From ideas to policymaking : the political economy of the diffusion of performance-based financing at the global, continental, and national levels
Texte intégral
(2) ! $`N?PRCKCLRBCK`BCAGLCQMAG?JCCRNP`TCLRGTC ZAMJCBCQ?LR`NS@JGOSC 5LGTCPQGR`BC-MLRP`?J CR #CLRPCB{ZRSBCQCL3AGCLACQ3MAG?JCQQSPJCQ-MLBCQ!DPGA?GLQ !K`PGA?GLQCR!QG?RGOSCQ 5LGTCPQGR`0?PGQ$GBCPMR . 4FaQCNP`QCLR`CCLAMRSRCJJC CLTSCBCJ{M@RCLRGMLBSEP?BCBC0FGJMQNFG?C$MARMP 0F$ CL3?LR`0S@JGOSC MNRGML3?LR`KMLBG?JC 5LGTCPQGR`BC-MLRP`?J CL3AGCLACQ`AMLMKGOSCQ 5LGTCPQGR`0?PGQ$GBCPMR . !TPGJ. m,?P?'?SRGCP .
(3) . . . . . . 5LGTCPQGR`BC-MLRP`?J &?ASJR`BCQ`RSBCQQSN`PGCSPCQCRNMQRBMARMP?JCQ 5LGTCPQGR`0?PGQ$GBCPMR ZAMJCBMARMP?JCZAMLMKGCQ CQN?ACQ QMAG`R`Q AGTGJGQ?RGMLQNCLQ`CAPGRGOSC NMJGRGOSCCR NP?RGOSCQQMAG?JCQ #CRRCRFaQCGLRGRSJ`C &PMKGBC?QRMNMJGAWK?IGLERFCNMJGRGA?JCAMLMKWMDRFCBGDDSQGMLMDNCPDMPK?LAC@?QCB DGL?LAGLE?RRFCEJM@?J AMLRGLCLR?J ?LBL?RGML?JJCTCJQ 0P`QCLR`CN?P ,?P?'?SRGCP ?`R``T?JS`CN?PSLHSPWAMKNMQ`BCQNCPQMLLCQQSGT?LRCQ 2MQCP#SQQg 0P`QGBCLRC )Q?@CJJC'S`PGL $GPCARPGACBCPCAFCPAFC 6?J`PW2GBBC $GPCARCSPBCPCAFCPAFC -?LSCJ?$C!JJCEPG #MBGPCARPGACBCPCAFCPAFC (`JaLC#F?PRML -CK@PCBSHSPW "MPGQ3?KSCJ -CK@PCBSHSPW #FPGQRGLC2MRFK?WP!JJGQML 2?NNMPRCSP "PSLM"MGBGL 2?NNMPRCSP .
(4) . . "+) 4B83J4BI;0?A8B4343J28B8>=;NJ2>=><84?>;8C8@D434;03855DB8>=3D58=0=24<4=C10BJ BDA;0?4A5>A<0=240DG=8E40DG6;>10;2>=C8=4=C0;4C=0C8>=0;. 1*,%1 &A>1;J<0C8@D4 ,C A?P?ARaPC NMJWACLRPGOSC BC J? EMSTCPL?LAC BC Q?LR` KMLBG?JC D?GR `KCPECP BCNSGQSLCTGLER?GLCB{?LL`CQBCQNhJCQB{GLDJSCLACNMJGRGOSCBCBGDD`PCLRQLGTC?SV$CNSGQJ?DGL BCQ?LL`CQ BCQ?ARCSPQGLDJSCLRQ?NNSGCLRJ?KGQCCLuSTPCB{SLCP`DMPKCBCDGL?LACKCLR BC J? Q?LR` JC DGL?LACKCLR @?Q` QSP J? NCPDMPK?LAC &"0 ,C &"0 PCNMQC QSP JC RP?LQDCPR BC PCQQMSPACQDGL?LAGaPCQAMLBGRGMLLCJJCQ\J?NCPDMPK?LACBCQNPCQR?R?GPCQBCQ?LR`%LB`NGRB{SLC ?@QCLAC B{SL?LGKGR` QSP JCQ NPCSTCQ QAGCLRGDGOSCQ BC QML CDDGA?AGR` J? NMJGRGOSC ? `R` CVN`PGKCLR`C B?LQ NJSQ BC BCQ N?WQ B{!DPGOSC QS@Q?F?PGCLLC ,CQ NPMHCRQ BC &"0 QMLR NPMKSQ N?P BCQ P`QC?SV B{CVNCPRQ RP?LQL?RGML?SV LMSTC?SV ?ARCSPQ BC J? EMSTCPL?LAC NMJWACLRPGOSC DGL?LA`Q N?P BCQ @?GJJCSPQ BC DMLBQ CR ?NNSW`Q N?P BCQ ?QQGQR?LRQ RCAFLGOSCQ NPMTCL?LR JC NJSQ QMSTCLR B{%SPMNC CR B{!K`PGOSC BS .MPB !SBCJ\ BS NMSTMGP DGL?LAGCP ACQ ?ARCSPQ CVCPACLR B{?SRPCQ DMPKCQ BC NMSTMGP KMGLQ TGQG@JCQ NMSP QRGKSJCP J? BGDDSQGML BC ACRRC NMJGRGOSC)LRPMBSGQ?LRJCAMLACNRB{xCLRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGMLy LMSQSRGJGQMLQSLC?NNPMAFC B{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC NMSP AMKNPCLBPC JCQ GLRCP?ARGMLQ QMAG?JCQ CL HCS B?LQ JC NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGML CLRPC JCQ ?ARCSPQ ?EGQQ?LR ?SV LGTC?SV EJM@?J AMLRGLCLR?J CR L?RGML?J ?GLQG OSC JCQ PCJ?RGMLQ BC NMSTMGP ?QWK`RPGOSCQ GLF`PCLRCQ \ ACQ GLRCP?ARGMLQ 0MSP ACJ? LMSQ P`?JGQMLQ SLC `RSBCGLRCPNP`R?RGTC\LGTC?SVB{?L?JWQCGK@PGOS`Q EJM@?J AMLRGLCLR?J L?RGML?J 03A42>=24?CD4;.MSQSRGJGQMLQSLA?BPCAMLACNRSCJGLRCPBGQAGNJGL?GPCCKNPSLR?LR?SVAF?KNQ BCQNMJGRGOSCQNS@JGOSCQ BCQPCJ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQ CRBCJ?Q?LR`KMLBG?JC.MSQ?L?JWQMLQJCQ A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQ BCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGML v JCSPQ QWQRaKCQ BC PCNP`QCLR?RGML JCSP NCPACNRGMLBSKMLBCCRNP`QSNNMQ`QQMSQH?ACLRQ PCQQMSPACQ RWNCQB{?SRMPGR` CRKMRGT?RGMLQv CR JCQ QRP?R`EGCQ OS{GJQ SRGJGQCLR NMSP D?TMPGQCP J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 #CQ QRP?R`EGCQ GLAJSCLR J{?LAP?EC GB`?RGMLLCJ BC J? NMJGRGOSC EDA>8N ;G6B>C< J? QRGKSJ?RGML BC J{`KSJ?RGML N?P J? AMLQRGRSRGML BC P`QC?SV EDA>8N :BJA6I>DC J? AMLBSGRC BC J{?ECLB? B{?NNPCLRGQQ?EC QSP JC &"0 EDA>8N A:6GC>C< CR J? DGV?RGML BC QR?LB?PBQ CR A?BPCQ BC AMJJ?@MP?RGML NMSP ?QQSPCP SLC CVN`PGKCLR?RGMLP`SQQGCBS&"0 EDA>8N:ME:G>B:CI6I>DC . G.
(5) . . #JC7>3>;>684 ,{M@HCRNPGLAGN?JBCJ?RFaQCCQRJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0CL!DPGOSCQS@Q?F?PGCLLC OSG Q{?PRGASJC ?SRMSP B{GLDJSCLRQ qCLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGMLr AGLO MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ RPMGQ P`QC?SVRP?LQL?RGML?SV CRNJSQB{SLCTGLER?GLCB{GLBGTGBSQ 4PMGQ`RSBCQMLR`R`P`?JGQ`CQ\RPMGQ LGTC?SV BGDD`PCLRQ LGTC?S EJM@?J ?PaLCQ NMJGRGOSCQ BC Q?LR` KMLBG?JC CR GLQRGRSRQ BC PCAFCPAFC CSPMN`CLQ LGTC?S AMLRGLCLR?J !DPGOSC QS@Q?F?PGCLLC CR LGTC?S L?RGML?J A?Q BS -?JG ,{?NNPMAFC B{?L?JWQC CQR NPGLAGN?JCKCLR OS?JGR?RGTC LMSQ ?TMLQ AMJJCAR` BCQ BMLL`CQ B{CLRPCRGCLQ ?NNPMDMLBGQ . B{M@QCPT?RGMLQ N?PRGAGN?LRCQ . CR BC BMASKCLRQ . $?LQJ{`RSBC\`AFCJJCAMLRGLCLR?JC ACQBMLL`CQOS?JGR?RGTCQQMLRAMKNJ`R`CQN?PBCQ?L?JWQCQBC P`QC?SVQMAG?SVCRBCQ?L?JWQCQQ`K?LRGOSCQ\N?PRGPBCKCQQ?ECQBCDMPSK#CQBMLL`CQ OS?LRGR?RGTCQAMKNJaRCLRJ?A?P?AR`PGQ?RGMLBCJ{SLBCQP`QC?SVRP?LQL?RGML?SVCRQMLGLDJSCLACQSP J?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0 +0;4DA 34 ;0 A4274A274 #CRRC PCAFCPAFC AMLQRGRSC J? NPCKGaPC ?L?JWQC B{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC B`R?GJJ?LR BCQ NPMACQQSQ KSJRGLGTC?SV CR NPMR`GDMPKCQ BGQAMSPQ AMLQRGRSRGML CL P`QC?SV CR NPMBSARGMLCRBGQQ`KGL?RGMLBCKSJRGNJCQDMPKCQBCQ?TMGPQ AMLBSGRQN?PBCQ?ARCSPQGLDJSCLRQv JCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGML v ?DGL BC D?AGJGRCP J? BGDDSQGML B{SLC GLLMT?RGML NMJGRGOSC JC &"0 B?LQ JC AMLRCVRC N?PRGASJGCP BC J? EMSTCPL?LAC NMJWACLRPGOSC #CRRC `RSBC ?NNMPRC B{GKNMPR?LRCQAMLRPG@SRGMLQRF`MPGOSCQCRCKNGPGOSCQ\J?JGRR`P?RSPC0PCKGaPCKCLR CJJCMDDPCSL A?BPC AMLACNRSCJ LMT?RCSP ?B?NR` ?S AMLRCVRC BC J? Q?LR` KMLBG?JC CR BC J? EMSTCPL?LAC NMJWACLRPGOSC OSGNCSRbRPC?NNJGOS`\BGTCPQRWNCQBCPCAFCPAFC$CSVGaKCKCLR CJJCDMSPLGRBCQ ?L?JWQCQCKNGPGOSCQSRGJCQQSPJCQNPMACQQSQBCEMSTCPL?LACNMJWACLRPGOSC OSGMLR`R`HSQOS{GAG NCS `RSBG`Q -CRR?LR CL JSKGaPC J{CVCPAGAC BS NMSTMGP B{?ARCSPQ CSPMN`CLQ CR LMPB?K`PGA?GLQ B?LQJCSPGLRCP?ARGML?TCABCQAMLQSJR?LRQCRB`AGBCSPQ?DPGA?GLQ ACRRC`RSBCMSTPC`E?JCKCLRJ? TMGC\B{?SRPCQPCAFCPAFCQ LMR?KKCLRQSPJCNF`LMKaLCBCD?@PGOSCB{SLCCVNCPRGQC?DPGA?GLC. '+*$* $GDDSQGML BCQ NMJGRGOSCQ !L?JWQC B{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC &GL?LACKCLR @?Q` QSP J? NCPDMPK?LAC %LRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGML !DPGOSCQS@3?F?PGCLLC. . . . GG.
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w RFCGP PCNPCQCLR?RGML QWQRCKQ RFCGP SLBCPJWGLE ?QQSKNRGMLQ ?@MSR RFC UMPJB PCQMSPACQ RWNCQMD?SRFMPGRW ?LBKMRGT?RGMLQw?LBRFCQRP?RCEGCQRFCWSQCRMNPMKMRC RFC BGDDSQGML MD 0"& 4FCQC QRP?RCEGCQ GLAJSBC NMJGAW DP?KGLE QRGKSJ?RGLE CKSJ?RGML RFPMSEF NMJGAW CKSJ?RGML BPGTGLE RFC JC?PLGLE ?ECLB? ML NMJGAW JC?PLGLE &"0 ?LB RFC QCRRGLE MD QR?LB?PBQ ?LB DP?KCUMPIQ MD AMJJ?@MP?RGML RM CLQSPC ? QSAACQQDSJ CVNCPGKCLR?RGML MD RFC &"0 NMJGAWCVNCPGKCLR?RGML . . GGG.
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{QQRPSARSPC?LBFMU GRGLDJSCLACQNMJGAWBGDDSQGML '4B40A27 E0;D4 4FGQ PCQC?PAF GQ RFC DGPQR NMJGRGA?J CAMLMKW ?L?JWQGQ BCR?GJGLE KSJRGJCTCJ ?LB KSJRGD?ACRCBNPMACQQCQ BGQAMSPQC LCRUMPIQ ?LBNPMBSARGML?LBBGQQCKGL?RGMLMDKSJRGNJCDMPKQ MD ILMUJCBEC JCB @W GLDJSCLRG?J NMJGAW ?ARMPQ w BGDDSQGML CLRPCNPCLCSPQ w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{ CVCPAGQC MD NMUCP GL RFCGP GLRCP?ARGML UGRF !DPGA?L AMLQSJR?LRQ ?LB NMJGAWK?ICPQ RFGQ QRSBW?JQMN?TCQRFCU?WDMPDSRSPCPCQC?PAFwN?PRGASJ?PJWMLRFCNFCLMKCLMLMDRFCK?IGLEMD ?L!DPGA?LCVNCPRGQC . /.')* 0MJGAW $GDDSQGML 0MJGRGA?J %AMLMKW !L?JWQGQ 0CPDMPK?LAC"?QCB &GL?LAGLE $GDDSQGML %LRPCNPCLCSPQFGN 3S@3?F?P?L!DPGA?. . . . GT.
(8) . . 1*,%11+"$$1&)&0"* . 1752'8&7,21 *#2+64' ,C A?P?ARaPC NMJWACLRPGOSC BC J? EMSTCPL?LAC BC Q?LR` KMLBG?JC D?GR `KCPECP BCNSGQ SLC TGLER?GLCB{?LL`CQBCQNhJCQB{GLDJSCLACNMJGRGOSCBCBGDD`PCLRCQDMPKCQ /QRPMK 4MQSL ,?EMSTCPL?LACEDAN8:CIG>FJ:A?P?AR`PGQCSLCAMLDGESP?RGMLB?LQJ?OSCJJCNJSQGCSPQSLGR`Q BCEMSTCPLCKCLR NCV MPE?LGQ?RGMLKSJRGJ?R`P?JC %R?R TGJJC ?EGQQ?LR\BGDD`PCLRQLGTC?SV N CV EJM@?J L?RGML?J P`EGML?J CVCPACLR JCSP ?ARGTGR` B{`J?@MP?RGML BC LMPKCQ CR PaEJCQ B?LQ SL BMK?GLCBMLL`BCD?_MLJ?PECKCLRTMGPCRMR?JCKCLR?SRMLMKC /QRPMK ,{?SRMLMKGCBC ACQ BGDD`PCLRCQ SLGR`Q BC EMSTCPLCKCLR BGDD`PCLAGC J? EMSTCPL?LAC NMJWACLRPGOSC BC J? xEMSTCPL?LAC KSJRGLGTC?SVy OSG PCDJaRC SL QWQRaKC Mk AF?OSC SLGR` CQR GK@PGOS`C B?LQ SLC QRPSARSPC ,?EMSTCPL?LACBCQ?LR`KMLBG?JC '3- KM@GJGQCBCQSLGR`QBCEMSTCPLCKCLR LMR?KKCLRBCQ ?ARCSPQGLRCPL?RGML?SVNS@JGAQCRNPGT`Q OSGCVCPACLRSLCGLDJSCLACAPMGQQ?LRC?SLGTC?SEJM@?J 0?PKGJCQ?ARCSPQNS@JGAQBCJ?'3- MLAMKNRCJCQMPE?LGQ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQKSJRGJ?R`P?JCQ BSQWQRaKCMLSQGCLNCV J{/PE?LGQ?RGML-MLBG?JCBCJ?3?LR`CRJCQGLQRGRSRGMLQDGL?LAGaPCQ GLRCPL?RGML?JCQNCV J?"?LOSCKMLBG?JC CRJCQMPE?LGQKCQBCAMMN`P?RGML@GJ?R`P?JC NCV J{!ECLAC&P?L_?GQCBC$`TCJMNNCKCLR ,CQ?ARCSPQNPGT`Q\@SRLMLJSAP?RGDGLAJSCLROS?LR\CSV JCQ MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ LML EMSTCPLCKCLR?JCQ /.' JCQ DMLB?RGMLQ NFGJ?LRFPMNGOSCQ N CV J? &MLB?RGML"GJJ-CJGLB?'?RCQ JCQRGLR?LIQ NCV JC:CI:G;DG AD76A:K:ADEB:CI CRJCQ EP?LBQN?PRCL?PG?RQNS@JGAQNPGT`Q NCV JC&MLBQKMLBG?JBCJSRRCAMLRPCJCQGB? J?RS@CPASJMQC CRJCN?JSBGQKC /LAMKNRC?SQQGSLLMK@PCGKNMPR?LRBCAMKN?ELGCQRP?LQL?RGML?JCQNPGT`CQ\ @SRJSAP?RGD NCV JCQQMAG`R`QBCAMLQCGJAMKKC&8$>CH:NDBE6CN #CQNhJCQB{GLDJSCLAC RP?BGRGMLLCJQQMLRJ?PECKCLRBMKGL`QN?PJCQN?WQ\F?SRPCTCLS 7FGRDGCJB /SRPCACSVAG BC LMSTC?SV ?ARCSPQ BC J? '3- `KCPECLR?TCA JC AMLAMSPQ BS NMJWACLRPGQKC JCQ P`QC?SV RP?LQL?RGML?SV N CV JC P`QC?S )GDK>9>C< ;DG !:6AI= 0( CR JCQ xCVNCPRQGLRCPL?RGML?SVy N CV `AMLMKGQRCQ BS B`TCJMNNCKCLR AMLQSJR?LRQ CL Q?LR` NS@JGOSC OSG CVCPACLR SLC ?SRMPGR` APMGQQ?LRCB?LQJ{?PaLCBCJ?'3-CR?SNPaQBCQB`AGBCSPQL?RGML?SVQSPJCQOSCQRGMLQBCQ?LR`. . T.
(9) . . 3FGDDK?L 3G ACQ LMSTC?SV ?ARCSPQ QMLR QSQACNRG@JCQ B{CVCPACP SLC DMPRC GLDJSCLAC NMJGRGOSC JCSPGLDJSCLACDGL?LAGaPCPCQRCJGKGR`CAMKN?P?RGTCKCLR\ACJJCBCQ?ARCSPQRP?BGRGMLLCJQ BCJ?'3- OSG?EGQQCLRNMSPJ?NJSN?PRAMKKC@?GJJCSPQBCDMLBQBCJ{?GBCCLQ?LR`KMLBG?JCv CR OSG DGL?LACLR BMLA BGPCARCKCLR MS GLBGPCARCKCLR JCQ ?ARGMLQ BC ACQ LMSTC?SV ?ARCSPQ /L NCP_MGR B{CK@J`C BC LMK@PCSV CLHCSV BC NMSTMGPQ B?LQ J? '3- 0MSP ?NNP`FCLBCP ACQ CLHCSV J{?L?JWQCBCJ{`AMLMKGCNMJGRGOSC !%0 EDA>I>86A:8DCDBN6C6ANH>HCL?LEJ?GQ BCACRRC?PaLCBC EMSTCPL?LAC CQR SL MSRGJ NCPRGLCLR NMSP JCQ AFCPAFCSPQ ,{!%0 xAMLACPLC J{GLRCP?ARGML BCQ NPMACQQSQNMJGRGOSCQCR`AMLMKGOSCQB?LQSLAMLRCVRCBMLL`J?P`N?PRGRGMLBSNMSTMGPCRBCJ? PGAFCQQC CLRPC BGDD`PCLRQ EPMSNCQ CR GLBGTGBSQ CR JCQ NPMACQQSQ OSG AP`CLR K?GLRGCLLCLR CR RP?LQDMPKCLRACQPCJ?RGMLQ?SDGJBSRCKNQy /%#$ N IG69J8I>DCA>7G: 3GJCQ?NNCJQ\ KM@GJGQCP J{!%0 NMSP `RSBGCP J? Q?LR` KMLBG?JC ?SEKCLRCLR "MGBGL 0?PRGAGN?LRQ ?R RFC "CJJ?EGM 7MPIQFMN ML 0MJGRGA?J %AMLMKW MD 'JM@?J (C?JRF GJ L{CVGQRC N?Q \ LMRPC AMLL?GQQ?LACB{!%0?NNJGOS`C?SAMLRCVRCNMJWACLRPGOSCBCJ?'3- /P JCKMSTCKCLRNMSPJ{?RRCGLRCBCJ?DJK:GIJG:,6CIU.C>K:GH:AA: #35 ?AACLRSCJCA?P?ARaPC NMJWACLRPGOSCBCJ?'3-,?JGRR`P?RSPCPCJaTCCLCDDCRSLCKSJRGNJGA?RGMLB{?ARCSPQ BCP`QC?SV CR B{CVNCPRQBCJ?'3-OSG?NNSGCLRvB?LQJCQBGQAMSPQ J{?JJMA?RGMLB{?GBCCLQ?LR`KMLBG?JC CRJ? KGQC\BGQNMQGRGMLB{?QQGQR?LACRCAFLGOSCvJCKMSTCKCLRNMSPJ{?RRCGLRCBCJ?#35 "PMJ?L?LB (GJJ #CRRC BCPLGaPC TGQC \ ?QQSPCP \ RMSRCQ JCQ NMNSJ?RGMLQ B{SL N?WQ SL ?AAaQ \ BCQ QCPTGACQBCQ?LR`BCOS?JGR`xQ?LQ?TMGP\PCBMSRCPOSCJCAMlRBCACQQCPTGACQ ?SKMKCLRMkGJQ BCTPMLRWPCAMSPGP JCQKCRRCCLQGRS?RGMLBCBGDDGASJR` DGL?LAGaPCy /-3 N ,?#35? `R` AMLQ?AP`C B?LQ JC NPMEP?KKC BC B`TCJMNNCKCLR NMQR AMKKC QMSQ/@HCARGD BC $`TCJMNNCKCLR$SP?@JC /$$ #F?NK?L $?LQACA?BPC J{/PE?LGQ?RGML-MLBG?JCBCJ? 3?LR` /-3 PCAMKK?LBCB{GLAGRCPJCQN?WQ\D?G@JCCR\KMWCLPCTCLS 0&-2 \?BMNRCPJ?MS JCQ P`DMPKC Q BC DGL?LACKCLR BS QWQRaKC BC Q?LR` ?B?NR`C Q \ JCSPQ AMLRCVRCQ /-3 3CJML JCQ AMLRCVRCQ JCQ 0&-2 NCSTCLR Q{CLE?ECP B?LQ J? TMGC BC J{?RRCGLRC BC J? #35 CL P`DMPK?LR JCQ KMBCQ BC DGL?LACKCLR BC JCSP QWQRaKC BC Q?LR` CL D?TMPGQ?LR RPMGQ BGKCLQGMLQB{`AMLMKGC BC J? Q?LR` J? BCK?LBC BC Q?LR` A\B J? AMSTCPRSPC BCQ @CQMGLQ B{?AAaQ ?SV QCPTGACQ B{SLC NMNSJ?RGML J{MDDPC BC Q?LR` A\B J? OS?LRGR` CR J? OS?JGR` BCQ QCPTGACQAMSTCPRQ CRJ{`OSGR` A\BJ?NPMNMPRGMLBCAMlRQBCQQCPTGACQAMSTCPRCN?PJ{%R?RMS JCQP`EGKCQBCNPMRCARGMLQMAG?JCTCPQSQACJJCBCQNMNSJ?RGMLQCRJ{?AAaQ\RMSRCQJCQNMNSJ?RGMLQ. . TG.
(10) . . QCJMLJCSPQ@CQMGLQGLB`NCLB?KKCLRBCQBGQN?PGR`QQMAGM`AMLMKGOSCQCRASJRSPCJJCQ !DGLB{?EGP QSPACQBGKCLQGMLQ GJAMLTGCLRBCRCLGPAMKNRCBCRPMGQDMLARGMLQCQQCLRGCJJCQBSDGL?LACKCLRBCQ QWQRaKCQBCQ?LR` +SRXGL J?AMJJCARCBCQPCQQMSPACQDGL?LAGaPCQ JCSPKGQCCLAMKKSL J{?AF?RBCQQCPTGACQBCQ?LR` A\BJCRP?LQDCPRBCQPCQQMSPACQKGQCQCLAMKKSL?SVNPCQR?R?GPCQ BCQCPTGACQ ?SLMKBCJ?NMNSJ?RGMLNMSPJ?OSCJJCJCQPCQQMSPACQMLR`R`KGQCQCLAMKKSL $?LQ JCQ N?WQ B{!DPGOSC QS@3?F?PGCLLC NJSQGCSPQ P`DMPKCQ BC DGL?LACKCLR BC J? Q?LR` MLR `R` KGQCQCL?T?LRN?PBGDD`PCLRQ?ARCSPQBCJ?'3- LMR?KKCLRJCQMPE?LGQ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQCR JCQMPE?LGQKCQBCAMMN`P?RGML@GJ?R`P?JC '?SRGCP?LB2GBBC #CPR?GLQBCACQ?ARCSPQMLRCS RCLB?LAC\D?TMPGQCPBCQP`DMPKCQTGQ?LR\?K`JGMPCPJ?BCK?LBCBCQ?LR`B?LQJCQ0&-2 AMKKC JCQ NMJGRGOSCQ BC EP?RSGR` BCQ QMGLQ 2M@CPR ?LB 2GBBC JCQ KSRSCJJCQ BC Q?LR` "MGBGL CRJCQRP?LQDCPRQKML`R?GPCQAMLBGRGMLLCJQ "`J?LBCR?J ${?SRPCQMLRNJSRhRAFCPAF` \NPMKMSTMGPBCQNMJGRGOSCQB{?K`JGMP?RGMLBCJ{MDDPCBCQ?LR`N?PJCPCAMSTPCKCLRBCQAMlRQ ,CC ?LB 'MMBK?L CR BCQ KCQSPCQ TGQ?LR \ ?SEKCLRCP J? NCPDMPK?LAC BCQ NPMDCQQGMLLCJQ BC Q?LR` 2MUCCR?J 4MSRCDMGQ ACPR?GLQ?ARCSPQBCJ?'3-MLRAMLQGB`P`OSCACQP`DMPKCQ ?T?GCLRE`L`P`BCQP`QSJR?RQNJSRhRB`ACT?LRQ#CPR?GLQMLRCQRGK`OSCACQP`DMPKCQL{?T?GCLRN?Q QSDDGQ?KKCLRRCLSAMKNRCBCJ?RPMGQGaKCDMLARGMLBSDGL?LACKCLRACJJCBCJ{?AF?RBCQQCPTGACQ -?RF?SCP %L P`NMLQC \ ACQ `ASCGJQ NJSQGCSPQ ?ARCSPQ BC J? '3- NMJWACLRPGOSC v MPE?LGQ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQ P`QC?SVCRGLBGTGBSQGLDJSCLRQvMLRNPMKSJ?KGQCCLuSTPCB{SLC P`DMPKC BC DGL?LACKCLR BS QWQRaKC BC Q?LR` B?LQ JCQ 0&-2 JC DGL?LACKCLR @?Q` QSP J? NCPDMPK?LAC &"0 4SPAMRRC4PCK@J?WCR?J ,C&"0QCDMA?JGQCQSPJ{MDDPCBCQ?LR`JCQ NPCQR?R?GPCQ BC QMGLQ BC Q?LR` QMLR DGL?LA`Q ?S KMGLQ N?PRGCJJCKCLR QSP J? @?QC BC JCSP NCPDMPK?LAC)JKM@GJGQCJCQRF`MPGCQ`AMLMKGOSCQBSNPGLAGN?J?ECLRCRBSAMLRP?R,CNPGLAGN?J N?P CVCKNJC JC KGLGQRaPC BC J? Q?LR` AML_MGR SL AMLRP?R DMPKCJ OSG GLAGRCP? SL ?ECLR N?P CVCKNJC SL NPCQR?R?GPC BC Q?LR` \ ?BMNRCP SL AMKNMPRCKCLR AMLDMPKC \ QCQ GLR`PbRQ %JBPGBEC ?LB0?JKCP #CJ?NCSRbRPCP`?JGQ`CLJSGMDDP?LRBCQ?T?LR?ECQDGL?LAGCPQCRCL`R?@JGQQ?LR BCQNPMA`BSPCQBCQSGTG`T?JS?RGMLBCJ{CV`ASRGMLBSAMLRP?R tJ{GLTCPQCBSQWQRaKCBCDGL?LACKCLRN?PJCQGLRP?LRQ ?TCA@SBECRPCAMLBSGRAF?OSC?LL`C JC &"0KCR?GLQGJ{?AACLRQSPJ{?RRCGLRCBCP`QSJR?RQQSPJ?@?QCBCAG@JCQB`DGLGCQ\J{?T?LAC B?LQJC AMLRP?R #CQAG@JCQAMPPCQNMLBCLR\SLCOS?LRGR` SLNMSPACLR?ECBCAMSTCPRSPC MSSLQAMPCBC. . TGG.
(11) . . OS?JGR` %JJCQ QMLR JG`CQ \ J? NPCQR?RGML BC QCPTGACQ BC Q?LR` OSG CQR x?AFCR`Cy N?P SL MPE?LGQKC RGCPQ,C&"0QCDMA?JGQCBMLAQSPJ?DMLARGMLB{?AF?R 3MSA?RCR?J tJ?DGLB{SLCN`PGMBC BMLL`C QMSTCLR SL RPGKCQRPC ?S AMSPQ BC J?OSCJJC J? NPCQR?RGML ? `R` P`?JGQ`C SL QWQRaKC BC T`PGDGA?RGML CR AMLRPCT`PGDGA?RGML QC KCR CL NJ?AC ?DGL BC AMLRPhJCP JCQ P`QSJR?RQ CR MN`PCP JC TCPQCKCLRBCNPGKCQ?SVNPCQR?R?GPCQ5LCN?PRGCBCACQNPGKCQQCPR\P`?JGQCPBCQGLTCQRGQQCKCLRQ B?LQ JCQ ACLRPCQ BC Q?LR` J{?SRPC QCPR BC QSPNJSQ ?S Q?J?GPC BCQ ?ECLRQ BC Q?LR` ,CQ NPGKCQ B{GLTCQRGQQCKCLRQ AMLRPG@SCLR \ QSQAGRCP SLC ?SRMLMKGC B`AGQGMLLCJJC ,GCP J? NCPDMPK?LAC BCQ NPCQR?R?GPCQ \ BCQ NPGKCQ NCPKCRRPC SLC ?SRMLMKGC B`AGQGMLLCJJC CR ?QQSPCP BCQ AWAJCQ BC P`RPM?ARGMLNJSQAMSPRQQMLRACLQ`QKMRGTCPJCQ?ECLRQBCQ?LR`\DMSPLGPBCQQCPTGACQBCKCGJJCSPC OS?JGR` PCLB?LR?GLQGJ?NPCQR?RGMLBCQCPTGACQNJSQ?RRP?W?LRCNMSPJCQN?RGCLRQCR?SEKCLR?LRJCSP SRGJGQ?RGMLBCQQCPTGACQ &PGRQAFCCR?J ,C&"0?`R`CVN`PGKCLR`B?LQNJSQBCBCQN?WQB{!DPGOSCQS@Q?F?PGCLLCCLRPCCR CLB`NGRB{SLC?@QCLACB{SL?LGKGR`QSPJCQNPCSTCQQAGCLRGDGOSCQBCQMLCDDGA?AGR` 0?SJCR ?J #MKKCNMSPNJSQGCSPQ?SRPCQP`DMPKCQBSDGL?LACKCLRBCJ?Q?LR` .?@WMLE?/PCKCR ?J 2GBBC J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 B?LQ RMSQ ACQ N?WQ PCNMQC BMLA QSP BCQ NPMACQQSQ LMLJG`Q\J?NPGQCBCB`AGQGMLDMLB`CQSPBCQ@?QCQD?ARSCJJCQ :K>9:C8: >C;DGB:9EDA>8NB6@>C< GJ CQR CQQCLRGCJ B{?L?JWQCP ?SRPCKCLR J? K?LGaPC BMLR ACRRC NMJGRGOSC ? E?EL` BS RCPP?GL ?SV LGTC?SV EJM@?J AMLRGLCLR?J CR L?RGML?J ,CQ NPMHCRQ NGJMRCQ BC &"0 QMLR NPMKSQ N?P BCQ MPE?LGQ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQ BCQP`QC?SVCRBCQCVNCPRQRP?LQL?RGML?SV DGL?LA`QN?PBCQ@?GJJCSPQ BCDMLBQGLRCPL?RGML?SV LMR?KKCLR\RP?TCPQSLDMLBQE`P`N?PJ?"?LOSCKMLBG?JC JC!:6AI= +:HJAIH"CCDK6I>DC-GJHIJC9 (2)4& CR?NNSW`QN?PBCQ?QQGQR?LRQRCAFLGOSCQOSG?EGQQCLR\ ACQBGDD`PCLRQLGTC?SV!SBCJ\BSNMSTMGPDGL?LAGCP ACQ?ARCSPQCVCPACLRBCKSJRGNJCQGLDJSCLACQ TGQ?LRJ{CVN?LQGMLBCACRRCNMJGRGOSC#CQGLDJSCLACQGLAJSCLRJ{?QQMAG?RGMLQRP?R`EGOSCBS&"0\ BCQ RCLB?LACQ CR BGQAMSPQ NMNSJ?GPCQ QSQACNRG@JCQ BC QSQAGRCP J{?BF`QGML BC LMK@PCSV ?ARCSPQ ;G6B>C< J?AMLBSGRCBCJ{?ECLB?B{?NNPCLRGQQ?ECBS&"0?SNPaQBCQ?ARCSPQJMA?SVBCQ0&-2 J{GLAGR?RGML \ J{`KSJ?RGML NMJGRGOSC CL NPMKMST?LR BCQ `AF?LECQ GLRCPN?WQ QSP JC &"0 CR J? D?AGJGR?RGMLCRJCAMLRPhJCBCJ{CVN`PGKCLR?RGMLBS&"0#CQDMPKCQB{GLDJSCLACQMLRB{?SR?LRNJSQ AMKNJCVCQ OS{CJJCQ QMLR PCJ?RGTCKCLR NCS TGQG@JCQ JCQ ?ARCSPQ BC J? '3- NPMKMST?LR ACRRC NMJGRGOSCQ{CDDMPACLRBCKCRRPCCL?T?LRSL&"0AMLBSGRCR?NNPMNPG`N?PJCQN?WQ ?DPGA?GLQ CL N?PRGASJGCP CRBCQGLRCPK`BG?GPCQJMA?SV AMKKCJCQNP?RGAGCLQ?DPGA?GLQBS&"0. . TGGG.
(12) . . 0MSPR?LR \ACHMSP GJW?CSNCSB{GLTCQRGE?RGMLCKNGPGOSCQSPJCQNPMACQQSQBCBGDDSQGMLBS&"0 B?LQ JCQ 0&-2 !@MKM MS QSP J{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC BC ACRRC BGDDSQGML 2CLK?LQ CR ?J %LMSRPC JCQ!%0BGQNMLG@JCQQCQMLRHSQOS{GAGDMA?JGQ`CQQSPJCLGTC?SL?RGML?J CVNJMP?LR JCQGLDJSCLACQCVCPA`CQN?PBCQ?ARCSPQCVR`PGCSPQB?LQACPR?GLQN?WQ?DPGA?GLQ "?PLCQCR?J #FGKFSRS CR ?J +GCLBP`@`MEM CR ?J 2CLK?LQ CR ?J ? ,? JGRR`P?RSPC QC AMLACLRPCQSPJCQCDDCRQCRJCQNPMACQQSQBCKGQCCLuSTPCBS&"0 2CLK?LQCR?J 7GRRCP CR?J 7GWQMLECCR?J 4PaQQMSTCLR J{GLDJSCLACBCQ?ARCSPQBCJ?'3-D?GQ?LRJ? NPMKMRGML BS &"0 CQR ?@MPB`C Q?LQ B`AMPRGOSCP QCQ MPGEGLCQ QCQ KSJRGNJCQ DMPKCQ BC K?R`PG?JGQ?RGML MSQCQGKNJGA?RGMLQNMSPJCQ0&-2 )LRPMBSGQ?LR JC AMLACNR B{xCLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGMLy %$ NMSP P`D`PCP ?SV ?ARCSPQ BC J? '3- NPMKMST?LR JC &"0 \ BGDD`PCLRQ LGTC?SV ACRRC RFaQC CLRCLB AMK@JCP JCQ J?ASLCQ BC J? PCAFCPAFC CR AMLRPG@SCP \ J{?T?LACKCLR BCQ ?L?JWQCQ BC J{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC BC J? BGDDSQGML CL AMLRCVRC NMJWACLRPGOSC CL CVNJMP?LR JCQ A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQ CR QRP?R`EGCQ B{GLDJSCLAC OSC JCQ %$ KM@GJGQCLR NMSP D?AGJGRCP J{CVN?LQGML BS &"0 CL !DPGOSC .MSQ LMSQ NMQMLQ J? OSCQRGML BC PCAFCPAFCQSGT?LRC
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
(20)
(21)
(22)
(23)
(24)
(25) 0MSP P`NMLBPC \ ACRRC OSCQRGML LMSQ P`?JGQMLQ SLC `RSBC GLRCPNP`R?RGTC \ LGTC?SV B{?L?JWQC GK@PGOS`Q EJM@?J AMLRGLCLR?J L?RGML?J ?DGL B{CV?KGLCP J{CVN?LQGML BS &"0 B?LQ JCQ N?WQ ?DPGA?GLQCRJCPhJCHMS`N?PJCQCLRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGMLB?LQACRRCCVN?LQGML . 1&5$*(7+=25,48((70=7+2'(6 *#2+64' '87'&'.+66=4#674'6*=14+37''6=.#$14#6+10&7%#&4'%10%'267'. ,CAF?NGRPC BMLRJCAMLRCLS?`R`NS@JG`B?LQJ?PCTSC0DGA9:K:ADEB:CI AMLQGQRC\N?QQCP CL PCTSC J? JGRR`P?RSPC RF`MPGOSC OSG NCPKCR BC AMLQRPSGPC JC A?BPC AMLACNRSCJ ESGB?LR J{?L?JWQC B?LQACRRCRFaQC$?LQACAF?NGRPC LMSQRCQRMLQ`E?JCKCLRJ?NCPRGLCLACBCACA?BPCCLJ{SRGJGQ?LR NMSPJ{?L?JWQCBCJ?JGRR`P?RSPCQSPJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0 ,?PCAFCPAFCQSPJ?BGDDSQGMLBCQNMJGRGOSCQCQRA?P?AR`PGQ`CN?PBCQKMBaJCQCVNJGA?RGDQAMF`PCLRQ OSG `T?JSCLR J{GKNMPR?LAC BCQ K`A?LGQKCQ BC BGDDSQGML LMR?KKCLR EDA>8N A:6GC>C< CR EDA>8N . GV.
(26) . . :BJA6I>DC 4MQSL /P K?JEP`NJSQGCSPQRCLR?RGTCQBCxP?KCLCPJCQ?ARCSPQyGLDJSCLRQB?LQ JCQNPMACQQSQB{`KCPECLACCRBCBGDDSQGMLNMJGRGOSC ACQ?ARCSPQPCQRCLRJ?PECKCLRMS@JG`QB?LQJ? JGRR`P?RSPCQSPJCQNMJGRGOSCQNS@JGOSCQ CLN?PRGASJGCPB?LQJCQ`RSBCQQSPJ?BGDDSQGML #?N?LMCR ?J .MSQ NPMNMQMLQ BC D?GPC NPMEPCQQCP J? JGRR`P?RSPC CL GLRPMBSGQ?LR JC AMLACNR B{xCLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGMLy %$ #CQ %$ QMLR BCQ GLBGTGBSQ BCQ P`QC?SV CR BCQ MPE?LGQ?RGMLQOSGAML_MGTCLRSLCGB`CBCNMJGRGOSCCRCLDMLRJ?NPMKMRGMLCLTSCBCE?ELCPBC J{GLDJSCLAC%LLMSQ@?Q?LRQSPJ?JGRR`P?RSPCPCJ?RGTC\J?BGDDSQGMLCRCLJ?PCJG?LR\BCQ`RSBCQQSP J? NPGQC BC B`AGQGML CL AMLRCVRC NMJWACLRPGOSC LMSQ GLRPMBSGQMLQ BCQ A?R`EMPGCQ B{?L?JWQC NMSP KCRRPCCLJSKGaPCJCQA?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQCQQCLRGCJJCQCRJCQQRP?R`EGCQB{GLDJSCLACCLRPCNPGQCQN?PJCQ %$#CQA?R`EMPGCQDMPKCLRSLA?BPCAMLACNRSCJGLRCPBGQAGNJGL?GPC CKNPSLR?LR?SVAF?KNQBCJ? BGDDSQGMLBCQNMJGRGOSCQNS@JGOSCQ 'GJ?PBG 3FGN?L?LB6MJBCL BCJ?QMAGMJMEGCBC J{?ARGMLNS@JGOSC (?QQCLRCSDCJ BCQPCJ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQ (??Q CRBCJ?Q?LR` KMLBG?JC 3FGDDK?L /LGBCLRGDGCOS?RPCA?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQCQQCLRGCJJCQCRGLRCPPCJG`CQBCQCLRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGML CL AMLRCVRC BC EMSTCPL?LAC NMJWACLRPGOSC ,CQ QWQRaKCQ BC PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ AMKNP`FCLQGML BS KMLBC CR NP`QSNNMQ`Q QMSQH?ACLRQ D?_MLL`Q N?P J? ASJRSPC CR J? DMPK?RGML OSG ESGBCLR JCSP ?ARGML AMLQRGRSCLR J? A?P?AR`PGQRGOSC #CQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ QMSQRCLBCLR JCQ KMRGT?RGMLQ NPMDMLBCQ GLR`PbRQNCPQMLLCJQ NMJGRGOSCQCRDGL?LAGCPQ OSG?LGKCLRJCSPB`AGQGMLBCNPMKMSTMGP SLC NMJGRGOSC BMLL`C A?P?AR`PGQRGOSC $CSV ?SRPCQ RWNCQ BC A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQ CQQCLRGCJJCQ B`AMSJCLRBCQAMLQ`OSCLACQBCJ{MSTCPRSPCOSGA?P?AR`PGQCJ?EMSTCPL?LACNMJWACLRPGOSC-bKC JCQ?ARCSPQNPMTCL?LRB{SL@?QLGTC?SBCEMSTCPL?LACNCSTCLRbRPCNMRCLRGCJJCKCLRNSGQQ?LRQCL P?GQML BC J? NMQQG@GJGR` BC BGDDSQGML TCPRGA?JC CR BC RP?LQDCPR ?QACLB?LR #CQ LMSTC?SV ?ARCSPQ BMGTCLR JSRRCP NMSP QC R?GJJCP SLC NJ?AC B?LQ J{?PaLC B`AGQGMLLCJJC CL KGQ?LR LMR?KKCLR QSP JCQ PCQQMSPACQ Q?TMGP PCQQMSPACQ K?R`PGCJJCQ QMAG?JCQ NMJGRGOSCQ CR RCKNMPCJJCQ \ JCSP BGQNMQGRGML A?P?AR`PGQRGOSC CR QSQAGRCP J? PCAMLL?GQQ?LAC BC KSJRGNJCQ DMPKCQ B{?SRMPGR` CVNCPRC QAGCLRGDGOSC DGL?LAGaPC KMP?JC NMSPB`NJMWCPJCSPNMSTMGP A?P?AR`PGQRGOSC $CQB`DGLGRGMLQ QMLRDMSPLGCQB?LQJC4?@JC?S) )01;40D J58=8C8>=B34BCH?4B34A4BB>DA24B4C5>A<4B3N0DC>A8CJ ><?>B0=C4B ,6KD>G . J58=8C8>= +:HHDJG8:H 4MSRCDMPKCBCQ?TMGP NCV AMLL?GQQ?LACQR?AGRCQ DMPK?RGML?AOSGQC CRA V.
(27) . &6IUG>:AA:H ,D8>6A:H )DA>I>FJ:H -:BEDG:AA:H >C6C8>VG: &DG6A: ,8>:CI>;>FJ: ME:GI: . 2CQQMSPACQFSK?GLCQ KMWCLQDGL?LAGCPQCRK?R`PGCJQ\BGQNMQGRGML #?NGR?JQMAG?JCRNPMNCLQGMLBCQ?ARCSPQ\B`TCJMNNCPBCQJGCLQ?TCAB{?SRPCQ NCPQMLLCQ 0PMNCLQGMLBCQ?ARCSPQ\KM@GJGQCPJCQ?ARCSPQNMJGRGOSCQHMS?LRSLPhJCAJ` N CV B`AGBCSPQ 0PMNCLQGMLBCQ?ARCSPQ\?TMGPRPMSTCPBSRCKNQ\B`BGCP\J?xA?SQCyBCJ? BGDDSQGML -NE:H9a6JIDG>IUG:8DCCJ::I688:EIU:6JC>K:6J<AD76A !SRMPGR`NPMTCL?LRBCJ?PCAMLL?GQQ?LACBSTMJSKCGKNMPR?LRB{GLTCQRGQQCKCLR DGL?LAGCPCLD?TCSPBCJ{?GBC?SB`TCJMNNCKCLR ,`EGRGKGR`PCAMLLSC BCACJSGOSGPCTCLBGOSCACRRCDMPKCB{?SRMPGR` BSPhJCBC NPCQAPGNRCSPBCAMKNMPRCKCLRQCRBCNPMBSARCSPBCLMPKCQQSPJ?@?QCBC A?R`EMPGCQAMLQGB`P`CQAMKKCT?JGBCQ 3R?RSRQAGCLRGDGOSCGLRCPL?RGML?JCKCLRPCAMLLSAMK@GL`\J?PCAMLL?GQQ?LACBCJ? T?JGBGR`BCQPCNP`QCLR?RGMLQBSP`CJBCACJSGOSGPCTCLBGOSCACRRCDMPKCB{?SRMPGR` 2CLMKK`CNPMTCL?LRB{CVN`PGCLACSJR`PGCSPCB{GKNJ?LR?RGMLB{SLCNMJGRGOSC BMLL`C RWNGOSCKCLRP`SQQGC CRMSB{SLCA?N?AGR`PCAMLLSC\RPMSTCPBCQ QMJSRGMLQ\BCQNPM@JaKCQ. #{CQR QCSJCKCLR Q{GJQ ?AOSGaPCLR SLC DMPRC J`EGRGKGR` OS{GJQ QMLR QSQACNRG@JCQ BC P`SQQGP JCSP CLRPCNPGQC BC QRGKSJ?RGML BC J? BGDDSQGML #CRRC CLRPCNPGQC PCNMQC QSP JC B`TCJMNNCKCLR BC NJSQGCSPQ QRP?R`EGCQ #CJJCQAG GLAJSCLR J{?LAP?EC BC J? NMJGRGOSC B?LQ BCQ MPGCLR?RGMLQ QSQACNRG@JCQ BC E`L`PCP J{?BF`QGML EDA>8N ;G6B>C< J? QRGKSJ?RGML BC J{`KSJ?RGML N?P J? AMLQRGRSRGML BC P`QC?SV NPMKMST?LR SLC KbKC NMJGRGOSC EDA>8N :BJA6I>DC J? AMLBSGRC BC J{?ECLB?B{?NNPCLRGQQ?ECQSPJ?NMJGRGOSC EDA>8NA:6GC>C< CRJ?DGV?RGMLBCQR?LB?PBQCRA?BPCQBC AMJJ?@MP?RGMLNMSP?QQSPCPSLCCVN`PGKCLR?RGMLP`SQQGCBCJ?NMJGRGOSC EDA>8N:ME:G>B:CI6I>DC 0?PDMGQ JCQ %$ Q{MPE?LGQCLR CL P`QC?SV GLDMPKCJQ AMKNMQ`Q BC xNPMDCQQGMLLCJQ NMQQ`B?LR SLC CVNCPRGQC CR BCQ AMKN`RCLACQ PCAMLLSCQ B?LQ SL BMK?GLC N?PRGASJGCPy (??Q N IG69J8I>DC A>7G: N?PR?EC?LR BCQ QWQRaKCQ BC PCNP`QCLR?RGML CR BCQ GLR`PbRQ AMLTCPECLRQ #CQ P`QC?SVAMLRPG@SCLR\NPMKMSTMGPJCQGLLMT?RGMLQNMJGRGOSCQN?PJCSPNMSTMGPBCAMLRPhJCBCQDJSV B{GLDMPK?RGMLCRBSQ?TMGP$?LQACA?Q MLN?PJCBC8DBBJC6JIUHUE>HIUB>FJ:HRP?LQL?RGML?JCQ (??Q . . . VG.
(28) . A0?78@D4 03A42>=24?CD4;. 0MSPGJJSQRPCPJ?T?JCSP?L?JWRGOSCBSAMLACNR LMSQ?TMLQCDDCARS`SLCPCTSC?NNPMDMLBGCBCJ? JGRR`P?RSPC QAGCLRGDGOSCCREPGQC QSPJCQCLRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGML %$ BSDGL?LACKCLR@?Q` QSPJ?NCPDMPK?LAC &"0 CL!DPGOSCQS@Q?F?PGCLLC.MSQKMLRPMLQAMKKCLRCRNMSPOSMGACRRC GLLMT?RGML NMJGRGOSC P`ACKKCLR BGDDSQ`C MDDPC SLC MNNMPRSLGR` SLGOSC NMSP B`KMLRPCP LMRPC AMLACNR B?LQ JC A?Q BS &"0 SL EPMSNC B{%$ GLDJSCLRQ CR DMPRCKCLR B`BG`Q Q{CQR CDDMPA` B{?AACLRSCP J? BGDDSQGML BC J? NMJGRGOSC #{CQR EP]AC ?S A?P?ARaPC NMJWACLRPGOSC BC J? '3- OSC ACPR?GLQB{CLRPCCSVMLRNSCVCPACPSLCGLDJSCLACQSPJCQNPMACQQSQBCBGDDSQGML .MRPCPCTSC?NCPKGQB{GBCLRGDGCPOSGQMLRJCQ%$BS&"0\J{`AFCJJCEJM@?JCAGLOMPE?LGQ?RGMLQ BCSV ?ECLACQ B{?GBC @GJ?R`P?JC SL @?GJJCSP BC DMLBQ K?HCSP SLC /.' CR SLC QMAG`R` BC DMPK?RGML RPMGQ P`QC?SV RP?LQL?RGML?SV SLC AMKKSL?SR` BC NP?RGOSC SL P`QC?S GLDMPKCJ B{6AJBC> CR SL P`QC?S BC NP?RGAGCLQ KSJRGN?WQ CR SLC RPCLR?GLC B{GLBGTGBSQ BCQ AMLQSJR?LRQ GLB`NCLB?LRQ CR BCQ AFCPAFCSPQ @?Q`Q CL %SPMNC MS CL !K`PGOSC BS .MPB CR BCQ CKNJMW`Q B{MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ GLRCPL?RGML?JCQ ,CQ P`QC?SV CR MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ JCQ NJSQ TGQG@JCQ QMLR A?P?AR`PGQ`Q N?P SLC ASJRSPC AMJJCARGTCMPE?LGQ?RGMLLCJJC ?LAP`C B?LQ JCQ RF`MPGCQ `AMLMKGOSCQ L`MGLQRGRSRGML?JGQRCQ CR J? xLMSTCJJC ECQRGML NS@JGOSCy OSG D?_MLLCLR JCSPQ QWQRaKCQ BC . VGG.
(29) . . PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ "PM?B 3GL?(C?JRF 0?PCVCKNJC J?QMAG`R`BCAMLQCGJFMJJ?LB?GQC ,>C6!:6AI= ?ARCSPGLAMLRMSPL?@JCBCJ?BGDDSQGML P`N?LB CLAMJJ?@MP?RGML?TCAB{?SRPCQQMAG`R`Q BC DMPK?RGML @`LGLMGQCQ CR A?KCPMSL?GQCQ LMR?KKCLR J{?NNPMAFC BS &"0 CR QCQ NPGLAGNCQ DMLB?KCLR?SV ?LAP`Q CL KGAPM`AMLMKGC RF`MPGCQ BCQ AMLRP?RQ CR BCQ GLAGR?LRQ ,CQ GLBGTGBSQ N?PR?ECLR `E?JCKCLR SL QWQRaKC BC PCNP`QCLR?RGML AMLQRPSGR QSP BCQ DMPK?RGMLQ CL `AMLMKGC CR QAGCLACQK`BGA?JCQ &PGRQAFCCR?J ,{CLQCK@JCBCQ%$QMLRKSQN?PJ?L`ACQQGR`B{M@RCLGP SL PCRMSP QSP GLTCQRGQQCKCLR NCLAF?LRQ NMSP J{?GBC @?Q`C QSP JCQ P`QSJR?RQ CR SLC KCGJJCSPC PCBBGRGMLBCQAMKNRCQ 0?SJ?LB2CLK?LQ CRN?PJ?TMJMLR`BCNPMKMSTMGPBCQ?NNPMAFCQ OSGQCK@JCLRPMKNPC?TCAJ{CVGQR?LR -MPE?L !S B`@SR BCQ ?LL`CQ JCQ %$ MLR AMK@GL` JCSPQ BGDD`PCLRCQ PCQQMSPACQ Q?TMGP QMAG?JCQ NMJGRGOSCQ RCKNMPCJJCQ K?R`PGCJJCQ CRJCSPQ?SRMPGR`QKMP?JCQCRCVNCPRCQ?DGLxB{CLAJCLAFCPSLC P`TMJSRGMLy -CCQQCL &MPRQ BC ACQ ?RMSRQ CR L?TGES?LR B?LQ JC AMLRCVRC D?TMP?@JC BC J? EMSTCPL?LAC NMJWACLRPGOSC JCQ %$ MLR ?GLQG CLRPCNPGQ BCQ ?ARGMLQ OSG Q{?SRM?JGKCLRCLR ?DGL BC D?TMPGQCP J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 ,{?LAP?EC QRP?R`EGOSC BC J? P`DMPKC &"0 B?LQ JCQ RCLB?LACQ NMNSJ?GPCQBCJ{?GBCCLQ?LR` AMMN`P?RGML3SB3SB CDDGA?AGR`BCJ{?GBC CRA ?D?AGJGR`J?KGQCCL uSTPC BC JCSPQ QRP?R`EGCQ B{`KSJ?RGML CR B{?NNPCLRGQQ?EC NMJGRGOSC CR ACJJCQAG MLR \ JCSP RMSP AMLRPG@S` \ AP`CP JCQ AMLBGRGMLQ B{SLC CVN`PGKCLR?RGML P`SQQGC BS &"0 B?LQ BC LMK@PCSV N?WQ ?DPGA?GLQ "?PLCQCR?J !SKbKCKMKCLR \N?PRGPBC MLPCK?POSCOSCJ?BGDDSQGML BS &"0 Q{?AA`JaPC CL !DPGOSC QS@Q?F?PGCLLC '?SRGCP CR ?J @ ,CQ A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQ CQQCLRGCJJCQ BCQ %$ BS &"0 CR JCSPQ ?ARGMLQ QCK@JCLR BMLA ?TMGP @GCL AMLBSGR JCQ NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGML,CR?@JC?S))P`A?NGRSJCJCQP`QSJR?RQOSGBMASKCLRCLRAF?OSCBGKCLQGMLBSA?BPCQSP JCQ%$
(30)
(31)
(32) .
(33)
(34)
(35)
(36) . .
(37)
(38) .
(39)
(40)
(41)
(42) * .$""* 7 +*+)&""0"* / &"* "/ )7!& ("/. " +**&//* ""0 2&/&&(&07 .1"/ ."0+1./1. &*2"/0&//")"*0. 2+&./+ &("/ 0"),+."(("/ ,+(&0&-1"/.
(43) 9 "4,".0 / &"*0&#&-1". //+ &0&+*!1 14!&/ +1./ $(+14 !+)&**0/"0+1 ,+,1(&."/. +*0.&1".6( .70&+*!1*" +))1*107 7,&/07)&-1" .
(44) 72"(+,,".!"/ /0*!.!/"01* $1&!"!"+**"/ ,.0&-1"//7/1. ("/"4,7.&"* "/!" . ##."!//&/0* " 0" %*&-1"14 0"1./*0&+*14. VGGG. .
(45)
(46)
(47)
(48) .
(49)
(50) !
(51) .
(52)
(53) .
(54)
(55) !
(56)
(57) .
(58)
(59) !
(60)
(61) . .
(62) +<KFLIJLI @EM<JK@JJ<D<EKJ M@J@9@C@KT8::IL<. +<KFLIJLI @EM<JK@JJ<D<EKJ. ,F:@8C<J K<DGFI<CC<J J8MF@I. ,8MF@I GFC@K@HL<J JF:@8C<J K<DGFI<CC<J. -<DGFI<CC<J D8KTI@<CC<J JF:@8C<J. &8KTI@<CC<J GFC@K@HL<J J8MF@I. @E8E:@UI< ;b <OG<IK DFI8C< . EHLVK<;b 8LKFI@KT ;b <OG<IK. b <OG<IK. b <OG<IK. @E8E:@UI< ;b <OG<IK DFI8C<.
(63)
(64)
(65)
(66) . JJF:@8K@FE;L) 8LO;@J:FLIJ>CF98LO ;FD@E8EKJ<K
(67) FL GFGLC8@I<J. )ITJ<EK8K@FE;L) :FDD<Jb @EJG@I8EK ;<Cb <OGTI@<E:<;<J G8PJG8@IJ. )I@E:@G<J =FE;8D<EK8LO;L )I<C@TJ8LO FI@<EK8K@FEJE8K@F. E8C<J<O@JK8EK<J. )ITJ<EK8K@FE;L) :FDD<Jb @EJG@I8EK ;<Cb <OGTI@<E:<;<J G8PJG8@IJ. JJF:@8K@FE;L) 8LO;@J:FLIJ >CF98LO;FD@E8EKJ <K
(68) FLGFGLC8@I<J.
(69)
(70) !
(71) . (I>8E@J<I;<J8K<C@<IJ ;b T:?8E><GFLIC<J <OGTI@D<EK8K<LIJ;< GIFA<KJG@CFK<J. IT8K@FE;LE=FILD ;T:?8E><<EC@>E< GFLIC<JGI8K@:@<EJ;L );8EJC<J)&+. FEKI@9L<ISC8 :IT8K@FE;LE< :FDDLE8LKT TG@JKTD@HL<). FEKI@9L<ISC8 :IT8K@FE;LE< :FDDLE8LKT TG@JKTD@HL<). FEKI@9L<ISC8 :IT8K@FE;LE< :FDDLE8LKT TG@JKTD@HL<). RM8CL8K@FE;<J<==<KJ ;<JGIF>I8DD<J G@CFK<J =@E8E:<D<EK
(72) FI>8E@J8K@FE;< =FID8K@FEJ. @JJTD@E8K@FE;< DLCK@GC<J=FID<J;< J8MF@I=FILD<E C@>E< 8K<C@<IJ=8:< S. =8:< <K: . 4:7(*79&.38 )IF;L:K@FE<K ;@JJTD@E8K@FE;< DLCK@GC<J=FID<J ;<J8MF@IG8IC8 =FID8K@FE. @JJTD@E8K@FE;< DLCK@GC<J=FID<J;< J8MF@IG8IC8 =FID8K@FE. @JJTD@E8K@FE;< DLCK@GC<J=FID<J;< J8MF@IG8IC8 =FID8K@FE. @E8E:<D<EK;< GIF>I8DD<JG@CFK<J LK@C@J8EKG8I=F@JLE< =FID<;<G<IJL8J@FE :F<I:@K@M<. &<KKI<S;@JGFJ@K@FE LEGFFC;b <OG<IKJ ;@JGFE@9C<JGFLI 8@;<IS Cb <OGTI@D<EK8K@FE. )8IK@:@G8K@FESC8 D@J<<E]LMI<;< GIFA<KJG@CFK<J. (==I<;b 8JJ@JK8E:< K<:?E@HL<8LO ;T:@;<LIJ. @E8E:<D<EK;< GIF>I8DD<J G@CFK<J LK@C@J8EK G8I=F@JLE<=FID< ;<G<IJL8J@FE. /8CFI@J8K@FE;< Cb <OG<IK@J<;L GI8K@:@<E. E:I8><<E T:FEFD@<;<C8 J8EKT. . E:I8><<E T:FEFD@< K?TFI@< ETFC@9TI8C<<K EFLM<CC<><JK@FE GL9C@HL< /@J@9@C@KT8::IL< I<KFLIJLI @EM<JK@JJ<D<EK. M8E:<D<EK;< :8II@UI< M@J@9@C@KT 8::IL< .
(73)
(74) . &8KTI@<CC<J GFC@K@HL<J J8MF@I.
(75)
(76)
(77)
(78) . .
(79)
(80)
(81)
(82) !
(83)
(84) . .
(85)
(86) !
(87)
(88) . 5&8 )E .3+472&9.43. VGT. /@J@9@C@KT8::IL<. .251.6:@*8 5 *= 47)&.). . :97*8'&.11*:785 *= . 422:3&:9@)* 7&9.6:*):. )01;40D )01;40D BH=C7JC8@D4 34B 20A02CJA8BC8@D4B 4BB4=C84;;4B 4C BCA0CJ684B 34B 3D &I?0AC8A340DC84A4C0;
(89) 1 . . 397*57.8* 85@(.&1.8@*)&381& +472&9.43&: /8CFI@J8K@FE;< Cb <OG<IK@J<;L GI8K@:@<EC8E>8><;L J<:K<LIGI@MT. &36:*243).&1**9 +43)8C !D .
(90)
(91)
(92) .
(93) . . #CRRC ?L?JWQC NP`JGKGL?GPC ? D?GR `KCPECP AGLO NPMNMQGRGMLQ OSG QC P?RR?AFCLR ?S AMLACNR BC NMJWACLRPGQKC ?NNJGOS` \ J? '3- #CQ NPMNMQGRGMLQ NP`QCLRCLR `E?JCKCLR BCQ GKNJGA?RGMLQ K?HCSPCQNMSPJ{`AMLMKGCNMJGRGOSCBCJ?BGDDSQGML ,? NPCKGaPC NPMNMQGRGML QSEE`P?GR OS{SLC AMLBGRGML L`ACQQ?GPC NMSP J? P`SQQGRC BC J? BGDDSQGML B{SLC NMJGRGOSC BMLL`C CQR OSC JCQ %$ P`SLGQQCLR JCSPQ PCQQMSPACQ CR JCSPQ RWNCQ B{?SRMPGR` NPMNMQGRGML )J QCK@JC @GCL OSC AC QMGR JC A?Q GAG J? KGQC CL AMKKSL BS Q?TMGP BCQ PCQQMSPACQK?R`PGCJJCQ QMAG?JCQ NMJGRGOSCQCRRCKNMPCJJCQBCQ%$CRJCD?GROS{GJQ@`L`DGAG?GCLRBC KSJRGNJCQDMPKCQB{?SRMPGR` KMP?JC DGL?LAGaPC CVNCPRC MLRKSJRGNJG`JCQAF?LACQBCP`SQQGRCBC JCSPQ?ARGMLQ#CP`QSJR?R?SLCGKNJGA?RGMLK?HCSPCNMSPLMRPC!%0BCJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0J? KGQCCLAMKKSLBCQPCQQMSPACQQCK@JCQCD?GPCL?RSPCJJCKCLRCLRPC?ARCSPQB`H\?QQCXNSGQQ?LRQ %LCDDCR LMSQAMLQR?RMLQOSCJ?P`NSR?RGMLCRJ?A?N?AGR`BCQ%$MLRHMS`SLPhJCGKNMPR?LRB?LQ J{GQQSCBSNPMACQQSQ3?LQJCQPCQQMSPACQNP`?J?@JCKCLR?AASKSJ`CQN?PJCQ%$ CRJCSPA?N?AGR`\ bRPCPCAMLLSQAMKKCBCQ?ARCSPQJ`EGRGKCQBCJ?'3-NMJWACLRPGOSC GJL{?SP?GRN?Q`R`NMQQG@JC BC KM@GJGQCP JCQ ?ARCSPQ LG JCQ PCQQMSPACQ DGL?LAGaPCQ L`ACQQ?GPCQ /L NCSR ?GLQG NMQRSJCP OSC JMPQOSCJCQQWQRaKCQBCPCNP`QCLR?RGMLCRJCQAMKN`RCLACQBCQ%$Q{?JGELCLRQSPJCAMLRCLSBCJ? NMJGRGOSC CR JMPQOSC ACJSGAG AMPPCQNMLB ?SV GLR`PbRQ BCQ @?GJJCSPQ JCQ AF?LACQ BC BGDDSQGML CL AMLRCVRCNMJWACLRPGOSC?SEKCLRCLR NPMNMQGRGML .MRPCPCTSCBCJGRR`P?RSPCCKNGPGOSC?`E?JCKCLRP`T`J`OSCJCQ%$?T?GCLRB`JG@`P`KCLRAML_SCR KGQCLuSTPCBCQQRP?R`EGCQNMSPD?TMPGQCPJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0 NPMNMQGRGML LMR?KKCLRCLJC B`DGLGQQ?LR BC K?LGaPC \ QSQAGRCP J{?BF`QGML ?SV LGTC?SV EJM@?J AMLRGLCLR?J CR L?RGML?J #CAG ? NCPKGQ B{?AAPMdRPC J{GKN?AR B{?SRPCQ QRP?R`EGCQ CLRPCNPGQCQ N?P JCQ %$ .ML QCSJCKCLR ACQ QRP?R`EGCQMLRAMLRPG@S`\`RCLBPCJ?BGDDSQGML CJJCQMLR`E?JCKCLRD?_MLL`JCQAMLRMSPQBCACRRC BGDDSQGMLCRBCACOSG`R?GR\BGDDSQCP%LCDDCR GJQCK@JCOSCQCSJQACPR?GLQBGQAMSPQCRACPR?GLCQ DMPKCQ B{?NNPCLRGQQ?EC BMLR JC AMLRCLS `R?GR RPaQ AMLRPhJ` `R?GCLR KGQ CL ?T?LR "?PLCQ CR ?J )AG CLAMPC Q{CVNPGKC J{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC A{CQR J{GLDJSCLAC BCQ %$ CVCPA`C ?S LGTC?S EJM@?JOSGNCPKCRSLRCJAMLRPhJCBCJ?BGDDSQGML NPMNMQGRGML ,CA?QBS&"0?`E?JCKCLRNCPKGQBCD?GPC`KCPECPBCQNF`LMKaLCQGLCVNJMP`Q%LAMLQGB`P?LR J{?NN?PCGJBCQRP?R`EGCQSRGJGQ`NMSPQRGKSJCPJ{`KSJ?RGMLBS&"0CL!DPGOSC ?GLQGOSCJ{GLDJSCLAC. . VT.
(94) . . BCQP`QC?SVB{CVNCPRQ?DPGA?GLQBS&"0 GJCQRNMQQG@JCBCB`BSGPCSLxCDDCR@MSJCBCLCGECy!GLQG GJCQRNPM@?@JCOSCACQCLRPCNPGQCQ NPGLAGN?JCKCLRBGPGE`CQN?PBCQ%$?EGQQ?LR?SLGTC?SEJM@?J MLR AMLRPG@S` \ J? DMPK?RGML B{%$ BC &"0 CL !DPGOSC MN`P?LR \ JCSP RMSP B?LQ BGDD`PCLRQ N?WQ ?DPGA?GLQ NPMNMQGRGML . *#2+64' 2241%*'&'%1..'%6''6&B#0#.;5'&'5&100='5 #CRRCRFaQCQ{GLQAPGRNPGLAGN?JCKCLRB?LQJCAF?KNBCQxEJ7A>8EDA>8NHIJ9>:Hy ,?QQUCJJ K?GQCJJC?BMNRCSLCK`RFMBCB{?L?JWQCKSJRGBGQAGNJGL?GPC %LECJG?LB2MRFK?WP!JJGQML BCD?_ML\PCLBPCAMKNRCBCJ?K?LGaPCJ?NJSQAMKNJaRCNMQQG@JCBCJ?AMKNJCVGR`BCQNPMACQQSQ BCBGDDSQGML,CQAGLONPMNMQGRGMLQNP`QCLR`CQAGBCQQSQESGBCLRJ?AMLBSGRCBCACRRCRFaQC!DGL B{?NNP`FCLBCP J? T?JGBGR` BC ACQ NPMNMQGRGMLQ RPMGQ `RSBCQ MLR `R` P`?JGQ`CQ \ RPMGQ BGDD`PCLRQ LGTC?SV EJM@?J ?PaLCQ NMJGRGOSCQ BC Q?LR` KMLBG?JC CR GLQRGRSRQ BC PCAFCPAFC CSPMN`CLQ AMLRGLCLR?J !DPGOSCQS@Q?F?PGCLLC CRL?RGML?J A?QBS-?JG 0PCKGaPCKCLR LMSQ?TMLQ`RSBG` J? D?@PGOSC BS BGQAMSPQ QSP JC &"0 ?S LGTC?S EJM@?J CR J{GLDJSCLAC BCQ %$ B?LQ ACRRC D?@PGOSC $CSVGaKCKCLR BCSV`RSBCQMLR`R`CLRPCNPGQCQPCQNCARGTCKCLRQSPJCPhJCBCJ?#M0BS&"0B?LQ J?BGDDSQGMLCRJ{GLDJSCLACBCQ%$QSPJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0?S-?JG ,? AMJJCARC BC BMLL`CQ ? `R` NPGLAGN?JCKCLR OS?JGR?RGTC LMSQ ?TMLQ PCASCGJJG BCQ BMLL`CQ B{M@QCPT?RGMLQ N?PRGAGN?LRCQ . B{CLRPCRGCLQ ?NNPMDMLBGQ ?SNPaQ BC P`NMLB?LRQ . PCAPSR`Q BC D?_ML ?AAGBCLRCJJC QCJML J? K`RFMBC @MSJC BC LCGEC CR N?P AFMGV P?GQMLL` CR BC BMASKCLRQ QSP JC &"0 . $?LQ J{`RSBC \ `AFCJJC AMLRGLCLR?JC JCQ BMLL`CQ OS?JGR?RGTCQ RGP`CQ BCQ BMASKCLRQ CR BCQ CLRPCRGCLQ MLR `R` AMKNJ`R`CQ N?P BCQ BMLL`CQ PCJ?RGMLLCJJCQ BC P`QC?SV QMAG?SV CR BCQ BMLL`CQ RCVRSCJJCQ BC KCQQ?ECQ BC DMPSK BC BGQASQQGML CL JGELC . #CQ BMLL`CQ OS?LRGR?RGTCQ AMKNJaRCLR LMR?KKCLR J? A?P?AR`PGQ?RGML BC J{GLDJSCLAC BGQASPQGTC BCJ{`KSJ?RGMLCRBCJ{?NNPCLRGQQ?EC,CR?@JC?S)))P`A?NGRSJCJCQBGDD`PCLRCQQMSPACQ BCBMLL`CQCRJCSPP?RR?AFCKCLR?SVRPMGQ`RSBCQ#CR?@JC?SKMLRPCOSCJCQBMLL`CQAMJJCAR`CQ ?SNPaQB{?ARCSPQCRB{MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ?EGQQ?LR\SLLGTC?SBMLL` AMJMLLCBCE?SAFC MLRNSQCPTGP \GLDMPKCPJ{?L?JWQCBCJ?BGDDSQGML\AF?ASLBCQRPMGQLGTC?SV . . . VTG.
(95) . )01;40D . >;;42C4343>==J4B4C2>AA4B?>=30=240E42;4B270?8CA4B. 633A?6;:.A:6B2.A 48;/.8 5B1-A01/;881/@101? 5.<6@>2
(96) 0;::H1? 8;.-81:@>1@51:? 2 :;@1?0Q;.? 0;/A91:@? ;:@5:1:@-8 2 1:@>1@51:?0;/A91:@? 1@91??-31?012;>A9 1:853:1 -@5;:-81:@>1@51:? 2 :;@1?0Q;.? 0;/A91:@? ;::G2?A@686?G2? ISGFE;8EKJ
(97) JS8E:<J;ZF9J<IM8K@FE :@EH;F:LD<EKJ @EJK@KLK@FEE<CJ. . 633A?6;:.A:6B2.A 0;:@6:2:@.8 5.<6@>2 2. 633A?6;:.A:6B2.A :.@6;:.8.86 5.<6@>2 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.
(98) ISGFE;8EKJ ;F:LD<EKJGIF;L@KJG8IC8 F+JLIC<!+ D<JJ8><J;<=FILD. ISGFE;8EKJ JS8E:<J;ZF9J<IM8K@FE ;F:LD<EKJJLIC<!+ 8L(8C@. ,CQCLRPCRGCLQMLR`R`KCL`Q?TCABCQGLDMPK?RCSPQAMLQGB`P`QAMKKCNPMKMRCSPQMSNP?RGAGCLQ BS&"0 WAMKNPGQBCQ%$ BCQPCNP`QCLR?LRQBCEMSTCPLCKCLRQ?DPGA?GLQ BCQSLGTCPQGR?GPCQOSG `RSBGCLR JC &"0 CR BCQ CKNJMW`Q B{MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ GKNJGOS`CQ B?LQ JC &"0 W AMKNPGQ B{MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ ?EGQQ?LR AMKKC %$ ,C R?@JC?S )6 NP`QCLRC J? BGQRPG@SRGML BCQ BGDD`PCLRCQ A?R`EMPGCQBCN?PRGAGN?LRQ )01;40D +&>ACA08CAJ20?8CD;0C8534B?0AC828?0=CB0DG4=CA4C84=B 33686.@6;: 6:?@6@A@6;::2882 >4.:6?.@6;: 6:@2>:.@6;:.82 *% #+ ;AB2>:292:@ :.@6;:.8<.E? .3>60.6:? *% '+ :?@6@A@6;: .0.1G96=A21.:? <.E?.3>60.6: *$%,+ :?@6@A@6;: .0.1G96=A21.:? <.E?2A>;<G2:? *$%,&+. . <.>@606<.:@? <.>@606<.:@? <.>@606<.:@? 6:16B61A28? 1;:@1;::G2? 1;:@1;::G2? 1;:@1;::G2? ;A29<8;EG? A@686?G2?1.:? A@686?G2?1.:? A@686?G2?1.:? 1K;>4.:6?92? 8205.<6@>2
(99) 8205.<6@>2 8205.<6@>2 . %;@.8 . . . .
(100) . ;<J<:FE;< >SESI8K@FE. . . .
(101) .
(102) . . . .
(103) . . VTGG.
(104) . ;:?A8@.:@ 6:1G<2:1.:@/.?G 1.:?<.E?.3>60.6: * $,+ ;:?A8@.:@ 6:1G<2:1.:@/.?G2: A>;<2 * $,&+ $;06G@G<>6BG2F/A@ 8A0>.@63*!#'!+ $;06G@G<>6BG2F/A@ :;:8A0>.@63 *!#'!+ A@>2* %#+ % %. . . . . ;<J<:FE;< >SESI8K@FE. . .
(105) .
(106) . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(107) .
(108) .
(109) . $CQ GLRCP?ARGMLQ P`N`R`CQ ?TCA JCQ N?PRGAGN?LRQ MLR AMLRPG@S` \ PCLDMPACP JCSP AMLDG?LAC CLTCPQ J{GLRCPTGCUCSQC ,' CRMLRNCPKGQBCPCASCGJJGPBCQBMLL`CQSRGJCQNMSP?L?JWQCPJCQQWQRaKCQBC PCNP`QCLR?RGMLCRJCQKMRGT?RGMLQBCQ?ARCSPQ,CQBMLL`CQOS?JGR?RGTCQMLR`R`RP?LQAPGRCQB?LQJCSP K?HMPGR` N?P ,' ,' JCQ ? CLQSGRC AMB`CQ \ J{?GBC BS JMEGAGCJ 1$!-GLCPm %KNJMW?LR SLC B`K?PAFCB`BSARMGLBSARGTC LMSQ?TMLQSRGJGQ`BGTCPQCQDMPKCQB{?L?JWQCGLRCPNP`R?RGTC N?PR?LR BCQ BGKCLQGMLQ BS A?BPC AMLACNRSCJ QSP JCQ %$ .MSQ ?TMLQ ?SQQG J?GQQ` J? NMQQG@GJGR` \ BCQ BGKCLQGMLQQSNNJ`KCLR?GPCQB{`KCPECP\N?PRGPBCQBMLL`CQCKNGPGOSCQ . =68/7$76 *#2+64' #(#$4+37''6.#&+((75+10&7&+5%1745574.'#70+8'#7).1$#. ,C AF?NGRPC NS@JG` B?LQ J? PCTSC AD76A>O6I>DC !:6AI= ? NMSP M@HCARGD J{?L?JWQC BS BGQAMSPQQSPJC&"0?SLGTC?SEJM@?J5RGJGQ?LRJ{?NNPMAFCNMQRQRPSARSP?JCBC#?PMJ"?AAFGNMSP ?L?JWQCPJ?K?LGaPCBMLRJCQNMJGRGOSCQPCDJaRCLRCRBMLLCLRAMPNQ\BCQPCNP`QCLR?RGMLQGKNJGAGRCQ BCNPM@JaKCQ "?AAFG LMSQ?TMLQ?L?JWQ`JCQBMLL`CQB{CLRPCRGCLQP`?JGQ`Q?SNPaQBC P`NMLB?LRQ AD4?@JC?S)6 BCLMRCQB{M@QCPT?RGMLN?PRGAGN?LRCB{?RCJGCPQQSPJC&"0 CRBCAGLO BMASKCLRQGLQRGRSRGMLLCJQQSPJC&"0NPMBSGRQN?PBCQ%$ ,{?NNPMAFC BC "?AAFG xDBB:CI A: EGD7AVB: :HI >A G:EGUH:CIU y KCR CL `TGBCLAC J? K?LGaPC BMLRJCQNMJGRGOSCQPCDJaRCLRJCQNPM@JaKCQOS{CJJCQCLRCLBCLRP`QMSBPCCRJ?K?LGaPCBMLRJ{?ARGML NMJGRGOSCQ{CVCPACN?PJC@G?GQBCACRRCxNPM@J`K?RGQ?RGMLy "?AAFG?LB'MMBUGL "?AAFG. . VTGGG.
(110) . . N?PR BS NPGLAGNC OSC JCQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BCQ NPM@JaKCQ DGESP?LR BC D?_ML GKNJGAGRC B?LQ JCQ NMJGRGOSCQ OSG QC TCSJCLR BCQ QMJSRGMLQ \ ACQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BC NPM@JaKCQ PCDJaRCLR JCQ AMKNP`FCLQGMLQ BS KMLBC BC ACSV OSG D?@PGOSCLR JCQ NMJGRGOSCQ $?LQ J{?NNPMAFC "?AAFG NMQC ?GLQGJ?OSCQRGMLQSGT?LRC*J:AHEGUHJEEDHUHDJ=NEDI=VH:HEGD;DC9:H;6TDCH9:8DC8:KD>GA:H 8=DH:H HDJH I:C9:CI 8:H G:EGUH:CI6I>DCH 9J ^EGD7AVB:_ RP?BSARGML GLQNGP`C BC ACJJC BC 1S?BP?LR #MLQCGJ . 0PCL?LR JC A?Q BS &"0 GJ Q{?EGQQ?GR B{GBCLRGDGCP JCQ NP`QSNNMQ`Q CR QWQRaKCQBCAPMW?LACQNPMDMLBQOSGQMSQRCLBCLRJCQPCNP`QCLR?RGMLQBCQNPM@JaKCQBCQQWQRaKCQ BCQ?LR`BCQ0&-2 CRB{?L?JWQCPAMKKCLRACQNP`QSNNMQ`QCRQWQRaKCQBCAPMW?LACD?_MLLCLR JCQBGQAMSPQQSPJC&"0?SLGTC?SEJM@?J.MSQ?TMLQ?GLQG`RSBG`JCQNP`QSNNMQ`QCRQWQRaKCQBC APMW?LACBCQ%$BS&"0K?GQ?SQQGACSVBCQLMLN?PRGQ?LQBS&"00?PKGACSVAG MLAMKNRC ACPR?GLQ MNNMQ?LRQ ?S &"0 K?GQ ?SQQG BC LMK@PCSV M@QCPT?RCSPQ )J Q{?EGQQ?GR LMR?KKCLR BC KCRRPCCLCVCPESCAMKKCLRACQQWQRaKCQBCPCNP`QCLR?RGMLQD?_MLLCLRJCQBGQAMSPQQSPJC&"0?S LGTC?SEJM@?J .MSQ?TMLQ?GLQGKGQCL`TGBCLACJCQQWQRaKCQBCPCNP`QCLR?RGMLQN`AGDGOSCQBCQ%$ ?EGQQ?LR?S LGTC?S EJM@?J CL KMLRP?LR AMKKCLR JCSPQ A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQ ASJRSPCJJCQ CR JCSP DMPK?RGML D?_MLL?GCLR JCSPQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ QMSQH?ACLRCQ BCQ NPM@JaKCQ %L SRGJGQ?LR JCQ QGV NPCKGaPCQ OSCQRGMLQBCJ{?NNPMAFCBC"?AAFG LMSQ?TMLQNSPCJGCPBCD?_MLAPGRGOSCACQPCNP`QCLR?RGMLQBCQ NPM@JaKCQ\JCSPAMKNP`FCLQGMLCR\JCSPAMLACNRGMLBS&"0AMKKCJ?QMJSRGMLNMJGRGOSCJ?NJSQ MNNMPRSLC MS J? KMGLQ MNNMPRSLC \ ACQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BC NPM@JaKCQ 0JSQ NP`AGQ`KCLR LMSQ ?TMLQ `RSBG` J? K?LGaPC BMLR J{SRGJGQ?RGML BCQ AF?KNQ Q`K?LRGOSCQ v PCDJCRQ BCQ N?PAMSPQ BCQ P`NMLB?LRQ v JG`Q ?SV QAGCLACQ BC J{`AMLMKGC QAGCLACQ BC J? ECQRGML QAGCLACQ AJGLGOSCQ QAGCLACQQMAG?JCQ`R?GCLRNP`QCLRQB?LQJCQBGQAMSPQQSPJC&"0 .MQ P`QSJR?RQ MLR KGQ CL `TGBCLAC BCQ AMLACNRGMLQ BS KMLBC RPaQ BGDD`PCLRCQ CR MLR PCJCT` NJSQGCSPQ JGKGRCQ LMR?KKCLR BCQ CLHCSV J?GQQ`Q NMSP AMKNRC ?SV NPM@JaKCQ PCNP`QCLR`Q B?LQ JCQ BGQAMSPQ v ?NNCJ?LR ?GLQG \ D?GPC NPCSTC BC LS?LAC 0?P CVCKNJC NCLB?LR JMLERCKNQ JCQ OSCQRGMLQB{`OSGR`MLR`R`J?PECKCLRGELMP`CQB?LQJCBGQAMSPQQSPJC&"0BCQ%$tJ{GLTCPQC JCQ MNNMQ?LRQ ?S &"0 MLR QMSTCLR `JSB` J? N?STPCR` BCQ AMLBGRGMLQ BC RP?T?GJ CR BCQ Q?J?GPCQ BC J? NJSN?PR BCQ NPMDCQQGMLLCJQ BC J? Q?LR` B?LQ JCQ 0&-2 &?GR GKNMPR?LR LMSQ ?TMLQ M@QCPT` OSC K?JEP`SLCDMPK?RGMLQGKGJ?GPC E`L`P?JCKCLRCL`AMLMKGC JCQ%$BS&"0LCN?PR?EC?GCLRN?Q. . VGV.
(111) . . CV?ARCKCLR JCQ KbKCQ NP`QSNNMQ`Q QMSQH?ACLRQ #CJ? ? QSQAGR` BCQ B`@?RQ N?PKG CSV $CQ QWQRaKCQ BC PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ QGKGJ?GPCQ AMLBSGP?GCLR BMLA N?PDMGQ \ BCQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BCQ NPM@JaKCQBGQRGLARCQ !DGL BC P`NMLBPC \ J? OSCQRGMLBC "?AAFG DBB:CI 8:II: G:EGUH:CI6I>DC 9J EGD7AVB: :HI :AA: 6EE6GJ: LMSQ LMSQ QMKKCQ NCLAF`Q QSP JCQ KMRGT?RGMLQ BCQ %$ NMSP Q{?RR?OSCP ?SV PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BCQ NPM@JaKCQ QSP JCSPQ PCQQMSPACQ Q?TMGP PCQQMSPACQ QMAG?JCQ CR RCKNMPCJJCQ CRA CR JCQ ?SRMPGR`Q DGL?LAGaPC KMP?JC CRA OS{GJQ CVCPACLR ?S LGTC?S EJM@?J .MSQ ?TMLQ LMR?KKCLR KGQ CL JSKGaPC J? K?LGaPC BMLR JCQ %$ K?JEP` JCSPQ BGDD`PCLACQ BC QR?RSR B?LQ J? '3- CVNCPRQGLBGTGBSCJQCRAMKKSL?SR`BCNP?RGOSCK:GHJH@?GJJCSPQBCDMLBQK?HCSPQ MLRKGQ CL AMKKSL JCSPQ ?RMSRQ NMSP ?SEKCLRCP JCSPQ AF?LACQ B{GLDJSCLACP J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 AMPPCQNMLB?LR \ JCSPQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BCQ NPM@JaKCQ NPMNMQGRGML -M@GJGQ?LR JCQ BMLL`CQ B{CLRPCRGCLQ LMSQ?TMLQKMLRP`OSCJCQ%$NP`QCLR?GCLRSLCLQCK@JCAMKNJCVCBCKMRGT?RGMLQ SLCP`CJJCTMJMLR`B{?K`JGMPCPJCQQWQRaKCQBCQ?LR`B?LQJCQ0&-2 BCQGLR`PbRQNMJGRGOSCQ CV E?ELCPBCJ?TGQG@GJGR`?SQCGLBCJ?'3- CRBCQGLR`PbRQDGL?LAGCPQ3{?JGELCPQSPJCAMLRCLSB{SL &"0 PCDJ`R?LR J? RCLB?LAC BC J{?GBC @?Q`C QSP JCQ P`QSJR?RQ NMNSJ?GPC AFCX JCQ @?GJJCSPQ JCSP NCPKCRRP?GR LMR?KKCLR B{M@RCLGP BCQ MNNMPRSLGR`Q BC DGL?LACKCLR ,CQ @?GJJCSPQ MLR DMPRCKCLR QMSRCLS J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 A?P GJ QCK@J?GR AMPPCQNMLBPC \ JCSP NP`MAASN?RGML B{SL PCRMSP QSP GLTCQRGQQCKCLR#CAGRCLB\T?JGBCPLMRPCNPMNMQGRGML &MPRQ BC ACQ KSJRGNJCQ ?RMSRQ JCQ %$ BCT?GCLR RPMSTCP BCQ KMWCLQ NCPRGLCLRQ NMSP NPMKMSTMGP JCSPBGQAM?SPQ?SLGTC?SEJM@?J.MSQ?TMLQSRGJGQ`GAGJ?QGVGaKCOSCQRGMLBC"?AAFG A{CQR\BGPC DBB:CI:IDX8:HG:EGUH:CI6I>DCH9J^EGD7AVB:_DCIUIUEGD9J>I:H9>;;JHU:H:IG:K:C9>FJU:H NMSPGJJSQRPCPJCQQRP?R`EGCQAML_SCQCRSRGJGQ`CQN?PJCQ%$NMSPPCLBPCGLAMLRMSPL?@JCJ?QMJSRGML \ JCSPQ PCNP`QCLR?RGMLQ BC NPM@JaKCQ NPMNMQGRGML #CQ ?ARGMLQ TGQ?GCLR LMR?KKCLR \ G PC B`DGLGP JC &"0 BC D?_ML QRP?R`EGOSC GG AMLRPhJCP J{?ECLB? B{?NNPCLRGQQ?EC QSP JC &"0 GGG B`DGLGP JCQ AMLBGRGMLQ BC J{CVN`PGKCLR?RGML BS &"0 GT CR QSQAGRCP J{`KSJ?RGML NMJGRGOSC CL SRGJGQ?LRBCNSGQQ?LRQCVCKNJCQBCQSAAaQBS&"0NMSPGLQNGPCPJCQB`AGBCSPQBCQ0&-2 tNJSQGCSPQPCNPGQCQ LMSQKMLRPMLQOSCJCB`@?RCLRPC%$CRxLML%$y KGQCLQAaLC?SAMSPQ BCQ CLRPCRGCLQ ? ?KCL` JCQ %$ \ PCA?BPCP JC &"0 ?DGL B{?AAPMdRPC Q? NMNSJ?PGR` 0JSQGCSPQ P`NMLB?LRQ xLML%$y MLR CVNPGK` JCSP GLOSG`RSBC OS?LR ?S D?GR OSC JC &"0 PCNP`QCLRC SLC. . VV.
(112) . . GLLMT?RGMLNMJGRGOSCOSGL{?N?QP`QMJSJCQNPM@JaKCQQRPSARSPCJQBCQQWQRaKCQBCQ?LR`B?LQJCQ 0&-2 !S AMLRP?GPC ACPR?GLQ P`NMLB?LRQ N?PJ?GCLR BS &"0 AMKKC B{SLC x8:G>H: HJG A: <SI:6J H6CH <SI:6Jy CRMS B{SLC xGU;DGB: ;G6<B:CI6>G:y A?P ACRRC P`DMPKC LC QC DMA?JGQ?GR OSC QSP J? P`KSL`P?RGML BCQ NPMDCQQGMLLCJQ BC Q?LR` #CRRC APGRGOSC ? GLAGR` JCQ %$ \ KMBGDGCP NPMEPCQQGTCKCLRJCSPBGQAMSPQCL -CCQQCLCR?J A )JQMLRGLQGQR`QSPJCD?GROSC JC &"0 NMSPP?GR AMK@JCP JC DMQQ` NMRCLRGCJ LML QCSJCKCLR CL MDDP?LR BCQ GLAGR?RGMLQ DGL?LAGaPCQ ?SV?ECLRQBCQ?LR` K?GQ`E?JCKCLRCL?SEKCLR?LRJ?NPMBSARGMLBCPCQQMSPACQNMSPNCPKCRRPC BCQ?K`JGMP?RGMLQBCJ{CLTGPMLLCKCLRBCRP?T?GJCRBCQAWAJCQBCP`RPM?ARGMLNJSQAMSPRQ0JSQGCSPQ PCNP`QCLR?LRQB{%$MLR?SQQGPCAMLLSOSCJC&"0BCT?GRbRPCAMKNJ`R`N?PB{?SRPCQP`DMPKCQBS QWQRaKCBCQ?LR`#CPR?GLQ%$MLRQRP?R`EGOSCKCLRB`DGLGJC&"0AMKKCSLCP`DMPKCQWQR`KGOSC QSQACNRG@JC BC QCPTGP BC JCTGCP \ RMSRCQ JCQ P`DMPKCQ BCQ QWQRaKCQ BC Q?LR` OS{GJ Q{?EGQQC B{SL xNMGLRB{CLRP`CyNMSPJ{?AF?RQRP?R`EGOSC B{?K`JGMP?RGMLBCJ?KMRGT?RGMLBCQ?ECLRQBCQ?LR` MS BCNPMKMSTMGPJ?NMNSJ?GPCxP`TMJSRGMLBCQBMLL`CQyBCQQWQRaKCQB{GLDMPK?RGMLQ?LGR?GPCQ%L MSRPC JCQ%$MLRAMLRPhJ`J?K?HCSPCN?PRGCBCJ{?ECLB?B{?NNPCLRGQQ?ECQSPJC&"0 CLD?@PGOS?LR CRNPMKMST?LRLMR?KKCLRBCQAMLRCLSQNMJGRGQ`QCRRCAFLGAGQ`Q '?SRGCP?LB2GBBC CRJCQ CVN`PGCLACQP`SQQGCQBC&"0 J?HJ88:HHHIDGNPU?LB?GQC LMR?KKCLR ,{GLDJSCLACBGQASPQGTCBCQ %$QCK?LGDCQR?GRBMLA\RP?TCPQJCSPA?N?AGR`\K?dRPGQCPJCQRCPKCQBSB`@?RCRJ?AGPASJ?RGMLBC Q?TMGPQQSPJC&"0?SLGTC?SEJM@?J ACOSGRCLB\AMLDGPKCPLMRPCNPMNMQGRGML 5LC QRP?R`EGC ? A?R?JWQ` J{CLQCK@JC BCQ RPMGQ BCPLGCPQ NPMACQQSQ J{MPE?LGQ?RGML BC KSJRGNJCQ TMW?ECQB{`RSBCB?LQBCQN?WQB{!DPGOSCQS@Q?F?PGCLLC,CQQRP?R`EGCQBCQ%$MLR`E?JCKCLRCS SL CDDCR @MSJC BC LCGEC N?PRGAGN?RGML \ J? AP`?RGML TG? BC KSJRGNJCQ DMPKCQ BC AM?AFGLE CR J? DMPK?RGML LMR?KKCLR B{x%$BCQCAMLBCE`L`P?RGMLyP`N?LB?LRJC&"0QSPJCAMLRGLCLR?DPGA?GL NPMNMQGRGML !S DGL?J ACRRC ?L?JWQC ? KMLRP` OS{GJ CQR NMQQG@JC CR NCPRGLCLR B{SRGJGQCP J{?NNPMAFCNMQRQRPSARSP?JGQRCBC"?AAFGNMSP?L?JWQCPJCQBGQAMSPQCLQ?LR`KMLBG?JC LMR?KKCLR N?PAC OS{CJJC NCPKCR BC B`N?QQCP JCQ B`@?RQ NMJ?PGQ`Q #CRRC `RSBC LMSPPGR ?GLQG BCQ ?PESKCLRQ LS?LA`QNMSPAMKNPCLBPCAMKKCLRJC&"0Q{CQRBGDDSQ`B?LQJCQ0&-2 RMSRCLHCR?LRACPR?GLQ BMSRCQ QSP J? NMQQG@GJGR` OSC JCQ ?ARCSPQ JMA?SV NPMKMST?LR JC &"0 LC QMGCLR N?Q LML NJSQ D?_MLL`QN?PJCQ%$?EGQQ?LR?SLGTC?SEJM@?J . . . VVG.
(113) . . *#2+64' #&+((75+10&7#70+8'#7%106+0'06#.#(4+%#+0 0MSP PCLBPC AMKNRC BC J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 ?S LGTC?S AMLRGLCLR?J LMSQ ?TMLQ P`?JGQ` SLC BCSVGaKC `RSBC CKNGPGOSC NS@JG` B?LQ J? PCTSC "CI:GC6I>DC6A #DJGC6A D; !:6AI= )DA>8N 6C9 &6C6<:B:CI .MSQLMSQQMKKCQGLR`PCQQ`Q?SA?QQN`AGDGOSCB{SLCLRPCNPCLCSPBCJ?BGDDSQGML OSG HMSC SL PhJC BC A?R?JWQCSP BCQ NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGMLCL !DPGOSC QS@Q?F?PGCLLC J? DBBJC6JIU9:)G6I>FJ:9J>C6C8:B:CI6HUHJGA6):G;DGB6C8: #M0&"0 %KNJMW?LR SL BCTGQ BC PCAFCPAFC KGVRC AMLTCPECLR \ BMKGL?LRC OS?JGR?RGTC LMSQ ?TMLQ BMASKCLR` JCQ ?RRPG@SRQ AMPPCQNMLB?LR ?SV A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQ CQQCLRGCJJCQ BC ACR %$ J? QRPSARSPC BSP`QC?SQMAG?JCRJCQQRP?R`EGCQKGQCQCLNJ?ACN?PJ?#M0&"0NMSPD?TMPGQCPJ?BGDDSQGMLBCQ NMJGRGOSCQ \ J? JSKGaPC BCQ BGKCLQGMLQ BS A?BPC BCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC BGDDSQGML 5LC ?L?JWQC Q`K?LRGOSC BS BGQAMSPQ BS DMPSK CL JGELC BC J? #M0 ? `R` P`?JGQ`C . KCQQ?ECQ #CQ P`QSJR?RQOS?LRGR?RGDQMLR`R`AMLDPMLR`Q\SLC?L?JWQCRF`K?RGOSCBCBMLL`CQB{CLRPCRGCLQ . CR\BCQBMLL`CQCVRP?GRCQBCJ?BMASKCLR?RGMLAJ`BCJ?#M0 LMRCBCQWLRFaQC @GJJCRQBC@JME BMASKCLRQ BC RP?T?GJ . $CQ ?L?JWQCQ BC P`QC?SV QMAG?SV QSP J? @?QC BC BMLL`CQ PCJ?RGMLLCJJCQ AMLRPG@SRCSPQ BS DMPSK CL JGELC AGR?LR BCQ KCK@PCQ BC J? #M0 CR BCQ LML KCK@PCQ MLR`R`KCL`CQNMSP`RSBGCPCLNPMDMLBCSPAMKKCLRJ?QRPSARSPCCRJ{MSTCPRSPCBCACRRC AMKKSL?SR` &"0 D?TMPGQ?GCLR JCQ NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGML AMLRGLCLR?JC .MSQ ?TMLQ CLQSGRC CKNJMW`SLCQRP?R`EGCGLRCP?ARGTCBCDSQGML xB:G<>C<y BCQRPMGQAMPNSQBCP`QSJR?RQOS?LRGR?RGDQ CR OS?JGR?RGDQ &CRRCPQ CR ?J 5LC DMGQ ACRRC DSQGML CDDCARS`C LMSQ ?TMLQ SRGJGQ` SLC ?NNPMAFC L?PP?RGTC NMSP PCJGCP J{CLQCK@JC BCQ P`QSJR?RQ \ AF?OSC BGKCLQGML BS A?BPC BCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGML ,CQ?RRPG@SRQ A?P?AR`PGQRGOSCQCQQCLRGCJJCQ BCQKCK@PCQBCJ?#M0AMKNPCL?GCLRBCQQWQRaKCQ BCPCNP`QCLR?RGML?LAP`QB?LQJCQQAGCLACQAJGLGOSCQCR`AMLMKGOSCQ CRSLCDMPRCKMRGT?RGMLBCQ KCK@PCQPCNMQ?LRQSPJ{GB`CQCJMLJ?OSCJJC#M0?K`JGMPCP?GRTGQG@GJGR`CRA?PPGaPCNPMDCQQGMLLCJJC ,CQ KCK@PCQ BC J? AMKKSL?SR` QCK@JCLR BGQNMQCP `E?JCKCLR BC PCQQMSPACQ QMAG?JCQ CR B{SL Q?TMGP GKNMPR?LRQ ,C EPMSNC NPGLAGN?J 8DG: <GDJE BC J? #M0 BMKGL` N?P BCQ KCK@PCQ CSPMN`CLQ BGQNMQ?GR CL MSRPC BC PCQQMSPACQ NMJGRGOSCQ AMLQ`OSCLRCQ CR B{SL ?AAaQ D?AGJGR` ?SV L *LT9<: Cb<OGI<JJ@FE _;<M@J ;< I<:?<I:?<X <JK C8 KI8;L:K@FE ;< 7*8*&7(- )*8.,3 <E 8E>C8@J <KK< <OGI<JJ@FE C8I><D<EK LK@C@JT< G8I C<J :?<I:?<LIJ =I8E:FG?FE<J EFLJ J<D9C< GCLJ G<IK@E<EK< HL< C<J <OGI<JJ@FEJ <DGCFPT<J <E I8E:<_:FE:<GK@FE;<I<:?<I:?<XFL_GC8E;<I<:?<I:?<X G8I<O<DGC< . . VVGG.
(114) . . PCQQMSPACQK?R`PGCJJCQ CRB{SLCP`NSR?RGMLGKNMPR?LRC@?Q`CQSPBGTCPQRWNCQB{?SRMPGR` CVNCPRCCR QAGCLRGDGOSCLMR?KKCLR 0JSQOS{SLCKGQCCLAMKKSLBCACQ?RMSRQ NPMNMQGRGML J{?L?JWQCBC J?#M0D?GRPCQQMPRGPJ?TMJMLR`?DDGAF`CBCACEPMSNCKGLMPGR?GPCBCD?GPC@`L`DGAGCPJCPCQRCBCQ KCK@PCQBCJ?#M0BCQCQ?T?LR?ECQ #CEPMSNC BMKGL`N?PBCQ%$CSPMN`CLQ ?N?P?GJJCSPQQMGELCSQCKCLRB`TCJMNN`BCQ?ARGMLQBC BGDDSQGML TGQ?LR \ J? DMGQ \ NPMKMSTMGP JCQ NP?RGAGCLQ ?DPGA?GLQ CR SL P`NCPRMGPC BC NP?RGOSCQ AMPPCQNMLB?LR\JCSPTGQGMLBS&"0 NPMNMQGRGML .MR?KKCLR ACEPMSNC??BPMGRCKCLR?QQMAG` JCQ NPGLAGNCQ BS &"0 ?SV NPM@JaKCQ K?HCSPQ BCQ QWQRaKCQ BC Q?LR` CL !DPGOSC ,C J?PEC AMLQCLQSQ B?LQ JCQ BGQASQQGMLQ RF`K?RGOSCQ CL JGELC QSP JC &"0 ? AP`` SL DMPR QCLRGKCLR BC AMKKSL?SR` OSGQ{CQRCLPCRMSPP`T`J`bRPCSLRCPP?GLNPMNGAC\J{`KSJ?RGMLNMJGRGOSCN?PKGJCQ KCK@PCQBCJ?#M0,?#M0&"0?`E?JCKCLRAFCPAF`\QSQAGRCPCR\T?JMPGQCPJ?NPMBSARGMLCR J{`AF?LECBCQ?TMGPQCVN`PGCLRGCJQQSPJC&"0CLRPCJCQNP?RGAGCLQ?DPGA?GLQ0MSPACRRCP?GQML CR N?PACOS{CJJC?P`SQQG\KM@GJGQCPSLCK?QQCAPGRGOSCBCNP?RGAGCLQBS&"0 J?#M0?`R`J?PECKCLR NCP_SC AMKKC JC NPGLAGN?J A?R?JWQCSP BCQ NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGML ?S LGTC?S AMLRGLCLR?J ${?GJJCSPQ BC J{?TGQ BC J? K?HCSPC N?PRGC BCQ P`NMLB?LRQ ACRRC AMKKSL?SR` ? HMS` SL PhJC BC NPCKGCPNJ?LB?LQJ?D?@PGOSCCRJ?NPMKMRGMLB{x%$BCQCAMLBCE`L`P?RGMLy OSGMLR\JCSPRMSP N?PRGAGN` \ J{CVN?LQGML BS &"0 QSP JC AMLRGLCLR NPMNMQGRGML #{CQR ?SQQG EP]AC ?S A?P?ARaPC NMJWACLRPGOSC BC J? '3- OSC J? #M0 ? NS CVCPACP QML GLDJSCLAC SLC EMSTCPL?LAC AJ?QQGOSC L{?SP?GRN?QJ?GQQ`J?NMQQG@GJGR`\SLxQGKNJCyP`QC?SBCNP?RGAGCLQBCHMSCPSLRCJPhJC ,? NPMKMRGML B{SL P`NCPRMGPC AMKKSL BC NP?RGOSCQ QSP JC &"0 ? AMLQMJGB` J{GK?EC B{SLC #M0 xAMKKSL?SR``NGQR`KGOSCy?SQCLQBC(??Q ,?AMF`QGML?DDGAF`CQ{CQRAMLQRPSGRCQSPSL ?JGELCKCLRBCQQWQRaKCQBCPCNP`QCLR?RGMLCRSLCAMLTCPECLACB{GLR`PbRQJCQNP?RGAGCLQCRJCSPQ NPMKMRCSPQCSPMN`CLQ?T?GCLRRMSQOSCJOSCAFMQC\E?ELCPB?LQJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0\RP?TCPQJCQ ?ARGTGR`Q BC J? #M0 NPMNMQGRGML #CQ ?ARGTGR`Q AMLQGQR?GCLR LMR?KKCLR \ RCQRCP BCQ DMPK?RQ GLRCP?ARGDQ CR MSTCPRQ W AMKNPGQ \ J? AMKKSL?SR` QAGCLRGDGOSC ?DGL B{`TGRCP BC BCTCLGP SLC AMKKSL?SR` PCNJG`C QSP CJJCKbKC CR NMPRCSQC B{SLC QCSJC CR KbKC xBMARPGLCy "CPRMLC CR ?J -?JEP`JCQCDDMPRQB`NJMW`Q SLACPR?GLAJGT?EC?NN?P?dRCLRPCJ?AMKKSL?SR`QAGCLRGDGOSC HSEC?LR ACQ ?ARGTGR`Q GLQSDDGQ?KKCLR QAGCLRGDGOSCQ CR JCQ KCK@PCQ BC J? #M0 B`DCLB?LR JCSP Q?TMGPCVN`PGCLRGCJN?PDMGQCL`JSB?LRJ?T?JGBGR`CVRCPLCBCACQ?TMGP '?SRGCPCR?J @ . . VVGGG.
(115) . . %LMSRPC JCQP`QSJR?RQBCJ{?L?JWQCBCP`QC?SMLRKMLRP`OSCJ?AMKKSL?SR`NPMKSCAMKKC`R?LR AMLBSGRC N?P J{!DPGOSC LC AMPPCQNMLB?GR N?Q CV?ARCKCLR \ J? QRPSARSPC BC EMSTCPL?LAC P`QC?S J?PECKCLR BMKGL`C N?P JCQ KCK@PCQ CSPMN`CLQ @GCL OSC JCSP BMKGL?RGML ?GR CS RCLB?LAC \ BGKGLSCP?TCAJCRCKNQ$CD?GR J{GLRCP?ARGML?SQCGLBCACRRCAMKKSL?SR`L{`R?GRFMPGXMLR?JCOSC HSQOS{\SLACPR?GLNMGLRJCQ`AF?LECQ`R?GCLRBMKGL`QN?POSCJOSCQCSPMN`CLQ NJSQQMSTCLRAGR`Q OSC JCQ ?DPGA?GLQ NCP_SQ AMKKC JCQ xCVNCPRQ MPGEGL?SV BS &"0y ,C D?GR OSC JCQ NP?RGAGCLQ ?DPGA?GLQ QMGCLR CL PCAFCPAFC B{MNNMPRSLGR`Q NMSP JCSP A?PPGaPC JCQ NJ?_?GR QMSTCLR B?LQ SLC NMQRSPC B{GLD`PGMPGR` TGQ\TGQ BCQ CSPMN`CLQ ${?GJJCSPQ ACSVAG AMLRGLS?GCLR \ ?TMGP SL ?AAaQ NPGTGJ`EG` ?SV MPE?LGQ?RGMLQ GLRCPL?RGML?JCQ W AMKNPGQ JCQ @?GJJCSPQ BC DMLB JCQ NJSQ GLDJSCLRCQ B?LQJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0 0MSP ?SR?LR A{CQR J{GK?EC B{SLC #M0 NPMKMST?LR BCQ CVNCPRQ ?DPGA?GLQ CR JCSP Q?TMGP CVN`PGCLRGCJ BCTCLSQ xAF?KNGMLQBS &"0y OSG ? `R` AMLQCPT`C B?LQ J{?PaLC BC J? '3- #CRRC GK?EC`R?GRDMPRCKCLRNP`QCLRCB?LQJCQBMLL`CQBCQCLRPCTSCQ%JJC?NPM@?@JCKCLR`R`CLRPCRCLSC N?PAC OS{CJJC QCPT?GR JCQ GLR`PbRQ BCQ NPMKMRCSPQ BS &"0 ?S LGTC?S EJM@?J OSG Q{CDDMP_?GCLR BC PCLBPC J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 AMKKC `R?LR AMLBSGRC N?P JCQ 0&-2 CR OSG TMW?GCLR CL J? #M0 SL xB6G@:IEA68:yMNNMPRSLNMSPPCAPSRCPBCQ?QQGQR?LRQRCAFLGOSCQ\J{CVN`PGKCLR?RGMLBS&"0,CQ NP?RGAGCLQ ?DPGA?GLQ QMLR PCQR`Q BC D?GR J?PECKCLR B`NCLB?LRQ BC DGL?LACKCLRQ CVR`PGCSPQ NMSP N?PRGAGNCP?SVNPMHCRQNGJMRCQBC&"0 $CNJSQ KbKCQ{GJQN?PRGAGN?GCLRBCD?_MLGKNMPR?LRC?SV ?ARGTGR`Q BC J? #M0 JCQ NP?RGAGCLQ ?DPGA?GLQ MLR AMLRGLS` \ ?TMGP @CQMGL BC J? T?JGB?RGML N?P JCQ xCVNCPRQ MPGEGL?SVy NMSP E?ELCP CL TGQG@GJGR` ,? #M0 ? BMLA D?GR `KCPECP BCQ NPMACQQSQ OSG K?GLRCL?GCLRJCQPCJ?RGMLQBCNMSTMGPGLGRG?JCQ !GLQG K?JEP` BCQ GLRCLRGMLQ JMS?@JCQ BC PCLTCPQCP JC N?WQ?EC B`AGQGMLLCJ `R?@JG SLC ?PaLC BC '3- BMKGL`C N?P BCQ ?ARCSPQ BCQ N?WQ \ F?SR PCTCLS BCQ NCPQMLL?JGR`Q GLDJSCLRCQ CR BCQ MPE?LGQ?RGMLQGLRCPL?RGML?JCQAMLRGLS?GCLR\ESGBCPJCNPMACQQSQB{CVN`PGKCLR?RGML B{`KSJ?RGMLCR B{?NNPCLRGQQ?ECBCQNMJGRGOSCQPCJ?RGTCQ?SVQWQRaKCQBCQ?LR` KbKCQGCJJCQ`R?GCLR?NNJGOS`CQ B?LQ JCQ N?WQ B{!DPGOSC QS@Q?F?PGCLLC NPMNMQGRGML ,CQ NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGML ?S LGTC?S AMLRGLCLR?J QRGKSJ`Q N?P J? #M0 ?SP?GCLR BMLA `AFMS` \ `@P?LJCP J{`AMLMKGC NMJGRGOSC BC J?. . VVGT.
(116) . . BGDDSQGMLBS&"0 K?POS`CN?PBCDMPRCQGL`E?JGR`QCLRPCJCQ?ARCSPQBCQ0&-2CRACSVBCQN?WQ\ F?SRPCTCLS B{%SPMNCCRB{!K`PGOSCBS.MPB . *#2+64'
(117) #&+((75+10&7#7#.+#7:0+8'#7:%'064#.#/#-1'6&=%'064#.+5= 4=)+10&'17.+-141'65'5&+564+%65 $?LQ SLC RPMGQGaKC `RSBC CKNGPGOSC NS@JG` B?LQ J? PCTSC !:6AI= )DA>8N 6C9 )A6CC>C< LMSQ LMSQ QMKKCQ NCLAF`Q QSP J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 ?S LGTC?S L?RGML?J CL SRGJGQ?LR JC A?Q BS -?JG $CNSGQ JC -?JG Q{CQR J?LA` B?LQ SLC P`DJCVGML QSP J{?BMNRGML BS &"0 ?DGL B{?K`JGMPCP J{SRGJGQ?RGMLCRJ?OS?JGR`BCQQCPTGACQBCQ?LR`K?RCPLCJJCCRGLD?LRGJC%LRPCCR JCN?WQ ?AMLLSBCSVAMSPRCQCVN`PGCLACQBC&"0B?LQJ?P`EGMLBC+MSJGIMPM ?NNCJ`CQxNP`NGJMRCyCR xNGJMRCy$CLMK@PCSV?ARCSPQ`RP?LECPQ B{%SPMNCCRB{!DPGOSC MLRAMLRPG@S`\BGDDSQCPJ{GB`CCR JCQ NPGLAGNCQ BS &"0 ?SNPaQ BCQ ?ARCSPQ K?JGCLQ BS LGTC?S ACLRP?J CR BC RMSQ JCQ LGTC?SV BC J? B`ACLRP?JGQ?RGMLQ?LGR?GPC#CQ?ARCSPQ`RP?LECPQN?PRGAGNCLR\J?AP`?RGMLB{SLLMW?SB{CVNCPRQBS &"0?S-?JG .MSQ?TMLQSRGJGQ`SLBCTGQB{`RSBCBCA?QOS?JGR?RGDJMLEGRSBGL?J,CA?Q`R?GRJ?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0 ?S -?JG BC \ LMR?KKCLR ?SV LGTC?SV ACLRP?J "?K?IM CR B`ACLRP?JGQ` P`EGML BC +MSJGIMPM CR QCQ BGQRPGARQ #CRRC `RSBC BC A?Q `R?GR BC RWNC >CHIGJB:CI6A 3R?IC B?LQ JC QCLQ Mk JCQ N?PRGASJ?PGR`Q BC J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 ?S -?JG NCPKCRRCLR BC P`T`JCP SL NF`LMKaLC QMAG?JB{GLR`PbRNJSQJ?PEC \Q?TMGPJ{GLDJSCLACNPMR`GDMPKCB{?ARCSPQ?EGQQ?LR\NJSQGCSPQLGTC?SV JCQxCLRPCNPCLCSPQBCJ?BGDDSQGMLy NMSPD?AGJGRCPJ{CVN?LQGMLBS&"0$?LQJCA?QK?JGCL LMSQ ?TMLQ KGQ CL JSKGaPC AMKKCLR JCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGML `RP?LECPQ %SPMN`CLQ CR !DPGA?GLQ CRJMA?SVMLRGLDJSCLA`J?BGDDSQGMLBS&"0B?LQACN?WQ ,{`RSBC BC A?Q `R?GR P`RPMQNCARGTC J? AMJJCARC BCQ BMLL`CQ Q{CQR B`PMSJ`C BC H?LTGCP \ LMTCK@PC%JJCQ{?NNSGCQSPBCQBMLL`CQAMJJCAR`CQ\N?PRGPBCCLRPCRGCLQ?NNPMDMLBGQ CLRPCRGCLQ GLDMPKCJQ AGLO Q`?LACQ B{M@QCPT?RGML N?PRGAGN?LRC BC P`SLGMLQ CR BMASKCLRQ AJ`Q QSP JC DGL?LACKCLR @?Q` QSP J? NCPDMPK?LAC &"0 NPMBSGRQ BC \ #CQ BMLL`CQ OS?JGR?RGTCQ MLR `R` CVNMPR`CQ B?LQ 1$!-GLCPm CR AMB`CQ QCJML SLC ?NNPMAFC GLRCPNP`R?RGTC ?PRGASJ`C ?SRMSP BCQ BGKCLQGMLQ BS A?BPC BCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGML 5LC QWLRFaQC ? CLQSGRCNCPKGQBCPCLBPCAMKNRCBCD?_MLCKNGPGOSCBCAF?OSCBGKCLQGMLBSA?BPCRF`MPGOSC. . VVT.
(118) . . ,{FGQRMGPC BC J? BGDDSQGML BS &"0 ?S -?JG BC \ Q{CQR P`T`J`C GLBGQQMAG?@JC BC J? D?@PGOSC CR BC J{?ARGML BCQ CLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGML %$ B?LQ AC N?WQ 5L %$ CSPMN`CL CVNCPR RP?T?GJJ?LR NMSP SL MPE?LGQKC FMJJ?LB?GQ BC AMMN`P?RGMLB`TCJMNNCKCLR CL Q?LR` JC x+)4y ?HMS`SLPhJCBCNPCKGCPNJ?LB?LQJ?D?@PGOSCB{%$K?JGCLQ3SPJ?@?QCB{CVN`PGCLACQ BCRP?T?GJCLAMKKSLNCLB?LRSLCBGX?GLCB{?LL`CQ ACRCVNCPRFMJJ?LB?GQ ?B`TCJMNN`BCQMJGBCQ PCJ?RGMLQ NPMDCQQGMLLCJJCQ ?TCA BCSV CVNCPRQ CL QWQRaKC BC Q?LR` RP?T?GJJ?LR B?LQ J? P`EGML BC +MSJGIMPM CRSLB`AGBCSPN?PRCL?GPCBCNPMHCRQBCB`TCJMNNCKCLRN?QQ`Q TGQ?LR\AMLQMJGBCPJCQ KCQSPCQBCB`ACLRP?JGQ?RGML ,?P`NSR?RGMLBCACRCVNCPRFMJJ?LB?GQ QMLQ?TMGPCRQCQPCQQMSPACQ QMAG?JCQ MLR `R` KGQCQ CL AMKKSL ?TCA JCQ PCQQMSPACQ RCKNMPCJJCQ CR NMJGRGOSCQ CR J{?SRMPGR` KMP?JCBCQ?ARCSPQK?JGCLQ NPMNMQGRGML ,CQSAAaQNCP_SBCACQNPMHCRQ OSGKM@GJGQ?GCLRJCQ NP`KGQQCQ BS &"0 AMLRP?ARS?JGQ?RGML ?DGL B{MN`P?RGMLL?JGQCP JC RP?LQDCPR BC AMKN`RCLACQ CL Q?LR` ?QQMAG` \ SL N?QQ` AMKKSL CR BCQ DMPK?RGMLQ QGKGJ?GPCQ CL `AMLMKGC CR ECQRGML BCQ QCPTGACQBCQ?LR` CRSLGLR`PbR\D?GPC`TMJSCPJCSPQA?PPGaPCQPCQNCARGTCQ MLRD?_MLL`JCQRPMGQ%$ K?JGCLQ#CRRCAMKKSL?SR`K?JGCLLCD?TMP?@JC?S&"0Q?T?GRCLCDDCROS{GJ`R?GRB?LQQMLGLR`PbR BC D?GPC Q? NPMKMRGML `R?LR BMLL` JCQ MNNMPRSLGR`Q B{?T?LACKCLR BC A?PPGaPC OSG BCTCL?GCLR NMQQG@JCQEP]AC?SVJ?PECQDGL?LACKCLRQBGQNMLG@JCQNMSPNGJMRCPACRRCNMJGRGOSC NPMNMQGRGML 5LCDMGQAMLQGB`P`N?PJ{CVNCPRFMJJ?LB?GQAMKKCQSDDGQ?KKCLRxNPbRy J{SLBCQ%$K?JGCLQCQR BCTCLS CL SL x%$ BC QCAMLBC E`L`P?RGMLy BGDDSQ?LR JC &"0 CL 'SGL`C CL AMJJ?@MP?RGML ?TCAJC+)4$`@SR JCQBCSV?SRPCQ%$K?JGCLQMLR`E?JCKCLR`R`NPMKSQCLCLRPCNPCLCSPQ BC J? BGDDSQGML N?P JCSP Q`JCARGML P`ACLRC NMSP N?PRGAGNCP \ J{CVN`PGKCLR?RGML BS &"0 CL -?SPGR?LGC#CNF`LMKaLCAMKNJCVCB{GLRCP?ARGMLQCLRPCGLBGTGBSQ?SVGLDJSCLACQGL`E?JCQOSC LMSQB`APGTMLQBCD?_MLB`R?GJJ`CB?LQJCAF?NGRPC T?JGBC\J?DMGQLMQCRNPMNMQGRGMLQ /LPCRPMSTCAC@CQMGLBCT?JGB?RGMLN?PJCQ%$xMPGEGL?SVyB?LQJCAF?NGRPCNP`A`BCLR,?NJ?AC NP`NMLB`P?LRC BC J{CVNCPR FMJJ?LB?GQ B?LQ J{CLQCK@JC BCQ NPMACQQSQ BC BGDDSQGML PCDJaRC LMR?KKCLRAMKKCLRJCNMSTMGPBCxQGKNJCQyGLBGTGBSQNCSRQ{CVCPACPB?LQJCQ0&-2 ,CQ %$ `RP?LECPQ CR K?JGCLQ MLR `E?JCKCLR AMLBSGR J{?ECLB? B{?NNPCLRGQQ?EC BS &"0 BCQ B`AGBCSPQ CR @SPC?SAP?RCQ K?JGCLQ ?S DGJ BS RCKNQ v N?P BC KSJRGNJCQ DMPK?RGMLQ TMW?ECQ B{`RSBCQ CR `AF?LECQ ?TCA BCQ CVNCPRQ ?DPGA?GLQ BS &"0 )JQ MLR ?SQQG GLDJSCLA` JCQ NPMACQQSQ B{`KSJ?RGMLCLRPCJCQ?ARCSPQCLD?TCSPBS&"0 CLMPE?LGQ?LR?SB`@SRBCJ?B`ACLLGCBCQ xBdLCPQ@?Q`QQSPJCQP`QSJR?RQyB?LQSLEP?LBFhRCJBC"?K?IMNMSPAMLT?GLAPCJCQB`AGBCSPQBC. . VVTG.
Documents relatifs
Because of the reality of variable surface and surface fractional coverage by water this is called the “minimum active area.” It was calculated for all SWAN water production rates
ا اخث ذنننننن يمثها نننننن ذ لهثانننننننلخاي نننننن مثاثلننننننحاي اخذننننننسث دمثانننننننلخادننننننيدرمثاتنننننن بادننننننقه ي الماحترنننننن لحثا
We will come up with a strong and a weak definition of uncertainty aversion (resp. seeking), providing a new characterization of necessity measures in terms of pessimism (resp.,
The germanium photodetector integration is carried out at the end of Si waveguides with a butt coupling scheme. This integration scheme calls upon the selective epitaxial growth of
( ﻪﻠﻀﻓ ﻰﻠﻋ ﷲ ﺪﻤﺤﻟﺎـﻓ رﻮﻨﻠﻟ ﻊﺿاﻮﺘﻤﻟا ﻞﻤﻌﻟا اﺬﻫ جﺮﺧ ﻰﻟﺎﻌﺗ ﻪﻧﻮﻋو ﷲا ﻞﻀﻔﺑ ﻢﻳﺮﻜﻟا رﻮﺘﻛﺪﻟاو ﻪﺟﻮﻤﻟاو فﺮﺸﻤﻟا ﻰﻟإ ﻞﻳﺰﺠﻟا ﻘﻳﺮﻄﻟا اﺬﻫ ﻲﻓ ﺎﻨﻟ ﺮﺒﻨﻣو ﻞﻴﻟد ﺮﻴﺧ نﺎﻜﻓ ﺚﺤﺒﻟا اﺬﻫ
Methodology to co-design temperate fruit tree-based agroforestry systems: three case studies in Southern France.. World Congress on Agroforestry, May 2019,
Cet écart entre les prin- cipes du mécanisme que la physiologie devra suivre et les explicantia qu’il est en 1710 déjà possible de proposer est manifeste dans la promotion de la
The other representative of RAS considers a dual approach to the concept of the digital economy: the first – classical one - according to which “digital economy” is