Fostering the development of European regions: a spatial dynamic panel data analysis of the impact of cohesion policy

Texte intégral

(1)Fostering the development of European regions: a spatial dynamic panel data analysis of the impact of cohesion policy Salima Bouayad Agha, Nadine Turpin, Lionel Vedrine. To cite this version: Salima Bouayad Agha, Nadine Turpin, Lionel Vedrine. Fostering the development of European regions: a spatial dynamic panel data analysis of the impact of cohesion policy. Regional Studies, Taylor & Francis (Routledge), 2011, 47 (9), pp.1-21. �10.1080/00343404.2011.628930�. �hal-01000321�. HAL Id: hal-01000321 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01000321 Submitted on 15 May 2020. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. /(%)+15 #$ * %*!01.,%* (%+*!(2! .%*! . 0!,, #%*/ 1D?L;HI?JR:K)7?D; L;DK;+B?L?;H);II?7;D (;)7DI;:;N "H7D9; . . ;C7=H;< 1).)RJ7<EHJ , " K8?;H; "H7D9;. . =HE,7H?I0;9> 1). , " K8?;H; "H7D9;. . B;HCEDJ1D?L;HI?JR 2;J=HE/KF 1). , " (;CF:;I "H7D9;. . %*. 1). " /7?DJ #;D;I>7CF7D;BB; "H7D9;. ! C7?BID7:?D; JKHF?D9;C7=H;< <H B?ED;B L;:H?D;9;C7=H;< <H

(3) %DJ>?IF7F;H M;KI;79ED:?J?ED7B 9EDL;H=;D9;;9EDEC;JH?9CE:;BJE?DL;IJ?=7J;M>;J>;HJ>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O 7<<;9J J>; !KHEF;7D ;9EDEC?;I 0>; C7?D 9EDJH?8KJ?ED E< EKH IJK:O ?I JE 9EDI?:;H 8EJ> IF7J?7B 7D: J;CFEH7B :OD7C?9I?D7II;II?D=J>;?CF79JE<!KHEF;7D9E>;I?EDFEB?9O !9EDEC;JH?9;IJ?C7J?EDIH;BOED7:7J7I;JE< !1 *10/

(4) *10/ H;=?EDI <HEC JE +KH H;IKBJI IK==;IJ J>7J +8@;9J?L; FHE=H7CC;I >7L; 7 :?H;9J;<<;9JEDH;=?ED7B# ,F 9 =HEMJ>H7J;I M>;H;7IJEJ7BIJHK9JKH7B<KD:I:EDEJ )EH;EL;H 9EDI?:;H7J?ED E<J>;IF7J?7B:?C;DI?EDE<J>;F7D;B8H?D=IJEB?=>J7IJ?BBI?=D?<?97DJ 8KJB;II?CFEHJ7DJ ?CF79JE<IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I OD7C?9F7D;BI #)) .;=?ED7BEDL;H=;D9; /F7J?7B ;F;D:;D9; /JHK9JKH7B"KD:I . . . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. ! C7?BI7B?C7 8EK7O7: 7=>7KD?L B;C7DI <H .

(5) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. . %DJHE:K9J?ED !KHEF;7D E>;I?ED ,EB?9O ?DL;IJC;DJI 7?C 7J ?CFHEL?D= J>; 9ECF;J?J?L; FEI?J?ED E< H;=?ED7B FEB?9?;I 8O ;D9EKH7=?D=H;=?EDIJEFHEL?:;FK8B?9=EE:I IK9>7ID;JMEHAIE<JH7DIFEHJ7D:;D;H=O ;DL?HEDC;DJ7BGK7B?JO ?DL;IJC;DJI ?D ;:K97J?ED 7D: H;I;7H9> :;L;BEFC;DJ %D EJ>;H MEH:I J>; E>;I?ED ,EB?9O <EIJ;HI H;=?ED7B :;L;BEFC;DJ 8O L7H?EKI C;7DI B?A; 9ECF;J?J?L;D;II ;D>7D9;C;DJ ?D<H7IJHK9JKH; ?CFHEL;C;DJ 79J?L; B78EKH C7HA;J<79?B?J?;I ?DDEL7J?ED;D>7D9;C;DJEHIKIJ7?D78B;:;L;BEFC;DJ 0>;FK8B?9=EE:IFHEL?:;:H;IKBJ<HEC. =EL;HD7D9; <H7C;MEHA JE ?DLEBL; BE97B 7D: H;=?ED7B 79JEHI ?D J>; :;I?=D 7D: :;B?L;HO E< J>; FEB?9O 0>?I =EL;HD7D9;<H7C;MEHA;D78B;IH;=?EDIJE79J?L7J;J>;CEIJ7FFHEFH?7J;:H?L;HIJE<EIJ;HJ>;?H:;L;BEFC;DJ 7D: JE:;I?=DFHE@;9JI?D78EJJEC KF7FFHE79> 0>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O>7IH;B?;:EDJ>;I7C;FH?D9?FB;II?D9; 0>;FEB?9OJ7H=;JI<KD:IJEM7H:I7B?C?J;: DKC8;HE<7?CI9EDL;H=;D9; 9ECF;J?J?L;D;II7D:9EEF;H7J?ED M?J>7<E9KIEDJ>;B;7IJ:;L;BEF;:H;=?EDI <KD:?D= ?I 87I;: ED CKBJ? 7DDK7B FHE=H7CC?D= M?J> ED=E?D= 7D7BOI?I 7D: ;L7BK7J?ED J>; :;I?=D 7D: ?CFB;C;DJ7J?EDE<J>;FHE=H7CC;I?DLEBL;H;=?ED7B D7J?ED7B7D:!179JEHI 7D:7::?J?ED7B?JO;DIKH;IJ>7J!1 ;NF;D:?JKH; ?I DEJ IK8IJ?JKJ;: <EH D7J?ED7B ?DL;IJC;DJ 0>; <E9KI ED J>; B;7IJ :;L;BEF;: H;=?EDI 9ED9;DJH7J;I <KD:?D=EDJ>;+8@;9J?L;H;=?EDI J>7JH;FH;I;DJ78EKJE<J>;!KHEF;7DFEFKB7J?ED 7D:8;D;<?J<HEC E<J>;7BBE97J;:<KD:I<EHJ>;B7IJFHE=H7CC; 0>;FEB?9OM7IH;D;M;:<EHI;L;DO;7HI?D :;87J;>7I@KIJ8;;DB7KD9>;:M?J>7L?;MJE9EDJ?DKEKI ?CFHEL;C;DJE<J>;FEB?9O 87I;:ED7FK8B?99EDIKBJ7J?ED78EKJJ>;8K:=;JH;L?;M7D:J>;J;HH?JEH?7B9E>;I?ED IJH7J;=O!KHEF;7DECC?II?ED JJ>?IIJ7=; ?J?I?CFEHJ7DJJE;L7BK7J;J>;?CF79JE<F7IJ/JHK9JKH7B "KD:I/";NF;D:?JKH;JE7II;IIM>;J>;HIJHK9JKH7BFEB?9?;I7H;;<<;9J?L;BOB;7:?D=JE7D7HHEM?D=E<:?IF7H?J?;I E<M;7BJ>8;JM;;D!1H;=?EDI 0>?IF7F;H<E9KI;IEDJ>7J;L7BK7J?ED<EHJ>; F;H?E: . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. FK8B?97D:FH?L7J;;NF;D:?JKH; 0>;FEB?9OI;;AIJE7::L7BK;8;OED:I?CFB;?DL;IJC;DJI M?J>7CKBJ? B;L;BI.

(6) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 8HE7: ;N7C?D7J?ED E< J>; ;CF?H?97B;L?:;D9; ED J>; HEB; E< FEB?9?;IED =HEMJ> 9EDL;H=;D9; 79HEIIJ>;!1 IK==;IJI J>7J 7 9ED9BKI?L; 7DIM;H 97D >7H:BO 8; =?L;D 0>EK=> J>; B?J;H7JKH; ED J>?I JEF?9 >7I 8;;D =HEM?D= H;9;DJBO J>; H;IKBJI >7L; 8;;D 7C8?=KEKI 0>; B7H=; DKC8;H E< :?<<;H;DJ CE:;B IF;9?<?97J?EDI :7J7 7D: ;9EDEC;JH?9 C;J>E:I E<<;H;: ?D J>?I B?J;H7JKH; C7O ;NFB7?D J>?I )EH; FH;9?I;BO M>?B; IEC; 7KJ>EHI :E <?D: ;L?:;D9;E<7FEI?J?L;?CF79JE<IJHK9JKH7B<KD:IED;9EDEC?9=HEMJ> EJ>;HI<?D:B?JJB;JEDE?CF79J7J7BB %D IEC;97I;I<?D:?D=I7H;9ED:?J?ED;:8OEJ>;H:;L;BEFC;DJ:H?L;HIJ>7D?DL;IJC;DJEHFEFKB7J?ED=HEMJ><EH ?DIJ7D9; ?DIJ?JKJ?ED7B GK7B?JO E< C;C8;H IJ7J;I !:;HL;;D ,; (3 EH 9>E?9; ?D ;NF;D:?JKH; J7H=;J .E:H?=K;P ,EI;7D:"H7J;I? . +D J>; M>EB; 9HEII I;9J?ED IJK:?;I J;D: JE EL;H;IJ?C7J; J>; ?CF79J E< J>; 9E>;I?ED FEB?9O %D J>;I; IJK:?;I ?=DEH?D=IF7J?7B;<<;9JIB;7:IJEKDH;B?78B;H;IKBJI8H;K,;(3 "KHJ>;HCEH; 9HEII I;9J?ED7FFHE79>;I:E DEJ 97FJKH; KDE8I;HL;: >;J;HE=;D;?JO 7CED= H;=?EDI 0>; <?HIJ I>EHJ9EC?D= ?I >7D:B;: 8O IJK:?;I ?D IF7J?7B 9HEII I;9J?ED M>?9>IK==;IJBEM;H?CF79JE<J>;FEB?9O M>?B;KDE8I;HL;:>;J;HE=;D;?JO97D8;9EDJHEBB;:8O KI?D=F7D;B:7J7 %DJ>?IA?D:E<9EDJ;NJ :OD7C?9F7D;B :7J7IF;9?<?97J?EDI7H;?D9H;7I?D=BO7:EFJ;:!IFEIJ? 7D:KIIEB;JJ? )E>B7D:$7=;D 0E:;J;HC?D;?<J>;/"<EIJ;HJ>;:;L;BEFC;DJE<!1H;=?EDI M;I>EKB:E8I;HL;J>;H;IKBJE<7H;=?EDM>;H; J>;H;M7IFEB?J?97B?DJ;HL;DJ?ED7D:FEJ;DJ?7BEKJ9EC;IE<J>;I7C;H;=?ED M?J>EKJFEB?J?97B?DJ;HL;DJ?ED 0>?I ?IIK; DEJ78B; M?J> DED ;NF;H?C;DJ7B :7J7 ?I E< ?CFEHJ7D9; JE EKH IJK:O 8;97KI; /" 7BBE97J?ED ?I >?=>BO 9EHH;B7J;: M?J>H;=?ED7B?D9EC; F;H 97F?J7!KHEF;7D ECC?II?ED )EH;EL;H M; 9EKB:;NF;9J I;L;H; C?IIF;9?<?97J?EDM>;DJ>;IF7J?7BIF?BBEL;H;<<;9JI7H;DEJ?D9BK:;:?DJ>;7D7BOI?I %<J>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O7<<;9JI J>;=HEMJ>FHE9;IIE<7F7HJ?9KB7HH;=?ED J>?I9>7D=;C7O7BIE7<<;9JJ>;=HEMJ>H7J;E<D;?=>8EKH?D=H;=?EDI %D:;;: J>;EC?II?EDE<J>;IF7J?7BIF?BBEL;H;<<;9JI97DFHE:K9;8?7I;:;IJ?C7J;IE<E>;I?ED,EB?9O?CF79J 0>;C7?D9EDJH?8KJ?EDE<EKHIJK:O?IJE7II;IJ>;?CF79JE<!KHEF;7D9E>;I?EDFEB?9O?D7IF7J?7BBO;NJ;D:;: /EBEMCE:;B 9EDI?:;H?D=8EJ>IF7J?7B7D:J;CFEH7B:OD7C?9I %DJ>?I9EDJ;NJ M;KI;7DEH?=?D7B;9EDEC;JH?9 7FFHE79>87I;:EDJ>;IJK:OE<7/F7J?7B OD7C?9,7D;B 7J7CE:;B/ , 3;97D;IJ?C7J;J>?ICE:;B8O. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. .

(7) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. .

(8) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 0E 7 B7H=; ;NJ;DJ J>; 7D7BOI;I E< J>; ?CF79J E< IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I ED H;=?ED7B =HEMJ> 7H; HEEJ;: ED J>; D;E9B7II?97B /EBEM =HEMJ> CE:;B /EBEM /M7D .EK=>BO IF;7A?D= J>?I CE:;B FH;:?9JI 7 9EDL;H=;D9;E<?D9EC;7CED=H;=?EDI>7L?D=7I?C?B7H;9EDEC?9IJHK9JKH; D;9EDECO9EDL;H=;IJEM7H:I7 IJ;7:OIJ7J;7I7H;IKBJE<:;9H;7I?D=C7H=?D7B97F?J7BFHE:K9J 3>;D97F?J7B?II97H9; ?J?IL;HOFHE:K9J?L; IE?J H;9;?L;I7>?=>H;JKHD ?D:K9?D=;9EDEC?97=;DJIJEI7L;CEH; ;97KI;E<:;9H;7I?D=C7H=?D7B97F?J7BFHE:K9J J>;97F?J7B=HEMJ>H7J;:;F;D:IEDJ>;:?IJ7D9;8;JM;;D?JI?D?J?7BIJE9A7D:?JIIJ;7:OIJ7J;L7BK; %DJ>?IIJ;7:O IJ7J; J>;H;=?ED7B?D9EC;9EDJ?DK;IJE=HEM 8KJJ>?I=HEMJ>?I:;J;HC?D;:8O;NE=;DEKI<79JEHIJ;9>DEBE=?97B 9>7D=; :;CE=H7F>?9 =HEMJ> H7J; :;FH;9?7J?ED H7J;U C;DJ?ED;: 8;BEM 7I IJHK9JKH7B 9>7H79J;H?IJ?9I %D:;;: H;=?EDIM?J>J>;I7C;IJHK9JKH7B9>7H79J;H?IJ?9ID;9;II7H?BO9EDL;H=;JEM7H:II?C?B7HIJ;7:OIJ7J;I . JEM7H:I ?JI IJ;7:O IJ7J; 7D: ?J ?D:K9;I IJHK9JKH7B 9>7D=;I M>?9> CE:?<O J>; IJ;7:O IJ7J;?D9EC; L7BK; E<B;II :;L;BEF;:7H;7I $;D9; J>;=HEMJ>E<97F?J7B I97H9;H;=?EDI?IJ;CFEH7H?BOIJ?CKB7J;:78EL;J>;H;=?EDXIKIK7B IJ;7:O IJ7J;=HEMJ>B;L;B M>;D/"<?D7D9;IF>OI?97B97F?J7B $EM;L;H J>;M7OE>;I?ED,EB?9O97D?D:K9; J>?IIJHK9JKH7B9>7D=;?IDEJ;D:E=;DEKI?DJ>;/EBEMCE:;B $;D9; J>?ICE:;B;NFB7?DIJ>;:;L;BEFC;DJF7J> <EH 7 =?L;D J;9>DEBE=O EDBO ;IF?J; J>; ;NJ;D:;: /EBEM CE:;B FHEFEI;: 8O 7@E .K8?E FK8B?9 ?DJ;HL;DJ?EDFB7OIDEF7HJ?DJ>;:OD7C?9I:;I9H?8;:8OJ>;CE:;B .EC;H 7HHE 7D:(K97I7CED=EJ>;HI>7L;FHEFEI;:7D;MCE:;BJE97FJKH;J>;C7?D HEB;E<J>;J;9>DEBE=?97BF7J>7D:J>;M7OFK8B?9FEB?9?;I97D7<<;9JJ>?IF7J> D7BOI?D=J>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O <H7C;MEHAM?J>J>?ICE:;BMEKB:IK==;IJJ>7JJ>;<KD:I7<<;9JH;=?ED7BBED= J;HC =HEMJ>H7J;I8OFHECEJ?D= B78EKH <EH9; JH7?D?D= CE:;B 87I;: ED >KC7D 97F?J7B :;L;BEFC;DJ (K97I ?D9H;7I?D= .;I;7H9> 7D: ;L;BEFC;DJ.EC;H EH CEH;=;D;H7BBO FK8B?9?D<H7IJHK9JKH;?DL;IJC;DJ7HHE 0>;H;8O FK8B?9 FEB?9?;I97D8;:?H;9JBO9EDI?:;H;:7I?DFKJI?DJ>;FHE:K9J?EDFHE9;IIEH7I<79JEHIJE?CFHEL;J>;GK7B?JOE< EJ>;H?DFKJIIK9>7IJ;9>DEBE=OEH>KC7D97F?J7B . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. 0>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O J>7J<?D7D9;IF>OI?97B97F?J7B >7IJME;<<;9JI?J7<<;9JIJ>;9EDL;H=;D9;E<7D;9EDECO.

(9) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 0>;JME7FFHE79>;I78EL;97D8;9EDI?:;H;:7I8;?D=DED IF7J?7B 8;97KI;J>;:;L;BEFC;DJE<7=?L;D;9EDECO ?I 9EDI?:;H;: I;F7H7J;BO <HEC J>; EJ>;H ED;I 0>; *;M !9EDEC?9 #;E=H7F>O *!# 7D: 'HK=C7DXI 9EH;. F;H?F>;HO CE:;BI 'HK=C7D 7:: 7 9H?J?97B F?;9; JE J>; H;=?ED7B =EL;HD7D9; FKPPB; 8O ;NFB7?D?D= J>; 9ED9;DJH7J?EDE<;9EDEC?979J?L?J?;I7D:J>;FHE:K9J?L;7:L7DJ7=;IE<IF7J?7B9BEI;D;II %DJ>?I<H7C;MEHA JME EFFEI?J;:?H;9J?ED7BIF7J?7BFHE9;II;IC7O8;7JMEHA +DED;>7D: 9;DJH?F;J7B<EH9;IB?A;;9EDEC?;IE<I97B; BE97B ?DDEL7J?ED FHE9;II;I JH7DIFEHJ 9EIJI EH FH;I;D9; E< :;C7D: <EH =EE:I 7CED= EJ>;H :H?L;HI J;D: JE FHECEJ;=;E=H7F>?97B9ED9;DJH7J?EDE<;9EDEC?979J?L?J?;I +DJ>;EJ>;H>7D: 9ED=;IJ?ED9EIJI7CED=EJ>;HI H;7B;IJ7J;9EIJI M7=;I7D:B78EKHC7HA;J9EIJI JH7DIFEHJ9EIJIJ;D:JE9EKDJ;H79J9ED9;DJH7J?EDE<;9EDEC?9 79J?L?J?;I 3;97DDEJ;J>;C7@EHHEB;E<JH7DIFEHJ9EIJIM>?9>7<<;9JJ>;I;JME<EH9;I %DB?=>JE<*!#J>;EH?;I E>;I?ED ,EB?9O >7I 7D 7C8?=KEKI ?CF79J ED H;=?ED7B ?D9EC; 9EDL;H=;D9; I :;I9H?8;: 8O )7HJ?D . H;:K9?D=J>;I;JH7DIFEHJ9EIJI $EM;L;H FK8B?9FEB?9?;IJ>7J<79?B?J7J;J;9>DEBE=?97B:?<<KI?EDIF?BBEL;H97D8; 8;D;<?9?7B<EHB;II:;L;BEF;:H;=?EDI )EH;EL;H "K;IJ7D:$K8;H I>EM?D7JME H;=?EDICE:;B J>7J7 IK8I?:O ED ?DL;IJC;DJ ?D J>; FEEH;H H;=?ED KD7C8?=KEKIBO ?D9H;7I;I M;B<7H; ?< J>; B78EKH C7HA;JI 7H; 9ECF;J?J?L; %<J>;H;?IKD;CFBEOC;DJ?D8EJ>H;=?EDI J>;;<<;9JE<H;=?ED7BIK8I?:?;I?IM;7A;H 0E IKC KF ;79> E< J>;I; J>;EH;J?97B 7FFHE79>;I I>;:I B?=>J ED ?DJ;H;IJ?D= 7IF;9JI E< J>; ;<<;9JI E< E>;I?ED ,EB?9OED!KHEF;7DH;=?ED7B=HEMJ> $EM;L;HJ>;O7H;:?<<?9KBJJE9ECF7H; )EH;FH;9?I;BO J>;7IIKCFJ?EDE< :;9H;7I?D=C7H=?D7B97F?J7BF 9 H;JKHDI?IDEJ9ECF7J?8B;M?J>J>;H;JKHDJEI97B;E<J>;;D:E=;DEKI=HEMJ>7D: *!# J>;EH?;I 0>KI M; >7L; JE 9>EEI; 7 87I?9 <H7C;MEHA JE H;BO ED ?J BCEIJ 7BB ;9EDEC;JH?9 IJK:?;I ?DL;IJ?=7J?D=J>;?CF79JE<J>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O7H;87I;:EDJ>;D;E 9B7II?97B=HEMJ><H7C;MEHA 3;H;BOED J>?I <H7C;MEHA J>7J FH;I;DJI J>; C7?D 7:L7DJ7=; E< 97FJKH?D= J;CFEH7B :OD7C?9I 3; ?DJHE:K9; ?D J>?I <H7C;MEHAJ>;;9EDEC?9IF?BBEL;HI!HJKH7D:'E9> (EF;P 7PE,;(3 !CF?H?97B<H7C;MEHA. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. JH7DIFEHJ?D<H7IJHK9JKH;?DL;IJC;DJI8;JM;;DH;=?EDI97DB;7:JE7D?D9H;7I;E<IF7J?7B9ED9;DJH7J?ED8O.

(10) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. "?HIJBO M; KI; J>; D;E 9B7II?97B <H7C;MEHA 7I 7 8;D9>C7HA KI?D= 7 :OD7C?9 F7D;B IF;9?<?97J?ED 0>;D M; ?DJHE:K9;IF7J?7BIF?BBEL;HI %DJ>;B7IJIJ;F M;;NJ;D:J>;CE:;BJEM7H:IJ>;?CF79J;L7BK7J?EDE<J>;FEB?9O )E:;BB?D=ȕ 9EDL;H=;D9;<EHIF7J?7B:OD7C?9F7D;B:7J7 "EBBEM?D= J>; IF;9?<?97J?ED E< 7HHE 7D: /7B7 % )7HJ?D I;L;H7B ;CF?H?97B IJK:?;I H;BO ED 7 ȕ. 9EDL;H=;D9;CE:;BM>;H;J>;# ,F;H97F?J7>;H;7<J;H# ,F 9 =HEMJ>:;F;D:IDEJEDBOEDJ>;?D?J?7B# , B;L;B 8KJ 7BIE ED EJ>;H 9ED:?J?ED?D= L7H?78B;I FHENO?D= J>; IJHK9JKH7B 9>7H79J;H?IJ?9I E< J>; IJ;7:O IJ7J; .;=?EDI:EDEJ>7L;J>;I7C;IJHK9JKH7B9>7H79J;H?IJ?9I7D:J>KI9EDL;H=;JEM7H:I:?<<;H;DJIJ;7:OIJ7J;?D9EC;. 9EDL;H=;D9;?I9ED:?J?ED7B;9EDEC?;I9EDL;H=;JEM7H:IJ>;I7C;=HEMJ>H7J; 7D:7=7FC7OF;HI?IJ?D?D9EC; B;L;B 0>?I97D8;;NFB7?D;:J>HEK=>J>;JH7DI?J?ED7B:OD7C?9IE<J>;# ,F 9 BD @ 0 ; . BD @ 0 ; − BD @ 0 ; − = − BD @ 0 ; − − , −λ; + BD @ 0 − , − λ; M>;H; BD @ 0 ; − ?IJ>;?D?J?7B# ,F 9 <EHH;=?ED0 BD @ 0 ?IJ>;IJ;7:OIJ7J;7D: λ ?IJ>;H7J;E<9EDL;H=;D9; 0>?ICE:;B?CFB?;I9ED:?J?ED7B9EDL;H=;D9;<EH7=?L;DIJ;7:OIJ7J; J>;=HEMJ>H7J;?I>?=>;H<EHH;=?EDIM?J> BEM?D9EC;7JJ>;FH;L?EKIF;H?E: BD @ 0 ; − 99EH:?D=BO M;KI;J>;<EBBEM?D==;D;H7BIF;9?<?97J?ED ?DB?D;M?J>J>;;CF?H?97B=HEMJ>B?J;H7JKH; KHB7K<,; (3 . M>;H;. '0 ; 7670 ;. § '0 ; BD¨ ¨ 767 0 ; ©. . 0 ; 7670 ;. · § · § ' ¸ = ( + β ) BD¨ 0 ; − ¸ + β BD¨ 0 ; ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ ¨ 767 0 ; − ¹ 0 ; © ¹ ©. · § 767 0 ; · ¸ + α 0 + µ ; + ε 0 ; ¸ + β BD¨ ¸ ¸ ¨ 767 0. ; − ¹ ¹ ©. . § 7670 ; · ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ 0 ; − ¹ ©. 7H;H;IF;9J?L;BOJ>;=HEII:EC;IJ?9FHE:K9J7D:J>;?DL;IJC;DJF;H97F?J77D: BD¨. ?IJ>;:;CE=H7F>?9=HEMJ>H7J; 0>;I;B7IJJMEL7H?78B;IF7HJBO:;J;HC?D;J>;=HEMJ>H7J;?DJ>;IJ;7:OIJ7J; . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. B;L;BI 0>;<KHJ>;H7H;=?ED<?D:I?JI;B<<7H<HEC?JIIJ;7:OIJ7J; J>;<7IJ;H?JI=HEMJ>H7J;M?BB8; %DJ>?I97I; .

(11) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 1I?D=F7D;B:7J7?CFHEL;IJ>;:;J;HC?D7J?EDE< BD @ 0 =HEMJ>H7J;8O9EDJHEBB?D=<EHKDE8I;HL;:>;J;HE=;D;?JO 79HEII H;=?EDI %IB7C J>HEK=> J>; ?DJHE:K9J?ED E< ?D:?L?:K7B ;<<;9JI 7D: J?C; ;<<;9JI H;IF;9J?L;BO α 0 7D: µ; 0>;H;<EH; β C;7IKH;I J>; # , 9EDL;H=;D9; 9ED:?J?ED7B ED ?DL;IJC;DJ F;H 97F?J7 7D: FEFKB7J?ED =HEMJ>H7J; %D J>; KD:;HBO?D= D;E9B7II?97B =HEMJ> CE:;B ;9EDEC?;I 7H; 7IIKC;: JE 8; ?D:;F;D:;DJ $EM;L;H I;L;H7B H;9;DJIJK:?;I>7L;;CF>7I?P;:J>7JJ>;9BEI;:;9EDECO7IIKCFJ?EDC?=>JDEJ8;L7B?:7D:J>7JM;D;;:JEJ7A; ?DJE 799EKDJ J>; FEII?8B; ?DJ;H:;F;D:;D9; 8;JM;;D 9EKDJH?;I EH H;=?EDI M>?9> 97D 8; ;NFB7?D;: 8O IF7J?7B ;NJ;HD7B?J?;I )EH;EL;H ;CF?H?97B;L?:;D9;IK==;IJIJ>7JJ>;FHE:K9J?L?JOE<J;9>DEBE=?97BIF?BBEL;HI:;9B?D;I7I. 7D7BOI?IE<IF7J?7B;<<;9JI IF7J?7B7KJE9EHH;B7J?ED7D:>;J;HE=;D;?JOE<J>;=HEMJ>FHE9;IIJE799EKDJ<EHIF7J?7B :;F;D:;D9; E<J;D :;J;9J;: ?D 9HEII 9EKDJHO =HEMJ> H;=H;II?EDI ; = 7BBX;H87 7D: (; #7BBE %D J>;I; IF7J?7B;9EDEC;JH?9IF;9?<?97J?EDI J>;IF7J?7BB7=?I7VC;J>E:EBE=?97BWC;7DIE<?DJHE:K9?D=J>;:?II;C?D7J?ED E<J;9>DEBE=?97BADEMB;:=; .;9;DJF7F;HI>7L;:;L;BEF;:7IF7J?7BBO 7K=C;DJ;:/EBEMCE:;BM>?9>;NFB?9?JBO J7A;I ?DJE 799EKDJ J;9>DEBE=?97B ?DJ;H:;F;D:;D9; 8;JM;;D 9EKDJH?;I KI?D= IF7J?7B ;NJ;HD7B?J?;I ED JEJ7B FHE:K9J?L?JO !HJKH 7D: 'E9> (EF;P 7PE ,; (3 7D: F>OI?97B 97F?J7B 799KCKB7J?ED !HJKH 7D: 'E9> 0>;?HCE:;BI?DJ;=H7J;IF7J?7B;NJ;HD7B?J?;IM?J>H;=7H:JE8EJ>F>OI?97B97F?J7B7D:J>;IFH;7:E< ADEMB;:=; ?CFBO?D=IF7J?7B>;J;HE=;D;?JO?DJ>;F7H7C;J;HIE<J>;FHE:K9J?ED<KD9J?EDB;7:?D=JE7IJ;7:O IJ7J; L7BK;<EHH;=?ED 0 M?J>IF7J?7B;NJ;HD7B?J?;I7D:=BE87BJ;9>DEBE=?97B?DJ;H:;F;D:;D9; +KH7?C?IJEFHEL?:;7D 7L;H7=;/";<<;9JEDH;=?ED7B:;L;BEFC;DJ 3;<EBBEM(EF;P 7PE,;(3 7D:!B>EHIJ,;(3 7D: 9EDI?:;HJ>7JJ>;IF;;:E<9EDL;H=;D9;?IJ>;I7C;<EH7BBH;=?EDI. . § ' BD¨¨ 0 ; © 7670 ;. § ' · § ' · ¸ = ( + β )BD¨ 0 ; − ¸ + ρ ¦ >01 BD¨ 1 ; ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ ¨ 767 1 ≠0 0 ; − ¹ 1 ; ¹ © ©. · § ¸ + β BD¨ 0 ; ¨ 767 ¸ 0 ; © ¹. · ¸ ¸ ¹ . § 7670 ; · ¸ + α 0 + µ ; + ε 0 ; + β BD¨¨ ¸ 767 − 0. ; © ¹. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. J>;=;E=H7F>?97B:?IJ7D9;8;JM;;DH;=?EDI?D9H;7I;I';BB;H /;L;H7BH;9;DJF7F;HIFHEL?:;7D;CF?H?97B.

(12) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. M>;H;. § ' 1 ; · ¸ ?I7<?HIJEH:;HIF7J?7BB7=7D: ρ H;FH;I;DJIJ>;?DJ;DI?JOE<79EDJ;CFEH7D;EKI ¸ 1 ; ¹ ©. ¦ > BD¨¨ 767 01. 1 ≠0. IF7J?7B;<<;9J %CF79JE<E>;I?ED,EB?9OED!KHEF;7D9EDL;H=;D9; 0>;FH;L?EKIIF;9?<?97J?ED?IDEM;NJ;D:;:JEM7H:I?CF79J;L7BK7J?EDE<J>;FEB?9O ?D9BK:?D=IJHK9JKH7B<KD:I JE7II;IIJ>;FEB?9O?CF79JEDH;=?ED7B=HEMJ> ? . ?H;9J;<<;9JEDH;=?ED7B:;L;BEFC;DJ. !CF?H?97B B?J;H7JKH; ED J>; ;<<;9J?L;D;II E< E>;I?ED ,EB?9O ?I CEIJ E<J;D 87I;: ED J>; D;E 9B7II?97B =HEMJ>. ;<<;9J?L;D;II E< FK8B?9 ?DL;IJC;DJ 9ED9;DJH7J;: ED ?D<H7IJHK9JKH; ?CFHEL;C;DJ 7I 7 :?H;9J ?DFKJ E< J>; FHE:K9J?EDFHE9;II $;D9; M;97D7IIKC;J>7JIJHK9JKH7B<KD:I:?H;9JBO7<<;9JH;=?ED7B=HEMJ>H7J;I7D:7I)E>B7D:$7=;D M;?DJHE:K9;J>;L7H?78B;/"?D;GK7J?ED § ' BD¨¨ 0 ; © 7670 ;. . § ' · · § ' ¸ = ( + β ) BD¨ 0 ; − ¸ + ρ ¦ >01 BD¨ 1 ; ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ ¨ 767 1 ≠0 0 ; − ¹ 1 ; ¹ © ©. § "0 ; + β BD¨¨ © 7670 ;. § "0 ; ¨ 767 0 ; ©. M>;H; BD¨. · § ¸ + β BD¨ 0 ; ¨ 767 ¸ 0 ; © ¹. · § 7670 ; · ¸ ¸ + β BD¨ ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ 0. ; − ¹ ¹ ©. · ¸ + α 0 + µ ; + ε 0 ; ¸ ¹. · ¸ ?IIJHK9JKH7B<KD:I9ECC?JC;DJI?DH;=?ED0<EHJ>;9KHH;DJF;H?E:; ¸ ¹. /JHK9JKH7B <KD:I 97D 7BIE ?D:K9; ?D:?H;9J ;<<;9JI ED ?DL;IJC;DJ ?D 8;D;<?9?7HO H;=?EDI %D <79J H;=?ED7B :?IJH?8KJ?ED E< FK8B?9 ?DL;IJC;DJ FEB?9O C7O ?D9H;7I; J>; H;JKHD E< FK8B?9 ?DL;IJC;DJ ?D H;9;?L?D= H;=?EDI ,K8B?9 ?D<H7IJHK9JKH; FHE:K9;: M?J> J>; IKFFEHJ E< IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I C7O 7BIE 7<<;9J ?D:KIJH?7B BE97J?ED 7D: ;D>7D9;H;=?ED7B7JJH79J?L;D;II /JHK9JKH7B<KD:IC7O=;D;H7J;FEI?J?L;8;D;<?J?D7H;=?ED8O?D9H;7I?D=8EJ>. § 0 ; ¨ 767 0 ; ©. FK8B?97D:FH?L7J;?DL;IJC;DJF;H97F?J7 BD¨. . · ¸ 7D:8OB;7:?D=JE7>?=>;HIJ;7:O IJ7J;?D9EC;L7BK; ¸ ¹. . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. <H7C;MEHA "?HIJBO J>; MEHA E< I9>7K;H #H7CB?9> J;D:I JE FHEL?:; ;CF?H?97B ;L?:;D9; E<.

(13) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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§ ' BD¨¨ 0 ; © 7670 ;. § ' · · § ' ¸ = ( + β ) BD¨ 0 ; − ¸ + ρ ¦ >01 BD¨ 1 ; ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ ¨ 767 1 ≠0 1 ; 0 ; − ¹ ¹ © ©. § " + β )1 + β )1 BD¨¨ 0 ; © 7670 ;. · § ¸ + β BD¨ 0 ; ¨ 767 ¸ 0 ; © ¹. § "0 ; · § 7670 ; · ¸ ¨ ¸ + β BD¨ ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ + β BD¨ 767 0 ; − ¹ 0 ; © ¹ ©. · ¸ ¸ ¹. · ¸ + α 0 + µ ; + ε 0 ; ¸ ¹. β 97FJKH;IJ>;I;B;9J?ED;<<;9J7D: β ?IJ>;7::;: L7BK;E<J>;/"<EH+H;=?EDI !9EDEC;JH?9?IIK;I I IJ7J;: ?D J>; ?DJHE:K9J?ED IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I 9ECC?JC;DJI 7H; IJHED=BO 9EHH;B7J;: M?J> F7IJ # , B;L;BI I C;DJ?ED;: 8O EKL;J 7D: 7BB;H87 J>?I 9EHH;B7J?ED 9EC;I <HEC J>; H;:?IJH?8KJ?L; 9ED9;HDI E< J>; 9E>;I?ED FEB?9O "KHJ>;HCEH; I;9J?ED :;I9H?8;I >EM J>; F7IJ # , 7<<;9JI J>; ;9EDEC?9 :;L;BEFC;DJ E< !KHEF;7D H;=?EDI )EH;EL;H M; 97D 7IIKC; J>7J J>; ;N?IJ;D9; E< IF7J?7B ?DJ;H79J?EDI 7<<;9JI 8EJ> J>; /" 7BBE97J?ED7D:J>;H;=?ED7B=HEMJ>FHE9;II;I 0>;I;9EDI?:;H7J?EDI7H;J>;H;<EH;9HK9?7B<EHJ>;;L7BK7J?EDE<J>; FEB?9O 0>?I ?I 7DEJ>;H H;7IED M>O ?J ?I ;II;DJ?7B JE J7A; ?DJE 799EKDJ 8EJ> IF7J?7B 7D: J;CFEH7B :OD7C?9I ?D 7II;II?D= J>; ?CF79J E< IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I /;9J?ED FH;I;DJI IEC; H;7IEDI M>O ?J ?I IE ?CFEHJ7DJ JE ?D9BK:; 8EJ>J;CFEH7B7D:IF7J?7B:OD7C?9I?DJ>;;IJ?C7J?EDE<J>;9E>;I?EDFEB?9O?CF79J )EH;FH;9?I;BO M;FH;I;DJ IEC; L7H?78B;I J>7J 7<<;9J 8EJ> FEJ;DJ?7B EKJ9EC;I E< J>; 9E>;I?ED FEB?9O ;9EDEC?9 :;L;BEFC;DJ 7D: J>; 7BBE97J?EDFHE9;IIE<IJHK9JKH7B<KD:I7BBE97J?ED . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. 0>;;GK7J?ED97D8;H;MH?JJ;D7I.

(14) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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§ "0 ; BD¨¨ © 7670 ;. § ' · ¸ = π ¦ >01 BD¨ 1 ; ¸ ¨ 767 1 ≠0 1 ; ¹ ©. · § ' · ¸ + π BD¨ 0 ; − ¸ + ,0 ; ¨ 767 ¸ ¸ 0 ; − ¹ © ¹. M>;H; J>; IF7J?7B B7==;: # ,. § ' 1 ; ¨ >. BD ¦ 01 ¨ 767 1 ≠0 1 ; ©. · ¸ ?I 7 IODJ>;J?9 M7O JE ?D9BK:; IF7J?7B :;J;HC?D7DJI E< J>; ¸ ¹. 7BBE97J?ED E< IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I BB J>;I; <79JEHI C7O 97KI; 9ED<KI?ED JE J>; ;NJ;DJ E< J>; ?CF79J E< 9E>;I?ED FEB?9O 7I J>;O 7<<;9J J>; :OD7C?9I E< H;=?ED7B :;L;BEFC;DJ H;=7H:B;II JE J>; ;<<;9J E< FEB?J?9I %D:;;: J>; EC?II?ED E< J>;I; JME L7H?78B;I MEKB: B;7: JE 8?7I;I J>7J MEKB: =HEM M?J> 7DO ?D9H;7I; ?D J>;?H H;IF;9J?L; 9EL7H?7D9;M?J>J>;7CEKDJE<<KD:I*-7FF;D:?N<EH7CEH;J;9>D?97BFH;I;DJ7J?EDE<J>;EC?II?ED8?7IE< ;79> 7KJEH;=H;II?L; J;HC "EH J>?I H;7IED M; IK==;IJ J>7J 7 IF7J?7B :OD7C?9 F7D;B :7J7 CE:;B ?I 7 IK?J78B; IF;9?<?97J?ED <EH C;7IKH?D= J>; ?CF79J E< 9E>;I?ED FEB?9O $EM;L;H ;IJ?C7J?ED C;J>E:I <EH IF7J?7B :OD7C?9 F7D;B :7J7 CKIJ :;7B M?J>J>H;; C7?D 7D: FEJ;DJ?7BBO 9ED9KHH;DJ FHE8B;CI ? I;H?7B :;F;D:;D9; 8;JM;;DJ>;. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. J>;7D7BOI?IEKL;J7D: 7BB;H87 %DJ>?IM7O ';CC;HB?D=7D:E:;IJ;?D I>EMIJ>7JIEC;E<.

(15) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. E8I;HL7J?EDI E< ;79> IF7J?7B KD?J EL;H J?C; ?? IF7J?7B :;F;D:;D9; 7J ;79> FE?DJ?D J?C; 7D:??? KDE8I;HL78B; ;<<;9JIIF;9?<?9JEIF79;7D:J?C;F;H?E:I !IJ?C7J?ED?DIF7J?7B:OD7C?9F7D;B7=;D;H7BH;L?;M %D B?D; M?J> H;9;DJ B?J;H7JKH; ;9A ,; (3 BED?=;D ,; (3 7 IF7J?7B 7KJEH;=H;II?L; IF;9?<?97J?ED I;;CI JE 8; 7FFHEFH?7J; JE GK7DJ?<O >EM J>; =HEMJ> H7J; E< 7 H;=?ED ?I 7<<;9J;: 8O J>; =HEMJ> H7J; ?D J>; IKHHEKD:?D=H;=?EDI 99EH:?D= JE DI;B?D 7D: 8H;K ,; (3 J>; 7::?J?ED E< 7 IF7J?7BBO B7==;: :;F;D:;DJ L7H?78B; 97KI;II?CKBJ7D;?JO7D:;D:E=;D;?JOFHE8B;CI7D:J>KI797D:?:7J;9EDI?IJ;DJ;IJ?C7JEHI>EKB:B?;8;JM;;DJ>;. :7J7/ , !B>EHIJ IK==;IJI7DKD9ED:?J?ED7BC7N?CKCB?A;B?>EE:;IJ?C7JEH<EH7D/ , CE:;BM?J> ;?J>;H 7 IF7J?7B B7= EH 7 IF7J?7B ;HHEH IJHK9JKH; KD:;H 7 H;IJH?9J?L; 7IIKCFJ?ED E< DE 7::?J?ED7B ;NFB7D7JEHO L7H?78B;I 5K ,; (3 7D: (;; 7D: 5K 7 FHEL?:; J>; 7IOCFJEJ?9 FHEF;HJ?;I E< 7 GK7I? C7N?CKC B?A;B?>EE:<EH7D/ , CE:;BM?J>;NE=;DEKI;NFB7D7JEHOL7H?78B;I )EH;H;9;DJBO 'EHD?EJ?I FHEFEI;: 7 IEBKJ?ED 87I;: ED $7>D 7D: 'K;HIJ;?D;HXI EHH;9J;: ?7I (;7IJ /GK7H;. KCCO 27H?78B; 7D:. ?DIJHKC;DJ7B C;J>E:I D:;HIED 7D: $I?7E ;NJ;D:;: JE 7BBEM <EH J>; IF7J?7B ;<<;9J )EH;EL;H J>;I; L7H?EKI ;IJ?C7JEHI C7O 8; 9ECFB;C;DJ7HO :;F;D:?D= ED M>?9> IF;9?<?97J?ED ?I 9EDI?:;H;: "EH ?DIJ7D9; 'EHD?EJ?I <E9KI;IED7VJ?C; IF79;H;9KHI?L;WCE:;BM>;H;7I5K7D:(;; MEHAED7VJ?C; IF79; :OD7C?9WIF;9?<?97J?ED !NJ;D:;:CEC;DJ9ED:?J?EDI<EHIF7J?7B:OD7C?9F7D;B:7J7 3;9EDI?:;HJ>7J#));IJ?C7JEHIFH;I;DJI;L;H7B?CFEHJ7DJ7:L7DJ7=;I "?HIJ #));D78B;I;79>IF;9?7B97I; E<J>;=;D;H7BIF;9?<?97J?EDJE8;;IJ?C7J;:M?J>EDBO7<;MCE:?<?97J?EDIJECEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDI "KHJ>;HCEH; #)) 7BBEMI J>; FEII?8B; I;H?7B 9EHH;B7J?ED E< 7::?J?ED7B L7H?78B;I JE 8; 9EDI?:;H;: 8O ?DJHE:K9?D= :?<<;H;DJ CEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDIEDJ>;;NFB7D7JEHOL7H?78B;I (;JKI9EDI?:;HJ>;=;D;H7BVJ?C; IF79;I?CKBJ7D;EKIWIF;9?<?97J?EDE<;GK7J?ED7D:. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. +(/7D:3?J>?D;IJ?C7J;I 0>;H;?I7H;B7J?L;BOH;9;DJ:;L;BEFC;DJ?DJ>;B?J;H7JKH;EDIF7J?7B:OD7C?9F7D;B.

(16) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. @0; = α@0 ; − + ρ ¦ >01 @0 ; + ?0 ; β + (η0 +ν 0 ; ) 1 ≠0. 3;H;IJH?9JEKH7JJ;DJ?EDJEJ>;IJ78B;97I; ? ; M?J> α < ρ < 7D: α + ρ < 3; 9EDI?:;H CEC;DJ H;IJH?9J?EDI ?DLEBL?D= DE 9EHH;B7J?ED 8;JM;;D <?HIJ :?<<;H;D9;: ;HHEHI 7D: ;7HB?;H B7==;: B;L;BIE< @ 0 ; − 7I:;I9H?8;:?DI;9J?ED ?. (. ). @ 0 : ∆ε 0 ; = <EH:D# 7D:; D#. (;J ?0 ; 8;:;<?D;:7I7L;9JEHE<9KHH;DJ7D:B7==;:L7BK;IE<7::?J?ED7B;NFB7D7JEHOL7H?78B;I ;F;D:?D=ED M>7J?I7IIKC;:78EKJJ>;9EHH;B7J?ED8;JM;;D ?0 ; 7D:J>;JME9ECFED;DJIE<J>;;HHEHJ;HC M;97D:;I?=D :?<<;H;DJCEC;DJ9ED:?J?EDIED: . ??. (. CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. • %< ?0 ; ?IIJH?9JBO;NE=;DEKI. ). ? 0 : ∆ε 0 ; = <EH:D#7D:; D# . • %< ?0 ; ?IM;7ABO;D:E=;DEKI ???. (. ). ? 0 : ∆ε 0 ; = <EH:D#7D:; D# . • %< ?0 ; ?IIJH?9JBO;D:E=;DEKI ?L. (. ). ? 0 : ∆ε 0 ; = <EH:D# 7D:; D# . I C;DJ?ED;:?DJ>;FH;L?EKII;9J?ED IJHK9JKH7B<KD:I9ECC?JC;DJI7H;IJHED=BO9EHH;B7J;:M?J>?D?J?7B# , M>?9> ?CFB?;I 7D E8L?EKI ;D:E=;D;?JO FHE8B;C <EH J>?I L7H?78B; $;D9; M; 9EDI?:;H J>?I L7H?78B; 7I ;D:E=;DEKI M>7J;L;HJ>;IF;9?<?97J?ED7D:J>;I;B;9J;:CEC;DJ9ED:?J?EDI;JI 0>; 9>E?9; E< CEC;DJ H;IJH?9J?EDI ED EJ>;H ;NFB7D7JEHO L7H?78B;I ?DL;IJC;DJ F;H 97F?J7 7D: :;CE=H7F>?9 =HEMJ> H7J; ?I B;II 9B;7H 0>KI EKH 9>E?9; M?BB 8; CEH; FH7=C7J?9 I;; I;9J?ED I IK==;IJ;: 8O ED: M;KI;7$7DI;D :?<<J;IJJE:?I9H?C?D7J;8;JM;;D:?<<;H;DJCEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDI;JIEDJ>;I;7::?J?ED7B L7H?78B;I . . .

(17) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. IJ>;IF7J?7BB7=?IIJH?9JBO;D:E=;DEKI J>;CEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDI:;I9H?8;:78EL;7H;DEJIK<<?9?;DJJEFHEL?:; 7D KD8?7I;: 7D: 9EDI?IJ;DJ ;IJ?C7J?ED D E8L?EKI IEBKJ?ED ?I JE ;IJ?C7J; ;GK7J?ED 7D: M?J> <KHJ>;H CEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDI9EDI?:;H?D= ¦ >01 @0 ; 7I7D;D:E=;DEKIL7H?78B; 0>;I;7::?J?ED7BCEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDI7H; 1 ≠0. MH?JJ;D?DJ>;I7C;M7O7I?. L. · § ¨¨ ¦ >01 @ 0 : ∆ε 0 ; ¸¸ = <EH:D# 7D:; D# ¹ © 1 ≠0. /F7J?7BBO M;?=>J;: ;NFB7D7JEHO L7H?78B;I. ¦> ?. 01 0 ;. 97D 8; KI;: JE ?DIJHKC;DJ J>; IF7J?7B B7= J;HC 0>;. 1 ≠0. ;NE=;DEKIF7HJE<J>;IF7J?7BB7=L7H?78?B?JO?I?:;DJ?<?;:KI?D=7VIF7J?7BBO M;?=>J;:CE:;BW 0>;L7B?:?JOE<J>?I FHE9;:KH;H;GK?H;IJ>;<EBBEM?D=CEC;DJH;IJH?9J?EDIM?J> ¦ >01 ?0 ; ;NE=;DEKI. L?. · § ¨¨ ¦ >01 ?0 ; ∆ε 0 ; ¸¸ = <EH; D# ¹ © 1 ≠0. !1IJHK9JKH7B<KD:I7D:+H;=?EDI 7J7:;I9H?FJ?ED 0>;7D7BOI;::7J7I;J>7I8;;D:;I?=D;:799EH:?D=JE;9EDEC;JH?9?IIK;I:;I9H?8;:?D/;9J?ED 3;KI;7F7D;B :7J7I;J E< H;=?EDI ?D C;C8;H IJ7J;I E< !1 I;; FF;D:?N M>?9> :;I9H?8;I J>; I;JI E< H;=?EDI ?D9BK:;:7D:;N9BK:;:?DJ>;I7CFB; +M?D=JEC?II?D=:7J7 7IC7BBDKC8;HE<H;=?EDI7H;;N9BK:;: 7CED= M>?9>I;L;H7B7H;;B?=?8B;ED+8@;9J?L;FHE=H7CC;I*;M#;HC7D(7D:;H "H;D9>EL;HI;7I;J9 3;KI; *10/:7J7B;L;B<EHJ>;C7?DF7HJE<EKHI7CFB; ;N9;FJ<EH#;HC7DO7D:J>;1D?J;:'?D=:EC<EHM>?9>:7J7 EDIJHK9JKH7B<KD:IH;=?ED7B7BBE97J?ED7H;7L7?B78B;7J*10/B;L;B "?D7BBO EKH:7J7I;JH;FH;I;DJI E<EL;H7BB!1 H;=?EDI7D: E<+8@;9J?L;H;=?EDI 0>;H;=?EDI 7H;E8I;HL;:EL;H7F;H?E:JEO;7HI 7J7 L7H?78B;I H;B7J;: JE ;GK7J?EDI JE 9EC; <HEC J>; 7C8H?:=; !9EDEC;JH?9I :7J787I; 0>; =HEII :EC;IJ?9FHE:K9J# ,7D:?DL;IJC;DJFHEL?:;:8O7C8H?:=;!9EDEC;JH?9I?D9EDIJ7DJ;KHEI>7L;. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. 1 ≠0.

(18) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. § '0 ; ¨ 767 0 ; ©. 8;;DJH7DI<EHC;:?DJEBE=7H?J>CIE<F;H97F?J7J;HCI BD¨. · § ¸ BD¨ 0 ; ¸ ¨ 767 0 ; ¹ ©. · ¸ ?DEH:;HJE9EDI?:;HJ>;I97B; ¸ ¹ § 7670 ; · ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ 0. ; − ¹ ©. ;<<;9J 0>;:;CE=H7F>?9=HEMJ>H7J;?IC;7IKH;:<HECJ>;JEJ7BFEFKB7J?ED:7J7:OD7C?9I BD¨. )E>B7D:$7=;D <E9KIJ>;?H7JJ;DJ?EDEDJ>;I>EHJ HKD=HEMJ>;<<;9JE<J>;IJHK9JKH7B<KD:IKI?D=7DDK7B :7J7ED 3;?DJ;H;IJ;:?DJ>;;<<;9JE<IJHK9JKH7B<KD:IEDBED=J;HC=HEMJ> 0>KI <EHJ>;;IJ?C7J?ED M;9EDI?:;H<?L;7==H;=7J;:J?C;F;H?E:I 7D: JE7LE?:I>EHJ. HKD L7H?7J?EDI ?D # , =HEMJ> H7J;I :K; JE 8KI?D;II 9O9B; ;<<;9JI 0>; 799KH7J; DKC8;H E< O;7HI H;GK?H;: JE 7LE?: I>EHJ HKD L7H?7J?EDI ?I IJ?BB :?I9KII;: ?D J>; B?J;H7JKH; 0;CFB; H;9ECC;D:I EH O;7HI BED=. F;H?E:I JE 9EBB;9J ?D<EHC7J?ED <HEC 7J B;7IJ JME F;H?E:I 8;<EH; J>; 8;=?DD?D= E< J>; FEB?9O 0>; F;H?E: >7I 8;;D IFB?J ?DJE F;H?E:I 7D: J>7J ?D9BK:; J>H;; :?<<;H;DJFEB?9OFHE=H7CI 7D: 0>;H;8O M;>7L;7F7D;BEDE8I;HL7J?EDIE< H;=?EDI:KH?D=F;H?E:I 0>;:OD7C?9F7D;BIF;9?<?97J?EDH;IJH?9JIJ>?IF7D;BJEF;H?E:I8;97KI;E<J>;. § '0 ; − · ¸ ¨ 767 ¸ 0>;L7H?78B;C;7IKH?D=J>;IJHK9JKH7B<KD:I9ECC?JC;DJI9EC;I<HECJ>; 0 ; − ¹ ©. 7KJEH;=H;II?L;J;HC BD¨. J> 7DDK7B H;FEHJ ED J>; IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I 7J7 ?D J>?I H;FEHJ 7H; 9EBB;9J;: EDBO ?D *10/ B;L;B <EH #;HC7DO7D:J>;1D?J;:'?D=:EC "EH:7J78;<EH; M;KI;!. "7BBE97J?ED9EBB;9J;:?DJ>;J>7DDK7B H;FEHJE<J>;!. " "?D7BBO 7BBL7H?78B;I7H;;NFH;II;:?D;KHEI /F7J?7BM;?=>JC7JH?NIF;9?<?97J?ED 0>;IF7J?7BM;?=>JC7JH?N?IKI;:JE;L7BK7J;J>;9EL7H?7D9;E<9>7H79J;H?IJ?9I79HEIIH;=?ED7BBE97J?EDI 3>?B;7 L7H?;JOE<M;?=>J?D=C7JH?9;IC7O8;9EDIJHK9J;: ?DEH:;HJE7BBEMIF7J?7B?DJ;H79J?ED J>;;CF?H?97BB?J;H7JKH; 9>EEI;IM;?=>JI87I;:ED7H9:?IJ7D9;EH9EDJ?=K?JO8;JM;;DH;=?EDI8H;K,;(3 . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. F;H?E:I 8KJ M; FH;<;HH;: JE <EBBEM J>; 7FFHE79> FHEFEI;: 8O 7:?D=;H 7D: 9>EI; GK?DGK;DD?7B J?C;.

(19) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 0>KI M; >7L; 9>EI;D 7 =;E=H7F>?97B :;<?D?J?ED E< D;?=>8EKH>EE: 87I;: ED 7H9 :?IJ7D9; 8;JM;;D H;=?EDI ?D EH:;H JE :;<?D; J>; % C7JH?N )EH; FH;9?I;BO M; >7L; 9>EI;D 7 2 D;7H;IJ D;?=>8EKHI M;?=>J IF;9?<?97J?ED . >01 2 H;FH;I;DJ?D=J>;;B;C;DJE< % C7JH?N?DHEM 0 7D:9EBKCD 1 > 01 2 = ?< 0 = 1 > 01 2 = ?< + 01 ≤ + 0 2 > 01 2 = ?< + 01 ≥ + 0 2 . + 01 ?I J>; :?IJ7D9; 8;JM;;D J>; 9;DJHE?:I E< H;=?EDI 0 7D: 1 7D: + 0 2 ?I 7 9KJ E<< :?IJ7D9; 87I;: ED J>; :?IJ7D9;E< 2 D;7H;IJD;?=>8EKH<EHH;=?ED 0 0>;?DJ;H79J?EDI7H;7IIKC;:JE8;D;=B?=?8B;78EL;J>?I:?IJ7D9; . > 01 2 /E J>;C7JH?N?IHEM IJ7D:7H:?I;: >01 2 = JEFHEL?:;;7I?;H?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED;79>M;?=>JC7O8; ¦ >01 2 1. ?DJ;HFH;J;:7IJ>;H;=?EDII>7H;?DJ>;JEJ7BIF7J?7B;<<;9JE<J>;I7CFB;7D:JEC7A;F7H7C;J;H;IJ?C7J;ICEH; 9ECF7H78B; . 2 D;7H;IJ D;?=>8EKHI I;;CI J>; 8;IJ M;?=>J C7JH?N JE H;FH;I;DJ IF7J?7B ?DJ;H79J?ED ?D EKH I7CFB; J>?I IF;9?<?97J?EDB;7:IJE;79>H;=?ED>7L?D=J>;I7C;DKC8;HE<D;?=>8EKH?D=H;=?EDI 2 ?D9BK:?D=?IB7D:I ?D EKHI7CFB; 7D:JEH;:K9?D=J>;>;J;HE=;D;?JOFHE8B;CE<H;=?ED7BIKF;H<?9?;IDI;B?D %D9EC;:OD7C?9I?D!KHEF;7DH;=?EDI (# #/!.',0'2#/00'/0'!/. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. BJ>EK=>M;>7L;9EDIJHK9J;: % M?J> 2 J>;H;IKBJI7H;I?C?B7HM?J> 2 7D: .

(20) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 078B;:;F?9JIJ>;:OD7C?9IE<# ,F 9 ?DL;IJC;DJF;H97F?J7 :;CE=H7F>?9=HEMJ>H7J;7D:IF7J?7BBOB7==;: # ,<EH+8@;9J?L;+H;=?EDI7D:EJ>;HH;=?EDI?D!KHEF; "EH;L;HOJ?C;F;H?E: +H;=?EDI;N>?8?J7# , F;H97F?J7<7HBEM;HJ>7DJ>;!KHEF;7D7L;H7=; 0>;:?<<;H;D9;8;JM;;D+7D:DED +H;=?EDI?D9H;7I;I<HEC J>; F;H?E:JE ED 7D:J>;DIBEMBO:;9H;7I;IJ?BBJE:7O '%1.# **1(2#./1/#$+.#$0#.'*0#.2#*0'+*'*!+)#*"%.+30& 50.#0)#*0/001/10&+./!(!1(0'+* ) .'"%#!+*+)#0.'!/"0 /#. "?=KH; >?=>B?=>JI J>; :?<<;H;D9; ?D # , F 9 7D: =HEMJ> H7J; 8;JM;;D + H;=?EDI 7D: *ED JH;7J;: H;=?EDI. BJ>EK=>J>;# ,F 9 =7FH;C7?DIH;B7J?L;BOIJ78B;8;<EH;7D:7<J;HJ>;E>;I?ED,EB?9OH;<EHC ED;97D I;; J>7J J>; =HEMJ> H7J;I 7H; IB?=>JBO :?<<;H;DJ 7D: CK9> CEH; ?CFEHJ7DJ <EH JH;7J;: H;=?EDI @KIJ 8;<EH; J>; H;<EHC 7D: 7J J>; ;D: E< J>; F;H?E: 9EDI?:;H;: IK==;IJ?D= J>7J J>; 97J9> KF FHE9;II ?I 7J MEHA M?J>?D 7 9ED:?J?ED7B9EDL;H=;D9;<H7C;MEHA "HECJE J>;H;=?EDIX=HEMJ>H7J;IL7HOJEECK9>JE9ED9BK:; J>7J H;=?EDI I;;C JE 9EDL;H=; JEM7H:I 9EKDJHO IF;9?<?9 IJ;7:O IJ7J; # , B;L;BI 8KJ J>; =HEMJ> H7J; =7F ?I IJ78B; 0>?IFHE9;II?IB?78B;JEIFH;7:EKJ<?HIJ7CED=J>;D;?=>8EKH?D=H;=?EDI7D:J>;D:?II;C?D7J;EL;HJ>;M>EB; !KHEF;7DIF79; +8I;HL;:IF7J?7B9EHH;B7J?EDI>?=>B?=>J7DE8L?EKIIF7J?7B:?C;DI?EDE<H;=?ED7B9EDL;H=;D9; I;;"?=KH; "?=KH;=H7F>IJ>;# , F;H 97F?J7=;E=H7F>?9F7JJ;HDH;B7J?L;JEJ>;!1 7L;H7=;# ,B;L;B <EHJ>;F;H?E:I 0>;H;=?EDI7H;IFB?J?DJE9B7II;I <HEC8;BEM E<J>;!KHEF;7D7L;H7=;JECEH;J>7D E< J>?I 7L;H7=; "EH J>; <?HIJ F;H?E: H;=?EDI M?J> ?D9EC; 8;BEM E< J>; !1 7L;H7=; 97D 8; <EKD: C7?DBO ?D J>; IEKJ>;HD F;H?F>;HO 7D: CEIJ E< J>;C 7H; ?D #H;;9; EH ,EHJK=7B IC7BB DKC8;H E< J>;I; H;=?EDI>7:# ,F 9 8;BEM E<J>;!17L;H7=;EL;HJ>;M>EB;F;H?E: )EH;FH;9?I;BOJ>;I;7H;?D/F7?D #H;;9; 7D: ,EHJK=7B !N9;FJ J>;I; F7HJ?9KB7H H;=?EDI J>; # , F 9 IF7J?7B F7JJ;HD 8;JM;;D . 7D: ?I CEH; :OD7C?9 ?D J>; F;H?F>;HO )EIJ H;=?EDI ?D /F7?D #H;;9; %H;B7D: EH ,EHJK=7B. . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. 8;<EH; 7D: 7<J;H J>; H;<EHC E< J>; E>;I?ED ,EB?9O M>?9> ?DJHE:K9;: +8@;9J?L; FHE=H7CC; ;B?=?8?B?JO .

(21) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. ;NF;H?;D9;:=HEMJ>H7J;I78EL;J>;7L;H7=;!1 =HEMJ>H7J; M>?B;J>;CEIJIF;9J79KB7HH;IKBJ?I<EH%H;B7D: ;L;D?<EDBOJMEH;=?EDI7H;9ED9;HD;: '%1.# #+%.,&'! ,00#.* +$ ,#. !,'0 .#(0'2# 0+ 0&#

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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. D;E9B7II?97B=HEMJ>;GK7J?ED078B;7I78;D9>C7HAIF;9?<?97J?ED 0>;D M;?DJHE:K9;7IF7J?7BB7=078B;.

(23) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. IF7J?7B 7KJEH;=H;II?L; J;HCI 7I ?DIJHKC;DJI <EH J>; H;=H;II?ED 1I?D= 7D EHJ>E=ED7B?JO 9ED:?J?ED 8;JM;;D J>;.

(24) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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§ '0 ; · ¸ ?CFB?;I7<7BBE<J>; + β 9E;<<?9?;DJ ¸ 0. ; © ¹. ¦ > BD¨¨ 767 01. 1 ≠0. <HEC JE M>?B; J>; 9E;<<?9?;DJI 7IIE9?7J;: M?J> ?DL;IJC;DJ 7D: :;CE=H7F>?9 =HEMJ> 9>7D=; L;HO IB?=>JBO J>; B7IJ <?L; 9EBKCDI E< 078B; 3?J>?D J>; / , IF;9?<?97J?ED M; <?D: ;CF?H?97B ;L?:;D9; E< 9ED:?J?ED7B 9EDL;H=;D9; E< !KHEF;7D H;=?EDI EDL;H=;D9; >;H; D;J E< IF7J?7B IF?BBEL;H ?I <7IJ;H M>;D M; 9EDI?:;H J>; ?CF79J E< D;?=>8EKH?D= ?D9EC; ED H;=?ED7B :;L;BEFC;DJ 0>?I FHE9;II ?I IJHED=BO 7<<;9J;: 8O IF7J?7B :;F;D:;D9; %D <79J J>; IF7J?7B B7= 9E;<<?9?;DJ IK==;IJI 7 IJHED= I?=D?<?97DJ ?CF79J E< IF7J?7B IF?BBEL;H;<<;9JI8;JM;;D!KHEF;7DH;=?EDI?DJ>;?H:OD7C?9IE<:;L;BEFC;DJ . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. 0>; H;=H;II?ED H;IKBJI 078B; E< J>; D;E 9B7II?97B 9EDL;H=;D9; ;GK7J?ED 7H; CEIJBO 9EDI?IJ;DJ M?J> J>;.

(25) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. 0>; I?CFB; :OD7C?9 F7D;B IF;9?<?97J?ED J>7J J7A;I ?DJE 799EKDJ J>; IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I 7I 7D 7::?J?ED7B L7H?78B; 7BBEMI KI JE 9ECF7H; J>; H;IKBJI M?J> FH;L?EKIIJK:?;I 078B; 0>; IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I I;;C JE :?H;9JBO 7<<;9J H;=?ED7B:;L;BEFC;DJ 8KJDEJM?J>J>;;NF;9J;:I?=DD;=7J?L;I?=D?<?97DJ;<<;9J $EM;L;H J>;;<<;9J8;9EC;I FEI?J?L; <EH J>; IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I 7BBE97J;: ?D +8@;9J?L; FHE=H7CC;I 0>; C7=D?JK:; E< J>; ;<<;9J ?I 9ECF7H7J?L;BO ?CFEHJ7DJ ?DB?D; M?J>FH;L?EKIH;IKBJI )E>B 7D: $7=;D KIIEB;JJ? 7D: !IFEIJ? ?D7I7C;I?CFB;:OD7C?9F7D;BIF;9?<?97J?EDM?J>EKJIF7J?7BB7= (#

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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. (# /0')0'+*+$3'0&"'.#!0#$$#!0+$/0.1!01.($1*"/#- *"

(27) .

(28) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. JEJ>;;B7IJ?9?JO;IJ?C7J;:8OI9>7K;HED1 / :7J77D:<EH7BBFK8B?9?DL;IJC;DJI7D:?DJ>;H7D=;E< ;B7IJ?9?J?;I97B9KB7J;:8O!IFEIJ?7D:KIIEB;JJ? )EH;EL;H ?J?IMEHJ>M>?B;DEJ?D=J>7JJ>;9KCKB7J?L;?CF79JE<DED +<KD:I?ID;=7J?L;8KJL;HOBEMM>;D ;IJ?C7J;: M?J>EKJ IF7J?7B ;<<;9JI KJ J>; ;<<;9J E< J>;I; <KD:I ?I DEJ I?=D?<?97DJBO :?<<;H;DJ <HEC M>;D M; ?DJHE:K9;J>;IF7J?7B;<<;9JI 0>;9KCKB7J?L;?CF79JE<J>;+<KD:I97B9KB7J;:<HECJ>;IF7J?7B:OD7C?9CE:;B ?IDEJD;=B?=?8B;7D?D9H;7I;E< E<+<KD:I=;D;H7J;I7D7L;H7=;?D9H;7I;E< E<# ,F;H97F?J7B;L;B E<H;9?F?;DJH;=?EDIM>?9>?IBEM;HJ>7D97B9KB7J;:M?J>DED IF7J?7B;IJ?C7J;I 3;7BIEDEJ;J>7JJ>;?CF79JE< IK8I?:?;IEDJ>;+H;=?ED7B:;L;BEFC;DJ=HEKD:I<EHJME J>?H:IE<?JI;<<;9JJ>;I>EHJJ;HC <EHJ>;I>EHJ J;HC7D: <EHJ>;BED=J;HC . (#1)1(0'2#*""'.#!0'),!0+$"#.'2#"$.+)#/0')0#/+$0 (#/

(29) *" . I C;DJ?ED;: ?D I;9J?ED IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I C7O =;D;H7J; 7 FEI?J?L; 8;D;<?J ?D 7 H;=?ED 8O ?D9H;7I?D= 8EJ> FK8B?9 7D: FH?L7J; ?DL;IJC;DJ F;H 97F?J7 7D: B;7:?D= JE 7 >?=>;H IJ;7:O IJ7J; ?D9EC; L7BK; 3; J;IJ J>; HE8KIJD;II E< EKH H;IKBJI 8O ;IJ?C7J?D= ;GK7J?ED M?J>EKJ ?DL;IJC;DJ F;H 97F?J7 078B; 0>?I EC?II?ED I?=D?<?97DJBO7<<;9JIJ>;L7BK;E<J>;7KJEH;=H;II?L;J;HCM>?9><7BBIJE7HEKD: 7D:J>;L7BK;E<J>;IF7J?7B B7=9E;<<?9?;DJM>?9>?D9H;7I;I<HEC 078B;JE7HEKD: $EM;L;H 8;OED:J>;9>7D=;?DL7BK;E<J>;I; 9E;<<?9?;DJI:K;JEJ>;EC?II?EDE<7A;OL7H?78B; ?DL;IJC;DJF;H97F?J7 J>;C7?DH;IKBJIM?J>H;=7H:JEJ>; ?CF79J E< IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I 7H; DEJ 7<<;9J;: 0EJ7B IJHK9JKH7B <KD: 9ECC?JC;DJI :EDJ I?=D?<?97DJBO 7<<;9J !KHEF;7DH;=?ED7B=HEMJ> M>;H;7I<KD:I7BBE97J;:?D+8@;9J?L;FHE=H7CC;I:E 3;97DC;DJ?ED >EM;L;H J>7JJ>;9E;<<?9?;DJ7IIE9?7J;:M?J>+8@;9J?L;<KD:IH?I;IIB?=>JBO<EBBEM?D=J>;EC?II?EDE<J>;?DL;IJC;DJF;H 97F?J7 (#/0')0'+*+$#-10'+*

(30) 3'0&+10'*2#/0)#*0,!. . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. .

(31) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. "?D7BBO M;9>;9AJ>;I;DI?J?L?JOE<EKHH;IKBJIJEJ>;FH;I;D9;E<IJHK9JKH7B<KD:IIF?BBEL;H;<<;9J078B; 3; ;N9BK:;EJ>;HIF7J?7BB7=L7H?78B;I8;97KI;J>;O97DDEJ8;9ED<EKD:;:M?J>J>;;<<;9JE<J>;/JHK9JKH7B"KD:I J>;I;IF7J?7BB7=IMEKB:8;EHJ>E=ED7BJEJ>;7BBE97J?EDE<IJHK9JKH7B<KD:I 3;97DDEJ;J>7JJ>;?DJHE:K9J?ED E<J>?IL7H?78B;:E;IDEJH7:?97BBO7<<;9JJ>;?DJ;HFH;J7J?EDE<EKHH;IKBJIJ>;;<<;9JE<<KD:I<EHEJ>;HFHE=H7CI H;C7?DI ?DI?=D?<?97DJ M>?B; J>; <KD:I IJ?BB FEI?J?L;BO 7<<;9J + H;=?EDI M?J> J>; I7C; C7=D?JK:; 7I ?D J>; FH;L?EKI;IJ?C7J?ED078B; 0>;B;L;BE<<KD:IH;9;?L;:8O7H;=?EDI;;CIJE8;9EHH;B7J;:FEI?J?L;BOM?J>J>; :;L;BEFC;DJ E< J>; H;=?EDI IKHHEKD:?D= ?J M>?9> 7BBEMI KI JE IK==;IJ FEI?J?L; IF?BBEL;H ;<<;9JI E< IJHK9JKH7B <KD:IEDH;=?ED7B=HEMJ> . ED9BKI?ED 0>; 7?C E< J>?I F7F;H ?I JE ;CF?H?97BBO ?DL;IJ?=7J; J>; ?CF79J E< E>;I?ED ,EB?9O ED !KHEF;7D H;=?ED7B 9EDL;H=;D9; 1I?D=7:OD7C?9F7D;B:7J7I;JE<H;=?EDIEL;HJ>;F;H?E: M;9EDI?:;H?DJ>;I7C; <H7C;MEHAJ>;IF7J?7B:;F;D:;D9?;I7D:J>;?CF79J7D7BOI?I 3?J>?DJ>;<H7C;MEHAE<7IF7J?7B:OD7C?9F7D;BIF;9?<?97J?ED M;<?D:;CF?H?97B;L?:;D9;J>7JJ>;E>;I?ED ,EB?9O<EIJ;HIJ>;;D:E=;DEKI:;L;BEFC;DJE<+8@;9J?L;H;=?EDI?D!KHEF; )EH;EL;H EKHH;IKBJI9ED<?HCJ>7J J>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O M>?9>7?CI7J9EKDJ;H87B7D9?D=J>;;<<;9JIE<# ,9ED9;DJH7J?EDEL;HJ>;H?9>;IJH;=?EDI 7JJ7?DIJ>?IE8@;9J?L; +KHH;IKBJIIK==;IJJ>7J+8@;9J?L;FHE=H7CC;I>7L;7:?H;9J;<<;9JEDH;=?ED7B# ,F 9 =HEMJ> H7J;I M>;H;7I JEJ7B IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I :E DEJ 3; ?DJ;HFH;J J>?I H;IKBJ 7I 7D +8@;9J?L; FHE=H7CC;I 7::;: L7BK; 9ECF7H;: JE JEJ7B IJHK9JKH7B <KD:I 0>?I <?D:?D= 9EKB: 8; ;NJ;D:;: JE J>; ;IJ?C7J?ED E< ?D:?H;9J ;<<;9JIEDDED +8@;9J?L;H;=?EDI; = J>HEK=>7J;9>DEBE=O:?<<KI?ED;<<;9J8KJJ>;O:EDEJ7BBEM7::?J?ED7B =HEMJ> IF;9?<?97BBO ?D J>;I; H;=?EDI M>;D M; 9EDI?:;H J>; IF7J?7B :;F;D:;D9;I 0>?I <H7C;MEHA 9EKB: 8; ;NJ;D:;:JEJ7A;?DJE799EKDJJ>;FEJ;DJ?7B:?<<KI?ED;<<;9JI?CFB?;:8O7IJHK9JKH7B9>7D=;?D:K9;:8OIJHK9JKH7B <KD:I;NF;D:?JKH;?DJ>;CEH;7:L7D9;:H;=?EDI . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. (#/0')0'+*+$#-10'+*

(32) 3'0&/,'((+2#./#$$#!0.

(33) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi : 080/00343404.2011.628930. D7BOI?D= J>; IF7J?7B :?C;DI?ED E< J>; F7D;B :7J7 M; <?D: J>7J H;=?ED7B IF?BBEL;HI :E >7L; 7D ?CF79J ED H;=?ED7B:;L;BEFC;DJ 0>;E>;I?ED,EB?9O9EKDJ;H87B7D9;IJ>;D;=7J?L;;<<;9JEDH;=?ED7B:;L;BEFC;DJJ>7J E99KHIM>;DJ>;H?9>;IJH;=?EDI9ED9;DJH7J;?D9EC;7D:79J?L?J?;IEDJ>;CI;BL;I %J?I>EM;L;HEKHEF?D?EDJ>7J ?CFHEL?D=H;=?ED7BIF?BBEL;HI97D9EDJH?8KJ;JE<EIJ;HJ>;;D:E=;DEKI:;L;BEFC;DJE<H;=?ED7B9BKIJ;HI 7I>7I 8;;D :;CEDIJH7J;: M?J> %DJ;HH;=?ED7B EEF;H7J?ED ,HE=H7CC;I %DJ;HH;= 1BJ?C7J;BO J>; E>;I?ED ,EB?9O ?I ?CFB;C;DJ;:7BED=M?J>EJ>;H!1FEB?9?;IB?A;7=H?9KBJKH7BFEB?9?;I ?D:KIJH?7BH;=KB7J?EDIJ>7J97D<7LEKHEH >7CF;H J>; ;<<;9JI E< J>?I FEB?9O !NJ;D:?D= EKH 7D7BOI?I JEM7H:I D7J?ED7B H;:?IJH?8KJ?L; ;<<;9JI D7J?ED7B F;DI?ED?D= IJH7J;=?;I 7D: H;=?ED7B 9BKIJ;H?D= 97D >;BF JE :;I?=D CEH; ;<<?9?;DJ FEB?9?;I JEM7H: H;=?ED7B :;L;BEFC;DJ )EH;EL;H ?J MEKB: 8; ?DJ;H;IJ?D= JE KI; J>?I JOF; E< CE:;B / , JE I?CKB7J; J>; :?<<KI?ED. J>7J:;J;HC?D;IIJ;7:OIJ7J;?D9EC;7D:?DI?CKB7J?D=J>;;<<;9JE<7D?D9H;7I;E<J>?IIJ;7:OIJ7J;7I7I>E9A :K;JEIJHK9JKH7B<KD:I;NF;D:?JKH;EDD;?=>8EKH?D=EKJ9EC;I $EM;L;H J>?IFHEFEI?J?EDH;GK?H;IJ7A?D=?DJE 799EKDJJ>;?CF79JE<J>?II>E9AEDH;=?ED7B7D:D7J?ED7B8;>7L?EKHH;IF;9J?L;BO; = ?DFK8B?9?DL;IJC;DJ?D EH:;HJEDEJH;BOEDJEEH;IJH?9J?L;7IIKCFJ?EDIIK9>7IJ>;7IIKCFJ?EDJ>7JJ>;I>E9AI7H;FHEFEHJ?ED7BJEJ>; 7CEKDJE<<KD:I7BBE97J;:JEH;=?EDI

(34) 0>;7KJ>EHI7H;=H7J;<KBJEJ>;F7HJ?9?F7DJIE<J>;%DJ;HD7J?ED7BED<;H;D9;E<J>;.;=?ED7B/JK:?;IIIE9?7J?ED ,R9I )7O JEJ>;F7HJ?9?F7DJIJEJ>;%4J> 3EHAI>EFE</F7J?7B!9EDEC;JH?9I +HBR7DI &KD; 7D:JE JME7DEDOCEKIH;L?;M;HI 0>?I FK8B?97J?ED >7I 8;;D <KD:;: KD:;H J>; ,.%) 9EBB78EH7J?L; FHE@;9J !1 J> "H7C;MEHA ,HE=H7CC; 0>;C;!*2 !DL?HEDC;DJ?D9BK:?D=9B?C7J;9>7D=;!KHEF;7DECC?II?ED #.;I;7H9> 9EDJH79J DE %JI 9EDJ;DJ :E;I DEJ H;FH;I;DJ J>; E<<?9?7B FEI?J?ED E< J>; !KHEF;7D ECC?II?ED 7D: ?I ;DJ?H;BO KD:;HJ>;H;IFEDI?8?B?JOE<J>;7KJ>EHI . . . CemOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. ;<<;9JI:K;JEIJHK9JKH7BFEB?9O?D!KHEF; 0>?IIJK:OC7O8;9EDI?:;H;:7<?HIJIJ;F?D;IJ?C7J?D=J>;;GK7J?ED.

(35) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. */!(%* ( 1D:;HJ>;>EE:?IIK;I?DJ>;IF;9?<?97J?ED7D:?DJ;HFEB7J?EDE<IF7J?7BH;=H;II?ED.

(36) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. 630;0*(3*6564@ .

(37) Author-produced version of the article published in Regional Studies, 2013, 47 (9), 1573-1593. The original publication is available at http://www.tandfonline.com/ doi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emOA : archive ouverte d'Irstea / Cemagref. ,EB?9O 7D: J>; /E9?E ;9EDEC?9 ?I7:L7DJ7=; E< !KHEF;7D .;=?EDI !,.065(3 ";<+0,: .