\WRIF WRMLQSO dhJLdV C7O BU@ B>TUZKVJPI[Q"Z[I[d TUV_JPOSI[WRd Mal ORQ WSC2\ VO&BU WXMYZ[WRV_B B[l B\h\JLO<I[\JPI d JPQ B O nKB MLOSQRJYTX VTUW JLB>\ O<ZKVNV BMLOSQRJYTUWRMV WRI[\_O @ C2WXV_d JPOSIm\ OR BU[l[WRI[n[JPIKdQNnKd B LaIKJPV_JPOSI[\R`aBUVhW G B>n[Z[TVJLO<IWSI[n2d \_JYC2?lK@ MPMJ LaTWXVJLO<IOR¥`[Z[JLMPIV G d JPI2TUOSI[\VWSISVh\(JPI#V Bl B\BI[TUBd ORoZm@ IKJPI<VB l Bd V_B>@nTUOSI[\VWSI<d V\"WSI[nb<Zm@ WRI<V_5J LmB \ B^@ \hZKQRQSd B\VNnKLJ z¥B BI<VNMPBU SBUMY\Nd OXdBU WRMPZ[WRV_JPOSIuO \hZ[T WSI&WXMPQRO JPV C VOVB CJYI[WRV_BN JPMLBBU WXMYZ[WRV_JYIKQ V B#W QSZ[C#B>ISVh\oOX Z[I[JPI<V_B l BV_Bn}Z[ImTV_JPOSIm\U OeB RB d V @ JY\ <JYI[n:OX TWRl[WS`KJLMPJPV©^}WXM d BWRn[^BKJY\_Vh\JYI:V @ B C§ l d OOR G WS\\JP\VWSI<VUK @ B d B"V @ B"VhWRTVJPT
(186) nKOB\W\JYCJPMYW d O d a F I:OSZ d eO d eB\ @ OBnW oW,^V_O d BWS\_O<IO<I&C#BUVW, W d JYWR`KMPB\ IKB TWRI ?@ @ W, SB\_O<CBJYIO d C2WXVJLO<I d d BMPWRV_Bn#@VOZ[IKJYI<d V_B d l d @ BUVBn2\_@ ^KC`mOSMP\ WSI[d n Z[\BJPV JPI WSI2JPI<Vd BUMPMLJPQRB>ISVo@ W,^R BC2WRJPIMLB>\\OSIBMPBW I[BnJPI#V JP\O JY\(V BVBT IKJYbZKBoO ImWRC#JPI[Q\hZ[B` G B[l B\h\JLO<I[\jV WXV C2WSXB\JPVlmO<\\JY`KMLBVO d BWS\_O<IWS`mO<ZKVIKOSBI G©TMPOS\Bn}l d ORQ d WRC2\ X : r F OW d V @ BR2v k ZK^K\2WSI[n c OoW d B>I[n d BUQSVU N V©HO G MPBU RBM#WSl[l d OSWST @ V_OoW d n[\MPBWSI l d OOX G©T @ B>T SJYIKQa F I. OoB d W d nKJWSI[nv O<l[laOm]B>nKJLVO d \Ud d P(I H P
(187) ,m SORMYZ[C#B#rSr>q 6OR aml[WRQRB>\ r sSqK[l JYIKQRB ¥r q[ D RB>\ OoB d VORVU B>I[WRI UJPO WSl d BV_VhW[*WRI[n "Z[I<VWRM 2WS\ OW d C2WRI] ? ^Kla B G V @ BO d BUV_JYTNZmI[TVJLO<I[WXM \BC2 (WSIS VJPT\U" ! F I $JYT#VO d} W d d H B I[ Om &%(' BH "\h*W d ) !v Z !IK O SoH!WSI[*
(188) n <HO L BA IK B ? WR+ \ @ !W d "# BnKJP -V_O ,/d .\.0 , B S SORMYZ[C#B DXtmr>xOR H [l[WRQRB\ 6Ss 6[ml d JYIKQRB d G B d MPWRQmDXxRx<DK s KWRCZ[BUM OoOSZ[V_JYI*0 J \JPI[Q d BaBTVJLO<I5VO`[ZKJPMPn B 4TUJLB> IS VWS I[n Y
(189) T B d3 V_5J LmB> n n[BIT JY\JLO<HI l d OK T B> n[Z dIB \54 F I vW d V>1 H I N `[WRn[J"WRI[n ? WS>W,^<WR\hZ F V_Oa B>nKJLVO d \U2 . H 76 8) ! ! H!Y
(190) $ 9+ 3
Documents relatifs
cosinus (en bleu à gauche) et d’une droite (en noir à droite) sur les données simulées pour 4 années à une température de 45°C, avec un bruit de fond interne réduit de 100,
Florence CARRÉ ~ Réoccupations funéraires de sépultures collectives néolithiques dans la boucle du
2 Vue plus en détails dans le chapitre 1... 2 phénomène d’agrégation des protéines amyloïdes en fibres et d’autres facteurs impor- tants doivent être pris en compte comme
In this chapter, we prove an a posteriori error estimates for the generalized overlapping domain decomposition method with Dirichlet boundary conditions on the boundaries for
Revue française d’héraldique et de sigillographie – Études en ligne – 2020-10 © Société française d’héraldique et de sigillographie, Paris,
Dans ce cas, comme les coulées du Bras de Sainte-Suzanne appartiennent au massif de La Montagne daté à plus de 2 Ma (McDougall, 1971), l’ensemble des coulées pahoehoe
In infantile Pompe disease patients, the glycogen storage diffusely affects brainstem motor and sensory neurons, and the whole spinal cord sensory neurons, interneurons, and
De ce point de vue, il est possible d’affirmer que la mission est accomplie : les projets de renouvellement urbain (GPV et ORU) élaborés depuis 1998 dans une centaine de villes
