HAL Id: hal-02747321
https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-02747321
Submitted on 3 Jun 2020
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
New insights on lime and lemon origins from targeted
nuclear gene sequencing, SSRs, InDels and cytoplasmic
markers genotyping
Franck Curk, Andres Garcia-Lor, Hajer Snoussi, Yann Froelicher, Gema
Ancillo, Luis Navarro, Patrick Ollitrault
To cite this version:
Franck Curk, Andres Garcia-Lor, Hajer Snoussi, Yann Froelicher, Gema Ancillo, et al.. New insights on
lime and lemon origins from targeted nuclear gene sequencing, SSRs, InDels and cytoplasmic markers
genotyping. 12. International Citrus Congress, Nov 2012, Valencia, Spain. 2012. �hal-02747321�
!
"# $
% &
#$
!
"#
$
% & #
'
'
( &#)" & *+,- #*.* # . / " .#& "! 0 / 1 2 % 3 &#&"&* $ . # * 4 &# #* # 0 $ 1 & * % *& #* $ & .- 5#*& *.* # + # 3 ' 0 &#&"& &#* . . , , * *!#)" '" # # 1 '" # # 3 & **+ &#* & &#* . , , * *!#)" +*" . 2 4 .*++ ! & 0 21 5 6
* & & ! #.7 " 8 * 6# 69 3 . 4 *8 #4# 6 3 + & # 6*..#& ".&8 # 69 * & & ! #.7 " 8 * 6# 69 3 . 4 *8 #4# 6 3 + & # 6*..#& ".&8 # 69
& # : .# 4 &, & 9*" : # & ; 0 1 $ 0 1 0 1 , 4
& .. ". & + # 6 2 + # * &, :*& # . . #9# &#* . !* .#! . #9# #&, # &*
&< * + # 0 < # . 1 * # &* !* &, ( 0' 16 * &* . #9- &, +,-.* - *9
&,# *"+ < " " . % 9 *! = & & 2 9 ! & !# :- )" # ( " . .
0 # * 6 ( :1 " . 0 * .# , 6 ((>3 " * 6 ((>1 !#&* ,* # . . 0 * .# , 6
( 1 = ,.* *+. &# ! 0 *&9- 6 (( 1 9* = . !* .#! *!+ < #&, ? + &  *9 &,
: # & ; > * - + # 6
& * " &#*
#
#
%
$ #
#
" . !* @ - . !* $*. ! . !* *" , . !* #!* && @ , @ ;# .#! . !*<#
#
( (6 (6 (6 (6 (6= (6A (6B (6> (6? C #. .* < . 9 4 + # * # . * + & % * " # 2 -. " .. # , . % # ! * # % + # ' , #& # #D * 2 # ! & * # % * # * ! " 5 " , , * ! : 4 @ . # + + 6 ! # &, , . ! * 4# .. * " 5 * " ) " & . " 6 6 .# ! #! * && @ , # : * . ! * < & . ! * " . ! * . : # : ! * & % . &# < & .# ! * " , . ! * $ * . ! . ! * + " .# ! @ -. ! * % * * @ ;# .# ! 6 ! * + , -. . . ! * < .+ #. #! @ , + 9 " #& , ! * " &# < & * $ . # . & < & * @ # #& * @# &, %"!! .* *" *@
%
$ #
#
%
@
"
$
@
Valencia late delta Ponderosa lemon Palestine Sweet lime
Lisbon lemon Limonette de Marrakech Willowleaf Avana apireno Cleopatra Chandler Pink Nam Roi Sans Pépins Tahiti Ichang papeda Rough lemon Karna lime Sweet lemon Volkameriana lemon Rangpur lime Meyer lemon Eureka lemon Citrus bergamia
Sevillano Sour Orange Bouquet de Fleurs SO Marsh Shamouti Eremocitrus Round kumquat Nagami kumquat Kumquat Microcitrus Microcitrus Rubidoux Pomeroy $ $ ' Mediterranean Avana apireno King Cleopatra Ponkan Sunki Dancy Clausellina Chandler Pink Nam Roi Sans Pépins Tahiti Rough lemon Karna lime Limonette de Marrakech Lisbon lemon Sweet lemon Volkameriana lemon RangpurLime Meyer lemon Ponderosa lemon Eureka lemon Citrus bergamia Dulce Palestina Marsh Shamouti Valencia late delta Eremocitrus Round kumquat Nagami kumquat Microcitrus Microcitrus Rubidoux Pomeroy
Sevillano Sour Orange Bouquet de Fleurs So % #$ ( #$ #$ C #. .* < . 9 4 + # * # . * + & % * " # 2 -. " .. # , . % # ! * # % + # ' , #& # #D * 2 # ! & * # % * # * ! " 5 " , , * ! : 4 @ . # + + 6 ! # &, , . ! * 4# .. * " 5 * " ) " & . " 6 6 .# ! #! * && @ , # : * . ! * < & . ! * " . ! * . : # : ! * & % . &# < & .# ! * " , . ! * $ * . ! . ! * + " .# ! @ -. ! * % * * @ ;# .# ! 6 ! * + , -. . . ! * < .+ #. #! @ , + 9 " #& , ! * " &# < & * $ . # . & < & *
# 7 %*+". &#* & " &" + & &#* 0 ') 1
0 & " &" *9&< 7 ,&&+7EE+ #& ,6: 6" ,# *6 "E & " &" 6,&!.1
# 7 # ,:* F*# # ' 9 *! " $ @ &
# 7 # ,:* F*# # ' 9 *! % @ &
02 < # 02# #!#. #&- .- # + & &#* 9* C# *< 17 ,&&+7EE < # 6 # 69 E *! 6+,+1
*" *"+ *9. !* .#! < #99 &# & 09# 17 *"+ G% . &# < & .#! 0 ' 61 @ -. !* 0 6 ' 61 %* * 0 61H *"+ G #!* && @ , 0 # *1
.#! 0 961 # :* < & " . !* 0 0 1 5" !61 # * I %*#&6H , 4 +"!! .* &-+ -&*+. ! 09# 16 *"+ , #& -&*+. ! < #&, *" 0 61 < ,#. *"+ , #& < #&, < & * + 9 "#& 09# 13 *"+ G *" , . !* 0 " ,61 $*. ! . !* 0 :61
+" .#! 0 :61H , # # @ # &-+ -&*+. ! *"+ G@ ;# .#! 0 0 0.1 Willowleaf King Ponkan Sunki Dancy Clausellina Arizona Diamante Corsican Poncire Comun Buddha hand Combava Citrus micrantha Mexican lime Alemow Kalpi lime Severinia $ * $ ) 0 0.5 Arizona Diamante Corsican Poncire Comun Digitado Combava Ichang papeda Melanesian papeda Citrus micrantha Mexican lime Alemow Kalpi lime Round kumquat Nagami kumquat Kumquat Severinia
.. .-D . !* .#! . & &* #& * 09# 16 *" * ++ + & . *"+ *9 *! . !* .#! .# .#! #!* && @ , # :* " < & . !*
6 *&, *"+ * &#&"& :- % . &# < & .#! *" , . !* $*. ! . !* +" .#! @ - . !* ! &* ".& ! # .- 9 *! #& * ! #
* & #:"&#* 6 %* * ! &* : # &.- . & &* +"!! .* #& * 6 @ ;# .#! . !*< +" .#! 0 :61H , # # @ # &-+ -&*+. ! *"+ G@ ;# .#! 0
0 , # &!61 < # 1 . !*< 0 C & 1 .+# .#! 0 C & 1 ,
-&*+. !6 * *9 &, *"+ ,*< - #& * ! ! & . * & #:"&#* 6 ! # &, . !*< #& * @ , 6 + " 6 $ * . ! # " + " +%
* & #:"&#* 6 %* * ! &* : # &.- . & &* +"!! .* #& * 6 @ ;# .#! . !*< .+# .#! , )"#.#: & * & #:"&#* *9 6 #& * 6 ', - 4 - . .-#99 &# & 9 *! &, *&, .#! . !* # &, ." & .- # 09# A16 ', ": ." & # *9&, *&, .#! . !* 09# A1 # .*: ..- # ! &< #&, &, & " &" .- # 6
%
.- #
(6A (6B (6> (6? & !# & #&E!# #&E%"! #&E@ @ E%"! % 73 72 C. micrantha Sweet oranges 0 (6 AJ 1 0 >6 =J 1 0 >6 J 1 %"!! .* %* * 6! # &, . !*< @ # *" @ , 6 + " $ * . ! # 6 " + ( (6 (6 (6 (6 (6= (6A 4# .. * " 5 * " ) " & . " 6 6 .# ! @ , .* ! * && # : * . ! * < & . ! * " . ! * 6 : ! # . : # * " , . ! * $ * . ! . ! * + " .# ! @ -. ! * % . &# < & .# ! % * * @ ;# .# ! 6 ! * + , -. . .. ! * < .+ #. #! @# E!# #&E #& %"!E%"! @ E@ 0 0.2 61 78 96 100 100 100 73 98 67 100 Lisbon lemon Ponderosa Mexican lime C. bergamia P ale stin e s w ee t C. macrophylla,Allemow Kalpi lime Sour oranges=B= % < # 	# # (> ? +: *9&, = & & )" 9 ! & 6 * , % # #+ . *!+* & .- # 0% 1 < + 9* ! 9 *! % & &* .-D &, +,-.* #&# *&-+# & " &" 0 6 6 # " 16 &< "++* &, & # & ! # - +* #&#* : &< &< * : # & ; ." & * +* &* # & + #9# , & *D- * #&-3 &,# ,-+*&, # <
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
" &# !* *!+. ; * # # " , 00%;@1; 1 ; 0%;@1 9* 0@# ; 1 ; 9* . !*< 0%; 1;0%; 1 9* 0 (6 AJ 1 # A7 # ,:* K*# # & 9 *! " . ! 0 ( . 1 w ee tlim e
# =7 %,-.* &# " . *&-+# & " &" "! 9 *! !".&#.* " .- # *9 = 9 ! &
# 7 2 % + & &#* 9* *&-+ # &#* *9 &, ?= +: )" 9 ! & *9&,
9
•* .# , 6 2 !:# 26 5 F656* & &# *6*&9- 6 2# *"& 6 5"!* & $6 5 *&&#%6# & " # 6@6" * 6..#& ".& %6 ((>6 , & #D &#* *9!# * & ..#& ! # ! # * 0 5.*16 @*. ". *.* - *" > 0 17? 6
•* .# , 6 @*", - C6 5 F656* & &# *6 !# # @6" * 6 @* #..*6 ..#& ".& %6 0 (1 < " #4 .!#&* ,*# .% ! 4.< # 9* ! &#* * ! & . #& " +,-.* -6 ' &# *!B7 ? A
• L*6" * 6 4* 6 ..#& ".& %6 0 (1 *!+ " *9 2 . ! # #+, # &, # &+#9#& " &" *9 ". & #& " &# #4#&-7+ + 9* &# * # &#*&" # 6 @*. ". &# *!# >B 0 17 BB ? 6
• # *6" 6 *" #6 @* #..* 6 #..*6" * 6 4* 6 ..#& ".& %6 0 (16" . +,-.* - < #&,# 0 "& 1 9*" . & 6 . *9 5*& -6 *#7 (6 (? E *:E! B
•" * 6* & &# *6 ' *.F6 6 *"& M6.. #* '6 C# %6 ' .* @6..#& ".& %6 @* #..*6 0 ((>1 ' 9:#.#&- *9&, ' 4 .*+ * ". . !&# 0 * & ; '1 &* *&, #& "+# &, #99  9* &# ! ++#6 5@ *!#? 0 >B17 6
•*&9- 6" * 6 * .# , 6# & " #6@6#..*"; 26 ..#& ".& %6 0 (( 1 2 4 .*+!& *9 !# * & ..#& ! *9 ,.* *+. &# *!&" # # G%* & : &&? (H6 B&,
" &# !* *!+. ; * # # " , 00%;@1; 1 ; 0%;@1 9* 0@# ; 1 ; 9* . !*< 0%; 1;0%; 1 9* %* * 6
" . -&*+. !# & * 9# ! + 4#*" ,-+*&, # 0 # *.* # & .6 (((1 9* *! .#! . !* ..*< + *+* # < * # # ,-+*&, # 9* *&, 7 " # :* < &. !* < .. @ , .#! ".&9 *! *" * ; #& * ,-: # #D &#*
# + *: :.- ,-: # : &< *" * - ..*< . !* 0 " &-+ 1 %* * * : &< &< * 0+"!! .* ; #& * 1 ,-: # $*. ! . !* +" .#! *" , . !* ,*". : # &,-: # : &< ! # 9 *! &, # # *"+ #& *
@ ;# .+# .#! ,*". ".&9 *! ; #& * ,-: # #D &#* . !*< ,*". : 0 ; #& * 1 ; #& * : *
', * # # *9 % . &# < &.#! @ - . !* ++ !* *!+. ;
"&" !".&#.* " % .- # *9 . "!: *9 #& 9* +,-.* &# # &#* *92 9 ! & < #.. ..*< &* #+, &, # & + #9# !* # *! & " &" *9&,# + &# ". *"+ < #.. #4 !* < :*"&,# * # # 6
Instituto Valenciano de Investigaciones Agrarias
, &#* . &#&"& 9* # ".&" . ,
& &#* . &*9 # ".&" . , 9* 2 4 .*+!&
*
." #*
•*&9- 6" * 6 * .# , 6# & " #6@6#..*"; 26 ..#& ".& %6 0 (( 1 2 4 .*+!& *9 !# * & ..#& ! *9 ,.* *+. &# *!&" # # G%* & : &&? (H6 B&, & &#*. * *9%. &@*. ". 5#*.* -%@5 ((5 .*0 + # 1 F" >6
•# *.* # 6 2 N6 6 &#.6 @ .96* &#..6 ' #:". &* 6 0 (((1 +,-.* - &# * # # *9#!+* & & +# # 4 &#&:- !*. ". ! 6 ', * &#. ++.# &# ((7 == AA6