• Aucun résultat trouvé

MAY 10

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "MAY 10"

Copied!
197
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

CENTRE FOR NEWFOUNDLAND STUDIES

TOTAL OF 10 PAGES ONLY MAY BE XEROXED

(Without Author's Permission)

(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)

-._, ·.I "

" ',

.. ~ : ·: ..... ' ....

·~.: .. _-·,.··, , , I• ~ .. . ~

,

. ' . . ~ •' .

.

.

···. --~·- '

.... · ._ ~

' ... · ,. •! • ~ . ' '\ . - . ·;,_'\. ...; . ~

-

~

.

-~---

_:_ ._i"' - - --.::__

. . --....

---.

... .~

'.

...

_

'-..:.

\

\,

(

.·

. ..

.

. .

,.,

...

•·

\

~

.. v . . ·.

' .. ·

\ .·.- (•' 1 ....

.. 1

..._

...

. "' .. A

ST~DY OF. SE~~~.TED · F~CTORS -~SOc'IATED

WITH

·.THE SUPPLY OF ·AND D~D- FOR .

.

· ' •

PUBLIC SCHOOL-TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS

.. --- _,. . \ ' . . . .... ...

. IN . THE

PROVI~CE. OF

NEWFOuNDLAND AND'

~RADOR' .

. . ·.FOR-;;-

SCBOO!v.EAR :~-9'85-1986

·.

:~-

,. '

- .

' ·.

' I

I '

\ \ ...

. '.

..

~ ~ ..

. ,

·. __ It.·_ ' • . _ ... ;.·- '. ··~·· ~-. . . .. ... ·. . . ~ : . . . '

·. --~ A. th~sis p~r~sei1teq. ·to_ the' · ·:· . . . ' / ·.

Depa_rt.nen:_~· of \Educational"Admini's't.ra~ ·

· : -~Me_fllor .i.a~-:--Uf!.~~~~i ty of Newfoundlancl · . -

' . '"-<~ ... ' ~- ~-

\.· ' -~

. .

.

..

.

I· ~-

>

' · -~- -

"<'---~

Submltt'ed 'in partial ·fulfillment of the requirements for the·degree of

· Master of Education' . .

' ~ @ .

)

' . .. '

( .

.. .

I v .

Harold L. Press '· · · ,

' ""'

'-Fall, . ; ' 1987 .

, ..

... ,.

' I

I

. / · .

/

. '

\

\

/

.

\

. · .. · . .. r ,•.

. \

_;:~- ~~- -

·

. .

.

..

.

-. . ~·· ·. ..

· .. \.JI

\

. ' I _j

! .

.

-~

•' '

1 : ..

·1 ,., .:

I .,

' _,.

I I

..-

I

\, ,!

'

...

.. ,

: · ' .

(6)

\ '

....

'• .

.

.

"

~ -~. '

.

·.\ ·

·"

' I

.

.

~; ,

~ o I ..._ _ _

' -

_ ,

r !

· - ·

J..

. .

· Permission has.· been graqt~d

·.to ·_the ~NatioJ?.al . Lfb_;a'i:-y · of Canana, / -· to microfilm- I ·this , t-he-s}s 'an~ ;to .. ·lel)d or. ·s~ll

./:-

~--~-·· f --

.

~ ' ' ~:~ -:~

. I

• •

~

.

. ·;:; ._;Q

.

Y. ...

'

-

)

.. 1

~

t · .

.. ,.

L'autorisation a ~t~ aQcord&e~

a

1~ Bibliotheque n~tiqnale.

du ..'.Canada· de micro.fi'lmer ·.

cette · these. et de preter· t>U .

. de ·vendre. des . exemplq ires du ·... ... . . , .

...

-

.... : .. ··

copies of the .fi~m~ \

~ .

,.. . .

"~

.... · ."·

. .

- , '

· ·film: ·. · · ·...., rn · ·

·. ' . . . . ·. \ . . . . . . '

'-. -..__

~ ·.

\

..

'

\ '. i,'

!.-.:\' .

l!t,

. .

...

,,

'

. .

. • .

' ·The author ('copyright. own~r). L'·a~teur . ( t[tulai)e ·du droit·.·. · .' -'· . . h:as r e s e r v e·d •b 'th'er. d'aut,eur) ' se ·."re-se'rve -1-es ·. ·.·: ·. ·

·. pu bl :i_qa•!; i OlJ.. ' rights,· _and au'tre·s ·droit's 'de:.•p,ubli'catlon: · ""' .··. · :·· · ..

nei·1ther ·, tne ·thesis·· npr · ; : ni .. la the'r;se ni'· fie lorigp · - :·.-.:-

• ·extensive extract·s· from :-l t ' ·.ext'raits de: .. 'cellt!:..cd · ne -

. may be ~rinted ·or_ ·otherwise qoi·vent_· ~-e~re imprim~s · ·ou '-·

.. ·re~roduced .· wi.th_out hi~/~er au~~ement rep~_oduits. saqs son ·

:. wr1t.ten permission. -·autorisation. ecri.te .. .. ~.

·• • .

.

I

,·

· ..

'·

...

~ . .

..

-

'

'-

.

. ..

.

' . '

. ~ \\ .

.

. .

.,

,

I.~BN. . , :-___ ' 0-315-39481~1 . . . ,• '

· . -

.

,.

--.

...._

.

. '

'

I

., I

. .. ...:.

. .

.

..

" ;' <

~~ - · . ·

~

. I

~

.. \ . · ..

.....

. ' . \"'. ~ ~·:. : ..

:·.

·~··' ~:~·e~

(7)

. .

' I .. ... -

· c ·. .

' \. .. ··;.~·.J.:''r'\: _:'~' ..

.)

. .

ill

,

!'

'

.

.. s

-- ·.• ~

----

\

;.,

ABSTRACT.

,.

...

. .

-The,

importance of reliable i.n.formation about teacher supply .and. de~an~ ~h~·s been .well ~tattlish~d. In' recent ..

\ ·. · ·yr/is·, the

educ~nal

system has undergone a dyRamic

sh~~

·:--:

- - -~ ---- . fr~m .

a chronic shor'tage of

·~eacbers

-t-o' an

a~py-ent .·

surplus:· · ..

·.--;he impaCt .of.

~his :.:~an~e ha~ implicati~r

Plamring ·arid

•.

. I

. .

'• ·

. '

·..J . . ·

\'

\'

. .

· ·deVelopment

~Y

university fioculti'es,.

9o

e,rru.;ent

pl~n~e[s, -~·

...

""; te:cher. recruits and ·.school administrato~s .•. :. . . .. .• . •.

. ,. ·.·

,Th~ lit~ratu[e

aha related re ...

ar~h

regard

te~che ~ . --~

': ·

-.. s~pP.f.'Ya~~nd demand as cd.tica~ to the tp_tal planning proces/. . . ~

~ . . . ' . . .

,esearchers. have concluded that the problem is. 'riot. s'o m~ch .. • ...

.

.

. ' .

f surpluses and shortag·es in abso'Iute ·.terms but short. ter~ ;::_·.

.

.

. .

.. var ia·nces in gec5gr~phi.c regions. and ·subject areas.. The

.

· - .

j.: purpQ~~

of

~hi~ study, ~as

tb

ide~tify f~ct~t; ~ssoci~ted

~ :

:. wiih-:thel supply of a·l_ld

dema~d:- :fa"; t~ach~;~ ~nd

. .

f _

·.

. ~ ..

. administrators ·_in ord~r ·to demon.st.r~te pot.ent.ial_ reg~<Juil

, · •• ' ; I .. "-, ' . ) .

al)d academi~ imbalances.:. More specifically_, this ~tudy was

.. .. . ..

/.

..

. . '

.

. .

. ,

•. ai:t a~t t'o -~dentify . the reasons for jo~ yac~ncies,. the.

. . . . .

.

subject and administrative a_reas· and geographic•locations

I .

· ~ncompassing t~-~~her deman.d, ·and the characteri~tics of the _'p6tentf~l and· ~~tu~l $Upply of new teachers.

.:

'

I

'·

. '/

A~ instr~ment was'_des~ne~ to obtain data relative to'~·

job vacancies· in ·individual $Chools and school districts,/ .

. ~ \ .

and the ·individ~als who fflle·d those jobs. Results of. th'e

. . . ~ ~ . . , I

. . . . . . . I

. anal_y_~is. o~ data ~·eveal_ed a·. g~ne_ral sur'plus ·of. te~ch~/.. ·

. . \ ~ . f . ii . . /'/ 1

. .

\

I

I

I

I /

' .

.I

/

. '

;-

/

/--

. ..

. .

._

(8)

~ ' I

' '

: i

( /. '

,. I

i -'

I ~

.- I

I -.

·f·· . . '

I -:

,,•

/"<

. '

~ .. '

· '

.

(

...

·::

.

· ... \. ,

..

...

'

'

..

~ : . '. ~ ~

' -~'

. .

..

.

.. .

' \

.,

.,

_)

ov~r

. , 600 l''

app1i~tions

. were • .. '

~-e~eived

.

.

forl-569. .

·vaca~cies

for

. .. . " \ . ' j

·.teachers and admiri\str~tors between September 1, 1985 and

. ~. '

' . ' * - .

~-August 31, ,1986. On the other hand, a shortage was evident

I ' ~ ' ' - , - t

1

in

edUc~~~th~r:PY

and potential sliOi"tagej in

gui~nce

and muslc~ . . , . / . . .

. - . J, . .

The findings. of-this .study strting1y .s~ggest ~hat .the ··

teache·r workforce is a dynamic .

enter~rise

. . \

~

.

Con~lder~ble

. : ; . .. . ,.:

' ' •. 't \ ' ' •• < . '

took 'place between.schools, d~str~cts

·' ~. . . .

...

·.· ( '

and pro~(n6e~ p6tentia ·- c~eatin~ jobr for -those ·~ot in· ~he

'

..,.

..

~ ,·

' '

,..

workforce.

..

'I .

.

The_: study found that . t.here · wefe. vacancies in cl11. r~gioils . ,

~

. '

..,

. .

. '

I . ' . . .

I I

. ~

' rates bei'ng· in communi,t'i_es ~i th

a

'popu1~t-ion of le~s=-s=--'. t""ht:"a""'n=--:-.-.-~'-,--:---

SQQ. It.was found t.hat

d~n{and

wa$ .. highest in

Labrad~r (i5.a

percent), the. most isolated -r~g"ion of the _P~ovince o

. I

. It was found that school,districts were-seeking both

1 ' ~

generaiist and sptlt:ialist

empioyee~> .

. Demand

w~s

. . greatest

. for ed~at·~on~l t~erapis_ts· ·<53· ·pe_~cent) and ·French··. Immer~i~n

- f ' -~

teachers ( 44 o fj '·perc·en~), while li_ttle ·demand was· experienced

... ' . - ' . '

.

. . ' . . .. ~

for~dministrators· (3o2 p~r~'ent> < ' ·

Fem4tfs comprised ·th7 m~jority _of-,teachers hired

. . . . . . 1-ft

males. comprised the majority .

- ot'

adminitltratot:s

.

. ~ ... . hir~d.

I , .... • ,.

&

-~11,;

j-

1 ::i ·

~

iii . . ~ _);·

and· Four

i .

r

(9)

l·.:~ ' ..

p'.t

•' ·';, ,•

. ..

·.

. 1

0

.

. .

, ... .

l .

..

. ' ~

' . 't~~>·

'--.~}

.

~ ~ ~

. -

~ ..

.. ..

_,

' . ' .• ... .. ._ iJ .

·' ~- percen_t of !\~w employees had no university de~ree ~nd •i9ht c.}•.

,...

. .

'l'he med~_pn.

pe~c~~t had at ·l~ast a

· '-· . r i

educational .experi,nce

Master's degr~.

t

fc:>r a.lf new' employees was t~o year.s ..

, ' ;

found that 41.5 percent of -new employees

~ . ~ I '· \

teaching

at

'the\ time and . 22 •. 7 .percent.;

. I -.._1 .

ca~e 'direc~ly

from

Membria~Unive .rs'ity". Tea~hers/w~r~ ·hi-~ - ~d

- ~ . . I

. FJ._nally, ·~ tl was

. . .

\

.. .

·' hired w~re already

oth~r

I

·\ ..

from other teache~~~ai~ing institutlons, from.other educati_ona;

i~~ti tut- -i-6~-~

OJJtsidef th.e · J?rovince ,·,

occupations,. And·

ti' om

the ·r~nks of the

' ~

- ...

·

.. ,.

·( .

. . - · /

I

. ~~

(] 0

(

:.·. ·t.

:!.

,

·'

'

. ,.

-;-'1

... /

~-v

.

-~-

•· ,,

•. ' ~ . ~u

' .. v "\. '\!~

.. . .

'

l .

· .

i.

·' . ' •• l

. '

'

.

,..

. ·.

...

~ ' -

•,' . . ..

. ' . . .~

f

. .. : ~

. '

(10)

~

· ..

··.

~

'·

.

.

. _,)

• . -

..

.. _.

.

. ·

.. "

•• '

• ..

.

.

.

: .·ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ; \,

..

I

••

'I ·

~ .. -

. ~ "*-· .

t . The wr i"te~ wishes . to exptes·s his· appreciation ta Dr.

. I

'

' !~ \

! ... . .

~

o~~riis . Tresla:~ ,'~s ~pek.is.o~,

('for

~is ·

·guidance and

constructive criticism. ttiroug'no.~t the · master's ,program. -~

rrp·

Dr. Hubert

Kitchen~

a· since:

t~~nk-ya:u .

for providing

..2,/

. . - . I . .,,;. .

~ --~-

..

di~-~c~~on

a11d .J?urpose ..

·to_.m~ . cou~se

of ;.stud.Y.· . . : ·

~ .

~'· ~r

•. _

Gr.atef~ . appreciati.~n i~xpres~~d

to Dr •. Boyce F;_ad$h.am · ·

~

·\

. ' t .

'fpr chalie'nging .~e '~0 pursue a worthwhi~e _.and. comprehens~ve

.

. .

·

. ...

:. . .

..

. .

..

. .

.thes~s t?p1.c •. , Al~o, ~very speci,al_ thanks_ l.S. exp~essed to ·

:.trr=r

.Ter'#y Boak ~-- D~·-' r'reder ick 'Aldrich -and Professor Jeffrey

'

.. . ·,

.. ..

. ·,: . . . ·: ..

,

~- . . .

Bu.lcock for 'their· ·-encouraqement.: .. and advice •

. . ...

. ,

' . . :

· · -.~he wr i t'~r- ·~auld l~ke to. express appreciat~C?n .to special

. ' . .

.

.

.., ..

friends . .,. ~r. Lenora Perry Faga~, Barbara ~opkins, Sam McGrath .1

~nd

.Shei·la Ander·son. The-ir·

compa~~ship too~· t~is ,

wo-rk

:beyon~ the level of an ~cademic exercis~.~

·- ...

. .

~.: ·

.Special mention is made to all superintendent·s,

, '1

.. ..

_

..

'

' ' I t

. ~~-~i.stant· super intenden_tJ and atl· ot~er.s· whose· particip_atiory

·

~n.~

·cooperation

d~r

ing a·n.

e~remely

·busy

tim~

of the· s'chool

. . ·. . . 4' . . .

.. year tieiped make this ~udy PC!~slble.

: Final-ly, to

my wif~ -~

:NCen,.,a

_sp~cial

and heartfelt

than~-you for her -~ncouragement, ·understanding arid patience·

t,._~~ughou t_ t~e . pro~·r am.

,

.

~

f ... .

--.

,.

•,'

. ,•

. ' .

. '

'•

-

r

..

I '

. f.

I

I

·;

·.!

i

t I

I I j

. , .

(11)

.

,

.. .

, ,

"-·"

. ·.--

...

0

I .

...

:

•'

... .

'•,

.. .... ..

\ "'' •'

~. '~ . .. ..

..

·.

···.

· \··:

. '

. ' _ _

\

..

. - - l, \ ·.. '

'

.

' ~ ... ' ," .. ;,• ' .. · ...

'

. ~ \ ' ' . · ... · . ' ,•

. . . 1!\

j

I"

'\.

. . ; ·

•,., .

}

}. '

. ,.

- ·

r

'

, ..

· . I

•.' '

Chapter

\

.. .

'

.

'

... ..

""

' ..

'

·.

-...

INTRODUCTION .• : • ·. • • • • • .- . • • • . . . ·1·

St~Je~~·nt --~~

the

Pro~~"em

:·. • • • • . • . • . •. . • • .

~

4.

.

The.Jreti.ca~ . F~~mew~~k

. • • ·. • • • • • . ... . ' 7

..

' '/

·

.

_. .sigfif:i?~-nce . ~f- tile -~t:·uay_._··

. .• · • · •• .••••• _ ..

13

Del1mitations. • • • • -.. .- • • • .• • • . 1'6

. I .: . . , . . -

· · Limitations • • • • • • ·• .- • • . • • . ~ 17 Asshmptions • • • • - • · • • • •

~

• . • • 18

•oetfnitiqn of .Ter •

~

., , ' • • • • • , .

or9an~i~ation o~

} \

Study~:·

• • • • •

~

• • •

lQ

'

20

. ··II o. /REVIEW' OF THE LITERATURE 'AND RELATED RESEARCH

·

Dyn(mic~

of the .Teacher

Labo~r' M~:rket

,;·. •· 22. -

'. . .

\

. '

Lit rature ~elated to_\ Teacher Supply

,I

a~d~emand _ .-_. ~ ~~ • • . • • •• • • • •. • • 23' H"stotical Per•p~cti~es (1900~1969) • • • • 23

' . ·. .

'\-

.

rrent ~ersp~ctives (i970~1985) · · . • . • ~ . •26

' ' . ' .

\.

. '

united States .. · • \ . • • • .• • • • • • 27 C~nada

. . .

;.

. . . .

\ \

\ . . . . . .

· · '

.

.•

.

·

t

New_foundl~nd ·and Labfa~or • • • • • • • 33

.. . · .Fi.,crrs •. Affecting

Te~cher

Demancj and Supply 36

31~

I ,

·....

.. II ·., ·.:

''1.

'.' :·r:

.

.. ·.

''

·I

:. ,.

·'i .

" ·.'

-~- <~

..

-'~..._.

.

.~ . . -~

c... . . ....

4

. ' ' I • , · Vi .. '· ...

\ . '• •, .

• • " ·•. " ..

,

___ .__,

~ ::'~:~

J

_..., ...

. .

'

' ',

:\ ;, ;- ..

··

. .

.

: ...

(12)

/ .

..•

..

· ..

'

' ...

I

. -

•• •

l ·Chapter'

;

"

I

.. . ·~

I

I

(

,

·_ -.~~·.

.

·

.

,

.

. . ..

.

.

- - - - · " " T '

. .

, j

j

I I '

Enrolment ·characteristics • • •

' I .

Teache~ .

workforce Charadter

i~t

.. ics _; • ·

~

. . . I . .. .

Cha~cter ~s~~~ o~. ~~terti~l ~~a~her~

• . • Polley I.n1t-1at1ves • • o • o

.I . ' -·.

, Econorn·ic Cqnditions ·. • • • • • • • • • • • D

' .

.

The Relationship ~etween Demand and·Supply

' ~ .

Dyriam.tc · Equili'bri'um • • . ..· .•

'

Surpl~ses·and :·

Summary· •.• .

. .

.

~

. .

• .. . . . .

. . .

•..

.

Page

.) . .('.~

. .

37

·38

39

40 41

...

-

..

·

41

42

. . . . . . . '

43'

.t ·

.

44 .

~ ' 1

. ·

... . ..

·.

\ ' .

. ..

.

- v

·.

. : \

..... .

\ \

.

.,

. \

. \ I.

\

~··

111.· METHODOLOGY. • • ! .... ;.... • ... 0

. .

....

.

.

. ..

,.

Popula~ion ·

...

../' ,' .

' . . ..

·~ ·.

.

.

. .

',

. .

I

. . . . .

.

.

.

. . .

o•

. . .

. .

~ ' . . "

Development .of.: .th~e Instr~ment • ·•

. . . . - .

,/.(

.. . . . . ,

Validity

. . . . .

. ' .. ,.

·· Reliabili_t i .. ~. • • •

-/'-' ·'

• •

. . . . . . - . . .

Instrument Response

. . .

\

. . . . . . . . . .

46 53 53 54

Method of ~a ta ·Analysis • • • • • • •. . ... • • • 56

·-"'tl: PRESENTATION Aifp INTERPRETATION OF DATA

~

• • •

57

·.

·.

?ract·e~_istics o.~

.Demand .• _ • •

~

• · • • : . . • •

~8

·: . ... :. . .'

_. I?_ern~ni·d. fo_br. T~achedr_!l __ and

1' Adrninistra_!:~-~~-..: __ ·_ .. ~ ____

62

·-~--: _ _ . ·_· _·_

. ,

.

.

I I '

n Su Ject an Spec alty Areas . ·•· • • ~.. . · ·

... ' '

.

'

. .

Demand for Subjec~ Teachers

. . . . .

. .

.: Demand .fo~ Special Education Personnel·

. . .

.

'

.

. De~and for Administrat?rs

. . . .

.

.

0 • • vii

.

.

. 65

70

' 71

. . ,..

..

.

-

.

. . .

· .

. \

(13)

.~-~~·~~::·-...

'

. .

L

"'·

. .

. :

. . ··

.. .

'

...

. ' .. .

'/ ' :·

.

. . -; . . .

: I .

)

,, :

j' • : '" . • ••• - ~.,' ~-

. '

! .

I I

: ~ . ;

..

·.

\

\ Chapter ./ I

. .

Page

-, I

\('

. .

. .

'

.· ....

',

. .

'

' .

'

\ l

v.

.... .

· • ·

.... .

' ' '1. (l

Demand for Teachers and Adm'in1stra'tors by Sel~c·ted. Geographic and Derrtographic

Character~stics • • • • • • • ; • • • • ~5

Demand by· ~'chooi Dis.trlct

' .

. .

••

75

. 77

. -

'

. . .

·o~mand ·byi:co~uni ty Size··

fe~nd b~School

Size • • • .

..

.

. . . .

83 . .

IYemand ;bY ~Region • • ·J • ;. 88

· ..

Satisfaction with Teachers and Admi~istrators

· · "Se.eking En\ployinent in the Education b • ·

M~rketplace · • • ~ ·.• . • .~ · • • •. ~ . ! •• .• 9 8 :

sa t'i " sfactio~ . "*' w'i

th

. . A~ailable

.. Supply

.

·. ·

.

• ' • . •

. 9a

t+filcti:on

wi,th

<:a?di~at~s . ~nt~i:vie.wed

\ 100 ·

· C aracte:r is~i?s of the~ Supply· ~f Nf~ Teachers and Adm1n1strators • .• • ; ·• • •· · . .-. • . • 104

·.Gener.al 'ch'Aracb~r i•ics of New Employe·es ., • 104 New Teachers by Specialty and: Region... .. • 109 New Admini'st~ators by Pos~tion. and Reg.ion • 117 .Prior. Activit-i-es of New .Emp,loy,ees • • • • • 0122

., . ·-r~

I> ;-

U .

·Summary • • • • • • • ,, . ., • • • •· • . • • 128

-

SUMMARY, FINDINGS, . C(>NCLPS.lONS I AND .REqOMMENDATIONS • • • • • •

.'sununary

. . . . .

Findings .• · • • • Conclusions

R~commendatioris

. .

· viii

·"'

.

.

.

·

. . .

~.

~

. . .

.

. . .

-

<I

. . . . . . .

129

.

. . .

.

129

. . . .

131

. . . . .

139

' 142

. . . . .

·~

4 ...

'

~ ·

..

'

.

'

.

' , . . · .. . . ~ '\

.

.

. .

;<~ . .'/,: .

.,

' .

·I

\ .

(14)

,v.~ ,, . '-·,' -

'·1";

. . ·· . .

.

. .

.

• :: "-'!

\

'(

..

1

... . . -

,.

. r'

..

....

' I'

. ·:.J '

...

,·;

...

. .

I

. .

·.

.· - . ..

. .

'

.

.

:--.

0 i

·.

...

'

'-''

Chapter· __ Page

,, I ftiJIJt

.

.

'

~ecorrune~~a-~_ions fo·r/.~r.ther · !le:Search Ot1\e_r · Reco~endatio s .. • ~ • • • • .•

. .

.

• • ; 142- 14-3

.. . .

0

.

•.'

Bibliography '

. . . . . . .

145

r / .

App~ndi:x A: Support Documentation

~ .

. .

·'

. . .. .

153

Appendix. B: ·survey Instrument i _ .• . . . 157

·. - '

. ·. .

· Appen_d,

i'x .. c:

Survey I~~.tr.umen.t .2 • • • • • • • • 161 .

· . - ~

.

. • .._,; .

. Appendix· D: . +nsfrument validation .- ; ., . • • • • 1t·a · ·

. . . . . . c .· .. . · . . ' . ..

Appendix/ E: CrQss· Reftrl;!nce of· Re~earch· . . .

Qu~-t'i.ons ~ith the· Instrument ( 2.). Question·s •• ·171

~pp~ix

F:.

tis~

of_· UrbWt ...

~~u~it~·~s

.• .• • • • 173

. I

/

.

.

....

.. ..

#"'

. .

I :

...

..

..

':':•>::·/;

' ' ·~. ,1'"'

..... }

. , .

.

.

. .

.. .

: '

'.

.

'• ~

-·~

..

'V" .

.

..

: .

~

.

.

-~ .

·

..

. ~

. . (

. ...

.... .

o .

. ix

..

. ·

.

\ . .

.,. . ...

..

:· .

·.·

' ...

"1!,

.A_ · .

·. · . ·.~ --·

I

·.p

>, .·_ ....

. '·

•.·

Références

Documents relatifs

Wenn die Kündigung einer Stelle von vielfältigen personalen und kontex- tuellen Faktoren mitbestimmt wird (Oesterreich, 2008) und sich keine vorher- sehbaren Muster zeigen

In summary, helping student teachers enact early cri- tiques demands to keep in mind at least the following components of formation: help teachers realize the value per se

Many career-education programs, consistent with policies espoused by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), emphasize generic employability skills,

Adding boric acid to dopamine solutions after a given oxidation and self-assembly duration allows to stop the growth of the PDA based nanoparticles to a controlled and

Christel Larbouret, Bruno Robert, Christine Linard, Isabelle Teulon, Sophie Gourgou, Frédéric Bibeau, Pierre Martineau, Lore Santoro, Jean-Pierre. Pouget, André Pèlegrin,

Ainsi, cette espèce permettra une comparaison des capacités de résistance thermique et d‟estimer l‟influence de l‟histoire évolutive sur la capacité de réponse à

Bilan Scientifique - Direction régionale des affaires culturelles Aquitaine, Service régional de l’archéologie, Paris: Ministère de la culture et de la communication Direction

❖ The selection, ordering, presentation and assessment of the material should be based on a careful consideration of the learners and their needs, the teaching conditions and the