Flexible Management and Dynamic Control of Network Quality of Service in Grid environments : the QoSinus approach
24
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Flexible Management and Dynamic Control of Network Quality of Service in Grid environments: the QoSinus approach . Pascale Vicat-Blanc Primet — Johan Montagnat — Fabien Chanussot — Mathieu Goutelle — . CNRS UMR5515, CREATIS, INSA de Lyon, 69621 Villeurbanne, France INRIA-ENS LIP, RESO, 46, allée d’Italie, 69 007 Lyon, France . N° 5083 January 2004. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5083--FR+ENG. THÈME 1. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !" $# %'&)(*&+&,-.0/'&1(32 465 789&,;:"<(3=>$#? A@B(3 CD=" (3&FEGHFI 4 &>:" 5 E 1JJ (*&#*I K LNM8OQPRM8SUTWV XYPZM0[$\]DSUM8^*PWL1_`XUabTc[ edgf8h8i M8^Hj h ^k[lM8m8^nM0[ dno M8p*XYTR^rq i M8^ts*O`O h [ ud jrM0[ i XYTRsrv h s3[wTcSUSYT d nxtyFgz3{y3|3zt}1 Fz)¡0~ ~Qy*{~QZxk¢£z)0zF8 ){w¤?{ww¥y*Q{$l7w¦n3Rc§© ¨ª7R Qn« «*¬?Rw Rll7lwYQ7wwl U7w <®¯$°>±>²´³¶µ·`¸¹±`º»£¼½±¾¿¸¹À£¸¾Á¯$°>±`¸ ÂgùÄű¾µÆ?Ç0È µºÉÉ0Äcþʣ±ËÃÁ±`Ì7®Í±`ÃÁÌ7®Í±'Î8Ï*ÐÑcÒÓ³ÕÔRºÎZ»ºÃ¹ÀÖÑcÑ׳9ÖÑɺر`¸ . . . Ù½Ú3Û`Ü$ÝlÞÍßÜà½á ÃÁâãʸر`Îͱ$Ã7ºäãäãÀ ÃÁ±$äãÀ ÄcÎeºÌÄc°>ÉÍäå±$¼WâåÎR¾¹±`ÃÁÌ$ÄÎÍα`Ì ¾ÁâåÄcÎ ÄægçèÂ;Ê£Äc°"ºâãθ¾Á®ºl¾´°>ºwÀ±¼Zé ®âåêÍâå¾nÌ7®ºÎÍØcâåÎØÉ0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ̱ëÌ7®0ºÃ7ºÌ ¾Á±$ÃÁâ㸾¹â©Ì$¸)ºÎÊ1°"ºwÀËÄìí±$Ã*Ê£âåì8±`ù±`ÎR¾3îR»ºäãâå¾À´Äæ0¸¹±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±gæºÌâãäãâð¾Áâå±Q¸$ñ ò¿Äló?±`ï±`Ãn¾¹®Í±Ë±`ÎÊ"¾Áı$Î0ÊÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱Q¸g¾Á®Í±´®Í±¾Á±$ÃÁÄر`Îͱ$Äc»¸n°>âå¼Äæ)Øcùâ©Ê>ôÄló¸?ر$¾ëæÃÁÄ°¾¹®±NÎͱ$¾é óÄÃÁõe°"ºwÀºì8±QÌ ¾¾Á®Í±Älïc±$Ã7ºäãänØÃÁâãÊuâãΣæÃÁºc¸¾Áù»0Ì ¾¹»Ã¹±>É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱Q¸$öF»£¾¹âãäãâå÷Qºl¾¹âãÄÎøäã±$ïc±$äëºÎÊùâã°DÉ0ºÌ ¾ ±QºÌ7® âãÎÊ£âãïRâ©Ê£»ºäFºÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾¹âãÄÎ)ú ¸É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°"ºÎÌ$±ñçèÎ ¾¹®Í⩸NɺÉ8±$Ãó±±$¼£º°>âåÎͱ¾¹®Í±Ì`º¸¹±1Äæ*¾¹®±±`FÄâãäå± æÃÁ±$Î0Ì7®Øcùâ©ÊW¾Á±`¸¾¹ê8±`Êu꺸¹±`ÊûÄÎùºÃ¹±Q¸±QºÃ7Ì7®eÎͱ¾óÄÃÁõ âåÎÍæÃÁºc¸¾Áù»Ì¾¹»ÍÃÁ±¾¹®º¾ÉÍùÄcÉ0ÄR¸±Q¸Nº ¸¹±¾1Äæ<ü¿âåæ é æ±`ù±`ÎR¾¹â©ºl¾¹±QÊÇ£±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±Q¸<óâð¾Á® ïwºÃ¹âãÄ»0¸<±$ÎÊ ¾¹Ä"±`ÎÊÉ0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ̱Q¸$ñ*ýu±1ÉÍù±Q¸±`ÎR¾¾Á®Í±þNÄRÇ£âåÎZ»¸¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$± ¾Á®ºl¾ëºâå°ÿ¾¹ÄÊÍÀRÎ0º°>âãÌ`ºäãäåÀºäãäåÄ£Ì$º¾¹±<¾Á®Í±Îͱ$¾ó?ÄcùõÃÁ±`¸¹Ä»ÃÁÌ$±`¸F¾¹Ä á ÃÁâãÊôÄló¸gâåÎ"ÄcÃÁÊ£±`Ã*¾¹Ä1°"ºl¾7Ì7®D¾¹®Í±`âåà ¸¹É8±`Ìâ 0Ìù±Qîc»âåÃÁ±$°>±$ÎR¾7¸¿»ÍÎ0Ê£±$ÃËÊ£âåì8±`ù±`Îc¾´äåÄRºÊeÌ$ÄÎÊÍâð¾ÁâåÄcθ$ñË<®Í±"þNÄRÇZâãÎZ»¸N¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±â©¸Nê0º¸¹±`Ê ÄÎû¾¹®Í± ºÉÍÉùÄRºÌ7®tñDý±¸¹®ÍÄlóÿ®ÍÄlóÿºêÍâãÄ°>±`ÊÍâãÌ`ºägºÉÉÍäåâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄÎùʣ⩸¾ÁùâãêÍ»£¾Á±`ÊuÄlï±`à ¾Á®Í±1ØÃÁâ©Ê½°"ºwÀ"ê8±$Îͱ ;æÃÁÄ° ¸¹»Ì7® ºÎ ºÊ£ïlºÎ0̱`ʺÎ0ÊÌ$ÄÎR¾¹ÃÁÄäãäã±`Êα¾óÄÃÁõ¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±ñ Ý 3Ûà á ùâ©ÊùÎͱ$¾ó?Äcùõû¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±ö á ùâ©ÊbþNÄRÇíöFü¿âåìkÇ£±$ÃÁï8ö3ÉÍÃÁÄØcÃÁº°D°"ºêÍäå±>Îͱ$¾ó?Äcùõ¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±ö e±`Ê£â©Ì$ºä ÉÍÉÍäãâ©Ì$ºl¾ÁâåÄcÎ .
(6) . !"$# &. %. ('. 2. kãx w w UQ k Y ¨Yw tå Ut +Yå wUw{`Q7 k¡1 « F<« «Áxí¨ ¡ w© ¡*~Q* z)z) yFë t¨ wwY £Y è¨ ¨ wwF 8| ¨t* Ác¨ª ¨ Q3*l¿Y¢0w è¨`w¨ w¨U)<y3 ztRY Y¹w7 Rwè¨t$<z)¨íw{Q3¤?0$w7w <¹¨ 7Q ). (* ,+-. ;7<7. ,+3+. :*F7. /.0-. =4. ,+. ;>. <2. 1+2. 3*. 54. 17. @?. 9+. :*. /C. 3*. GBH4. A>;*. 3*. 16. @I. 16. 12 *. B. DC. *87. ,+. 16. 3*. 12. 9+. E4. :*. 16. Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4 76 61 52 00 — Télécopie +33 4 76 61 52 52. 3*. ;4. *.
(7) @!EkF& " #&)(*& " 5 5 7 EF<(F="# ( E) 5 E 5 D=" (3& 1(*G' J J(3&"#*I 4 &> : í -
(8) : ÊÍÄ °"Û ºâã Îͱ` ¸*çèà Â*öRîc±`¸N»âÍØÉ0ÃÁâå±`äã»Íäå±Q︿±`ÎR¸¹Ä¾ëÎRºw¾¿ïÄØcâã·$Ã*ÎÍÊ£·`ÃÁ±`º¸näåÉ8±`°D±$ù±`æÄÎRÃÁ¾N°"̺ÄcÎÎÌ$¸¾Á±`ù¸n»Ê£âð¾Áâåìí±`¸¿·$ÃÁ¸¹±$»ÍÎRÃ˾¹±QÊ£¸*±`±¸N¾ëâãÎcÉ;ÁÃÁ±$ÄÃ7É8ÌÄcÄc¸¹Îͱ$ÎÍÃn±Ê£¼£âåâãìíÄ·$ÎÃÁ¸N±$ÎR̾¹Äc±Q°D¸3ÉæÄäå±$μẔQ¾¹¸¿âãÄʣΣ± é Î0ºäãâð¾Á·`¸Ê£±îR»ºäåâå¾¹·Êͱ¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±ñ ?±$É8±$ÎÊͺÎR¾`ö3äå±Q¸1É0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ̱Q¸1Ê£±"ê0Äc»£¾±`Îuê8Ļ;îR»Í±"äå±"ÃÁ·`¸¹±`º» ºc¸¹¸¹»ÍÃÁ± º»£¼ Ê£âåì8·`ù±`ÎR¾Á¸D¾ÀZÉ0±Q¸"Ê£±ô»£¼ ʺθ>»ÍαØcùâãäãäå± ºlìí±`̾¹±$ÎR¾"äã±`¸>É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱Q¸ØcäåÄcêºäã±`¸>Ê£± 䩺ØÃÁâåäãäã±öt¸¹ÄÎuÎÍâåïc±`º»uÊkú »£¾Áâåäãâã¸Áºl¾ÁâåÄcÎtöt±$¾äå±Q¸ËÉ0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ0̱`¸´Ê£±Ì7®ºcÌ»ÍαDÊ£±Q¸1¸±Q¸1ºÉÍÉäåâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄθ`ñ ?± Ã7ºÉÉ0Äcþ"·¾Á»Ê£âã±ûäã±eÌ$ºc¸Ê£±e䩺øÉÍ䩺l¾Á±æÄÃÁ°>±eÊ£±WØÃÁâãäåäã± æÃÁºÎÌ$ºâ㸹±W±`FÄâãäã±ñHÆgäåäã±e±Q¸¾½ê0º¸¹·$±e¸¹»ÍûÍÎͱ âãΣæÃ7º¸¾¹ÃÁ»Ì ¾Á»ÍÃÁ± Ê£± ÃÁ·`¸¹±`º»b±¼£É0·`ùâã°>±$ÎR¾Áºäå±îR»ÍâÉÍÃÁÄÉ8Äc¸¹±½»ÍÎ ±$θ¹±$°êÍäå± Ê£±W¸¹±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±Q¸üNâåìkÇZ±`ùï+º»£¼ É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°"ºÎÌ$±`¸Ê£±´ê0Äc»£¾±$Îê0Äc»£¾ïwºÃ¹âã·$±Q¸$ñ ±Ë¸¹±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±þNÄRÇ£ç NDZ`¸¾Éù·Q¸±`Îc¾Á· ñ ?±$äã»ÍâåéªÌ$âkÌ7®Í±$Ã7Ì7®Í ± ºäåäãÄ»±$Ã<Ê£ÀZκ°>â©îc»±$°>±$ÎR¾<äå±Q¸?ÃÁ±`¸Á¸¹Ä»ÍÃ7̱Q¸gÃÁ·`¸¹±`º» º»£¼"ô»Í¼ Ê£±´äãºØÃÁâåäãäã±´Ê£±´°"ºÎÍâã¯$ÃÁ± ºc¸¹¸¹»ÍÃÁ±$Ãäå±`»ÍÃÁ¸ ê8±`¸¹Äâãθ1ÊͺθËäã±`¸Ê£âåìí·$ÃÁ±$ÎR¾¹±Q¸1ÌÄÎ0Ê£âð¾ÁâåÄcθ1Ê£±Ì7®ºÃ¹Øc±DÊÍ»uÃÁ·`¸¹±`º»tñ ±¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±"þNÄZÇZç ´Çû±Q¸¾ê0º¸¹· ¸¹»ÍÃnäUú ºÉÍÉÍÃÁÄ£Ì7®Í± ñ ±Q¸*ê0·`ÎÍ· 0Ì$±`¸gÊtú »ÍÎ>¾Á±$丹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±<ù·Q¸±Qº»ºwïlºÎÌ·<±¾ëÌ$ÄÎR¾¹ÃÁÄäãäã· É8ĻûÍÎͱºÉÉÍäåâ©Ì$"!$º# ¾¹âãÄ&Î% êÍâãÄ°>·`Ê£â©Ì$ºäå±1ʣ⩸¾¹ÃÁâåêÍ»·$±1¸»Ã»ÍÎͱ1ØÃÁâãäåäã±´¸¹ÄÎR¾·$ØRºäã±$°>±$ÎR¾Ê£·`°DÄcÎR¾¹ÃÁ·`¸`ñ ' ÜQÛ ß ( Ûuà Ç£±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±>ÃÁ·`¸¹±`º»ûÉ8Ä»ÍÃ1䩺ØÃÁâåäãäå±cö3þNÄRÇ á ÃÁâåäãäå±cöFüNâðìtÇZ±`ùïíöF¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±ÃÁ·`¸¹±`º»ûÉÍÃÁÄØcÃÁº°Dé °"ºêÍäå±cöͺÉÍÉäåâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄΰD·QÊ£â©Ì$ºäã± #. . !. 1 F
(9) . D.
(10)
(11) . Ó. . 1. 8)(*&" . 5 ë# F& <®±ÉͻùÉ8Äc¸¹±Äæ ?Ä°>ÉÍ»£¾7ºl¾ÁâåÄcκä á ùâ©Ê͸´â©¸¿¾ÁĺØØcù±`Øcºl¾Á±ºä©ºÃÁرDÌÄäãäã±`Ì ¾ÁâåÄcÎeÄ渮ºÃ¹±QÊWÃÁ±`¸¹Ä»ÍÃ7̱Q¸ ÌÄc°DÉ»£¾¹âãÎÍØötÌ$Ä°>°»ÎÍâãÌ`ºl¾ÁâåÄcÎtö8¸¾¹ÄcÃÁºØ±cö0âãΣæÄÃÁ°"ºl¾ÁâåÄcξÁĽêÍ»âåä©ÊºÎe±Ì$âå±`Îc¾1ºÎ0Êeï±`ùÀ ®ÍâãØ®ûÉ0±`Ãé æÄcù°"ºÎ̱Ì$Ä°>ÉÍ»£¾ÁâåÎÍر$ÎZïZâåÃÁÄÎÍ°>±`Îc¾næÄcÃ?Êͺ¾ÁºéUâãÎR¾¹±$Î0¸âãï±ÄcÃëÌÄc°DÉ»£¾¹âãÎÍØéªâãÎc¾Á±$θ¹âãﱺÉÉÍäåâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄθ Uñ »£¾1¾Á®Í±"»ÍÎÊͱ$ÃÁäåÀZâãÎÍØeÌÄc°D°»ÍÎÍâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄÎuâåΣæÃ7º¸¾¹ÃÁ»Ì¾¹»ÍÃÁ±>Äæ¾¹®Í±Q¸±"䩺ÃÁر>¸¹Ì`ºäã±"Ê£â㸾¹ÃÁâãêÍ»£¾¹±QÊù±$ÎZïZâåÃÁÄÎÍé °>±`Îc¾7¸ë⩸<ºÌ$Ä°>ÉÍäã±¼>âåÎR¾¹±`ÃÁÌ$ÄÎÍα`Ì ¾ÁâåÄcÎÄæt°»Íäå¾¹âíçè ʣÄc°"ºâãθëóâå¾¹®Ì7®ºÎØâãÎÍØÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱NÌ7®ºÃ7ºÌé ¾Á±$ÃÁâ㸾¹â©Ì$¸ëºÎÊ>Ê£âåì8±`ù±`ÎR¾ëîc»0ºäãâð¾ÀÄæt¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±æºÌ$âåäãâð¾Áâå±Q¸$ñ ?ÄÎ0¸±Qîc»±$ÎR¾¹äãÀ !" °"ºwÀ ±$¼£®Íâåêâð¾g±$¼R¾Áù±`°>±®±¾¹±`ùÄcر`Îͱ$âå¾À1âåÎDÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱ºÎÊÃÁ±$äã⩺êÍâãäåâå¾À˾¹®0ºl¾ëÌ$ºÎDÌ$Äθ¹â©Ê£±$Ã7ºêÍ#äãÀ ºl&ìí%$±`̾n¾¹®Í± ØcäåÄcêºäkºÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾¹âãÄÎÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱Q¸$ñ <®Í±`ù±ºÃÁ±½°"ºÎZÀuÉ0ÄR¸¹¸¹âãêÍäå± »£¾¹âãäãâå÷Qºl¾¹âãÄÎ0¸Ä濺eØcùâ©ÊkönÎÍľÄÎäåÀùâãÎc¾Á±$θ¹âãï± Ì$Ä°>ÉÍ»£¾ÁâåÎØûêÍ»£¾"ºä©¸¹Ä âãÎR¾¹±`ÃÁºcÌ ¾¹âãï±Ë»¸ÁºØc±1óâð¾Á®Wù±`°>ľ¹±ºcÌ$Ì$±`¸Á¸<¾¹Ä"±$¼ZÉ8±$Î0¸âãï±1âãθ¾¹ÃÁ»Í°>±$ÎR¾Á¸¿ÄîZ»ÍØc±¸¹Ì$âå±`Îc¾Áâ 8ÌÊͺl¾7º>꺸¹±`¸ ±$¼£ÉÍäåÄcÃÁº¾¹âãÄÎ æÄcýâãθ¾7ºÎÌ$±ñ ?ÄÎ0¸±Qîc»±$ÎR¾¹äãÀö°"ºÎZÀ Êͺ¾Áºø¾ÁÃÁºÎ¸æ±$ýÉ0ºl¾¾Á±$ÃÁθ óâåäãäËÄZÌ`Ì»ÍÃâãÎ;¸»0Ì7® ºÎ+±$ÎZïZâãùÄcÎÍ°>±$ÎR¾`%ñ »Íäãõ+Êͺl¾7ºW¾¹Ã7ºÎ0¸æ±`ÃæÃÁÄ° Äα äãÄ£Ì$ºl¾ÁâåÄcÎø¾¹Äu¸Äc°>± ľ¹®Í±`ÃäãÄ£Ì$ºl¾ÁâåÄcθDºÎÊù¾Áâå°>± Ì$Äθ¾¹Ã7ºâãÎͱQÊb°>±`¸Á¸ÁºØ± ±$¼£Ì7®0ºÎÍØc±`¸DÄæ Îͱ$éUØcÃÁºâåα`Ê ÉºÃ7ºäãäå±`äºÉÍÉäåâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄθ>°"ºwÀb®0ºwï±¾¹Ä+Ì$ÄR±$¼£â㸾`ñ çèÎ á ÃÁâãʸ$ö¾¹®±ûîR»ºäãâð¾À Ä渹±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì± þNÄR&Ç ¾Á®Í±e®Í±$¾¹±$ÃÁÄØc±$Îͱ`Ä»¸>°>âå¼Äæ´âãÎÊ£âãïZâãÊÍ»ºä¿ôÄló¸>ù±Q̱`âåïc± °"ºwÀùºlìí±`̾¾Á®Í±½Älïc±$Ã7ºäãägØÃÁâãÊ+âåΣæÃ7º¸¾¹ÃÁ»Ì¾¹»ÍÃÁ±É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱Q¸$ö*»£¾Áâåäãâã÷`ºl¾ÁâåÄcÎ+äã±$ï±`ä?ºÎÊøâã°DÉ0ºÌ ¾>±`ºcÌ7® âãÎÊ£âãïZâãÊÍ»ºätºÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾¹âãÄÎÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱cñ ¿ÎDâã°>É0Äcþ7ºÎR¾*±ìíÄù¾F¾ÁÄ´ÉùÄlïZâ©Ê£±þNÄZǺÃÁÌ7®Íâå¾¹±QÌ ¾Á»Íù±?âåξ¹®±çèÂùÎͱ$¾ó?Äcùõ£¸F®º¸3ê8±$±`ÎDÊ£ÄcÎͱ<Ê£»ÍÃÁâåÎÍØ ¾Á®Í±1䩺¸¾Êͱ`Ì$ºcÊ£±ñn<®Í±1çèÎR¾Á±$ÃÁÎͱ¾ÌÄc°>°»ÍÎÍâå¾À®ºc¸Ê£± 0Îͱ`ÊeþNÄRÇ ¸¹±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±Q¸<ºÃ7Ì7®Íâð¾Á±`̾¹»ÍÃÁ±`¸?¾¹®0ºl¾¿¸ÁÌ$ºäã±ö ó®âåäã±ë±`κêÍäãâãÎÍØ¿ºóâ©Ê£±ëÃ7ºÎرgÄæþNÄZÇËØ»0ºÃ7ºÎR¾¹±`±`¸`ñFÈNÎͱëÌÄcÎR¾¹Ã7ºÊ£â©Ì ¾ÁâåÄcδÄ棾¹Ä£ÊͺwÀíú ¸tÃÁ±¾Áºâåα`ÊËçèÂùþNÄZÇ ºÉÍÉÍÃÁÄcºcÌ7®Í±`¸näãâãõ±NüNâåìkÇZ±`ù
(12) ï ã² í⩸ë¾Á®Í±$ÀºÃ¹± % ' ¸¹Ää㻣¾¹âãÄθg¾¹®º¾<Ì`ºÃÁ±¿ÄcÎɺÌ7õc±¾7¸ äã±$ïc±$ä Ó>ê»Íâåä©Ê£âãÎÍØêÍäãÄ£Ì7&õ ºÎÊ ºØØÃÁ±$ØRºl¾Á±`¸ó®Íâãäå±±`Îʾ¹Ä"±`ÎÊ »¸¹±$Ã7¸ÉºwÀºl¾¾Á±$ÎR¾¹âãÄÎ ¾ÁÄ>¾¹®Í±É0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ0̱`¸ Äæ¿âãÎÊ£âãïRâ©Ê£»ºäôÄló¸ äå±`ï±$ä<×ùºê¸¾¹Ã7ºÌ¾»ÍÎÍâå(¾ ñ ¿¸¹±$Ã7¸®ºwï± ÎÍÄûó<ºwÀu¾¹Äù¸É8±`Ì$âðæÀøâãÎ ºcÊ£ïlºÎÌ$± ºÎ0Ê Ì$ÄÎR¾¹ÃÁÄäZ¾Á®Í±¿¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±<¾¹®Í±`À±¼£É8±`̾?ºl¾gô0Äló äã±$ïc±$äUñ3FÄ1±$κêÍäã± á ùâ©Ê>»¸¹±$Ã7¸gºÎÊ>ºÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾¹âãÄÎ0¸*¾¹ÄºcÌ$̱Q¸¹¸ ¾Á®Í±½þNÄRÇûÌ$ºÉ0ºêÍâãäåâå¾¹âã±`¸´Äæë¾¹®±"çèÂrÎͱ$¾ó?Äcùõ£¸Nó?±"ºÃ¹Øc»Í±¾Á®ºl¾º ¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±Dâ㸴ÃÁ±`îR»Íâãù±QÊW¾Á®ºl¾ºê0¸¾ÁÃÁºcÌ ¾Á¸ ºÎÊeâãÎR¾¹±`Ãæºc̱`¸N¾Á®Í±½þNÄRÇWÄcê£Å±`̾¹âãï±DÄæ?¾¹®Í±DôÄló¸ËºÎ0Êe¾Á®Í±>ɺÌ7õc±¾Näã±$ïc±$ä?þNÄZÇe¸¹±$ÃÁïRâ©Ì±Q¸¿Äì8±`ù±QÊeêZÀ »ÎÊ£±$ÃÁäãÀRâãÎÍØNÎͱ¾óÄÃÁõ£¸$ñkçèξ¹®Í⩸3ɺÉ8±$ÃQöwó?±?ÉÍù±Q¸±`ÎR¾)¾¹®±þNÄZÇZâåÎZ»¸F¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±ë¾¹®º¾F®ºc¸)ê8±$±`ÎÊ£±Q¸âãØÎͱQÊ˾¹Ä °"ºÎºØc±?¾Á®Í±¿üNâðìtÇZ±`ùï>Ì䩺¸Á¸±Q¸gºl¾n¾Á®Í±±QʣرÄæ0¾Á®Í±Îͱ$¾ó?ÄcùõDºÎʾÁĺäãäåÄ£Ì`ºl¾¹±¾Á®Í±$° ¾¹Ä á ÃÁâ©ÊDôÄló¸nâãÎ ÄcÃÁÊͱ$Ãg¾ÁÄ°"ºl¾7Ì7®"¾¹®±N¸¹É0±QÌâ 0Ì¿ÃÁ±`îR»ÍâãÃÁ±$°>±$ÎR¾Á¸ëÄætâãÎÊ£âãïZâãÊ£»0ºä8ØÃÁâãʺÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾ÁâåÄcθ$ñ*<®Í±´Ì7®ºÃ7ºÌ¾¹±$ÃÁ⩸¾ÁâãÌ`¸ ºÎÊ ¾Á®Í±>ê0±`®ºwïZâåÄc»ÍÿÄæg¾¹®Í±þNÄRÇeÌ$ºÉ0ºêÍâãäåâå¾¹âã±`¸NÄæë¾¹®Í*± )ÍÃÁ±$ÎÌ7®ØÃÁâãÊW¾¹±`¸¾¹ê8±`Êû±`FÄâãäå±>ºÃÁ±Éù±Q¸±`Îc¾Á±`Êkñ <®±½É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱½Ã¹±Qîc»âåÃÁ±$°>±$ÎR¾7¸Ä濺 á ùâ©ÊøêÍâãÄ°>±`ÊÍâãÌ`ºä<ºÉÍÉÍäãâ©Ì$ºl¾ÁâåÄcÎ+ºÎÊø¾¹®Í±Ã¹±Q¸»äð¾7¸Äê;ÁºâãÎͱQÊ Älïc±$þ¹®±´±Q)Äcâåäã±1Îͱ$¾ó?ÄcùõºÃ¹±´±¼Íº°>âãÎͱ`Êtñ 4 &>:¶E)& 5 3&E ,l&1( @ (* E + . . . 0.
(13) D. . '. D. . . D. . ,.- /. 021 3547698&1 :;1 <>=&?. Ç£±$ï±`ÃÁºäºÎºäåÀ£¸¹âã@¸ ÖZöR²QÖ c®ºwïc±g¸®ÍÄlóδ¾Á®ºl¾t¾Á®Í±þNÄZǴù±Qîc»âåÃÁ±$°>±$ÎR¾7¸k¸É8±`̾¹ÃÁ»Í°rÄæ á ùâ©Ê´ôÄló¸k⩸têÍÃÁÄcºcÊ $Ì Ä°>ÉÍÃÁâ㸹âãÎÍØËÎͱ$±QÊ͸näãâåõc±?¾Á®Í±Øc»ºÃ7ºÎR¾¹±`±`ÊÊ£±$äãâåïc±$ÃÁÀÄætºËÌÄc°>ÉÍäå±$¾¹±®Z»ÍØc±Êͺl¾7º äå±cö¾Á®Í±ÉÍÃÁ±`Ê£â©Ì ¾7ºêÍâãäåâå¾À Äæ¾¹®Í± ? ¾Á®ÍÃÁÄ»ÍØc®ÍÉÍ»£¾Qö*¾¹®Í± ê0Äc»ÍÎÊ£±QÊbÊ£±`äåâãï±`ùÀ¾¹âã°>± ÄæNº äã±¾ÁÃÁºÎ¸æ±$ÃQö*º¸¾7ºêÍâãäãâð¾ÀRéªäå±`ï±$äëæÄà ʺl¾ÁºéªÊͱ$äãâåïc±$ÃÁÀñ F. . zFz BA~ « C ;?.
(14) ×. #. ! . 1 . . . . . . <®Í±NÎͱ¾óÄÃÁõÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°"ºÎÌ$±°>ģʣ±$ä8ó?±NÌÄÎ0¸â©Ê£±$ÃQöâãÎ"¾Á®Í±¿ÃÁ±`¸¾?Äæ8¾Á®Í⩸ëɺÉ0±`Ã`öR⩸?º¸¹±¾Äæ)îR»ºÎc¾Áâðé ¾7ºl¾Áâåïc±´þNÄRÇ>Ì7®ºÃÁºcÌ ¾Á±$ÃÁâ㸾¹â©Ì$¸`ñ)<®Í±Q¸±¿Ì7®0ºÃ7ºÌ ¾Á±$ÃÁâ㸾¹â©Ì$¸nºÃ¹±¿êÍâð¾ÃÁº¾¹±cöcÊ£±`äãºwÀcö$Åâå¾¾Á±$ÃÄÃëÊ£±`äãºwÀDïlºÃÁâ㺾¹âãÄÎtö äãÄc¸Á¸ÃÁº¾¹±1ºÎ0Ê ±`ùÃÁÄÃÃ7ºl¾¹±cñ üNâ㸾¹ÃÁâãêÍ»£¾¹±QʺÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾ÁâåÄcθ¿Øc±$Îͱ`ÃÁºäåäãÀ ù±`äåÀ ÄcÎ ?ÂHÉÍùľ¹Ä£ÌÄcäFÃÁ»ÍÎÍÎâåÎÍØÄlï±`ÿçèÂræÄôóâãÊͱDºÃ¹±Qº Ì$Ä°>°»ÎÍâãÌ`ºl¾ÁâåÄcθ$ñ)çèÂû⩸FºNÌÄÎÎͱ`̾¹âãÄÎÍäã±`¸Á¸tÉÍÃÁľÁÄ£ÌÄäRºÎÊ1¾¹®Í±`ù±$æÄÃÁ±gâð¾*®ºc¸)ÎÍÄNâåήͱ$ÃÁ±$ÎR¾F°>±QÌ7®ºÎÍ⩸¹°>¸ ¾ÁÄÊ£±`äåâãï±`ÃØc»ºÃ7ºÎR¾¹±`±`¸ºcÌ$Ì$ÄÃ7Ê£âåÎØW¾¹Äû¾¹Ã7Bº ̽Ì$ÄÎR¾¹Ã7ºÌ¾Á¸`ñeçèÎ+¾Á®Í±½çèÂÿùÄc»£¾¹±`ÃÁ¸ºäãÄÎÍØûºûɺl¾Á®øæÃÁÄ° ¸¹±$Î0Ê£±$Ã˾ÁÄeÊ£±`¸¾¹âãκl¾ÁâåÄcÎtök¾Á®Í±Ã7ºl¾¹±"º¾Ëó®âãÌ7®øºØcØÃÁ±$ØRºl¾¹±QÊ ¾¹Ã7Bº ÌD⩸ʣâãù±QÌ ¾¹±QÊe¾ÁÄeºÎùâãÎc¾Á±$ùæºÌ$±D°"ºwÀ ±$¼Í̱$±QÊ ¾¹®±DÃ7ºl¾Á±º¾´ó®Íâ©Ì7®e¾Á®Í±>âåÎR¾Á±$ùæºÌ±DÌ$ºÎeæÄÃÁó<ºÃ7ʾ¹®Í±D¾¹Ã7Bº ÌÄÎZóºÃÁÊt'ñ )3âãÃÁ¸¾`öí¾Á®Í±D±¼Í̱`±`Ê£±QÊ ¾ÁÃÁº ÌNóâãäãä)ê8±îR»Í±$»Í±QÊâåξ¹®±Ê£±$ïZâ©Ì±cú ¸°>±`°DÄcùÀ½»ÍÎR¾¹âãät¾¹®±ÌÄÎر`¸¾¹âãÄÎ ¸¹»Í긹âãÊ£±Q¸$ö;¹®Í±`Î ¾¹®Í±1¾ÁÃÁº Ì óâãäãä?ê8±ÊÍâã¸ÁÌ$ºÃÁÊ£±QÊù¾¹Äuºäãäå±`ïZâ㺾¹±½Ì$ÄÎÍØc±`¸¾¹âãÄÎtñ ?Äθ¹±`îR»Í±`Îc¾ÁäåÀcön±$ÎÊ+¾¹Ä±$ÎÊùô0Äló¸óâãäåä<±$¼ZÉ8±$ÃÁâã±$ÎÌ$± ïlºÃ¹ÀZâãÎÍؿ䩺l¾Á±$ÎÌ$À îR»Í±$»±`¸3ÄÎâåÎR¾¹±`Ãæºc̱Q¸ )ÄÃF¾¹Ã7Bº Ì?äåÄR¸¹¸)¾¹®º¾gÌ$ºÎDÊͺ°"ºØ±?ÊÍÃÁº°>º¾¹â©Ì$ºäåäãÀ´¾¹®Í±<±$Î0Ê1¾¹Ä ±`ÎÊ´¾¹®Ã¹Äc»ÍØ®ÍÉ»£¾`ñ3<®Í±ëâãÎÌÃÁ±`ºc¸âãÎÍØ<âãÎc¾Á±$ÃÁ±`¸¾tæÄà á ùâ©Ê ?Äc°DÉ»£¾¹âãÎÍØ°"ºõc±*¾¹®Í±?Îͱ$±QÊ͸kæÄcÃ)É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°"ºÎÌ$± Ì$ÄÎR¾¹ÃÁÄä0ºÎÊ"ÄcÉ£¾¹âã°>âã¸Áºl¾ÁâåÄcÎâãÎçèÂbÎͱ$¾ó?Äcùõ£¸n°>Äcù±¿ºÎÊ"°>ÄÃÁ±ïZâå¾ÁºäíºÎ0ÊÌ7®ºäãäã±$ÎÍØcâåÎÍØ0ñ3<®±NüNâðìtÇZ±$ÃÁï ºÉÍÉÍÃÁÄcºcÌ7®â©¸âãÎÌ$ù±`°D±`ÎR¾ÁºäãäãÀÊ£±`ÉÍäåÄlÀc±`ÊùÄlïc±$Ã1çè âãΣæÃ7º¸¾¹ÃÁ»Ì ¾Á»Íù±Q¸$ñe<®± á ùâ©ÊøÎͱ$¾ó?ÄcùõuÌäãÄ»Êù⩸º Ì$Ä°>ÉÍäã±¼ ºØcØÃÁ±$Øcº¾¹âãÄÎ Äæ®±¾¹±`ùÄcر`Îͱ$Äc»¸Ê£Äc°>ºâåÎ0¸Äìí±$ÃÁâãÎÍØbïlºÃÁâãÄ»¸"É8±$ùæÄÃÁ°"ºÎÌ$±`¸½Ø»ºÃÁºÎc¾Á±$±Q¸ ºÎÊWþNÄRÇ ¸¾ÁÃÁº¾¹±$Øcâå±Q¸¾¹®º¾ á ùâ©ÊÊ£±`¸¹âåØcÎͱ$ÃÌ`ºÎÍÎľÌÄcÎc¾ÁùÄcäYñgFóÄ>¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±`¸<ºÃÁ±Ëر`Îͱ$Ã7ºäãäåÀ"ÉùÄlïZâ©Ê£±`Ê Æg¼ZÉ8±`ÊÍâð¾Á±`ÊøæÄcùó<ºÃ7Ê£âãÎÍØWæÄcþ¹âã°>±¸¹±$Î0¸âå¾¹âãï±½¾¹Ã7Bº ̽ºÎÊ ¿¸Á¸¹»Íù±QÊ )ÍÄcùó<ºÃ7Ê£âãÎÍØ æÄÃDÃ7ºl¾¹±¸±`θ¹âð¾Áâåïc± ¾ÁÃÁº Ìñ çèÎD¾¹®±Î±¼Z¾g¸±QÌ ¾¹âãÄÎ0¸$öºÎ±$¼£º°>ÉÍäå±<Äæ8ºÎD®ÍâãØ®DÉ0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ̱ á ùâ©Êα¾óÄÃÁõÌäãÄ»Êâã¸*Éù±Q¸±`Îc¾Á±`Êkñ '. ,.- ,. 1 1
(15) 6 91. =1 ?= 1 < = 1 < 1 =
(16) @8 "! 1 8$#%
(17) 8$:& <('1 ? ?=&4*). <®±±éèFÄâãäå±ÉùÄű`Ì ¾#å²QÓ*â㸴ºÎe±$¼£É0±`ùâã°>±$ÎR¾ÁºäFóâ©Ê£±ºÃ¹±Qº>ØÃÁâãÊW¾¹±`¸¾¹ê8±`Êtñ´<®Í±±éU¾¹Äcâåäã±,+®º¸¾¹®ÍÃÁ±$± Ì$Ä°>ÉÍäã±$°>±$ÎR¾7ºÃÁÀ"Äê£Å±QÌ ¾¹âãï±Q-¸ . ¾¹Ä"êÍ»âåä©Ê ºÎ±¼£É0±`ùâã°>±$ÎR¾Áºäk®ÍâãØ® É0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ̱´ØÃÁâãÊ ÉÍ䩺l¾Á±éUæÄÃÁ° ¾¹®º¾¸¹Ì`ºäã±`¸¾¹Ä )ÃÁºÎ̱cñ . ¾¹Ä1Ê£±`ï±$äãÄÉDÄÃÁâãØâãκä á ùâ©ÊD¸±`ùïZâ©Ì±`¸F¾ÁÄNæ»äåäãÀ±¼£ÉÍäãÄâå¾*¾¹®Í±¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±`¸*ºÎÊDÌ$ºÉºÌ$âð¾Áâå±Q¸3Äìí±$ÃÁ±`ÊêRÀº ï±`ùÀ1®ÍâãØ®DÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱?Îͱ¾óÄÃÁõíñF<®Í±<±$éY¾ÁÄâãäå±°>âãÊÍÊÍäå±`óºÃ¹±âåÎR¾Á±$ØÃ7ºl¾Á±`¸)¾¹®Í±<°>Äc¸¾nù±Q̱`Îc¾nºÎ0Ê Ã¹±`äå±`ïlºÎR¾ëóÄÃÁõZ¸*Äæí¾¹®Í±æÃÁ±$Î0Ì7®ÌÄ°>Éͻ;¹±$Ã?¸¹Ì$âå±`Î̱䩺ê8ÄÃ7ºl¾ÁÄÃÁâå±Q¸ ç ¿µç ö ¿µ¿&Ç næģ̻¸¹±`Ê>ÄcÎ ±$ÎÍ®0ºÎÌ$±`Ê ÌÄc°D°»ÍÎÍâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄÎ ¸¹±$ÃÁïZâãÌ$±`¸`ñ . ¾¹Äù±$ïlºä建¾¹± ¾¹®Í± Ê£±`ÉÍäåÄlÀZ°>±$ÎR¾"ÌÄR¸¾>ÄæËÌ7®ÍÄZÄc¸¹±`Ê+Ì$Ä°>ÉÍ»£¾ÁâåÎÍØuâãÎc¾Á±$θ¹âãï± ºÎÊ Êͺl¾7ºléªâåÎR¾¹±`θ¹âåïc± ºÉÍÉäåâ©Ì$º¾¹âãÄθºÎʾÁÄ"±`¸¾¹âã°"ºl¾¹±´¾Á®Í±1É0±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ̱ËØcºâåν¾¹®Í±`À½°"ºwÀÄcꣾÁºâåÎÄlï±`Ã?¾Á®Í±1ØÃÁâ©Êkñ <®Í± /NòNü ïZÃÁºâå°>±$ÎR¾¾Áù¯Q¸®º»£¾ÊÍ·$êÍâå(¾ Îͱ¾óÄÃÁõbâãΣæÃ7º¸¾¹ÃÁ»Ì ¾Á»Íù±ûâåÎR¾¹±`ÃÁÌ$ÄÎÍα`Ì ¾7¸"¾Á®Í±ûØcùâ©Ê ÎÄZÊͱ`¸óâð¾Á®ºcÌ$Ì$±`¸Á¸ëäãâåÎõ"Äæ?²N¾¹Ä"Ö á êÍɸ`ñg<®Í±N±$éY¾ÁÄâãäå±´°>âãÊÊ£äå±`óºÃ¹±Nù±`äåâã±`¸Äcν±¼£â©¸¾ÁâåÎØ°>â©ÊÍÊ£äã±$ó<ºÃÁ± á äåÄcêÍ»¸ Ð ªö á ùâ©Ê´ÆgÎÍØâãÎͱcñåñãñ ºÎÊ´âãÎR¾¹±$ØcÃÁº¾¹±Q¸íÎͱ$óuêÍ»ÍâãäãÊÍâåÎÍØ¿êÍäåÄ£Ì7õ£¸`ñ)<®Í±n±éèFÄâãäå±n°>â©ÊÍÊ£äã±$ó<ºÃÁ±*ºâå°"¸ ¾ÁÄ´æ»ÍäåäãÀ±$¼£ÉÍäåÄcâð¾*¾Á®Í±É0Äló±$Ã*Äæ¾¹®±Îͱ¾óÄÃÁõZâåÎÍØNâåÎÍæÃÁºc¸¾Áù»Ì¾¹»ÍÃÁ±ñnÈNÎͱ<Äæ8¾¹®Í±ÄcùâãØâãκäRºâå° Äæ8±$éªFÄâãä㱠⩸뾹Ä1æģ̻0¸ëÄcÎ"¾¹®Í±´òâãØ®Â*±`ÃæÄcù°"ºÎ0̱ á ÃÁâãÊ ¿±¾óÄÃÁõZâåÎÍØÊÍâå°>±$Î0¸âãÄνºÎÊ>¾Áı$ïlºä建¾¹±¾Á®Í±¿ê8±$α ; ¾Á®ºl¾Øcùâ©Ê°>â©ÊÍÊ£äã±$ó<ºÃÁ±`¸ºÎÊ ºÉÍÉÍäãâãÌ`ºl¾ÁâåÄcθÌ$ºÎ Øc±¾<æùÄc°6±$ήºÎÌ$±`ÊÎͱ$¾ó?ÄcùõZâãÎÍؾÁ±`Ì7®ÍÎÄäãÄØâã±`¸`ñ <®Í±DÉ8±$ùæÄÃÁ°>ºÎ̱ÉÍÃÁÄêÍäã±$°!Äæg¾¹®Í±DØÃÁâ©ÊWÎͱ¾óÄÃÁõWºÃÁ±¸¾¹»ÊÍâå±QÊeâãÎû±éèFÄâãäå±æùÄc°!Ê£âðìí±$ÃÁ±$ÎR¾ËêÍ»£¾ Ì$Ä°>ÉÍäã±$°>±$ÎR¾7ºÃÁÀ"É0ÄcâåÎR¾Á¸<Äæ3ïZâã±$0ó 1è¡©¨Y 8 £)z)yF t wY Yè¨ 2㦠U7wÁ¨U l7`w8 w wt? 4 3 åwwwg$glw ?}Ëw Y¨Yn zt Y7Y 9'. D. ,+. 4. 6. 9+. :*. :*. ;>. 2. :*. ,+. 12. @+. :*. y3zt .
(18)
Documents relatifs