Original article
Location of genes in Apis mellifera scutellata-derived mitochondrial DNA of Africanized honey bees
MC Arias FG Nobrega
1 Universidade de São
Paulo,
Faculdade de Medicina de RibeirãoPreto, Departamento
deGenética,
14049 RibeirãoPreto,
SãoPaulo;
2Universidade de Sâo
Paulo,
Instituto deBiociências, Departamento
deBiologia,
Caixa Postal 11461, 05499 São
Paulo, SP,
Brazil(Received
21August
1988;accepted
25 November1991)
Summary —
The mitochondrial DNA of Africanizedhoney
beeshaving
a mtDNAhaplotype
knownfrom the African
subspecies Apis
melliferascutellata,
wasanalysed
for the location of 6 mitochondri- al genesby hybridization
to mitochondrial geneprobes
fromSaccharomyces
cerevisiae. Genes for the small andlarge
ribosomalRNAs, cytochrome
oxidase subunitsI,
II and III andapocytochrome
bwere
positioned
relative to the mitochondrial DNAfragments generated
with 6 different restriction en-donucleases utilized
singly
or in combination. Results show that these genes are in the same rela- tivepositions
asDrosophila
genes.Africanized
honey
bee / mitochondrial gene / genemapping
/ restriction endonuclease / mo- lecularhybridization
INTRODUCTION
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)
hasrecently
been
the focus
of anumber of molecular, genetic and evolutionary studies (Wilson
et
al, 1985; Tzagoloff and Myers, 1986;
Avise et
al, 1987; Moritz
etal, 1987).
Inmulticellular animals, mtDNA
is a circularmolecule
ofapproximately
16 kbcarrying
a set
of highly
conservedgenes through-
out
the species and phyla studied
so far(Wilson et al, 1985). The complete deter-
mination of nucleotide sequences
ofmtDNA
in man(Anderson
etal, 1981),
mice (Bibb
etal, 1981), cattle (Anderson
et
al, 1982), Xenopus (Roe
etal, 1985) and Drosophila yakuba (Clary and Wol- stenholme, 1984) revealed genes for
2ri- bosomal RNAs,
22tRNAs,
3subunits of cytochrome oxidase,
2subunits
ofATPase, apocytochrome
b and 7coding regions
for differentsubunits
ofthe NADH
dehydrogenase (Mariottini et al, 1986).
*
Correspondence
andreprints
Abbreviations: mitochondrial gene abbreviations are
explained
in thelegend
tofigure
3.These studies showed conservation of gene
content butrevealed
adistinct gene
orderamong phyla and
differenttRNA
po-sitions (Clary and Wolstenholme, 1985;
Dubin et
al, 1986).
Partialsequencing
work
inhoney bee mtDNA has been
com-pleted by Crozier
etal (1989), encompass-
ing the COI and COII genes.
Here we re-port
on the location of 6mitochondrial genes
in thehoney bee determined by
het-erologous hybridization
withmtDNA
geneprobes from Saccharomyces cerevisiae.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Samples
of ≈ 300white-eyed
pupae, 11days old,
were collected from 2 Africanized colonieskept
at the Laboratório deAbelhas, Depto
deEcologia Geral, USP,
Såo Paulo. Mitochondrial DNA was isolated frompurified organelles
ac-cording
to theprocedure
of Moritz et al(1986).
Restriction enzyme
digestion,
agarosegel electrophoresis,
Southern transfer of DNAfrag-
ments to
Hybond-N
filters(Amersham),
prepara- tion of nick-translated radioactive DNAprobes
and
hybridization
conditions were as described in Sambrook et al(1989).
Mitochondrial DNA fromyeast petite
mutants wasprepared
asdescribed
by Nobrega
andNobrega (1986).
The
yeast petite
strains used are described in table I.Hybridization
withheterologous yeast probes
was
performed overnight
in 6 xSSC,
0.1% Sar-osyl,
50μg/ml
denatured carrier DNA at 40 °C.The filters were
initially
washed in 2 xSSC,
0.1 %
Sarkosyl
at roomtemperature prior
to au-toradiography.
After the first exposure the filterswere washed in more
stringent
conditionsby
in-cubation
in the
wash solution for 1 h at 45, 50, 55 or 60 °C withautoradiography
after each wash to determine the location of the DNA bands mosthomologous
to theprobe
utilized.Rehybridization
of filters to newprobes
wascarried out after removal of the radioactive
probe by
incubation at 45 °C for 15 min in 0.4 N NaOH followedby
washes in 2 x SSC. The fil-ters were
exposed
toX-ray
film to ensure com-plete
removal of label before re-use.RESULTS
ANDDISCUSSION
Single
and doubledigestions
used forhy-
bridization studies
areshown
infigure
1and table
IIand results of
atypical hybridi-
zation experiment
areshown in figure
2.Hybridizations clearly indicated gene posi-
tion except for the COIII gene. In this
case(fig 2,
lanes 9 and10),
there is astrong
la-beling of the
second EcoRImtDNA
band(3
950bp) but there
isalways
aweaker la- beling of the first (9
400bp) and third (3 200 bp) band
as well.This result
was notimproved
withthe
increasedstringen-
cy. We decided to
place COIII
at the firstEcoRI
fragment (9
400bp)
due to resultsof double digest with EcoRI
andClaI that
split the
secondEcoRI fragment (3 950 bp) (Arias et al, 1990). Autoradiography
of thisdigest
afterhybridization
withCOIII probe
showed strong signal
at the first EcoRIfragment (9
400bp),
nolabeling
ofClaI pieces and
a weaksignal
at thethird
EcoRI
fragment (3
200bp) band.
Amitochon-
drial gene map based
onhybridization with yeast probes appears
infigure
3.The introduction of African bees
(Apis
mellifera
scutellata)
to Brazil in 1956 fol- lowedby dispersal
of descendentsthroughout South and Central America
stimulatedinvestigators
tolook
formolecu-
lar markers
tostudy the
processof African-
ization.Restriction fragment polymorphism
in
honey bee
mtDNA hasbeen widely
used to
provide molecular markers for
such studies(Moritz
etal, 1986; Smith, 1988; Smith et al, 1989; Hall and Muralid- haran, 1989; Smith and Brown, 1990;
Sheppard et al, 1991).
The size of
mtDNA
inApis mellifera has
been estimated at around 16 kblong
(Smith, 1988;
Ariaset al, 1990)
and is simi- lar in size to thatreported for Drosophila
yakuba (Clary
andWolstenholme, 1984)
and
man(Cann
etal, 1987). Major gene
ECO RI HIND II ACC
IHIND III
XHOI ECO R V
ACC I
ACC
I8
ECO RI
ECO RI
PST IECO RI
ECO RI
order is
identical
inXenopus, Homo, Bos
and Mus
(Moritz
etal, 1987), although
in-versions and
transpositions
arefrequent, chiefly
amongtRNA
genes(Clary and Wol- stenholme, 1985; Wolstenholme
etal, 1987). Studies
infishes suggest
that thereis conservation
ofmajor gene order
inthe
phylum Chordata (Moritz et al, 1987).
Sequence
datareported
todate from honey
bee mtDNA describe a set of 6 con-secutive
genes(tRNAs
forLeu, Asp, Lys and Trp, COI, COII)
and thelarge rRNA
gene
inApis
melliferaligustica (Crozier
etal,
1989 and Vlasak etal, 1987, respec-
tively). Compared
toDrosophila, Apis gene order displays translocations of
3 of the 4tRNA genes. Such tRNA transpositions
have been documented between
most or-ders (Dubin et al, 1986; Haucke and Gellis-
sen,1988) but
notransposition affecting respiratory complex
subunits have been found.Conditions of reduced stringency
wereutilized to
map, by hybridization
toyeast probes,
thecorresponding honey bee
mitochondrial
genes.
Mosthybrids
re-mained intact after
washes
in 2 xSSC
and60 °C indicating
aconsiderable degree of similarity. Yeast probes
areavailable for
in-dividual mtDNA
genesand have been used successfully
inmapping organelle
genes (Macino, 1980; Spithill et al, 1983;
Borkhardt and
Olson, 1986). Concerning
our
difficulty
inpositioning
theCOIII
gene, it isinteresting
thatSpithill
etal (1983)
re-ported extensive hybridization of the yeast COIII probe
to severalnon-adjacent
mtDNA fragments
inLeishmania
tarento-lae.
Our results reveal
aconserved gene
or-der between Apis mellifera
andDrosophila,
and reinforce the
inversiondetected be-
tween invertebrate andvertebrate ge-
nomes
concerning the large and small ri-
bosomal subunit genes(fig 4).
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank J Lino and CK Takahashi for techni- cal
support,
LGonzaga
de Castro for the illus- trations and ATzagoloff
forproviding
theyeast petite
mutants. This work wassupported by
FA-PESP, CNPq,
BIOO/FINEP and the USP/BIDproject.
Résumé — Localisation des
gènes
surl’ADN mitochondrial issu
d’Apis
mellife-ra scutellata chez des abeilles africani-
sées.
L’ADN mitochondrial(ADNmt)
estune molécule circulaire
longue
d’environ16
à
18kb.
Ladétermination complète des séquences de nucléotides chez l’homme,
la
pieuvre,
la vache et ladrosophile
amontré que
le nombre degènes
et leur or-ganisation
sontrestés quasiment inchan- gés
au coursde l’évolution, l’ordre
nechangeant qu’entre les phyla
etprincipale-
ment
parmi
lesgènes d’ARN t .
Nous avonsdéterminé
laposition de
6gènes dans la
molécule d’ADN mt issue d’abeilles présu-
mées
africanisées.
Les mitochondries pro- venant d’environ 300nymphes
auxyeux
blancs ontété purifiées par centrifugation
dans
ungradient
desaccharose. L’ADN mt
a
été extrait
etpurifié.
Leséchantillons
ontété digérés soit seuls,
soit encombinaison
avec
les endonucléases suivantes : AccI, ClaI, EcoRI, EcoRV,
HindIII etXhol (fig 1,
tableau
II).
Lesfragments
ontété séparés
sur des
gels d’agarose
à0,9%
et transfé-rés
surdes
filtresHybond-N. Des sondes spécifiques
pourles principaux gènes mi-
tochondriaux
(COI, COII, COIII, CytB,
sous-unité
ribosomalepetite
etgrande) (ta- bleau I)
ontété
obtenuesà partir des
mu-tants
«petite» de la
levureSaccharomyces
cerevisae
etmarqués par nick translation.
L’hybridation
aété faite
en unenuit à 40 °C dans 6
xSSC, du Sarkosyl à 0,1%
et 50
μg/ml d’ADN porteur dénaturé. Nous
avons
utilisé
unetempérature
basse(40 °C) afin
d’obtenir la formationd’hybride
avec les
sondes de levure hétérologues.
Après autoradiographie,
les filtres ontété
lavés successivement dans 2 xSSC,
Sar-kosyl à 0,1% à 45, 50,
55 et60 °C
avecautoradiographie après chaque lavage
pour
révéler les bandes ayant
laplus gran-
destabilité d’hybride. La figure
2 donne lesrésultats. Nous
avons construit une cartedes gènes
pourl’abeille africanisée d’après
les résultats de
l’hybridation (fig 3).
Legène COIII
estplacé
sur lepremier frag-
ment
EcoRI bien
quela sonde
montre unehomologie
avec les 2 autresfragments EcoRI. La comparaison
avecles
cartes dugénome
de ladrosophile
etde la souris
montrequ’entre
les 2insectes,
l’ordre desgènes
estconservé
et que l’on retrouvel’inversion déjà
mise enévidence
entre lesgènes de
l’ARNribosomal des Vertébrés
et ceuxdes Invertébrés.
abeille
africanisée
/gène
mitochon-drial /
cartographie
degènes
/ endonu-cléase
derestriction
/hybridation molé-
culaire
Zusammenfassung — Lage
von Genenin der von
Apis mellifera
scutellata ab- stammenden mitochondrialen DNA afri-kanisierter Bienen.
Die mitochondriale DNA(mtDNA) ist ein ringförmiges Molekül
von etwa 16
bis
18 kbLänge. Die vollstän-
dige Bestimmung der Nukleotid-Sequenz
bei
Mensch, Xenopus, Rind
undDrosophi-
la haben
gezeigt,
daßGengehalt
und ihreOrganisation während der Evolution
in hohem Maße unverändertgeblieben sind;
sie zeigen
nurbeim Vergleich zwischen
Tierstämmen Unterschiede in der Anord- nung,
und zwarvorwiegend
beiGenen der
tRNA. Wir bestimmten die
Lage
von sechsGenen des mitochondrialen DNA-Moleküls der Afrikanisierten Biene,
dievermutlich
von
Apis mellifera scutellata
abstammt.Von ungefähr
300weißäugigen Puppen
wurden
dieMitochondrien
durchZentrifu-
gierung
imSucrosegradienten gereinigt.
Die mtDNA wurde aus den
Organellen
ex-trahiert
undgereinigt.
DieProben wurden
fürsich
odergemeinsam
mitfolgenden
Endonukleasen
abgebaut: AccI, ClaI, EcoRi, EcoRV, HindIII,
undXhol (Abb
1und Tabelle
II). Die Fragmente
wurden in0.9%
Agarosegel getrennt und auf Hybond-N-Filter übertragen. Spezifische Untersuchungen auf die mitochondrialen
Hauptgene (COI, COII, COIII, CytB, kleine
und
große ribosomale Untereinheit;
TabI)
wurden
mittels geeigneter "petite" Hefemu-
tanten
durchgeführt
undmit
Nick-Translation markiert. Die Hybridisierung
wurde über Nacht
in 6 xSSC,
0.1 %Sarco-
syl und
50μg/ml denaturierter Träger-DNA
bei 40 °C durchgeführt. Wir benutzten nie-
drigere Temperaturen (40 °C),
umHybrid- bildungen
mit denheterologen Hefeson-
den zu
ermöglichen.
Nach derAutoradio- graphie
wurden die Filter sukzessive in 2 xSSC,
0.1%Sarkosyl bei 45, 50,
55und 60 °C gewaschen,
mitAutoradiographie
nach
jedem Auswaschen;
damit sollten dieBande
mit der höchstenHybrid-Stabilität aufgedeckt werden.
DieErgebnisse
werden in
Abbildung
2gezeigt.
Wirhaben
nach den
Hybridisierungsresultaten
eineGenkarte für
dieafrikanisierte Honigbiene
konstruiert
(Abb 3).
DasCOIII-Gen kam auf dem
erstenEcoRI-Fragmen
zuliegen,
obwohl die
Sonde
eineHomologie mit
denanderen
beidenEcoRI-Fragmenten zeigte.
Diese Karte
zeigt bei Vergleich mit den
Genkarten
vonDrosophila und Maus (Abb 4)
einekonservative Genanordnung
bei den beiden Insekten und deckt diesel- be Inversion auf, die schon früher
bei den ribosomalenRNA-Genen zwischen
Verte- braten und Invertebratengefunden
wurde.afrikanisierte Biene / mitochondriales
Gen
/Genkarte
/ Endonuklease / mole- kulareHybridisierung
REFERENCES
Anderson
S,
BankierAT,
BarrellGT,
DeBruijn MHL,
CoulsonAR,
DrouinJ, Eperon IC,
Nier- lichDP,
RoeBA, Sanger F,
SchreierPH,
Smith
AJH,
StadenR, Young
IG(1981)
Se-quence
organization
of the human mitochon- drial genome. Nature(Lond) 290, 457-465
AndersonS,
DeBruijn MHL,
CoulsonAR, Epe-
ron
IC, Sanger F, Young
IG(1982) Complete
sequence of bovine mitochondrial DNA. Con- served features of the mammalian mitochon- drial genome. J Mol
Biol 156,
683-717 AriasMC,
SoaresAEE, Nobrega
FG(1990)
Im-provements
to the mitochondrial restriction maps for italian and africanizedhoney
bees.Braz
J Genet 13,
501-507Avise
JC,
Arnold J, BallRM, Bermingham E,
LambT, Niegel JE,
ReebCA,
Saunders NC(1987) Intraspecific phylogeography:
themitochondrial DNA
bridge
betweenpopulation genetics
andsystematics.
AnnRev Ecol
Syst
18, 489-522Bibb
MJ,
Van EttenRA, Wright CT, Walberg MW, Clayton
DA(1981) Sequence
and or-ganization
of mouse mitochondrial DNA. Cell 26, 167-180Borkhardt
B,
Olson LW(1986)
The mitochon- drial genome of theaquatic phycomycete
Blastocladiella emersoni. Curr Genet
11, 139-
141
Bonitz
SG,
CoruzziG,
ThalenfeldBE, Tzagoloff
A
(1980) Assembly
of mitochondrial mem-brane
system.
Structure and nucleotide se-quence of the gene
coding
for subunit I ofyeast cytochrome
oxidase. J Biol Chem 255, 11927-11941Cann
RL, Stoneking M,
Wilson AC(1987)
Mito-chondrial DNA and human evolution. Na- ture
(Lond)
325, 31-36Clary DO,
Wolstenholme DR(1984)
The Dro-sophila
mitochondrial genome. In: OxfordSurveys
onEukaryotic
Genes(Maclean N, ed)
OxfordUniversity Press, vol 1,
1-35Clary DO,
Wolstenholme DR(1985)
The mito-chondrial DNA molecule of
Drosophila yaku-
ba : nucleotide sequence, gene
organization
and
genetic
code. J MolEvol 22,
252- 271 CoruzziG, Tzagoloff
A(1979) Assembly
of themitochondrial membrane
system.
DNA se-quence of subunit II of
yeast cytochrome
oxi-dase. J Biol Chem
254,
9324-9330Crozier
RH,
CrozierYC, Mackinlay
AG(1989)
The COI and COII
region
ofhoneybee
mito-chondrial DNA: evidence for variation in in- sect mitochondrial
evolutionary
rates. MolBiol Evol 6,
399-411Dubin
DT,
HsuChenCC,
Tillotson LE(1986) Mosquito
mitochondrial transfer RNAs for va-line, glycine
andglutamate:RNA
and genesequences and vicinal genome
organization.
Curr
Genet 10,
701-707Dujon
B(1980) Sequence
of the intron andflanking
exons of the mitochondrial 21S rRNA gene ofyeast
strainshaving
differentalleles at the w and rib-1 loci.
Cell 20,
185- 197Hall
HG,
Muralidharan K(1989)
Evidence from mitochondrial DNA that Africanhoney
beesspread
as continuous maternallineages.
Na-ture
(Lond)
339, 211-213Haucke
HR,
Gellissen G(1988)
Different mito- chondrial gene order among insects: ex-changed
tRNA geneposition
in the COII / COIIIregion
between anorthopteran
and adipteran species. Curr Genet 14,
471-476 LiM, Tzagoloff
A(1982)
Identification of the par-amomycin-resistance
mutation in the 15S rRNA gene ofyeast
mitochondria. J Biol Chem257, 5921-5928
Macino G
(1980) Mapping
of mitochondrial structural genes inNeurospora
crassa. J BiolChem
255, 10523-10565
Mariottini
P, Chomyn A, Riley M,
CottrellB,
Doo- littleRF,
Attardi G(1986)
Identification of thepolypeptides
encoded in theunassigned reading
frames2,4,4L
and 5 of human mito- chondrial DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA83,
1563-1567Moritz
C, Dowling TE,
Brown WM(1987)
Evolu-tion of animal mitochondrial DNA. Relevance for
population biology
andsystematics.
AnnRev Ecol
Syst
18, 269-292Moritz
RFA,
HawkinsCF,
CrozierRH, Mackinlay
AG
(1986)
A mitochondrial DNApolymor- phism
inhoneybee (Apis mellifera). Experien-
tia 42, 322-324
Nobrega FG, Tzagoloff
A(1980) Assembly
ofthe mitochondrial membrane
system.
DNA sequence andorganization
of thecyto-
chrome b gene in
Saccharomyces
cerevisiaeD273-1 0B. J Biol Chem 255, 9828-9837
Nobrega MP, Nobrega
FG(1986) Mapping
andsequencing
of thewild-type
and mutant(G116-40)
alleles of thetyrosyl-tRNA
mito-chondrial gene in
Saccharomyces
cerevisiae.J Biol Chem 261, 3054-3059
Roe BA, Ma
DP,
WilsonRK, Wong
JHF(1985)
The
complete
nucleotide sequence of theXenopus
laevis mitochondrial genome. J Biol Chem260, 9759-9774
Sambrook
J,
FritschEF,
Maniatis T(1989)
Mo-lecular
Cloning: A Laboratory
Manual. ColdSpring
HarborLaboratory,
ColdSpring
Har-bor,
New YorkSheppard WS,
RindererTE,
MazzoliJA,
Stelzer JA and Shimanuki H(1991)
Gene flow be- tween African- andEuropean-derived honey
bee
populations
inArgentine.
Nature(Lond) 349, 782-784
Smith DR
(1988)
Mitochondrial DNApolymor- phisms
in five Old Worldsubspecies
ofhoney
bees and New World
hybrids.
In: AfricanizedHoney
Bees and Bee Mites(Needham GR, Page
REJR,
Delfinado-BakerM,
BowmanCL, eds)
JohnWiley
andSons,
NewYork,
303-312
Smith
DR,
Brown WM(1990)
Restriction endo- nucleasecleavage
site andlength polymor- phisms
in mitochondrial DNA ofApis
mellife-ra mellifera and A m carnica
(Hymenoptera:
Apidae).
Ann Entomol Soc Am 83, 81-88 SmithDR, Taylor OR,
Brown WM(1989)
Neo-tropical
Africanizedhoney
bees have Africanmitochondrial DNA. Nature
(Lond)
339, 213- 215Spithill TW, Simpson AM, Simpson
L(1983)
Identification of sequence
homologies
be-tween maxicircle DNA of L tarentolae and
specific yeast
mitochondrial structural genes.In:
Manipulation
andExpression
of Genes inEukaryotes (Nagley P,
LinnaneAW,
PeacockNJ,
PatemanJA, eds)
AcademicPress,
NewYork, 307-311
Thalenfeld
BE, Tzagoloff
A(1980) Assembly
of mitochondrial membrane
system.
Se- quence of the oxi 2 gene ofyeast
mitochon- drial DNA. J Biol Chem 255, 6173-6180Tzagoloff A, Myers
AM(1986)
Genetics of mito- chondrialbiogenesis.
Ann Rev Biochem55,
249-285Vlasak
I, Burgschwaiger S,
Kreil G(1987)
Nu-cleotide sequence of the
large
ribosomalRNA of
honeybee
mitochondria. Nucleic Ac- ids Res 15, 2388Wilson
AC,
CannRL, George M, Gyllensten UB, Helm-Bychowski KM, Higushi RG,
PalumbiSR, Prager EM, Sage RD, Stoneking
M(1985)
Mitochondrial DNA and two perspec- tives onevolutionary genetics.
Biol J Linn Soc 26, 375-400Wolstenholme
DR,
MacfarlaneJL,
OkimotoR, Clary DO,
Wahleitner JA(1987)
BizarretRNAs inferred from DNA sequences of mito- chondrial genomes of nematode worms. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA