Adaptable Replicated Objects in Distributed Environments
27
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Adaptable Replicated Objects in Distributed Environments Mesaac Makpangou 5 6
(3) 7 8 9:; , ,< 9=,>@?5,$% ".0/1$%#/1,2 34. Georges Brun-Cottan
(4) !#"%$'&)(*+)+-,$.0/1$%#/1,2 34. ACBEDGFIH7J Mai 1995. PROGRAMME 1. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10) "!$#% & '( )
(11) * !,+- '/.0!12
(12) 3!4 5687:9";:68<>=49"? @BAC47EDFDHGE@.
(13) !#"%$'&)(*+)+-,$.0/1$%#/1,2 34. I 68<FG:GKJ I GKL&M/GE@ ;:7:?. 5 6
(14) 7 8 9:; , ,< 9=,>@?5,$% ".0/1$%#/1,2 34. NOPRQROSRTUTVXW0YZ[O"\]&^`_aVb\c_ d&O Vbegf ShOSRijilVbk i`VbeHmon SReaVbe0poVqpoPsr&ruVHt Vbebm&O:Vbt eaVbSRd:v VH_[e wKea_HVbk TVbe0p&^xea_aO"^`n duVbt e NOP8yzVH_4{ |,} }[Shf&f PRO _gpoV O Vb\"]oVHO\"]oV~r/XRRRY SR^WbRR%Y Rf ShQRVbe b Rs ]&^je>f Shf VHO-f&O VbeaVbrE_ eSRrShO\] ^`_aVb\c_ doO VSRr&pSOd&r:_ ^xTUVe dof fPRO_>VbrEK^`OPsr&TVbrE_PRO SRp&Shf&_ ShnBi`V,O VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_ eH ]oV ShO\]&^x_aVb\c_ doO VqeaVHf ShO"Sh_aVbeu_ ]oV _ wKf Vc eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\4i`PRQs^x\ PR(SO VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpXPRn:yaVb\c_HmKVR£Qoo\cPsr&\Hd&O O Vbr&\cwU\cPsrE_aO Psi¤mK¥OPsT¦_ ]oV4QRVbroVHO^j\[i`PRQs^x\hmKVR£Qo:\cPsr: e ^xe _aVbr&\cw§TUSRr&ShQRVbTVbrE_H ZO VHf ix^j\HSh_aVbp¨PRn:yaVb\c_,^xe0e _aOd&\c_ doO Vbp^xrE_aP\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ e0©[^`_ ] QRVbroVHO^j\U^xrE_aVHO SR\cVbebXZ%f&O PRQROSRTUTUVHO>\HSRrªSRp&Shf _>SO VHf ij^x\HSh_aVbp«PRn:yaVb\c_>_aP§_ ]oVShf&f ix^¢ \HSh_ ^`Psr¬eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\HenKwO VHf ixSR\H^jroQª\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ eU_ ]&Sh_^xTfBi`VbTVbrE_QRVbroVHO^x\§ixPRQs^x\h®|,doO ShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doO VRmo©0]&^xi`V,TUSh¯:^xroQ-_ ]oV O VHf ix^j\HSh_aVbpPRnoyzVb\c_u° Vcvo^`n ixVRmKpoPKVbegroPR_gf&OVb\Hixd&poV4PRfo _ ^xTU^x±bSh_ ^`Psr&en SRe VbpUPsrUPRnoyzVb\c_eaVbTUSRrE_ ^x\He3PROPsrXShf&fBix^x\HSh_ ^`PsrUe fVb\H^`¡B\HeH²Z³_aPKPsi¢n PbvUPR O VbSRpowE_aPh d&eaV>PRn:yzVb\c_ eO Vbp&d&\cVbep&VHRVbi`PRf TVbrE_\cPsea_PRO[roVH©´O VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c__ wKf VbeH µ¨¶E· ¸ ¹º 8»R O VHf ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsr/m[\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw³TXSRr&ShQRVbTVbrE_Hm[¡Br&VQROSR^jr¬\cPsr \HdoO O Vbr&\cw \cPsrE_aO Psi¤m&PRn:yaVb\c_[eaw:ea_aVbTmBp&^xea_aO^xn do_aVbpeawKe _aVbT ¼¢½¿Á¾ ÀÂbà ¿¾ Ä(Å`À ƤÇcÈ.
(15) q
(16) ² '
(17) )
(18) g
(19) 3
(20) !$
(21) 3!,+'/.0!!
(22) 312
(23) 3!4 '
(24) 3g' ¶ ¶
(25) V f ShfB^`VHOgf&OoVbt eaVbrE_aVd&r&V,ShO"\]&^`_aVb\c_ d&O VqVH_[d&rVbrE:^`O Psr&roVbTUVbr _p £VcvVbt \Hdo_ ^`Psr¨fPsd&OpoVbe PRn:yaVH_ eXOoVHt fBix^K dVbt eSRp&Shf _ Shn i`VbeH ShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doO V«e:VHt f ShO V«i`VbeT Vbt \HSRr&^xe TVbepuVHt f Vbr&p&SRrE_ p&d_ wKf Vp&V-i£ PRnoyzVH_ Vcv ixV-\cPsrE_aOPs i`VpoV\cPsr&\HdoOO Vbr&\cV[ poVbe T Vbt \HSRr&^xe TUVbe,Q Vbt ruVHt O"^Ed&Vbe Vcv i`VU\cPsrE_aOPs i`VXp&VX\cPs]VHt O Vbr&\cV" 0 rªPRn:yaVH_qO:VHt f ix^K duVt Vbea_-ea_aOd&\c_ doOoVXt Vbr \cPsTf Pse SRrE_ e T-d&r&^xep ^xr _aVHOSR\cVbe3Q Vbt ruVHt O"^E d&VbeH 0 rXf&O PRQROSRTUTUVbdoOf Vbdo_3SRp&Shf _aVHOd&rUPRn:yzVH_O:VHt f ix^KduV t SRd nVbe Ps^xrªp d roVXShf&f ij^x\HSh_ ^`Psr/m(Vbr O VbTfBixSR\HSRr _-i`Vbe-\cPsTf Pse SRr _ eQ Vbt rVHt O^K doVbeH 0 PR_aO V ShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doO VRm _aPsdo_ Vbr«O Vbr&p&SRrE_ i£ PRn:yaVH_ O:VHt f ix^K duV-t ° Vcvo^`n i`VRm/r£ Vcvo\Hixdo_,f SRe i`Vbe,PRf _ ^xTU^¢ e Sh_ ^`Psr en SRe:VHt Vbe4e doO4ixSeKVbt TUSRrE_ ^E d&VpoV>i £ PRn:yzVH_0Psd¨i`Vbe[\HShOSR\c_KVHt O^xea_ ^K doVbe,Shf&f ij^x\HSh_ ^`RVbeH 4 roVn P`! _aVSXk Psd&_ ^xixe[p £ PRn:yzVH_ e0f&O"VH _ eXSk i£ VbTf i`Ps^ f VHOTVH_0p&VOoVbt p&d ^`O V>i`Vbe4\cP do _ e,poVpVct RVbi`PRf&f VbTVbrE_poV>r&PsdoRVbSRd:v_ wKfVbe[p£ PRn:yaVH_ eOoVHt f ix^#E duVbt eH. $ º ¸ & % ¶ OoVHt f ix^j\HSh_ ^`Psr/m \cPsrE_aO Ps i`V[p&V\cPs]VHt O Vbr&\cVRm:\cPsr _aOPs ixV0poV\cPsr&\Hd&O O Vbr&\cV-Sqk QROSR^xr ¡Br/m&e wKea_HVbk TVSk PRn:yaVH_ eHm eaw:ea_cVbk TV>OoVHt fBShO _ ^.
(26)
(27)
(28) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$ ;. <. :. !,'/.qU) / .0!. }VHfBix^x\HSh_ ^`Psr^xe[OVb\cPRQsr&^`±HVbpPRf&O^jTUShO w^xrE_aVHO Vbea_4_aPVbr&] SRr&\cV-S8SR^jixShn ^xix^x_ wSRr&pO Vbix^xS8 n ^xij^`_ w§^xrp&^xe _aO^`n do_aVbp¨Vbr :^`O Psr TVbr _ eb}[VHf ix^x\HSRe,roVHVbp_aPn V-TXSR^xr _ SR^jroVbp\cPsr e ^xea_aVbrE_Hm ©[]&^j\]OSR^jeaVbeg_ ]oV>^je e doV,PR²_ ]oV 5='/$($> ' ?@5'9 -6 ! A ©[]&^x\"]§\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cweaVbTUSRrE_ ^x\He ^xeqShf f&O PRf&O^jSh_aV¥PRO-Sf ShO _ ^x\Hd ixShO>Shf&f ij^x\HSh_ ^`Psr BDC[P©%^xeq_ ]oVX\cPsrE_aOSR\c_-^jTf i`VbTVbrE_aVbp ©[^`_ ]&Psdo_yzVHPRf ShO"p&^`±b^xroQPRVHOSRixi(f VHO PROTUSRr \cEV B F,H^ G VHO Vbr _²Shf&f ij^x\HSh_ ^`Psr&e/O"V Ed&^xO V3p&H^ G VHO VbrE_\cPsrE_aOSR\c_ e\cPsr&\cVHOr ^xroQ0\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw PR O VHf ix^¢ \HSh_aVbpea_ Sh_aVRmEPROp&H^ G VHO VbrE__aOSRpoVH=P G/e3n VH_Á©VHVbrf VHO ¥PRO"TUSRr&\cVSRr&p\cPsr&e ^xea_aVbr \cwR ¨PROVHPh RVHObm PsroV-f ShO _ ^x\Hd ixShO0\"]oPs^x\cVTU^`Qs]E_0\"]&SRroQRV^xrSp&^ GVHO VbrE_0r&VH_ ©PRO ¯K^jroQVbrE:^`O Psr&TVbrE_ PRO©[]&Vbr_ ]oVqShf&f ij^x\HSh_ ^`PsrVHRPsi`RVbeH I VShOV¨Sb©uShO V¨PR,_ ]oOVHV¨Shf&f&O PsSR\"]oVbeHmf&O PRf PseaVbpnKw PR_ ]&VHOSRdo_ ]oPRO"eHm_aP SRp&Shf _U_ ]oV \cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw \cPsrE_aOSR\c__aPShf&f ix^j\HSh_ ^`Psr eaf Vb\H^¢¡\HeHK J²^`Oe _HmShf&fBix^x\HSh_ ^`Psr³f&O PRQROSRTXTVHOe TU^`Qs]E_>\"]oPEPse VSRTPsroQS§OSRroQRVXPRu\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw TUSRr ShQRVbTVbr _-f&O PR_aP:\cPsixee dof&f PRO _aVbp nKw_ ]oVeaw:ea_aVbM T L N&m OKQm PSR {:Vb\cPsr&p/m f O PRQROSRTUTVHO"e[\HSRr«d&eaVqnBSRe ^x\qnBd&^xixp&^jroQnBi`PK\¯KTe L£U R _aP«^xTf i`VbTUVbr _ VbSRe ^ji`w Se d ^`_ Shn i`VU\cPsr&e^xea_aVbr&\cw TUSRr ShQRVbTVbr _-f&O PR_aP:\cPsi¤ ]&^`Op(m/f&O Ph QROSRTUTUVHOe[\HSRr^xTf ixVbTVbr _u_ ]oVn Vbea_\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cw§\cPsr _aO"SR\c_HmBO VbixwK^xr&QPsr¨ea_aOd \c_ doO^xroQ TP:poVbixe(TXSh¯K^xr&Q_ ]oV\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwqTXSRr&ShQRVbTVbrE_f&OPR_aPK\cPsiKSg¡ O"ea_ \HixSRe e PRn:yaVb\cV_ L¢WRWRmK!W WSR ]oVbe VShf&f&OPsSR\]oVbeSRp&poOVbe eqPsr&ixw f ShO _>PRg_ ]&VXf&O PRnBi`VbT ]&VU¡ Oe _>PsroV¥P:\Hd&eaVbePsr f VHO PROTUSRr&\cVn do_p&PEVbe-ix^xTU^x_ _ ]oV\"]oPs^x\cVPRgf&O PRQRO"SRTUTVHOe_aP S¨f&OVbpoVc¡BroVbp eaVH_PR f&O PR_aP:\cPsixeH ]&V,ijSRea_u_ ©PXi`VbSbRVShf&f ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsrXf&OPRQROSRTUTVHOeu©0^`_ ]_ ]oV,n doOpoVbrPRf&O Ph QROSRTUTX^xroQ_ ]oVb^`O\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw\cPsrE_aOSR\c_H ]&^jegf Shf VHO[f&OVbeaVbr _ e4SRrShO\]&^x_aVb\c_ doO VSRr&pSXOd&r:_ ^jTVqVbrEK^`OPsr&TVbrE_[PRO
(29) -"
(30) "X5 !%$ Y JoPRO° Vcvo^`n ^jix^`_ wRm _ ]oV[f&OPRfPse VbpShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doOV4ea_aO"d&\c_ doO VbeS>OVHf ix^x\HS8 _aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_,^jr _aP_ ]oO VHV-¯K^jr&p&egPR3\cPsTUfPsr&Vbr _ e A SR\H\cVbe e,PRnoyzVb\c_ eHm O VHfBix^x\HSRe[SRr p\cPsr&e^xez _aVbr&\cwTUSRr&ShQRVHOeH&Z -Z[
(31) Vbr&\HShf e d ixSh_aVbegSi`P:\HSRi\cPRfKwXPR_ ]oV,O VHf ix^j\HSh_aVbpe _ Sh_aV>SRr&p P=G VHOe[SRr^xr _aVHOSR\cV_aPTUSRr&^xf d&ixSh_aV,_ ]&^xe[ea_ Sh_aVRZ4r ,$$T5 ! ^xeS©O"Shf&f VHOg_ ]&Sh_ \cPsrE_aO PsixeSR\H\cVbe eaVbeX_aP ^`_ eSRe eaP:\H^xSh_aVbpO VHf ij^x\HS: Z 5='4$($>,' ?\7]='#^_,- \cPKPRfVHO"Sh_aVbe ©[^`_ ]SR\H\cVbe e4PRn:yaVb\c_ e0_aPTUSR^xrE_ SR^xr§_ ]&V\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cwPR_ ]oVO VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpea_ Sh_aVR/Z0\H\cVbee PRn:yaVb\c_ eSRr&pO VHfBix^x\HSReShO Vg_ÁwEf Vc eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\©[]&VHO VbSRe\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cw-TXSRr&ShQRVHOeShO VgQRVbr&VHO^x\h ]&Sh_^xeHm_ ]oV^jr _aVHOr SRii`PRQs^j\UPR[S\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cwªTUSRr&ShQRVHOpoPKVbe-roPR_-p&VHfVbr p PsrSRr w ^xroPROTUSh_ ^xPsrªO VbijSh_aVbp_aP_ ]&V_ÁwEf VPR[_ ]&VOVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp PRn:yaVb\c_H` F4Vbeaf ^`_aVn Vb^xroQQRVbroVc O^x\hm(S\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw«TUSRr&ShQRVHO-e dof&f PRO _ e0¡Br&VQROSR^xr \cPsr&\HdoOO Vbr&\cw«\cPsr _aO Psim/_ ]&SRro¯:e _aP _ wKf Vc eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\ (','9 5=' ShO Qsd&TUVbr _ e-f SRe e Vbp nKwªSR\H\cVbe ePRnoyzVb\c_ eHZ4r^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr ^xeS QRVbroVHOSRij^`±HVbp§i`P:\ ¯©[^`_ ]SQRVbr&VHO^x\q^xrE_aVHO lSR\cV _aP\cPsTfBShO Vq^`_g©[^`_ ]PR_ ]&VHO0^xrE_aVbr _ ^xPsr&eH PO Vbp d&\cVX_ ]oVpoVHRVbi`PRf TUVbr _\cPsea_-PRroVH©~OVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpªPRn:yzVb\c_-_ wKf VbeHm _ ]oVXOd r:_ ^xTV VbrEK^`OPsr&TVbrE_4=P G VHO&e a|[Z0}>m(S_aPEPsi`nPvPRO VbSRpowE_aPh d&eaVU\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ eHc b4PKP:p \HSRr: p&^xp Sh_aVbe3PROg^xr&\Hixd&e^`PsrU^xrE_aTP a|[Z0}®ShO V4\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr&ShQRVHO\HixSRe e Vbe^jTf i`VbTVbrE_ ^xroQ \cPsTUTPsr i`w d&eaVbp \cPsr&e^xea_aVbr&\cw \cPsrE_aOSR\c_ eHe d3SR\] \cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw TUSRr&ShQRVHO\HixSRe e^xTf i`Vc TVbrE_ eS¨f ShO _ ^x\Hd ixShO>\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw \cPsr _aO"SR\c_H²Z4\H\cVbe eSRr&p ^xr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr \HixSRe eaVbe>PR\cPsT TPsr&ixwXd&eaVbpO VHf ij^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yzVb\c_g_ÁwEf Vbe VR£Qo e _aOd&\c_ doO VbppoP:\Hd&TVbrE_Hm:_aO VHV SRr&p\cPsrE_ SR^¢ roVHO ShO VQRPKP:p\HSRr&p&^xp&Sh_aVbe_aPKPo (PKPR¯:^xroQ«_aP _ ]oVldo_ doO VRm PsdoOUd&i`_ ^jTUSh_aVQRPsSRi^xe-_aP VbSReaV«Sª\cPsTf PsroVbrE_zn SReaVbp³f&O PRQRO"SRTUTU^xroQoK C0^`Qs] i`wea¯K^jixi`Vbp leaw:ea_aVbT Uf&O PRQROSRTXTVHOe fgfih jk>lm>n.
(32) "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(33) ='_^_5=. N. ©[^xijiopoVHRVbi`PRf\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwUTXSRr&ShQRVHO\HijSRe eaVbeSRe3©Vbixi&SReSR\H\cVbe eHm:^xrE_aVbr _ ^`PsrSRr&pUOVHf ix^x\HS \HixSRe e VbePRO3QRVbroVHOSRi`f doO f PseaVgO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_3_ÁwEf VbeH ]oVbeaV\HijSRe eaVbeShO V_ ]oVbrTUSh¯RV SbhSR^xixShnBi`V_aPShf f ix^x\HSh_ ^`PsrUf&O PRQROSRTUTUVHOeH C0Vbr&\cVRmK_ ]oVf&O PRQRO"SRTUTVHO3PR(SroVH© OVHf ix^x\HS8 _aVbpPRn:yaVb\c__ÁwEf V0] SRe/y d&ea__aP>¡ Qsd&O V[Psdo_©[]&^j\]X\cPsTUfPsr&Vbr _ ePR ^`_ eO VHf ix^j\HSh_aVbpUPRn:yaVb\c_ _ wKf VShO VTU^xee ^xroQ4¥OPsT ag|[Z4}³SRr&p_ ]&Vbr\cPsr&\cVbr _aO"Sh_aV[Psr_ ]oVp&VHRVbi`PRf TVbrE_PRB_ ]&PseaV \cPsTf PsroVbrE_ eH 0VH©[i`wE poVHRVbi`PRf Vbpq\cPsTUfPsr&Vbr _ e \HSRr>_ ]&Vbrqn V3SRp&poVbp>^xr _aP a|Z4}qR|,r&\cV SRp&poVbp(mo_ ]oVbeaV>\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ e\HSRr¨nVqd eaVbpnEwn PR_ ]Vcvo^xea_ ^xroQUSRr proVH©®Shf&f ij^x\HSh_ ^`Psr&eH |,doO©PRO ¯\cPsT>nB^xroVbeU^xrE_aP S e ^xr&Qsi`V¥OSRTUVH©PRO ¯ _ ]oV¨SRp&8SRrE_ ShQRVbeXPR4_ ]oV_ ]oOVHV¨Shfo f&O PsSR\"]oVbe\H^`_aVbpªShn PRVRm ©0^`_ ]oPsdo_q_ ]&VpoOS©n SR\¯KeH zr f ShO _ ^j\Hd&ixShObm(_ ]&VXf&O PRf PseaVbp ShOa \] ^`_aVb\c_ doO VUpoPKVbe roPR_,f&O Vb\Hijd&poV-PRf&_ ^xTU^`±bSh_ ^xPsr&e VR£Qo(\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cwTXSRr&ShQRVbTVbrE_qTUSbw Vcv:f i`Ps^`_u_ ]oVqeaVbTXSRr _ ^x\He[PR_ ]&V PRn:yzVb\c_0TVH_ ]oP:p&eu¥PRO¡BroV,QROSR^xr§\cPsr \HdoO O Vbr&\cw\cPsr _aOPsi¤ Z4ixeaPom/PsdoO>Shf f&O PsSR\] poPKVbeqroPR_>i`VbSRVX_ ]oVXVbr _ ^`OVf&O PRQROSRTUTX^xroQ,V GPRO_>_aP§f&OPRQROSRT TVHOe /OSh_ ]oVHObm/PRVHO_ ]oV_ ^jTVRm/_ ]oVU_ SRea¯«PRf&O PRQROSRTXTVHOe,©[^xijin VU\cPsrE_ ^xrKdoPsd&e i`wO Vc p&d&\cVbp¨SRe^`_^xeij^`¯RVbi`wU_ ]&Sh_0TPsea_[\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ e©0^xixiBnV Psd&r&p^j@r ag|[Z4}q ]oVOVbea_(PR:_ ]oVf Shf VHO ^je/PRO QsSRr&^`±HVbpSRe(Psixi`P©[eH{KVb\c_ ^`Psr0uf&O VbeaVbrE_ e(_ ]&Vf&O PRQROSRTXTU^xroQ TP:poVbi SRr&p^jr _aO P:p&d&\cVbe0_ ©PShf&f ix^j\HSh_ ^`Psr&e0_ ]&Sh_4] SbRVn VHVbrnBd&^xi`_[d&fPsr¨PsdoO eaw:ea_aVbT ]oVbe V§Shf&f ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsr&eShO V§d&eaVbp SReUOd&r&r&^jroQ¨VcvoSRTf i`VbeX^xr {KVb\c_ ^`Psr[«_aP f O VbeaVbrE_PsdoO ShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doO VRh{KVb\c_ ^`Ps2r N_ ]&Vbrqp&^xe \Hd e eaVbe/eaPsTV3O VbixSh_aVbp ©PRO ¯# J²^xr&SRixi`wRm{KVb\c_ ^xPsr[upoOS©[e eaPsTV\cPsr&\Hixd&e ^xPsr&eH D. I. . g ['/.4)! ! #"%$&$&'()!*$* +-,.. VSRee d&TV _ ]oV Psixi`P©[^xroQpoVc¡r&^`_ ^`Psr&eu^xr_ ]&VqO Vbea_gPR²_ ]oVqShO _ ^j\Hi`V A / Z
(34) '9 ^xeSRr wXVbr _ ^`_ÁwXTUSh¯:^xroQ>^jr RP:\HSh_ ^`Psr&ePsrSqO VHf ij^x\HSh_aVbpXPRnoyzVb\c_H ]&^xe\HSRr n VqSX_ ]oO VbSRp/m&SXf&O P:\cVbe eHm&S_aOSRr e SR\c_ ^`Psr§PRO0VHRVbr¨S]Ed&TXSRrn Vb^xroQo I VSRe ed&TV _ ] Sh_ S0\Hix^`VbrE_^xeSb©uShO V_ ] Sh_PRn:yaVb\c_ e²ShO V3f PR_aVbrE_ ^xSRixi`w e ] ShO Vbpq©[^x_ ]qPR_ ]oVHO²\Hix^`VbrE_ eH / Z4r ! %3# ? ^xeS e VH_PR-p&Sh_ SSR\H\cVbe eaVbe§ij^xTU^`_aVbp³^xr¬_ ^xTVRV JoPRO§VcvoSRTf i`VRmuSRr SR\c_ ^xK^`_ÁwXPsrSpoP:\Hd&TVbrE_ue _aOd&\c_ doO Vbp^xrE_aP-e Vb\c_ ^`Psr&egTUSw\cPsr&e ^jea_PR TP:p&^`wK^xr&Q e Vb\c_ ^`Psr&e>W,_ ]&O PsdoQs]¨K / Z4r ! %3# ? 5=7]=(' \cPsr&e^xea_ e(Psr>_ ]oVe VH_ PRoi`PRQs^x\HSRi f ShO _ e(PR&SRr>PRn:yaVb\c_ SR\H\cVbe e Vbp nKwªSRrSR\c_ ^`:^`_ wR JoPROU^jr&ea_ SRr&\cVRm _ ]oVSR\c_ ^`:^`_ wªp&PsTUSR^xr ¥PRO_ ]oVShn PRVSR\c_ ^`:^`_ w VcvoSRTf ixVq^xr&\Hixd&p&Vbee Vb\c_ ^`Psr&e>WhmSRr&p¨K / Z 5'/$($> ' ?15=' -6# eaf Vb\H^¢¡BVbe²_ ]oVgf&O PRf VHO _ ^`Vbe²_ ] Sh__ ]oV[\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr&S8 QRVbTUVbr _,f&O PR_aP:\cPsi Td&e _d i¢¡Bixi¤/ dv:SRTfBi`VbePRe d \]f&O PRf VHO _ ^`Vbe0^xr&\Hixd&p&V,Sh_aPsTX^¢ \H^x_ wRm(^xeaPsijSh_ ^`Psr/mBSRr p_ ]&PseaV_ ]&Sh_ d&r&poVHOixwhShO^`Psd e0TP:poVbixe0PRTUVbTPRO w¨\cPsr&e^xez _aVbr \cwR / Z 5='/$>+$,,'!? -65 5!5=
(35) ^xTUf i`VbTVbrE_ eS\cPsr&e ^xea_aVbr \cw§\cPsr _aOSR\c_H(Z\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw f O PR_aPK\cPsi^jr&\Hixd&poVbe¨_ ]oVpoVH_aVb\c_ ^`PsrSRr&p _ ]oV O VbeaPsijdo_ ^`Psr PR\cPsr:°B^j\c_ eSRTUPsroQ 021 f3054.
(36)
(37)
(38) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$. \cPsr \HdoO O VbrE_SR\H\cVbe e Vbe_aP_ ]oVUO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp PRnoyzVb\c_Hm ^¤£VR\cPsr&\Hd&O O Vbr&\cw \cPsrE_aO Psi¤Z \cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw f O PR_aPK\cPsiSRixeaPf&O PK^xp&Vbe>TVb\"]&SRr&^xe TXeq_aPf&O PRf ShQsSh_aVO VHf ix^j\HS§dofo p Sh_aVbeH Z4r´Shf&f ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsr¬^je\cPsTUfPse Vbp´PR>f&OPK\cVbe e VbeH d3SR\"]´f&O P:\cVbe e^xpoVbrE_ ^¢¡ VbeSeaVHfBShOSh_aV SRp&poOVbe e(eaf SR\cVRm8SRr&p>TXSbw \cPsr _ SR^jrT-d&i`_ ^`fBi`V_ ]&O VbSRp&e(PR:Vcv:Vb\Hdo_ ^`Psr/U d3SR\"]>f&OPK\cVbe e(©[^`_ ] SR\H\cVbe eg_aPSe ]&ShOVbpXO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_u]&Psixp&eHm:^xr^`_ euSRp&poO Vbe eeaf SR\cVRmoS-O VHf ij^x\HSqPR_ ]&^xe O VHf ij^x\HSh_aVbpXPRnoyzVb\c_HoNOPK\cVbe e Vbe\cPsTUT-d&r&^j\HSh_aV4nKwUe ]&ShO"^xroQ>OVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpXPRn:yzVb\c_ :O VHfBix^x\HSRe PRgSRr PRn:yaVb\c_^jr«_ doOr \cPsTUT-d&r&^j\HSh_aVX:^xSdof/p&Sh_aVbeqTVbee ShQRVbee Vbr _>SRr p O Vb\cVb^`RVbpªnEw _ ]oVb^`O\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr ShQRVHOb 2. -( (-'(-! ,"%$ ., . ]oVShO"\]&^`_aVb\c_ d&O V0poVbe\cO^`n Vbp^xr_ ]oVOVbea_PR _ ]&^xef Shf VHO3] SRen VHVbrUd&eaVbp_aP^xTf i`VbTUVbr _ _ ©Pp&^xea_aO"^`n do_aVbpUShf f ix^x\HSh_ ^`Psr e A Z p&^jea_aO^`n d&_aVbp\cPEPRf VHOSh_ ^`RV,Vbp&^x_aPROSRr&pS-e ^xT-d&ixSh_ ^`Psr PRSf ShO ¯:^xroQi`PR_H ]oV f doO f PseaVbePR²_ ]oVbeaVShf&f ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsr&euShO Vq_aPUVH:^xpoVbr&\cV A / ]oV,¡BroVcQROSR^jrSRr&pPRf VHOSh_ ^`Psr: e fVb\H^`¡B\,\cPsr&\HdoO O Vbr \cw\cPsrE_aO Psi¤ / ]oV QRVbroVHO^x\H^x_ wPR_ ]&V>\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cwTXSRr&ShQRVbTVbrE_ / C0P©´p&^ GVHO VbrE_3\cPsrE_aOSR\c_ eg\HSRrnV0d&eaVHld&ixi`weaVbi`Vb\c_aVbpSR\H\cPROp&^xr&Q>_aP-O VbSRix^xea_ ^j\u_aOS8 p&VH=P G eHS JoPRO^xr ea_ SRr&\cVRm]oP©ªS\cPsrE_aO Psixi`Vbpq©VbSh¯RVbr&^jroQPRo\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cw4TXSbw f VHOTU^`_ SUnVH_a_aVHO0\cPsr&\HdoO O Vbr \cw©0]&^xi`V,ea_ ^xixiVbr&edoO^xroQ\cPRO OVb\c_ roVbe eH ]oV OVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_ e[d eaVbpnKw_ ]oVbe V>Shf&f ix^j\HSh_ ^`Psr&egShO VqpoVbe\cO^`n Vbpn&O^`Vc°BwUn Vbi`P©q.
(39) ¶ %s& ¶ » º & ¶ . V ]&SbRVSRp&poVbpªe]&ShO Vbp OVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpªn d G VHOe _aP¨_ ]&VX©Vbixi¢¯:roP©[r b d3TUSR\HeVbp&^¢ _aPRObzrSp&^xea_aO"^`n do_aVbp\cPEPRf VHOSh_ ^`RV Vbp ^`_ ^xroQeaVbe e ^xPsr/m:_ ]oVq\cPEPRf VHOSh_ ^jroQ1d3TUSR\HeaVbe[]oPsixp O VHf ij^x\HSReuPRe ]&ShO VbppoP:\Hd&TVbrE_H Z poP:\Hd&TVbrE_\cPsrE_ SR^xr&eS S V _aVcv:_-e _aOd&\c_ doO Vbp ^xrE_aPeaVb\c_ ^`Psr eHme d&n eaVb\c_ ^`Psr&ebm(f S8 OShQROShfB]&eHm,SRr&peaP Psr/ ]oV p&PK\Hd&TUVbr _«^xrE_aVHO SR\cV\cPsTf O^xeaVbe A "! #%$'&)()* SRr&p + &,$" "! #,$ &-()* TVH_ ]&PKp&e_aP O VbSRpSRr&p TPKp ^`¥w e Vb\c_ ^`Psr\cPsr _aVbrE_ e /. -$!0 #,$ &-(,*'1 2 -3 (,4 $ 'm 5 -$! #,$ &-()* 2 -3 ()4"$ m !0 #,$ &-(,* SRr&p " "60 0$" "! #,$ &-()* TUVH_ ]oPKp eu_aPUTUS8 r&^`fBd&ixSh_aV_ ]oVpoPK\Hd TVbr _ea_aOd&\c_ d&O VR7 . -$! #,$ &-()* 2 -3 ()4"$ QRVH_ e_ ]oVPsdo_ ix^xr&V§PR _ ]oV poP:\Hd&TVbrE_u©[]oVHO VbSR8e 5 0$ ! #,$'&)()* 2 03"()4"$ O VcPROp&VHOegeaVb\c_ ^`Psr&ebB{KVb\c_ ^`Psr\cPsrE_aVbr _ e4SRr&p poP:\Hd&TVbrE_qea_aOd&\c_ d&O V\HSRr n VTUPKp&^`¡ Vbp\cPsr \HdoO O VbrE_ i`wR% zr RP:\HSh_ ^`Psr&e _aP 0"! #%$'&)()* O Vbeaf " 6 -$ "!0 #%$'&-(,* SRr 9 p . -$!0 #,$ &-(,* 2 -3 (,4 $ poProPR_\cPsro°B^x\c_>©0^`_ ] PsroVSRroPh _ ]oVHOb rERP:\HSh_ ^`Psr&e-_aP 0 !0 #,$ &-(,* poPr&PR_-\cPsr:°^x\c_>©[^x_ ] PsroVSRroPR_ ]oVHObm roPRO-©[^`_ ] SRrEwPR _ ]oVq_ ]&O VHV ¥PRO"TVHO¯:^xr&p&euPR²^xrERPK\HSh_ ^`Psr eH I. fgfih jk>lm>n.
(40) "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(41) ='_^_5=. O.
(42) ¶ %s& ¶ » º ¶ . ]oVf ShO ¯:^xroQ i`PR_e ^xT-d&ixSh_ ^`Psr¬\cPsr&e ^xp&VHOeS f ShO ¯:^xroQ i`PR_©[^`_ ]¬Td i`_ ^`f i`V¨Vbr _aOSRr \cVbeH ]oVp&^xea_aO"^`n do_aVbp eafBSR\cVSRixixPK\HSh_aPROVbroPRO\cVbe_ ]oVPsixi`P©[^xroQ§^jr hShO^xSRrE_ A Sh_SRr wª_ ^xTVRm _ ]oV>rKd&Tn VHOgPR²\HShO"e[^xr_ ]&Vqf ShO ¯:^xroQi`PR_[^jei`Vbe eg_ ] SRr§^`_ e[\HShfBSR\H^`_ wR/|,roV>Shf&fBix^x\HSh_ ^`Psr \cPsTf PsroVbrE_3Od r&e3Sh_VbSR\]VbrE_aOSRr&\cVR ]oVHwe ]&ShOV0SO VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp\cPsd&rE_aVHOOVHf&O VbeaVbrE_ ^xroQ _ ]oV>rKd&Tn VHOgPRO VHV>eafBSR\cVbe^xr_ ]oVqixPR_H ]oVU\cPsd r _aVHObm O VHf&O VbeaVbrE_aVbpªSRe>SO VHf ix^j\HSh_aVbp ^xrE_aVHQRVHObm(Vcv:fPRO_ eqTVH_ ]oP:p&e & * #," ,* $ SRr&p $" 5 $- * #," ,* $ ]oV\cPsd&rE_aVHO^xrE_aVHOr&SRiji`wVbro¥PRO"\cVbeX_ ]oV«^xrE8ShO"^xSRr _XPRqO Vc TUSR^xr ^xroQ roPsr&roVHQsSh_ ^xRVR` I¬]&Vbr S \HShOi`VbSbRVbe_ ]oV¨i`PR_Hm3_ ]oV§\cPsd&rE_aVHO^xe^jr&\cO VbTVbrE_aVbp & * #," ,* $ "Q I ]oVbr S¨\HShOShOO^`RVbeHm_ ]oVXTVH_ ]oP:p $ 5 $ ) * #% ' )*"$ ^jeq^xrERPR¯RVbp A _ ]&^xeTVH_ ]&PKp Sh_aPsTU^x\HSRiji`w _aVbea_ e^`>_ ]oV \HShO§\HSRr³VbrE_aVHO¨SRr&p ^`qe PompoVb\cO VbTVbrE_ e_ ]oV \cPsd&rE_aVHO (^`_,O VH_ doO"r&e,_aOdoV^`_ ]&V_aVbea_qe d&\H\cVHVbpoVbp(m(SRr&p«SRijeaVPR_ ]oVHO ©[^xe VR zrERPK\HSh_ ^`Psr e _aP & * #, ,* $ poPUr&PR_[\cPsr:°B^x\c_g©0^`_ ]PsroV>SRroPR_ ]&VHOb ¦'/
(43) z
(44) )'/
(45) |,doO ¥OSRTUVH©PRO ¯qT-d&ea_\HShf&_ doO VSRixisSR\H\cVbe eaVbe²_aP0O VHf ix^j\HSReHmb^xrqPRO"poVHO _aP0Vbr&e doO V3_ ]&Sh_ _ ]oVHw O VbTUSR^jr-\cPsr e ^xea_aVbrE_²©[^`_ ]-O "V Kd&^`O Vbp\cPsrE_aOSR\c_H ]oVbe V_Á©P ¯RVHw-ld&r&\c_ ^`PsrShO Vuf VHO PROTVbp nKw_ ]oV >>$$ 5_ !"! SRr&p_ ]oV 5='/$($> ' ? 7]='!^Y,- leaVHV J ^xQsdoO VU W " Z\Hix^`VbrE_0SR\H\cVbeeaVbe SXOVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp¨PRn:yzVb\c_,:^xSU^`_ e4SR\H\cVbe e,PRn:yaVb\c_ lZ[| "m/SU©OShf fVHO0Vbr: \HShf e d ixSh_ ^xroQ0_ ]oVi`P:\HSRiEO VHf ix^x\HS:8Z0r-Z[| VbroPRO\cVbe _ ]oVPsixi`P©[^xroQ0SR\H\cVbe e²f&O PR_aP:\cPsiK©[]oVbr S\Hix^`VbrE_gSR\H\cVbe eaVbe0_ ]oV,PRn:yaVb\c_H9 J²^`Oea_Hm:_ ]oVqZ[|SR\ Kd&^`OVbegSi`PK\¯O PsT _ ]oVq\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw TUSRr&ShQRVHO&{:Vb\cPsr&p/mo^`_u^xr RPR¯RVbeu_ ]&V,ixPK\HSRiO VHf ij^x\HS:mKr&PR_ ^`¥w:^xroQ-SRr wTP:p&^¢¡B\HSh_ ^`PsrX_aP_ ]oV \cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr&ShQRVHOb ]&^`Op/mo^`_uO VbixVbSReaVbe_ ]oVi`PK\¯B Z \Hix^xVbr _\]oPKPseaVbeuS\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw\cPsr _aOSR\c_unKwX^xr&e _ SRr _ ^xSh_ ^jroQq_ ]oV,Shf&f&O PRf O^xSh_aV[\cPsr&e^xez _aVbr&\cwXTXSRr&ShQRVHOb ]oV4\cPsr&e ^xea_aVbr \cwUTUSRr&ShQRVHOg^xTf ixVbTVbr _ e3_ ]oV,\cPsr&e ^xea_aVbr \cwX\cPsr _aO"SR\c_Hm TUSh¯RVbe0poVb\H^xe ^`Psr eu_aPUQROSRrE_[i`P:\ ¯:eHm SRr&pf O PRf ShQsSh_aVbe[d&f p Sh_aVbeH ]oV¨O Vbea_UPR,_ ]oVeaVb\c_ ^`Psr ^jePRO QsSRr&^`±HVbp³SReXPsixi`P©[eH{KVb\c_ ^xPsr³KxW¨p ^xe \Hd&e e VbeU]oP© _aP Vcv:f i`Ps^`_Hm^xrSQRVbroVHO^x\©uSbwRm_ ]&VPRn:yzVb\c_Ue VbTUSRr _ ^j\He_aP SR\]&^xVHRV_ wKfVbp\cPsr \HdoO O Vbr&\cw \cPsrE_aO PsigSRr&p_ ]oVi`PRQs^x\HSRiuea_aO"d&\c_ doO VPR[PRn:yaVb\c_ e_aP SR\] ^`VHRV¡BroVcQROSR^jr \cPsr \HdoO O Vbr&\cw \cPsrE_aO Psi¤{KVb\c_ ^`Psr K ª_ ]&Vbr³poVH_ SR^jixeU_ ]oVShO\] ^`_aVb\c_ doO V«\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ eHmVbe fVb\H^jSRixi`w_ ]oV n SRe ^j\ ^xr _aVHOSR\cVbe[PR_ ]oVSR\H\cVbe ePRn:yaVb\c_0SRr p_ ]oV>\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr&ShQRVHOb J. . '#'(-! , % ,' '( 3 $*" #' 3( |,roV¨_aVb\]&r&^#EdoV¨_aP ^xr&\cOVbSReaV¨\cPsr&\HdoOO Vbr&\cwSRr&p f VHO PROTUSRr \cV¨^xe_aP VcvKfBi`Ps^`_PRn:yaVb\c_ eaVbTUSRrE_ ^x\H*e L¢Wb&muWbomuW#P:mR=RZ0roPR_ ]&VHOU^xe¡BroVcQROSR^xr\cPsr&\Hd&O O Vbr&\cw \cPsr _aO Psi L£UR3|,doO ShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doO Ve dof&f PRO _ eun PR_ ]/m:_ ]&SRro¯:eg_aP %'9 '9 5'/$ . 021 f3054.
(46)
(47)
(48) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$. Address Space 1. Client 1. Access Object. Replica 1. Consistency Manager. Consistency Manager. Replica 2. Access Object. J²^`QsdoO V W A
(49). Client 2. Client 3. Psr&\cO VH_aVgO VHf&OVbeaVbr _ Sh_ ^xPsrPRS,OVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_3e ] ShO VbpnEw_ ]oO VHVg_ ]oOVbSRp&e i`P:\HSh_aVbp§^xr_Á©PUf O PK\cVbeeaVbeH/F,SRe ]oVbp§ix^jroVbeu^xpoVbrE_ ^`¥wi`PRQs^x\HSRi/p&^jea_aO^`n d&_aVbpXPRn:yaVb\c_gn Psd&r: p&ShO^xVbeH. fgfih jk>lm>n. Address Space 2.
(50) "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(51) ='_^_5=. W.
(52)
(53)
(54)
(55) "!!$#% &'
(56) (
(57)
(58) )*+! ,.
(59) / 012#%*3! ,.
(60) /'4'
(61) 56#% '
(62) /
(63)
(64) )*+! ,.77 8 '9:<;=> = 9&' 59
(65) =(
(66)
(67) &@? 77 'A 9'
(68) B =C5D '5 FE G(5&HG ' IJKL 4 !,MON>?QPRST! ,MU.?VAW& T4P ! ,MXY
(69) /A 9 '
(70) Z B[#\ '
(71) (Z
(72)
(73) & )]? 5&\G & ^
(74) & !$#_IJKL 4a`bPRSTa`cAW& T4P&**d!. Y-. ,.-. "
(75) '
(76) e 9
(77) f#g 5 GCZ CJ h?
(78) :A 9'
(79) ]? (
(80) A G
(81) C? 5C\G ^' &
(82) ' >*. /
(83)
(84) ' ij
(85) '
(86) e 9
(87) f#k 5 G CJ h?
(88) :A 9'
(89) ]? (
(90) A G
(91) .? 5&\G & ^
(92) & >* "ID!/' &
(93) ' ") IJKL 4] "PD!/' &
(94) ' ") PRST] A !/' &
(95) ' ") AW& T4P]-. Y.
(96) $##l5 GC CJ ))
(97) :A 9
(98) ))&'
(99) A G
(100) * ))m#nI )) P )) A **$`` ##l5 GC CJ <))o
(101) A G
(102) & C* ))m#nI ))qpcP )) A **$`` ##l5 GC CJ <))
(103) :A 9'
(104) &* ))m#nI )) P ))rpjA/**$`` ##l5 GC CJ >* ))m#nI ))qpcP ))rpjA/**$`` ##_
(105) :A 9'
(106) s))('
(107) A G
(108) ZCC* ))m#ptI)) P )) A **$`` ##_
(109) :A 9'
(110) &* ))m#ptI)) P ))rpjA/**$`` ##%
(111) A G
(112) & * ))m#ptI))qpcP )) A **u-. ¶ Z[nBea_aOSR\c_\HixSRe e<x * $" )* $ &-(,* poVc¡Br&VbeX_ ]oV«TUSRr&p Sh_aPRO w ^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr¬^xrE_aVHOa lSR\cVR $ 5 $ #-(,*Oy"6 &#%$ ^jeq^xrERPR¯RVbp nEw poVHO"^`RVbp \HixSRe eaVbe>PRzx * $" )*"$'&-(,* _aP¨VbixShn PROSh_aVRm SR\H\cPROp&^jroQ_aPU_ ]oV #,'&%$ -'&-(,* mE_ ]&V ¡Br&SRi O Vbed&i`_uPR²_ ]oV & 5 { (,*Oy"6 &#%$'& * .f&O Vbp ^x\HSh_aVR v cw. 021 f3054.
(113)
(114)
(115) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$. Z4r ^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr \"]&ShOSR\c_aVHO^x±HVbeSRr SR\c_ ^xK^`_Áw lS¨eaVH_qPRup&Sh_ S§SR\H\cVbe eaVbeix^xTU^x_aVbp^jr«_ ^xTV _ ]&Sh_ S[\Hix^`VbrE_(f ijSRr&e/_aP[f VHO PROT´PsrSO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp PRn:yaVb\c_H PRO Vf&O Vb\H^xe Vbi`wRmbSRr>^xrE_aVbrE_ ^`Psr ^xpoVbrE_ ^¢¡ Vbe,S\Hix^xVbr _Hm(SRr SR\c_ ^`:^`_ÁwpoPsTXSR^xr l^¤£VR/_ ]oVUi`PRQs^j\HSRi²f ShO _ e,PR_ ]oVPRn:yaVb\c_ _ ]&Sh_ ShO Vg\cPsr&\cVHOr&VbpnEw_ ]oVg^xr _aVbr poVbpSR\H\cVbe eaVbe ²SRr p-S,eaVH_PRSR\c_ ^`Psr_ wKf Vbe²_ ]&Sh__ ]&^xe \Hix^`VbrE_ ^xrE_aVbr&p&eu_aPUf VHO PROT Psr_ ]&V>eaf Vb\H^¢¡ VbppoPsTXSR^xr/oZ0r¨^xr _aVbrE_ ^`PsrQRVbr&VHOSRix^`±HVbeSXi`PK\¯B
(116) Psr&e^xpoVHO_ ]oV\cPEPRf VHOSh_ ^`RVVbp&^`_ ^xr&QUShf&f ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsr/&Z0r^xrE_aVbr _ ^`PsrTU^`Qs]E_[eaf Vb\H^`weaPsTV eaVb\c_ ^`Psr eu_ ]&Sh_u_ ]oV \Hix^`VbrE_^xrE_aVbr&p&e_aPUSR\H\cVbe e[p&doO^xr&Q>eaPsTV SR\c_ ^`:^`_ wR4 J&PROVbSR\]§e Vb\c_ ^`Psr SR\H\cVbe eaVbpnKw_ ]&^xeSR\c_ ^`:^`_ÁwRmB_ ]oV^xr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr¨PRn:yzVb\c_4eaf Vb\H^¢¡ VbeSRrSR\c_ ^`Psr VR£Qo\cPsrE_aVbr _ e TP:p&^¢¡B\HSh_ ^xPsrSRr&pixSbwRPsd&_0TP:p&^¢¡B\HSh_ ^xPsr 3_aPUn V fVHO¥PROTUVbp/ Z4r w ^xr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr\HixSRe e^jTf i`VbTVbrE_ e-SnBSRe ^x\QRVbroVHO^x\^xrE_aVHO lSR\cVR` J ^xQsdoO V(«e ]oP©[e-_ ]&^xe ^xrE_aVHO lSR\cV A / & 5 OVH_ doOr&e_aOdoV ^`/_ ]&V,\cPROO Vbeaf Psr&p&^xr&QSR\c_ ^`:^`_ w^xe©VbSh¯4 aO^`Vc° wRm:©V p&^xez _ ^jroQsd&^xe ]_Á©P\HSh_aVHQRPRO^`Vbe0PR²SR\c_ ^xK^`_ ^xVbe A ©VbSh¯SRr&p¨ea_aO PsroQo "
(117) D# (3S% >$ poP r&PR_u\cPsro°B^x\c_u©[^`_ ]PsroV SRroPR_ ]oVHO o_ ]&Sh_g^xeHmK_ ]oV PROpoVHOg^xr©[]&^j\]_ ]oVHwShO V f VHO PROa TUVbpPsrp&H^ G VHO Vbr _²O VHfBix^x\HSRe ^xe^`O O VbixVH8SRrE_H -65='Y^ SR\c_ ^`:^`_ ^`Vbe f PR_aVbrE_ ^xSRixi`w>\cPsro°B^x\c_ ©0^`_ ]PsroV>SRroPR_ ]&VHO0SRr&p©[^x_ ]SRr w©VbSh¯SR\c_ ^xK^`_ÁwR / & 5 { ()*>y 6 & #,$ & * .ªO VH_ d&Or&e_aOdoV«^`q^`_ eShO Qsd&TVbrE_\cPsr:°B^x\c_ e©[^`_ ]³_ ]oV«\HdoO O VbrE_ ^jr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr§SRi`Psr&QXp&^xTVbr e ^`Psr&eeaf Vb\H^¢¡ VbpnKw_ ]&V>\HSRixi`VHOb ]oV0\cPsTfBShO^xeaPsr\HSRrXn V4poPsroV0SRixPsroQ>_ ]oOVHV4p&^jTVbr&e ^`Psr e A _ ]oV0SR\c_ ^xPsr_ÁwEf VRmK_ ]oV SR\c_ ^xK^`_ÁwqpoPsTUSR^xrqPRO_ ]oV\Hix^`VbrE_ ^xpoVbrE_ ^¢¡ VHOb zr _ ]oV\cPEPRf VHOSh_ ^xRV3Vbp&^`_ ^jroQgVcv:SRTUf i`VRm _Á©P ^jr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr&e\cPsr:°B^j\c_SRixPsroQ«_ ]oVSR\c_ ^`K^x_ w p&PsTUSR^xr ^`_ ]oVb^`O\cPRO OVbeaf Psr&p&^xroQ SR\H\cVbee3poPsTUSR^jr&e PRVHOixShf VR£Qo _ ]oVHw]&SRVS eaVb\c_ ^`Psr^xr\cPsTUTUPsr R_ ]oVHw\cPsro°B^x\c_ SRixPsroQq_ ]oV[SR\c_ ^xPsrU_ wKf V[^`_ ]oV[\cPRO OVbeaf Psr&p&^xroQ SR\c_ ^`:^`_ ^`Vbe3ShO V[roPR_3\cPsTXTdo_ Sh_ ^xRV ¡r&SRixi`wRm²_ ]oVHw\cPsr:°B^x\c_SRi`Psr&Q _ ]oV§\Hix^`VbrE_Up&^xTVbr e ^`Psr ^`[_ ]oVHwShO V§^xr ^`_ ^xSh_aVbp nEw p H^ GVHOVbr _\Hix^xVbr _ eH / & 5 5 $ O VH_ d&Or&e_aOd&V^`,^`_ eXShOQsd&TVbrE_O VHf O VbeaVbrE_ eXS ' >$> ! %3# ? Z4r SR\c_ ^xK^`_Áw ^xe/SroVbe _aVbpqSR\c_ ^`:^`_ w,PR ^`E_ ]oVPsixi`P©0^xroQg\cPsr&p&^`_ ^xPsr&e/ShO V3e Sh_ ^jez¡ Vbp A l^ SRr p ShO Vq^xr&^`_ ^jSh_aVbpXnKw_ ]&V,eSRTVq\Hix^`VbrE_ l^x^ 3_ ]oVqSR\c_ ^`:^`_ wpoPsTUSR^xrPR ^xeg^xr&\Hixd poVbp©[^`_ ]&^xr_ ]oV Psr&VqPR J²^`QsdoO Vbe²SRr p N4e ]oP©_ ]oV^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr-\HixSRe e VbeSRe e PK\H^xSh_aVbp-©[^x_ ]q_ ]oVO VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp\cPsd&rE_aVHO SRr&p_ ]&V O VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp¨poPK\Hd TVbr _H . . . .
(118) . . . . . . . . . ¶ ( H º' wª&R% ¥ ·
(119) Psr&e^xpoVHO,_ ]oVUO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp \cPsd&rE_aVHO>d&eaVbp nEwPsdoO f ShO ¯:^xroQi`PR_qShf f ix^x\HSh_ ^`Psr((| roVU\HSRr PRn eaVHORV3_ ]&Sh_ A l^ _aP0TXSh¯RVe doOV_ ]&Sh_ eafBSR\cVbe ©[^jixihroPR_p&^je Shf&f VbShObmHSRixis^xr \cO VbTVbrE_ e T-d&ea_ n VUVHRVbrE_ d&SRixi`w«f VHO PROTVbp Psr SRixiO VHf ij^x\HSRe l^x^ 0_aPQsd&ShOSRrE_aVHV_ ]&Veaf SR\cV^xr hShO^xSRrE_Hm SRixi_aVbea_SRr&pp&Vb\cO VbTVbrE_SR\c_ ^`K^x_ ^`VbegTd ea_unV4Qsi`PRn SRiji`wUPROpoVHOVbp/ PU]oVbixf\HShf&_ d&O V _ ]oV . . . . . !"!$#%'&$(*)+%-,.(
(120) !-/0!"12!$( 354/*%76 !"8
(121) /0!-4:9;,<( !2=>!. 4?@/0&-8/0/0!E4F?. h. fgfih jk>lm>n. ( !. h. h. !$#5(C/0!-&G( ?H3 JI. h. !$6 ?@&&-3. h. /0?@/A( !. h. &$,B1"%. h. %'='!-12!. h. ()C?@D@D. 9!.
(122) W. "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(123) ='_^_5=.. . 77 5 AhEVI n
(124) :D : 7 7
(125) & fE .
(126)
(127)
(128) ' "
(129) G
(130) . G/A
(131) L&'P: 4 ATKT4P]?kPT 8 PeIT ATKT4PY <A
(132)
(133)
(134) '
(135)
(136) . A
(137) L&'P:+
(138) :.A
(139) ^
(140) ]-. . A
(141)
(142)
(143) ' f#lA
(144) L P:3h? A
(145) ^*
(146) :#\>*u?
(147) f#%*Y. Y-.
(148)
(149) "!!$#% &'
(150) A
(151)
(152)
(153) ' )&*O
(154) / 012#%*u
(155) /'4'
(156) 56#% '
(157) A
(158)
(159)
(160) ' )C*u
(161) /A 9 '
(162) Z B[#\ '
(163) A
(164)
(165)
(166) )f? 5C\G >*u-. A
(167) &
(168)
(169) F Z01f#%*
(170)
(171) :"!!/ 4 A TKT4P]Y A
(172) &
(173)
(174) F 4
(175) 5.# '
(176) A
(177) Z
(178)
(179) & )" *
(180) (
(181) !!( E
(182) ]Y A
(183) &
(184)
(185) F A 9
(186) & Bf# '
(187) A
(188) &
(189)
(190) )u? 5&\G & ^
(191) & >*
(192)
(193) '
(194) e 9'
(195) f#dN>? #_
(196) : pt!( Ej
(197) :C*u? #%'
(198) pj!( E
(199) &*u? '
(200) *uY. { (,4* $" 0 x * $" )*"$'&-(,* ^je(_ ]oVu^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr-\HixSRe e d&eaVbp>nEw>_ ]oV3O VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp-\cPsd&r: v cw ¶ _aVHOb x *
(201) #% ' )*"$ PRf VHOSh_ ^`Psr&eqShOV\HixSRe e^¢¡ Vbp SRe©VbSh¯m ©[]&VHO VbSRe $ 5 $ )* #% )*"$ PRf VHOSh_ ^`Psr&e0ShO V\HixSRe e ^¢¡BVbp§SRe,ea_aO PsroQo $" 5 $ #)()*Oy"6 & #,$ ^je[^xr&]&VHO^`_aVbpO PsT n SReaV\HijSRe e x *"$ ,* $'&)()* . 021 f3054.
(202)
(203)
(204) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$. . r&Sh_ doOVPRVbSR\"] SR\c_ ^`:^`_ wRm & 5 e ]oPsd ixp O Vbe fPsr p ->.9 ¥PRO^xrE_aVbr _ ^xPsr&eSReeaPK\H^jSh_aVbp ©[^`_ ]SR\c_ ^`:^`_ ^`Vbe-_ ]&Sh_Psr i`wª^xr&\cOVbTVbr _SRr&p =
(205) $ PROPR_ ]oVHOeH _^xe-_ ]oVbrdof_aP _ ]oV \cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw TUSRr&ShQRVHO _aP[Vcv:f i`Ps^`_ _ ]&^xe/f&OVbp&^x\HSh_aV_aP0PROpoVHO _ ]&VPRVHOSRijiEeaVH_PRoSR\c_ ^`K^x_ ^`Vbe ^xrPRO"poVHOX_aPª^jTf&O PRV§f VHO ¥PRO"TUSRr&\cV§©[^x_ ]oPsdo_:^`PsixSh_ ^xroQ _ ]&V\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw\cPsr _aO"SR\c_H J²^`QsdoO V e ]oP©[e_ ]oV4^jr _aVHO lSR\cV,SRr&pX_ ]&V4^xTUf i`VbTVbrE_ Sh_ ^`PsrUPR _ ]oV0^xrE_aVbrE_ ^`Psr\HijSRe eud&eaVbp nKw_ ]oV>O VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp\cPsd r _aVHOb
(206) Psr&e^xpoVHOroP©_ ]&VgO VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbppoP:\Hd&TVbrE_VcvoSRTf i`VR ]oVu_ ]oOVHVg¥PsixixP©[^xr&Q4SRi`_aVHO"r&Sh_ ^`RV \]&Ps^x\cVbePRO_ ]oV>e VH_PR©VbSh¯SR\c_ ^`:^`_ ^`VbeShO V>"V Ed&SRiji`wXhSRix^xp A . . 0 !0 #,$ &-(,* . 0$ ! #%$'&)()* 2 03"()4 $ * 0 "! #%$'&)()* / 0 !0 #,$ &-(, * "60 0$ ! #,$'&)()* / 0 !0 #,$ &-(, /. F4VHf Vbr&p&^xroQPsr_ ]&V O VbixSh_ ^`RVqO "V KdoVbr&\cwPR²TUVH_ ]oPKp^jr RP:\HSh_ ^`Psr&eHm PsroV PRO0SRroPR_ ]&VHO[SRi¢ _aVHOr&Sh_ ^xRVg©[^xixiE]&SbRVg_ ]oVgn Vbea_ f VHO PROTUSRr&\cVR ]oVu\HdoO OVbr _²RVHOe ^xPsrPR _ ]oVg\cPKPRfVHO"Sh_ ^`RV Vbp&^`_ ^jroQShf&f ix^x\HSh_ ^xPsr leaVHV J²^`QsdoO V g^xTf i`VbTUVbr _ eu_ ]oV,¡BOea_SRi`_aVHOr Sh_ ^`RVR. & ¶" º'
(207) Z4r^xrE_aVbrE_ ^`PsrX\HSRrn V ae TXShO _^jrPROpoVHO_aP-^jTf&O PRV[_ ]oV4poVHQRO VHV4PR \cPsr&\HdoO OVbr&\cwREZ4r ^xrE_aVbr _ ^xPsr \HSRr _ Sh¯RV^jr _aP§SR\H\cPsd&rE_>_ ]&VUi`PRQs^x\HSRiea_aO"d&\c_ doO VPR_ ]oVUPRn:yaVb\c_>SRr&p PROq_ ]oV PRn:yaVb\c_z eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\e VH_(PRoSR\c_ ^`Psrq_ÁwEf VbeH ]oVn VH_a_aVHO^xrE_aVbrE_ ^`Psr&e(\HShf&_ d&O VPRn:yaVb\c_ ea_aOd \c_ doO V SRr&p eaVbTUSRrE_ ^x\HeHmu_ ]oV«TPRO V \Hix^xVbr _ e\HSRr f&O PRQROVbe e\cPsr&\HdoO O VbrE_ i`wR P^xijixd&ea_aOSh_aV_ ]oV ^xTfBSR\c_gPR _ ]&V ae TUShO _ roVbee PR^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr eHmo\cPsr&e ^xpoVHO[_ ]oV ¥Psiji`P©[^jroQ_ ©PXVcvoSRTf i`Vbe A Wh4{odof&f PseaV-_ ]&Sh_ _ ©P§©O^x_aVHOe4©SRrE_ _aP§TP:p&^`w§_ ©P¨eaVHf ShO"Sh_aVUeaVb\c_ ^`Psr&e,PRuSpoPh \Hd TVbr _H dSR\]\Hix^`VbrE_ lTPRO Vf&O Vb\H^xeaVbixwRm_ ]oVSR\H\cVbe ePRnoyzVb\c_PRf VHOSh_ ^xroQPsr]&^xe n Vb]&SRix 3\cOVbSh_aVbe0SRr§^jr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr§poVbe\cO^`n ^xr&Q_ ]oV^xr _aVbr poVbpSR\c_ ^`:^`_ wR ^jr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr&eg\cPsr&e^xpoVHOgSpoPK\Hd TVbr _gSRed r&ea_aOd&\c_ d&O Vbp/m VbSR\"]§^xrE_aVbr _ ^xPsr©[^xixiBO Vc Kd&^`OVuS,i`P:\ ¯-Psr_ ]oVuVbrE_ ^`O VpoP:\Hd&TVbrE_H ]oVbeaV^jr _aVbrE_ ^`Psr&e²©[^jixiE\cPsro°B^x\c_²n Vb\HSRd&eaV _ ]&VHw-TP:p&^`w _ ]oVe SRTUVpoPsTUSR^xr/= C0Vbr&\cVRm ^xr-_ ]&^xe²\HSReaVRm _ ©P ©O^`_aVHOe²\HSRr&r&PR_TPh p ^`¥w\cPsr&\HdoO OVbr _ i`wp&H^ G VHO VbrE_eaVb\c_ ^`Psr&eb (^xr&e _aVbSRpX_ ]oV,^xrE_aVbr _ ^xPsrX_ Sh¯RVbeg^xrE_aPSR\H\cPsd&r _u_ ]oV4i`PRQs^x\HSRiea_aOd&\c_ d&O V0PR(S-poP:\Hd: TUVbr _ ©0^`_ ]UeaVb\c_ ^`Psr eHm e donBeaVb\c_ ^`Psr&eSRr&pUf ShOShQROShf ] e "mRVbSR\]^xrE_aVbr _ ^`PsrUO "V Ed&Vbea_ e SixPK\¯Psr&ixwXPRO_ ]oVq\cPsr&\cVHOr&Vbp§eaVb\c_ ^`Psr§SRr ppoPUroPR_\cPsr:°B^j\c_H4 C[Vbr&\cVRmo_ ]&VqTPh p ^¢¡B\HSh_ ^`Psr&eu©0^xixin Vq\HShO O^`VbpPsr§\cPsr \HdoO O VbrE_ i`wR K
(208) Psr&e ^xpoVHO(r&P©ª_Á©P4\Hix^`VbrE_ e A PsroV©uSRrE_ e _aP[TUPKp&^x¥w0_ ]oV3\cPsrE_aVbr _ e PRoeaPsTV3e Vb\c_ ^`Psr ©0]oVHO VbSReg_ ]oV>PR_ ]oVHO©uSRr _ e[_aPXTP:p&^`wX_ ]oVqixSwRPsdo_PR _ ]oV>e SRTUV>eaVb\c_ ^`Psr/ ]oVbeaV _Á©PPRf VHOSh_ ^`Psr e3poProPR_3OVbSRixi`w\cPsr:°B^x\c_ A PsroV4TPKp ^¢¡ Vbe_ ]&V0poP:\Hd&TVbrE_\cPsrE_aVbr _ e ©0]oVHO VbSReg_ ]oV>PR_ ]oVHO0TP:p&^¢¡BVbe_ ]&V>TVH_ S8 p&Sh_ SpoVbe \cO^`nB^xroQ-_ ]oV>ixSwRPsdo_H . . . fgfih jk>lm>n.
(209) Wb. "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(210) ='_^_5=.. sI G&
(211) S
(212) " EEE 77
(213) D9 5 G
(214) 3
(215) C 77 $#%
(216) /
(217) &
(218) s
(219) D G
(220) :* 77 (s5 GC. ^J ]#\ '
(221) sI G
(222) S
(223) )&*u7 7 '4'
(224) 56#%
(225) oZ >* ^<5 GC. ^'4
(226) 5.#% '
(227) sI G
(228) S
(229) )*OY. G(LC P:3. 5 8 '
(230) & h?k0
(231) 8 '
(232) & h?.
(233) 8 '
(234) ' W :
(235) ]? 8
(236) 8 '
(237) & W :
(238) .? L 55 8 '
(239) ' h? I
(240) 8 '
(241) ' CY-. sL&3 6 7 7 I G
(242) S
(243) 35S
(244) ]- 7 7 L&'P:s
(245) :.L&. s5 GC.
(246) :. #% &'
(247) "I G
(248) S
(249) )]? &'
(250) "L&'P:)*u-. 77 ^s5 G&C. (J ]#% '
(251) sL&')*u77 '4 '
(252) 5 (s5 GC. ( 4'
(253) 5.#% &'
(254) <LC )*u ( P:A 9'
(255) B#%'
(256) sL&')*uY. sI G&
(257)
(258)
(259) CZ
(260)
(261) & 8
(262) L& <5S
(263) f77 '
(264) ('5 A
(265) ^
(266) ] I G
(267) Z
(268)
(269) & ]#H &'
(270) L&')]? '
(271) A
(272) )* 77 ; >5^
(273)
(274) (Z ' G&
(275) :FE I G
(276) Z
(277)
(278) & )<
(279) !$#%
(280) "L&')*u-. Y-.
(281)
(282) "!!$#% &'
(283) "I G
(284) Z
(285)
(286) & )&*O
(287) / 012#%*u
(288) /'4'
(289) 56#% '
(290) I G
(291) Z
(292)
(293) &' )*u
(294) /A 9 '
(295) Z B[#\ '
(296) "I G
(297)
(298)
(299) )]? 5&\G & >*O-. ¶ (# 4 ,* $ x * $" )* $ &-(,* \HijSRe e3eaf Vb\H^¢¡BVbe_ ]oV0^jr _aVbrE_ ^`PsrX\HijSRe ePROpoP:\Hd&TVbrE_H # #- 55Km ##) 5 5 3 SRr&p ( # 4' )*"$
(300) -$ ShO V>eaf Vb\H^¢¡\0PR²_ ]&^jeg^xTf i`VbTUVbr _ Sh_ ^`Psr( v cw. 021 f3054.
(301)
(302)
(303) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$. :. . I G
(304) &
(305)
(306) F Z01f#%*. .
(307) $#_
(308) : ! ! #_
(309) : ! !.
(310) 8
(311) W:
(312) &* 5 8 '
(313) *u-. ``. . I G
(314) &
(315)
(316) F 4
(317) 5.#H C'
(318) I G&
(319)
(320)
(321) ' )" *
(322) . . #%
(323) !!/ @E
(324) * )). # .
(325) # EH 4'
(326) 5.#Z* !!
(327) C*.
(328) "!. . I G
(329) &
(330)
(331) F A 9
(332) Bf# '
(333) I G
(334)
(335)
(336) ' )" u? 5&\G & ^
(337) & >*. .
(338)
(339) '
(340) e 9
(341) f# #\
(342) pj!^ E
(343) *O? #$% .
(344) & ' ( )"! # EHJ ]#Z* !!
(345) *u? #$% .
(346) & ' ( )"! # EH P:A 9'
(347) & B.#Z* !!
(348) C**. F0VH_ SR^jixe4PR_ ]oV (# 4' )* $ x *"$ )*"$'&)()* \HijSRe e0SRe,^xTUf i`VbTVbrE_aVbp¨^xr_ ]oV\cPh v cw ¶ PRf VHOSh_ ^`RV0Vbp&^`_aPROb Z4\c_ ^`:^`_ ^`Vbe\]oPseaVbrSRe©VbSh¯XShO V0_ ]oPseaV4^xr RPR¯:^xroQ _ ]&V "! #%$'&)()* PRO . -$! #,$ &-()* 2 -3 ()4"$ TVH_ ]oP:p&eH +*. fgfih jk>lm>n.
(349) W,N. "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(350) ='_^_5=.. ^jr. _aVbrE_ ^`Psr&e \cPsr&e^xpoVHO,Psr&i`w " 0 SRr&p '&,$" SR\c_ ^xPsr«_ wKfVbebm/_ ]oV_ ©P§\Hix^`VbrE_ e H\ SRr roPR_fVHO¥PROT2_ ]oVb^`OSR\c_ ^`Psr&e\cPsr&\HdoOO + Vbr _ ixwR3 [^xr&ea_aVbSRp ^xrE_aVbr _ ^xPsr&e\HShf _ doO V _ ]&VeaVbTUSRrE_ ^x\He>PRuijSbwRPsdo_-SRr&pª\cPsrE_aVbr _ ebmn PR_ ]ªTUPKp&^`¡B\HSh_ ^`Psr«©[^xiji²nVUSRiji`P©Vbp \cPsr \HdoO O VbrE_ i`wR Z¯RVHw¨\"]&ShOSR\c_aVHO^xe _ ^x\^je[_ ]&Sh_Hm poVbeafB^`_aVq_ ]oV_ wKfVc ^jr&poVHf Vbr&poVbr&\cV>PR\cPsr&e ^xea_aVbr \cw§TUS8 r&ShQRVHOebmEPsdoOuShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doO V,e dof fPRO_ eeaVbTUSRrE_ ^x\F eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\[PRf&_ ^xTU^x±bSh_ ^`Psr&eHmEK^xSe TUShO _^xr: _aVbrE_ ^`Psr&eH rE_aVbr _ ^xPsr&e>ShO V_ wKf Vc eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\n d&_>\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cw TUSRr&ShQRVHOePsr&i`w d&eaVX_ ]oVb^`O QRVbroVHO^j\ ^xr _aVHOSR\cVq_aP\cPsTf ShO Vq_Á©P^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr eH 2 3$ 3(-,( - +),' ' #' 3( ZOVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp PRn:yaVb\c_U^xeTUSRpoVPR[_ ]&O VHV¯K^xr p&e>PR4\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ e leaVHV*J²^`QsdoO V«W A l^ O VHf ij^x\HSRe^xTfBi`VbTVbrE_ ^xroQ_ ]oVqPRn:yaVb\c_0e VbTUSRr _ ^j\He[Sh_[VbSR\"]e^`_aVRm l^x^ SR\H\cVbee0PRnoyzVb\c_ e4^xT f i`VbTUVbr _ ^xr&Qq_ ]oV,SR\H\cVbe euf&O PR_aP:\cPsi¤m:SRr&p l^j^x^ ²S-p&^xea_aO"^`n do_aVbpU\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwUTXSRr&ShQRVHO^xT f i`VbTUVbr _ ^xr&Q0_ ]oV\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw-f&O PR_aP:\cPsi¤ ]oV¡ O"ea_²_ ©P>\cPsTf PsroVbrE_ eShO Vg_ wKf Vc eaf Vb\H^¢¡B\ VbSR\]_ wKf VgPRBOVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpPRnoyzVb\c_3T-d&ea_p&Vc¡BroVgSqeaf Vb\H^¢¡B\RVHOe^`PsrPR _ ]oVbeaVgPsroVbe " ]oV ixSRea_gPsr&V>^xeuQRVbroVHO^j\hm ^¤£VR&\HSRr§n V O Vbd eaVbpSRe[^xeunKwSRixi O VHf ij^x\HSh_aVbpPRn:yaVb\c_[_ wKf VbeH {KVb\c_ ^`Psr eUK KxWhmK K SRr p K K f&O Vbe Vbr __ ]oVbeaV\cPsTf PsroVbr _ e^jr_ doOrSRr&pp&^je \Hd&e e ]oP© _ ]oVHwShO VqO VbijSh_aVbp©[^`_ ]PsroVSRroPR_ ]oVHOb. ¶ %s . F,Sh_ Sª^xrS O VHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpPRnoyzVb\c_XShOV§Vbr&\HShf e d ixSh_aVbp ^xrO VHfBix^x\HSReHZ O VHf ix^x\HS«^xeXSRrPRno yaVb\c_Xi`P:\HSh_aVbp ^xr S f ShO _ ^x\Hd&ijShOf&O P:\cVbe eUSRp&poOVbe eUeaf SR\cVR-Á_Xr&VHVbp&eUroPR_U©PRO O wShn Psdo_ \cPsr&\HdoOO Vbr&\cw§PRO,O VHf ij^x\HSh_ ^`Psr¨e^xr&\cV>PR_ ]&VHOq\cPsTf PsroVbr _ e4PR_ ]&V-ShO\"]&^`_aVb\c_ doOVTXSRr&ShQRV \cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw_aOSRr&e f ShO VbrE_ i`wRBZO VHfBix^x\HSf&OP:^xpoVbe[SeaVHO :^x\cV^jr _aVHO lSR\cV-_aPTUSRr ^`f d&ixSh_aV _ ]oVUOVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbp e _ Sh_aVRc I VSRr _ ^x\H^xf Sh_aVU_ ]&Sh_-SO VHf ix^j\HS©[^xixi PR_aVbrªn VUSRrª^jr&ea_ SRr&\cVUPR S«QRVbroVHOSRi[f doO f PseaV\HixSRe eU¥Psd&r p^xr ©[^xpoVbi`w SbhSR^xixShn i`V§ij^`n&OShO w VR£Qo2 b ij^`n&Q -m gdKFZm{ d&r&TP:p&^¢¡ Vbp(. s ¶ b º ¶ R . 4Z rSR\H\cVbe euPRnoyzVb\c_ lZ[| 3^xeS©OShf fVHO3Vbr&\HShf e d&ijSh_ ^xroQSi`P:\HSRi O VHfBix^x\HS: dSR\]Z[| ]&SRe _ ©P§^xrE_aVHO lSR\cVbe A S\Hix^xVbr _,^xrE_aVHO SR\cVUd eaVbpnEw¨ixPK\HSRi²\Hix^`VbrE_ e4_aP§SR\H\cVbe e _ ]oVO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp PRn:yaVb\c_ O VHfBix^x\HS&SRr&p³SRr dof/\HSRixig^jr _aVHO lSR\cVd eaVbpnKw_ ]oV¨\cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr&ShQRVHO_aP O VHf PRO _gO VbTUPR_aV>TP:p&^¢¡B\HSh_ ^`Psr eH ]oVU\Hij^`Vbr _^xr _aVHOSR\cV^xeqp&^`:^xpoVbp«^xr _ ©P¨f ShO _ e A _ ]oVX\cPsr&\Hd&O O Vbr&\cw \cPsrE_aO Psi3^xrE_aVHO lSR\cV SRr&p-_ ]oVueaVHO :^x\cVu^xr _aVHOSR\cVRRZ \Hij^`Vbr _²TUSw>f&O PR_aVb\c_S4ea"V KdoVbr&\cVuPRB^xrERP:\HSh_ ^`Psr&e²d&r&poVHO²S e ^xr&Qsi`V^xrE_aVbr _ ^`Psr(mbnEw n OSR\ ¯RVH_ ^xr&Q[_ ]oVbT®nVH_Á©VHVbr . & * #%$'&'&,$ 3 SRr p )* #,$'&'&%$3 ]oVqe VHO K^j\cVq^xr _aVHOSR\cV-^xeg^xpoVbrE_ ^x\HSRi _aPX_ ] Sh_PR²_ ]oV ©OShf&f VbpO VHfBix^x\HS leaVHV J²^`Qsd&O V O " d3SR\"]¨TVH_ ]&PKpPR _ ]&^xe[^xr _aVHOSR\cV>^jTf i`VbTVbrE_ e_ ]oVqPsixi`P©[^xroQSR\H\cVbe e[f&O PR_aP:\cPsi A 021 f3054.
(351)
(352)
(353) !"#%$&('*)+$, - ,./"102'43#%-65'478,'9%$. <A
(354) 7 7
(355) = 3 CfE
(356) ' .- A '
(357) ': %G B ]- 77
(358) = . . . 0. & '
(359) ': G& B . 77
(360) (Z
(361) 9. . . 7 7 :
(362)
(363) 9 L&
(364)
(365) :)3B& L&'
(366) &
(367) : #Z
(368)
(369) ' )*u '5 5L&
(370)
(371) :6#_L&
(372)
(373) :)*u7 7 D
(374) 9 '5( ' G
(375) #%
(376) *u
(377) '
(378) L 5I' G
(379). 77. s . . #ZZ
(380) *u-. Z
(381) 9 '5 5
(382) # 5
(383) C 1 *u- 77 5
(384) C 1 ! 77 G & = 53
(385)
(386) &. Y-. . . . ¶ S { )( 4 * $ - ]oPsixp&eu_ ]oVqrKd&Tn VHOgPR O VHVqeafBSR\cVbe[^xr_ ]oV>f ShO ¯:^xroQi`PR_H. v cw. hW zr&ea_ SRrE_ ^xSh_aVbeSRr ^xrE_aVbrE_ ^`Psr PRn:yaVb\c_poVbe \cO^`nB^xroQ«_ ]oV¨SR\H\cVbe e\"]&ShOSR\c_aVHO^xe _ ^x\HeXPR _ ]&V>^xrERPK\HSh_ ^`Psr¨SRr&p_ ]oV>\Hij^`Vbr _^jpoVbr _ ^`¡ VHOb K __ ]oVbr ^xr RPR¯RVbe_ ]&V\cPsr&e^xea_aVbr&\cw TXSRr&ShQRVHO . & * #,$ & '&%$3 fBSRe e ^xroQ _ ]oV f O VHK^xPsd&e i`wX\cOVbSh_aVbp^xrE_aVbrE_ ^`Psr/ K 4| r&\cVX_ ]oVSR\c_ ^`:^`_ w ^xeSRixi`P©VbpªnEw _ ]oV\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cw TUSRr&ShQRVHObm²^`_>^xrERPR¯RVbe-_ ]oV \cPROO Vbeaf Psr&p&^xr&QTUVH_ ]oPKpPR²_ ]oVi`PK\HSRi OVHf ix^x\HS: No _ ]oVTVH_ ]oP:p&edof/p&Sh_aVbep&Sh_ S:mE^`_\cO VbSh_aVbe3SqTUVbe e ShQRVO VHf O VbeaVbrE_ ^xroQ,_ ]oVdof/p&Sh_aV SRr p§eaVbr&p&eg^x_ K^xSU_ ]oVq\cPsr&e ^xe _aVbr&\cwTUSRr&ShQRVHO _aP^`_ egf VHVHOeH K 0PR_ ^`w_ ]oV[Vbr&pUPR_ ]&V0SR\c_ ^`:^`_ w )* #%$'&'&,$ 3 _aP>_ ]oV[\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwTUSRr ShQRVHOb J²^`QsdoO VbKe O SRr&D p P4e ]&P© _ ]&VeaVHO :^x\cV[^xrE_aVHO lSR\cV[SRr&p_ ]oVgfBeaVbd&poPq\cP:poVPROVbSR\]TVH_ ]oP:p PRO_ ]oVqO VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp\cPsd&rE_aVHO[VcvoSRTf i`VR . .
(387) ¶ » H, ¶ »³ º' H ¶" · ª Ow ¶ . o] V 5='4$($>,' ? 7]='!^Y,- ^xTf i`VbTUVbr _ e>_ ]oV\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cw \cPsrE_aOSR\c_H ] ^xe>^xr \Hixd&poVbe TUSR^xr i`wXf Psix^x\H^xVbePROQROSRrE_ ^xroQUixPK\¯KeSRr p¥PRO[f&O PRf ShQsSh_ ^xr&QXdof/p&Sh_aV,O V"KdoVbea_ eH Z \cPsr&e ^xea_aVbr \cw¬TUSRr ShQRVHO¨^xeQRVbroVHO^j\h Á_§\HSRr´n V d&eaVbp _aP TXSRr&ShQRV V \H^`VbrE_ i`w¬_ ]oV \cPsr&e ^jea_aVbr&\cw PR[SRrEw O VHf ij^x\HSh_aVbpªPRnoyzVb\c_Hm O VHQsShOp&ixVbe e>PR[_ ]oVOVHf ix^x\HSh_aVbpªPRn:yzVb\c__ÁwEf VR d3SR\"]\cPsr e ^xea_aVbr&\cwqTXSRr&ShQRVHO ]&Psixp&e(S[O VH¥VHOVbr&\cV3_aP,SRr>Z[| PR&^`_ e SReeaPK\H^jSh_aVbp>O VHfBix^x\HSh_aVbp PRn:yaVb\c_H fgfih jk>lm>n.
(388) W!O. "5- ^Y>$ ->.Y' 5 ' >$, \
(389) ='_^_5=.. C 5 A
(390) FH &' G'
(391) .#%
(392) G
(393) * A
(394) &
(395)
(396)
(397)
(398) ! A
(399)
(400)
(401) ' f#ZZ4 A TKT4Pf?
(402) '5.#%**u- 77. # N*. 77 L& 1DM
(403) & G@
(404)
Documents relatifs
2) Le développement local c'est-à-dire les expériences d'intervention en développement économique communautaire, en économie sociale et en économie solidaire mises
La définition générale du concept d'évaluation formative des apprentissages retenue pour cette recherche constitue une synthèse découlant de la recension d'un ensemble
Effets et pouvoirs de la voix dans la philosophie et la littérature antiques Paris, Classiques Garnier, 2021 (Kaïnon - Anthropologie de la pensée ancienne, 19), ISBN :
relève de traités, et que les États membres sont des États au sens du droit international public, c’est à ce juste titre que J. Fischer peut qualifier l’Union actuelle de
Afin de saisir le déploiement de ce discours, j'analyserai dans un premier temps les représentations liées au temps dans le roman, en m'arrêtant d'abord sur toutes celles qui,
Cette recherche, de type qualitatif, consiste en une exploration de la littérature dont les buts sont de décrire selon divers auteurs, différe ntes expériences
For each sam- pling point is also given the value output of the merging process with the difference between the SH degree 100 expansions subtracted, the index corresponding to the
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
