Precise
positioning in multi-GNSS mode
Cécile Deprez & René Warnant Novembre 2017
Compatibilities
between GNSS
BeiDou E5a E6 L2 B2 B3 Lower L-Band L5 E1 L1 B1 Upper L-Band Frequency (Mhz) GPS Galileo BeiDou E5b B1 BeiDou III E5a+b B2 More satellites available
Benefits
of multi-GNSS
BeiDou + Galileo
Addition
of
GNSS
rises
the number of visible
satellites
Galileo BeiDou
4.7 4.8
Mean number of visible satellites/day
GPS
8.7
7.3
Galileo + GPS
Benefits
of multi-GNSS
More satellites available
• Satellites visible anywhere anytime • Improved satellite geometry
P
osition
D
ilution
O
f
P
recision
T
he
geometry
of the satellites affects the position precision :
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 GPS Galileo BDS P DO P 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
E1/L1 E5a/L5 E5b/B2
GPS L1 + Galileo E1 GPS L5 + Galileo E5a Galileo E5b + BeiDou B2
Multi-GNSS
solution
improves
geometry
DOP v
New frequencies available
Benefits
of multi-GNSS
More satellites available
• Satellites visible anywhere anytime • Improved satellite geometry
0.20 0.19 0.15 L1 L2 L5 0.24 0.17 B1 B2 0.13 0.16 0.16 0.06
E1 E5a E5b E5a+b
BDS Galileo
GPS Metres
Best precisions
with
Galileo
code signals
New signals = more robust
𝜎
𝑃𝑂𝑆= 𝐷𝑂𝑃. 𝜎
𝑂𝐵𝑆Benefits
of multi-GNSS
More satellites available
• Satellites visible anywhere anytime • Improved satellite geometry
Improved precision on position New frequencies available
0 1 2 3 GPS Galileo BDS Pr ecisi on on pos it io n (3D RMS) 0 1 2 3
E1/L1 E5a/L5 E5b/B2
Me
tr
es
Multi-GNSS
solution leads to
more precise positions
regardless of the type of receiver used
GPS L1 + Galileo E1 GPS L5 + Galileo E5a Galileo E5b + BeiDou B2
Benefits
of multi-GNSS
More satellites available
• Satellites visible anywhere anytime • Improved satellite geometry
Improved precision on position New frequencies available
Drawbacks
of multi-GNSS
Differences between GNSS • Coordinate systems • Time systems • Hardware delaysadditional biases
negligible estimable constant variable Additional unknown RemovedISBs
are
receiver-dependent
University of Liège
Trimble
Septentrio
R9 R9x5
xS
x4
x4
Mixed-receiver
pairsIdentical-receiver
pairsMean:
1.52 m
Mean:
0.00 m
2014 2015 2016
ISBs
are
stable
across years
Mean:
2.85 m
Mean:
2.83 m
Mean:
2.85 m
Firmware updates
for phases
Receiver multipath filter
for codes
ISBs
might be
affected
by
After
Before
After
Conclusion
Drawbacks of multi-GNSS • Coordinate systems • Time systems
• Hardware delays Constant - Receiver and frequency dependent
Constant – given in the ephemeris data Negligible
Benefits of multi-GNSS • Availability
• Position precision improvement • Reliability
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
E1/L1 E5a/L5 E5b/B2
M
ulti-GNSS
improves
positioning results
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 GPS Galileo BDS P DO P P reci sion on p os itio n Obs Metres Metres