Correctness and robustness of 3D rigid matching with bounded sensor error
42
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Correctness and Robustness of 3D Rigid Matching with Bounded Sensor Error Xavier PENNEC. N˚ 2111 Novembre 1993. PROGRAMME 4. Robotique, image et vision. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche. 1993.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8) "!#$ % & ')(* +! ,-" '( ./# 01 24356 7 8:9;=<?>A@BC C B#D EFHGJIKFML$N#N#OQPR S)GJTUGJVXWZY\[:O\]:W^N1L*IKOQO_V)`aWZbcW^GJd EeFXGJf=O_V gh:Wji:L*[:FXO SkL$h:hUGJFHVli?OmFHOonqp:O"FMnMp:Okdsrat?uKuJuvR wkG$`\O_NT:FXOmu_xJxKy R yKz{h|L*IJOob }~o* J\OQh:FXO$bcO_daV
(9) Wd#VXp:WZb
(10) hUL*hUO_F LhFHO$nWjbcOlbcVX[Ui?G*ekW^IJd:N#O"d?V2L*dUi O_GK NO_VHFXWZn)QLKbcp:W^d:IGJF)VXp:OQFHOonGJIKd:WVXWGJd1G$
(11) yKFXWIKWZiGKT:f=O$nVMb
(12) Wd#VXp:Omh:FHOobcO_dUnOQG*[:d nO_FHVL*WdaV=\ W`\O_d1LmTUGJ[:dUiaO$iO_FXFHGKFGJd1hUGJW^d?V
(13) O$L*VX[:FHOob]?6OQh:FXGJhUL$I\L*VXOW^VVHpFHGJ[IJp VXp:OnGKN#h:[:VL*VHW^GJdUb VHGAi?O_VXO_FHN#W^d:OmVHp:O&VXFML$dUbcjL*VHW^GJdL$dUi FHGJVL*VXWGJdO_FXFHGJF"&p:WjbvL$ ^G$ beVXp:OmnGKN#h:[:VL*VXWGJd&G$VHp:OlnGKN#hUL*VXWT:W^W^Vcl_GJd:O]?O_W^VHp:O_F2WdVHp:O WN1L$IJO)GKFWdVHpO p|LJbcpVML$T:O]JVHGQW^dUbc[FHOVXp:O nGKFHFHOonVHd:OobHbG$ VXp:O)L$IKGJFHW^VHp:N+]JW¡¢O\ VHpO L*TUb=O_dUnO)G$£¤L$Zb=O dO_I\L$VHW`\OobpWZbGKFH¥WZb
(14) h:FHO$b=O_daVHO$i{GKFVXp:OQOoLJbcV¦bHY\[UL*FXO$b)L*d|iLT|LJbcWjbi?O§Ud:WVXWGKd NO_VHp:GaibO&b=p:G$¨VHp:OsO$Y\[:W`KL*^O_dUnOlG*6VHp:OobcOmV=GN#O_VHpGai:bkL$dUihUGJW^d?V GJ[:V VHpO LKn_n[:FLJn©G*mVXp:OAnGJN#h|L*VHW^T:W^WV="GJd:O$bªOAL*jbcG©bcVH[|i?VHp:O1FHGKT:[Ub=VHd:O$bXb{G$mVHpO L$W^IJd:N#O"d?V
(15) L$IKGJFHW^VHp:N«Wd¬nGJN#h[:VHW^d:ImVHp:OQNO$L*d&da[:NT£O"F'G$p?ahUGJVXp:O$bcOobL*d|i¤L$Zb=O hUGbcWVXW`\O$b))WVXp[:dWGJFXNFML$dUi?GKN/N#Gai?O"Zb)L*d|i bHnO_dO\)g®?hUO_FXWN#O"d?VbnGKd?§UFHN¯GK[:F L$dUL*^:b=WZb p:WjbvVXp:O_GJFXO_VHWjn_L*6b=VH[Ui?pULKbWN#hUGJFXVML$d?Vmh:FLJnVXWZn_L$)L*hh:Wjn_L*VXWGJd|b°W^d±
(16) GJ[N#O ²Ooi?WZn_L$³¡N1L*IKO$bk dUL*^:b=WZb]UO bcp:G$5VHpUL$VkGJFQV=ah:WZn"L*bcW^VH[UL$VHW^GJdUb]L$dL*^WIJdN#O_daV bXnqpO_N#On_L*d´LJnMp:W^O_`\O#yKµFXO_IJWjbcVHFL*VXWGJdGKFL*d¶Gan"n[Ub=WGKdªFL*VXWGLJb&ZL$FHIKOLKb&·J¸\¹ )W^VHpAL&d:O_IJ^WIKWT:^OkFXWZbc¥G*¤L$ZbcOmN1L$VMnMpºG$O"F)VHpUL$du_¸\»a¼_½M ¾A¿ÁÀÃÂXÄsÅ£$ÆJ ±'GK[:NO³¡N1L$IJOsEFHGanOobHbcW^d:I:]yKÇSÈW^IJWZiASÈOonGJIKd:WVXWGJdÉ]ÃyJÇS)O_IJWjbc VXFML$VHWGKdÃ]
(17) k^WIJdN#O_daV_] O_GKN#O_VHFXWZn&QLKbcp:W^d:I:]Ê
(18) GKFHFXO$nVHdO$bHb]Ê
(19) GJN#hUL$VHW^T:W^WV=ËUGKd:O$b] S)GJT[UbcVXd:O$bHb ÌÎÍ Ð¡Ï Ñ=Ò_Ó Ð
(20) Ï ÔÕÑ×ÖÙØMÚ. Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 93 65 77 77 – Te´le´copie : (33) 93 65 77 65.
(21) 3 A '" ' m 4 2
(22) 2 " ¬ +*
(23) 2 "!¬$+ & # + 3 6 ./È m ¿?
(24) ¿ wkGJ[|bh:F O$ b=O_daVHGJd|b&i:L*dUbnO_V L*FXVHWZnO#[:dO O" VH[Ui?Oh:FO$ nWZbcO¬i?O$b&L*^IJGK FXWVXp:N#O$b&i kW^IJd:O"N#O_daVO_Vi?OQLKnqpUL$IJO O_ GK N O_ VHFXWZY\[:O1hUGJ[:F1ZLFHO$nGKd:dUL$WZbHbXL*dUnO i GJT:f=O"VMbvFXWIKWZi?O$bsyJT:FX[:WV O$ bgVML$d?Vi?GKd:d O_ O[:d:O#O_FXFHO_[FTUGJFXd O_ O1b=[:F&O$bmhUGJWdaVMb n"L*FMLKnV O" FHWZb=VHWjYÁ[:Oob]$d:GJ[Ub
(25) ZLkhFHGJh|L*IJO"GJdUb)i:L$dUbO$b
(26) n_L$Zn[ZbhUGJ[Fi O_ VHO_FXN#WdO_FÃ ¢O_FHFXO_[:F b=[:F&ZL1VHFL*dUb=ZL*VXWGKdªO"VZLFXGJVL*VHW^GJdÃ
(27) Ê
(28) O_ZLhUO_FXN#O_VmOn_L$Zn[:¦i?O#jL_GKd:OAi?O1nGKN# h|L*VHW^T:W^WV O\ ]ÃbcGKWVsi:L$dUb ¢WN1L$IJO\] bcGKWV&iL*dUbmZLVL*T:^O#iaO#pULJnMpUL$IJO\]Ãd O$ nO$bHbXL*WFXOhUGK[:F LKbHb=[:FHO_F6 ¢O_®:LKnVHW^VH[UiaO)i?O L*IKGJFXWVHpN#O\]_W¡¢O\$ L$TUbcO"dUnO i?O)¤L*[:®d O_ IL*VXW¤baÊ
(29) OkVXFML_`KL*W OobcVQh:F O$ bcO"d?V O hUGJ[:FmjL N O_ VXp:Gai?O&iaO$bkN#GKWdUi?FXO$b n_L*FXF O$ bkO"Vk[:dO& N O_ VHpGai?OhUL$Fsi O §U dWVHW^GJd©i?OTULJb=O\wkGJ[UbQN#GKd?VXFHGKdUbQ Oo YÁ[:W^`KL*O"dUnOsi?OnO$bmi?O_[:® N O_ VHp:GaiaO$bkO_Vmd:GK[Ub O"dO"®:L$N#Wd:GKdUbZLh:F O$ nWjbcWGKdÃ:w GJ[U b O_ VX[Ui?W^GJdUb)L$[UbHb=WÃZLFHGKT:[Ub=VHO$bXbcO&iaOQ L*IKGJFXWVHpN#O i k^WIJdO_N#O_daVkO"d¶n"L*Zn[:ZL$d?VsO#d:GKNTFHO#N#G$\O_d©i?O¤L$[:®hUG\bcW^VHW ¤b&Lo`\Oon#i?O$bN#GK i O_ O$b
(30) O_V)[:d:O bHn O_ dOmnGJNh£G!b O$ b)iaOvhUGKWdaVMb)L*" O$ L*VXGJW^FHO$b
(31) [:d:WGKFH N O" N#O_daVF O_ h|L*FHVXWZb:kO$b O"®?h O" FHWO"dUnO$b
(32) nGKd?§UFHNO_d?V6d:GJVXFHOsL*d|L*bcO Ê
(33) O_VXVH O O_ VH[UiaOVHp O_ GJFXWZY\[:O6LQi W^N#hUGJFXVML*daVHOobÃL*h:h:^WZn_L$VHW^GJdUbhFML*VXWZY\[:O$b
(34) °*O"d&kdUL$bcO i ³¡N1L*IKO$b)#² O$ i?Wjn_L*^O$b±
(35) GJ^[:N#WZY\[:O$b]?d:GK[UbQN#GJdaVHFXGJdUb Y\[:OhUGJ[Fmi?O$bQb=WVX[UL*VXWGJd|bkV=? hWZY\[:O$b]\$ L*^IJGKFHWVXp:N#O i kW^IJd:O"N#O_daVhUO_[:V)FXO$n_L$O_F6i?O$bW^N1L*IKO$b
(36) yJ L_aL*daV[:d1VL*[:® i Gan_n[VML$VHW^GJdAi?Os·J¸\¹L_`\O$n [:d1FHWZbXYÁ[Oi O_FXFHO_[:F6d O_ IKWIKO$L*TO&ºWd?% O_ FXWO_[F L1 u_¸ »Á¼ ½ & Å:$Â( ')¿ ÃFML$WVXO_N#O_daV
(37) i ³×N¬L*IJOobyJs]USÈO$nGJd:dUL$WZbXbHL*d|nO&S)WIKWZi?OmyK]US)O$n_L*jL*IKO yK]akW^IJd:O"N#O_daV_]$QLKnqpUL$IJOQ O_ GK N O_ VHFXWZY\[:O\]Kg®:LKnVHW^VH[Ui?O]?ËUGJd:Oob'iaOvÊ
(38) GKN#hUL*VXWT:W^W^V O\ ] S)GJT[UbcVXO$bHb=O\.
(39)
(40)
(41)
(42) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(43) $,+"% *.-/
(44) 0 )12
(45) 35463. u. ¬ È '"¬ 9 T:f=O$nVFHOonGJIKd:WVXWGJd1Wjb)L{N1L$f=GJFVLJb=¥G$6L*FXVHW § nWZL$ `aWZb=WGJdÉU³×d1N#GbcV¦n_LJb=O$b]:GKT:f=O$nVMb L$FHOsFHWIKWZiAL*dUi1¥?d:G$)d W^dLKi?`KL*dUnOL*dUi1Op|Lo`\OmVXG#FHO$nGJIJdW_OmVHpO_NWd+n[VHVHO"FHO$i bXnO_d:Oob]:FHOoYÁ[:W^FHW^d:I&VHp:OsN#Gai?O_^ÙT|LJbcOoi¬FXO$nGKIJd:W^VHWGKd L$IJGKFHW^VHp:N1b:QbXbc[:NWd:I&GKT:f=O$nVMb L$dUi bHnO_d:OsL*FXOFHO"h:FHO$b=O_daVHO$i#Ta1bcO_VbkG*eWdaVHO_FXO$bcVO$L$VH[:FXO$bmºÙhUGJW^d?Vb]UWdO$b :0:0:M½)L$dUi VXp:O_W^FIJO_GKN#O_VXFHWZnFXO_ZL$VHWGKdUbº¤nG\GJFi?WdUL$VHO$bM½M]\VHpO)h:FHGKT:O_N WjbeV=6GJZGJZi#°KGJdGJd:O)pUL$dUi 6O&pUL_`\OVXGFXO$nGKIJd:W^_O)p:Wjnqp GKT:f=O$nVbQL*FXO&Wd VHpObHnO_dO&L*d|i GKdVXp:O&GJVXp:O_FQpUL$dUi )pO_FHOsVHp:O_AL$FHOhZLJnO$i UO bHL_1VHpUL$VmL*d GKT:f=O$nV WZb)FHO$nGKIJd:W^_O$i1W
(46) VXp:O_FHOsO_®aWZbcVbkL N¬L*h:h:W^d:I#G$VXp:OGJT:f=O$nVlWd VHpObHnO_dO&VHpUL$VvN¬L*VMnMp:O$b)L#N#W^d:WN&[NhUO_FMnO"d?VL*IJO&G$ GKT:f=O$nVO$L$VH[:FXO$b)VHGbHnO_dO OoL*VH[FHO$b 9 n_n^[Ui?O$iGJT:f=O$nVbÈhFHO$b=O_d?VXWd:I&^O$bHb)VHp|L*dVXp:WZb NWd:W^N&[:N )W^ dGJV T£OmFXO$nGJIKd:W"O$i kNGJd:I N1L*daQN#O"VHp:Gai:<b ; FHWjxJt =¤]*V=6GkFXO$nO_daVVXO$nMp:d:WZY\[:O$b]J O_GJN#O"VHFHWjn
(47) QLJb=p:Wd:I ;?>J ·J · = L$dUikW^IJd:N#O"d?, V ;¢ @QB· A]\ C·Kz =¤]Jh:FHG$`\O$iVXGsLJi:L$h:V6O_aVHGmGan_n^[UbcW^GJd)WVXp L&FHOoLJbcGKdUL*TO&nGJN#h:^O_®aWV¡\akW^`\O_d#N#W^d:WN¬L*Ub=O_VMb nGJFXFHO$b=hUGJdUi?O"dUnO$b]:GJd:Osn_L$d nGKN# h[:VHO6L)VHFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHW^GJdmTUO_V=O_O_dlVHp:O
(48) N#Gai?O"\L*d|ivVHpObXnO_d:O_k^WIJdN#O_daV:[UbcOob VXp:G\b=O NWd:W^N#L$b=O_VMbsnGJFXFHO$b=h£GKdUi?O_d|nO$bLKbp?ahUGJVXp:O$bcOobL*d|i`\O_FHW §UO$bkVXp:O_N4TaN¬L*h:h:W^d:I VXp:O#N#GaiaO_GJdaVHG VXp:O1bXnO_d:OL*dUi©bcO_O_¥aWdIGJF bHnO"d:O{OoL*VH[FHO$bsnGbcO#VXGh:FXO$i?WZnVHO$i GKd:O$b£ W^VHpVXp:O&bXL*N#OmN#W^d:WNL* b=O_VMb]£6O&n_L$d i?O§|d:O&L&N#Gai?O_ÃT|LJbcWjbkL$dUi L#bXnO_d:O T|LJbcWjb]
(49) TUGJVHp W^d?`KL$FHWZL$d?VGKF#VHpO nGKdUbcWji?O_FHOoiªb=O_VG*mVXFML*d|b×GJFXN1L*VXWGKdUb) O_GJN#O"VHFHWjn p|LJbcpWd:I [Ub=O$bvVXp:O&¤LJnVsVHpUL$VGJVXp:O_FsN#Gai?O_OoL*VH[FHO$bmpUL_`\OW^d?`KL*FXWZL$d?VsnG\GKFMi?W^dUL*VXO$b W^dVXp:ON#Gai?O_T|LJbcWjb°Ã[Ub=Wd:IALp|LJbcp©VML*TO\] 6O#n"L*dL$VvFXO$nGKIJd:W^VHWGKdVXWN#OsFHO_VXFHW^O_`\O GKFO$LKnqp bHnO_dO#hUL*W^F#ºTULJb=WZb]hUGJWdaV½lVHp:Oh£GbHb=WT:^O#N1L*VnqpO$i NGai?O_
(50) hUL*W^FMbQn_n[: N[:jL*VHW^d:I#O_`aWZiaO_dUnO$b] O¬i?WFXO$nVH^GKT:VML$WdVXp:O#N#GbcVmW^¥\O_AN#Gai?O_T|LJbcWjb&L*dUiWVMb N¬L*VMnMp:O$b$p:WZb2n_L*dsT£O)FXO_hUO$L*VXO$iG$`\O_F2L*aWN¬L*IJO6N#WdWNL*\b=O_VMb]*¥\O"O_h:WdIkO$LKnqpsVHW^N#O VXp:OmTUO$bcV N1L*VnqpWd:I kG$6O_`\O_F_]ÃVXGTUOhFMLJnVHWZn"L*)L$dUi¶FHGKT:[Ub=V_]VHpO$bcO1N#O_VXp:Gai:bpUL_`\O1VHG©i?O$L$))WVXp [dUnO_FXVML*W^d?V=&W^dVXp:OQW^N1L*IKOÈO$L$VH[:FXO$bU³¡dUiaO_O$i ]\O_FXFHGJFbWd#NO$LJb=[:FHO_NO_d?V2G*O$L*VX[:FHO$b L$FHWjbcOFHGKN4i?&W D O_FHO_daVk¤LKnVHGKFMbmL*^GJd:I1VHpO&WN1L$IJOhFHGanO$bXbcW^d:I:] FL*d:IKWd:I#FXGJN i?OGKFH N¬L*VHW^GJdUbWd VHp:O `aWZb=WGJd bcbcVXO_N L$dUi VXp:OW^d:p:O_FXO_daV#bXL*N#h:^Wd:I©G*&VXp:OWN1L$IJO VHG W^dULJn"n[:FMLKnWOobkWd W^N1L*IKO&h:FHO_hFHGanO$bXbcW^d:I\bsbc[UnMpLJbQ§UVXO_FHW^d:I#GJFQO$L$VH[:FXOO"®?VXFMLJnVHWGKdà pa[Ub] L$d L*^WIKd:N#O_daV)b=:b=VHO_N¯pULKbkVHG¥?dG* GJFQO$LKnqp1h:FXO$i?WjnVHO$iO$L$VH[:FXOW^d)p:Wjnqp W^N1L*IKO&_GJdO&WVmpULJbQVXG§UdUiL1bc[:hh£GKFHVXWd:IAWN1L$IJOO$L$VH[:FXO\à IJO"GJN#O_VXFHWjnvpULKbcp:W^d:I b=:b=VHO_NN[Ub=V)i?O"VHO_FXN#Wd:O)VXp:OsL*FXO$L{)pWZnMp#N[|bcVW^dUi?O_®¬L#ºÙN#Gai?O"¡]?T|LJbcWjbq½6hUL*W^F_ EGKVHp#GJF L$WIKd:N#O_daV
(51) L$dUi#IJO_GKN#O_VHFXWZn)pULJb=p:WdI:]:WVXp:G\b=OmFHO_IKWGJd|b)L*FHOmVXG\G&ZL*FXIJO\] W^dUnGKFHFHOonVN¬L*VMnMp:O$b&N1L_TUO©LJn_nO"h:VHO$i ]'IKW`aWd:IFXWZb=OVHGhUG\bXbcW^T:! FHGJILK MONQPKHRTS RVU MWK ºW¡¢O\UL#nGKdUbch:W^FML$VHWGKd VHpUL$VQOoLJi:bkVXG#VHpOv¤L*jbcOsFHO$nGKIJd:W^VHW^GJd G*¦L$d GJT:f=O$nXV ; lQxK¸ =½M] )pO_FHO$LKbkWeVHp:O_¬L*FHOb=N1L*^O_F6VHpUL$d d:O$nOobHbHL$FH\] nGKFHFHOonVkN¬L*VMnMp:O$b
(52) N1L_#TUO&N#WZbXbcO$i ] 7. 8.
(53) t G UHRM ^ O$LJiaWd:IsVHG FHGJI?K M /M GJS RVUMWKlºÙdGFHOonGJIKd:WVXWGJd)p:O_d#VXp:OQGJT:f=OonV
(54) WZb'hFHO$b=O_d?V½M\³¡d#VXp:WZb h|L*hUO_F_] O[|bcO&VHpO&VHO_FXN P M S /M K K)VHGAY\[UL*^W#VXp:OL*TUb=O_dUnO&G$
(55) ¤L*Zb=O&d:O_IL*VHW^`\O$b L$dUi P JKS /M K KVXG#Y\[UL*^WVHp:OmN#W^d:WNWoL*VHW^GJdG*¤L*jbcOmhUG\bcW^VHW^`\O$b @Qb=Wd:ImVXp:O$bcO V=GsL*^IJGKFHWVXp:N1b]ÁVXp:O)§UFMb=V'6GJFX¥WjbeVXp:O_dVHGsnGKN#h:[:VXO)VHp:OlnGJNhUL* VXWT:W^W^Vc_GJd:Oob] )p:WjnqpL$FHO&VXp:O&FHO_IKWGKdUbQd:O_O$i?OoiVHG1WdUb=[:FHOnGJFHFXO$nVXd:O$bHb G*6O_`\O_F"] O"`\O_dW 6O¥ad:G$ O_®LJnVH1VXp:O&_GJdO$b]UVHp:O"FHO&N1L_AbcVXWTUO¤L*jbcO&hUG\b=WVHW^`\O$bQn_L$[UbcOoi TaFL*dUiaGJNÇWN¬L*IJOO$L$VH[:FXO$b
(56) L*h:hUO$L$FHW^d:ImWd&VHpO$bcO)FXO_IJW^GJdUb°JWd¤LKnV_]$GJd:^O_®LJnV
(57) i:L*VL n"L*d1O_dUb=[:FHOQVXp:OsL*TUb=O_dUnOlG*¤L*Zb=Omh£GbcW^VHW`\OobbcW^dUnOQW^VWjb'O$Y\[:W`KL$O_daV
(58) VHGd?[:^U`\GJ[N#O O"FHFHGKF"GJd:O$b
(59) kd´L*dUL$bcWjb{G$mVHp:O1O_®ahUO$nVXO$id?[:NTUO_FmG*sb=[UnMpª¤L*jbcO1hUG\b=WVHW^`\O$bWZb G$VHO_dA[UbcO[:ÃVHG¥?dG* VHp:O YÁ[UL$W^VcG*eVHp:OmFHOonGJIKd:WVXWGJdÉ] L$dUin_L$dp:O"h#§U®aWd:Ip:G$ N[UnMpG$
(60) VHpOvNGai?O_ p|LJb)VHG&TUON1L$VMnMp:O$i&VHG¥\O_O_h#VXp:WZbFL*VXOv^G$m ³¡d#¤LJnV"]:VHp:O"FHOmL$FHOmV=G)L_:bG$
(61) nGJdUi?[|nVHW^d:I&VHp:OsL$dUL*^:b=WZb i?O_hUO_dUi?W^d:I&GJdAp:G$ 6O&N#Gai?O_2VHp:O&O_FXFHGKF_p:O&TUGJ[:d|i?O$iO_FXFHGKFvpaah£GKVHp:OobcWZbmLKbHbc[N#O$bkVXpUL*VmhUG\b=WVHW^GJdUL$ O"FHFHGKFWjb'TUGJ[:d|i?O$i \VH[UiaWO$b
(62) [:dUi?O_F6VHp:WjbLKbHbc[N#h:VHW^GJd#6O_FHO WdWVHWjL*VXO$i GKFIKO_GJN#O"VHFHWjn p|LJbcpWd:I[UbcW^d:I&hUGJW^d?VO$L$VH[:FXO$bTaO >ÃL$N1i:L*d GK¤bcGKd ; GKZxJ ¸ =ÃL$dUi FHW^N1bcGKd [:VHVXO_d:GanMp:O_.F ; lQxK¸ = GJFltJ5L d:OFXO$nGKIJd:W^VHWGKdÃ]:L$dUiO"®?VXO_dUi?O$i#VXG#tK FHOonGJIKd:W VXWGKd[dUi?O_F)FXWIJWji#VHFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHW^GJdUb)L$dUib=WN#W^ZL*FXWVXWO"beW^!d ;L>J xa0u =¡ nGJN#h:^O_VHO L$dUi hFHO$nWjbcOlbcVX[Ui?#G$
(63) tK L #dOQFHO$nGJIJdWVHW^GJd#)W^VHp#IKO_GJNO_VHFXWZn)pULJb=p:Wd:IL$dUi1L*^WIJdN#O_daV ¦LJb#L$Zb=Gh:FXO$bcO"d?VXO$iWd ; l \xJ y =¡
(64) ³¡d LNGJFHOFHO$nO"d?V&6GJFH¥ ;¢ lxJ y =¡]
(65) k^VHO_F&hFHO_ b=O_daVMb)L*dAL$dUL*^:b=WZbG*2tK L #d:OlFHO$nGKIJd:W^VHW^GJd1[UbcW^d:I&W^d:O)O$L*VX[:FHO$b)W^VHp1L$W^IJd:N#O"d?V" 9 d VXp:OGKVHp:O_FpUL*dUi ]ÈlL*[|bHbcWjL*d O_FHFXGJF#NGai?O_W^d:I OoLJi:bVXG HhFHGJT|L*T:W^WZb=VHWjnFHOonGJ IKd:WVXWGKd ?]6L*dUi)LKbb=VH[Ui?W^O$i GKFIKO_GJNO_VHFXWZn&pULJb=p:Wd:I©T?S)WIKGJ[:VbcGb 4k[:N#NO ;¢Sklx?u_La] S QxauTÃ] SÈW^I\xKt:] S QxJ y = GKFQtKÇbcW^N#WjL*FHW^VHW^O$b
(66) L*dUi tKÇL d:OFXO$nGJIKd:WVXWGKd [|bcWdI&h£GKWdaVÈOoL*VH[FHO$b:³¡d1FHO$nO"d?V6GJFX¥:)b ;¢)bHLKxJy:] :lxJJy =É)bHL$WL$dUi aL$FMLKnqp:W^¥{Gan[Ub GKd tK L d:OmFHOonGJIKd:WVXWGJd1)W^VHpAL*^WIJdN#O_daV'GKFk[|bcWdI&WdOkO$L*VX[:FHOob Ê
(67) GKdUnO_FXd:Wd:IAN#O$i?Wjn_L*ÃW^N1L*IKWd:I] Od:O_Ooi VXG i?O$L$
(68) )WVHp`\GJ^[:N#OsWN1L$IJO$bQb=[UnMp LKb)yJ Ê6
(69) ¡bXn_L*d|bGJF ² S ³ ;¢kaLJxK0y =¡:EFXO_`?W^GJ[Ub
(70) GKFH¥b ; lQxKt:]:kl²lxJt:]UQlxJy = [|bcO$iAL{N#GaiaW§UO$i#IKO_GJN#O"VHFHWjnÈp|LJbcpWd:I#GKd n[FH`\O$b)L$dUi LJi:iaFHO$bXbcO$i1VHp:Om[:dUnO_FHVL*WdaV= "GJd:Osh:FHGKT:O_N¯[Ub=Wd:I¬L*dL*hUG\b=VHO_FXWGJFXW6bcVML$VHWjbcVHWjn_L*O$b=VHWN¬L*VHW^GJd1G*6W^d?`KL*FXWZL$d?VbkLKn_n[: FLJn?S)O$nO"d?VFXO$bc[VMbW^d{O$L$VH[:FXOkO"®?VXFMLJnVHWGKd ;¢p:WZxKy?]aklxJy = bcp:G$ p:G$ VHGsO_®aVHFMLKnV FXO_WjL*T:^OÈOoL*VH[FHOQhUGJW^d?Vb'FHGKN¯yJ bc[Fc¤LJnO$b')W^VHpAL&bc[:TÙ`\G$®aO_Uh:FHO$nWZbcW^GJdÃ]L*dUi#VXp?[Ub GKhUO_d VHp:O&hFHGJTO_N¯G*ÈyJ FXO$nGJIKd:WVXWGKd [:dUi?O_FlFHWIKWZi1VHFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHW^GJdUbk)W^VHp hUGJW^d?V OoL*VH[FHO$b ³¡dVHp:OAb=O$YÁ[O_6O#)W^'Gan[Ub&GJdFXO$nGJIKd:WVXWGKdªTa©L*W^IJd:NO_d?VsL$dUiªIKO_GJN#O"VHFHWjn p|LJbcpWd:I GJFyKµFHW^IJWji VXFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHWGKdUb&L*d|iªhUL$FHVHWjn[:jL*FH^GKdVc6G N#O_VXp:Gai:bvGJF nGJN#h:[VHWdI)VHp:O
(71) FHGKVML$VHWGKd&L$dUiWVbÃLJbHb=GanWZL$VHO$i[dUnO_FXVML*W^d?V= _GJdO\°_GJd:O
(72) GJF2L*^WIJdN#O_daV W^dAbcO$nVXWGKd t? t?]UL$dUiGJd:OmGJF IJO_GKN#O_VXFHWZn pULJb=p:Wd:IWd+bcO$nVHWGKdAt? y £VXp:O_dÃ]:W^dAbcO$nVXWGKd ta P]LbcVML$VHWjbcVHWjn_L*¦bcVX[Ui?)W¦bcp:G$«VHpUL$V&GJ[:F&hFHO$i?WjnVHOoiTUGJ[:dUibL$FHOAYÁ[WVHOO" .
(73) .
(74). .
(75). . . . . . !. . #". $. %. &. '. . )(.
(76) y b=[:WVXO$i \O$nVHWGKdy)W^Gan[|bvGJd©FHGJT[UbcVXd:O$bHbG$)VXp:O1L*^WIKd:N#O_daVQbXnqpO_N#O\]:GJFmVHpO hFHO$i?WjnVHW^GJdb=VML*IKO&º¡yau$½M]\L$dUiVHpO_d{GKF
(77) VHp:O)`\O_FXW§ n"L*VHW^GJdb=VML*IKO&º¡ya t\½M\p:Wjb)WO$LKi VXGVXp:OQO_®ahUO$nVHOoid?[:NTUO_FG$äL*Zb=OQhUG\b=WVHW^`\O$b]L*dUi#VHpOkO_®ahUO$nVXO$inGJN#h:^O_®aWV=\ >ÃLJb=V T[:V&d:GJV&^O$LJb=V_]O1)W^L$h:h:^Wd´bcOonVHW^GJdP GK[:F&VHp:O"GJFHO"VHWZn"L*)b=VH[UiaVHG VXp:OAn_LJb=O G$
(78) `\GJ^[:N#OQNO$i?WZn"L*UWN1L$IJO$bFXO_IJWjbcVXFML*VXWGKd L*d|ibcpG* VXpUL*VlL*^WIJdN#O_daV)n_L$d LJnMp:W^O_`\O FXO_IJWjbcVXFML*VXWGKd&)WVHpL$d&Gan_n^[UbcW^GJdFML*VXWGmLKbZL$FHIKO LJb
(79) ·J¸\¹ )WVHp LQh:FHGKTUL*T:W^W^VcmG$£¤L$Zb=O N¬L*VMnMp#^G*6O_FVXpUL*d©u_¸\»a¼* !¬ " '"¬ +v & )"!¬$ 6 2\ '"¬ lbHbc[N#Wd:I 6OAL*FHOA[UbcW^d:I O$L*VX[:FHO$b&hUGJW^d?Vb]
(80) LyJ/FHW^IJWji VXFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHWGKd¶pULKbb=W® h|L*FML$N#O_VXO_FMb]:T:[:V VHp:FXO_Omh£GKWdaVMbQL$FHOsd:O_O$i?Ooi¬VXG{GKFHN LN#W^d:WNL* b=O_V° L*^VHp:GK[:IJpL h|L*WF
(81) G$N1L*Vnqp:OoivhUGJW^d?Vb'aWO_ji:byQO$Y\[UL*VXWGJd|b]\VHp:O O$Y\[UL*VXWGKdUbh:FHG$`aWZi?O$i&Ta&L*dGJVHpO_F hUGKWdaVQN1L*VnqpWd:IL$FHO&W^d:¥\O$i#)WVXpVXp:O&h:FHO"`?W^GJ[Ub)GJd:Oob TUO$n"L*[Ub=O&VHp:O i?WZb=VML*d|nO&TUO_VH 6O_O_dV=GmhUGJWdaVMbpULKb'VXGFHO"N1L*W^d&Wda`JL$FHWjL*daV_\kO"dUnO LQhUL*W^FG$ÃN1L$VMnMp:O$bGKd:&aWO_ji:b W^dUi?O_hUO_dUiaO_d?VlO$YÁ[|L*VHW^GJdUb WdUb=VHO$LKi G$ z1L*dUiL#VHp:W^FMihUL$WFmG*6N1L$VMnMp:O$i1h£GKWdaVMbQWZb dO_O$i?O$i#VXGnGJN#h[:VHOmL$ÃVXp:OmhUL*FL*N#O_VXO_FMb
(82) G*6LFXWIKWZi#VHFL*dUb¡GJFHN¬L*VHW^GJdà 6¿
(83)
(84)
(85) M R 6R GJI K M S FHP R R M P 6RTS RVP RTS
(86) NQP R SF M GJS MWK R K
(87)
(88)
(89) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(90) $,+"% *.-/
(91) 0 )12
(92) 35463 .
(93). . QR
(94) .
(95) F<R G.
(96) M(G
(97).
(98). ). NQPK MP F,S
(99) M M N6P R
(100) S K<G
(101) S
(102) M GJS
(103) P P M I R
(104) QR GJIJK M S K R K P
(105) KS G R
(106) /M% !" G RTS RVP
(107) 6GJI R
(108) QU0G3RVG
(109) S K$# FHP M&%G N ITM S
(110) M R
(111) SM('TNQP R
(112) S R KS G
(113) 3MWK R
(114) M G(
(115) SRLN ITM S*) + P. :FHGKN¯d:G$¨GJdÃ]:^O_Vmº-,$.!/(,$01/(,32½6T£OsVHp:OmVXp:FHO_OmN#GaiaO_ÃhUGJWdaVMb nGKN#hUG\bcW^d:I&VHpO NGai?O_)N#W^d:WN1L$6bcO_VL*dUi4, LIKO_d:O_FXWZnGJ[:FXVHp hUGJW^d?VG*mVXp:O N#Gai?O_¤ \W^N#WjL*FX\] 6O)W^Ãd:GKVHO1º-5 .!/(5 01/(5!2_½)L$dUi 5{VXp:O&iaW D O_FHO"d?V)O_®LJnVkW^N1L*IKOvhUGKWdaVMbÉk[:OVXG#N#O$L$ b=[:FHO"N#O_daVkO_FXFHGKFMb] On_L$dGKd:LKn_nO$bXbº 56 . /56 0 /!56 2 ½lL$dU7i 5\6 ] VXp:ON#O$LJb=[:FHOoi`KL*^[:O$b] )W^VHp 596 8;:45!8<>=?5!8 L*d|i 5@6 :A5<B=C5 pOvTUGK[:dUi?O$i1O_FHFXGJFlLJbXbc[:N#hVHWGKdALJbHb=[:N#O$b
(116) VHpUL$V D =?5 8 DFEHG!I L*dUi D =C5 DJEKG9I C:GKFkO$LKbcOsG*6L$dUL*^:b=WZb]:6O)W^ GKd:1[Ub=OVXp:M O LN0 d:GJFXN EGJ[:d|i:bÈ)W^VHpAGJVHpO_FkOoYÁ[:W^ `KL$O_daVd:GKFHN1bb=[UnMp#LKNb LPO GKQF LN.6n_L*dTUOkGKT:VML$Wd:Ooi{[Ub=Wd:ImO$Y\[:W^`JL$O_d|nO)nG\O 1nW^O_daVMb ºO\ I?W^dyK] D1RSD 0 EUT y D1RVD O ½M C. . .
(117) P. G UHRM . .
(118) ! "# $ %. O&d:G$ Gan[UbQGJdVHp:O&VXp:FHO_O LJi:iaWVHW^GJdUL$
(119) Wda`JL$FHWjL*daVMbQnGKdUbcVXFML$Wd:W^d:I#VHpO&N1L*Vnqp:W^d:I TUO_V=6O_O_dW^N1L*IKO&L$dUi . NGai?O_N#Wd:W^N#L$bcO_Vb°'& 8 : D , 8)( , 8+* ., 2.- D º0/:«uC/Mt /My\½ L$FHOsbc[|nqp1Wda`KL*FXWZL*daVMb EO$n"L*[Ub=OQVHp:OobcOm`KL*[O$b)L*FXOvW^d?`KL$FHWZL$d?V6T?FHWIKWZi#VHFL*dUb¡GJFXN1L* VX5 WGKdUb]ÃON[UbcV pUL_5 `\1O & 8 : D 5 82( 5 83* ., 24- D L*dUi©bcGVXp:ON1L*Vnqp:W^d:I#Wjb GKd: `KL$WZiW 55 D 5 6 8 ( 5 6 8+* ., 2.- D ( & 8 55 E t G!I 6¿
(120)
(121) 7 6
(122) M R KS G 3MWK 3M S- M M S P NQP R SVK R S
(123) M R QR GJI K M SXG M S
(124) M M R QU0G 3RVG S K M G
(125) P /MM RTS
(126) G P NQGJS R HRTI&RTS-8HP /M P F G R K G:9 : t G!I + ² L$d?mN#O_VXp:Gai:bn_L*dsTUO[Ub=O$ivVXGQVML$¥\O)LJia`JL$d?VL*IKO)G*UVXp:O$bcO6VHp:FXO_OW^d?`KL$FHWZL$d?Vb$Qb ¤L$FmLJb IJO_GKN#O_VHFXWZnkp|LJbcpWd:I#WjbQnGKdUnO_FXd:O$i ]:VXp:O_FHO L*FXO&bcW^N#h:^1y#LJii?O$iiaWN#O_d|bcWGKdUb GKFVXp:O_N Wd´VHp:O1pULKbcp:VML$T:O( C:GJFL*W^IJd:NO_d?V"]6O n_L$d¶[Ub=O nGKdUbcVXFML*W^d:O$i´bcO$L$FMnMp º ; FHWjxJ t =Ù½
(127) GJF LbcW^N#h:^OkpULKbcp:W^d:I:
(128) .
(129).
(130). .
(131). %.
(132).
(133). .
(134).
(135).
(136). . . . . . < ; =?>@A) BC! !0:DFEG IHJ
(137) $ ! K @=?L $ 6)MN6)M O PRQ GPSQGT VU WQ JX
(138) VP Q YQ
(139). Æ ¿#$$ =ÅU ? Å ~
(140) ¿ÁMÄs¿a¿ ÅÃÆ¿!' WQÆ´_\¿ZQ¿
(141) <PSQGPZÂ
(142) '
(143) _¿\$ lbHbc[N#Wd:IAL1N#Gai?O_NWd:W^N1L*b=O_V#º , .1/(,$0!/(,32½ WZbsLJbXbcGanWjL*VHOoi VXG L$dWN1L$IJO&N#W^ dWN1L$b=O_Vº 5 6 . / 5 6 0!/ 5!6 2½M]ÃO&pUL_`\O&VXG¬§|dUi VXp:OFHWIKWZiVXFML*d|b×GJFXN1L*VXWGKdN1L$h:h:W^d:I#VHpO NGai?O_aGJdaVHGmVHp:O bXnO_d:O E[:V
(144) i?[O)VHGmN#O$LKbc[:FXO_N#O_daV O_FXFHGKFMb]\W^VWZb`\O"FHm[:d:^W¥\O_^QVHpUL$V L$d?mFXWIJWjiQVHFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHW^GJdO"®:LKnVH^QN1L*h|b VHp:O6N#Wd:W^N#L$KbcO_VbKkO_dUnO2O)nMp:G\GbcOVXp:WZb VXFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHWGKd1T?1L&OoLJbcV bXYÁ[|L*FHOobN#O_VHpGai p:O VXFML$dUbcjL*VHW^GJd hUL*FXV1G*&VXp:O VHFL*dUb¡GJFXN1L*VXWGJd n"6 L*d T£O FX6 O_h:FXO$bcO_daVHOoiªTa¶VHpO nMp:GKWZnO$b
(145) G*6L&N#Gai?O" GJFXWIKW\d [ ] L*d|iLbHnO_dOQGJFXWIJW^d [_^M > O_V ` TUOmVHpOvFXGJVL*VHW^GJdUL$ h|L*FHVsºÙFXGJVL*VHW^GJdAN1L*VXFHW®U½Map:OmIKO_d:O_FXWZnkVXFML*d|b×GJFXN1L*VXWGKdG$6L&N#Gai?O_ h£GKWdaV ,µWjbQ° 5 I abRc : [_6 ^ < `{6 º , ( [ ]k½ pa[Ub]*6O)L$d?V2VHGk§Ud|idº [ ]F/ [_6 ^M½ÃL$dUi `¶6 N#W^d:WN#W _W d:I6VHp:O)N¬L*h:h:W^d:I)O_FXFHGJF2T£O"Vc6O_O_d VXp:OQVXFML*d|b×GJFXN#O$iNGai?O_UN#WdWNL*bcO_V¦L*dUi#VHpOQWN1L$IJO N#WdWN1L$:b=O_V_\ WVXp1LOoLJbcV bXYÁ[|L*FHOobÈN#O"VHp:Gai ]aVHp:O"N#W^d:WNW"O)VHp:OsnFXWVHO"FHWGKd 2 e : f D 5 6 8 ( [6 ^ ( `&6 -º , 8W( [ ]k½ D 0 8+g . h!i kj "%2l 22Vm%5 Vn.
(146)
(147)
(148)
(149) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(150) $,+"% *.-/
(151) 0 )12
(152) 35463. . Q bQ¤L*FsLJbVXFML$dUbcjL*VHW^GJdWjbmnGJdUnO_FHd:Ooi ]ÃVHp:Oi?O_FXW`KL*VXWGJdG* VXp:OnFHW^VHO_FXWGJdO$LKbcW^ b=p:G$ bVHpUL$V)VHp:OmGKFHWIKWdUb6n_L*d1TUOmVML$¥\O_d#O$Y\[UL* VHG&VXp:OQTUL$FHnO_daVHO_F6G*O$LKnqp#NWd:W^N1L* b=O_V [6 ^ : yu (º 5 6 .V<U5 6 0 <45!6 2_½ [ ]7: yu -º ,$.S<>,$0 <B,32_½ pO$bcOGJFXWIKWdUb TUO_Wd:I¶§|®?O$i ]QO)W^d:G$6GJFH¥ Wd TUL*FX:nO_d?VXFHWjn FML$N#O$b°Q^O_V º R . / R 0!/ R 2½lL$dUi R T£O&VXp:OTUL*FX:nO"d?VXFHWZnsnG\GJFi?Wd|L*VHOobvG*¦VHp:O&NGa6 i?O_hUGJW^d?Vb&º R 8 : , 8 ( [ ]k½M]\1º 6 .!/?6 0 /?6 2½ÉL*dUi 6 VHp:GbcO)G*|VHp:O¦bHnO_dO'GKd:O$b
(153) º 6 8 : 5 6 8 ( [_^q½$p:OFXGJVML$VHW^GJd N[Ub=VVHpO_FHOGKFHOQNWd:W^N#W _O)VHp:OsnFXWVXO_FHW^GJd 2. e : f. 83g .. D 6 8 ( `6 R 8 D. d?GJFXVH[:dUL$VHO_^\]\O pUL_`\OkdGL*dUL$aVHWZn"L* bcGK[:VXWGJdÉ]?T:[:V6Oli?WZb=hUG\bcOmG$2Ld?[:NO_FHWjn_L* FXO$bcGK[:VXWGKd[Ub=Wd:IsY\[UL*VXO_FHdWGJd|bº¡b=O_O ;¢kaLJxau =Ù½)p:WZnMp&WZb2i?O_`\O_^GJhUO$iWdL$h:hUO_dUi?W^® 6)MN6)M 6 sÅ
(154) ? PÙG~ P 'RPZM À \ Å Q7¿ X=ÅUW QÅ:V U¿?
(155) ÅÃÆ¿ '' Å PRQ£ lbHbc[N#Wd:ImVXp:OQN#Gai?O" . L$dUi1bHnO"d:OQN#W^d:WNL*bcO_Vb)L*FXOQO_^ LJbHb=GanWZL$VHO$i ]:VHp:O_FXOkO"®?WjbcVMb LsbHnO"d:OQGJFXWIKWd [ ^ : -º 5 . < 5 0 < 5 2 ½eL*dUi#LmFHGKVML*VXWGKdN¬L*VHFXW® S N1L$h:h:W^d:ImO_®:LKnVH^ VXp:ONGai?O_aN#Wd:W^N#L$\b=O_2 VVHGlVHp:O6O_®:LKnV
(156) bXnO_d:O6N#Wd:W^N#L$\b=O_V)C° 598;:
(157) [ ^ < `º , 8 ( [ ] ½M pOQO_®LJnV¦bHnO_dOQhUGJWdaV nGKFHFHOobchUGJdUiaWd:I&VXGLvGJ[:FXVHp#N#GaiaO_ hUGJW^d?V ,)W VHp:O"d#TUO W^d 5 : [ ^ <<`º , ( [ ] ½6L*dUi1)W TUOvNO$LJb=[:FHO$iWd 5 6 :45<B=?5\ 9 d´VHp:OAGJVHpO_Fp|L*dUi ]
(158) VHpOhFHO$i?WjnVHOoi hUGbcWVXWGKd G*mVXp:WZb&bXnO_d:OAh£GKWdaVWjbIJW^`\O_dT? 5 I abRc : [6 ^ < `6 -º , ( [ ]6½MakO_dUnO\]JO pUL_`\O 5 6 :H5 I abRc < =C5 ( = [_^ < =:`º , ( [ ]'½ L$dUi [Ub=Wd:ITUL$FHnO_daVHFXWZnnG\GJFMiaWdUL$VHO$b 5U6 : 5 I abRc < = < =:` R )p:O_FXOGJFXO\]VHpO GKTUbcO"FH`\O$ihUGJW^d?V 5A6 nGJFXFHO$b=h£GKdUi?W^d:IVXG VHp:O1N#GaiaO_hUGJW^d?"V , n_L*dTUO#GJ[:d|iªWd L*d `\GK[:NOkG$
(159) FMLKi?W[Ub G9 : N1L$® D = <>=:` RVD E N¬L*® D = D < ºN1L*® D =:` D ½ D1RVD L$FHGK[:dUiVXp:Omh:FHOoi?WZnVXO$ihUGJW^d?V 5 I abSc pO#TUGJ[:dUiaO$iªO_FXFHGKF&LJbXbc[:Nh:VHW^GJdLKbHbc[N#O$bvVXpUL*V D = [_^ D E G!I ]bcG D = D$E t G!I w GJVHOVHp|L*VGK[:F"GJd:OGJd:^ WdUn[Ui?Oob VXp:OFHO$L$nGJN#hUL$VHW^T:W^WV=#_GKd:O1bcW^dUnOOG$`\O_ FXO$bcVXWN1L$VHO$b WV_Ép:D O#¥\O_D Ah:FHGKD T:6 O_N4W^dD VXp:WZbsL*dUL$bcWjb WjbvVXp:O#iaO_VHO_FXN#Wd|L*VHW^GJdAG* VHpO FXGJVL*VHW^GJdUL$)O_FHFXGJF =:` : ` ( ` °6O#i?O"N#GJdUb=VHFL*VHOWdL$h:hUO_dUi?W^® EQ^uVHp|L*V_] @.
(160) z |[ bcWdITUL$FHnO_daVHFXWZn nG\GJFi?WdUL$VHO$b°. G UHRM . . D=` D E. P y. G!I . .0 < . . . º ½ )WVXp. 00 < [. . 0. ¿aÅU$¿
(161). . . U. . . . 8. . :. . 0 : . y. D1R 8 ( R D D1R . R 0 D.
(162) . 1D R 8 D D1R 8 D 0. . K K R
(163) S
(164) QGJS5G P M I G
(165) G K 3M
(166) /M R
(167) 6R JG I K M S
(168) QG U M 3M M
(169) $ GJS ' (
(170) MS
(171) M K 3M
(172) /M,N6P R
(173) S 5 6 P MWKNQP
(174) R
(175) S POG P M I Q N P R
(176) S R R
(177) G 3M
(178) S 3R P P' R
(179) QGJS MWK G
(180)
(181) QPJS 3M P S KHR M G
(182) G M G P F G R K . G 9 : 3M
(183). . . t G I ºXu < ty. S M M GJSS
(184) M(N M R 3S M)N6P R
(185) S. . .0 < . ½. 00 D1RVD. 5 I abRc : [6 ^ < ` 6 R +. ;< =?>@A) BC! !0:DFEG IHJ
(186) K$ =?' . . %@! K. O_GKN#O_VXFHWZn
(187) pULJb=p:WdI&WZb`\O_FHnG\b=OkVXG&L$WIKd:N#O_daVT:[:VW^V6bcO_hUL$FML$VHO$b
(188) N#Gai?O_ n_L$Zn[:^[Ub FXGJN bHnO_dO&GJd:O$bÃQbXbc[:N#Om6O&pUL_`\OLN#O_VXp:GaiGJFmiaO§Ud:W^d:I1L*d©g[Un^WZi?WjL*dT|LJbcWjb )W^VHp1O$LKnqp#NGai?O_ÃL$dUi1bHnO"d:OQN#W^d:WN1L$UbcO"V_:L*¥aWdILvGJ[:FXVHpNGai?O_UhUGJWdaV_]UL$W^IJd: NO_d?Vlh:FHGJf=OonVMbQWVsWdVHp:O¬bHnO_dO#L$dUiG\GK¥:bvGKF&LAbHnO_dO#hUGJWdaVmVHp:O"FHO ºGJF&L$FHGK[:dUi )pO_dO_FXFHGKFkWjbÈVL*¥\O_dAWdaVHGLJn_nGK[:daV½MU³¡dUb=VHO$LKi ]ÃkO"GJN#O_VXFHWjnkpULJb=p:WdI1nGJNh:[:VHOobWVMb nG\GJFMiaWdUL$VHO$bkW^dVXp:ON#GaiaO_ TULKbcWjbQL*dUi bXL_:b)VHpUL$VmLbHnO_dOhUGJW^d?V )WVXpVHpO$bcO nG\GJFX iaWdUL$VHO$bkW^dVXp:O&bXnO_d:OsTULJb=WZbQn_L$d TUON1L$VMnMp:O$i UkO"dUnO\]:W^d Lh:FXO_h:FXGanO$bHb=Wd:I¬bcVML$IJO\] 6Okf=[Ub=Vkp|Lo`\OmVXG1nGJNh:[:VHOlVHp:O nG\GJFi?WdUL$VHO$b G*
(189) O_`\O"FH#N#GaiaO_ÃhUGJWdaV WdOoLJnMpT|LJbcWjb iaO§Ud:O$iT?LN#GaiaO_:N#W^d:WN1L$:b=O_V)L$dUiW^dUi?O_®&VXpUL*V)TULKbcWjb')WVXp#VHpG\bcOsnG\GKFMi?W^dUL*VXO$b )VFHO$nGKIJd:W^VHW^GJd¶VXWN#O]O+nqpG\G\bcOLbHnO_d:ONWd:W^N1L*6bcO"V_]6nGJN#h[:VHO1VHpO nG\GKFMi?W^ d|L*VHOobvG* O"`\O_FHbXnO_d:OhUGJWdaVW^dVHpO#LKbHbcGanWZL*VXO$iTULJb=WZb&L$dUiLJn"n[:N[:ZL$VHO&VHpFHGJ[IJp VXp:Op|LJbcpÙVL*T:^OO_`aWZiaO_dUnO$bG$6N1L*Vnqp:W^d:IGJFlO_`\O_FH1N#GaiaO_ÃTULJb=WZbó¡d¤LJnV_]UOn_L$d nGJjL*hUb=OO_`\O"FH#N#GaiaO_ÃWdAVHp:O&pULKbcp:VML$T:O] N1L*¥aWdI&VHp:OsFHO$nGKIJd:W^VHW^GJdVXWN#OsL$N#GbcV W^dUi?O_hUO_d|i?O_daVG*2VHpOQd?[NTUO_F
(190) G*2N#Gai?O"Zb)ºÎGKF LN#GJFXOmi?O_VL*W^O$ii?O$bHnFHWhVHWGKd#G*2VHpO L$IKGJFHW^VHp:N bcO_O ;L>J ·K·:] >J xa0u =Ù½M ³¡d GJ[:F n_LJb=O\]£GJF yJÇFHWIKWZi1FHO$nGKIJd:W^VHW^GJdÃ] 6O)W^ LKi:iyiaWN#O_d|bcWGKdUb)Wd VHpO&pULJb=p:ÙVL*T:^OW^dUi?O_®aWdIVXp:O#yLJi:i?W^VHW^GJdUL$'W^d?`KL$FHWZL$d?VbÈGJF VXp:OsnqpG\bcO"dNWd:W^N1L*Ub=O_V_.
(191) A.
(192)
(193)
(194) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(195) $,+"% *.-/
(196) 0 )12
(197) 35463. 1¿ QGPSQGT ~ : P X=$Å
(198)
(199) PRQGP
(200) '"¿Á O6GJ[:jiW^¥\OvVXG§UdUi Li?O§Ud:W^VHW^GJd VHp|L*VQ^O$LJi:b)VHGVHp:ObXL*N#OsVHFML$dUb×GKFHN1L$VHW^GJd LKb )W^VHp#VXp:O O$LKbcV)bXYÁ[|L*FHOob'N#O_VXp:Gai akO_d|nO\]J6OmL*^FHO$LKi?&¥?dG* VXpUL*V)VXp:O GJFHW^IJW^d#N[|bcV TUOQVL*¥\O_dO$YÁ[|L* VXGVXp:OQTUL$FHnO_daVHO_F"|Ê
(201) GKFHGKZL$FH u G*eL*h:hUO_d|i?W® bcp:G$ b[Ub
(202) VHpUL$V VXp:O&OoLJbcVsbXYÁ[UL$FHO$bQFXGJVML$VHW^GJd©bc[:hUO_FXWN#hUG\b=O$bQL$®?O$bQGKFHVHpGJIJGKdUL*6VHG1VHpO&Vc6G1VHFHW^h:O"VMb G$)hUGJW^d?Vbp:O_FXOGJFXO&On_L$dnMp:G\GbcO1L$dL$®?Wjb GKFHVXp:GJIKGJdUL$VHG1VXp:OhZL*dOi?O§Ud:Ooi TaVHp:OAN#WdWNL*)b=O_V_
(203) ÃGi?O§Ud:O L$d g[UnWji?WZL$d¶TULKbcWjb]
(204) O b=VHW^)pUL_`\OVXGnMp:G\GbcO L$d:GJVXp:O_F L$®?WjbWd#VXp:WZb
(205) `\O_FHh:ZL$d:O\]aVHp:OQVXp:WFiGJdOvTUO_W^d:IL*[VHGJN¬L*VHWjn_L*^i?O§Ud:O$i#LKb GKFHVXp:GJIKGJdUL$VHG&VXp:OmGJVHpO_FMbU³×V b=O_O_N1b
(206) i?W 1n[:V6VHGnqp:G\GbcOsbc[|nqpAL*d+L*®aWZb^O$LJi?W^d:I&VHG VXp:OsbHL$N#OQVHFL*dUb¡GJFXN1L*VXWGJd+LJb)W^VHpVXp:OmO$LKbcVX¡bXYÁ[UL$FHO$bNO_VHp:Gai :pa[Ub]UOmnMp:G\GbcO VXp:O N#G\b=V
(207) bcVL*T:^OmL*®aWZbWdVHpO)N#Wd:W^N1L*ab=O_V °\VHp:O GJd:Oli?O§|d:O$i&T?&VXp:OkV=6GvhUGKWdaVMb'G$ N¬L*®aWN1L$Ãi?WjbcVML$dUnOº¡bcO"Ov§UIK[:FHO1D u$½M GAD L_ `\GJWjD iGJFXWO_D daVM L$VHW^D GJdhFHGJD TO_N1b]:O bcGJFXVQVHpO VXp:FHO"OhUGJW^d?Vbº / / o½¦bc[|nqp+LJb ( ( ( pO&i?O§|d:WVXWGJd G$ VXp:OmTULJb=WZb)WZbVXp:O_FHOGJFHO 6)M 2M . . . . . . . .
(208) .
(209) . . . !#"%$'&(". . . . [ . "%$
(210) " "%
(211) "% *)+ #), . . -/.. h ". . .. . 0. . 2. l $l "
(212) " l m0 n. 0213&46570 813&2 9 0:13&4 5 0 813&2 9. -;.=<. ". 813 9 813 9. -;.?>. " .. h 5. .@<?A. \W^dUnO O$Y\[UL$WVXWO$bn_L$d p:GKZi:b#W^d VXp:O GJFXWO_daVML$VHWGKd¨nGJda`\O_d?VXWGKdÃ]'VXp:O_FXOn_L*d TUO b=O_`\O_FL*JhUGbHbcW^T:O
(213) TULKbcO$bJ O_dUnO\]L)IJFXO$L*Vn_L$FHO
(214) pULKb VXGkTUO
(215) VML$¥\O_dmWdmVHp:O2h:FHO_hFHGanO$bXbcW^d:I b=VML$IJO\°aWÃV=6GGJF6O_G`\9O_d&VXp:G!FHO_I Oli?WjbcVML$dUnO$b
(216) TUO_V=O_O_dVHpOkVXp:FHO_O hUGJW^d?VbL*FXOmnGKN#hUL*VXWT:^O ºW¡¢O\JO$Y\[UL*[:h#VHG : t ½M]\GJdOkpULKb'VXp:O_d#VXGvW^dUi?O_®&VXp:Oli?W D O_FXO_d?V2h£GbHb=WT:^OQTULJb=O$b W^VHp1VHpWZbh:FXO$n_L*[VHWGKdÃ]:OmpUL_`\OQdGO_®aVHFL&n_L*FXOmVHG&VML$¥\OsL*V FHO$nGKIJd:W^VHW^GJd1VHW^N#O\ 6)M 2M 6 sÅ
(217) ? PÙG~ P 'RPZM À \ Å Q\¿ PSQ PSQ U :V PÙ Q£\ÅÃÅ£$GÆ PSQ ?$¿a :\¿ > O"V +º / !/ o½)TUO&VXp:OFXGJVL*VHW^GJdN1L*VXFHW^® : ; .1/ 0 / 2W=¤ÃÃGnGJN#h:[VHOVXp:OnG\GJFX iaWdUL$VHO$bkG$ LhUGKWdaV R W^d VHp:O&TULKbcWjbkO&pUL_`\Oi?O§Ud:O$i ]UOQf=[|bcVmpUL_`\OVXGb=GJ^`\OVHpO b=:b=VHO_N : [H< . . CB. ED. . F. GD. IH. JH. KD. . . .
(218) ·. G UHRM . ¡³ d¨VXp:OhFHO_h:FXGanO$bXbcWdI bcVML$IJO\] O©i?O§UdOVXp:OTULKbcWZb#FHGKN VXp:ON#W^d:WNL*lbcO_V º ,$. /(,$0!/V,32½M]IJO"V&VHp:O1GJFXWIKWd [ ]«L$dUiVHp:O1FXGJVML$VHW^GJd ` Ia.b I : º-,$.!/(,$01/(,32½M ¨N#GaiaO_ hUGJW^d?V)NWZbVHpO_d1WdUi?O"®?O$iT?#VXp:OmGan_L$VHW^GJd R : ` I » a. b I -º , ( [ ])½ lbHbc[N#Wd:I&6OpUL_`\Osh£O"FcO$nV N#Gai?O"Zb]:VXp:WZb n_L$d T£OiaGJd:Os)WVHpGJ[:VQO"FHFHGKF_ ÈV FHOonGJ IKd:WVXWGKdVXWN#O]Á6OsbcGJ^`\OQWd#¤LKnV 4º ` ab <B= ` ab ½º R <B= R V½ :45<>=?5 ( [_^ ( = [_^ lbHbc[N#Wd:I©VHp:OFHO$L$mGan_L$VHWGKd¨G* VHp:OhUGJW^d?V 5Wd Wda`KL*FHWjL*daVAbchULKnOWjb#IJW`\O"d T? ` ab R :45 ( [^)L*dUi1[UbcW^d:I&TUL*FX:nO_d?VXFHWjnQnG\GJFi?Wd|L*VHOob]UOk§Ud|i = R : º ` 6 ab ½ » . º = ( =:` a.b R ½ L*¥aWdI#LTUGJ[dUiGJd1WV)6OmpUL_`\O D = RVDE D ` 6 a» b . D º D = D < D =:` ab DJD1RVD ½ 9 dUnOsL$I\L*W^dVXp:OmT£GK[:dUi?OoiO_FHFXGJF LJbXbc[:Nh:VHW^GJd1O_dUb=[:FHO$b)VHp|L*V D = D E t G!I ]UL$dUi b=WdUnO ` 6 ab WZbQLFXGJVL*VHW^GJdÃ] D `v6 a.» b . D :«uJ 9 d VHpO&GJVHpO_FQpUL$dUi ] 6Oi?O_N#GKdUbcVXFML*VXOW^d L$h:hUO_dUi?W^® EQ tVXpUL*V"]:[UbcW^d:ITUL*FX:nO"d?VXFHWZnlnG\GJFi?WdUL$VHO$b° D. . . . . . . . . . . D = ` a b D E. P y. G9I . .0 < . sº ½ )W^VHp. 00 < [. . 0. . y. D1R 8 ( R D D1R . R 0 D.
(219) . y. . ¿aÅU$¿
(220). . . . 8. . . :. . 0 :. tN1L$® 8. U. . D1R 8 ( R D. 6
(221) S
(222) M S
(223) M M$ R M
(224) KHRVP
(225) 6GJI K NQG3M P F R
(226) 6U0GRVG
(227) S P P R
(228) 6GJS M K V# K ) ' KNQG3M P F S
(229) M
(230) QGK(
(231) S G3ITM ) GXNQP R
(232) S,I&P GJS M JG S R
(233) QG KXG G%R M WP)R
(234)
(235) 6P 1 PF. . G :. t. u ty. G9I < $. D1RVD . .0 < . 00 A.
(236)
(237)
(238)
(239) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(240) $,+"% *.-/
(241) 0 )12
(242) 35463. . . x. $ ! DF$ "$ ! @ H\ L $ B @ @%. pOGJFXN[ZL*VXWGKdG*mVXp:O1V=GT£GK[:dUi:bT£O"Wd:I FL*VHpO_F#nGJN#h:^O_® ] hFHWd|nWhUL$^i?[O VXG1VHp:OFHGKVML*VXWGKdUL*
(243) hUL$FHV_]ÃW^VvWjbkWdaVHO"FHO$b=VHWdI#VHG1¥ad:G$Ç)pUL*VmVHpO_ FHO$L$^NO$L*dÃ] W¡ O )p|L*VAL*FXO VHp:OAIJO_GKN#O_VHFXWZn#hUL$FML*NO_VHO_Fb{W^N#h:^WZn_L$VHO$i ]2L*dUi [:h VXG)pUL*V1`KL*^[:O$bG$ VXp:G\b=OhUL$FML$N#O_VHO"FMbOsn_L$d1¥\O_O_hAL{IKG\Gai nGJda§ i?O_dUnO\Up:WZb))W^ p:O"h1[Ub nqp:G\GbcW^d:I VXp:O&N#W^d:WN1L$Ãb=O_VQTa nGKd?§UFHNWd:I#pO_[:FHWjbcVXWZn_b)GJFmGJdVHpOnGJdaVHFL*FHiaWZbHn"L*FMiaWd:I1nO_FH VL*W^dN#W^d:WNL*b=O_VMblLJbmi?O_IKO_d:O_FL*VHOoi TUO$n_L$[UbcOG*6VXp:OO"FHFHGKF_ÃÇb=O$nGKdUi W^N#hUGJFXVML*daV Y\[:O$b=VHW^GJd#Wjbp:G$ jL*FHIKOmGJF)VHW^IJpaVGK[:F)TUGJ[:dUibQL*FXO\]:L$dUi#p:G$ FXO_h:FHOobcO_daVML$VHW`\O G*2VHpO N¬L*®aWN1L$?O_FXFHGKFVHpO_L*FXO\6 C:GJF6VHp:OlbHL$¥\OQG*2b=WN#hWZnWV¡\]$O )W^UGJd:^TUOmnGKdUnO_FXd:O$i )W^VHp1VHpOvFXGJVL*VHW^GJdUL$O"FHFHGKF_ 6)M 2M } Q 'ZÀ PÙ&WÅ X_X=ÅU
(244) 'Ù &W QÆ ÆÅ
(245) W PSQ´WÅ X U 'SP'Æ PZMÀ > O"V&º R . / R 01/ R 2_½TUO&VXp:O&N#Gai?O_ÃT|LJbcWjbºÙNWd:W^N1L* bcO"V½)W^dTUL$FHnO_daVHFHWjnkFML*NO\Up:WZb VXFHW^h:O_V
(246) GJFXN1bL&VHFXWZL*dIJOm)p:GbcO nqpUL$FMLKnVHO_FXWZb=VHWZn"bL*FXOº¡L*NWZi:b=VGJVXp:O_Fbq½ . IB. . . M 3 R M SM. D1R 8 ( R D . D R . ( R 0 R . ( R 2 D : 2 1D R . R 0 D. H: 0 0 H. :. 8. . º q½ £º ½ > O"V T£OmVXp:OmFMLJiaW[Ub)G*2VHp:OmTULKbcWjbÈW^dUbHnFXWTUO$i1nW^FMn^O\\Osn_L$db=O_OmVHpUL$Vº ;LEO_FxJt0=Ù½ . : t : u ²GKFHO_G$`\O_F"]?VXp:Osi?O§Ud:W^VHW^GJd#G$ vW^N#h:W^O$bVHpUL$V D1R 8 D L*dUi#p:O_d|nO 0 : º f D1R 8 D ½ º f D1R 8 D 0 ½ . WN#W^ZL*FX\]"bcW^dUnO D1R 8 ( R D t \]\O)IKO_V 0 : y º¡tmN1L*® D1R 8 ( R D ½ .aL*¥aWd:I VXp:WZbW^d?VXGLJn_nGJ[:daV_]:6Ob=pUL*^ÃG$`\O_FHO$b=VHW^N1L*VXO)VHp:OmFHGKVML$VHWGKdUL*O_FXFHGJF)Ta D =:` D P T t G9I y L$dUi#p:O_dUnOQVHp:OlFML*VXWGKd G!I n"L*d1TUOmnGJd|bcWZiaO_FHO$iLJbVHpOQh:FHOonWZb=WGJdG*2VHp:OQFXGJVL*VHW^GJdà p:O"FHOGKFHO\] 6O¥ad:G$ VXG9pUI L*V . WjbQVHp:Oi?GJNWdUL$VHWdI#VHO_FXN ] L*dUiVXp:O`JL$Wji?WV=G$ VXp:O)GJFHN[:jLJbWjb'IJW^`\O_d&Ta ÁkG$O_`\O"F_]$WV
(247) WZb[:dUnO$L$F')pO_VHp:O"F .6i?GJN#W^dUL*VXO$b b=VHFXGJd:IK1GJF d:GJV"£Osi?FML_¨W^dR §UIKR[:FHOstVXp:WZbO"FHFHGKFk)W^VHp1VHpO&nGKd?`\O_daVHW^GJd#VXpUL*V VHpO Ooi?IJO6G*UN1L$®?W^N[N O_d:IKVHpsWZbº .!/ 0M½M$O¦L*Zb=GkVL*¥\O6VHp:Wjb ^O_d:IJVXpvGKF[:dWVN#O$LJb=[:FHO O_dUnO\]UVHpO&O_FHFXGJFmWZbQiaFML_)dW^d )¤L*®aWZbQWd[:d|nVHW^GJdG*6VHp:OhUG\b=WVHW^GJdG*¦VHp:O&VXp:WFi . TFHG3M. . .
(248) .
(249) . H. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(250) u"¸. G UHRM . . ".. 14. 12. 10. 8. R. 6. -0.4 -0.2 y. 0 0.2 0.4. . 0.7. 0.8. 0.6. 0.4. 0.5. 0.3. 0.2. "0 2. x. "%$' 463
(251) J
(252) J"% " 3
(253) * >. . l "%
(254) " l m J"%
(255) 0 n. Uh GKWdaV R 2'W^dUbcWji?O)L$d&O$Y\[:WjL*VHO"FML*aVHFXWZL$d:IJ^O\*O i?Gmd:GKVh:FHOobcO_daVVHpOVHGKVML$£O"FHFHGKF
(256) bcW^dUnO GKFTUGJVXpN#O"VHp:Gai:bVHp:O)IKFML*hp:WZn_b2L*FHOlbcW^N#WjL*F
(257) °KLJb
(258) LQFHO$b=[:V"] 0GJdmhUO_FcGKFHN«Lk`\O_FX b=N1L*^ `\O_FXVHWjn_L* bcpWV_ ¨b=O$nGKdUi#h£GKWdaV)WZbVXpUL*V)VXp:OmTULJb=WZb)i?O§|d:WVXWGJdN#O_VHpGai#L*h:hUO$L$FMb)VHG&TUOsbc^WIJpaVH^ TUO_VXVHO_F6VHpUL$dVXp:OQOoLJbcV bXYÁ[|L*FHOobGJd:O\QnVX[UL*^\]\VHpWZbpULKbVHG&TUOmN#Gai?O_FL*VHOoiT?VHpO `\O"FHbcN1L$ FXO_ZL$VHW^`\OQi?&W D O_FHO_d|nOmbcpG*)dAT?§UIJ[:FXOsy? . 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02. -0.4 -0.2 y. 0 0.2 0.4. . 0.8. 0.7. 0.6. 0.5. 0.4. 0.3. 0.2. x. "%$ ' #m& "3 V+
(259) ) * V+ l * 0 n. . ÃLKbcVT[:V#d:GKV^O$LJb=V_]VXp:O N#W^d:WN[:N O_FHFXGJF#Wjb¬GKT:VML$Wd:OoiªGJF1VHp:O OoYÁ[:W^ZL$VHO_FL* VXFHWjL*d:IKO\]\)p:Wjnqp1b=O_O_N1bFL*VHpO_F)nGKp:O_FXO_d?V"akO_dUnO O n_L*dAnGKdUn[|i?OkVXp:O$b=OQV=GNO_ VXp:Gai:b L*FXOQN#GJFXOQGJF)^O$bHb
(260) O$Y\[:W`KL*^O_daV_]\VHp:Olh:FHW^dUnWh|L*UhUL*FL*N#O"VHO_F6G*2VHp:OQO"FHFHGKF)TUO_Wd:I u )p:O"FHO WZbVXp:OmFMLJiaW[UbG$
(261) VHp:OmTULKbcWjbÈW^dUbHnFXWTUO$i#nWFMnO\ >. . .
(262)
(263)
(264)
(265) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(266) $,+"% *.-/
(267) 0 )12
(268) 35463. uKu. } \( $ :JÀ´ÅWXk U¿A~'Å GQÆ1
(269) $ ?VPVP\ '
(270) ÆÃÀ ÃGTUO#hFMLJnVHWZn"L*¡]Ã6Od:O"O$i VXG¥ad:G$ÇVHp:OLJn"n[:FMLKnG* GJ[FTUGJ[:d|i:b
(271) p:OL*W^N-G$ VXp:WZbsbcVX[Ui?WjbvVHGnMpUL$FMLJnVHO_FXW_OVHp:O1FXO$L*¦i?WZb=VHFHW^T:[:VXWGJd©G*lO_FHFXGJFFXO_ZL$VHW^`\O_AVHG VHpO hFHO$i?WjnVHOoi TUGK[:dUi p:O_FXOGJFXO\]
(272) Op|Lo`\OAVHGb=O_hUL$FML*VXO VHp:O+i?W D O_FXO_daVhUL$FML$N#O_VHO"FMb W^d?VXG1Vc6GAnZLKbHbcOob{°ÃVXp:G\b=O#)p:WZnMp2L D O$nVVHpOh:FXO$i?WjnVHO$iTUGK[:dUi ]2L*dUiVXp:G\b=O#)p:Wjnqp iaGd:GKV_]:[:hUGKd)p:Wjnqp1Om)W^ÃnGJN#h:[VHOQGK[:F i?WZb=VHFXWT:[:VXWGKdG$
(273) O_FXFHGJF" Ê
(274) ^O$L*FX\]\VHpOnGJN#h:[VHO$i&TUGJ[:dUi D =:` D GJF D = ` ab D GJd:^#i?O"h£O"dUi:bGJdAVHp:Olh£GbcW^ VXWGKdG$)VHpO&N#Gai?O_T|LJbcWjbmL*dUiVXp:O&O_FXFHGJFmTUGJ[dUi R G!I 9 VHp:O"FQhUL*FL*N#O"VHO_Fb]Ãb=[UnqpLKb VXp:OO"FHFHGKFkGKd VHp:OsTULJb=WZbkhUGKWdaVMb)GJFQVXp:OhUG\b=WVXWGJd G$6VHp:Osh£GKWdaVkVXG#TUOh:FXGanO$bXbcO$i ] TUO_^GJd:IVHGVHpOb=O$nGKdUinjLJbXbUQnVXI [UL*^\]aOsL*FXOW^d?VXO_FHO$b=VHO$iWd1VHp:Osi?WjbcVXFHWT[:VHW^GJdG$ D = ` RSD GKFLk§U®aO$ihUL$WF ºÙT|LJbcWjb] G ½]JT:[:V6bcW^dUnO)VXp:WZbWZbWdO$L*FW^d D1RVD ]JO n_L$d{Gan[Ub GKd D = ` RVD D1RVD O)VHp:O"FHOGKFHO)nMp:G\GbcO P\¸J¸QFL*dUi?GKNÇhUL*W^FMbºTULJb=WZb] G I ½M]KLJbXbc[:N#W^d:IQGKd:sVHpUL$V G I u_¸ VHG L_`\GKWZii?O"IJO_d:O"FML*VXO$iTULKbcO$b C:GJFsO$LJnMphUL$WF"]OnGKN#h:[:VXOVXp:O#h:FXO$i?WZnVHO$i TUGK[:dUi D = ` D )p:Wjnqp¬LJnVbkLKbÈVXp:OsL*TUbXnWZbXbHL&GJdGK[:F IJFML$h:pà p:O_d1Osi?WjbcVX[:FHTu_¸K¸J¸ VXWN#OobkVHp:OTULKbcWZb)W^VHp©L[:dWGJFXN-FL*dUiaGJN O_FHFXGJFTUGK[:dUi?O$iT? G!I GJd©O$LJnMpT|LJbcWjb hUGKWdaV#L$dUi GKFO$LKR nqp i?WZb=VH[:FXTUL*d|nO1O nGJN#h:[VHO#VXp:OO_FXFHGKF D =:` RVD D1RVD GJF ¸K¸ FL*dUiaGJN hUGKWdaVMb ºÙ[:dWGJFXN jLoQ½'O VHpa[UbGKT:VML$Wd LhUGJh:[ZL*VXWGKd G* ¸J¸¸J¸K¸ `KL$[:O$b G*6VHp:OsFHGKVML*VXWGKdUL*O"FHFHGKFmL*d|iO&nMp:G\GbcO&VHG¬nqpUL$FMLKnVHO_FXW_OmVXp:WZbkhUGKh:[:ZL$VHW^GJd TaWVb{N#OoL*d´L*dUi¶N¬L*®aWN[:N4`KL*[O$b6p:O$b=O`KL*^[:O$bL*FHO VXp:OGKFMi?W^dUL*VXO$b&GJd VHpO IKFML$h:pà U¿ '¿? : *¿a
(275) ª¿\V UÅÃÆ p:O'§UFbcVGJTUb=O_FH`KL$VHWGKd&GJdsVHp:O
(276) IJFL*h:p&hGJVXVHO$imWdQ§UIK[:FHO6PQWZb VXp:O)nGKN#hULKnVHd:OobHb G*VHpOkN#OoL*d&O_FXFHGJF¦i?WZb=VHFXWT:[:VXWGKd#L$FHGJ[dUi1L ^Wd:O?Ê
(277) GJN#h[:VHW^d:ImVHp:OQFXO_IJFXO$bHb=WGKd WdO\]?6OQIJGKV N#OoL*d#O_FXFHGKF : h:FXO$i?WZnu_VHy O$: it O"FHFHGKF Qb¦¤L$FmLJbQVXp:ON1L$®?W^N[NÇO_FHFXGJFQWjbQnGJd|nO_FHdO$i ]:)p:WjnqpAWZbQLKnVH[UL$^)p|L*VQ6O O_FXO&VHO_N#hVHWdI&VHG1TUGJ[:dUi ]O&GKTUbcO"FH`\O&L1b=hUL*FbcOi?WZb=VHFHW^T:[:VXWGJdÉ VHp:WjbQbcO"O_N1b FML*VXp:O_FmdUL$VH[:FL*6bcW^dUnO&VHpO&N1L*®aWN[:N«G* L#hUGJh[:ZL$VHWGKdWZb d:GJVm`\O_FXb=VML$T:O\ Ê6L*^Wd:I G% VXp:WZb)b=VML*VXWZb=VHWZnK]:OsbcpUL$Ãp:G$6O_`\O_FdGJVHOmVXpUL*V N1L*® Ia.bSc E N¬L*® E N1L*® I abRc t : V U¿A~ PÙÂMÆ¿ Q'PZV P Å Q
(278) ¿Á UÅÃÆ p:O)IJFL*h:p&WjbbcGmb=WN#W^ZL$FÃVHGQVXp:O)O$LKbcV2bHY\[UL*FXO$bGJd:O)VXpUL*V2WVWZb`aWFXVH[UL$lWdUi?Wjbc VHWdIJ[:WjbcpUL$T:O\ p:OsGJd:^iaW D O_FHO"dUnOm)p:WZnMp n"L*dTUO&d:GKVHO$i1WZbkVXp:OFXO_IJFXO$bHb=WGKd 6)M2M 6. . . . . . . . . .
(279) u"t. G UHRM . Mean and Max error Vs Predicted error. 0.5 y=x/2. 0.4. Maximum Error. 0.3 y 0.2 Mean Error. 0.1 00. 0.2. 0.4. x. 0.6. 1. 0.8. " $3 '
(280)
(281) J@l " l,Vl 3 0"& 3
(282) +" * * m% 3 Gl *2 . . WdOQGJdAN#O$L*dO_FHFXGJFm°. #N OoL*d#O_FXFHGKF : h:FXO$i?WZnu_VHt O$: ix O"FHFHGKF p:WjbmbcVML$VHWjbcVHWjn_L*ebcVH[|i? VHp:O"FHOGKFHO&LKnqpWO_`\O$b)VHGAnGKd?`aWd|nWd:IVHpUL$VvVXp:O&V=G#NO_ VXp:Gai:bAL*FHOO$Y\[:W`KL$O_daV_
(283) ²GKFHO_G$`\O_F"]'W^V#h:FHG$`\O$b#VXpUL*V1GJ[FTUGK[:dUi:bAL*FHO©Y\[:WVXOO" b=[:WVXO$i . 2 G$ %WI $H7 B @ @%. @ h¶VHGp:O_FXO\]O+i?O_`\O_^GJhUO$iL N#O_VHpGai )pWZnMp L_`\GJWji:bL$¤L$ZbcOAd:O_IL*VHW^`\O$b
(284) pO N¬L*f=GJF i?FML_)TULKnq¥G*lVML$¥?W^d:I©L TUGJ[dUiªGKd¶VHpOO_FXFHGJF&W^d?VXGLJn_nGJ[:daV&WZb&VHp:O1FL*h:Wji IKFHG$)VHp G$6VHp:Om¤L*Zb=OhUG\b=WVXW`\O$b)W^VHp VHpO&bcW^_OmG*6VHpOO_FXFHGJF _GKd:O\ VHFLJi?O"ÙG DpULKb VXp:O_d1VHG&TUOmFHOoL*W^_O$iTUO_V=6O_O_d#VXp:OmVc6G&O_®aVHFHO"N#O$bp:OsbcVML$VHWjbcVHWjn_bG*ebcOonVHW^GJdAt?¢P: t b=[:IJIKO$bcV)VXpUL*V6VHp:OlO_FHFXGJFjL_¶WZb
(285) W^d:O$L*F
(286) )W^VHp#FXO$bchUO$nV6VHGsVHp:OQhFHO$i?WjnVHOoiT£GK[:dUi UpO Wji?O$LkWjbVHpO_d&VHGQ[|bcOlL*dLJi$f=[UbcVXN#O_daVnG\O 1nW^O_daVGKd&VHp:O)h:FXO$i?WjnVHO$imTUGJ[:dUi ?³¡d&GKFMi?O_F VXGmi?GmVHp|L*V_]KO i?FLoW^d§UIJ[:FXO L*dL*TULKn[UbWdUiaWZn_L$VHWdIkVXp:O)FML$VHO)G* hUGJW^d?VbGJ[:VbcWZiaO VXp:OO"FHFHGKFk"GJd:OsLJblL [:d|nVHW^GJdG$
(287) VHpO&LJi$f=[UbcVXN#O_daV)nG\O ¬nW^O_d?V":³ÙGKFkW^dUbcVL*dUnOm6O L$FHO&^G\GJ¥aWd:I#GJF L¬FXO$nGKIJd:W^VHWGKd )WVXp ¸Á¹G*¦VHp:O&N#GaiaO_hUGKWdaVMb] O&n"L*d©L*^G$ u hUGKWdaV[:hUGJd u_¸J¸VXGTUO =GJFHIKGJVXVHO_d ºO$LKi?WdIVXG L1P\xÁ¹ FHOonGJIKd:WVXWGJd ½mL*d|iVHp:O"d VXp?[|b)i?W`aWZi?OlVHp:OmFMLKi?W[|bÈG$GK[:FkO"FHFHGKF)_GJdOvTa§U`\O . . ". $.
(288)
(289)
(290)
(291) !#"%$"&(') * "%
(292) $,+"% *.-/
(293) 0 )12
(294) 35463. u"y. Ratio of the number of excluded points 1.. 0.1. 0.01. 0.001. 0.0001. 1e-05 Adjustment coefficient on the predicted error 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. " $3 ' "% *
(295) 0Vl(J 3"
(296) 0 Zm0"
(297) $ "&0
(298) ,3 3
(299) +"%$*0 W(, * 5 H "%
(300) 0 "
(301) " n
(302) * "% "& m "W "%
(303) $
(304)
(305)
(306) 0 l
(307) ,2"
(308) J J "
(309)
(310) J"%
(311) 0 J 0"% J
(312) n . . 2 '
(313) ¯$ '(+ 6 +¬$2 ¡³ dVHp:O)hFHO_`aWGK[Ub
(314) bcO$nVXWGKdÃ]JOGan[UbcO$iGJdT:[:Wji?WdIQO_FHFXGJF
(315) _GKd:O$bGJF6L*^WIKd:N#O_daVL$dUi IKO_GJNO_VHFXWZnpULKbcp:W^d:I:]^O$LJi?W^d:IVXGnGJFXFHO$nVHd:O$bXb°Ã[Ub=Wd:I VXp:G\b=O1nGJNhUL*VXWT:W^WV=1_GKd:O$b] 6O&L$FHOnO_FXVML$WdVXG#L_`\GKWZi¬¤L$Zb=O&d:O_I\L$VHW^`\O$b E[:V VHpOYÁ[:OobcVHW^GJdAWZb)d:G$ pG* FXGJT:[Ub=V b=[UnMp#N#O_VXp:Gai:bL$FHO\aOl)W [UbcO GJF)VHpWZbb=O$nVXWGJdVHp:OQ^O$LJb=V bHY\[UL*FXO$bN#O_VXp:Gai ]\T:[:V p|Lo`aWdIb=p:G$)dVXpUL*V
(316) VXp:OkT|LJbcWjb
(317) i?O§Ud:W^VHW^GJd&N#O_VXp:GaiWZbO$Y\[:W^`JL$O_daV_]$VHpO L*dUL$bcWZb)W^ L$Zb=Gp:GKZi:b'GKFkW^V_ p:O L*W^NG*
(318) VXp:WZbh|L*FHV WZbVXp:O&L$dUL*^:b=WZbG$
(319) VHp:O L*^IJGJFXWVXp:N1b'VXG#iaO_VHO_FXN#WdOk)pUL$V WjbÈVXp:Omh:FHGKTUL*TWW^V=#G*
(320) FXO$nGKIJd:W^_Wd:IL&N#Gai?O"ÃWdALFML$dUi?GKN/bXnO_d:OU³×d#¤LKnV_]?GKFkGK[:F L$h:h:^WZn_L$VHWGKdUb]UO&)W^GJd:^1T£OnGJdUnO"FHd:O$i)W^VHp VXp:O&L$WIKd:N#O_daV bHnMp:O_NOvTUO$n"L*[Ub=O W^V))W^ÃL*hh£OoL*FQVXGTUOVXp:OmTUO$bcV VHFLJi?O_G DTUO_V=6O_O_dAnGJNh:O_®aWV=sWd1VHW^N#OmL*d|inGKN# hO_®aWV= WdN#O"N#GJFX\ó¡d´L+§UFbcVbcVXO_hÃ]O1)W^)L$dUL*^?"OVXp:O1h:FHOoi?WZnVXWGKd¶b=VML$IJOG$ VXp:OAL*^IJGJFXWVXp:N L*d|iªb=p:G$VHp|L*V&WVn"L*dTUO`\O"FHh£G$6O_Fc[:¤p:OAL$dUL*^:b=WZbG*lVHpO `\O"FHW§£n_L*VXWGJdAb=VML*IKO)W^VHp:O"d L*^G$ [UbkVXG1nGJd|n[UiaOGJd VXp:O&O_®ahUO$nVHOoida[:NTUO_F)G$ ¤L$Zb=OvhUGbcWVXW`\O$bQºZ¤L*jbcOmFHO$nGJIJdWVHW^GJdUbM½M]L*dUi1GJdVXp:OmWdUia[UnO$i1nGKdUbcO$Y\[:O_d|nO$b C:GJF VHpOL$dUL*^:b=WZb]:OsnGJd|bcWZiaO_F LnGJ^O$nVXWGJdG* N#Gai?O"Zb'G$Q ,µhUGKWdaVMb)O$LJnMpÃ] L$dUiLQbHnO"d:O)G* hUGJW^d?VbJO LJbXbc[:NO)LQ[:d:W GJFHN5i?WjbcVXFHWT[:VHW^GJd&G* VXp:O bHnO"d:O)hUGJWdaVMb G$`\O_F6VHp:OlWN1L$IJO\]aL*d|iL*jbcGL[:dWGJFXN¯i?WjbcVHFXWT:[VHWGKd#G*2VHpOvNGai?O_ hUGKWdaVMbQ C:GJF)VHpO bXL*¥\OmG*ebcW^N#h:^WZnW^Vc]*6Ov)W^Én_L*^ TULKbcWZb ULN#WdWN1L$UbcO_V".
(321) uP. G UHRM . ?%Y K$ 2M M U \U GU PSQGT VU
(322) . . ¿ : _ ¿ ¿ EOGJFHOmN1L$h:h:W^d:IVXp:ONGai?O_ÃGJdaVHGVHp:O bHnO_dO\]:OspUL_`\OvVXG#h:FXO$i?WZnV)VHp:OsN1L*Vnqp:W^d:I TUO_V=6O_O_dsLÈNGai?O_\L$dUiL bHnO_d:O
(323) TULJb=WZb*O6bHL_VHp|L*VWdmGJ[:F2n_LKbcOVXp:WZb WjbnGJdUb=VHFML$Wd:Ooi Ta VHp:FXO_O6LJi:i?W^VHW^GJdUL$\Wda`JL$FHWjL*daVMb])p:WZnMpQ6O
(324) nqpG\bcO
(325) VXG)T£O
(326) VXp:O
(327) WdaVHO_FXÙhUGJW^d?VÉi?WZb=VML$dUnOW^d VXp:O
(328) TULJb=WZb* W^VHpVXp:O
(329) GJFXWO_daVML$VHWGKdsnGJda`\O_daVHWGKdmG* b=O$nVHW^GJdst? y?^uJ]_VHpOVHpFHO_O6i?WjbcVML$dUnO$b L$FHOGJFi?O_FHOoi bc[UnMp VXpUL*V . 0 0_¦Qb#Wd VHpOTULKbcWjbiaO§Ud:W^VHWGKd N#O_VXp:Gai ] VXp:O[:d:WZY\[:O_dO$bHbQG*¦VHp:WjbQGJFHW^O_daVML*VXWGKdb=h:W^VMbQWdaVHGAbcO"`\O_FML$
(330) n_LJb=O$b&º¡LAbcN1L$da[:NT£O"F pG*6O_`\O_F½W2V=G&GKF)O_`\O_d#VXp:FHO_Osi?WjbcVL*dUnOob)L*FHO nGJNhUL*VXWT:^O\ > O_ V : º ,$. /(,$0 / , 2_½2TUOmLvN#GaiaO_UTULJb=WZbL$dUi !. : º .!/0!/ ?2_½W^VMb'`\OonVHGKF'G$ W^d?`KL$FHWZL$d?VbU bHnO_d:OT|LJbcWjb 4:5-º 5 .!/(5 0 /(5!2_½6)WVXp`\OonVHGKF)G*
(331) W^d?`KL*FXWZL$d?V b !0)WZb nGKN# h|L*VHW^T:O))W^VH p W D !0 ( . D O EAG 9 : t G!I \ÃGvVL*¥\O LKi?`KL*daVML*IKOQG*ÉVHp:O LKi:i?W^VHWGKdUL* W^d?`KL$FHWZL$d?Vb]J6O)T:[:W^ZiWdLQh:FHO"h:FHGanOobHbcW^d:IsbcVL*IJOlLQpULJb=p#VML$T:O)W^dUi?O_®aWdIQO_`\O_FXhUG\b= b=WT:^OmN#Gai?O_ÃTU] LKbcWjb¦FXGJN¯WVbÈ`\O$nVHGJF)G$
(332) Wda`KL*FXWZL*daVMb L*d|iVHpO&LJbXbcGanWjL*VXO$iO_FHFXGJF _GJdO ºVHp:O"FHO1L$FH O
(333) b=[UnMpTULJb=O$bq½)Vh:FXO$i?WjnVHW^GJdVXWN#O\]UOsf=[UbcV&pUL_`\O#VXG nMp:G\G\b=OAL*d W^N1L*IKO)TULJb=WZb6L*2dU iFXO_VHFXWO_`\O6VHp:FXGJ[:IKp1VHp:O pULJb=p#VML$T:O VHpOQnGKN#hUL$VHWTO)N#Gai?O":TULJb=O$b° 6Omi?W^FHO$nVX&pUL_`\O VHp:Olp?ahUGJVHpO$bcO$bVXG&TUOQ`KL*Wji:L*VXO$iW^d#VHp:Ol`\O_FHW § n_L*VXWGKd1bcVL*IJO?O L$FHOQdG*¶Gan[UbcW^d:IGKd#VHp:OlL_`\O_FML$IJO d?[NTUO_FG$N#Gai?O_TULJb=O$b)nGJNhUL*VXWT:^O)WVXp#GJdO W^N1L*IKOQTULKbcWZb]UL*dUi1VHp:OsL_`\O_FL*IJOmda[:NT£O"F'G$
(334) pa?hUGJVXp:O$b=O$bVHGTUOv`\O"FHW§|O$i 2M M 6 Q$$ÅU} Q 'ZÀ P C:GKFQVHp:O bHL$¥\OG*¦b=WN#h:^WZnW^V=\]\O_V VHp:O i?WNO_dUbcW^GJd1G*6VXp:ON#GaiaO_L$dUi bHnO_d:OW^N1L*IKO$b TUO&u 1 u 1u L*d|i¬^O_V TUOQVXp:OmbHn"L*O)¤LJnVHGJF"a Gi?O"VHO_FXN#Wd:O6VHp:O O_®ahUO$nVHOoi{da[:NT£O"F G$NGai?O_UTULJb=O$b nGJN#h|L*VHW^T:O))W^VHpALFML$dUi?GKN¯bHnO"d:OQTULKbcWZb]:OQ§UFbcVdO_O$i#VHG&¥ad:G$ VXp:OO_®?hUO$nVHO$i KN M G G$ L$dO_daVHFH] )p:WZnMp WZbQVXp:ONO$L*d h:FXGJTUL$T:W^WV=G$ WdUiaO_®?W^d:I GKd:OmN#Gai?O_ N#WdWN1L$UbcO_V" & ¿aW Q $¿? Æ > O_ V :º Á½6TUOVHpOh:FXGJTUL$T:W^WV=Ai?O_dUb=WV=#G*¦L&`\O$nVXGJF G*
Documents relatifs
loppé, tandis que le kilométrage des lignes ferroviaires ouvertes au trafic fret se réduisait, ainsi, et beaucoup plus fortement encore, que le nombre de points d'accès (gares et
A partir des mêmes données de l’ OCDE , en appliquant la même spécification aux biens et aux services, Ceglowski [2006] obtient des coefficients plus élevés pour le PIB dans
Le document du MOFCOM précise ici le rôle de l’ACGP (planification préliminaire et coordination des grands projets guinéens ; contrôle de la qualité des projets) puis présente
antennal segment, body length of about 2–3 mm, uniformly dark brown scutellum, one pair of strong prescutellar setae, left ventral epandrial lobe with a row of about 18 teeth on
Dans le cadre de ce travail, l'analogie est d'ordre méthodologique : par « comme si », nous indiquons que nous avons soumis des programmes informatiques à des méthodes d'analyses
Ces métadiscours ainsi définis comme ayant pour seuls objets les codes linguistiques et leurs fonctionnements, leurs représentations aussi, souvent en termes de normes sociales,
La démarche de la présente étude a consisté, à partir de l’observation d’une même syllabe dans divers contextes, à relever les variations de quatre paramètres
Compte tenu de leurs spécificités, les entreprises publiques et celles qui relèvent du secteur de l’économie sociale et solidaire constituent un terrain idéal
